the 53 abaf-bvfa award for best financial information 2013... · delhaize – cofinimmo – befimmo...
TRANSCRIPT
THE 53rd ABAF-BVFA AWARD
FOR BEST FINANCIAL
INFORMATION
24/10/2013
2 L P A
24/10/2013 3
4
53rd
Awards Ceremony for Best Financial Information
Financial reporting: the secrets of the best recipes
THE 53rd ABAF-BVFA AWARD
FOR BEST FINANCIAL
INFORMATION
Luc Van der Elst – Chairman ABAF-BVFA 24/10/2013 5
6
Interview Mr. Bart De Smet
CEO Ageas
Winner of the 2012 overall Award
By Douglas Geddes (The Crew)
Award 2013
7
Panel
-Wim Hoste (KBC Securities)
-Arnaud Goossens (Emerald Fin. Advisers)
-Ilse Moens (PwC)
Moderator Douglas Geddes (The Crew)
Best Practice: Intro…
8
Film
(The Investor Relations point of view)
Prepared by BIRA
Best Practice: Intro
9
Best Practice:
Annual Report
10
KBC – AbInbev – Telenet – Delhaize – Quest – Belgacom…
Annual Report “Market & Competition”
PwC
Link market discussion to strategic choices
What is clear and what is not
Headline findings – 2013 PwC Pilot Programme benchmarking
40%
Discuss future market trends
83% 11
PwC
External impact on activities
Shanks group
12
13
Befimmo – UCB – Ageas – Cofinimmo…
Annual Report: “Strategy”
PwC
Integrate the business model into other areas of the reporting
What is clear and what is not
Headline findings – 2013 PwC Pilot Programme benchmarking
40%
Make reference to the business model
67% 14
PwC
Base reporting on strategic themes
What is clear and what is not
Headline findings – 2013 PwC Pilot Programme benchmarking
21%
Include strategic priorities
94%
Embed sustainability in strategy
25% 15
PwC
Business model - inputs, outputs and outcomes
Coca Cola - HBC AG
16
17
Umicore – Befimmo – Cofinimmo – Delhaize – Deceuninck …
Annual Report: Risks
17
PwC
Integrate the risks into other areas of the reporting
What is clear and what is not
Headline findings – 2013 PwC Pilot Programme benchmarking
23%
Report the principal risks
96% 18
PwC
Risks and opportunities – current and emerging
Schroders
The key risks are assessed in the light of the
current economic and geographical
environment. The probability and dynamics of
potential costs of the key risks are also
presented in a very concise manner.
The diagram indicates the
assessment of the likelihood,
timeframe and impact of the
emerging risks on the
business.
19
PwC
Risks and opportunities - risk appetite and risk dynamics
Fresnillo
Shows where there is a
difference between the
risk rating and risk
appetite and sets out
what action is being
taken; gives a clear
indication of where there
have been changes in
each risk during the
year, together with an
explanation.
After identifying nine
principal risks, defines
the individual risks in a
table and describes the
action being taken to
mitigate the risk.
Input to Risks
20
21
What is the future of Annual
Reports?
Annual Report
22
Best Practice:
Press releases
23
Press Releases: Topline breakdown
Telenet – Belgacom – Deceuninck - AbI – D’Ieteren – Solvay…
24
Press Releases: Publication delays
Quest – Barco – Deceuninck – Melexis – Mobistar – Nyrstar…
25
Belgacom – EVS – Telenet – KBC – Delhaize – Tessenderlo…
Press Releases: Quarterly Results
26
Best Practice:
Investor Relations
27
“Dear all,
Bekaert will release its third quarter
trading update 2013 on 14 November
before opening of the Brussels stock
exchange.
Please be informed that Bekaert will be in
closed period as from 14 October
onwards.“
Investor Relations: Alert Service
Deceuninck – D’Ieteren – Recticel – Ablynx – Delhaize …
28
Investor Relations: Consensus
29
Can social media be useful for
analysts?
Investor Relations
30
Best Practice:
Website
31
Delhaize – Cofinimmo – Befimmo – KBC – Ageas - Belgacom
Website: Debt Section
32
Best Practice
Want to see more…?
•Full Award 2013 presentation (next week) on
www.abaf-bvfa.be
•PwC survey on Integrated Reporting …
33
Luc Van der Elst Chairman ABAF-BVFA
Award Ceremony
34
The Award Screening Process
35
• 51 companies, 70 analysts, 192 valuation forms
Screening Process
36
• Annual Report (100 points)
• Press Releases (100 points)
• Investor Relations (200 points)
• Website (100 points)
• Overall (500 points)
Screening Process
37
• Companies: 51 (2012: 53)
In: RealDolmen
Out: Devgen / Duvel / Transics
• Analysts: 70 (2012: 74)
Belgium: 57 (53)
Outside Belgium: 13 (21)
Screening Process
38
• Good mix Sell-side and Buy-Side Analysts
Screening Process
39
Screening Process
• Changes versus last year
Separate guidelines for Biotech companies
Additional horizontal analysis for Press Releases
39
40
• Objective : minimum 3 surveys per company
Quality objective and control
41
• Nice distribution of coverage (min. 2 – max. 6)
Quality objective and control
41
42
Results
&
Ranking
43
Theoretical
max. Highest score
Benchmarks
Average Average Average
Overall M&S Bel20
OVERALL 500 412,4 337,9 330,3 359,8
1. ANNUAL REPORT 100 84,7 67,1 65,3 71,8
2. PRESS RELEASES 100 87,6 65,1 60,9 72,3
3. INVESTOR RELATIONS 200 173,7 138,4 139,0 144,0
4. WEBSITE 100 81,8 67,2 65,1 71,7
SECONDARY CLASSIFICATION
Info regarding the past 125 104,7 84,7 82,3 91,0
Info regarding the present 285 238,7 196,8 192,4 207,7
Info regarding the future 90 72,5 56,4 55,6 61,1
Aggregate Results
44
Annual Report
Average Average AverageOverall M&S Bel20
1. ANNUAL REPORT 100 84,7 67,1 65,3 71,8
1.1 Key figures & ratios 10 9,6 6,9 7,5 7,3
1.1.1. Key figures & ratios 5 5,0 3,8 3,7 3,9
1.1.2. Years of history 5 5,0 3,1 3,7 3,4
1.2 Products & Services and Segments 10 10,0 7,4 7,0 8,0
1.3 Competitive position 10 8,0 5,5 5,1 6,1
1.4 Strategy 20 18,7 12,2 11,4 13,5
1.4.1. Info on strategy 10 10,0 6,8 6,4 7,3
1.4.2. Medium to long term objectives 10 9,3 5,4 5,0 6,2
1.5 Financial section 30 28,7 21,8 21,4 22,6
1.5.1. Quality financial statements 10 9,3 7,3 7,2 7,7
1.5.2. Quality of the Notes 20 20,0 14,5 14,2 15,0
Eg info on intangible assets 5 4,7 3,7 3,7 3,9
Eg info on financial debt 5 5,0 3,6 3,7 3,9
Eg info on pension deficit 5 5,0 3,4 3,4 3,8
1.6 Operational and financial risks 10 8,8 6,7 6,5 7,1
1.7 Other (relevant) info 10 8,7 6,7 6,4 7,2
Theoretical
max.Highest score
Benchmarks
45
Press Releases
Average Average AverageOverall M&S Bel20
2. PRESS RELEASES 100 87,6 65,1 60,9 72,3
2.1 FY/HY results: Numbers 20 18,0 14,8 14,3 15,6
2.1.1. Is set of numbers complete? 10 10,0 7,6 7,3 8,1
2.1.2. Is there YoY comparison? 10 9,6 7,2 7,0 7,5
2.2 FY/HY results: Comments 30 27,2 20,0 18,6 22,5
2.2.1. Changes in topline numbers 10 9,2 6,5 6,1 7,2
2.2.2. Quality of comments 10 9,6 6,7 6,2 7,4
2.2.3. Info on segments/ assets 10 9,2 6,8 6,3 7,8
2.3 FY/HY results: Guidance 10 9,6 5,8 5,3 6,7
2.4 FY/HY results: Publication delays 20 20,0 12,0 10,9 13,8
2.4.1. Time to publish full year results 10 10,0 5,7 5,3 6,1
2.4.2. Time to publish half year results 10 10,0 6,3 5,5 7,7
2.5 Quarterly results 10 10,0 6,1 5,6 7,0
2.6 Other 10 8,4 6,4 6,2 6,8
Theoretical
max.Highest score
Benchmarks
46
Investor Relations
Average Average AverageOverall M&S Bel20
3. INVESTOR RELATIONS 200 173,7 138,4 139,0 144,0
3.1 Availability & Reactivity 20 20,0 15,9 15,8 16,3
3.2 Consistency 20 20,0 15,3 15,3 15,9
3.3 Reliability 20 20,0 15,1 15,0 16,2
3.4 Access to senior management 20 20,0 14,7 15,3 13,3
3.5 Date alert service 20 20,0 14,9 14,2 15,5
3.6 Consensus number 20 20,0 9,9 9,4 12,0
3.7 Analyst meetings & Conf. calls 20 18,7 14,2 14,2 14,7
3.8 Insight business model & activities 20 20,0 13,7 14,1 13,8
3.9 Updates on strategy 20 17,3 13,1 13,0 13,7
3.10 Guidance 20 20,0 11,6 12,7 12,5
Theoretical
max.Highest score
Benchmarks*
47
Website
Average Average AverageOverall M&S Bel20
4. WEBSITE 100 81,8 67,2 65,1 71,7
4.1 Operational information 25 20,3 16,3 16,0 16,7
4.1.1. Info on history 10 9,3 6,5 6,3 6,7
4.1.2. Info on services, products, mrkts 10 9,0 7,1 7,1 7,0
4.1.3. Links to other relevant websites 5 4,0 2,7 2,6 3,0
4.2 Financial information 30 29,0 20,1 18,9 23,1
4.2.1. Archive ann. rep./press releases 10 10,0 7,9 7,6 8,2
4.2.2. Archive recent presentations 10 10,0 6,7 6,1 7,8
4.2.3. Info on financial debt 10 9,5 5,5 5,1 7,1
4.3 Investor relations 20 18,5 13,8 13,4 14,5
4.3.1. Contact details of IR 5 5,0 3,4 3,4 3,6
4.3.2. Subscription service 5 5,0 3,4 3,4 3,3
4.3.3. Financial calendar 10 10,0 7,0 6,7 7,6
4.4 Varia 10 8,3 6,7 6,7 6,9
4.4.1. Info on shareholder structure 5 4,3 3,3 3,3 3,3
4.4.2. Info on corporate governance 5 4,4 3,5 3,4 3,6
4.5 Organisation & navigation comfort 15 13,8 10,3 10,1 10,4
Theoretical
max.Highest score
Benchmarks
48
The Award
Rankings
49
3. Cofinimmo
2. Befimmo
1. UCB
Best Annual Report
50
3. UCB
2. Belgacom
1. Telenet
Best Press Releases
51
3. GIMV
2. Deceuninck
1. KBC
Best Investor Relations
52
3. Delhaize
2. Belgacom
1. KBC
Best Website
53
Winner 2011: Belgacom
Winner 2010: Umicore
Winner 2012: Ageas
Not eligible overall 2013 Award:
54
5. Belgacom
4. Umicore
3. Telenet
2. UCB
1. KBC
Ranking Overall Award 2013
All screening criteria will be
available on www.abaf-bvfa.be
as from tomorrow
Detailed individual scores will be
made available asap to the
participating companies via BIRA
55
Lottery
Offered by
Ann Vanlommel, Managing Director
56