trabalhos de arqueologia 18 - the basque whaling ship from ... · a 16th century basque whaling...

26
269 SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS The basque whaling ship from Red Bay, Labrador: a treasure trove of data on Iberian atlantic shipbuilding design and techniques in the mid-16th century ROBERT GRENIER A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed to be the San Juan, a galleon or nao sunk in 1565, the wreck was relocated in September 1978 by a Parks Canada team in the harbour of Red Bay, Labrador. It was discovered mostly buried, in an excellent state of preservation, in water 25 to 40 feet deep, some 100 feet from the inner shore of Saddle Island, at the entrance to the harbour. Loaded with hundreds of barricas originally filled with whale oil, the wreck was lying near a series of rendering ovens on shore. From the autumn of 1978 until the early winter of 1985, the wreck site became the object of one of the most painstaking underwater archaeological projects undertaken anywhere. Typically each field season was 5 to 6 months long, and a total of 14000 hours of diving in Red Bay’s icy arctic waters were amassed during the project. The end result was the full excavation of the site, including the dismantling and raising to the surface of 3000 timbers which were meticulously recorded in laboratory conditions and then reburied systematically on the site, in a manner which will preserve them. Since the completion of the “First Dig” over a decade and a half ago, our team of archaeologists and researchers has conducted a methodical “Second Dig” through the collected archaeological and archival data. One of our principal goals has been to understand and explain the design and construction of this 16th century ship of Iberian penin- sula origin. Parks Canada’s Red Bay research has yielded a report of 3000 manuscript pages, illustrated with more than 1200 elaborate drawings, maps and photographs: putting the finishing touches on the report, which will be submitted for publication shortly, has preoccupied our team and has prevented us from contributing in due fashion to the symposium proceedings Archaeology of Medieval and Modern Ships of Iberian-Atlantic Tradition. At the suggestion of the editor, however, we have submitted an illustrative overview of our findings: 30 of the 1232 illustrations to be included in the final report. Some of these illustrations are photographs of the 1:10 scale archaeological research model we developed following Richard Steffy’s pioneering approach, while others are line drawings, site maps, and photographs. Most have been chosen to illustrate diagnostic elements of the 204 tonelada Iberian ship as found at Red Bay, particularly features in the midship and stern sec- tions of the ship.

Upload: others

Post on 18-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

269

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

The basque whaling ship from Red Bay,Labrador: a treasure trove of data on Iberianatlantic shipbuilding design and techniquesin the mid-16th century

❚ ROBERT GRENIER ❚

A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in

America, north of Florida. Believed to be the San Juan, a galleon or nao sunk in 1565, the wreck

was relocated in September 1978 by a Parks Canada team in the harbour of Red Bay, Labrador.

It was discovered mostly buried, in an excellent state of preservation, in water 25 to 40 feet

deep, some 100 feet from the inner shore of Saddle Island, at the entrance to the harbour.

Loaded with hundreds of barricas originally filled with whale oil, the wreck was lying near a

series of rendering ovens on shore.

From the autumn of 1978 until the early winter of 1985, the wreck site became the object

of one of the most painstaking underwater archaeological projects undertaken anywhere.

Typically each field season was 5 to 6 months long, and a total of 14000 hours of diving in Red

Bay’s icy arctic waters were amassed during the project. The end result was the full excavation

of the site, including the dismantling and raising to the surface of 3000 timbers which were

meticulously recorded in laboratory conditions and then reburied systematically on the site, in

a manner which will preserve them. Since the completion of the “First Dig” over a decade and

a half ago, our team of archaeologists and researchers has conducted a methodical “Second Dig”

through the collected archaeological and archival data. One of our principal goals has been to

understand and explain the design and construction of this 16th century ship of Iberian penin-

sula origin.

Parks Canada’s Red Bay research has yielded a report of 3000 manuscript pages, illustrated

with more than 1200 elaborate drawings, maps and photographs: putting the finishing touches

on the report, which will be submitted for publication shortly, has preoccupied our team and has

prevented us from contributing in due fashion to the symposium proceedings Archaeology of

Medieval and Modern Ships of Iberian-Atlantic Tradition. At the suggestion of the editor, however,

we have submitted an illustrative overview of our findings: 30 of the 1232 illustrations to be

included in the final report.

Some of these illustrations are photographs of the 1:10 scale archaeological research model

we developed following Richard Steffy’s pioneering approach, while others are line drawings,

site maps, and photographs. Most have been chosen to illustrate diagnostic elements of the

204 tonelada Iberian ship as found at Red Bay, particularly features in the midship and stern sec-

tions of the ship.

Page 2: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

270

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG

. 1

– S

ite

pla

n s

ho

win

g m

ost

ly a

rtic

ula

ted

str

uct

ura

l re

mai

ns,

exp

ose

d f

oll

ow

ing

th

e ex

cava

tio

n o

f th

e h

ull

in

teri

or.

Fro

m l

eft

to r

igh

t d

ow

n t

he

cen

trel

ine

are:

th

e b

ow

spri

t, l

ead

ing

to

th

e g

entl

e

curv

e o

f th

e st

em,

the

kee

lso

n a

nd

mai

n m

ast

step

, fo

llo

wed

by

the

low

er e

nd

of

the

ster

n p

ost

an

d t

he

coll

apse

d t

ran

som

. T

he

lon

git

ud

inal

tim

ber

s o

n t

he

up

per

mid

dle

sec

tio

n i

nd

icat

e th

e le

vel

of

the

low

er d

eck

(D

raw

ing

: P

. W

add

ell,

Par

ks

Can

ada;

24

M-8

4-1

01-

07).

3432

302

82

62

42

22

018

1614

1210

86

42

20

0

T S R Q P N M L K J H

Page 3: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

271

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG

. 2

– S

catt

ered

tim

ber

pla

n r

epre

sen

tin

g t

wo

-th

ird

s o

f th

e n

earl

y 30

00

tim

ber

s re

cord

ed o

n s

ite.

Th

e k

eels

on

an

d o

utl

ine

of

the

arti

cula

ted

hu

ll,

wh

ich

co

vere

d m

uch

of

the

loo

se t

imb

ers,

is s

ho

wn

su

per

imp

ose

d (

Dra

win

g:

Par

ks

Can

ada;

24

M-2

00

0-1

01-

2).

3432

302

82

62

42

22

018

1614

1210

86

42

20

0

T S R Q P N M L K J H

Page 4: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

272

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG

. 3

– P

rofi

le o

f th

e p

rin

cip

al t

imb

ers,

sh

ow

ing

th

eir

bas

ic d

imen

sio

ns.

Th

e st

em c

on

form

s ro

ug

hly

to

an

arc

of

9 c

od

os

(5.1

6m

) ra

diu

s, r

efle

ctin

g t

heh

eig

ht

of

the

stem

at

its

forw

ard

mo

st p

oin

t.

Th

e k

eel le

ng

th (

14.7

3m)

isp

rese

nte

d h

ere

as a

mea

sure

men

t b

etw

een

th

e u

ptu

rn i

n t

he

kee

l ra

bb

et a

t st

eman

d s

tern

. A

t th

e st

em t

his

co

rres

po

nd

s to

th

e af

t en

d o

f th

e k

eel-

to-s

tem

scar

ph

(n

ot

visi

ble

)

wh

ile

in t

he

ster

n t

his

occ

urs

at

the

up

turn

of

the

hee

ltim

ber

(D

raw

ing

: C

. P

iper

, P

ark

s C

anad

a; 2

4M

-94

-10

3-2

).

Page 5: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

273

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG

. 4

– D

uri

ng

th

e ex

cava

tio

n,

con

stru

ctio

n o

f a

1:10

sca

le m

od

el o

f th

e h

ull

rem

ain

s w

as c

om

men

ced

, fo

llo

win

g R

ich

ard

Ste

ffy’

s p

ion

eeri

ng

wo

rk o

n t

his

res

earc

h p

roce

ss.

Th

is i

s an

ou

tbo

ard

vie

w o

f th

e

star

bo

ard

sid

e o

f th

e ar

chae

olo

gic

al m

od

el,

mo

stly

up

to

th

e w

ater

lin

e. M

od

el m

aker

Mar

cel

Gin

gra

s is

sh

ow

n b

ehin

d.

On

ly s

elec

ted

fra

min

g a

nd

pla

nk

ing

is

in p

lace

(P

ho

to:

D.

Pag

é, P

ark

s C

anad

a, R

D-

44

59T

).

Page 6: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

274

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG

. 5

– I

nb

oar

d v

iew

of

the

star

bo

ard

sid

e o

f th

e m

od

el w

ith

sel

ecte

d f

ram

es a

nd

pla

nk

s in

pla

ce.

Th

e fl

oo

rs a

nd

fir

st f

utt

ock

s o

f fo

urt

een

mid

ship

fra

mes

, fr

om

th

e 7th

aft

to

th

e 6

th f

orw

ard

of

the

mas

ter

fram

e, w

ere

pre

-ass

emb

led

an

d l

ater

ally

co

nn

ecte

d a

t d

ove

tail

jo

ints

(F

igu

res

9 –

13)

. ‘F

loat

ing

fra

mes

’, a

s in

sh

ell-

firs

t co

nst

ruct

ion

fra

min

g m

eth

od

, w

ere

no

t la

tera

lly

con

nec

ted

an

d a

re e

vid

ent

on

th

e

mo

del

at

the

leve

l o

f th

e se

con

d f

utt

ock

s fr

om

bo

w t

o s

tern

an

d a

t th

e le

vel

of

the

firs

t fu

tto

cks

fore

an

d a

ft o

f th

e ce

ntr

al p

re-a

ssem

ble

d f

ram

es.

Th

e w

hit

e d

ots

sh

ow

mys

teri

ou

s in

ner

‘p

lug

s’ l

ink

ed t

o t

he

des

ign

an

d c

on

stru

ctio

n p

roce

ss (

Ph

oto

: D

. P

agé,

Par

ks

Can

ada,

RD

-44

58T

).

Page 7: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

275

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG

. 6

– S

chem

atic

dra

win

gs

sho

win

g t

he

forw

ard

en

d o

f th

e k

eel,

in

pla

n a

nd

in

sta

rbo

ard

pro

file

, at

th

e p

osi

tio

ns

of

the

7th

– 1

5th

fra

mes

fo

rwar

d o

f th

e m

aste

r fr

ame.

Th

ey s

ho

w t

he

kee

l’s

risi

ng

forw

ard

en

d w

ith

in

teg

rate

d c

arve

d g

arb

oar

ds,

th

e n

arro

win

g o

f th

e fl

at s

urf

ace

bet

wee

n t

he

gar

bo

ard

s, a

nd

ou

r in

terp

reta

tio

n o

f h

ow

th

e sc

rib

ed c

ircl

es w

ere

rela

ted

to

th

e n

arro

win

g o

f th

is s

ur-

face

(an

exa

mp

le o

f th

e gr

amin

hosy

stem

). T

he

nar

row

ing

dec

reas

ed i

n i

ncr

emen

ts t

hat

co

rres

po

nd

ed t

o t

he

dia

met

ers

of

the

scri

bed

cir

cles

. W

hil

e th

e fl

at s

urf

ace

of

the

kee

l is

ho

rizo

nta

l, t

he

sid

es

of

the

inte

gra

ted

gar

bo

ard

s ri

se w

ith

no

rel

atio

nsh

ip t

o t

he

scri

bed

cir

cles

(D

raw

ing

: C

. P

iper

, P

ark

s C

anad

a; 2

4M

-94

-10

3-1,

1a,

1b).

Nar

row

ing

of

Car

ved

Gar

bo

ard

sA

SF

OU

ND

ME

AS

UR

ES

Ris

ing

of

Car

ved

Gar

bo

ard

sA

SF

OU

ND

ME

AS

UR

ES

(C

M)

Page 8: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

276

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 7 – Detail of the model showing an oblique view of the scarph joint between the carved keel with integrated

garboards (at right) and the heel of the stem (at left). Notice how the forward end of the carved keel yields to a

standard garboard arrangement at the stem scarph (Photo: R. Chan, Parks Canada, RD-309X).

FIG. 8 – The model, looking aft viewed obliquely, from the centre towards the starboard quarter, featuring the

keelson, main mast step, dovetailed floor timbers, and, in the background, a portion of the transom structure

(Photo: R. Chan, Parks Canada, RD-310X).

Page 9: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

277

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 9 – Exploded view of the lateral dovetail joints of the master frame and of the 1st frames forward and aft, both identical in

section to the master. Notice the combination of two large treenail fastenings and two metal spikes at each floor to first futtock

joint, all of which were driven fore-aft (Drawing: R. Hellier, Parks Canada; 24M-83-103-14).

FIG. 10 – Schematic drawing showing the location of a scribed ‘arrow’ used to mark the turn of the bilge on the first futtock,

TT 407. Similar marks were found on other futtocks from the fourteen morticed frames (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada;

24M-94-103-9).

Page 10: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

278

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 12 – After they were raised to the surface for recording, four of the midship floor timbers (1st forward to 3rd aft of the mas-

ter frame, top to bottom) and eight reinforcing chocks for the main mast step were placed in their original arrangement for

this photograph. The second frame from the top is the master frame, with two dovetail mortices at either end. In the fore-

ground, the floor shows the carved-out sump hole cut vertically through it (Photo: R. Chan, Parks Canada; 24M-2056M).

FIG. 11 – Detail inboard view of the model, facing

starboard, featuring the mast step assembly

locked over the master frame (at left), the main

mast mortice, the roughly cut pump well sump,

and the indented under side of the keelson.

Notice that originally four first futtocks were

dovetailed to the master floor, although only two

are in place on the model (Photo: D. Pagé, Parks

Canada, RD-4440T).

Page 11: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

279

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 13 – Schematic drawing showing the stern faces of fourteen morticed midship floor timbers. Mortices cut into the forward

faces of the floors are indicated by a dashed line (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-92-103-5).

MORTICED FLOOR TIMBERS

CENTRE LINE BETWEEN MORTICES

POSITION OF KEEL

STERN

MASTER

BOW

35 mm TREENAIL

12 mm IRON NAIL

6

5

4

3

2

1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

2212

2213

2214

2215

2216

2217

2218

2219

2220

2221

2222

2223

2224

2225

Page 12: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

280

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 14 – Schematic drawings of the rising floor timbers 7th – 25th forward of the master frame. Unexplained 35mm ‘plugs’ were

located on the aft faces of the crutches (except the 18th forward), and are indicated here by a dashed ‘o’ since the view is from

forward. The arrows indicate the position of the flower-line ribband. Notice the variability in the shape of the limber holes

(Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-95-103-21, 21a).

7

89

12 13 14

15

1617

18 19

20

21

22

23

24

25

10

11

Page 13: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

281

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 15 – Reconstruction drawing of the mast step assembly as found, facing the starboard bow, showing: the keelson’s enlarged

dimensions around the rectangular mortice for the mast heel (with an inserted corrective block), the roughly cut sump hole on

the port side, and, as shown in Figure 12, four chocks on either side of the step separated by empty spaces which were sealed

by short planks. The chocks were morticed into heavy footwales, which ran parallel to the keelson. In the foreground, unfas-

tened limber planks lie atop the floors between the keelson and footwales. Notice the ‘T’ shape of the carved keel (Drawing: C.

Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-87-103-1a).

FIG. 16 – Model detail showing the base of the main mast and the pump well assembly with the pump tube in the middle, sur-

rounded by the four corner posts of the well chamber. The cask stowage arrangement shown here was determined archaeolo-

gically by in-situ cask remains and dunnage patterns on the ceiling left by ballast stones around the pump well (Photo: R. Chan,

Parks Canada, RD-302X).

Page 14: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

282

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG

. 17

– S

chem

atic

dra

win

g o

f th

e st

ern

po

st’s

sta

rbo

ard

ele

vati

on

sh

ow

ing

ho

w t

he

bas

ic p

ro-

po

rtio

ns

of

the

ster

n a

re w

ho

le c

odos

de

ribe

ra(5

7.4

6cm

) m

easu

rem

ents

. A

lso

no

tice

th

e 6

ang

le o

f th

e st

ern

po

st,

a d

iag

no

stic

fea

ture

of

ship

s o

f th

e p

erio

d (

Dra

win

g:

C.

Pip

er,

Par

ks

Can

ada;

24

M-9

1-10

3-15

a)

Up

per

dec

k

Mai

n d

eck

3 co

do

s

3 co

do

s

10 c

od

os

6 c

od

os

± 1

0 c

od

os ± 3

co

do

s

Lo

wer

dec

k

LIN

EO

FT

UC

K

69

0

3 co

do

s ±2

met

res

FIG

. 18

– L

ow

er s

tarb

oar

d s

tern

of

the

mo

del

at

the

kee

l an

d s

tern

po

st j

un

ctio

n,

sho

win

g c

arve

d p

lan

ks

wra

pp

ed a

rou

nd

th

e lo

wer

en

d o

f th

e fa

shio

n p

iece

,

crea

tin

g a

sea

mle

ss l

ink

bet

wee

n t

he

tran

som

an

d s

tarb

oar

d s

ide.

Th

is w

as a

clev

er w

ay t

o o

verc

om

e w

eak

nes

s an

d l

eak

age

at t

his

cri

tica

l ju

nct

ion

in

th

e

squ

are

tuck

hu

ll (

Ph

oto

: R

. C

han

, P

ark

s C

anad

a; R

D-1

137W

).

Page 15: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

283

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG

. 19

– D

raw

ing

of

the

po

rt s

ide

of

the

hee

l as

sem

bla

ge

sho

win

g t

he

low

er f

rag

men

t o

f th

e st

ern

po

st s

carp

hed

to

th

e h

eel

tim

ber

an

d l

ink

ed t

og

eth

er b

y a

hu

ge

ster

n k

nee

an

d i

ron

bo

lts.

On

e cr

ut-

ch t

imb

er,

the

17th

aft

of

the

mas

ter

fram

e, i

s sh

ow

n m

ort

iced

ove

r th

e fo

rwar

d e

nd

of

the

kn

ee (

Dra

win

g:

S.

Lau

rie-

Bo

urq

ue,

Par

ks

Can

ada;

24

M-8

3-10

3-2

).

Page 16: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

284

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 20 – The model’s transom planked in a chevron pattern with the carved planks shown in Figure 18 at its base. The starboard

transom is pierced by a large, square loading port with a hinged cover. On the port side, a much smaller square port shows

signs of a nailed cover on the outside. The transom and stern post also show the imprint of two rudder gudgeons and straps.

A third gudgeon mortice appears at the very top end of the stern post just below the tiller port. Above the tiller port is a single

carved timber morticed over the counter frames and pierced with two hawse holes. On the port side top corner above the trans-

om beam, a standing knee defines the tumblehome of the absent fashion piece (Photo: C. Moore & R. Chan, Parks Canada,

RD-1106W).

Page 17: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

285

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 21 – A drawing of the flat transom showing many of the features identified in Fig. 20. Notice the six large iron bolt holes

which reveal the positions of internal lodging knees, some of which are shown in Fig. 22. This drawing also emphasizes the

location of the two lowermost rudder gudgeons and their strapping, out of a total of five (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada;

24M-91-103-14a).

Page 18: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

286

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 22 – The model, showing the inboard structure of the flat transom stern. The break-up of the hull scattered many of the lod-

ging knees, and at least two examples missing here were not relocated on site (Photo: C. Moore, Parks Canada; RD 1162W).

Page 19: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

287

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 23 – Inboard view of the starboard side of the model, showing three lower deck standing knee fragments fixed to the wall of

the ship. They were flanked by short, notched sill planks (albaola), and sat over a carved waterway. Below the carved waterway

fragment on the model, in the centre of the photograph, is a short section of the beam shelf (Photo: R. Chan, RD-326X).

FIG. 24 – Lower deck reconstruction drawing from archaeological evidence, featuring: double deck beam, standing knee, water-

way, albaola, and stringer (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-93-103-8).

Page 20: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

288

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 25 – The Red Bay vessel’s reconstructed midship section, taken at the master frame. Most of the main deck features had

vanished, except for a few indicators on fragments of related futtocks. While evidence for the level of the main deck in the bow

and stern is firm, the evidence available for its level at midship is somewhat ambiguous. On the one hand an initial location at

3 cubits (codos de ribera of 57.46 cm) above the lower deck as expected from the documents and Basque practices, while on the

other hand a subsequent raising of this deck there (shown by the dotted line) is suggested by fastener evidence. It should be

noted that the available evidence suggests the absence of planking on the main deck at midship. The upper and lower deck

levels are more firmly established by archaeological evidence (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-92-103-7b).

Page 21: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

289

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG

. 2

6–

In

ner

sta

rbo

ard

sid

e o

f th

e m

od

el s

ho

win

g t

he

po

siti

on

of

the

tran

sver

se

fore

mas

t st

ep r

esti

ng

clo

se t

o t

he

stem

, at

lo

wer

dec

k l

evel

. B

elo

w t

he

step

is

the

seco

nd

sca

rph

of

the

stem

(P

ho

to:

R.

Ch

an,

Par

ks

Can

ada,

RD

-34

1X).

FIG

. 2

7–

Mod

el l

ookin

g f

orw

ard

, ju

st a

ft o

f th

e st

em,

show

ing t

he

two m

ain

com

pon

ents

of

the

port

sid

e h

awse

hole

ass

emb

ly (

esco

benq

ue)

. T

he

ou

ter

port

ion

wit

h t

he

larg

e ca

rved

hole

show

s a

rou

nd

ed r

eces

s w

her

e it

ove

rlap

ped

a w

ale.

Th

e in

ner

port

ion

of

the

asse

mb

ly,

ori

ente

d a

t an

an

gle

, w

as s

ecu

red

ove

r h

ull

fra

min

g,

ther

eby

rein

forc

ing t

he

bow

ass

emb

ly

(Ph

oto

: R

. C

han

, P

arks

Can

ada,

RD

-34

0X

).

Page 22: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

290

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

FIG. 28 – Drawings of three futtocks of different types illustrating the level of detailed archaeological recording of timbers conduc-

ted at Red Bay, including tool marks and fastener angles and depths of penetration (Drawings: J.C. Farley, C. Piper, R. Hellier,

Parks Canada; 24M-95-103-9A).

Timber tag: Drawing#:

443 83-88-D42

-D43

448 83-87-D42

45 84-22-D730 50 cm

Page 23: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

291

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

FIG. 29 – Schematic drawing showing the typical fastening pattern of two treenails and two iron nails per frame in the outer hull

planking. This detail shows strakes 6 to 9 in the area of the 3rd to 6th first futtocks forward of the master frame. Notice the

change of treenail pattern: treenails on the 3rd and 4th futtocks angle aft, while those on the 5th and 6th futtocks angle

forward. Also observe the variability in the butt-end fastening pattern (Drawing: C. Piper, Parks Canada; 24M-94-103-13).

FIG. 30 – The capstan reconstruction, with bars, partner, and step, positioned between the main and mizzen masts on the upper

deck. The increased thickness of the partner assembly at its forward end (middle right) is noticeable, designed to compensate

for the deck sloping down forwards. The step sits transversely astride two hatch carlings on the main deck below. The capstan

is a one-piece timber fitted with six whelps to guide and grab the turns of the rope at its lower end (Drawing: R. Hellier, Parks

Canada, 24M-83-103-4).

9

8

7

6

3 4 5 6 forward

Page 24: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

292

PROCEEDINGS • INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ARCHAEOLOGY OF MEDIEVAL AND MODERN SHIPS OF IBERIAN-ATLANTIC TRADITION

SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY

AUDY, M.; GRENIER, R.; RINGER, J.; STEVENS, W.; WADDELL, P. (1981) - Sommaire du travail effectué sur le terrain

en 1980 à Red Bay (Labrador) sur les vestiges submergés du San Juan et de la station baleinière basque. Research

Bulletin. Ottawa. 163.

BARKHAM, M. (1981a) - Report on the 16th century Spanish Basque shipbuilding c. 1550 - c. 1600. Ottawa: Parks Canada

(Manuscript Report Series; 422).

BARKHAM, M. (1981b) - Life on Board a 16th-Century Basque Whaler. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 75.

BARKHAM, S. (1978) - The Basques: filling a gap in our history between Jacques Cartier and Champlain. Canadian

Geographical Journal. 96:1, p. 8-19.

BARKHAM, S.; GRENIER, R. (1978/1979) - Divers find sunken Basque galleon in Labrador. Canadian Geographical

Journal. 97:3, p. 60-63.

BERNIER, M.-A. (1996) - Les archéologues aux pieds palmés. Avec la collaboration de Robert Grenier. St-Lambert: Éditions

Héritage.

BRADLEY, C. (1982) - Preliminary Analysis of the Staved Container Remains Recovered from the 1981 Underwater

Excavations at Red Bay. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 260.

BRADLEY, C. (1985) - Summary of Staved Container Remains from the 1981 Field Season in Red Bay, Labrador. In

KEITH, D. H., ed. - Underwater Archaeology: The Proceedings of the 13th Conference on Underwater Archaeology. San

Marino, California (Fathom Eight Special Publication; 5), p. 33-36.

BRADLEY, C. (1993) - Ship’s Fittings and Rigging Components Recovered from the 1983 Underwater Archaeological

Excavation at Red Bay, Labrador. Research Bulletin. Ottawa. 300.

GRENIER, R. (1983) - De Red Bay au Richelieu: Ouvrir les Volets sur l’Histoire. La Plongée. (mars-avril), p. 20-23.

GRENIER, R. (1985) - Excavating a 400 Year-Old Basque Galleon. National Geographic. 168:1, p. 58-68.

GRENIER, R. (1988) - Basque Whalers in the New World: The Red Bay Wrecks. In BASS, G., ed. - Ships and Shipwrecks of

the Americas. London, p. 69-84.

GRENIER, R. (1989) - Basque Whalers of Labrador. In COURCY, J. de; SHEEHY, D., eds. - Atlantic Visions. Dublin: Boole

Press, p. 109-123.

GRENIER, R; LOEWEN, B.; PROULX, J.-P. (1994) - Basque Shipbuilding Technology c. 1560-1580: The Red Bay Project.

In WESTERDAHL, C., ed. - Crossroads in Ancient Shipbuilding, Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium on Boat

and Ship Archaeology, Roskilde, 1991. Oxford: Oxbow Books (Oxbow Monograph; 40), p. 137-141.

GRENIER, R.; TUCK, J. (1981) - A 16th-Century Basque Whaling Station in Labrador. Scientific American. 245:5, p. 180-

-188.

GRENIER, R.; TUCK, J. (1988) - Red Bay, Labrador: World Whaling Capital A.D. 1550-1600. St. John’s: Atlantic Archaeology Ltd.

IZAGUIRRE, M. (1985) - El Rescate Del Galeon Vasco. Viajar. Madrid. 7:70, p. 60-68.

LEBLANC, G. (1984) - Sur les Traces des Basques. Québec Science. 22:11, p. 16-24.

LIGHT, J. D. (1990) - The 16th century anchor from Red Bay, Labrador: Its Method of Manufacture. The International

Journal of Nautical Archaeology and Underwater Exploration. 19:4, p. 307-316.

LIGHT, J. D. (1992) - 16th Century Basque Ironworking: Anchors and Nails. Materials Characterization. 29, p. 249-258.

LOEWEN, B. (1995) - Le baleinier basque de Red Bay, Labrador (XVIe siècle). Étude du clouage dans les murailles de la

coque. In L’aventure maritime, du golfe de Gascogne à Terre-Neuve. Actes du 118e congrès national des sociétés historiques et

scientifiques, Pau, octobre 1993. Paris: Éditions du CTHS, p. 145-157.

LOEWEN, B. (1996) - El estudio de la historia marítima vasca en Canadá. Revista de estudios marítimos del País Vasco;

memoria No. 1: estado de la cuestión de los estudios marítimos en el País Vasco. San Sebastián: Museo Naval, p. 151-166.

LOEWEN, B. (1998) - The Red Bay vessel. An example of a 16th-century Biscayan ship. Itsas Memoria. Revista de Estudios

Marítimos del País Vasco. San Sebastián. 2, p. 193-199.

LOEWEN, B. (1999) - Les barriques de Red Bay et l’espace atlantique septentrional, vers 1565. Ph.D. dissertation. Québec: Laval

University.

Monde de Jacques Cartier (Le). L’aventure au XVIe siècle. Le monde de Cartier ressuscité grâce a l’archéologie sous-marine (1984).

Paris: Libre-Expression.

Page 25: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed

293

SESSÕES DE TRABALHO • WORK SESSIONS

MURDOCK, L. D.; DALEY, T. (1984) - Underwater Molding of a Cross-Section of the San Juan Hull. In GRATTAN, D. -

Proceedings of the ICOM Waterlogged Wood Working Group Conference. Ottawa.

MURDOCK, L. D.; NEWTON, C.; DALEY, T. (1981) - Underwater Molding Techniques on Waterlogged Ships Timbers

Employing Various Products including Liquid Polysulphide Rubber. In GRATTAN, D. - Proceedings of the ICOM

Waterlogged Wood Working Group Conference. Ottawa, 1981. Ottawa: The International Council of Museums, p. 39-40.

PROULX, J.-P. (1983) - Les Basques et la pêche à la baleine: XIe au XVIIIe siècle. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 111.

RIETH, É. (1995) - Les apports complémentaires de la documentation archéologique, expérimentale et écrite à la connais-

sance du navire du milieu du XVIe siècle de Red Bay (Labrador). Quelques réflexions méthodologiques. L’aventure

maritime, du golfe de Gascogne à Terre-Neuve. Actes du 118e congrès national des sociétés historiques et scientifiques, Pau, octo-

bre 1993. Paris: Éditions du CTHS, p. 145-157.

RINGER, J. R. (1983a) - Progress Report on the Marine Excavation of the Basque Whaler San Juan (1565): A Summary of

the 1982 Field Season. In THOMSON, J., ed. - Archaeology in Newfoundland and Labrador. 3, p. 76-94.

RINGER, J. R. (1983b) - Progress Report on the Marine Excavation of the Basque Whaling Vessel San Juan (1565):

A Summary of the 1982 Field Season. Research Bulletin. Ottawa. 206.

RINGER, J. R. (1985) - A Summary of Marine Archaeological Research Conducted at Red Bay, Labrador: The 1984 Field

Season. In THOMSON, J., ed. - Archaeology in Newfoundland and Labrador. 5, p. 190-223.

RINGER, J. R. (1986) - Summary of Marine Archaeological Research Conducted at Red Bay, Labrador: The 1984 Field

Season. Research Bulletin. Ottawa. 248.

RINGER, J. R. (1991) - Ballast Utilization of the 16th-Century Spanish Basque Whaling Vessel San Juan (1565). In

Underwater Archaeology Proceedings from the Society for Historical Archaeology Conference, p. 115-117.

RINGER, J. R.; AUDY, M. J. (1984) - Cargo Lading and Ballasting on the 16th Century Basque Whaling Vessel San Juan

(1565). In KEITH, D. H., ed. - Underwater Archaeology: The Proceedings of the 13th Conference on Underwater Archaeology.

San Marino, California (Fathom Eight Special Publication; 5), p. 20-27.

ROSS, L. (1980) - 16th-Century Spanish Basque Coopering Technology: A Report of the Staved Containers Found in 1978-

1979 on the Wreck of the Whaling Galleon San Juan, Sunk in Red Bay, Labrador, 1565. Manuscript Report Series.

Ottawa. 408.

ROSS, L. (1985) - 16th-Century Spanish Basque Coopering. Historical Archaeology. 19:1, p. 1-31.

STEVENS, W. (1981) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report, 1978-1980. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 255, p. 202.

STEVENS, W. (1982) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report, 1981. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 256, p. 139.

STEVENS, W. (1983) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report,1982. Microfiche Report Series, Ottawa. 264, p. 101.

STEVENS, W. (1984) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report, 1983. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 265, p. 101.

STEVENS, W. (1985) - Progress Report on the Marine Excavation at Red Bay, Labrador: A Summary of the 1983 Field

Season. In THOMSON, J., ed. - Archaeology in Newfoundland and Labrador. 5, p. 166-189.

STEVENS, W. [et al.] (1985) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report, 1984. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 465, p. 193.

STEVENS, W. [et al.] (1986) - The Red Bay Project: Interim Report, 1985. Microfiche Report Series. Ottawa. 472, p. 55.

UNGLIK, H. (1982) - Metallurgical Investigation of a Wrought Iron Chain Link From a 16th-Century Basque Underwater Site

of Red Bay, Labrador. Ottawa: Canadian Parks Service, Conservation Branch.

WADDELL, P. (1985a) - The Pump and Pump Well of a 16th-Century Galleon. International Journal of Nautical Archaeology

and Underwater Exploration. 14:3, p. 243-259.

WADDELL, P. (1985b) - Pump Remains of the 1565 Spanish Basque Whaler San Juan. In KEITH, D. H., ed. - Underwater

Archaeology: The Proceedings of the 13th Conference on Underwater Archaeology. San Marino, California (Fathom Eight

Special Publication; 5), p. 27-32.

WADDELL, P. (1986) - The Disassembly of a 16th-Century Galleon. International Journal of Nautical Archaeology and

Underwater Exploration. 15:2, p. 137-148.

WADDELL, P. (1988) - Reburial of a 16th-Century Galleon. In Proceedings of Oceans 88. Washington, p. 833-836.

Page 26: Trabalhos de Arqueologia 18 - The Basque whaling ship from ... · A 16th century Basque whaling ship is the oldest European wreck yet discovered in America, north of Florida. Believed