the portuguese policy toward the imf manuel da fonseca soares the current situation the portuguese...
TRANSCRIPT
The Portuguese Policy toward the IMFManuel da Fonseca Soares
The Current Situation
The Portuguese Foreign Policy
Agenda
Policy Recommendation
s
The Current Situation at the IMF
• Italian director represents Portugal in the Board of Directors
• Other members:• Albania
• Greece
• Malta
• San Marino
• Timor-Leste (the only non-European)
• Portugal as 2nd largest stakeholder within its group, after Italy
• Lack of cultural, economical and political ties with these
actors. Especially in comparison to other European partners
and Portuguese speaking countries worldwide.
The Portuguese Foreign Policy AgendaPriority #1 – Successful candidacy to the UNSecurity Council for 2011-2012
▫ 2 seats in dispute▫ 2 competitors – Germany and Canada
Portuguese Odds – need for pragmatic evaluation of its limitations
• UNSC elections characterized by a barter system• Portuguese ODA figures dwarf those of Canada and Germany• Canada and Germany both have directors at the IMF Board
• Germany as the 3rd largest stakehodler at the IMF• Canada uses constituency – multilateral commitment mechanism
• Major powers do not reveal their voting orientations
One state, one vote – all votes count. Majority in WEOG + 2/3 of UNGA
The Portuguese Foreign Policy Agenda
• Portugal disburses mere 4.4 % of Germany’s and 12% of Canadian ODA
• Clear steping up of ODA figures ahead of the UNSC election
Source – OECD-DAC – Development Co-Operation Directorate
Policy Options• Free riding the system
▫ Abstention from the developments in the international system▫ Increased susceptibility to crises
• Bridging developing and developed world▫ Portugal as a recently industrialized country▫ Residual bargaining power compared to that of Germany and
Canada
• Proposal for group re-alignment at the IMF▫ Brazil at the top. Portuguese-speaking + members of Brazil’s group▫ Re-enactment of historical linkages with South Atlantic
• Objectives:▫ Foster attitudinal changes about Portugal’s character▫ Solidarity towards calls for IFI reform in the developing world▫ Signaling commitment to the developing world. G77 IS 2/3 of the
UN
All votes count – US vote equals that of Palau