traditional dried fruits: valuable tools to meet dietary ......research center and u.s. department...
TRANSCRIPT
TraditionalDriedFruits:ValuableToolstoMeetDietaryRecommendationsforFruitIntake
AriannaCarughi
PURPOSE
Itisthepositionofthisgroupthattraditionaldriedfruitsshouldbeincludedtogetherwithfreshfruits in dietary recommendations for fruit and vegetable intake around the world.Epidemiological studies have shown a consistent relationship between a diet rich in fruit andvegetablesandalowerriskformanychronicdiseasesincludingcancer,heartdiseaseandstroke,obesity and type 2 diabetes. The strength of the association between fruit and vegetableconsumptionandhealthhasledorganizationsaroundtheworldtorecommendthatpopulationsincrease their daily fruit and vegetable intake. Despite campaigns and educational efforts, asignificantgapstillremainsbetweentherecommendedamountoffruitsandvegetablesandthequantities actually consumed by populations around theworld. Traditional dried fruits provideessential nutrients, such as fiber and potassium, and an array of health protective bioactivecompounds.Theyaredevoidoffat,verylowinsodiumandhavenoaddedsugars.Becausetheyare naturally resistant to spoilage, easy to store and transport, available year round, readilyincorporated into other foods, and relatively low in cost, dried fruits represent an importantmeanstoincreaseoverallconsumptionoffruit,tobridgethegapbetweenrecommendedintakeoffruitsandtheamountpopulationsactuallyconsume.
2
UygunAksoyDepartmentofHorticultureEgeUniversityIzmir,Turkey
AriannaCarughiSun‐MaidGrowersofCalifornia&CaliforniaDriedFruitCoalitionSacramento,California
JamesAndersonMedicineandClinicalNutritionUniversityofKentuckyLexington,Kentucky
MaryJoFeeneyCaliforniaDriedPlumBoardLosAltos,California
DanGallaherDepartmentofFoodScienceandNutrition,CollegeofFood,Agricultural&NaturalResourceSciences,UniversityofMinnesota,St.Paul
AndrianaKalioraDepartmentofScience&Dietetics–NutritionHarokopioUniversityAthens,Greece
VaiosKarathanosDepartmentofScience&Dietetics–NutritionHarokopioUniversityAthens,Greece
Shin‐ichiKayanoDepartmentofHealthandNutrition,FacultyofHealthScienceKioUniversityNara,Japan
JimPainterSchoolofFamilyandConsumerSciencesEasternIllinoisUniversityCharleston,Illinois
RonPriorDepartmentofFoodScienceUniversityofArkansasFayetteville,Arkansas
3
PraveenVayallilDepartmentofPathologyUniversityofAlabamaatBirminghamBirmingham,Alabama
GaryWilliamsonDepartmentFoodScience&NutritionUniversityofLeedsLeeds,UnitedKingdom
TedWilsonDepartmentofBiologyWinonaStateUniversityWinona,Minnesota
TraditionalDriedFruits:ValuableToolstoMeetDietaryRecommendationsforFruitIntake
Itisthepositionofthisgroupthattraditionaldriedfruitsshouldbeincluded
togetherwithfreshfruitsindietaryrecommendationsforfruitandvegetableintake
aroundtheworld.Epidemiologicalstudieshaveshownaconsistentrelationshipbetweena
dietrichinfruitandvegetablesandalowerriskformanychronicdiseasesincluding
cancer,123heartdisease45andstroke,6obesityandtype2diabetes.78Thestrengthofthe
associationbetweenfruitandvegetableconsumptionandhealthhasledorganizations
aroundtheworldtorecommendthatpopulationsincreasetheirdailyfruitandvegetable
intake.9101112Despitecampaignsandeducationalefforts,asignificantgapstillremains
betweentherecommendedamountoffruitsandvegetablesandthequantitiesactually
consumedbypopulationsaroundtheworld.Traditionaldriedfruitsprovideessential
nutrients,suchasfiberandthemineralspotassiumandcalcium,andanarrayofhealth
protectivebioactivecompounds.Theyaredevoidoffat,verylowinsodiumandhaveno
addedsugars.Becausetheyarenaturallyresistanttospoilage,easytostoreandtransport,
lowincarbonoffset,availableyearround,readilyincorporatedintootherfoods,and
relativelylowincost,13driedfruitsrepresentanimportantmeanstoincreaseoverall
consumptionoffruit,tobridgethegapbetweenrecommendedintakeoffruitsandthe
amountpopulationsactuallyconsume.
I.DefinitionofTraditionalDriedFruits
Thecategoryof“traditionaldriedfruits”comprisesthosewherealargeportionoftheir
originalwatercontenthasbeenremoved,eithernaturallythroughsundrying(e.g.raisins
andfigs)orthroughtheuseofspecializeddryersordehydrators(e.g.driedplums).It
includesdriedapricots,peachesandotherdriedtreefruitstreatedwithsulfurdioxide
beforedryingtoinhibitbrowning.Italsoincludesdates,whichareconsideredtobedried
fruits,eventhoughmostvarietiesarenotdriedbutare"fresh"fruitwithnaturallylow
moisturecontent.Traditionaldriedfruitsdonotincludedriedfruitsinfusedwithsugar
solutionsorfruitjuiceconcentrates(e.g.driedblueberries,cranberriesorcherries),candied
driedfruits(e.g.driedpineapples)ordehydratedfruitswithverylowmoisturecontent.
5
Becausetraditionaldriedfruitsareminimallyprocessed,theyretainmostofthenutritional
valueoftheirfreshcounterparts.Atthesametimenothingisaddedtothefruitsthatalters
theirnutritionalvalue.
II.ScientificSupportforRecommendationstoIncreaseIntakeofFruitsandVegetables
Therationalethatsupportsrecommendationsforpopulationstoeatmorefruitsand
vegetablesisthree‐fold:First,highfruitandvegetableintakeisassociatedwithareduced
riskofmanychronicdiseases.Second,mostfruitsandvegetablesprovidemanyessential
nutrients,includingpotassium,dietaryfiber,calcium,magnesiumandvitaminsA,CandK.
Fruitsaremajorsourcesofpotassium,fiber,andvitaminC.Ofthese,fiberandpotassium
areofparticularpublichealthconcernbecauseworldpopulationsunderconsumethem.
Third,mostfruitsandvegetablesareverylowinsodium,whenpreparedwithoutaddedfats
orsugars,arerelativelylowincaloriesandthefiber/sugarratioishigh.
III.FruitandVegetableIntakeandChronicDisease
TheWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)estimatedin2000that2.7milliondeaths(4.9%)
and26.7milliondisabilityadjustedlifeyearswereattributabletolowfruitandvegetable
intakeglobally.14Further,31%ofischemicheartdisease,20%esophagealcancer,19%of
ischemicstroke,19%ofgastriccancerand12%oflungcancergloballycouldbeprevented
byincreasingdietaryintakeoffruitsandvegetablestotheminimumrecommended
establishedbytheWHO(400gramsoffruitsandvegetablesadayortheequivalentoffive
servingsof80gramseach).15AmongEuropeannations(EU‐15),theestimatednumberof
deathsthatcouldbepreventedrangefrom44,000iffruitandvegetableintakewereto
reach400gperdayand121,000ifconsumptionweretoreach600gperday.16Although
lowfruitandvegetableintakeisonlyoneofthemanyriskfactorsforcardiovasculardisease
andcancer,itsimpactissignificant.Forexample,findingsfromtheWHOGlobalBurdenof
DiseaseStudyshowthat28%oftheburdenofischemicheartdiseaseindevelopedregions
oftheworld(includingEurope,NorthAmerica,AustraliaandJapan)couldbeattributedtoa
lackoffruitandvegetablesinthediet.17Thiscompareswith58%fromhighbloodpressure,
63%fromhighcholesterol,33%fromoverweight,22%fromphysicalinactivity,22%from
tobaccoand0.2%fromalcoholintake.Usingindustrydrydownratiosforfruit(fresh:
6
dried)iaservingofdriedfruitwouldmakeasignificantcontributiontowardsmeetingthe
weightrecommendationsforfruitandvegetableintake.
Figure1.Prevalenceoflowfruitandvegetableconsumptionformenandwomencombined(pooledsampleof52countries)byage
strata1
1WorldHealthSurvey2002–2003,AdaptedfromHallJN,MooreS,Harper,SBandLynchJW.Globalvariabilityinfruitandvegetableconsumption.AmJPreventiveMed.2009;36(5):402‐409.
Despitethesestatisticsasignificantgapstillremainsbetweenfruitandvegetable
recommendationsandthequantitiespopulationsactuallyconsume.Arecentanalysisof
datafrom52countriestakingpartintheWorldHealthSurvey(2002‐2003)showedthat
78%ofrespondentsatelessthantheminimumrecommendedfivedailyservingsoffruits
andvegetables.18Thehighpercentageoflowfruitandvegetableintakewasseenamongthe
richandthepoor(73.4%and81.6%fortopandbottomincomequintiles);amongthe
iIndustrydrydownratiosvaryconsiderabledependingonthetypeoffruitanddryingmethod.Forexample,itisapproximately1:2.5‐3.5forMediterraneanapricots;1:3forCaliforniaplums,1:3.3forCalimyrnafigsand1:4‐4.25forraisins.Usinga40gservingsizethisisequivalentto100,120and170goffreshfruit.
7
youngandtheold(Figure1);inurbanandruralareas,andforbothmenandwomen.ii
SimilardataareavailablefromAustralia,19SouthAfrica,20England21andtheUnitedStates.22
Lookingatfruitintakealone,intheUSmorethan75%ofadultmenandwomenfailtoreach
theminimumrecommendleveloffruitperday,intakesbeinglowamongallagegroups
(Table1).23Infact,accordingtotherecentlyreleasedDietaryGuidelinesforAmericans
(DGA),fruitsaresecondonlytowholegrainsinrepresentingthelargestgapbetweenusual
intakeandtherecommendedgoal(Figure2).23
Table1.MedianintakesoffruitintheUnitedStatescomparedtorecommendedintakebyage‐sex1
MedianIntakes
(cupequivalent)
MinimumRecommendedIntake
(cupequivalent)AdultMen 0.9 2
AdultWomen 0.8 1.5
AdolescentBoys 0.8 2
AdolescentGirls 0.6 1.5
Boys9–13 0.8 1.5
Girls9–13 0.8 1.5
1DatatakenfromtheReportoftheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericansCommitteeontheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericanshttp://www.cnpp.usda.gov/dgas2010‐dgacreport.htm
IV.Essentialnutrientsprovidedbydriedfruits
a.Potassium
Driedfruitsareaparticularlysignificantsourceofdietarypotassium.Onaperserving
basis(40gorabout1/4cup)driedfruitsrankamongthetoppotassiumsourcesindietsiiLowfruitandvegetableconsumptiondefinedasfewerthanfiveservingsorlessthan400goffruitandvegetablesdaily.
8
aroundtheworld.Ascanbeseenfromthechartsbelow(Figure3),driedfruitscompare
positivelyinpotassiumcontenttothemostcommonfreshfruitoptions.
Itisnowrecognizedthatincreasingdietarypotassiumintakecanlowerblood
pressure.24Ahigherintakeofpotassiumalsoattenuatestheadverseeffectofsodiumon
bloodpressure.Potassiumintakeisverylowamongmostchildrenandadultsandsohas
Figure2.Usualintakeofspecificfoodsaspercentofgoalinthe
UnitedStates1
1AdatedfromtheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericans2010.Basedondatafrom:USDA,AgriculturalResearchCenterandU.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,CenterforDiseaseControlandPrevention.WhatWeEatinAmerica,NHANES2001‐2004and2005–2006.
becomeasubstantialpublichealthconcernforhealthagenciesaroundtheworld.2526The
InstituteofMedicine(IOM)hassettheAdequateIntake(AI)forpotassiumforadultsat
4,700milligramsperday.Usingthisvalueasareference,potassiumintakeacrosscountries
inNorthAmerica,Europe,AsiaandOceania(Figure4)isconsistentlylow.25Meanpotassium
intakerangefrom1,700mgperday(China)to3,700mgperday(Finland,theNetherlands,
9
Poland).IntheUSusualpotassiumintakeofthepopulationis56%oftherecommended
goal.
Figure3.Potassiumcontentofthe10mostcommonlyconsumedfreshfruits1andofdriedfuits2
1Weightofasfollows:apple132g;banana101g;grapes151g;mango165g;orange131g;peach130g;pear148g;pineapple165g;strawberries152g;watermelon150g.Thesevaluesareforstandardservings.WHOrecommendsaminimumof5servingsoffruitandvegetableperdayor400g.2DatafromtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture/AgriculturalResearchServiceNutrientDataLaboratoryhttp://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search/
10
Figure4.Currentpotassiumintakesanddifferencesfromtherecommended(AdequateIntakeof4,700mg,IOM)levelfordifferent
countries1
1DataforJapantakenfromtheNIPPONDATA80/90ResearchGroup.Turinetal.JEpidemiol2010;20(3S):S567‐S575.DatafortheothercountriesfromvanMierloAJetal.ArchIntMed2010;170(16):1501‐1502
b.Fiber
Driedfruitsareanimportantsourceofdietaryfiber.Onaperservingbasis(40gor
about1/4cup)driedfruitsdeliverover9%ofthedailyvalueoffiber,dependingonthe
fruit.27Ascanbeseenfromthechartsbelow(Figure5),driedfruitscomparefavorablyin
theirfibercontenttocommonfreshfruitoptions.
11
Figure5.Fibercontentof10mostcommonlyconsumed
freshfruits1anddriedfuits2
1Weightofservingsasfollows:apple132g;banana101g;grapes151g;mango165g;orange131g;peach130g;pear148g;pineapple165g;strawberries152g;watermelon150g.2DatafromtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture/AgriculturalResearchServiceNutrientDataLaboratoryhttp://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search/
Highfiberdietsarerecommendedtoreducetheriskofdevelopingvariousconditions
includingconstipation,type2diabetes,andobesity,andlaterinlife,diverticulitis,colorectal
cancerandcardiovasculardisease.Healthagenciesaroundtheworldrecommendthat
peopleconsumehighfiberdiets.USfiberrecommendationsforbothchildrenandadultsare
14gramsoffiberforevery1,000caloriesoffoodconsumedeachday.Thisbecomes25to
38gramsoffiberperdaydependingonageandgender.However,inadequateintakeof
12
fiberiswidespread.IntheUSlessthan3%ofAmericansolderthan1yearexceedtheAI(38
grams)forfiberconsumption.
c.Otheressentialvitaminsandminerals
Becausedifferenttypesoffruitdifferwidelyintheirnutrientcontent,nationaland
internationalagenciesrecommendchoosingfromavariety.Driedpeachesandapricotsare
animportantsourceofprovitaminAactivityandcarotenoids(Figure6).Driedplumsare
particularlyhighinVitaminK(24microgramsper40gramservingor30%DV).27Driedfigs
arehighincalcium(over10%dailyvalueaccordingtovariety),andmanganese(15%DV).
RaisinsanddriedplumsareamongthetopsourcesofboronintheAmericandiet.2829
Analysisofaselectionofdriedfruit(sultanas,Carinacurrants,Zantecurrants,apricotsand
plums)fromAustralia,California,Turkey,IranandSouthAfrica,showedthattheyprovided
significantamountsofseveralmicronutrientssuchasiron,manganese,copper,zinc,
seleniumandfolicacidatlevelsrangingfrom5to20%USDailyValueper40gram
serving.30Levelsdifferedaccordingtodryingmethod,andregionalandvarietalfactors.
WhiledriedfruitsdonotprovidevitaminC,intheUnitedStatesandindustrialized
countriesintakesofvitaminCmeetorexceedrequirements.31323334Forexample,inthe
UnitedStates69%ofthepopulationhaveintakesofvitaminCabovetheserequirements.In
themostrecentDGAreporttheDGACommitteeconcludesthat,“ItisunlikelythatvitaminC
isofmajorpublichealthsignificanceforthevastmajorityofhealthyindividualsintheUS.”35
ThisisprobablybecauseintheUSandmanyindustrializedcountries,childrenand
adolescentsconsumemorethanhalfoftheirfruitintakeasjuice.However,whilefruitjuice
providespotassiumandvitaminC,itlacksmuchofthefiberofthewholefruit.Including
driedfruitsalongsidefreshfruitindietaryrecommendationsexpandstherangeofnutrients
availabletothepopulation,particularlyofthosenutrients,fiberandpotassium,thatwould
benefitthemajorityofpeople.
V.DriedFruitsLackConstituentsConsumedinExcessinWesternDiets
Westerndietsarecharacterizedbyintakeofexcessiveamountsofsodium,solidfats,
andaddedsugarsthatreplacenutrient‐densefood,makingitdifficultforpeopletoachieve
recommendednutrientintakeandcontrolcaloricvalueofthediet.Likefreshfruit,
traditionaldriedfruitsarefreeoffat,transfats,saturatedfatandcholesterol.Driedfruits
alsohaveverylowsodiumcontent.Becausefruitsrequirenofatorsalttomakethem
13
palatable,theyarechoicefoodstoreducesodiumandsolidfatsinthedietandareatthe
coreofhealthydietarypatterns.Traditionaldriedfruitsalsohavenoaddedsugars.Drying
removespartofthefruits’waterandsoconcentratestheirnaturalsugars.This,however,is
normalizedbyasmallerservingsize.
Figure6.CarotenoidandvitaminAcontentofselecteddriedfruits1
Fruit Driedpeach Driedplum DriedapricotVitaminA(IU)per
40gramserving
865 312 1442
1DatafromtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture/AgriculturalResearchServiceNutrientDataLaboratoryhttp://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search/
VI.TraditionalDriedFruits:IntegralPartofHealthyDietaryPatterns
Dietsaroundtheworldareverydifferent,soarethedietrelatedhealthoutcomessuch
asbloodpressure,riskofcardiovasculardiseaseandtotalmortality.Consensusisemerging
thateatingdietsthatfollowcertaindietarypatternsisassociatedwithalowerriskofmajor
14
chronicdiseases.ExamplesofthesepatternsaretheDietaryApproachestoStop
HypertensionorDASH‐stylepatterns,theMediterraneanstyledietarypatterns,and
vegetariandiets.Acommonfeatureofthesedietsisemphasisonfruits,vegetablesand
otherplantfoods.Accordingly,fiberintakeishighandsaturatedfatislow.Driedfruitsare
verycommoncomponentsofthesetypesofdiets.Thismayexplainwhyananalysisfrom
NHANES(1999‐2004)3637datashowedthatintakeofdriedfruitisassociatedwithlower
bodymassindex(BMI),reducedwaistcircumferenceandabdominalobesity.Driedfruit
consumptionwasalsoassociatedwithimprovednutrientintake(highervitaminA,vitamin
K,potassium,iron,magnesiumandfiber),morefruitsservingsperdayandhealthieroverall
diets(asmeasuredbyasignificantlyhigherHealthyEatingIndex,HEI2005)inbothadults
(19+)andchildren.Whilethesedataareassociational,theysuggestthatthosepeoplethat
eatdriedfruitaremorelikelytofollowhealthyeatingpatterns.
VII.DriedFruits:ASourceofHealthProtectiveBioactiveCompoundsandAntioxidantCapacity Driedfruitsareexcellentsourcesofphenoliccompoundsinthediet.3839404142
Thesemakeupthelargestgroupofplantbioactivecompoundsorphytochemicalsinthe
dietandtheyappeartobe,atleastinpart,responsibleforthehealthbenefitassociatedwith
theconsumptionofdietsabundantinfruitsandvegetables.Phenoliccompoundscontribute
themostantioxidantcapacityoffruitsandvegetables43andhaveamultitudeoffunctional
capabilities,whichmayhaveabeneficialeffectonhealth.Valuesforantioxidantcapacity
(OxygenRadicalAbsorbanceCapacityorORAC)andtotalphenoliccontentofaselectionof
driedfruitareshowninTable2.Valuesaremuchhigherfordriedfruitthanthe
correspondingvaluesforfreshbecauseantioxidantsareconcentratedduringthe
dehydrationprocess.LipophilicORACvaluesareverylowinmostfruitsandvegetables
comparedtohydrophilicvalues,whichmakeup90%ormoreoftotalantioxidantcapacity.
Whilethereislossandmodificationofspecificpolyphenolsduringdrying,totalantioxidant
capacityandtotalpolyphenolcontentarerelativelyunchangedduringtheprocess,implying
thatmanyofthephenoliccompoundsareyetunidentified.44Thiscouldincludeoligomeric
orpolymericproductsthataredifficulttocharacterize.Proanthocyanidinsdetectedinplum
andgrapesareabsentindriedplumandraisins,whichsuggeststhatthesecompoundsare
degradedduringthedryingprocess.45Anthocyaninsarenotdetectedindriedfruitsandare
15
likelydegradedtophenolicacids.Muchworkneedstobedoneinthisarea.Availabledata
showsthatdriedfruitshaveauniquespectrumofphenols,polyphenolsandtannins.In
raisins,themostabundantphenoliccompoundsaretheflavonoidsquercetinand
kaempferol,andthephenolicacidscaftaricandcoutaricacid.46Thepredominantphenolic
compoundsinGreekcurrantsarevanillic,caffeic,gallic,syringic,p‐coumaric,and
protocatechuicacidsandtheflavonoidquercetin.47Hydroxycinnamates,especially
chlorogenicacidisomersarethemajorphenolicsindriedplums,representingmorethan
94%ofthetotal.48Rutinisthepredominantflavonol.49Driedplumsalsocontainquinic
acidthatismetabolizedtohippuricacid,whichsomeresearchsuggestshelpsprevent
urinarytractinfections.5042Informationonphenoliccompoundsindatesiscomplexsince
compositionvariessignificantlyaccordingtovarietyandmaturationstages.5152Verylittle
informationisavailableontheantioxidantcharacterizationofotherdriedfruits.
Table2.Totalphenoliccontentandantioxidantactivityofdriedfruits,grapesandplums1
DriedFruit TotalPhenolics (mgofGAE/gwet
weight)
L‐ORAC
(μmTE/g)
H‐ORAC
(μmTE/g)
DegletNoordates 6.6±1.1 0.32±0.16 39±3
Medjooldates 5.7 0.27 24
Driedfigs 9.6±0.1 1.8±0.1 32±3
Driedplums 12±1.6 1.8±0.6 84±17
Raisins 10.7±1.6 0.35±0.13 30±5
Grapes 1.5±0.1 ‐ 11±2
Plums 3.6±1.1 0.17±0.1 62±20
1DatafromtheUnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture/AgriculturalResearchServiceNutrientDataLaboratoryhttp://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search/
VIII.DispellingMyths
Contrarytothepopularperceptionthatdriedfruitpromotecavities,recentstudies
indicatethattheymayactuallypromoteoralhealth.Bioactivecompoundsfoundinraisins
16
anddriedplumsappeartohaveantimicrobialpropertiesthatinhibitthegrowthofbacteria
thatcausecavitiesandgumdisease.53Driedfruitsalsoexhibitrapidclearingrates,placing
themamongtheleastretentivefoodswithinasampleofsnackfoods.54Raisinshavebeen
showntoattenuateacidogenicityofeatingcereals;55andtoblockinvitrobiofilmformation
andadherenceofbacteriatoexperimentalsurfaces.56Finally,mostdriedfruitscontain
minimalamountsofcariogenicsucrose.
Anothermisconceptionisthatdriedfruits,becauseoftheirsweetness,exertahigh
glycemicandinsulinresponse.Recentstudiesactuallyshowthattraditionaldriedfruits
havealowtomoderateglycemicandinsulinindex(Table3)andaglycemicandinsulin
responsecomparabletofreshfruits.57585960Thiscouldbeduetothepresenceoffiberand
polyphenols,phenolsandtanninsthatcanmodifytheresponse.61626364Foodswithalow
glycemicindexmayhelptodecreasetheriskofdiabetesandareusefulinthemanagement
oftheestablishedcondition.
Table3.GlycemicIndexoftraditionaldriedfruits
Fruit GlycemicIndexDriedapricots
1 30
Driedpeaches2 35
Driedplums3 29
Raisins4 52
Dates5 39
Driedapples6 29
DriedFigs7 61
1Averageof3reportedvalues.GlycemicIndexDatabase:SydneyUniversity'sGlycemicIndexResearchService(SUGiRS)HumanNutritionUnit,SchoolofMolecularandMicrobialBiosciences,SydneyUniversityhttp://www.glycemicindex.com.2,3,6,7GlycemicIndexDatabaseSUGiRS(seeabove)4KimY,HertzlerSR,ByrneHK,MatternCO.NutrRes2008;28:304‐85MillerCJ,DunnEV,HashimIB.SaudiMedJ2002;23(5):536‐8
17
IX.OtherReportedHealthBenefitsSpecifictoDriedFruits
Driedfruitspromotedigestivehealth.
Thereisconsiderableresearchsupportingtheroleofdriedfruitparticularlyin
regulatingbowelfunctionandmaintainingahealthydigestivesystem.6566Recently
publishedresearchshowsthatdriedplumsaremoreeffectivethanpsylliumforthe
treatmentofmildtomoderateconstipation,andshouldbeconsideredasafirstline
therapy.67Studiesalsoindicatethatraisinsalsoprovideprebioticcompoundssuchas
fructans,whichmayhelptomaintainintestinalbalanceandcolonichealth.6869
Driedfruits,particularlydriedplums,maypromotebonehealth.
Researchconductedwithdriedplumsindicatesthattheyhavearoleinsupportingbone
health.Animalstudiesshowthatdriedplumsreducelossofboneindifferentmodelsof
osteoporosis.707172Thismaybebecausetheyarerichinphenoliccompounds,suchas
phenolicacidsandlignans,whichmaystimulateboneformationandenhanceosteoblast
activity.73Driedfruitshavealsobeenfoundtocontainisoflavonesthatmaycontributeto
theeffect.7475Driedfruitsareagoodsourceofothernutrientsreportedtoinfluencebone
healthincludingcalcium,magnesium,vitaminKandboron.Forexample,100gofdriedfigs
hashighercalciumcontentthanthesamequantityofmilk.Boronispostulatedtoplayarole
inosteoporosispreventionandlowboronintakeshavebeenshowntoimpairbone
strength.76
X.DriedFruitsandDietaryRecommendationinDifferentCountries
TraditionaldriedfruitsqualifyfortheProduceforBetterHealthFoundation’s“Fruit&
Veggies:MoreMatters”logo,whichrequiresthatnothingbeaddedtothefruitthatalter
theirnutritionalvalue.TheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericanshavelongconsidereddried
fruitsas“wholefoods”nutritionallyequivalenttofreshfruit.iiiDriedfruitsarealsoincluded
asequivalenttofreshfruit(insmallerservingsizes)incurrentdietaryrecommendationsin
Argentina,Australiaiv,Britainv,Canada,France,Germany,ItalyviandSweden.77Itis
importanttonotethatwhileallofthesecountriesemphasizevarietyinfruitselection,some
(i.e.UK,SouthAfricaandAustralia)limittheamountofdriedfruitthatshouldbeconsumed
iii¼cupofdriedfruit(rangingfrom36to43grams,dependingonthefruit)countsasoneservingoffruit.ivOnly1servingperdaybecausedriedfruitsmay“contributetotoothdecay.”vServingsizeis30grams.viRaisinsandotherdriedfruitcan“improvedigestivehealth”
18
onadailybasis.Thisiscounterintuitiveassomedriedfruitsare,andhavebeenfor
centuries,staplefoodsindifferentregionsoftheworldmakingasignificantcontributionof
thedietaryrequirementsoftheirpopulations.
XI.Conclusion
Driedfruitsshouldbeincludedsidebysidewithfreshfruitrecommendations
aroundtheworldbecausetheyhelpmeetdietaryguidelinesfordailyfruitservingsand
addressbarrierstofruitintake.Thegreatestbenefitofincludingdriedfruitsregularlyinthe
dietisthatitisameanstoincreaseoverallconsumptionoffruitandthecriticalnutrients
theycontain.Driedfruitshavetheadvantageofbeingeasytostoreanddistribute,available
yearround,theyarereadilyincorporatedintootherfoodsandrecipes,relativelylowcost
andpresentahealthyalternativetosugarysnacks.Thescientificbasisforrecommending
higherfruitintakeistheepidemiologicalevidencethatindividualswhoregularlyeat
generousamountsofthesefoodshavelowerratesofcardiovasculardisease,obesity,
severalcancers,diabetesandotherchronicdisease.Yettodaythemajorityofpopulations
eatdietsthatarelowinfruitandvegetablesandconsequentlylowinthenutrientsthey
provide.Traditionaldriedfruits,withtheiruniquecombinationofessentialnutrients,fiber
andbioactivecompoundsareaconvenientsteptowardhealthiereatingandameansto
bridgethegapbetweenrecommendedintakeoffruitsandactualconsumption.
19
References
1BlockG,PattersonBandSubarA.Fruit,vegetablesandcancerprevention:Areviewoftheepidemiologicalevidence.NutrCancer1992;18:1‐92WorldHealthOrganization.Cancerpreventiveeffects.In:IARCHandbookofCancerPrevention:FruitandVegetables.IARCPress,Lyon,France.2008;8:53‐623SteinmetzKAandPotterJD.Vegetables,fruitandcancerprevention:Areview.JAmDietAssoc1996;10:1027‐10394HungH,JoshipuraKJ,JiangR,etal.Fruitandvegetableintakeandriskofmajorchronicdisease.JNatCancerInst.2004;96(21):1577‐15845HuB.Vegetariandietsandriskofselectedchronicdiseases:Plantbasedfoodsandpreventionofcardiovasculardisease:Anoverview.AmJClinNutr2003;78:544‐5516NessARandPowlesJW.Fruitandvegetables,andcardiovasculardisease:Areview.IntJEpidemiol1997;269(1):1‐127SchroederH.ProtectivemechanismsoftheMediterraneandietinobesityandtype2diabetes.JNutrBiochem2007;18(3):149‐608FeldeisenSEandTuckerKL.Nutritionalstrategiesinthepreventionandtreatmentofmetabolicsyndrome.ApplPhysiolNutrMetab2007;32(1):46‐609ProduceforBetterHealthFoundation2007.http://www.fruitsandveggiesmorematters.org(accessedJanuary2011)10UnitedStatesDepartmentofAgriculture,UnitedStatesDepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.DietaryGuidelinesforAmericans2010.http://www.health.gov/dietaryguidelines/dga2010/document/pdf/DGA2010.pdf(accessedFebruary2011)11WorldCancerresearchFund/AmericanInstituteforCancerResearch.Food,Nutrition,PhysicalActivityandthePreventionofCancer:AGlobalPerspectiveWashingtonDc:AIRC,200712FruitandVegetablesForHealth:AJointreportfromtheJointFAO/WHOWorkshop,KobeJapan2003http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/publications/fruit_vegetables_report.pdfaccessedFebruary201113ReedJ,FrazaoE,ItskowitzR.HowmuchdoAmericanspayforfruitsandvegetables.UnitedStatesDepartmentofAgricultureEconomicResearchServiceAgricultureInformationBulletinNumber760.http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/aib790/aib790.pdf14LockK,PormeleauJ,CauserL,MvKeee.Lowfruitandvegetableconsumption.InEzzatiM,LopezAD,RogersA,MurrayCJL,eds.Comparativequantificationofhealthrisk:globalandregionalburdenofdiseaseattributabletoselectedmajorriskfactors.Geneva,Switzerland:WHO200515WHO/FAODiet,nutritionandthepreventionofchronicdisease.ReportofaJointFAO/WHOExpertConsultation.Geneva,Switzerland:WHO,200316PomerleauJ,LockK,McKeeM.TheburdenofcardiovasculardiseaseandcancerattributabletolowfruitandvegetableintakeinEuropeanUnion:differencesbetweentheoldandnewMemberNationsPublichealthNutr2005;9(5):575‐8317WorldHealthOrganization.TheWorldHealthReport2002;Reducingrisk,promotingahealthyLife.Geneva,Switzerland200218HallHN,MooreS,HarperSBandLynchJW.Globalvariabilityinfruitandvegetableconsumption.AmJPrevMed2009;36(5):402‐409
20
19AustralianBureauofStatistics(ABS)Nationalhealthsurveysummaryofresults2004‐2005ABSCatalogueNo4364.0Canberra,Australia:ABS200620SchneiderM,NormanR,StynN,BradshawD.SouthAfricanComparativeriskAssessmentCollaboratingGroup.EstimatingtheburdenofdiseaseattributedtolowfruitandvegetableintakeinSouthAfricain2000.SAfrMedJ2001;97:717‐2321BlakeM,ChaudhuryM,DeverillC.HealthSurveyforEngland2003volume2.Riskfactorsforcardiovasculardisease.Norwich,UnitedKingdom:hermajesty’sStationaryOffice200422GuentherPM,DoddKW,ReedyJ,SmithSMMostAmericanseatmuchlessthantherecommendedamountoffruitsandvegetablesAmJDietAss2006;106(9):1371‐923ReportoftheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericansCommitteeontheDietaryGuidelinesforAmericanshttp://www.cnpp.usda.gov/dgas2010‐dgacreport.htm24AppelLJ.LifestylemodificationsasameanstopreventandtreathighbloodpressureJAmSocNephrol2003;14:S99‐S10225vanMierlo,LA,GreylinA,ZockPL,KokFJ,GeleijmseJM.Suboptimalpotassiumintakeandpotentialimpactonpopulationbloodpressure.ArchIntMed2010;170(16);1501‐150226TurinTC,OkudaN,MiuraK,NakamuraY,RumanaN,UeshimaH.DietaryintakeofpotassiumandassociateddietaryfactorsamongrepresentativesamplesofJapanesegeneralpopulation:NIPPONDATA80/90.JEpidemiol2010;20(3S):S567‐S57527U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture,AgriculturalResearchService,NutrientDataLaboratory,USDAnationalnutrientdatabaseforstandardreferencehttp://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/search28RaineyCJ,NyquistLA,ChristensenREetal.DailyboronintakefromtheAmericandiet.JAmDietAssoc1999;99:335‐4029Stacewicz‐SapuntzakisM,BowenPE.;HussainEA.;Damayanti‐WoodBI,FarnsworthNR.Crit.Chemicalcompositionandpotentialhealtheffectsofprunes:afunctionalfood?Rev.FoodSci.Nutr.,2001,41,4,251‐28630BennetLE,SighDEandClingelefferPR.MicronutrientMineralandFolateContentofAustralianandImportedDriedFruitproductsClinReviewsSciNutr2011,51:38‐4331ChunOK,FloegelA,ChungS‐J,ChungCE,SonWO,KooSI.EstimationofantioxidantintakesfromdietandsupplementinU.SAdults.JNutr2010;140:317‐32432Kirsh,V.A.,Hayes,R.B.,Mayne,S.T.,Chatterjee,N.,Subar,A.F.,Dixon,L.B.,Albanes,D.,Andriole,G.L.,Urban,D.A.,andPeters,U.SupplementalandDietaryVitaminE,ß‐Carotene,andVitaminCIntakesandProstateCancerRisk.JNatlCancerInst2006;98(4):245‐25433NagelG,LinseisenJ,vanGilsCH,PeetersPG,Boutron‐RuaultMC,Clavel‐ChapelonF,RomieuI,TjonnelandA,OlsenA,etalDietarybeta‐carotene,vitaminCandEintakeandbreastcancerriskintheEuropeanProspectiveInvestigationintoCancerandNutrition(EPIC).BreastCancerResTreat2009;119(3):753‐765.34VioqueJ,WeinbrennerT,AsensioL,CastellóA,YoungIS,FletcherA.PlasmaconcentrationsofcarotenoidsandvitaminCarebettercorrelatedwithdietaryintakeinnormalweightthanoverweightandobeseelderlysubjects.BrJNutr.2007May;97(5):977‐86.35http://www.cnpp.usda.gov/Publications/DietaryGuidelines/2010/DGAC/Report/D‐2‐NutrientAdequacy.pdfAccessedFebruary201136KeastDR,andJonesJM.Driedfruitconsumptionassociatedwithimproveddietqualityandreducedoverweightorobesityinadults:NHANES,1999‐2004.Tobepresentedatthe2009FNCEMeeting.37KeastDR,andJonesJM.Driedfruitconsumptionassociatedwithreducedimprovedoverweightorobesityinadults:NHANES,1999‐2004.FASEBJ.2009;23:LB1138WuX,BeecherGR,HoldenJM,etal.LipophilicandhydrophilicantioxidantcapacitiesofcommonfoodsintheUnitedStates.JAgricFoodChem.2004;52:4026‐3739VinsonJA,ZubikL,BoseP,etal.Driedfruits:excellentinvitroandinvivoantioxidants.JAmCollNutr.2005;249(1):44‐50
21
40VinsonJA,SuX,ZubikLandBoseP.Phenolantioxidantqualityandquantityinfoods:fruits.JAgricFoodChem.2001;49(11):5315‐2141KalioraAC,KountouriAM,KarathanosVT.Antioxidantpropertiesofraisins(VitisviniferaL.).JMedFood.2009,12(6):1302‐942Kayano,SI,KikuzakiH,FukutsukaN,etalAntioxidantactivityofprune(PrunusdomesticaL.)constituentsandanewsynergist.JAgricFoodChem2002,50(13):3708‐1243ChunOK,KimD‐O,SmithNL,SchroederD,HanJT,LeeCY.DailyconsumptionofphenolicsandtotalantioxidantcapacityfromfruitsandvegetablesintheAmericandiet.JSciFoodAgr2005;85:1715‐2444MadrauM,Sanguinetti,AmaroA,FaddaCandGaA.Contributionofmelanoidintotheantioxidantactivityofprunes.JFoodQuality2010;33(1s):155‐17045GuL,KelmMA,HammerstoneJFetalScreeningoffoodscontainingproanthocyanidinsandTheirStructuralCharacterizationUsingLC‐MS/MSandThiolyticDegradation.JAgricFoodChem,2003,51(25):7513‐2146WillimasonGandCarughiA.Polyphenolcontentandhealthbenefitsofraisins.NutrRes2010,30:511‐947ChiouA,KarathanosV,MylonaAetal.Currants(VitisviniferaL.)contentofsimplephenolicsandantioxidantactivity.FoodChem.2007,102:516‐2248NakataniN,KayanoS.KikuzakiH.etalChlorogenicacidisomersinprune(PrunusdomesticaL.)JAgricFoodchem.2000,48(11):5512‐649DonovanJLMeyerASandWaterhouseAL.Phenoliccompositionandantioxidantactivityofprunesandprunejuice.JAgricFoodChem199846(4):1247‐5250FangN,ShanggongYandPriorRL.LC/MS/MSCharacterizationofphenolicconstituentsindriedplums.JAgricFoodChem,2002,50(12):3579–358551BiglariF,AlkarkhiAFM,EasaAM.Antioxidantactivityandphenoliccontentofvariousdatepalm(Phoenixdactylifera)fruitsfromIran.FoodChem2008;107:1636‐4152Al‐FarsiM,AlasalvarC,MorrisA,BaronM,ShahidiF.Comparisonofantioxidantactivity,anthocyanins,carotenoids,andphenolicsinthreenativefreshandsun‐drieddate(PhoenixdactyliferaL.)varietiesgrowninOman.JAgricChem2005;53:7592‐9953Rivero‐CruzF,ZhuM,KinghornADandWuCD.AntimicrobialconstituentsofThompsonseedlessraisins(Vitisvinifera)againstselectedoralpathogens.PhytochemicalLetters2008;1:151‐454KahketS,VanHouteLRandStocksS.Lackofcorrelationbetweenfoodretentiononthehumandentitionandconsumerperceptionoffoodstickiness.JDentRes.1991;70(10):1314‐955UtrejaA,LingstromP,EvansCA,SalzmannLBandWuCD.Theeffectofraisins‐containingcerealsonthepHofdentalplaqueinyoungchildren.Peddent2009;31(7):498‐50356WuCD.Grapeproductsandoralhealth.JNutr2009;139:1818S‐23S57KimY,HertzlerSR,ByrneHK,MatternCO.Raisinsarealowtomoderateglycemicindexfoodwithacorrespondinglylowinsulinindex.NutrRes2008;28:304‐858MillerCJ,DunnEV,HashimIB.GlycemicIndexof3varietiesofdates.SaudiMedJ2002;23(5):536‐859JAAnderson,HAHuth,MMLarson,AJColby,EJKrieg,LPGolbach,KASimon,SLWasmundt,CJMalone,TWilson.GlycemicandInsulinResponsetoRaisins,GrapesandBananasinCollegeAgedStudentsFASEBJournal.2011;InPressAbstract#616160JAAnderson,KFAndersen,RAHeimerman,MMLarson,SEBaker,MRFreeman,ACarughi,TWilson.GlycemicResponseofType2DiabeticstoRaisins.FASEBJournal.2011:InPressAbstract#7598.61Zunino,S.Type2diabetesandglycemicresponsetograpesorgrapeproducts.JNutr2009;139:1794S‐800S
22
62JohnstonKL,CliffordMN,MorganLMCoffeeacutelymodifiesgastrointestinalhormonesecretionandglucosetoleranceinhumans:glycemiceffectsofchlorogenicacidandcaffeine.AmjClinNutr2003;78‐728‐3363BjörckI,ElmståhlHL.Theglycaemicindex:importanceofdietaryfibreandotherfoodproperties.ProcNutrSoc.2003Feb;62(1):201‐6.64WidanagamageRD,EkanayakeS,WelihindaJ.Carbohydrate‐richfoods:glycaemicindicesandtheeffectofconstituentmacronutrients.IntJFoodSciNutr.2009;60Suppl4:215‐2365TinkerLF,SchneemanBOandDaviesPA,etal.Consumptionofprunesasasourceofdietaryfiberinmenwithmildhypercholesterolemia.AmJClinNutr.1991;53:1259‐6566SpillerGA,StoryJA,LodicsTA,PollackM,MonyhanS,BtterfieldGandSpillerM.Effectofsun‐driedraisinsonbileacidexcretion,intestinaltransittime,andfecalweight:Adoseresponsestudy.JMedFood2003;6(3)87‐9167AttaluriA,DonahoeR,ValestinJ,BrownKRaoSSC.Randomisedclinicaltrial:driedplums(prunes)vspsyllumforconstipation.AlimentPharmacolTher2011,37(7):822‐868CamireMEandDoughertyMP.Raisindietaryfibercompositionandinvitrobileacidbinding.JAgricFoodChem.2003;51:834‐83769CarughiA.Raisinsasasourceofprebioticcompounds.FASEBJ2009;23(1):716.970DeyhimF,StoeckerBJ,BrucewitzGH,etal.Driedplumreversesbonelossinanosteopemicratmodelofosteoporosis.Menopause2005;12(6):755‐6271FranklinM,BuSB,LernerMR,etalDriedplumpreventsbonelossinamaleosteoporosismodelviaIGF‐1andtheRANKpathway.Bone2006;39:1331‐4272HalloranBP,WronskiTJ,VonHerzenDC,ChuV,XiaX,PingelJE,WilliamsAA,SmithBJ.Dietarydriedplumincreasesbonemassinadultandagedmalemice.JNutr2010;140:1781‐873HooshmanSandArjmandiBH.Viewpoint:Driedplum,anemergingfunctionalfoodthatmayeffectivelyimprovebonehealth.AgingResReviews2009;8:122‐2774LigginsJ,BluckLJCandRunswickS.Daidzeinandgenisteincontentoffruitsandnuts.JBiochem2000;11(6):326‐3175ThompsonLU,BoucherBA,LiuZ,CotterchioM,KeigerN.PhystoestrogencontentoffoodsconsumedinCanadaincludingisoflavones,lignansandcoumestan.NutrCancer2006;54(2):184‐20176NielsenFH.Isboronnutritionallyrelevant?NutrRev.2008;66(4):183‐9177FoodandAgricultureorganizationoftheUnitedNations.FoodBasedDietaryGuidelines.http://www.fao.org/ag/humannutrition/nutritioneducation/fbdg/en/accessedFebruary16,2011