theory of recoil effect in haxpes and its prospect as a ... · haxpes 2009 (nsls), 20 may 2009...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a Tool for Material Research
Y. Kayanuma
aGraduate School of Engineering,Osaka Prefecture University
Japan
HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009
Collaborators:
Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU)
![Page 2: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
1. Introduction
Recoil effect of atoms, molecules and solids
2. Core level X-ray photoemission in graphites
3. Valence band X-ray photoemission
4. Outlook
Recoil spectroscopy?
![Page 3: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Anomalies in HXPES for 1s core-level in graphiteY. Takata et al.
Normal angle emission
RT
1. Shift of the binding energy
2. Anomalous broadening depend on X-ray energy
3. Asymmetric line shape
![Page 4: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
pP rr−=
Mm
mp
MPE ×==Δ
22
22 rr
220001
=Mm
keV82
2
≈m
preV!36.0≈ΔE
Recoil effect is observable!
(carbon atom)
![Page 5: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Energy momentum relation
10keV 20keV
Mom
entu
m
chpX /ν=
mEpe 2=
Eh orν
1.0/ keV,10at ≈= eX pphν 01.0/ ≈ΔΔ∴ eX EE
Momentum of photon is negligible.
But momentum of photoelectron is NOT.
![Page 6: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
A guy with weight 70kg dived from a ship of 1500t , and you observed the ship to move!
![Page 7: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Doppler Broadening
νh
pr
M M
Energy conservation
pPirr
−
iPr
MpP
mp
MPh ii
c 2)(
22
222 rrrr−
+=++ νε
MpP
MPh
mpE ii
cobs 2)(
22
222 rrrr−
−++== νε
MpP
Mph i
c
rrr⋅
+−+=2
2
νε
( ) ( ) TkEpM
P
MpPEE B
iiobsobs Δ==
⋅=− 2
32
2
2
2
22 r
rrr
EMp
Δ=2
2r
0=⋅
MpPirr
m
In crystal, ωh→TkB
![Page 8: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
We need quantum mechanics
ωhMpE
2
2
=ΔsolidM
M
)(1 ωh<<Δ<< ES
ωh/ES Δ=
)(1 ωh>>Δ>> ES Observed peak shift EΔ=
Observed peak shift 0=
Se−
Mossbauer Effect
Asymmetric line shape quantum effect of phonons
![Page 9: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Recoil effect comes out from only one assumption.
)( Rrr cc
rrr−=ψψAdiabatic
approximation
Translational symmetry
Momentum conservation
Initial state
Atomic position is a dynamic variable.
Rr
Final state ( )rkiV
r kvrr⋅= exp1ψ
Fermi’s golden rule
( )∑ Γ+−−−+
ΨΨΓ=
f mcn
iIf
hE
HEI
22
2
)(εενεπ
![Page 10: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
[ ])(exp)( )( tGeetF ikutiku =≡ −
( )( ){ }titntG qqqq
q λλλλ
λ ωωα sin1cos12)( 2 −−+=∑
22
2 λλ
λ ηω
α qq
q kNM
⋅⎟⎟⎠
⎞⎜⎜⎝
⎛=
rh
Wave vector of electronAtomic mass
Displacement vector of atom
)(21)( || tFedtEI itEt∫
∞
∞−
−Γ−= hh
π
![Page 11: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Phonon dispersion of graphite
L. Wirtz and A. Rubio, Solid State Commn., 131,141 (2004)
bending
stretching
Equi-frequency surface
//k
Anisotropic Debye Model
![Page 12: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Excitation energy dependence (normal emission)
meV(HWHM)80=Γ
M)120meV(FWHresolutionalExperiment =
Y. Takata et al. Phys. Rev. B 75, 233404 (2007).
![Page 13: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Emission angle dependence (7940eV, RT)
grazing
normal
Y. Takata et al. Phys. Rev. B 75, 233404 (2007).
![Page 14: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
D
ES,λ
λ ωhΔ
=
ES D Δ=,λλ ωh
DDDD ES ,,,, λλλλ ωωω ∝Δ= hh
Peak shift =
1if >>λS
Width =
Effective electron-phonon coupling const.
Why?
coordinate space Momentum space
Doppler broadening is larger for high ω
![Page 15: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
Recoil effect is universal Neutron scatteringsElectron scatteringsHX photoelectron emission
....etc
But,the photoelectron carries also information on the electronic state it has occupied initially.
The recoil effect in valence level XPS will be much more interesting !
![Page 16: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Which atom(s) receives the recoil momentum?
Recoil effect in Bloch electrons?
![Page 17: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Y. Takata et al.
Au=197Al=27
Striking recoil shift does exist!
-1-0.500.51
AuAl
Intensity (ar
b. units)
Binding Energy (eV)
hν=7940eVT=20K
![Page 18: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Al (pseudopotential)Free electron (FCC)
existence of HX photoemission existence of Umklapp process
electrons see lattice
Even nearly free electrons see lattice structure!
27eV11
eV108 3
≈×
=Fermi
ronphotoelect
pp
Momentum is not conserved.
![Page 19: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Recoil Effect of Bloch Electrons
∑ +−=ji
jijie aaRRtH,
)(rr
)(0)( iii Rrarrrrrr
−=≡ + ϕϕ iii uRR rrr+= 0
)(2 ji
jij
jL RRV
MP
Hrr
r
−+= ∑∑≠
0+∑= ii
ik acψ
01iikR
i eN
c =)()(0
ii
ikRk Rrer i
rrv −=∑ ϕψ
⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛ += +∑ 2
1,,
,, λλ
λλω qq
qqL bbH h
Wannier function
Bloch function
![Page 20: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )tFedteKkI jj
RkKithEit jk ∑∫ ⋅−∞
∞−
−−−Γ−=0
21,
rrrhh rrr εν
π
( ) ( ) 0uKtuKij eetF j
rrrr⋅−⋅=
( ) ( ) ( )tFdteEI tkhEitKk 02
1, ∫∞
∞−
−−−Γ−= hrhrr
εν
πε
It seems that a single atom receives the recoil momentum.
Shrinkage of the wave function by the measurement?
Off diagonal terms are negligible.
dynamical structure factor
![Page 21: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
-1-0.500.51
Au(Experiment)Al(Experiment)Au(Theory)Al(Theory)
Intensity (arb. units)
Binding Energy (eV)
hν=7940eVT=20K
Recoil effect of photoelectrons in the Fermi edge of simple metalsY. Takata et al., Phys. Rev. Lett, 101, 137601(2008)
-1-0.500.51
Au(Experiment)Al(Experiment)Au(Theory)Al(Theory)
Intensity (arb. units)
Binding Energy (eV)
hν=880eVT=50K
Origins of broadening
1. Temperature (Fermi distribution)
2. Resolution (Gaussian broadening)
3. Recoil effect (New!)
![Page 22: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Next TargetHow is it in compounds?
Recoil splitting ?
BM
AM
BE
BE
Soft X-ray
Hard X-ray
![Page 23: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
pp−
12
b
a
( )12212211 21 +Δ++= εεeH
( )212
22
1
21
22XXV
MP
MPHa −++=
( )dxdipAApH I h−=+= + ,
ae HHH +=
( ) ( )111 1 Xxxx −=≡ ϕϕ
( ) ( )222 2 Xxxx −=≡ ϕϕ
Model 1 diatomic molecule
![Page 24: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
( ) ( )111 1 Xxxx −=≡ ϕϕ
( ) ( )222 2 Xxxx −=≡ ϕϕ
21
21
βα
αβ
+=
+−=
b
a
a
b
Adiabatic approx.
0⊗⊗⊗=Ψ gbhi ν
mKkvacf ⊗⊗⊗=Ψ
( )mKkbm K
k EhbgpkKmI εεενδε −−−+=∑∑ 2,,0,,)(
![Page 25: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
termscross)()()( 22
22
12
12 ++= kkk III εςβεςαε
( )xdxdiedx i
ikx
i ϕς ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛−=
−
∫
kε0
kε0
+
relativeEΔ CMEΔ
CMEΔ
21
2 ςα×
22
2 ςβ×
![Page 26: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Model 2 composite metal
Heavy atom and light atom
In a unit cell
( ) ( ){ } jRki
j
BjB
AjAk eRrwkCRrwkC
Nr
0
21 )()(1)(rrrrvrrrr ⋅∑ −+−=ψ
Bloch function
Atomic positions are dynamic variables (not parameters).
Au
Al
![Page 27: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
)()()( εεε BA DDD +=
( ) ( ) ( )tFedtEI AthEi
A ∫∞
∞−
−−−= hεν
πε
21,
( )( ){ }⎥⎥⎦
⎤
⎢⎢⎣
⎡−−+= ∑ titntF qqq
q
AqA λλλ
λλ ωωα sin1cos12exp)(
2
22
2 λλ
λ ηω
α qqA
Aq k
NM⋅⎟
⎟⎠
⎞⎜⎜⎝
⎛=
rh
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ){ }∫∞
∞−+= εεςεεςεε ,, 22 EIDEIDfdEI BBBAAA
Local DOS
Contribution from A site
Contribution from B site BA→
Valence band PES may split due to recoil effect!
![Page 28: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
How about amorphous materials?Which atom(s) receive recoil momentum?
![Page 29: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
Yokohama CU, Yamada Lab.
LiCoO2
Recoil effect as a probe of local atomic environment
Lithium ion battery
![Page 30: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
R
Valence level
Second Order Effect of Recoil
Valence band Auger
Valence band X-ray emission
![Page 31: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
νh
νh
Recoil Spectroscopy of Local Vibration
site selective
angle selective
level selective
![Page 32: Theory of Recoil Effect in HAXPES and Its Prospect as a ... · HAXPES 2009 (NSLS), 20 May 2009 Collaborators: Y. Takata (RIKEN/SPring-8) , S. Tanaka (OPU), S.Oshima(OPU) 2 1. Introduction](https://reader036.vdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f6f2f8d7afd5b472f6cc7/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
Message of this work1. Recoil effect in x-ray photoemission is a purely kinematic effect.
Only the adiabatic approximation is needed theoretically.
2. Line shape in core level recoil spectra carries information of the
rigidity of the atomic environment. (Doppler broadening)
3. Even Bloch electrons show recoil effect. (From which atom was it ejected?)
4. Valence spectra may split due to recoil effect.
Recoil Spectroscopy, a new tool?