Government of Madhya Pradesh Water Resources Department

Mantralaya Vallabh Bhawan, Bhopal

Memo No. DS/DRIP/59/DSRP/31/o To,

Bhopal datedo/ltpo2!

Chief Engineer (BODH)

Water Resources Department,

Bhopal (M.P.)

Sub:- Reconstitution of new Dam Safety Review Panel (DSRP) for Dam Rehabilitation and Improvement Projeet (DRIP) -II & II.

Ref (1) Minutes of meeting Memo no. 778/DS/DRIP/189/DRIP-II Proposal 2020, Bhopal dated 09-12-2020

2) Memo No. DS/1/CP/31/2009/815, Bhopal, Dated10/08/2020. (3) Memo No. DS/1/CP/31/2009/1052, Bhopal, Dated 18/09/2019.

Government of India decided to take up Dam Rehabilitation and Improvement Project (DRIP) - II and II which is approved by the Department of Economic Affairs (DEA)

and concurred by World Bank with a funding pattern in ratio 70:30 (World Bank: Agency). Constitution of Dam Safety Review Panel (DSRP) and Dam Safety Inspection by DSRP is

mandatory for implementation of project. The State Government has already constituted DSRP and Common pool as per the guideline of CWC stated in Memo No.

DS/1/CP/31/2009/1052, Bhopal, Dated 18/09/2019.

There are 27 number dams envisaged to be rehabilitated in Madhya Pradesh under DRIP

phase II & II. DSRP visits only 11 number projects could be completed due to travel

restrictions in the wake of Corona Pandemic. A review meeting between the officers of

Central Water Commission (CWC) and Madhya Pradesh Water Resources Department

(MPWRD) held on 9th Dec 2020 under the Chairmanship of ACS, MPWRD, in which officers of C.W.C. suggested to form new DSRP panels with the experts from Madhya

Pradesh. So, The State Government is pleased to reconstitute new DSRP and Common

pool as per the Minutes of Review meeting on preparedness of Madhya Pradesh for

DRIP phase II & III as stated below.

DSRP 1: S. No. Designation Name

Shri Manoj Aacharya Shri T.R. Suman

3. Shri M.G. Choure

- Chairman

- Member, Hydro Mechanical expert - Member, Construction Supervision Expert

-Member, Hydrology_

2.

4. Shri R.C.Maheswari Shri Mahesh Chandra Upadhyay-Member, Geologist5.

18 DSRP -2:

S. No. Name Designation 1. Shri S. K. Khare - Chairman

Shri Bharat Gosavi -Member, Design Expert Member, Hydro Mechanical expert

-Member,Hydrology |- Member,Geologist

2.

3. Shri R.C. Saxena 4. Shri Ashok Goyal 5. Shri M.P. Shrivastava

Common Pool:-

S. No. Name Designation Shri Ranjit Chandra Chakraborty-Dam Safety Specialist Shri Y.C. Sharma

1.

2. - Design Expert

Terms and Conditions for Chairman and Members of the Dam Safety Review Panel

and Common Pool as approved by the Finance Department, Government of MP. as

indicated below:- Remuneration@ Rs. 7500/- (Rupees Seven Thousand Five Hundred only) per day spent for the work as per the Government of Madhya Pradesh, Water

Resources Department, order no. DS/1/CP/131 /2017/MPS/31/1266 dated

03.07.2017 and Memo No. DS/1/CP/31/2009/815, Bhopal, Dated10/08/2020 as and when revised by the Government of M.P.

I.

T.A. and D.A. @ as admissible to Grade-I Offcers of the State Government wil be payable when they are on tour.

II.

Members of the panel will be eligible for accommodation in the Government Rest

House/Inspection Bungalovws, Circuit Houses ete, on the same conditions which are applicable to the Grade-I officers of the State Government.

III.

Tems of reference for Dam Safety Review Panel as indicated in Guidelines for

Safety Inspection of Dam published in January, 2018 under Chapter 10 -Comprehensive Dam Safety Review.

IV.

The Expenditure will be chargeable to respective head of DRIP - II& I

(V.S.Tekam) Deputy Seceretary,

Govt. of M.P.Water Resources Deptt.

Bhopal, Dated Of/1 202 Endt. No. DS/DRIP/59/DSRP/31/02 Copy forward to:-

1. Secretary, Government of India Ministry of Water Resources, River Development &

Ganga Rejuvenation, Shram Shakti Bhawan, Rafi Marg, New Delhi- 110001. 2. The Accountant General, Madhya Pradesh, Gwalior/Bhopal. 3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Madhya Pradesh,

Vallabh Bhawan, Bhopal. 4 The Chief Engineer, Dam Safety Organisation, Central Water Commission, Sewa

Bhawan, R.K. Puram, New Delhi- 110 066.

5. The Project Director, Dam Safety Rehabilitation Dte& Project Director, DRIP,

Central Project Management Unit, Central Water. Commission, GOI, 3d Floor, CWC Library Building, R.K.Puram, New Delhi 110 066.

6. The Engineer-in-Chief, Water Resources Department, Tulsi Nagar Bhopal.

7. The Chief Engineer, Chambal Betwa Basin, Bhopal. 8. The Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Hoshangabad. 9. The Chief Engineer, Narmada Tapti Basin, Indore.

10. The Chief Engineer, Wainganga Basin, Seoni.

11. The Chief Engineer, Dhasan Ken Basin, Sagar. 12. The Chief Engineer, Ganga Basin, Rewa.

13. The Chicf Engineer, Yamuna Basin, Gwalior. 14. Chief Engineer, Rajghat Canal Project, Datia 15. Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Ujjain

16. Web Manager, O/o E-in-C, WRD to upload for order on website.

Copy to Concern 1- Shri Ranjit Chandra Chakraborty, Retired Secretary, Mob. No. 9425372734 2- Shri S. K. Khare, Retired Chief Engineer, Mob. No. 9425113432 3- Shri Manoj Aacharya, Retired Chief Engineer, Mob. No. 9893243688 4- Shri Bharat Gosavi, Retired Superintending Engineer, Mob. No. 9340108335 5- Shri Y.C. Sharma, Retired Superintending Engineer, Mob. No. 9425007969 6- Shri R.C. Saxena, Retired Superintending Engineer E/M, Mob. No. 8989950590 7- Shri T.R. Suman, Retired Superintendent Engineer E/M, Mob. No. 9827264814 8- Shri M.G. Choure, Retired Superintending Engineer, Mob. No. 98262365 1 6

9- Shri Ashok Goyal, Retired Superintending Engineer, Mob. No. 9425029428

10-Shri M.P. Shrivastava, Retired Director (GIS) Mob. No. 9921140609

11-Shri Mahesh Chandra Upadhya, Retired Director (GIS), Mob. No. 9630094788 12-Shri R.C. Maheswari, Retired Executive Engineer, Mob. No. 9302306652

Deputy Secretàry, Govt. of M.P.Water Resources Deptt.

2ter Se Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams January 2018

Chapter 10. COMPREHENSIVE DAM SAFETY REVIEW c

Comprehensive Dam Sakety Review iss a procedure for assessing the dam safety as an entirety, which comprises a detailed study of dam engineering with specialist supports, and assessment of the records and reports from investigation, design, construction,

commissioning, operation, instrumentation monitoring and surveillance

activities.

dam owner or dam operator- who is

responsible for self-supervision or internal

supervision and the second pair of cyes has to belong to an independent body -

usually a supervisory authority, boards of

experts, consultants or a mixture of the above-mentioned bodies. maintenance,

The need for comprehensive safety review

of a dam has also been emphasised by the

MinistryDevelopment and Ganga Rejuvenation in

the National Dam Safety Bill 2017, which is

in the active stage of consideration for

introducing in the Parliament.

of Water Resources, River A comprehensive dam sakery review should

assess the integrity of a dam against known

failure modes, review of monitoring

program, program on-site inspections, and

review mechanisms for the various types of

dams based on current acceptable safety

criteria (e.g. engineering standards, dam safety guidelines) or risk management criteria, which may defer from original construction time of the dam.

The draft National Dam Safety Bill 2017

requires owners of specified dams to

arrange ftor comprehensive satety evaluation

of their dams through an independent panel of experts.

Comprehensive dam safety review report is

produced to document the results of safety

review and to recommend remedial or

As pointed out in 1COLD Bullcin 154, the main purpose of the comprehensive safety

maintenance work. Dam owners may use

risk assessment techniques with safety

reviews to determine the urgency and extent

of works and to prioritise remedial works

review is to obtain an overall view of the

actual state of safery of the dam, and

determine whether any rehabilitation (structural as well non-structural) measures, modifications or alterations, are

necessary to ensure that the level of safery is appropriate, and ensure that the principle of continual improvement is observed.

for their dams

In view of ever changing economic

importance of the dams as well the changing

hazard perceptions for the downstreamn, the

comprehensive safety reviews of the dams

are generally being conducted globally at

regular intervals of typically 5-30 years (Switzerland- 5 years, China, 6-10 years,

Canada, 5-10 years, United Kingdom -10

years, Japan-30 years etc.).

The Dam Safcty Review Panel should be constituted to carry out a comprehensive

assessment of the dam system and provide

answers to the following questions:

Does the dam conform to current

regulatory requirements? Are All over the world the usual practice of

supervision of dams is based on the "four-

cyes principle. This applies to dams in state

or public ownership or privately-owned dams as well as. The fundamental principle is that the first pair of eyes belongs to the

the managerial and

organizational currently in placc sufficient to

maintain the levels of safety in

arrangements

conformance with the above

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 159 of 190

hleliH oe Maleny Inapethon f Dunn Jawary 29I

uiromwN Cmpehoalve anlety revlewi

)eview all vailalle releyan davabases, infomaon ineluling

denbgpn veports, e51e9n epos,

And past rehabiliratio cords omprehensive natey vevlewn ArO normally conhctel erlolicully with the froqueney leending on tlhe level of rink to people, property and the environment, "The Interva tor

BUPVelllanee records deermine CACI eAUse of prolblem, It may also include arny design hmivations, and deficlencics in performance, and inlication of adverse trends, if any.

comprehensive Henerally from 5-10 yearn; nOmettmes up to 0 years lepenling On the potential comscquenees of the failure of the dam. The satety review has 1o be performed by experts with adequnte education, experience and expertise. In practice for all large dams the review is often made by a group or Independent Panel of Experts' (comprising of qualitied engineers and experts in other

ticlds, e.g geologists, dam safety expecrt, seismic expert etc.), called "Dam Safety Review Panel (DSRP)". In India, it is proposed that DSRP cvaluations of cach large dam are undertake once in 10 years. During this performance, any safety incidences, results of satety inspections, instrumentation data, major repairs and maintenance activities are

comprehensively analysed.

Nalety reviewa I

b) Gencral assessment of hydrolopjeand hydraulic conditíons in view of the mandatory review of desiyn flood.

c)General assessment of seisnic safety of dam, especially if there is a change in the seismic zoning of the dam location or any old dam not designed for scismie loading at that point of time.

d) Detailed on-site inspection of the dam and appurtenant structures;

including changes that were made and the reasons for such changes or

cvaluation, the dam

design revisions. Review any potential for the development of unsafe conditions (eg. unexpected foundation conditions, presence of scepage, indications of distress or

erosion, mechanicai equipment

malfunctioning, ageing of the dam

10.1 Compulsory movements, Comprehensive Dam

Safety Reviews in Certain and electrical

Cases etc.) e)Site inspection and witnessing of

testing of gates, hoists and valves that fulfil dam and reservoir safety functions (íincluding their operating equipment, power control,

The comprehensive dam safety evaluation

should be compulsory in the case of:

(2 major modification to the original structure or design criteria;

Supplies and (b) discovery of an unusual condition

at the dam or reservoir rim; and and protection

telecommunication systems). Testing may not be necessary if the Dam

has an extreme hydrological or seismic

Owner completed and event. documented recent tests that

adequately requirements (both hydraulically and structurally; however, the operation and performance records for the tests should be reviewed in depth).

saisfy the test 10.2 Comprehensive Dam

Safety Review Procedures

The terms of reference of the comprehensive dam safety evaluation shall include but not limited to: Assessment of the adequacy of the

dam and its appurtenant structures,

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 160 of 190

er Se Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams L

January 2018

including all hoisting loacdings, update current material

properties. gates,

arrangements and valve systems that fulfil dam and reservoir safety functions, to safely perform to current intended functions for all

Terp Planning, secretarial and assistance

coordination of a visit of DSRP team for

loading conditions. The reviewers are unlikely to reanalyze the dams but may identify if there is a need for further analysis, design or assessment of an element of the

inspection of identified dams shall be done

by the concerned dam owner agency. Sufficient time (blocked period of visit) shall

be allocated for inspection of each dam

depending upon Size of dam and for

finalization of inspection report. The period

and timings for dam inspection must serve

the basic purpose of comprehensive review; it may sometime require the multiple

inspections.

facility and identify this as a dam safety issue.

g) Review

management system for its adcquacy and compatibility with current state of-the-art design

approach, surveillance, testing procedures and records, and

providing any, clarifications on

matters relating to operations or

dam safety to surveillance staff.

of the dam safety

methods and

operating. 10.3 Details to be provided to and

maintenance and DSRP before inspection

A memorandum for dam inspection shall be

prepared by the concerned dam manager/ Executive Enginer covering: the dam

salient features; recommendations of carlier h) Review previously identified dam

safety issues, and the adequacy of their resolution, or whether there are

impediments that prevent their

resolution.

safety inspections and compliances; design flood revisions; understanding of present

anticipated and any difficulties

the

remedial problems

measures encountered

and

being and n operation

i) Review of the organization of

operational infrastructure.

maintenance of dam. The memorandum

resources and shall be made available to cach member of

DSRP team for examination at least three months ahead of proposed inspection.

)Review of emergency preparedness procedures,

Cxercises, tacilities and equipment,

and implementation part with al

disaster

including training, If possible, owner agency must facilitate the

DSRP team to interact with experts who

had been involved in construction stage of

dam, important rehabilitations, any past Expert Group constituted for some need based unscheduled inspections etc. in order to have one to one interaction for

concern management

agencies

k) Review of known potential hazards and dam safety threats

Dam Hazard comprehensive assessment of past issues. )Review Classification

of the

The technical memorandum shall consist of m) Review of the outputs from the

identified potential failure modes

key

all relevant details/data/drawings for thec dam project to be inspected by the Pancl of Experts and in general includes:

and their performance indicators. determine the

appropriateness of the design loads

and conditions such as the need to (a) General Information

flood estimates, seismic i, Scope of project

revise

ii. Basic data and salient fearures

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 161 of 190

January 2018 Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams

ii. Issues related to safety of dam (e) Dam and Spillway

iv. Previous Inspection reports i. Special problems

v. Details of key personnel ii. Foundation including treatment

vi. All manuals i.e. Reservoir Operation Manual, Operation and Maintenance Manual, Sccurity Manual etc.

treatment of faults shear zones weak zones, curtain / consolidation

grouung, drainage provisions, any treatment, other special cutoff

vii. Emergency

Communications, Auxiliary Power, Downstrcam Warning system & Security of site.

preparedness trench, diaphragrm walls etc.

11. Design criteria and result of stability

analysis

iv. Special studies

Dynamic analysis etc.) (b) Hydrology (Finite element,

i. Description of drainage basin v. Design and drawings of spillway

gates, hoist arrangement, sluicegates,

emergency gates, auxiliary gates, review of adequacy of strength of

ii. Original inflow design flood report

ii. Highest observed inflow flood along with date and ime

exisang and hoisung gates arrangemernt especially in case older system not conforming to present

design criteria if any, auxiliary power

iv. Spillway capacity at FRL & original MWL

v. Elevation-Area-Capaciry of the reservoir arrangement etc.

vi. Bathymetry report/ data if any, t assess present gross and l1ve storage

vi Adequ2cy of design - from dam

safery consideraions of dam vii. Hydraulic design of Spillway and

Energy Dissipation Arrangements including past model study reporrs if .

()Geology including geology

geological reports i. Dam Site

any.

Vil. Instrumentatuoon i Qualiy and sufficiency of the

geological investigaions.

analysis and interpretation of instrumentation data including structural behavior

ii. Special problems and their treatment reports.

iv. Reservoir competency

geological report ix. Pre-construction material testing

reports including adequacy of field and

per as

v. Slope stability issues along reservoir laboratory invesugauons, appropriateness of materials selected

rim. etc.

(d) Layout including Drawings x. Post-construction testing reports, if i Dam any.

i. Spillway xi. Seismiciy Seismic Parameters approved by the National ii. Junction between Embankment &

Concrete/Masonry dams Committee on Seismic Design Parameters for Dams)

iv. River/Canal outlets Construction history

v. Instrumentaion g) Dam incidents/failures, remedial

measures/modifications undertaken

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD DS_07_v1.0 Page 162 of 190

Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams January 2018

h) Reservoir Operation & Regulation constitution and composition of the DSRP

shall be as follows: Plan

i. General a) Each DSRP shall consist of at least six

key experts- with one Chairman' and

others designated as 'members' as per the detail given in Table.10-1. The core

personnel shall be identificd based on

comprehensive expertise. For ensuring the continuity and workability, the core composition of

any team shall normally not be altered

except for compelling reasons.

. Reservoir filling

. Operation manual

iv. Water release protocol normal

condition and during floods. their dam safety

All these pertinent records (including design records, construction records along with in

recent operation and

with built drawings, maintenance records along

shall be made instrumentation data)

available at dam site during inspection by

the dam manager/Executive Engineer for

examination by the DSRP team.

b) During any evaluation by DSRP, one or

required disciplines of Central/State may be

included as additional member of

DSRP team for facilitating sufficiency need-based

the more experts from

Further investigation may be required prior to concluding a comprchensive dam safety

review. The investigation may include:

and for meeting requirements of domain expertise for

inspections. based

n special specific circumstances, on

where insufficient data exist, the dam may have to be surveyed and

new plans drawn

recommendations of the DSRP

Chairman, more experts shall also be

included in the team as 'special invitee'.

sampling and testing of materialsin the dam and its foundations in c) The members of DSRP may comprise

of working as well as retired officials

Central

the required conjunction geotechnical drilling and mapping

to

from the Government

State Governments, Organisations, Public Sector Undertakings, Reputed Private Institutions, reputed freelance

experts etc. The Chairman of any DSRP

team shall be a reputed expert having

proven credentials in dam safety area

along with adequate experience in

dealing with dam safety matters. The

minimum qualification and experience

of the other DSRP members as per the details given in the Table. 10-1. A

minimum of tifty percent of the

members of DSRP shall be from outside

calculation of new revised design flood and flood routing studies,

hydraulic model studies etc.

Any advance modelling to assess the

exact behavior of dam and predicted

forecasting of critical parameters;

may require in-situ various material

properties as inpuut

revision of seismic loadings

10.4 Composition of DSRP

of the State. Due to large number of dams in each State, the some of the States may have more than

one DSRP with a view to ensure and imely

completion of all specified comprehensive dam safety evaluation. In order to ensure

uniformity composition,

d) During the inspection by DSRP, DSRP

team shall be accompanied by an officer

of not less than a Chief Engineer/ General Manager in rank, of dam

owning agency, and wrap up meetingB of standardization

framework and

the for

Doc. No. cDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 163 of 190

January 2018 Guidelines for Safety Inspection ot Dams

shall be with the Head of Department. In case of any unscheduled inspection during hydrological or seismic event, wrap up meeting shall be with Principal Secretary/Executive Director of dam

owning agency

term and long term rehabilitations,

material testing, Physical modelling, Advanced Modelling ctc. (x) Key

Records/Information/Reports,

Key Drawings-original and modified

xii) Relevant photographs and detail

of videos

(xi)

DSRP will consist of the members of the Recommendations of DSRP may also

include: b)

following domain expertise:

i Dam Safety Specialist 1) emergency measures or any

actions, if required, to assure the4 immediate and long-term safery ot

i. Design Expert

11. Construction Supervision Expert the structure.

iv. Geologist

i1) related to design, construction,

operation, monitoring and evaluation, and

inspection of the structure, if

required.

remedial measures and actions v. Hydrologist

vi. Hydro - Mechanical Expert maintenance,

vii. Instrumentation Expert

vii. Seismic Expert

Members of DSRP shall have sufficient ii) investigations and analyses, if

required.

additional detailed studies, experience in the field of safety of dams

preferably from the areas of dam-design,

hydro-mechanical engineering. hydrology geo-technical instrumentation, seismic, dam-rehabilitation or such other field ctc. The requirement and minimum qualifications of various members of the DSRP are described in Table 10-1.

iv improvements maintenance and inspection of

dam, if required.

recommendations for investigations, in routine

v)short-term and long-term risk reduction measures (structural well

as non-structural), and comments 10.5 Reports of

Comprehensive Safety Evaluation

on time frame for their

implementation c) After dam inspection visit by DSRP,

a wrap up meeting shall be arranged by dam owner, wherein head of

department along with concern Chief Engineer, and his/her complete team dealing with dam matters shall attend it. In case unscheduled dam safety inspection i.e. unusual flood event or seismic event, wrap meeting shall be arranged with concern Principal Secretary or higher rank official in case of Water Resources Department, or with CMD in case of Public Sector

Separate report shall be prepared by DSRP for each inspected dam, and shall include, but not limited to:

a) The outlines of Comprehensive Dam

Safety Review report should include these Chapters, ) Description of

dam and its operation, (i) Evaluation

of Design, Construction and Analysis detail, (ii) Inspection, Testing and

Examination Detail, (iv) Hydrologic Review, (v) Seismic Review, (vi) Instrumentation and Evaluation, (vii) Risk Consequences, (viii) Future

Performance Undertakings, with highest authority in case of privare owner to apPpraise Monitoring, (ix)

Recommendaions; issues for short

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 164 of 190

Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dama

critical issues experlenced by the

DSRP OpovmorH And lold eraeoned lumllar with the dam and in ooraton shoulkd

or the d) The report shall be prepared by

oln the T'eam OXAmnalon They nhould he

DSRP team jolntly within a reasonable time after completing the visit, and ench report shall be slgned by every member of the DSRP team before its submissicon to the Water

CApablo o anAworlng or obtalning AnAwOrH t0 quostlons the Toam may

have coneernlng KIBUng COndilon Ancd the operatlon of the da,

b) Dam Inapection shall ho earrled ou

by DSRP an por thone Guldeinen for

Safoty lnapocthon of Dams-covering

inspection items brought out in Annexure-1, and foCuning on features, CVents and evidence an brought out in

Annexurc-|| of this chapter,

Resources Department or Dam Safety Organization of the State an well as further onward transmission,

c) In case final report submisslon by DSRP needs more time, an lInterim

highlightingReport Various issues needs to be important

submitted within two months from the date of dam inspection visit and final report submission may be discusscd with concern dam owner,

The DSRP will be advisory in

function and provicde an expert

opinion on nafety condition8 of the clam and various studies eonducted

recommendations8

C)

as well as CDSO in case DSRP has And give been constiruted by CDSO under special conditions.

SUuggestions for further improvement and rehabilitation recquirements.

of implementation "ehabilitation project for any dam, all

necessary reviews must have bcen

completed and the review pancl's

d) For ny 10.6 Roles and the

Responsibilities of Dam Safety Review Panel

recommencdations must havc becn The roles and the responsibilities shall

include as under. eliscussed with the (Chief Ingincer and Senior Officers of Water Resources

Safety Dam Department Organisation.

a) DSRP members shall have the desirec and

and ability to make a comprchensive review of all data related to the dam

thorough onsite

examination. They should be capable

of making in-depth evaluations and

arriving logical conclusions. DSRP

should be observant, have good

analytical reasoning, and not bc

disconcerted when confronted with

Any rchalbilitation work propo8al to

be undertaken by a dam owner must include the DSRP.

C) and make a

recommendations of

In cases, where 1DSRP after the comprchensive dam safcty cvaluation recommends a remeclial action, the State Dam Safety Organisation shall pursue with the concerned owner of the large dam to ensure that remeclial measures arc carriccd out in time, for which thc concernecl clam owner shall

voluminous detail. They should be to concentrate on

and safety

conditions able considerations conducive to dam failures and be alert

for changed conditions Team suspicious,

non-complacent, SOund

members should be provide adequate funds. inquisitive, methodical, and

engineering judgment. They should have an independence view and avoid

quick,

In cascs whcre thcre are unresolved 8) points or issucs that emerged berween DSRP and the owner of the dam, the matter shall be referrecd to the State

possess

unfounded conclusions.

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0 Page 165 of 190

Guicdelines for Safety Inspection of Dams anuary 2018

safety experts. Appropriate communication

is sent to concern expert and the dam

owning agencies that have engaged them as

DSRP Members.

Dam Safety Organisation, and in case, no agreemeni is arrived at, the matter

shall be referred to the Central Dam

Safety Organisation (CDSO) which shall give requircd guidance wherever

and necessary send their recommendations to the State GOvemment concerned for their

implementation.

10.7 Empanelment of Members

of DSRP

CDSO will maintain a register ot

accredited experts who may be appointed as members of the DSRP by the States/ dam Owners. Accreditation of DSRP

be done by Committee

members will the

Empanclment Chairmanship of Member (D&R), CWC.

Basic information about the potential panel members is collected by CDSO through

online invitation of application on official

web site of CDSO/CWC and submitted to

under the

the Committee for approval. The Committee after the review may seek any

additional information as necessary and

evaluate the candidate based on the

defined criteria and recommend the

for suitability empanelment as a member of DSRP and

will upload the detail of empaneled experts

on official web site for the reference of

of the candidate

dam owners.

DSRP members are enrolled for a initial

period of 3 years. The performance of the

DSRP members to be reviewed based on

the dam safety evaluation reports

submitted by them, their readiness for

pertorming the assigned evaluations in the

defined ime frame and the quality of the

recommendations and suggestions, as well

as feedback of danm owners.

The Empanelment Committee considers

and the pertormance evaluations determines the renewal of the accreditation

for a further period of 3 years or dropping

their names from the list of accredited dam

Doc. No. CDSO_GUD DS_07_v1.0 Page 166 of 190

Guidelines tor Satety Inspection of Dams Anuary 2018

Table 10-1. Minimum Qualification Criteria for the Members of DSRP

S1. Minimum No. Experts Experience Qualification

Experience in handling dam safety related issues

of minimum of 5 number of large dam projects

Additional weightage in case cundicdate hacd been a

member of to

B.E./B.Tech. or cquivalent degree in Civil Engg. Preferably Master Degree in Geotechnical

Engg/ Geological Engg /Water Resources Engineering/Hydrology or Master degree in Geology or Engincering

Geology

m that handled disasters of any

ype (cspecially related to cdam disasters) at

national and international level.

Have ar least 15 ycars of relatecd expericnce in

design, construction, safety evaluation, and/or

operation of dams. IExperience of rehabilitatlon of

old dam

Dam Safety

Expert 1.

structures Would Aet aclditional

weightage. Professional expcricnce of inspection of dams,

instrumentation, emergency action planning ctc.

Experience in planning and designs for minimum

of five large cdam projects. B.E./B. Tech. or equivalent degree in Civil Engg. Preferably Master

Degree in Structural

Engg./ Hydraulic Engg. / Water Resources

Development

Have at least 15 years of relatecl expericnce in

planning and design of large clam projccts.

Experience of rehabilitation of old dam structurcs

would get additional weightage.

Design Expert

Experience of Construction, Work Supervision and Quality Assurance for a minimum of 5 large

B.E./B. Tech. or dams. cquivalent in Civil Engg.

Preferably Master Degree

in Structural Engg. /

Hydraulic Engg. / Water

Resources Development

Experience of rchabilitation of old dam strucrurcs

would get additional weightage. Professional experience of at least 15 years in

construction of dam projects.

Construction

Supervision Expert

3.

Master Degree in

Geology / Engineering

Geology

Experience of hanclling various geological aspccts

of minimum of 5 large dam projects.

Professional expericnce of ar least 15 ycars in

dealing with enginecring gerological aspects of water resources projects

Geologist

Experience in dealing with hydrological planning of major dam projects especially design flood

estimation, review of design floodl, design storm

inputs, secdimentation aspccts ctc. ot at least 10

large dam projects.

Additional weightage for an expert having exposure to various relevant hydrological

modelling tools, work done for dam break

modelling, inundation mapping, development of emergency action plan ancd its implementation etc.

Professional experience af at least l5 years in

denling with hyclrological aspects of water resources projects

B.E./B. Tech. or

cquivalent in Civil Engg, Preferably Master Degree

in Hydrology / Hydraulic Engg. 7 Water Resources

Development

. Hydrologist

Hydro Mechanical

B.E./B. Tech. or

cquivalent. in Civil/ Mech. Engg, Preferably

Experience in planning and design of Gates &

Hoists for a minimum of 5 large dam projects. .

Expert

Page 167 of 190 Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0

anuary 2018 Guidelines for Satety Inspection of Dams

SI. Minimum Experience Experts Qualification

Master Degree in Structural Engg. / \Water

Resourees Development

No. IExperience in rehabilitation of spillway gates,

under-sluice gates, emergency gates, ercction of

H.M. works etc. would get acdditional weightage.

Demonstrate relevant experience during the last

10 years prior to empanclment

Professional expericnce of at least 15 ycars in

designs of HM Works of large dam projects and

cspecially works done at detail cngincering

projects and rehabilitation HM works done,

lExperience in planning and installation of all kinds of dam instruments for a minimum of three

B.E./B.Tech. or large dam projects. equivalent in Civil Engg Prefcrably Master Degree

in Structural Engg./ Water Resources

Demonstrate relevant experience during the last

10 years prior to applying for empanelment.

Experience of rehabilitation of old dam structurcs

would get additional weightage.

Professional experiene of at lcast 20 years in

design of dam projects.

Instrumentauon 7.

Expert

Devclopment, or Master Degree in Physics

Expcrience in planning and designs for minimum

of five large dam projects accounting for scismic

loadings, having thc exposure of time history

series as well as scismic spectra will be an

additional advantage. Also work done for site

specific seismic design parameters would be given

additional weightage

B.E./B. Tech. or equivalent in Civil Engg

Preferably Master Degree

in Structural Engg. / Physics./ Water Resources Development or Master degree in

Geology/ Engineering Geology

8 Seismic Expert Demonsrate relevant cxperience during the last

10 years prior to applying for empanelment.

Experience of rehabilitation of old dam structures

would get additional weightage.

Professional experience of at least 15 years in

design of dam projects.

Experience in architectural planning, design and landscaping of Water Resources Projects

Additional weightage for any work relatedto tourism development done for any dam which

may include planning, design, supervision during construction, and any other works rclated to it

Professional experience of at least 15 years in activities related to Architecrure planning and

landscaping Demonstrate relevant experience during the last

10 years prior to applying for empanelment

Architecture

PlanningLandscaping Expert

B.Arch. degree in

Architecture and Planning preferably M. Arch degree in architecture

and

9.

Note: The DSRP «spert hsted at Si. No.9 shall be part of DSRP team in case dam is having Tourism

Component or derelopment of Tourism Component is being proposed by dam owning agengy keeping in view the

tourism potential as well as financial implication etc

Page 168 of 190 Doc. No. CDSO_GUD_DS_07_v1.0