the basel ii discrimination and distortion

3
Bank loans Ex-ante: Not- risky Ex-post: Not- risky “As expected” Ex-ante: Risky Ex-post: Risky Risk premium collected Ex-ante: Not- risky Ex-post: Risky Ex-ante: Risky Ex-post: Not- risky

Upload: per-kurowski

Post on 16-Apr-2015

53 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

My brief presentation on how the Basel Committee discriminates in favor of "The Infallible" and against "The Risky" with their loony and dangerous capital requirements for banks based on perceived risks.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Basel II discrimination and distortion

Bank loans

Ex-ante: Not-riskyEx-post: Not-risky

“As expected”

Ex-ante: RiskyEx-post: Risky

Risk premium collected

Ex-ante: Not-riskyEx-post: Risky

Danger Zone!!!

Ex-ante: RiskyEx-post: Not-risky

“Great news”

Page 2: The Basel II discrimination and distortion

The Risk Weights of Basel IICLAIMS ON SOVEREIGNS

Credit Rating Risk Weight Capital Required Allowed Leverage

AAA to AA 0% 0.0% Infinity

A+ to A 20% 1.6% 62.5 to 1

BBB+ to BBB- 50% 4.0% 25 to 1

BB+ to B- 100% 8.0% 12.5 to 1

Below B- 150% 12.0% 8.3 to 1

Unrated 100% 8.0% 12.5 to 1

CLAIMS ON CORPORATES

Credit Rating Risk Weight Capital Required Allowed Leverage

AAA to AA 20% 1.6% 62.5 to 1

A+ to A 50% 4.0% 25 to 1

BBB+ to B- 100% 8.0% 12.5 to 1

Below B- 150% 12.0% 8.3 to 1

Unrated 100% 8.0% 12.5 to 1

http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs118b.pdf

Page 3: The Basel II discrimination and distortion

Basel II’s “perceived-risk” discriminationBasel II’s “perceived-risk” discrimination

AAA Rated Not Rated

a. Expected Default Losses (after additional research) 0.02% 1.50%

b. Transaction and further credit investigation costs 0.02% 1.50%

c. Desired Risk Adjusted Margin (“Mark Twain”) 1.00% 1.50%

d. Required Interest Rate Spread 1.04% 4.50%

e. Basic Capital Requirement 8.00% 8.00%

f. Basic Bank Leverage 12.5 to 1 12.5 to 1

g. Basic Expected Return on Equity (c*f) 12.50% 18.75%

h. BASEL II’s Risk-Weight (RW) 20.00% 100.00%

i. Capital Requirement Adjusted for Risk-Weights (e*h) 1.60% 8.00%

j. Risk-Weigh Adjusted Bank Leverage 62.5 to 1 12.5 to 1

k. Estimated Cost of External Funds 4.00% 4.00%

l. Additional external funds per unit of loan 6.40% 0.00%

m. Additional costs of external funds ((k*l)*Δj) 12.80% 0.00%

n. Risk-Weight Adjusted Expected Return On Equity ((c*j)-m) 49.70% 18.75%

Possible Outcomes:

a. Additional R.O.E. Banks provided by BASEL II 37.20%

b. Or: Potential Lower Interest Spread Offered 0.60%

c. Or: Required Higher Interest Spread to Compensate 2.98%

[email protected] http://www.subprimeregulations.blogspot.com/