using helianthus annuus seeds to solve a...
TRANSCRIPT
P
age1
Using Helianthus annuus Seeds to Solve A Mystery
Name: Supreet Babbar
Student Number: 999739074
Practical Section: 12
Teaching Assistant: Chris Kong-Kee
Submission Date: November 19th, 2012
P
age2
Introduction:
Forensic botany is the use of botanical evidence in criminal investigation. The recognition, collection and
preservation of plant materials can play a vital role in determining the manner or time of death. It can also be used
to investigate if the death was accidental, a suicide or a homicide (Coyle et al, 2005). This concept of forensic
botany can be applied to the case of Roger T. Peterson‟s suspicious death. The victim‟s body was found under a
tree behind his store. In addition to the evidence for the blunt force trauma to the body, Helianthus annuus seeds
were found on and around the body (Rush et al. 2012). These seeds were compared to the seeds collected from the
home the prime lead suspect. In order to prove that the suspect was at the scene of crime, it was necessary to
answer the question if the two seed samples collected as evidence were similar. Confirmation or the rejection of
the two seed samples being similar is not enough to prove that the suspect is guilty or innocent. In this investigation
environmental factors such as temperature and moisture were not taken into account, although they have shown to
affect the physical characteristics of Helianthus annuus. Based on other circumstantial evidence collected including
fingerprints of Bobby Walden found at the cash and on the back door, along with his habit of leaving a trail of
Helianthus annuus seeds and his history of petty thefts it is hypothesized that he was at the scene of the crime and
the prime suspect of this case. In addition statistical analysis of the seed samples was also conducted. The
hypothesis is test by comparing the calculated sample t test value to the critical value. If the sample t statistic was
greater than the critical value, this data demonstrates that the two seed samples from the victim and suspect are
different, rejecting the null hypothesis. The hypothesis is test by comparing the calculated sample t test value to the
critical value. If the sample t statistic was lower than the critical value, then this data demonstrates that the two seed
samples from the victim and suspect are the same, failing to reject the null hypothesis.
Abstract:
The purpose of the experiment was to analyze the seed evidence collected from the victim and the suspect
to help solve the murder case of Roger T. Peterson. It was hypothesized that Bobby Walden, the prime suspect, had
a role to play in the death of the victim and had been at the scene of the crime. The circumstantial evidence
targeting Bobby Walden, were his fingerprints found in the store and the trail of his favourite snack, Helianthus
annuus seeds. A total of thirty five seeds each were collected from Bobby Waldon‟s house and from on and around
the victim‟s body. The length (in mm), width (in mm), depth (in mm), weight (in grams) and volume (in mm3) of
P
age3
all seeds were recorded and transferred to an Excel spreadsheet. The mean, standard error value, standard deviance,
and variation values were generated through the calculations based on the measured characteristics. In addition, the
sample t statistic values were calculated for the measured characteristic of the seeds collected from the suspect and
the victim. The t statistic values were found to be higher than the t critical value (more than 1.995). This confirms
the rejection of the null hypothesis, indicating that the seed sample characteristics of those of the victim and
suspects were different. Furthermore, it would be unfair to implicate the suspect as having been at the scene of
crime when the victim died, as his seeds did not match up to seeds found at the crime scene.
Method
On the morning of August 15, 2012, at Highland Creek, Roger T. Peterson was found murdered in his pet
store. Helianthus annuus seeds were collected from around the body of the victim and from the house of the prime
suspect, Bobby Walden. The seeds were sent to the Forensic Botany Department at UTSC to help with the
investigation of this mysterious death. A total of thirty-five seeds each were collected and analyzed from the
suspect and of those found near the victim. The botanists were divided into two groups and were provided
randomly with packets of Helianthus annuus seeds. The packet contained six to seven Helianthus annuus seeds. A
marker was used to number the seeds in the packets provided to the forensic botanist to analyze. The botanist used
a ruler to measure the length (in mm), width (in mm) and depth (in mm) of the seeds. The volume was calculated
by using the following formula, V = 4π/3 (length/2)(width/2)(depth/2). The mass of each seed was measured by
using a top-loading balance (in grams). All the measurements were recorded on the “Data Sheet” (Rush et al.
2012). The data of the seeds where transferred to an Excel spreadsheet and the descriptive statistics were
calculated (mean, maximum, minimum, standard deviation, variance etc.). A t-test (Mean 1 – Mean 2|/√ (SEM12 +
SEM22) was constructed to compare the measurement variables (length, width, volume, depth and weight) of the
Helianthus annuus seeds taken from the suspect to those collected from the victim. The t statistic values were
compared to the critical values, in order to determine if Mr. Walden was present at the scene of crime where the
body was found and could be a potential lead suspect in the case.
Results:
P
age4
The characteristic of length, width and depth of Helianthus annuus seeds from the suspect and the victim
were compared and analyzed and. The measured characteristics were compared against the descriptive statistics,
which included the mean, standard deviation, minimum and maximum values of both samples (Refer to Table 1).
From this constructed table, the values obtained for length, width and depth of the seeds were shown to have
perceptible different between the victim and suspects seeds. The mean value for length, width and depth were
notably higher for seeds collected from the suspect in comparison to the seeds found on and around the victim. The
maximum and minimum measurement values of the data set for length, width and depth are consistently higher in
the seeds of the suspect than of the victim. In addition, the values for standard in terms of length, width and depth
were larger for the seeds of the suspects in relation to those of the victim.
P
age5
Table 1: Measurement Characteristics of Helianthus annuus Seeds collected from the Victim and the Suspect
Length (mm) Width (mm) Depth (mm)
Victim Suspect Victim Suspect Victim Suspect
Minimum
10 11 5 4 2 2
Maximum
18
20 9 10 5 8
Mean
12.26 14.67 7.01 8. 3.74 4.44
Standard
Deviance
1.591
2.03 1.11 1.705 0.785 1.29
P
age6
Using Excel, the variance, standard deviation and SEM were calculated for the measurement
characteristics of the seeds found on the victim and seeds collected from the suspect. The student t-test was created
for each of the measurement variables (Table 2). From the experiment, the degree of freedom for length, width, and
depth was calculated as 68. Subsequently, the „critical t‟ at p=0.05 was determined to be 1.995. The value of the
„sample t‟ was constructed for each of the measurements described above. The values of the „sample t‟ for each
characteristic were interpreted and were found to be notably higher than the value of critical t. This led to the
rejection of Ho (null hypothesis).
Similarly a statistical test was also conducted for weight and volume (Table 3). The degree of freedom for
both variables was calculated to be 68. In addition the critical value remained the same as 1.995. For both
measurements the „critical t‟ value was notable smaller than the sample t value, resulting in the rejection of the null
hypothesis.
P
age7
Table 2: t -Test Analysis for Measurements (Length, Width, Depth) of Helianthus annuus collected from the Victim and the Suspect
P
age8
Table 3: t Test Analysis for Measurements (Volume, Weight)of Helianthus annuus Seeds Collected from the Victim and the Suspect
P
age9
Moreover, the means of the volume and weight of the seeds were graphed to compare the finding of the
victim to the suspect‟s seed. Figure 1 demonstrates the mean volume (mm3) of the suspect and victim seeds, along
with respective error bars representing one standard derivation of the mean. Through this representation, it is
demonstrated that the mean of the suspect seeds are much higher in contrast to the seeds collected from the victim.
In addition, the standard deviation of the suspect‟s seeds mean volume was significantly larger than the deviation of
the victim‟s seeds mean volume. Figure 2 demonstrates the mean weight (in grams) of the seeds from the suspect
and the seeds collected from the victim, along with respective error bars representing one standard derivation of the
mean. The mean weight of the suspect‟s seed was noticeable higher than victim‟s seeds. Furthermore, the standard
deviation of the mean weight of the seeds collected from the suspect was also larger than the deviation of the mean
weight of the seeds from the victim.
P
age1
0
Figure 1: The mean volume of Helianthus annuus seeds collected from the victim and the suspect. The Error bars
represents one standard deviation of the mean (N=35 seeds)
Figure 2: The mean weight of Helianthus annuus seeds for victim and suspect. The Error bars represents one
standard deviation of the mean (N=35 seeds)
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
0.18
Victim Suspect
Vo
lum
e (
mm
3)
Seeds
Series1
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Victim Suspect
We
igh
t (g
)
Seeds
average
P
age1
1
Discussion:
The sample t statistic for each measurement of the Helianthus annuus seed was found to be more than the
critical t statistic value, rejecting the null hypothesis. This implies that the seed sample of the victim and of the
suspects do not show any correlation between each other. Since the seed samples of both suspect and victim vary in
length, weight, volume, depth and width, it can be concluded that Mr. Walden was not present at the scene of the
crime. Therefore, the results do not validate the hypothesis. There are external factor that influence may have
contributed to the errors in calculating dimensions and mass of the Helianthus annuus seeds. For instance,
carbonization, a process that involves an increase temperature, aids in preserving plant parts has been known to
alter the dimensions (length, width, height) and mass of sunflower seeds (Braadbaart et al, 2007). The seed samples
used in the study may have been exposed to various unaccounted for environmental conditions, including variations
in temperature and moisture content of air (humidity); which may have affected their physical characteristics.
Correction factors need to be applied in order to determine the accurate dimensions of the seeds. It is also possible
that the seed evidence may have been depreciated, dried, molded, creating alterations in its initial form (Coyle et al,
2005). Consequently, the dimensions of the seed may have been altered. Another implication that may have caused
errors in the resulting data is the moisture the seeds were exposed to. The bulk density of Helianthus annuus seeds
decreases with the increase in moisture content (Gupta et al. 1996).
Potential errors encountered during the experiment include parallax error while taking measurements. The
instrument used for measurement was not accurate for lengths less than one millimetre. Additional information for
this research could be acquired through more sophisticated means such as microscopy to see the finer details on the
seeds and also using plant DNA testing (Coyle et al, 2005). To conclude, the sunflower seeds collected from the
body do not prove that Bobby Walden had been present at the scene of the death of Mr. Peterson. The analysis of
the Helianthus annuus seed evidence showed that the seeds found near the body were different than the seeds
collected from Bobby Walden. Overall the size measurements were larger for the seed samples from the suspect as
compared to the victim. As larger seeds are used for human consumption and smaller seeds are for pets (birds etc.),
it is very likely that the seeds found near the body were from the bird feeder found near the body.
P
age1
2
Citations:
Braadbaart F, Wright P.J. 2007. Changes in Mass and Dimensions of Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) Achenes
and Seeds Due to Carbonization. Economic Botany. 61 (2): 137-153
Coyle HM., Lee CL, Lin WY, Lee HC, Palmbach TM. 2005. Forensic Botany: Using Plant Evidence to Aid in
Forensic Death Investigation. Croat Med J. 46(4):606-612.
Gupta R.K., Das S.K. 1996. Physical Properties of Sunflower Seeds. J . agric . Engng Res. 66(1):1 – 8
Rush S, Gladilina E, Olavasen, M, and Marushia R. 2012. BIO A01-Introductory Biology Lab Manual for Fall
2012. Toronto, Ontario: University of Toronto Scarborough Printing Services. pp. 33-38.