using minitab for re
DESCRIPTION
Using minitab for reliabilityTRANSCRIPT
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
Reliability Estimation Using Minitab
IE 7270 Reliability Estimation Fall 2010
GS WASSERMAN
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
Using Minitab
MINITABHAS TWO MAIN WINDOWS –
A SESSION WINDOW and A WORKSHEET WINDOW
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
PART ONE:Generate Dataset
Weibull-Step 1
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004 PART ONE:
Generate Dataset
Weibull-Step 2
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004 PART ONE:
Generate Dataset
Lognormal-Step 2
ln tmed
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004 PART TWO:
Data Analysis
Most widelyUsed procedure
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
Time or Failure
Gives:-MLE or LSXY-Confidence level
Distribution to fit:
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
STAT > REL. PARAMETRIC – RIGHT CENSORING
15001000500
99
95
90
80
70
60
50 40
30
20
10
5
1
Time to Failure
Per
cen
t
Probability Plot for TimeNormal Distribution - ML Estimates - 95.0% CI
Censoring Column in Censored = 0
LocationScale
MTTFStDev
MedianIQR
FailureCensor
AD*
946.19 124.11
946.19 124.11
946.19 167.43
5 1
1.9995
15001000500
99
95
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
5
1
Time to Failure
Per
cent
Probability Plot for TimeNormal Distribution - ML Estimates - 95.0% CI
Censoring Column in Censored = 0
LocationScale
MTTFStDev
MedianIQR
FailureCensor
AD*
946.19 124.11
946.19 124.11
946.19 167.43
5 1
1.9995
V13 output shown here
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
Column of Censor Flags
For multiply-censoredData, create a column of Indicator variables – 0 or 1-- to denote censored or not!
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
OPTIONS
• Graph
• Maximum Likelihood or Rank Regression
NOTE: In Minitab V15,the plotting position optionsare found in Tools ..> Optionson the main menu. Select probabilityplots, and explore the options within!
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
STAT > REL. PARAMETRIC – RIGHT CENSORING
Distribution Analysis: Time
Variable: Time
Censoring Information Count
Uncensored value 5
Right censored value 1
Censoring value: Censored = 0 = 0
Estimation Method: Maximum Likelihood
Distribution: WeibullParameter Estimates
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Parameter Estimate Error Lower Upper
Shape 8.91335 3.07276 4.53525 17.5179
Scale 989.515 50.6525 895.056 1093.94
Log-Likelihood = -31.823
Goodness-of-Fit
Anderson-Darling (adjusted) = 3.089
Characteristics of Distribution
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Estimate Error Lower Upper
Mean(MTTF) 936.625 52.8708 838.527 1046.20
Standard Deviation 125.579 37.9430 69.4595 227.040
Median 949.652 52.9506 851.341 1059.32
First Quartile(Q1) 860.433 66.2041 739.986 1000.49
Third Quartile(Q3) 1026.45 51.5637 930.202 1132.65
Interquartile Range(IQR) 166.016 53.3979 88.3823 311.841
Table of Percentiles
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Percent Percentile Error Lower Upper
1 590.588 114.953 403.279 864.896
2 638.711 107.747 458.894 888.990
3 668.820 102.734 494.948 903.771
4 691.158 98.8003 522.274 914.651
5 709.092 95.5254 544.544 923.363
6 724.172 92.7022 563.479 930.690
7 737.242 90.2104 580.036 937.054
8 748.818 87.9742 594.803 942.711
9 759.237 85.9418 608.171 947.827
10 768.733 84.0766 620.411 952.515
20 836.256 70.7763 708.432 987.144
30 881.437 62.4473 767.161 1012.74
40 917.684 56.7372 812.955 1035.91
50 949.652 52.9506 851.341 1059.32
60 979.858 50.9185 884.973 1084.92
70 1010.34 50.7807 915.556 1114.93
80 1043.78 53.0748 944.772 1153.17
90 1086.58 59.5762 975.864 1209.85
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004 STAT > REL. PARAMETRIC –
RIGHT CENSORINGWeibull – Rank Regression
Time
Perc
ent
1500
100090
080
070
060
050
040
030
0
99
90807060504030
20
10
5
3
2
1
Table of Statistics
Median 941.991IQR 193.816Failure 5Censor 1AD* 3.010
Shape
Correlation 0.971
7.56295Scale 988.765Mean 928.587StDev 145.190
Probability Plot for Time
Censoring Column in Censored = 0 - LSXY EstimatesWeibull - 95% CI
Distribution Analysis: Time
Variable: Time
Censoring Information Count
Uncensored value 5
Right censored value 1
Censoring value: Censored = 0 = 0
Estimation Method: Least Squares (failure time(X) on rank(Y))
Distribution: Weibull
Parameter Estimates
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Parameter Estimate Error Lower Upper
Shape 7.56295 3.29313 3.22146 17.7554
Scale 988.765 59.5474 878.679 1112.64
Log-Likelihood = -31.929
Goodness-of-Fit
Anderson-Darling (adjusted) = 3.010
Correlation Coefficient = 0.971
Characteristics of Distribution
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Estimate Error Lower Upper
Mean(MTTF) 928.587 61.4105 815.698 1057.10
Standard Deviation 145.190 55.5404 68.5997 307.293
Median 941.991 62.0240 827.943 1071.75
First Quartile(Q1) 838.588 82.4504 691.605 1016.81
Third Quartile(Q3) 1032.40 63.1884 915.697 1163.99
Interquartile Range(IQR) 193.816 79.2151 86.9949 431.804
Table of Percentiles
Standard 95.0% Normal CI
Percent Percentile Error Lower Upper
1 538.188 149.414 312.335 927.360
2 590.240 140.790 369.821 942.031
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
STAT > DISTRIBUTION ID
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
STAT > DISTRIBUTION ID OUTPUT
Time
Perc
ent
12501000750500
90
50
10
1
Time
Perc
ent
1200900600
99
90
50
10
1
Time
Perc
ent
10000100010010
90
50
10
1
Time
Perc
ent
15001000500
99
90
50
10
1
Correlation CoefficientWeibull0.971
Lognormal0.985
Exponential*
Loglogistic0.982
Probability Plot for TimeLSXY Estimates-Censoring Column in Censored = 0
Weibull Lognormal
Exponential Loglogistic
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
Distribution (adj) Coefficient• Weibull 3.010 0.971• Lognormal 2.966 0.985• Exponential 4.846 *• Loglogistic 2.972 0.982• 3-Parameter Weibull 3.006 0.983• 3-Parameter Lognormal 2.962 0.985• 2-Parameter Exponential 3.091 *• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 2.967 0.983• Smallest Extreme Value 3.041 0.965• Normal 2.958 0.985• Logistic 2.960 0.982
• Table of Percentiles• Standard 95% Normal CI• Distribution Percent Percentile Error Lower Upper• Weibull 1 538.188 149.414 312.335 927.360• Lognormal 1 629.833 118.034 436.220 909.379• Exponential 1 7.76524 2.90518 3.72991 16.1663• Loglogistic 1 589.331 126.776 386.588 898.398• 3-Parameter Weibull 1 749.089 5.91779 746.971 760.778• 3-Parameter Lognormal 1 611.877 137.129 343.109 880.644• 2-Parameter Exponential 1 771.599 0.847374 769.939 773.261• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 1 569.976 145.153 285.481 854.472• Smallest Extreme Value 1 437.715 239.707 -32.1025 907.532• Normal 1 579.636 172.859 240.840 918.433• Logistic 1 518.562 196.889 132.666 904.457
• Weibull 5 667.625 124.906 462.681 963.350• Lognormal 5 705.210 99.1708 535.325 929.008• Exponential 5 39.6310 14.8270 19.0361 82.5071• Loglogistic 5 693.414 102.899 518.416 927.485• 3-Parameter Weibull 5 757.883 19.9768 746.971 798.066• 3-Parameter Lognormal 5 697.362 110.129 481.513 913.212• 2-Parameter Exponential 5 779.260 4.32469 770.829 787.782• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 5 686.298 111.843 467.091 905.506• Smallest Extreme Value 5 634.819 162.917 315.507 954.131• Normal 5 683.597 129.462 429.856 937.339• Logistic 5 668.119 134.911 403.699 932.539
• Weibull 10 734.291 108.985 548.947 982.213• Lognormal 10 749.013 87.9662 595.007 942.881• Exponential 10 81.4052 30.4558 39.1017 169.476• Loglogistic 10 746.392 89.8963 589.450 945.119• 3-Parameter Weibull 10 769.478 31.8354 746.971 834.474• 3-Parameter Lognormal 10 745.393 95.3475 558.515 932.270• 2-Parameter Exponential 10 789.303 8.88327 772.082 806.907• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 10 743.418 95.4027 556.432 930.404• Smallest Extreme Value 10 721.865 130.201 466.676 977.054• Normal 10 739.019 107.967 527.407 950.631• Logistic 10 735.819 109.039 522.105 949.532
• Weibull 50 941.991 62.0240 827.943 1071.75• Lognormal 50 926.423 64.8013 807.736 1062.55• Exponential 50 535.550 200.363 257.243 1114.95• Loglogistic 50 926.803 64.9904 807.790 1063.35• 3-Parameter Weibull 50 896.636 75.0375 760.993 1056.46• 3-Parameter Lognormal 50 929.586 64.6516 802.871 1056.30• 2-Parameter Exponential 50 898.486 58.4414 790.944 1020.65• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 50 929.281 64.8025 802.271 1056.29• Smallest Extreme Value 50 949.673 60.3403 831.408 1067.94• Normal 50 934.518 64.4412 808.216 1060.82• Logistic 50 934.894 64.4584 808.558 1061.23
• Table of MTTF
• Standard 95% Normal CI• Distribution Mean Error Lower Upper• Weibull 928.587 61.411 815.698 1057.10• Lognormal 939.255 67.278 816.230 1080.82• Exponential 772.635 289.063 371.123 1608.54• Loglogistic 941.771 67.159 818.926 1083.04• 3-Parameter Weibull 963.863 116.291 760.882 1220.99• 3-Parameter Lognormal 937.329 65.727 808.508 1066.15• 2-Parameter Exponential 955.485 84.313 803.735 1135.89• 3-Parameter Loglogistic 939.558 65.914 810.370 1068.75• Smallest Extreme Value 924.193 65.442 795.929 1052.46• Normal 934.518 64.441 808.216 1060.82• Logistic 934.894 64.458 808.558 1061.23
STAT > DISTRIBUTION ID SESSION OUTPUT
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGDEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL &MANUFACTURING ENGINEERINGMANUFACTURING ENGINEERING
IE 7270: Reliability EstimationIE 7270: Reliability EstimationFall 2004Fall 2004
DISTRIBUTION OVERVIEW• WEIBULL – RANK REGRESSION
Time
PD
F
12501000750500
0.003
0.002
0.001
0.000
Time
Perc
ent
12501000750500
90
50
10
1
Time
Perc
ent
12501000750500
100
50
0
Time
Rate
12501000750500
0.03
0.02
0.01
0.00
Table of Statistics
Median 941.991IQR 193.816Failure 5Censor 1AD* 3.010
Shape
Correlation 0.971
7.56295Scale 988.765Mean 928.587StDev 145.190
Probability Density Function
Survival Function Hazard Function
Distribution Overview Plot for TimeLSXY Estimates-Censoring Column in Censored = 0
Weibull