Y1 – 20%Y2 – 40%Y3 – 60%

Y1 – 80%Y2 – 60%Y3 – 40%

Intervention Period 6-12 Months

Payment by Results Criteria

1. ASB

2. Not in School

3. Out of Work Benefits

4. Local Filter

Initial select 1 and 2 then 3 and 4

1/3 per year

Deduct 1/6 for deadweight

Self Declaration

Annual Cohort Refresh

PBRAttachment

Maximum Claim Per Family £4,000

Estimated Support Cost £10,000

Education― Each child fewer 3 fixed exclusions― Less 15% absence (unauthorised); 12 months

1

Crime― 60% reduction ASB in family; 6 months― 33% reduction under 18 offending; 6 months

2

Progress to Work (£100)― Single adult volunteered work programme― Attached to ESF provision (6 months)

3

In Employment (£800)― One adult in continued employment in last

6 months

4

Family Cohort Selection

(£700)

Less restriction than initially expected

More scope for flexibility

Unlikely to claim back attachment fee if unsuccessful

Attachment fee not linked to a specific family

High weighting on employment

Encourage maximum number in year one

Encourage selection of larger cohort up front

Disincentive support for larger families

Self declaration

No excessive monitoring system