the international b corp and benefit corporation movement · the international b corp and benefit...
TRANSCRIPT
GLAMM 2015
The International B Corp And
Benefit Corporation
MovementDoing Well by Doing Good
Presented by
Jonathan S. Storper
Hanson Bridgett LLP
Globalaw Renewables & Cleantech Initiative
• A certification conferred by the
non-profit B Lab – operations
as a whole
• A company that meets a high
level of social and
environmental performance
AND makes a legal
commitment to consider all
stakeholders
• Any for-profit company in any
country can pursue
certification (LLC’s, LLP’s
included)
• Membership Dues
• A corporate form (taxed like a
C-corp or an S-corp) that has a
higher level of transparency,
accountability and purpose
• A legal entity that has
protection and permission to
consider its impact on all
stakeholders, not just
shareholders
• 30 states in the US and
counting
• Similar forms exist or being
considered in other countries
e.g. UK, CAN, Italy
B Corp International
Certification
United States
Benefit Corporation
How to Become a B Corp
Earn a verified score of 80
points on the B Impact
Assessment
Give the company permission to
consider all stakeholders.
Make a profile showing topline
performance on Bcorporation.net.
80+
To learn more, visit:
www.bcorporation.net/become-a-b-corp/how-to-become-a-b-corp
Show Leadership
Attract and Engage Talent
Save Money and Access Services
Partner with Peers
Benchmark Performance
Differentiate from Pretenders
Generate Press
Attract Investors
Membership Dues
Why Become a Certified B Corp
Attract and Engage Talent
“B Corps are 46% more likely to have satisfied and
engaged employees than ordinary businesses.”
B Analytics
“Employees who are satisfied in their jobs because
they believe in what they are doing have 16% better
overall performance and 125% less burnout than their
peers.” Harvard Business Review
“Almost two-thirds of millennials said they would rather
make $40,000 a year at a job they love than $100,000
a year at a job they think is boring.”
Forbes
• B Corp certification provides a platform to engage current staff and
give employees more meaning in their work
Global Movement>1414 B Corporations 42 Countries 130 Industries 1 Unifying Goal
https://www.bcorporation.net
In 2015, Brazil’s top cosmetics, fragrance and toiletries maker, Natura, became
the largest – and first publicly traded – company to attain B Corp sustainability
certification.
Consumer goods giant Unilever’s chief executive Paul Polman has stated that
becoming a B Corp would send a powerful signal that the purpose of business
is not just profit, but to have a positive impact on society and the environment.
The Guardian
Friday 23 January 2015
Examples
Benefit Corporations - Maintain Mission
• Bakes the values of the company
into its legal DNA
• Gives protection and permission to
consider non-financial stakeholders
(community, employees, suppliers,
environment)
• Ensures that mission can survive
over time
• Expanded purpose beyond
maximizing share value to explicitly
include general and specific public
benefit
• Directors must consider & balance
stated public benefit purpose and
non-financial stakeholder interests
when making decisions
• Requires report to owners and the
public on Company’s social and
environmental performance
What is Different About a Benefit Corporation?
For-profit company:
Legal Protection for Stated Values
• Safe harbor for directors for multi-stakeholder approach• Flexibility to prioritize among profits, environment and social
concerns
Exit Strategies and Succession Planning
• Stated values unchanged by sale of minority/majority of stock
• Greater flexibility to identify the "right" buyer and succession planning
10587122.1
Why Become a Benefit Corporation?
Misperceptions About Benefit Corporations
Benefit corporations are NOT
• Nonprofits
• Taxed differently
• Required to be audited or certified
• Subject to additional liability exposure from third parties
• Prevented from going public
Kickstarter decided to become a public benefit corporation because
“there’s a huge difference between a values document and the legal
foundation of your company,” said Mr. Chen, who serves as chairman.
NY Times
September 20, 2015
Patagonia has been a 40-year experiment in what it means to be
a responsible company, and becoming a B Corp has ensured
that our experiment will keep pushing forward.”
- Rose Marcario, Patagonia CEO
Mainstream venture capital firms have supported portfolio
companies’ election of benefit corporation status:
• Foundry Group, Founders Fund, Andreessen Horowitz,
Benchmark, Sherbrooke Capital, Toby Coppel and Hadi Partovi,
Freshtracks Capital, Bullet Time Ventures, Generation Equity
Investors, Ironwood Equity Fund, Lighter Capital and Golden
Seeds Capital, Collaborative Fund, Baseline Ventures
Benefit corporations have raised capital from mainstream venture
capital investors:
• River Hollow Partners, NEA, Forerunner Ventures, The Westly
Group, Claremont Creek Ventures, Prelude, Mindful Investors,
Lighter Capital, DBL Investors, Tim Drapper, CommonAngels
Ventures, Brand Foundry and Greycroft Partners, Learn Capital,
Bertelsmann
B Corps and Benefit Corporations are Raising
Venture Capital
Traditional, cleantech and social impact investors all reported
finding value in benefit corporation form:
• Westly Group
• Claremont Creek Ventures
• Prelude
• DBL
Raising capital as a benefit corporation:
Investor Perspective
Few changes to investment process were required:
• Minimal increase to legal due diligence
• Most did not require additional disclosure to limited partner investors
• Confirmed benefit corporation status not an obstacle to future
investment
“Westly Group's investment in yerdle was not hampered by their benefit corporation
status and did not greatly change our due diligence process. Instead, we viewed
their status as part of the founding team's vision and as a valuable tool that created
alignment between their core business model and the company's mission.” –Mike
Jackson, Westly Group
The Fortune 500 are supporting benefit
corporations
Founded in 2006, Plum Organics is the No. 1 brand
of organic baby food in US
• June 2013: Acquired by Campbell Soup Company
• Plum approached Campbell about converting to
benefit corporation status in time for DE effective
day 2 months later
• Campbell approved the transition so that Plum
could continue to balance profitability mission, an
important brand attribute consumers expect and
value. “There’s a lot more authenticity in the process today and there’s a lot more strategy
around long-term shareholder value. If you get in line with that, it’s not a scary proposition. Frankly, I kind of like being the only [publicly-held owner of a DE Public
Benefit Corporation] — it’s a great story for us to tell. But it’s a model that a lot of
others could follow.” - Dave Stangis, VP Corporate Affairs and Social Responsibility,
Campbell Soup Co
Corporate Social Responsibility (“CSR”)
B/Benefit Corporation - profitable/competitive
operations taking all stakeholders into account
- All operations
CSR – company’s sense of responsibility towards certain
aspects of the community or the environmental which
may be changed at any time if it hinders the organization
or is not honored by the public/customers
- “Save the Whales” project
- Use of renewable energy sources
Becoming a benefit corporation: Ello
• Raised $5.5M from Freshtracks Capital, Bullet Time Ventures,
Foundry Group and announced transition to PBC
• Transition promotes consumer trust and protects mission
Ello, is an anti-facebook social
networking site founded in 2013 by
the founder of KidRobot
• Concern from users that
manifesto and privacy would
disappear
"Signing the Ello charter was a no-
brainer for us as investors. We
believe in the mission, and the (b corp
status) further enforces the
manifesto...” – Bullet Time Ventures
"Benefit corporation creates
alignment between investors and
entrepreneurs around the mission
and focus of the business allowing
both parties to work together
successfully.” – Seth Levine, Foundry
Group
Becoming a benefit corporation: AltSchool
AltSchool operates a growing network of K-8 micro-
schools and improves access to quality schooling
for all children
• 2013: Incorporated in Delaware as a C Corp
• 2013: Raised $33 M Series A funding
• 2014: Received unanimous support to become a
public benefit corporation from its investors,
including Founders Fund and Andreessen
Horowitz
• 2015: Raised $100 M from Andreessen
Horowitz, Founders Fund, Learn Capital and
First Round Capital AltSchool’s benefit corporation legal status allows the team to think
beyond short-term profits and focus on fundamentally improving the
education system for many decades to come” – Founders Fund
Becoming a benefit corporation: Farmigo
• During financing, intent to become a benefit corporation was
clear
• Investors determined that director liability wouldn’t change
• Benefit corporations status did not pose an upfront obstacle
in investor discussions
Farmigo, founded in 2009, is
an online farmer’s market
• Raised $10M from
Benchmark, Sherbrooke
Capital, Toby Coppel and
Hadi Partovi
Raising capital as a benefit corporation:
Cotopaxi
Cotopaxi is a vertically-integrated outdoor gear
and apparel brand, with a social mission at its
core
• 2013: Incorporated as a PBC and started
fundraising
• No pushback from investors on corporate form
• Raised $3 M in seed funding NEA, Lerer
Hippeau Ventures, and Forerunner Ventures
• 2015: Raised 6.5M in Series A led by Greycroft Partners with
NEA, Lerer Hippeau Ventures, Forerunner Ventures and
Brand Foundry
Raising capital as a benefit corporation: Alliant
International University
Alliant International University is a private
university with more than 4,000 students
and ten campuses
• In 2015: Converted from non-profit to
benefit corporation
• At the same time, Bertelsmann’s subsidiary Arist Education
System, their VC fund, acquired a controlling interest
• Bertelsmann’s plans to make $564.7M in acquisitions
through Arist Education systems and all acquired universities
will be benefit corporations
Raising capital as a benefit corporation: Yerdle
• 2012: Incorporated as a benefit
corporation
• Raised capital from angel investors and
$1.7M in seed funding via capped
convertible note
Yerdle , founded in 2012, by former
executives at Walmart and Satchi & Satchi,
is an app for exchanging used goods
• Raised $5M from VC funds in series A financing round from The
Westly Group, Claremont Creek, Prelude, Mindful Investors
and DBL Investors
• Benefit corporations status did not pose an upfront obstacle in
early investor discussions
Jonathan S. Storper, Esq.
Jonathan is the co-chair of the legal working group which drafted
the benefit corporation legislation in California, and a partner at
the law firm of Hanson Bridgett LLP in San Francisco, California
where he chairs the firm’s corporate department. He was
selected as the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year for 2012
for his work on this legislation.
Hanson Bridgett LLP
425 Market Street, Suite 2600
San Francisco, California 94105
415-995-5040
Thank You
Questions?