the importance of science in monitoring · pichilingue 3 la suerte casablanca l-a la palomera lote...

26
Álvaro Durán, PhD Forest Health Research Scientist Ontario Forest Research Institute Forest Research and Monitoring Section Science and Research Branch Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry The Importance of Science in Monitoring

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

Álvaro Durán, PhDForest Health Research ScientistOntario Forest Research Institute

Forest Research and Monitoring SectionScience and Research Branch Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

The Importance of Sciencein Monitoring

Page 2: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

MonitoringObserve and check the progress or quality of (something) over a period of time; keep under systematic review.

Page 3: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

MonitoringObserve and check the progress or quality of (something) over a period of time; keep under systematic review.

Page 4: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

The Google Ngram Viewer is an online search enginethat charts frequencies of any set of comma-delimitedsearch strings using a yearly count of n-grams found insources printed between 1500 and 2008

Page 5: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 6: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 7: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 8: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 9: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Monitoring Science

Inform management decision

Technology

Page 10: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Example 1:

Movement of Phytophthora ramorum in USA nurseries

Page 11: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Sudden oak death

woodlands.co.uk

woodlands.co.uk

Page 12: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 13: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 14: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 15: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Phytopthora detection using lateral devices

Page 16: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Example 2:

Use of monitoring to determine the pruning prescription based on risk

Page 17: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Neonectria fuckeliana affecting Pinus radiata

Canker caused by Neonectria fuckeliana on the stem of Pinusradiata.

Page 18: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Wood sampling for the detection of N. fuckeliana

Wood sample

Detection of N. fuckeliana using molecular markers

Page 19: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Presencia de Neonectria fuckeliana en predios de FVSA (Evaluación molecular)

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Presencia (%)

VISTA NORTE

CONFIANZA,LA

TRES CHIFLONES 12

Parcela Piedra Blanca

ALEUCAPI 6

TRES CHIFLONES H-5

PURREHUIN 4

SAN RAFAEL 6

HUEQUECURA

PICHILINGUE 3

LA SUERTE

CASABLANCA L-A

LA PALOMERA LOTE 4

HIJUELA FUTA

Predio

Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE

Arg

entin

a

Chi

le

Arg

entin

a

Chi

le

Plantaciones en evaluación

SummerWinter

Page 20: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Example 3:

Monitoring of Beech Bark Disease

Page 21: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Beech bark disease (BBD)

Bugwood.orgCanker caused by Neonectriafaginata on the stem of a beechtree.

Death beech tree due to BBD. Broken tree due to the damagecaused by BBD.

Page 22: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 23: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Page 24: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

- Selection of genetic resistance

- Determine areas to modify forest management

- Evaluate presence of biological control agents

- Areas where environmental conditions reduce the impact of the disease

What product is possible to have with the BBD monitoring program?

Page 25: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

OFRI ―Forest Health Research Program

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry

Summary- Monitoring feeds science and science informs monitoring

- Advances in technologies have changed the way we monitor

- The strengths and quality of the data is highly correlated with the strengths and quality of the monitoring effort

- With good quality data, it is possible to make better decisions

- The only way to move from “what I think” to “what I know” is research

Page 26: The importance of Science in monitoring · PICHILINGUE 3 LA SUERTE CASABLANCA L-A LA PALOMERA LOTE 4 HIJUELA FUTA Predio Mean Mean±SE Mean±1,65*SE Chile. Argentina. Plantaciones

Thank you

Merci

Gracias

Ontario Forest Research Institute Forest Health Research Program

[email protected]

Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry