usa v. keys: plaintiff motions in limine

8/20/2019 USA v. Keys: Plaintiff Motions in Limine

1/168

6T.]. KIA #6 R D XRLLE LE AL]]

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODRToitdn ]tftds FttlrodyKF^^JDP N. ]D@FAXFTA JDKD]F^JFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrodys486 I ]trddt, ]uitd 68-688]fmrfkdotl, MF 94:6>^dadpjlod7 (965) 44>-2088Efmsikiad7 (965) 44>-2988

AD]AID R. MFANPDAAFssistfot Fttlrody @dodrfaToitdn ]tftds Ndpfrtkdot le Gustimd, Mrikiofa NivisiloGFKD] ]IAUDRNdputy Mjide elr Aiti`ftiloMlkputdr Mrikd fon Iotdaadmtufa Xrlpdrty ]dmtiloPfsjio`tlo, NM 284=8^dadpjlod7 (282) 46>-6825

Fttlrodys elr XafiotieeToitdn ]tftds le Fkdrimf

IO ^JD TOI^DN ]^F^D] NI]^RIM^ MLTR^

DF]^DRO NI]^RIM^ LE MFAIELROIF

TOI^DN ]^F^D] LE FKDRIMF,

Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.

MF]D OL. 276=-MR-:2 CGK

TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #6RD@FRNIO@ XRLLE LE AL]]

NF^D7 ]dptdkbdr 24, 2864ÎKD7 9788 f.k.MLTR^7 Jlo. Cikbdray G. Kudaadr

^jd Toitdn ]tftds klvds elr fo io aikiod ruaio` lo tjd fnkissibiaity le tjd dvindomd it wiaa leedr

tl prlvd tjd alss dadkdot le tjd mjfr d̀ io Mluot 2 le tjd ]updrsdnio` Ionimtkdot. ^jd Toitdn ]tftds

iotdons tl leedr dvindomd tjft bdtwddo Lmtlbdr 2:, 2868 tjrlu`j Gfoufry 4, 2868, Cdys’s mlursd le

mlonumt mfusdn alss io tjd klodtfry vfaud le tjd tikd tjft sfafridn dkpalydds spdot iovdsti`ftio` fon

rdsplonio`. ^jd prlle wiaa bd prleedrdn mjrlolalìmfaay. Eirst, Elx >8 dkpalydds wiaa tdstiey fblut

tjdir tikd-mlosukio` deelrts tl indotity fon stlp tjd pdrpdtrftlr le fttfmcs tjft bd`fo sllo fetdr Cdys

wfs eirdn. Ft tjd tikd, tjdy mluan olt prlvd Cdys wfs bdjion tjd mlonumt, but io tjd mlursd le ndoyio`

rdsplosibiaity, Cdys prdnimtdn tjft Foloyklus wfs ̀ lio` tl fttfmc ^jd Als Fo`dads ̂ ikds. ^jft

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :- 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ( =B )


2/168

2T.]. KIA #6 R D XRLLE LE AL]]

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

jfppdodn, le mlursd, fon Cdys wfs bdjion it. Io tjd sdmlon pfrt le tjd @lvdrokdot’s mfsd, ^ribuod

Mlkpfoy ioelrkftilo tdmjolal`y dkpalydds wiaa tdstiey fblut tjd tikd tjft tjdy spdot rdsplonio`,

mlonumtio` f nfkf`d fssdsskdot, fon rdstlrio` tjd systdk.

Nurio` tjd leedosd, Elx >8 fon tjd ^jd Als Fo`dads îkds wdrd bltj pfrt le ^ribuod Mlkpfoy

fon sjfrdn tjd sfkd odtwlrc fon alìo mrdndotifas. ^jd ]updrsdnio` Ionimtkdot mjfr`ds tjft

ndedonfot’s mlursd le mlonumt afstdn bdtwddo Lmtlbdr 2:, 2868 fon Gfoufry 4, 2868. (]updrsdnio`

Ionimtkdot ft Mluot 6, µ 6(j)3 Mluot 2, µµ 6-2). ^jd prlpdr ioquiry elr tjd gury is wjft f``rd`ftd

nfkf`d Cdys mfusdn io tjft pdriln. Mrdftivd Mlkputio` v. @dtalfndn.mlk AAM , =:5 E.=n 9=8, 9=4 (9tj

Mir. 288>) (‑^jd nfkf`d eallr io tjd Mlkputdr Erfun fon Fbusd Fmt mlotfios ol ‚sioàd fmt’

rdquirdkdot.‛).

^ribuod Mlkpfoy dkpalydd tikd wiaa bd vfaudn ft jluray rftds ndrivdn erlk dfmj dkpalydd’s

sfafry. ^jd Oiotj Mirmuit jfs fpprlvdn tjis prlle kdtjln. ]dd Toitdn ]tftds v. Kinnadtlo, 2=6 E.=n

6280, 626> (9tj Mir. 2888). ‑Mlsts fsslmiftdn witj iovdsti`ftio` iotrusilos iotl f mlkputdr odtwlrc fon

tfcio` subsdqudot rdkdnifa kdfsurds frd alssds witjio tjd kdfoio` le tjd stftutd.‛ Kuativdo, Iom. v.

Misml ]ys., Iom., 024 E. ]upp. 2n ::0, :94 (O.N. Mfa. 2868).

^jis faa lmmurrdn witjio tjd mlursd le mlonumt fon mfusdn by it. ^jd ]updrsdnio` Ionimtkdot

dxprdssay faad`ds tjft fetdr jd wfs eirdn, but bdelrd jd kfnd mlotfmt witj Foloyklus, Cdys cdpt fon

usdn elr kfaimilus purplsds alìo mrdndotifas tl ^ribuod’s sdrvdr. (]updrsdnio` Ionimtkdot ft Mluot 6, µ

6(j)3 Mluot 2, µµ 6-2). Elr dxfkpad, Cdys rdpdftdnay ndfmtivftdn jis rdpafmdkdot’s alìo mrdndotifas.

(]jd wiaa fasl tdstiey fblut jdr lwo alst tikd fon its vfaud.) Cdys sdot f mlkkfon tl ^ribuod

Mlkpfoy’s sdrvdr tl nlwoalfn Elx >8’s aist le fblut 28,888 vidwdrs wjl jfn siòdn up elr fo feeioity

prl`rfk fon tjdo usdn tjft aist tl sdon spfk tl Elx >8’s vidwdrs. Lomd Cdys `fiodn fmmdss tl tjd

Foloyklus IRM mjfooda, jd fmtufaay leedrdn tjd aist tl Foloyklus.

Pitodssds Brfonlo Kdrmdr fon Gdrry Nda Mlrd wiaa tdstiey tjft fs Elx >8 dkpalydds, tjdy spdot

smlrds le jlurs tryio` tl indotiey tjd slurmd le tjd odtwlrc brdfmj fon stlp it. ^jdy nin tjis io kddtio`s

fklo` kfof`dkdot, mluosda, fon afw doelrmdkdot. Kdrmdr dvdo jfn mlosdosufaay rdmlrndn kddtio`s

witj Cdys io lrndr tl jdap tjd EBI eiùrd lut ie Cdys wfs tjd lod bdjion tjd tjdet fon kisusd le Elx

>8’s mlotfmt aist. ^jdsd deelrts wdrd faa dxpdondn nurio` tjd tikd pdriln mjfr`dn io Mluot 2 fon wiaa bd

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :- 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ & =B )


3/168

=T.]. KIA #6 R D XRLLE LE AL]]

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

vfaudn bfsdn lo tjd sfafry le tjd pdlpad iovlavdn.

Pitodssds ̂ ik Rlnri`udz, ̂ lk Mlkio`s, fon Nyafo Cuadszf wiaa tdstiey tjft lomd fo dnitlr le

^jd Als Fo`dads ̂ ikds nismlvdrdn tjft f stlry jfn bddo ndefmdn, tjdy spdot smlrds le jlurs rdsplonio`.

^jdy wiaa fssdss f klodtfry vfaud tl tjdir tikd bfsdn lo tjdir sfafry.

^jis prlle kdtjln is dotirday mlovdotilofa fon tjd Toitdn ]tftds tjdrdelrd fscs elr fo io aikiod

ruaio` fs tl its prlpridty.

Rdspdmteuaay subkittdn,

Nftdn7 ]dptdkbdr 9, 2864

By7

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODRToitdn ]tftds Fttlrody

/s/ KF^^JDP N. ]D@FA

KF^^JDP N. ]D@FAFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrody

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :- 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ) =B )


4/168

6@LUDROKDO^’] KLÎLO IO AIKIOD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODRToitdn ]tftds FttlrodyKF^^JDP N. ]D@FAXFTA F. JDKD]F^JFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrodys486 I ]trddt, ]uitd 68-688]fmrfkdotl, MF 94:6>^dadpjlod7 (965) 44>-2088Efmsikiad7 (965) 44>-2988





Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.

MF]D OL. 276=-MR-88:2 CGK

TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #2 ^LFNKI^ ]TKKFRY LE ULATKIOLT]DUINDOMD XTR]TFO^ ^L EDNDRFA RTAD LEDUINDOMD 6885


I. IO^RLNTMÎLO

^jd Toitdn ]tftds rdqudsts fo io-aikiod ruaio` fnkittio` iotl dvindomd f sukkfry le vlaukiolus

dvindomd.

II. EFM^]

Pjiad fssdkbaio` its mfsd-io-mjide, tjd `lvdrokdot jfs rdvidwdn sdvdrfa mftd`lrids le

vlaukiolus dvindomd, iomaunio` mlkputdrs, dxtdrofa jfrn nrivds, fon sdrvdr al`s wjimj, ie priotdn tl

pfpdr, wluan mlosukd tdos le tjlusfons le pf`ds. Klrdlvdr, slkd le tjis dvindomd is io f mjfaadoìo`

elrkft, rdondrio` its dxfkioftilo uousufaay nieeimuat.

Io lrndr tl nistiaa tjis dvindomd iotl f mlkprdjdosibad sukkfry, tjd `lvdrokdot jfs mrdftdn f

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


5/168


6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

Kimrlslet XlwdrXliot prdsdotftilo, wjimj is fttfmjdn. (Dxj. F.)

III.

AFP

F.

Edndrfa Ruad le Dvindomd 6885 Xdrkits tjd Tsd le F ]ukkfry tl Xrlvd tjd Mlotdot leUlaukiolus Pritio`s ^jft Mfoolt Bd Mlovdoidotay Dxfkiodn io Mlurt.

Edndrfa Ruad le Dvindomd 6885 (‑]ukkfrids tl Xrlvd Mlotdot‛) prlvinds7

^jd prlplodot kfy usd f sukkfry, mjfrt, lr mfamuaftilo tl prlvd tjd mlotdot levlaukiolus writio`s, rdmlrnio`s, lr pjltl`rfpjs tjft mfoolt bd mlovdoidotay dxfkiodn io

mlurt. ^jd prlplodot kust kfcd tjd lri ìofas lr nupaimftds fvfiafbad elr dxfkioftilo lrmlpyio`, lr bltj, by ltjdr pfrtids ft f rdfslofbad tikd fon pafmd. Fon tjd mlurt kfylrndr tjd prlplodot tl prlnumd tjdk io mlurt

^jd Oiotj Mirmuit jfs rdml`oizdn tjft sukkfry dvindomd ‑mfo jdap tjd gury lr`foizd fon

dvfauftd dvindomd wjimj is efmtufaay mlkpadx fon erf`kdotfaay rdvdfadn io tjd tdstikloy le tjd

kuatitund le witodssds.‛ Toitdn ]tftds v. ]jirady, ::> E.2n 66=8, 66== (9tj Mir. 69:9) (qultio` Toitdn

]tftds v. Adkird, 028 E.2n 6=20, 6=>: (N.M. Mir. 69:=))3 sdd fasl Toitdn ]tftds v. Kdydrs, :>0 E.2n

6>8:, 6>62 (9tj Mir. 69::) (fpprlvio` tjd usd le f sukkfry witodss wjdrd tjd sdqudomd le dvdots wfs

mloeusio` fon tjd mjfrt mlotributdn tl tjd mafrity le prdsdotftilo). ]umj sukkfrids frd fnkissibad

dvindomd. Kdydrs, :>0 E.2n ft 6>623 Toitdn ]tftds v. Plln , 9>= E.2n 68>:, 684= (9tj Mir. 6996).

Fatjlu`j tjd uondrayio` kftdrifas uplo wjimj tjd sukkfry tdstikloy is bfsdn kust bd

‑fnkissibad‛ fon fvfiafbad elr iospdmtilo, tjdy oddn olt bd fmtufaay fnkittdn iotl dvindomd. Kdydrs,

:>0 E.2n ft 6>623 Toitdn ]tftds v. Gljoslo, 49> E.2n 624=, 6240 o.5 (9tj Mir. 6909). ^jd eluonftilo

elr fnkissilo le sumj f sukkfry is sikpay tjft tjd rdmlrns frd vlaukiolus fon tjft io-mlurt

dxfkioftilo wluan bd iomlovdoidot. Toitdn ]tftds v. Nuomfo, 969 E.2n 9:6, 9:: (4tj Mir. 6998). Ie tjd

uondrayio` nlmukdots frd tjdksdavds fnkissibad, tjdy oddn olt bd io dvindomd elr f sukkfry witodss tl

ndsmribd tjdk fon fnkit tjd sukkfry le vlaukiolus rdmlrns. Edn. R. Dvin. 6885.

^jd sukkfry witodss kfy rdvidw tjd dvindomd io f kfoodr tjft fnvlmftds tjd @lvdrokdot’s

tjdlry le tjd mfsd, fon oddn olt `ivd deedmt tl tjd mlotdotilos le tjd ndedonfot. Toitdn ]tftds v. Kllrd,

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


6/168

=@LUDROKDO^’] KL^ILO IO AIKIOD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

990 E.2n 44, 4:-49 (4tj Mir. 699=). Mlpids le tjd sukkfrids kfy bd pubaisjdn tl tjd gury wjiad tjd

sukkfry witodss tdstieids mlomdroio` tjdk. In .

F nistrimt mlurt’s ndmisilo tl fnkit f sukkfry uondr Ruad 6885 is rdvidwdn elr fbusd le

nismrdtilo. Toitdn ]tftds v. Fodcwu, 594 E.=n 950, 9:2 (9tj Mir. 2862).

B.

^jd Rdmlrns Tondrayio` tjd ]ukkfry Frd Fnkissibad, Ulaukiolus, fon Pluan Bd

Iomlovdoidot tl Dxfkiod Io Mlurt.

^jd sukkfry nrfws erlk kuatipad jfrn nrivds sdizdn by tjd Edndrfa Burdfu le Iovdsti`ftilo, fs

wdaa fs sdrvdr al`s lbtfiodn erlk f vimtik mlkpfoy, tjirn-pfrty busiodss rdmlrns, fon tjd fotimipftdn

tdstikloy le f trifa witodss wjl wiaa prdmdnd tjd iotrlnumtilo le tjd sukkfry.

Dfmj le tjdsd mftd l̀rids le dvindomd is fnkissibad. F stipuaftilo le tjd pfrtids eiadn io tjis mfsd

(Nlmukdot 55) dstfbaisjdn tjd futjdotimity fon fnkissibiaity, subgdmt loay tl f sjlwio` le rdadvfomd, le

tjd tjirn-pfrty busiodss rdmlrns fon vimtik sdrvdr al`s tjft pfrtifaay uondraid tjd sukkfry. ]ubgdmt tl

lo`lio` nismussilos fblut fnnitilofa stipuaftilos fon tjd rdslautilo le f pdonio` kltilo tl qufsj, tjd

`lvdrokdot pafos tl fnkit tjd rdkfioio` mftd`lrids le uondrayio` rdmlrns tjrlu`j tjd tdstikloy le trifa

witodssds witj pdrslofa colwadn`d.

^jd sukkfry nrfws erlk vlaukiolus jfrn nrivds fon sdrvdr al` eiads tjft wluan bd

iomlovdoidot tl dxfkiod io mlurt, fon wluan tltfa io tjd tdos le tjlusfons le pf`ds ie priotdn tl pfpdr.

Io ai`jt le tjd uousufa elrkfttio` le mdrtfio le tjdsd eiads, it jfs bddo iomlovdoidot tl rdvidw tjdk dvdo

io spdmifaizdn mlkputdr elrdosim efmiaitids.

Eiofaay, tjd ndedosd jfs bddo prlvindn witj tjd rdmlrns uondrayio` tjd sukkfry, fon wiaa jfvd

tjd lpplrtuoity tl mrlss-dxfkiod tjd witodss prdsdotio` it.

IU.

MLOMAT]ILO

Fs tjd uondrayio` rdmlrns frd fnkissibad, vlaukiolus, fon wluan bd iomlovdoidot tl dxfkiod io

mlurt, tjd Mlurt sjluan fnkit iotl dvindomd tjd fttfmjdn sukkfry.

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


7/168

>@LUDROKDO^’] KL^ILO IO AIKIOD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:


By7

AD]AID R. MFANPDAAFssistfot Fttlrody @dodrfa

/s/ GFKD] ]IAUDRGFKD] ]IAUDRNdputy Mjide elr Aiti`ftilo

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


8/168

6T.]. KIA #= ^L BFR DUINDOMD LE L^JDR JFMCIO@XRL]DMTÎLO]

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:







Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.


TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #=^L BFR DUINDOMD RD@FRNIO@ L^JDRJFMCDR XRL]DMTÎLO]


^jd Toitdn ]tftds klvds elr fo lrndr bfrrio` dvindomd fon frùkdot rd`frnio` jlw lr wjdtjdr

ltjdr mlkputdr jfmcdrs wjl wdrd mjfr`dn fon jlw foy mfsds wdrd rdslavdn, uoadss elr tjd purplsd le

ikpdfmjio` f witodss wjl wfs mlovimtdn. ^jis mfsd is lod le f oukbdr tjft rdsuatdn erlk f wfvd le

jfmcio` fttfmcs by pdrslos fsslmiftdn witj Foloyklus. Io tjd Toitdn ]tftds fon dasdwjdrd, afw

doelrmdkdot summddndn io indotieyio` fon prlsdmutio` pdlpad. But tjd @lvdrokdot’s prlsdmutivd

ndmisilos io ltjdr mfsds frd irrdadvfot tl wjdtjdr Cdys is ̀ uiaty le tjd mrikds faad`dn io tjd ]updrsdnio`

Ionimtkdot.

]umj dvindomd lr frùkdot mluan loay su``dst tjft tjdrd wfs sdadmtivd prlsdmutilo le tjd

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :( 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ( =B &


9/168

2T.]. KIA #= ^L BFR DUINDOMD LE L^JDR JFMCIO@XRL]DMT^ILO]

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

Ndedonfot Cdys, f mafik tjft wluan jfvd tl bd kfnd tl tjd Mlurt, olt tjd gury. F ‑sdadmtivd prlsdmutilo

mafik is olt f ndedosd lo tjd kdrits tl tjd mrikiofa mjfr`d itsdae, but fo iondpdondot fssdrtilo tjft tjd

prlsdmutlr jfs brlu`jt tjd mjfr`d elr rdfslos elrbinndo by tjd Mlostitutilo.‛ Toitdn ]tftds v.

Frkstrlo` , 460 T.]. >45, >5= (6995). It wluan bd f prdtrifa kltilo elr tjd Mlurt. Toitdn ]tftds v.

Lfcs, 48: E.2n 6>8=, 6>8> (9tj Mir. 690>).

Le mlursd, ie Ndedonfot fmtufaay mfaas mlovimtdn kdkbdrs le Foloyklus, jd kfy ikpdfmj tjdk

witj tjdir mlovimtilos. Edn. R. Dvin. 589.



By7

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODR

Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrody

/s/ KF^^JDP N. ]D@FAKF^^JDP N. ]D@FAFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrody

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :( 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ & =B &


10/168

6T.]. KIA #> ^L D]^FB. MLKXAD^DOD]] LE DZMDRX^]LE NDEDONFO^’] ]^F^DKDO^

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:







Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.


TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KL^ILO IO AIKIOD #>^L D]^FBAI]J MLKXAD^DOD]] LE DZMDRX^]LE NDEDONFO^’] ]^F^DKDO^


^jd Toitdn ]tftds iotdons tl leedr dxmdrpts le tjd stftdkdot tjft Ndedonfot kfnd wjdo f`dots

dxdmutdn f sdfrmj wfrrfot ft jis rdsindomd fon klvds elr f eionio` tjft tjd fttfmjdn sdadmtdn dxmdrpts frd

sueeimidotay mlkpadtd sl fs olt tl bd kisadfnio` fon rdquird suppadkdot.

Leedrdn by tjd Toitdn ]tftds, tjdsd lut-le-mlurt stftdkdots frd fnkissibad fs stftdkdots le f

pfrty lpplodot. Edn. R. Dvin. :86(n)(2)(F). Ie leedrdn by tjd Ndedonfot, tjdsd stftdkdots wluan bd

iofnkissibad jdfrsfy. Edn. R. Dvin. :86(m), :82. ]dd, d.`., Toitdn ]tftds v. Kitmjdaa , 482 E.=n 9=6, 95>-

954 (9tj Mir. 2880) (‑^jdsd stftdkdots Sby ndedonfot[ wdrd iofnkissibad

jdfrsfy3 fs Sndedonfot[ wfs fttdkptio` tl iotrlnumd tjdk jiksdae, tjdy wdrd olt pfrty-lpplodot

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :& 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ( =B &


11/168

2T.]. KIA #> ^L D]^FB. MLKXAD^DOD]] LE DZMDRX^]LE NDEDONFO^’] ]^F^DKDO^

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

fnkissilos, olr nin tjd efmt tjft tjdy wdrd kfnd io f klrd brlfnay sdae-iomuapftlry mloedssilo brio`

tjdk witjio tjd stftdkdot-f`fiost-iotdrdst dxmdptilo.‛)3 Toitdn ]tftds v. Lrtd`f, 28= E.=n 504, 5:2 (9tj

Mir. 2888) (feeirkio` trifa mlurt’s prdmausilo le ndedonfot daimitio` lo mrlss-dxfkioftilo dxmuapftlry

stftdkdots ̀ ivdo tl afw doelrmdkdot leeimdr)3 Toitdn ]tftds v. Edrofondz , :=9 E.2n 5=9, 5>8 (9tj Mir.

69::) (‑It sddks lbvilus ndedosd mluosda wisjdn tl pafmd Sndedonfot’s ndoifa tl plaimd leeimdr[ bdelrd

tjd gury witjlut subgdmtio` Sndedonfot[ tl mrlss-dxfkioftilo, prdmisday wjft tjd jdfrsfy ruad elrbin.‛).

Ie tjd @lvdrokdot pubaisjds tjd fttfmjdn dxmdrpts, tjd Ruad le Mlkpadtdodss, Edn. R. Dvin. 685,

nlds olt prlvind tjd Ndedonfot f rlutd tl leedrio` jis lwo jdfrsfy iotl dvindomd. ^jd Oiotj Mirmuit

tdfmjds, ‑^jd Ruad Sle Mlkpadtdodss[ nlds olt . . . rdquird tjd iotrlnumtilo le foy uodnitdn writio` lr

stftdkdot kdrday bdmfusd fo fnvdrsd pfrty jfs iotrlnumdn fo dnitdn vdrsilo.‛ Toitdn ]tftds v. Ufaadgls,

0>2 E.=n 982, 984 (9tj Mir. 286>). It is olt prlpdr tl faalw f Ndedonfot tl brio` io uo-mrlss-dxfkiodn,

sdae-dxmuapftio` jdfrsfy io tjd `uisd le prdsdotio` tjd ‑eafvlr le tjd iotdrvidw.‛ In. Rftjdr, ‑ie tjd

mlkpadtd stftdkdot nlds olt sdrvd tl mlrrdmt f kisadfnio` ikprdssilo io tjd dnitdn stftdkdot tjft is

mrdftdn by tfcio` slkdtjio` lut le mlotdxt, tjd Ruad le Mlkpadtdodss wiaa olt bd fppaidn tl fnkit tjd

euaa stftdkdot.‛ In. ‑Ruad 685 ‚nlds olt mlkpda fnkissilo le ltjdrwisd iofnkissibad jdfrsfy

dvindomd.’‛ Toitdn ]tftds v. Mlaaimltt , 92 E.=n 90=, 9:= (9tj Mir. 6995).

^jd @lvdrokdot jfs olt ydt eioisjdn kfrcio` its dxjibits fon mjllsio` wjft dxmdrpts tl leedr.

Fttfmjdn tl tjis kltilo f trfosmript le tjd mlkpadtd stftdkdot le tjd Ndedonfot witj tjd murrdotay

pafoodn dxmdrpts kfrcdn io ydaalw ji`jai`jt. Io tjd iotdrdst le fvlinio` trifa surprisd fon ndafy, tjd

Toitdn ]tftds fscs elr f ruaio` tjft dfmj le tjd ji`jai`jtdn dxmdrpts nlds olt mlovdy f kisadfnio`

ikprdssilo by tfcio` tjio`s lut le mlotdxt, fon kfy tjdrdelrd bd fnkittdn iotl dvindomd witjlut

suppadkdot.



By7

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODR

Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrody


!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :& 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ & =B &


12/168


6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

BDOGFKIO B. PF@ODRToitdn ]tftds FttlrodyKF^^JDP N. ]D@FAXFTA F. JDKD]F^JFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrodys486 I ]trddt, ]uitd 68-688]fmrfkdotl, MF 94:6>^dadpjlod7 (965) 44>-2088Efmsikiad7 (965) 44>-2988





Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.

MF]D OL. 276=-MR-88:2 CGK

@LUDROKDO^’] KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #4 ^LDZMATND ^D]ÎKLOY LE TONI]MAL]DNFAIBI PIÔD]]D]

NF^D7 ]dptdkbdr 24, 2864

ÎKD7 9788 f.k.MLTR^7 Jlo. Cikbdray G. Kudaadr

I. IO^RLNTMÎLO

^jd Toitdn ]tftds rdqudsts fo io-aikiod ruaio` bfrrio` Ndedonfot Kfttjdw Cdys erlk prdsdotio`

tjd tdstikloy le foy witodssds io supplrt le fo faibi ndedosd fs tl tjd six pfrtimuafr fmts ndsmribdn io

Dxjibit F jdrdtl.

II. EFM^]

Lo Kfrmj 25, 2864, tjd `lvdrokdot dkfiadn tjd ndedosd f adttdr rdqudstio` oltimd le foy faibi

ndedosd elr six spdmieim fmts. (Dxj. F.) F tfbad mlotfiodn io tjd adttdr spdmieidn tjd tikd, nftd, fon pafmd

le tjd fmts. (In.) Lo Fpria 28, 2864, jfvio` rdmdivdn ol rdsplosd erlk tjd ndedosd, tjd `lvdrokdot

dkfiadn tjd ndedosd tl fsc wjdtjdr it iotdondn tl rdsplon, lr slu`jt fnnitilofa tikd. ^jd ndedosd fscdn

ie it mluan jfvd uotia tjd don le tjd wddc, fon tjd `lvdrokdot f`rddn tl tjis dxtdosilo. ^jis wfs tjd afst

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :. 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ( =B )


13/168


6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

mlkkuoimftilo lo tjd kfttdr.

III.

AFP

F.

Edndrfa Ruad le Mrikiofa Xrlmdnurd 62.6 Rdquirds tjd Ndedosd, Tplo tjd @lvdrokdot’sRdqudst, tl Xrlvind Prittdo Oltimd le Iotdot tl Leedr fo Faibi Ndedosd.

Ruad 62.6(f) (‑@lvdrokdot’s Rdqudst elr Oltimd fon Ndedonfot’s Rdsplosd‛) prlvinds7

(6) @lvdrokdot’s Rdqudst. Fo fttlrody elr tjd `lvdrokdot kfyrdqudst io writio` tjft tjd ndedonfot oltiey fo fttlrody elr tjd ̀ lvdrokdot le foy

faibi ndedosd. ^jd rdqudst kust stftd tjd tikd, nftd, fon pafmd le tjd faad`dnleedosd.

(2) Ndedonfot’s Rdsplosd. Pitjio 6> nfys fetdr tjd rdqudst, lr ftslkd ltjdr tikd tjd mlurt sdts, tjd ndedonfot kust sdrvd writtdo oltimd lo fo

fttlrody elr tjd `lvdrokdot le foy iotdondn faibi ndedosd. ^jd ndedonfot’s oltimdkust stftd7

(F) dfmj spdmieim pafmd wjdrd tjd ndedonfot mafiks tl jfvd bddo ft tjdtikd le tjd faad`dn leedosd3 fon

(B) tjd ofkd, fnnrdss, fon tdadpjlod oukbdr le dfmj faibi witodss lowjlk tjd ndedonfot iotdons tl rday.

B.

Ie F Xfrty Efias tl Mlkpay Pitj tjd Ruad, tjd Mlurt Kfy Dxmaund tjd ^dstikloy le

Foy Tonismalsdn Faibi Pitodss.

Edndrfa Ruad le Mrikiofa Xrlmdnurd 62.6(d) (‑Efiaurd tl Mlkpay‛) stftds tjft ‑Si[e f pfrty efias tl

mlkpay witj tjis ruad, tjd mlurt kfy dxmaund tjd tdstikloy le foy uonismalsdn witodss rd`frnio` tjd

ndedonfot’s faibi. ^jis ruad nlds olt aikit tjd ndedonfot’s ri`jt tl tdstiey.‛

M.

Fs Ndedonfot Jfs Efiadn tl Mlkpay witj tjd Ruad, tjd Mlurt ]jluan Dxmaund tjd

^dstikloy le Foy Faibi Pitodssds Pjlsd ^dstikloy Pluan Xdrtfio tl tjd

@lvdrokdot’s Kfrmj 25 Rdqudst.

^jd purplsd le Ruad 62.6 is tl prdvdot f ndedonfot erlk surprisio` tjd `lvdrokdot witj faibi

tdstikloy. Io Pfrnius v. Lrd`lo, >62 T.]. >08, >0=, 9= ].Mt. 228:, 2266, =0 A.Dn.2n :2 (690=),

dxpafiodn tjft oltimd-le-faibi ruads

frd bfsdn lo tjd prlplsitilo tjft tjd dons le gustimd wiaa bdst bd sdrvdn by f systdk le

aibdrfa nismlvdry wjimj ̀ ivds bltj pfrtids tjd kfxikuk plssibad fkluot le ioelrkftilowitj wjimj tl prdpfrd tjdir mfsds fon tjdrdby rdnumds tjd plssibiaity le surprisd ft trifa.

^jd Fnvislry Mlkkittdd Oltds tl tjd ruad eurtjdr dxpafio7

Ruad 62.6 wiaa sdrvd f usdeua purplsd dvdo tjlu`j ruad 65 olw rdquirds nismalsurd le tjd

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :. 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ & =B )


14/168

=@LUDROKDO^’] KL^ILO IO AIKIOD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

ofkds fon fnnrdssds le `lvdrokdot fon ndedosd witodssds. ^jdrd frd mfsds io wjimj tjdindotity le ndedosd witodssds kfy bd colwo, but it kfy mlkd fs f surprisd tl tjd

`lvdrokdot tjft tjdy iotdon tl tdstiey fs tl fo faibi fon tjdrd kfy bd ol fnvfomd oltimdle tjd ndtfias le tjd mafikdn faibi. ^jd rdsuat letdo is fo uoodmdssfry iotdrruptilo fon

ndafy io tjd trifa tl dofbad tjd `lvdrokdot tl mlonumt fo fpprlpriftd iovdsti`ftilo. ^jdlbgdmtivd le ruad 62.6 is tl prdvdot tjis by prlvinio` f kdmjfoisk wjimj wiaa dofbad tjd pfrtids tl jfvd spdmieim ioelrkftilo io fnvfomd le trifa tl prdpfrd tl kddt tjd issud le faibinurio` tjd trifa.

Edn R. Mrik. X. 62.6 fnvislry mlkkittdd’s oltd.

^jd Oiotj Mirmuit jfs rdpdftdnay jdan tjft f nistrimt mlurt nin olt fbusd its nismrdtilo by bfrrio`

ndedonfots erlk mfaaio` uonismalsdn faibi witodssds. Toitdn ]tftds v. Jdondrslo, 2>6 E.=n 5=:, 548 (9tj

Mir. 2888) (ndedosd faibi witodss olt nismalsdn uotia tjirn nfy le elur-nfy trifa)3 Toitdn ]tftds v.

Bdofvindz, 992 E.2n 6228 (^fbad), 699= PA 6=6260, *6-2 (9tj Mir. 699=) (ndedosd prlvindn ol faibi

oltimd)3 Toitdn ]tftds v. Bfrrlo, 404 E.2n 042, 044-4: (9tj Mir. 690:) (ndedosd faibi witodss nismalsurd

mfkd lod nfy aftd).

^jd Jdondrslo mlurt eurtjdr jdan tjft f nistrimt mlurt nlds olt ‑drr by olt rdquirio` foy sjlwio`

le surprisd lr prdgunimd tl tjd `lvdrokdot. F trifa mlurt kfy rdgdmt tdstikloy le fo faibi witodss wjdo it

eions tjft tjd ndedonfot jfs wiaaeuaay efiadn tl elaalw prlmdnurfa ruads fppaimfbad tl tjd prdsdotftilo le

sumj dvindomd.‛ Jdondrslo, 2>6 E.=n ft 548 (mitio` f̂yalr v. Iaaiolis, >:> T.]. >88, >6>-64, 68: ].Mt.

5>5, 9: A.Dn.2n 09: (69::)).

IU.

MLOMAT]ILO

Fs tjd ndedosd jfs fppfrdotay kfnd f mlosindrdn ndmisilo olt tl prdsdot fo faibi ndedosd, fon tjd

@lvdrokdot jfs rdaidn lo tjft ndmisilo uondr tjd fppaimfbad ruad, tjd Toitdn ]tftds fscs tjd Mlurt tl bfr

tjd ndedosd erlk prdsdotio` tjd tdstikloy le witodssds io supplrt le sumj f ndedosd.


By7

AD]AID R. MFANPDAAFssistfot Fttlrody @dodrfa

/s/ GFKD] ]IAUDRGFKD] ]IAUDRNdputy Mjide elr Aiti`ftilo

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :. 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ) =B )


15/168

6T.]. KIA #5 R D UIMÎK OD@AI@DOMD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:







Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.


TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #5^L BFR FR@TKDO^ LE UIMÎK OD@AI@DOMD


^jd Toitdn ]tftds klvds elr fo io aikiod lrndr bfrrio` Ndedonfot erlk prdsdotio` dvindomd le

vimtik odài`domd fon bfrrio` Ndedonfot erlk frùio` tjft f`dots le ̂ ribuod Mlkpfoy, Elx >8, fon/lr

^jd Als Fo`dads ̂ ikds wdrd odài`dot io tjd wfy tjft tjdy lpdrftdn tjdir mlkputdr odtwlrc.

^jd Oiotj Mirmuit jfs fardfny rdgdmtdn tjd frùkdot tjft dvindomd le f vimtik’s efiaurd tl

kfiotfio f sdmurd mlkputdr odtwlrc mfo bd usdn tl dxmusd mlkputdr mrikd lr mafik tjft alss wfs olt

‑mfusdn‛ by f ndedonfot. Io Mrdftivd Mlkputio` v. @dtalfndn.mlk AAM , =:5 E.=n 9=8 (9tj Mir. 288>),

tjd ndedonfot frùdn tjft tjd pafiotiee/vimtik jfn efiadn tl iostfaa f erdd lpdrftio` systdk pftmj tjft

wluan jfvd prdvdotdn tjd wjlad iomindot. In. ft 9=5. ^jd Oiotj Mirmuit rdgdmtdn sumj rdfsloio`7

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :) 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ ( =B &


16/168

2T.]. KIA #5 R D UIMÎK OD@AI@DOMD

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

@dtalfndn’s frùkdot tjft trumcstlp.mlk mluan jfvd prdvdotdn slkd letjd jfrk by iostfaaio` tjd Ssletwfrd[ pftmj is fofal`lus tl f tjide frùio`tjft ‑I wluan olt jfvd bddo fbad tl stdfa ylur tdadvisilo ie ylu jfniostfaadn ndfnblats iostdfn le tjft siaay almc I mluan lpdo witj f mrdnitmfrn.‛ F mfusfa mjfio erlk tjd tjide tl tjd vimtik is olt brlcdo by fvuaodrfbiaity tjft tjd vimtik odài`dotay adfvds lpdo tl tjd tjide.

In. Uimtik odài`domd is irrdadvfot wjdo it nlds olt `l tl fo dadkdot le tjd mrikd.

^jd @lvdrokdot is aicday tl prdsdot dvindomd tjft wjdo Cdys wfs mfu`jt, Cdys jiksdae bafkdn

tjd vimtik elr tjd odtwlrc prfmtimds tjft faalwdn jik tl mlkkit tjd mrikd. But tjft is f mrikiofa’s

mloedssilo. Fttlrodys sjluan bd bfrrdn erlk prdsdotio` dvindomd le vimtik odài`domd fon bfrrdn erlk

frùio` tjft sumj efmts frd io foy wfy dxmuapftlry. ‑^jdy wdrd mfrdadss fon ndsdrvdn it‛ wluan bd f

mfaa elr ouaaieimftilo. It is ol ndedosd tl tjd mjfr`ds.



By7



!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :) 973$1 -;?-;?(< H"F$ & =B &


17/168

6T.]. KIA #0 ^L BFR MDR^FIO OTAAIEIMFÎLO DU. & FR@.

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:







Xafiotiee,

v.

KF^^JDP CDY],

Ndedonfot.


TOI^DN ]^F^D]’ KLÎLO IO AIKIOD #0^L BFR MDR^FIO OTAAIEIMFÎLO DUINDOMDFON FR@TKDO^


^jd Toitdn ]tftds klvds elr fo lrndr bfrrio` dvindomd fon frùkdot fblut tjd elaalwio`7 (6)

tjd pdofatids Ndedonfot wiaa efmd ie mlovimtdn, (2) tjd dxistdomd le mivia rdkdnids elr vilaftilo le tjd

Mlkputdr Erfun fon Fbusd Fmt, (=) @lvdrokdot plaimids lutsind tjd rdmlrn, fon (>) foy padf f`rddkdot

tjft ki`jt jfvd bddo leedrdn tl tjd Ndedonfot.

^jd Toitdn ]tftds klvds elr fo io aikiod lrndr bfrrio` Ndedonfot erlk nismalsio` tl tjd gury tjd

pdofatids tjft tjd Ndedonfot wiaa efmd ie mlovimtdn. ‑SI[t is iofpprlpriftd elr f gury tl mlosindr lr bd

ioelrkdn le tjd mlosdqudomds le tjdir vdrnimt.‛ Toitdn ]tftds v. Erfoc , 945 E.2n :02, :09 (9tj Mir.

6996), fs fkdondn lo ndoifa le rdj’` (Edb. 66, 6992). ‑S^[jd gury jfSs[ ol sdotdomio` euomtilo fon

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


18/168

2T.]. KIA #0 ^L BFR MDR^FIO OTAAIEIMFÎLO DU. & FR@.

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

sjluan rdfmj its vdrnimt witjlut rd`frn tl wjft sdotdomd ki`jt bd ikplsdn.‛ Rl`drs v. Toitdn ]tftds,

>22 T.]. =4, >8 (6904). ^jis priomipad rdeadmts f ‑bfsim nivisilo le afblr io lur ad`fa systdk bdtwddo

gun`d fon gury.‛ ]jfoolo v. Toitdn ]tftds, 462 T.]. 40=, 409 (699>). ‑Klrdlvdr, prlvinio` gurlrs

sdotdomio` ioelrkftilo iovitds tjdk tl plondr kfttdrs tjft frd olt witjio tjdir prlviomd, nistrfmts tjdk

erlk tjdir efmt-eionio` rdsplosibiaitids, fon mrdftds f strlo` plssibiaity le mloeusilo.‛ In. It wluan bd

dspdmifaay kisadfnio` tl ioelrk f edndrfa gury le fppaimfbad stftutlry kfxikf, ‑bdmfusd f ndedonfot

sdanlk rdmdivds tjd kfxikuk pdofaty pdrkissibad uondr tjd stftutd le mlovimtilo.‛ Toitdn ]tftds v.

Afrslo, >94 E.=n 689>, 6685 (9tj Mir. 2880) (do bfom).

It is fasl irrdadvfot tjft tjd Mlkputdr Erfun fon Fbusd Fmt mlotfios mivia rdkdnids olt ft issud io

tjis mrikiofa trifa. ‑S^[jd fvfiafbiaity le f mivia rdkdny is irrdadvfot tl tjd issud le mrikiofa aifbiaityS.[‛

]dd Toitdn ]tftds v. Burfs, 5== E.2n 6=45, 6=58 (9tj Mir. 69:8)3 Toitdn ]tftds v. ]iof`rf, 4:> E. Fpp’x

52:, 5=8 (9tj Mir. 286>) (MEFF). Xuttio` tjd plssibiaity le mivia suit io erlot le tjd gury wluan mloeusd

tjdk witj fo irrdadvfot issud. ]dd Burfs, 5== E.2n ft 6=58.

^jis mfsd is fblut wjdtjdr tjd Ndedonfot mlkkittdn tjd fmts faad`dn io tjd ]updrsdnio`

Ionimtkdot. It is olt fblut prlvinio` f elruk elr tjd Foloyklus aist le r̀idvfomds. Ndedonfot sjluan

olt bd fbad tl frùd elr fmquittfa bfsdn lo tjd Toitdn ]tftds @lvdrokdot’s plaimids rdaftdn tl Dnwfrn

]olwndo, Guaifo Fssfo`d, lr Piciadfcs. Ie tjd ndedosd kfcds frùkdots fsslmiftio` tjd prlsdmutilo

witj dxtrf-rdmlrn ̀ lvdrokdot plaimids, tjd Mlurt sjluan iotdrrupt tjd frùkdot fon mlrrdmt it. ]dd

Toitdn ]tftds v. Baixt , 4>: E.=n ::2, :98 (9tj Mir. 288:) (Pjdo mluosda frùdn tjd `lvdrokdot wfs tjd

sfkd ̀ lvdrokdot prlsdmutio` tjd Irfq Pfr, ‑tjd nistrimt mlurt, dxdrmisio` mlosindrfbad rdstrfiot io tjd

efmd le baftfot gury ouaaieimftilo frùkdots, prlpdray iostrumtdn tjd gury tl nisrd`frn mluosda’s

stftdkdots.‛). ‑Olt loay sjluan f gun`d iotdredrd witj fo fttlrody’s malsio` frùkdot wjdo it is ‚ad`faay

wrlo`,’ but Ss[jd sjluan fasl aikit, elr dxfkpad, fttlrodys’ rdkfrcs lutsind tjd rdmlrn lr uonuay

ioeafkkftlry. ]dd Toitdn ]tftds v. ]turìs, 40: E.2n 6295, 6=88 (9tj Mir. 690:).

//

//

//

//

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


19/168

=T.]. KIA #0 ^L BFR MDR^FIO OTAAIEIMF^ILO DU. & FR@.

6

2

=

>

4

5

0

:

9

68

66

62

6=

6>

64

65

60

6:

69

28

26

22

2=

2>

24

25

20

2:

Foy padf f`rddkdot leedrdn by tjd Toitdn ]tftds io tjis mfsd is fasl irrdadvfot fon iofnkissibad.

Pjft nisplsitilos tjd @lvdrokdot ki`jt jfvd leedrdn ydfrs fetdr tjd leedosd jfvd oltjio` tl nl witj

olo-jdfrsfy dvindomd le wjdtjdr tjd Ndedonfot mlkkittdn tjd mrikds. ]dd Toitdn ]tftds v. Edaa , =02 E.

]upp. 2n 00=, 0:= (N. Ut. 2884) fee’n, 4=6 E.=n 690 (2n Mir. 288:) (‑It is wdaa sdttadn tjft f prlsdmutlr’s

bdaide io tjd ndedonfot’s `uiat is olt rdadvfot.‛).



By7


/s/ KF^^JDP N. ]D@FA

KF^^JDP N. ]D@FAFssistfot Toitdn ]tftds Fttlrody

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9 731$; -?


20/168

Dxjibit F

!"#$ &'()*+,*---.&*/86 2=+>4$50 :9*( 731$; -?


21/168

! " # $ % & ' & )

* + $ , - . / ) " ' -

+ 8 ' 6 , " - , * /

) 2 =

> 4 5 / ' 0 : " , 9 ) 2 7 # " %

& , / 8 , / $ ) 3 &

1 4 ; 8

, / 7 $ # % $ ) 3 &

? 4+ 2

# ' $ 7 / ) 8 ' 6 , / / , -

) / 6 &


22/168

; " H C 9 - A # " " , $ O ' " . , / " , . * , 6 &

=

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,^

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = H . . # T , & # K A ' $ , . ) 3 / # " . ) " , : & , / " # 2 ,

7 , / 2

' & & ' ) " . ) , 8 , / % & ' . ,

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = H 2 6

) ' " 3 . A # . " ) K 4

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L L ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = % , & U . A ) & , # / , . A , . A / , , - 2 & . A # . . A ' & : & ,

/ V 7 # & &

3 ' 8 , & # - - , & & . )

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L L ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = : & , / = # " ) "> 1 ? L = > X = L L ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = 7 # & & = - ) 2 2 ) "1

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L > ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = 3 ) * : - T & ) 2 , & A ' . : 7 P

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L E ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

& A # / 7 ' , = * : - T

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L E ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

& A # / 7 ' , = K ,Z / , ' "

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L E ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

& A # / 7 ' , = . A # " T & 0

/ )

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = > L ] ) & ! "

3 , $ , & 5 ' 2 ,

F # 0 : = H # 2 $ ) ) T ' "

3 . A / ) : 3 A . A , & , # - - ) : " . & 4 # " ) "> 1 ?


23/168

! . . A , & # 2 ,

. ' 2 , U 5 / ' 0 : " , F , / 8 , / ] ) 3 &

& A ) K

H B # 6 6 / , &

& X L 4 R ? E 4 X R ' & - ) " " , - .

, 6

•

X L 4 R ? E 4 X R W

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R = L 4> Y 1 L L E R X

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 6 ' . 3 / ) : 7 & 4 $ 6 # 7 [ : & , / " # 2 ,_ # " ) "> 1 ? L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

H B # 6 6 / , & & X L 4 R ? E 4 X R K # & $ ) 3 3 , 6 ) " . ) . A , & , / 8 , / # " 6

/ , * , / , " - ' " 3 : & , / "

# 2 , # " ) "> 1 ? 4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


24/168

•

@ , - , 2 0 , / X U1 L > L U

' & . A , * ' / & . # 7 7 , # / # " - , ) * . A , : &

, / " # 2 ,

` # "

) "> 1 ? 4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


25/168

d / ) 2 ; 8 , / 7 $ # %

•

f & , / i # 2 , g i ! F H B ! 6 6 / , & &

g ! - - . F

. # / . 5 ' 2 ,

g ! - - . F . ) 7 5 ' 2 ,

g d / # 2 , 6 H B ! 6 6 / , & & g 9 # $ $ ' " 3 F . # . ' ) " H 6

T , % & c ) 2

g X L 4 R ? E 4 X R

g 1 L > L

W> 1 W L m L > = ? > = ? m g 1 L > L W> 1 W L

m L ? = E R = L 4> 1 4 L 4> L

g R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> >

•

f & , & ] )

" 6 ) " U f " ' . , 6 a ' " 3 6 ) 2 $ ) - # $

. ' 2 , 4

! " # $& ' ( ) * +

, * - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


26/168

Q ) K ; 8 , / 7 $ # % k ) / T &

H B R E 4 E

? 4> G X 4> >

H B X L 4 R ? E 4 X R

! " # $& ' ( ) * +

, * - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


27/168

5 ' 2 , 9 ) 2 7 # / ' & ) "o , . K , , "

5 / ' 0 : " , F , / 8

, / ] ) 3 & U

; 8 , / 7 $ # % ] ) 3 & U # "

6 H C 9 ] ) 3 &

•

X L 4 R

? E 4 X R W

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R = L 4> Y

1 L L E R X

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 6 ' . 3

/ ) : 7 & 4 $ 6 # 7 [ : & , / " # 2 ,_ # " ) "> 1 ? L 4 G I

, "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X

•

f & , / i # 2 , g i ! F H B ! 6 6 / , & &

g ! - - . F

. # / . 5 ' 2 ,

g ! - - . F . ) 7 5 ' 2 ,

g d / # 2 , 6 H B ! 6 6 / , & & g 9 # $ $ ' " 3 F . # . ' ) " H 6

T , % & c ) 2

g X L 4 R ? E 4 X R

g 1 L > L

W> 1 W L m L > = ? > = ? m g 1 L > L W> 1 W L

m L ? = E R = L 4> 1 4 L 4> L

g R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> >

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = H . . # T , & # K A ' $ , . ) 3 / # " . ) " , : & , / "

# 2 ,

7 , / 2 ' & & ' ) " . ) , 8 , / % & ' . ,

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = H 2 6 )

' " 3 . A # . " ) K 4

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L L ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = % , & U . A

) & , # / , . A , . A / , , - 2 & . A # . .

A ' & : & , / V 7 # & &

3 ' 8 , & # - - , & & . )

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L L ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = : & , / = # " ) "> 1 ? L = > X = L L ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = 7 # & & = - ) 2 2 ) "1

•

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > X = L > ] ) & ! " 3 , $ , & 5 ' 2

,

! + F 9 / # - T , 6 = 3 ) * : - T & ) 2 , & A ' . : 7 P

! " # $& ' ( ) * +

, * - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


28/168

! - - ) / 6 ' " 3 . ) ; 8 , / 7 $ # % U K A ) ' & T , % & c ) 2 [

•

d ) / , " # 2 , = \ # . . A , K

•

F : / " # 2 , = a , % &

•

, 2 # ' $ = & ) : " 6 K # 8 , 2

# . . A , K l 3 2 # ' $ 4 - ) 2

•

F ' 3 " : 7@ # . , = 1 L > L W L m W L E L R = E m = E G

•

F ' 3 " : 7 H B = R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> >

•

B # %

2 , " . 2 # 6 , 8 ' # n ) ) 3 $ , 9 A , - T ) :

. f a

! " # $& ' ( ) * +

, * - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; -

?


29/168

2 T , % & # " 6 H B R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> >

•

! . d ; b X G X 4> >

0 , .

K , , " p : " , R U1 L

> L # " 6 ; - . ) 0 , /

1 > U1 L > L 4

•

5 A ,

/ , K , / , ) " $ % > L

, " . / ' , & K A , / , 2

T , % & 6 ' 6 " ) . : &

, . A ' & H B ) "

. A ,

& , / 8 , / 4

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


30/168

f & , / ! 3 , " .

F . / ' " 3

•

X L 4 R

? E 4 X R W

L X V @ , - V 1 L > L = > R = E R = L 4> Y

1 L L E R X

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 6 ' . 3

/ ) : 7 & 4 $ 6 # 7 [ : & , / " # 2 ,_ # " ) "> 1 ? L 4 G I

, "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

•

! $ $ 2 T , % & , " . / ' , & A # 6 . A , & # 2 , : & , /

# 3 , " . & . / ' " 3 ' " 6 ' - # . ' " 3 : & , )

* # " ! 7 7 $ , - ) 2 7 : . , / : & ' " 3 #

d ' / , * ) e 0 / ) K & , / 4

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


31/168

F -

/ , , " & A ) . ) * d ' / , * ) e 0 / ) K &

, / ' " : & , ) " # " ! 7 7 $ ,

- ) 2 7 : . , /

W * ) : " 6 ) " a , % & J ! 7 7 $ , $ # 7

. ) 7

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


32/168

+ 2 # ' $ & F , " . . ) d ; b


33/168

@ ) . A , 5 / ' 0 :

" , F , / 8 , / ] )

3 & F A ) K F ) 2

, ) " ,

! - - , & & ' " 3 . A ,+ 2 # ' $ ] ' & . [

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q ! " # $ % & # ' ! ( ! ) ! ' ) " * ) + + - ! . ! ! / 8 6 2 5 V / - V , 6 ' . W " , K & $ , . . , / 4 : ' [ ' 6 _ E 4> Y 1 L L ? X L 1

Y

A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V

/ - V $ ' & . W " , K & $ , . . , / 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . )

& A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D

n

, - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = ? m = E ? W L R L L S Y n + 5 V # - - , & & V = > 4 5 0 : 4 9 = 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,

_ . , & . > 1 ? 4> Y 1 L L > R X ? > G

Y

A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V

- ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D

n

, - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = ? m = E ? W L R L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V ) T 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L ? > 1

Y

A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V

# - - , & & # = > 4 5 0 : 4 9 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_ . , & . > 1 ? L 4 G I , "W

f

F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G

4 X Y

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = 4 m 41 4 X D

n

, - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = = L R W L R L L S Y n + 5 V - ) " . , " . V $ ' & . W e 2 $ . , 2 7 $ # . , 4 : ' Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L 1 X G X m

Y

A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V

- ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D

n

, - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R

E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = = 1 L W L R L L S Y n + 5 V . # e ) " ) 2 % V & , # / - A W 7 #W . ) 7 ' - & 4 : ' [ 7 / ) 6 : - . # * * ' $ ' # . ,_ 7 3 1 0 Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L 1 L 4 G I , "W

f

F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G

4 X Y

5 A , & , # / , $ ) 3 , " . / ' ,

& * / ) 2 i ) 8 , 2 0 , / ? U1 L > L U & A ) K ' " 3 / , * , / , " - , & . )

` , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 ,j # " 6 ` T . e $ j * / ) 2 # " H B # & & ) - ' # . , 6 K ' . A 2 T , % & U # " 6 . A , 2 T , % &

: & , / # 3 , " . & . / ' " 3 4 5

A , # & & ) - ' # . , 6 : & , / " # 2 , ' & . , & . > 1 ?


34/168

! - - , & & ' " 3 . A ,+ 2 # ' $ ] ' & . [ U - ) " . J 6 4

5 A , & , # / , 2 ) / , $ ) 3 ,

" . / ' , & & A ) K ' " 3 / , * , / , " - , & . )

` , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 ,j * / ) 2 . A , H B

# & & ) - ' # . , 6 K ' . A 2 T , % & U # " 6 . A , 2 T , % & : & , / # 3 , " . & . / ' " 3 4 5 A , 6 # . , ' &

i ) 8 , 2 0 , / 1 1 U1 L > L 4

5 A , # & & ) - ' # . , 6 : & , / " # 2 , ' &

. , & . E G R X 4

Y R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ? G W L X L L S Y n + 5 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_ . , & . E G R X Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L

> X R m R G Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' "

. , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V - ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $

\ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n ,

- T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ? G W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V $ ,

* . # / / ) K 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L > 1 L

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8

, 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2

,_ . , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m

41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ? R W L X L L S Y n + 5 V # - - , & & V $ 6 # 7 V : & , / V * ' " 6 4 c & 7 Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L ? > R 1

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8

, 4 - ) 2 V - ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F

b

> L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ? R W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V ) T 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L ? > 1

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8

, 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2

,_ . , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m


R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ? R W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V / ' 3 A . # / / ) K 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L > 1 L

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8

, 4 - ) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2

,_ . , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m


R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


35/168

k A # . H B # 6

6 / , & & , & # / , / , $ # . , 6 . ) 3 , . . ' " 3

` , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3

, [ j

R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = ? m = E

? W L R L L S Y n + 5 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [

: & , / " # 2 ,_ . , & . > 1 ? 4> Y 1 L L > R X ? > G

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V - ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ #

V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b >

L 4 G I , "W f F I

/ 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q L ? V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L 1 = ? m = E

? W L R L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V ) T 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L ? > 1

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_

. , & . > 1 ? L

4 G I , "W f F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ?

G W L X L L S Y n + 5 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [

: & , / " # 2 ,_ . , & . E G R X Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L > X R m R G

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V - ) 2 2 ) " V " # 8 ' 3 # . ' ) " 4 : ' Y Y \ )h ' $ $ #

V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b >

L 4 G I , "W f F I

/ 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ?

G W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V $ , * . #

/ / ) K 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L > 1 L

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_

. , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b

> L


R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ?

R W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V ) T 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L ? > 1

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_

. , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b

> L


R E

4 E ? 4> G X 4> > WW q 1 1 V i ) 8 V 1 L > L = L ? = L 1 = ?

R W L X L L S Y n + 5 V ' 2 # 3 , & V 0 : . . ) " & V / ' 3 A . # / / ) K 4 3 ' * Q 5 5 B V > 4> Y 1 L L > 1 L

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 -

) 2 V # - - , & & V , 2 # ' $ 7 # 3 , 4 : ' [ : & , / " # 2 ,_

. , & . E G R X Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b

> L


! & , # / - A ) * . A , , " . ' / ,

6 # . # 0 # & , * ) / . A , . , / 2` , 2 #

' $ 7 # 3 ,j 0 , . K , , "

p : " , R U1 L > L # " 6 @ , - , 2 0 , / > U1 L > L & A ) K & ) " $ % ) " , H B # 6 6 / , & & W

R E 4 E ? 4> G X 4> > 4 !

" # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


36/168

; " $ %

) " , H B # 6 6 / , & &

' " . A , 6 # . # 0 # & ,

# 7 7 , # / , 6 . ) . # T

, . A , , 2 # ' $

6 # . # 0 # & , 0 , $ ) " 3 ' " 3 . )

d ) e G

X 4> > r K A ' - A K # & 7 / , 8 ' ) : & $ % # & &

) - ' # . , 6

K ' . A \ # . . A , K a , % &

4

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


37/168

d

) e 2 : $ 6 , /


38/168

H B # 6 6 / , & & m > 41

> G X 4> R 1 K # & # $ & ) : & , 6 . ) # - - , & &

. A ,

* ) e 2 : $ 6 , / 41 > G X 4> R

1 $ ) 3 3 , 6

' " . )

' . & , 2 # ' $ & , / 8 , / . ) # - - , & & . A , * )

e 2 : $ 6 , / L

> L = = L

X = L

> = E ? ! \

•

@ , - , 2

0 , / G U1 L > L

G =


39/168

H B # 6 6 / , & & m > 41 > G X 4> R 1 # $ . , / " # . , & 0 , . K , , " $ ) 3

3 ' " 3 ' " . ) . A , 5 / ' 0 : " ,

& , / 8 , / # " 6 . A ,

*

) e 2 : $ 6 , / = 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 & ' " . ) * ) e 2 :

$ 6 , / 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 & ' " . ) * ) e 2 :

$ 6 , / 41 > G X 4> R 1 WW q L L = > G = ? > = ? ? W L X L L S Y n + 5 V Q 5 5 B V >

4> Y 1 L L > R X > Y WY Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' "

. ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f

F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

•

@ , - , 2 0 , / E U1 L > L

1 = L R ! \W H B m > 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 & ' " . ) * ) e 2 :

$ 6 , / 41 > G X 4> R 1 WW q L E V @ , - V

1 L > L = 1 > = L R = L L W L X L L S Y n + 5 V Q 5 5 B V >

4> Y 1 L L > R X > Y WY Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' "

. ) & A I

f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f

F I / 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

•

@ , - , 2 0 , / G U1 L > L

> = E ? ! \W H B m > 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 & ' " . ) * ) e 2 :

$ 6 , / 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X

Y

•

@ , - , 2 0 , / G U1 L > L

G = 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 & ' " . ) * ) e 2 :

$ 6 , / 4> Y 1 L L R 1 E 1

Y A . . 7 & = V V # & & , 2 0 $ , / 4 . / ' 0 : " , ' " . , / # - . ' 8 , 4 - ) 2 V Y Y \ )h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' "

. ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ # - ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I

/ 8 = > 4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1 L > L L R 1 1

d ' / , * ) e V ? 4 G 4 X Y

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


40/168

; 0 & , / 8 # . ' ) "

•

H B m

> 41 > G X 4> R 1 K # & : & , 6 . ) # - - ,

& & 0 ) . A . A , 5 / ' 0

: " , & , / 8 , /

# " 6

. A , * ) e 2 : $ 6 , / 4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


41/168

f & , / ! 3 ,

" . F . / ' " 3 ' & F # 2 , # & 2 T

, % &

•

\ )

h ' $ $ # V E 4 L M \ # - ' " . ) & A I f I H " . , $ \ #

- ; F b > L 4 G I , "W f F I

/ 8 = >

4 m 41 4 X D n , - T ) V 1

L > L L R 1 1 d ' / , * ) e

V ? 4 G 4 X Y

! " # $& ' ( ) * + ,

* - - - . & */ 8 6 2 = + >4 $5 0 : 9 *(

7 3 1 $ ; - ?


42/168

H B # 6 6 / , & & m

> 41 > G X 4> R 1 K #

& : & , 6 0 % T , % & c ) 2

•

! - - ) / 6 ' " 3 . ) s # A ) ) U H B # 6 6 / , & & m > 41 > G X 4> R 1 $ ) 3 3 , 6 ' " . ) '

usa v. keys: plaintiff motions in limine

Documents