thayer how india-vietnam strategic ties are mutually beneficial

Upload: carlyle-alan-thayer

Post on 04-Jun-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    1/13

    Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

    How India-Vietnam

    Strategic Ties AreMutually Beneficial

    ietnams defense relations with

    India lessen its near total defensedependency on Russia.

    L ,

    H ,

    G C I

    . I

    /

    .

    G I

    . I , I

    $100

    . I

    A. A

    .

    I BM

    .

    , I

    500

    I .

    I . I 1982,

    I

    J C E, C,

    C .

    I 1980 1990. M 1994, M 2000 M 2003.

    By Carl Thayer

    December 03, 2013

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    2/13

    2007 I

    I

    M D. J D

    : , ;

    ; ; ;

    .

    J D ,

    :

    F, I D .

    2007.

    , I ,

    , .

    , I

    .

    F, , I

    , ,

    , .

    F, I

    .

    , I

    , , , ,

    HI/AID, .

    . I

    D 2007, I D M A. K. A M

    , G , H. M , ,

    . A I 5,000

    I

    .

    2007, , I

    , . I

    A 2008, A 2009, MJ

    2010, M 2011, J 2011, M 2012.

    I F 2008, A M, C A C,

    H L. G. K , C

    A (A). I ,

    L. G. , D C, I

    D D (DD).

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    3/13

    G .

    I 2009, D M G I.

    L. G. H L, A D C , H

    C I A, G K J 2010. G

    , ,

    ,

    .

    D M A. K. A H 2010

    AEA D M M . D

    G .

    ,

    , , . I

    ,

    , .

    , I .

    I J 2011, A H, C ,

    I F A

    C. H I .

    I D K D

    H 2011.

    , , .

    .

    , I

    . D K

    M D . I

    : , 30,

    , .

    I B . I I ,

    .

    D D M C G , L. G. D B

    I 2013. H

    D C C

    C I A F. G

    E C.

    I ,

    C

    . I I

    E A, . F , I C

    .

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    4/13

    D . I

    , , . I

    AEA,

    AEA F I

    C.

    I , , ,

    . I ,

    I .

    G I, J

    C. A

    C .

    L A C.

    Reply

    A (?) ,

    C 1978, I

    . B .

    ,

    .

    F , , C ,

    , . B I

    . ,

    2.5+ C

    . ,

    .

    Reply

    @,

    B !

    F, , .

    . I D G

    An Nam

    December 4, 2013 at 05:04

    nirvana

    December 4, 2013 at 00:29

    Little Helmsman

    December 4, 2013 at 05:35

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    5/13

    ! F , H.

    M , , .

    H .

    H

    ,

    , ,

    .

    H . .

    . C

    .

    C C

    C

    . C

    .

    2013 C .

    C C

    C ! !

    B, I H

    ! C C

    ? 86 C

    , , .?

    I I

    .

    Reply

    , , ,

    .

    , .

    C ,

    C

    .

    Mark TruongDecember 4, 2013 at 14:24

    nirvana

    December 5, 2013 at 02:39

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    6/13

    @ M ,

    I L H

    . H

    C ( I

    ). B

    .

    , .

    . B

    , I ,

    .

    I BM

    .

    H C

    ? I C

    . C

    I.

    , ,

    . D

    1979? I , I

    . LL.

    C A. M

    . B C

    , . , .

    . A

    C ?

    A C .

    C . C.

    L A C . B .

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    7/13

    B?

    A C, F

    . CHIA

    ..

    ..

    C

    I

    . .

    , C I 2, 3 4

    . J

    . I

    &

    . B

    , .

    : A M, C A C, . H

    C C C.

    I. F

    , I

    I .

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    8/13

    I I

    . I ,

    F, A, C I

    .

    , I

    . , A,

    . , ,

    MG21, C J8 J10

    . I ,

    .

    I , I I.

    A C , A . I M 2010, A 90

    .

    :

    ://../2013/06/

    10.

    ://../.?=88342

    A ?

    G I

    .

    F : I

    M D,

    A . I A

    124 , A

    90. I

    , .

    A , . I MD

    .

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    9/13

    : A .

    25 , C 99 (40

    ), 90 (

    25 ).

    : I . A 23.9 /,

    A 90 (26.3 /),

    99 (28 /), M1A1 A (24.5 /), AM

    56 (27.2 /) .

    A, . A $2 ,

    .

    F, ,

    , , . B

    , .

    ..

    1000

    D

    I M D,

    A

    .

    I M D I A/MD. I , I

    A D G A, I A

    90

    . MD DD MB

    A A.

    I MD ,

    .

    I A,

    DD, . H,

    A 90, A

    MD ,

    .

    90 A ,

    50% , ,

    . B , A

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    10/13

    , 60

    , ,

    / ,

    A .

    , ,

    MG21 C ?

    L , M 2000.

    ,

    ( I D M):

    M : M 1.8

    : 850

    C : 300

    M : 6800

    MG 21 ( J, FA):

    M : M 2

    : 1110

    C : 330

    M : 4700

    A , MG21 ,

    , ,

    M21.

    A M 2000.

    I I , F

    . I

    I

    .

    ,

    I A

    . I L CA (LCA). A

    , .

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    11/13

    ,

    , , ,

    21. ,

    , 21 ,

    . ,

    3 .

    , A . B

    .

    120 , 7.62 A ,

    12.7 , 2 9

    , ,

    , , BC

    . C

    ://../

    70/, 40/

    . ,

    60/.

    C , A 90,

    .

    ://..//2.

    A

    ://../.?

    =&=1777

    C ,

    , ,

    . :)

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    12/13

    A ,

    .

    , , DD

    .

    A

    .

    . ,

    A

    A . A, ,

    ( )

    .

    D . A D

    .

    A ,

    .

    A

    A

    .

    , A (

    ), ,

    .

    DD .

    AEA

    .. .

    1.3

  • 8/13/2019 Thayer How India-Vietnam Strategic Ties Are Mutually Beneficial

    13/13