tips for parenting in a commercial culture

Upload: steriandediu

Post on 30-May-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    1/32

    WE GIVE THANKS FOR OUR CHILDREN . MAY WE CONTINUE TO BE BLESSED

    BY THEIR SIMPLE WONDER SO THAT WE MIGHT NOT TAKE FOR GRANTED

    ONE SINGLE MOMENT OF THIS MIRACLE TO WHICH WEVE BEEN BORN.

    STEVE MYRVANG

    TIPS FOR PARENTINGIN A

    COMMERCIAL CULTURE

    Center for a New American Dreamwww.newdream.org

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    2/32

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    3/32

    PROTECTING OUR KIDS

    Cradle to Grave Brand Consciousness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4

    Kids Spending and the Nag Factor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5

    Where Does the Sales Pitch Happen? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6

    On-Screen Advertising . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6

    Advertising in Schools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7

    Channel One Captive Kids, Lost Time . . . . . . . . . . .8

    THE IMPACT OF COMMERCIAL CULTURE ON KIDS

    The Psychological and Physical Effects of the Tube . . .9

    Growing Up Too Quickly The Lost Art of Play . . . .10

    Our Overbooked Children . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .12

    Poor Money Management Skills . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .13

    Low-Income Families, Immigrant Families and the

    Pressure to Consume . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .14

    POSITIVE STEPS FOR PARENTS

    Taming Tube Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

    Commercial-Free Schools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

    Healthy Choices for Healthy Kids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .16

    Eco-Responsible Consumers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .17

    Creative Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .18Guard Your Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19

    Shopping, Money and Stuff . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20

    Your Children (and You) Are More than a Bra nd . . . .21

    Remembering Others . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .21

    SO WHAT DO KIDS REALLY WANT? . . . . . . . . . . . . . .22

    YOU ARE NOT ALONE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24

    What You Do Matters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24RESOURCES FOR PARENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .25

    The Center for a New American Dream . . . . . . . . . . .25

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    4/32

    4 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    PROTECTING OUR KIDS

    Our children are a blessing. They remind us tha t the worldis full of wonder and possibility. They make us laugh,exhaust us with their endless questions and needs and

    evoke indescribable feelings of love. We dedicate ourselves

    to their well being and we try to instill

    within them wholesome values, inde-

    pendent thinking and a dedicat ionto the common good.

    Our children are also a chal-

    lenge. It goes without saying that

    raising kids in todays noisy, fast-

    paced culture is difficult. For good or

    ill, kids today are exposed to a wider world. The voices of

    home and community have been joined by a chorus of voic-es from around the globe, clamoring for our childrens

    attention. Unfortunately, an increasing number of those

    voices are trying to sell them something. A new generation

    of hyper-consumers is growing up right in front of our eyes.

    CRADLE TO GRAVE BRAND CONSCIOUSNESS

    Virtually from bir th, todays children are exposed to TVcommercials, banner ads, billboards, logos and product

    placements . In what is called cradle to grave marketing,

    advertisers openly court children on an unprecedented

    scale, rushing to create brand loyalties the minute a child is

    old enough to distinguish company logos or recite product

    jingles.

    My two-year old can barely speak, yet when she sees atoy commercial she clearly states, I want that, says

    Michelle Payne of Washington.

    Advertisers are targeting kids today because thats where

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    5/32

    the seeds of hyper-consumerism a re planted. The evidence

    is obvious:

    x At s ix months of age, the same age they are imitating

    simple sounds like ma-ma, babies are forming mental

    images of corporate logos and mascots.1

    x According to recent marketing industry studies, a per-

    sons brand loyalty may begin as early as age two.2

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 5

    x At three years of age, before they can read, one out of

    five American children is already making specific requests

    for brand-name products.3

    KIDS SPENDING AND THE NAG FACTORFew people take the power of children more seriously

    than advertising executives. Marketers are interested in

    children both as consumers and for the enormous influence

    they have on their parents buying pat terns.

    x Kids spending is skyrocketing. In 1991, children aged

    four to 12 spent $8.6 billion of their own money each year. 4

    By 1999, four- to 12-year-olds took in $31.3 billion in

    income from allowance, jobs and gifts, and spent 92 percent

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    6/32

    of it.5 In 2001, teenagers spent $172 billion.6

    x

    Children are exhibiting extraordinary influence over theirparents spending. Twenty years ago, children aged four to

    12 influenced about $50 billion of their parents purchases.

    By 2001, that figure reached an estimated $300 billion.

    Marketers call this influence the nag factor or pester

    power.7

    WHERE DOES THE SALES P I TCH HAPPEN?Most kids spend the bulk of their time in one of threeplaces parked in front of a TV or a computer, or sitting in

    a classroom. Is it any wonder that advertisers make their

    biggest pitches in these places?

    On Screen Advertising

    Whether its through televisions or computers , American

    children get a lot of screen time (four and a half hours aday!),8 and these screens are full of advertising. A lot of

    these advertisements are aimed specifically at children.

    Thousands of other ads both on the web and on TV

    are aimed at adults but absorbed by kids.

    x The average American child aged 2 to 17 watches 17

    hours, 30 minutes of TV per week.9

    x On average, American children view over 20,000 TV

    commercials each year, which works out to well over 50 TV

    ads a day.10

    x The average American child aged 2-18

    spends nearly five and a half hours a day

    out of school consuming media in the

    form of TV, music, magazines, videogames and the internet, amounting to

    what Kaiser Family Foundation

    president Drew Altman refers to

    6 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    7/32

    as a full time job for the typical American child.11

    x Children between the ages of five and 18 will spend an

    estimated $1.3 billion online by 2002.12

    Advertising in Schools

    Parents can see how much advertising comes at their

    kids from TV and the web. What they cant see is how much

    advertising kids are exposed to during school hours, a time

    that is supposed to be set aside for learning. How much

    commercialism is in our schools? A lot. Over the past

    decade, advertisers have become much more sophisticated

    at targeting kids in school.

    While there have been some successful cases of commu-

    nities pushing back, the trend toward commercialized

    school environments continues. Sports uniforms are covered

    with logos. Textbooks are filled with brand names. Soda and

    candy machines in the hallways and fast food vendors in the

    cafeteria are commonplace. Some school curriculums even

    contain corporate-sponsored lessons that tout the so-

    called environmental benefits of the oil industry, the timber

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 7

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    8/32

    industry, the nuclear energy industry and the pesticide

    industry. And millions of children spend partof their school day watching commer-

    cials for junk food, teen fashion

    and violent films via Channel

    Ones in-school television net-

    work.

    Channel OneCaptive Kids,

    Lost Time

    Students in schools with

    Channel One, a twelve-minute

    news and advertising televi-

    sion program viewed daily

    in 12,000 middle and

    high schools across the

    country, are required to

    watch the program on nine

    out of ten school days. In

    return for requiring students to watch

    TV during class time, Channel One provides the schools

    with video equipment.

    Its not so clear that schools profit from this ar range-

    ment. The hidden costs in lost class time appear to far out-

    weigh the free hardware a school might receive. Research

    reveals that taxpayers in the U.S. pay $1.8 billion dollars

    per year for the class time lost to Channel One.13 And even

    more disturbingly, kids who should be in school to seek

    knowledge and stimulate critical thinking are instead a cap-

    tive audience for a company whose prime aim is to coax

    them to buy.

    8 T I P S F OR PA R EN T IN G I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    9/32

    THE IMPACT OF COMMERCIAL CULTUREON KIDS

    I m quite concerned that kids (and adults) today are equat-ing money with success and happiness. I was appalledwhen my nine-year-old daughter asked her grandmother

    how much her birthday gift cost. Dave Johns, Oregon.

    We all want to s teer our children toward positive,

    healthy sources of fulfillment, but its not easy. Money cant

    buy you love, friends or happiness, but advertiser s want us

    to think that it can, and many children are simply too young

    to separate the hype from reality. According to a recent

    Junior Achievement poll, 43% of teenagers associated the

    American Dream with accumulat ion of mater ial posses-

    sions, and nearly three-quarters of teens expect future job

    satisfaction to be directly related to how much money they

    make.14

    THE PSYCHOLOG ICALAND PHYS ICAL EFFECTS OFTHE TUBE

    My children are seduced

    into believing that if they

    have the right things or more

    things, they will not just be

    happier, but also more popu-

    lar. This culture that sees

    kids mostly as consumers is

    creating a future generation

    of kids that have not felt val-

    ued for their character or

    their contributions to the

    greater community. Jane Brolsma, Oregon.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 9

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    10/32

    When a society is preoccupied with material things,

    children and adults lose touch with non-commercial sources

    of happiness. In trying to fulfill non-material needs materi-

    ally, we can lose contact with friends, nature and crea tive

    play. Ads have encouraged this generation to have mater ial

    expectations they cant fulfill, says noted author and clini-

    cal psychologist Mary Pipher. This generation is the I

    want generation. They have been educated to entitlement

    and programmed for discontent .15

    Studies show that less time in front of the TV and more

    time outdoors would do our children a world of good. Early

    experiences with the natura l world have been positively

    linked with enhancing the development of imagination and a

    sense of wonder in children. Time outdoors in nature also

    plays a key part in helping children feel comfortable in the

    world around them. Child development studies are finding

    todays kids are increasingly biophobic fearful of the

    natural world. That is, they only feel comfortable in

    synthetic, climate-controlled environments.16

    Too much time spent in front of the TV also has been

    linked with increased violence, low self-esteem and obesity.

    Both the Surgeon General and a Stanford University study

    have linked watching TV to excess body weight. In some

    school districts, over half the student population is over-

    weight. And, unfortunately, many of these children will carry

    their weight problems into adulthood over-

    weight teenagers have an 80% chance of

    becoming obese adults.17

    GROWING UP TOO QUICKLYTHE

    LOST ART OF PLAYThanks to the constant bombard-

    ment of advertising geared toward

    10 T I P S F OR PA R EN TI N G I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    11/32

    adults, children are a lso growing up fas ter and doing adult

    things at younger and younger ages. Advertisers exacerbate

    this trend by deliberately using older kids in advertisements

    aimed at younger children. Ironically, toy advertisers have

    been victims of their own successes. An article in TheWashington Postdescribes the age compression faced by

    toy marketers each year, kids outgrow toys at younger

    ages, and toy marketers have to adjust accordingly. So do

    parents!18

    Many younger children, particularly girls, want to emu-

    late the images they see on TV and dress like older children.

    My nine-year-old daughter believes she should be allowedto wear makeup and wear clothes that are skimpy and quite

    inappropriate. She chooses these looks from magazine ads

    geared to pre-teens, says Susan Kemp of Illinois.

    Tying identity and se lf-worth to coolness encourages

    kids to value image over substance and cash over compas-

    sion. The more image-oriented we become, the more empty

    we feel, and young people are especially sensitive to this.From eating disorders to crime and drug use, much of the

    trouble our young people experience comes from an inabili-

    ty to find lasting satisfaction in material goods.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 11

    HOPEZANES

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    12/32

    OUR OVERBOOKED CH ILDRENThe pressure on our kids to go, do and be is unrea l.

    They are pushed to grow up younger and expect more.

    Kitty Welton, Utah.Like the frantic tempo of many ads, the pace of life for

    the average child is a lot faster than it once was. Like it or

    not, many kids are getting an unintended ear ly lesson in

    leading a hectic, on-the-go lifestyle. Alvin Rosenfeld, author

    ofThe Over-Scheduled Child, is concerned tha t lots of kids

    are pushed too hard toward achievement without enough

    time for relaxation, imagination or friendship. Whats hap-pened, he explains, is, you have to be in every activity, all

    the time. You have to be in soccer and take flute and take

    French lessons and go for I-dont-know-what and its end-

    less. It has become the American way of raising children. 19

    Constant striving for achievement is hard on kids and on

    their parents. Rosenfeld explains, Overscheduled kids,

    many of them, by the time theyre 12 or 14, dont know whothey are. The ones who are winning, doing all the accom-

    plishments, feel like frauds. They say, Nobody knows who I

    am, because I constantly have to be who they want me to

    12 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    HOPEZANES

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    13/32

    be.20 Parents want happy, successful children, but some-

    times the best way to achieve that is to give kids time to

    relax and explore in an unstructured way. Slowing down

    offers kids a refreshing chance to escape from the hurry-

    hurry hype of our commercial culture.

    POOR MONEY MANAGEMENT SK I L L SCommercial pressure fuels an insatiable desire for more,

    and instant credit makes it all too easy to make impulse

    purchases. In a society that pushes us to spend, spend,

    spend, it takes a lot of extra effort to instill good money

    management skills in our chil-

    dren. Despite the booming

    economy of the late 1990s:

    x The average personal savings

    rate in the United States plum-

    meted to 1.6% in 2001. (From

    1959 through 1992, the annual

    savings rate never dipped below

    7%, and the average rate of sav-

    ings was 8.8%.)21

    x In 2001, for the sixth straight

    year in a row, more Americans

    declared bankruptcy than gradu-

    ated from college.22 2001 also

    set the record for personal bankruptcy declarations

    1.5 million near ly 20% more than in 2000.23

    x Between 1990 and 1999, the amount of credit card debt

    held by the average college s tudent jumped by over 300%,

    from $900 to $2,748. University administrators cite finan-

    cial mismanagement as a crisis among college students.24

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 13

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    14/32

    LOW-INCOME FAMIL IES , IMMIGRANT FAMIL IES

    AND THE PRESSURE TO CONSUMEOur commercial culture is particularly problematic for

    people who cant a fford to buy the latest brand name items.

    When young people define their self-worth by what they

    wear or own, low-income kids feel the pressure most acute-

    ly. As Jennifer Hall of Michigan explains, When my oldest

    child was four years old he was already embarrassed to be

    seen in our beat-up car when I dropped him off at day care.The effect of the affluent kids is pervasive it even affects

    things as seemingly innocuous as lunch. The poor kids qual-

    ify for free hot breakfast and lunch, which creates a caste

    system in the schools. Kids dont understand why they cant

    have what they want when their friends do. What are we

    supposed to do, tell them they can only be friends with poor

    kids to make it easier for mom and dad to say no?Recent immigrants also worry about this pressure on

    their children. Barbara Gottleib-Robles of Maryland says

    about her daughter, shes finding it hard (as a 4 12-year-old

    recent immigrant to the States) to resist the dazzle of all

    her friends toys, videos, games, new shoes, etc. etc. ad

    nauseam. We wonder what values

    she will finally hold.Immigrant families strug-

    gle to maintain ties to

    their native lands while

    adapting to life in a new

    culture, and this pressure

    becomes especially acute

    because of the strong pull ofAmerican commercialism.

    14 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    15/32

    POSITIVE STEPS FOR PARENTS

    With hundreds of billions of dollars spent each year on

    advertising, it's impossible to be immune from commer-

    cialism, but there are steps we can take to protect our

    families . To nurture our children, we need to consciously

    reclaim our time and establish

    rituals and traditions that are

    healthy for our kids. Here are

    some of the positive actions

    parents can take.

    TAMING TUBE T IMEIf you are concerned that your

    kids a re spending too much time

    in front of the television or com-

    puter, consider taking some of

    the following steps.

    x Establish limits on how much

    time your children spend online or

    watching TV, and keep the TV and computer in public areas

    of the house where you can keep an eye on them.

    x

    Encourage crea tive a lternatives to television.x Mute the television during commercial breaks, or watch

    commercials with your children and help them understand

    the companies marketing techniques.

    x Set a good example. Watch occasional programs that you

    choose with good reason. Always be willing to explain your

    decisions.

    T I P S F OR PA R EN T IN G I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 15

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    16/32

    COMMERCIAL-FREE SCHOOLSHow can we keep our schools commercial-free?

    x Ask the PTA to hold a meeting about commercialism in

    the school. Work with teachers to analyze how and when

    commercial messages are reaching children, whether in text-

    books, the cafeteria, hallways, through fundraising events,

    monthly discount book sales (that increasingly sell jewelry,

    toys, and non-educational products), etc. Then figure out

    what needs to be done to reduce commercial exposure.

    x Does your childs school have Channel One? If so, ask to

    watch a broadcast. If the level and content of the advertis-

    ing disturbs you, work with other parents to get r id of

    Channel One. Bra instorm a lterna tives and put your plans

    into action. In dozens of communities across the country,

    parents have successfully gotten rid of Channel One in their

    schools.

    HEALTHY CHOICES FOR HEALTHY KIDSEmpower your children to be responsible for their own

    health and aware of the connections between their

    health and the health of the world.

    x Spend more time in

    nature. A park oreven your own

    yard will do. It

    helps connect

    children and

    adults to the larg-

    er scheme of things

    and offsets the noiseand rush of daily life. It also

    encourages kids to be physically active.

    x Teach your children to be aware of their health and their

    16 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    17/32

    choices. Faced with super sized meals and extra large

    sodas, kids have almost no chance of developing realistic

    food expecta tions without guidance and support.

    x Grow your own food even a pumpkin seed in a pot.

    Involve the kids. Teach your child about the connections

    within the natura l world. Experience the beauty together.

    Talk about where things come from, who made them, what

    they are made of.

    ECO-RESPONS IBLE CONSUMERSHelp your child understand tha t every product is made

    from materials extracted from the Earth, and that materialthings dont just disappear when the garbage gets picked

    up.

    x Teach your children about what happens to all that stuff.

    When we consume lots of plastic, or heavily packaged goods

    and products that eas ily break, we a re leaving a heavy bur-

    den for future generations to bear.

    x Seek out sources of products that are durable and made

    from biodegradable or recycled mater ials and which use

    less energy. Try to find recycled paper, locally-grown organic

    food and other earth-friendly products.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 17

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    18/32

    CREAT IVE PLAYThere are many alternatives to commercialized electronic

    enter tainment. Encouraging childrens creativity is one of

    the best ways to help them develop into self-sufficient,

    thinking adults.

    x Give kids the gift of music and art,

    both as enjoyers and makers. Buy

    music lessons ra ther than fancy elec-

    tronic gadgets.

    x Give children a big box of crayons

    and rolls of shelf paper. Supply them with

    sidewalk chalk, old cardboard boxes and

    other makings of creative play.

    x Pretend! Imagine you live in medieval France. Imagine

    youre ninety years old. Imagine youre president. Imagining

    encourages empathy in children. Collect old clothes or buy

    some at a thrift store; make a dress-up chest and act out

    stories.

    x Have an electricity-free night. Roughing-it at home by

    candlelight without the distractions of electrical gadgets

    offers a fun opportunity to bond as a family.

    x Organize a tr ipto the park for an

    old-fashioned game

    of capture the flag

    or hide and seek.

    18 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    HOPEZANES

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    19/32

    GUARD YOUR T IMEIts really about making

    them the priority in your

    life. A half hour may not

    sound like much, but if

    its quality time it can

    be better than two or

    three hours of distract-

    ed attention. Investing

    quality time in the kids

    while theyre young will

    pay large dividends in the

    future. All they need is to

    know that you are there for

    them, and that you love

    them. Barrett Sherwood,

    California.

    x Make time a positive

    force in your own life, and be a good role model: try to get

    work done without being a workaholic. They will look to you

    for an example, so show them how to set priorities and

    make time for people you love.

    x Make dinnertime special. Eat together as often as possi-ble. Slow down and create a dinnertime ritual of getting

    reconnected and really paying attention to each other as a

    family, even if you can only make it happen once or twice a

    week.

    x Devote the 20 minutes before bedtime exclusively to

    your children. Reconnect with them, read a book, swap

    news of the day, listen, pray or create some other ritual thatgives both of you the regular opportunity to express your

    mutual love.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 19

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    20/32

    SHOPP ING , MONEY AND STUFF

    By teaching our children just to pay attention to the flowof money and stuff in our lives, we are giv-

    ing them the tools they will need for

    financial security and helping to fos-

    ter a healthy attitude about money

    and spending.

    x Teach your child the value of

    money. Offer an allowance and setup a regular plan with your child

    for depositing a portion of the

    allowance in the local bank, and per-

    haps for donating a portion to a local

    charity. Let kids spend their own money and

    live with the consequences of their choices.

    x When your children beg for the lates t toy craze, ta lk

    about why they want the new object before just saying no or

    giving in. By talking about the root cause of the want and

    whether it really is something worth having, you may be

    able to diffuse their fixation on the object. Learn to say no

    and set limits.

    x Shopping can be fun a time to share, laugh and be

    together. Just dont turn the mall into your pr imar y dest ina-

    tion or shopping into your favorite sport.

    x Bring kids along when you shop for birthday presents for

    other children and ask them to think about the enduring

    value of different toys. Its a good opportunity to teach them

    critical consumer skills.

    xBe a role model. Avoid impulse shopping. Make a shop-

    ping list and s tick to it.

    20 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    21/32

    YOUR CH ILDREN (AND YOU) ARE MORE THAN A BRANDSometimes children need to be reminded that the

    thoughts in their head and the love in their heart matter

    more than the logos on their clothing. Brands are a form of

    labeling, of judging someone in a superficial manner based

    on their appearance.

    x Discuss stereotypes, labels and judgments . Help kids

    value people for who they are, not what they own.

    x Seek out clothing that is brand- or label-free. Talk with

    kids about why youre doing this.

    REMEMBER ING OTHERSA culture of affluent commercialism can spawn selfish-

    ness and a ttitudes of entitlement among young people. One

    cure to hyper-consuming kids is a good dose of awareness

    remembering that not everyone lives like they do.x Volunteer with your children in a soup kitchen or other

    establishment where they can meet people less fortunate

    than themselves.

    x Take them to

    visit their grand-

    parents, or to a

    retirement commu-

    nity to speak with

    the elder ly.

    Encourage kids to

    ask their elders

    what life was like

    when they were young, whats brought them joy in life and

    what they value most.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 21

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    22/32

    SO WHAT DO KIDS REALLYWANT?

    Recently, the Center held an art and essay contest, askingchildren, ages 5 to 17, What do you really want thatmoney cant buy? Their responses were extraordinary, not

    only for their creativity, vision and hope, but because they

    catalog the human heart. These children spoke universal

    truths, of the human hunger for deep connections to

    friends, family, nature and community, as well as their

    desire for a safer, more beautiful world.

    What did they say? I want a true friend that sticks with

    you through thick and thin, writes ten-year-old Brandon.

    My mom

    because she

    takes good care

    of me and

    helps me with

    my homework

    and I love her

    very much

    writes seven-

    year-old Aaron.

    Money could

    never buy the

    22 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    FRIENDS, JACQUELINE, AGE 12

    MORE TIME, STEPHANIE, AGE 11

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    23/32

    conversation that my Dad and I have in the car on the way

    to hockey practice. We talk about everything tha t you could

    think of. We talk about friends and about what is going on

    in the world I love the time with my Dad and no one or no

    thing could replace it, says eleven-year-old Seth.

    I want to play in the snow every winter. I want to swim

    in the ocean every summer. I want to plant trees in the park

    with my friends every spring. I want to jump in puddles

    every autumn. I want to

    adopt a homeless dog and

    a little kitten from a shel-

    ter (mom, please let me!)

    and teach them never to

    fight. I want there to be

    peace on Earth and I

    want people to take bet-

    ter care of our planet,

    writes one of our finalists,

    ten-year-old Anastasia,

    born in Russia and now

    living in Jersey City.

    I want peace; a quiet-

    ness for my soul. An ease

    for my thoughts and a rest for my heart I want faith. To

    possess the substance of things hoped for and the evidence

    of things not seen reflects Elisa, a very wise fouteen-

    year-old.

    Children can show us the way if we help them slow down

    and stay attuned to their deeper, non-material yearnings.

    They can help us rediscover what we want that money cant

    buy. Our true des ires, for the most part , are universa l: love,

    peace, security, friends and the knowledge that we are part

    of something larger than ourselves.

    To see more winning entries , log on to

    www.newdream.org/campaign/kids/contest.html.

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 23

    LOVE AND RESPECT AROUND THE

    WORLD, M. MCCOSKEY, AGE 7

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    24/32

    YOU ARE NOT ALONE

    The task of conscientious parenting is always daunting,and theres a lot to be gained by reaching out to friends,family and the community for support in your efforts to

    reduce the negative impact of commercialism on your chil-dren. Join a babysitting trading co-op. Find parental sup-

    port groups. Speak with your parents or other people who

    have already wres tled with these issues . Together, youll find

    creative and innovative solutions that work for you, and

    wed love it if youd share some of your suggestions with us.

    WHAT YOU DO MATTERSObviously, these tips alone wont single-mindedly solve allthe problems presented by our commercial world. But its

    important to acknowledge tha t parents do have the power to

    promote a healthy understanding of money, spending and the

    effect of commercialism on our quality of life, the environ-

    ment and a just society. This way, we help to raise a genera-

    tion of young people who can lead happier and healthierlives as they build better and s tronger communities. Its a

    tall order, but its worth pursuing for you, your children

    and future generations.

    24 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    25/32

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 25

    RESOURCES FOR PARENTS

    THE CENTER FOR A NEW AMER ICAN DREAMThe Center for a New American Dream is a membership-based

    non-profit organization working to challenge the more is better

    definition of the American dream. We help Americans consume

    responsibly to protect the environment, enhance qua lity of life a nd

    promote social justice. We work with individuals, inst itutions , com-

    munities and businesses to conserve natural resources, counter

    the commercialization of our culture and promote positive changes

    in the way goods are produced and consumed.

    WE INVITE YOU TO BE OUR PARTNER

    If you found this brochure to be useful, let us know. We appreciate

    your feedback and encouragement. Our work depends on the gen-

    erosity and support of people across the country. Please consider

    becoming a supporting member of the Center for a New American

    Dream.

    As a member, youll rece ive a copy of the Center s 30-minute

    video, More Fun, Less Stuff: The Challenges and Rewards of a New

    American Dream; our quarterly publication Enough; and a monthly

    e-mail bulletin with information about ongoing campaigns, book

    recommendations and action tips. Become a supporting member of

    the Center for a New American Dream and join us as we encourage

    Americans to adopt our motto: More Fun, Less Stuff!

    ORGANIZATIONS

    TV-Turnoff Network www.tvturnoff.org, [email protected],202-518-5556

    National Institute on Media and the Familywww.mediaandthefamily.org, [email protected],

    1-888-672-KIDS

    Center for Media Education

    www.cme.org, [email protected], 202-331-7833

    Dads and Daughers

    www.dadsanddaughters.org, [email protected],1-888-824-DADS

    (continued next page)

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    26/32

    26 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    Commercial Alert

    www.commercialalert.org, [email protected], 503-235-

    8012Stop Commercial Exploitat ion o f Childrenwww.commercialexploitation.com, Diane LevinDlevin@whee-

    lock.edu, 617-879-2167

    BOOKS

    Canada, Geoffrey. Reaching Up For Manhood. Beacon, 1998.

    Hewlett, Sylvia Ann and Cornel West. The War Against Pa rents :

    What We Can Do for Amer icas Beleaguered Moms and Dads.

    Houghton Mifflin, 1998.

    Pipher, Mar y. The Shelter of Each Other: Rebuilding our Families.

    Ballantine Books, 1996.

    Rosenfeld, Alvin, PhD., and Nicole Wise. The Over-Scheduled Child:

    Avoiding the Hyper-Parenting Trap. Griffin, 2001.

    Taylor, Betsy. What Kids Really Want That Money Cant Buy.

    Warner, 2003.

    MAGAZINESStay Free! Magazinewww.stayfreemagazine.org,

    [email protected],

    718-398-9324.

    Zillions: Consumer Repor ts for Kidswww.zillions.org, 101 Truman

    Ave., Yonker s, NY 10703-1057, fax: 914-378-2985.

    Stone Soup, literary magazine by and for kids 8-13.

    www.stonesoup.com, lgabr [email protected], 1-800-447-4569.

    New Moon, a magazine for girls and young women.www.newmoon.org, [email protected], 1-800-3814743.

    OTHER

    Video: The Cost of Cool, a video about youth, consumption, and the

    environment. Available from Population Communications

    International www.population.org. (Look for it at your library first!)

    Simplicity Activities for 4th/5th Graders from seedsofsimplicity.org.

    1-877-UNSTUFF. Also available: 7-minute video, Kids Speak Outon Stuff.

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    27/32

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 27

    THE CENTER FOR A NEW AMER ICAN DREAMSKIDS AND COMMERCIAL ISM CAMPAIGN IS ENDORSED BY:

    INDIVIDUALS*

    The Honorable Dianne FeinsteinUnited States Senator

    Marian Wright Edelman

    Founder and Pres ident, Childrens Defense Fund

    RaffiChildrens Troubadour, Author

    Sylvia Ann Hewlett

    Co-author with Cornel West ofThe War Agains t Parents: What We CanDo for Amer icas Beleaguered Moms and Dads

    Patch AdamsGesundheit Institute

    Mary Pipher, Ph.D.Author ofReviving Opheliaand The Shelter of Each Other: Rebuilding

    Our Families

    Juliet SchorBoston College

    Author ofThe Overspent American

    Bill McKibbenAuthor ofThe End of Nature

    Joanna Macy

    Co-author with Molly Young Brown ofComing Back to Life: Practices to

    Reconnect Our Lives , Our World

    David Walsh

    President, National Institute on Media and the Family

    Author ofDesigner Kidsand Selling Out Amer icas Children

    Arnold Fege

    President, Public Advocacy for KidsFormer director of governmental relations, National PTA

    Michael JacobsonDirector of the Center for Science in the Public Interest

    Co-author with Laurie Mazur ofMarketing Madness

    Alex MolnarDirector of the Center for the Analysis of Commercialism

    in Education

    Author of Giving Kids the Business: The Commercialization

    of Amer icas Schools

    Peggy OMaraEditor and Publisher, MotheringMagazine

    Marian Tomps on

    Founding mother of La Leche League

    (continued next page)

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    28/32

    28 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    Jean Kilbourne, Ph.D.Visit ing Scholar, Wellesley College

    Creator ofKilling Us Softly: Advertisings Image of WomenTerry Tempest WilliamsAuthor ofRefuge: An Unnatural History of Family and Place and An

    Unspoken Hunger

    Brian Swimme, Ph.D.Author ofThe Hidden Heart of the Cosmos

    Cecile Andrews

    Author ofThe Circle of Simplicity: Return to the Good Life

    Dan Zanes

    Family Entertainer, Musician

    David SuzukiGeneticist, co-author with Amanda McConnell of

    The Sacred Balance: Rediscovering Our Place in Nature

    Bonnie McDanielAuthor ofThe Art of Good Living

    Red GrammerFamily singer and songwriter

    * (The organizations of individual endorsers are listed for identification purposes only.)

    ORGANIZATIONS

    Bridging the Gap

    Center for Commercial-Free Public Education

    Consumer Federation of America

    Center for Media Education

    Co-op America

    Commercial Alert

    Consumer s Choice Council

    Dads and Daughters

    Earth Ministry

    Friends of the Earth-USGlobal Action Plan for the Earth

    Honor the Earth Fund

    Media Education Foundation

    Mothers & Others

    National Head Start Association

    New Road Map Foundation

    Obligation Inc.

    Physicians for Social Responsibility

    Rainforest Action Network

    Redefining ProgressSecond Nature

    Stay Free! magazine

    TV-Free America

    Worldwatch Institute

    Zillions: Consumer Reports for Kids

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    29/32

    T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE 29

    FOOTNOTES

    1 James McNeal and Chyon-Hwa Yeh. Born to Shop, AmericanDemographics, June 1993 , pp 34-39.

    2 Cited in Bra nd Aware , Childrens Busines s, June 2000.

    3 New Poll Shows Marketing to Kids Taking Its Toll on Parent s,

    Families. Center for a New American Dream, 1999.

    www.newdream.org/campaign/kids/press-release.html

    4 James McNeal. Tapping the Three Kids Mar kets, American

    Demographics, April 1998, pp 37-41. Teenage Research Unlimited.

    Press releas e 1 /25/02, Teens Spent $172 Billion in 2001 www.teenre -

    search.com.

    5 McNea l quoted in: Campbell, Kim. How ads get kids to sa y, I want it!

    Christian Science Monitor, September 18, 2000 .

    6 Teenage Research Unlimited. Press releas e 1/25/02, Teens Spent $172

    Billion in 2001 www.teenresearch.com.

    7 James McNeal. Tapping the Three Kids Mar kets, American

    Demographics, April 1998, pp 37-41.

    8 Annenberg Public Policy Center. Media In The Home 2000: The Fifth

    Annual Survey of Parents and Children.

    http://www.appcpenn.org/reports /2000/, 19.

    9 Ibid.

    10 American Academy of Pedia tr ics (1999). Cited by Nat ional Institute on

    Media and the Family, Children and Advertising Fact Sheet 2002.

    11 Kaiser Family Founda tion Study Kids & Media @ The New

    Millennium. See www.kff.org.

    12 U.S. News and World Report, 1999, as cited in National Institute on

    Media and the Family, Internet Advertising and Children Fact Sheet

    2002.

    13 According to a 1998 study by Profess or Alex Molnar, director of the

    Univers ity of Wisconsins Center for the Analysis of Commercialism in

    Education, and Max Sawicky, an economist with the Economic Policy

    Institute.

    14 American Drea m 2000, poll by Interprise for Junior Achievement.

    http://www.ja.org/about/about_new_poll.shtml.

    15 Pipher, Mar y. The Shelter of Each Other: Rebuilding our Families. NewYork: Ballantine Books, 1996.

    16 See Orr, D.W. Earth in Mind. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1994. 131.

    (continued next page)

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    30/32

    30 T I P S F OR PARENT I NG I N A COMMER I C A L CULTURE

    17 Squires, Sally. Obesity-Linked Diabetes Rising in Children.

    Washington Post. November 3, 1998, p. 207.

    18 Shen, Fern. Toys? But Im 10 Now! The Was hington Post, February

    17, 2002, p. H1.

    19 Tres trail, Joanne. Overscheduled, Overwhelmed inter view with Alvin

    Rosenfeld. Chicago Tribune. September 2, 2001.

    20 Ibid.

    21 Per sona l sa vings ra te data from the Burea u of Economic Analysis , US

    Department of Commerce.

    22 Projections of Educat ion Stat istics to 2010, Nat ional Center for

    Education Statistics, US Department of Education, and Non-BusinessBankruptcy Filings by Chapter, 19902001, American Bankruptcy

    Institute (www.abiwolrd.org/sta ts/1990nonbuschapter.html).

    23 Morning Edition, Nat ional Public Radio. Per sona l bankruptcy filings

    jump by nearly 20 percent in 2001 May 8, 2002.

    24 Credit Card Use Continued Among College Students , Nellie Mae web-

    site, www.nelliemae.com. Hadley, Jane. Credit Cards Get Students in a

    Hole Fast , Seattle Post Intelligencer, May 11, 1998.

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    31/32

    HELP US RE - SHAPE THE AMER ICAN DREAM!

    $______ Membership $30 ($15 senior/student/low-income). Membership

    includes our quarte rly newsletter Enough!, a copy of the Centers new

    30 minute video hosted by Danny Glover and a More Fun, Less Stuff

    bumper s ticker.

    $______ More Fun, Less Stuff: The Challenges and Rewards of a New

    American Dream hosted by Danny Glover. 30 minute video. $12.00

    $______ Simplify the Holidays brochure $4.00

    $______ Good Times Made Simple: The Lost Art of Fun $4.00

    $______ Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture $4.00

    $______ Donation (please circle one) $10 $25 $50 $75 $100 $______

    $______ Gift Subscription $15, if purchased a long with one $30 membership.

    Otherwise, gift memberships cost $25 each. Includes membership

    advantages listed above plus a hand-written card acknowledging your

    gift. You will receive a note with our tha nks. Please a tta ch name and

    address of the gift recipient.

    $______ TOTAL

    METHOD OF PAYMENT

    t CHECK t VISA t MASTERCARD t AMEX

    CARD NUMBER EXP IRATION DATE

    NAME AS IT APPEARS ON CREDIT CARD

    SIGNATURE

    PLEASE COMPLETE FORM

    Please note that our mailing list is never traded, exchanged or sold.

    NAME

    ADDRESS CITY

    STATE/P ROVINCE ZIP COUNTRY

    P HONE/ FAX E- MAIL ADDRESS ( FO R OUR E- MAIL SE RVICE)

  • 8/14/2019 Tips for Parenting in a Commercial Culture

    32/32

    CENTER

    FOR

    A

    NEW

    AMERICANDREAM

    6930Carroll

    Ave,Suite900

    TakomaPark,Maryland20912

    Printedon100%

    post-con-

    sumerwastepaperusingnon-

    heavymetalbasedsoyinks.

    100%PCW

    100%postconsumerrecycled,processchlorine-freepaper