the aapg century – giant fields through the decades ... · the aapg century – giant fields...

41
The AAPG Century Giant Fields through the Decades* Robert K. Merrill 1 and Charles A. Sternbach 2 Search and Discovery Article #70267 (2017)** Posted June 19, 2017 *Adapted from oral presentation given at AAPG 2017 Annual Convention and Exhibition, Houston, Texas, April 2-5, 2017 **Datapages © 2017 Serial rights given by author. For all other rights contact author directly. 1 Catheart Energy, Inc., Sugar Land, Texas, United States ([email protected] ) 2 Star Creek Energy, Katy, Texas, United States Abstract A giant oil field is generally estimated to contain in excess of 500 MMBOE estimated ultimate recovery. Since the late nineteenth century, at least four factors seem to control the frequency of discovery of giant oil and gas fields. These factors include concepts (e.g., geological models), technology, price, and access to drilling locations. The importance of understanding these factors drove creativity in the exploration process. In our efforts to understand common petroleum system parameters in these fields and, importantly, what is unusual about each field, leads to “Discovery Thinking” in our search for new oil and gas fields. In the mid- to late-nineteenth century the recognition of seeps focused exploration efforts. This was followed by recognizing the importance of anticlines. Petrophysical tools followed in the early 20th century as well as the application of seismic as an exploration tool. These tools continued to be developed and improved with time and processing advances in the 1970's significantly improved our ability to image the subsurface and characterize the reservoir. Advances in drilling technology have led us from the land to deep water. The integration of rock mechanics using geology, geophysics, and engineering in this decade led to new workflows for geologists, geophysicists, and engineers to complete wells in reservoirs previously considered too tight for economic production. This integration brought together intensive core analysis and new sample imaging techniques to characterize the pores in low-permeability rocks that we now recognize as basin-wide “unconventional” fields. Traditional roles in discovering giant fields over previous decades included the “rockers” (geologists well versed in reservoirs), the “trappers” (geophysicists mapping the geometry of accumulations), and the “sealers and the sourcers” (explorers following source rock and seals). More than ever, successful giant field discovery in the decade 2000 through 2010 was led by the “integrators.” If you know how to hammer, every problem is a nail. The enhancement of the tools including Basin analysis,

Upload: others

Post on 21-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades*

Robert K. Merrill1 and Charles A. Sternbach

2

Search and Discovery Article #70267 (2017)** Posted June 19, 2017

*Adapted from oral presentation given at AAPG 2017 Annual Convention and Exhibition, Houston, Texas, April 2-5, 2017

**Datapages © 2017 Serial rights given by author. For all other rights contact author directly.

1Catheart Energy, Inc., Sugar Land, Texas, United States ([email protected]) 2Star Creek Energy, Katy, Texas, United States

Abstract

A giant oil field is generally estimated to contain in excess of 500 MMBOE estimated ultimate recovery. Since the late

nineteenth century, at least four factors seem to control the frequency of discovery of giant oil and gas fields. These factors

include concepts (e.g., geological models), technology, price, and access to drilling locations. The importance of understanding

these factors drove creativity in the exploration process. In our efforts to understand common petroleum system parameters in

these fields and, importantly, what is unusual about each field, leads to “Discovery Thinking” in our search for new oil and gas

fields. In the mid- to late-nineteenth century the recognition of seeps focused exploration efforts. This was followed by

recognizing the importance of anticlines. Petrophysical tools followed in the early 20th century as well as the application of

seismic as an exploration tool. These tools continued to be developed and improved with time and processing advances in the

1970's significantly improved our ability to image the subsurface and characterize the reservoir. Advances in drilling technology

have led us from the land to deep water. The integration of rock mechanics using geology, geophysics, and engineering in this

decade led to new workflows for geologists, geophysicists, and engineers to complete wells in reservoirs previously considered

too tight for economic production. This integration brought together intensive core analysis and new sample imaging techniques

to characterize the pores in low-permeability rocks that we now recognize as basin-wide “unconventional” fields. Traditional

roles in discovering giant fields over previous decades included the “rockers” (geologists well versed in reservoirs), the

“trappers” (geophysicists mapping the geometry of accumulations), and the “sealers and the sourcers” (explorers following

source rock and seals). More than ever, successful giant field discovery in the decade 2000 through 2010 was led by the

“integrators.” If you know how to hammer, every problem is a nail. The enhancement of the tools including Basin analysis,

Page 2: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

geochemistry, cutting-edge seismic imaging, and rock mechanics have become critical additions to the explorer's skill set. The

ingenuity of combined disciplines continues to meet the demands of an energy hungry world. AAPG Memoir 113 documents the

fifth decade of the Giant Fields series.

Selected References

Gries, R.R., 2017, Anomalies: Pioneering Women in Petroleum Geology: 1917-2017: Jewel Publishing LLC, ISBN 978-1-

936499-09-0, 405 p.

Halbouty, M.T., 1970, Geology of Giant Petroleum Fields: American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Memoir 14, 575 p.

Höök, M., B. Söderbergh, K. Jakobsson, and K. Aleklett, 2009, The Evolution of Giant Oil Field Production Behavior: Natural

Resources Research, v. 18/1, p. 39-56

Kelley, W.L., D.R. Harrell, R.S. Bishop, and K. Wells, 2009, Proposition: Global Effort to Model Largest Oil Fields: Oil and

Gas Journal, June 8, 2009, p. 20-25.

Robelius, F., 2007, Giant Oil Fields - The Highway to Oil: Giant Oil Fields and their Importance for Future Oil Production:

Ph.D. Thesis, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, 168 p.

Stone, D.S., 2006, Structures of the Rocky Mountain Foreland: Salt Creek Field, A Prototypical Basement-Involved Thrust-

Generated Fold: Mountain Geologist, v. 43/2, p. 145-156.

Tennyson, M.E., 2005, Growth History of Oil Reserves in Major California Oil Fields during the Twentieth Century: United

States Geological Survey Bulletin 2172-H, p.4.

Website Cited

https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/sedthick/sedthick.html. Website accessed May 2017.

Page 3: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Houston ACE April 2, 2017

Robert K. Merrill and Charles A. Sternbach

The AAPG Century– Giant Fields through the Decades

Page 4: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Why Study Giant Fields? � Contribute prosperity and major wealth transfer for

nations � Provide significant infrastructure with economies of

scale for smaller discovery developments � Global supply tracks giant field output� Giants keep getting bigger� Provide insight into petroleum systems for

exploration and development programs

6/4/2017

Page 5: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Giant fields contribute 60% of Global Production since the 1960’s

6/4/2017

World Crm ie Oil PnxllUl;tiQ-n 1!Jl5-l005

&0 ,-----------------------------------------------------------------

70 +-------------------------------------------------------------~

~60 +---------------------------------------~ ~

~-.. 50

t .. 1 40 +------------------, "­CI. .. ': 30 Q

20 +--------------------------

10 +-------------------

o 1 925 1930 1935 1.94!) 194 5 t 950 195 1 Ii(] 1 6 1 -70 1975 1980 t 9&5 1990 19 5 200!) ?OOS

• Hlsrorlcill IProdLJCdon All Giant s • To 20 Glsnts

H glll"e 3.1 Wodd daily oil production sbol\ing th~ ,eolltJilb nOli of giaut fi~]d5 (K~IDl~y, et 3~_ .2009. Qft~!f Robfliu5, 200 ,and Ho()k, ~t ai, 2009).

World Crm ie Oil PnxllUl;tiQ-n 1!Jl5-l005

&0 ,-----------------------------------------------------------------

70 +-------------------------------------------------------------~

~60 +---------------------------------------~ ~

~-.. 50

t .. 1 40 +------------------, "­CI. .. ': 30 Q

20 +--------------------------

10 +-------------------

o 1 925 1930 1935 1.94!) 194 5 t 950 195 1 Ii(] 1 6 1 -70 1975 1980 t 9&5 1990 19 5 200!) ?OOS

• Hlsrorlcill IProdLJCdon All Giant s • To 20 Glsnts

H glll"e 3.1 Wodd daily oil production sbol\ing th~ ,eolltJilb nOli of giaut fi~]d5 (K~IDl~y, et 3~_ .2009. Qft~!f Robfliu5, 200 ,and Ho()k, ~t ai, 2009).

Page 6: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Giants Keep Getting Bigger!

6/4/2017 From: Tennyson, M.E., 2005, Growth history of oil reserves in major California oil fields during the twentieth centrury; U.S. Geol. Survey Bull. 2172-H, p.4

3,000,000

EXPLANATION Midway-Sunset ~ Buena Vista (1909) - Coalinga E Extension (1938)

2,500,000 - Coles Levee N (1938) - Cymric (1909) - ,- Edison (1928)

>' - Elk Hilis (1 919) "'", - Fruitvale (1928) w-,

- G,.eley (1936) >w 2 ,000,000 0", - Kern Front (1912) Ua:: - Kern River (1899) w «

"'OJ - Kettleman North Dome (1928) w,,- - Lost HHis (1910) !;:o - McKittrick (1896) :;;'" 1,500,000 - Midway-Sunset (1890) _0 ~z - Mount Poso (1926) Elk ::o;li - North Belrldge (1912) 0::0 - Rio Bravo (1937) w o

- Round Mountain (1927) !;:I :;;f- 1,000,000 - South Belridge (1911)

Coalinga _ z Yow)umne (1974) r-'--f- -' . Coalinga (1887) '" w

500,000

O~~~~~~~ 20 40 50 60 70

YEARS SINCE DISCOVERY

3,000,000

EXPLANATION Midway-Sunset ~ Buena Vista (1909) - Coalinga E Extension (1938)

2,500,000 - Coles Levee N (1938) - Cymric (1909) - ,- Edison (1928)

>' - Elk Hilis (1 919) "'", - Fruitvale (1928) w-,

- G,.eley (1936) >w 2 ,000,000 0", - Kern Front (1912) Ua:: - Kern River (1899) w «

"'OJ - Kettleman North Dome (1928) w,,- - Lost HHis (1910) !;:o - McKittrick (1896) :;;'" 1,500,000 - Midway-Sunset (1890) _0 ~z - Mount Poso (1926) Elk ::o;li - North Belrldge (1912) 0::0 - Rio Bravo (1937) w o

- Round Mountain (1927) !;:I :;;f- 1,000,000 - South Belridge (1911)

Coalinga _ z Yow)umne (1974) r-'--f- -' . Coalinga (1887) '" w

500,000

O~~~~~~~ 20 40 50 60 70

YEARS SINCE DISCOVERY

Page 7: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

What is a Giant Field? � Oil: Estimated Ultimate

Recovery (EUR) ≥ 500 MMBO

� Oil and Gas: EUR ≥ 500 MMBOE � Gas conversion = 6000

cu ft per barrel � Gas Field ≥ 3 tcf gas� Supergiant Fields ≥

5 Billion BOE � Megagiant Fields ≥

10 Billion BOE

6/4/2017

Courtesy of Dick Bishop, 2016

957 Giant Fields 97 Super-giant Fields

7 Mega-giant Fields

Page 8: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Future Giants Require � Open access to exploration in remote and challenging

areas � Historical Explorers – “Rockers”, “Trappers” and

“Sealers & Sourcers”� Technological integration: The ingenuity of the

combined disciplines � “Big Data” – Parallel processing & Neural networks � Understanding Reservoirs from the micro to macro scale � Mapping Traps and Migration paths � Geochemistry: Source Rock & HC Generation � Drilling and Completion practices

6/4/2017

Page 9: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

� Database of 1,062 Giant Fields (Mike Horn) � IHS Support � AAPG Archives going back 100 years - Datapages � AAPG Giant Field Memoirs like the upcoming

release, Memoir 113

Source Material

6/4/2017

Mike Horn

2017

Memoir 14

Memoir 30

Memoir 54

Memoir 78

Memoir 113

Page 10: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

1856-1925 1926 - 1945 1946-1970 1971-1987 1988-2005 2006-2017

NU

MBE

R O

F G

IAN

T FI

ELD

S

YEAR

NORTH AMERICA EASTERN EUROPE AND FORMER USSR CENTRAL AND SOUTH AMERICA

MIDDLE EAST ASIA AND OCEANA AFRICA

WESTERN EUROPE

US Dominated Exploration

Globalization/ Mergers

Emerging Countries

GlobalExpansion

Where and When were they Found?

6/4/2017

Post WWII Growth

OPEC/ Nationalization

Page 11: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

1860

1870

1880

1890

1900

1910

1920

1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

2000

2010

2020

Dol

lars

US

Year

Oil Price 2014 USD Nominal Oil Price Real Global Oil Price

Oil Price and Number of Giant Discoveries

6/4/2017

US Dominated Exploration

OPEC/Nationalization

Globalization/ Mergers

Post WWII Growth

Global Expansion Emerging Countries

Nominal = Inflation Adjusted $; Real Global Price = Adjusted for US Dollar Value

0

50

100

150

200

250

Num

ber o

f Gia

nt F

ield

Dis

cove

ries

Page 12: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Concept & Technology Evolution

6/4/2017

Con

cept

s Seeps & Anticlinal Traps

Deep Water Stratigraphic Traps

Petrophysical

Unconventional

Tech

nolo

gy

1850

1900

1910

1920

1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

2000

2010

2020

Rotary Drilling

Geophysical Single Fold

Pre-Stack

3D Seismic Landsat

CDP

Attributes

Drilling & Completion

Stimulation Multi-Stage Enhanced Horizontal

Offshore Evolution Cemented Casing

Resistivity Logs Archie’s Laws

Combined Tools Computing

US Dominated Exploration OPEC/Nationalization n

Globalization/ Mergers

Post WWII Growth Global Expansion Emerging Countries

p Wp WDeepDeepncoUn

Pre

3D Seismicsttt

AttAtt

MncedHorizoo

WWo

ee

catat

rr

MnHorizon

gg

WWo

e

cttt

tt

MnHorizon

gg

nal

e

n

kkss

e

n

k kss

ee

Page 13: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

\ \

Giant Fiel I o Giant

o Super-giant

- 0 Mega-giant

• 1 00 200 lOCI 400

HoustonACE2017

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

\ \

Giant Fiel I o Giant

o Super-giant

- 0 Mega-giant

• 1 00 200 lOCI 400

HoustonACE2017

Page 14: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1850 . 1900

11 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1850 . 1900

11 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 15: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1901 ·1910

8 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1901 ·1910

8 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 16: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Oecade 1911 - 1920

15 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Oecade 1911 - 1920

15 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 17: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1921 - 1930

31 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1921 - 1930

31 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 18: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Oecade 1931 · 1940

48 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Oecade 1931 · 1940

48 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 19: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1941 ·1950

39 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1941 ·1950

39 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 20: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1951 ·1960

99 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1951 ·1960

99 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 21: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1961 -1970

227 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1961 -1970

227 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 22: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1971 - 1980

219 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1971 - 1980

219 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 23: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1981 • 1990

94 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 1981 • 1990

94 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 24: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

,

= .. :::::~ -Giant Fields of the World Decade 1991 · 2000 " "",:-;"";

105 Fields

o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

,

= .. :::::~ -Giant Fields of the World Decade 1991 · 2000 " "",:-;"";

105 Fields

o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 25: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 2001 ·2010

128 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

,

Giant Fields of the World Decade 2001 ·2010

128 Fields

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----~

= .. :::::~ -o 1 00 200 3011 400

Houston ACE 2017

Page 26: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

US Dominated Exploration 1856 – 1925

6/4/2017

US Dominated Exploration

n,

" " GloballzaUonIMergers

OPEC/NationalizaUon

Poat WW II Growth

Global Expansion Giant Fields of=t~he~w~o~rld~n~~S==~ ~=-~~? _~ ~~~-Ius Dominated ~: - 1856 . 1925 .:;;;:» "----'-:7l

-110 ., .. -140 . , .. ., .. .,. , ,. .. .. .. , .. n, '" , .. '"

n,

" " GloballzaUonIMergers

OPEC/NationalizaUon

Poat WW II Growth

Global Expansion Giant Fields of=t~he~w~o~rld~n~~S==~ ~=-~~? _~ ~~~-Ius Dominated ~: - 1856 . 1925 .:;;;:» "----'-:7l

-110 ., .. -140 . , .. ., .. .,. , ,. .. .. .. , .. n, '" , .. '"

Page 27: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

US Dominated Exploration

;.. Prior to 1900 v' Emerging concept of where to

drill- Seeps and Anticlines

;.. 1900 - 1925 v' Surface mapping of Anticlines v' 1914 First 1 D seismic v'

v' First resistivity log

v' 1919 Cementing casing v' Rotary Drilling

6/13/2017 Houston ACE 2017

Courtesy Robbie Gri es, 2016

Page 28: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Salt Creek, Field, Wyoming, USA

Adapted from: Stone, D.S., 2006

6/4/2017

"'''t" -."

~ ... -, 8"$1'"

/ BASIN

, Y" j

Ai ,,'

.1/ ~­/

/

"'''t" -."

~ ... -, 8"$1'"

/ BASIN

, Y" j

Ai ,,'

.1/ ~­/

/

Page 29: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Global Expansion 1926 – 1945

6/4/2017

Global Expansion

Page 30: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ---

Global Expansion

~ 1926 - 1935 " 1928 Reflection seismic " 1930 Stratigraphic traps

~ 1935-1945 " 1938 First offshore drilling " Evolution of petrophysical logs

" 1941 Archie 's laws

" Three cone roller bit " 1941 Diamond bit " Multiple bullet-shot casing

perforator

" Texas RRC - Controlled & cooperative development

6/1312011 Houston ACE 2017

. .. I Ii..-

... . "'. \ -", . . ~ ........ \ .. .....

SCHE:M~AT~'C~~~~~~i,~ • EAST TI BASIN

Page 31: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Post WWII Growth 1946 - 1970 .,.. "00 . , .. -,.. ... ~ "M • • .. .. .. ,.. •• '* '00 I ..

.. •

.. ..

.. Globalization/Mergers ... . .. OPEC/Nationalization

• Post WW II Growth

Giant Fields of the World I~=::;~

~ n~~~~~5~;;L~P~0~st.WWII Gro~wt~h~Lr~~~~--..=i : •

.,.. .,. ., . .lm .too _ _ ~ .M • • .. M .. ,.. I. ,. ,.. '00

6/13/2017 HoustonACE2017

Page 32: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ---

Post WWII Growth ~ 1945 - 1960

" Petrophysical logs evolve " 1947 - Kermac#16 drilled 10 miles

offshore Louisiana

" 1949 -Hydraulic Fracturing license to Haliburton issued by Stanolind

" 1954 Jackup drilling

~ 1961 - 1970 " Digital computers enable 2D seismic,

log analysis, & data management

" 1965 "BrightSpots" " Semisubmersible drilling rig

" Measurement while drilling

~ 1970 - First Giant Fields Memoir 14

6/1312011 Houston ACE 2017

,

-• • ' 11

' . I ~ ::..,...;... '. Q""j ,

b'+

\ .. .. . , . "

Page 33: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

OPEC & Nationalization 1971-1987 . ,.. ., .. , . - - • • • • • ,.. , .. ,. ,

• •

• •

• •

" " Globalization/Mergers

." ." OPEC/Nationa li zation

Post ww II Growth

Giant Fields of the World I~;:::~ OPEC· Nationalization I"' lc.;1

-Global Expansion

- • . '00 ., .. , . • • • • • • '00 , .. ,.. , ..

6/13/2017 HoustonACE2017

Page 34: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

OPEC & Nationalization � Arab Oil Embargo � Seismic technology evolves

� Seismic data in color � Seismic response & interval

attributes � Seismic stratigraphy � 3D seismic emerges

� Petrophysics � 1977 first logging truck equipped

with a computer � 1978 Digital sonic tool (SDT)

� Geochemistry � Directional Drilling � 1980 - Giant Fields Memoir 30

6/4/2017

Page 35: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Globalization & Mergers 1988 – 2005

6/4/2017

Globalization/Mergers

_180 _180 _140 _1:!0 _100 ~O

10 I I I I

OPEC/National_on

Post WW II Growth

Global Expansion

I I -110 -180 -140 -120 -100 ~o

~ , ro " " " '00 '" '" '" '" I I I I I I

Giant Fields of the World ~~-I Globalization· Mergers p=:~=~

1988 . 2005 ~ ~-:7I I ~ ·ro

I ro " " "

I '00

I

'" '" I

'" '"

"

_180 _180 _140 _1:!0 _100 ~O

10 I I I I

OPEC/National_on

Post WW II Growth

Global Expansion

I I -110 -180 -140 -120 -100 ~o

~ , ro " " " '00 '" '" '" '" I I I I I I

Giant Fields of the World ~~-I Globalization· Mergers p=:~=~

1988 . 2005 ~ ~-:7I I ~ ·ro

I ro " " "

I '00

I

'" '" I

'" '"

"

Page 36: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Globalization & Mergers � Seismic attribute analysis

matures � Horizontal drilling & Staged

hydraulic fracturing � First subsalt discovery � 1999 – First dual activity drill

ship � Deep water drilling matures � Giant Fields Memoir 54 – 1992� Giant Fields Memoir 78 – 2003

6/4/2017

Discover Enterrprise from: 1999 Oil & Gas Journal

From: Rigzone

Page 37: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Emerging Countries 2006 – Present

6/4/2017

Emerging Countries

-110

GloballzaUonIMergers

OPEC/NationalizaUon

Poat WW II Growth

Global Expansion

. , .. I -140 . , .. I ., .. I ..,

Giant Fields of the World Emerging Countries

.,. 2006 - Present , I ,. .. I .. .. I , .. I n, '"

I , ..

n,

'"

'"

-110

GloballzaUonIMergers

OPEC/NationalizaUon

Poat WW II Growth

Global Expansion

. , .. I -140 . , .. I ., .. I ..,

Giant Fields of the World Emerging Countries

.,. 2006 - Present , I ,. .. I .. .. I , .. I n, '"

I , ..

n,

'"

'"

Page 38: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ---

Emerging Countries :.- Seismic technology

" Processing algorithms evolve " Multi-attribute analysis matures

" Spectral decomposition and elastic inversion

:.- Subsalt drilling becomes common

:.- New turbidite plays

:.- Source Rocks become reservoir targets " Horizontal drilling " Multi-stagefracs

" M icroseismic

:.- Giant Fields Memoir 113 6/1312011 Houston ACE 2017

Ffom,RoMevil<,ln Q'lISS

From: ZagorSki,ln press

Page 39: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

The Usual, and the Unusual “As we make it a point to learn how these giant fields formed, we should study the modes of occurrence of theaccumulations, the types of trap, how each trap formed and how it was found, the age of the reservoir and the age, or ages, of the sediments in which the petroleum generated and from which it was expelled and migrated to the trap. We should ask ourselves: first, what is usual about each of these accumulations? Andsecond, what is unusual? Then we must concentrate on the unusual, for commonly it isthat unusual aspect which is the key toaccumulation. Prejudiced ideas should be discarded, for it is these old, ingrained, hard-nosed prejudices which also stifle exploration; old prejudices must not be tolerated in our thinking of the future.”

6/4/2017

Page 40: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades

Houston ACE 2017

Where We Have Been

6/4/2017

Sediment Thickness in meters

https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/sedthick/sedthick.html

10 •• •• 0 • -10 I

0

-70 0 20

0 .... .. , ~ ... , OO"~ ~

OO~ I/ O • • ..... /' ¢Ill> f ~

0

i

40

, ,<~JO • ., • '\ • • , -'=t •• 8 ~· • , d· . r!

" o~ .-'

£ . ~

• 0 '" • ifT .....

q,0 ... " ... ~(. • ." ~; 0 ~~. 0 ",{t . 4..:P.:. ~ . , 1- · o .. .~ .0 \ • 0 . • "" -., ,.

tIP , ,J <»

• • 0

• .. (,. .. 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320

O.....Jr.Nw~Olm-....JCX>C'O.....Jr......Jr......lr......Jr......Jr......lr......lr......Jr......Jr......Jr.

0000000000 0000000000 0000000000

o

-" N W +:> (]1

o 0 o 0 o 0

000 000 000

OJ ~ ex> (0

000 000 000

o o o

--r: ' f

. 0

340 360

10 •• •• 0 • -10 I

0

-70 0 20

0 .... .. , ~ ... , OO"~ ~

OO~ I/ O • • ..... /' ¢Ill> f ~

0

i

40

, ,<~JO • ., • '\ • • , -'=t •• 8 ~· • , d· . r!

" o~ .-'

£ . ~

• 0 '" • ifT .....

q,0 ... " ... ~(. • ." ~; 0 ~~. 0 ",{t . 4..:P.:. ~ . , 1- · o .. .~ .0 \ • 0 . • "" -., ,.

tIP , ,J <»

• • 0

• .. (,. .. 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320

O.....Jr.Nw~Olm-....JCX>C'O.....Jr......Jr......lr......Jr......Jr......lr......lr......Jr......Jr......Jr.

0000000000 0000000000 0000000000

o

-" N W +:> (]1

o 0 o 0 o 0

000 000 000

OJ ~ ex> (0

000 000 000

o o o

--r: ' f

. 0

340 360

Page 41: The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades ... · The AAPG Century – Giant Fields through the Decades* . Robert K. Merrill. 1. and Charles A. Sternbach. 2. Search and

80

70 • 60

50

40

30

-'0 -20

-40

o

,

.. Owowo

I BIOCk 2Q.

,

Giant Oil Fields Through the Decades ----

The Journey Continues

illtYladlmlr Filanoysky .. h agly

-•

Tulimaniq

. " . -..... . ..:.:r.. ....

,-

_ Vac:a Muerta

I .. , . -0((-.. .) 180 200 240 280 300 320 340 360

Sediment Thickness in meters

0 - ~ w ,. ~ 0> ~ - - - - - - - - - -"0 "0 "0 "0 0 0 0 0 - ~ w ,.

~ 0> ~ 0> <0

8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

hnps.lmwwn gdc.n oaa.gov/mgglsedlh icklsedth ickhtml

6/1312011 HoustonACE2017