the influence of the open government partnership (ogp) on the open data discussions

8/22/2019 The Influence of the Open Government Partnership (OGP) on the Open Data Discussions

1/23

ePSIplatform Topic Report No. 2013 / 10 , October 2013

1

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

:)1+.#4& 3);(%* #.+1, ?+@ ABCD E CB

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&,

341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#& 84,4

9%5*)55%+&5

F),"+15G H+I94& J4&+(#4K L#1+&%*4 M1#,)

3);(%5"#9G-*,+;#1 ABCD


2/23


2

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

!4;(# +' M+&,#&,5 @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@ AN#OP+195G @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@ DF;5,14*,E :Q#*),%0#


3/23


3

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

-%./'01,2

-.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%.K -.#& 84,4K /+0#1&2#&,K .+(%*OK *%0%( 5+*%#,OK J+(9+04K >+24&%4

3#,+0"4+5 67%48+9:% ;8+24&%47 ,+ (++U 2+1#

%& 9#,4%( +& "+P 9%9 ,"# -/3 .1+*#55 %&'()#&*#9 ,"# &4,%+&4( +.#& 94,4 .+(%*%#5@


4/23


4

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

= >?"+ 9, @A%* B':%0*


5/23


5

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

F(( I+0#1&2#&,5 ,"4, "40# 5);2%,,#9 4 (#,,#1 +' %&,#&,K *+22%,,#9 ,+ 4;%9# ;O -/3 .1%&*%.(#5

4&9 .1+*#55#5 ;O #&9+15%&I ,"# -/3 8#*(414,%+&K 4&9 %&%,%4,#9 ,"# .1+*#55 +' 9#0#(+.%&I

*+&*1#,# 4*,%+& .(4&5 41# *+&5%9#1#9 .41,%*%.4,%&I I+0#1&2#&,5 %& -/3 4&9 (%5,#9 +& ,"# -/3

P#;5%,#@

-/3 .41,%*%.4,%&I I+0#1&2#&,5 *+22%, ,+ 2##,%&I '%0# *+22+& #Q.#*,4,%+&5K 4&9 ,"#O 41#G

:&9+15# ,"# "%I"Z(#0#( -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 8#*(414,%+&c

J4U# *+&*1#,# *+22%,2#&,5K 45 .41, +' 4 *+)&,1O 4*,%+& .(4&K ,"4, 41# 42;%,%+)5 4&9

I+ ;#O+&9 4 *+)&,1Ob5 *)11#&, .14*,%*#c

8#0#(+. *+)&,1O 4*,%+& .(4&5 ,"1+)I" 4 2)(,%Z5,4U#"+(9#1 .1+*#55K P%," ,"# 4*,%0#

#&I4I#2#&, +' *%,%[#&5 4&9 *%0%( 5+*%#,Oc M+22%, ,+ 4 5#('Z455#552#&, 4&9 %&9#.#&9#&, 1#.+1,%&I +& ,"# *+)&,1Ob5 .1+I1#55c 4&9

M+&,1%;),# ,+ ,"# 4904&*#2#&, +' +.#& I+0#1&2#&, %& +,"#1 *+)&,1%#5 ,"1+)I" 5"41%&I

+' ;#5, .14*,%*#5K #Q.#1,%5#K ,#*"&%*4( 455%5,4&*#K ,#*"&+(+I%#5 4&9 1#5+)1*#5K 45

4..1+.1%4,#@

!")5K ;O Y+%&%&I ,"# -/3 4&9 #&9+15%&I ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 8#*(414,%+&K /+0#1&2#&,5 41#

')((O 1#5.+&5%;(# 4&9 *+22%,,#9 ,+G

31+2+,# +.#&7K ;#*4)5# 2+1# %&'+124,%+& 4;+), I+0#1&2#&,4( 4*,%0%,%#5 5"+)(9 ;#

,%2#(O 4&9 '1##(O 404%(4;(# ,+ .#+.(#c

:&I4I# *%,%[#&5 %& 9#*%5%+&Z24U%&IK ;#*4)5# ,"%5 24U#5 I+0#1&2#&, 2+1# %&&+04,%0#

4&9 1#5.+&5%0#c

=2.(#2#&, ,"# "%I"#5, 5,4&94195 +' .1+'#55%+&4( %&,#I1%,OK ;#*4)5# ,"+5# %& .+P#1 2)5,

5#10# ,"# .#+.(# 4&9 &+, ,"#25#(0#5c 4&9

=&*1#45# 4**#55 ,+ P ,#*"&+(+I%#5 ;#*4)5# +' ,"#%1 )&.1#*#9#&,#9 .+,#&,%4( ,+ "#(.

.#+.(# 1#4(%[# ,"#%1 45.%14,%+&5 '+1 4**#55 ,+ %&'+124,%+& 4&9 4 2+1# .+P#1')( 0+%*# %&

"+P ,"#O 41# I+0#1@

=& 499%,%+& ,+ .41,%*%.4,%&I I+0#1&2#&,5K *%0%( 5+*%#,O +1I4&%[4,%+&5 *4& *+&,1%;),# ,+ -/3 0%4

1)&&%&I '+1 2#2;#15"%. +' ,"#


6/23


6

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

.41, %& 9#0#(+.%&IK 2+&%,+1%&IK 4&9 5)..+1,%&I ,"# %2.(#2#&,4,%+& +' *+)&,1O 4*,%+& .(4&5K ;+,"

,"1+)I" .41,%*%.4,%+& %& 9+2#5,%* .);(%* *+&5)(,4,%+&5 4&9 2)(,%Z5,4U#"+(9#1 '+1)25K 45 P#(( 45

,"1+)I" ,"# .1+0%5%+& +' ,#*"&%*4( #Q.#1,%5#@ >#.1#5#&,4,%0#5 '1+2 1#(#04&, %&,#1&4,%+&4(

+1I4&%[4,%+&5 4&9 %&,#1I+0#1&2#&,4( ;+9%#5 24O 4(5+ ;# %&0%,#9 ;O ,"# -/3 JK +1 %5 ,4U%&I

4*,%+&5 ,"4, )&9#12% ,"# 04()#5 4&9 .1%&*%.(#5 +' -/3K .41,%*%.4,%+& +' ,"4, I+0#1&2#&, %&

-/3 %5 I+%&I ,+ ;# 4991#55#9 ;O ;+," ,"# M1%,#1%4 4&9 +24&%4K J+(9+04K \U14%K


7/23


7

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

M+"+1, T +' *+)&,1%#5 %5 #Q.#*,#9 ,+ Y+%&%&I %& F.1%( ABCT 642+&I P"%*"


8/23


8

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

=EI@A%* B':%0*


9/23


9

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

k+.#& I+0#1&2#&,k P45 4 ;49 *"+%*#@ =, "45 I#,#9 ,++ 2)*" *+&')5%+&@ J4&O .#+.(#K #0#&

%& ,"# R"%,# `+)5#K 5,%(( 455)2# ,"4, +.#& I+0#1&2#&, 2#4&5 ,14&5.41#&*O 4;+), I+0#1&2#&,^@

=&5,#49 5"# .+%&,5 +), ,"4, ]P#1# #1 #Q*()5%0#(O 4;+), 24U%&I ,14&5.41#&, %&'+124,%+& 4;+),

,"# P+1U%&I5 +' I+0#1&2#&,^ 4&9 5"+)(9 ;# %&5,#49 4;+), 4 5"+1,"4&9 '+1 +.#& %&&+04,%+& +1

,"# %9#4 ,"4, P+1U%&I %& 4 ,14&5.41#&,K .41,%*%.4,+1OK 4&9 *+((4;+14,%0# '45"%+& "#(.5 %2.1+0#

.#1'+124&*#K %&'+12 9#*%5%+& 24U%&IK #&*+)14I# #&,1#.1#)15"%.K 4&9 5+(0# .1+;(#25 2+1#

#''#*,%0#(O@^

F 1#.+1, '1+2 ,"# g4,%& F2#1%*4 1#I%+&5CB

5"+P5 ,"# 542# )&*(41%,O %& ,"# -/3 .1+*#55 4;+),

P"4, +.#& I+0#1&2#&, %5 4&9 %,5 1#(4,%+&5"%. P%," +.#& 94,4@ !")5 ,"# +1I4&%[4,%+&5 "40# ,1%#9

,+ ;# #Q.(4% ,"# U#OP+195G ]+.#& I+0#1&2#&, %5 4 ,++( ,+ *+&,1%;),# ,+ ,14&5.41#&*O 4&9

4**+)&,4;%(%,OK ;), %, 9+#5 &+ 5);5,%,),# ,"# 1%I", ,+ %&'+124,%+& %& 4&O 5"4.# +1 '+12c +.#& 94,4

5#10#5 45 4& %&5,1)2#&, ,+ ,"+5# 1%I",5@ !"# ,P+1U5 *+% ,"# '+((+P%&I '+12)(4 ,+I#,"#1 e

-.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. j F**#55 ,+ %&'+124,%+& 45 4 1%I", l !14&5.41#&*O 4&9

4**+)&,4;%(%,O 45 4 .);(%* .+(%*O l -.#& 94,4 45 4& %&5,1)2#&,@^

F(5+ ,"# ?/- /(+;4( =&,#I1%,O .+%&,5 +),CC

,"4, ]4 5%[#4;(# &)2;#1 +' F*,%+& 3(4&5 %&*()9#9 4,

(#45, + *+22%,2#&, ,"4, P# *(455%'%#9 45 ;#%&I +),5%9# +' ,"# 5*+.# +' i+.#& I+0#1&2#&,@i ^

-,"#1 .#+.(# 4(5+ _)#5,%+& ,"# '4*, ,"4, ,"# +.#& 94,4 2+0#2#&, %5 5)*" 4 I1#4, %9#4 '+1 -/3@

?4,"4&%#( `#((#1 '1+2 /(+;4( =&,#I1%,O #Q.(4%&5CA ,"# *+&*#1&G ]6@@@7 +.#& 94,4 .1+0%9#5 4& #45O

P4O +), '+1 5+2# I+0#1&2#&,5 ,+ 40+%9 ,"# 2)*" "419#1K 4&9 (%U#(O 2+1# ,14&5'+124,%0#K +.#&

I+0#1&2#&, 1#'+125 ,"4, 5"+)(9 .1+;4;(O ;# "%I"#1 ). +& ,"#%1 (%5,5@ =&5,#49 +' '#,%5"%[%&I +.#&

94,4 .+1,4(5 '+1 ,"# 54U# +' "40%&I +.#& 94,4 .+1,4(5K =b9 14,"#1 5## I+0#1&2#&,5 %&*+1.+14,%&I

+.#& 94,4 45 4 P4O ,+ 4991#55 2+1# ')&942#&,4( 5,1)*,)14( *"4((#&I#5 41+)&9 #Q,14*,%0#5

6,"1+)I" 24.5 4&9 ;)9I#, 94,47K ,"# .+(%,%*4( .1+*#55 6,"1+)I" 1#4(Z,%2# 9%5*(+5)1# +' *42.4%I&

*+&,1%;),%+&57K +1 ;)9I#, .1%+1%,%#5 6,"1+)I" +&(% .);(%*4,%+& +' ;)9I#, (%Z%,#257@^

!"%5 %5 5)..+1,#9 4(5+ ;O ,"# *+22%,2#&,5 249# ;O ,"# 5%I&4,+1%#5 *+)&,1%#5@ F& %&,#1#5,%&I

10#I%+&4( m !14&5.41#&*%4 =&,#1&4*%+&4( 6RH= R+19 H4&U

=&5,%,),#7 e 34I# VK 404%(4;(# 4, ",,.GEEPPP@5*1%;9@*+2E9+*ECddCDDABCE/++9Z314*,%*#5Z%&Z-/3Z

?#,P+1U5ZF(%4&[4Z>#I%+&4(Z!14&5.41#&*%4Z=&,#1&4*%+&4(ZRH=ZR+19ZH4&UZ=&5,%,),#CC


10/23


10

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

4&4(O5%5CD

249# ;O 3);(%* =&,#I1%,O %& ABCA +& +0#1 TB M+)&,1O F*,%+&5 3(4&5 5"+P5 ,"4, +0#1 CXB

*+22%,2#&,5 P#1# 4*,)4((O 249# %& ,"# '%#(9 +' -.#& 84,4K P"%*" P45 + +' ,"# 2+5, .+.)(41

*4,#I+1O +' *+22%,2#&,5K ,+I#,"#1 P%," ,"# ]:Z/+0#1&2#&,^ *+)(9 ,+ 4(2+5, 4 ,"%19 +' 4(( +.#&

I+0#1&2#&, 4*,%0%,%#5G

"#$$%&$'(& )*&%+%&, -#*./ )0'1 "#.(&

:ZI+0#1&2#&, CXX

-.#& 84,4 CXB

M%,%[#& :&I4I#2#&, CDC

F**#55 ,+ =&'+124,%+&E f1##9+2 +' =&'+124,%+& XD

H)9I#,5 m f%&4&*%4( 3(4&&%&I hX


11/23


11

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

I 67"#.+1,%&I J#*"4&%52@ !"#

'%15, 1#.+1,5CW

*+&9)*,#9 %& ,"# #%I", '+)&9%&I *+)&,1%#5 +' ,"# .41,"%. 9)1%&I ,"# .45,

2+&,"5 9+ %(()5,14,# ,"%5 .1+*#55 0#1O P#((@ f+1 #Q42.(# +' ,"# :)1+.#4& '+)&9%&I *+)&,1%#5 +'

,"# -/3K \N "45 ;##& 5+ '41 ,"# 2+5, 4*,%0# %& -.#& 84,4@ F(5+K 5"49+P *%0%( 5+*%#,O 1#.+1,5Cd

+1

+,"#1 5,)9%#5 "40# 4(5+ "%I"(%I",#9 ,"# -/3 .1+*#55#5 %& ,"# +,"#1 .41,5 +' ,"# P+1(9@Ch

R# "40# 9#*%9#9 '+1 ,"# .)1.+5# +' ,"%5 41,%*(# ,+ '+*)5 ,P+ *+)&,1%#5 %& :)1+.#K P"#1# ,"#

4),"+15 "40# ;##& %&0+(0#9 %& ,"# +.#& 94,4 .+(%*%#5 .1+*#55K %& +19#1 ,+ "%I"(%I", 5+2# +' ,"#

.41,%*)(41%,%#5 +' ,"#5# .1+*#55#5 %& ,"# &4,%+&4( *+&,#Q,@

J+(9+04K #0#& %' %, %5 +),5%9# ,"# :)1+.#4& \&%+&K 5##25 2+1# 4904&*#9 +& ,"# +.#& 94,4

.+(%*%#5 4&9 )5#9 ,"# -/3 .1+*#55 45 4 P4O ,+ *+&5+(%94,# ,"#%1 *)11#&, +.#& 94,4 5,14,#IOK

P"#1#45 >+24&%4K #0#& ,"+)I" %, %5 %& ,"# :\ 5%&*# ABBhK "40# )5#9 ,"# -/3 .1+*#55 ,+ ;1%&I

,"# +.#& 94,4 .+(%*O +& ,"# /+0#1&2#&,i5 ,4;(#@

IE=K'$1':"H4*U %& ABCBK ,"# /+0#1&2#&, +' J+(9+04 #&9+15#9 4& 42;%,%+)5 ]J+(9+04 /+0#1&4&*# :Z

,14&5'+124,%+& 31+Y#*,^ 4&9 ,")5K *+22%,,%&I ,+ ;#,,#1 5#10%&I %,5 *%,%[#&5@ !"%5 .1+Y#*, 4%25 ,+

;)%(9 (#49#15"%. *4.4*%,O %& ,"# )5# +' =M!5K 2+9#1&%[# 4&9 %2.1+0# .);(%* 5#*,+1 I+0#1&4&*# %&

J+(9+04K ;++5, ,"# *+)&,1Oi5 *+2.#,%,%0#7K *1#4,# 4 2+1# 4,,14*,%0# %&0#5,2#&, *(%24,# 4&9

,+ %&*1#45# ,14&5.41#&*O 4&9 4**+)&,4;%(%,O ;O I%0%&I *%,%[#&5 4 0+%*# %& .);(%* 24,,#15 ;O

+.#&%&I I+0#1&2#&, 94,4@

CWF04%(4;(# 4, ",,.GEEPPP@+.#&I+0.41,"%.@+1IE%&9#.#&9#&,Z1#.+1,%&IZ2#*"4&%52

Cd#I%+&4( m !14&5.41#&*%4 =&,#1&4*%+&4( 6RH=

R+19 H4&U =&5,%,),#7 e *%,#9 4;+0#


12/23


12

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

=2.(#2#&,4,%+& +' ,"%5 %&%,%4,%0# %5 .+55%;(# 9)# ,+ ,#*"&%*4( 4&9 '%&4&*%4( 5)..+1, '1+2 ,"#

R+1(9 H4&U@

-.#& /+0#1&2#&, 84,4 %&%,%4,%0# %5 + +' ,"# U#O .%((415 +' ,"# ]/+0#1&4&*# :Z,14&5'+124,%+&^

4I#&94 4&9 P45 (4)&*"#9 %& F.1%( ABCCK ,")5K J+(9+04 ;#*+2%&I ,"# Ch,"

*+)&,1O ,+ Y+%& ,"#

/(+;4( -.#& 84,4 =&%,%4,%0#@ F5 .41, +' ,"%5 .%((41K ,"# /+0#1&2#&, (4)&*"#9 4& -.#& 84,4 .+1,4(

e 4 5%&I(# .(4,'+12 '+1 4**#55%&I I+0#1&2#&, 94,4 %& J+(9+04 Z PPP@94,#@I+0@29@ %I", 4',#1 ,"# /+0#1&2#&, "49 4..1+0#9 %,5 -.#& /+0#1&2#&, F*,%+& 3(4& '+1 ABCAZABCD +&

F.1%( TK ABCAK 4& ]-.#& =&&+04,%+& R##U^ 9#9%*4,#9 ,+ -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 1#(4,#9 %&%,%4,%0#5


13/23


13

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

'+((+P#9 %& J4O +' ABCA@ 8)1%&I ,"4, P##U #0#&,5 5)*" 45 84,4 n+)1&4(%52 H++, M42.K 3);(%*

:Q.#&9%,)1# 94,4;45# ,14%&%&IK !#*"M42. 4&9 `4*U4,"+& P#1# +1I4&%[#9 %& +19#1 ,+ .1+0%9#

*%0%( 5+*%#,OK 2455Z2#9%4 1#.1#5#&,4,%0#5 45 P#(( 45 .);(%* 5#104&,5 4&9 9#0#(+.#15 P%," ,"#

+..+1,)&%,O ,+ (#41& P ,++(5 ,+ #Q.(+1#K 0%5)4(%[# 4&9 ,14&5'+12 94,4 %&,+ 04()4;(#

4..(%*4,%+&5K %& 499%,%+& ,+ 14%5%&I 2+1# 4P41#7 4;+), ,"# ;1+49#1 -.#& /+0#1&2#&,

FI#&94 #&9+15#9 ;O ,"# /+0#1&2#&, +' J+(9+04@

-.#& =&&+04,%+& R##U %&*()9#9 9#0#(+.2#&, +' ,"1##K "%I"Z0%5%;%(%,O ]5"+P*45#^ 4..(%*4,%+&5@

!"#5# 4..(%*4,%+&5 249# %&&+04,%0# )5# +' J+(9+04b5 H--

F'(4@29 6P"%*" *+11#*,(O 4(%I&5 &42#5 4&9 (+*4,%+&5 +' 4(( J+(9+04& 5*"++(5 P%," 5.#&9%&I7c 6A7

H)I#,@29 6'%15, 24Y+1 1#)5# +' H--

49+.,#9 4&9 (4)&*"#9 ;O ,"# J4O+1 +' M"%5%&4)7@

- +' ,"# %22#9%4,# 0%5%;(# 1#5)(, +' F..5TJ+(9+04 %5 ,"#

(4)&*" +' ,"# PPP@+.#&94,4@29 .+1,4( ,"4, "45 ;##& .),

,+I#,"#1 ;O 9#0#(+.#15b *+22)&%,O ,+ 24U# .);(%* I+0#1&2#&,

94,4 4**#55%;(# ,+ )5#15 +' 2+;%(#K 9#5U,+. 4&9 P#; 4..(%*4,%+&5@

!"# -.#& =&&+04,%+& R##U #&5)1#9 5)**#55')( (4)&*" +'

J+(9+04b5 '%15, !#*"M42. 4&9 `4*U4,"+&K 1#'#11#9 ,+ 45 F..5TJ+(9+04@ CV ,#425 +' 9#0#(+.#15

"40# 9#5%I 5#0#14( .1+,+,O.#5 +' 4..(%*4,%+&5 ;45#9 +& +.#& I+0#1&2#&, 94,4@

F..5TJ+(9+04 P45 4 ,O.%*4( `4*U4,"+& 6+',#& 4 0#1O (++5#(O 5,1)*,)1#9 #0#&,7@ =, #&*+2.455#9

4 "%I"(O %&&+04,%0# "O;1%9 2+9#( 9#5%I ,+ ;# 9#24&9Z91%0#&K *+2.#,%,%0#K 4&9 *"4((#&I#Z

'+*)5#9G *+&9%,%+ +& 1#)5# +' I+0#1&2#&, +.#& 94,4 4&9 .1%&*%.(#5 +' 5)5,4%&4;%(%,O@

f)1,"#12+1#K .1#.414,%+& '+1 ,"# #0#&, %&0+(0#9 %&,#&5%0# ,#42 Z 4&9 1#(4,%+&5"%. ;)%(9%&I

;#,P##& 9#0#(+.#15K P"+ 5+)I", +.#& 94,4K I+0#1&2#&, 4I#&*%#5 4&9 *%0%( 5+*%#,O

+1I4&%[4,%+&5 P"+ P4&,#9 ,+ "40# ,"#%1 .1+;(#25 4991#55#9 ,"1+)I" P 4..(%*4,%+&5@


14/23


14

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

I+0#1&4&*# 4&9 _)4(%,O +' .);(%* 5#10%*#5 P"%(# 4(5+ 5,1#&I,"#&%&I ,"# %&&+04,%0# *4.4*%,O +' ,"#

I+0#1&2#&,@

=& 499%,%+& ,+ ,"# 4;+0# 2#&,%+ #Q42.(#5 4&9 #0#&,5 ,"4, '+((+P#9 1%I", 4',#1 J+(9+04

Y+% -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%.K ,"#1# %5 4&+,"#1 %2.+1,4&, +),*+2# +' ,"4, .1+*#55

P"%*" 1#(4,#9 ,+ ,"# (4)&*"K 4, ,"# #&9 +' J4O ABCAK +' 4 *%0%( 5+*%#,O P+1U%&I I1+). +& :Z

/+0#1&2#&,E-.#& /+0#1&2#&, P%,"%& ,"# ?4,%+&4( 341,%*%.4,%+& M+)&*%(CV

6*%0%( 5+*%#,O 490%5+1O

;+9O ,+ ,"# /+0#1&2#&, +' J+(9+047@ F *+22)&%,O +' +.#& 94,4 9#0#(+.2#&, PPP@*+99@29

P45 5#, ). ;O ,"%5 *%0%( 5+*%#,O P+1U%&I I1+). 45 4 5.4*# '+1 *%0%( 5+*%#,O +1I4&%[4,%+&5 ,+ 5"41#

4&9 (#41& 4;+), P4O5 ,+ )5# -.#& 84,4K 4;+), -.#& /+0#1&2#&, %&%,%4,%0#5 4&9 24&O 2+1#@

!"# I1+). 4%25 4, 2+&%,+1%&I ,"# .1+I1#55 +& ,"# %2.(#2#&,4,%+& +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&,

F*,%+& 3(4& %&*()9%&I +& ,"# -.#& 84,4 *+2.+&,K 45 P#(( 45 %9#&,%'%#5 4&9 .1+2+,#5 P

%&%,%4,%0#5 4&9 +..+1,)&%,%#5 '+1 *%0%( 5+*%#,O ,+ )5# .);(%* 94,4 %& ,"#%1 94OZ,+Z94O 4*,%0%,%#5@ -

+' ,"# %&,#1#5,%&I %&%,%4,%0#5 ,"4, J+(9+04 Y+% 45 4 1#5)(, +' ,"# P+1U%&I I1+).5b #''+1,5 ;4*U

%& ?+0#2;#1 ABCA %5 ,"# /(+;4( 341,"%. '+1


15/23


15

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

/+0#1&2#&, %& ,"# '%15, .(4*#S^ 4&9 5+ 1#5.+&9#&, *(#41(O 5,4,#9 ,"4, ,"#O 41# %&,#1#5,#9 %& 94,4

1#(4,#9 ,+ #9)*4,%+&K .);(%* .1+*)1#2#&,5K "#4(,"K Y)5,%*#K #&0%1+&2#&,K #*+&+2OK 4I1%*)(,)1#K

*+&5,1)*,%+&K +,"#15@ `+.#')((OK 94,4 '1+2 ,"#5# 5#*,+15 P%(( ;# 4 ,+. .1%+1%,O '+1 ,"# P 4*,%+&

.(4&@

HO Y+%&%&I ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 2+1# 5OIO P45 *1#4,#9 41+)&9 -.#&

84,4 %& J+(9+04K #0#& %' ,"# .1+I1#55 249# %5 5,%(( 2+9#5,@ !"# 2+2#&,)2 '+1 -.#& 84,4

3+1,4(5 45 P#(( 45 '+1 *1+P95+)1*%&I 94,4 4..(%*4,%+&5 %& J+(9+04 %5 I1+P%&I@ `+P#0#1K ,"#1# 41#

5,%(( 4 &)2;#1 +' %2.+1,4&, *"4((#&I#5 ,+ ;# 4991#55#9 %& ,"# ).*+2%&I '),)1# 4&9 ,"#O 1#(4,# ,+

9%I%,%[%&I .);(%* 94,4K +.#& 94,4 '+124,5K 5,4&9419%[4,%+& +' *(455%'%#15K 9#*+).(%&I .);(%* 94,4

'1+2 .#15+&4( 94,4K ;)%(9%&I ,"# *4.4*%,O +' .);(%* 5#104&,5 ,+ P+1U #''%*%#&,(O P%," ,"# 94,4K

;)%(9 ,"# *4.4*%,O +' *%0%( 5+*%#,O +1I4&%[4,%+&5 ,+ )5# ,"# 94,4 #''#*,%0#(O 45 .41, +' ,"# P+1U

,"#O 9+ 4, (+*4( 4&9 &4,%+&4( (#0#(5 4&9 24&O 2+1#@ !"#5# *"4((#&I#5 5"+)(9 ;# 4991#55#9 %& 4

*+2.1#"#&5%0# 24&K %& +19#1 ,+ 1#(#45# 2+1# .);(%* 94,4 4&9 ,")5K #Q.(+1# ;+," %,5 5+*%4(

4&9 #*+&+2%* .+,#&,%4(@

IEIL'+24&%4 "45 ,14&5.+5#9 ,"# :\ 8%1#*,%0# ABBDEXVE:M +& ,"# 1#Z)5# +' .);(%* 5#*,+1 %&'+124,%+&

;O (4P CBXEABBhAB 1#I419%&I ,"# 1#Z)5# +' %&'+124,%+& '+1 .);(%* %&5,%,),%+&@ !"# >+24&%4& (4P

"45 4(5+ ;##& 2+9%'%#9 %& ABBV ;O (4P ACDEABBV@ :0#& ,"+)I" ,"# (4P %5 *(+5#(O '+((+P%&I ,"#

,#Q, +' ,"# 9%1#*,%0#K %& .14*,%*# ,"# (4P P45 &+, %2.(#2#&,#9 4, 4(( %& ,"# '%15, W O#415@ !"# (4*U

+' 4&O 5).#10%5+1O 4),"+1%,O +1 4&O 9%1#*, 54&*,%+&5 '+1 ,"# .);(%* %&5,%,),%+&5 ,"4, 9+ &+, 4((+P

,"# 1#Z)5# +' ,"#%1 %&'+124,%+& P#1# 24Y+1 "4&9%*4.5K P"%*" *+)(9 &+, ;# +0#1*+2#@ H), ,"#

.+(%,%*4( P%(( 4, ,"# "%I"#5, (#0#( P45 .1+;4;(O ,"# 24Y+1 %&"%;%,+1 +' 4&O 1#4( .+(%*O P%," #''#*,5

+& ,"# I1+)&9@ J+5, +' ,"# .);(%* %&5,%,),%+&5 "49 &+ U&+P(#9I# #0#& +& ,"# #Q%5,#&*# +' ,"#

(4PK #0#& (#55 +& "+P ,+ 4..(O %,@ !"# 1#Z)5# +' .);(%* %&'+124,%+& ;O .1%04,# *+2.4&%#5 +1

?/-5 P45 64&9 %& '4*, 5,%(( %57 249# ;O 5*14.%&I ,"# %&'+124,%+& '1+2 .);(%* P#;5%,#5@

>+24&%4 #Q.1#55#9 ,"#%1 %&,#1#5, ,+ 5%I& ,"# -/3 8#*(414,%+& %&


16/23


16

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

-&*# ,"# 9+55%#1 1#I419%&I ,"# -/3 F*,%+& 3(4& P#&, ,+ ,"# J%&%5,1O +' n)5,%*# 6J+n7 4&9 P45

455%I ,+ ,"# ,#42 ,"4, P+1U#9 +& ,"# ?4,%+&4( F&,%Z*+11).,%+&


17/23


17

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

%9#&,%'%#9 4**+19%&I ,+ ,"# 4;+0# .414I14."c 94,4 5#,5 ,"4, 41# 5);Y#*, ,+ *+2.)(5+1O

9%5*(+5)1# 4**+19%&I ,+ g4P &+@ WTTEABBC6f1##9+2 +' F**#55 ,+ %&'+124,%+& (4P7c

H), %& 1#4(%,O &+,"%&I 24Y+1 "4..# ;O ,"# #&9 +' ABCAK 4(5+ 9)# ,+ 4& )&5,4;(# .+(%,%*4(

5%,)4,%+& ,"4, 249# %, )&*(#41 P"+ P+)(9 4*,)4((O ;# ,"# %&5,%,),%+& ,"4, P+)(9 *++19%&4,# ,"%5

.1+*#55@ F& %&9#.#&9#&, 1#.+1,AT

'1+2 ,"# ?/- +24&%4K P"%*" ,++U .41, +' ,"# -/3

*+&5)(,4,%+& .1+*#55K 1#(#45#9 %& Ch 8#*#2;#1 ABCA )&9#1(% ,"# (%2%,4,%+&5G

=2.(#2#&,%&I ,"# -/3 F*,%+& 3(4& %5 5,%(( +& 4 0#1O ;45%* 5,4I#

8%55#2%&4,%+& +' %&'+124,%+& Z 45 ,"# '%15, 5,#. %& %2.(#2#&,%&I ,"# -/3 3(4& Z %5 5,%(( %&

,"# ;#I%&&%&I

!"# .);(%* 4),"+1%,%#5 _)#5,%+ 4;+), ,"# 5);Y#*, 5"+P#9 4 9%5%&,#1#5, 4&9 5#(9+2 %,P45 4 *+&')5%+& ;#,P##& +.#& 94,4 4&9 .);(%* %&,#1#5, 94,4

!"# #''+1,5 '+1 +''#1%&I +.#& 94,4 ,+ *%,%[#&5 41# '+1,)%,+)5@

!"# 1+49 '1+2 P+195 ,+ 4*,%+& ,+P4195 404%(4;%(%,O +' +.#& 94,4 _)%*U(O 5"+1,*),Z#9 4',#1 4 P

'+12#9 9#.41,2#&, 6*4((#9 8#.41,2#&, '+1 -&(%


18/23


18

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

%&0+(0#2#&, +' U#O .);(%* 5#*,+1 4*,+15 '1+2 J+n


19/23


19

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

M )'*4$8,9'*,-.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 "45 *#1,4%&(O 24&4I#9 ,+ ;)%(9 ,"# 2+2#&,)2 41+)&9

-.#& 84,4 %&%,%4,%0#5 %& 5#0#14( -/3 2#2;#1 *+)&,1%#5 41+)&9 ,"# I(+;#@ HO "40%&I

/+0#1&2#&,5 .1+9)*# &4,%+&4( F*,%+& 3(4&5 +& -.#& /+0#1&2#&,K -.#& 84,4 24O ;#*+2# +

+' ,"# U#O .1%+1%,%#5 45 .41, +' *+)&,1O F*,%+& 3(4&5K #5.#*%4((O %' ,"# *%0%( 5+*%#,O *4& 4(5+ .)5"

'+1 %,@

`+P#0#1K %& *+)&,1%#5 P%," (%2%,#9 #Q.#1%#&*# +' .41,%*%.4,+1O 9#2+*14*O 2+1# #''+1,5 41#

#9#9 %& +19#1 ,+ ;)%(9 ,"# 9#24&9 '+1 +.#& 94,4 0%4 -.#& /+0#1&2#&,K 5+*%4( 4**+)&,4;%(%,OK

*%,%[#&Z*#&,#1#9 4..1+4*"#5 4&9 .14*,%*#5@

F, ,"# 542# ,%2# -/3 %5 4 I++9 ,++( '+1 *%0%( 5+*%#,O ,+ .1+2+,# ,"# )54I# +' -.#& 84,4K ;), %,

#95 ,+ ;# ,4*U(#9 %& 4 2)(,%Z5,4U#"+(9#1 4..1+4*"K P"#1# ,"# ;)5%7 5#*,+1 4&9

#&,1#.1#)15 2)5, ;# %&0+(0#9@ -.#& 84,4 41# 4 2#4&5K &+, 4 I+4(K 4&9 %, %5 4& %2.+1,4&,

45.#*, ,"4, U#O 5,4U#"+(9#15 5"+)(9 ;# #2."45%[%&I 2+1# 4&9 2+1# +',#&@ !"4, %5 P"O %, P45

*1)*%4( ,"4, ,"# -.#& 84,4 #0#&,5 ;1%&I %& ,+I#,"#1K &+, +&(O 9#0#(+.#15b *+22)&%,OK ;), 4(5+

2455Z2#9%4 1#.1#5#&,4,%0#5K *%0%( 5+*%#,O 1#.1#5#&,4,%0#5K /+0#1&2#&, 1#.1#5#&,4,%0#5@

R"%(# %, %5 5,%(( ,++ #41(O ,+ 455#55 .1+.#1(O ,"# +0#14(( %2.4*, +' ,"# -.#& 84,4 %& J+(9+04 4&9

>+24&%4K %, %5 '4%1 ,+ 54O ,"4, ,"# 404%(4;(# #0%9#&*# 5)II#5, ,"4, %,5 5"+1, ,#12 9%1#*, %2.4*, "45

4 I1#4, .+,#&,%4( '+1 ')1,"#1 9#0#(+.2#&, 4&9 I1+P," %' .1+.#1 2#*"4&%525 41# 5#, ). %& .(4*#@

=2.4*, %5 2+1# (%U#(O ,+ ;#*+2# 0%5%;(# %& ,"# (+&IZ,#12 %' %, 1#5)(,5 +), +' ,"# *+2;%&4,%+& +'

,#*"&+(+I%*4( 4&9 +1I4&%[4,%+&4( %&&+04,%+&@

M%0%( 5+*%#,O *+22)&%,O ;#*+2#5 2+1# 4&9 2+1# %&,#1#5,#9 %& (++U%&I 4, %&%,%4,%0#5 ,"4, .)15)#

,"# I+4(5 +' %2.1+0%&I .);(%* 5#10%*#5 4&9 .1+2+,%&I P#;Z;45#9 %&&+04,%+&K ,")5K *+0#1%&I ,"#

.+(%*O .1%+1%,%#5 +' I++9 4&9 +.#& I+0#1&4&*#K 5#10%*# 9#(%0#1O 4&9 %&&+04,%+&@ `+P#0#1K ,"#

;%II#5, *"4((#&I# (%#5 %& ,"# )&9#15,4&9%&I +' ,"# ,O.# +' 5#10%*#5 #9#9K ,O.# +' 5#10%*#5 '+1

P"%*" ,"# (+*4( *+&,#Q, %5 1#49OK ,O.# +' 5#10%*#5 ,"4, "40# ,"# .+,#&,%4( ,+ 5#10# 4 P%9#1

*+22)&%,O +' )5#15@ M%0%( 5+*%#,O 5"+)(9 ;# 2+1# 4*,%0# 4&9 2+1# #&I4I#9K 4&9 5"+)(9 (#41&

"+P ,+ 5*1),%&%[# I+0#1&2#&, 4&9 ,4U# 2+1# 1#5.+&5%;%(%,O '+1 ,"# *+Z9#(%0#1O +' 5#10%*#5@

-/3 .1+0#9 ,+ ;# 4 04()4;(# ,++( '+1 .1+2+,%&I +1 #&"4&*%&I +.#& 94,4 .+(%*%#5K ;), %, %5 ). ,+

,"# *+)&,1%#5 ,"#25#(0#5 ,+ )&9#15,4&9 "+P ,"#O *4& 9#0#(+. ,"# 1#Z)5# +' .);(%* %&'+124,%+&

;#O+&9 ,"# -/3 1#_)%1#2#&,5 Z 4&9 P# 5.#*%'%*4((O 1#'#1 ,+ ,"# %&0+(0#2#&, +' ,"#


20/23


20

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

#&,1#.1#)15 4&9 ,"# *+22#1*%4( 1#Z)5# +' .);(%* %&'+124,%+&@ H+," *+)&,1%#5 #Q42.(#5 ,"4,

P# 9%5*)55#9 %& ,"%5 .4.#1 41# 5,%(( (4*U%&I #Q42.(#5 +' 5)**#55 5,+1%#5 +& ,"# *+22#1*%4( 1#Z)5#K

45 4 9%1#*, 1#5)(, +' ,"# 3


21/23


21

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

L%(%0%*4%,

C@ )6%1(81 9'3%#(16 : ;01(/#I%+&4(Z!14&5.41#&*%4Z=&,#1&4*%+&4(ZRH=ZR+19ZH4&UZ=&5,%,),#

A@ "6#/'4 *#(/.6&1&%#( >?@ABCD-/3 \N ABCD 814', ?4,%+&4( F*,%+& 3(4&G '1+2 -.#& 84,4 ,+

-.#& /+0#1&2#&,K \N M4;%, Z ",,.5GEEPPP@I+0@)UEI+0#1&2#&,E*+&5)(,4,%+&5E+.#&Z

I+0#1&2#&,Z.41,"%.Z)UZ914',Z&4,%+&4(Z4*,%+&Z.(4&ZABCDE+I.Z)UZABCDZ914',Z

&4,%+&4(Z4*,%+&Z.(4&Z'1+2Z+.#&Z94,4Z,+Z+.#&ZI+0#1&2#&,

D@ "0'&.D 7 >?@A?C E N#O ,4U# 4P4O '1+2 -.#& =&&+04,%+& R##U %&%,%4,%0#5 %2.(#2#&,#9 %&

J+(9+04 9)1%&I J4O ABCAK >#.+1, '1+2 n) CK ABCA

T@ "0'&.D 7 >?@A?C F J+(9+04 -.#& /+0#1&2#&, F*,%+& 3(4& Z .1+*#55K *+&,#&, 4&9 '),)1#

+..+1,)&%,%#5K '1+2 7#6J KD L0J ?D ?@A?C !"# 31+2%5#5 4&9 3#1%(5 +' -.#& /+0#1&2#&,

84,46-/87K",,.GEEPPP@*%ZY+)1&4(@,E%&9#Q@.".E*%#YE41,%*(#E0%#PEXAXEXWW

h@ G'?@A?C F F55#55%&I -/3 F*,%+& 3(4&5K

",,.GEEPPP@I(+;4(%&,#I1%,O@+1IE;(+IE+I.Z4*,%+&Z.(4&Z455#552#&,5

CA@R6#S16 =(&'30%&, >?@A?C F


22/23


22

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

Cd@NNRYC >[.(' ?@A?C F F1,%*(#5 +' /+0#1&4&*# Z

",,.GEEPPP@+.#&I+0.41,"%.@+1IE

Ch@N ?@ABC6+&(O %& >+24&%4&7K ;O

>+24&%4 ?@A?CZ =&5%9# ,"# -.#& 84,4 P"%,# .4.#1G P"4, 9+#5 %, 4(( 2#4&S

",,.GEEPPP@,"#I)419%4&@*+2EP5E94,4;(+IEABCAEY)&EAVE+.#&Z94,4ZP"%,#Z.4.#1

AT@;%/1*#+1D = >?@ABCZ J+(9+04 24U%&I 5,#.5 ,+P4195 4 2+1# %&*()5%0# 4&9 .41,%*%.4,+1O

.1+*#55 41+)&9 -.#& /+0#1&2#&, Z

",,.GEE;(+I@+.#&I+0.41,"%.@+1IEABCDEBVE2+(9+04Z24U%&IZ5,#.5Z,+P4195Z4Z2+1#Z

%&*()5%0#Z4&9Z.41,%*%.4,+1OZ.1+*#55Z41+)&9Z+.#&ZI+0#1&2#&,E

AW@71/1(%D G >?@ABC F =&')5%&I J+(9+04b5 9#0#(+.2#&, 4I#&94 P%," ,"# .1%&*%.(#5 +' +.#&

I+0#1&2#&, Z ",,.GEE;(+I@+.#&I+0.41,"%.@+1IEABCDEBdE%&')5%&IZ2+(9+045Z

9#0#(+.#&,Z4I#&94ZP%,"Z,"#Z.1%&*%.(#5Z+'Z+.#&ZI+0#1&2#&,E Ad@701S%'D " >?@A?C>+24&%4b5 1+49 ,+ -/3 4**#55%+& Z

",,.GEEPPP@4*49#2%4@#9)EABWCBBBE>+24&%45q>+49q,+q-/3qF**#55%+&

Ah@^#064 21(X >?@A?C Z -.#& %5


23/23

!"# %&'()#&*# +' ,"# -.#& /+0#1&2#&, 341,"%. 6-/37 +& ,"# -.#&

84,4 9%5*)55%+&5

)'A.09H?+ 9*('0

the influence of the open government partnership (ogp) on the open data discussions

Documents