tsr subramanian v. union of india judgment
TRANSCRIPT
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 1/47Page 1
1
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO.82 OF 2011
T.S.R. Subr!"#" $ Or%. & P'##"'r%
V'r%u%
U"#" * I"+# $ Or%. & R'%,"+'"%
WITH
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO.2- OF 2011
J U D G M E N T
K.S. Radhakrishnan, J.
1. Ar#/' -2 * ' C"%#u#" * I"+# % b''"
#"3'+ b4 *'5 '!#"'" r'#r'+ /## %'r"% #6#6#"6
' "'/'%%#4 * r#u% r'*r!% *r ,r'%'r#" *
#"'6r#47 *'r'%%"'%% "+ #"+','"+'"/' * /## %'r"%
' C'"r' "+ S' ''% #" ' /u"r4. Pr4'r%
!+' #" #% 5r# ,'##" r' b%'+ " r#u% r',r%
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 2/47Page 2
2
"+ r'/!!'"+#"% !+' b4 %''r C!!#''%
,,#"'+ *r #!,r#"6 ' ,ub#/ +!#"#%r#". O"
' b%#% * r#u% r',r%7 *5#"6 r'#'*% r' %u6 #"
' 5r# ,'##" 9
(#) I%%u' 5r# #" ' "ur' * !"+!u% r "4 'r
,,r,r#' 5r#7 r+'r r +#r'/#" r':u#r#"6 '
R'%,"+'"% /r'' " ;#"+','"+'"< C##
S'r#/' =r+ r C!!#%%#" b ' C'"r' "+
' S' b%'+ " r'/!!'"+#"% b4 ' H
C!!#''7 200 (,r >.0?7 ,r >.117 M#"
R'/!!'"+#"% N.-8)@ ' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#'
R'*r!% C!!#%%#" 2008 (10 R',r7 ,r ?.8)@
' %'!'" +,'+ ' C"*'r'"/' * C#'*
M#"#%'r% " E**'/#' "+ R'%,"%#'
A+!#"#%r#"7 1??@
(##) I%%u' 5r# #" ' "ur' * !"+!u% r "4 'r
,,r,r#' 5r#7 r+'r r +#r'/#" r':u#r#"6 '
r'%,"+'"% *#B'+ '"ur' *r /## %'r"%
'"%ur#"6 %b##4 b%'+ " r'/!!'"+#"% b4 J
C!!#%%#" 1?8 (,r .2)@ C'"r S**#"6
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 3/47Page 3
-
S/'!'7 1?? (,r 1.017 ,r 1.027 ,r 1.0-7
,r 1.12)7 ' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!%
C!!#%%#" (10 R',r7 ,r 8.7 ,r ?.87 ,r
1.>)7 H C!!#'' R',r7 200 (M#"
R'/!!'"+#"% N.-?)@
(###) I%%u' 5r# #" ' "ur' * !"+!u% r "4 'r
,,r,r#' 5r#7 r+'r r +#r'/#" r':u#r#"6 '
r'%,"+'"% !"+' ''r4 /## %'r"
*r!4 r'/r+ %u/ #"%ru/#"%+#r'/#"%
r+'r%%u66'%#"% 5#/ '%' r'/'#'%7 " "4
*r! #%'r +!#"#%r#' %u,'r#r% bu % *r!
,##/ ur##'%7 '6#%r%7 /!!'r/# "+
bu%#"'%% #"'r'%% "+ 'r ,'r%"%:ur'r%
#"6 #"'r'%7 5#'+#"6 #"*u'"/' r ,ur,r#"6
r',r'%'" %' #" ur#4 b%'+ " ' ,r#"/#,'%
r'/6"#'+ b4 Ru' -(-)(##)(###) * ' A I"+# S'r#/'
C"+u/ Ru'%7 1?8 "+ % #!,#/#4 r'/6"#'+ b4
' S""! C!!#'' R',r7 1?2 (S'/#" 7
%ub9,r --###.
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 4/47Page 4
2. T#% Cur7 /"%#+'r#"6 ' #!,r"/' * '
!'r7 #%%u'+ "#/' r#u% S' G'r"!'"% "+
' U"#" T'rr#r#'% % % %/'r#" '#r #'5% " '
r#u% #%%u'% r#%'+ #" #% /%'. M% * ' S'%
' *#'+ +'#'+ /u"'r **#+#% 'B,#"#"6 '#r
%"+ 5# r'6r+ ' r'#'*% ,r4'+ *r #" #% 5r#
,'##".
-. Sr# .. V'"u6,7 'r"'+ %'"#r /u"%'
,,'r#"6 *r ' 5r# ,'##"'r%7 r'*'rr'+ 'br'4
' b'9!'"#"'+ r',r% "+ #6#6'+ '
"'/'%%#4 * ' /r'#" * C## S'r#/' =r+ (*r
%r CS=)7 b ' C'"r' "+ S' ''7 5#
+'6r'' * #"+','"+'"/' % # /" !3'
r'/!!'"+#"% " r"%*'r% "+ ,%#"6% 5#u
%/r#*#/#"6 ' 'B'/u#' *r''+! * ' G'r"!'".
L'r"'+ %'"#r /u"%' ,#"'+ u %u/ CS= %
*u"/#" #" br' +#%r4 /,/#4 "+ #%
r'/!!'"+#"% 5# " #!,%' "4 /"%r#" " '
#"+','"+'"/' * ' ,##/ ur#4 '**'/ ,%#"6%
"+ r"%*'r%7 #"/u+#"6 ,r'!ur' r"%*'r%. L'r"'+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 5/47Page 5
>
%'"#r /u"%' % #6#6'+ ' "'/'%%#4 *r
,r#+#"6 *#B'+ '"ur' *r /## %'r"% '"%ur#"6
%b##4 5#/ #% #64 "'/'%%r4 *r #!,'!'"#"6
r#u% ,r6r!!'% 5#/ 5# ' %/# "+ '/"!#/
#!,/ " ' %/#'4. L'r"'+ %'"#r /u"%' %
#6#6'+ ' r'%"% *r r'/+#"6 * #"%ru/#"%7
+#r'/#"% "+ r+'r% b4 ' /## %'r"% % '4
/" *u"/#" #"+','"+'"4 "+ ' ,%%#b##4 * rb#rr4
"+ #'6 +'/#%#"% /u+ b' #+'+.
. Mr. Pr% u+7 'r"'+ ASG ,,'r#"6 *r '
U"#" * I"+#7 ,,%'+ #" ,r#"/#,' ,r4'r *r %'#"6 u,
* #"+','"+'" CS= ' C'"r' "+ ' S' ''%7
5#/7 //r+#"6 ' 'r"'+ ASG7 5u+ b' #"'r*'r#"6
5# ' 6'r"!'" *u"/#"%. L'r"'+ ASG %
%ub!#'+ "4 !'/"#%! 5##" ' 6'r"!'"
%ru/ur' /u+ b' u6 *7 bu #"'!'" * "4
,'r%"7 5%''r #6 ' !4 b'7 5 #% " ,r * '
C'"r' r ' S' G'r"!'"7 5u+ " b' +#%b'7
'%,'/#4 #" ' b%'"/' * "4 %u/ ,r#%#" #" '
C"%#u#" r ' 5% !+' b4 C'"r' "+ ' S'
G'r"!'"%. L'r"'+ ASG % %ub!#'+ b%'+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 6/47Page 6
" ' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#'' (ARC)7
+r* =# '"#'+ ;C## S'r#/'% P'r*r!"/' S"+r+%
"+ A//u"b##4 =#7 2010< 5% ,r#+'+ #"/r,r#"6
/'r#" r'/!!'"+#"% #" ' b'9!'"#"'+
r',r%. Fur'r7 # 5% ,#"'+ u ' +r*
Cb#"' N' *r ' #"r+u/#" * ' %#+ =# #" '
Pr#!'" #% u"+'r /"%#+'r#" * ' C'"r
G'r"!'". Fur'r7 # 5% % %ub!#'+ *r
*#B#"6 ' !#"#!u! '"ur'% * /+r' ,% #" ' I"+#"
A+!#"#%r#' S'r#/' 5% #"##'+ #" N'!b'r7 200
b4 ' D',r!'" * P'r%""' $ Tr#"#"6. C+r'
/"r#"6 ur##'% * ' I"+#" P#/' S'r#/' "+
I"+#" Fr'#6" S'r#/' 5'r' % r':u'%'+ 3'
"'/'%%r4 *59u, /#" *r *#B#"6 ' !#"#!u!
'"ur'% #" ' /+r' ,% *r ' I"+#" P#/' S'r#/' "+
I"+#" Fr'#6" S'r#/'. Dur#"6 ' ,r/'%% *
/"%u#"7 # 5% ,#"'+ u /!!'"% * '
S' G'r"!'"% 5'r' %u6 " ' ,r,% * *#B#"6
!#"#!u! '"ur' * ,%#"6 * IAS O**#/'r%. 1- S'
G'r"!'"% 6r''+ 5# ' ,r,%7 5#' %!'
S'% +#+ " 6r''. T' !'r 5% *ur'r +#%/u%%'+ #"
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 7/47Page 7
' !''#"6 5# ' C#'* S'/r'r4Pr#"/#, S'/r'r#'%
* ' S'% /"/'r"'+ " -1.>.200 "+ 6#" "
..2008 #" D'#. N#*#/#" ,r#+#"6 *r 5 4'r%
!#"#!u! '"ur' *r IAS ,%#"6 #"6 b''" #%%u'+ *r
1- S'%J#" C+r'%. R'*'r'"/' 5% % !+'
%u+4 r',r * ;C'"r' *r G+ G'r""/'<7
H4+'rb+ "+ # 5% %'+ ' %!' #% u"+'r
/"%#+'r#" 5# ' C'"r G'r"!'". W# r'6r+
' ,r4'r *r r'/r+#"6 * #"%ru/#"%+#r'/#"%7 '/.7
# 5% ,#"'+ u ' r':u#r'!'"% r' ,r#+'+
u"+'r ' A I"+# S'r#/' C"+u/ Ru'%.
>. L'r"'+ /u"%'% ,,'r#"6 *r ' S'
G'r"!'"% "+ ' U"#" T'rr#r#'% ' % ,/'+
'#r %"+ " r#u% r'#'*% %u6 *r #" #% 5r#
,'##". L'r"'+ S"+#"6 /u"%' ,,'r#"6 *r '
S' * Ur Pr+'% %ub!#'+ ' S' %
r'+4 '%b#%'+ C## S'r#/' =r+% #" 'r!% * '
G'r"!'" r+'r% +'+ 2.12.2001 "+ 1?.>.2007
5#/ #% !'" ,'r' 5# r'%,'/ IAS "+
Pr#%#" C## S'r#/'%7 I"+#" P#/' S'r#/'% "+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 8/47Page 8
8
Pr#%#" P#/' S'r#/'% "+ *r I"+#" Fr'% S'r#/'%
"+ '#r *''+'r %'r#/'%. O'r "+ b'7 ' S' %
% *r!u'+ r"%*'r ,#/4 +'+ 1>.>.2008.
L'r"'+ /u"%' ,,'r#"6 *r ' S' * Mr%r
% !+' r'*'r'"/' ' Mr%r G'r"!'"
S'r"% R'6u#"% * Tr"%*'r% "+ Pr''"#" *
D'4 #" D#%/r6' * O**#/# Du#'% A/7 200> "+
%ub!#'+ ' A/ ,r#+'+ *r r"%*'r *
G'r"!'" %'r"% "+ ,r''"#" * +'4 #"
+#%/r6' * **#/# +u#'%.
. R'#'*% ,r4'+ *r #" #% 5r# ,'##" r' b%'+ "
' H C!!#'' R',r7 2007 2"+ A+!#"#%r#'
R'*r!% C!!#%%#" (10 R',r)7 2008. 2"+
A+!#"#%r#' S'r#/' C!!#%%#" (1> R',r)7 '
R',r * ' C!!#'' " Pr''"#" * Crru,#"7
S""! C!!#'' R',r7 '/. W' ' 6"'
ru6 %' r',r% #" +'#.
A. CIVIL SERVICE =OARD (CS=)
. T' G'r"!'" * I"+# " -r+ F'brur47 2007
,,#"'+ ' H C!!#'' 'B!#"' ' 5'
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 9/47Page 9
?
6!u * C## S'r#/' r'*r!% "+ ' 'r!% * r'*'r'"/'
* ' C!!#'' 5'r' % *5% 9
;(#) M3#"6 ' C## S'r#/'K r'%,"%#' "+ /##'"9*r#'"+4@K r"%,r'"@K //u"b'@ "+K '#/#" #% () /#"% "+ (b) #"'r*/' 5# ',','7
(##) M3#"6 ' /## %'r#/' '96'r""/'*r#'"+4.
(###) Pu#"6 ,r'!#u! " #"''/u 6r5 */## %'r"% "+ " u,6r+#"6 '#r+!#" 3"5'+6'7
(#) Pr'/#"6 ' /## %'r#/' 6#"% 5r"6*u,r'%%ur' 'B'r'+ b4
() +!#"#%r#' %u,'r#r%@(b) ,##/ 'B'/u#'@(/) bu%#"'%% #"'r'%%@ "+(+) 'r '%'+ #"'r'%%.
() C"6'%7 #* "4 "'/'%%r47 #" ' r#u% AI"+# S'r#/'% Ru'% "+ C'"r C## Ru'% ,r#+' %ur4 /'r ' ,r,%'+/## %'r#/' r'*r!%.
(#) C"6'% #" ru'% 6'r"#"6 ' +#%/#,#"r4,r/''+#"6% 6#"% /## %'r"% +'/'"r#' ' ,r/'%% % *r %,r/#/b'7 "+ !3' ' +#%,% *%u/ ,r/''+#"6% #!'9bu"+.
(##) A"4 'r !'r ' C!!#'' !4/"%#+'r r''" ' %ub'/ * /##
%'r#/' r'*r!%.<
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 10/47Page 10
10
8. O" '%b#%!'" * I"+#" C## S'r#/'% =r+7 '
H C!!#'' !+' ' *5#"6 r'/!!'"+#"% 9
;>.0? W' *u"+ %!' S'% /!,#'+ 5#' r'/!!'"+#"% * ' C"*'r'"/' *C#'* M#"#%'r% "+ %' u, C## S'r#/'%=r+%E%b#%!'" =r+% 5# C#'*S'/r'r4 * ' S' % ' C#r!" "+'r %'"#r **#/#% * ' S' % M'!b'r%.
=u ' =r+% %' u, b4 'B'/u#' r+'r #"+#**'r'" S'% ' *#'+ #"%,#r'/"*#+'"/' % !r' *'" " "7 '4 '!'r'4 *r!#'+ ' 5#%'% * '#r C#'*M#"#%'r% #" !'r% * r"%*'r * **#/#%. W'r' *#r!4 * ' #'5 C## S'r#/'% A/% b' '"/'+ !3' ' C## S'r#/'%=r+ E%b#%!'" =r+ b #" ' S'%"+ #" ' G'r"!'" * I"+# %ur4 #"/r/'r. I" ' ,r,%'+ %' u, #" 'G'r"!'" * I"+#7 ' A,,#"!'"%C!!#'' * ' Cb#"' 5# b' ' *#"ur#4 *r r"%*'r * **#/'r% u"+'r 'C'"r S**#"6 S/'!'. T' %!' ,r#"/#,' **#B'+ '"ur' %u+ ,,4 %'"#r **#/'r%7 5r' " u"+'r ' C'"r S**#"6 S/'!'7 bur' 5r3#"6 u"+'r ' G'r"!'" * I"+# *r5#/ ' D',r!'" M#"#%'r #" /r6' #%' *#" ur#4 *r r"%*'r. T' C#'*M#"#%'r 5# b' ' *#" ur#4 *r r"%*'r * Gru, A **#/'r% * S' S'r#/' "+ AIS**#/'r% %'r#"6 #" /""'/#" 5# **#r% * 'S'. I* C#'* M#"#%'r +'% " 6r'' 5#' r'/!!'"+#"% * ' C## S'r#/'%=r+ E%b#%!'" =r+7 ' 5# ' r'/r+ #% r'%"% #" 5r##"6. A" **#/'rr"%*'rr'+ b'*r' #% "r! '"ur' ''"u"+'r r+'r% * ' C#'* M#"#%'r /" 6#'
' !'r b'*r' r''9!'!b'r
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 11/47Page 11
11
O!bu+%!". T' C#r,'r%" * 'O!bu+%!" 5# b' r'#r'+ **#/# * ,r'""'%4 "+ #"'6r#4. T' 'r 5 !'!b'r%
/" b' " ,r9#!' b%#% *r! !"6 %'r#"6**#/'r%. I" %u/ ,r'!ur' r"%*'r% 'O!bu+%!" % %'"+ r',r 'G'r"r * ' S'7 5 % /u%' # b'#+ #" " A""u R',r b'*r' ' S'L'6#%ur'. T' O!bu+%!" !4 % ,4+!6'% ' **#/'r % r"%*'rr'+ /!,'"%' #! *r +#%/#" "+ !'"6"4 /u%'+ +u' %u/ r"%*'r. W' r'
/"%/#u% 5' r' r'/!!'"+#"6 %ur4 brr#'r *r':u'" r"%*'r * %'"#r**#/#% bu ' !'r % /!' %u/ ,%% # r':u#r'% %ur4 r'!'+4. W' %/r#*4 ' C#'* M#"#%'r % ' #6'%,##/ 'B'/u#' % ' *#" ,5'r% r+'rr"%*'r * " **#/'r b'*r' #% '"ur' #% 'r.
>.10 W' r' % * ' ,#"#" ,%#"6% * Gru, = **#/'r% !u% b' +"' b4 ' H'+* ' D',r!'" #" S' "+ ' %!''"ur' ru' % b' 6#'" %ur4 b/3#"6.W' 5'r' +#%'+ b4 %!' 5#"'%%'% "4' C#'* M#"#%'r% r+'r% *r r"%*'r %u+b' 3'" #" /%' * Gru, A **#/'r% **#/'r%* A I"+# S'r#/'% "+ " M#"#%'r * S'%u+ ' "4 ,5'r% r+'r r"%*'r r,,r' ,r,% *r r"%*'r * "4 **#/#'#'r * "4 S' S'r#/' r * ' A I"+#S'r#/'. W' 6r'' 5# ' #'57 % #" ur,#"#" 5#"6 r'%"% * ,##/ 'B,'+#'"/4r ''" +u' u"5'%!' r'%"%7 M#"#%'r%#" S'% *'" r' " b' !3' ,r,'r u%'* ' ,5'r '%'+ #" '! *r r"%*'r * '#r+',r!'" **#/'r%. I* M#"#%'r % /6'"r'%"% %3 *r r"%*'r * " **#/# b'*r'' /!,''% #% '"ur'7 ' 5# !' ' C##S'r#/'% =r+ b' %' u, u"+'r ' "'5 C##
S'r#/'% A/ "+ ' C## S'r#/'% =r+7 5#
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 12/47Page 12
12
#% #'5% " r',r * #":u#r4 b4 +'%#6"'+**#/'r7 % %ub!# ' /%' ' C#'*M#"#%'r *r *#" r+'r%. Tu% #" S'
G'r"!'"7 M#"#%'r% ,r,% *r r"%*'r* "4 **#/'r * Gru, AGru, = 5# b'*r!4 +'/#+'+ b4 ' C#'* M#"#%'r * 'S'.
>.11 I" ur ,#"#"7 C## S'r#/'% =r+% !u%b' %' u, #" S'% " %#!#r #"'% % 'C'"r'. T' C'"r A/ %u+ ' ,r#%#" '"b' ' S'% +, ' 5 "+ !3'
# ,,#/b' #" ' S'%7 5#u 6#"6ru6 ' "6 ,r/'%% * +r*#"6 "'5 5"+ 6'#"6 # ,%%'+ #" ' L'6#%ur'. T'C## S'r#/'% =r+ #" S' 9 /#r'+ b4 'C#'* S'/r'r4 "+ /!,r#%#"6 %'"#r **#/'r% 9% ,'r*r! ' *u"/#"% r'#"6 r"%*'r7'!,"'!'"7 ,r!#"7 "+ +',u#" ***#/'r% ,'r*r!'+ b4 ' E%b#%!'" =r+* G'r"!'" * I"+#S,'/# C!!#'' *S'/r'r#'% * G'r"!'" * I"+#7 b *5#/ r' /#r'+ b4 ' Cb#"' S'/r'r4.U"+'r Ar#/' -0? * ' C"%#u#"7Pr#!'" !4 % '"/ C## S'r#/'% A/%'#"6 u, C## S'r#/'% =r+ *r ' U"#"G'r"!'" 5#/ 5# ,'r*r! ' *u"/#"%b'#"6 ,'r*r!'+ ,r'%'" b4 'E%b#%!'" =r+ ,r'%#+'+ 'r b4 'Cb#"' S'/r'r4. T' C## S'r#/'% A/ !4% ,r#+' *r S,'/# C!!#'' *S'/r'r#'% ,r',r' ,"' * "!'% *r,,#"!'" *r ,%% * A++##" S'/r'r#'%"+ S'/r'r#'% G'r"!'" * I"+#. U"+'r' "'5 C## S'r#/'% A/7 Cb#"'M#"#%'rM#"#%'r * S' 5# #"+','"+'"/r6' #" G'r"!'" * I"+# !4 b' 6#'" #!' #!# //',%'"+ b/3 ,r,%% *r 'E%b#%!'" =r+ r'6r+#"6 ,%#"6 ***#/'r% 5# #% b%'r#"%. I" "4 ,r#/ur
/%'7 #* ' E%b#%!'" =r+ *'r 6##"6 '
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 13/47Page 13
1-
#'5% * ' M#"#%'r #" /r6' #% u!%/"%#+'r#" +'% " /"6' #% r#6#"r'/!!'"+#"7 ' Cb#"' S'/r'r4 !4
%'"+ ,r,%% * ' E%b#%!'" =r+ 5#b%'r#"% * ' M#"#%'r #" /r6' ru6' H!' M#"#%'r7 M'!b'r * ' ACC 'Pr#!' M#"#%'r7 5 '+% ' ACC *r *#"+'/#%#".
>.12 I"'r #7 C## S'r#/'% =r+ * S'% % ,'r*r! *u"/#"% * r'/!!'"+#"6**#/'r% * A I"+# S'r#/'Gru, A1 %'r#/' *
' S' *r r"%*'r +#**'r'" ,%% u"+'r' S' G'r"!'". I 5u+ b' 'B,'+#'"b'*r' " **#/'r #% %u6 b' r"%*'rr'+ #"' ,ub#/ #"'r'% 5'" ' % " /!,''+#% '"ur'7 " +!#"#%r#' #":u#r4 * %u!!r4 "ur' #% '+ %/'r#" #* 'r"%*'r #% u%#*#'+ % !'r * ,ub#/ ,#/4.
T' +!#"#%r#' #":u#r4 5# b' /"+u/'+ %'B,'+##u%4 % ,%%#b' b4 +'%#6"'+**#/'r "!#"'+ b4 ' C## S'r#/'% =r+. I",,r,r#' /%'%7 ' C## S'r#/'% =r+ !4% +#r'/ ' **#/'r ,r/''+ " '' "*u ,4 "+ 5"/'% # ' +!#"#%r#'#":u#r4 #% 'r "+ +'/#%#" #% 3'" r'6r+#"6#% r"%*'r. T' +'%#6"'+ **#/'r /"+u/' #":u#r4 5# b' r+#"r#4 ' R',r#"6O**#/'r * ' **#/'r %u6 b' r"%*'rr'+.
T' C## S'r#/'% =r+ " r'/'#, * ' r',r* #":u#r4 * ' +'%#6"'+ **#/'r % +#%'' C#'* M#"#%'r r'6r+#"6 u%#*#/#" *rr"%*'r * ' **#/'r #" ' ,ub#/ #"'r'%b'*r' #% "r! '"ur' #% 'r. Or+#"r#4 'C#'* M#"#%'r #% 'B,'/'+ 6r'' 5# 'r'/!!'"+#"% * ' C## S'r#/'% =r+ %r"%*'r * " **#/# #% ru#"' +!#"#%r#'!'r " 5#/ C## S'r#/'% =r+ !u%' +'/#%#' r'. =u #* ' C#'* M#"#%'r+'% " 6r'' 5# ' C## S'r#/'% =r+
"+ r+'r% r"%*'r * " **#/# b'*r' #%
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 14/47Page 14
1
'"ur' #% 'r7 ' !4 ' r'/r+ #" 5r##"6r'%"% *r %u/ r"%*'r. I* ' **#/# #%r"%*'rr'+ b'*r' #% '"ur' 5#u +':u'
u%#*#/#"7 ' 5# ' ' r#6 ,,r/ r'' !'!b'r C## S'r#/' O!bu+%!" %'u, *r ' ,ur,%'.
R'/!!'"+#" -8 I" ' ,r,%'+ C##S'r#/' 57 ' #6'% ,##/ 'B'/u#' %/"#"u' b' ' *#" ur#4 r+'rr"%*'r * "4 **#/'r b'*r' #% '"ur' #% 'r@bu ' 5# b' 'B,'/'+ 6#' +u'
/"%#+'r#" R',r * ' A+!#"#%r#'I":u#r4#'5% * ' C## S'r#/'=r+E%b#%!'" =r+ "+ r'/r+ r'%"%" ' "''+ *r ,r'!ur' r"%*'r * " **#/'r.I #% r'#'r'+ ' ,##/ 'B'/u#' %' ' *#" ur#4 r"%*'r " **#/'r "4 %6' #" ' ,ub#/ #"'r'%. A" **#/'r66r#''+ b4 r+'r * ,r'!ur' r"%*'r /"6#' ' !'r b'*r' r''9M'!b'rO!bu+%!"7 5 !47 5'r' %u#b'7 5r+!"'r4 /!,'"%#" ' 66r#''+**#/'r. T' /"%#u#" * ' O!bu+%!" 5#b' ' %!' % ' O!bu+%!" ,r,%'+ *r' D#%,u'% R'+r'%% Cu"/# % ,r .1?* #% R',r. T' Pr'%#+'"G'r"r %r'/'#' r',r% *r! ' O!bu+%!" "+ %4 " A""u R',r " %u/ r"%*'r% " 'b' * ' L'6#%ur'. T'r' %u+ b' %u#b' ,r#%#" #" ' 5 '"b' S'% +, # "+ !3' # ,,#/b' #" ' S'%5#u 6#"6 ru6 ' "6 ,r/'%% *+r*#"6 5 "+ 6' # ,%%'+ #" 'L'6#%ur'. ,r >.0- >.10)<
?. T' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#%%#" 5% %'
u, b4 ' Pr'%#+'" r'*'/#"6 ' R'%u#" +'+ -1%
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 15/47Page 15
1>
Au6u%7 200> ,%%'+ b4 ' G'r"!'" * I"+#. T'
C!!#%%#" 5% %' u, %u66'% !'%ur'% /#''
,r''!,#' r'%,"%#b'7 //u"b'7 %u%#"b' "+
'**'/#' +!#"#%r#" *r ' /u"r4 ''% * '
6'r"!'". T' '"ur' * ' C!!#'' 5% 'B'"+'+
*r! #!' #!' "+ ' C!!#'' %ub!#'+ #% r',r
#" ' 4'r 2008. O" ' :u'%#" * ' %'#"6 u, * '
#"+','"+'" CS=7 ' C!!#'' % !+' ' *5#"6
r'/!!'"+#"%
;?..1 T' C!!#%%#" %u66'%% "#"+','"+'" Aur#4 %u+ +' 5#!'r% * %%#6"!'" * +!#"%7 ,r',r#"6,"'% *r ,%#"6 * **#/'r% ' '' * SAG"+ b'7 *#B#"6 '"ur'% *r r#u% ,%%7+'/#+#"6 " ,%% 5#/ /u+ b' +'r#%'+ *r'r '"r4 '/. A% #% Aur#4 5u+ b','r*r!#"6 ' b'9!'"#"'+ /ru/# %3%7# 5u+ b' "'/'%%r4 '"%ur' #%#"+','"+'"/' b4 6##"6 # %ur4 b/3#"6"+ %#,u#"6 # %u+ b' '+'+ b4 "'!#"'" ,'r%" 5# 'B,'r#'"/' * ,ub#/ **#r% b' ,,#"'+ b4 ' Pr#!' M#"#%'r #"/"%u#" 5# ' L'+'r * ' O,,%##"#" ' L3 Sb. T' Aur#4 %u+ ' *u #!' M'!b'r9S'/r'r4 * ' r"3 *S'/r'r4 G'r"!'" * I"+#7 "+ ,'r%"%* '!#"'"/' #" ,ub#/ #*' "+ ,r*'%%#"% 5#/3"5'+6'+ /"r#bu#"% %/#'4 %M'!b'r% * ' Aur#4. T#% Aur#47 b'"!'+ % ' C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#47
%u+ b' /"%#u'+ u"+'r ' ,r,%'+ C##
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 16/47Page 16
1
S'r#/'% A/. A% ' /"%#u#" * ' C'"rC## S'r#/'% Aur#4 u"+'r "'5 5 !43' %!' #!'7 ' %#+ Aur#4 !4 b'
/"%#u'+7 #"##47 u"+'r 'B'/u#' r+'r%.<
10. Pr ?.8.' % r'*'r% ' /!,%##" * '
C!!#'' 5#/ r'+% % *5% 9
“?.8.'. A C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %u+b' /"%#u'+ u"+'r ' ,r,%'+ C##S'r#/'% =#. T' C'"r C## S'r#/'%
Aur#4 % b' *#'9!'!b'r b+4/"%#%#"6 * ' C#r,'r%" "+ *ur!'!b'r% (#"/u+#"6 ' !'!b'r9%'/r'r4).
T' Aur#4 %u+ ' *u #!' M'!b'r9S'/r'r4 * ' r"3 * S'/r'r4 G'r"!'" * I"+#. T' C#r,'r%" "+!'!b'r% * ' Aur#4 %u+ b' ,'r%"% *'!#"'"/' #" ,ub#/ #*' "+ ,r*'%%#"% 5#/3"5'+6'+ /"r#bu#"% %/#'4. T'C#r,'r%" "+ !'!b'r% * ' Aur#4% b' ,,#"'+ b4 ' Pr'%#+'" " 'r'/!!'"+#"% * C!!#'' /"%#%#"6 *' Pr#!' M#"#%'r "+ ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##" #" ' L3 Sb.
(EB,"#"9 W'r' ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##" #" ' L3 Sb % " b''"r'/6"#'+ % %u/7 ' L'+'r * ' %#"6'r6'% 6ru, #" ' O,,%##" #" ' L3Sb % b' +''!'+ b' ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##").<
11. T' S'/"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#%%#"
F#*''" R',r (A,r# 200?) % % !+' r#u%
%u66'%#"% #" r+'r ,r#+' '6#%#' b/3#"6
'%' !'%ur'%7 ' C!!#%%#" % r'/!!'"+'+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 17/47Page 17
1
'"/!'" * C## S'r#/'% L5 5#/ 5# /'r
,'r%""' +#"6 /## ,%% u"+'r ' U"#". T'
C!!#%%#" r'/!!'"+'+ *r ' /"%#u#" *
C'"r C## S'r#/' Aur#47 !"6 'r #"6%7 5#/
r'+% % *5%
;VIII. Constitution o th! C!ntra" Ci#i"
S!r#i$!s Authorit%
#. T' C'"r G'r"!'" %7 b4"#*#/#" #" ' O**#/# G''7/"%#u' b+4 b' 3"5" % 'C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 'B'r/#%'' ,5'r% /"*'rr'+ "7 "+ ,'r*r!' *u"/#"% %%#6"'+ #7 u"+'r #%A/.
##. T' C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %b' *#'9!'!b'r b+4 /"%#%#"6 * 'C#r,'r%" "+ *ur !'!b'r% (#"/u+#"6' !'!b'r9%'/r'r4). T' Aur#4%u+ ' *u #!' M'!b'r9 S'/r'r4* ' r"3 * S'/r'r4 G'r"!'" *I"+#. T' C#r,'r%" "+ !'!b'r% *' Aur#4 %u+ b' ,'r%"% *'!#"'"/' #" ,ub#/ #*' "+ ,r*'%%#"%5# /3"5'+6'+ /"r#bu#"% %/#'4. T' C#r,'r%" "+ !'!b'r% *' Aur#4 % b' ,,#"'+ b4 'Pr'%#+'" " ' r'/!!'"+#"% * C!!#'' /"%#%#"6 * ' Pr#!'M#"#%'r "+ ' L'+'r * ' O,,%##"#" ' L3 Sb.
(EB,"#"9 W'r' ' L'+'r * '
O,,%##" #" ' L3 Sb % " b''"
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 18/47Page 18
18
r'/6"#'+ % %u/7 ' L'+'r * ' %#"6'r6'% 6ru, #" ' ,,%##" #" ' L3Sb % b' +''!'+ b' ' L'+'r * '
O,,%##").
2..2.> Sub%':u'"47 #" #% R',r ";R'*urb#%#"6 * P'r%""' A+!#"#%r#"< ('
T'" R',r)7 ' C!!#%%#" %u66'%'+ +'#'+ ,r/'+ur' *r ,/'!'" * **#/'r% '!#++' "+ , !"6'!'" ''% #" '
U"#" G'r"!'". I /% *r ' /"%#u#"* C'"r C## S'r#/' Aur#4 b4 575#/ 5# b' " #"+','"+'" *#' !'!b'rb+4 /"%#%#"6 * ,'r%"% * '!#"'"/' #",ub#/ #*' "+ ,r*'%%#"% 5# /3"5'+6'+/"r#bu#"% S/#'4. T#% Aur#4 5# b''!,5'r'+ +' 5# r6' "u!b'r *#%%u'% /"/'r"#"6 /## %'r#/'% %u/ %%%#6"!'" * +!#" **#/'r%7 ,r',r#"6,"'% *r ,%#"6 ' ''% * J#"S'/r'r4 "+ b'7 *#B#"6 '"ur'% *r %'"#r%%#6"!'"% "+ %u/ 'r !'r% !4b' r'*'rr'+ # b4 ' U"#" G'r"!'". T'C!!#%%#" #% * ' #'5 'r' %u+ b' %#!#r C## S'r#/'% 5 "+ S' C##S'r#/'% Aur#4 *r '/ S'. T' !"+'"+ *u"/#"% * ' S' =+4 5u+ r6'4/#"/#+' 5# %' ,r'%/r#b'+ u"+'r ',r,%'+ U"#" C## S'r#/'% L5. T#%Aur#4 %u+ +' 5# #%%u'% *,,#"!'" "+ '"ur' * #6'r **#/#% * r"3% #" ' S' G'r"!'"% #"/u+#"6 'C#'* S'/r'r47 Pr#"/#, S'/r'r#'%7E"6#"''r9#"9C#'*% "+ ' Pr#"/#, C#'*C"%'rr * Fr'%%. H5''r7 # ' #!'' ,r,%'+ 5 #% '"/'+ "+ ' S' C##S'r#/' Aur#4 #% /"%#u'+7r'/!!'"+#"% !+' ,r 2.1.2.> b'
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 19/47Page 19
1?
!4 b' #!!'+#'4 +,'+ b4 ' S'G'r"!'"%.
2..2. R'/!!'"+#"%
) A*'r '"/!'" * ' S' C## S'r#/'%L5 " ' #"'% * ' ,r,%'+ U"#"'"/!'"7 ' ,r,%'+ S' C##S'r#/' Aur#4 %u+ +' 5# !'r%/"/'r"#"6 ,,#"!'" "+ '"ur' *%'"#r **#/'r% * r"3% #" ' S'G'r"!'"% (#"/u+#"6 ' C#'*
S'/r'r47 Pr#"/#, S'/r'r#'%7 E"6#"''r9#"9C#'*%7 'r A6'"/4 H'+% "+Pr#"/#, C#'* C"%'rr * Fr'%%).
b) T# ' #!' %u/ " Aur#4 #%/"%#u'+7 ' *5#"6 !'/"#%! !4b' +,'+ *r ,,#"!'" * ' C#'*S'/r'r4 "+ Pr#"/#, C"%'rr *Fr'%% #" ' S'%9
K T'r' %u+ b' /'6#u!% r'/!!'"+ ,"' * "!'% 'C#'* M#"#%'rCb#"' *r '%' 5,%%. Fr ' ,% * C#'*S'/r'r47 #% /'6#u! !4 /"%#%* () M#"#%'r "!#"'+ b4 'C#'* M#"#%'r7 (b) ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##" #" ' S' L'6#%#'A%%'!b4 "+ (/) ' #"/u!b'"C#'* S'/r'r4. Fr ' %''/#" ' ,% * Pr#"/#, C#'*C"%'rr * Fr'%% '/'6#u!% !4 /"%#% * () T'M#"#%'r I"9/r6' * Fr'%%7 (b) ''+'r * O,,%##" #" ' S'L'6#%#' A%%'!b4 "+ (/) 'C#'* S'/r'r4.
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 20/47Page 20
20
K T'r' %u+ b' *#B'+ '"ur' *'% 5 4'r% *r b '%',%%.
K T' %''/#" *r ' ,% * C#'*S'/r'r4 "+ Pr#"/#, C#'*C"%'rr * Fr'%% %u+ b'5#+'"'+ #"/u+' **#/'r% b' %,'/#*#'+ %'"#r#4 ('.6. -0 4'r%).A **#/'r% 5# '"#r#4 #6'r" ,r'%/r#b'+ #!# %u+ b''#6#b' b' ,r * ' ,"'.
/) A% r'6r+% ' ,,#"!'" "+ '"ur' *' D#r'/r G'"'r * P#/'7 'r'/!!'"+#"% !+' b4 'C!!#%%#" #" #% R',r " ;Pub#/Or+'r< ,r >.2.-. %u+ b'#!,'!'"'+.<
12. W' ' 'br'4 r'*'rr'+ ' R',r * '
H C!!#''7 R',r * ' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#'
C!!#%%#"7 20089200?7 5#/ #6#6'+ ' "'/'%%#4
* /r'#" * " #"+','"+'" CS= ' C'"r' % 5'
% ' S' ''.
B. FIED TENURE
1-. Vr#u% C!!#''% ' % r'/!!'"+'+ "+
#6#6'+ ' "'/'%%#4 * ,r#+#"6 *#B'+ '"ur' *r
/## %'r" % % '"%ur' %b##4 "+ '**#/#'"/4 *
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 21/47Page 21
21
+!#"#%r#". T' C'"r S**#"6 S/'!'7 1??7
#6#6'+ ' "'/'%%#4 * *#B'+ '"ur' ,r#+'
/'r#" +'6r'' * %b##4 ' +!#"#%r#".
R'*'r'"/' #" #% r'6r+ !4 b' !+' ,r% 1.017
1.027 1.0-7 1.12 "+ 1.1- "+ ' %!' r'
'Br/'+ 'r'#"b'5 *r '%4 r'*'r'"/'
;1.01 T' *#B'+ '"ur' * +',u#" *,%#"6 u"+'r ' C'"r G'r"!'" #% ''r * ' C'"r S**#"6 S/'!'. R#"b'5''" ' C'"r' "+ ' S'%7 C'"rM#"#%r#'% "+ ,r'" /+r'%7 "+ '+:ur'r%"+ ' *#'+7 ,r#+' /'r#" +'6r'' *,r6!#%! ,#/4 *r!u#" "+,r6r!!' #!,'!'"#" *r! ' C'"rM#"#%r#'%. =%'+ " ' 'B,'r#'"/' 6#"'+ %
*r7 ' ,'r#+% * '"ur' ' +#**'r'" ''%' b''" ,r'%/r#b'+ % u"+'r9
# U"+'r S'/r'r4 - 4'r%
## D',u4 S'/r'r4 4'r%
###. D#r'/r > 4'r%
#. J#" S'/r'r4 > 4'r%
1.02 A" **#/'r +#"6 ' ,% * J#"S'/r'r4 r ':u#'"7 5'" ,,#"'+ ,% u"+'r ' G'r"!'" * I"+# ' ''* A++##" S'/r'r47 5u+ ' '"ur' *- 4'r% *r! ' +' * ,,#"!'" %A++##" S'/r'r4 %ub'/ !#"#!u! * >4'r% "+ !B#!u! * 4'r% * /!b#"'+
'"ur' % J#" S'/r'r4.
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 22/47Page 22
22
A++##" S'/r'r4. W'r' " **#/'r r'!#"%" '' ('#'r *r! ' C'"r' r *r! #%C+r' ur#4 r b) " ' 'B,#r4 * #%
'"ur' % J#" S'/r'r4 # #% ,,#"!'" %A++##" S'/r'r47 ' '' ,'r#+ % b'/u"'+ % '"ur' +',u#". A++##"S'/r'r4 4'r%7 'B/', *r /%'% /'r'+u"+'r ' ,r'#u% '+#"6.
S'/r'r4 N *#B'+ '"ur'.
1.0- E'r4 **#/'r % r''r ' '"+ *
#% '"ur' % #"+#/'+ b' " ' 'B/+' * #% /!,'#"6 #% '"ur'. H' 5#75''r7 ' /#/' r''r #% /+r'" ' -1% M4 ,r'#u% ' +' * ''"+ * #% '"ur' #" /%' ,'r%" 6ru"+%%u/ % /#+r'"% '+u/#" '/.7 "'/'%%#'%u/ r''r%#". N 'B'"%#" *'r /!,'#"* ' *u '"ur' 5u+ b' 5'+.
1.12 () O**#/'r% * ' I"+#" Fr'#6" S'r#/'
,,#"'+ ,%% u"+'r ' C'"r S**#"6S/'!' 5u+ ' '"ur' * r'' 4'r%.
(b) T'4 % " "r!4 b' r'#''+7 'B/',5# ' ,,r * ' ,,#"!'"%C!!#'' * ' Cb#"' *r! C'"rS**#"6 S/'!' ,% b'*r' '#r '"ur'.
1.1- N 'r %#*% * **#/'r% *r! "'
M#"#%r4I)',. "'r 5# "r!4 b'/"%#+'r'+. H5''r7 #" ' /%' * Pr#'S'/r'r4 M#"#%'r% ' ,#/4 *5'+5u+ b' 9() T' r'+',4!'" * Pr#' S'/r'r4 #"' %!' M#"#%r4D',r!'" % D',u4S'/r'r4 r D#r'/r #% +#%/ur6'+.
(b) T' Pr#' S'/r'r4 ( M#"#%'r) 5
% b''" '!,"''+ *r +#"6 ,% * J#"
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 23/47Page 23
2-
S'/r'r4 ' C'"r' %u+ % " b'/"%#+'r'+ *r r'/#" #" ' %!'M#"#%r4D',. "+ ' **#/'r %u+ b'
,%'+ %!' 'r M#"#%r4D',.<
1. T' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#%%#" (10
R',r) % %,'3% * ' %!' #" ,r% 8.>.117 8.>.127
8.>.17 8. (')9 (6)7 ?.8(')9(6) "+ 1.>(VIII) "+ ' %!'
r' 'Br/'+ 'r'#"b'5 *r '%4 r'*'r'"/'
;8.>.11. T'r' ,,'r% b' u""#!#4 " ',#" # #% "'/'%%r4 6#' *#B'+ '"ur' /## %'r" #" #%'r ,%. I" */7 'Dr* Pub#/ S'r#/'% =#7 200 % %#,u'+#" Cu%' 1(')
;T' C'"r G'r"!'" % *#B !#"#!u! '"ur' *r /+r' ,%%7 5#/
!4 b' *#'+ " ' b%#% * !'r#7%u#b##4 "+ 'B,'r#'"/'.<
8.>.12 I" Cu%' 227 ' =# '"#"% ' C+r'C"r#"6 Aur##'%
;"#*4 5##" ,'r#+ * %#B !"% *r!' /!#"6 #" *r/' * #% A/7 "r!%"+ 6u#+'#"'% *r r"%*'r% "+ ,%#"6%
!#"#" /"#"u#4 "+ ,r'+#/b##4 #"/r''r +"/'!'" "+ /:u#%##" *"'/'%%r4 %3#% "+ 'B,'r#'"/'% % 5'% ,r!#" * 6+ 6'r""/'.
Tr"%*'r% b'*r' ' %,'/#*#'+ '"ur'%u+ b' *r #+ r'%"% b' r'/r+'+#" 5r##"6. Pr#+'+ ' "r!'"ur' * ,ub#/ %'r"% % " b''%% " 5 4'r%.<
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 24/47Page 24
2
8.>.1 T' C!!#%%#" #% * ' #'5 'C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 (+#%/u%%'+ #"+'# #" C,'r ?) %u+ b' /r6'+ 5# '
r'%,"%#b##4 * *#B#"6 ' '"ur' *r /##%'r#/' ,%% u"+'r ' U"#" G'r"!'". A,r'%'"7 ' *u"/#"% * ' Aur#4 r''"#%6'+ % +#%r4 u"+'r ' ,r#%#"% *' Dr* Pub#/ S'r#/'% =#7 200. T#% "''+% b' /"6'+7 "+ % *r % ' *#B#" *'"ur' #% /"/'r"'+7 # #% %u66'%'+ '+'/#%#" * ' Aur#4 %u+ b' b#"+#"6 "' G'r"!'". T' Aur#4 %u+ % b'
6#'" ' r'%,"%#b##4 !"#r ,%#"6%"+ ,/' b'*r' Pr#!'" ,'r#+#/'u#" * ' /u 'r6' '"ur' *r'/ ,% "+ *r ' C'"r G'r"!'" % 5'. E%b#%!'" * S' C## S'r#/'Aur##'% *r ' S'% 5# %#!#rr'%,"%#b###'% "''+% b' ur6'"4 3'" u,b4 ' S' G'r"!'"% 5'r' '"ur'% r'!u/ '%% %b'. T' +'#% * ' S' C##S'r#/'% Aur##'% 5u+ b' 'B!#"'+ b4 'C!!#%%#" #" #% R',r " S'A+!#"#%r#".
8. (') (6) P"a$!&!nt at Midd"!Mana'!&!nt L!#!"
&&.
'. T' C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %u+b' /r6'+ 5# ' r'%,"%#b##4 **#B#"6 '"ur' *r /## %'r#/' ,%##"%"+ #% +'/#%#" * ' Aur#4 %u+b' b#"+#"6 " G'r"!'".
*. O**#/'r% *r! ' r6"#'+ %'r#/'%%u+ " b' 6#'" ""9*#'+%%#6"!'"% #" ' *#r% 8910 4'r% * '#r/r''r.
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 25/47Page 25
2>
6. S' G'r"!'"% %u+ 3' %',% /"%#u' S' C## S'r#/'% Aur##'%" ' #"'% * ' C'"r C## S'r#/'%
Aur#4.
?.8 (') (6) P"a$!&!nt at To( Mana'!&!ntL!#!"
&&
'. A C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %u+ b'/"%#u'+ u"+'r ' ,r,%'+ C## S'r#/'%
=#. T' C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %b' *#'9!'!b'r b+4 /"%#%#"6 * 'C#r,'r%" "+ *ur !'!b'r% (#"/u+#"6 '!'!b'r9%'/r'r4). T' Aur#4 %u+ ' *u #!' M'!b'r9S'/r'r4 * ' r"3 *S'/r'r4 G'r"!'" * I"+#. T'C#r,'r%" "+ !'!b'r% * ' Aur#4%u+ b' ,'r%"% * '!#"'"/' #" ,ub#/ #*'"+ ,r*'%%#"% 5# /3"5'+6'+/"r#bu#"% %/#'4. T' C#r,'r%" "+!'!b'r% * ' Aur#4 % b' ,,#"'+b4 ' Pr'%#+'" " ' r'/!!'"+#"% * C!!#'' /"%#%#"6 * ' Pr#!' M#"#%'r "+' L'+'r * ' O,,%##" #" ' L3 Sb.
(EB,"#"9 W'r' ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##" #" ' L3 Sb % " b''"r'/6"#'+ % %u/7 ' L'+'r * ' %#"6'r6'% 6ru, #" ' O,,%##" #" ' L3Sb % b' +''!'+ b' ' L'+'r * 'O,,%##").*. T' C'"r C## S'r#/'% Aur#4 %u++' 5# !'r% * %%#6"!'" * +!#"% **#/'r%7 ,r',r#"6 ,"'% *r ,%#"6 * **#/'r% ' '' * J#" S'/r'r4 "+ b'7 *#B#"6'"ur'% *r %'"#r ,%%7 +'/#+#"6 " ,%%5#/ /u+ b' +'r#%'+ *r 'r '"r4 "+%u/ 'r !'r% !4 b' r'*'rr'+ #
b4 ' G'r"!'".
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 26/47Page 26
2
6. A %#!#r ,r/'+ur' %u+ b' +,'+ *r*##"6 u, /"/#'% SAG '' "+ #6'r #"
' /'"r ,#/' 6'"/#'%. Fr 'B!,'7 #" 'C'"r Pr9M##r4 Fr/'% ' %'"#r,%##"% %u+ b' ,'"'+ /!,'##"*r! **#/'r% * ' CPMF%7 IPS "+ ' Ar!'+Fr/'% (#"/u+#"6 %' /!,'#"6 '#r SrS'r#/' C!!#%%#"%). S#!#r4 *r '#"'#6'"/' 6'"/#'% **#/'r% *r! ' r!'+*r/'% % 5' % ' CPO% 5# 'B,'r#'"/' #"' *#'+ * #"'#6'"/' %u+ b' /"%#+'r'+
*r ,%#"6% #6'r ''% #" ' #"'#6'"/'6'"/#'%.
1.> R!$o&&!ndations
;A "'5 C## S'r#/'% =# !4 b' +r*'+. T'*5#"6 %#'" *'ur'% !4 b' #"/u+'+ #"' ,r,%'+ =#.
&&.
VIII. F#B#" * T'"ur'% A %'"#r ,%%%u+ ' %,'/#*#'+ '"ur'. T' %3 **#B#"6 '"ur'% *r r#u% ,%% !4 % b'%%#6"'+ #% #"+','"+'" 6'"/4 C'"rC## S'r#/'% Aur#4.<
1>. T' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#%%#" (1>
R',r)7 200? % %,'3% * ' %!' #" ,r% 2..1.2
"+ 2..2. "+ ' %!' #% 'Br/'+ b'5 *r r'+4
r'*'r'"/'9
;2..1.2 I" r+'r ,r#+' '6#%#' b/3#"6 '%' !'%ur'%7 ' C!!#%%#" %r'/!!'"+'+ '"/!'" * C## S'r#/'%
L5 5#/ 5# /'r ,'r%""' +#"6 /##
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 27/47Page 27
2
,%% u"+'r ' U"#". A% r'/!!'"+'+ ,r6r, 1.> * #% R',r7 ' ,r,%'+5 % ' *5#"6 %#'" *'ur'%
&..
). *i+ation o T!nur!. A %'"#r ,%%%u+ ' %,'/#*#'+ '"ur'. T' %3 **#B#"6 '"ur'% *r r#u% ,%% !4 % b'%%#6"'+ #% #"+','"+'" 6'"/4 C'"rC## S'r#/'% Aur#4<.
&..
-. *un$tions o th! C!ntra" Ci#i"S!r#i$!s Authorit%. T' C'"r Aur#4% +#%/r6' ' *5#"6 *u"/#"%
&..
#. F#B ' '"ur' *r ,%% ' S'"#rM"6'!'" L'' #" G'r"!'" * I"+#.
2..2. Fr ,,#"!'"% ' ,%% * 'C#'* S'/r'r4 "+ ' Pr#"/#, C"%'rr* Fr'%7 ' C!!#%%#" /!!u"#/'+ '*5#"6 #"'r#! %u66'%#"% 'G'r"!'" #" D'/'!b'r 2009
#) T'r' %u+ b' /'6#u! r'/!!'"+ ,"' * "!'% ' C#'*M#"#%'r Cb#"' *r '%' 5 ,%%. Fr ',% * C#'* S'/r'r47 #% /'6#u!% !4/"%#% *
() M#"#%'r "!#"'+ b4 ' C#'* M#"#%'r7
(b) ' L'+'r * ' O,,%##" #" ' S'L'6#%#' A%%'!b4 "+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 28/47Page 28
28
(/) ' #"/u!b'" C#'* S'/r'r4. Fr '%''/#" ' ,% * Pr#"/#, C#'*C"%'rr * Fr'%% ' /'6#u!% !4
/"%#% *
()T' M#"#%'r I"9/r6' * Fr'%%7
(b) ' '+'r * O,,%##" #" ' S'L'6#%#'
A%%'!b4 "+
(/) ' C#'* S'/r'r4.
##) T'r' %u+ b' *#B'+ '"ur' * 5 4'r% *rb '%' ,%%.
###) T' %''/#" *r ' ,% * C#'* S'/r'r4"+ Pr#"/#, C#'* C"%'rr * Fr'%% %u+ b'5#+'"'+ #"/u+' **#/'r% b' %,'/#*#'+%'"#r#4 ('.6. -0 4'r%). A **#/'r% 5# %'"#r#4#6'r " ,r'%/r#b'+ #!# %u+ b' '#6#b' b' ,r * ' ,"'.<
1. T' H C!!#'' R',r7 200 % #6#6% '
%!' % #% !#" R'/!!'"+#" N.-? 5#/ r'+% %
*5% 9
;(-?). T' ,r,%'+ /!,r''"%#' 5" ' C## S'r#/'% % #"/r,r'7 inter
alia, C+' * E#/% "+ %ur4 !#"#!u!'"ur' #" ,% " **#/'r. U"+'r ',r,%'+ 57 #* " **#/'r #% %u6 b'r"%*'rr'+ b'*r' #% '"ur'7 'r' 5u+ b'" 'B,'+##u% +!#"#%r#' #":u#r4 b4 +'%#6"'+ %'"#r **#/'r b' 'r!r3'+ *r#% ,ur,%'. T#% /" b' +#%,'"%'+ 5# #* 'r"%*'r #% " ,r!#"+',u#"*r'#6"
r#"#"6. I" 'r /%'%7 ' R',r *
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 29/47Page 29
2?
I":u#r4 5# ' #'5% * ' C## S'r#/'=r+E%b#%!'" =r+ 5u+ b' ,u u, ' C#'* M#"#%'r #* **#/'r * ' A I"+#
S'r#/'% S'r#/''r /## %'r#/'% 5r3 #" 'S'%7 r ' A,,#"!'"% C!!#'' * 'Cb#"' #* ' **#/'r% 5r3 u"+'r ' C'"rS**#"6 S/'!'. Fr ' **#/'r% * ' 'rC'"r S'r#/'% 5r3#"6 #"M#"#%r#'%D',r!'"% bu " u"+'r 'C'"r S**#"6 S/'!'7 ' "'5 5 5#,r'%/r#b' '"ur' 5# ,r#%#" *r+!#"#%r#' #":u#r4 b'*r' " **#/'r #%
%u6 b' r"%*'rr'+ 'B/', " %,'/#*#'+6ru"+%.<
C. RECORDING OF INSTRUCTIONS AND DIRECTIONS
1. P'##"'r% ' #6#6'+ ' %'r#u% ,r'+#/" "
5#/ ' /## %'r"% r' ,/'+ 5'" '4 r' %3'+
#!,'!'" 6'r"!'" +'/#%#"%7 " r +#r'/#"%7
%u66'%#"%7 #"%ru/#"% '/. Mu/ * ' +''r#r#"
* ' %"+r+% * ,rb#4 "+ //u"b##47 //r+#"6
' P'##"'r%7 /" b' r/'+ ,r/#/' * #%%u#"6 "+
/#"6 " 'rb #"%ru/#"% r r r+'r% 5#/ r' "
r'/r+'+. T#% #%%u' 5% ++r'%%'+ b4 ' S""!
C!!#'' 54 b/3 #" 1?2. Pr6r,% .20 "+ .21
+' 5# %' %,'/%7 5#/ r' 6#'" b'5 *r '%4
r'*'r'"/'
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 30/47Page 30
-0
;.20. W' ' r'+4 !'"#"'+ ''B#%'"/' * /"/!'" "+ u%.Ob#u%4 '%' + " #"/u+' 6'"u#"'
r',r'%'"#'% * /!!'r/# "+ #"+u%r#*#r!%. I" #% r'6r+ ur r'/!!'"+#"%r' 9
(#) N **#/# %u+ ' "4 +'#"6% 5# ,'r%" /#!#"6 / " b'* * bu%#"'%% r #"+u%r# u%' r "#"+##+u7 u"'%% ' #% ,r,'r4 //r'+#'+7"+ #% ,,r'+ b4 ' D',r!'"7 '/.
/"/'r"'+. Su/ ,r/'+ur' 5# 3'', u,'r%"% 5# u"%ur4 "'/'+'"% rr',u#". T'r' %u+7 * /ur%'7 b' "r'%r#/#" " ' ,r,r#'r r !"6'r'/. * ' *#r! r ' ,,#/" #!%'*,,r/#"6 ' ur##'%.
(##) E'" ' //r'+#'+ r',r'%'"#'%%u+ " b' 5'+ %'' **#/'r% b'5 %,'/#*#'+ '' ' '' b'#"6 %,'/#*#'+#" '/ r6"##" *'r 3#"6 #"/"%#+'r#" ' *u"/#"% * 'r6"##"%7 ' u!' "+ "ur' *' 5r3 b' '"+'+ 7 "+ '%ru/ur' * ' r6"##". H5''r7/r' %u+ b' 3'" #!# ,'r!#%%#b'/"/% ''% 5#/ ' /"/'% */rru,#" r' /"%#+'r'+ b' %!. T#%5u+ *'" !'" " /"/ 5u+b' ,'r!#'+ ' '' * %ubr+#"'**#/'r%.
(###) T'r' %u+ b' %!' %4%'! * 3'',#"6%!' %r * r'/r+ * #"'r#'5%6r"'+ //r'+#'+ r',r'%'"#'%.
(#) T'r' %u+ b' *#r4 %'"#r **#/'r+'%#6"'+ #" '/ D',r!'" 5#/
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 31/47Page 31
-1
" ,,#/" '/.7 !4 6 #* #% /%' #%b'#"6 u"r'%"b4 +'4'+.
I #% "'/'%%r4 ,r,'r ,r/'+ur' %u+ b'+'#%'+ #" /"%u#" 5# ' C'"r V#6#"/'C!!#%%#" *r //r'+##"6 "+ ,,r b4 '+',r!'". ='*r' 6r"#"6 ,,r '"'/'+'"% * ' ,'r%" ,r,%'+ b'//r'+#'+ %u+7 #* ,%%#b'7 b' 'r#*#'+. I" "4/%' " ,'r%" 5 #% " +'*#"#'4 '!,4'+ b4 "'%b#%'+ u"+'r3#"6 5 5# b' r'%,"%#b' *r#% /"/ "+ /#"% %u+ b' ,,r'+.
.21. I #% % +'%#rb' **#/'r% b'"6#"6 ,r'%/r#b'+ /'6r#'% 5 ' +' 5#'%' r',r'%'"#'% %u+ !#"#" r'6ur+#r4 * #"'r#'5% "+ +#%/u%%#"% 5# 'r'6#%'r'+ r',r'%'"#'% 5''r # 3'%,/' #" ' **#/' r !'. T' 6'"'r,r/#/' %u+ b' %u/ #"'r#'5% %u+b' #" ' **#/' "+ #* # 3'% ,/' !'7r'%"% %u+ b' r'/r+'+. A"4 bu%#"'%% r+#%/u%%#" 5#/ #% " % r'/r+'+ %u+ b'+''!'+ b' #rr'6ur /"+u/7 * 5#/%'r#u% "#/' %u+ b' 3'" b4 ' %u,'r#r%.
18. Fur'r7 5' % "#/' ' A I"+# S'r#/'%
(C"+u/) Ru'%7 1?87 5#/ % %'% '
+#r'/#"% * ' **#/#% %u,'r#r % r+#"r#4 b' #"
5r##"6. Ru' -(-) * ' b'9!'"#"'+ Ru'% r'+% %
*5% 9
-(-) (#) N !'!b'r * ' S'r#/' %7 #" ','r*r!"/' * #% **#/# +u#'%7 r #" ''B'r/#%' * ,5'r% /"*'rr'+ " #!7 /
'r5#%'
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 32/47Page 32
-2
" #" #% 5" b'% u+6!'" b' ru' "+/rr'/ 'B/', 5'" ' #% /#"6 u"+'r '+#r'/#" * #% **#/# %u,'r#r.
(##) T' +#r'/#" * ' **#/# %u,'r#r %r+#"r#4 b' #" 5r##"6. W'r' ' #%%u' * r+#r'/#" b'/!'% u"#+b'7 ' **#/#%u,'r#r % /"*#r! # #" 5r##"6 #!!'+#'4'r'*'r.
(###) A !'!b'r * ' S'r#/' 5 % r'/'#'+r +#r'/#" *r! #% **#/# %u,'r#r % %''3
/"*#r!#" * ' %!' #" 5r##"67 % 'r4 %,%%#b' "+ #" %u/ /%'7 # % b' ' +u4 *' **#/# %u,'r#r /"*#r! ' +#r'/#" #"5r##"6.
EB,"#" I A !'!b'r * ' S'r#/' 5b#u4 *#% ,'r*r! %3 %%#6"'+ #!5##" ' #!' %' *r ' ,ur,%' "+ 5# ':u#4 * ,'r*r!"/' 'B,'/'+ * #! % b'+''!'+ b' /3#"6 #" +'#" +u4 5##"' !'"#"6 * ' %ub9ru' (1)@
EB,"#" II N#"6 #" /u%' (#) * %ub9ru'(-) % b' /"%ru'+ % '!,5'r#"6 G'r"!'" %'r" '+' #% r'%,"%#b###'%b4 %''3#"6 #"%ru/#"% *r! r ,,r *7 %u,'r#r **#/'r r ur#4 5'" %u/#"%ru/#"% r' " "'/'%%r4 u"+'r ' %/'!'* +#%r#bu#" * ,5'r% "+ r'%,"%#b###'%.<
1?. W'7 #" #% r'%,'/7 ,#" u ' r'%,"%' *
/'r#" S'% "+ U"#" T'rr#r#'% #" ' !'r *
/r'#" * " #"+','"+'" CS=7 *#B'+ '"ur' * /##
%'r"% "+ r'/r+#"6 * +#r'/#"%7 r' "'#'r
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 33/47Page 33
--
/"%#%'" "r ,%##'. =u 6'"'r47 '4 '
5'/!'+ ' %u66'%#" *r *#B#" * '"ur' %ub'/
' r#+'r #" /'r#" 'B/',#" /#r/u!%"/'%7 '
S' G'r"!'"% %u+ ' ' ,5'r r"%*'r
,'r%" ,r'!ur'4 b'*r' /!,'#" * ' '"ur'. F'5
S'% ' 5'/!'+ ' %u66'%#" ''r4 C##
S'r" %u+ r'/r+ ' #"%ru/#"% "+ +#r'/#"%
r'/'#'+.
20. U"#" "+ ' S' G'r"!'"% ,,r''"+
/r'#" * " #"+','"+'" CS= r #"%#u#"
rr"6'!'" *r r'6u#"6 r"%*'r% "+ ,%#"6% *
**#/'r% 5u+ b' " #"ru%#" #" ' 'B'/u#' *u"/#"
* ' C'"r' "+ S' G'r"!'"% '+'+ b4 '
,##/ 'B'/u#'%7 5 r' +#r'/4 r'%,"%#b' '
,','. Fur'r7 '4 ' % 3'" u, %"+ '
%#+ rr"6'!'" 5u+ '+ +u #"' * /"r7
/r'#"6 /!,'B##'% #" !"6#"6 +!#"#%r#'
*u"/#"% "+ **'/#"6 '**#/#'"/4 * /## %'r"%. W#
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 34/47Page 34
-
r'6r+ *r':u'" r"%*'r% * **#/'r%7 '4 ' 3'"
u, ' %"+ 'r' #% r'+4 /'r /u ,#/4
'B/', #" /%'% * ,r!#"7 #" ' #"'r'% * 5r3 "+
+!#"#%r#' r'%"%7 r"%*'r "+ ,%#"6 5# b' +"'
"4 *'r /!,'#" * r'' 4'r% * '"ur'. F'5
S'% ' #%%u'+ +#r'/#"%7 6' 5r#'" +#r'/#"% #"
/%' * r +#r'/#"% * Su,'r#r O**#/'r% #" #"' 5#
Ru' -(-)(##)9(###) * A I"+# S'r#/'% (C"+u/) Ru'%7
1?8.
21. C,'r IV * ' C"%#u#" * I"+# +'% 5#
%'r#/'% u"+'r ' U"#" "+ ' S'%. Ar#/' -0?
+'% 5# ' r'/ru#!'" "+ /"+##"% * %'r#/' *
,'r%"% %'r#"6 ' U"#" r ' S'7 5#/ 'B,r'%%4
!+' %ub'/ ' 'r ,r#%#" * ' C"%#u#" *
I"+#7 I" 'r!% * Ar#/' -0? ,,r,r#' L'6#%ur'7
Pr#!'" r ' S' L'6#%ur' #% '!,5'r'+
'6#%'7 r'6u' ' r'/ru#!'" "+ /"+##"% *
%'r#/' * ,'r%"% ,,#"'+ ,ub#/ %'r#/'% "+ ,%
'! #" /""'/#" 5# ' **#r% * ' U"#" r * "4
S'. I" 'r!% * ' ,r#% Ar#/' -0?7 "u!b'r *
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 35/47Page 35
->
ru'% ' b''" !+' *r! #!' #!' b4 ' U"#"
"+ ' S' G'r"!'"% "+ '4 6'r" "+ r'6u'
' ,ub#/ %'r#/'% #" I"+#. Ar#/' -10 * '
C"%#u#" ,r#+'% *r !'!b'r% * ' /## %'r#/'%
* ' U"#" "+ A I"+# S'r#/'% b' '+ #" /## ,%
' ,'%ur' * ' Pr'%#+'" "+ !'!b'r% * '
/## %'r#/'% * ' S' ' ,'%ur' * ' G'r"r
* ' S'. Ar#/' -11 ,r#+'% /'r#" %*'6ur+%
r'6r+#"6 +#%!#%%7 r'! r r'+u/#" #" r"3 *
,'r%"% '!,4'+ #" /## /,/#4. Ar#/' -12 ,r#+'%
/"%#u#" * A I"+# S'r#/'%. Ar#/'% -18 --- +'
5# ' U"#" Pub#/ S'r#/' C!!#%%#" (UPSC) "+
S' Pub#/ S'r#/' C!!#%%#"% (PSC). Ar#/' -20
%#,u'% # % b' ' +u4 * ' U"#" "+ '
S' PSC% /"+u/ ' 'B!#"#"% *r ,,#"!'"
' %'r#/'% * ' U"#" "+ %'r#/'% * ' S'7
r'%,'/#'4.
22. UPSC r ' S' PSC% r' b' /"%u'+ #"
!'r% r'#"6 ' !'+ * r'/ru#!'" /##
%'r#/'% "+ " ' ,r#"/#,'% b' *5'+ #" !3#"6
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 36/47Page 36
-
,,#"!'"% /## %'r#/'% "+ ,%% "+ #" !3#"6
,r!#"% "+ r"%*'r% *r! "' %'r#/' "'r. O*
'7 ' UPSC% "+ PSC% r' b'#"6 +'"u+'+ * '#r
,5'r% * /"%u#" 5#' !3#"6 ,r!#"% "+
r"%*'r *r! "' %'r#/' "'r. Ar#/' -2- 4%
+5" # % b' ' +u4 * ' UPSC ,r'%'"
""u4 ' Pr'%#+'" r',r * ' 5r3 +"' b4 '
C!!#%%#" "+ " r'/'#, * %u/ r',r ' Pr'%#+'"
% /u%' /,4 'r'* 6''r 5# '
!'!r"+u!7 'B,#"#"6 % r'6r+ ' /%'%7 #* "47
5'r' +#/' * ' C!!#%%#" 5% " //','+7 '
r'%"% *r %u/ ""9//',"/'7 b' #+ b'*r' '
Hu%' * Pr#!'". S#!#r ,r#%#" % 'B#%% *r '
S' PSC%. Ar#/' -2-A ur#'% Pr#!'" %' u,
+!#"#%r#' r#bu"% r'6r+#"6 +#%,u'% 5# r'6r+
r'/ru#!'" "+ /"+##"% * %'r#/'7 ,,#"'+ ,ub#/
%'r#/'%. Pr#!'" #" 'B'r/#%' * #% ,5'r% u"+'r
Ar#/' -0? '"/'+ ' A I"+# S'r#/' A/7 1?>17 5#/
ur#'% U"#" G'r"!'" #" /"%u#" 5# '
S' G'r"!'"%7 !3' ru'% *r ' r'6u#"% *
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 37/47Page 37
-
/"+##"% * %'r#/' * ,'r%"% ,,#"'+ A I"+#
S'r#/'%.
2-. Pr V * ' C"%#u#" +'% 5# ' U"#".
Ar#/' >- %'% ' 'B'/u#' ,5'r * ' U"#"
% b' '%'+ #" ' Pr'%#+'" "+ % b' 'B'r/#%'+ b4
#! '#'r +#r'/4 r ru6 **#/'r% %ubr+#"' #!
#" //r+"/' 5# #% C"%#u#". Ar#/' 1> *
C,'r VI * ' C"%#u#" %'% ' 'B'/u#'
,5'r * ' S' % b' '%'+ 5# ' G'r"r "+
% b' 'B'r/#%b' b4 #! '#'r +#r'/4 r ru6
**#/'r% %ubr+#"' #! #" //r+"/' 5# '
C"%#u#". Ar#/' - * ' C"%#u#" %'%
%ub'/ ' ,r#%#"% * ' C"%#u#" 'B'/u#'
,5'r * ' U"#" % 'B'"+ !'r% 5# r'%,'/
5#/ Pr#!'" % ,5'r !3' 5% "+ '
'B'r/#%' * %u/ r#6%7 ur#4 "+ ur#%+#/#"7 %
'B'r/#%b' b4 ' G'r"!'" * I"+# b4 #ru' * "4
r'4 r "4 6r''!'". Ar#/' 1- * ' C"%#u#"
%'% 'r' % b' Cu"/# * M#"#%'r%7 ' C#'*
M#"#%'r % ' '+ #+ "+ +#/' ' G'r"r #"
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 38/47Page 38
-8
'B'r/#%' * #% *u"/#"%7 'B/', #" % *r % ' #% b4 r
u"+'r #% C"%#u#" r':u#r'+ 'B'r/#%' #% *u"/#"%
r "4 * '! 5# #% +#%/r'#".
2. T' b' r' ' /"%#u#" ,r#%#"% 5#/
6'"'r4 +' 5# ' ,5'r * ' 'B'/u#'. T'
,r#"/#,'% 6'r"#"6 ' r'% "+ r'%,"%#b###'% *
,##/ 'B'/u#' "+ /## %'r"%7 r' 'r'*r'7
/"%#u#"4 +'*#"'+ "+ % b%'+ " ' b%#% *
r#u% ru'% *r!'+ b4 ' Pr'%#+'" "+ G'r"r *r
' /"+u/ * bu%#"'%% #" ' G'r"!'". M#"#%'r% r'
r'%,"%#b' ' ,',' #" +'!/r/4 b'/u%' '4
r' ' ''/'+ r',r'%'"#'% * ' Pr#!'" % 5'
% ' G'"'r S' A%%'!b4. C## %'r"% ' b'
//u"b'7 * /ur%' '#r ,##/ 'B'/u#' bu
'4 ' *u"/#" u"+'r ' C"%#u#"7
/"%':u'"4 '4 r' % //u"b' ' ,',' *
#% /u"r4.
2>. Pr6r, 1>.1.- * ' r',r * ' 2"+
A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#'' (2008) r'+% %
*5%
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 39/47Page 39
-?
;A '4 5r3#"6 r'#"%#, b'5''"
M#"#%'r% "+ /## %'r"% #% /r##/ *r
6+ 6'r""/'. W#' ' ,r#"/#,'%6'r"#"6 ' r'% "+ r'%,"%#b###'% *
M#"#%'r% "+ /## %'r"% r' 5'
+'*#"'+ #" ,##/ 'r47 #" ' /u
5r3#"6 * #% r'#"%#, #% +##%#" *
r'%,"%#b##4 b'/!'% burr'+ 5# b
%#+'% *'" '"/r/#"6 u," ' 'r%%,'r' * r'%,"%#b##4. I" "4
+'!/r/47 M#"#%'r% r' r'%,"%#b'
' ,',' ru6 Pr#!'" "+
'r'*r' ' /## %'r"% ' b'
//u"b' ' M#"#%'r. H5''r7 "
#!,r# /## %'r#/' #% r'%,"%#b' "
"4 ' 6'r"!'" * ' +4 bu
' C"%#u#" * ' "+ 5#/ '4
' 3'" " * 44. A ' %!'
#!'7 #!,'!'"#"6 ' ,#/#'% * ' +u4
''/'+ 6'r"!'" #% /r' *u"/#" *
/## %'r"%. T #% 54 ' +##%#" *
r'%,"%#b##4 b'5''" ' /## %'r"%
"+ !#"#%'r% "''+% b' !r' /'r4
+'*#"'+. A *r!'5r3 #" 5#/
r'%,"%#b##4 "+ //u"b##4 #% 5'
+'*#"'+ 5u+ b' u%'*u.<
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 40/47Page 40
0
2. C## %'r"%7 % r'+4 #"+#/'+7 ' *u"/#"
#" //r+"/' 5# ' C"%#u#" "+ ' 5% !+' b4
' Pr#!'". I" ' ,r'%'" ,##/ %/'"r#7 ' r'
* /## %'r"% % b'/!' 'r4 /!,'B "+ "'ru%.
O*'" '4 ' 3' +'/#%#"% 5#/ 5# ' *r
r'/#"6 /"%':u'"/'% #" ' '/"!#/ "+
'/"6#/ *#'+%. T'#r +'/#%#"% !u% b' r"%,r'"
"+ !u% b' #" ,ub#/ #"'r'%. T'4 %u+ b' *u4
//u"b' ' /!!u"#4 '4 %'r'. M"4 * '
r'/!!'"+#"% !+' b4 ' H C!!#''7 r#u%
r',r% * ' 2"+ A+!#"#%r#' R'*r!% C!!#%%#"7
2008 "+ S""! C!!#'' R',r ' #69
#6'+ r#u% /u"' #" ' ,r'%'" %4%'! 5#/ /%
*r %'r#u% '"#" b4 ' ,##/ 'B'/u#' % 5' %
' 5 !3'r%.
2. W' *#"+ #7 5''r7 +#**#/u 6#' ,%##'
+#r'/#" /"%#u' " #"+','"+'" CS= ' C'"r'
"+ S' L''7 5#u 'B'/u#' /"r7 5#/ H
C!!#'' % r'/!!'"+'+ b' %ur4 #" "ur'7
7 /!,r#%#"6 * ,'r%"% *r! u%#+' '
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 41/47Page 41
1
G'r"!'". P'##"'r% ,/'+ /"%#+'rb' r'#"/' "
' u+6!'" * #% Cur #" Prakash Singh and
Others v. Union of India (200) 8 SCC 1 "+ ur6'+
%#!#r +#r'/#"% b' 6#'" #"%u'7 '% %!'
'B'"7 ' /## %'r"% *r! ,##/'B'/u#'
#"'r*'r'"/'. R'#r'+ ,'r%"%7 5%''r '!#"'" '4
!4 b'7 % " 6u#+' ' r"%*'r% "+ ,%#"6%7
+#%/#,#"r4 /#"7 %u%,'"%#"7 r'#"%'!'"7 '/. * /##
%'r"%7 u"'%% %u,,r'+ b4 5 '"/'+ b4 '
Pr#!'" r ' S' L'6#%ur'.
28. CS=7 /"%#%#"6 * #6 r"3#"6 #" %'r#/' **#/'r%7
5 r' 'B,'r% #" '#r r'%,'/#' *#'+%7 5# '
Cb#"' S'/r'r4 ' C'"r' "+ C#'* S'/r'r4
' S' ''7 /u+ b' b''r 'r"#' (# '
Pr#!'" '"/% 5)7 6u#+' "+ +#%' ' S'
G'r"!'" " %'r#/' !'r%7 '%,'/#4 "
r"%*'r%7 ,%#"6% "+ +#%/#,#"r4 /#"7 '/.7 u6
'#r #'5% % /u+ b' 'rru'+7 b4 ' ,##/
'B'/u#'7 bu b4 r'/r+#"6 r'%"%7 5#/ 5u+ '"%ur'
6+ 6'r""/'7 r"%,r'"/4 "+ //u"b##4 #"
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 42/47Page 42
2
6'r"!'" *u"/#"%. Pr#!'" /" % u"+'r
Ar#/' -0? * ' C"%#u#" '"/ C## S'r#/' A/7
%'#"6 u, CS=7 5#/ /" 6u#+' "+ +#/' ' ,##/
'B'/u#' r"%*'r "+ ,%#"6%7 +#%/#,#"r4 /#"7 '/.
CS= /"%#%#"6 * 'B,'r% #" r#u% *#'+% #3'
+!#"#%r#"7 !"6'!'"7 %/#'"/'7 '/"647 /u+
br#"6 #" !r' ,r*'%%#"#%!7 'B,'r#%' "+ '**#/#'"/4 #"
6'r"!'" *u"/#"#"6.
2?. W'7 'r'*r'7 +#r'/ ' C'"r'7 S' G'r"!'"%
"+ ' U"#" T'rr#r#'% /"%#u' %u/ =r+% 5#
#6 r"3#"6 %'r#"6 **#/'r%7 5 r' %,'/##%% #" '#r
r'%,'/#' *#'+%7 5##" ,'r#+ * r'' !"%7 #* "
r'+4 /"%#u'+7 # ' Pr#!'" br#"6% #" ,r,'r
'6#%#" #" %'#"6 u, CS=.
-0. W' "#/'7 ,r'%'" ' /## %'r"% r' "
#"6 %b##4 * '"ur'7 ,r#/ur4 #" ' S'
G'r"!'"% 5'r' r"%*'r% "+ ,%#"6% r' !+'
*r':u'"47 ' 5#!% "+ *"/#'% * ' 'B'/u#'
'+ *r ,##/ "+ 'r /"%#+'r#"% "+ " #"
,ub#/ #"'r'%. T' "'/'%%#4 * !#"#!u! '"ur' %
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 43/47Page 43
-
b''" '"+r%'+ "+ #!,'!'"'+ b4 ' U"#"
G'r"!'". I" */7 5' "#/'7 !% 1- S'% '
//','+ ' "'/'%%#4 * !#"#!u! '"ur' *r /##
%'r"%. F#B'+ !#"#!u! '"ur' 5u+ " "4 '"b'
' /## %'r"% /#'' '#r ,r*'%%#" r6'%7
bu % ', '! *u"/#" % '**'/#' #"%ru!'"% *
,ub#/ ,#/4. R',''+ %u**#"6r"%*'r * ' **#/'r% #%
+'''r#u% 6+ 6'r""/'. M#"#!u! %%ur'+
%'r#/' '"ur' '"%ur'% '**#/#'" %'r#/' +'#'r4 "+ %
#"/r'%'+ '**#/#'"/4. T'4 /" % ,r#r##' r#u%
%/# "+ '/"!#/ !'%ur'% #"'"+'+ #!,'!'" *r
' ,r "+ !r6#"#'+ %'/#"% * ' %/#'4.
-1. W'7 'r'*r'7 +#r'/ ' U"#" S' G'r"!'"%
"+ U"#" T'rr#r#'% #%%u' ,,r,r#' +#r'/#"%
%'/ur' ,r#+#"6 * !#"#!u! '"ur' * %'r#/' r#u%
/## %'r"%7 5##" ,'r#+ * r'' !"%.
-2. W' ' 'B'"%#'4 r'*'rr'+ '
r'/!!'"+#"% * ' H C!!#''7 200 "+
S""! C!!#'' R',r "+ %' r',r% '
#6#6'+ ' "'/'%%#4 * r'/r+#"6 #"%ru/#"% "+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 44/47Page 44
+#r'/#"% b4 ,ub#/ %'r"%. W' "#/' !u/ * '
+''r#r#" * ' %"+r+% * ,rb#4 "+
//u"b##4 5# ' /## %'r"% #% +u' ' ,##/
#"*u'"/' r ,'r%"% ,ur,r#"6 r',r'%'" %' 5
r' #" ur#4. S""! C!!#'' " Pr''"#" *
Crru,#"7 1?2 % r'/!!'"+'+ 'r' %u+ b'
%4%'! * 3'',#"6 %!' %r * r'/r+% #" %u/
%#u#"%. Ru' -(-)(###) * ' A I"+# S'r#/' Ru'%
%,'/#*#/4 r':u#r'% r+'r% *r! %u,'r#r **#/'r%
% r+#"r#4 b' #" 5r##"6. W'r' #" 'B/',#"
/#r/u!%"/'%7 /#" % b' 3'" " ' b%#% * r
+#r'/#"%7 # #% !"+r4 *r ' **#/'r %u,'r#r
/"*#r! ' %!' #" 5r##"6. T' /## %'r"7 #" ur"7
5 % r'/'#'+ %u/ #"*r!#"7 #% r':u#r'+ %''3
/"*#r!#" * ' +#r'/#"% #" 5r##"6 % 'r4 %
,%%#b' "+ # #% ' +u4 * ' **#/'r %u,'r#r
/"*#r! ' +#r'/#" #" 5r##"6.
--. W' r' * ' #'5 ' /## %'r"% /""
*u"/#" " ' b%#% * 'rb r r #"%ru/#"%7 r+'r%7
%u66'%#"%7 ,r,%%7 '/. "+ '4 !u% % b'
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 45/47Page 45
>
,r'/'+ 6#"% 5r"6*u "+ rb#rr4 ,r'%%ur'
'B'r'+ b4 ' +!#"#%r#' %u,'r#r%7 ,##/
'B'/u#'7 bu%#"'%% "+ 'r '%'+ #"'r'%%. Fur'r7
/## %'r"% % % " ' "4 '%'+ #"'r'%%.
R'%u"47 'r' !u% b' %!' r'/r+% +'!"%r'
5 ' /## %'r" % /'+7 #* ' +'/#%#" #% " #%7
bu #* ' #% /#"6 " ' r +#r'/#"%7 #"%ru/#"%7 '
%u+ r'/r+ %u/ +#r'/#"% #" ' *#'. I* ' /##
%'r" #% /#"6 " r +#r'/#"% r +#/#" *
"4b+47 ' 5# b' 3#"6 r#%37 b'/u%' ' /"" 'r
3' u, ' %"+7 ' +'/#%#" 5% #" */ " #% 5".
R'/r+#"6 * #"%ru/#"%7 +#r'/#"% #%7 'r'*r'7
"'/'%%r4 *r *#B#"6 r'%,"%#b##4 "+ '"%ur'
//u"b##4 #" ' *u"/#"#"6 * /## %'r"% "+
u,+ #"%#u#" #"'6r#4.
RT A$t and Ci#i" S!r#ants
-. D'!/r/4 r':u#r'% " #"*r!'+ /##'"r4 "+
r"%,r'"/4 * #"*r!#". R#6 I"*r!#" A/7
200> (RTI A/) r'/6"#'% ' r#6 * ' /##'"
%'/ur' //'%% #"*r!#" u"+'r ' /"r * ,ub#/
ur#47 #" r+'r ,r!' r"%,r'"/4 "+
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 46/47Page 46
//u"b##4 #" ' 5r3#"6 * ''r4 ,ub#/ ur#4.
S'/#" - * ' A/ /"*'r% r#6 #"*r!#"
/##'"% "+ /rr'%,"+#"6 b#6#" u"+'r S'/#"
" ''r4 ,ub#/ ur#4 !#"#" ' r'/r+% %
' #"*r!#" %u6 *r /" b' ,r#+'+. Or "+
'rb #"%ru/#"%7 #* " r'/r+'+7 /u+ " b'
,r#+'+. =4 /#"6 " r +#r'/#"%7 " r'/r+#"6 '
%!'7 ' r#6% 6ur"''+ ' /##'"% u"+'r '
R#6 I"*r!#" A/7 /u+ b' +'*''+. T' ,r/#/'
* 6##"6 r +#r'/#"%#"%ru/#"% b4 ' +!#"#%r#'
%u,'r#r%7 ,##/ 'B'/u#' '/. 5u+ +'*' ' b'/
"+ ,ur,%' * RTI A/ "+ 5u+ 6#' r! *r
*r##%! "+ /rru,#".
->. W'7 'r'*r'7 +#r'/ ' S' G'r"!'"% "+
U"#" T'rr#r#'% #%%u' +#r'/#"% #3' Ru' -(-) * '
A I"+# S'r#/'% (C"+u/) Ru'%7 1?87 #" '#r
r'%,'/#' S'% "+ U"#" T'rr#r#'% 5#/ 5# b'
/rr#'+ u 5##" r'' !"% *r! +4.
-. T' Wr# P'##"% r'7 //r+#"647 +#%,%'+ * 5#
' b' +#r'/#"%.
7/27/2019 TSR Subramanian v. Union of India Judgment
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tsr-subramanian-v-union-of-india-judgment 47/47
...&&&&&&&&&&&..J. (.S. R+3r#%"")
&&&&&&&&&&&&..J.(P#"3# C"+r G%')
N'5 D'#7
O/b'r -17 201-.