towards assembly automation at small size scalesskgupta/assemblyautomation_seminar.pdf · towards...

52
Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering Department and Institute for Systems Research University of Maryland, College Park

Upload: vanque

Post on 03-Feb-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales

Satyandra K. Gupta

Mechanical Engineering Department and Institute for Systems Research

University of Maryland, College Park

Page 2: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Assembly at Small Scale

• A large number of small parts need to be assembled in a small package ─ Assembly operations need to be

performed in 3D space ─ Assembly operations need to

manipulate small parts in a very tight space

• Weight and size are crucial ─ Layered packaging approaches

cannot be used ─ Need to create sufficient room for

energy storage CardioARM for Cardiac Surgery: Consists of 50 rigid cylindrical links Photo courtesy: Biorobotics Lab, Carnegie Mellon University

Page 3: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Our Idea

• Competitive Manufacturing in US requires ─ Material choices ─ Shape and size complexity ─ Low lead time ─ High throughput rate ─ Reduced manual labor ─ Low environmental impact

Robotics

Injection Molding

Advanced Polymer Composites

3D Printing

Page 4: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

In-Mold Assembly: A New manufacturing Approach

• Introduce multiple materials in the mold sequentially ─ Change mold cavity between different molding stages

• Perform assembly and fabrication inside the mold ─ Mold acts as fabrication tool and assembly device

• Eliminate post-molding assembly ─ Attractive in markets where labor cost is high

This two degree of freedom gimbal comes out of mold fully

assembled (Work done at UMD)

Presence of an already molded component fundamentally changes the thermomechanical characteristics of the mold in the molding process

Page 5: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

In-Mold Assembly (Cont.)

• Traditional manufacturing ─ Fabricate individual parts ─ Assemble parts to create products

• Difficulties ─ Complex assembly operations need to be

done manually ─ Assembling small parts is very challenging

• Benefits of in-mold assembly ─ Eliminate assembly operations ─ Eliminate difficulty in assembling small

parts ─ Reduce part count/unit cost ─ Lower cycle time ─ Improve joint quality

Old Design – Fabrication & Assembly New Design – In-mold assembly

(Credit: Drs. Jayant Sirohi and Inderjit Chopra)

11 part assembly 5 part in-mold assembly

Page 6: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

In-Mold Assembly Methods

Final part The part has to be removed completely from the first mold and then

assembled into the second mold.

First stage Injection

After the first mold stage, the part has to be dismantled…

• Closing the mold • Injection of material • Opening the mold

• Closing the mold • Injection of material • Opening the mold

Second stage Injection

…and has to be assembled into the mold of the second mold stage

Cavity shape after completing first stage

Cavity shape before starting second stage

(a) moving a mold piece (b) removing partition (c) changing a mold piece

Cavity shapes need to change during molding before injecting second stage

Overmolding

Morphing Cavity

Page 7: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Spherical joint

In-Mold Assembled Joints

• We have developed mold design templates for successfully realizing revolute, prismatic, spherical, and universal joints using in-mold assembly

• We have developed methods to control shrinkage of the second stage part to provide the adequate joint clearances

Prismatic joint

Rotor structure

Revolute joints

Rigid Body Joints

Compliant Clip

Compliant members

Compliant Joints

• We have developed mold design templates for realizing variety of 1 DOF and 2 DOF compliant joints using in-mold assembly

• We have characterized the influence of interface geometry on the interface strength to optimize joint performance

A.K. Priyadarshi, S.K. Gupta, R. Gouker, F. Krebs, M. Shroeder, and S. Warth. Manufacturing multi-material articulated plastic products using in-mold assembly. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 32(3-4):350-365, March 2007.

R.M. Gouker, S.K. Gupta, H.A. Bruck, and T. Holzschuh. Manufacturing of multi-material compliant mechanisms using multi-material molding. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 30(11-12):1049-1075, 2006.

Page 8: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Use of In-Mold Assembly in Creating Embedded Electronics

• We used in-mold assembly process to successfully embed batteries, motors, and electronics in a multi-functional structure

• We have shown that embedded electronics exhibits superior resistance to mechanical and thermal impacts

Full circuitry embedded in polyurethane

Full circuitry embedded in ABS

Page 9: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Macroscale Assembly vs. Mesoscale Assembly

• Macroscale ─ Traditional manufacturing and

assembly is feasible ─ In-mold assembly reduces part

count ─ In-mold assembly will have cost

advantage for larger batch sizes

• Mesoscale (parts between 0.25 mm to 5 mm) ─ Traditional manufacturing and

assembly not possible for truly 3D assembly operations

─ In-mold assembly is the only solution without drastic part redesign

─ Definite cost advantage since cycle times are considerably lower and product possibilities extended

Page 10: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Realizing Polymer-Polymer Mesoscale Revolute Joints Using Two-Shot Molding

Page 11: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Mesoscale: Unacceptable pin deformation

Macroscale: Conventional methods may suffice

• Challenges at Mesoscale

• Modeling Plastic Deformations

First stage Injection

Second stage Injection

First stage part (ABS)

Second stage part (LDPE)

Example Defective Component

Side Core

In-Mold Assembly: Challenges at Mesoscale

Second stage Injection Location

Bent pins due to second stage injection

CFD analysis using FLUENT 6.3.26 for force modeling

Premolded component

Second stage melt

Structural analysis using ANSYS 11.0 for deformation modeling Distinction between macroscale and mesoscale

from the In-mold Assembly perspective Ananthanarayanan, A., Gupta, S.K., and Bruck, H.A., "Characterization of a Reverse Molding Sequence at the Mesoscale for In-mold Assembly of Revolute Joints" Journal of Polymer Engineering and Science, 50(9): 1843–1852, 2010.

+

Page 12: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Goals

• Identify defect modes unique to in-mold assembly at the mesoscale caused due to direct scaling down of macroscale molds

• Develop mold design solutions, to overcome defect modes that were identified

• Develop process models to characterize and control defects unique to mesoscale in-mold assembly

Component modeled for study

Part with Hole

Part with Pin

Pin diameter = 0.75 mm

Page 13: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

First Successful Demonstration

• Successful in-mold assembly of revolute joint with mesoscale features

• Pin dimensions

─ Modeled: 0.76 mm ─ Molded: 0.71 mm ─ Estimated Shrinkage: 6.6% ─ Length: 2.5 mm

First stage part (ABS)

Second stage part (LDPE)

Part with 0o

Rotation

Part with 90o

Rotation

Page 14: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

In-Mold Assembly: Two Alternative Methods

Gate 1

Second stage Injection First Stage Part

Second Stage Part

0º Orientation

90º Orientation

Side core used as a support structure

Gate Second stage part (LDPE)

Gate 2 0º Orientation 90º Orientation First stage part (ABS)

Second stage Injection

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7

Radial Support Length (mm)

Def

orm

atio

n (m

m)

ExperimentalFE Analysis

• In-mold Assembly using Radial Supports • In-mold Assembly using Bi-directional filling

Ananthanarayanan, A., Gupta, S.K., and Bruck, H.A., "Characterization and control of plastic deformation in mesoscale premolded components to realize in-mold assembled mesoscale revolute joints," Polymer Engineering and Science. 49(2), pp. 293-304, 2009

Ananthanarayanan A., Gupta S.K. and Bruck H.A., “Modeling and Characterization to Minimize Effects of Melt Flow Fronts on Premolded Component Deformation during In-Mold Assembly of Mesoscale Revolute Joints”, ASME Journal of Manufacturing Systems and Engineering, 132 (4): 041006, 2010.

Page 15: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Summary

• To best of our knowledge this was the first demonstration of in-mold assembly to create mesoscale revolute joint ─ No significant change in mold tooling costs because of in-mold assembly

process ─ Cycle times for the process is comparable with macroscale in-mold assembly

process • We have developed mold design solutions which enable constraining

premolded components to inhibit deformations ─ Characterization of forces on premolded component due to flow of molten

polymer around it ─ Characterization of plastic deformation of premolded component due to flow of

the molten polymer around it

Page 16: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Application in Minimally Invasive Neurosurgical Intracranial Robot (MINIR)

• Robot inserted through a surgical corridor carefully dissected by the neurosurgeon

• Tumor resection by liquefying tissue and washing out the debris

• Under direct control of human

• Targeting information obtained exclusively from frequently-updated MRI ─ Fully MRI-compatible device

• 0.3” – 0.5” diameter Envisioned MINIR system electro-cauterizing the tumor

Page 17: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Benefits

Two Different Orientations of In-Mold Assembled Robot Structure

• Mesoscale In-mold assembly strategies used to manufacture prototype robot

• Radial support length of 1.27 mm used for in-mold assembly of each module

• SMA wiring capability illustrated by placeholder 24 gage wires

Weight 1.9 Grams

Page 18: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Realizing Metal-Polymer Mesoscale Revolute Joints Using Insert Molding

Page 19: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

In-mold Assembly using Insert Molding

s

• Advantages ─ Single shot molding utilized for in-mold

assembly ─ Joint made of rigid material (metallic

insert) improves overall part quality Pins do not deform due to polymer flow

• Issues ─ Optimization of joint size to ensure

manufacturability ─ Joint jamming has to be controlled

0° Orientation 90° Orientation

Sprue

Metal insert

Runner

Cavities

Page 20: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Controlling Joint Parameters

• Smallest possible joint dimensions should be used to minimize joint size • Control joint friction due to radial stress • Prevent failure at weld-line

Where is the yield stress and FSWL is the ratio of the weld line strength to base material yσ

rrσ

Polymer flow during injection molding

Metallic cylindrical Insert

Weld-line

σθ

σrr

Main contributor to σrr Scaling parameter k = (R-r)/r

Page 21: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Experimental Verification

Acceptable thickness ratio

Joint successfully fabricated at mesoscale (joint radius = 0.4 mm)

• In-mold assembled joints manufactured using ABS polymer and brass inserts

Joint jammed at Macroscale (joint radius = 3.175 mm)

Joint torque increase with joint sizes

Hoop stress v/s thickness ratio

Alternate method required for using in-mold assembly method at macroscale

Page 22: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Reducing Joint Interference Stress

part made of softer polymer: Young’s modulus Es Base material:

Young’s modulus Eh

Radius: r

Radius: r’

σrr

Radius: R

Metallic cylindrical insert

• Step 1: Soft polymer molded on metallic insert ─ Initial radial interference stress σrr’ given

by

─ Outer radius (rPa) of the shim Decreases due to shrinkage Increases due to interference in the inner radius

• Step 2: Base material molded on top of soft polymer ─ Principal of superposition used to calculate

interference stresses ─ Final interference stress given by σrr

─ Final stress at the interface between shim and base material given by σint

σ = A-1 δ Where:

Page 23: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Macroscale In-mold Assembly: Results

• Analytical results show good agreement with finite element simulations to predict interface stresses

• Analytical formulation can therefore be used to predict joint stresses and thereby select joint parameters for manufacturing in-mold assembled macroscale revolute joints using insert molding method

Successful macroscale joint manufactured by combining insert molding and multi-material molding

Interface stress for different thickness ratios (k)

Page 24: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Step 1: Mold Assembly consisting of Metal inserts Step 2: Single Shot Injection Step 3 (a): Removal of Side Cores

Step 3 (b): Removal of Side Cores Step 4: Ejection Two different orientations of Neurosurgical Robot Structure

In-mold Assembly of MINIR using Insert Molding

A. Ananthanarayanan, L. Ehrlich, J.P. Desai, and S.K. Gupta. Design of revolute joints for in-mold assembly using insert molding. ASME Journal of Mechanical Design, 133(12):121010, Dec 2011.

Page 25: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Summary

• Designed and developed in-mold assembly strategies using insert molding

• Developed analytical formulations for determining joint interface stresses in in-mold assembled revolute joints

• Designed and developed a mold design for manufacturing a 9 degree of freedom articulating structure for use as a robot

Page 26: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Embedding Shape Memory Alloy Actuators in Articulated

Structures Using In Mold Assembly

Page 27: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Goals

• Design and develop molds for manufacturing an articulated miniature robot as an in-mold assembly using insert molding with embedded SMA

• Testing of SMA movement and force generation after the manufacturing process of the surgical robot

Page 28: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Molded articulated miniature robot

with embedded actuators

Page 29: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Actuated articulated miniature robot after in-mold assembly

• Successful actuation of each joint of the robot in both directions • Generation of sufficient force to smoothly actuate the joint

A. Ananthanarayanan, L. Ehrlich, M. Ho, J.P. Desai and S.K. Gupta. Embedding Shape Memory Allow Actuators in Miniature Articulating Polymer Structures Using In-Mold Assembly. North American Manufacturing Research Conference, Notre Dame, IN, June 2012

Page 30: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Realizing Multi-Material Miniature Mechanisms Using In-Mold Assembly

Page 31: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

5 mm

Hinge displacement due to lack of positioning features

Challenges

• Hinge has to provide the desired range of motion

• Structure has to transfer loads • Materials need to be connected • Hinge has to be accurately positioned

for in-mold assembly • Miniature scale of the mechanism can

impose additional space constraints Link fracture examples

Hinge fracture examples

5 mm

1 mm

5 mm

Anchoring feature shearing Anchoring feature plastic deformation

Page 32: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Identification of Hinge Geometry

• Necessary hinge geometries ─ Flexing section

Enable rotation Transfer load Flash prevention Fatigue resistance

─ Positioning feature Positioning inside 2nd stage mold

─ Interlocking features Hinge anchoring in the link Load transfer

• Encapsulating link volume

X-Y:

X-Z:

X-Y:

Y-Z:

X-Y:

Y-Z:

X-Y:

X

Y

Z

Page 33: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Identification of Hinge Geometry (Cont.)

• Parametric model for optimization ─ Number of parameters: 15 ─ Number of constraints: 7

Feature Symbol Description

Hinge Active

Section

tA Thickness (symm. wrt. rot. axis) bA Breadth (along rot. axis) LA Length (for the range of motion) rHIN Hinge arc radius

Hinge Embedded

Section

LEHi Length (along LA direction) hIP Interlocking protrusion height bIP Interlocking protrusion breadth LIP Interlocking protrusion length rIP Interlocking protrusion radius bIV Interlocking void breadth tIV Thickness around interlocking void

hPOS Positioning protrusion height rPOS Positioning protrusion radius

Link Connection

LEL Hinge encapsulating length bEL Encapsulating breadth tEL Encapsulating thickness rEL Link ending radius

Fn# Formula Description g1 tA<<bA Define the rotation axis g2 tA>tAMIN Constrain the remaining DOF g3 AA>σA

MAX/σT Load-guided cross-section area: AA=tA*bA

g4 LEH<LEL<LEMAX Maximum embedded lengths (functional

space constraint)

g5 AITOT ≥ AA

Minimum total interlocking area AI

TOT=2*[(LIP*hIP)+(tA*bIP)]+(bIV*tA) g6 bIP ≥ hIP Prevent shearing of interlocking protrusion g7 tA,tIV,rIP,rPOS≥tTOOL

MIN Size constraints from tool size

Hinge parametric model: Parameters

Hinge parametric model: Constraints

Page 34: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Overall Approach

Elaborate Mechanism

Shape

Mechanism Concept

Manufacturability Rules

Design Requirements

Determine Joint

Geometry Interconnection of Miniature Hinges

Mechanism Parametric Model

Hinge Parametric Model

Compliant joints Rocker

Crank

Wing supports

Rigid links

Prismatic joint

Rigid body revolute joints

Page 35: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Parametric Optimization Mechanism Design Level

• Mechanism Design Analysis: ─ Kinematic analysis (ADAMS)

─ Finite element analysis (ProMechanica)

• Results:

Kinematic Simulation

Model

Drive Mechanism

Shape

Experimental Forces

Boundary Conditions

Estimate Force

Distribution

Parametric Model

Calculate Stress Distribution

Final Mechanism Design

Modify Elements with Exceeded

Stresses

Strength Constraints

Satisfactory Factor of Safety?

No

Yes

Manufacturability Constraints

New Model

Constant Velocity (BC)

Thrust (BC)

Lift (BC)

Reaction Forces (Outputs)

Lift (BC)

Reaction Forces (Output)

A B C

D E

F

Component Applied to Unit Value X A N -1.159 Y A N -32.767 Z A N -1.559 X C N 0.026 Y C N 31.141

Mechanism Design Optimization Flowchart

Variable Unit Value Rocker thickness mm 2.1 Rocker breadth mm 2.5 Wing arm thickness mm 2.5 Wing arm breadth mm 5.1 Hinge encapsulation thickness mm 7.5 Hinge encapsulation breadth mm 5.0

Page 36: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Parametric Optimization Hinge Design Level

• Optimization approach:

• Results:

Objective Functions

Process Cost Part Weight (Volume)

Constraints Functional

Space Load Transfer

Range of Motion

Process

Molding Feature Size

Design Features

Hinge and Link-bar Connection Hinge Geometry

Variables Hinge Design

Parametric Model

Design Optimization

LA LEH1 LEH2

LIP

rIP rPOS hPOS

bIP

tIV

tA

hIP bA

bIV

rHIN

LDPE

HIPP

Variable Symbol Value Hinge thickness tA 1.10 Hinge breadth bA 5.59 Hinge length LA 0.51 Interlocking protrusion height hIP 0.65 Interlocking protrusion breadth bIP 0.80 Interlocking protrusion length LIP 6.94 Thickness around interlocking void tIV 0.80

Variable Symbol Value Hinge thickness tA 0.79 Hinge length LA 1.52 Hinge radius hHIN 1.27 Interlocking protrusion length LIP 5.59

Hinge Design Parametric Model

Page 37: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Example of Optimized Assembly

• Hinge design optimized for MAV drive mechanism ─ Transferring torque from high-power brushless motor to the wings ─ High-impact polypropylene as hinge material

Variable Symbol Value Unit Hinge thickness tA 0.79 mm Hinge breadth bA 5.59 mm Hinge length LA 1.52 mm Hinge radius hHIN 1.27 mm Interlocking protrusion height hIP 0.65 mm Interlocking protrusion breadth bIP 0.80 mm Interlocking protrusion length LIP 5.59 mm Interlocking void breadth bIV 2.50 mm Thickness around interlocking void tIV 0.80 mm Hinge encapsulation length LEL 5.00 mm Hinge encapsulation breadth bEL 1.00 mm Hinge encapsulation thickness tEL 0.75 mm LA LEH1 LEH2

LIP

rIP rPOS hPOS

bIP

tIV

tA

hIP bA

bIV

rHIN

Rigid Link

Hinge

rEL tEL

bEL

LEL

Link Volume Extended to Encapsulate the Hinge

Multi-Material Mechanism with 7 Links and 6 Hinges

Page 38: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Gate and Runner Design

• Goals ─ Ensure mold filling ─ Provide for required flow patterns

• First stage molding (hinge) ─ Film gate aligned with hinge rotation axis ─ Sacrificial features supporting demolding

• Second stage molding (mechanism) ─ Gate location constrained with respect to

the properties of second stage filled polymer moldings (fiber alignment)

─ Multi-link compliant mechanism in-mold assembly results in multi-cavity molds with complex runner system Multi-Material

Compliant Frame

Sprue Increased Diameter of the Long Runners to Minimize Flow Resistance

Sacrificial Features

Compliant Hinge

Film Gate

Runner

Side Gates (circled)

Runner System

W. Bejgerowski, J.W. Gerdes, S.K. Gupta, and H.A. Bruck. Design and fabrication of a miniature compliant hinges for multi-material compliant mechanisms. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 57(5):437-452, 2011.

Page 39: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Creating Flapping Wing Micro Air Vehicles

• Attributes of fixed wing flight ─ High forward speeds required for generating lift ─ Low maneuverability ─ Difficult to operate in confined spaces

• Attributes of rotary wing flight ─ Low forward speeds and hovering possible ─ High frequency leads to noisy operation

• Attributes of flapping wing flight ─ Low frequency flapping leads to quiet flight ─ Low forward speeds lead to high maneuverability ─ Ability to use in surveillance operations

Page 40: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Results

• Successful in-mold assembly of multi-material compliant MAV drive frame

• MAV tested to be capable of: ─ Remote launch from a four-wheel RC vehicle ─ Sustained outdoor flight with controlled ascent,

descent, and steering ─ Controlled landing in a safe area ─ High degree of realism (falcon attacks)

Sprue and Runner System

Multi-Material Drive Frame

Parameter Unit Value

Weight g 38.0

Payload Capacity g 32.0

Flapping Frequency Hz 5.2

Wing Area cm2 920.2

Wing Span cm 63.5

Flight Duration* min 20

Flight Velocity m/s 3.0 *with 21.1g 3x250mAh-cell li-po battery pack

Page 41: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Video

• J.W. Gerdes, K.C. Cellon, H.A. Bruck, S.K. Gupta. Characterization of the mechanics of compliant wing designs for flapping-wing miniature air vehicles. Experimental Mechanics, Accepted for publication. • J.W. Gerdes, S.K. Gupta, and S. Wilkerson. A review of bird-inspired flapping wing miniature air vehicle designs. ASME Journal of Mechanism and Robotics, 4(2), 021003.1-021003.11, 2012. • W. Bejgerowski, J.W. Gerdes, S.K. Gupta, and H.A. Bruck. Design and fabrication of miniature compliant hinges for multi-material compliant mechanisms. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing

Technology, 57(5):437-452, 2011. • D. Mueller, H.A. Bruck, and S.K. Gupta. Measurement of thrust and lift forces associated with drag of compliant flapping wing for micro air vehicles using a new test stand design. Experimental Mechanics,

50(6):725–735, 2010. • W. Bejgerowski, J.W. Gerdes, S.K. Gupta, H.A. Bruck, and S. Wilkerson. Design and fabrication of a multi-material compliant flapping wing drive mechanism for miniature air vehicles. ASME Mechanism and

Robotics Conference, Montreal, Canada, August 2010. • D. Mueller, J. Gerdes, and S.K. Gupta. Incorporation of passive wing folding in flapping wing miniature air vehicles. ASME Mechanism and Robotics Conference, San Diego, August 30-September 2, 2009. • W. Bejgerowski, A. Ananthanarayanan, D. Mueller, and S.K. Gupta. Integrated product and process design for a flapping wing drive-mechanism. ASME Journal of Mechanical Design, 131: 061006, 2009.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJmeFKf0l-g

Page 42: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Summary

• Established technical feasibility for creating multi-material compliant structures with miniature hinges using injection molding process

• Developed design optimization approach for creating multi-material compliant mechanisms using multi-material molding

• Implementation on a successfully flying MAV

Page 43: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Embedding Actuators in Thermally Conducting Polymers Using In-Mold

Assembly

Page 44: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Motivation

• Low heat dissipation from actuators embedded in structures of traditional unfilled polymers ─ Excessive heat can overheat and damage the structure

• Can emerging thermally conductive polymer composites help to overcome this issue?

Minimally Invasive Neurosurgical Intracranial Robot (MINIR)

UMD “Small bird” Micro Air Vehicle

Page 45: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Thermally Conductive Polymer Composites

• Easily injection-molded • Thermal conductivities an order of magnitude higher then bulk

polymers • Adding function to part structure – heat dissipation • Thermal and mechanical characteristics

depend on filler orientation

Measure Units Grilamid L16 NJ-6000 TC Test Method

Density kg·m−3 1010 1610 ASTM D792

Thermal Conductivity W·m-1·K-1 0.22 11 ASTM C177

Tensile Strength MPa 42 110 ASTM D638

Elongation at Break % 275 1.9 ASTM D638

Flexural Modulus GPa 1.3 22.2 ASTM D790

Flexural Strength MPa 59 109 ASTM D790

Melt Temperature Range °C 190 to 270 260 to 277

Page 46: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Using In-Mold Assembly for Embedding DC Motor

• In-mold assembly of a simple gearbox-like structure: ─ Didel “Blue SS” 7mm DC pager motor (max 1.5 W) ─ brass sleeve for output shaft

• Pager motor produces heat ─ will overheat and fail when embedded in regular bulk polymer

• In-mold assembly challenge: ─ Preliminary experiments showed excessive motor housing deformation due to

polymer pressure during injection molding

Cavity for motor cables

Mold half Brass sleeve

DC motor

Fill cavity

Page 47: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Embedding DC Motor Process Optimization

• Determination of injection pressure: ─ Ansys model of the motor housing

─ FEA to obtain allowable injection pressure

10.6 4 1 0.4

3.1 3.5

zero-displ. B.C.

pressure B.C.

Page 48: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Embedding DC Motor Temperature Measurement

• In-mold assembled samples:

• Motor temperature measurement: ─ Constant load applied to motor shaft ─ Power generation (1.5W) controlled by voltage and current

• Results: ─ Unfilled Nylon12 (Grilamid L16): 96.0 C ─ Filled Nylon12 (NJ-6000 TC): 65.5 C Motor embedded in unfilled polymer

runs 46% hotter! W. Bejgerowski, S.K. Gupta, and H.A. Bruck. A systematic approach for designing multi-functional thermally conducting polymer structures with embedded actuators. ASME Journal of Mechanical Design, 131(11): 111009, 2009.

Page 49: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Summary

• Thermally conducting polymers show significantly improved

thermal performance compared to unfilled polymers • Demonstrated applicability of thermally conductive polymers

towards creating multi-functional structures with embedded actuators using in-mold assembly

Page 50: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Conclusions

• In-mold assembly enables large design space ─ Bio-compatible polymers ─ Parts with small features

• In-mold assembly enables realization of joints to transfer power and motion ─ Revolute, Prismatic, Spherical

• In-mold assembly enables embedding of prefabricated components in the structure without damaging them ─ Actuators, Batteries, Sensors

Robotics

Injection Molding

Advanced Polymer Composites

3D Printing

In-mold assembly brings together many exciting developments in manufacturing

Page 51: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Future Directions

• In-situ in-mold assembly for repair and on-the-site structure modifications

• Integrating energy harvesting technologies in molds • Modular robotics components for cavity morphing • Continuous cavity morphing • Further Miniaturization • Managing anisotropy in composites

Page 52: Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scalesskgupta/AssemblyAutomation_Seminar.pdf · Towards Assembly Automation at Small Size Scales Satyandra K. Gupta Mechanical Engineering

Acknowledgements

• Students ─ Arvind Ananthanarayanan ─ Wojciech Bejgerowski ─ Leicester Ehrlich ─ John Gerdes ─ Dominik Mueller

• Collaborators ─ Hugh Bruck, Jaydev Desai, and Stephen Wilkerson

• Sponsors ─ AFOSR, ARO, NIH, and NSF