ultralow production and integration costs, … · 2015-10-07 · supported by: 3 advanced detector...

46
Daniel Ferenc, Andrew Chang, David Johnson, Chris Ducote Physics Department, UC Davis Important contributions by late Eckart Lorenz, MPI Munich and UC Davis Tom Ypsilantis, CERN and EP Paris Colloquium at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, June 24. 2015 ABALONE MASS-PRODUCTION PHOTOSENSOR TECHNOLOGY: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, EXCEPTIONAL PERFORMANCE AND ROBUSTNESS, LOW RADIOACTIVITY and MORE

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Daniel Ferenc, Andrew Chang, David Johnson, Chris Ducote

Physics Department, UC Davis

Important contributions by late

Eckart Lorenz, MPI Munich and UC Davis Tom Ypsilantis, CERN and EP Paris

Colloquium at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, June 24. 2015

ABALONE MASS-PRODUCTION PHOTOSENSOR TECHNOLOGY:

ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, EXCEPTIONAL PERFORMANCE AND ROBUSTNESS, LOW RADIOACTIVITY and MORE

Page 2: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 3: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University of California Some UC Davis grants, private donations, etc.

ABALONE Photosensor technology PATENT ISSUED YESTERDAY VACUUM PHOTOSENSOR DEVICE WITH ELECTRON LENSING. The U.S. Patent awarded on June 23, 2015, Patent No. 9,064,678. New patent submitted recently, PCT/US15/031188, more patents coming. 2 older patents are also relevant.

STARTUP COMPANY HAS BEEN FORMED: ‘PHOTONLAB, Inc.’

Some previous presentations: D.F., “ABALONE TECHNOLOGY AND PROTOTYPE TEST RESULTS,” LIGHT’14, October 2014, Ringberg. Daniel Ferenc, “PHOTON COUNTING IN THE NEXT DECADE,” KEYNOTE LECTURE at the ASPERA TECHNOLGOY FORUM, Munich, Oct. 2010, Daniel Ferenc, “NEW PHOTOSENOR CONCEPTS AND PRODUCTION METHODS

-VACUUM AND GASEOUS PHOTOSENSORS ,“ SHORT COURSE, IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium, Knoxville TN, Nov. 2010.

Page 4: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

OUTLINE

THE PROBLEM

THE ABALONE TECHNOLOGY AS THE SOLUTION

ABALONE PHOTOSENSOR PROTOTYPE PERFORMANCE (25 MONTHS OF CONTINUOUS OPERATION)

SELFIES TAKEN BY ABALONE PROTOTYPE:

LOOK HOW CLEAN AND EMPTY I AM ( > 10X LESS AFTERPULSING THAN THE BEST PhotoMultiplier Tubes)

LOOK HOW I CLEAN MYSELF INTERNALLY (by 3 complementary methods) LOOK HOW I RESOLVE SINGLE PHOTONS LOOK HOW SINGLE PHOTONS ARE DISTINGUISHED FROM THE PEDESTAL LOOK HOW I FORM LARGE-AREA THIN-SHELL DETECTORS IMAGINE HOW USEFUL MAY I BE FOR YOUR NEXT-GENERATION DREAM TOY

Page 5: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

MOTIVATION

PHYSICS RESEARCH

LARGE-AREA PHOTOSENSORS

MEDICAL IMAGING NUCLEAR SECURITY

THE PROBLEM

ALL RELY ON THE 80-YEAR-OLD PHOTOMULTIPLIER MANUFACTURE •HANDWORK - OLD, EXTREMELY SLOW AND ENERGY CONSUMING MANUFACTURE •VERY EXPENSIVE PRODUCTS , BUT LOW QUALITY •FRAGILE and BULKY PMT TUBES, HARD TO IMPLEMENT IN MATRICES OR WATER/ICE •POOR PERFORMANCE (COLLECTION EFFICIENCY, SINGLE-PHOTON SENSITIVITY…) •LIMITED QUANTITIES, ONE (TWO) SUPPLIERS – MONOPOLY

UNIQUE AMONG 1930’s ELECTRONIC MANU-FACTURES THAT IS STILL AROUND CHALLENGE TO THE READER: PLEASE NAME ANOTHER ONE

5

Page 6: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 7: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 8: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 9: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 10: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 11: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 12: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Ben Einstein “I was impressed, however, by the look and feel that was achieved with so few parts.”

HUFFINGTON POST

June 23

Page 13: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 14: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 15: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 16: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 17: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 18: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 19: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 20: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 21: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 22: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 23: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University
Page 24: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

ABALONE Daniel Ferenc UC Davis LIGHT'14

ABALONE FOCUSING IS ARRANGED “BEHIND THE (VACUUM) SCENES” (i.e. in the ‘AIR’)

Conductive surfaces OUTSIDE THE VACUUM

(their dimensions make the focusing lens)

‘AIR’ ‘AIR’

THE ELECTRIC FIELD PENETRATES GLASS

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 25: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 26: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Discussions with Sebastian Boeser and Spencer Klein Ice Cube

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 27: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

ABALONE Daniel Ferenc UC Davis LIGHT'14

ABALONE FOCUSING IS ARRANGED “BEHIND THE (VACUUM) SCENES” (i.e. in the ‘AIR’)

‘AIR’ ‘AIR’

CUT AND “EXPORT” THE FIELD LINES TO THE NEIGHBORING

UNITS IN A MATRIX Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 28: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 29: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 30: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 31: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 32: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 33: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

ABALONE Daniel Ferenc UC Davis LIGHT'14

(1) DOME

(3) WINDOWLET

SCINTILLATOR

(2) BASE-PLATE

PHOTOCATHODE

ELECTRON TRAJECTORIES

POSITIVE IONS - AFTERPULSING

ion hit area ~4 mm

ION TRAJECTORIES

(for ions originating from the Windowlet

and its neighborhood)

Page 34: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

ABALONE Daniel Ferenc UC Davis LIGHT'14

Page 35: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

May 2015

Nov 2013

ABALONE SELFIES: TIME-OF-FLIGHT MASS SPECTROSCOPY

ION TIME OF FLIGHT

SELF-VACUUM

PUMPING:

A. CHEMI-

SORPTION

B. PHYSI-

SORPTION

C. ION

IMPLANTATION

U = 15 kV

U = 15 kV

AFTERPULSING < 5 x 10-4 ions/pe

Page 36: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

TOF ~ U-1/2

U = 10 kV

U = 15 kV

U = 20 kV

U = 25 kV

ION TIME OF FLIGHT

Page 37: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

U = 20 kV U =25 kV U = 27 kV

SIGNAL AMPLITUDE

SINGLE PHOTONS

Back-Scattered photo-electrons

(non-returning)

1 pe

2 pe

Page 38: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

25 electrons Back-Scattered

Cr-coating

CASINO-2 Simulation

LYSO CRYSTAL

Page 39: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

ELECTRON BACK-SCATTERING FROM THE LYSO WINDOWLET

CASINO PROGRAM

MOST ELECTRONS RETURN TO THE

WINDOWLET

NO RETURN

DOUBLE- DIP

= Full energy

Page 40: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

THERMIONIC ELECTRON EMISSION = f(U)

U = 20 kV U = 25 kV U = 27 kV

PEDESTAL (G-APD)

1 th. el.

SIGNAL AMPLITUDE

DARK COUNTS, WITHOUT A LIGHT SOURCE

Page 41: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

U = 20 kV U = 25 kV

SIGNAL vs. PEDESTAL

SIGNAL AMPLITUDE

Page 42: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

U = 20 kV

U = 25 kV

U = 28 kV

Page 43: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

220

Page 44: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678

Page 45: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188

Page 46: ULTRALOW PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION COSTS, … · 2015-10-07 · SUPPORTED BY: 3 Advanced Detector Research Rewards (ADR), DOE NNSA/DOE Grant Proof Of Concept (POC) Award, University

Patent No. 9,064,678 and patent pending PCT/US15/031188