the problems of understanding of maidans as a historical process in ukraine in context of...

55
The Problem of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe The International Conference "Revolutions, maidans and protests in contemporary Ukraine. The current state of research and future directions“ 20 June 2016 at the Natolin campus of the College of Europe in Warsaw

Upload: nataliya-zubar

Post on 08-Jan-2017

163 views

Category:

Government & Nonprofit


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

The Problem of Understanding of Maidans

as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist

Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

The International Conference "Revolutions, maidans and protests in contemporary Ukraine. The current state of research and future

directions“20 June 2016 at the Natolin campus of the College of Europe in Warsaw

Page 2: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 3: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Revolution on GraniteRevolution on GraniteOctober 2-17, 1990 October 2-17, 1990

158 people on hunger strike158 people on hunger strike

@inception@inception

Page 4: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@inception@inception

Page 5: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 6: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@inception@inception

Page 7: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@inception@inception

Page 8: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 9: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #1@maidan #1

Page 10: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Ukraine without KuchmaUkraine without KuchmaDecember 15, 2000 - March 9, 2001December 15, 2000 - March 9, 2001

Biggest rally 10.000 peopleBiggest rally 10.000 people

Protest ended with clashes with the police.Term Maidan used for the first time

@maidan #1@maidan #1

Nataliya Zubar
President Kuchma served full term. Beheaded Gongadze’s body and later his head were found and the trial is still continuing.
Page 11: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #1@maidan #1

Page 12: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #1@maidan #1

Page 13: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@basics@basics

Nataliya Zubar
To break through the government’s information blockade, protest leaders decided to set up a website named Maidan. Site went live December 20 2000. Earliest snapshot in Internet Machine is dated Febuary 21 2001.
Page 14: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 15: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 16: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Orange RevolutionOrange RevolutionNovember 22, 2004 – January 23, 2005November 22, 2004 – January 23, 2005

Biggest rally 1.000.000 peopleBiggest rally 1.000.000 people

Non violent peaceful protestTerm Maidan introduced to Ukrainian language

@maidan #2@maidan #2

Nataliya Zubar
On the dawn of a cold November day, the tent camp was set up and an occupation strike started to protest the falsified results of President’s Election. The Orange Revolution introduced the protest meaning of “Maidan” word into Ukrainian language.
Page 17: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Kyiv

@maidan #2@maidan #2

Nataliya Zubar
Maidans lasted for weeks in Kyiv and many other cities of Ukraine
Page 18: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Kharkiv

@maidan #2@maidan #2

Nataliya Zubar
including in Kharkiv - native city of presentation's author, second biggest city of Ukraine, the biggest in the east.
Page 19: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #2@maidan #2

Nataliya Zubar
NGOs played a vital role in maintaining the infrastructure of protests and fundraising.
Page 20: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 21: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

No Political CorruptionNo Political CorruptionJuly 2006 – March 2007July 2006 – March 2007

Biggest rally 10.000 peopleBiggest rally 10.000 people

Longest lasting protest action. Had no special name.

@maidan #3@maidan #3

Nataliya Zubar
After the Parliamentary Election Socialist Party left the democratic coalition, forming majority with the reactionary parties thus violating the promises to electors.
Page 22: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #3@maidan #3

Nataliya Zubar
Tent camp set up with major demand to the President to dismiss the Parliament and to announce new elections.
Page 23: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #3@maidan #3

Nataliya Zubar
After 9 months of protests, the President dismissed the Parliament.
Page 24: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 25: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Tax MaidanTax MaidanNovember 16 – December 3, 2010November 16 – December 3, 2010

Biggest rally 20.000 peopleBiggest rally 20.000 people

Maidan used for the first time in the protest name

@maidan #4@maidan #4

Nataliya Zubar
Government introduced draft of Tax Code, which could destroy small business in Ukraine.
Page 26: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #4@maidan #4

Nataliya Zubar
Tent camp was set up with demand to veto the Code.
Page 27: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #4@maidan #4

Nataliya Zubar
Protests lasted country wide until government complied with demands partially. The central slogan says "Revolution will be".
Page 28: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 29: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Language MaidanLanguage MaidanJuly 3 – August 8, 2012July 3 – August 8, 2012

Biggest rally 10.000 peopleBiggest rally 10.000 people

@maidan #5@maidan #5

Nataliya Zubar
Parliament passed the “Language Law” perceived as a threat to Ukrainian language.
Page 30: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #5@maidan #5

Nataliya Zubar
Citizens demanded to recall the law. Slogan says "No (Ukrainian) language - country is a prison"
Page 31: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #5@maidan #5

Nataliya Zubar
An occupation strike started in Kyiv and other towns of Ukraine. Photo from Kharkiv
Page 32: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #5@maidan #5

Nataliya Zubar
Protest was not successful. It was dismissed with brute police force.
Page 33: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 34: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

EuroMaidanEuroMaidanNovember 21, 2013 – February 22, 2014November 21, 2013 – February 22, 2014

Biggest rally 2.000.000 people (counted by BBC)Biggest rally 2.000.000 people (counted by BBC)

107 people killed by the police

@maidan #6@maidan #6

Nataliya Zubar
The Euromaidan or Revolution of Dignity started as protest against the attempt to cancel the process of integration of Ukraine into the European Union. The key of its success is the continuity of protest traditions and the lessons the Ukrainian civic society has learned from every previous success and failure and repression.
Page 35: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #6@maidan #6

Nataliya Zubar
Euromaidan is a real anti-imperialist revolution which confirmed the civilizational choice of Ukraine as European country.
Page 36: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

@maidan #6@maidan #6

Nataliya Zubar
Euromaidan was joint action of civic society and politicians. However, this time civic society became the major driver forcing politicians to act, when they tried to avoid actions.
Page 37: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Kharkiv@maidan #6@maidan #6

Nataliya Zubar
Euromaidan protests were country wide
Page 38: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Human Rights Above All

@maidan #6@maidan #6

Nataliya Zubar
"Human Rights Above All" because one of major slogans of the revolution.
Page 39: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

What triggers Maidans? What triggers Maidans? Violence Violence that is perceived as excessive and non-legitimate.

Page 40: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 41: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

TV anchor of Russian Infowar

Ukrainian TV, 2000-2004

Russian TV, now

Page 42: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 43: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Russian message for Ukrainians

Page 44: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Ukrainian response

Page 45: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 46: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

War of symbols, 2013

Page 47: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Vitaliy Ovcharenko © 2015

Page 48: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Ilia Repin © 1891

Page 49: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 50: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

22.02.2014, Yanokovych fled, Kharkiv

Page 51: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 52: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Donbas – Russia or Not Russia?

Page 53: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe
Page 54: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Major ProblemsMajor Problems•Memento effect, short memory•People record emotions not factsPeople record emotions not facts•History is written by the poor quality media,History is written by the poor quality media,not participants or historiansnot participants or historians•Russia still fabricates alternative historyRussia still fabricates alternative history

Page 55: The Problems of Understanding of Maidans as a Historical Process in Ukraine in Context of Post-Communist Systemic Transformations in Eastern Europe

Nataliya ZubarNataliya ZubarMaidan Monitoring Information Center, Chair

Kharkiv, UkraineEmail: [email protected]

Phone: +38 068 550 6687

Twitter: @nataliezubar

@contact@contact

Nataliya Zubar
Author was an observer of Revolution on Granite and participant of all next Maidans.