the world major scientific periodicals to be used by
TRANSCRIPT
« , » The world major scientific periodicals to be used by
researchers of renewable energy, local and sec- ondary energy
resources
, Lazarev, Vladimir Stanislavovich, Skalaban, Aleksey Vital’evich
Belarusian National Technical University . , 16 220013, . , .: +375 17 292-98-75 [email protected] [email protected]
16 Yakub Kolas St., 220013, Minsk, Republic of Belarus Tel.: +375 17 292-98-75 [email protected] [email protected]
. , - , - , , , . « , » - - - . - ; « ». 378 , - , - , - - 2016-2020 c – - .
Abstract. It is known that the selection of n acceptably representative sample of the world scientific peri- odicals to be used as backgrounds of a high-quality research should focus not only on specialized journals, but also on periodicals, the topics and the titles of which are formally not related to the research area. In the present study the determination of the best periodicals to be used in research on renewable energy, local and secondary energy resources has been fulfilled with the aid of four varieties of citation analysis, twelve journals specialized in power production being used as the source items of citation data. The methods of the analysis were clarified and elaborated; the concept and the term "discipline receptivity factor" were proposed. The practical result is a list of 378 world periodicals, that is planned to be used in creating a comfortable scientific information environment by using the world leading databases reflecting the most valuable collection of scientific journals that are necessary for quality performance of scientific research on Priority areas of scientific-technical activity in the Republic of Belarus for 2016-2020 followed by the establishment of an operational system of selective alert informing prominent experts that implement the respective areas. : , , , - , -, , , - , Keywords: journals, periodicals and serial publications, citation, citatedness, citations analysis, discipline impact factor, discipline receptivity factor, renewable energy, local and secondary energy resources
- 2016 , – - - [1].
- , . « , » .
[2], - 1/3 - . , , , , - , . [3; 4] , , - [5]. (- , , - , [5] , -, - ; , [6], - [7] .) / - : - () , , , [8-10].
- -
– – - « , ». (- , ) - - , - , - «».
, - - , – – . , - , , , , – , – , - - « » . , «» , - , , «» ; - . - , «» - « » - , .
- -, - – « » [11]. , ( ) « », «», , - (, , ) . , , , 1000 , 500 , , 100 , – 50 , 500 50 (, , ) - , : 10 «» . , – 0,5 (500/1000 = 50/100). ,
: . , : - , - , , - ; , , .
, , .. , . , - - , : , - 1. , « » , , - , , - ; «- » [12, c. 84–85]. - . - «» , .. , . , , , , - , , , , , – … , – ; «», - , - – . , « », « - » , , « » ,
1 , «» (.. «- ») .. [13], - . , « » [11]. , - – ... .. 1927 [3]! , , , - 10 – , [3, p. 387]. , , 1927 .
, « » .
Web of Science™, – Journal Citation Reports®, 12 . , - [12, . 80—81]. - , , - [4; 14; 15] ( – [16]). 89 , “Energy & Fuels“ Journal Citation Reports® 2014 2, – c ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory3, - . , web- . - , - . - ( ) « ». , « » , - , . - : 1) , 2) «» - « », 3) 2014 . “Journal Citation Reports”® ( – JCR) , 4) . - “eigenfactor” (« - ») [12, c. 100–101]. JCR. - . 1. « »
2 - 2016 , 2015 Web of Science Journal Citation Reports . 3 ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory – - Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, ( ) ( ) - 200 . [17]. , - .
1. , « ,
»
.
«- » 2014 .
2014 .
4 5 1 Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re-
views; USA; ELSEVIER; 1364-0321 8 5,901 11 21 901
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy; USA; IEEE, 1949-3029
17 4,882 44 1 368
3 BioEnergy Research; USA; SPRINGER; 1939-1234
18 3,541 41 1 577
4 Renewable Energy; England; ELSEVIER; 0960-1481
20 3,476 15 16 421
5 Solar Energy; USA; PERGAMON- ELSEVIER; 0038-092X
21 3,469 14 16 656
6 Wind Energy;England; WILEY-BLACK- WELL;1095-4244
28 3,069 36 2 354
7 IET Renewable Power Generation; Eng- land; IET; 1752-1416
46 1,904 52 1 116
8 Journal of Energy Resources Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; 0195-0738
47 1,886 51 1 124
9 Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; 0199-6231
49 1,614 34 2 477
10 International Journal of Green Energy; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; 1543- 5075
57 1,215 59 796
11 Journal of Renewable and Sustainable En- ergy; USA; AIP; 1941-7012
61 0,904 56 886
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utiliza- tion and Environmental Effects; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; 1556-7036
80 0,386 53 1 015
, , , , - . , - , - , , , , [14];
4 89 , “Energy & Fuels“. 5 .
[14] “Renewable and Sustain- able Energy Reviews” - . , , , « - », , , , “eigenfactor”, , ( « - ») . ( “eigenfactor” ).
, , - , , -- (“Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”) « » ( ) - , - - , « - , », , , -. - , , - .
2014 12-
2009-2014 2014 12- 2009-2014
JCR: JCR , “Go to Journal Profile” -, “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”. - “Source Data”, “Citing Journal Data” (- “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”) “Cited Jour- nal Data” ( “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”). 12 . “Citing Journal Data” - 2009-2014 ; - , - , 12- - -. ( - - « , », - 2009-2014 .) ,
JCR « » - .
( ) 12- – JCR “Cited Jour- nal Data”.
-
- - ( - ) 2014-2009 . - 12- -- . - “ Go to Journal Profile” Journal Citation Reports®. - “Key Indicators” “Citable Items” 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010 2009 , - , , , . , - 2009-2014 ., citable items 2009-2014 ., . , G. Hirst 1977 “discipline impact factor” – « »6 [4, p.171; 18]. , cit- able items. - .
( ) 12- - - - . , 2014-2009 . - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” ( -
6 : « , [ : - – .., ..]; , , , ; . C. , , DIF DIF = nc/ns, nc J ts. JCR. tc ns - JCR . , , 1977 . [18] c JCR 1976 1975 ., tc 1974-1975, ns – 1972-1975 .» [4, p.171].
), , – - , . - , .. - .
, 2014 . - - , - . – 2014- – . - - , - - 2009-2014 , - « , - », - () . , - - 2009-2014 ., 2014 . , « - » , - 12- - 2009-2014 - , 2014 . « - » - « ».
: . , - , « » , , «» - «» . «- » : - , ; , 50 66% /7 . , 15- (
7 « » - [2]. ( , .. - ; , - .)
/ ), - 8. : « » , / 15- , , - , - , / 15- 2009-2014 . « » - , - / - , - – .
/.
12-
2 - 12- -, , , « », - 3 – 12- -, , , « ».
2. - « » « »
.
-- ; ; ISSN
- (t)
, t, - , - 15 (tl)
, t 2009-
2014 . ()
.. .. t
.. t
.. C
D E F 1 Renewable and Sus-
tainable Energy Re- views; USA; ELSE- VIER; ISSN: 1364-0321
68 36 9
33 340 48,76 %
19 904 59,70 %
8 15 [19]. , - . , « » . ; . 9 2 , 0 , 15 .
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable En- ergy; USA; IEEE, ISSN: 1949-3029
4 057 100 %
1 953 48,13 %
2 218 54,67 %
1 750 78,89 %
6 331 100 %
2 954 46,65 %
2 763 43,64 %
1 415 51,21 %
21 526
16 197
3 855 100 %
1 383 35,87 %
1 582 41,03 %
2 137 100 %
1 029 48,15 %
1 017 47,59 %
541 53,19 %
8 Journal of Energy Resources Technol- ogy – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0195-0738
2 469 100 %
852 34,50 %
907 36,76 %
399 37,37 %
9 Journal of Solar En- ergy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0199-6231
2 627 100 %
346 33,52 %
10 International Jour- nal of Green En- ergy; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1543-5075
2 231 100 %
825 36,97 %
863 38,68 %
503 58,28 %
11 Journal of Renewa- ble and Sustainable Energy; USA; AIP; ISSN: 1941-7012
7 495 100 %
3 343 44,60 %
3 712 49,52 %
1 839 49,54 %
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utili- zation and Environ- mental Effects; USA; TAYLOR &
4 657 100 %
1 871 40,17 %
2 520 54,11 %
FRANCIS; ISSN: 1556-7036
, 2, (- D), , , 15 , 42% ( 57,10% - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” 32,50% - “ Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME”). - , « » 15 , – . , 57,10% “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re- views” 39 040 - , 15- , , - - 15- , - 35 134 . «11- », , «- » , .
, ( F), - 2009-2014 ., 15 , 50% , «» 2009-2014 .
– , «» 2009 , , , – 2009-2014 . 46% JCR - ( E).
( - - 12.)
, 3, , , ( “Renewable Energy”), ( , “Solar Energy” – . ). , : - , «», «- » (, [20]).
, “Solar Energy”, , -, - , - 2014 , . - « » “Solar Energy” – « » 12- , , JCR , : 2005 . ; 2008 . – 1,6; 2009 . – ; 2014- – 3,469.
3: - , - 15 (
30,10% 81,91% – D); – 2009-2014 ( , , 15). - .
3. - « » « »
.
(Rt)
, Rt, - , - - 15 (Rtl)
, Rt 2009-
2014 . (R)
.. .. Rt
.. Rt
.. C
Sustainable Energy Reviews; USA; ELSEVIER; ISSN: 1364-0321
21 901
83,04%
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable En- ergy; USA; IEEE, ISSN: 1949-3029
1 329
1 577
100% 785
16 421
16 656
2 354
1 116
100% 772
69,18% 891
79,84% 619
1 124
100% 574
51,07% 390
34,70%
279
48,61%
10 2 , 0 , 15
nology – Transac- tions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0195-0738
9 Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0199-6231
2 477
30,48%
526
31,40%
10 International Jour- nal of Green En- ergy; USA; TAY- LOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1543-5075
796
67,34%
315
71,11%
11 Journal of Renewa- ble and Sustainable Energy; USA; AIP; ISSN: 1941-7012
886
99,66%
316
99,68%
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utilization and En- vironmental Ef- fects; USA; TAY- LOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1556-7036
1 329
100% 400
30,10% 658
64,83%
263
65,75%
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utilization and En- vironmental Ef- fects; USA; ISSN: 1556- 7036
1 329
100% 400
30,10% 658
64,83%
263
65,75%
( . 2) - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” - . -- “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” , - (. 2, ), “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re- views” 68 339 , «» – - , 73 582. « » 2009-2014 . (. 2, - E) «-» - : 33 340 “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” 33 995 «».
, « » “Renewable Energy” (UK) “Solar Energy” (USA) - , . «» ? ,
“BioEnergy Research” ( 6 331 ), “Wind Energy” ( 3 855 ) “Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME” (- 2 627 ) “International Journal of Green Energy” ( «-» 2 231 ) - « , ». “Solar Energy” 16 656 , (. 3), - – 16 197 (. 2): – - ( - ), «», - (, “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, 2 3, ). , «-» – – [16]. : - - .
, : “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” - / , 12- .
,
2009-2014 427 . «- », , - . ( 15- , «» - 23 , «- ».) , 427 (450) , , 15-, , - , 2009-2014 . - 15- . 230 (53,86% 427 51,11% 450 – - ). - .
( «-» JCR11, “THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - JOURNAL SEARCH” (http:// ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/mjl/) , ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory , , Google) - , , , . - , «-» JCR Web- ”THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - JOURNAL SEARCH”, :
1) “IEEE Power Engineering Society. General Meeting” – Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (ISSN: 1932-5517);
2) “Energy Procedia” – , Elsevier BV, (ISSN: 1876-6102) – - , , [28], - ;
3)“World Energy Outlook” (ISSN: 1026-1141) – , ;
4) “The Electricity Journal” (ISSN: 1040-6190) – (: Elsevier Inc., ), - - – , ;
5) “Procedia Engineering” (ISSN: 1877-7058) – - , - , Elsevier Inc., Netherlands);
6) “International Journal of Energy and Environment” (ISSN: 2076-2895) – , International Energy and Environment Foundation (), ;
7) “World Development Indicators” (ISSN: 1029-4325) – (: The World Bank, ), - , 800 , – - ;
8) “BP Statistical Review of World Energy” (ISSN: 1475-858X) – - (: B P p.l.c., ), 10 .
. , Journal
11 “Go to Journal Profile” JCR.
Citation Reports® (« »), - ; , - « ». «11- » - ( « - » « ») , 12, . , “Solar Energy” - ( ) «» - – 22-.
, - . - : “ENRGY PROCED” (130 ; – 88 « » 42 – “Solar Energy”) “Energy Procedia” (60 ; – 44 « » 16 – “Solar Energy”); « - » JCR . , – “Energy Procedia” (ISSN: 1876-6102) : “Energy Procedia” [21] “ENRGY PROCED” ([22] – c. 203). , , ( “Energy Procedia”), - . - .
“ENERG BUILDINGS” (595 ; – 381 « - »; – “Renewable Energy”, “Solar Energy”, “Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy”) “ENERGY BUILD” (87 ; – 67 « » 20 – “Solar Energy”): – - “ENERGY AND BUILDINGS”13. [23] c “Energ. Buildings” ([23] – c. Synnefa A. et al.), ENERGY BUILD ([24] – c. Santamorius M., Pavlou K., Synnefa A. et al.) , .
12 , , . 13 “ENERG BUILDINGS”, JCR « - » , «-»; - “ENERGY BUILD” «-» ( “Go to Journal Profile”) .
9 , , 2009-2014 , - - « » JCR. : “Energy Procedia”, “World Energy Outlook”, “IEEE Power Engineering Society. General Meeting”, “The Electricity Journal”, “Procedia Engineering”, “Wind Engineering”, International Journal of Energy and Environment”, “World Development Indicators” “BP Statistical Review of World Energy”. - .
«Wind Engineering» (ISSN: 0309- 524X, UK, Sage Publications Ltd., - , ) [27]: – , “Thomson Reuters Master Journal List” Emerging Sources Citation Index ( – 23 2016 ) «-». , - Scopus. 14 : , «- » “World Economic Outlook” , -, 70- ( ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory).
, , , , : ,
15 « » - , .. , , . , – (200) « - », 0,010499; .
”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America”, , , « », «» 0,0032108 ( 309); «» - 2009-2014 . 71! – «», 22424 “citable items” - - . , – , - , , ! , “Energy & Environment” (, , « » 2014 0,655) “The Energy Journal” (C, , «- » 1,772) .
,
2009-2014 - , , 15- - , 262 , - ( 4 , « »). , 15- «-», - 207 . « » – “Renewable and Sus- tainable Energy Reviews” – 143 - (69,08%), .. « 11» 30,92% - . - , “ ”, “Renewable Energy” “Solar En- ergy”. 207 - - - “Energy Procedia”, « - ». ( , , - - [28].) , , « », “Energy Procedia” - “Solar Energy” “Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME”, - « » – “Renewable Energy”.
, : “Journal of Physics: Conference Series“, . – - , , – : “Chemical Engineering Transactions“ – - (The Italian Association of Chemical Engineering); “Proceedings of SPIE” (, UL- RICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory “SPIE - International Society for Optical Engineering. Proceedings”) – - (International Society for Optical Engineering); “AIP Conference Proceedings” – ; “IEEE Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition. Conference Proceedings” – Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, - . “Safety, Reliability and Risk Analysis”, - “CRC Press” - - ; “Computer-Aided Chemical Engineering” – - , Elsevier BV () - ; , “MATEC Web of Conference”. , , – , – - « »16. - , , 4 . 9 . C , 207 ( , ) 6 , , , - , , . , . , - ; ,
16 «» , : , - « » , , - , .
, 12 2009-2014 2014 citable items 2014 , « -- ». , - , - , .. JCR citable items, «» , - «-» JCR. 239 , , «» « ». « » , 0,009; « - » , , 15. , 0,009 , 224 , 12 , ( - ). 46 « » . (20,54%) , « » , - . , 12- , « », , , 244 ( - ): 198+46=244. . - , , “Brodogradnja” (ISSN: 0007-215X) - 12- - (14, 199), « - » – 35. citable items, 2014 – 29. “Journal of Building Performance Simulation” (ISSN: 1940-1493)
2014 29 citable items, - « » ( 47) - (11, 222). «Building Simulation» «-» – 13 ( 207), « » (69) - citable items (55).
“Journal of Energy in Southern Africa” (15), , - 2014 30 citable items, « - » – 33. , - - « » . 4 , « » - : “PLos One” 2014 - 30040 citable items, “Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics” – 2880, “Journal of Applied Physics” – 4260, “Applied Physics Letters” – 5042. - 2014 , , ( - , , 2014 , « » « », - 12- -).
, - « », 20- , - 12- -, :
- 4- ( « » );
- 9- – , - « » JCR « »;
- – THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - -, «- »;
- 6- JCR - 2014 « ».
, « » -
12- - , , , 244 ( - ), «224+20».
4, , - . 12- - (∑ ); , – « » (∑/ ); , « » 12- - ( « ») – - 12- - (R∑ ); - , - – « » (R∑/P ). 378 . 275 – , - ( , - « »), 73,54% . 141 , - 12- -, - 275 , 51,27% 57,79% , , - . , - 12- - 103 – 42,21% .
4 - , - . «/ ( JCR)» - , JCR .
, “Journal of Materials Chemistry ” ( – 90): JCR, “Journal of Materials Chemistry” “Journal of Materials Chemistry C”17 - ( ; 17 ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory, – “ Journal of Mate- rials Chemistry C: materials for optical and electronic devices” (ISSN 2050-7526, Royal Society of Chem- istry, ).
). - “Journal of Materials Chemistry” - “Journal of Materials Chemistry C” – , – 4 “Journal of Ma- terials Chemistry ”, .
.4. – 378 , ( ) ( ) - , - ( - , ). - - [29].
275 378- – , - ( , - « »), 73,54% . , - 12- - ( 103 ) – 42,21% .
12 - - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, [14] , - [15], -- (, [15, p. 89]).
, “Renewable and Sustaina- ble Energy Reviews” , – – . - , - . , ( 12-) -
, «» , «- », “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, “Solar Energy”.
G. Hirst [4] , - , – - «» - , . , - - , - . , - ( - ) , , - - « » , . , « » - , - , - «-» JCR. - , « » G. Hirst, « », . - - () .
, - , , - [30], open access; , - , - , , , [31]. - . - , Microsoft Excel. . , . , . .
1. - - 2016-2020 // - , 24.04.2015, 1/15761.
2. Bradford S.C. Documentation: 2nd ed. – London: Lockwood, 1953. – P. 141– 159.
3. Gross P.L.K., Gross E.M. College libraries and chemical education // Science. – 1927. – v. 66, N 1713. – P. 385–389.
4. Hirst G. Discipline impact factor – a method for determining core journal list // J. Amer. Soc. Inform. Sci. – 1978. – v. 29, N 4. – P. 171–172.
5. .. - - // - . .1. – 1984. – N 6. – . 14–15.
6. .., .. // - . .1. – 2015. – 2. – . 8 –19.
7. .., .. // . . -. – 2015. – 1. – . 31–50.
8. .. // : . . . / - ; .- "" . – , 1989. – . 173–186.
9. Lazarev V.S. On chaos in bibliometric terminology // Scientometrics. – 1996. – v. 35, N 2. – P. 271–277.
10. Lazarev V.S. Properties of scientific periodicals under bibliometric assessment // International Journal of Information Sciences for Decision Making. – 1997. – N 1 (December). – P. 1–17.
11. Garfield E. Citation analysis as a tool of journal evaluation // Science. – 1972. – v. 148, N 4060. – P. 471–479.
12. : / .. , .. , O.. , .. . – : - -, 2014. – 250 c.
13. . (1971) , -. – . – N 3. – 149–155.
14. Sengupta I.N. Impact of scientific serials on the advancement of medical knowledge: An objective method of analysis // International Library Review. – 1972. – v. 4. – P. 169—195.
15. Hafner A.W. Citation characteristics of physiology literature, 1970-72 // Int. Libr. Rev. – 1975. – v. 7. – P. 85—115.
16. .. – // . . - . – 1984. – N 10. – . 21–27.
17. Ulrich’s Periodicals Directory ( ). – https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulrich%E2%80%99s_Periodicals_Directory. – : 20.06.2016.
18. Hirst G., Talent N. Computer science journals – an iterated citation analysis // IEEE Trans. Prof. Commun. – 1977. – v.20, N 4. – P. 233—238.
19. Price D.S. de Solla. Network of scientific papers // Nature. – 1965. – v. 149, N 3683. – P. 510–515.
20. .., .. // / . . -. – , 1985. – . 37–43.
21. ( ) http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1876610214007632. : 16 2016 .
22. ( ) https://books.google.by/books?id=CyfnCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA45&lpg=PA45& dq=ENRGY+PROCED+volume+50&source=bl&ots=8U1z57ETqG&sig=Cjr 5Ykp74Ap4wE8_J- wolAwKIKY&hl=ru&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiQrOPuoN7MAhUK2BoKHZ7- C48Q6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&q=ENRGY%20PROCED%20volume%2050 &f=false. : 16 2016 .
23. ( ) http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/03787788/39/11 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/03787788/39/7 .
25. ( ) https://books.google.by/books?id=8zyFCwAAQBAJ&pg=PA277&lpg=PA27 7&dq=sinnefa+a.+39&source=bl&ots=6mideZamtX&sig=BQJ2zWZwskN57 HBdu3E0OjHI- 9k&hl=ru&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi0zp6osNHMAhXE2hoKHey7BDQQ6AEI QzAI#v=onepage&q=sinnefa%20a.%2039&f=false. : 11 2016 .
26. ( ) http://www.worldenergyoutlook.org/. : 19 2016 .
27. ( ) http://www.multi-science.co.uk/windeng.htm. : 19 2016 .
28. Energy Procedia ( ). – http://www.journals.elsevier.com/energy-procedia. – 16.05.2016.
29. SciVal: SciVal. 1.01; 2014 / . . , .; Elsevier. – . . .. . .. . – .., ..: « – ». – 82 c.
31. .. : / . . , . . // - : - : . . . , 3-4 2014 . / - “ . .. ” ; .: .. [ .]. – : , 2014. – . 138–144.
, Lazarev, Vladimir Stanislavovich, Skalaban, Aleksey Vital’evich
Belarusian National Technical University . , 16 220013, . , .: +375 17 292-98-75 [email protected] [email protected]
16 Yakub Kolas St., 220013, Minsk, Republic of Belarus Tel.: +375 17 292-98-75 [email protected] [email protected]
. , - , - , , , . « , » - - - . - ; « ». 378 , - , - , - - 2016-2020 c – - .
Abstract. It is known that the selection of n acceptably representative sample of the world scientific peri- odicals to be used as backgrounds of a high-quality research should focus not only on specialized journals, but also on periodicals, the topics and the titles of which are formally not related to the research area. In the present study the determination of the best periodicals to be used in research on renewable energy, local and secondary energy resources has been fulfilled with the aid of four varieties of citation analysis, twelve journals specialized in power production being used as the source items of citation data. The methods of the analysis were clarified and elaborated; the concept and the term "discipline receptivity factor" were proposed. The practical result is a list of 378 world periodicals, that is planned to be used in creating a comfortable scientific information environment by using the world leading databases reflecting the most valuable collection of scientific journals that are necessary for quality performance of scientific research on Priority areas of scientific-technical activity in the Republic of Belarus for 2016-2020 followed by the establishment of an operational system of selective alert informing prominent experts that implement the respective areas. : , , , - , -, , , - , Keywords: journals, periodicals and serial publications, citation, citatedness, citations analysis, discipline impact factor, discipline receptivity factor, renewable energy, local and secondary energy resources
- 2016 , – - - [1].
- , . « , » .
[2], - 1/3 - . , , , , - , . [3; 4] , , - [5]. (- , , - , [5] , -, - ; , [6], - [7] .) / - : - () , , , [8-10].
- -
– – - « , ». (- , ) - - , - , - «».
, - - , – – . , - , , , , – , – , - - « » . , «» , - , , «» ; - . - , «» - « » - , .
- -, - – « » [11]. , ( ) « », «», , - (, , ) . , , , 1000 , 500 , , 100 , – 50 , 500 50 (, , ) - , : 10 «» . , – 0,5 (500/1000 = 50/100). ,
: . , : - , - , , - ; , , .
, , .. , . , - - , : , - 1. , « » , , - , , - ; «- » [12, c. 84–85]. - . - «» , .. , . , , , , - , , , , , – … , – ; «», - , - – . , « », « - » , , « » ,
1 , «» (.. «- ») .. [13], - . , « » [11]. , - – ... .. 1927 [3]! , , , - 10 – , [3, p. 387]. , , 1927 .
, « » .
Web of Science™, – Journal Citation Reports®, 12 . , - [12, . 80—81]. - , , - [4; 14; 15] ( – [16]). 89 , “Energy & Fuels“ Journal Citation Reports® 2014 2, – c ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory3, - . , web- . - , - . - ( ) « ». , « » , - , . - : 1) , 2) «» - « », 3) 2014 . “Journal Citation Reports”® ( – JCR) , 4) . - “eigenfactor” (« - ») [12, c. 100–101]. JCR. - . 1. « »
2 - 2016 , 2015 Web of Science Journal Citation Reports . 3 ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory – - Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, ( ) ( ) - 200 . [17]. , - .
1. , « ,
»
.
«- » 2014 .
2014 .
4 5 1 Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re-
views; USA; ELSEVIER; 1364-0321 8 5,901 11 21 901
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy; USA; IEEE, 1949-3029
17 4,882 44 1 368
3 BioEnergy Research; USA; SPRINGER; 1939-1234
18 3,541 41 1 577
4 Renewable Energy; England; ELSEVIER; 0960-1481
20 3,476 15 16 421
5 Solar Energy; USA; PERGAMON- ELSEVIER; 0038-092X
21 3,469 14 16 656
6 Wind Energy;England; WILEY-BLACK- WELL;1095-4244
28 3,069 36 2 354
7 IET Renewable Power Generation; Eng- land; IET; 1752-1416
46 1,904 52 1 116
8 Journal of Energy Resources Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; 0195-0738
47 1,886 51 1 124
9 Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; 0199-6231
49 1,614 34 2 477
10 International Journal of Green Energy; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; 1543- 5075
57 1,215 59 796
11 Journal of Renewable and Sustainable En- ergy; USA; AIP; 1941-7012
61 0,904 56 886
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utiliza- tion and Environmental Effects; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; 1556-7036
80 0,386 53 1 015
, , , , - . , - , - , , , , [14];
4 89 , “Energy & Fuels“. 5 .
[14] “Renewable and Sustain- able Energy Reviews” - . , , , « - », , , , “eigenfactor”, , ( « - ») . ( “eigenfactor” ).
, , - , , -- (“Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”) « » ( ) - , - - , « - , », , , -. - , , - .
2014 12-
2009-2014 2014 12- 2009-2014
JCR: JCR , “Go to Journal Profile” -, “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”. - “Source Data”, “Citing Journal Data” (- “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”) “Cited Jour- nal Data” ( “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”). 12 . “Citing Journal Data” - 2009-2014 ; - , - , 12- - -. ( - - « , », - 2009-2014 .) ,
JCR « » - .
( ) 12- – JCR “Cited Jour- nal Data”.
-
- - ( - ) 2014-2009 . - 12- -- . - “ Go to Journal Profile” Journal Citation Reports®. - “Key Indicators” “Citable Items” 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010 2009 , - , , , . , - 2009-2014 ., citable items 2009-2014 ., . , G. Hirst 1977 “discipline impact factor” – « »6 [4, p.171; 18]. , cit- able items. - .
( ) 12- - - - . , 2014-2009 . - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” ( -
6 : « , [ : - – .., ..]; , , , ; . C. , , DIF DIF = nc/ns, nc J ts. JCR. tc ns - JCR . , , 1977 . [18] c JCR 1976 1975 ., tc 1974-1975, ns – 1972-1975 .» [4, p.171].
), , – - , . - , .. - .
, 2014 . - - , - . – 2014- – . - - , - - 2009-2014 , - « , - », - () . , - - 2009-2014 ., 2014 . , « - » , - 12- - 2009-2014 - , 2014 . « - » - « ».
: . , - , « » , , «» - «» . «- » : - , ; , 50 66% /7 . , 15- (
7 « » - [2]. ( , .. - ; , - .)
/ ), - 8. : « » , / 15- , , - , - , / 15- 2009-2014 . « » - , - / - , - – .
/.
12-
2 - 12- -, , , « », - 3 – 12- -, , , « ».
2. - « » « »
.
-- ; ; ISSN
- (t)
, t, - , - 15 (tl)
, t 2009-
2014 . ()
.. .. t
.. t
.. C
D E F 1 Renewable and Sus-
tainable Energy Re- views; USA; ELSE- VIER; ISSN: 1364-0321
68 36 9
33 340 48,76 %
19 904 59,70 %
8 15 [19]. , - . , « » . ; . 9 2 , 0 , 15 .
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable En- ergy; USA; IEEE, ISSN: 1949-3029
4 057 100 %
1 953 48,13 %
2 218 54,67 %
1 750 78,89 %
6 331 100 %
2 954 46,65 %
2 763 43,64 %
1 415 51,21 %
21 526
16 197
3 855 100 %
1 383 35,87 %
1 582 41,03 %
2 137 100 %
1 029 48,15 %
1 017 47,59 %
541 53,19 %
8 Journal of Energy Resources Technol- ogy – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0195-0738
2 469 100 %
852 34,50 %
907 36,76 %
399 37,37 %
9 Journal of Solar En- ergy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0199-6231
2 627 100 %
346 33,52 %
10 International Jour- nal of Green En- ergy; USA; TAYLOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1543-5075
2 231 100 %
825 36,97 %
863 38,68 %
503 58,28 %
11 Journal of Renewa- ble and Sustainable Energy; USA; AIP; ISSN: 1941-7012
7 495 100 %
3 343 44,60 %
3 712 49,52 %
1 839 49,54 %
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utili- zation and Environ- mental Effects; USA; TAYLOR &
4 657 100 %
1 871 40,17 %
2 520 54,11 %
FRANCIS; ISSN: 1556-7036
, 2, (- D), , , 15 , 42% ( 57,10% - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” 32,50% - “ Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME”). - , « » 15 , – . , 57,10% “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re- views” 39 040 - , 15- , , - - 15- , - 35 134 . «11- », , «- » , .
, ( F), - 2009-2014 ., 15 , 50% , «» 2009-2014 .
– , «» 2009 , , , – 2009-2014 . 46% JCR - ( E).
( - - 12.)
, 3, , , ( “Renewable Energy”), ( , “Solar Energy” – . ). , : - , «», «- » (, [20]).
, “Solar Energy”, , -, - , - 2014 , . - « » “Solar Energy” – « » 12- , , JCR , : 2005 . ; 2008 . – 1,6; 2009 . – ; 2014- – 3,469.
3: - , - 15 (
30,10% 81,91% – D); – 2009-2014 ( , , 15). - .
3. - « » « »
.
(Rt)
, Rt, - , - - 15 (Rtl)
, Rt 2009-
2014 . (R)
.. .. Rt
.. Rt
.. C
Sustainable Energy Reviews; USA; ELSEVIER; ISSN: 1364-0321
21 901
83,04%
2 IEEE Transactions on Sustainable En- ergy; USA; IEEE, ISSN: 1949-3029
1 329
1 577
100% 785
16 421
16 656
2 354
1 116
100% 772
69,18% 891
79,84% 619
1 124
100% 574
51,07% 390
34,70%
279
48,61%
10 2 , 0 , 15
nology – Transac- tions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0195-0738
9 Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME; USA; ASME; ISSN: 0199-6231
2 477
30,48%
526
31,40%
10 International Jour- nal of Green En- ergy; USA; TAY- LOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1543-5075
796
67,34%
315
71,11%
11 Journal of Renewa- ble and Sustainable Energy; USA; AIP; ISSN: 1941-7012
886
99,66%
316
99,68%
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utilization and En- vironmental Ef- fects; USA; TAY- LOR & FRANCIS; ISSN: 1556-7036
1 329
100% 400
30,10% 658
64,83%
263
65,75%
12 Energy Sources Part A – Recovery Utilization and En- vironmental Ef- fects; USA; ISSN: 1556- 7036
1 329
100% 400
30,10% 658
64,83%
263
65,75%
( . 2) - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” - . -- “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” , - (. 2, ), “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Re- views” 68 339 , «» – - , 73 582. « » 2009-2014 . (. 2, - E) «-» - : 33 340 “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” 33 995 «».
, « » “Renewable Energy” (UK) “Solar Energy” (USA) - , . «» ? ,
“BioEnergy Research” ( 6 331 ), “Wind Energy” ( 3 855 ) “Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME” (- 2 627 ) “International Journal of Green Energy” ( «-» 2 231 ) - « , ». “Solar Energy” 16 656 , (. 3), - – 16 197 (. 2): – - ( - ), «», - (, “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, 2 3, ). , «-» – – [16]. : - - .
, : “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews” - / , 12- .
,
2009-2014 427 . «- », , - . ( 15- , «» - 23 , «- ».) , 427 (450) , , 15-, , - , 2009-2014 . - 15- . 230 (53,86% 427 51,11% 450 – - ). - .
( «-» JCR11, “THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - JOURNAL SEARCH” (http:// ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/mjl/) , ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory , , Google) - , , , . - , «-» JCR Web- ”THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - JOURNAL SEARCH”, :
1) “IEEE Power Engineering Society. General Meeting” – Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (ISSN: 1932-5517);
2) “Energy Procedia” – , Elsevier BV, (ISSN: 1876-6102) – - , , [28], - ;
3)“World Energy Outlook” (ISSN: 1026-1141) – , ;
4) “The Electricity Journal” (ISSN: 1040-6190) – (: Elsevier Inc., ), - - – , ;
5) “Procedia Engineering” (ISSN: 1877-7058) – - , - , Elsevier Inc., Netherlands);
6) “International Journal of Energy and Environment” (ISSN: 2076-2895) – , International Energy and Environment Foundation (), ;
7) “World Development Indicators” (ISSN: 1029-4325) – (: The World Bank, ), - , 800 , – - ;
8) “BP Statistical Review of World Energy” (ISSN: 1475-858X) – - (: B P p.l.c., ), 10 .
. , Journal
11 “Go to Journal Profile” JCR.
Citation Reports® (« »), - ; , - « ». «11- » - ( « - » « ») , 12, . , “Solar Energy” - ( ) «» - – 22-.
, - . - : “ENRGY PROCED” (130 ; – 88 « » 42 – “Solar Energy”) “Energy Procedia” (60 ; – 44 « » 16 – “Solar Energy”); « - » JCR . , – “Energy Procedia” (ISSN: 1876-6102) : “Energy Procedia” [21] “ENRGY PROCED” ([22] – c. 203). , , ( “Energy Procedia”), - . - .
“ENERG BUILDINGS” (595 ; – 381 « - »; – “Renewable Energy”, “Solar Energy”, “Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy”) “ENERGY BUILD” (87 ; – 67 « » 20 – “Solar Energy”): – - “ENERGY AND BUILDINGS”13. [23] c “Energ. Buildings” ([23] – c. Synnefa A. et al.), ENERGY BUILD ([24] – c. Santamorius M., Pavlou K., Synnefa A. et al.) , .
12 , , . 13 “ENERG BUILDINGS”, JCR « - » , «-»; - “ENERGY BUILD” «-» ( “Go to Journal Profile”) .
9 , , 2009-2014 , - - « » JCR. : “Energy Procedia”, “World Energy Outlook”, “IEEE Power Engineering Society. General Meeting”, “The Electricity Journal”, “Procedia Engineering”, “Wind Engineering”, International Journal of Energy and Environment”, “World Development Indicators” “BP Statistical Review of World Energy”. - .
«Wind Engineering» (ISSN: 0309- 524X, UK, Sage Publications Ltd., - , ) [27]: – , “Thomson Reuters Master Journal List” Emerging Sources Citation Index ( – 23 2016 ) «-». , - Scopus. 14 : , «- » “World Economic Outlook” , -, 70- ( ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory).
, , , , : ,
15 « » - , .. , , . , – (200) « - », 0,010499; .
”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America”, , , « », «» 0,0032108 ( 309); «» - 2009-2014 . 71! – «», 22424 “citable items” - - . , – , - , , ! , “Energy & Environment” (, , « » 2014 0,655) “The Energy Journal” (C, , «- » 1,772) .
,
2009-2014 - , , 15- - , 262 , - ( 4 , « »). , 15- «-», - 207 . « » – “Renewable and Sus- tainable Energy Reviews” – 143 - (69,08%), .. « 11» 30,92% - . - , “ ”, “Renewable Energy” “Solar En- ergy”. 207 - - - “Energy Procedia”, « - ». ( , , - - [28].) , , « », “Energy Procedia” - “Solar Energy” “Journal of Solar Energy Technology – Transactions of the ASME”, - « » – “Renewable Energy”.
, : “Journal of Physics: Conference Series“, . – - , , – : “Chemical Engineering Transactions“ – - (The Italian Association of Chemical Engineering); “Proceedings of SPIE” (, UL- RICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory “SPIE - International Society for Optical Engineering. Proceedings”) – - (International Society for Optical Engineering); “AIP Conference Proceedings” – ; “IEEE Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition. Conference Proceedings” – Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, - . “Safety, Reliability and Risk Analysis”, - “CRC Press” - - ; “Computer-Aided Chemical Engineering” – - , Elsevier BV () - ; , “MATEC Web of Conference”. , , – , – - « »16. - , , 4 . 9 . C , 207 ( , ) 6 , , , - , , . , . , - ; ,
16 «» , : , - « » , , - , .
, 12 2009-2014 2014 citable items 2014 , « -- ». , - , - , .. JCR citable items, «» , - «-» JCR. 239 , , «» « ». « » , 0,009; « - » , , 15. , 0,009 , 224 , 12 , ( - ). 46 « » . (20,54%) , « » , - . , 12- , « », , , 244 ( - ): 198+46=244. . - , , “Brodogradnja” (ISSN: 0007-215X) - 12- - (14, 199), « - » – 35. citable items, 2014 – 29. “Journal of Building Performance Simulation” (ISSN: 1940-1493)
2014 29 citable items, - « » ( 47) - (11, 222). «Building Simulation» «-» – 13 ( 207), « » (69) - citable items (55).
“Journal of Energy in Southern Africa” (15), , - 2014 30 citable items, « - » – 33. , - - « » . 4 , « » - : “PLos One” 2014 - 30040 citable items, “Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics” – 2880, “Journal of Applied Physics” – 4260, “Applied Physics Letters” – 5042. - 2014 , , ( - , , 2014 , « » « », - 12- -).
, - « », 20- , - 12- -, :
- 4- ( « » );
- 9- – , - « » JCR « »;
- – THOMSON REUTERS MASTER JOURNAL LIST - -, «- »;
- 6- JCR - 2014 « ».
, « » -
12- - , , , 244 ( - ), «224+20».
4, , - . 12- - (∑ ); , – « » (∑/ ); , « » 12- - ( « ») – - 12- - (R∑ ); - , - – « » (R∑/P ). 378 . 275 – , - ( , - « »), 73,54% . 141 , - 12- -, - 275 , 51,27% 57,79% , , - . , - 12- - 103 – 42,21% .
4 - , - . «/ ( JCR)» - , JCR .
, “Journal of Materials Chemistry ” ( – 90): JCR, “Journal of Materials Chemistry” “Journal of Materials Chemistry C”17 - ( ; 17 ULRICHSWEB™ Global Serials Directory, – “ Journal of Mate- rials Chemistry C: materials for optical and electronic devices” (ISSN 2050-7526, Royal Society of Chem- istry, ).
). - “Journal of Materials Chemistry” - “Journal of Materials Chemistry C” – , – 4 “Journal of Ma- terials Chemistry ”, .
.4. – 378 , ( ) ( ) - , - ( - , ). - - [29].
275 378- – , - ( , - « »), 73,54% . , - 12- - ( 103 ) – 42,21% .
12 - - “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, [14] , - [15], -- (, [15, p. 89]).
, “Renewable and Sustaina- ble Energy Reviews” , – – . - , - . , ( 12-) -
, «» , «- », “Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews”, “Solar Energy”.
G. Hirst [4] , - , – - «» - , . , - - , - . , - ( - ) , , - - « » , . , « » - , - , - «-» JCR. - , « » G. Hirst, « », . - - () .
, - , , - [30], open access; , - , - , , , [31]. - . - , Microsoft Excel. . , . , . .
1. - - 2016-2020 // - , 24.04.2015, 1/15761.
2. Bradford S.C. Documentation: 2nd ed. – London: Lockwood, 1953. – P. 141– 159.
3. Gross P.L.K., Gross E.M. College libraries and chemical education // Science. – 1927. – v. 66, N 1713. – P. 385–389.
4. Hirst G. Discipline impact factor – a method for determining core journal list // J. Amer. Soc. Inform. Sci. – 1978. – v. 29, N 4. – P. 171–172.
5. .. - - // - . .1. – 1984. – N 6. – . 14–15.
6. .., .. // - . .1. – 2015. – 2. – . 8 –19.
7. .., .. // . . -. – 2015. – 1. – . 31–50.
8. .. // : . . . / - ; .- "" . – , 1989. – . 173–186.
9. Lazarev V.S. On chaos in bibliometric terminology // Scientometrics. – 1996. – v. 35, N 2. – P. 271–277.
10. Lazarev V.S. Properties of scientific periodicals under bibliometric assessment // International Journal of Information Sciences for Decision Making. – 1997. – N 1 (December). – P. 1–17.
11. Garfield E. Citation analysis as a tool of journal evaluation // Science. – 1972. – v. 148, N 4060. – P. 471–479.
12. : / .. , .. , O.. , .. . – : - -, 2014. – 250 c.
13. . (1971) , -. – . – N 3. – 149–155.
14. Sengupta I.N. Impact of scientific serials on the advancement of medical knowledge: An objective method of analysis // International Library Review. – 1972. – v. 4. – P. 169—195.
15. Hafner A.W. Citation characteristics of physiology literature, 1970-72 // Int. Libr. Rev. – 1975. – v. 7. – P. 85—115.
16. .. – // . . - . – 1984. – N 10. – . 21–27.
17. Ulrich’s Periodicals Directory ( ). – https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulrich%E2%80%99s_Periodicals_Directory. – : 20.06.2016.
18. Hirst G., Talent N. Computer science journals – an iterated citation analysis // IEEE Trans. Prof. Commun. – 1977. – v.20, N 4. – P. 233—238.
19. Price D.S. de Solla. Network of scientific papers // Nature. – 1965. – v. 149, N 3683. – P. 510–515.
20. .., .. // / . . -. – , 1985. – . 37–43.
21. ( ) http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1876610214007632. : 16 2016 .
22. ( ) https://books.google.by/books?id=CyfnCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA45&lpg=PA45& dq=ENRGY+PROCED+volume+50&source=bl&ots=8U1z57ETqG&sig=Cjr 5Ykp74Ap4wE8_J- wolAwKIKY&hl=ru&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiQrOPuoN7MAhUK2BoKHZ7- C48Q6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&q=ENRGY%20PROCED%20volume%2050 &f=false. : 16 2016 .
23. ( ) http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/03787788/39/11 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/03787788/39/7 .
25. ( ) https://books.google.by/books?id=8zyFCwAAQBAJ&pg=PA277&lpg=PA27 7&dq=sinnefa+a.+39&source=bl&ots=6mideZamtX&sig=BQJ2zWZwskN57 HBdu3E0OjHI- 9k&hl=ru&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi0zp6osNHMAhXE2hoKHey7BDQQ6AEI QzAI#v=onepage&q=sinnefa%20a.%2039&f=false. : 11 2016 .
26. ( ) http://www.worldenergyoutlook.org/. : 19 2016 .
27. ( ) http://www.multi-science.co.uk/windeng.htm. : 19 2016 .
28. Energy Procedia ( ). – http://www.journals.elsevier.com/energy-procedia. – 16.05.2016.
29. SciVal: SciVal. 1.01; 2014 / . . , .; Elsevier. – . . .. . .. . – .., ..: « – ». – 82 c.
31. .. : / . . , . . // - : - : . . . , 3-4 2014 . / - “ . .. ” ; .: .. [ .]. – : , 2014. – . 138–144.