the structural properties of milky way dwarf galaxies · felipe santana (u. de chile) dwarf...

38
Ricardo Muñoz The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies (Universidad de Chile) Collaborators: Marla Geha (Yale) Patrick Côté (HIA/DAO) Peter Stetson (HIA/DAO) Josh Simon (Carnegie) George Djorgovski (Caltech) Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc

Upload: others

Post on 12-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Ricardo Muñoz

The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies

(Universidad de Chile)

Collaborators:

Marla Geha (Yale)

Patrick Côté (HIA/DAO) Peter Stetson (HIA/DAO) Josh Simon (Carnegie) George Djorgovski (Caltech) Felipe Santana (U. de Chile)

Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005)

Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005)

Milky Wayinner 100 kpc

Page 2: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

2004: Eleven known Milky Way satellite galaxies.Visual searches provide no evidence for a larger population . . . (Simon & Blitz 2002, Willman et al. 2002, Whiting et al. 2002)

Page 3: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

2005-present: SDSS has revolutionized the field

Belokurov et al. (2006)

Page 4: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

tidal stream

2005-present: SDSS has revolutionized the field

Belokurov et al. (2006)

Page 5: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

globular

clusters

tidal stream

2005-present: SDSS has revolutionized the field

Belokurov et al. (2006)

Page 6: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

new dwarf

globular

clusters

tidal stream

2005-present: SDSS has revolutionized the field

Belokurov et al. (2006)

Page 7: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) coverage

The New Milky Way Dwarf Galaxy Landscape

Name Year DiscoveredLMC B.CSMC B.CSculptor 1937Fornax 1938Leo II 1950Leo I 1950Ursa Minor 1954Draco 1954Carina 1977Sextans 1990Sagittarius 1994Ursa Major I 2005Willman I 2005Ursa Major II 2006Bootes I 2006Canes Venatici I 2006Canes Venatici II 2006Coma Berencies 2006Segue I 2006Leo IV 2006Hercules 2006Leo T 2007Bootes II 2007

Leo V 2008

Belokurov et al. (2006)

The Satellite Numbers:Classical dSphs = 11Ultra-Faint dwarfs = 17

28

To SDSS depth, full sky = 11 + 4x17 ≈ 80

To LSST depth, full sky > 400 MW dwarfs

Segue II 2009Pisces I 2009

Pisces II 2010Bootes III 2009

Page 8: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

How faint are the Milky way dwarfs?

from http://chandra.as.utexas.edu/~kormendy/dm.html

Fornax Sculptor

Carina Sextans

Page 9: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

How faint are the Milky way dwarfs?

Page 10: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

How faint are the Milky way dwarfs?

Page 11: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

How faint are the Milky way dwarfs?

Page 12: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Globular Clusters

Classical Dwarf dSphs

Martin et al. (2008)

Lum

inos

ity

Size

Page 13: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Martin et al. (2008)

UFDs

Lum

inos

ity

Size

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Globular Clusters

Classical Dwarf dSphs

Page 14: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Wolf et al. (2010)

GCs

UFDs

MW

dSph

M/L

Mass

Why do we call them galaxies?: kinematics

UFDs seem to be the most dark matter dominated systems in the Universe!

Page 15: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

New luminosity regime poses a serious challenge to do a proper photometric

characterization.

Page 16: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

New luminosity regime poses a serious challenge to do a proper photometric

characterization.

Belokurov et al. (2007)

SDSS photometry

Page 17: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

A New Deep Survey (CFHT/Magellan)

Page 18: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Muñoz, Geha & Willman (2010)Belokurov et al. (2007)Coma Berenices,

Comparison between SDSS y Megacam

SDSS photometry Megacam photometry

Page 19: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Mr

rhalf (pc) Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 20: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Mr

rhalf (pc) Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 21: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Mr

Mr

rhalf (pc) Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 22: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxiesM

r

Line of constant surface brightness

rhalf (pc)

Page 23: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 24: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Surface brightness floor probably a selection bias

Page 25: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Surface brightness floor probably real.

Page 26: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 27: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Galaxies are intrinsically elongated

Page 28: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Globular Clusters seem intrinsically round

Galaxies are intrinsically elongated

Page 29: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 30: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 31: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Photometric Properties of Milky Way dwarf galaxies

Muñoz et al. (2014)

Page 32: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Metallicity-Luminosity Relationship

Metallicity-Luminosity relationship also suggests that UFDs are indeed galaxies.

[Fe/

H]

Luminosity (Lsun)

Page 33: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Metallicity-Luminosity Relationship

Metallicity-Luminosity relationship also suggests that UFDs are indeed galaxies.

Page 34: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Metallicity-Luminosity Relationship

UFDs?

Metallicity-Luminosity relationship also suggests that UFDs are indeed galaxies.

Page 35: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

Metallicity-Luminosity Relationship

or tidally disrupting?

Metallicity-Luminosity relationship also suggests that UFDs are indeed galaxies.

Page 36: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

The Future

Page 37: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

The Future

Bullock et al. (2009) Diemand et al. (2008)

Page 38: The Structural Properties of Milky Way Dwarf Galaxies · Felipe Santana (U. de Chile) Dwarf Galaxies (post-2005) Dwarf Galaxies (pre-2005) Milky Way inner 100 kpc. 2004: Eleven known

final thoughts

However, the UFDs represent a new regime in luminosity that greatly impacts our ability to study them

The Future is bright, only 1% of virial volume of Milky Way has been exhaustively searched (and only northern sky)

•High quality, deep photometry is required to determine reliable structural parameters and to investigate their morphologies.

•CFHT/Magellan survey is nearly finished. It represents the deepest and most comprehensive database for outer halo structure. STAY TUNED.

Milky Way dwarfs are good probes of dark matter and galaxy formation:

• Good targets for indirect dark matter detection experiments (Fermi, ACTs).

• Phase space density constraints.

• Good for studying galaxy formation thresholds.