the energy efficiency program landscape · new mexico gas company. new york state energy research...
TRANSCRIPT
The Energy Efficiency Program Landscape
Alice RosenbergSenior Program ManagerApril 23, 2019Hamilton, ON
Evolving Dynamics and Objectives
2
About CEE and Binational Market Transformation
Emerging HVAC Programs and Technologies
Integrated Demand Side Management (IDSM)
Agenda
3
CEE and Binational Market Transformation
4
Focuses on transcendent needsBrings together utilities serving customer concentrationsCEE members–80% of $9B industryLeverages earned standingGoverned largely by utility executives
The Consortium
5
Program AdministratorsAlabama PowerAlliant EnergyAmeren Illinois Atmos Energy CorporationAustin EnergyAvistaBaltimore Gas & Electric Company
BC Hydro Berkshire GasCape Light CompactColumbia Gas of Massachusetts
Columbia Gas of OhioCommonwealth Edison Company
Connecticut Natural GasConsolidated Edison Company
Consumers EnergyDC Sustainable Energy Utility (DCSEU)
Dominion Energy UtahDTE EnergyDuke EnergyEfficiency MaineEfficiency VermontÉnergir (Gaz Métro)Energy Trust of OregonEugene Water & Electric
BoardEversource
Focus on Energy—Wisconsin
FortisBCGeorgia PowerGreat Plains Natural GasGulf PowerHawai‘i EnergyHydro OneHydro-QuébecIdaho PowerLos Angeles Department of Water & Power
MidAmerican Energy CompanyMississippi PowerMontana-Dakota UtilitiesNational GridNatural Resources CanadaNB PowerNebraska Public Power District
New Jersey Natural GasNew Mexico Gas CompanyNew York State Energy Research and Development Authority
Nicor GasNorthern California Power
AgencyNW NaturalOncorPacific Gas and ElectricCompany
PECO
PNMPotomac Electric PowerCompany (Pepco)
PSEG Long IslandPuget Sound EnergySacramento Municipal
Utility DistrictSalt River ProjectSan Diego Gas & Electric Company
SaskPowerSeattle City LightSnohomish County PUDSoCalGasSouth Jersey GasSouthern California EdisonSouthern Connecticut GasSouthern Minnesota
Municipal Power AgencySouthwest GasTacoma PowerTampa ElectricTECO Peoples GasTennessee Valley AuthorityUnion GasUnited Illuminating Company
UnitilVectren OhioVermont Department ofPublic Service
Vermont GasXcel Energy
Efficiency Organizations National Laboratories
American Council for anEnergy-Efficient Economy
California Institute for Energy and Environment
Fraunhofer Center for Sustainable Energy Systems
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources
National Renewable Energy Laboratory
Natural Resources DefenseCouncil
Northeast Energy Efficiency Partnerships
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Pacific Northwest NationalLaboratory
Southwest Energy EfficiencyProject
Federal AdvisorsNatural Resources CanadaUS DOEUS EPA
CEE Members Working Together
6https://www.cee1.org/annual-industry-reports
7Source: CEE 2017 State of the Efficiency Program Industry
US Electric DSM Expenditures By Customer ClassInvestment in Load Management
8
Building Binational Market Capacity
Address multiple measures, fuel types, and customer classes
Create and leverage association, business and government relationships
Maintain consistency in policies and positions
Are inclusive of market stakeholders
Instill lasting commitment with industry partners
Member Driven Initiatives:
Extend the regulatory compact
Are voluntary
Analytically based
Rely on organizations with standing
Reward those who compete
Are vetted with stakeholders
Are technology and fuel neutral
9
CEE HVAC Initiatives
Air Source Heat PumpsCentral Air ConditionersNatural Gas FurnacesNatural Gas Boilers
Unitary Heat PumpsUnitary Air ConditionersVRF Multisplit Systems
Natural Gas Boilers(commercial)
10
Emerging HVAC Programs and Technologies • Residential
• Commercial & Industrial
11
Residential
EM&V
Nonenergy Benefits
Electrification / Fuel
SwitchingConsumer Roadmaps
Awareness/ Education
IAQ/ Health
ORGANIZATIONAL DRIVERS
Load Management
Customer Engagement
12
Residential
Trade Allies
Midstream Models
Quality Installation
Trade Allies
Low Income
Envelope
Whole House
Attachments
PROGRAMMATIC TRENDS
13
Residential
ECM –Furnace
Standards
Connected Thermostats
Controls and
Connected Equipment
Evaporative Cooling
ASHPs
Minisplits
Low Ambient Performance
Ductless Heat
Pumps
Variable Capacity
Low Load Furnaces
PRODUCTS AND TECHNOLOGIES
14
Residential
Connected thermostat pilots or programs
6 10
37
58
125
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
40 Full Time Ongoing
Programs
15
Commercial
EM&V
Variable Capacity Systems
More stringent minimum standards
New Refrigerants?
Evolving Load
Profiles
IoT
ORGANIZATIONAL DRIVERS
Grid Benefit
16
Commercial
Trade Allies
Midstream Models
System Efficiency
Trade Allies
Equity/SMBs
IAQ/ Comfort
Control Retrofits
New value streams
PROGRAMMATIC TRENDS
17
Commercial
Smart Pumps
Control Retrofits
Multi or Variable Speed
Equipment
Unitary Air-Cooled A/C
Energy Profiles
Equipment Monitoring
Boilers
ASHPs
PRODUCTS AND TECHNOLOGIES
VRFs
18
Integrated Demand Side Management (IDSM)
19
Evolving Utility Goals and Objectives
Increasingly complex technologies in the market
New capabilities and functionalities of connectivity
Growing services, industry players, and opportunities
Diverse member portfolio goals and objectives
Changing EM&V structures and role of behavior
IN RESPONSE TO…
20
12
Declining Electric Load Growth
• Energy efficiency and conservation have become a part of the general culture
• Growth of customer self-generation
Need for Increased Investment
• Customer desire greater reliability/ resiliency (post Superstorm Sandy, etc.)
• General aging infrastructure
• Usage control technologies (Smart Grid)
• Cybersecurity
Disruptive Technologies• Greater Distributed Generation
• Battery storage evolving and being piloted
• Electric vehicle penetration is increasing
Utilitiesare challenged
under the existing
regulatory model
NEED/INSERT A GRAPH OF HISTORICAL LOAD TRENDS FOR EACH OF THE THREE UTILITIES.
Historical & Forecasted Electricity Growth
Grid Quality Credit Quality
Some Dynamics Utilities Face
21
The Utility of the Future: In Concept
22
Grid balancing and load management
Program M&V data
Enhanced customer engagement
Ancillary services
New Integrated DSM program offerings
Financial savings from new EE and DR opportunities
Non-energy benefits: remote control, enhanced comfort, health/wellness
Air quality/carbon
Potential Benefits of Connected
Energy Efficiency
Load Management
Behavior Change
Integrated Home
Platform
RESIDENTIAL
C&I Energy Management Framework
COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL
IDSM
23
Connected Opportunities for HVACRLoad ManagementReal-time EM&VOn-board Diagnostics/QIIn-field PerformanceMaintenanceBehavior Change
Integrated Home
Platform
RESIDENTIAL
C&I Energy Management Framework
COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL
Load ManagementReal-time EM&VEquipment MonitoringSmart PumpsRemote ControlOptimize Efficiency
24
Working TogetherAHAM CHA-1 standard for communication elements of connected appliances and AHAM SA-1 standard for commands of connected appliances
Development of ANSI Standard 1380 for demand response-ready variable capacity central air conditioners and heat pumps
Development of ANSI Standard CTA-2045A
ENERGY STAR connected criteria for select product areasDOE test procedures to address connected capabilities
Coordination of pilots using CTA-2045, functional specifications for end-uses: water heaters, thermostats, electric vehicle supply equipment, HPWHs, variable speed pool pumps, and PTACs
ANSI C137 standard for definitions. Others in development for energy measurement, data modeling, user interfaces, security
