the varieties, classification, and origin of magic1
TRANSCRIPT
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 1/19
The Varieties, Classification, and Origin of Magic
Author(s): James H. LeubaSource: American Anthropologist, New Series, Vol. 14, No. 2 (Apr. - Jun., 1912), pp. 350-367Published by: Blackwell Publishing on behalf of the American Anthropological AssociationStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/659937
Accessed: 28/11/2008 06:00
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained athttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=black .
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We work with the
scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that
promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
Blackwell Publishing and American Anthropological Association are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access to American Anthropologist.
http://www.jstor.org
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 2/19
THE VARIETIES,CLASSIFICATION,AND ORIGIN OFMAGIC1
BY JAMES H. LEUBA
I THE VARIETIESNDCLASSIFIATION F MAGI
THE termmagicI wouldrestrict o thosepracticesntendedto secure omedefinitegain bycoercitive actson in essential
.disregardI) of the quantitativerelations mpliedin theordinary nd in the scientific ealingswiththe physicalworld;(2)
of the anthropopathicelations btaining mongpersons.Althoughmagic never makes an anthropopathic ppeal, it
frequently rings o bear ts peculiar oercitive irtueuponfeelingbeings. It aims,thenSat compellingouls,spirits,or gods to dothe operator'swill, or at preventinghemfromdoingtheirown.
In necromancy,piritsaresummonedy meansof spellsandincan-tations. In ancientEgypt the art of dealingcoercitivelywithspiritsandgodsreacheda highdevelopment. Maspero,peakingof a curiousbeliefregardingnames,says, "When the god in amomentof forgetfulnessrof kindnesshadtaughtthemwhattheywanted [thesacrednames], herewasnothing eft forhim but toobeythem."2 At Eleusisit wasnot thenamebut the intonation
of thevoice of the magician hat producedhe mysteriousesults.31A further discussion of magic and of its relation to religion will be found in the
author's book, A Psychological Study of Religion; its Origin, Function, ond F?4ture,
New York, Macmillan, I 9 I 2 .
aMaspero, G. C., Etudes de mythologie et d'archeologieegyptiennes, Paris, I903.
sBibliothequeEgyptologique, vol. II, p. 298.
5 Foucart, Paul, Recherches sur la Nature des Mysteres d'Eleusis, MEmoiresde
;'Institut, vol. xxxv, 2d part, pp. 3I-32. Cf. Maspero, op. cit., p. 303.
A surprising revival of the belief in the magical power of names came to my notice
a few years ago. At a campmeeting of Seventh Day Adventists in Massachusetts,I heard an ex-cowboy evangelist deliver an impassioned address on the power of the
"Word ". He showed by many citations from the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures
that the Book did not teach the direct action of God and Christs but that whateverthey did was accomplished through the power of the Word. It was by the Word,
not by God, that the world was created, and it was by belierring n the Word that men
were saved.
35o
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 3/19
35ILEUBA]
VARIETIES AND ORIGIN OF MAGIC
But how shouldbe classed he behavior f a suppliantwho at-
tempts by requests,offerings, doration, r other anthropopathic
means o inducea ghost,spirit,or god to give him magicalpower?The Dieriof centralAustralian dry spells"call upon he spiritsof
theirremoteancestors,whom-they all MuraMura, o grant hempower o make a heavy rainfall.''l This behaviorbelongsclearly
to the religious ype; but that which follows the suppliant'suseof the magicalpowersecured rom he'spirit is magic. A spirit
may be askedto use his magicalpowerhimself. In that case the
suppliantuses the anthropopathicmethod of bringingabout amagical ction.2
To one who approacheshe subjectof magic or the first time,
the possibility f bringing rder nto the chaos of magical ustoms
seems remote. Beforetaking up the originsof magic,we wouldbetter gain some knowledgeof its many forms. This may bedone convenientlyby makinga criticalexamination f a widely
used classification,n the course f whichstudy it will appear hatseveral mportant arieties f magic alloutsideof this classification.
"If we analyze the principles f thought on which magic is
based,"writesJ. G. Frazer,"they will probably e found o resolvethemselvesnto two: first,that like producesike, or that an effectresemblests cause; and, second, hat thingsthat have once been
in contact with each other continueto act on each other at a
distanceafter the physicalcontacthas been severed. The formerprinciplemay be calledthe Law of Similarity, he latter the Law
of Contact or Contagion. From the first of these principles,namely, he Lawof Similarity, he magiciannfers*fllat e can pro-
duce any effecthe desiresmerelyby imitating t; from he secondhe infers that whateverhe does to a materialobject will affect
Frazer, J. G., The Golden Bough, 2d ed., vol. I, p. 86.
2 Jevons's view differs from this in that for him the magical Pawer always belongs
to a conscious agent. " Magic is the mysterious power of a person or conscious agent
to cause injury or, secondarily, it may be, benefit to another person who may be
at a distance; a power which when exerted is accompanied by, or ascribed to, an ex-
clamation, a gesture or an action indicating and effecting what is willed. To us the
exclamation or gesture indicates only what is willed. In the opinion of the savage,
who fails to discriminate between the categories of likeness and identity, the action
he performs not merely resembles, but is the action which he wills." (F. B. Jevons,
Magic, Proceedings Third International Congressof the Hislory of Religions, pp. 7I-78.)
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 4/19
352 AMERICAN ANTNROPOLOGIST [N. S., I4, I9I2
equally the personwith whom the object was once in contact,
whether t formspart of its body or not. Charmsbased on the
Law of Similaritymaybe'calledHomceopathicr ImitativeMagic.Charmsbasedon the Law of Contactor Contagionmay be called
ContagiousMagic.''lThis classificationlearly mbraceshe largernumber f magical
practices, speciallyhe injuring f images n order o injure nemies,the simulation f birth o produce hild-bearing,he numerousasesof homeopathicmagicboth in medicine nd outsideof it; the con-
tagious magicof-navel-string nd placenta, f woundsand blood,of garments,of footprints,and the like.2 Yet several types of
magic remainoutside this classification, r are broughtwithin it
only by extremely ar-fetched xplanations. "The Bushmende-spisean arrow hat hasonce ailedof its mark;and,on the contrary,
consider ne that has hit as of doubIe alue. They will, therefore,rathermakenew arrowshow much ime and troubIe oever t may
cost them, hancollect hose hat havemissed ndusethemagain."3Similarlyother tribes attach a specialvalue to a hook that has
caughta big fish. One might bring the mentalprocess nvolved'here ackto Frazer's econdprinciple,ContagiousMagic:"Things
that haveoncebeen n contactwitheachother ontinue o act oneachotherat a distance fterphysical ontacthasbeensevered." But itis possible o makea simpler xplanationhan the ascriptiono the
hookof a specificpoweracting telepathically ponfish. Nothingneedbe involvedhere, t seems o me,but the conviction hat some-
thing hat hashappened nce s likelyto happen gain. No principleis simplerand more irmlyestablishedhan this; it is an imperfectformof this corollarsof the Principle f Identity: something hathashappened ncewillhappenagainunder dentical ircumstances.The savage goes wrong becausehe thinks merely of the hook,instead of taking into accountall the circumstances.But if he
^Frazer,J. G., op. cit., 3d ed., vol. I, p. 52. See also Frazer,Lecturcs n theEarlygistory of the Kingship,Macmillan, 905, p. 54; and A. van Gennep's eview of thatbook in Revuede l'Histoiredes Refigions, 906, vol. LIII, pp. 39640I.
2See for illustrations,The GoldenBough,3d ed., vol. I, pp. 55-2I4.
8Lichtenstein,M. H. K., Trauelsn SouthAfrica, vol. II, p. 27I, quoted by LordAvebury,Originof Cs"Ziwhion,th ed., p. 34.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 5/19
LEUBA] VARIETIES AND ORIGINOF MAGIC 353
prizes he hook,not simplybecauset hasalready aught ish,butbecausehe thinksof the hookas possessing n attractivepower
over fish,the mentalprocessat the root of his actionis anotheranda morecomplex ne; he nowbelieves n actionat a distance.
Consideredsychologically,he behavior f the savagewhenheprefershesuccessful ookmaythusbeof twoquitedistinctkinds.Themagicbasedupon hesimple onvictionhatwhathashappenedonce s likelyto happenagain indsnoplace n Frazer'system;forthe two branches f magicthat he recognizes mayconveniently
be comprehendednderthe generalnameof SympatheticMagic,since both assumethat thingsact on each otherat a distance,through secret ympathy,heimpulsebeing ransmittedromoneto the otherby meansof whatwe mayconceivea kindof invisibleether.''1 Thereremainshequestion f fact. Doesthesavageacton thesetwo principles, r onlyon the onementioned y Frazer?Factsandargumentswillbeoffered elow n support f theformer
alternative.Frazer's lassificationmayagainprove nadequaten regardo
certaindancesperformedy thewomenwhen he menareengagedinwar "In theKafirdistrictof theHindooKoosh,while hemenareout raiding, he women eavetheirwork n the fieldsandas-semble n the villagesto dancedayand night. The dancesarekeptup mostof eachday andthe wholeof eachnight.... The
dancesof theseKafirsaresaidto be performedn honorof certainofthenational ods,butwhenweconsiderhecustomnconnectionwiththe otherswhichhave just been passed n review,we mayreasonably urmise hat it is or was originally n its essenceasympathetic harm ntended o keepthe absentwarriorswakeful,lesttheyshouldbesurprisedntheir leepby theenemy."2Accord-ingto theauthor f TheGoZdenough,hispracticewould husfallunder he Lawof
Similarity,o whichhe gives, as wehaveseen,adoubleform. It is the firstalternative hat applies n this case,"likeproducesike": the keepingawakeof the womencauses hemen to keep awake. This is a possibleexplanation. But it is
1Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 3d ed., vol. I, p. 54.
2 Ibid., pp. I33-I34.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 6/19
AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST54 [N. S., I4, I9I2
noteworthyn theother nstances ivenby Frazerlhat thestay-at-homesarenotsimply rying o keepawakebut thattheyaredoing
manyother things,not all of whichcan be interpreted s mimeticmagic(likeproducesike).
It seemsvery likelyto methat the primary auseof thedanc-ing is not thebelief that the keepingawakewill makethewar-riorswakeful,but the excitementand anxietyunderwhichthewomenwouldnaturally aborwhile theirhusbandsare fighting.A state of hightensionmay beexpected o work tself off,notonly
accordingo a law of "likeproducesike,"that is, ofcontagion, utin all sorts of spontaneous ctivities. The facts appear o agreewith thistheory. Thedance s notkept upnightand day in everytribe, and in most of them, so far as my informationoes, theredoes not appearto be any deliberatepurposeof resisting leep.Nordothesewomenusedancingalone; in sometribes heyrefrainfrom exualntercourse,elieving hatif they do nottheirhusbands
willbeeitherkilledorwounded. Incertainslands hewomenandchildrenare forbiddeno remain nside the houses, or to twinethreadorweave. If one turnsto the savages'ownexplanationftheiractions,onefindsgreatvariation. I donot discovern Frazerthat any tribegives the interpretationhat he suggests;but hereports hat the YukiIndianssay that if they dance all the time"theirhusbandswill not growtired." In Madagascarhe women
saythatbydancing heyimpart trength, ourage, ndgood ortuneto theirhusbands. Whybring hesevarious eremoniesackto anintentionof keeping hewarriorswake? Someof theactionsmaybe inspiredby that purpose, ut why all of them? Let us say,rather, hat the anxiety-of he womentendsto workitself off inspontaneousmovements, omeof them having, in the beginningat least,no mimetic or telepathicconnectionwith the fighting
of the husbands. They simply danceor jump up and downforrelief,andthe relieffelt leadsto the repetitionof the movement.Thus thedancinghabit s formed.
Now if the womendancewhilethey are filledwith a desirefor the successof the men in war, does not our knowledgeof
1Frazer, ibid., pp. I3I-I34.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 7/19
LEUBA] VARIETIES AND ORIGINOF MAGIC 355
psychology ead us to expect the formationof a causal con-nectionbetweendancingand the successof the warriors?At
first this connectionwill probablybe regardedas general,andnot as a specificrelationbetweendeprivingoneselfof sleep andkeepingawake the warriors. The dancing,at this stage, willbea magicalceremonyf the simplestsort. But certainmentaltendencieseadilyead to modificationsf the primitivedancing.The mindsof the dancerswill at timesbe filled with imagesofthe fighting,and these imageswill tend to shape the move-
ments. In thiswaymimicry f fightingmaytaketheplaceof theoriginaldancing. Amongthe Tshi-speaking eoplesof the GoldCoast,for instance,"thewivesof themenwhoareawaywiththearmypaintthemselveswhite,andadorn heirpersonswithbeadsandcharms. Onthe daywhena battleis expected o takeplace,theyrunaboutarmedwithguns,orstickscarved o look ikeguns,andtakinggreenpawpawsfruits hapedsomewhatikea melon),
theyhackthemwithknives,as if theywerechopping fftheheadsof the foe."1 In the QueenCharlotteslands,"when he menhadgoneto war,the womenat homewouldget up veryearlyin themorning nd pretend o makewarby fallingupontheirchildrenandfeigning o takethemforslaves." Certainribeswentas farasto scourgeeverelywolads,bywayofhelpinghewarriors.
If any of these dancersaccounted or the practiceby sayingthatkeeping
awakehelpedwarriorso remainwatchful,I shouldlookupon this statementas an afterthought. The idea of thedangerfsurpriseo thesleepingmenwouldreadily nough onnectitselfwiththedancers'ossof sleep,a lossarisingrom hedancing,whichs itselfanexpressionf anxiety.2
Perhaps he largestand most importantclass of magicnotprovidedorin the classification e areconsiderings Will-Magic.Here s one instance akenfromancientIndia:
In orderto pro-tecthisbelongingsromdestruction,he Buddhistmonk sdirectedtomakea "firmresolve," aying,"For the spaceof sevendays
1Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 3d ed., vol. I, p. I32.
2 On dancing and its relation to primitive religion, see Irving King, The DeveZ-opme7l:f Religion, I9IO, pp. I08-II2,
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 8/19
356 AA{ERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST [N. S., I4, I9I2
let not this and that articlebe burntby fire,borneawayby a flood,blown to pieces by the wind, carriedoff by robbers, r eaten by
rats and the like.... Then for the spaceof seven days no harmwill touchthem.''1 This is not a requestaddressed o a spirit,buta "firmresolve" hat the wishexpressed hall be realized. In theKei islands,when a battle is in progress, he womenwave fansin the direction f the enemyand sing, "O golden fans Let our
bullets hit, and those of the enemy miss."2 The essenceof Will-Magic is the belief that an exertionof the will takes effect at a
distance. This kind of magicmay or may not be complicated ythe addition f magical lements f another ype.
Can Will-Magicbe classedunderFrazer'sLaw of Similarity?This law is expressedn a double orm: "Like producesike,"and"An effect resemblests cause." Fromthis law, we are told, themagiciannfers hat he can produce ny effecthe desiresmerelyby
imitating t. But imitation s not in the least a requirement f
Will-Magic, lthough t may be superadded. The formula"likeproducesike" means, f it meansanything, hat because wo things
have elementsincommon,shape,color,etc.,nuhat appens o one
will happen o the other also. Nothingof this is necessarilyn-volved in Will-Magic. The other form of the law, "an effectresemblests cause,"appliesno better. It means hat if you want,
for nstance, tumor o dryup,you cansucceed y causing omething
else to dryup;or if you want aundice o disappear, ou cansucceedby making he yellowcolorof some object,a flower, or instance,vanish. In these casesthe effectyou have produced ecomes he
causeof a similar ffect.It must be observedhere that these two formulations f that
which s givenby Frazer s one awrepresent acha differentmentalprocess. If the savage s awareof this difference,he two mentalprocesses hould not be includedunderone principle. To do so
seems o me to obliterate istinctions, ather han to bringorderby
means of a helpful generalization. If primitive man does not
1 Pali Texts, Visuddhi-Magga. chap. XXIII, taken from Buddhism in Translatiox,
Henry C. Warren. Harvard University Press, I896, p. 385.
2 Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 2d ed., vol. I, p. 33.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 9/19
LEUBA] VARIETIES AND ORIGIN OF MAGIC 357
discriminate,henthe distinctionhasno applicationo the mentalprocessesnvolvedn savagemagic.
AlthoughI feel confidentn aiffirminghat Frazer's lassifica-tion needscompletion, do not claimthat the followingone isadequate.
I. Principleof Repetition.Somethinghat hashappened nceis likely o happen gain. A successfulrrowwillmeetwithfurthersuccess,andone that has failedwith further ailure. No ideaofa telepathicpowers involvedhere.
2. PrtncipZef Transmissionf an Effect rom one ObjectoAnother.-SympatheticMagic. An actiontakingplace-uponanobjectwilltakeplacealsouponanother bjectwhen hetwoobjectsareconnectedwitheachotherin the mindof the magician. Theconnectionsmaybe of severalkinds. I mention hreeof these:(a) The objectsbeara likeness o eachother(association y sim-ilarity):injuring he likenessof a thing injures he thing itself.(b)Theobjectshave
beenorare n contact associationy contigu-ity): whatevers doneto a toothoncebelongingo a personwillhappen o the personhimself. A variation f thisformof magic sseen n the customof rubbing neselfwitha partof a powerfulndcourageousnimalnorder o acquirehese raits. (c)Theobjectshave been in the relationof causeand effect:coolingthe arrowwhichhas nflicted woundwillpreventnflammationfthewound.
In this classof magican attractionor a telepathicnfluencesexertedbetweenobjects.
3. Princip7zefE;giciencyf Will-Egort.Other ystemsof classificationreof coursepossible. A classi-
ficationaccordingo the natureof the Power nvolved n the mag-icaloperationndtherelation f thisPower othemagicianppearsto meto haveconsiderablemerit,so I addit here.
CZass. Practicesnwhich heresnoideaofa Powerbelonging
to theoperator rhisinstrument,ndpassing hence o the objectofthemagical rt. Tothisclassbelongmany nstances fso-calledSympatheticMagic;lmanyof the taboo customs;most modern
1Hang a root of vervain around the neck in order to cause a tumor to disappear;asthe plant dries up, so will the tumor. If the fish do not appear in due season, makeoneof wood and put it into the water. Keep the arrow that has wounded a friend in acoolplace, so that the wound may not become inflamed.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 10/19
AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST58 [N. S., I4, I9I2
superstitions,those, for instance,regardingFriday, the number
thirteen,horseshoes, lantingwhenthe tide is comingn. In these
instances he effect is thoughtto followupon the cause withoutthe mediation f a forcepassing, et us say, fromthe magician o
the wooden ish placed n the streamand thence o the living fish.
An illustration f this classof magichasalreadybeengiven in the
old lady'sbeliefthat goodluck wouldcometo a household s the
resultof sparrows avingfallendownthe chimney. The gambler
who believes n his ''luck" does not usually conceiveof it as a
Power n any true senseof the word. Several acts drawn romchild life, whichpoint to this same conclusion,will be noted pres-
ently.
Divinationby casting ots or othenvise,whena spirit or god
is not supposedo guidethe cast, maybe includedhere as a sub-
division. The aim of divinations to securean itemof knowledge
forthe magician,while heotherpracticesf this classarecalculated
to produce ffectsof someother kind. But in neithercase doesthereexistthe ideaof a Powermediating etween he thingsought
and its antecedent.
Class I. Non-personal owersarebelieved o belongto themagicianhimself,or to particular bjects} uch as the magician's
instruments, nd to passfromtheseinto other objects,or to act
upon hemso as to produceertain ffects. If the magician imself
possesses his force, he does not thinkof it as identicalwith his"will,"oreven as intimately onnectedwith it.
Howittrelates hat somenativeAustralianseggedhim not to
carry n a bag containingquartzcrystalsa toothextractedat an
initiationceremony. They thoughtthat the evil power of the
crystalswouldenter the tooth and so injure he bodyto which thad belonged.l Manycharmshavea potencyof thisnature,while
others ha+re n animisticsignificance;hat is, they involve theaction of spirits,and so do not belonghere. Eatingthe fat of a
braveandstronganimal,or rubbing neselfwith it, in order o gain
1 Journal of the AnthropologicalInstitute, vol. XIII (I884), p. 456, quoted by Frazer.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 11/19
LEUBA] VARIETIES AND ORIGINOF MAGIC 359
courage ndpower, s an act belongingo this secondclass, as arealsomostcasesof ContagiousMagic.
Thereseems o be amongall peoplesa stageof developmenttwhicha Powerikethatdescribedbozzes conceivedlearly noughto be givena name;it is calledby sometribes n NorthAmerica,for instance,Wakanda,nd Manain Melanesia. This variouslynamednon-personal otency s the efficientcause of by far thegreaterpartof the magicalpractices.
ClassIII. Will-Magic. This includes he casesin whichthe
magicianeelsthathiswill-efforts anefficientactor. Under hisheadusuallyfall spells,incantations, nd solemncurses' A manwhosays to the magicspear,- Gostraightandkillhim,"feelsnodoubtthat by these words, n whichquivershis wholesoul, hedirects hespearonits errand f death.
Whendiscussingheoriginof non-personalowers,wesawhowearlymans attention s directed o his will-efforts,nd howvery
soonhe attempts o turnhis "will"to accountn the magicalway.Among he NorthAmerican ndians, ending orthone'sthoughtandwill is a common ractice. MissFletcherellsusthat,"Whena raceis takingplace,a manmaybendhis thoughtsandhis willuponone of the contestants . . in the beliefthat this act, this'sendingof his mind,'will helphis friend o win.''l In this andsimilarcasesthe will-powertself seemsto perform he magical
deed;while more commonly,perhaps, he spell or incantation"carries one'swillto anotherperson,whois thencompelledo actaccordirlgo the desireof the magician.
Theimportancefthisclassofmagics sogreat hatMaretthasraised he questionas to whetheran accompanyingpellis not anindispensableartof "perfect"magic;2 nd F. B. Jevonsfollowshimin connectingmagicalpowern generalwiththe senseof one's
ownenergy.3 In my opinion, his exercise f the will is the char-acteristic fonlyoneclassofmagic. Inmagicaswellasinreligion,1Fletcher,Alice C., Notes on CertainBeliefsconcerningWillPoweramongthe
SiouxTribes,Science NewYork),N. S., V, I897, pp. 33I, 334.
2 Marett,R. R., TheThresholdfReligion,pp.52et seq.a In the chapteron the originof the ideaof non-personal ower,I have al ready
arguedagainstthe view that will-magics the primary ormof magic.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 12/19
AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST60 1N. S., I4, I9I2
we must, t seems o me,admitselreralndependentrigins. What
followswill, I hope,beconclusive n thispoint.
In thisattemptat classification,wouldnot givethe impressionthat the conceptions f the savageareclearand definite. On the
contrary, hold themto be hazy andfluid. Whatappears o him
impersonalt one momentmaysuddenly ssume hecharacteristics
of a spirit. Mana, for instance,althoughusually an impersonal
force stored in plants,stones, animals,or men,at times takes
on trulypersonaltraits. One shouldnot be surprisedo meet
with casesthat belong o severalclasses. The followings a goodinstanceof the minglingof will-magicwith othertypes. "The
ancient Hindoos performedan elaborateceremony,based on
homeopathicmagic, orthe cure of jaundice. Its maindrift was
to banishthe yellow colorto yellowcreatures nd yellow things,
such as the sun, to which t properlybelongs,andto procure or
the patient a healthy red color froma living vigoroussource,
namely,a red bull. Withthis intention,a priestrecited he fol-lowing spell: 'Up to the sun shall go thy heart-acheand thy
jaundice:n the colourof the red bulldo we envelop hee! We
envelop heein red tints,unto long life. May this persongo un-
scathedand be freeof yellow colour! . . Into the parrots, nto
the thrush, owe put thyjaundice, ndfurthermore,nto the yellow
wagtaildowe put thy jaundice.' Whilehe uttered hesewords, he
priest, in orderto infuse the rosy hue of health into the sallowpatient,gavehim waterto sip whichwas mixedwith the hairof a
red bull; he pouredwaterover the animal'sbackand made the
sick mandrink t; he seatedhim on the skin of a redbull and tied
a pieceof the skinto him. Then n order o improvehis colourby
thoroughly radicatinghe yellow tint, he proceeded hus. He
first daubedhim fromhead to foot with a yellow porridgemade
of turmeric r curcums a yellow plant),set him on a bed, tiedthreeyellowbirds, o wita parrot,a thrush,and a yellowwagtail,
by meansof a yellow stringto the foot of the bed; then pouring
waterover the patient,he washedoff theyellowporridge,nd withit no doubtthe jaundice, rom him to the birds. After that, by
way of givinga finalbloom o his complexion,e tooksomehairsof
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 13/19
VARIETIES AND ORIGIN OF MAGICLEUBA]
36I
a redbull,wrapt hem n gold eaf,and glued hemto the patient'sskin."l
II. THE ORIGINSOFMAGICALEHAVIOR
The idea of non-personalowers s no moresynonymouswithmagic hantheideaof great,unseen,personal eingss synonymouswith religion. If there is to be a magicalart,ways and meansofusingthe Powermust be produced. How did the apparently nd-less varietyof magicalpractices ome o be? Mostof themwill beaccounted or by the followingprinciples f explanation. They
are of unequalmportance, uteachaccounts, t seems o me, for aclassof magic.
(a) Childrenoften amusethemselvesby makingprohibitions
andbacking hemup withthreatsof punishment. "If you dothis,"
they say, " thatwill happen o you." The "this" and the "that"have usually no logicalconnection,nor does the child have any-thoughtof a particular oweroragentmetingout the punishment.
It is importanto remembernthis connectionhat what s donein the make-believe pirit by one person s oftentaken seriously
by another, ndependently f any empirical erification. A littlegirl, seven yearsof age, was told that killinga snail wouldcauserain. She immediately cceptedhe statement,and rationalargu-ments did not take the idea out of her head. How many of thesenselesssuperstitions f the savage arose in this way we shall
neverknow. It seemsprobable, owever, hat manyof the com-mands,precautions, nd prescriptionsn the life of the savagehavehad this origin;for there is frequentlyno logicalconnectionbe-tween he deedforbidden rprescribednd thethingto be secured.I have n mindcertain aboocustoms,partsof initiation eremoniesof the Australians,4egulations overninghunting,and the like.A good instanceof the last is foundamongthe CentralEskimo:
certainkindsof gamemust not be eatenon the sameday; noneofthe deer'sbonesmust be brokenduring kinning;and bits of theanimalmust be buried n the groundor placedunderstones. In
1 Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 3d ed., vol. I, p. 79.
2 Spencer and Gillen, Native Tribes of Central Australia, London, I099, chap
VII-IX.
AM. ANTH., N. S., I4-24
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 14/19
362 AMERICANNTHROPOLOGIST|N. S., I4, I9I2
manyasesa fullerknowledgewouldundoubtedly isclose easons
of tility,realor imaginary,orthesemagicalpractices;but that
this ouldbe true n every nstance eemsanunjustifiablessump-tion. The fact that the savage s usuallyreadywith reasons or
his ehaviors no proofthat thesereasonsie at the basisof the
practices.Theexplanationsmaybe afterthoughts.
(b) It seems good psychology o hold that certainmagical
practicesriginatedn threatsof untowardhappeningsmadefor
thepurposeof preservinghingsvital to the life and prosperity
ofthe tribe, for instance,the authorityof the chief, and thesanctity f the marriage elation. The magicalbeliefswhichen-
force ontinence n the partof the wivesof menengagedn war
appearo havehadthisorigin. Thepunishmentmaybeanything
whichs regardeds efficacious.In Madagascaronjugal idelity
isenforcedby the threatthat the betrayedhusbandwillbe killed
orwoundedn the war;among he indigenousribesof Sarawak,
thebeliefis that the camphor btainedby the menin the jungle
willevaporatef the womenareunfaithful;whilein East Africa,
the husbandwill, in the sameeventuality,be killedor hurt by
theelephanthe is hunting.l Thehighsanctionwhich he require-
mentsof social ifegiveto beliefsof thiskind s readilyunderstood.
The mentalattitudeout of whichthesebeliefsaroseneednot
be regarded s a deliberatentention o deceive he women. One
shouldbear n mindthe halfmake-believe,alfseriousattitudeof
childrenn their ntercourse ithoneanother. Yet I donotthink
it impossiblehat beliefsof this sorthaveoriginatedn purposive
deception. Spencer ndGillen2elateof the mostprimitive eople
known o us, the Aruntaof centralAustralia,hat the adultmales
rule hewomen ndchildren ymeansofa bogiecalledTwanyirika.
(c) Themotivewhich eadscivilizedpeople o makevowsmay
account orcertainmagicalpractices. Oneof theoriginalmpulses
of humannatureseemsto be to try to avoida catastrophe r to
secureadvantagesby promising o do somethingwhich would
1Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 2d ed.. vol. I, pp. 2t3I.
2Spencer and Gillen, op. cit.. p. 246, note I. See also TheNorthernTribesof
CentralAustralia, p. 49I-492.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 15/19
363EUBA] VARIETIES AND ORIGIN OF MAGIC
gratify he personwho has controlover the eventF This motive n
its cruder orm s a desire o do somethingmeritoriousn order o
deserve mmunity romdanger. Customs f continencemay havehad the originmentioned bove,or they may have arisen rom he
women'sefforts o do somethingpraiseworthy,o that the life oftheirhusbandsmightbe preserved nd theirsuccess nsured.
(d) Other types of magicalbehaviorhave their origin n the
spontaneous esponseof the organism o specificsituations. In
states of excitement he liberatedenergy must find an outlet in
movements. To restrainevery externalsign of intense emotionis unendurable. By the bedsideof a sick personone loves, one
must do something or him. The "expression" f the excitement
is not altogetherat random. It takes place according o certainprinciples.1For instance, t is a common act that even men of
culturewhen under stress of emotionact in the absenceof the
objectof theirpassion s if it werepresent. A mangrindshis teeth,
shakeshis fist, growlsat the absentenemy; a mother alks fondlyto her departedbabe and presses t to her breast. The less a
person s under he controlof reason, he more ikely s he to yield
to suchpromptings.If a happy coincidencewere to lead to a connectionbetween
suchbehavior nd success n war,these spontaneous ctionswould
becomemagical, hat is, actionsperformedn the beliefthat they
are of assistance o the warriors. But coincidingortunate ventsarenot necessaryo the establishmentf the connectionn question.It is psychologically robable hat the desire n the mind of the
1 Compare Irving King: " In innumerable cases they [magical and religious acts]
can be shown to be primarily the natural reaction of the psycho-physical organism,
almost its mechanical reflex, in situations of strain and relaxation, or to such conditions
as require practical adjustments of some sort." Op. cit., pp. I79 I88.
In attempting to explain the bodily movements which accompany emotions, Darwin
set down three principles, two of which should be taken into account in the consider-
ation of the origin of magical behavior: the principle of actions due to the constitution
of the nervous system, and the principle of serviceable associated habit. Charles
Darwin, Expression f the Emotions n Man and Animals,pp. 28 ff. These principles
become, in Wundt's treatment of the matter, the principle of the direct modification of
innervation, the principle of the association of related feelings, and the principle of the
relation of the movements to sense-representations. W. Wundt, Physiologische sy-shologie, th ed,, vol. I.II pp. 286296.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 16/19
364 AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST [N. S., I4, I9I2
personduring he spontaneous ctivitieswill lead to a connectionbetween hese and the realization f the desire. It is worthwhile
to dwella moment onger n this possibility. I hadoccasion o dis-cuss above certaindancingceremonies. I attempted here to ac-count for the magicaldances f the womenwhile he menareat waras due in theiroriginal orm o a spontaneousxpression f restless-ness and excitement. Durationand repetitionof the excitementwould avor ts expressionn coordinated,ntelligiblemoarements-mimicry f fighting, or instance. If now thereappears senseof
necessary onnectionbetweenmimic fightingand success n war,-what was a merespontaneous xpression f excitementbecomesamagical practice. This step is not impossible, or if, while thedancing oeson, the wish orthe success f the warriorss uppermostin the mindsof the women, he dancingwill probably ometo beregarded s a condition f success. This ast step wouldbe no morethan an expression f the well-knownawof association: wo thingsthat have been together n the mind tend to recall each other.Thus formsof behavior risingas a release romemotional ensionsgraduallyassume definitenessand become means of exercisingmagical nfluence, uite independentlyf any experimental-roof.
Several of the numerousvarieties of so-called SympatheticMagic, particularlyhe widespread racticeof doing to an eigythat whichone would ike to do to the original, an be accountedfor by the addition o the formerprinciples f the followingaw of
mentalaction. Objectsresembling ach other becomeassociatedin the mind,so that the mindtends to pass fromone to the other.Like objects may becometo some extent equivalents n-mentaloperations. The fact that the satisfaction o the person aboringunder he excitement f angeror any otheremotion ncreaseswiththe similarityof the object upon which he wreakshis vengeanceto the personreally ntended,was probablydiscovered y chance
and led to the makingof imagesand effigies or magicalpurposes.(e) In the precedingmodesof origin,movements nd behaviorsfirstappear ndependentlyf any magical ntention,and afterwardacquirea magicalsignificance. But the magicalprinciples oonbecamedisengaged rom magicalpractice. At this point a newchapteropened n the historyof the magical rt. Magicno longer
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 17/19
365EUBA]-VARIETIESAND ORIGIN OF MAGIC
aroseonly by chance,but new formswerecreateddeliberately.
From his momentthere must have been a tendencyto treat,
accordingo moreor less definitemagicprinciples,verydiflicultsituation.
Herebelongmostof thenumerousracticeshatmaybeclassed
underheheading"likeproducesike." That"likeproducesike"
is a law of natureexpressed verywhere boutus. Cold,for in-
stance, producescold, and fire engenders ire. The frequent
spreadingof infectiousdiseasesamongvegetables,animals,and
menseemsquitesuicient to suggest hisbelief. Theattentionofthe savagewouldnaturallybe drawnvery earlyto that relation,
becauseof the manystrikinganddangerousormst talies. Now,
as he is quiteunableto distinguishamongthe differentagencies
involvedn thevarious xperiencesf thissort,hecannotdraw he-
linebetween he "likes" thatreallyproduce" ike" andthosethat
do not; hencehis very strangeexpectations.And as it is often
impossible o obtain or manipulate he objects possessinghe
qualitydesired,he wholecomes o be replaced y a part,oreven
by a symbol,which s treatedas if it containedhe powerof the
whole. Forexample, atingor wearinga partof a courageousr
powerfulnimalmakes neboldorstrong,orprotects romdanger;
rubbing he chinof a youngmanwith a rat's totem makesthe
hairgrow,etc.
Anotheroriginofthe sameclassis suggestedby an interesting
observationmadeby Sully.1 A littlegirlthought hat makingher
hair idywould toptheblowing fthewind. Thewinddisheveled
her;converse]y,puttingher hair in orderwouldmakethe wind
cease. Similarly omechildrenmagine hat sincethe windpro-
duceswhistling ounds,whistlingwill producewind. The second
of twosuccessivevents s thought o be ableto reproducehefirst.
In attemptingo demonstratehe priorityof magic o religion,Frazerwrites:"Magicis nothingbut a mistakenapplication f
theverysimplest ndmostelementary rocess fthemind,namely,
the associationof ideas by virtueof resemblancer contiguity,
1Sully, J., Studiesof Chxldhood,896, p. 80.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 18/19
366 AMERICAPfANTHROPOLOGIST 1N. S., I4, I9IZ
whilereligion ssumes he operation f conscious r personal gents,superior o man, behind he visible screenof nature. Obviously
the concept f personal gent s more omplex hana simple ecogni-tion of the similarity r contiguityof ideas.... The very beastsassociate he ideas of thingsthat are like each other or that have
been foundtogether n their experience.... But who attributes
to the animals belief hat the phenomena re workedby a multi-
tude of invisibleanimalsor by one enormousand prodigiouslystronganimalbehind he scenes? It is undoubtedlyrue that the
mind of man tends to pass from one object to others similarorpresentat the same time; but this psychologicalact does not in
itself account or magic. The mindof animals s regulated n like
manner. In the spring he sightof a feathermakes he bird"think"of nest-building, nd the smell and sight of the master'scoatprobably rings he master o the dog'smind. Yet animalsdo notpractise the magical art. This fact shows the insufficiency f
"a simple mistaken) ecognition f the similarity nd contiguity fideas"as an explanation f the originof magic. If an animalhadhad his attention drawn o the colorof carrotsand jaundice,he
mightobserve he color ikeness etween hem;and also " coat " and"master"might followeachother n a dog'smind. But in order
to treat the coat as he wouldthe master,or to eat carrots or the
cureof jaundice, he dog musthave, in addition o the association,
the beliefthat whatever s done to the coat will be suffered y themaster,and that the eating of carrotswill cure the disease. The
existenceof these ideas, togetherwith their motor and affective
values, makes magic possible. Frazerseems to have overlooked
this fundamental ifference etweenmereassociation f ideas and
the essentialmentalprocessesnvolved n magic. This differencemay be further llustratedby the instanceof a dog biting in rage
the stick with whichhe is beingbeaten. He is indeeddoingto thestick what he would ike to do to the man; but in attacking he
I Frazer, J. G., op. cit., 2d ed., vol. I, p. 70. Oldenburg (Die Religiondes Veda,Berlin, I894) was first, I believe, in holding to a pre-religious magical stage of culture.
But it is Frazer who first made a clear separation, not only between magic and religion,
but also between magic and the belief in spirit-agents.
8/7/2019 The Varieties, Classification, And Origin of Magic1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-varieties-classification-and-origin-of-magic1 19/19
367LEUBA]
VARIETIES AND ORIGIN OF MAGIC
stick he does not think that he is injuring he man. His action s
blindly mpulsive,whilethe formof magic n question nvolves he
purpose f inflictingnjury on something lse than the stick andthe belief hat the injury s actuallydone.l
If magical ctionscannotbe deduced imply rom he principles
of association, hey can at least be classified ccording o the kindof association hey illustrate. For although the various ideasbrought ogether n magic, n a relatzon f cause and effect, arefrequently aid to have come togetherby "chance," ome of the
conditionsunderwhich they have in fact becomeconnectedareexpressiblen the universalawsof association;namelyf ssociation
by similarity r contrast,by contiguityor spatialopposition, nd
by emotional ongruity r disparity. Whenevermagical cts have
been classified, t has been mainlywith reference o the kindsofassociation nvolved n the mental processes. But every kind of
activity involvingmentaloperations alls in some of its relations
under he lawsof association,ence heseclassificationsrerelativelyunfruitful. I haveattempted, herefore,o groupmagical racticesaccording o a factorof greater ignificance, amelv, he natureof
the power nvolved.
BRYN MAWRC0LLEGE
BRYN MAWR, PENNSYLVANIA
1 Cf. R. R. Marett, From Spell to Prayer, Folk-Lore, vol. xv (I904), PP. I36-I4I,
reprinted in The Threshold of Religion, pp. 44-48.