the rhineland massacres - wordpress.com...source: anna komnene, byzantine historian and daughter of...

9
The Rhineland Massacres Eager to fight non-Christians in the Holy Land, some Crusaders decided to attack non-Christians in Europe as well. In what were later known as the Rhineland Massacres, they slaughtered entire communities of Jews, in spite of protests by local officials and clergy. “[I swear] to go on this journey only after avenging the blood of the crucified one (Jesus) by shedding Jewish blood and completely eradicating any trace of those bearing the name 'Jew,' thus assuaging his own burning wrath. Source: Godfrey of Bouillon, Frankish Knight of the First Crusade

Upload: others

Post on 01-Apr-2021

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheRhinelandMassacresEagertofightnon-ChristiansintheHolyLand,someCrusadersdecidedtoattacknon-ChristiansinEuropeaswell.InwhatwerelaterknownastheRhinelandMassacres,theyslaughteredentirecommunitiesofJews,inspiteofprotestsbylocalofficialsandclergy.“[Iswear]togoonthisjourneyonlyafteravengingthebloodofthecrucifiedone(Jesus)bysheddingJewishbloodandcompletelyeradicatinganytraceofthosebearingthename'Jew,'thusassuaginghisownburningwrath.Source:GodfreyofBouillon,FrankishKnightoftheFirstCrusade

Page 2: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheRhinelandMassacresEagertofightnon-ChristiansintheHolyLand,someCrusadersdecidedtoattacknon-ChristiansinEuropeaswell.InwhatwerelaterknownastheRhinelandMassacres,theyslaughteredentirecommunitiesofJews,inspiteofprotestsbylocalofficialsandclergy.“Itcertainlyseemsamazingthatonasingledayinmanydifferentplaces,movedinunisonbyaviolentinspiration,suchmassacresshouldhavetakenplace,despitetheirwidespreaddisapprovalandtheircondemnationascontrarytoreligion.Butweknowthattheycouldnothavebeenavoidedsincetheyoccurredinthefaceofexcommunicationimposedbynumerousclergymen,andofthethreatofpunishmentonthepartofmanyprinces.”Source:HughofFlavigny,BenedictineMonkandContemporaryHistorian(livingatthetime)

Page 3: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheRhinelandMassacresEagertofightnon-ChristiansintheHolyLand,someCrusadersdecidedtoattacknon-ChristiansinEuropeaswell.InwhatwerelaterknownastheRhinelandMassacres,theyslaughteredentirecommunitiesofJews,inspiteofprotestsbylocalofficialsandclergy.“…cruelforeigners,fierceandswift,FrenchmenandGermans…[who]putcrossesontheirclothingandweremoreplentifulthanlocustsonthefaceoftheearth.”Source:EliezerbenNathan,ContemporaryJewishChronicler

Page 4: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

InteractionsBetweenCrusadersandByzantinesAlthoughAlexiusI,theByzantineEmperor,hadoriginallyaskedforthePopetosendknights,tensionsquicklygrewbetweentheCrusadersandEmperor,whowasnotexpectingsomanyknights,andwasthreatenedbytheirnumbersandtheiractions.Hehesitantlyadmittedthemintothecity,butrequiredtheLord’stoswearloyaltytohim,andtheyreluctantlyagreed.“WhentheFrankshadallcometogetherandhadtakenanoathtotheemperor,therewasonecountwhohadtheboldnesstositdownuponthethrone.Theemperor,wellknowingtheprideoftheLatins,keptsilent,butBaldwinapproachedtheFrankishcountandtakinghimbythehandsaid,‘Yououghtnottositthere;thatisanhonorwhichtheemperorpermitstonoone.Nowthatyouareinthiscountry,whydoyounotobserveitscustoms?’TheinsolentcountmadenoreplytoBaldwin,butsaidinhisbarbarouslanguage,asiftalkingtohimself,‘Thismustbearude[emperor]whowouldaloneremainseatedwhensomanybravewarriorsarestandingup.’Alexisnotedthemovementoftheman'slipsandcalledaninterpreterinordertolearn,whathehadsaid;butwhentheinterpreterhadtoldhimhedidnotcomplaintotheFranks,althoughhedidnotforgetthematter.”Source:AnnaKomnene,ByzantineHistorianandDaughterofEmperorAlexiusI

Page 5: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheSeigeofJerusalemThesiegeofJerusalemwasatremendousvictoryfortheCrusaders,whosucceededintakingtheholycityinthenameofChristianity.However,thebloodysiegeinvolvedterriblefightingandendedindisasterforthecity’sinhabitants,whowerenotonlyMuslimsbutalsoJewsandChristians,fightingtogethertodefendtheircity.“TheFranks(Crusaders)enteredthecitymagnificentlyatthenoondayhour…Withtrumpetssoundingandwitheverythinginanuproar,exclaiming,‘Help,God!’theyvigorouslypushedintothecity,and[rightaway]raisedthe[flag]atthetopofthewall.Alltheheathens(disbelievers),completelyterrified,changedtheirboldness(braveness)toswiftflightthroughthenarrowstreets…NowherewasthereaplacewheretheSaracens(Muslims)couldescape…Notoneofthemwasallowedtolive.”

Source:ChroniclesofFulcherofChartres,1127

Page 6: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheSeigeofJerusalemThesiegeofJerusalemwasatremendousvictoryfortheCrusaders,whosucceededintakingtheholycityinthenameofChristianity.However,thebloodysiegeinvolvedterriblefightingandendedindisasterforthecity’sinhabitants,whowerenotonlyMuslimsbutalsoJewsandChristians,fightingtogethertodefendtheircity.“Butnowthatourmenhadpossessionofthewallsandtowers,wonderfulsightsweretobeseen.Someofourmen—andthiswasmoremerciful—cutofftheheadsoftheirenemies;othersshotthemwitharrows,sothattheyfellfromthetowers;otherstorturedthemlongerbycastingthemintotheflames...Indeed,itwasajustandsplendidjudgmentofGodthatthisplaceshouldbefilledwiththebloodoftheunbelievers,sinceithadsufferedsolongfromtheirblasphemies(falsebeliefs)…Itwasnecessarytopickone’swayoverthebodiesofmenandhorses...[OntheTempleMount]menrodeinblooduptotheirknees...Thecitywasfilledwithcorpsesandblood.”Source:Raymondd’Aguilers,aCatholicpriestwhotraveledwithcrusadersintheFirstCrusade

Page 7: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

TheSeigeofJerusalemThesiegeofJerusalemwasatremendousvictoryfortheCrusaders,whosucceededintakingtheholycityinthenameofChristianity.However,thebloodysiegeinvolvedterriblefightingandendedindisasterforthecity’sinhabitants,whowerenotonlyMuslimsbutalsoJewsandChristians,fightingtogethertodefendtheircity.“ThepopulationwasputtotheswordbytheFranks,whopillaged(raided)theareaforaweek...InMasjidal-Aqsa[mosquenexttotheDomeoftheRockontheTempleMount]theFranks(Crusaders)slaughteredmorethan70,000people,amongthemalargenumberofImams(prayerleaders)andMuslimscholars...TheFranksstrippedtheDomeoftheRockofmorethanfortysilvercandelabra...andagreatsilverlampweighingforty-fourSyrianpounds,aswellasahundredandfiftysmallersilvercandelabraandmorethantwentygoldones,andagreatdealmorebooty(loot).”Source:ThePerfectHistorybyIbnAl-Athir(ArabMuslimHistorian),1200s.

Page 8: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

CrusadersLivingintheHolyLandTheconquestofJerusalem,theCrusaderscreatedfourstatesintheHolyLand.CenteredonthecitiesofJerusalem,Edessa,Antioch,andTripoli,thesestateswereintendedtobeChristianstrongholdsagainstattemptsbyMuslimforcestotakebackthelandfromtheCrusaders.Theyalsoprovidedanopportunityforlandlessknightstogainlandsoftheirown.ManyCrusadersremainedintheHolyLand,enjoyingthebenefitsoftheirnewhome.“...[W]ewhowere[Westerners]nowhavebeenmade[Easterners]…Wehavealreadyforgottentheplacesofourbirth...Somealreadypossessherehomesandservantswhichtheyhavereceivedthroughinheritance.Somehavetakenwivesnotmerelyoftheirownpeople,butSyrians,orArmenians,orevenSaracens(Muslims)whohavereceivedthegraceofbaptism...Forthosewhowerepoor[inEurope],hereGodmakesrich.Thosewhohadfewcoins,herepossesscountless[wealth];andthosewhohadnothad[anyproperty],here,bythegiftofGod,alreadypossessacity.ThereforewhyshouldonewhohasfoundtheEastsofavorablereturntotheWest?”Source:ChroniclesofFulcherofChartres,1127,onlifeintheCrusaderStatesaftertheFirstCrusade

Page 9: The Rhineland Massacres - WordPress.com...Source: Anna Komnene, Byzantine Historian and Daughter of Emperor Alexius I The Seige of Jerusalem The siege of Jerusalem was a tremendous

ReactionfromtheMuslimWorldHowever,MuslimswhohadbeenexpelledfromtheirhomesbyCrusadersbegancallingontheleadersofnearbyMuslimlandstofightbackagainsttheseEuropeaninvaderswhohadkilledtheirbrothersinfaith.EvenpoetsfromMuslimlandsfarfromanyCrusaderviolencesuchasIraqurgedtheirpeopletotakeuparmsandtraveltotheHolyLandtodefendtheirbrothersfromtheinvadingFranks.“...SonsofIslam,behindyouarebattlesinwhichheadsrolledatyourfeet.Dareyouslumber(sleep)intheblessedshadeofsafety,wherelifeissoftasanorchardflower?Howcantheeyesleepbetweenthelidsatatimeofdisastersthatwouldwakenanysleeper?WhileyourSyrianbrotherscanonlysleeponthebacksoftheir[horses]orinvultures'bellies!...”

Source:AbualMusaffaralAbiwardi:IraqiMuslimpoetoftheeleventhandtwelfthcenturies.