to what ends eu foreign policy? contending approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 thomas and...

16
UCD Dublin European Institute DEI Working Paper 11-2 To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to the Union’s Diplomatic Objectives and Representation Daniel C. Thomas and Ben Tonra

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

UCD Dublin European Institute

DEI Working Paper 11-2

To What Ends EU Foreign Policy?

Contending Approaches to the Union’s Diplomatic Objectives and

Representation

Daniel C. Thomas and Ben Tonra

Page 2: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

Working Paper: © Daniel C. Thomas and Ben Tonra 2011

This paper should be cited as follows: Daniel C. Thomas and Ben Tonra, To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to the Union’s Diplomatic Objectives and Representation, UCD Dublin European Institute Working Paper 11-2, July 2011.

All opinions expressed are the sole responsibility of the authors.

Cover Photo: © European Union

About the Authors

Daniel C. Thomas is Associate Professor of European Governance in the School of

Politics and International Relations and Director of the Dublin European Institute,

both at University College Dublin. Contact: [email protected]

Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security and

Defence Policy and Associate Professor of International Relations at the UCD School of

Politics and International Relations. Contact: [email protected]

About the Dublin European Institute

The Dublin European Institute (DEI) supports scholarly research and debate on the

sources, processes and implications of European integration and governance. Based

within the School of Politics and International Relations at University College Dublin,

the DEI is the oldest and largest university centre for research on European affairs in

the Republic of Ireland.

For more information, see: http://www.ucd.ie/dei or contact: Dublin European

Institute, UCD School of Politics and International Relations, University College

Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, IRELAND

Page 3: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!"#$%&'!&($#)*+,$-)(%!

"#$!%&'$()&#$(*()!+,!&#$!-.!/*)#!0$1'$%$(&2&*3$!,+'!4+'$*)(!5,,2*'%!2(6!7$89'*&:!;+<*8:!=/0>!

2(6! &#$! <29(8#! +,! &#$! -9'+1$2(! -?&$'(2<! 58&*+(! 7$'3*8$! =--57>! 2'$! *(&$(6$6! &+! #$<1! &#$!

-9'+1$2(! .(*+(! 28#*$3$! 2! 8+@@+(! $,,$8&*3$! 1'$%$(8$! *(! A+'<6! 2,,2*'%B! C$&! &#$%$!

*(%&*&9&*+(2<!*((+32&*+(%!8+D$?*%&!A*&#!2!%&9EE+'(!+E%&28<$!&+!,+'$*)(!1+<*8:!@2F*()!2&!&#$!-.!

<$3$<G!&#$!,28&!&#2&!@$@E$'!%&2&$%!+,&$(!#23$!6*3$')$(&!1+<*8:!1'$,$'$(8$%!2(6!$28#!'$&2*(%!

2! 3$&+! +3$'! -.! ,+'$*)(! 1+<*8:! *(*&*2&*3$%B! 7+! $3$(! &#+9)#! &#$! -.! (+A! #2%! @+'$! '+E9%&!

@$8#2(*%@%!,+'!6*1<+@28:H!2(6!&#$!'$3*%$6!"'$2&:!+(!-9'+1$2(!.(*+(!'$D8+@@*&%!@$@E$'!

%&2&$%! &+! 19'%9$! 8+@@+(! 1+<*8*$%H! &#$! 8#2<<$()$! +,! '$28#*()! 2)'$$@$(&! *%! 9(<*F$<:! &+!

6*%211$2'B!!

!

I(!266*&*+(H!&#$!($A!/*)#!0$1'$%$(&2&*3$J%!,*'%&!&A+!:$2'%!*(!+,,*8$!#23$!E$$(!%9''+9(6$6!E:!

8+(&'+3$'%:!K!%+@$!%19''$6!E:!&#+%$!A#+!E$<*$3$!&#2&!%#$!%#+9<6!E$!@+'$!1'+D28&*3$H!2(6!

%+@$!E:!&#+%$!A#+!A+9<6!1'$,$'!&#2&!@$@E$'!%&2&$%!'$&2*(!8+(&'+<!+3$'!-.!,+'$*)(!1+<*8:BL

!

798#!,'9%&'2&*+(!A*&#!5%#&+(J%!1$',+'@2(8$!*%!1$'#21%!*($3*&2E<$H!)*3$(!&#2&!%#$!A2%!)*3$(!

&#$!%91$'D#9@2(!&2%F!+,!@2(2)*()!&#$!8'$2&*+(!+,! &#$!--57!,'+@!2!32'*$&:!+,!1'$D$?*%&*()!

+')2(*%2&*+(%!A*&#*(!&#$!M+9(8*<!%$8'$&2'*2&!2(6!-9'+1$2(!M+@@*%%*+(!A#*<$!%*@9<&2($+9%<:!

'$1'$%$(&*()! &#$! .(*+(! 2E'+26! 2(6! 1'+@+&*()! 2)'$$@$(&! 2@+()! *&%!@$@E$'! %&2&$%! 2(6!

*(%&*&9&*+(%B! N9&! &#$! 8+(&'+3$'%:! 2<%+! '$,<$8&%! &#$! *(%&*&9&*+(2<! 8+@1<$?*&:! +,! &#$! /*)#!

0$1'$%$(&2&*3$J%! 692<D#2&&$6! 1+%*&*+(! 2&! &#$! ($?9%! +,! %&'9))<$%! ,+'! 1+A$'! 2(6! *(,<9$(8$!

2@+()!@$@E$'!%&2&$%!2(6!-.!*(%&*&9&*+(%B!

!

5826$@*8! %8$1&*8%! #23$! <+()! 2')9$6! &#2&! &#$! -.! #2%! '$28#$6! &#$! <*@*&%! +,! O)+3$'(2(8$!

A*&#+9&! )+3$'(@$(&J! 2(6! 82((+&! #23$! 2! '$2<! ,+'$*)(! 1+<*8:! 9(<$%%! *&! E$8+@$%! 2! %&2&$G! P5!

-9'+1$2(! ,+'$*)(! 1+<*8:! 8+9<6! +(<:! E$! 28#*$3$6! E:! 8'$2&*()! 8$(&'2<! *(%&*&9&*+(%! A*&#*(! 2!

-9'+1$2(! .(*+(! 8212E<$! +,! *6$(&*,:*()H! %$<$8&*()H! 2(6! *@1<$@$(&*()! 2! 8+#$'$(&! %$&! +,!

+EQ$8&*3$%R!&#*%!8+9<6!+(<:!E$!28#*$3$6!E:!&#$!$%&2E<*%#@$(&!+,!2!-9'+1$2(!%&2&$!2(6!#$(8$!

2! -9'+1$2(!)+3$'(@$(&ST

!5(6!:$&!6$%1*&$! &#$%$! 8#2<<$()$%H!A$!F(+A! &#2&! &#$!-.!2)'$$%!

2(6! *@1<$@$(&%! #9(6'$6%! +,! 8+@@+(! ,+'$*)(! 1+<*8:! 28&*+(%! 1$'! :$2'! 2(6! &#2&! &#$! -.!

,'$U9$(&<:! %1$2F%! A*&#! 2! %*()<$! 3+*8$B! 7+! #+A! 6+! -.! @$@E$'! %&2&$%! 2''*3$! 2&! 8+@@+(!

1+<*8*$%!'$)2'6*()!*%%9$%!2(6!28&+'%!E$:+(6!&#$*'!8+<<$8&*3$!$?&$'(2<!E+'6$'V!W#2&!*%!&#$!'+<$!

+,!&#$!/*)#!0$1'$%$(&2&*3$!*(!&#*%!'$)2'6V!

!

"#$!1+*(&!+,!&#*%!121$'! *%!(+&!&+!+,,$'!2!%*()<$!2(%A$'!&+!&#$!U9$%&*+(!+,!-.!,+'$*)(!1+<*8:!

6$<*E$'2&*+(!2(6!'$1'$%$(&2&*+(H!E9&!&+!1'+1+%$!2(!2(2<:&*82<!%&'98&9'$!,+'!'$%$2'8#!*(!&#*%!

2'$2B!"#$!121$'!1'$%$(&%!%$3$(!6*%&*(8&!@+6$<%!6'2A(!,'+@!&#'$$!211'+28#$%!&+!-9'+1$2(!

)+3$'(2(8$B!;2'&! II!+,! &#$!121$'!1'$%$(&%! &A+!@+6$<%! *(%1*'$6!E:!2(! I(&$')+3$'(@$(&2<*%&!

211'+28#X! ;2'&! III! 1'$%$(&%! &A+!@+6$<%! *(%1*'$6! E:! 2!Y+'@2&*3$! I(%&*&9&*+(2<*%&! 211'+28#X!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

L

!5(6'$A!W*<<*%H!ON$<)*2(!@*(*%&$'!19E<*8<:!2&&28F%!-.!,+'$*)(!'$<2&*+(%!8#*$,HJ!!"#$%&'(&'H!Z![2:!T\LLB!5(6'$A!

0$&&@2(H!O[-;%!6$,$(6!5%#&+(!,'+@!-.!@$@E$'!%&2&$%HJ!!"#$%&'(&'H!LL![2:!T\LLB!I2(!"'2:(+'H!O-.!,+'$*)(!

@*(*%&$'%!'+9(6!+(!]26:!5%#&+(HJ!)*&+,-.'/0.1H!T^![2:!T\LLB!

T

!_23*6!5<<$(H!2*3+45&.6%+73'+!-'35&!*(!`+#(!;$&$'%+(H!/$<$($!7Q9'%$(H!8+93::31+;3'&0<1+=3>0?@+73'+!-'35&A+93:5&B01<+(0%031%+73'+9;4=!=0+9&<$6)$G!]+(6+(!2(6!Y$A!C+'FH!Laab>H!1Bcd!!

Page 4: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$%!&#'(!)*!+',-,$(-!(.',,!/0%,1-!2$-+2',%!34!50$-('67(282-(!#$%!9072010:27#1!)$-(2(6(20$#12-(!#++'0#7.,-;!!

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

!N.,-,!#--6/+(20$-!',:#'%2$:!(.,!+',=,',$7,-!#$%!7#1761#(20$-!0=!/,/3,'!-(#(,-!1,#%!(0!(.,!,E+,7(#(20$! (.#(! B.27.,8,'! /,/3,'! -(#(,! 2-! 1,#-(! ',7,+(28,! (0! 7.#$:,! B211! %0/2$#(,! CH!=0',2:$!+01274!34!(.',#(,$2$:!(0!8,(0!#$4!+'0+0-#1!(.#(!2-!=6'(.,'!='0/!(.,!-(#(6-!Q60!(.#$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!M!N.,-,!-,8,$!/0%,1-!%0!$0(!#%%',--!(.,!J2:.!K,+',-,$(#(28,D-!'01,>-?!2$!(.,!2/+1,/,$(#(20$!0'!+6'-62(!0=!CH!=0',2:$!+01274;!

P!9(#$1,4!J0==/#$$@! RS3-(2$#(,!0'!S3-01,(,T!N.,!U#(,!0=! (.,!O#(20$!9(#(,!#$%!(.,!5#-,!0=!V,-(,'$!C6'0+,D@!40$#0%56@! 801;! WX@! $0;M@! FWYY@! ++;! ZY"IWFX;! <$%',B![0'#87-2A@! 78$& )8"-9$& :"1& ;51"+$& >)(.#7#@! O\]! 50'$,11!H$28,'-2(4!&',--@!FWWW?;!

Page 5: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$%! &'(! #)*+,! -&,#./01! 2(! &$3*4! '&4)%5! +%! ,&(6! +%! .&77&(! -&,#.#*%! 4*89#4*! 9(+(#7&9%!

%9--&4$5!:$3*!;<!'#,,!=*!3+7-*4*)000!=/!$3*!.&(%$+($!$34*+$!&>!3+?#(6!&(*!&>!#$%!(97*4&9%!

7*7=*4! %$+$*%! =4*+@! >4&7! #$%! 4+(@%A0B! C%! +! 4*%9,$5! $3*! ;<! '#,,! 3+?*! )#>>#.9,$/! +.$#(6!

)*.#%#?*,/5!#>!+$!+,,5!#(!'&4,)!+>>+#4%0!!

!

D3#%!+--4&+.3!#%!.&(%#%$*($!'#$3!$34**!-&%%#=,*!-&,#./!&9$.&7*%E!(&(F)*.#%#&(5!)*+),&.@!+()!

,&'*%$! .&77&(! )*(&7#(+$&40! G3*4*! 7*7=*4! %$+$*%H! -&,#./! -4*>*4*(.*%! +4*! 79$9+,,/!

*I.,9%#?*5! $3*/!7+/! .3&&%*! $&!@**-! $3*! #%%9*!&>>! $3*!;<!+6*()+!J!+(!&9$.&7*!&(*!.&9,)!

4*>*4! $&! +%! (&(F)*.#%#&(0! K45! .&7-*$#$#?*! =+46+#(#(6! &?*4! 79$9+,,/F*I.,9%#?*! -4*>*4*(.*%!

7+/! -4*?*($! $3*! +)&-$#&(! &>! +(/! .&77&(! -&,#./! J! +(! &9$.&7*! @(&'(! +%! )*+),&.@0! 2(!

.&($4+%$5!'3*4*!$3*!)#%+64**7*($!&>!$3*!7*7=*4!%$+$*%!#%!+!7+$$*4!&>!)*64**5!.&7-*$#$#?*!

=+46+#(#(6!'#,,! 4*%9,$! #(!+64**7*($!&(!'3+$*?*4!-&,#./! #%!+..*-$+=,*! $&!+,,!7*7=*4! %$+$*%!

+()!.,&%*%$!$&!$3*!#)*+,!&9$.&7*!&>!$3*!&(*!,*+%$!4*.*-$#?*!$&!.3+(6*0!D3#%!,&'*%$!.&77&(!

)*(&7#(+$&4! LMNOP! -&,#./! 7+/! 4*>,*.$! +64**7*($! (&$! $&! .3+(6*! +(! *I#%$#(6! -&,#./! &4!

+64**7*($!&(!+!(*'!-&,#./!$3+$!4*>,*.$%!$3*!-4*>*4*(.*%!&>!$3*!7&%$!.&(%*4?+$#?*!7*7=*4!

%$+$*L%P0!

!

D3#%!*I-,+(+$#&(!>&4!;<!>&4*#6(!-&,#./!&9$.&7*%!.+(!=*!4*-4*%*($*)!+%!>&,,&'%E!

!

!"#$%&$'()*$+,$%)-(.($)/%$0$%$'1$2)3)4$(5)5/("5')! )65+/$("("#$)7.%&."'"'&)! )85'9:$1"2"5';)!$.:<51=)5%)>5?$2()65++5')!$'5+"'.(5%))!

D3*! -4*.&()#$#&(! >&4! $3#%! 7&)*,H%! *I-*.$+$#&(%! #%! $3+$! $3*! 7+@#(6! &>! .&77&(! -&,#.#*%!

4*89#4*%!9(+(#7&9%! %9--&4$! >4&7!7*7=*4! %$+$*%0! 2>! $3#%!-4*.&()#$#&(!'*4*!*,#7#(+$*)!=/!

$4*+$/! .3+(6*%! L+! 7&?*! $3+$! 2($*46&?*4(7*($+,#%7! '&9,)! .&(%#)*4! 9(,#@*,/P5! $3*(! $3*%*!

*I-*.$+$#&(%!'&9,)!3+?*!$&!=*!4*?#%*)0!!

!

2>! $3*! .&7-*$#$#?*!=+46+#(#(6!7&)*,! #%! .&44*.$5! +()!;<! >&4*#6(!-&,#./! #%! )&7#(+$*)!=/! $3*!

-4*>*4*(.*%!+()!?*$&! $34*+$%!&>!7*7=*4! %$+$*%! F!7&%$! ,#@*,/! $3*!=#6!&(*%! F! $3*(! $3*!Q#63!

R*-4*%*($+$#?*!+()! $3*!;;CS!'&9,)!3+?*! ,#$$,*! #(>,9*(.*!&?*4! $3*! $#7#(6!&4!.&($*($!&>!;<!

.&77&(!>&4*#6(!-&,#.#*%0!K(!$3*!&$3*4!3+()5! $3*!7&)*,! #%!+6(&%$#.!'#$3!4*6+4)!$&! $3*!QR!

+()! ;;CSH! 4&,*! #(! $3*! 4*-4*%*($+$#&(! +()! #7-,*7*($+$#&(! &>! '3+$*?*4! -&,#.#*%! 7*7=*4!

%$+$*%!+64**5!+%!$3*/!7+/!>#()!#$!.&(?*(#*($!$&!)*,*6+$*!$3*%*!>9(.$#&(%!$&!$3*!%9-4+(+$#&(+,!

,*?*,0!

!

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'(&)"*+,"%%-.*&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!T&%*-3!T9-#,,*5!UD3*!;94&-*+(!<(#&(!+()!2($*4(+$#&(+,!K9$.&7*%H!/.0$,.10-".1%&2,*1.-310-".5!?&,0!1"5!(&0!V5!WXXX5!--0!YZXFYV10![4#$\!S.3+4->5!UD3*!T&#($FO*.#%#&(!D4+-E!M*%%&(%!>4&7!]*47+(![*)*4+,#%7!+()!;94&-*+(!

2($*64+$#&(H5!456%-7&8#9-.-:0,10-".;!?&,0!BB5!(&0!"5!WX^^5!--0!V"XF_^0!B!S&-3#*!`*9(#*45!UG3+$!S#(6,*!a&#.*b!;94&-*+(!2(%$#$9$#&(%!+()!;<F<S!D4+)*!c*6&$#+$#&(%H5!/.0$,.10-".1%&2,*1.-310-".5!?&,0!1Y5!(&0!W5!VZZZ5!--0!WZ"FW"15!-0W"V0!!

Page 6: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$%! &'()*! '+! ,-.%/('0%/-1%-.2&)31! 4'%3! -'.! !"#"$$%&'()! )-4)*2.%! .$2.! 56! +'/%)(-! 7'&)*8!'9.*'1%3!:)&&!/%+&%*.!.$%!7/%+%/%-*%3!'+!.$%!1'3.!*'-3%/02.)0%!0%.'!7&28%/3!'-!.$%!)339%!2.!$2-4;! <%*)7/'*).8! )3! 2! 3.2-42/4! %=7%*.2.)'-! )-! /%&2.)'-3! 21'-(! 3.2.%3>! %37%*)2&&8! )-!)-3.).9.)'-2&)3%4!/%&2.)'-3$)73!.$2.!%-49/%!'0%/!.)1%;!?'!*%/.2)-!*'-3.%&&2.)'-3!'+!)339%3!2-4!7/%+%/%-*%3! *'9&4! */%2.%! )-*%-.)0%3! +'/! 1%1@%/! 3.2.%3! .'! &)-A! *'-*%33)'-3! '-! '++B3%..)-(!+'/%)(-! 7'&)*8! )339%3! 2-4! .$93! 2*$)%0%! 19.92&! (2)-3! .$2.! 20')4! .$%! 48-21)*3! 2-4!*'-3%C9%-*%! '+! *'17%.).)0%! @2/(2)-)-(;D! #$)3! /%*)7/'*).8! *'9&4! @%! %).$%/! E37%*)+)*F! '/!E4)++93%F;G!!

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

!!"#$%&$'()*$+,$%)-(.($)/%$0$%$'1$2)3)4$1"/%51"(6)! )75&8%599"'&)! ):&%$$+$'()!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!D!P%2.$%/!5&A'!T*U)@@%->!E,339%!I$2/2*.%/)3.)*3>!,339%!V)-A2(%>!2-4!?.2.%3!I$')*%!'+!W2/(2)-)-(!?./2.%()%3!)-!.$%!59/'7%2-!6-)'-F>!-./&!%(+.0+1/&.2"%!+3/4('#+3.('#)>!0'&;!XD>!-';!Y>!Z[X[>!77;!\J\BD[J;!G!<'@%/.!];!U%'$2-%>!E<%*)7/'*).8!)-!)-.%/-2.)'-2&!/%&2.)'-3F>!5!,"&!%,'.!%(+6&7%!'8%,'.!9+0'&;!"[>!-';!X>!XJG\>!77;!!XBZD;!J!#$'123!U^-)(!2-4!_)/A!`9-(%>!Ea$8!_'-F.!Q%.'!R&28%/3!63%!#$%)/!R':%/bF>!1/&.2"%!+:!'.!+3.(','#$>!0'&;!X[>!-';!">!Z[[J>!77;!Y[DBYc">!2@3./2*.;!!

Page 7: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

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`'+)#;!_5!K&1$'(9!]IA%;')+)+,!ID!Y1-#),+!V1;)/?L!E1-$'2)8#!B+(2)2:2)1+';)($!'+.!H;2#-+'2)8#!H%%-1'/&#(9=&62-$+2,-."2,%&;"%.-.549!81;5!ab9!+15!a9!OGGZ9!%%5!PPZJ"c5!Y-'+4!d/&)$$#;0#++),!'+.!`'+)#;!_5!K&1$'(9!]E1-$'2)8#!)+(2)2:2)1+';)($!'+.!ID!Y1-#),+!V1;)/?!)+!_1$%'-'2)8#!V#-(%#/2)8#=9!62-$+2,-."2,%&;"%.-.549!81;5!ab9!+15!a9!OGGZ9!%%5!aZFJ"Ga5!FO!_1:+/);!10!2&#!I:-1%#'+!D+)1+5!B&<$57+$&C7+"*$&.2&,&D$--$+&E"+%#(&C7+"*$,2&<$57+.-:&<-+,-$1:5!\-:((#;(9!FO!`#/#$3#-!OGGP5!

Page 8: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$%&'(#$)!*+,!,-.,%*/*#0$!*+/*!1,12,3!4*/*,4!5#&&!$0*!1/6,!%011#*1,$*4!2,703,!*+,!8$#0$!+/4! (,&#2,3/*,(9! %0$7#(,$*#/&#*:! #$! *+,! '4,! 07! 4+/3,(! #$7031/*#0$9! /$(! (,%#4#0$;1/6#$)! 2:!%0$4,$4'4<! #$%&'(#$)!*+,!/=0#(/$%,!07!>'/&#7#,(!1/?03#*:!=0*#$)!,=,$!5+,3,! #*! #4!.,31#**,(!2:!*3,/*:@AB!C,$%,!*+,!*,$(,$%:!/10$)!4%+0&/34!*0!3,7,3!*0!/!D%0$4'&*/*#0$!3,7&,-E!4+/3,(!2:!703,#)$!.0&#%:!1/6,34!#$!F8!G,12,3!4*/*,4@AH!!

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

!!"#$%#$&$' #"()' *' !"#$&+,-,."#' (%/+%0' ! ' !""1%(-,.2%' 3-(4-.#.#4' ! ' 5&,&-+'6")1(").$%'1"+.67'!

S+#4!10(,&P4! ,-.,%*/*#0$4!(,.,$(!'.0$! *+,! 703'1! #$!5+#%+! F8!.0&#%:!(,&#2,3/*#0$4!0%%'3!/$(! *+,! &,=,&! 07! 4,%3,%:! *+/*! 4'330'$(4! *+,4,! (,&#2,3/*#0$4@! I$! ./3*#%'&/3<! %00.,3/*#=,!2/3)/#$#$)! #4! 103,! &#6,&:! *0! ,1,3),! 5+,$! *+,! #44',! #$! >',4*#0$! #4! 4'2?,%*! *0! %0&&,%*#=,!(,&#2,3/*#0$!5#*+#$!F8!703'14<!5+,3,!*+,!F8P4!.30%,('3/&!$0314!/3,!104*!4/&#,$*<!/$(!5+,$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!AB!T$'(!F3#6!UV3),$4,$<!!"#$"%&'(")*++,-.%/"0)&-)12,-+".3)4-(",3.3%"!KO,5!W036R!X*!G/3*#$P4!Y3,44<!AZZ[L@!U,773,:!\,5#4<!QI4!*+,!QC/3(!]/3)/#$#$)P!I1/),!07!*+,!^0'$%#&!G#4&,/(#$)_!S+,!^011#**,,!07!Y,31/$,$*!`,.3,4,$*/*#=,4!/$(!*+,!\0%/&!F&,%*#0$4!a#3,%*#=,P<!5-2,3.$)-#)6-77-3)8.,9"&):&2;'"0<!=0&@!B"<!$0@!H<!AZZb<!..@!H[Z;McH@!U,773,:!\,5#4<!QI$4*#*'*#0$/&!F$=#30$1,$*4!/$(!F=,3:(/:!F8!a,%#4#0$!G/6#$)R!`/*#0$/&#4*!03!^0$4*3'%*#=#4*_P<!6-7+.,.&'(")=-$'&'%.$):&2;'"0<!=0&@!B"<!$0@!A<!dccB<!..@!Z[;AdH@!G#%+/,&!F@!X1#*+<!12,-+">0)?-,"'@3).3;):"%2,'&A)=-$'%AB)C/")D30&'&2&'-3.$'E.&'-3)-#)6--+",.&'-3!K^/123#(),R!^/123#(),!8$#=,34#*:!Y3,44<!dccHL@!AH!X#10$!O'**/&&<!12,-+".3)=-$'&'%.$)6--+",.&'-3!Ke-703(R!e-703(!8$#=,34#*:!Y3,44<!AZZdL@!AM! a/=#(! \/-! /$(! U/1,4! X,2,$#'4<!C/")8.3.@",) .0) F"@-&'.&-,B) G.,@.'3'3@) #-,) 6--+",.&'-3) .3;) 6-7+"&'&'(")4.'3! KO,5! W036! /$(! \0$(0$R! S+,! f3,,! Y3,44<! AZb"L@! Y@! S,33,$%,!C0.1/$$<! QS50! Y/3/(#)14! 07!O,)0*#/*#0$R!]/3)/#$#$)! /$(! Y302&,1! X0&=#$)P<!*33.$0) -#) &/") *7",'%.3) *%.;"7A) -#) =-$'&'%.$) .3;) :-%'.$) :%'"3%"<! =0&@! MHd<!AZZM<! ..@! dH;H[@! e&,! F&)4*3g1<! /$(! ^+3#4*,3! Ug$440$<! QO,)0*#/*#0$! #$! *+,! F'30.,/$! 8$#0$R! ]/3)/#$#$)! 03!Y302&,1;X0&=#$)_P<!5-2,3.$)-#)12,-+".3)=2H$'%)=-$'%A<)=0&@![<!$0@!M<!dccc<!..@!"bH;[cH@!A"!e&,!F&)4*3g1!/$(!^+3#4*,3!Ug$440$<!12,-+".3)I3'-3)F"@-&'.&'-30B)=,-%"00"0<)F"&J-,90).3;)D30&'&2&'-30!!K\0$(0$R!`0'*&,(),<!dccML@!F')h$#/!a/!^0$%,#ij0;C,&(*<!QI$*,)3/*#=,!/$(!a#4*3#2'*#=,!]/3)/#$#$)!X#*'/*#0$4!#$!*+,!F'30.,/$!8$#0$R!N+/*!a#77,3,$%,!a0,4!I*!G/6,_P<!F"@-&'.&'-3)5-2,3.$!=0&@!dd<!$0@!d<!dcc"<!..@!!AHM;"M@!!

Page 9: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

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

!

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

Page 10: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$! %&'()*+! ,-*! .*(%*.,/&0! &$! 0&(12,/3*! 4/05%&0)/),*0%6! /)! )'78*%,! ,&! 9*:/7*(2,*! 2%,)! &$!

;$(21/0<=! ,-2,! :/0>! /))'*)! 209! %-&/%*)! ,&! .(*?*@/),/0<! /9*2)! 209! .(/&(! *@.*(/*0%*)ABC! D-/)!

$(21/0<! /)! /0,*0)*:6! .&:/,/%2:E! )'%%*))$'::6! $(21/0<! 2! .&:/%6! 2)! %&0)/),*0,!F/,-! ,-*! G0/&0H)!

$&(12:!0&(1)!209!.(/&(!.&:/%6!%&11/,1*0,)!*$$*%,/3*:6!9/)*1.&F*()! /,)!&..&0*0,)+!F-/:*!

$(21/0<! 2! .&))/7:*! .&:/%6! 2)! /0%&0)/),*0,! F/,-! *@/),/0<! 0&(1)! 209! %&11/,1*0,)!

9/)*1.&F*()! /,)! )'..&(,*()A! I::! JG! 2%,&()+! /0%:'9/0<! 1*17*(! ),2,*)! 209! )'.(202,/&02:!

/0),/,',/&0)+! ,-')! -23*! 2! .&F*($':! /0%*0,/3*! ,&! $(21*! JG! .&:/%6! %-&/%*)! /0! ,*(1)! &$! .(*?

*@/),/0<!0&(1)!209!%&11/,1*0,)!%&0)/),*0,!F/,-! ,-*/(!.&:/%6!.(*$*(*0%*)A!K*17*(!),2,*)!

,-2,! $2/:! ,&!9&!)&!F/::! $/09! ,-*1)*:3*)! ,(2..*9! /0! )'..&(,!&$!JG!.&:/%/*)! ,-2,!9/3*(<*! $(&1!

,-*/(!.(*$*(*0%*)A!D-*!0&(12,/3*!*0,(2.1*0,!*@.:202,/&0!&$!JG!$&(*/<0!.&:/%6!9*:/7*(2,/&0!

%20!,-')!7*!(*.(*)*0,*9!2)!$&::&F)E!

!

!"#$%&'%()*+',-.$+&'/+0,1(23+2,..(%.*'%$+4+56*%,-(2&1+7-&.('8+! +9'%-&0.*'%+! +:,-.;2,'$($%*'%+0,1(23+!

D-2,! )2/9+! ,-*! 96021/%)! &$! 0&(12,/3*! *0,(2.1*0,! 2(*! 0&,! *L'2::6! .&F*($':! /0! 2::!

%/(%'1),20%*)A! D-*6! 2(*! 1&),! :/>*:6! ,&! &3*(%&1*! .&:/%6! 9/3*(<*0%*! /$! ,-*(*! /)! 20!

'0%&0,(&3*()/2:!0&(1!F/,-!%:*2(!7*-23/&'(2:! /1.:/%2,/&0)+! /$!.&:/%6!9*:/7*(2,/&0!&%%'()! /0!2!

)/,*!F-*(*!JG!0&(1)!2(*!)2:/*0,+!209!/$!,-*(*!/)!-/<-!.'7:/%!2,,*0,/&0!,&!,-*!9*:/7*(2,/&0)AMN!!

!

O$!,-*!0&(12,/3*!*0,(2.1*0,!1&9*:!/)!%&((*%,+!,-*0!,-*!P/<-!Q*.(*)*0,2,/3*H)!(&:*!F&':9!7*!

,&!$(21*!209!.'7:/%/)*!.&:/%6!%-&/%*)!/0!2!1200*(!,-2,!.(&1&,*)!2<(**1*0,)!%&0)/),*0,!F/,-!

.(/&(!0&(12,/3*!209!.&:/%6!%&11/,1*0,)A!D&!)'%%**9!/0!,-/)!(&:*+!,-*!PQ!F&':9!')*!.'7:/%!

.(&0&'0%*1*0,)! ,&! -/<-:/<-,! .(*?*@/),/0<! JG! 32:'*)! 209! .&:/%6! .&)/,/&0)! (*:*320,! ,&!

F-2,*3*(!/))'*4)5!,-*!G0/&0!/)!$2%/0<A!R-*!F&':9!-23*!,&!9&!)&+!-&F*3*(+!/0!2!1200*(!,-2,!

(*12/0*9! ,('*! ,&! ,-*!.(*?*@/),/0<!32:'*)!209!%&11/,1*0,)!F-/:*!12/0,2/0/0<! ,-*! ,('),!&$!

1&(*! J'(&)%*.,/%! 1*17*(! ),2,*! <&3*(01*0,)A! S/,-/0! %&0$/9*0,/2:! JG! $&('1)+! )'%-! 2)!

1**,/0<)! &$! F&(>/0<! <(&'.)+! ,-*! TRU+! 209! U&(*.*(+! ,-*! PQ! F&':9! (*%&11*09! %&11&0!

.&:/%/*)! %&0)/),*0,! F/,-! ,-*)*! .(*?*@/),/0<! 32:'*)! 209! .&:/%6! %&11/,1*0,)+! F-/:*!

*0%&'(2</0<!1*17*(!),2,*)!,&!%&0)/9*(!,-*!/1.:/%2,/&0)!&$!,-*/(!%-&/%*)!$&(!,-*!:&0<?,*(1!

%(*9/7/:/,6!&$!JG!$&(*/<0!.&:/%6A!

!

"#$%!&'(!)*+,%$-.%/0/,123*./*4*5/.#4!&+,%/%-%/*+#4/,1!!U&0),('%,/3/)1!/)!20!2..(&2%-!,&! /0,*(02,/&02:!(*:2,/&0)!F-/%-!2))*(,)!,-2,! /0,*(?)'78*%,/3*!

.(&%*))*)! )-2.*! 1*9/'1! ,&! :&0<?('0! &',%&1*)! 76! ,(20)$&(1/0<! /9*0,/,/*)A! R&1*! &$!

U&0),('%,/3/)1H)! 2))*(,/&0)! &3*(:2.! F/,-! ,-&)*! &$! V&(12,/3*! O0),/,',/&02:/)1! 4.(*)*0,*9!

27&3*5+!7',!,-*!$&(1*(!/)!9/),/0<'/)-*9!76!/,)!(*8*%,/&0!&$!,-*!:2,,*(H)!2))'1.,/&0!,-2,!2%,&()H!

/9*0,/,/*)!209!.(*$*(*0%*)!2(*! $/@*9A!S-/:*! )&1*! )%-&:2()! /0)/),! ,-2,!U&0),('%,/3/)1! /)!0&,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!BC! Q&7*(,! WA! X*0$&(9! 209! W23/9! IA! R0&F+! YZ(21/0<! T(&%*))*)! 209! R&%/2:! K&3*1*0,)E! I0! #3*(3/*F! 209!

I))*))1*0,H+!!""#$%& '()*(+& ,-& .,/*,%,01+! 3&:A! M[+! 0&A! B+! MNNN+! ..A! [BB?[\CA! Q&9<*(! IA! T260*+! YT*()'2)/&0+!Z(21*)!209!V&(1!U&0),('%,/&0H+!2#3,4($"&5,#3"$%&,-&6"7(3"$7*,"$%&'(%$7*,"8+!3&:A!]+!0&A!B+!MNNB+!..A!\]?[BA!MN!R%-/11*:$*00/<!209!!D-&12)+!YV&(12,/3*!O0),/,',/&02:/)1!209!JG!Z&(*/<0!T&:/%6!/0!U&1.2(2,/3*!

T*().*%,/3*HA!

Page 11: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "!

#$%&'($#! )*! '$($+,)$! )$%),-.$! /01*)/$%$%! ,(#! &%! )/2%! &(3*41,)&-.$! 5&)/! %*3&,.! %3&$(3$6!*)/$+%!,+'2$!)/,)!%*3&,.!%3&$(3$!%/*2.#!(*)!-$!$72,)$#!5&)/!2)&.&),+&,(&%4!*+!+,)&*(,.&%489:!!

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

!;/$! )/+$$!4*#$.%! 1+$%$()$#!-$.*5!,+$!-,%$#!#&==$+$()! ,%%241)&*(%! +$',+#&('!5/$+$! )/&%!)+,(%=*+4,)&*(! *332+%! ,(#! /*5! #$$1.0! &)! +$,3/$%8! I..! )/+$$! *=! )/$%$! 4*#$.%! /&'/.&'/)!1*)$()&,.!1+*3$%%$%!*=!3*(G$+'$(3$! &(!JK!=*+$&'(!1*.&30!)/,)!+$72&+$!,!=,+! .*('$+!1$+&*#!*=!)&4$!)/,(!&(!)/$!4*#$.%!,-*G$8!!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9:!\*/(!]$++,+#!^2''&$6!AC/,)!?,<$%!)/$!C*+.#!_,('!;*'$)/$+`!a$*FK)&.&),+&,(&%4!,(#!)/$!U*3&,.!T*(%)+23)&G&%)!T/,..$('$B6!10/$*0./-"0.%&2*3.0-4./-"06!G*.8!X96!(*8!Q6!:""[6!118![XXF[[X8!!^&3/,+#!W+&3$!,(#!T/+&%)&,(!^$2%FU4&)6!AV,('$+*2%!b&,&%*(%`!T+&)&3,.!R()$+(,)&*(,.!;/$*+0!,(#!T*(%)+23)&G&%4B6!5+*"6$.0&7"+*0.%&"8&10/$*0./-"0.%&9$%./-"0,:&G*.8!Q6!(*8!P6!:""[6!118!9X"F9"Q8!99!?,+3/!,(#!@.%$(6!9$#-,;"<$*-03&10,/-/+/-"0,8!9P!V,G&#!I..$(6!=>"&?6$.@,&8"*&5+*"6$6!18Q98!9Q!R-&#8!18XP!9X!\*.0*(!_*5*+)/6!AJ2+*1$,(!V$=$(3$!,(#!)/$!T/,('&('!W*.&)&3%!*=!)/$!J2+*1$,(!K(&*(H!_,('&('!)*'$)/$+!*+!/,('&('!%$1,+,)$.0B6!7"+*0.%&"8&A"BB"0&!.*@$/&?/+#-$,!G*.8!P"6!(*8!Q6!9OO:6!118!ZYXF["6!18ZYY8!9Y!^*-$+)!@8!c$*/,($!,(#!\*%$1/!a0$!\+86!A;+,(%'*G$+(4$(),.!^$.,)&*(%!,(#!R()$+(,)&*(,.!@+',(&%,)&*(%B6!="*%#&C"%-/-;,6!G*.8!9Z6!(*8!:6!:"ZQ6!118!P"FY98!9Z!U&4*(!a2)),..6!5+*"6$.0&C"%-/-;.%&A""6$*./-"0!D@>=*+#H!@>=*+#!K(&G$+%&)0!W+$%%6!:""9E6!18P:98!9[!W/&.&11$!#$!U3/*2)/$$)$6!D.&A""6$*./-"0&6"%-/-E+$&$+*"6$$0$!DM+2%%$.%H!b,-*+6!:"[YE8!!

Page 12: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "#!

$%&&'()*+! ,-./.! *-.! 01.$)23)0.4! 5(%,3.46.! 2(4! .71./*)0.! )0! 4.8)(.4! )(! *./&0! %8! *-.)/!'(4./0*2(4)(6! %8! 4.$)0)%(! &25)(6! 4+(2&)$0! 2(4! 0*/'$*'/.0! '(4./1)(()(6! 1%3)$+9:;! <-.!$/)*)$23!1%)(*!-./.! )0! *-2*! *-.!200'&.4! )(*./(23)02*)%(!%8!.71.$*2*)%(0! )0!%$$'//)(6!,)*-)(!2!$%&12/2*)=.3+! 0&233! .$-.3%(! %8! >/'[email protected]! )(0)4./09! A-)3.! &2(+! 2(23+0*0! 8/2&.! *-)0!1/%$.00!,)*-)(!%(.!%8!2!$-2(6)(6!)4.(*)8)$2*)%(BC#%*-./0!-2=.!2/6'.4!*-2*!*-./.!)0!0*)33!0%&.!0$%1.!8%/!0..)(6!*-)0!)(!2*!3.20*!12/*3+!/2*)%(23)0*!*./&09C"!<-)0!1/%$.00!&)6-*!@.!/.1/.0.(*.4!20!8%33%,0D!

!!"#$%&' $()*$*+*$"(,#$),*$"('-' )"%$,#$),*$"('".'/0+))1#)23,)14',%*"0)'! ' 1#$*1' $41(*$*&'%5,(61'! '71,8#&'/0+))1#)2$41(*$.$14'9"#$%&'!

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``.)%19%/92*`!

Page 13: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! ""!

#$! %&#$'(()#*+,! &#,'(! +*-! (./('0.'*1! %#,)23! +*-! 14'! 2&'+1)#*! #$! (.24! *#&5(! +*-!

'6%'21+1)#*(!+1!7.&#%'+*!,'8',9:;!!

!

<4&''!-)(1)*21!-)5'*()#*(!#$!7.&#%'+*)=+1)#*!4+8'!/''*! )-'*1)$)'->!*+1)#*+,!+-+%1+1)#*! 1#!

7?!%#,)23!5+@)*A!B-#C*,#+-)*ADE!*+1)#*+,!%&#F'21)#*!)*1#!7?!%#,)23!5+@)*A!B.%,#+-)*AD!+*-!

*+1)#*+,! )*1'&+21)#*! +*-! ,'+&*)*A! C)14)*! 7?! %#,)23! 5+@)*A! B2&#((G,#+-)*AD9::! ! H4),'! (#5'!

+.14#&(!-'$)*'!14'('!)*!%+&1!)*!I+1)#*+,)(1!J*(1)1.1)#*+,!1'&5(K!14'!+%%&#+24!%&'('*1'-!4'&'!

&'(1(! #*! +! L#2)#,#A)2+,! J*(1)1.1)#*+,)(1! +%%&#+24! C)14! +! $#2.(! #*! 4#C! 8+,.'(! +*-! *#&5(!

'8#,8'K!A)8)*A!&)('!1#!(4)$1(!)*!+5/)1)#*(K!'6%'21+1)#*(!+*-!)-'*1)1)'(!#8'&!1)5'9!

!

<4'!$)&(1!-)5'*()#*!#$!7.&#%'+*)(+1)#*!)(!14+1!#$!+-+%1+1)#*9!<4)(!)(!1&+-)1)#*+,,3!&'%&'('*1'-!

+(! /')*A! +! 1#%G-#C*! %&#2'((! )*! C4)24! 5'5/'&! (1+1'(! &'+21! +*-! +-F.(1! 1#! 7.&#%'+*!

'*A+A'5'*19! M(! +! &'(.,1K! 14'! 7?! /'2#5'(! NO%+&1! #$! 14'! #&A+*)=+1)#*+,! ,#A)2! #$! *+1)#*+,!

%#,)1)2(! +*-! *+1)#*+,! %#,)23G5+@)*AP9:Q! J*! 1'&5(! #$! 8+,.'(! +*-! *#&5(K! 14'&'$#&'K! C'! +&'!

,##@)*A! $#&! '8)-'*2'! ')14'&! #$! (4)$1)*A! -'$)*)1)#*(! #$! 2#&'! *+1)#*+,! 8+,.'(! +*-! *#&5(! #&!

'8)-'*2'!#$!8)()/,'!*+1)#*+,!2#*1'(1+1)#*!#8'&!(.24!*#&5(!C4'&'!(#5'!)5+A'!#$!R7.&#%'S!)(!

%,+3)*A!+!&#,'9!!

!

<4'!('2#*-!-)5'*()#*!)(!14+1!#$!%&#F'21)#*!C4'&'!*+1)#*+,!8+,.'(!+*-!*#&5(!+&'!'6%#&1'-!1#!

14'!7.&#%'+*!,'8',!)*!+!/#11#5G.%!%&#2'((9!T'&'!C'!+&'!,##@)*A!$#&!'8)-'*2'!#$!'$$#&1(!#*!

14'!%+&1!#$!5'5/'&!(1+1'(!+*-!*+1)#*+,!+21#&(!1#!2#*(1&.21!7.&#%'! )*!14')&!#C*! )5+A'E!1#!

%&#F'21!C',,G'(1+/,)(4'-!*+1)#*+,! $#&')A*!%#,)23! 1&#%'(!#*1#!14'!?*)#*!B7?!+(! )*1'&*+1)#*+,!

%'+2'@''%'&K!+(!/&#@'&U5'-)+1#&!#&!+(!(.%'&%#C'&DK!+*-!14'&'/3!1#!B&'D2#*$)A.&'!7.&#%'+*!

%#,)23!)*!C+3(!14+1!+&'!&'$,'21)8'!#$!C',,!'(1+/,)(4'-!*+1)#*+,!8+,.'(9!!!

!

<4'! $)*+,! -)5'*()#*! #$! 7.&#%'+*)=+1)#*! )(! 14+1! #$! )*1'&+21)#*! +*-!5.1.+,! ,'+&*)*A9! <4)(! )(!

%&'('*1'-!+(!14'!%&#2'((!/3!C4)24!5'5/'&!(1+1'(!2#5%#('!2#,,'21)8',3!+A&''-!*#&5(!+*-!

8+,.'(!')14'&!#*!/'4+,$!#$!14'!?*)#*!+(!+!C4#,'!#&!+(!(./('1(!C)14)*K!%#1'*1)+,,3!/+('-!#*!

(4+&'-! 4)(1#&)2+,! '6%'&)'*2'K! A'#A&+%43K! 2.,1.&'! #&! %#C'&! %'&2'%1)#*9!H)14)*! 14)(!5#-',K!

14'!)*1'&*+,)(+1)#*!#$!*#&5(!(4#.,-!/'!8)()/,'!+2&#((!14'!*+1)#*+,!$#&')A*!%#,)23!2#55.*)13E!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:;!V'*!<#*&+K!!"#$%&'()#*+,-*.,(+$(/$+*.,(+*0$/('#,1+$)(0,234$5&.2"6$5*+,-"$*+7$8',-"$/('#,1+$)(0,23$,+$."#$

%&'()#*+$9+,(+!BW#*-#*>!M(4A+1'K!;XX"D9!V'*!<#*&+K!RY#*(1&.21)*A!14'!Y#55#*!Z#&')A*!+*-!L'2.&)13![#,)23>!

<4'!.1),)13!#$!+!2#A*)1)8'!+%%&#+24SK!:(&'+*0$(/$;(<<(+$=*'>#.$?.&7,#-K!8#,9!Q"K*#9!QK!;XX:K!%%9!\:"G]^9!::!Y,+.-)+!_+F#&K!R7.&#%'+*)(+1)#*!+*-!Z#&')A*!+*-!L'2.&)13![#,)23>!?*-'&5)*)*A!#&!I'(2.)*A!14'!`+1)#*+,!

L1+1'aSK!@(0,.,2-K!8#,9!;]K!;XX]K!%%9!"\]GbX9!Y,+.-)+!_+F#&!+*-!c+&#,)*+![#5#&(@+K!R7.&#%'+*)(+1)#*>!Z&+5'C#&@!

#&!Z+(4)#*aSK!;A?@$A('&<K!8#,9!:K!*#9!]K!;XX]9!Y4+&+,+5/#(!<(+&-+*)-)(!+*-!L1',)#(!L1+8&)-)(K!R<4'!

7.&#%'+*)(+1)#*!#$!d&''@!Z#&')A*![#,)23>!M!Y&)1)2+,!M%%&+)(+,SK!%&'()#*+$8+.#1'*.,(+K!8#,9$;\K!*#9!;K!;XX]K!%%9;"\G:b9!I'./'*!H#*AK!R<4'!7.&#%'+*)=+1)#*!#$!Z#&')A*![#,)23S!)*!Y4&)(1#%4'&!T),,!+*-!_)24+',!L5)14!B'-(9D!

8+.#'+*.,(+*0$B#0*.,(+-$*+7$."#$%&'()#*+$9+,(+$Be6$#&->!e6$#&-!?*)8'&()13![&'((K!;XX]D9!I'./'*!H#*AK!!"#$%&'()#*+,C*.,(+$(/$A'#+2"$/('#,1+$)(0,234$A'*+2#$*+7$."#$%9$,+$%*-.$D-,*!BV+()*A(1#@'!+*-!`'C!f#&@>![+,A&+8'!_+25),,+*K!;XX^D9!M*+!79!g.*2#(!+*-!c+&#,)*+![#5#&(@+K!R<4'!h'+-,#2@!14+1!`'8'&!T+%%'*'->!<4'!)5%+21!#$!

'*,+&A'5'*1!#*!14'!Y#55#*!Z#&')A*!+*-!L'2.&)13![#,)23!Y#.*2),!H#&@)*A!d&#.%(SK!%&'()#*+$@(0,.,2*0$%2(+(<3$B#E,#FK!8#,9!^K!;XX\K!%%9QG:X9!<''5.![+,#(++&)K!!"#$D'.$(/$D7*).*.,(+$D$-.&73$(+$."#$%&'()#*+,C*.,(+$(/$A,+0*+7G-$/('#,1+$*+7$-#2&',.3$)(0,23$B<+5%'&'>!<+5%'&''*!3,)#%)(1#K!;X""D9!:Q!I#/'&1!W+-&'24K!R7.&#%'+*)=+1)#*!#$!h#5'(1)2![#,)1)2(!+*-!J*(1)1.1)#*(>!<4'!Y+('!#$!Z&+*2'SK!:(&'+*0$(/$

;(<<(+$=*'>#.$?.&7,#-K!8#,9!:;K!*#9!"K!"bbQK!%%9!^bGiiK!%9^b9!!

Page 14: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "#!

$%&'%()*+,! -&./!0.1*(2!/34'&$! %.! 3+312$%$! 3+5! (.//'+%3%.&$6! 7)*$!/.5'1! *$! 0'&)30$! 8'$%!

&'0&'$'+%'5!3$9!

!

!"#$%&'$()*$*+*$"(,#$),*$"('-')"%$,#$),*$"('".'(,*$"(,#'."/0$1('2"#$%&',%*"/)'! ')3$.*'$('(,*$"(,#'."/0$1('2"#$%&'$40(*$*&'! '5"40/,*0#&'6+/"20,(740("5$(,*04'2"#$%&'!

:*%)*+! %)*$! $('+3&*.;! %)'&'! *$! ,&'3%'&! $<8$%3+%*='! '+,3,'/'+%! .-! +3%*.+31! -.&'*,+! 0.1*(2!

*5'+%*%*'$! >*%)*+! %)'! (.+$%&<(%*.+! .-! %)'! (.11'(%*='! ?<&.0'3+! 0.1*(26! 7)'&'! *$! 31$.! =*$*81'!

/.='/'+%!*+!%&35*%*.+31!+3%*.+31!-.&'*,+!0.1*(2!0.$*%*.+$!@!'='+!!"#$%&'()*+('*,+(!@!.&!3%!1'3$%!'A01*(*%!(.+%'$%3%*.+!.-!%)'/6!7)'!-.(<$!.-!+3%*.+31!0.1*(2!/34'&$!*$!1*4'12!%.!0&*.&*%*$'!

%)'! '--'(%*='! 'A'(<%*.+! .-! 3! (.//.+! 0.1*(2! 3+5! *%$! (&'5*8*1*%26! ! B3%*.+31! -.&'*,+! 0.1*(2!

/34'&$!/32! 31$.! 8',*+! %.! 0&'$'+%! 3! (.)'&'+%! 3+5! '--'(%*='! ?C!0.1*(2! 3$! 8'*+,! 3! +3%*.+31!

-.&'*,+!0.1*(2!.8D'(%*='!*+!*%$!.>+!&*,)%6!!

!

E-! %)'!?<&.0'3+*$3%*.+!/.5'1! *$!(.&&'(%;! %)'+!%)'!F*,)!G'0&'$'+%3%*='!8'(./'$!$./'%)*+,!

.-!3!0.1*%*(31!0&.%3,.+*$%!*+!)'&!.>+!&*,)%6!H)'!>.<15!8'!'A0'(%'5;!0&.3(%*='12;!%.!$''4!.<%!

.00.&%<+*%*'$! %.! 5'-*+';! 5*&'(%! 3+5! 'A'(<%'! C+*.+! -.&'*,+! 0.1*(2! ,.31$6! ! I+'!/*,)%;! 3$! 3!

(.+$'J<'+(';!'A0'(%!%.!$''!$./'!%'+$*.+$!>*%)*+!%)'!KLM!3$!%)'!FG!$%&*='5!-*&$%!%.!(&'3%'!

3+5!%)'+!%.!8<*15!<0.+!M.<+(*1!(.+$'+$<$6!7)'!FG!>.<15!31$.!%'+5!%.!.--'&!(&*%*(31!&'-1'(%*.+!

.+!%)'!$<(('$$N-3*1<&'!.-!%)'!C+*.+!*+!*%$!'--.&%$!%.!(&3-%!(.//.+!0.1*(2;!0'&)30$!'='+!,.*+,!

$.! -3&! 3$! 0<81*(12! %.! 30012! 0&'$$<&'! .+! +3%*.+31! ,.='&+/'+%$6! L%! 3! /*+*/</! .+'! >.<15!

'A0'(%! %.! $''! )'&! 3(%*='! '+,3,'/'+%!>*%)! +3%*.+31! -.&'*,+! 0.1*(2! '1*%'$! .+! $0'(*-*(! *$$<'$!

8<%;! /.&'! (&*%*(3112;! %.! 0&'$$! %)'! ,'+'&31! (3$'! -.&! %)'! C+*.+! 3$! 3! (&'5*81'! 3+5! '--'(%*='!

-.&'*,+!0.1*(2!3(%.&6!7)*$!/*,)%!31$.!'+%3*1!)'&!35=.(3(2!.-!0&.('5<&31!3+5N.&! *+$%*%<%*.+31!

()3+,'!%.!%)3%!'+56!

!!

-"!'.)/0)1"..'23%,')4!'&3%35)6"*#$3%"&)!

7)*$!-*+31!/.5'1!1..4$!3%!?C!-.&'*,+!0.1*(2!3$!8.%)!%)'!'A%'&+31!&'0&'$'+%3%*.+!.-!%)'!C+*.+!

8<%! 31$.! 3$! O.+'! .-! %)'! 8.<+53&2P0&.5<(*+,! 0&3(%*('$! ('+%&31! %.! %)'! 0&.5<(%*.+! 3+5!

&'0&.5<(%*.+!.-!%)'!*5'+%*%2!Q.-!%)'!$%3%'R!*+!>).$'!+3/'!*%!.0'&3%'$S6TU!7)'!(.&'!&'$'3&()!

3,'+53!3$$</'$!%)3%!%)'&'!'A*$%$!3!/<%<3112!(.+$%*%<%*='!&'13%*.+$)*0!8'%>''+!*5'+%*%2!3+5!

-.&'*,+! 0.1*(2! 3+5! %)3%! ?C! -.&'*,+! 0.1*(2! *$! 3! 5*$(<&$*='! 0&3(%*('! -&./!>)*()! %)'! C+*.+V$!

(.11'(%*='!$.(*31!*5'+%*%2!'/'&,'$6!!

!

7)'!0&.('$$!82!>)*()!%)*$!.((<&$!*$!.+'!%)3%!*$!3$$</'5!%.!(&'3%'!3+5!*+$%3+%*3%'!(.11'(%*='!

*5'+%*%2!8.<+53&*'$6!L!(.&'!()311'+,'!-.&!%)'!C+*.+!*$!%)3%!*%$!8.&5'&$!3&'!+.%!-*A'56!K*&$%;!?C!

-.&'*,+!0.1*(2!)3$! %.!3((.//.53%'! %)'!0.$$*8*1*%2!.-! %)'! W.%)'&V!8'(./*+,!03&%!.-! %)'! W<$V!

%)&.<,)! '+13&,'/'+%6! H'(.+5;! %)'! 8.&5'&$! .-! %)'! C+*.+V$! 0.1*(2! $03('$! 3&'! +.%!/<%<3112!

&'*+-.&(*+,;!>*%)!%)'!8.&5'&$!.-!%)'!C+*.+V$!/.+'%3&2!<+*.+!Q%)'!'<&.R!8'*+,!5*--'&'+%!-&./!

%)3%!.-! *%$!(<$%./$!<+*.+!3+5!-&./!%)'!8.&5'&$!.-!%)'!H()'+,'+!X.+'6!K*+3112;! %)'!C+*.+V$!

'A0.&%!.-!*%$!0.1*(*'$!%.!+.+P/'/8'&!$%3%'$;!%)&.<,)!%)'!?<&.0'3+!?(.+./*(!L&'3!Q??LR!3+5!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TU!Y3=*5!M3/08'11;!7*%3%&8)9'2:*%35;)<&%3'!)93$3'()="*'%8&)>".%25)$&!)3?')>".%3%2()"=)%!'&3%35)QZ*++'30.1*$9!

C+*='&$*%2!.-!Z*++'$.%3![&'$$;!"\\#R;!06]U6!

Page 15: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "#!

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

!!"#$%&' $()*$*+*$"(,#$),*$"(' -' ."#$%&' /01"%2,*$),*$"('! ' *2,()3"21,*$"(' "3' (,*$"(,#'$/0(*$*$0)4$()*,(*$,*$"('"3'5+2".0,('$/0(*$*&'! ')*2"(6#&'578/03$(0/'."#$%&'!

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`D]"\@!!!U$&+%&-!a(ME!,-2!P4;!U>&)2)(+E!:O(<<6!Z*)2&)9!,-2!S2,+$/>&!V($9/2&9L!.*)?,6E!U?/$<&)4,-2!,-2!$%&!'P=E!2-%"(+0'-/'3%"-!*+('4()*5"+)#-(E!>*4@!YYE!-*@!]E!++@Y#JDJ^@!#J!K%*C,9!F/99&!,-2!b,-,!a,$%,)/-,!G),1*?9H6E!3%"-!*+('4.*()#)6'7-"$+)#-('#(')8*'9%:0#1';!8*"*'+(.'#('7-"*#5('9-0#16E!F'TV.!V-4/-&!B*)H/-0!3,+&)!Y^^_N^]@!PFc%$$+LNN???@)&5*-+)*X&5$@&(N+)*X&5$?&1N+*)$,4+)*X&5$NF'TV.B*)H/-03,+&)9@%$C4!!

Page 16: To What Ends EU Foreign Policy? Contending Approaches to ... › t4cms › 11-2 Thomas and Tonra.pdf · Ben Tonra is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam of European Foreign, Security

!

! "#!

$%&'()*+,'!-.'/!01%*1!$1'2!-3'/+$'4!5-5'!-6!$1'&!)788')$!$1+$!9%.'/8'5*')!+&-58!&'&:'/!

)$+$')! +/'! '+)%,2! -.'/*-&';! <1'! =>(3'))%&%)$! &%81$! $1'/'6-/'! *-5*,79'! $1+$! $1'! 3+3'/!

3/-.%9')!?+$1'/%5'!@)1$-5!0%$1!)'.'5!5'0!/'+)-5)!$-!9')3+%/;!A5!$1'!-$1'/!1+594!$1'!=>(

-3$%&%)$! &%81$! /'$-/$4! $1'/'! +/'! +$! ,'+)$! )'.'5! 3+$1)! $-! +8/''&'5$4! +59! -5,2! -5'! 5''9!

)7**''9!-5!+52!8%.'5!%))7';!!

B$!)1-7,9!+,)-!:'!:-/5'!%5!&%59!$1+$!'+*1!-6!$1')'!&-9',)!%)!+5!C%9'+,!$23'D4!+5!+:)$/+*$%-5!

6/-&! /'+,%$2! 01%*1! %)! 9')%85'9! $-! +,,-0! 7)! $-! %9'5$%62! +59! $-! %5$'//-8+$'! $1'! ,-8%*)! +59!

.+/%+:,')!+$!0-/E;!@)!+*+9'&%*!/'+9'/)!0%,,!/'*-85%)'4!)-&'!-6!$1'!9%66'/'5*')!:'$0''5!$1'!

&-9',)!/')7,$!6/-&!$1'!9%66'/'5*')!:'$0''5!$1'%/!759'/,2%58!F+59!)-&'$%&')!%5*-&3+$%:,'G!

-5$-,-8%*+,!+))7&3$%-5);!H-/!$1'!3-,%*2(&%59'94!$1'!3/')'5$+$%-5!-6!+!&7,$%(&-9',!)*1'&+!

)7*1!+)!$1%)!*+5!:'!6/7)$/+$%58!+)!%$!&%81$!0',,!:'!+/87'9!$1+$!','&'5$)!-6!'+*1!&-9',!+/'!

'.%9'5$!%5!:-$1!$1'!1%)$-/2!+59!$1'!*-5$'&3-/+/2!3/+*$%*'!-6!?HIJ!+59!?IKJ;!L-0'.'/4!0'!

0-7,9! +/87'! $1+$! '.'5! 1'/'4! $1'! )$792! -6! $1')'! %9'+,! $23')! &+2! 3/-.'! 7)'67,;! H7/$1'/!

9'$+%,'9!/')'+/*1!7)%58!$1%)!)*1'&+!&+2!%9'5$%62!3/'9-&%5+5$!&-9',)!+)!0',,!+)!+5)0'/%58!

M7')$%-5)! +)! $-! $1'! *-59%$%-5)! +59! *%/*7&)$+5*')!759'/!01%*1!9%66'/'5$!&-9',)!&%81$! :'!

'.%9'5$! +$! 9%66'/'5$! $%&')! +59!01'5N1-0! )7*1!&-9',)!&%81$! %5$'/)'*$! -/! -.'/,+3! O! +,,! -6!

01%*1!1+.'!-:.%-7)!+59!*/%$%*+,!%&3,%*+$%-5)!6-/!3-,%*2(&+E%58;!!

<1'!P%):-5!$/'+$2!1+)!5-$!&+9'!+52!-6!$1%)!'+)%'/;!Q%.'5!$1+$!$1'!LR!&7)$!-3'/+$'!+*/-))!

$0-!9%66'/'5$!9'*%)%-5!&+E%58!)2)$'&)!F)73/+5+$%-5+,!+59!%5$'/8-.'/5&'5$+,G4!0%$1!9%)$%5*$!

)'$)! -6! *-,,'+87')! F?-,,'8'! -6! ?-&&%))%-5'/)! +59! H-/'%85! @66+%/)! ?-75*%,G4! +59! 0%$1! 1'/!

3-,%$%*+,! +**-75$+:%,%$2! )3,%$! :'$0''5! $1/''! %5)$%$7$%-5)! F?-&&%))%-54! J+/,%+&'5$! +59!

?-75*%,G4!%$!%)!3'/1+3)!/'&+/E+:,'!$1+$!)1'!1+)!+*1%'.'9!+52!)1/'9!-6!%5)$%$7$%-5+,!-/!3-,%*2!

*-1'/'5*';! @$! $1'! )+&'! $%&'4! &+52! 'S3'*$+$%-5)! -6! 1'/! -66%*'! O! )-&'! +/87+:,2!

75/'+)-5+:,'! -/! '.'5! %5*-&3+$%:,'! ((! 1+.'! 5-$! :''5! &'$! +59! )-&'! &'&:'/! )$+$')! +/'!

8'$$%58! /')$,'));! <1%)!1%81,%81$)! $1'!E'2!3+/+9-S!+$! $1'!1'+/$!-6! =>!9%3,-&+*2!+59! 6-/'%85!

3-,%*2T! 9')3%$'! $1'!&+52! %5)$%$7$%-5+,! %55-.+$%-5)! )%5*'! $1'! */'+$%-5! -6! =7/-3'+5! J-,%$%*+,!

?--3'/+$%-54!$1'/'!%)!8--9!/'+)-5!$-!)7)3'*$!$1+$!)-&'!F-/!&+52G!&'&:'/!)$+$')!,+*E!$1'!

3-,%$%*+,!0%,,!$-!9'.',-3!+!$/7,2!*-&&-5!6-/'%85!+59!)'*7/%$2!3-,%*2!6-/!$1'!>5%-5;!

!<1'!&-9',)!-7$,%5'9!+:-.'!+/'!+5!+$$'&3$!$-!9/%,,!9-05! %5$-!$1%)!*-&3,'S!+59!*-5$')$'9!

6%',9!%5!)'+/*1!-6!8/'+$'/!*,+/%$2!-5!$1'!&-$%.+$%-5+,!6-/*')!:'1%59!=>!6-/'%85!3-,%*2&+E%584!

$1'!3+/+&'$'/)!$1+$!9'6%5'!C)7**'))4D!+59!$1'!,-58'/($'/&!%&3+*$!-6!$1%)!%5$'5)%6%'9!)2)$'&!

-6!%5$'/8-.'/5&'5$+,!9'*%)%-5!&+E%58;!R'8+/9,'))!-6!01%*1!&-9',!-5'!6%59)!&-/'!+**7/+$'4!

$1%)!'S'/*%)'!1',3)!7)!37$!*/%$%M7')!-6!$1'!LRD)!3'/)-5+,%$2!+59!0-/E%58!C)$2,'D!%5!$1'%/!3/-3'/!

3'/)3'*$%.';!!!!!!!!!

!