unraveling the secrets of graphene by multiscale simulations
TRANSCRIPT
Accelrys Contract Research Services
Unraveling the secrets of graphene by multiscalesimulations
07102010
Dr. Johan Carlsson
Contract Research
Contract Research Services
• The Nobel Prize in Physics 2010 was awarded jointly to Andre Geim and Konstantin Novoselov "for groundbreaking experiments regarding the two-dimensional material graphene"
Nobel prize in Physics 2010
Andre Geim Konstantin Novoselov
Contract Research Services
• Graphite is the thermodynamically stable form of pure carbon.
• Graphene is the individual layered building blocks of graphite.
Graphene, the new old material
Contract Research Services
Carbon in different dimensions
0-D 1-D 2-D 3-D
FullerenesNanotubes
Graphite
Diamond
Graphene
Graphene is the mother of sp2-carbon and is now filling the missing link
from 0- 3 dimensions.
Contract Research Services
• Transistors
• Sensors
• Solar cells
• Trans-electrode membrane
Applications of graphene
Lin et al., Science 327, 662 (2010).Schedin et al., Nature Materials 6, 652 (2007).
Xang and Müllen, Nano Lett. 8, 323 (2008).
Garaj et al., Nature 467, 190 (2010).
Contract Research Services
Scientific interest in graphene
• The first true 2D-crystal
• The electrons in graphene behave as massless relativistic particles.
Relativistic space-time cone
Contract Research Services
• Graphene: The material for next generation of nanoelectronics?
• Simulations of fundamental aspects for device engineering:– Electronic structure of single layer graphene– Multilayer effects– Strain engineering– Edge effects in graphene channels– Role of defects?– Functionalization
• Scientific interest in graphene– Can a 2D crystal exist?– Are the electrons in graphene relativistic?
Outline
Contract Research Services
• The electrons in Graphene has very high mobility and long scattering length• Graphene would form extremely thin conduction channels
Graphene in nanoelectronics
Josephson junction with graphene film as
normal conductor
Heersche et al., Nature 441(2007)
Trauzettel et al., Nature Physics 3 (2007)
Spin qubits in graphene quantum dots
Lin et al., Science 327, 662 (2010).
High electron mobility transistor (HEMT)
Contract Research Services
• Exfoliation of graphite
• Oxidation of graphite
• Heating of SiC
• Epitaxial CVD growth
Synthesis of graphene
Forbeaux, et al, Phys. Rev. B 58, 16396 (1998).
Mattausch et al., PRL 99, 076802 (2007).
Contract Research Services
K.S. Novoselov, PNAS 102, 10451(2005); and Science 306, 666(2004)
Studying graphene with pen and paper
Contract Research Services
Electronic structure of Graphene
Unit cell with two atoms
Assume that the -band is a linear
combination of pz-orbitals centered at A
and B lattice sites
=C1 A+C2 B
Insert into the Schrödinger Equation:
H =E
And multiply with the pz-orbitals.
A B
Tight binding description after Wallace, Phys. Rev. 71, 622 (1947).
Contract Research Services
Tight binding for Graphene
This gives a two dimensional secular equation
With the solution
Summing over the nearest neighbors B gives the
matrix element H12
Summing over the next nearest neighbors A’ gives
the matrix element H11
02
1
2221
1211
C
C
ESHH
HESH
1211
2
12
2
22112211 4)(2
1HHHHHHH
SE
2cos4
2cos
2
3cos41 2
0
2
12
akakakH
yyx
A B
A’A’
A’
A’A’
A’
2cos
2
3cos2cos2011
akakakEH
yxy
Contract Research Services
• The Fermi surface is limited to the six corner points in the Brillouinzone. The band structure has linear dispersion around these Dirac Points.
Tight binding band structure for Graphene
Tight binding for Graphene
K
M
Brillouin Zone
kx (Å-1)
Contract Research Services
Preparation:
• Enter a graphene sheet into a supercell
Ab-initio calculations
•DFT calculations:
•Castep: Plane waves, Energy cut-off: 450 eV
•DMol: Localized orbitals, Radial cut-off 12 au
•Exchange-Correlation: PBE-GGA
•Atomic relaxation until Force/atom < 0.01eV/Å
Contract Research Services
• Graphene has two types of
bands: and
• Graphene is a zero gap semi
conductor with linear dispersion
at the Dirac point.
DFT band structure of graphene
M
K
Contract Research Services
Measurements of the electronic structure
Photoemission spectra of graphene grown on SiC
T. Ohta et al., PRL 98, 206802 (2007)
Conductivity of exfoliated graphene.
Novoselov et al., Nature 438, 197 (2005)
K M
-F
(eV
)
Contract Research Services
• Weak interactions between the layers in few layer graphene gives subtle effects on the electronic structure.
Layer effects on the electronic structure
Contract Research Services
Bilayer of graphene
1L Graphene 1x1 2L Graphene 1x1
McCann and Fal’ko, PRL 96,086805 (2006).
The vertical interaction between the two layers split the -band.
Contract Research Services
Multi layers of graphene
1L Graphene 1x1 2L Graphene 1x1
4L Graphene 1x1 Graphite 1x1
Contract Research Services
• The graphene sheet may buckle under compression
• The bonds are extended under strain
Strain Engineering of Graphene
4% compression
of lattice const
Contract Research Services
• The bonds are shorter under compression leading to increased dispersion and broader band width.
• The bonds are elongated under strain leading decreasing dispersion and narrower band width.
• No gap opening under moderate homogeneous strain, since no symmetry breaking.
Electronic effects of strain
-4% compression
- 4% stretching
Contract Research Services
• The electronic structure is affected if the graphene sheet is cut into ribbons to make conduction channels in field effect transistors.
Edge effects in graphene channels
Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 206803 (2008)
Contract Research Services
Electronic structure of graphene ribbons
The band structure is similar to a nanotube:
The wave functions in the graphene ribbon have dispersion along the ribbon, but they are quantized perpendicular to the ribbon. But …
Quantization
Contract Research Services
Bandstructure of the zig-zag edge
There are two types of edge states at a zigzag edge:
Localized sp2-dangling bond state
Semi localized pz-state
QuantizationSTM picture of a zigzag edge on graphite.
Giunta and Kelty, J. Chem. Phys. 114, 1807 (2001).
Contract Research Services
Bandstructure of the zig-zag edge
The anti ferromagnetic magnetic state is most favorable.
Bare edge, FerromagneticBare edge, Anti ferromagnetic
Son et al., Nature 444, 347 (2006).
Contract Research Services
Vacancies in graphene
Contract Research Services
• Vacancies take the form of a combination of a large ring plus pentagons. • No spontaneous defect formation in equilibrium in graphene.
Vacancies in graphene
odd motifs even motifs
JMC and Scheffler, Phys. Rev. Lett 96, 046806 (2006)
V3 V4
V1 V2
Eform( C ) = Emotifslab(NC) + NC C -EG
C = C - ½ EC2 (eV)
Efo
rm(e
V)
D3
SW
V1
V3
V2
V4V5V6
Formation energy
G free C-atom
at T = 0 K
Contract Research Services
• Heat of formation for defective graphene is comparable to other metastable forms of carbon such as nanotubes.
• Defects may be formed during growth and frozen into the structure.
Graphene sheets with moderate amount of defects
Heat of formationj
form
j
jCnGVG ECHHi
ii1
1
Contract Research Services
• The defects induces a pz-state and a dangling bond at zigzag atoms
Electronic structure of defects in graphene
Density of States (DOS)-point wave function
(isosurface for 0.1 e/Å1.5)
+ --
db-state for V1
+
+
--
JMC et al., PRL 96, 046806 (2006)
-SW
–V1
–V2
+- +
+
pz-state for V1
pz-state for V2
Contract Research Services
Chemistry of graphene
Böttcher et al., Nanotech. 17, 5889 (2006).
Functionalization Burning
Contract Research Services
Ab-initio Thermodynamics
E form(T ,p) {EVNC (NO ) Fvib(T ) NC C} {EG NO O(T ,p)} q F
),(),(),( pTNpTGpTG i
i
iform
Gas(T ,p) EDFT (T 0) (T ,p0 ) kT ln(p
p0)
G solid(T ,p) EDFT (T 0) Fvib(T ) PVX
Fvib : Stretching and bending
modes of the C-O groupsF
vib(T
)
(T)
C=O
C-O-C
O=C-O-C=O
O-C=O-O
C-O-C=O
Contract Research Services
• The defect free basal plane is inert towards O2.
Oxygen adsorption of graphene
O2 adsorption
O diffusion
Contract Research Services
• The pentagons were identified as the active sites for O2-dissociation.
Oxidation of carbon materials
O2 adsorption
O diffusion
Equilibrium vacancy structure during oxidation
V3:3O
V1:2O
V5:4OV2:2O
V4:3O
Vacancies are dominated by C-O-C and C=O groups at low pO2 . Atmospheric
pressure also forms O=C-O-C=O.
T=650 C
V6:4O
Contract Research Services
• Additional O2 adsorption forms larger groups, such as C-O-C=O (Lactones) and O=C-O-C=O (Anhydrides).
O2-adsorption at an O-saturated vacancy
V4:3O+2Otop V4:5O (Lactone) V4:7O (Anhydride)
O2 adsorption
O diffusion
V4:30
Contract Research Services
Two step mechanisms for oxidation:
1: Saturation of undercoordinated C-atoms by O2-dissociation
2: Additional O2-dissociation activates the CO2-desorption.
JMC et al, Phys. Rev. Lett 102, 166104 (2009)
Contract Research Services
Fundamental questions about graphene
• Can graphene exist as a true free-standing 2D-crystal?
• Do the electrons in graphene really behave as massless relativistic particles?
Relativistic space-time cone
Contract Research Services
Graphene: a perfect 2D crystal?
The Mermin-Wagner theorem says that 2D crystals are unstable at finite temperature!
Contract Research Services
• The TEM observations indicate that individual graphene layers are buckled at finite temperature!
• Real or experimental artifact?
Experimental observations of Graphene at finite T
TEM-picture of a single Graphene layer placed on a TEM-gitter,
Meyer et al., Nature 446, 60(2007)
Contract Research Services
Preparation:
• Enter a large graphene sheet into a supercell
Simulations of graphene at finite temperature
•Atomistic Molecular dynamics simulations
•Materials Studio Forcite
•Atomistic Monte carlo simulations
Contract Research Services
MD simulations of graphene
T=298 K
T=1000 K
Large fluctuations perpendicular to the graphene layer.
Contract Research Services
• No restoring forces perpendicular to the graphene sheet-> Soft modes.
Phonons in Graphene
Mounet et al., Phys. Rev. B 71, 205214 (2005).
LA
TA
LO
TO
ZOZA
Contract Research Services
• Finite temperature Monte Carlo Simulations of a single
graphene layer showed that the layer ist buckled at finite
temperatures.
• The buckling is due to that there are no restoring force
perpendicular to the graphene layer.
Simulations of graphene at finite temperture
Fasolino et al., Nature Materials 6, 858 (2007).
JMC, Nature Materials 6, 801 (2007).
Contract Research Services
Relativistic effects in a pencil trace?
Relativistic particles obey the Dirac equation:
such that the energy has the form
E2=m2c4+p2c2,with a gap mc2
but massless particles has linear dispersion without a
gap.
B
A
B
Amc
x
ii
ix
i
Contract Research Services
• The band structure of graphene at the Fermi level has the same dispersion as a mass less Dirac particle if c is exchanged for vF!
Comparison of the Dirac spectrum to graphene
Relativistic particles Electrons at the Fermi level in graphene
Contract Research Services
• Graphene has a number of unique properties as the first truly 2D material.
• There are many promising applications for graphene, but it remains to be seen which of these that will have market success.
• Simulations can give insight into important properties for device engineering.
Summary