thanks so much for all the data: the amundsen sea sector data set: applications with umism: where...

52
Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James L Fastook University of Maine We thank the NSF, which has supported the development of this model over many years through several different grants.

Upload: tracey-bennett

Post on 28-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set:

Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future?

Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set:

Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future?

James L Fastook

University of Maine

We thank the NSF, which has supported the development of this model over many years through several different grants.

James L Fastook

University of Maine

We thank the NSF, which has supported the development of this model over many years through several different grants.

Page 2: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

BEDMAP vs AGASEA/BBAS*

Airborne Geophysical survey of the Amundsen Sea Embayment (Holt et al., 2006 & Vaughan et al., 2006)

Page 3: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Embedded ModelsEmbedded Models

● High-resolution, limited domain

– runs inside

● Low-resolution, larger domain model.

● Modeling the whole ice sheet allows margins to be internally generated.

– No need to specify flux or ice thickness along a boundary transecting an ice sheet.

● Specification of appropriate Boundary Conditions for limited-domain model, based on spatial and temporal interpolations of larger-domain model.

● High-resolution, limited domain

– runs inside

● Low-resolution, larger domain model.

● Modeling the whole ice sheet allows margins to be internally generated.

– No need to specify flux or ice thickness along a boundary transecting an ice sheet.

● Specification of appropriate Boundary Conditions for limited-domain model, based on spatial and temporal interpolations of larger-domain model.

Page 4: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 16263 nodes, 40 km

Page 5: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 9000 nodes, 10 km

Page 6: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 10920 nodes, 5 km

Page 7: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 6402 nodes, 5 km

Page 8: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 9000 nodes, 10 km

Page 9: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 10920 nodes, 5 km

Page 10: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 6402 nodes, 5 km

Page 11: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 10920 nodes, 5 km

Page 12: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grids: 6402 nodes, 5 km

Page 13: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Nested Grid: Summary & runtimes

Grid

Nodes

DeltaX

DeltaT

Steps

Time/step(s)

Time(hr)

A116263

40 10 4000

0.81 0.9

E1 9000

10 5 8000

0.80 1.8

F110920

5 140000

0.88 9.8

G1 6402

5 140000

0.54 6.0

Full36000

5 140000

2.9 (est) 32.0

Page 14: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Vostok Temperature Proxy

Page 15: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Area-growth and retreat

Page 16: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Volume-growth and retreat

Page 17: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Water Peak during retreat

Page 18: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Data (Rignot 2004) and Results

1

3

5

7

9

2

4

6

Page 19: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Data (Lang 2004) and Results

65

4

3

2

1

Page 20: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: velocity

Page 21: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: bed

Page 22: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: thickness

Page 23: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: water

Page 24: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: velocity

Page 25: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: velocity

Page 26: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: bed

Page 27: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: thickness

Page 28: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: water

Page 29: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: velocity

Page 32: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Growth and retreat: water

● See AGASEA:Water● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-2

006/AGASEA%3AWater.html

Page 34: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Thwaites: velocity

● See Thwaites:Velo● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-2

006/Thwaites%3AVelo.html

Page 36: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: Thickness

● See PIG:Thick● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/PIG%3AThick.html

Page 37: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: velocity

● See PIG:Velo● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/PIG%3AVelo.html

Page 38: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

PIG: water

● See PIG:Water● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/PIG%3AWater.html

Page 39: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Future Retreat ScenariosFuture Retreat Scenarios

● Beginning with end of glacial cycle

– Run 100 years with conditions that produced present grounding line position.

– Then 1900 years with 1.00 Weertman thinning at grounding line wherever the bed is below 550 m.

● Beginning with end of glacial cycle

– Run 100 years with conditions that produced present grounding line position.

– Then 1900 years with 1.00 Weertman thinning at grounding line wherever the bed is below 550 m.

Page 40: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Weertman Parameter

Page 41: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Future Retreat ScenariosFuture Retreat Scenarios

● Beginning with end of glacial cycle

– Run 100 years with conditions that produced present grounding line position.

– Then 1900 years with 1.00 Weertman thinning at grounding line wherever the bed is below 550 m.

● Two Cases:

1. Condition is applied everywhere.

• Ross and Filchner-Ronne, as well as East Antarctica.

2. Condition is only applied in Amundsen Sea Sector.

• Two distinct patterns of retreat emerge for these two cases.

● Beginning with end of glacial cycle

– Run 100 years with conditions that produced present grounding line position.

– Then 1900 years with 1.00 Weertman thinning at grounding line wherever the bed is below 550 m.

● Two Cases:

1. Condition is applied everywhere.

• Ross and Filchner-Ronne, as well as East Antarctica.

2. Condition is only applied in Amundsen Sea Sector.

• Two distinct patterns of retreat emerge for these two cases.

Page 42: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 1: thickness

● See Case 1:Thick● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 1%3AThick.html

Page 43: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 1: velocity

● See Case 1:Velo● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 1%3AVelo.html

Page 44: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 1: water

● See Case 1:Water● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 1%3AWater.html

Page 45: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 2: thickness

● See Case 2:Thick● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 2%3AThick.html

Page 46: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 2: velocity

● See Case 2:Velo● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 2%3AVelo.html

Page 47: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 2: water

● See Case 2:Water● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 2%3AWater.html

Page 48: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Future: water percent & volume

Page 49: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

1. Conclusions: Past cycle1. Conclusions: Past cycle

• From a modeler’s perspective the new data set is great.

• The nested, embedded model captures the salient features of the Amundsen Sea Sector velocity field.

• The water system is

- dendritic, - follows bed topography, - appears to be decreasing in area as the present

is approached, - with peak water volumes during or just prior to

periods of retreat.

• From a modeler’s perspective the new data set is great.

• The nested, embedded model captures the salient features of the Amundsen Sea Sector velocity field.

• The water system is

- dendritic, - follows bed topography, - appears to be decreasing in area as the present

is approached, - with peak water volumes during or just prior to

periods of retreat.

Page 50: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

2. Conclusions: Future retreat2. Conclusions: Future retreat

• Retreat scenarios depend strongly on whether grounding-line thinning is confined to the Amundsen Sector (Case 2) or involve the Ross and Filchner-Ronne too (Case 1).

• In Case 1, retreat is much faster and more extensive, and comes in from behind the Amundsen Sea Sector.

• Case 2 looks more like the classic “weak underbelly” with retreat in Thwaites and up the PIG with a non-smooth episodic retreat punctuated by pulses of water production that seem to precede retreat steps.

• Retreat scenarios depend strongly on whether grounding-line thinning is confined to the Amundsen Sector (Case 2) or involve the Ross and Filchner-Ronne too (Case 1).

• In Case 1, retreat is much faster and more extensive, and comes in from behind the Amundsen Sea Sector.

• Case 2 looks more like the classic “weak underbelly” with retreat in Thwaites and up the PIG with a non-smooth episodic retreat punctuated by pulses of water production that seem to precede retreat steps.

Page 51: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 1: Rate

● Case 1:Rate● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 1%3ARate.html

Page 52: Thanks SO Much for ALL the Data: The Amundsen Sea Sector Data Set: Applications with UMISM: Where and How Much WATER? What WILL happen in the future? James

Case 2: Rate

● See Case 2:Rate● Requires bandwidth, movies are large…● http://tulip.umcs.maine.edu/~shamis/iweb/WAIS-

2006/Case 2%3ARate.html