v.e. of selecting flooring materials king fahad university of petroleum & minerals college of...

V.E. of Selecting V.E. of Selecting Flooring MaterialsFlooring Materials

KING FAHAD UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM & MINERALSKING FAHAD UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM & MINERALSCollege of Environmental Design College of Environmental Design

Construction Engineering & Management Construction Engineering & Management CEM 512 – Value EngineeringCEM 512 – Value Engineering

Presented byPresented by::

Mustafa Al-HumoodMustafa Al-Humood

OUTLINEOUTLINE

IntroductionIntroduction DescriptionDescription ObjectivesObjectives V.E. PhasesV.E. Phases

Study Study SummarySummary

InformatioInformationn

CreativCreativee

FunctionFunctionalal

JudiciaJudiciall

DevelopmeDevelopmentnt

ImplementatiImplementationon

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION

Flooring has a deep impact on the Flooring has a deep impact on the total space of the building, it adds total space of the building, it adds wideness and effects the vision if it is wideness and effects the vision if it is very well selected in a way that very well selected in a way that reflects your style and matches the reflects your style and matches the general style of the building.general style of the building.

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION

Good planning & choosing the flooring Good planning & choosing the flooring materials could save your time and materials could save your time and money, therefore it is important to money, therefore it is important to determine the function of each space determine the function of each space of your building. of your building.

DESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION

An owner would like to cover his apartment’s An owner would like to cover his apartment’s floor with suitable materials .floor with suitable materials .

The total space of the apartment is 87 sm for The total space of the apartment is 87 sm for which the floor to be covered. which the floor to be covered.

The apartment consists of : The apartment consists of : 2 bedrooms (3.5x5 m /ea), 1 kitchen 2 bedrooms (3.5x5 m /ea), 1 kitchen

(3.5x3.5m) ,(3.5x3.5m) , 1 bathroom (3.5x2m), a living room (6x5m) 1 bathroom (3.5x2m), a living room (6x5m)

and an entrance (1.5x2m).and an entrance (1.5x2m).

OBJECTIVESOBJECTIVES

To cover the floor with good looking To cover the floor with good looking materialsmaterials

To stay within a reasonable budgetTo stay within a reasonable budget To complete the work in a short timeTo complete the work in a short time To provide comfort the usersTo provide comfort the users

COST DATACOST DATA

MATERIALSMATERIALSUNITUNIT COST (SR/SM)COST (SR/SM)Total (SR)Total (SR)

Local Carpet908068

Natural Marble18015898

Artificial Rubber252413

Tile7847

Ceramic353045

Wood11510243

Granite655648

FUNCTIONAL PHASEFUNCTIONAL PHASE

VerbVerb Noun Noun ProvideProvide AppearanceAppearance

ProvideProvide ComfortComfort

WHYWHYFUNCTIONFUNCTIONHOWHOW

To have a good To have a good looking floorlooking floor

To cover the To cover the apartment's apartment's floorfloor

Using flooring Using flooring materialsmaterials

What must it What must it do?do?

CREATIVE THINKINGCREATIVE THINKING

1.1. Cover with CarpetCover with Carpet

2.2. Cover with Natural MarbleCover with Natural Marble

3.3. Cover with Artificial RubberCover with Artificial Rubber

4.4. Cover with TilesCover with Tiles

5.5. Cover with CeramicCover with Ceramic

6.6. Cover with WoodCover with Wood

7.7. Cover with GraniteCover with Granite

TotalTotal RankRank

Carpet 5 8 9 8 3 3 36 Carpet 5 8 9 8 3 3 36 6 6 Natural Marble 3 10 5 5 7 7 37 Natural Marble 3 10 5 5 7 7 37 5 5 Artificial Rubber 10 3 9 8 7 8 45 Artificial Rubber 10 3 9 8 7 8 45 2 2 Tile 10 2 4 5 8 8 37 Tile 10 2 4 5 8 8 37 5 5

Wood 3 10 7 6 8 4 38 Wood 3 10 7 6 8 4 38 4 4

Ceramic 9 10 5 6 7 9 46 Ceramic 9 10 5 6 7 9 46 1 1

Granite 6 9 7 6 6 6 40 Granite 6 9 7 6 6 6 40 3 3

Easy to cleanEasy to clean

Health and SafetyHealth and Safety

WastageWastage

Fixing TimeFixing Time

AppearanceAppearance

Initial CostInitial Cost

Combining IdeasCombining Ideas

TotalTotal RankRank

Idea 1 2 7 3 4 5 6 27 Idea 1 2 7 3 4 5 6 27 66

Idea 2 Idea 2 10 10 5 6 7 9 47 1 10 10 5 6 7 9 47 1

Idea 3 Idea 3 9 9 7 7 5 7 44 9 9 7 7 5 7 44 44Idea 4 Idea 4 3 9 5 6 7 9 36 3 9 5 6 7 9 36 55

Idea 6 9 8 7 7 8 7 46 Idea 6 9 8 7 7 8 7 46 22

Idea 5Idea 5 7 8 7 7 8 8 45 3 7 8 7 7 8 8 45 3


Health and SafetyHealth and Safety

WastageWastage




IdeaIdeaAdvantageAdvantageDisadvantageDisadvantageRankRankKitchen (Rubber)Kitchen (Rubber)

Rooms (Carpet)Rooms (Carpet)

Entrance (Tiles)Entrance (Tiles)

Bathroom (Ceramic)Bathroom (Ceramic)

Living Room (Marble)Living Room (Marble)

Nice Appearance in Nice Appearance in living roomliving room

High CostHigh Cost

Long time fixingLong time fixing

Many KindsMany Kinds

66

Kitchen (Ceramic)Kitchen (Ceramic)

Rooms (Ceramic)Rooms (Ceramic)

Entrance (Ceramic)Entrance (Ceramic)


Living Room (Ceramic)Living Room (Ceramic)

Very Low CostVery Low Cost

Resist HumidityResist Humidity

Nice Appearance & Nice Appearance & cleaningcleaning

Only one typeOnly one type

SlippageSlippage

11

Kitchen (Ceramic)Kitchen (Ceramic)




Living Room (Granite)Living Room (Granite)

Nice appearance in Nice appearance in living room living room

Different typesDifferent types

Long time fixingLong time fixing44

Kitchen (Rubber)Kitchen (Rubber)

Rooms (Wood)Rooms (Wood)

Entrance (Wood)Entrance (Wood)


Living Room (Wood)Living Room (Wood)

Nice AppearanceNice Appearance


High CostHigh Cost

Long time fixingLong time fixing

55


Rooms (Wood)Rooms (Wood)




Nice AppearanceNice Appearance

HealthyHealthy


Fixing time Fixing time 33






Low costLow cost

Nice appearanceNice appearance

Not so easy to cleanNot so easy to clean22

Determining WeightsDetermining Weights

A. Initial cost 5 8 A. Initial cost 5 8 B. Appearance 6 10B. Appearance 6 10C. Fixing time 2 3C. Fixing time 2 3D. Easy to clean 1 1D. Easy to clean 1 1

A - 2

C - 2

A - 2

B - 2B - 3

A / B

3 Major performance3 Major performance2 Medium Performance 2 Medium Performance 1 Minor performance1 Minor performance

A

B C D E F

B

C

D

E

Score

Assigned Wt

TotalTotal

Idea 1 7 2 3 6 101Idea 1 7 2 3 6 101

Idea 2 Idea 2 10 10 5 9 204 10 10 5 9 204

Idea 3 Idea 3 9 9 7 7 190 9 9 7 7 190

Idea 4 Idea 4 9 3 5 9 138 9 3 5 9 138

Idea 6 8 9 7 7 180Idea 6 8 9 7 7 180

Idea 5Idea 5 8 7 7 8 165 8 7 7 8 165





10 8 3 1

Evaluation MatrixEvaluation Matrix

SavingsSavings

Idea# 2 to Idea # 1 195% savingIdea# 2 to Idea # 1 195% saving Idea# 2 to Idea # 3 92% savingIdea# 2 to Idea # 3 92% saving Idea# 2 to Idea # 4 185% savingIdea# 2 to Idea # 4 185% saving Idea#2 to Idea # 5 117% savingIdea#2 to Idea # 5 117% saving Idea#2 to Idea # 6 88% savingIdea#2 to Idea # 6 88% saving

SummarySummary

The proposed Idea will meet the The proposed Idea will meet the criteria and will save time and money criteria and will save time and money

SubjectiveSubjective

THANK YOUTHANK YOU

v.e. of selecting flooring materials king fahad university of petroleum & minerals college of...

Documents

granite slide

introduction flooring

good looking materials

good looking floor

short time

total space

totalrank idea

mustafa alhumood slide