the effect of developing the lean product on the lean
TRANSCRIPT
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
380 http://www.webology.org
The Effect of Developing the Lean Product on the Lean Supply
Chain: A Field Study for the Light Industries Company
Dr. Zahra Abd Mohammed
Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration, College of Administration and
Economics, Mustansiriyah University, Baghdad, Iraq.
E-mail: [email protected]
Received February 19, 2021; Accepted June 16, 2021
ISSN: 1735-188X
DOI: 10.14704/WEB/V18SI02/WEB18107
Abstract
The Industrial companies are facing many challenges like shortening the product lifecycle,
reducing production costs, responding to the customers' various needs, the markets'
globalization, the competition's increase and swift developments in the environment of the
business. These challenges forced the industrial companies to look for lean practices and tools
to develop their products leading to create a lean supply chain that eliminates the waste of
time, the cost, and inventory along with the supply chain.
The research problem was formulated by introducing several questions on the impact of
developing the practices and tools of the lean product for the lean supply chain, whereas the
research hypotheses were subjected to several tests to ensure their validity. Moreover, a
questionnaire included (48) questions was used as a main tool of collecting the necessary data
about the sample in order to achieve the objectives of the research.
The Light Industries Company was chosen as a sample of applying the research, and the
statistical program (STATA- MP V15.1) was used to analyze the data.
One of the important results which the research was concluded is that when the dimensions of
the variable of developing the lean product (the value stream mapping and set-based
concurrent engineering, the visual management and quality improvement, the computer-aided
design and modular design) are separated and gathered again, they will have a significant
effect on the lean supply chain's variable (the suppliers and procurement, the over production
and warehousing, the transportation and customer).
Keywords
Lean, Product Development, Lean Product Development, Supply Chain, Lean Supply Chain.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
381 http://www.webology.org
Introduction
In the competitive markets, the industrial companies are working hard to provide products
of a high quality and low cost, therefore, they try to use the best practices and tools to
develop their products along with focusing on the process of eliminating all the activities
that have not any value to the supply chain. Consequently, the philosophy of lean is
considered as one of the most important and applicable philosophy, because it contributes
in reducing the waste and enabling the access to greater quantities of the production and
resources, and thus the use and application of the lean was spread in all industrial sectors
and drawn the increased attention and wide interest of the public sectors in the past
decades. The lean concepts are aiming to eliminate all type of the waste through the
operational processes. whereas the lean initiative approaches are referring to the
achievement of the right task, at the right time, and in the right quantity in order to
implement the continual process flow at eliminating the waste, reducing the lead time,
doing the inventory process and at the end improving the productivity. Then, the
philosophy of lean was applied in various fields, including the product development and
supply chain.
The research idea focused on identifying any of the practices and tools that contribute to
develop the products in order to be lean (value stream mapping, set-based concurrent
engineering, visual management, quality improvement, computer-aided design and
modular design). These practices and tools have an impact upon the components of lean
supply chain (suppliers, procurement, over production, warehousing, transportation and
customer) so that they can improve the efficiency, reduce or eliminate the waste of time,
the efforts and costs within the supply chain, as well as to gain a clear understanding of
the value that has been added for the customer.
Literature Review
The lean practices and tools have been implemented on a large scale over the past two
decades and in the variety of the industries and services around the world, this is because
the concept of the lean initiatives reduces the waste in the overproduction, and defects,
transportation, mobility, waiting, inventory, and over-process. The lean constantly strives
to maintain the consistency with the flow of the materials and information as well as to
get the positive results (Chaurasia et al, 2019), and also because the product development
is considered as an important component of the companies, and thus, the continuous and
successful product development management is becoming necessary for business
sustainability. In the past few years, the companies have faced a pressure from the
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
382 http://www.webology.org
stakeholders to implement the principles of the lean in their product development
processes (Hejazi et al, 2020) and this has led to a growing literature about the Lean
Product Development (LPD) (Marodin et al, 2018). therefore, the lean product
development is considered as an approach that can reduce the waste in the projects aiming
to develop the products, especially the products that contain technically complex
components, which are required usually higher costs and longer times of the development,
and so the repetition of the process of developing the product can be necessary to ensure
the quality of the final products (Belvedere et al, 2019).
The principles of lean were applied in the supply chain in the 1990s because its
management (SCM) gained a prominent rank due to its ability to create opportunities of a
high value for the companies and competition (Sartori and Frederico, 2020). therefore, the
lean philosophy was applied in the supply chain, and then the lean supply chain (LSC) can
be defined as a set of organizations directly linked by upstream and downstream flows of
the products and services, the information and funds that collaboratively work to reduce
the cost and waste by efficiently pulling what is needed so as to meet the needs of the
individuals and customers (Tortorella et al, 2017).
For the importance of lean, (Tiamaz and Souissi, 2019) suggested to make a general
roadmap for applying the lean in various fields in order to improve the operations, where
the roadmap would make the process possible to adapt the steps to be followed for
applying the lean. The roadmap has been defined as a set of phases that are linked to the
principles, and each phase is defined as a set of steps that are linked to the tools. This
roadmap shows to the operations' manager the objectives that it is aiming for as well as
the lean principles and tools that must be used (Tiamaz and Souissi, 2019).
The researcher conducted a survey for many researches, and she was found that there is
not any study that combined between the practices and tools of developing the lean
product and the lean process of the supply chain. Therefore, the research focused on
identifying lean practices and tools that can be applied to develop the product, which
helps to push the improvement efforts successfully in leaning the components of the
supply chain by eliminating all waste in the components of the supply chain.
Research Methodology
Research Problem
The research problem is focused upon two aspects which are:-
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
383 http://www.webology.org
Knowledge aspect: Many writers and researchers have introduced the practices and tools
of developing the lean product, but they presented some of them and overlooked others,
so the current research tries to present an integrated set of the practices and tools adopted
in developing the lean product that have a very important role in leaning the supply chain.
Field aspect: This aspect can be clarified by formulating the following questions:-
1. Is there a clear perception among the company's management, designers, factory
managers, engineers, and technicians about the concept and types of the lean
practices and tools of the product development?
2. How do the practices and tools of the lean product development affect the lean
supply chain?
Research Objectives
The research aims to achieve the following objectives:-
1. What are the practices and tools related to develop the lean product that have a role
in leaning the supply chain?
2. What are the practices and tools of developing the lean product? And which of the
components of the lean supply chain are most important for the light industries
company?
3. Measuring the correlation between the lean product development and the lean supply
chain.
4. Measuring the impact of the lean product development in the lean supply chain.
Research Procedural Scheme
Figure (1) shows the schematic drawing of the research variables, which shows the
independent variable of developing the lean product as well as the dependent variable of
the lean supply chain.
Research Methods
1. Research Tools
The Light Industries Company was selected as a research sample for the purpose of
testing the research hypotheses, and for collecting the information about the research
sample, a questionnaire was prepared to cover the research variables. Forty questionnaires
were distributed to the engineers and technicians who work in the factories of the sample
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
384 http://www.webology.org
company, to the designers in the Design Department and to the heads of the Purchase,
Stores and Transportation Departments. Thirty four completed questionnaires were
received and analyzed, and the response rate of respondents was 85%.
The questionnaire included (48) questions, see appendix (1, 2), and the fivefold scale was
used, the statistical methods were also applied in analyzing the data by using the
Statistical program (STATA-MP V15.1).
2. Field Visits and Interviews
The researcher conducted a number of field visits to view the reality of the work in the
Light Industries Company, also she held a number of interviews with the company and
factories managers, as well as the engineers, the technicians, and employees in the
departments in order to collect data about the company and its factories in addition to
identifying the nature of work. Moreover, the researcher reviewed the reports and records
of the company as well as the factories.
Figure 1 Research procedural scheme
Quality Improvement
Set-Based Concurrent
Engineering
Value Stream
Mapping
Lean Product
Development
Modular Design
Computer- Aided
Design
Lean Transportation
Lean Warehousing
Lean Manufacturing
Lean Procurement
Lean Customers
Lean Supply Chain
Lean Suppliers
Visual Management
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
385 http://www.webology.org
Theoretical Background
Lean Product Development
The Lean is considered as a philosophy as well as an approach that is focused upon
eliminating the waste and streamlining the operations by close coordination of all
activities (Stevens, 2018). The concepts of lean are operating well in the case of the
demand of relatively stable, predictable and small product diversification (Konecka,
2010).
The objective of the lean is to create value-adding processes that are streamlined and
efficient and at the same time, they provide the necessary information to the employees
(Dumitrescu and Dumitrache, 2011). Thus, the lean thinking is considered as an
optimization philosophy that focuses on creating the value and eliminating the waste.
Moreover, in the book "The Machine that Change the World", the term lean is described
as a combination of ideas and principles developed by Toyota, and that were described by
Taichi Ohno to explain the Toyota production system but later the lean thinking phase
was included the important aspects like the value, the attentions, and five basic principles
of the lean.
Then, the development of the lean products means the lean manufacturing that is applied
to product development. The researchers and practitioners took different ways in their
attempts to describe or explain the product development approach (Muhammad et al.,
2015), while the roots of the development of the lean product are returned to the early of
1990s, which were introduced by Womack and others in 1991 and by Womack and Jones
in 1996. Those scientists and researchers sought for the explanations of the differences
between the Japanese and Western cars making in terms of developing the product. The
development of the lean product is known as the development of a new product, and the
development of Japanese products means the introduction of a new product and the design
of lean design, the development of Toyota products and the lean product lifecycle
management (Johansson and Sundin, 2014). Once the concepts and methods of lean
success are achieved in the field of the production processes, the application of the lean of
developing the product is started in order to provide products that add value to the
customer, and in case of avoiding the wasting, the interactive ability for both the market
demand and company's competitive position will be enhanced (Pinheiro and Toledo,
2016).
Because product development requires significant change, the products have become
more complex, and the competition and price pressures are increased, therefore the
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
386 http://www.webology.org
individual customer's requirements are became increasingly difficult to be achieved. This
complexity requires an increase in the effort and time when it is developed, so in the
recent introduction, the concepts of the lean in developing the product have been
presented firstly (Rauch et al., 2016).
There are two main competitive advantages of applying the lean product development:-
1. It is an enabler to achieve the next level of the lean production.
2. It improves the product development performance.
The product development is represented the life blood to many companies because they
represent the major investments in the resources. Therefore, the manager executives strive
to develop the lean products in order to improve the market response, the design in
quality, in addition to reducing the costs, and shortening the lead times (Liker and
Morgan, 2011).
The main aim of developing the product is to provide the product at a low production
cost, a good quality, and fast delivery to achieve the customer satisfaction (Bilal and
Wasim, 2015).
The researcher defines the development of the product as a systematic approach that
develops the products and focuses on creating the value to the customer as well as
reducing the waste of time, the effort, and cost in order to survive and grow faster than
their competitors.
Lean Practices and Tools of Product Development
The application of the lean manufacturing philosophy in developing the product would
make the process of developing the product more streamlined and efficient, in addition to
increasing the reactivity of the company. The tools in the lean manufacturing, for
instance, Kaizen, Value Stream Map, 5s, and other basic tools can be also adapted in
developing the product process to eliminate all kinds of the waste. Moreover, some
practices are used to achieve the lean's goals where they were used in developing the
product like the concurrent engineering, the visual management, and supplier engagement.
The following table (1) shows the Lean practices and tools of developing the product.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
387 http://www.webology.org
Table 1 Lean practices and tools of developing the product
Lean Practices and Tools Author's name and the year
1- Set-Based Concurrent Engineering
2- Value - Focus
3- Chief Engineering Technical Leadership
4- Knowledge – Based Environment
(Muhammad et al., 2013)
1-Mistake-Proofing (poke-yoke)
2- Knowledge Based Engineering (Bilal and Wasim, 2015)
1-Value Stream Mapping
2-Visual Management
3- Set-Based Concurrent Engineering
(Pinheiro and Toledo, 2016)
1- Standard Parts
2- Modular Design
3- Highly Capable Production Systems with Quality Built in
4- Concurrent Engineering
(Stevences, 2018)
Source: The author
The researcher suggests for developing the lean product a set of practices and tools that
will have an impact on the lean supply chain components:-
1. Value Stream Mapping: it is the visual representation of the flow value of process,
which is similar to the process flow chart. The value flow determines all steps of the
operations and tasks that are performed to deliver the product or service from the
beginning to the end. The typical value flow includes both the process steps and tasks
that are neutral, this means that they add a value but at the same time they do not add
any value (Schroeder et al., 2018). Toyota Company made a map value stream
originally that is called "Planning Information and Materials Flow", which purpose is
to help in eliminating the steps of operations and tasks that do not add value, as well as
identifying the development opportunities (Stevences, 2018).
2. Set-Based Concurrent Engineering: The concurrent engineering takes the form of the
multi-function teams and meetings where the organizational stakeholders in the
purchasing, manufacturing and marketing processes, as well as in the quality assurance
and assembly along with the designers and engineers are integrated into the product
development project at an early stage and who are also involved in reviewing the
product design and proposals in order to ensure that current plans of developing the
product have met the needs of the internal and external stakeholders.
Concurrent engineering has become the main approach to the product design and
development process. Concurrent engineering focuses on the product design stage to
Achievement the tasks correctly from the first time (Azeez & AL-tayar, 2021).
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
388 http://www.webology.org
The work is done in parallel, which helps avoid repetition and rework the designs later
(Akaberi, 2011). The application of concurrent engineering in companies helps to manage
the design and development of the product, adjust the cost of providing the product,
manage the proffer of the new product, speed in the process of prevention, and provide a
platform to reuse the product (Basu et al., 2013).
3. Visual Management: The visual management is used to facilitate the common
understanding of the product development team. it uses electronic or physical means in
order to make the problems visible (Pinheiro and Toledo, 2016). Moreover the visual
administration aims to make the planned current situation of the process transparent for
all, so that anyone (whether he is engaging in the process or not) can see what is
happening directly. It is usually using a visual sign like the computer and screen, the
normal and traffic signals, and lamps.
The visual administration is distinct with several advantages, where it shows the safe and
effective working practices as a common focus for the team meetings as well as an
assessment of the current situation of the process, in addition to understanding the tasks
and priorities of the work and determining the flow of work, i.e. what has been done and
what is going to be, along with identifying when something is not going as it was planned,
…etc (Slack et al., 2013).
4. Quality Improvement: The research and study in the quality improvement are
considered as an endless process, which is usually focusing on the discovery and
elimination of the problem's causes.
The Andon system makes signals such as (sound alarm, lights, etc.) in case of there is
abnormality in the production system like the malfunction of a machine and device, or
there is a manufactured part which is not meeting the given specifications (Russell and
Talyer, 2011).
The quality improvement has also another term, it is "Poka-Yoke" that means "a failure in
the error". it is emphasizing on the achievement of the perfect quality at every process and
at every time, therefore the managers and employees must work hard in order to develop
the processes and systems that create the right performance, all time, for the tasks in every
time. The term "Poka-Yoke" refers to the focus on redesigning the operations in such a
way that mistakes will be impossible or they will be obvious to the worker immediately
(Swink et. al., 2014).
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
389 http://www.webology.org
5. Computer-Aided Design, CAD: If the designer uses the computer effectively in
designing the products by using the three-dimensional drawings, he will save time and
money throughout shortening the cycle of developing the product along with the speed
and ease of changing, analyzing, and adjusting the designs according to the given
specifications.
The computer-Aided Design helps the flow of the information into the other sections
along with the review of many possible options before making the final product design
decisions (Hezier et al., 2017). The possibility of linking the computer -aided design to
the manufacturing process is considered as one of the characteristics of this component,
therefore it is necessary to link the product design with the process choice, and due to the
computer-aided design, the integration between the product design and choice of process
becomes more easier (Reid and Sanders, 2013).
6. Modular Design: It is a set of parts that are processed as a single unit, and this will
significantly reduce the number of units handled and simplify the process of the
aggregation and procurement, the operation and training … etc. (Stevens, 2018).
The operations manager believes that the modular design is useful because it achieves the
product development, and at the same time, it makes the production and subsequent
changes easier. Moreover, the marketing gives the priority to the modular design because
it gives flexibility to the ways with which the customers can be satisfied (Hezier et al.,
2017).
Lean Supply Chain
In the current global markets, the supply chains play a fundamental role in developing of
an organization and maximizing the profit (Fakhrzad et al, 2018). The supply chain is
considered as a network of the business entities that supplies the product or services from
upstream to downstream, therefore the intensity of information exchange must manage
between functions and activities effectively. The supply chains are considered as networks
of organizations where nodes are connected together in the different processes and
activities, from up to down, in order to make a value to the products or services
(Huddiniah and ER, 2019).
The lean supply chain is an enabler for any organization that is looking for to become
more lean and efficient. the organizations that are applying the lean supply chain, can use
the philosophy of the lean more easily, because it will be a high value for the customers
throughout its respond to the customer needs efficiently and quickly, and this in turn, it
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
390 http://www.webology.org
will makes the lean supply chain operates easily, in addition to creating a superior
financial for these organizations (Daud, 2010).
The lean supply chain makes a stress on the removal of all non-add value activities within
the supply chain. It also emphasizes on reducing the required time for preparing and
putting together the machines. Moreover it enhances the performance of the production
system because it provides an economic production with small batches, in addition to
reducing the costs and increasing the profits and flexibility of the production.
The flexibility and responsiveness are considered as important factors in the lean supply
chains especially for the customers' design, timing and distribution requirements, but they
are not highlighted much in the lean production (Gilaninia et al., 2011). It is necessary to
operate the processes of the lean supply chain lean as a one batch than running each
process in the chain lean separately. Therefore, the company must follow the lean
synchronization philosophy of processing the chain as a whole and with everyone being
involved in the process. The fast throughput within the processing network creates a high
value and reduces the costs throughout the processing network. it also reduces the
inventory levels and the waste, in addition to achieving the exact match between the
supply and demand (Slack and Jones, 2018).
The lean supply chain is considered as a new way of thinking about the processing
networks, and here it needs the coordination of the processors besides the balance
between cooperation and competition. The cooperation involves a set of cooperative
relations in addition to the coordination of mechanisms. The Vendor partnerships and
alliance strategy are considered the key features of the lean supply chain management.
Therefore, the relationships must be close and good with processors who are expected to
process small and frequent shipments of high quality materials (Stevenson, 2018).
Moreover, the companies must make strong relationships with the suppliers so that they
can ship the product frequently and within short time so that the customers can receive it
at the specific time and with the required quality. Therefore, the company has to look at
the suppliers as its partners in the company (Krajewski et al., 2016). The flexible
approach can be used in the supply chain and in the stable environments where it can
enhance the performance of the supply chain by reducing the operating times (throughout
making the supply chain more responsive to customer requirements), improving the
quality, reducing the costs and improving the customer service. The lean supply chains
seek to eliminate the need of the inventory, the waiting time, and temporary stores.
Therefore, this case will be achieved well if both the suppliers and customers work as
partners in simplifying the system. Thus, the partners must work together to develop an
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
391 http://www.webology.org
environment where the processors can access their customers' processes easily and vice
versa (Swink et al., 2014).
The lean supply chain is defined as a set of companies linked directly with the flow of the
products and services, the finance, and information that work collaboratively to reduce the
costs and to achieve what is required to meet the customer demands efficiently and
effectively (Kimani, 2013).
The researcher defines the lean supply chain as it is defined by all parties where it is
related to the flow of the products and services, the money and information from the
lowest to the top level of the supply chain and to the reduction or elimination
cooperatively all types of the waste of time, the inventory, the costs within the supply
chain.
Lean Supply Chain Requirements
There are six basic required characteristics to make and maintain a lean supply chain
(Daud, 2010), (Johansson, 2010):-
1. The demand management: The management must coordinate with the suppliers to
secure the requirements in a proper time and when they are needed, and this will be
achieved by building strong relationships among them.
2. The cost and waste reduction: To achieve a lean chain, it requires a cooperation
among the chain's members to eliminate all kinds of waste, consequently, this will
lead to a reduction in the total cost.
3. The process standardization: The standardization of the process makes the product or
service moving through the system to the final customer without waiting, and this will
lead to a rapid delivery of the product to the final customer.
4. The adoption of the industrial standards: The lack of standardizing the industrial
standards among the trading partners leads to the waste of time and increase in the
costs, in addition to standardizing the specifications for the customers that will
enhance the efficiency of the product or service with which the customers were
supplied.
5. The cultural change: The partners of the supply chain (the suppliers and customers)
must work and cooperate as one team.
6. The establishment of cooperative projects: The use of teams in the cooperative
projects will help these teams to coordinate the work of the supply chain.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
392 http://www.webology.org
Lean Supply Chain Components
There is a set of basic components of the supply chain that must be leaned in order to
obtain a lean supply chain. The following table (2) shows the researchers' views on the
lean supply chain components.
Table 2 Lean supply chain components Lean supply chain components Author's Name and Year
1- Lean Suppliers 2- Lean Procurement
3- Lean Manufacturing
4- Lean Warehousing 5- Lean Transportation
6- Lean Customers
(Daud, 2010)
1- Lean Suppliers 2- Lean Procurement
3- Lean Manufacturing
4- Lean Warehousing 5- Lean Transportation
6- Lean Customers
(Johansson, 2010)
1- Lean Procurement 3- Lean Production
4- Lean Transportation
(Kimani, 2013)
1- Lean Suppliers
2- Lean Procurement 3- Lean Manufacturing
4- Lean Warehousing
5- Lean Logistics 6- Lean Customers
(Jacobs and Chase, 2018)
Source: The author
The researcher agrees with (Jacobs and Chase, 2018), (Daud, 2010), (Johansson, 2010)
about the lean supply chain components that are:-
1. Lean suppliers: The removal of the non-added activities of the value enables the
processors to respond towards the changes, and the prices that are offered by
processors, will be less because of the lean processes and their quality throughout
avoiding a lot of inspections. It also helps the company's suppliers to receive the
needed requirements at a proper time. The company must plan the value flow to solve
the problems so that it can improve the lean of suppliers.
2. Lean Procurement: The purchases are done by the electronic procurement. The
electronic procurement is achieved by the transactions and strategic sources, the
tenders and reverse auctions that use the web-based applications and software
programs in order to remove the human element from the multiple functions in the
company. The purchasing lean is based on the clarity and transparency, where the
suppliers is able to see the customers’ operations, and the customers are able to see
the processes of the suppliers. Therefore, the overlap in these processes must be
improved to maximize the value from the point of view of the end-customer. The
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
393 http://www.webology.org
companies also need to determine the current value flow and the future value flow
that show the purchase.
3. Lean Manufacturing: The lean production systems focus on producing what the
customer needs and at time in which he wants the quantity and the minimum
resources only. The lean production system is also considered as the biggest
opportunity to reduce the costs and improve the quality. The lean system must
interact with the customer's request so that it can smooth the manufacturing process,
in other words, the production of the commodity will be only done if there is a
request from a certain customer.
4. Lean Warehousing: Such ideal functions as the material receipt and inventory
replenishment, the warehouse status and packing for the shipment, the inventory
selection and shipping are distinct by the avoidance of the non-valuable steps and
losses in the product storage operations. The waste can be found in many storage
operations that have the shipping defects led to the over-charges and over-shipping of
the products, to the surplus stock that requires an additional space, and reduction of
the storage efficiency, to the excessive movement and dealing, besides the unladed
items and inefficient information systems.
5. Lean Transportation: The lean concept can be applied on the functions linked with the
materials' movement during the system, and some these key areas include the pooling
orders and optimized method selection, the cross load, perfect routing and combined
multi-stop truckloads, along with processes of transporting the export and import.
Some other areas of supply functions need to be optimized by eliminating the non-
adding activities and improving value-adding activities.
6. Lean Customers: The lean customers need an understanding of the business
requirements as well as the identification of the important and accurate customer's
demands. Lean customers add a value to the customers themselves throughout an
increased speed and flexibility, so they expect high levels of the delivery performance
because the value means what the customer wishes. The lean customers are interested
in creating an effective partnerships with their suppliers, and also the Lean customers
expect a value from the products that they buy, in addition to providing a value for
their customers.
Results and Analysis
Sample Company Descriptive Analysis
The Light Industries Company has been chosen as one of the leading companies in the
Electrical Appliances Industry, and it is one of the mixed sector companies that was
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
394 http://www.webology.org
established in 1959. The company has three factories, namely the Refrigerators Factory,
which produces three kinds of refrigerators with different sizes, and the Freezers Factory
which produces several types of freezers, while the third factory is the Heaters and
Cookers Factory. The questionnaire was distributed on the research sample as shown in
Appendixes (1) and (2).
The table (3) shows the frequency (repetition) and percentages of both variables of the
lean product development and the lean supply chain.
The majority of the responses for each dimension was higher than the value of the mean
and generally this reflects a good level of agreement about the answers and thus
respondents' answers were homogeneous. This case motivates the company's management
to take care of these dimensions and support them. The second dimension of the related
lean product development to the set-based concurrent engineering (X2) comes first in
terms of the relative importance according to the responses of the inspected sample with a
rate of (78.24), then the related sixth dimension to the modular design (X6) is with a rate
of (75.88), and then the related variable to the lean supply chain components (y) is with a
rate of (75.42).
Table 3 Frequencies and percentages of both variables of lean product development and
the lean supply chain
Lean Product
Development
(X)
Response Scale
Average
Standard
Deviation
Relative
importance
Always
5
Most of
time 4
Sometime
3
Rarely
2
Never
1
F % F % F % F % F %
Value Stream
Mapping X1 8 23.53 22 64.71 3 8.82 1 2.94 - - 3.699 0.536 73.97
Set-Based
Concurrent
Engineering X2
11
32.35 19 55.88 4 11.76 - - - - 3.912 0.577 78.24
Visual
Management
X3
4 11.76 12 35.29
10 29.41 6 17.65 2 5.88 3.147 0.996 62.94
Quality
Improvement
X4
5 14.71 19 55.88 9 26.47 1 2.94 - - 3.684 0.607 73.77
Computer-
Aided Design
X5
4 11.76 7 20.59 13 38.24 8 23.53 2 5.88 3.250 0.879 65
Modular
Design X6 5 14.71 21 61.76 7 20.59 1 2.94 - - 3.794 0.711 75.88
Lean Supply
Chain (y) 2 5.88 28 82.35 4 11.76 - - - - 3.771 0.419 75.42
Source: Results of statistical analysis of the questionnaire using the statistical program
STATA-MP V15.1
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
395 http://www.webology.org
Correlation Relationships Descriptive Analysis
In order to identify the nature of the correlation relationships among the dimensions of the
lean product development variable (X) and the lean supply chain components variable (y),
the correlation coefficients were calculated for Spearman (r) in order to examine the
existence of the relationship, and then the t-test was used to test the significance of the
relationship among the dimensions, and as it shows below in the table (4).
Table 4 The correlation coefficients of Spearman and t-Test
Lean Product Development (X) Lean Supply Chain Components (y)
r t Sig
1- Value Stream Mapping X1 **0.567 3.896 0.001
2- Set-Based Concurrent Engineering X2 0.437* 2.096 0.044
3- Visual Management X3 0.263 1.543 0.133
4- Quality Improvement X4 0.745** 6.318 0.001
5- Computer- Aided Design X5 0.549** 3.710 0.001
6- Modular Design X6 0,641** 4.722 0.001
Lean Product Development (X) 0.698** 5.516 0.001
Source: the statistical analysis results of the questionnaire by using the statistical program
STATA-MP V15.1.
The table (4) shows that there is a strong direct significant correlation between the
dimension of the value stream map and the lean of the components of the supply chain,
where the value of Spearman's correlation coefficient was (0.567), and this indicates that
the more interest in developing the value stream map, the more lean happens in the
components of the supply chain, and vice versa, whereas the value of the test hypothesis
(t) reached (3.896) at a level of significance less than (0.01), and this indicates the
significance of the correlation between the two dimensions, as well as there is also a direct
significant correlation between the Set-Based Concurrent Engineering dimension and the
components of the supply chain, where the value of Spearman's correlation coefficient
reached (0.437), and this indicates that the greater the interest in the Set-Based Concurrent
Engineering, the lean of the components of the supply chain increased, and vice versa,
while the value of the test hypothesis (t) reached (2.096) at a level of significance less
than (0.05), and this referred to the significance of the correlation between the two
dimensions.
It is also evident that there are strong positive significant correlations at a significance
level being less than (0.01) between the dimensions of (the quality improvement, the
computer-aided design, and modular design) and the lean components of the supply chain,
where the values of the correlation coefficient reached to (0.745, 0.549, and 0.641)
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
396 http://www.webology.org
respectively, whereas the values of the test hypothesis (t) reached to (6.318, 3.70, and
4.722), respectively, at a significant level being less than (0.01) that indicates the
significance of the correlations.
It is also evident that there is a weak and insignificant correlation at a level of significance
being less than (0.05) between the visual management and lean of the components of the
supply chain, where the value of Spearman's correlation coefficient reached (0.263), and
the value of the test hypothesis (t) reached (1.543), which indicates a lack of significance
for the correlation relationship between the two dimensions.
Also the table (4) shows that there is a strong correlation relationship between the
independent variable lean product development (X) and the dependent variable the lean
supply chain (y), where the correlation coefficient of spearman is (0.698) which indicates
that the more attention given to the dimensions of lean product development will lead to
an increased attention to the lean supply chain components. The value of (t) is of (5.516)
at a significant level and it is less than (0.01), so it indicates the significant correlation
between the two variables.
Regression's Descriptive Analysis between the Lean Product Development and Lean
Supply Chain
The regression analysis method was used in order to test whether there is a significant
impact for the lean product development (X) in the lean supply chain (y), and below the
table(5) shows the results:-
Table 5 Determination of the coefficient values, the regression coefficient and F test Lean Product Development (x) Lean Supply Chain Components (y)
R2 β F P- value
1- Value Stream Mapping X1 0.322 0.444 15.178 0.001
2- Set-Based Concurrent Engineering X2 0.121 0.252 4.391 0.044
3- Visual Management X3 0.069 0.111 2.379 0.133
4- Quality Improvement X4 0.555 0.514 39.914 0.001
5- Computer- Aided Design X5 0.301 0.261 13.768 0.001
6- Modular Design X6 0.411 0.378 22.297 0.001
Lean Product Development (x) 0.50 0.570 30.428 0.001
Source: the statistical analysis results of the questionnaire by using the statistical Program
STATA-MP V15.1.
The table (5) shows the (F) test values and the coefficient values of the determination
(R2), the slope values of the regression equation (β), and values of (p - value), where it
appears:-
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
397 http://www.webology.org
1. The value of the F-test for the indicator of the value stream map reached to (15.178)
and at the level of significance is of (0.001), which has a significant indication at a
level of significance being less than (0.01), moreover, the value of the determination
coefficient was (0.322), meaning that the indicator of the value stream map explains
(0.322) of the change that occurred in the components of the supply chain. The value
of the coefficient (β) indicates that the change in the value stream map by one unit
leads to a change in the lean of the components of the supply chain at (0.444), and
thus, there is an existence of a significant effect of the value stream map on leaning
the components of the supply chain.
2. The value of the F-test for the indicator of the Set-Based concurrent engineering was
(4.391) and at the level of significance of (0.044), which is of significant indication at
a level of significance less being than (0.05), while the value of the coefficient of
determination was (0.121) and this means that the indicator of Set-Based concurrent
engineering explains (0.121) of the change in the lean of the components of the
supply chain. Moreover, the value of the coefficient (β) indicates that the change of
Set-Based concurrent engineering by one unit leads to a change in the lean of the
components of the supply chain at (0.252), and thus, there is an existence of a
significant effect of the Set-Based concurrent engineering on the lean of the
components of the supply chain.
3. The value of the F-test for the indicator of the visual management was not significant
at a significant level of less than (0.05), and reaches to (2.397), and this indicator
explains (0.069) of the change in the lean of the components of the supply chain,
whereas, the value of the coefficient (β) reached to (0.111), and therefore there was
no significant effect of visual management on the supply chain's lean components.
4. The value of the F-test for indicator of the quality improvement was (39.914) and the
level of significance is of (0.001), which has significant indication at the level of
significance being less than (0.01). Thus, the value of the determination coefficient is
of (0.555) and this means that the indicator of the quality improvement explains
(0.555) of the change in the lean of the components of the supply chain. Moreover,
the value of the coefficient (β) indicates that a change in quality improvement by one
unit leads to a change in the lean of the components of the supply chain at (0.514),
and thus there is a significant effect of quality improvement on leaning the
components of the supply chain.
5. There is an existence of a significant effect at the level of significance less than (0.01)
for the indicator of the computer-aided design on leaning the components of the
supply chain, where the F-test value was (13.768) and at the level of significance of
(0.001). The value of the determination coefficient was (0.301), and this means that
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
398 http://www.webology.org
the indicator of the computer aided design explains (0.301) of the change occurring in
the components of the supply chain. Thus, the value of the coefficient (β) indicates
that a change of computer-aided design by one unit leads to a change of lean of the
components of the supply chain by (0.261).
6. There is an existence of a significant effect at the level of significance less than
(0.01), for the indicator of the modular design on leaning the components of the
supply chain, where the value of the F-test was (22.297) and the level of significance
of (0.001). The value of the determination coefficient was (0.411), meaning that the
modular design index explains (0.411) of the change in the lean of the components of
the supply chain. The value of the coefficient (β) indicates that the change of the
modular design by one unit leads to a change in leaning the components of the supply
chain by (0.378).
7. There is a significant effect at a significance level less than (0.01) for dimensions lean
product development (X) in the lean supply chain components (y). The value of (F)
test is (30.428) and the significance level is (0.001). The coefficient of determination
is (0.50), and this means that the dimensions of lean product development (X) are
account for (0.50) by the change in the variable of the lean supply chain components
(y). The value of (β) indicates the change in the dimensions of the lean product
development (X) and in one unit which leads to a change in the lean supply chain
components (y) of (0.570).
Conclusions
The lean has become as one of the most popular terms in the field of the production, the
product, and supply chain. It has been defined as a systematic approach to identify and
eliminate the waste of time and materials, the inventory and effort.
The present research presents the different views that have been introduced by writers and
researchers about the practices and tools, which are used in developing the product. The
authors and researchers have expressed different views about the components of the lean
supply chain. The researcher and after his review and study to these views, especially
those studies related to the lean product development and the lean supply chain, she was
able to identify the practices and tools that contribute in the lean product.
The distinctive contribution of the research is that it is focused on introducing six of the
practices and tools that contribute in the lean of product (the value stream mapping and
set-based concurrent engineering, the visual management and quality improvement, the
computer-aided design and modular design), and which will have a significant impact on
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
399 http://www.webology.org
the lean of the six components of the supply chain (the suppliers and procurement, the
over production and warehousing, the transportation, and customer). Therefore, the
researcher prepared a questionnaire of (48) questions in order to measure the correlation
and effect of developing the lean product practices and tools on leaning the supply chain.
The difficulty of finding industrial companies that produce various products and use the
practices and tools of developing the lean product was as one of the determinants of the
research, so the researcher tried to choose an industrial company that products many
products, and at the same time, it is proper to the practices and tools of developing the
lean product where these practices and tools have an actual role in leaning the supply
chains for its products. Therefore, the light industries company was selected, and when
the questionnaire was applied upon it, the results revealed that the set-based concurrent
engineering got the first rank in terms of the relative importance, which was followed by
the modular design and then the components of the lean supply chain.
The results of the study indicated to a significant correlation between the development of
the lean product and the lean supply chain. This shows that the light Industry Company
has paid little attention in this concern, so its management must present greater efforts to
the application of the practices and tools for developing the product, which will reflect in
the lean components of the supply chain.
The company is working in a wide competitive environment, therefore its management
must pay more attention to the practices and tools of developing the lean product which is
considered as a critical factor for the company's success.
In the future, a lot of lean product development practices and tools can be identified in
order to contribute more support and help quickly to the components of the supply chain.
The importance and necessity of developing the new products in some sectors emerged at
the present time as a result of Covid-19 outbreak, therefore the companies must use the
lean practices and tools in their new products, in addition to leaning the supply chain in
order to respond quickly to the customer and market requirements.
References
Akaberi, A. (2011). Set-based concurrent engineering process: contextualization, industry
analysis and business game development. Master thesis of science, Milano, Italy.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
400 http://www.webology.org
Azeez, K.A., & AL-tayar, H.S. (2021). The Role of Developed Concurrent Engineering on
Enhancing a Competitive Capability for Manufacturing Firms. Webology, 18,
322-338.
Basu, S., Biswas, N., Biswas, S.N., & Sarkar, S. (2013). A study on concurrent
engineering-based design and product development. International Journal of Recent
Advances in Mechanical Engineering (IJMECH), 2(1), 15-20.
Belvedere, V., Cuttaiab, F., Rossic, M., & Stringhettide, L. (2019). Mapping wastes in
complex projects for Lean Product Development. International Journal of Project
Management, 37(3), 410-424.
Bilal, A.M., & Ahmad, W. (2015). Lean enablers for product design and development.
International Journal for Scientific Research and Development, 3(2), 203-208.
Chaurasia, B., Garg, D., & Agarwal, A. (2019). Lean Six Sigma approach: a strategy to
enhance performance of first through time and scrap reduction in an automotive
industry. International Journal of Business Excellence, 17(1), 42-57.
Daud, A.B. (2010). A study on lean supply chain implementation in Malaysia’s electrical
and electronics industry: Practices and Performances. Master thesis, USM,
Malaysia.
Dumitrescu, C., & Dumitrache, M. (2011). The impact of Lean Six Sigma on the overall
results of companies. Economia. Seria Management, 14(2), 535-544.
Fakhrzad, M.B., Pourfereidouni, H., & Pourfereidouni, M. (2018). Dual-channel supply
chain synchronization with deterministic and stochastic demand under cost-sharing
contract. International Journal of Supply and Operations Management, 5(1), 28-41.
Gilaninia, S., Taleghani, M., Mousavian, S.J., Tajani, T.K., Ghoreishi, S.M., Shaahidi,
S.F., & Seighalani, F.Z. (2011). Comparative study of lean and agile supply chain
management along with the optimal model presentation of agile supply chain
management. Journal of Business and Management Review, 1(4), 46-56.
Hejazi, A., Bhuiyan, N., & Othman, M. (2020). Performance measurement of a lean
product development process. SAGE Journals, 28(3), 198-209.
Heizer, J., Render, B., & Munson, C. (2017). Operations management sustainability and
supply chain management, 12th edition. Pearson education, Inc. U.S.A.
Jacobs, F.R., & Chase, R.B. (2018). Operations and supply chain management, 5th edition.
McGraw- Hill Education, New York, U.S.A.
Huddiniah, E., & ER, M. (2019). Product Variety, Supply Chain Complexity and the
Needs for Information Technology: A Framework Based on Literature
Review. Operations and Supply Chain Management: An International Journal,
12(4), 245-255.
Johansson, E. (2010). Can lean be mean? A study of negative consequences of lean in
supply chains. Master thesis in Business Administration, Blekinge School of
Management.
Johansson, G., & Sundin, E. (2014). Lean and green product development: two sides of the
same coin?. Journal of Cleaner Production, 85, 104-121.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
401 http://www.webology.org
Kimani, M.W. (2013). Lean supply chain management in manufacturing firms in Kenya.
Master thesis in Business Administration, School of Business, University of Nairobi,
Kenya.
Konecka, S. (2010). Lean and agile supply chain management concept in the aspect of risk
management. Log Forum, 6(4), 23-31.
Krajewski, L.J., Ritzman, L.P., & Malhotra, M.K. (2013), Operations management:
processes and supply chains, 10th edition, Global edition, Pearson, Boston, U.S.A.
Liker, J.K., & Morgan, J. (2011). Lean product development as a system: a case study of
body and stamping development at Ford. Engineering Management Journal, 23(1),
16-28.
Marodin, G., Frank, A.G., Tortorella, G.L., & Netland, T. (2018). Lean product
development and lean manufacturing: Testing moderation effects. International
Journal of Production Economics, 203, 301-310.
Muhammad, K., Ahmed, A., Essam, S., Badr, H., Paul, E., Mikel, S., & Amaia, S. (2013).
Toward a lean product and process development, International Journal of Computer
Integrated Manufacturing, 26(12), 1105-1116.
Pinheiro, L.M.P., & De Toledo, J.C. (2016). Application of lean approach in the product
development process: a survey on Brazilian industrial companies. Gestão Produção,
São Carlos, 23(2), 320-332.
Rauch, E., Dallasega, P., & Matt, D.T. (2016). The way from lean product development
(LPD) to smart product development (SPD). Procedia CIRP, 50, 26-31.
Reid, R.D., & Sanders, N.R. (2013). Operations management: an integrated approach. 5th
edition, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., U.S.A.
Russell, R., & Taylor, B.W. (2011). Operations management: creating value along the
supply chain. 7th edition, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., U.S.A.
Sartori, J.T., & Frederico, G.F. (2020). Understanding the relationship between supply
chain management maturity dimensions: findings from a case study in a truck
manufacturing company. International Journal of Business Excellence, 20(3),
419-432.
Schroeder, R.G., & Goldstein S.M. (2018). Operations management in the supply chain:
decisions and cases. 7th edition, McGraw-Hill Education, 2 Penn Plaza, New York,
U.S.A.
Slack, N., Jones, A.B., & Johnston, R. (2013). Operation management. 7th edition, Pearson
Education Limited, England, U.K.
Slack, N., & Jones, A.B. (2018). Operations and Process Management: Principles and
Practice for Strategic Impact. 5th edition, Pearson education limited, England.
Stevenson, W.J. (2018). Operations management. 13th edition, McGraw-Hill Education, 2
Penn Plaza, New York, U.S.A.
Swink, M., Melnyk, S.A., Cooper, M.B., & Hartley, J.L. (2014). Management operations
across the supply chain. 2ed edition., McGraw- Hill Companies, Inc., New York,
U.S.A.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
402 http://www.webology.org
Tiamaz, Y., & Souissi, N. (2019). Lean Roadmap: A Step by Step Guide for a Process
Manager. International Journal of Innovative Technology and Exploring
Engineering, 8(9), 3171-3178.
Tortorella, G.L., Miorando, R., & Marodin, G. (2017). Lean Supply Chain Management:
Empirical research on practices, contexts and performance. International Journal of
Production Economics, 193, 98-112.
Appendixes
Appendix (1): Lean product development in the sample company Never
1
Rare
2
Not often
3
Often
4
At all
times
5
Questions
Response Rate %
Lean product development
1- Value Stream Map
2.9 0 41.2 35.3 20.6 1- A value stream map is used at developing the
product
0 0 17.6 50.0 32.4 2- Identifying the activities that add a value to the
product
14.7 23.5 32.4 29.4 0 3- Identifying the activities that don’t add a value to
the product.
0 0 8.8 64.7 26.5
4- Reducing the number of used parts in the product
in order to reduce the production time, assembly and
costs, in addition to improving the product's
performance.
2-Set-Based Concurrent Engineering
11.8 00 41.2 38.2 8.8 5-The company's management works on applying
the concurrent engineering by adopting the parallel
activities instead of the sequential activities.
0 0 32.4 44.1 23.5 6-The company's management authorizes the
concurrent engineering team to practice sufficient
powers and make decisions in order to achieve the
given tasks quickly.
0 0 5.9 44.1 50.0 7- The company seeks to develop the product in
order to lean the supply chain's components..
0 2.9 20.6 52.9 23.5 8- The company is working on developing its
products based on several sources like the customers
and development teams, the sales representatives
and others.
3-Visual Management
2.9 17.6 41.2 20.6 17.6 9-The company's management sets up visual signs
like (computer screen, lights, lamps, etc.) in order to
facilitate the common understanding of the product
development team.
20.6 14.7 20.6 44.1 0 10- The used visual signs show the problems to be
visible to everyone.
11.8 26.5 23.5 38.2 0 11-The used visual signs provide a visual picture of
the schedules and phases of the product
development project.
5.9 11.8 35.3 20.6 26.5 12- The visual signs are used in order to take the
preventive measures in a timely manner, and to
reduce the costs and time, in addition to achieving
the quality performance.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
403 http://www.webology.org
4-Quality Improvement
0 23.5 20.6 41.2 14.7 13-The management of the company uses the
warning signals like the sound alarms or lights in
order to indicate the existence of the quality
problems like (manufactured part does not meet the
specifications, damage of the machine or the device,
etc).
14.7 14.7 23.5 38.2 8.8 14- For the purpose of eliminating all defects before
they occur, the company's management chooses
such means as the procedures or simple device in
order to detect errors and fix them immediately.
0 0 8.8 41.2 50.0 15-All working personnel in the factory are
responsible for maintaining the quality of work and
product.
0 8.8 11.8 76.5 2.9 16-The factory management has a plan for
continuous improvement included various activities
in order to avoid the waste, the mistakes.
5-Computer- Aided Design
5.9 44.1 26.5 11.8 11.8
17-The customers' needs and desires are taken into
account when the products designs are developed.
5.9 38.2 23.5 20.6 11.8 18-The company uses the computer aided design
techniques in order to develop the product designs.
0 0 11.8 47.1 41.2 19- The computer aided design techniques
contributes in eliminating the waste of time, the
effort, and cost.
5.9 26.5 38.2 23.5 5.9 20- The computer aided design techniques achieves
a fast product development.
6-Modular Design
0 17.6 20.6 50.0 11.8 21-The company's management uses the modular
design in order to develop the product designs.
0 2.9 32.4 47.1 17.6 22-The modular design reduces the number of
handled parts.
0 2.9 20.6 55.9 20.6 23- The modular design can eliminate the waste of
time, the effort, and cost by simplifying the
purchases, the production, and assembly.
0 2.9 32.4 38.2 26.5 24-The company's management relies on the
modular design to reduce the product delivery time
to customers.
Appendix (2): Lean supply chain in the sample company Never
1
Rare
2
Not often
3
Often
4
At all
time
5
Questions
Response Rate %
Lean supply chain
1-Lean Suppliers
0 5.9 38.2 52.9 2.9
1- The elimination of the non-added value
activities pushes the suppliers to respond quickly
to the changes
0 11.8 14.7 70.6 2.9
2- The company's management works to share the
suppliers in the information in order to reduce the
information volatility.
0 0 20.6 41.2 38.2
3-The company's management relies on a small
number of suppliers at building long-term
relationships with them.
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
404 http://www.webology.org
11.8 14.7 8.8 44.1 20.6 4- The company's management is working hard to
avoid plenty inspection.
2-Lean Procurement
23.5 26.5 14.7 11.8 23.5
5- The company's management follows the
modern methods of procurement, like the method
of electronic procurement in order to carry out
purchases.
0 2.9 41.2 55.9 0
6- The company's management uses the clarity
and transparency with its suppliers in the
procurement processes.
11.8 2.9 44.1 8.8 32.4 7- The company's management depends on the
small and frequent purchase payments.
0 0 14.7 82.4 2.9
8- There is an information exchange flow
between the company's factory and suppliers in
order to reduce the costs and integrate the supply
chain.
3- Lean Manufacturing
0 2.9 32.4 52.9 11.8
9-The factory's management determines the
required quantities of the production due to the
customers' needs and minimum resources.
0 0 38.2 58.8
2.9
10-The factory's management determines the
steps and unnecessary activities that don't add any
value to the customer to reduce the costs and
improve the quality of the product manufacturing.
0 2.9 38.2 35.3 23.5
11-The factory's management is interested in
improving the process and in communicating the
information to the source that requires it at a
timely manner.
0 0 26.5 55.9 17.6
12- The factory's management is working hard to
make parts movement fast in all stages of the
production and supply network in order to meet
customers' demands.
4-Lean Warehousing
17.6 0 35.3 41.2 5.9
13- The removal of losses, steps, and activities
that do not add any value to the storage
operations like (the product excess shipping, the
surplus stock and shipping defects that are caused
the returns … etc.
0 0 8.8 52.9 38.2
14- Specifying the basic storage functions that
add value to the storage operations (e.g. material
receipt, store location… etc.).
0 0 8.8 64.7 26.5 15- The Determination of suitable storage areas in
order to minimize the space and costs.
8.8 2.9 38.2 44.1 5.9
16- An efficient information system is used in
order to monitor the movement of the inventories
5-Lean Transportation
0 0 11.8 58.8 29.4
17-The factory administration determines the
movements and activities that are not added any
value to the product (starting from the movement
of materials from the supplier to the warehouse,
and from the stores to the factory or among the
work stations, as well as from the suppliers to
Webology, Volume 18, Special Issue on Information Retrieval and Web Search
September, 2021
405 http://www.webology.org
stores of finished goods).
0 0 2.9 70.6 26.5
18- The factory's management reduces the
transport distances by using methods of
improving the internal ranking and organizing the
work system locations
0 0 8.8 20.6 70.6 19- The factory's management makes the
administrative procedures of transportation easy.
0 5.9 32.4 41.2 20.6 20- The ideal method of transfer is defined as a
gathering of the orders, optimal paths and others
6-Lean Customers
0 0 23.5 70.6 5.9
21- The customers' needs are identified clearly so
that they can add a value to the customers through
their participation.
0 0 17.6 76.5 5.9
22- The factory's management reduces the lead
time and on-time delivery, the appropriate quality
and increased flexibility (in terms of the volume
and mass customization).
0 0 61.8 17.6 20.6 23- Such problems as the delay of delivery that
affect the customers must be identified
0 5.9 26.5 52.9 14.7 24- The procedures must be Implemented in order
to solve the customers’ problems immediately