the machine is (changing) us: youtube culture and the politics of authenticity
DESCRIPTION
presented at the Personal Democracy Forum 2009. The real presentation also includes 15 minutes of mashed up YouTube videos - basically a shortened but updated version of An Anthropological Introduction to YouTube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPAO-lZ4_hUTRANSCRIPT
by by Michael WeschMichael Wesch Kansas State University Kansas State University
mediatedcultures.netmediatedcultures.net
1984 A.D.
Media Ecology
Media are not just tools.
Media are not just means of communication.
Media mediate our conversations
Media change
Media our conversations change change
“We shape our tools,and thereafter our tools shape us.”
- Marshall McLuhan
the conversationsthe conversationsof our cultureof our culturehappen herehappen here
the conversationsthe conversationsare controlled by feware controlled by few
the conversationsthe conversationsare controlled by feware controlled by few
and designedand designed for the masses for the masses
the conversationsthe conversationsare always entertainingare always entertaining
the conversationsthe conversationsare always entertainingare always entertaining(even the serious ones)(even the serious ones)
the conversationsthe conversationsare punctuated byare punctuated by
30 second commercials30 second commercials
the conversationsthe conversationscreate our culturecreate our culture
the conversationsthe conversationscreate our culturecreate our culture
of irrelevanceof irrelevanceincoherenceincoherence
and impotenceand impotence
“What steps do you plan to take to reduce the conflict in the
Middle East?”
“Or the rates of inflation,crime, or unemployment?”
“What do you plan to do aboutNATO, OPEC, the CIA, etc.?”
“I shall take the liberty of answering for you: ...
“You plan to do nothing.”
“You plan to do nothing.”
- Neil Postman 1984
“The public has adjusted to incoherence and been amused into indifference.”
- Neil Postman 1984
25 years later ...
“What we are encountering is a panicky, an almost hysterical, attempt to escape from the deadly anonymity of modern life ... and the prime cause is not vanity ... but the craving of people who feel their personality sinking lower and lower into the whirl of indistinguishable atoms to be lost in a mass civilization."
“What we are encountering is a panicky, an almost hysterical, attempt to escape from the deadly anonymity of modern life ... and the prime cause is not vanity ... but the craving of people who feel their personality sinking lower and lower into the whirl of indistinguishable atoms to be lost in a mass civilization."
- Henry Seidel Canby 1926
Assembly line
It's a one-wayIt's a one-wayconversationconversation
You have to be on TVYou have to be on TVto have a voiceto have a voice
You have to be on TVYou have to be on TVto be significantto be significant
The MTV GenerationShort attention spansMaterialisticNarcissisticNot easily impressed
“in the midst of a fabulous array of historically unprecedented and utterly mind-boggling stimuli ...
“in the midst of a fabulous array of historically unprecedented and utterly mind-boggling stimuli ...
whatever.”
“in the midst of a fabulous array of historically unprecedented and utterly mind-boggling stimuli ...
whatever.”
- Thomas de Zengotita
A brief history of “Whatever”
pre-1960s: "Whatever. That's what I meant." Late 60s: "I don't care. Whatever." 1990s: MTV Generation – the indifferent "Meh."
“I find it hard.It's hard to find,
oh well, whatever,nevermind.”
“I feel stupid,and contagious.Here we are now.
Entertain us.”
flattering
A brief history of “Whatever”
pre-1960s: "Whatever. That's what I meant." Late 60s: "I don't care. Whatever." 1990s: MTV Generation – the indifferent "Meh."
A brief history of “Whatever”
pre-1960s: "Whatever. That's what I meant." Late 60s: "I don't care. Whatever." 1990s: MTV Generation – the indifferent "Meh." Late 90s - present: "Whatever. I'll do what I want."
the search for identity and recognitionthe search for identity and recognition
the search for the authentic selfthe search for the authentic self
the search for the authentic selfthe search for the authentic self
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides:Two Slides:
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment” 2. “negation of all horizons of significance”2. “negation of all horizons of significance”
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment” disengagementdisengagement 2. “negation of all horizons of significance”2. “negation of all horizons of significance”
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment” disengagement disengagement 2. “negation of all horizons of significance”2. “negation of all horizons of significance” fragmentationfragmentation
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
Two Slides: Two Slides: towards ...towards ...
1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment”1. “self-centered modes of self-fulfilment” disengagement disengagement 2. “negation of all horizons of significance”2. “negation of all horizons of significance” fragmentationfragmentation special interest sound bite politics special interest sound bite politics
Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)Charles Taylor's “Ethics of Authenticity” (1991)
If the conversations of our cultureIf the conversations of our culturenow happen here ...now happen here ...
Why this matters ...Why this matters ...
not controlled by the few not controlled by the few not one-waynot one-way created by, for, and around networks, not massescreated by, for, and around networks, not masses transform individual pursuits into collective actiontransform individual pursuits into collective action makes “group” formation “ridiculously easy”makes “group” formation “ridiculously easy”
(Paquet/Shirky) (Paquet/Shirky)
Why this might Why this might deeplydeeply matter ... matter ...
We know ourselves We know ourselves through our relations with others. through our relations with others.
New media create new ways of relating to others.New media create new ways of relating to others. New media create new ways of knowing ourselves.New media create new ways of knowing ourselves.
1,728,000 minutes/day
Over 1,000x faster than you can watch
493,714 videos/day
493,714 videos/day(just on YouTube)
1,000,000+ online videos per day
over 99.9% irrelevant to you (estimated)
Who is on YouTube
(percentage of videos featuring people of different ages)
viewed by less than 1% of Americansviewed by less than 1% of Americans
60s: “I don't care. Whatever (you think).”60s: “I don't care. Whatever (you think).” 90s: “Whatever. (I don't care what you think).”90s: “Whatever. (I don't care what you think).” Future: “I care. Let's do whatever it takes ... by Future: “I care. Let's do whatever it takes ... by
whatever means necessary.” whatever means necessary.”
Toward a new future of “whatever”Toward a new future of “whatever”
by michael weschassistant professor of cultural anthropology
Kansas State University
more information, including videos viewed over 15 million times
and translated in over 15 languages ...
mediatedcultures.net