the right to decide in democracy between recentralisation and independence at the regions quarterly...
DESCRIPTION
2014 is going to be remembered as one of the most ‘experimental’ years in order to put direct democracy into practice by the right to decide (López 2011) by small nations (Keating 2014), in reference to their nation-states (Ohmae 1995). While, the 18th September was the date of the independence referendum for the future of the UK and Scotland, the 9th November, is already uncertain whether or not the right to decide via consultation will take place in Catalonia.TRANSCRIPT
]~~yS JLOPFLQQK
dhUegYe_j
`U[Uk]aY bZ g\Y
A# (743-?#+9,6;0/9#,6.#'/,96361#36#)/1376,4#%/>/4785/6<#
A# B/#)74/#70#&7>/965/6<;#36#(9757<361#$4=;</9;
A# *-7<<3;2#)/0/9/6.=5#@#<2/#(7;<;-938<
4,*60-)* 0+4,* .*.(*23,-1
/0 $'&! $"#% -335* %
� � "'&*�� � � �� "&+�)�� � � � '% % �&+�� &� �� � � � +�
)
?^db_TeSdY_^0./2# cm# aicha# ni#
\_#l_g_g\_l_^#[m#
ih_# i`# nb_# gimn#
v_ r j _ l c g _ h n [ f w#
s _ [ l m # c h # n _ lg m#
i`# jonncha# ^cl_]n#
^_gi]l[] s # chni#
jl[]n c]_# nblioab#
nb_# _r _l]cm_# i`# nb_# lcabn# ni# ^_]c^_#
(I� j_t *#0.//)#\s #mg[ff#h[ncihm#(H_[ncha*#
0./2)#qcnb#l_`_l_h]_#ni#nb_cl#h[ncih+
mn[n_m# (Lbg[_*# /773),# Lh# nb_# /6 nbnb
P_jn_g\_l#nb_#go]b#^cm]omm_^#P]inncmb#
ch^_j_h^_h]_#l_`_l_h^og#]ih]_lhcha#
nb_#`onol_#i`#nb_#RH#[h^#P]inf[h^#q[m#
b_f^9#biq_p_l*#qbcf_#nb_#7nbnb#Kip_g\_l#
b[m#\__h#jlipcmcih[ffs #m_n#`il#[#]ihmofn[+
ncih#jli]_mm#ni#n[e_#jf[]_#ch#@[n[fihc[#
ih#nb_#lcabn#ni#^_]c^_*#[n#nb_#ncg_#i`#
qlcncha#nbcm#[lnc]f_*#ch#L]ni\_l#qbc]b#
cm#domn#ih_#gihnb#jlcil#ni#nbcm#^[n_*#cn#
cm#[fl_[^s #oh]_ln[ch#qb_nb_l#il#hin#nbcm#
qcff#b[jj_h,#
Jil_ip_l*# [#af[h]_#[n# nb_#]oll_hn#
Bolij_[h#l_acih[f#]igj[l[ncp_#^_\[n_*#
qbc]b#q_#g[s #`l[g_#[m#[#]ihnchoiom#
n_hmcih#\_nq__h#l_]_hnl[fcm[ncih#[h^#
ch^_j_h^_h]_# ch# l_f[ncih# ni# h[ncih+
mn[n_#\il^_lm*# l_p_[fm# nb[n*#qbcf_# nb_#
RH# Dip_lhg_hn# f_a cn cg cm_^# nb_#
P]inncmb#Dip_lhg_hn# [h^# mojjiln_^#
nb_#P]inncmb#Fh^_j_h^_h]_#l_`_l_h^og#
[m#\_cha#[#bcabfs #^_gi]l[nc]#_r _l]cm_*#
Pj[ch# mnc f fm# mn[h^m# ion# [m# l_g[chcha#
hilg[ncp_fs #ch` f_r c\f_#qcnbion*#mi#`[l*#
_p_h#]ihn_gjf[ncha#[hs #h[ncih+mn[n_#
l_+m][ f f cha# jli]_mm# (?l_hh_l*# 0..2)#
[h^*#ch^__^*#qcnbion#[jj[l_hnfs #b_[l+
cha# nb_# ]f[cgm#i`# mg[ff#h[ncihm# mo]b#
[m#@[n[fihc[#[h^#nb_#?[mko_#@iohnls #
`il#nb_#cgjf_g_hn[ncih#i`#[#^_fc\_l[+
ncp_#^_gi]l[nc]#jli]_mm#mcgcf[l#ni#nb_#
P]inncmb#l_`_l_h^og,#
Fn# cm# ch# nbcm#]ihn_r n# nb[n# nbcm# [lnc+
]f_#chn_h^m#ni#mb_^#mig_#fcabn#ih#nb_#
^_\[n_#nblioab#[h#[h[fs mcm*# `lig#nb_#
^_gi]l[nc]#j_lmj_]ncp_*#i`# nb_# mcgc+
f[lcnc_m#[h^#^c``_l_h]_m#\_nq__h#nbl__#
mg[ff#h[ncihm#qcnb#l_`_l_h]_#ni#nb_cl#
l_mj_]ncp_#h[ncih+mn[n_m,#Fh#nbcm#l_a[l^#
q_#l_`_l#ni#P]inf[h^*#@[n[fihc[#[h^#nb_#
?[mko_#@iohnls #[m#mg[ff#h[ncihm#[h^#
nb_#RH#[h^#Pj[ch#[m#nb_cl#l_`_l_hnc[f#
h[ncih+mn[n_m,
Qbcm# [l nc]f_# a[nb_lm# nia_nb_l# nb_#
jl_fcgch[l s # ]ih]fomcihm#i`# [#\_h]b+
g[lecha# mno^s # i`# _cabn# ]cn s +l_acih#
][m_m#]ih^o]n_^#\s #g_#[h^#`oh^_^#\s #
Fe_l\[mko_# [h^# nb_# OP># (m__# qqq,
]cns l_acihm,ila),#Qb_#jlid_]n#][n_ailcm_m#
`iol#i`#nb_m_#][m_m#[m#h[ncih[fcmnc]#]cns +
l_acihm#z #nb_#?[mko_#@iohnls #(Pj[ch)*#
P]inf[h^#(RH)*#@[n[fihc[#(Pj[ch)#[h^#
F]_f[h^#z #[h^#nb_#l_g[chcha#`iol#][m_m#
[m# hih+h[ncih[f cmn c]# ]cn s +l_acihm# z #
Ao\fch#(Fl_f[h^)*#Milnf[h^#(Ll_aih)*#
Ll_moh^#(A_hg[le#[h^#Pq_^_h)#[h^#
Icp_ljiif-J[h]b_mn_l# (RH),# Qbcm#
[lnc]f_# `i]om_m#ih# nbl__#h[ncih[fcmnc]#
]cns +l_acihm#nb[n#` cn#qcnb#nb_#][n_ails #
i`# mg[ff# h[ncihm# (m__#@[ft [^[*# 0./2*#
bnnj8--qqq,jimnch^_j_h^_h]_,ila),#
, 979BHF5 @=G5H=CB�J9FGIG�89JC@IH=CB�� �=B89D9B89B79Bmn[\fcmb_^# h[ncih+mn[n_m# [l_# ch]l_[m+
chafs # \_cha# `il]_^# ni# l_nbche# nb_cl#
n_llcnilc[f#gi^_f#\s #^_pifpcha#jiq_lm,#
>m#H_[ncha#(0./2)#[lao_m*#vafi\[fcm[ncih#
[h^#Bolij_[h#chn_al[ncih#b[p_#_h]iol+
[a_^#nb_#l_+_g_la_h]_#i`#[#h_q#]cpc]#
h[ncih[fcmg#qcnbch#_mn[\fcmb_^#h[ncih+
mn[n_mw,# @ihm_ko_hnfs *# ]cn s +l_acih[f#
mg[ff#h[ncihm# [l_# nls cha# ni# ` ch^# nb_cl#
viqhw#jf[]_#ch+\_nq__h#nb_cl#l_`_l_hnc[f#
h[ncih+mn[n_m#[h^#mojl[h[ncih[f#\i^c_m#
mo]b#[m#nb_#BR,#
Eiq_p_l*#_mn[\fcmb_^#h[ncih+mn[n_m#
[l_#`[]cha#nbcm#^_g[h^#ch#p_ls #^c``_l+
_hn#q[s m,# Fh#j[lnc]of[l*#q_# ][h# ` ch^#
l_g[le[\f_# ^c` `_l_h]_m# \_nq__h# nb_#
RH#[h^#Pj[ch#s _n*#^_mjcn_#nb_m_*#oh^_l#
hi#]cl]ogmn[h]_m#mbiof^#nb_#l_]_hnfs #
_g_la_^-h_q#]cn s +l_acih[f#il^_l# \_#
`ilainn_h,#Qb_#h_q#il^_l# mbiof^# \_#
J>;�, ?! ". �. E�� ;8?9; ?D?D�� ;CE8H683 �7;7;JM;;D
H;8;DJH6B?I6J?ED 6D9�#D9;F;D9;D8;��-8E8EJB6D9�� 6J6BED?6
6D9�. ";�� 6I6IGK;K;�� EKDJHO
#;CF�� 5 @N585 �) L:CF8�/ B=J9FG=HM�/ %
=;IF9�� ���� CA D5 F=B;�H<F99�7=HM F9;=CB5 @�GA 5 @@�B5H=CBG��-7CH@5B8�� 5H5 @CB=5�5B8�H<9�� 5GEI9�� CIBHFM
J^daRT3 fff'RXchaTVX^]b'^aV
=;IF9�� ��P� 9B7<A 5F? =B;�� =HM , 9;=CBG�69MCB8�( 5H=CB -H5H9GQ
.BHE68��fff'RXchaTVX^]b'^aV
� '% % �&+�� &� �� � � � +�� � � "'&*�� � � �� "&+�)�� � �
*
n[e_h# m_lciomfs # nblioab#j[s cha#]fim_#
[nn_hncih#ni#cnm#^_gi]l[nc]#^cg_hmcih#
[h^#ni#nb_#]f_[l#n_llcnilc[f#[h^#jifcnc+
][f#]ihm_ko_h]_m#`il#nb_#]cns +l_acih[f#
mg[ff#h[ncihm#chpifp_^#\on#[fmi*#gimn#
cgjil n[hn fs *# `il# nb_c l# l_`_l_hn c[ f#
h[ncih+mn[n_m#[h^#`il#nb_#BR#[m#[#qbif_*#
[m#[h#cgjfc][n_^#mojl[h[ncih[f#\i^s ,
Qb_#RH#[h^#P]inf[h^#cgjf_g_hn_^#
nb_# lcabn# ni#^_]c^_# nblioab# nb_#/6nbnb
P_jn_g\_l#ch^_j_h^_h]_#l_`_l_h^og,#
Qb_# l_mofnm# mbiq_^# [#33&# vKiw#pin_#
p_lmom# [# 23&# vV_mw# pin_# `il# P]inncmb#
c h^_j_h^_h]_ * # q cn b# ^_pi +g[ r #
l_p_[f_^#ni#\_#nb_#]bic]_#i`#[#g[dilcns ,#
K_p_lnb_f_mm*# nb_# l_`_l_h^og# f_^# ni#
mcahc` c][hn#a[chm#ch#l_a_h_l[ncha#fi][f#
^_gi]l[]s *# l_chpcail[ncha# jif cnc][ f#
^_\[n_#[h^#chcnc[ncha#[#l_+_p[fo[ncih#i`#
P]inf[h^wm#l_f[ncihmbcj#qcnb#nb_#RH,#
@ihmc^_lcha#nb_m_#mbc`nm*#cn#g[s #\_#nb[n#
nb_#^_pifoncih#jli]_mm#`il#P]inf[h^#b[m#
ihfs #domn#\_aoh,
Lh# nb_# inb_l# b[h^*# Pj[ ch# [h^#
@[n [ fih c[# ([h^# [ f mi# nb_# ?[mko_#
@iohnl s )# [l_# `[l# `lig# ]b[hh_f f cha#
[hs # [al__g_hn# nb[n# qiof^# `[]c f c+
n[n_# ^_fcp_l s # i`# nb_# lcabn# ni# ^_]c^_,#
Colnb_lgil_*# Pj[ch# l_g[chm# ^_n_l+
gch_^#ni#l_]_hnl[fcm_#nb_#h[ncih+mn[n_#
[h^# m__gm# ni# l_a[l^# ^_`_h^cha# nb_#
@ihmncnoncih#[m#nb_#ihfs #ao[l[hn__#i`#
^icha#mi,#Eiq_p_l*#g_[hqbcf_#h_cnb_l#
nb_#]f[cgm#i`# nb_#@[n[f[hm#hil# nbim_#
i`# nb_#?[mko_m# [l_#\_cha# fcmn_h_^# ni#
[h^#ch^_j_h^_hncmg#cm#]ihnchocha#ni#
a[nb_l#[^pi][n_m,#
=B5 @�F9A 5 F? G��� CA D5 F=B;�-7CH@5 B8�� 5H5 @CB=5 �5 B8�H<9�� 5 GEI9�� CIBHFM
?_fiq*#F#jlipc^_#[#\lc_`#^_m]lcjncih#
i`#_[]b#i`#nb_#mg[ff#h[ncihm#]ih]_lh_^#
b_l_#qcnb#l_`_l_h]_#ni#cnm#h[ncih+mn[n_8#
(m__#Q[\f_#/)8
Fh# P]in f[h^*# nb_# ch^_j_h^_h]_#
ijncih# q[m# [al__^# ih# \s # \inb# nb_#
l_acih[f#P]inncmb#aip_lhg_hn#[h^#nb_#
?lcn cmb# aip_lhg_hn,# Qb_# ion]ig_#
jl_m_hn_^#[h#ionmn[h^cha#f_p_f#i`#]cnc+
t _h#_ha[a_g_hn,#Eiq_p_l*#[fnbioab#
nb_#mg[ff#g[lach#q[m#ch#`[piol#i`#hi#
ch^_j_h^_h]_*#nb_#l_`_l_h^og#m__gm#
ni# mcah[f# nb_# \_achhcha# l[nb_l# nb[h#
nb_#_h^#i`#[#]cns +l_acih[f#^_pifoncih#
jli]_mm#`il#P]inf[h^#([h^#j_lb[jm#[fmi#
`il#inb_l#v?lcncmbw#mg[ff#h[ncihm),
@[n[ fih c[ *# ih# nb_# inb_l# b[h^*#
l_p_[fm# [# ]igjf_n_fs # ^c` `_l_hn# mcno[+
ncih9#nb_#Pj[hcmb#@ihmncnoncih[f#@ioln#
b[m# momj_h^_^#[#]ihmofn[ncih#jli]_mm#
ih#nb_#@[n[f[h#ch^_j_h^_h]_#l_`_l_h+
^og*# jligjncha# 7..# gohc]cj[fcnc_m#
ni#a[nb_l#ch#L]ni\_l#ch#`[piol#i`#nb_#
]ihmofn[ncih,#?s #nb_#ncg_#nbcm#[lnc]f_#
cm#jo\fcmb_^*#q_#qcff#ehiq#qb_nb_l#il#
hin#cn#q[m#ofncg[n_fs #b_f^,#O_a[l^f_mm#
i`#nb_#_p_hnwm#i]]oll_h]_#[h^#cnm#ion+
]ig_*#cn#mbiof^#[n#f_[mn#bcabfcabn#nb_#
f[]e#i`#^_gi]l[nc]#`l[g_qile#ni#^_[f#
qcnb#[#]f[cg#nb[n#cm#mojjiln_^#\s #gil_#
nb[h#5.&#i`#@[n[fihc[,###
Cch[f fs *# nb_#?[mko_#@iohnl s #jl_+
m_hnm# [# h_q# [h^# jimcncp_# ]ihn_r n,# >#
^_g[h^#`il#[#l_`_l_h^og#cm#\ioh^#ni#
i]]ol#miih_l#il#f[n_l#[m#[#]ihm_ko_h]_#
i`# nb_# ip_l]igcha# i`# nb_# jifcn c][ f#
pcif_h]_# nb[n# ^igch[n_^# nb_# jl_pc+
iom#_l[,#Qb_#g[ch#cmmo_#`il#[hs #mo]b#
l_`_l_h^og*#biq_p_l*#cm#nb_#]ihncho_^#
f[]e#i`#jl_j[l[ncih,#Colnb_lgil_*#nb_#
l_acih#g[s #g__n#nb_#m[g_#^c`` c]ofnc_m#
[m#nbim_#`[]_^#\s #@[n[fihc[#l_a[l^cha#
Pj[chwm#ch` f_r c\f_#jimcncih,
HUVUbU^SUc?l_hh_l*#K,#(0..2)#) 8J�FG4 G8�FC4 68F�R �0 E54 A �
:BI8EA 4 A 68�4 A 7�G;8�E8F64 ?<A : �B9�FG4G8;BB7*#
Lr `il^8#Lr `il^#Rhcp_lmcns #Ml_mm,
@[ft [^[*#F,#(0./2)#+BFG$A 78C8A 78A GM<4 ��
!?P]@iP]XZ?^]P>PaP,#(qqq,
jimnch^_j_h^_h]_,ila)#P[h#P_\[mnc� h8#
Ql[hmfie[f#jo\fcmbcha,#([p[cf[\f_#[n#
qqq,nl[hmfie[f,]ig)#
D_h_l[fcn[n#^_#@[n[fohs [#(0./2)#2 ;<G8�
+4 C8E�BA �/ ;8�) 4G<BA 4?�/E4 A F<G<BA �B9�
� 4 G4 ?BA <4 ��D_h_l[fcn[n#^_#@[n[fohs [,#
A_j[lng_hn#i`#nb_#Ml_mc^_h]s *#
?[l]_fih[,#([p[cf[\f_#[n8#qqq,
][n[f[haip_lhg_hn,_o)#
E_llm]b_f*#Q,#(0./2)#� <G<8F�.G4G8�4 A 7�
"?B54 ?<F4 G<BA ��� <GLE8:<BA 4?�"BI8A 4 A 68�
<A � HEBC8�4 A 7�) BEG;� @ 8E<64 #Lr ih8#
Oionf_^a_,
H_[ncha*#J,#[h^#E[lp_s *#J,*#(0./2)#.@ 4??�
A 4 G<BA F�<A �4 �5<: �JBE?7��2 ;4 G�.6BG?4 A 7�64 A �
?84 EA �B^ch\olab8#Io[nb#Ml_mm,
I� j_t *#G,#(0.//)#x Clig#nb_#lcabn#ni#m_f`+
^_n_lgch[ncih#ni#nb_#lcabn#ni#^_]c^_8#>#
jimmc\f_#j[l[^cag#mbc`n#ch#nb_#mnloaaf_#
`il#nb_#lcabnm#i`#mn[n_f_mm#h[ncihQ �
, H4 78EA F�78�- 868E64 *#Ki#2,#Kip_g\_l*#
?[l]_fih[8#RKBP@L@>Q,
Lbg[_*#H,#(/774)#/ ;8�8A 7�B9�G;8�A 4 G<BA �
bcPcT*#K_q#Vile8#Cl__#Ml_mm#Mo\fcmb_lm,
P]inn*#>,*#>ah_q*#G,*#Pid[*#B,#[h^#Pnilj_l*#
J,#(0../)#x Dfi\[f#]cns +l_acihmy *#
ch#>,#P]inn#(_^,)#"?B54 ?�6<GLE8:<BA F��
/E8A 7F�G;8BEL�CB?<6L#jj,#//z 1.,#Lr `il^#
Rhcp_lmcns #Ml_mm*#Lr `il^,
Qb_#P]inncmb#Dip_lhg_hn#(0./1)#.6BG?4 A 7OF�
!HGHE8��3 BHE�"H<78�GB�4 A �$A 78C8A 78A G�
.6BG?4 A 7��2 ;<G8�+4 C8E��P]inncmb#
Dip_lhg_hn*#B^ch\olab ([p[cf[\f_#[n8#
qqq,m]inl_`_l_h^og,]ig)#
� F� #;CF� � 5 @N5 85 # cm# [# O_m_[l]b#
C_ffiq*#I_]nol_l#[h^#Mifc]s #>^pcm_l#
[n# nb_# Conol_# i`# @cnc_m+@LJM>P*#
Rhcp_lmcns #i`#Lr `il^#(RH)*#Fe_l\[mko_#
(Pj[ ch)# [h^# ?clgchab[g# >mnih#
Rhcp_lmcns #(RH),#E_#cm#[h#OP>#B[lfs #
@[l__l#Dl[hn#bif^_l#qcnb#qqq,]cns l_+
acihm,ila#jlid_]n,
XV^a'RP[iPSP6R^\_Pb'^g'PR'dZ
;^T^_dUc/ #A[n[#l_f[n_#ni#nb_#?[mko_#@iohnls #
mc^_#ch#Pj[ch,#Qb_#Cl_h]b#mc^_#cm#hin#
l_jl_m_hn_^#ch#nb_m_#` caol_m,
0 bnnj8--qqq,hs ncg_m,]ig-0./2-.6-.4-
qilf^-_olij_-][n[f[h+pin_+m__h+[m+n_mn+
`il+m_j[l[ncmnm+ch+_olij_,bngf
@cns +l_acih[f#mg[ff#h[ncih Mijof[ncih#ch#Jcffcihm
(K[ncih+Pn[n_#&)
DAM#]ihnlc\oncih#
l_f[n_^#ni#K[ncih+Pn[n_#(&)
P]inf[h^ 3,1#(6) 7
@[n[fihc[ 5,3#(/4) /7/7
?[mko_#@iohnls / 0,0#(3,3) 4
J56@9�� ��� =HM F9;=CB5 @�GA 5 @@�B5H=CBGQ�DCDI@5H=CBG�5B8�=9F9F
.BHE68��/ ;8�) 8J�3 BE>�/ <@ 8F+