transformers technologies
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
1/86
Development of New Concepts &
Technologies - Design of Transformersfor Reliable Operation
M. Gopal RaoM.E; F.I.E
Former Director (Transmission),
A.P.TRANSCO, Hyderabad
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
2/86
A transformer is a static device used for transferringpower from one circuit to another without change infrequency.
Operates on the principle of mutual induction betweentwo ckts linked by a common magnetic field.
EMF induced in a winding is proportional to the fluxdensity in the core, cross section of the core, frequencyand no. of turns in the winding.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
3/86
H.V WindingL.V Winding
Core
Fundamental equation of transformer
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
4/86
A transformer basically consists of:
Magnetic Circuit comprising Limbs, yokes, clamping structures
Electrical circuit comprising primary, secondary windings
Insulation comprising of transformer oil and solid insulation viz.paper, pressboard, wood etc. and bracing devices
Main tank housing all the equipment
Radiators, conservator tank
On or Off load tap changer
Vent pipe, Bucholtz relay, Thermometers
Fans, Cooling pumps connected piping
Terminals i.e. connecting leads from windings to bushing withsupporting arrangements
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
5/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
6/86
Design Parameters
Voltage Ratio No. of phases
Flux density Rated capacity
Current density Insulation& cooling medium
Insulation levels Tap changerVector group Cooling arrangement
Percentage Impedance Oil preservation system
Short circuit withstand
capacity Operating conditions
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
7/86
Features of Power Transformers
Single Phase
Three phase
Star or Delta connected Primary
Star or Delta connected Secondary With or without Tertiary winding
Provided with Off-circuit tap switch or On-load TapChanger for voltage regulation
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
8/86
Codes and Standards
Codes or Regulations are mandatory requirementsstipulated to ensure the safety of the product during testingand service.
Standards are the basis of agreement and can be used forlimited scope or even restricted. Standards also promoteinterchangeability. Standards exist for material, product,process, testing, calibration etc.
Specifications are based on mandatory requirements of thepurchaser and agreed requirements of the standard.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
9/86
OPERATING CONDITIONS
The environment in which a transformer works and the
quality in design and construction play a role on its
performance. A transformer working under normal operating
conditions, in all probability, gives satisfactory performance
throughout its lifeNORMALOPERATING CONDITIONS:
1. Rated voltage and rated current with permissible margins.
2. Temperatures of oil and windings not exceeding the
prescribed values.3. Availability of auxiliary and control supply and proper
functioning of accessories and protective devices.
4. Free from external faults such as line breakdowns and
equipment breakdowns.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
10/86
User should specify the conditions under which transformer is expected
to work viz. quality and nature of load temperature limit, voltageconditions, short circuit withstand capacity considering present and
expected fault levels.
Parameters specific to locations are to be evaluated and specified to
assess the operating requirement.
Manufacturers should ensure that factory tests as required under
standards and the user specifications are done to verify the quality and
ability of the transformer to withstand all service stresses during life timeof the transformer.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
11/86
Insulation
Major Insulation: Oil and Paper or cellulose material.
Paper and pressboard insulation immersed in oil and subjected to
temperature for longer periods, lose mechanical strength. Dielectric
strength remains until paper is charred, when free carbon becomes
conducting or too brittle to withstand mechanical shocks. De-
polymerization of insulation takes place when deterioration starts.
Ageing of tr. depends on the dielectric performance of the insulation
system.
Higher the temperature the faster is insulation deterioration.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
12/86
Transformer operates at below normal temperatureLoss of life of
insulation is less than normal.
Operating temp. is greater than normalloss of life is higher than
normal.
Transformer may be safely operated for a time at above normal
temperature provided the loss of insulation life during this period isadequately compensated by operating for a sufficiently long time at
temperatures below normal.
Between 80 to 140 deg. C, the rate of loss of life due to ageing ofinsulation is doubled for every 6degrees c rise in temperature.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
13/86
Proper upkeep of solid and liquid insulation to their specified levels with
marginal and permissible variations ensure longevity. This is possible byproper operation such as maintaining the load current and voltage and oil
and winding temperatures at their rated levels and not exceeding these
levels.
Paper or oil dielectric have varying degree of sensitivity to degradation
upon overloading, ingress of moisture, improper handling and storage
affecting life. It is necessary that moisture ingress into oil is prevented by
suitable oil preservation system.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
14/86
Normally flux density is chosen near knee point of magnetization curve
leaving sufficient margin to take care of voltage and frequency variations.
CRGO steel with silicon content of approx. 3% is used for magneticcircuit. Characteristics of good core are :
1. Max. magnetic induction to obtain a high induction amplitude in an
alternating field.
2. Minimum specific core loss and low excitation current
3. Low magnetostriction for low noise level
4. Good mechanical processing properties.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
15/86
Magnetostriction is change in configuration ofa magnetizable body in a magnetic field whichleads to periodical changes in the length of thebody in an alternating magnetic field.
Due to magnetostriction of laminations in analternating field core vibrates generating noisein the core.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
16/86
Current density is an important parameter to design the section of the
conductor for a specified temperature rise, rated capacity and short
circuit withstand capacity of the transformer.
Different types of windings :
Distributed crossover winding
Spiral windingHelical winding
Continuous disc winding
Interleaved disc winding
Shielded layer winding
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
17/86
CHARACTERISTICS OF TRANSFORMER OIL:
A. PHYSICAL
Appearance
The oil shall be clear, transparent and free from suspended
matter
If color of oil is
a) Light - indicates degree of refining
b) Cloudy or foggy - Presence of moisture
c) Greenish tinge - Presence of copper salts
d) Acid smell - Presence of volatile acid. Can causecorrosion
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
18/86
Density: At 27deg. c is 0.89gm/cu.cm. This ensures that
water in the form of ice present in oil remains at the bottom
and does not float up to a temp. of about
10 deg. c.
Viscosity: Is a measure of oil resistance to continuous flow
without the effect of external forces. Oil must be mobile in
transformers to take away heat. Viscosity shall be as low as
possible at low temperatures. Maximum value at 27deg.cshall be 27 cst
Flashpoint: is the temperature at which oil gives so much
vapor, which when mixed with air forms an ignitable mixtureand gives a momentary flash on application of a flame.
Minimum flash point of a good oil shall be 140 deg. C.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
19/86
Pour point
is the temperature at which oil will just flow under prescribed
conditions. If oil becomes too viscous or solidifies it will hinderthe formation of convection currents, thus cooling ofequipment will be affected.
Maximum pour point shall be -9 deg. C
Interfacial Tension
Is the measure of resultant molecular attractive force betweenunlike molecules like water and oil at the interface. Presence ofsoluble impurities decrease molecular attractive force between
oil and water. This gives an indication of degree of sludging ofoil.
Minimum value 40 dynes/M or 0.04 N/M
.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
20/86
CHEMICAL
Neutralization Number
Is a measure of organic and inorganic acids present in the oil.Expressed as mg. of KOH required to neutralize the totalacids in one gm. Of oil.
Limits for fresh oil - 0.03 mg KOH/gm - maximum
Limits for used oil - 0.05 mg KOH/gm - maximum
It leads to formation of sludge, metal surface corrosion andlowering of dielectric strength.
Corrosive SulphurIt indicates the presence sulphur, sulphur compounds, whichare corrosive in nature and corrode the copper surface.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
21/86
Oxidation Stability
This is measured by ageing the oil by simulating actualservice condition of a transformer. Covers the evaluation
of acid and sludge forming tendency of new mineral oils.For used oil, should be minimum to minimize electricalconduction and corrosion
Water Content: Due tomoisture entry into oil.
a) By accidental leakage
b) Breathing actionc) During oil filling or topping up
d) By chemical reaction
In unused oil - Maximum 30 ppm
Oil in transformer 145 KV & above - Maximum 15 ppmOil in transformer below 145 KV - Maximum 25 ppm
It reduces electrical strength and promotes degradation of
oil as well as paper.
ELECTRICAL
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
22/86
ELECTRICAL
Electric Strength
Is the voltage at which arc discharge occurs between two
electrodes when oil is subjected to an electric field under
prescribed conditions.
New oil unfiltered - 30 KV minimum (rms)
New oil filtered - 60 KV minimum (rms)
Resistivity
It is numerically equal to the resistance between opposite facesof a centimeter cube of oil. Insulation resistance of thewindings of transformer is dependant on the resistivity of oil.A low value indicates the presence of moisture andconducting contaminants.
Values for a new transformer are(12)
At 27 deg. c 500x 10 ohm.cm
(12)
At 90 deg. c 30x 10 ohm.cm
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
23/86
Dielectric Dissipation Factor (Tan Delta & Loss Tangent)
Is measure of dielectric losses in oil & hence the amount of heat
energy dissipated.
It gives an indication as to the quality of insulation. A high value
indicates presence of contaminants or deterioration products
such as water, oxidation products, soluble varnishes, and resins.
1) Tan delta at 90 for unused oil - maximum 0.2
2) Tan delta at 90 oil before charging transformer -
maximum 0.005 (1/2%)
Low value of tan delta indicates low losses
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
24/86
Vector Group and Polarity
When induced voltages of pri . and sec. windings are in same direction, polarity
of the two windings is same. This is called subtractive polarity. When theinduced EMFs are in opposite direction , the polarity is called additive.
Pri. and sec. windings on any one limb have induced emfs that are in time phase.
Different combinations of internal connections and connections to terminals
produce different phase divergence of sec. voltage.
Vector group or connection symbol of a transformer denotes the method of
connection of pri. and sec. windings and the phase angle divergence of sec. with
respect to primary.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
25/86
Vector Groups
1
3
4
U
VW
u
w
v
u
w
v
1 & 3 YNd1
2 & 4
YNd11
U
VW
2
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
26/86
U
VW
u
v
w
u
v
w
1
2
3
4
Vector Groups
U
VW
1 & 3 Dyn11
2 & 4 Dyn5
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
27/86
Vector Group Test
A
BC
a
b
c
A
BC
a
bc
DY 11
VAb = VAc
VBb = VBc
VCb > VCc
Aa = 0
Ab = bc = ca
Bb = Cc
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
28/86
Tap changer
Device for regulating the voltage of transformer.
Off circuit tap changer : Tap changing is effected when tr. is off. These
are cheaper. They are used where frequency of tap changing is very less.
On load tap changer : Here tap changing is effected without interruptingload. On load tap changer normally consists of transition resistors which
bridge the circuit during tap changing operation.
Two types of OLTCs :
Single compartment typeIn this type selection of taps and switchingare carried out on the same contacts.
Double compartment typeIn this tap selection is done separately and
switching is done in a separate diverter switch.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
29/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
30/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
31/86
Externally mounted OLTC/1
Requirements for a tap changer
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
32/86
Requirements for a tap changer
Percentage variation required for each tap
No. of taps and step voltage
Maximum through currentInsulation level to ground and between various contacts.
No of steps and basic connections
Temporary overloads and short circuit strength
Automatic voltage regulating relays are used for automatic control of bus
bar voltage.
Output of voltage transformer connected to controlled voltage side of the
tr. is used to energize AVR relay. When voltage deviation exceeds a
preset limit, a control signal to raise or lower tap operation is given. A
time delay unit is connected in the circuit to prevent unnecessary
operation or hunting of tap changer during transient voltage change.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
33/86
Types of Tap Changers
Based on function
Constant Flux Voltage Variation (CFVV)
Variable Flux Voltage Variation (VFVV)
Combination of above both Based on method of tap change
Linear
Reversing
CoarseFine Bridging
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
34/86
Tap Changer Location
Neutral End Middle of winding Line End
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
35/86
Linear Reversing Coarse
Fine
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
36/86
Basic conditions of operation
Load current must not be interrupted during tap
change operation.
Tap change must occur without short-circuiting the tap
winding directly. Positive change of tap position.
It means make-before-break mechanism to beused. This calls for a transition impedance.
Also the mechanism should be fast acting typespring loaded.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
37/86
General Design considerations
Capable to normal load/overloads on transformer.
Maximum system voltage
Step voltage & no. of steps
Test voltage to earth and across tapping range
Maximum surge voltage to earth and across range.
Maximum test voltages between phases (whereapplicable)
Current ratingnormal and overload
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
38/86
Parts of Tap Changer
Selector switch
Tap selection takes place in this switch
Diverter Switch
Makebefore-break mechanism with transitionimpedance. Arcing takes place and hence housed ina separate compartment.
Surge relay
Conservator with oil level gauge.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
39/86
Transition Impedance
Reactor type
Resistor type
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
40/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
41/86
P i i l f T h ti
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
42/86
R2R1
75
3
1
8
6
4
2
N
Principle of Tap changer operation
M2 T2 T1 M1
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
43/86
M2 T2 T1 M1 M2 T2 T1 M1 M2 T2 T1 M1
M2 T2 T1 M1 M2 T2 T1 M1 M2 T2 T1 M1
1 2 3
4 5 6
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
44/86
Parts of Tap Changer
Motor drive mechanism
Should rotate in both the directions
Step-by-step operation
Tap change in progress indication
Tap change complete indication
Sequence contact
Remote Tap position control & indication
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
45/86
Cooling Arrangement
Controlling the temperature inside the tr. is necessary to reduce thermal
degradation of insulation to ensure longer life. Heat generated in the tr. istransmitted to atmosphere through oil.
Different types of cooling:
ONAN typeOil natural and air natural. Hot oil is circulated by natural
means dissipating heat to atmosphere by natural means.ONAF typeOil natural, air forced. Here air is blown on to the cooling
surfaces. Forced air takes away heat at a faster rate.
OFAF typeOil forced, air forced. If the oil is force circulated within the
tr. and radiator by means of an oil pump, in addition to forced air, still
better rate of heat dissipation is achieved over ONAF
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
46/86
OFWF typeOil forced, water forced. Here water is employed for
cooling oil instead of air. Ambient temp. of water is less than atmosphericair. Hence better rate of cooling is obtained. In this type oil to water heat
exchangers are employed. Differential pressure between oil and water is
maintained. Oil is circulated at a higher pressure.
ODAF/ODWF typeOil directed, air/water forced. If the oil is directed
to flow past the windings, large quantities of heat can be taken away by
oil. Cool oil is directed to flow through the windings in predetermined
paths. Oil is circulated by a forced oil system like oil pumps. This ensures
faster rate of heat transfer.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
47/86
Oil Preservation System: Oil readily absorbs moisture. Presenceof moisture reduces dielectric strength of oil. Different methods are
available to reduce contamination of oil with moisture.
1. Silica gel Breather: It is connected to the conservator tank. It consists
of a cartridge packed with silica gel dessicant and a small cup containing
oil. Air is drawn into the conservator thro. oil cup and breather where
most of the moisture is absorbed.
2. Bellows and Diaphragm sealed conservators: A bellow type barrier or
a diaphragm type barrier is fitted in the conservator. Air entering the
conservator tank pushes the diaphragm downwards. As oil expands the
diaphragm is pushed upwards. Position of diaphragm is indicated by oillevel indicator. Diaphragm acts as a barrier.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
48/86
3. Gas sealed Conservators: In this method a cushion of an inert gas like
Nitrogen is provided over oil surface in the conservator. Gas pressure is
always maintained higher than atmospheric pressure. Nitrogen gas
pressure inside the conservator is regulated by nitrogen cylinder andpressure reducing valve which admit Nitrogen to the conservator when
the pressure falls. Excessive pressure developed inside the conservator is
relieved through a relief valve.
4. Refrigeration Breathers: An air dryer is fitted to the conservator. Air
breathed thro. the unit is dried in passing down a duct cooled by a series
of thermoelectric modules based on Peltier effect. Top and bottom ends
of the duct are terminated in the expansion space above oil level in the
conservator and air is continuously circulated thro. the duct bythermosyphon forces.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
49/86
Short circuit withstand Capacity:
Effects of short circuit: Energy in the system gets released in
the form of heavy flow of current when fault occurs.
Every fault fed by the transformer stresses the windings. The
stress developed in the winding is related to the intensity of
fault.
Each fault causes sharp rise in temperature and producesmechanical forces in the winding.
These forces act in the axial and radial directions of the
winding, and cause compressive or tensile stresses on the
winding and tend to deform it.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
50/86
RADIAL FORCES: ARE DUE TO FLUX IN THE SPACE
BETWEEN COILS. TEND TO BURST COILS AND
CRUSH ON THE CORE.
STRENGTHENING OF WINDING
AXIAL FORCES: ARE DUE TO RADIAL COMPONENT
OF FLUX WHICH CROSSES THE WINDING AT THE
ENDS AND GIVES RISE TO AXIAL COMPRESSIVE
FORCE TENDING TO SQUEEZE THE WINDING IN
MIDDLE.
PROPER DRYING, COMPRESSION AND CLAMPING
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
51/86
THERMAL EFFECT: RAPID RISE OF TEMPERATURE
CAUSES
i) MECHANICAL WEAKENING OF INSULATION DUE
TO THERMAL AGEINGLONG TERM EFFECT.
ii) DECOMPOSITION OF INSULATION TO PRODUCE
GASESSHORT TERM EFFECT.
iii) CONDUCTOR ANNEALINGBECOMES BRITTLE
& CRACKS WILL BE FORMED.
LIMIT OF MAX. AVERAGE TEMPERATURE AFTER
SHORT CIRCUIT IS 2500C FOR OIL IMMERSED
TRANSFORMER USING COPPER WINDING.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
52/86
Design Basis
Life-time cost of transformer
= Initial cost of transformer
+
Operational cost for its life period
This is called the
Capitalized cost of transformer.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
53/86
Design Basis -Capitalization
Rationalized CBIP Capitalization Formula:Capitalized Cost = Initial Cost (IC) + Capitalized { No-
load Loss (Wn) + Load Loss (Wl) + Auxiliary Losses (Wa) }
Capitalized cost = IC + Xn.Wn +Xl.Wl +
Xa.Wa
Factors affecting Xn; Xl and & Xa
Rate of Interest
Rate of Electrical Energy
Life of Transformer
Design Basis
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
54/86
Design Basis
The design of a transformer aims at achievinglowest capitalized cost.
Low No-load Loss means higher magneticmaterial cost and vice-versa
Low Load Loss means higher copper (material)
cost and vice-versa.
Several iterations are made to optimize the totalcost before freezing the design and drawings aremade.
Extensive use of CAD programs is needed forfinalizing design.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
55/86
Design Principles - Core
Higher the number of steps in cross section, better is spaceutilization and smaller is the core diameter.
90 to 95 % utilization factor is optimal.
Core area (A) is determined by the Flux Density (B) whichin turn depends on many factors - like loss capitalization
and overall design economics.
As the no load losses attract very high capitalization,
attempts are continuously made to reduce them.
D i P i i l C
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
56/86
Design Principles - Core
Improved manufacturing techniques likecore building with 2-lamination packets, step-lapjoints, v-notched laminations,bolt-less cores are used.
Hi-core steels like M0H, ZDKH, etc are availablein which the specific core losses are lower thannormal grades.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
57/86
A A
View A-A
Conventional Step lap
D i P i i l
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
58/86
Design Principles
Windings- L.V winding
L.V Windings in Transformers are either Spiral OR layer wound for low current ratings
Helical Wound with radial cooling ductsfor higher ratings.
Disc type wound
Distributed Cross-over (Run-over) coils
The conductor used is paper insulated rectangularcopper (PICC)
For higher currents, transposed conductors are used,to uniformly distribute the current across the cross
section of the wire of coil.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
59/86
Spiral/Layer type Winding
Mandrel/Press-board cylinder
Cooling Duct
Conductor Layer 1
Conductor
Layer 2
Conductor Layer 3
Design Principles- L.V winding
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
60/86
Design Principles L.V winding
Helical Coil (Single layer) Helical coil (Double Layer)
Start Finish
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
61/86
Transposed Conductors
Transposed conductors (CTC) are used to improve current distribution in the
cross section of the winding wire.
Individual cable can be coated with epoxy so that the cured and finished
conductor is mechanically stronger and withstand short circuit forces better.
Design Principles H V Winding
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
62/86
Design Principles H.V Winding
HV winding invariably uses PICC orCTC.
Type of winding used is
- Layer winding or
- Disc winding up to 132 kV and/or- Interleaved winding or
- Rib shielded winding
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
63/86
Temporary Over-voltages Switching Over-voltages Over-voltages due to lightning.
Power Systems Over voltages
POWER SYSTEM OVER VOLTAGES
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
64/86
Temporary Over-Voltages
Typically due to faults < 1.2 pu
ms to tens of second or even minutes
Not dangerous to insulation
S it hi O V lt
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
65/86
Switching Over-Voltages
Due to system switching operations
1.5 pu 5 pu depends on system voltage
mostly damped asymmetric sinusoids
front time of first peak tens of s to a few ms.
decides external insulation in EHV/UHV systems
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
66/86
Over Voltages due to Lightning
Due to direct or indirect lightning strokes.
known to contribute to 50% of system outages in EHV& UHV systems
few hundred kV to several tens of MV.
Few kA to 200 kA
very short duration : time to front : 1 to few tens of s
time to tail : few tens to hundreds of s.
Decides line insulation (BIL)
Severely influences Transformer insulation.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
67/86
Cg
Cs= K Cg/Cs
Design Principles
Impulse Voltage Distribution
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
68/86
Design Principles
Impulse Voltage Distribution
= 0
= 1 0
=5
X
V
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
69/86
Disc Type Winding
Paper Insulated Conductor
Press-board Cylinder
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
70/86
V
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
71/86
Impulse Voltage
Distribution
1. Plain Disc Winding
2. Rib Shield Winding
3. I nter-leaved Disc Winding
Number of discs from line end
O
L
T
AG
E
G
R
A
D
I
E
N
T
P
u
D i P i i l T ti Wi di
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
72/86
Design Principles Tertiary Winding
In Star-Star Connected Transformers and Auto-
transformers, Tertiary Winding is used-
- to stabilize phase to phase voltages in case of
unbalanced load
- Suppressing third harmonic currents in earthed neutral
- reducing zero sequence reactance
- for supplying auxiliary load or for connecting
capacitors.
D i P i i l T ti Wi di
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
73/86
Design Principles Tertiary Winding
Tertiary is required to be designed for a power rating equal toone-third the rated power, it increases the cost of thetransformer by 10- 12 percent.
Tertiary winding is known to fail due to transferred surges andShort circuits
Present practice is to do away with tertiary up to 100 MVA for 3
phase 3 limbed core transformers.
CASE STUDY OF FAILED 100 MVA
220/132 KV AUTO TRANSFORMERS
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
74/86
220/132 KV AUTO TRANSFORMERSTRANSFORMER NO. 1.- DATE OF FAILURE 11.05.1992
OBSERVATIONS: BURNING AND TWISTING OF TURNS INTHE TERTIARY WINDINGS (V&W PHASES) NEAR THE
TOP END.
FAILURE APPEARS TO BE MAINLY MECHANICAL.
TYPE OF TERTIARY WINDING : SPIRAL WITHOUT ANY
INTENTIONAL COOLING. THE AXIAL ASYMMETRY IN
THE ASSEMBLY OF WINDINGS IS OBSERVED, AXIAL
COMPRESSIVE FORCE IN TERTIARY IS WORKED OUT
TO BE 133% i.e. HIGHER BY 33%.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
75/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
76/86
REASONS FOR FAILURE:
TERTIARY WINDING USED FOR STABILIZING
PURPOSE FAILURE ACOMPANIED BY EXTERNAL
SINGLE LINE TO GROUND FAULT (132 KV LINE
CONDUCTOR SNAPPING).
DUE TO HIGH CIRCULATING CURRENTS WHEN
TRANSFORMER FEEDS UNBALANCED SYSTEM
(TRACTION, REROLLING, MILLS).
TEMPERATURE RISE LEADS TO INSULATIONFAILURE.
INCREASED SHORT CIRCUIT FORCES ON THE
WINDING.
THE RATING OF TERTIARY WINDING AND THE
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
77/86
THE RATING OF TERTIARY WINDING AND THE
IMPEDANCES BETWEEN HV TO TERTIARY AND IV TO
TERTIARY IN RESPECT OF TRANSFORMERS WITH
LOADED TERTIARY WINDING AND WITH STABILIZINGTERTIARY WINDING (NOT INTENDED FOR LOADING).
TYPE OF %IMPEDANCE BETWEEN
TERTIARYHV TO IV TO TRANSF.
TERTIARY TERTIARY RATING
LOADED 57 TO 70.5 41 TO 65.5 15MVA
TERTIARY
UNLOADED 28 TO 37 17 TO 22 13 TO 15
TERTIARY MVA
It is observed that failure of transformers particularly with tertiary
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
78/86
p y y
windings, in no. of cases occurred, where system impedance is low and
the fault level is high.
Impedances between pri. To tertiary and sec. to tertiary is observed to be
low causing excessive stresses in the tertiary winding leading to its
failure.
It is therefore felt necessary to strengthen the tertiary winding andincrease the leakage reactance between tertiary to other windings to bear
the stresses developed under faults.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
79/86
ADDITIONAL DESIGN CONSIDERATION FOR
TERTIARY WINDING
1. RAISING THE %IMPEDANCE BETWEEN HV TO
TERTIARY & IV TO TERTIARY TO 35% & 25%
RESPECTIVELYWITHONLYPOSITIVETOLERANCE
OF 15%.
2. INCREASING THE RATING OF TERTIARY
WINDING TO 1/3 CAPACITY OF THE
TRANSFORMER.
3. TO PROVIDE INTENTIONAL COOLING FOR THE
TERTIARY WINDING FOR FASTER AND LARGER
DISSIPATION OF HEAT.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
80/86
Design Process
Design should meet
Requirements of customer specification
Relevant national or international standards
Statutory and regulatory requirements
Manufacturers Plant Standards
Optimized design
O ti i ti
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
81/86
Optimization
Objective of Optimization
To arrive at a design that yields minimum capitalized
cost.
It is a function of the following:
Core diameter
Core height
Flux Density
Current Density
COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN-
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
82/86
PURPOSE OF IT
Improve productivity of design personnel
Reduce delivery cycle
Better analysis and arriving at a most optimum design
To solve electro-static, electro-magnetic problems and toprovide a robust structural and thermal design.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
83/86
More precise calculations
Tailor made designs
No standard ratings specified above 1 MVA
Change of specification parameter
Relative change of material cost
Ongoing development of technology
Poor quality results in failures.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
84/86
q y
Types of failures
Infant failures: Early life failures are the result oflatent defects.
- Latent defects are abnormalities that cause failure,depending on degree of abnormality and amount ofapplied stress.
- Delivered defects are those that escape test /inspection within the factory
- They are directly proportional to total defects inthe entire processes.
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
85/86
-
8/11/2019 Transformers Technologies
86/86