the muse view on the dynamics of gcs - cosmic-lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar...

29
The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs Sebastian Kamann (IAG) T.-O. Husser, B. Giesers, S. Dreizler (IAG), D. Krajnović, M. M. Roth, P. Weilbacher, M. Wendt, L. Wisotzki (Potsdam), E. Emsellem (ESO), J. Brinchmann (Leiden), R. Bacon (Lyon)

Upload: ngodan

Post on 25-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs

Sebastian Kamann (IAG)T.-O. Husser, B. Giesers, S. Dreizler (IAG),D. Krajnović, M. M. Roth, P. Weilbacher, M. Wendt, L. Wisotzki (Potsdam), E. Emsellem (ESO), J. Brinchmann (Leiden), R. Bacon (Lyon)

Page 2: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

22016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Why integral-field spectroscopy?

“traditional” spectroscopyneeds isolated starsfew targets in centre of GConly brightest giants

centre of M13 (seeing ~0.7”)

Page 3: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

32016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Why integral-field spectroscopy?

“traditional” spectroscopyneeds isolated starsfew targets in centre of GConly brightest giants

integral-field spectroscopyspatial information preservedanalysis similar to imagesdeblend sources

centre of M13 (seeing ~0.7”)

Page 4: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

42016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

PampelMuse

PSF-based extraction for integral-field data (Kamann+13)example for NGC 6397:

Page 5: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

52016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

An example: Looking for an IMBH in M92

seeing-limited IFU observations with PMAS~80 stellar spectra extracted

central dispersion from individual velocities: MBH < 10³ Msun

HST PMAS

Kamann+14

Page 6: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

62016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

An example: Looking for an IMBH in M92

uncovering the integrated lightresolved stars along red giant branchknow positions & PSF

HST PMAS

Page 7: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

72016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

An example: Looking for an IMBH in M92

uncovering the integrated lightresolved stars along red giant branchknow positions & PSF → subtract them

HST PMAS

Page 8: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

82016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

An example: Looking for an IMBH in M92

uncovering the integrated lightresolved stars along red giant branchknow positions & PSF → subtract them

use resolved & unresolved stars : MBH < 7x10² Msun

HST PMAS

Page 9: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

92016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

MUSE in a nutshell

commissioned 2014 at the VLT

panoramic IFScombination of 24 IFUs1'x1' FoV with 0.2” samplingλ ~ 4800Å – 9300Å

R ~ 1770 – 3590

“point and shoot”very stablehigh throughputexcellent optical quality

Page 10: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

102016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Why MUSE?

>2 nights of PMAS: <5 hours of MUSE:

Page 11: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

112016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Why MUSE?

>2 nights of PMAS: <5 hours of MUSE:

Page 12: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

122016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

A large MUSE survey

ongoing observations of ~25 clusters with MUSE

aim: ~10000 stars per cluster, multi-epoch observations

science cases:binary fractions and periodsintermediate-mass black holesstellar parameter analysesserendipitous discoveries

currently: ~1000 exposures 30 TB of data

NGC 6441

Page 13: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

132016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Legacy value of blind spectroscopy

example: Planetary nebula in NGC 6441

Page 14: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

142016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Legacy value of blind spectroscopy

example: Planetary nebula in NGC 6441

Page 15: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

152016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Our testbed: NGC 6397

nearby GCmoderate masscentral dispersion ~5 km/s[Fe/H] = -2

Page 16: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

162016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Our testbed: NGC 6397

nearby GCmoderate masscentral dispersion ~5 km/s[Fe/H] = -2

19000 spectra / 12000 stars(could be even more ...)10500 spectra with S/N>10(almost) complete CMD

And

erso

n et

al.

(200

8)

Page 17: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

192016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Velocity dispersion profile of NGC 6397

remember: σ~5 km/s challenging for kinematics!

at large radi:good agreement between MUSE and HR studies

at small radii:MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

Page 18: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

202016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Velocity dispersion profile of NGC 6397

remember: σ~5 km/s challenging for kinematics!

at large radi:good agreement between MUSE and HR studies

at small radii:MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

kinematics as function of stellar mass

Page 19: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

212016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Possibility for 2D kinematics

Rotation Dispersion

Page 20: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

222016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Jeans models for NGC 6397

IMBH central excess of remnants

isotropic models using JAM code (Cappellari+08)central dispersion underestimated with constant M/Lexcess mass of 600 Msun

two explanations:

Page 21: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

242016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

The other clusters

analysis of full sample currently in progresssome impressions:

NGC 3201

Page 22: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

252016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

The other clusters

analysis of full sample currently in progresssome impressions:

NGC 3201NGC 7089

Page 23: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

262016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

The other clusters

analysis of full sample currently in progresssome impressions:

NGC 3201NGC 7089NGC 2808

Page 24: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

272016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

The other clusters

analysis of full sample currently in progresssome impressions:

NGC 3201NGC 7089NGC 2808

Page 25: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

282016/03/22Massive multiplex MUSE spectroscopy in globular clusters S. Kamann (IAG)

Searching for binaries with MUSE

dedicated multi-epoch strategysearch for RV Variables

complementary to photometryBSSs, neutron stars, ...

example: NGC 3201~3200 stars with S/N > 105 epochs of data

analysis: Benjamin Giesers

Page 26: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

292016/03/22Massive multiplex MUSE spectroscopy in globular clusters S. Kamann (IAG)

The binary fraction in NGC 3201

very consistent results from all epochs:

ultimate goal is to get binary periodsstill more epochs needed

(9.1 ± 1.4) %

Page 27: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

302016/03/22Massive multiplex MUSE spectroscopy in globular clusters S. Kamann (IAG)

The binary fraction in NGC 3201

very consistent results from all epochs:

ultimate goal is to get binary periodsstill more epochs needed

(9.1 ± 1.4) %

Δt [days]

v_ra

d [k

m/ s

]

Page 28: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

312016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Blind spectroscopy: BSSs in M30

Ferraro et al. (2010) MUSE RV variability

Page 29: The MUSE view on the dynamics of GCs - Cosmic-Lab · intermediate-mass black holes stellar parameter analyses serendipitous discoveries ... MUSE can probe much closer to the centre

322016/04/21MODEST 2016 - Sebastian Kamann (IAG)

Conclusions

Crowded field 3D spectroscopy is a powerful tool to investigate globular cluster dynamics.

MUSE is great!spectroscopy with unprecedented sample sizes blind spectroscopy → wide unexplored spaceMUSE+AO is coming soon