uc santa barbara geography - a new framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11....

7
(1998) In M.J.Egenhofer & R.G.Golledge (Eds.), Spatial and temporal reasoning in geographic information:)systems, (pp. 143-154). New York: Oxford University Press. Chapter 11 A New Framework for Understanding the Acquisition of Spatial Knowledge in Large-Scale Environments Daniel R. Montello People acquire knowledge about the spatial layout of the places they experience (cities, neighborhoods, buildings). This includes knowledge of locations, distances, and directions. The acquisition of this knowledge begins immediately, as soon as one arrives in a place, but presumably continues over long time periods, for months, years, and even decades. This knowledge can become quite extensive and elaborate. It provides a framework for the organization of experience and supports sophisticated spatial behavior such ascreative wayfinding and direction giving. The developmental process of acquiring knowledge about the spatial layout of places over time is termed. Theoreticians from a variety of disciplines (cognitive, developmental, and environmental psychology; behavioral geography; planning and architec:ture; computer science) have attempted to describe and model spatial microgenesis. The long-dominant framework for understanding this process posits the following sequence: knowledge is initially acquired, followed by knowledge, which is followed by knowledge. In brief, according to this, landmark knowledge is knowledge of distinctive objects or scenes stored in memory. Route knowledge is knowledge of travel paths connecting landmarks. Survey knowledge is configurational knowledge of the locations and extents of features in some part of the environment that is not limited to particular travel paths. In this chapter I will reconsider the dominant framework in some detail, identify some problems with it, and offer an alternative framework that I believe is more conceptually coherent and more consistent with research evidence. The Dominant Framework The most influential expositions of the dominant framework are by Hart andMoore (1973; Moore, 1974) and,especially with respect to microgenesis, SiegelandWhite (1975). Many of their ideascamefrom Piaget'sextensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,including his idea of a progression from topological to projective and metric knowledge (e.g.,Piaget and lnhelder,1967).Otherimportant influences were 143

Upload: others

Post on 30-Mar-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

(1998)In M.J.Egenhofer & R.G.Golledge (Eds.), Spatial andtemporal reasoning in geographic information:)systems,(pp. 143-154). New York: Oxford University Press.

Chapter 11

A New Framework for Understanding the Acquisition ofSpatial Knowledge in Large-Scale Environments

Daniel R. Montello

People acquire knowledge about the spatial layout of the places they experience(cities, neighborhoods, buildings). This includes knowledge of locations, distances,and directions. The acquisition of this knowledge begins immediately, as soon asone arrives in a place, but presumably continues over long time periods, for months,years, and even decades. This knowledge can become quite extensive and elaborate.It provides a framework for the organization of experience and supportssophisticated spatial behavior such as creative wayfinding and direction giving. Thedevelopmental process of acquiring knowledge about the spatial layout of placesover time is termed.

Theoreticians from a variety of disciplines (cognitive, developmental, andenvironmental psychology; behavioral geography; planning and architec:ture;computer science) have attempted to describe and model spatial microgenesis. Thelong-dominant framework for understanding this process posits the followingsequence: knowledge is initially acquired, followed by knowledge, which isfollowed by knowledge. In brief, according to this, landmark knowledge isknowledge of distinctive objects or scenes stored in memory. Route knowledge isknowledge of travel paths connecting landmarks. Survey knowledge isconfigurational knowledge of the locations and extents of features in some part ofthe environment that is not limited to particular travel paths. In this chapter I willreconsider the dominant framework in some detail, identify some problems with it,and offer an alternative framework that I believe is more conceptually coherent andmore consistent with research evidence.

The Dominant Framework

The most influential expositions of the dominant framework are by Hart and Moore(1973; Moore, 1974) and, especially with respect to microgenesis, Siegel and White(1975). Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatialontogeny, including his idea of a progression from topological to projective andmetric knowledge (e.g., Piaget and lnhelder, 1967). Other important influences were

143

Page 2: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

_.n

: ~

3

co

co

co

3 =

' ~

co

-_

.~

0 ,-

.,..,

='

co

-n

3 0

-=

co

-n

~

>

0 '"

,-..

<:..

., 0"

-0

n

n co

-.

~.

g g

~.

co

~

a ::i

co

~

0

5.

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

g 0'

r;

. ~

~

~

'"

~

~

5 3

~

2 ::c

~

~

~

~

"'.

~

0

~

~;;:

. -~

-=

. co

,

0 =

. -.

'" -=

. n

co

Vi

3""

."'

~

(JQ

"'

0 --

3 -=

=

., 0

3 n

~

0 ..,

0

='

",.,

",'

..,

3 0"

-

=-

::.

=.

co

0 0.

'<

=

" a.

0

='

-~

~

0 .g

=

' 0

~

c ;;"

'"

<'

0 (J

Q

3 is

co

~

(J

Q

~

='

~

-<x.

~

<

' =

' _.

<'

~

~

~

'<

-:;

::.

='

Q)

~

~

~.

~

-.=

=

=-

~

0 ..,

~

-Q

. "'

~

..,

Q)

<'

.2

;; ~

g

~.

-,~

~

. ~

~

(J

Q

~

~

'-'

3 ~

. <

' 3

~

~

~

co

~

~n

-C

n Q

) co

n

'" =

=

<

: C

'"

0 =

3co

~

-"

:;

~

=.

Q.

co

Q)

-.co

n

-C

-.,.

~

0 ~

.Q

-~

-0"

-co

~

(JQ

3

~

=.

-co

~

co

..,

n ..,

~

co

-.

=

~0..,

~

-

3Q

) (JQ

0 --

'" ~

~

0

~ o..,

Q

) ~

. <

' -<

'C

~

-.

0 ~

-n

-3

n

~

-.0

-<'

<'

~

=

~

...~

n

<'

-.~

~

n

co

9-

~

0.

-co

-N

~

3 '"

~.5

.:::-

g C

"'-

:<0

0"2.

",

~

=3

'" <

' 8

~.

~

~

~

-..,

R.n

~

~

g ~

0'

n

~..,

-.

~'-"

0-3

~"'-

:<~

'"

co

Q)

="

.,.,

~

-0

0.

~

-;.

~

=

.0

"0

="

~

(JQ

~

>

<:

0 ~

~

~

n

~

~"O

-<

'"

~"'

5.:;1

; ~

~

3

~

0 Q

. =

. <

. ~

5.

-.0

~

--,..

, <

' ~

Q

. '<

0

'" ~

n

-*

0.

<';;

" ~

~

~

-'"

~

-n

<

' <

' (J

Q (

JQ

<'

-,..,

0

0 <

'0

..,

.' 0

~

-'"

<'

~

(:§

-..,

"0

~

_.'-"

n

0 ;;-

.Q

~

co

co

-c

<'

0 -=

=

'<

-.a

~

.-=

=

-C

~

,.-.

'"~

3

~

~

co

:I n

-0.

0"

'" 0'

\0

c;

- co

'"

N

~

0 0'

"'

C

"' 3

==

r;

. -0

. ,..

, =

- (J

Q

~

"0

=

"0

~

~

-0

..,

3 '"

3 ::c

c;

-,

..Co

co

0 9

"'.

co 30

'<

~

..,

<x.

~

n ,-

.. ~

-.

., co

..,'

<'

n -(

JQ

="

0 =

- co

<'

'" ;;-

...:

: ...

1 ~

-.

-?:

=.

0 ~

~

(J

Q=

,..

,,;.

3..,

"-<

x "O

--Q

.3

-"'~

"con

~.

--'"

.-.n

. =

:"'~

--,..

,"O

G

3.

.~

Co

~

G

G

G

g ~

. ..,

~

co

~

~

5.

3 \0

=

. ~

~

~

;1

-~'~

0

~

~

="

r.I3

=.

-.G

~

~

'"

'" ~

'"

~

§'

§ ~

~

Q

. ~

~

' 8

S'

<'

0'

:?.

n 'a

: ~

~

(J

Q g

r;

. ~

g

~-

g r.

I3 ~

=

~

~

~

~

.;;:"

O

o'

<'

S'

g ~

g-

§-

-@

.: S

' ;?

,5-

-g

?,

~

~

?,

~

~

S

' ~

;:;

~

~

; g

0 '0

~

0'

:,.

, 0

~

~

0 ~

':<

::

~

~

9-

~

5'

; ~

~

0

a.

~

~

~

;:;

§ ~

'"

O"'~

-n"'-

""'N

."'~

-.

"':::"

""

"'G~

g""c

oo~

"'~~

co=

=s.

con=

=3,

<""

G-G

"'~0.

~'~

~

§ ~

: ~

g

.8 c~

~ 3

~

~

g ~

~

:?

" ~]

! ~

§"

. ;;

§ ~

~

~

g

S'

§:

~

~

0'

~ .

g -g

: ~

~

:J

: g

:;..g

~

~

~

~

9:

;.

~-"

""'~

0.

~

--r.

I3n<

,Q.-

'" -'"

"'0

~G

3"-

. ~

"'G3-

"O

G"'-

n -:

<

5"

3 g

g 0

<J

G

~

0.

:; co

:I)

;;.

~

. P

o 0

~

~-

§ ;;

'" ~

9-

~

a

~

,..,

'0

~

G

co

~

0 =

0

0'

<'

§ 3

'" ..,

g,

~

=;.

r;'

~

-n

3 <

: ~

_.

~'

~

g 5.

(J

Q

(:§

'" 3

co

.,...,

-~

s-

0'

g

-,

~

~

Q.

(JQ

S

' ~

g-

co

,..

, ",

' ~

, ag

o.

co

co

0"

n 5

~.

~

co

:r;:

S'

~

S'

~

:::

;.,

g 0.

~

3~

0.

~

S'

~

~

"'"3

3 (J

Q §

, ~

~

~

g (J

Q .:-

c

ri 9-

0.

0~

~

0

3 ~

~

'<

_ 0-.

~

n'

(JQ

~

co

0

'" co

G

'" ~

n

co

G

--=

- ,

co

'-'

~

>

-0.

~

~..

0 ~

. "'.

., ,.

",'

~

co c

o .2

!. ::

3-c

o '<

0~

-;

:. -,

. ~

~

'"

-.'"

n -c

o '"

..,

..co

-~

G

_.-o

,~

W

'n-.

"'~

.-_

33

_W'O

W'-~

n.

"'~

'" ~

.-

,~

Q.

~

~

-.5.

~

.-

? 3

0-

C

N

~

0.

t""'

~

co

0.

~

5 0

'" "0

~

. 3

~

co

"'--

..,

'<

n ~

'"

'T1

='

"0

0"

(JQ

:; ~

~

G

n"

" ~

~

'"

~

'" co

-"

""

~

=,

co

~.

'0

C

-03

.,...,

--

"0

;. ~

~

, -.

-,

(JQ

;;-

G

<

'~

C

-.

3 3

~;1

i.,

=

.. '"

0.'-"

~

~

~

~

~

n

~

n (J

Q

n ~

~

3

co0

:: ~

. ~

s'

::i

co

~

0" ;

."0

~

: '<

~

.

g ~

Q

) 3

~

0 -o

. ~

~

~

Q

. cr

- 3

o.

;;"

0 C

co

~

;;-

~

co

~

co

~

3 ...

0 ~

~

;'

-~

~

'" co

co

...

,'"

~

S'

~-

6'

;' co

0. 3

.~

§ ~

0

~

~.

~

~

co ~

:1

)3

~

;!], ~

;?

, rfQ

- ~

=,

S'

;;"

a,.g

, ~

. ~

a.

::

~

(JQ

3 ~

9"

.8

a.

g 2:

:Q

) Q

. ~

:I "'.

~

0

Q.

0,..,

...

, ~

~

0

'" 0

=-

-<'

co

3 -0

'<

-n

..,

-.

~

'<

-r;..

c,

.-.

'"5.

~

3"

~

~

o'

g

~

9-

~

;::'

~

g,

-:r;

: ~

g;

::,

~

a ~

~

~

~

~

~

@

~

,-

.. G

"0

~

. ~

~

~

~

0'

~

~

~

::c

~

: [

~

in.

~

§.: ~

s:

::

~

: &

~

~

, ~

~

~

g

~

go

g. ~

[

~o;.

~

~

CO

c~

'fl

~

. ~

g

g '0

§

a §-

~

~

§.

§: ~

O~ :;

;co

-~

. ~

'"

~

~

~,

3 co

~.

,. ~

co

,.

co 0

'"

--~

~

..,

co..,

-'"

3

'-'

0g,

~.:

~

~

~

O'

c~

§@

g;;:g

'?

§ ~

5.

~3[

~

~

s:~

. g-

~

' ~

Jg

. ~

~

a

~

~

[;?,

&

:;.

~.

5 ,::

~

~

~

~

'

0 n

c co

<

' --

~

~"O

N

-.

~

3 ...

G

0 ~

co

"0

'"

C

co

~

"0

'" G

,

co

Q.

-0

G=

:I)

n

-0.

~

';;

~

~

0.

-,

0 0

W

.Qc

~

co

G

",...

""

(JQ

=

. co

'"

-cr-

<

: G

Oo

~

"0

~

G"

~

9-

G

\0

3 '7

'! ~

, n

'" -~

o.

(J

Q

~

-co

in.

~

~

--'-'

-.

., ~

~

0

co

-0

..,

-.~

'<

~

'"

'" ...

, ~

..,

..,

co

'" 0\

-'

"""0

~

"co

-:<

?:

~

~

~

~ o

~

0- ~

aa

~

~

Cn

~

~

:r;:

Vi

~

§ ~

';

~

R'.§

g

§ ~ o

E

~

!:?.

Vi

~'

g g

5'

g "c

...9

~

~

3 ~

-Q.

~'~

-.

-,

n <

' -0

0

,. 0

,. ,.

<:

0 c'

" -c

o ~

-

3'<

-.

-' ~

-c

o 0.

~

~

: 0"

g

=-

~

'" ~

~

;?

, ~

:.

3~

'"

~,..

, '"

'0

~

:;..,

~:'~

'Oe

!. ~

e

'0

e --

6'

C

Q.

-.~

2:

- -'-

""0

G"'-

0 ~

- ~

,.

,.-

:,"'<

,...

3(JQ

U

~-.

.,O"

..".,

"'~

~

~

C

C

~-

~

~

n ~

C

...

:,.-.

~

G (

JQ g

0.

~

C

G

;;"

0.".,

~

::!.

0 r;

. (J

Q

~

Q.

~

~

g .<

' '<

3

~

r;.

g 0'

\0

:::

!.--

, ;

-~

-.Q

~

~

co

~

~

n

C

<'

_.co

n

~

~

n G

'<

~

0"

':<

~

~

"O

G

-.':-

' co

0

Vi

-,

C

0\

~

-.5

g-

..,

9-

'" ~

~

5.

=

- ~

' 5.

G

g

g ~

Q

. ~

0.

~

~

~

C

Q

. ~

. ~

C

:I)

~ o

-:<

~

~

~

~

s-

*

---;

:;'

';;

::B

5.

~Q

. -,

co

0

...,

co

3n

, 0

., _.

,. '"

03

...0"

~

G

-~

'"

~

~

co

---

-(JQ

,..

, G

""

<'

,'"'"0

<

' -.

~

<'

3;S

. '"

~

03

-.0"

'"

co

n ~

"'.

., a

G

C'

co

=,

3 ~

:

~Q

. co

~

co

-,

~

,...

0.

-,

~

co

co

0 "0

0

3~

,-

.. 0

~

-.-c

o ~

-:

G

-0

-0

. ~

..,

0.

., '"

0 co

0"

0

C

'" "0

~

~

0

:. ~

co

...

'" -.

-~

,. ~

~

~

..,

~

co

~

0

(;

"0

~

cr-

-,

G

'" ~

...

, -c

o ~

"0

9-

..,

"0

~.

~

.~

'""0<

' ~

..,

0'

-~

'"

~

C

'" G 3

0 ~

30

~

3 co

...

G

C

<:

-Q.

0 3

~

;-

~

Q.

~

-'"

G

g 0

~

0 0

0 ..,

<

' "'.

., Q

. .0

V

i e!

. 0

0"

~

~.

--~

-<

: -<

' ~

(J

Q

...~

-.

<'..

, '"

0 ~

_.

'"(J

Q_.

."77

.,,,

':-,0

':-'=

,-"

,. -,

<,

, _O

Go.

. o.

co~

. ,(

JQ""

. 0.

..,

...,0

.,

z:o

...

n-nG

-"O

o"'_

-3

G"'~

3-~

3",

-",

no

~~

QI..

.QI

~G

-0

0 G

=

G

C

:::

C

'<

G

-QI

=.

0 0.

3

G

QI

G

QI

C

...Q

I ;;1

0

(')

'in g

~

3'.-

~

"""o

nGC

G"'~

q =

, ~

=

,.~

"'r--

=-_

n_n=

G..,

- ~

=

G

-oo~

c -o

&.."

.,C~

~

on

G

oo...

=

-QI

o.G

Q

I =

=

3

(')

.on

'" =

...

"'..."

""

"0

..,

(JQ

~

'<

-C

0.

=,

0.

0..

C

0.

-QI

G

=

8.

<

'" ...

0 <

C-o

n G

=

- =

03

0\0

>

< Q

I ~

G

C

G

~

3G

=

- (')

G

~.

C

QI

,. ...

, =

- Q

) on

-..I

=

_.C

" ~

0.

. '<

'"

~

=-

..,

-

On

= "0

'< ~

n :

< --,

., 3

Co "

=, ~

'" (')

~ ?'"

=- -'...

.., 0

-~ =

(;'i Q)

=. 'Q;

0\ 0.

~ 0

~ G...

~"DO" 'g'

~ =-~.'"

DO ~

-<:~," n'

~ ~

=- "

~ S'

0 0

DO c(')

m

~

':'

~

~

3

0.

~

9.

0 ..,

~

0

=

.' "0

~

co

o G

a

~

~

~

0.."

Q

)...

~

n =

=

: <

3"

r:

r §

3 "

0..

~

C-<

v~

.C

G

=

.,

...,

G

,. =

(')

r"

' 0

""

"0

;'..,

~"

" on

0

~

n 0

-"

~

on

~

" 0.

. C

o F

D

=- 0-g

=:

g-

~

3 -J

~

~

~

~

~

=

:.:;;

on ~

Q

I S

' g

;"

~

~

~

- ..,9

'" !!

-E ..

,0

c.

=3=

: C3

~

.~

"'.

-<.:

~

~

~

5,

~

g,

~

: --

'" Q

) =

' -,

<

: "0

~

Q

I =

-.

v'

,. '"

-<:

-v.

-,

QI

--'.

,. <

: N

,.

DO

0

- ~

~

.o

n g

--"0

~

~

9.

, (;

" 0

~.:;

;~.

=:

=

0.

c.

::.

~ c0

~

~

.g

'f'

~

~

DO ..,

g ~

~

=

, c

o.~ ~

~

S

2" >

a .1

S

' ~C

o~

:

c (0

' -',

~

-.-,

n-

o..'

"",

-,.

"'=0

-~D

O,.

---,

- ~

:-

-'"

"0

:;

,. '"

0.

=

QI "

0 Q

I 0.

C-:;.

~...

'..

. ~

~

:::

, -,

""

, ~

'- D

O

0..

(.II

--.,

-~

C"

~

0 -"

'"

\0

0 "0

'" ~

<

: (J

Q

--~

-

3~

...

~

...D

O

DO

"',

0

0..

,. D

O

=

-~

.-,

~

0 =

- -~

..,

~

C

D

O

0 ~

0

~3

' 0

~

0 Q

I ~

'"

-'"

-n

~

n ~

'"

0 '5

- ~

'5."

'" ~

'in

-o

8.'

~~

~"D

O§D

OO

"..,

""~

..,

0

N

n =

- :J

'<

.:

--~

0

'<

0 ~

-:

:. 0'

C

" S

...

o'

~

go

-,

r:r

~~

' :-

" ~

...,

-~

: ~

'"

:, Q

. :J

. s:

~

~

Q

. ~

~

:;:."

~

0\

~

~

;;I

5'

~

~

e;

...

, 3

3 :J

. &

.. '<

@

~

~

0

=

~,~

~

~

c=

-o

g 3

a ~

N

Q

. :.

~

~

3 ~

~

g,

'<

. g

~n

Q

0.'.

0.

3 .o

n Q

.."'"

in

=

'" Q

I"O

(')

, C

"' ~

~

c

'" 0

(0"

0 &

.. ~

~

C

-~

C

D

O ~

~

D

O ~

~

-'.

., ~

g ~

~

[

~

;;;,

~

~'~

'~'

g ~

.~.

~

~

~

~

~

g ~

~

~

~

@ [

~

~

~,

~,~

~,

~

[ ~

~.

~~

' ~

~

~

~

[

[ ~

~,

0.

c.

0.

(')

&..

0 ~

c

S'

~

'5

g &

.. in

' 0'

n

~

g ~

, =

<

'"

~

ii'

~

go

~

-,

~

'" '"

=

~

~

~

..,

e,?,

;.

Co

g g

5.

.,

:;:.

!?.

~

:0

~

3 ~

c.

'"

QI

-=

-=.

=

0=.

':-'

=

~

i ~

s.

~

f!E

.::3

~

g Q

. go

c.

~

"i

~

~

~

~

g ~

'0

F

DQ

.go

:J.

~

0 ~

~

.~

--

'<:=

~"'~

=Q

I "'-

...

" ,.~

-'.

, "-

<:

3,.'

-~

~

_.-~

~

-~

. =

- 'in

~

=-

0.

g in

. g

n -=

>

's

;' 0

n'

~

~

8.

;-

S'

3 (0

' ~

0

~

=-;

. ~

G

5.

: ~

-'8

~

'

~

'" ~

~

o._\

Oc~

~-

n.-"

,=."

,=,-

S._

=""

~=

~~

~

(BQ

..o..;

3

~.D

O-o

.=

~~

-DO

3-'

'0.."

'..,

0 =

- 00

-n

-~

c.

~

~

<

: =

<

: 0

~

-0.

-0

~

Co

Co

'<

,,'

" =

- on

~

0.

. -C

o -j

g 5.

G

go

0

9,

Co

-,§.

(')

::;

; :;:

. 0

~

~

a'

'" ~

, (;

" 0.

. (;

" ~

8.

~

9.

, ~

~

g

~

~

go

~

~

g-

~

,;2

5'

S'

a 's

;' ~

9.

, ~

~

3

3 ~

~

g

~

~

8,

g=

c:

.:'

(')

~

~

0 S

."O

~

0.

0

0.

'" ~

0.

D

O ~

~

~

0

=-

a 00

E:.

~

n :0

c

=

--~

~

-,

D

O -.

., ..,

:::

- -'"

'0

~

g

go

~

0=

~

§.

.Q. ~

. -:

: ~

;"

~

3.

~

:

~

"J:

[ go

~

~

~

~'.!

A

~

~

~

~

8 '5

g'

:,

~

3,

~ 3:

~

a-

~

i :

e,

~

g'

:::

--~

-D

O

,-

C"

--,

00

'" '"

~

-DO

.

0.,

~Q

.-

3'"

'" '"

,,"'.

-~

" 0

0 -<

~

~

~

=

~

--

" -,

Q

-.

., ,,~

- -.

"...

-..,

~"o

o =

- Q

I 0.

"

~

'<

on -

, 00

~,

~'

" ~

c

:;"'

..,

'" -,

Q

I <

D

O a

~

00 -

.=

0 Q

I "0

--

, '<

=

=

0 3

~

~

-,

"',

3 n

3 ~

-.

0 .,

-<

~

~

~

~

00 0

0 9.

~

,:0 3

:0 ~

a

~

!?.

a ~

g

:?3

~

g =

:

~

~

~

'0

~

!?.

C"

&..

.:I:

~

~,

~

Co

0 0.

~

3 §,

~

: ~ 3

~

Q;

~

_0~

~

~

~

~

0.

0"""

"',

"'~o:

o~~

~-"

c_.

."..,

-;

--'

=-

DO

=

~on

,,-

, ",

00""

"~

C

::

~

...,

;3

c.

~

~

~

'" 0.

-'<

0

on

-:0

...0.

=

"i ~

~

'<

-j

., ~

-D

O

go"1

:J

DO

-,

-0

00

" 3

-0

-,

~

:...

.".,

~

:0

~

::!,

0 -

3~

(;

" ~

, 0

':;

(JQ

:J

" =

: :J

...

DO

~

0.

G

G

-~

00

8

~

0 0

~'=

-~

=

;:.

~

~

'"

0;

c D

O

" n'

..,

Q

0 ::

-=

DO

:J"

:0

0.

~

...C

G

G

=

:i

~

=

G

-,

'" 0.

'5

~

, "

'" "0

0 =

0.

~

-,

--

" 0

., -c

-,

c

0

;; (')

:j

~,

~

CJ

.-0.

. ~

8.

n

~

0.

0.

DO

~

0.

'" 1

~

~

0 Q

. ~

g"

~

3

~

@"

q.

=-

r:r

:. 0

§ "'.

(0

' Q

0;

~

~

~

-QI

non"

, <

: ~

C

-0

S

' n

C

~

:J"

n 0.

=

=

I

~

~'

.""

~:o

G

. D

O

" "

Co

C

Co

.Co

0'0'

..,

" :0

: ~

<

' g-

-<

."

0 0

'0

-,

~

3~

...

DO

3

0..

g :;'

-<

: g

::.

:;.

'0

""

'-'"

0 o'

n

or;

~

0 *

=

0 3

..,

~

-~

-,

0;

"' S

' 0;

~

n

~.

(')

C

:: ::0

~

, ~

-g

~

~

D

O

G

-=-

S'

QI

...~

~

()

'::

: ~

3

-J

S

~

~

g '?

- 0

:;-'

'" g

...~

g

~

~

0/

~

5.

~

&..

5.

5 ~

:J"

3 --

, 00

Q

I .-

DO

,

9.,

--D

O

=

~

9 G

C

0

='

"0'

~.g

' ~

~

--

=

~

~

or;

" ~

3

~

3 ~

~

3~

~

-,

--

."..

-'""'"

0

-,

DO

=

-=

0.

G

.'in

DO

'..

. G

~

..,

(JQ

-;-

--,

DO

. 0

'" -D

O

<

00 _

.DO

"'"

g

n ~

:o

":-'

'">

~.

0.

--<

::

\0

--<

~

-.

<

ri ~

'<

&

.. -,

c

..,;;:

g

=

:: (;

" *

'00

g-

S'

DO

..,

~

..,

~

DO

=-

-~

~

~--

~-o

=

oo""

~,

<:\O

n~-n

o.

-~O

Jg"

~

o.=

QI.

'v,

5.'

o;,,~

"o~

-:o

'<

3~

~

3"

~

~

:::

. ~

~

S

' "J

:!:!)

@ 3

~

(;"

0.~

~

8.

~

,03

~

~

g g,

or

; ~

~

go" g..

.:!l

in

' ii'

3

S'

5'

~:

~

~

"0

~

~""

'. --

""--

n -.

"-'0

~

'-~

"""

~o-

non

(JQ

00

_.~

00

"'"

S'

~

g 5.

g,

§,

§

in'

~.

~

9 g.

C

J a

~:J

: '5

m

~

";

2.

0'"

~

§'

"':

~

" 3.Q

)c.

'1

g ~o.

.!?.

~

~

~

B

?;' 3

:

§ K

-g

--~

n

---'"

<

: "

DO

~

<

-~

-..,

-DO

D

O

., ""

~

., -.

~

v~.,

0 ~

' ~

' '"

:0

c.

-.n

0'

=

(')

0 3

0..,

3!

_.->

<

~

-on

~

-'='"

~

-=-

~

..,

., Q

. -.

., ~

»

0 -,

-

~

...:

-~

:::

g'

3 =

~

...

~

~.

* ~

;;

~

n g.

S

' (')

~

~

g,

9

[':.<

:"

~

(jq'

~

'0

Co

0/

.-0/

'0

9

'!"

~

';'

9 9'

e;

~

g.

~

~

=

~

:0

"0

3 =

. g-

0"

=

: 0

-,

G'

=

0'

C

~

(;"

; ;3

g.

-,

=

:0

ce;o

::!

,:::

c 0

=

G:o

:;:

. ~

=

: g

';'

'('

" ,

0.,

,9

.Co"

;' '"

""...

,0..

DO

.-

~ .g i: .~ r f -:. '" ~ "~ ~ [ e ~ ~ -g ~ C

O)

~ 00 ~.

~.

~ ~

Page 3: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

N

--<

':-

'"

'"!1

--~

--

0'0

0=

o._Q

O,.,

~

~

--

=

QO

...,

':-3

~

0>

QO

,-..

~...

, '"

'" 0

QO

=-

--"'=

-=

o.c"

,n~

==

- --

c""-

~~

'O~

c~~

"'"..,

.gE

;"o(

")

0"s;

.3,.,

0.

QO

--

~

-:;-

Q

O

---~

6

~

--~

- ("

)"'-

--~

--3

"'---

""

"'3

~-:

::.

~r'n

~

<~

--

-,.,

=o~

Son

.g,.,

::o.~

o.'"

%:;"

'o~

0(I

Q

~

0 ~

--

-(IQ

--

,. (I

Q

--..,

,.,

,.3

~

~

~

0 0

~

=

~

-~

=~

c

~

~

%

'" ~

- =

n

-0

':-

3 =

0.

:;:-=

--=

-('O

--~

.:::~

~=

-",

=~

~("

)"-

-o-"

",--

~

--oo

~"',

.,~

;-

=

~

2:

- ~

=

- ~

~

0-

~

~

,.,

0

on-

0~

~

0

'<

:l.

<-

-=

-=

n ("

) ~

,.,

0"

'"..,

<

' '<

~

=

- 0.

~

'"

0 --

~

'<

-"'-

<

; ~

~

o=:o

O

' =

-:;'

,.,

~

--

QO

,.,

.c~

'0

=

-Q

O

~C

QO

=-n

QO

~

o Q

O

QO

0.

n <

0

=-

n -c

'0

'"

'0

--~

-9

: c

n

-~<

""c~

QO

ocE

;"~

=-

('0",

-2"

c-<

;c""

'=""

"nw

,--

n--

",~

~~

:O"',

:.c~

('O=

n §c

""O

~

'0

0.

=-

(;

--~

-'"

0

=-

0.

'" S

' (;

'" -.

(IQ

~

=

- '<

0

'-'

"'..,

.., "

'0~

..,

~

E

:. '0

Q

O -3

8

~

~

~ .

('0

~--

QO

~

~:.

<:0

=-

'Oo.

QO

)<o.

.cn'

O=

~_~

- o.

-n<

-..,

~O

" n-

o~"'~

-_

.~~

'"

0 '0

~

C

C

Q

O

<

--.'0

~

-.

., ..,

'" '-'

c

('0

~

QO

..,

n

~

~-

n =

0

0 ~

('0

-.-~

. ('0

-Q

O

~

-n

-.~

n

..,

=

('0

==

",~

=~

.n""

On=

(")

('0-.

3=--

~=

",Q

O'<

_.-

o'""

--

~-

'" 0

~

n --

':-.

=

QO

g

~

~

'" :;

QO

3Q~

~<

QO

!:?,g

s.35

-=

-n;-

QO

~.

0 a

,.,

('0 S

o g

-(IQ

Q

O =-

~

~

-~(I

Q"'"

, Q

O'"

'" C

':.~

:;"

' "'<

'=

~~

s;

.=-:

n~

;o~

Q

O'O

'O<

;-.

n ~

~

.",

0 '"

-=..,

30

QO

..,

~o

,.,-

3--

-~

=n,

.,--

'-'

-OQ

O

~~

~Q

O"

3~

.c

. '0

=

- =

0"

0

<' ,

. '"

3Q

O

~C

-<;=

.=

'0"

_.>

~~

e!

..°'"

0-

(")

--~

n-

-'"

c..,

,.,"'>

<,

QO

('O-

~-~

~

~-o

~

_.."

,<=

)<

~

-=

- =

--

=

0.

C

=

-00.

-Q.

'<

0 ~

'"

0 -.

-n3

~

,.,=

-~

.C"'Q

O

<,"

'(")

0 ~

'" <

-=

0Q

Ou~

,.,

-Q

O

!!..~

Q

-=-o

~

~=

~

~."

'no

,. ,.,

~

n

--0.

-=

'" ('0

0

..,-Q

O~

"'-

'QO

"0

-

':.

,., '

" ~

=

- '"

-00

~

<'

'" 0.

=

C<

n Q

O

~

<

()

n -

~

=-,

-..

'" '"

~

<

QO

-0

~

-.~

~

Q

O ~

0"

=

("

) Q

O ~

0.

'<

n)<

'"

~

':.

~

~

0.

0.

-::

,. ~

QO

'0

=

Q

O

~

00

(IQ

-,

'0

'""'-

~

30

0.("

) <

QO

-'"0-

" "=

--

~=

~-

'0

'<~

. ~

~

~

0

'" ~

()

0.

'"

§-o

~

-==

-n

><

3

('0:.

,.,

=

n ~

0

':-

0 --

QO

'Q

=

0.

",oo

n oo

.~=

-.

'" ""

-"'-S

.':.

Q

O

~

=

(IQ

-C

0"

9;

no

0 0

QO

-,

,0.

,~"

~

-.,."

, u~

(")

~

-_.(

/)

-3

co "

" -c

o ("

) -'"

-'"

Co

,-.

(/)

--co

-'

'" ("

) =

'" ..~

c co

~

~

,."

c =

- '"

~

<

=-

--:0

'0

=

- =

'"

~

, -<

-n

-.

:--'

:---

.=

OQ

3 0

'" ...

po -

-:0

~

-.~

=

. co

~

'" ~

0

c .-

-:

~

=-~

. =

- ~

~

~

0 '"

'0

-:

0 '<

N

=

=

-=

- -'<

3

=

'" 0

-'<

~

-';i

3 ("

) ~

~

~

~

-.

Co

0 ~

=

3

So ~

§

~

=-

~ ~

§

~

~ :

~

'0

~.'?

;: ~

~

S

~

~

~

g. ~

~

g

~

~ ~

~

§i

~

[ ~

~

~

~

~

~

1:

: ~

~

§ [~

. g

'" -,

C

o .§

'"

=-

~

;;.

a.

s ~

c

'" 0

(")"

-:

.tJ

~

C

o 3

~

0 c

=

:; -,

:.

(")

Co

:; =

-;::,

-:

; -~

...

~

Co

-.~

~

0,~

~

~

~

~

~

-.

-~

.g:

O=- -

.,0

~

c ...

0 ~

3~

. -'"

c

OQ

Co

:]. -

.=-

C'"

'<

~.

-:

'<

Co

~'"o

-_.'.

",-(

")--

",~

,.-

po

;::

~-'(

")("

)'"

(")(

")

=,

--.

...c

'-'

-.co

("

) -.-

~

0 =

co

~8.

3 '"

'" ...

=-

'<

~

--,

=-

-~

;n°

0 -(

")

Co.

tJ

'"S

' '*

F

- e.

. ~

~

S

' S

' ~ 3

.:;

S

~

;::- a

:

g ~

~

;.

'" S

' -;:

3 ~

~.

'0

Co

3~

'0

~

, ~

S

~

'(;

:g

S

~

g.

?

~

~

§.;

.gC

o(")

=

=

-:0

=.

-~=

-_.c

=o

oco

c",~

~("

) "'"

,Co~

~

_0-.

~

"",,-

-.-O

Q=

~

...~

_.

""'_

.~...

~

=

-',<

",,'.

3:o

-~-;

:: ~

_.

~""

" ~

._.

&;

'tA

\0'

~

t:=

'" ~

-~

g

0 co

0

'" =

co

3

'" -,

-;

:: <

i'

(")

...=

- ("

).

;;.

=:.

c -'"

-'(

; '<

~

~

~

~

~

'(; ~

. ~

\O oo-.'?

: ~

~

. ~

~

':o

§ ;

~

S:

;n' ~

g'

§:

~

~

@'g -:

g- ~

~

~

~

~ ;

~

t

: :f;

; [~

~

:f;;

~

* 3.:g

0

~~

. ~

'" -'-

' ~

--

'0

~

Co

~

-~

n .3

0

'<3

--:

=-

'0

:0

~

-.<

'(;

0

~

,. ("

) -,

,.

=-=

-.

\0:;:

-0=

cc

o"'

c°:

;-'~

c

:;.~

~.~

"""=

-:;;:

"~_.

~~

"'0

'" -.-~(")

3o

3~

'.-'

"""°

""'-'

" -<

"'~--

~o"

'-'."

'=-C

o-.'.

><

-"'~

<

~

=-.

tJ=

-...

="

(/)

00

-'"

-'0

o =

- '"

~

~

-()

~

=

3 g

~

=

'" ~

~

;n

° 0

OQ

~

-.

=-

co=

- n:

I: -,

0"

=

~

c

'" -.

(")c-S

' ~

~

!":>

~

=-

(") ~

... 3

§ .(

) ~

~

~

~

C

o '<

~

:] °

3 _ 3

.~

...0

;l 3

~

~.

~

:::.

!?.

~

~

Co

~

~...

'<

:;.

E!..

,2

~-.

'" -~

co

0

-'"

-'"

()

~

co

~

()

=-

,. O

Q

<

-'"

'0

"~

0-3

~

~

'T

1 -J

-:

~

;;.

~

=

~

'0

'"

(")

~

=-

><

...

S'

~

g '0

~

'"

c ::.

0

~

~

'" ~

-~

~

'"

'0

...'"

n ~

O

Q~

E

!..

~

~

~

-,.:.

~ ...

1), '"

~

g

:;, c

o §:

~

=-

g -g

n'

OQ

",'

'tA ~

0'

g

'Q. 'f

A 3

::

~

g "' c

:. ~

~

;

~

~.

~.

g,]

~

~

g~

c

,<'

'O,-

.~

I ~

-~

.-'_

. C

o-"O

' -"

""-.

~

"'.o

"'~...

o"

'~=

o=

.-o~

~

~

e..

§ po

~

.g

0

~.

~

~

3 ~

'<

0

g.

Co

8.

;n...

g a

go

§ =

- '0

~

(;

"' :'

§ ;;"

-,

gg

5.

("

)~,

;-.."

-<

O

Q

§ E

!..

~

g ~

.

0'"8

1)

, C

o =

S

' ~

5.

.; ~

.:;

~

2-.

8 ~

=

- g-

. ;-

:: '0

--

~

ji!

~

5.

~

0 ~

~

1)

, 3

g '"

'" ~

'0

§

Co

~

-,

~

'"=

'"

=-

~

Co

~

co

~

-:

~

n'

=

~3

~

()

c --

3 ~

~

~

=-

S.

3_.

g =

:::-

:::.

!?.

=.

'" ~

. g

'" =

- c

Co

~

=

~

Co

:?,

'" C

...

(J

~

-Co

~

Co

~

OQ

C

o '<

=

- ~

'"

~

~

~.

~

-,

~

-co'

" '"

~

~

~

(")

-.0

><

C

co

ri ~

9

0 -8

. -~

'"

~

'"'

~"2

. ~

=

- ~

()

'"

:=.

-'<

0 ~

".

, --

.~

=

~

'" =

?!

" 'tA

~

~

0

0 :::

. ~

'0

...

~'<

-=

- '"

0 ("

) =

-~

'"

~

co '

<

-C

...~

-.

-:II

co

-.~

, co

("

) ~

--

-0

-.~

'0

'0

~

[g

.;-

=-

:::.~

. a

~

~

~

'(;

~

~

n ~

~

.=

[ ;

:. n'

.Po

~

::::-

2"

~

~

~

~

~

'8

~

1);

3" .g o

33~

8.

~

~

~

.o-

~-.

~

- "'<

:II-.

-~

~-

--.~

(")"

"",<

'"

"'OQ

"'3

~

-, c;

'0 o

-'" ~

'" '"

n -~

~ 0

= '0

0 ~

(") 1iQ.

co '0

~ ~

-c (")

-0 ~

0 ~

~ 0"

c '0

~ ~

-

g, =

- §.

--;0

~

~

3

~

'5" ~

§.

~.

.-: ~

~

~

S

: §

-:§.

~

!! =

= ~

3 ;::

g

5. ~

~

g ~

~

-<

.;;

~~

.~.~

. ~

~

'0

Q

' S~

~

8.

~

~

.":"

=

~

~ "

8 ~

~

g

;. ~

~

;. =

~

~ '<

~

. '<

~

§

§. ~

~

1)

, ; 9

!?. ~

:?

, ~

~

~

~

~

_ 0c

co

~

~.'<

\0

-C

o -.

=

-E!..

-.

=

(")

~

3 0

'" '"

=

=-

...'<

'-'

.'4

, -3

c

.tJ

-.("

) ~

-S

' ("

) '0

~

<

:II

:II

Co'

. ~

~

. S

' ("

) -0

0

:=.

~

OQ

=

- ~

'"

-co

=-

° '<

~

s

~

~

~.

c '"

~

~.

~

c 8.

c

0 ~

O

Q

-=-

Q;

=

n

~

'0

~

~

~

~

~

~

g~.

~

~

~

[ ,::

~

~

~

~

~

~

g

~

~

g ~

5.

~

. ~

~

~

. ~

~

~

§-

~

~

~

~

~

[g

~

,tf$:

~_.

_"'~

'-'=

OQ

-~

",

<

1 C

o'O

O("

)~

'<O

QC

O...

"'C

o<'"

~-'~

.,3'

E

!.. 5.

~

~ ~

;:

-6c.=

- -<

g

g ;-:

g ~

~

g

~

~

g- ~

g.

S.

8. ~

=

- ~

3

0 3;n

° S

~

S

'~..§

' ~

~

~

g.

~

~.:;

~

~

~

-.'<

~

...

'" ~

--

' .-

'"'

-.-

C-,

'"

,. O

Q3

~

.".,

()

"~o

~"~

~

--

="

'" ~

~

C

o --

.tJ

Co

-~

.'-'

..:..

OQ

~

-(

")

0 C

o ~

-:

0

-'0

(")

=

=

~

-'"

=

roo

OQ

~

~

c

Co

-.-~

~

~

~

=

~

~

~

c

.""'

~

;-

Co

~

=-

~

0 ~

~

-'"

~

...

=.

n n

~'

I ~

. '<

'0

-~

..~

=

0 E

!..

-.'"

~

; S

' ~

;-

C

o n'

o.

~

<

. ~

~

S

' '"

~

:-

z.

=:.

~

2:

=

~

§ ~

~

co

3

~

'(;

~

<.

3 .=

- e.

. ~

S

' '"

0 0

-,

;::

;n°

3""

' -=

-~

'0

--

~3

7 -.

()

-~

0 ~

C

o -r

oo

-:II

~

-~

()

'" -.

,~'tA

...

~

-0:

~ ...O

Q

"~.

.\oJ

n '"

-,

-'0

-"~

...

~

Co

-.,.

~

~

~

~

~

.-'<

--

-co~

' -~

--

8.

¥"

~

~

~

~

~

g §.

~

' §

;. g

~

~:

oa

§ '0

n

~

g B

. =

~

5

~.

3 ~

~

. ~

~

. 3"

n.

s.

~

8.

g

~

S'

~~

::~

. \0

~

S

' ~

-.

~

-.~

O

Q ~

~

=

- :II

~

'"

co

Co

~'1

),

~

=-

-~

~

~

'" ~

--

.] ~

n

~

~

~

So

0~

~

O

Q ~

-J

O

Q

:-

~

-]

t:=

;::

n...

~

""'

~

=,

'0

g O

Q

I: ~

,-.

..."2

. =

- =

~

. ~

-'"

~

~

~

~

~

ro

o ~

ro

o =

-_r

oo::.

., ~

-:-c

"'Co~

'(;)'~

c~

~

3""

"<~

()

(")_

.~...

oo

o~'~

~

Co(

")

'<;:-

'"

;::,

~

:I:

-~

=-

--.tJ

C

o ~

-.

=

~

...~

co

..J

~

~

O

. '"

roo

~

3 O

Q

-,

-.0

OQ

~

~

:;.

=-

(")

...0

\0 ;

0 =

- ~

~

=-

:: ~

5.

-:;

E!..

n =

- ~

>

<

~

~

E!..

Co =

2

=->

~

'" ("

) '"

~

-.~

~o

-:

~

'" ~

~

-0

co

0 00

-J

~

-.

~

~

c C

o ...

=-"

"' ~

'"

-.:II

'<

-0

~

~

~

-

~

...=

~

0:

-0

\ =

~

'<

...

~

=-

~

'" ~

~

~

. ("

) -~

~

~

;n

° '0

~

()

~

~

. 0

~

0 ~

.~

~

go

=

~

=

~

";"_

I, O

Q"'~

=-I

Co_

=-,

(")=

-'<'"

Co"

,OQ

.~-,

-."-

,, ...

, ,-

,

> z (D ~ ~ ~ = (D ~ Q ., ~

=-"

'()Q

ro--

,

0 ro

~

~

0.

~

~

~

'"

~

~

-,3

~O

",

~=

o='"

=3

=()

Q",

<0

30-'

0~

=~

~~

~

~

"'-;.0

.

~

5'

0 ;

0 ~

.c

-~

~

~

=

~

-.

:I::!.

()

Q

=

=

-.~

c

~

~

~

0 '"

-:I

0n

.-<

'<

-~

~

0.

~

0.

~

. C

-.

n ~

_.;!

=.

...'"

()Q

0

()Q

~

3~

~

~

=

n -.

~

-.~

~

~

~

'"

~

<

""~

-.

3 ~

n

0~

" 0

o'

~

...~

:;.

,Q

~o~

'" ~

=

o~-

~-.

=...

n.

..",c

oo:

n ~

0.

n

=

~

,Q

~

n "

~

-.-'"

~

3~

C

-<

'"

n ~

~

00

: =

C

n

-.O~

~

n

g3

~ ~

0 3

~

-0.

~

-.0.

'"

0.

~

~

=

-.,.

~.

~

~

,?c

r;

~

n ;.

3 ~

0

~.

;. tn

. ~

:i 3

~.

~0

g ~

'<

~

ri

~

~

~

3 g

~

0 C

o go

0

<

...=

'"

c:

;. =

~

-(

)Q

...=

. 5'

'--

' 0.

0"

~

-~

!'

-

~_.

~

n:;;~

~"'~

~~

' 0'

" ~

.~.,.

",,~

0"

0"

0.

<

~

-<:

~

-.~

"

=

3 ~

~

~

0

n '"

o-<

~~

",(')

...g~

...~

~

_.~

=

~...

e!.n

c ~

~0

03'A

o.°~

~

=~

~

~n"

'.~

~

~

~

w

' C

=

~

~

~

~

~

.. 0.

~

~

=

n

0"

~

~

'" -.

=

-.(i"

ro

'"

n .

c ~

~

-<

~

~

eo

.. ~

~

. ~

~

0

n'"

~

~

:;-

"'~...

=

:!.

~

."'

".,=

..n

"'to

s~go

.o.=

n~g,

~g~

;~

~

[g.~

a.=

~,,~

3O

"'~

=3

~

-.'-"

'.ro

~

...5

()Q

=

C

~

~

0.

'"

-.",

:J.

<

ro

'" '"

g o'

0.

ri

~

ri ~

=

~

'"

.8;

~

=

g ~

~

~

. ~

~0.

~g~

~~

;-~

cc3

~o

:ioo"

'==

'"

0 .~

'<

~

:!.

~

n

n ...

:-.

'" n

""

~0.

0.

'8

0

>

o'

~

c g

n ~

~

~

~

'0

' a:

~

. 9.

~

...c_

-'-=

="'n

'<~

o ,-

..0.

Oo:

.,Qn

:!.

0 ~

-~

0

~

n ~

-~

?l

~

N

=

=

~

C

~

=

()Q

~

-<

: -~

'"

~

~

w'

~

-1

0 -.

0 ~

~

()Q

~

. ~

~

~

=

.0=

~

~

"';:.

\.It..

.,:"'"

=

-.,,-

..,

=

n ~

~

0

c w

, '-'

n

~

~

!! eo

.. n'

~

. 0

0.O~

~

~

~

...

()Q

~

g.

:;.

0

~.

--.0

..(

)Q

-,.

C

()Q

0

=.

n =

<

0.

-<:

ri =

- =

<

; -c

~

~o.

~

-~

-.~

n

:;-

n-.

-' --

"()Q

-=

~

'"

=

" 0

ria[g

~2.

o.~

~~

~~

'"(

;:-

;n~

~;'

n =

o'

'"

-.()

Q

~

'" ~

. ~

...

0.

...S

' =

1'

=.

3 '--

' ~

~

~

0

3-n

~

~

0

'" =

-

0~=

~~

0-

3~

~~

0"

",

"':":

<'"

=

'" =

- ~

0

~

-.=

'<

c

""

3 -.

",~

o.~

=

~~

,<"'9

:0.

~;:;

' ~

n~=

_.~

C

~

0.0

~

'" ,-

.. -(

)Q

"'::.

~

~

n ~

<

'"

'" ~

-~

~

~

~

~

,.

0.-.

ro""

--.~

3~

~

. ~

=

5.

()

Q

'" ,

~

~

=0

0.

~

()Q

-<

: -

3-.

3 '"

~O

,,()Q

-'

3~

' ~

,.n'"

-'"

--.

-~

=

-"

...~

~

~

-n""

"""

ri3~

-~~

-!,o

n~~

~

=~

na

c-o.

-.

~

~

=

...7"

' ~

0

=

'<

~

'<

=

C

-<:

Co

n

.=

~

~

~

~0

0 =

'<

~

;. ...

'<

01

n -.

0()

Q,<

=~

'" n:

l,,~

- ~

~

",nO

Q"'0

~",

()Q

-'"

n'"

n.."

'=S

' ~

g

3~

...~

~

c

~

0 2.

g

c -<

.s

. ~

a:

~o.

~

..."

;~-'n

~

O"

n:;.(

)QO

~~

~

~

=

'"

-~.

2...'

8 a

~

son

~

=

-.'"

~

0 ~

~

\000

0 ~

~

()

Q

0 =

~

>

;' '"

0no

=...

<;-

' =

=-~

.n...

~

~...

~

-.0.

~

';"

' ;.!

:!;

~

~

~

=

~

~.

-~-,

"':

:.

, ~

:.

CO

~O

Og:

0~~

'<"'~

'".~

<C

Om

o'~

",<

'<

."

' co

co~

co3

~

~

'"'"

co

.o'--

'~co

,-o

,-~

\0

--oo

Xo,

ooc

og...

,'-"

<0-

'""'~

--o

c '"

~

CO

~

~

0,

:.O

Q,..

-~

o'<

e?~

;'~3

~ .

-.o'

-On

--0<

"'~

oo~

oC

ON

"'OQ

~

..~.

~

r""3

~--

0",

° --

.'<

-.

'"o,

~,-

-..~

n

--~

\0

-.C

O00

°",

\0 ~

: ~

..~

CO

X'.

~-.

n 0,

"'-",

-CO

\J

n,<

~ --.

CO

o .

~

~

-o,

co\O

""'~

oo"'0

,-C

~~

0,

-'"

o ~

o o

~.~

0,

'<-'<

0,\O

co~

,~

"' '"

-o'n

_."' '-'-:

::.\0

~

Z

00 ~

.Q

--

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .§ '> i ~ ~.

~.

~ .., ~ ;: ~:

g. oQ,

~ ~ §: ~ ~ ~ §: ~ ~ -.I

Page 4: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

-.'"

~

~

"'.,..

. --

.=.

-~

0 :.

=.

~

-I\)

0

~

0 .c

-~

~

~

~

--

3 0

<

~

I\)

<

-3

33

I\)

~

0\

-.'"

3:)

Q~

"><

~~

"'"

~'~

co."

"~I\)

~~

~

""oc

c~-"

'~

~~

""-'O

_~@

~

- ~

~

...~

-g

~

s:

-"'g

.c

--

3?

-~

(IQ

0

~

-0

~

Co

--3.

c %

-~

~

. ~

g

0.

--3

~

~

'" d

=?

=:~

<

~

!!

g.

~

?:.

--3

3 (I

Q

~

~

~

~...

!:?

...c~

~

-~::~

~~

~~

~c-

'~;=

""'~

(J:~

~"'~

~::

3~

~

~~

'0-.

3~~

-;=

.'-';:

:'~

~-,

~~

~~

o.~

~~

~-:

:-.

><

~I\)

~"'~

~'

,,~~

- 1\

)3

~:-

3("

)-"'-

'..,l\

)o-,

("):

::~

-~o-

=:

~O

-I\)

".

o~

-.:,=

:co_

~"!

1(J:

..,

""'=

, ~

",I\)

-~

~~

- 0<

-

..,

~

~

=

~

~

~

(").

.,-:<

:::

'" 3.

., o.

~~

~

-o

~

::'0

1\)'

(")

'" 0

~

I\)

~:;-

:;-

~;I>

-~

~-,

0.(I

Q

~

~-

~~

0

~

(")~

--~

I\)<

: ~

<:(

)Q-=

~

S=

~~

"'

3"'~

~=

-~

-,-'o

=

~'"

~~

0'

"%

S

~

~

'::

:..

~'

~

0.

(;"

s:-

S'

S

~'

(;"

~

~

:!:,

;n°

~.

'" ~

~

:s

o -,

D

: ~

0" ~

. 'it

~

E

o- ~

~

~

i!D

' ~

0 _ 0

~

s:-

~

I\)

I\)

'0

~

~0

0.

~

~

~

~

0.

~

(")

0 0

0.

0 '-'

<

I\)

~

(;

' 3

~

=:

c c

~

~

~

-'"

0 ~

t"

" ~

...

~

0.

'<

=

-~

~

3 ~

0.

=

. ~

'"

~

'-'

~

~

~

~3~

(I

Q .

,...

~

Co'

; =

'"

~

E:-

:.1

:=

I\)

g.

'"

!! 0

(;'

:;-

.,..

E:

0 ;=

" (;

" "' 0

~

_ 3;=

" '"

~

~

~

~"

-co'

" ~

' I\)

~

-t

IJ

-,

~

0.

-v~

~

, -.

-'"

~

-,

--~

-:

: -,

~

5"

, 2.

;'

~

8.

S

~

§~.

i!D' ~

g

0 ~

0 3

.:g

g e-

. ~

~

~'

~

-<

~

~

g ~

go

(;"

a

~

~

~

0.

(;"

rf$;

~

§,

~

g ~

g

~

~

~~

(IQ

(IQ

-,

..,

o.~

_.~

-"":

: -'"

~

~

o--,

~~

-~o.

..,o.

.",,~

o ,"

,_..I

\)~

-.

.,--,

~

'"

~

S'

0<:

~

~

~

<

Y'.

-'"

~

-,

~

='?

: ~

0-

C

o'"

=

~

-'<

'" (I

Q

~

.,..

<:

:;-

0 ..,

..,

~

~

~

-~

c

~,

~

~

:: ~

~-

,<0.

-' 1\

)0

I\)-,

~--

~

~

...",

~"'-

o-,-

,~<

:><

- ~

("

)-~

§

c c

~

~

* 0

~

d s:

- <

ia

...~

-0

("

) =

. ~

0"

3

~ o.=

= i

i' 0'

0

c .,

'" I\)

~

~

%

0

;=" '

it '!:

?: S

0

~

3 ~ o

'"0

-.'"

~.

~

=:

~

~

-~

~

--~

~

~

~

-.

,..

(IQ

0

C

~

o..!-

~

~

. 0

-,

--.<

~

,

~,

~

~'

8.!

~;

~

~

~,

3 ;'

~

~

5"

g ;.

~

~.

~

~

5",';

~

g

§'

~

~

~

g.

3"

0'

~

:' ~

~

;;;

~

§.

~

~

~

~

..:g

~"'=

..,

::--,

..,

~

~~

~

~~

-(lQ

~"'

a~

~"-

.<:(

")"'~

1\)1

\)

,.~..,

cs

:-~

.1

:.-1\

)~

.,

'<

~0

~...

0'

" ,::

" ::

-0.

~

-~

~

~

><

~

'" ~

~

'"

...~

.~

<

: ~

-

00.

3

., 0

-.~

;I>

-,.-

~

o.

o.

-~~

--

c~~

~"'_

.. -'~

-,-

,. -~

~--

-I\)

O

(IQ

<

: 0'

.

~

'<

- ..,..,

(I

Q

~

'" .,

'" ~

("

) '"

I\)

0.

-0

:: :.

~

~

'" "

I\)

;: ~

~

"

~

'" -,

~ o.

'<3

c -~

;:-

. 0

~

0.

~ Co

~

--~

- '.~

<:-

I\)O

~

--,

-~'..

.,-'-

-'.00

.~

c,.

(IQ

'. ,.

OIl'

-' 0-

I\)

(;

' 0

~

0.

I\)3

'" <

v~

-.

., -~

~

~

0

-~

-I\)

~

~

::

"!1

~

-I\)

(I

Q

S'

I\)

~

~

I\)

.-

1),

~

~

...0-

~

~

-~

S

o ~

--,

~

~

~

~

~

~

-'"

~

:!:,

;-

~

~

--0.

3-,

~

~

~

(I

Q =

, 0

0-

.,o.~

"--"

;:-

~.c

-'-

' ~

,.

-0"

u~

~

~

'" ~

0.

I\)

~

C

~

~

I\)

<

("

) I\)

0.

,

~

0 '<

~

-.

., ~

<

: .-

, ,.

~

~

~,.g

;.

g ~

-:

;;:

~,

; g

~

@

[ ~

d o.

~

~

~

~

~

:: ~

;g

; ~

-:

~

~

.~

~

~.S

: ~

~

3

~

~

~.

[.3

~

~

~

[ ~

~

o~-'

"'()Q

-'"

'..,

-,.~

- ()

Q~

-.

,~.

~~

~..,

~~

,. _.

~..,

-',<

-'-o

--'"

~:?

. -c

~

'"

-~

~

c c

0-..~

--

3 ~

~

0'

-,

0

~ 3~

~

:.

-",.

I\)

-,

--~

;n

' ~

~

-,

~

.O

Il c

---

0'"

,,-,..

,. 0.

(")

~-,

~_.

~

-o.~

0

~=

O-~

~

-"'~

"""'-

<

~

(IQ

..,

0.'"'

'it

~

0.

r;

~

d -<

-,

;;

I\)

I\)

=

<

~

~

~

0- 0()

Q ~

:,

~

~

'" -5

-'

3;.

I\)

0-

-0.

~

n.

~

0'

=:

~

~

~

""

~

~

(;'

:?.

-(")

~

~

~

3

~

~

=

--,

0.

0.

'" ~

'<

~

-g

o 0

-=:

--~

I\)

0

0-

~

(IQ

~

~

,

0.

~

'" 0

~

Q

:' p.

~

S

o ~

~

~

~

~

~

g S

' ~

,'o;:;

; ~

~

~

s:

fq.

8 ~

~

~

, ~

§

~

~'g

s

g ~

~

~

' '0

~

[

g ~

[

g f

[~'

\0

e-.

-'"

~'

~

~

c '<

~

~

~

3

~

0.

3 ~

~

~

0

~

3 ~

~

'<

0.

~

~

..,

~

(;"

~

0.

-So

;: 3

2 .I:

. 0.

~

-,

~

\0

~

Q

~

~;'

'" e-

. 0'

~ o.

3 '"

g -:

g

3 '"

C

0 ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

&

S

o 0

~,~

E

:-

(;"

;=.;

~

~

~

g -

3e-

. ~

~

-<

N_~

--_~

~

(")

00-_

~("

)1\)

~""

"'(;"

.c

~C

o-."

'-~~

(;""

'ou~

o.

""~

""

'-"

'.""-

,'-'

~

0.

=

, ~

~

-,

'"

c ~

-~

'"

:. ~

..,

~

~

.,

0.-~

0

., :.

';':

::!-

I\)

'<

~

'" ~

(I

Q

0 ~

~

...

I\)

~

'" (0

" ~

~

0.

"0.

~~

()Q

""

(")-

~

-~

"'<:

-,.~

--

~

-,

~~

~-.

_~~

'""

"'~I\)

.,

'0

-.,@

;: ~

i!D

' ~

%

'it

;n

° I\)

S

o ~

' 0.

' ~

~

~

: ~

(;

" ~

S

o ~

. ~

..8

~

~

'0

8.

~2

~ o~

~

. 0

~

~

~

(lQ 3g

g ~

%

-<: (IQ

~ <:

--I\) 0.

-.,'" '"

~

0..,

--c

--c

~

:. '"

, ~

~

..,0.

n-

'~~

~'_

.~

~

~-~

~

~.

o.O

-.c'

o-..,

'.~

-,

-c;n

'~""

"'o-o

o"'~

:' ~

..,""

-0~

0"

~o

~-~

I\)

~<

o~~

- ..,

_.~

~

~.,

, '<

0."'1

\)'"

~

~

., -,

~

C

o _.

~

0 0.

-'

<

"'"

I\)

~

~

'" ~

~

t::

"

-I\)

I\)

~

3

0 (I

Q

.c

c I\)

~

30.

-<

: %

_.

c -

0 ~

~

:s

o ~

0

0 ~

<

.,.

. I\)

~

~

~

()

Q

..,

(")'"

-.

'<

0 ~

'<

0.

0.

~

..,

~

s=

~

'<

'"1

0

0 (;

" ~

~

~

~

.g:

~~

~

..,

~

-0

.,.

. 3

(IQ

~

~

("

) 0

..,

~

..,

tr1

<:

~

~

3 ~

0

0.

'" 0

()Q

"'~

' 0

'<

~

~

0.

~

~

~

~

~

3 g.

S

' 0.

I\)

~

-'

0"

~

><

n

(IQ

I\)

3

g <

=

: 0-

' 3'

~

";

;;'

~

~

s.

=:

~

~

§ ~

S

o s.

0.

%

g

=.

(IQ

~

~

~

P

. s:

-I\)

0

3 ~

S

o ~

~

~

-~

~

2,

~

0

§ g.

8.

~

5.

g

3 0

0 0

~,

§ N

' S

o e-

. ~

3

;n°

I\)

0 ~

"!1

~

%

OIl.

~

'<

s:-

~ 3I\)

S

' ~

%

~

g

~.

~

Ei

~

%

go.O

ll '"

I\)

~

1];

0.

0 ~

::'

~

~

~

~

~

g

I\)

; g.

~

~

;n

' ~

' ~

-<

~

~

0-

~

0-

,..

-,

()Q

~

'<

,-,

I\)

~

I\)

-0

'" ~

3;n

° ~

Co

~

--;'

_ 0.0

. ..,

-'<

("

) c

s=

~

~

=.,

'" '"

~"'o

o~~

...

3'("

) s=

(")"

,-

~

(")

(")

~-

~

-'~"

Oc

~.

~<

:~<

.c

; ~

s.

~

~

3

~

'it

~

Q,

~

;;-

t"

Q,

~

=:

g ~

!!

~

g ~

~

g

g S

o ~

~

%

8.

S

' 8.

:

@.

5'

g -~

. ~

g

~:,

'" '

~

~

~

~

~:]

c:

~

0 0

c3

.9

~

"';-

~,

'" ~

0

;-

0 ~

;n'

~

~

-~

;' 0.

0

(IQ

'"

I\)

~

'" ~

.'it

:.

--3

~

0'

I\)

~

~

=

~O~

s.

~

~

a(;

' ;n

' =

, ~

0'

E

:, ...

, g

3 (;

" .,

0.

'it

Son

c

3 0"

~

3

""

C

~

~~

-::o

-o

-"""

",

""<

"' I\)

=

.<-:

::::.

0 o.

<:c

~

~""

~,~

cn"'~

1\

)31\

)(IQ

~

~.

~

g Q

~

?-

~

~

~

~

~

Q, ~

~

,~

[ ~

~

-1

Q

, Q

, s?

~.

Q

~

~

i!D' =

? ~

-<

go

~

~,

g.

9 ~

.2

. g.

1

~

S'

3~

-n

-3

'"

'" '-

'" ~

"-

'"0

~.

~

=.

~

~

"0

-:

=.

~

'" (I

Q

c:

'" _.

"""0

~

(I

Q

~

"0

Z

=.

t""'

~

So

~.

n n

~

~~

~oS

~';;

~o

~

"Oo.

:oa,

<oo

aoos

~oo

"O

;ag-

~§~

~

;..e-

a~e:

.~~

~~

~~

~

_"O

_~-_

c ;J

..,(I

Q

-

o~

~

~~

~..,

~~

..,--

~

o.no

o-v

~n

3-<

0 ~

~

~

..,

.., '

-' '"

..,

n C

~

.-

, ~

~

00

c

'",

~

'~

.., '

" ,

co O

:! ()

~

C

n

~

~

o'

~

~

'<

-.~

a

n (I

Q ~

..,

~.

g :-

"2

~

~

. 'C

c:

~

~

~

~

:;3

~

;;

3 ::

~.o

~

"0

0

':--.

0 O

;!; ;

~

~

C

:.c

3 ,.-

. n

;:;"

~

~

~

~

'-'

~

n ~

~

Q

~

~

..,

~.

0.

n ~

~

a

0..'"

=

0"

~

0

=

~

~

0.

~

~

"0

§ m

~

=

~

~

0"

5.

~

~

0.

0

8 -.

~

=-:

. 0.

=

. 0.

-.

30

~

=

0 (;

~

=

'"

"'g 0

..,

0"

g

~

.., ~

~

. ~

~

2.

0.

~

-.0

'<

~

~

~

..,

~

5. (

IQ C

'"

C

~

~

~

-(IQ

0

=1.

£

.."~

(I

Q =

0.

0

o.

0 ~

~

0-"

0 -"

,' n

-a

e:.

~

0 -.

~

e:. "

".

<

~

~

8.

~

~..,

~

_.

(IQ

.,

; \0 00

~

=

~

-~

- =

.3-~

~

"0.

'"

--0

0 ."

.. ~

n

3 (I

Q ~

3~

Q

O Ii"

0.

3:.

0..

'" ~

~

. n

:. ..,

'"

n 0.

~

~

0

~".

,"O

-0

~

-~

~

~

c

3'"

0 ~

...

0'"0

-.

(IQ

0'

c

'" 0.

'"

_.cn

!"

' -g

-~

. n

~

~

-:-

-.-~

~

~

3a

a 8.

-:

!. \0

~

"0

~

=

-g

~

'<

-<

..,

-g

.: ~

..,

:;:

~ O

Q "0

g

';; ~

~

0

-.n

0."0

--

=-:

,

00.

3~

~

..,

..,

3

<

OQ

~

'<

~

n ..,

n

0.

~

-~

n 3

~

-~

~

3 -~

~

0.

~

~

-.

~

3 =

-=

~

\0

n

0 ~

0

3 ~

~

n.

g o'

~

~

. 0"

'-'

~

.g

0 &

. ~

. ;.

'" g

5 Q

O tn

. '"

'" '"

~

g "'g

. -.

0"

(;

~

~

~

e:

8."(

;' ~

. 00

e:

. 2.

'C

~

-6

' 2-

. '"

~0.

.0

~

g c

~

=-

~

~

g 0

~

~

~::;

' ~

c:

a

;;;-

~

~

~

~';;

' :;-

g

~

n~.

;;.

~

0 ;S

."O

()

Q '

:<

::;9

~

Ii"

a S

o.'"

g ~

g.

o~"O

=~

:;a-.

o.-~

.~"'~

~'"

o.~

==

-~-~

~.'"

"'-

o~

"'-""

o.

20."

,~0

<=

.,.

, -"

<

-'"

~

'" "0

"0

0"

"0

0 =

co

.' ~

~

"'.

"..

'<

-c

n.

--(I

Q

..,

~

~

'"

go

[ 3.

~

~

g-

~

.3

g

~c

g.

;-

~

:§.

~

~.

~

~

~

~

~"

~

go ~

~

~

.0

;-

0' :

]

~

~

~

~.c

~..;

~..,-~

~

..g

8 ~

~o

g "0

-,.

"v

QO

~

~..,

~-,

."

~

,-

~

3"

v 0.

a

-~.

=

0.

-..,

"0

tn.

-0.

e:.

Q.

~

-0

=

~

..,

"0

~"O

~

=

. -n

=

no

-.

~

~

-c

~

~

QO

=

:: ..,

or

;; =

'"

0 -'<

n

~

-~

"0

...~

--

(IQ

-~

3

-<

8.

a 0

c '"

~

~

;. S

' ~

.c

.,.

, '"

-.c

~

~.

0 -~

~

3

-0-

g ~

0"

-.

"'g

~.

0 (;

0

~.

~

0 '<

~

~

=

go

'"

~

~

a ::

-~

=

(IQ

~

5.

~

~

. =

~

~

~

0"

.."

.:

(;

c "(

;' ~

. ~

.-

.'<

=

QO

<

'"

0.

_ 0'A

0.

n

0 ~

-~

--

.' =

~

-~

'-'

n o

..,

~3

0.,

~

~

-'"

~ .

;...

~

- 0

"':J

~

'0

~,

QO

~

0..,

0 ,.

33

---,

~

. -.

"0

~

,. ~

n

=

\0

0 "0

-.

v~

~

~

So

c ~

0.

Q

O

..,

(IQ

-g

~

=

. -.

~

~

~

3 :

3~

~

0

~

0';:'

'0

~

0.

~

0

'0

=,;

0.

~

- <.~

<

\0

3

~

n.:

3 ~

."

'_._

~."

,,=.s

.~.-

0'

" "'~

~

~

_'O

,~

..,

S.(

IQ",

-~~

- c~

.-

n~~

~~

'" ,.-

. ~

..,

Q

O

-~

-.e:

. =

_.

'" 0

0.

~

~

~

~

~.

0 '"

~

-0

~

'" c

'<

~

:. Q

O

~

'" o.

~

~

~

0 -n

0.

0

-=-

-e:.

0 0.

C

.."

(IQ

'0

';;

3 ~

-n

0"

' =.

(")

~

.,.,

£ (I

Q '0

..,

0.

..,

~

:- '

<

~

=

-n

'" 0

n ~

.~

g

g ':-

' 3

9" a

9"

(;

~.

~

~ ~

S

o ~

Q

~

~

~

0:

a ~

. n

~

~

g ~

~

~

. ~

~

S

.~.

--3

~

3 ~

3

~

~

~

~

~-?

~

5'

3

~

.0

~

3 e:

. ~

: ~

~

0

~

[ ~

. ~

Q

O ~

£ 9"

(")

-:-

5.

~

0.

e:.

~

-So

-<

~

Q

So

g 3

0. ~

3

g -g

[ g-

~

~

~

. n

~

n '"

0'

~

~

8. g

5

3 :.0

n

5. g

. :;-

~

S'

~

-<

~

go 9

" s

~

~

~.::

;:; ~

;

g, ~

0

~.

§:

~

~

~,

=.

=-

n 0.

-0

. '9

~

'"

~

0"

;s.

...~

Q

O

~

: ~

~

Ii"

~

~

~

...

n 0

=.

-.~

:::

" _.

~

~

0 ~

~

0

.PO

Ii"

~ o.

...<

~

~

(I

Q

-(IQ

...

~

'<

..,

0"

-0

=.

..,

...'"

QO

--

.'"

0 -.

,.,

--~

""

~

~

.,.

, (I

Q

--0.

tn.

~

OQ

~

a

~

0 ~

~

:

S.

~.

...g

'<

~

3 e:

. ~

0

So

=.

~

S.

~

So.

c e:

§.

e:

;"

g

QO o.

C

~

~

0 g

; ;

~

\0 (

IQ '0

~

".

"0

-.

~

,.-. ~

.-.

-~

~3

--S

o 0

~ O

Q

C

~

~

<

~

...C

~

~

3-..,

00 ~

- ~

.'" 3"

3 a

~ m

'0 =-

~ ~

=- ~

3 ~

-.~ ~

~ ,.-.

c:;"' a

e:. (IQ

0. Q;

~ ~

e: ::

;: 0"'

--~ ~

0\ -~

'" -~.

~

0.~

~

0-~

9;

'"

'" -.

(IQ

C(I

Q

, ~o.

0 ~

-.

'-'

~

n ,.

~,,~

'v~

CV

~~

Q

O

~3

"o-.

.,~..

",-

-~

-_.~

--

~

~~

~=

':f

; ~

';;

g

g 0"

g

0.

~

(IQ

0.

0

-:-

'" :!.

';;

~

'"

cj;.

ri '"

~

=.

3 -g

~

.o

,.-.

e:.

~

0.

0 ~

~

0.

(I

Q

~

0 ~

-g

'!'

'" -';

; ~

. -~

~

~

--

O~ .

£ 3

-~

.0. ~

. -Q

O

~.

c.

n ("

) n

- <.~

=

. '"

3 Q

O

~

~

~

~

~

0.

.,.,

c 0

~

~.

c--

QO

""'

o.',

-,

v ~

"'-

no.

..,

---

On-

'. -~

..,

=~

='

~

-.~

..,

=

. ~

-;

. (I

Q

-~

0 <

-~

0.

~

~

~

~

.."

<

-~

-.

'iO

~

n =

(I

Q

~

..,

'"0

~

-.~

..,

0.

~

'iO

~

3 ~

0

:-

0 (;

' ~

;

8.

QO

..,

~

~

~

(I

Q

'" o~

. ~

~

~

0

0.

2!..

=

:; c

c ~

~

~

_.

~.

-.~

-~

0

-.=

-0.

(lQ c

0 "'g

~

-.

."

...~

'0

~

~

'"

0 ~

~

0 3

:-:;

n ~

"0

:: ~

-:

: -~

-~

~

'0

;

~

~

~

~

~

:. n

E

~

G

0.

"'~

QO

. -~

"'n

_..,'

. .-

,-

=-'"

"'~n

"'---

~-"

'~~

OV

~o

-~("

)~

"'~

-~""

~o~

<~

:>-

""'Q

Oo.

~

-'~-~

(1

,. ..,

~

.~~

~

..""

0 ~

;;;

~

iiQ

' 3

-g

0.:0

n.

a

; S

o ~

~

Ii"

;:;,

~

~

'<

n"

:;-

-:-

~

=1.

g

0 ~

" ~

'<

~

. ~

e:

. ~

~

:0

n

"0

~

QO

(;

.g

~

;: ~

<

. ~

=

.:>

\0

~

3 ~

~

..,

0.

~

3.

~

.0

g

~

0 '"

QO

;: ~

-0

~

.c

'"

~

So

\0

~

3 0.

0.

Q

O"0

~

. -';

; -.

3 c:

-.

-:"

=

tn.

~

'<

~.

~

~

~

~

'" ~

~

-"

':0

0"

':<

Ii"

~

e:

~

.."

~

5.

'00

,.-.

0 "0

e:

c:

;

0 =

~

~

-,

<

-~

C

0

QO

'"

'0

c:

~

C

-.-:

; 0.

0"

.."

'0

S

o.

'" Q

O

'" '-'

:c

...

=.

'" -

g ~

C

o.

(I

Q

n ~

~

t"

"' =

-.

~

0 ~

'iO

a.

a

=.

'" ~

~

(1

a

~

3"

~.

S.

(IQ

:;

(;'

0 ~

~

. g.

~

'0

~

~

~

§

0 ~

~

~.

&;

6.

~

e:

~

g 2"

~

g

~

~

~

So.

'" "'g

~

"0

;..

a g.

"O

~

~

'<

e:

~

=:

...~

=

-.

o'

--g.

§.

=

' =

. (1 0

2- ;

~

C

=

'0

""'..

,ro.

3.(

1-

~-"

'_v~

~

-<

"-'~

-'.."

" ~

~--

~~

"-

"'~(I

Q

~

(")

~

~

'" <

Q

O

~

-~

,. '0

'"

'<

~

-.v~

. 0

QO

:::'

0 ,

'" ~

~

-.

~

n -'<

3

...~

C

_.

0"

;"'

-.n.

--

C

~

~

,.,

'" -C

~

. 0.

'<

3.'0

-~

-.

0.

< '

-' ~

-.

0~

,.-

. .-

.~

~

--

~-~

-=.~

~\O

~

o<",

o..,

(").

.. ~

c~

O"_

~

~

"'~'O

~~

:o

-'"0

~

~

-0

0 ..e

- \0

~

-~

~

~

';;

~

~

~

~

3

0 ~

~

~

S

o 'iO

e:

. ~

' ~

~

o~

. 'iO

§.

0

(1

~

~

~

~

-g

0 0

:;:

~

6.

g-

~

:;:

Vn

!::3

0.

tn'

;-

~

~

;-

'<

l' '<

~

,

ri 0.

7.

...

~

,'"

~

0.

=-

QO

-"

~"

0.

~

0.

, .."

..,

)..

" .g ~:

g" ~ ~ ~ §: ~ ~ :;: ~ :;;,.

~ -0~ 9- §.:

e ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 00 ~"

g""'" '"'

Page 5: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

~n~

3=

-""-

'n~

3'"

~--"'~.Q O"

,-'~..,-< <:

0""'

-= <

3-.

~

'<

('0

C

""'

(0

-,

('0

--.

('O:o

~o

",=

('0

~~

~..,

c

('O~

3~"'=

n:;';

j""

2:

~

g ::;

a.

a.

~

"2

..('0

~

::;

~

, >

~

('0

~

~

~

~

~

go

3

('0

..,

~

~

~

0 ~

--,-

_.~

('O~

~

<_.

"._~

'" ;j"

"-0

-' ('O

-<-=

~('0

'"

('0

n '-'

..c

'" ~

S

' -n

:.

-~

(;

'<

~

-,

~

S'

'" ~

--

3 ('0

-=,-

'c

' -n

('O

o('O

§ o=

o~o'

~~

('On(

'Oo

~

3 ~

.0

'0

0

~

~

"3"

0 3~

9

9 g-

0

a.

9 ~

in

' ~

0.

: "

~

OIl

~

~

~

§.

g ~

~

(O~

('Oon

('O

oo..,

~

o 3-

('0

=2'

:"""

('O('O

tn'c

5'

2,

::0 ~

~

3

3 0

"2.

in'

§.

§.

q §'

3

§.

2,

'" 0

~

a.

='

~

~

:., ~

in

' 8.

;-

~

\0

, 0

~

3 ~

=

('0

8.

~'

('0 g

('0

-~

g-

=

, 3

-~

~

;j""

()

~

-

S'@

.;:::a

3~

~

["2.

.('0

~

~

~

(:

;' ~

=

~

"3

" 6.

~

g

Q

go

~

~

('0

~

~,

go

('0-

~_.

-('O

~""

, ('O

~~

=tn

'()n

a.

('O--

n5'-3

-a.

~

~

3~

. ~

()

~

~

0

...:l

~

a.

0 0

('0

~

a.

0 n

0"

-.0

-"3"

~

-

~-'c

()~

o=~

~""

""--

'('O

""

~o"

"'"

o('O

~=

('O..,

~.;j

""0"

~

!:'

.. ~

~

a.

0"

3

=.

(0

~

(0O;j"

" -~

..,

n

~::.

;j"

";:

0 n

~

-.::-

('0

0 --

-()

'" n

=

a.

..,

,. ~

('0

'"

-~

('0

c ~

~

;j"

" ~

~

~

'<

~

~

-5

=

§ g

g =

. ~

. :;"

in

' ~

~

~

~

~

8.

('0

@

"""

'g

=.

§ 0

a

"'="'~

-<-'n

(;~

"'~

;j""(

'O"'~

~

~

=~

c-.O

=

ns:

- 3

~

~

...:;'

0'

()

a.

:!.

. 0

3 0'

:-

-~

'"

'" S

' ~

::.

n

=

=

~

..c

('0 (

'0~

~

~

~?

g ~

o'

'<

= 3

~..,

...

~

()

g 0"

- ~

'<

g

a.~

o;

0 ~

--~

~.~

~

~

n ~

~

~~

ri'<

;j""

~3

~=

""-"

"s:

- ~

a

-;j""

~

tI1

'"

6.

~

g Q

3

~

c;

;j""

~

~

~

tn'

~

0 9

~.

2,~

-~

~

-=

c

c --

~

0 -.

g ..c

;j"

" '"

3 3

~

~

0 -~

~

~

0 g.

=

0

;-

n g.

5'

~

~

@

g

'" c

(:;'

C

(0

~.

8.

6.

Ii"

~

<'

~

..£3

0 s:

- -:

: -~

;j"

" n

~

;j""

a.

~

s:-

~

-,

a.

-~

~.

c~

n

3 ~

-.

a.

-,

n ~

~

~

@

~

,...,

~

'<

0 -=

~

('0

'"

~

-.

-'00-

"'~~

3c~

'<-<

~

.'5'-"

"0'"

o('O

~~

a.;j"

"-'"

~,

~

~,.e

. ~

' g

§ s'

~

~

~

~

~

Q

1]

; ~

¥

;;:"

~

g-:

0 ~

~

~

~

. Jg

'~

~_u

~""

"",-

~,..

.,~

'" a.

3<

~"'"

.-,

.",(

)c~

~-,

"-:

('O~

:;.

~

~~

~

O"-

'"<

J Q

'"

'(;'

:::,

8.

~

g '0

~

g:

~

3

=

g ;3

;:

~.

~

s:-~

. ~

0

g a

§ ~

0.:

= ~

. '"

~

~

'" ",

. '"

~

8.

~.

~

'" =

~

=

. 8~

. =

~

-3

3=

..."

~

-~

-.o-

.«)

0-<

0 ~

..,

n-3"

, ~

~

c =

":;j"

" 0

=3

=

~

~!!.

. n

~

;j""

'" ~

~

_.

~

v;:

~

~

=

c -

=

N

~

~,-

. '"

~

~

a.

~

<

=

('0

-,.

-0

--nN

-'!1"

~;j"

"n~

o~~

o n~

_-o"

, '"

"'=~

~

~()

'<

0'"

co

-'~n"

""""

"""

~()

('O8.

~~

0~

-.:"

"~9=

'50

:...

~

~

~

~

-0

~

~

0 s:

- .-

.)C

~

-~

=

=

..,

~

3

0 '"

""n-

=~

~,;j

""o=

"'-<

~~

",

.~(;

('O~

()

-e:"

';j""

'(O

=~

'" ~

('0

?'

""

-.=

..,

~

~

. ~

('0

0

~

~

=

a.

'" G

=

~

('0

-~

~

~

C-

3n_

~~

~"'=

~o

O~

-O"~

;;:

~-~

'<

"'=a.

G

co

'" -~

_.

,. ~

~

w

' ..,

u~

-"'"

-.

.0"

--~

-

30

~

~

--.'"

3=

~

~

~

=

'"

-.~

~

n

a.

~_.

u~~

--,

;j""'"

~

--

""'n

-' -.

CO

-"

~~

Q

:?

; \0

0

~

c -.

co~

. s:

- ~

=

. G

0

;j""

3 =

0

-3

~

'0

@

-.~

:;:

. co

-=

=

=

. n

~

-3

co

0 ~

g

co

3 ~

~

~

=

~

~

=

3~

=

~

,. -"

0

'<

0 3

~

'<

co

0 a.

G

=

0

=

~

~

=-

~

'" ~

'!1

""

=

~

a.~

, C

~

~

c

@

=.

'" ~

~

n

goo

a.

('0

~

~

~

2,O=

@

co

~

in'

~

~

n@

§-

~

~..c

tn

' 5'

~

§

~~

. ~

:!.

~

5"

. 3

~0

-~..,

'"

u~

~

--.'<

c

-=

..,

-~

-~

G

G..,

.c~

"-~

'n'-"

"-",

,-..,

w

_.~

~O

- -'o

~

~"=

'3

; Ii"

~

S

~

Ii"

;..

. g

-<

0 :;:

. g

~.

@

~

~

~

@

=.

=

rf:;

~

g 0'

-~

~

=

a.

:: '"

~

=

,-.

_3'

~

~3

-.n

G

~

..,

'" g

3 ~

.., 0

'" ..,

2,

~

=

..,0

=

~-<

-~

---G

. ~

_

3G

n ~

. u~

\0

co

:s-

-<

-0

~

'"

~

G

:s-

~

0 G

-.

~

:; 0

~

~

3G

-.

\0

=.

~

:s-

, --

=

-~

-.a.

3'

" ~

...

-<

0 ~

'"

G

G~

~

~

N

-<

-<

~

~

-G

;j"

" 0

&"

;j""

-.=

-,

~

n

=

~

~

'" G

0

-~

-~",

..~G

=..,

O,

~~

- ~

=,

",,;j

""

a ,~

",

"

"I1

61

m

m

(j (j

>;J

-~

~

;-

~;g

=

(11

'<

-~-~

=

=

-"

'-~

~

'"

0'

(11

(11

, ~

' -,

~

~

-,

. (1

1 0

, ~

'<

>':1

~

\O""

(;-'~

::-o

g,~

0.

.,=

\O~

~

~

~

I".~

00

'-.

I ...

~

~

OQ

(1

1 ~

O

Q

00 -

""

OQ

~

~

...

c ~

rn

~

~

;-

~

':I

n.

,'"

:-

- ~

- ?:

--

~

<)I

;..

, 5.

,0

...~

' ~

~~

~.:?

.~

,--~

",:-

.l;o

'-1".

~

;:"

""'-I

"~~

~-

'"""

=

:-t"

"'",@

. =

:=

=~

I"

1"

-."-

'~o.

.m

\O(1

I 0.

. c

-..,

=\O

~~

~"

"'~

-~("

O5.

-(,;5

;.?

~

~.

.N

C ...~

g.

e!

~

=

~

=

~

g

~

~-<

-~

..,

--.=

-~

.I

'" <

;:.

.I

-~

Q.~

0\

0("0

",

0..-

""

'~-~

(1

1

-.-=

Z~

O'~

Z""

'~w

~"'~

'"

<~

(j -

'j"""

-.,.,

I"

0~-.

0.

VII"

(11-

:::

O~

'O'

"","

'o~

'~=

0\

-

,~9.

. ("

OtV

_~"'~

..<o.

.. \;)

-=--

~~

~

=-(

1I~

.:rt"

"'(11

,<

~~

,_o.

.I"

~=

Q

;~"'~

I"

'<~

"'=

(j\O

3-W

,

=

~

---Q

. ~

-0

' -.

.j (1

1~

. 00

-~

=

,.

...tT

J .~

~

-.

0 -

-..~

0(j

...9c

"'--'~

0...

!"':.

.'O'

"';:"

-.

.,'

c;'=

.' .0

(11.

10.(

"0

OQ

0

CO

'~:-

"...,

=

5"(j

0..

I"

.10.

-=

3~

I"

(1

1 ""

0'

-,

0

'" '"

f--

, "-

..'

J (1

1 0

Q;

=-

'0

'" "I

1 -m

~

r;

;-.

OQ

0

=

-0

c ~

~

'"'

" ::!

. 0.

, ~

0.

. =

=

. ...

,-.

VI

=

"'"

~~

I"

-'"

=w

3 ..(

1I~

=("

Og-

-.c

-:...

<.

-O

Q'I"

'

"'~~

~c~

_.

(11"

"'(11

2

""

-'0

~

cn

~'

03

~.:1

:. -I

" '"

~:s

- \O

~.

'" ~

:: ~

=

-~

=

. Z

~

~

-

-00=

...

, --

-

(j0

""'("

0_.

C0'

.1

0.

()Q

Q

. (1

1 ~

=

.,;:

~

=

-.'<

=

~

-

~

.-=

'"

~

()Q

'"

~

..=

I"

0 ~

~

~3~

,0

~I"

t"

"'---

m-(

)Q

-(11

...

--.=

I"

3a.

...

, ~

.-

'O0'

"~~

0.."

,,0..

I"_.

I"

0.,

~

0 ~

. -<

.'0

=3

~.

0"

~

~.

S

(;

~

S

@:-

,,::

~.

:?.

~

:-~

~

"'~=

: =

""~

-

~

-~

=

()Q

, ~

-.

~"J

~

~

9:

~

~

O\;S

0.

.;J

-~

~

(11 ~

o'

:

@

'" ~

w

::

C

0..

\0

~.

=.

m

~

=

~~

...--\O

-..c

oo~

o...

-.'"

~,.

_.-I

" -:

-.

-~=

. C

~

~

"I

1 --

.=

0:

5'

0'

-.0

~

-.tJ

:I 0

~

'0

~

0 I"

~

...

~

~

c i=

~

::.

...0'

'0

~

...,

c -'"

~

.,""

--31

".

~'"

3~

'O

'"'

("0

00

-.("

0 ~

--

'0

~

I"

'"

-.:?

? ~

~=

~V

I;:"~

~

=-

~=

~

-,._

~_.

~

-

~

tV

cn~

5-

'"

I ~

~

~

--

~

~

VI

'0

~

--0

-~

-0

-'"

~~

~

\0

~

. ~

,

0\

=

~

n ~

~

~

-"I

-~m

--~

=

_.

~

_."

.,...

--,::

0

-.0

1";:,

~

~

tV

O

Q",

o..-

~

""

-,,;;

;"

"-

~

-.00

(1

1;:"

on

~

\;)

<

(1

1...

'""~

e

-..j

:--

0 ~

-'"

~

::.

~'-

-'~""

-,

-,

~ ~ ~ ~ = /') ~

41'i"

'~~

co"'"

,--

co -

0 =

::'

. ~

=

Oco

oco=

.~

cn Q

: ~

=

Ii ~

cnoo

co(i"

O~

~n

~

-0.

0 n

'" 0'

1 >

=

o'

::§.:~

~3Z

"'"r

1 ~

C

O <

"'~~

.,<~

~

-~

~

,,.

n -'"

c ~

-C

O

CO

u~

-.

=;:.

,oo.

=s?

'°0.

~

Q

O

<

_.=

"'~n-

.aoo

n ::'

. ~

n

~

=

~=

=~

oco-

§.O

'IooO

'l=~

.0

~

~

0.

In'

cn

(i":A

'oo~

n.g

o Z~

~

~~

.E"

~("

)~

"'~~

~

'"'

-a

_.=

~

=

I.,.J

~

0 =

0.

.,

:I: >

' ~

=

>

5'

~_.

~

8.

=-

0'1

co~

-.

~

0'1

co

: '"

(i"=

oo~

=co

oo-(

-C'c

oF-@

'"""c

o-=

-'"

v~no

.a~

~~

~o

~~

=-'"

,--

30o

~~

0 ""

<ia

'Oo.

~

=I

3 ~

-.

So

co""

o~

co

-~

~a~

---'>

co~

~",

.,>2"

,.c

o--

co~

o-~

coo

-co

",

~.

co ~

-o

n0.

-~

=

-.

coo

-~co

-00"

0;

:"-

~

-=.-

co c

o -.

'<

,. '"

.,.,n

-~

~0-

--.

3,~

-'"

-.00

-_

.'"co

n

:0

0 '0

=

-.

~c=

CW

O'lO

;-~

"'":-

'o=

:;:3~

:o@

-""~

~,<

_<~

Soa

., "'-

- ~

-.

",

~~

'" =

-

Q=

~~

~>

~.o

.-~

-",o

."'0

.,0'"

.~

'O",

:o.Q

;:;a

~

w

-n

-.n

, ,

,

n = = n :" (.IJ -. = = (.IJ

> ~ = 0 ~ ~ Q,.

IJQ a ~ = - ~

"0

'" 0-

"0

"0

"'"

-'"

'""'"

O\O

~~

,<o-

~::T

"O"O

0 ~

\0

-0

=

~

~

tn

. I"

I"

"0 0-.

N

-~

~

0.

0.

-.::.

::.

.-

j1"

. --

C

=

-.0.

I"

I"

::T

:!!.-

""'~

~

-"

;j;~

o-

~

--~

::.

~

0 ;::

- 3

-g

0 '<

~

~

-.

n0

=

""-'~

'...':

j;'=

~

':--"

O

=

0

=O

l"o"O

"'o=

~"

O"'O

'=

.'"

~

=

...::T

I"

3

~

-.~

...!:?

.

1"~

1"("

)~:I~

~"O

~~

3c=

o."O

o~o.

~~

~~

=I"

'"0.

~

"0

0

'" C

- ::T

0.

;;1

0

;' ::.

o'

3~

~

a.

0

~

I"

(")

'""

::.

0 =

'""

<

-0

--0

=-

~

'" '"

=

-~.

0.3

\0

::T

=

-.::T

r:;

'" e!

. I"

::T

.-

-.00

~

=

I"

~

~"O

N

~

';;

;, -

(")0

0~0-

-~0'

-'~::T

0.-

'" ,

...\0

...

=.

...0

-.::T

"O~

-"'I"

OO

~~

'T'::

C,"

,,~I"

0.

::T

00

=

=

~

~

n"

'"--

.~

~.

--~

'"

::T'"

~;.S

""

g"1"

0.

-.""

"-

~~

--.'-

' S

I"

C

~

S

o =

>

c~

~

go

'"

~

~

=

=

~

~

~

-~.

"O-I

""O

e:c_

o.~

o.~

O'-

...~

'-'

I"

'"

::T -

.'"3

-

~I"

. -~

"'~=

- _.

:I~""

" _.

~~

n~

o"':;

o

~-~

2?.~

0.0.

-0."

'1"1

":=

'So(

")"'=

I"~

§.S

o;;(

")';j

;~~

~

Z

.g

?;.

go

-.~

I"

0

~

_.3

-."1

"...:

:' =

"'-3

1"'"

0~3~

-<1"

"""

...0

="'I

"""<

~=

~"O

"O=

8~?,

~...

~",

. ...

"OI"

;-~

="O

1"=

"O~

~I"

--~

",o.

I"

-~""

"""~

.~o

'...

~l"n

OI"

I"::.

""

"I"

-:

:. _.

'"3

'(;

"0

""'

0-:

:.

-"0

1"'"

~...

~

=~

::.

::-~

3=0"

'=n

"",'

~

N~

~

~

0"

03--

0'-"

~

0-

""0

""'"

:I-':j

;'o

;:.",

o..,c

:; \0

~

"'"

:0

~

(;

. ~

e!

. ~

~

. 0-

~~

~~

OO

~I"

~",

~::T

~?!

,-,~

"O..:

::!~

=~

033~

::T

'<'"

~

0.

-."'"

0 C

~

'(;

'<

0-

~

"0

-'"

-:;.

n 3

3 "0

I"

~

a

3 .g

~

2:

(;

. ::T

'"

o"""

"O8.

oo"'~

--"O

_::T

",o

~-:

:T::T

~g-

I"S

."'~

o~_.

~~

1"I"

"'=~

~

~o.

~<

o---

.0.

0.

~

(;.

-.0.

_.

:!.

."",

N

n_~

I"=

""o.

N~

-~

:1:

I"

::T

'" -.

., ~

-.

"0:!.

0.

0

'(;

I"

~

n 3

~

~

=

~

=-,

<~

-=oc

"'~~

'"~

::T~

0--

3-0

~

'" I"

~

~ o.

::.

..,

0 s

=._

.'"

"""

--

~I')

-'T'~

=-"

,=~

""

0 "'==

-"-'=

1')=

--'=

~

I')oo

.~O

(1<

I')(1

o>.c

- 3 (1

I')

~

~ ~ '0

~ ~ E.

=-

30

<

'0

I')3

~

5'

~

(1 ~ '-'

-~

~ ,. 0

1')3~

~01

'),v"

0.--

3'0

-(1 = -. 3~ I')

~

'" 'E.

~ -.~

g >

~ '-;

~ '0 ~

~'"

I')-~

_.

-I')

-I

') ~ '=T

~

0.

::I

~ = ~ 0..

C

= =-

0:1

. (1

-.

(1

=. 0.

I')-~

(1

.c",

1')

0 0.

&;

§ ~ ~ 0.

C

'0

E.

'" = = _.=

c .c

-~

...

'" :; '<

- ...~

"'c=

--o-

'" I') ~ ;:.

-.I')

-.

I')

= '0

=. -.'0

'" " ~ 0 '" ...~

;;'=

T=

-!"O

~",

~~

=-~

",><

~

0 I')

C

(1

-.' =-

-(1C

_~~

o~~

~"'~

~o-

-><

, "'i

:..

~.c

~ 3~0.

'O~

=01

').c

3c

:1. ><

(1 0

'< '"

-.'0 C

_. ~ ~'O

0 '"

~~

. -'"

~

~ ~ =

. o 3c=-I')~~:;-", (1,..

""

~O

~""

"-'-'

.~

a'~

'E.-

~

g~

~ 0 (1

3 1')'O

~~

O(i"

~"';

'~g~

5.

~ '0

~ 3 0. _.~

~

-.0 :1.

0 0.~

~g.

~3

-~(1

_.

'030

'0

,. -=-

-~ -.-~

"'--~

o~~

-"'~

I')",

-=

- '" 0

.-0 '0

--

'~~

'O

0 .8"';

-~a.

~;-

~0~

~53

~~

0-<

~~

S:(

i"'

(i"'"C..

.<"'(

1-

0.< '=T

-=

0.

.-

."

~ ,.,j5

'g-;

&~

";:;'

~g~

~ ~-~

~~

~'O

-o

~ ~'E

.0~

o3~

~~

~ ~ o9! ~ ~ '0

~ ~.0.= ~ -. " --'" < ~ -- "'~~

O--

~

'" <

0.

I')

3-,

. =

- -'.,j~

- ""

<""

_.

~ ~'T

'~;

c~(1

;;"(1

>

<0.

"-'

-(1'

0 (1

'0 ~ ~ 0 \0

= § =. 3 ;- <-'o

o~°:

:l<~

= O'O

~N

a'O

~~

"O

I') '0

..3

~ C

~ '" =.

;-~

;-~

~

Q!~

'E.

0 '<

~. (1

0 9-:

0.

=

. '<

~ .? 0 ~

~ ~ ~ =- 0 0'<

_. c.

'=T

~

(1

~ = ...,

-.-

-1')~

"'-""

"(1~

0.0.(1

(1.

~ 00(10

~. --.'"

~

c 3

~~

"' 0§

3 "2

~00

~

~3- < I')

~ 00~30 =. ~ ~

:;:-

_.:1

. c c ~

0 0.':'

~

':-'

, ~ -,- -\.It).

. ~ ~:

O'

;3 ~ ~ e. §.: ~ ~ t " ~~ ~ §: § ~ ~ ~ c ~ ~ 00 g,. s. ;:UI

0

Page 6: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~,C

' r"

r"

r"

r"

r"

r"

0 0

0 0

0 n

n n

n ~

~

~

0

-,

n n

~

~0

=

=

=

nZ

ZZ

=~

~

~

..:

0.

=

='"

v ~

~

"~

--

, n

0.

0.-,

n

-n0

3n

, ,..

. n

-n

-~

~

~

~

'- n,

-=

- 0.

0-

=

~

,~,

~'

~

-~

--'

\ J

lj ~

3

" ::-

, 3

':I

3 ""

~

O

Q

t--,

-.

n -,

:to

. ,

N

n n

n ~

n

~

3 3

3 n

-n

-'(;

a

~

.0

>

~

.0

~

3 E

.0

~

'c

n ~

() 3

e:

~

g ~

~

e:

5'

g

] ~

~

~

[,~

~

1;

: ~

~

~

~

~

2

~

~

0 n

~

2:.c

~

::

~'7

3~

' '~

5"

;: ~

""'~

~

~

~

"'n

' ':I

.-

nn'

~~

",<

:=',=

o:~

=~

n~",

O_n

v ':I

"2v

~.o

' t"

'o""

_ 00

' ~

~

""'n

':"'~

' ~

;:),,"

,o~

'1:Im

~,

~3n"

,,-.,.

: ;::

";""

n'"

'"",~

-',v-

.""

J~

J~;:

"'.'=

'=~

N-~

'\J

.: ~

.'-.

_.:~

~

,3

~e.

~

~'~

N..'

:I~;-

'~

...;-

',-.'

...0

' n~

""

,~...

o I

...2.

-,

~

n 0-

' (J

mo

~

g...,

~~

no,'

-',

0",,:

:: :~

~:;;

"~-~

~;

..'!J

§n~

n.

~5.

OQ

-~=

§..9

:Z",

,=,<

~~

.?5.

,,~

'~o.

. 0\

~

~

:"

\

J ;

~

n '

':-:"

::-

~

'"

m

~

'1:1

:::

:;:

=

0'"

in'

0.

-.,.

~,-

'O

Q

(/)

:

'1: ~

:g

§ ~

~

[

~

~

5. ;

2 T

~

~

2 ~

~'

~ '

:- ~

~

~.

5. ~

~

§:

5.

~

;2 ~

~

~

: ,0

0 ;-

o. c~

~

~

~

~

~

~

. ~

~

~

Onn

o.n.

'n

':I

n~-

...~

C

>ln

;:m"~

-nn~

n-

~

"'=-'~

o.t

~;::

-""

~

~

~,

~

~

~

~

~

~,

.c

~

,\Q ~

: =

[

;..

~

a ;..

N

~

~

;..

., ~

.c

§

~

~

go ~

~

3

~

o. o-.§'

~

~

, ~

§.

~

, 0

~

~

,n

~

~""

0'

""'1

:I-_N

'"rjo

n

I "';

:"""

'--N

V""

O

Q-"

:"'~

~.

"~--

-':-

""';"

'-~5.

n~

'1

:1

~

r i

~

; ~

.~.

~

3 ~

3

~

~

a.

5 ~

-6

- --

; ~

~

. @

~

;:;

~

, g'

5-

~

~

,~

9 g~

' ~

,n

:::

; ~

0"

[

~

5.

a 5.

::-,

3 ~

."

n

'1:1

'1:1

C

IJ ;:

3

~

00 ~

-.

.I tt1

'<

~

...,

-,

\Q ~

-'"

n

=

'" ~

, ','

1:1

lj ~

m~

=

, ~

§

" ~

0

~

N

""

-0~

.n

;._.~

;'1

:1

c;)n

~'

'1:1

' -.

" "'?

~

n O

'-:;;"

~~

':1

":3

-,;:

=

20.

:-0.

0\~

~

QN

~~

~

~:=

.~~

, 1]

,~~

.~=

0 S

.::o~

§§-g

~,

~~

"O""

"""';

.~=

n9c;

)n

o"""

>~

~

Q~

' Y

' ~

'.S

o g,

5

'. ~

g

=

~

~

g,...

, O

Q ~

~

. 0.

~

g,

5.

~

;:;;

&;

;2

~

'(;

~

~

:=.

(j ~

8.

=

&

.2

~

~

r ;-

3'

;to

' ~

~

~

~

n n

~

...=

'(;

S

' ~

~

-,

g

S',

~:-

'J

(J

~

0\

~

n '"

.'"

~

(/)

0 ~ 3

~

S'

-g

n 5,

;::

- ."

~

"'"

n

no;::

.. ~

:;;

"

~

=

~

~

'"rj

0.

_0-' 0

~

, :

~,

~,..

. ~

3'

0"

=

'Z

'-'

-~.

::-. .

..,0-

~ O

Q

-0.

~,

':1 -e!.

of:,.

~

0- 0

'3

:;'

~..:

n"

" ~

""m

-.

--\J

'~n~

=

--""

\Q--

'" ~

:;;

"~-':

I-.'

~

--N

'<

~,§

O

Q ~

~

=

n ~

, 0.

a

n ~

. =

.3

.'"

\Q O

Q ~

c'

00 ,.

.. g

~

~.

;::- §

'"

=

o' O

Q ..,...

-~

~

~

\Q §

~

~

~o

0 ~

'"

=

0 -:

t...

""

0 oo

"":;;

"OQ

00

'-'"

;::.o

.~

0.

:o.=

~

-\C

~n=

00

. ,.,

-=

-~

~

n

:;;" -

" ~

.:...

33

--.~

, 0.

.. -~

0

n ~

' ~

O

Q

:-.

,-

" "':

JO

~

0.

'" of

:,.

-,

0.0.

- --

.'OQ

~'

,,"""

""~

".

C""

N

"'V~

n"'o

. -"

"0

...~

.,,:~

.3~

S'~

n_,

~

()

'1:1

"':

.:::~

'"

--~

,'1:1

~~

-"

n ~

-'...,

c;)~

.:--1

;:::;;

"~

(/);

:~"0

n

~

OQ

.0

>

~

-~

;i

~

~

';:;;

~

-:

~

-g

g §

~,"

9 ...

~.

n ~

::a

n

§ ~

0

~

~

~

n 5.

-g

~

~

3~~

~

=()

\Q~

"

><

,..

. .o

o~.

-_o.

~of

:,.~

, 0>

..0

~'(;

n ~

n

[ ~

, =

Q

g

~

~

t'" ~

;: 'l

~

~

;.;.

2 cA

[

g- ~

§

~

~

~~

. .,

-;:

s'

~

~.

3 ~

'e

:. ~.

~

[:.-~

,

0.

~

':?; ~

, e!

.~'

~~

. ~

:;

~

0- V

I ~

'1

:1

; g

~

~

1.

~.

::-. ~

s:

OQ

~

0

0 :-

'"

~

n'

~

~

0\ =

E;

g ~

~

::0

:s:

g

~

§ '"

~

;: ':'

:~'

Y'

'e:.~

, [

~

C

t'"

~

~

g ::i

.!.

. S

' ~

. <

6 ~

=

g,

~

'"

e:

5:B

~

0 ~

~

0.

\Q

n

3 -~

~

-O

Q

::-. V

I ':I

e!

. _.

C

~

;;.

!'J ~

;::

" ..~

N

O";

: 3

:: -'"

;::

- 0"

0.

~..

~~

S

' of

:,. ~

:"'"

~

()

:<: ~

8.

' :

~

..:

~

';::

~

g ~

O

Q

C

g. 0

,o

f:,. ~

~

0 =

..-

g ':I

~

~

N

;'

OQ

VI

S'

=

0\

~

~

~

n,

"J

=

'" n

>

E.

~

n =

g

-~

~::-

. 0"

-:

:-,

c n'

0.

--

§.

..-J

g,

OQ

~

.!..

~

~

.l",

~

~:::

-~

0.

:

~

n ~

~

<

-.

'" \Q

~

~

0 ~

~

?a

=

:

OQ

~

&;

So

>

1.

0 ~

V

I ...

~

' '=

~

. n

(8

~

(;"

(J

S'

~;:;

. ~

~

.g

-00

o'

;: ~

3

I -:

: <

6 m

n

N

~S

' ~

00

~

:' g

!'J S

. ~

;' a'

~

~

!'J

S'

3 ~

S

' n:

to.

~

':<

e.

\0

~

? 'e

:. m

~

. ::j

~

t'"

90: ~

S

' ~

~

;. ~

,o

f:,. g.

~

g.

0

~?>

:..

. g.

~

"8

5.

~

~,~

:t

§ ~

15

:

~

~

g ,V

I ~

~

~

'?

; ~

--

~~

n

-~,

OQ

" ,

0::

...'

~

-.0.

-,

--

n -n

~

_.

'<

\0

n\Q

->

~,..

. ~

'"

n -~

,=

' -.

,.,

-n

;: "

-~

\Q3

~

0. =

\Q

<.

~.

\Q

,:=:

(II.c

~

~

~

;:

;::

(II

'e:.

-~

-;::0

~

V

i" C

e!

. ;::

:; '"

0-

00

~.

-.~

g

~-'n

""~

(I

IC"'-

., ,

n \O

~

0.,

~

-00

(II

-'"

,-

g-

~

.~

8,

~

~

~;j1

§

3:

~

~

:!!:

~::-

~

~

~

§

~

~;'

~

:-

~

~

~

~

~

~

e!.

0 O

Q

~"

...~

=

~

.'1

:1

,.,

,.,

,...

.~

0.

.£::-

~

n

_.~

n

-.cr

~

,--

"'"

~

~

~-'

;::-

-..J

--

"',,"

~

~

n"

" --

0.

~

~

0.::-

. ~

'~.

' ~

:::

:-.

~

cr

':I

...~

Z

C

m

~

00

0

(;"

(JQ

-0

S

' ::-

.n

~

..:

-.':1

-~

~

~

_C

-::-

, ':I

O

Q

C

.~

=

" ;::

=

'=

~

~0=

-=

n 00

. '--

" 0

0 0

,,-.0

~

."

,0

_'

--

~

~

~

~

~:J

::J:

:J:

:J:

:J:

0 0

0 0

0 "n

C

CO

O

S"

0 :;'

Q

O

QO

Q

O

0 0

0 0

CO

~

N'"

:3

,.~

"O

-'"

- NQ

. --

Co

~(D

(D

0

--.(

D

.""

(D

(D

(D

~

~;n

' ..

;I.-

..N

..~

~

~

:. '<

0

~

~

3 :3

~

. )0

0 -~

~

0

<:

-"0

'<

-'"

: Q

. (D

..C

o W

(J

Q

Co

cn

Co

--""

""

';)

co

cn

-.'"

0 Y

' ~

0

'" 0

? -.

.<;.

~

~

~

cn

-=

.~

-.n.

\0

~

. \0

"0

)00

(IQ

x

0 (I

Q

-.J

(JQ

0

~

(IQ

\C

2

~

~

~.

"0

:;'>

N

~

(JQ

~:3

<

-_

.Q..,

., ",

~~

oo=

Ooo

~

(D~

C(D

..co~

:3~

(D\C

...

(j ()

Q...

~

I ~

~

-.

QO

cn

;::

. ~

~

(D

(j

~

" =

. .'"

~

~

O

' W

Q

.. v.

:. ~

. ~

~

. _:

.' '"

~.

~,,~

~

c:

. ~

. '"

~.

N.

-",-

" -'

~'(D

' "'.

~

\J-

.~

(D

.coo

~""

~w

o~'

-~~

\J-,

",

-

()Q

~

N

: ~

~

. C

"" c

o ~

o'

=

C

"" Q

O cn

ttJ

; !'J

~

Q

O ~

~

>-'

:3

r-

-:3'

3.

~

. 0:

3'

-go

..~

~

"n

C

~

~~

."c.

.0

;2

?;

~

, ~

..~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~::o

"0

~

::

~:

~

q §

~.g

p

g g

P

.!..

:?.

P

~

~

P

?O::o

9'

~

~

. ";

' ~

~

~

~

(D. ~

~

~

g

~

~

:;0'

;,..

;"

~

~.

~

~

~

p ::.

~

n

[Co

~

C

:-1

'il.

~

~

~

a ~

:::

~

~

~

~

~

1-- ~

~

C

"J

--J

3"0

:3

~

~

-"'"

3 :;

.<:

, J

3.-

~

-QO

C

~

~

L.

' '..

:: -~

\0

:-"1

!'J

., ~

'"

Co

:J'

_.::;

..'

co

0

:: :J

: ~

:3

:-

1 ;:-

.,

~

3;:..

~

-~

~

.9-'

--~

~

~

:3 <

,,"0"

:: ~

~

E

.:

---'.

...

:3:;

.C""

-.

-C

"0

'" :::

-~

(D

' C

o3

.';)

v~

'- \0

~

. ~

'-'

~

'"

,,_.

v~

~N

cn

~

~

.~

.(

JQ

~

>

0 (D

~

C

o'

~

~

~"O

. Q

. C

""

(JQ

cn

~

~

.\0

~

~

-.

::;'

~.

~

\ J

(D'

~':-

:' .-

.W

~.

~

QO

-~

0

'" ~

~

~

'" N

:3

0

,...

~.

~

~!b

0

3 "

_.~

-:

3 2

~

;. 0

~

-~

~

~

::0

~N

~

~

.. ~

~

~

=

~

-g

3

~

g ""

' Q

. 0

~

:3

~

g~.

~ ~

~

. 5

:3

C

0 '(;

" I

g:3

~

~

-3

~

\0

;l.-

v.

<

:J'

v.

" ("

\ Q

. '>

::!

:J

: cr

' 0

~

.: ~

-(

JQ:3

:J

' -~

~

~

(J

Q -

-3

N.

I ~

-g

-.

-~I

-' (D

\0

~

~

;:-

'"

'" -0

."

'. .~

:J':3

:3

(D

~

~

. ~

:3

v~

J

;: (D

~

~

.. o.

'"

""'

:;:

:J'

? ~

~

~

3

~

=:.

~

0:

~

~

~

~

: ~

::

-<

~.

..~:3

'-

~

C

'ff:

8.:;.

~

~

~

~

. ::i

~

.-

.:3

"0

~.0

\: ~

v.

~

Q

O 0%

~

~

g ?O

~

:;.

g.

Q

?O '

;; ,..

, ~

C

o ~

<

' cI

S

3 C

o ~

~

~

.(

IQ.o

~

~

g?

O

~

QO

:;.

~

5.-

zQ

O \O

~:3

-_

."

"~(J

Q

~-

QO

:I':;~

' (D

"O

~

(D

~-

QO

'- ~

-~

~

:3

\0

Q.

00 '

"-

:-

("\.

=

"-

0 :o

j .,

.-:.

~

~

:3

QO

3Q

O -

3.~

.3

..~

z 0

~

-.Q

. 0

v.

-00

Q

O

..~'

~

-.""

-.

~

.~

'" Q

. ...

:3

-~

~

~

.'"

~

~

J ("

')00

<:

3--

,:,

-:3

~

..,,~

.,.

: ()Q

-.tI

1 ~

~

Q

O Q

. Q

O;'

..9.

~

(D ~

::

~

~"

~

~

'- ()

Q c

: 3

I~

-.'"~

. (J

Q

--0

,-J

'-"

-.C

o "':

3 "0

-~

"

..,..

,-J

~

-L

' .~

.~

~

~

~

!! ~

=

. ~

C

~

~

.-§

'" ~

""

' C

o ~

'"

~

ttJ

~.

'(;"

§ :;

~

~

~

g.

=:

~

::-

"n o~

. ~

~

-QO

-.

J :

---~

C

--

'-'

~

(JQ

~

G

~

(D

~

0

., -0

-.

J '.

o'

"E.'

~

~

~.

=-

~.

.co.

8.

C

) ~

. ':"

:"

0 --

.g

--~

r-

:::

.: g.

~

. ~

~

.;:

~

=

~

~

~

~

~.

C)

3 =

=

.~=

=

-..,.

, -.

-(JQ

~

-,

3\0

C

~

Q

O

:3

~

-.(D

...

~

...~

QO

0

~

0 '"

(D

N

:3

(D

~

:. ~

'"

5 -.

J -~

~

(D

~

=

=

0 -(

JQ

(JQ

c.

~

~

.:>

0 ~

(D

0'

("

\=

=

~.

Q7

-.'

~

N

Co.

~

0

v.

"0

()Q

(D

0\

fA

n'

~

3

~

QO

' :J

'~

.5"

.()Q

~

.. ~

Co

.-=

=

'f ~

..'

" ~

~

:3

I

~

~

~.

.~

~

~

'" ~

-:

<

~

",'"

0"

:3

5 ~

~

(j

'" -'.

Q

~3

ttJ

~

~

..(D

-~

"

-0

w;'

~

0 '>

,

0 ~

'"

-~

~.o

0

0 Q

O

oS

=.

C

:;~

'"

,. -0

" \0

<

: ,-

J ""

' '

~

-~

_.L.

' ("

\ :J

' "

:-

.3

'" Q

O

...Q

O

.: ~

~

""

'...

I ~

."

,"'..

. v.

~

-.

,..,

~

<:

...'"

.;:-

0 Q

O

..J

0 -C

I1

;:-'-"

:-:-

~

;. ("

\ -.

00

~

~

'<

(j ~

o'

~

~

"8

§:

I' ~

:;.

~

0 0

~

0 =

=

~:J

' .0

- ~

~

. g;

-~

'E.

~

5"

g I

=-.

w

~

n'

g.

So

-0

~

~

~

~

~

(JQ

-.

0 ~

.c

:-

Q.

0%

~

z ~

c:

"'~

. '5

;~

~

".

.. -~

-~

-.

~

~

;g

~

--.~

~

("

') ..~

~

=

- ()

Q

Z

'" -(

D

0 (I

Q

~

'-'

<:

("\

(IQ

~

0%

'"

~

3 \0

0

~

~

~

-'(;"

~

,~

~

g ~

...,

~

=:

~

~

~.

~

':<

~

~

!'J

~.

(D

5._.

~

~

-g.

-.\0

~

=

()

Q

(D'

Q.

~

~

~

'ii"

()Q

~

g.

0:

-<

-0

0

~.,-

': 0:

<: c

o ~

("

\:;i

'" -

~

...":

. -"

8 t;:

:> '(

;" .

-' ~

~

(J

Q

~

0 ;:-

:3

~

. -.

~

~

==

. ~

0

='

;:..

~

~

"0

~Q

; ~

:::

: ~

~

=

- C

o cn

-0

~

~

~

'"

-~.

~

c-

g §

N

(IQ

0

("\.2

~

Q

. >

~

~.

~

~

~

~0

-.J

~

~

-~

0'

~

-.~

§

~

(D

()Q

""

Q

. \0

co

co

~

C

..~

..~

-.

co

--~

~

.~

0\

"...

-:.

~

-(JQ

~

~

-~

-.

' ,

~

-=:

'0'

"-

~~

. '"

-.'-'

..~

:-

- 0

~

-'..

.co

cn

I Q

.!b

~

f!!.

0 =

'" ::.

. "'.

. ()

Qon

'""

~

~

..~

0

N

==

'" =

=

~3

-co

~

.W

.~:.

='"

~

(D

-"

~

(D

~~

~

~

~

:J

' \0

0o c

(j .._

:.:o!

'.Q

~0

co

.~

0 ~

3~

~

co

~

co

;:-

~-

='"~

I

=

C"J

CO

..0

C

' ~

-~

=

=

~

~'"

("\

'(;"

~

('i

~

~

(D

~

~

~

';;

n"'"

~

=.

.:-.

='

--.~

:o

J a

~

:::-

co

~

co

=.

cn

g ~

~

~_.

0

co,<

-'(;"

'"

co""

~

~

-0

Nf!!

.;:"_

",(D

~

-.

==

...,

"O~

-,

.'"

~.

<'"5

0

3 0"

'. Q

. ~

(J

Q

(D

~.

c v.

-.

v.'"

co

\0

'" (J

Q

-..,

:3

'(;"

,-.

...~

~

~

-g

., ~

.:3

~

~

e -(

JQ

~

o~.

,.,.

Q;

I -.

I O

' ~

\0

...

~

~

~

'<

tI1

~

:;':;:

.. (J

Q

(DC

,.

-\0

(D

~

.(D

~

-"

"' =

=

-~

=-

W

0 -~

:3

' Q

. (J

Q -

'. ...

~

:; c'

§

s ~

:::

~

0"

~

F

~

~

o'

~

~

~

0 ~

" S

o:;'

5'

';;

§ r.

. ~

~

~

..;

~

~

..~

Q.

0 (D

,. '<

,

..~

., ~

.0

.-

" (D

(J

Q

"0

Q..

.0

'" ~

..

~ ~ §: e ~ ~ -:s i{ g"l.A ""'

~ " "§ ~:

§" -Q.,

.{S

'~ §: ~ ~ ~ "" ~ '" V

I '""

Page 7: UC Santa Barbara Geography - A New Framework for …montello/pubs/microgenesis.pdf · 2002. 11. 28. · Many of their ideas came from Piaget's extensive theorizing about spatial ontogeny,

-

~-~ .154 Spatial and Temporal Cognition

~

-

velopment variations." In D. Canter andT. Lee (Eds.), Ps)'chology and theBuilt Environment. London: Architectural Press, 1974, pp. 184-194.

Piaget, J., and B. Inhelder: The Child's Conception of Space. New York: Norton,1967.

Presson, C. C., and D. R. Montello. "Points of reference in spatial cognition:Stalking the elusive landmark." British Journal of Developmental Psychol-ogy. 6: 378-381, 1988.

Rand, G. "Some Copernican views of the city." Architectural Forum. 132: 77-81,1969.

Rybash, J. M., and W. J. Hoyer. "Hemispheric specialization for categorical andcoordinate spatial representations: A reappraisal." Memory and Cognition.20: 271-276, 1992.

Sadalla,E. K., and D. R. Montello. "Remembering changes in direction." Envi-ronmentand Behavior. 21: 346-363, 1989.

Shemyakin, F. N. "Orientation in space." In B. G. Ananyev (Eds.), PsychologicalScience in the USSR. Vol. 11466 (1). Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Tech-nical Services, 1961, pp. 186-255.

Siegel, A. W., and S. H. White. "The development of spatial representations oflarge-scale environments.".In H. W. Reese (Ed.), Advances in Child Devel-opment and Behavior. Vol. 10, New York: Academic Press., 1975, pp. 9-55.

Smyth, M. M., and J. E. Kennedy. "Orientation and spatial representation withinmultiple frames of reference." British Journal of Psychology. 73: 527-535,1982.

Thorndyke, P. W., and B. Hayes-Roth. "Differences in spatial knowledge ac-quired from maps and navigation." Cognitive Psychology. 14: 560-589,1982.

Tolman, E. C. "Cognitive maps in rats and men." Psychological Review. 55:189-208, 1948.

Werner, H. Comparative Psychology of Mental Development. New York: Interna-tional Universities Press, 1948. -

Worchel, P. "Space perception and orientation in th~ ~lin~." Psy(:hologicaLMono-graphs: General and Appliea. 65 (332): 1-27, 1951. -,-

~I

if.{

I;

#

~