test.ssla.rutest.ssla.ru/dissertation/dissert/23-11-2015-1do.pdf · 2015. 11. 23. · created date:...

2
OT3bIB HayrlHoro pyKoBoAI'ITeJrfl o Arrccepra rlr u IIIyivr o nofi Kpucru nsI A.nexca HApoBH bI Ha TeMy: <<ilpunqurrbr MeArraqu[>, rrpeAcraBJreHHofi Ha corrcKaH[e yueuoft cTerreHrr Ka HArrA aTa rop r.rA n rrecKrrx HayK rro c [equaJr bHocTrr 12.00.15 - rparr(Aancnufi rpoqecc; apdurpaxHufi rpoqecc ,{uccepraqzx K.A. Illyl,ronofi nocB.f,rrleHa anryamnofi reMe. Ourrr coBpeMeHHoro pa3Bvrrurfl. MeAr4arluu qpe3Bblqafino saxeH TeM, qro o[peAeneHrle MecTo 3aKoHoAaTeJrbcTBa o MeAr.raqvrvr B cucTeMe coBpeMeHHoIo poccuficxoro rrpaBa AoJrxrHo KoHrlenryzrJrbHo c$oplarEpoBarb cucreMy poccnficxofi ue4uaquu, He 3aropMo3rrB peQoputtpoBaHze rpaxAaHcKoro cyAorlpou3BoAcrBa B groM HarrpaBneHvrr\ c nan6oree BbrcoKLrM rcoe$$raql4eHToM noJle3Horo Aeficrnnx MexaHr{3Ma yperyirkrpoBaHus, cnopoB c rloMolqbro MeAl{aropoB. llpuuuuax ro BHr{MaHr.Ie, qTO MeAr4ArJVrs. B ee coBpeMeHHoM TIOHHMaH?IH AJIf, POCCUU cpaBHlrreJrbHo HoBoe npaBoBoe rBJreHI,Ie (xorx, KaK LI3BecrHo, caMo uo ce6e ypefyJrr4poBaHI{e roHSrlltrron c rroMorrlblo He3aBlrcr4Mofo rrocpeAHr{Ka rrorBr4Jrocb paHee rccyAapcrBeHHoro cy4a), cJreAyer fILITbIBam Ia oco6eHHocrl4 pocczficroro MeHT€rJrr{Tera. Kar clpaBeAJrr4Bo orMeqaerc.f, B AI{ccepraIII4r{, rrpr4HlrB 03 (O MeAr,rarlr4r4>, 3aKoHoAarenb BHec B rrpoqeccyulrrbHbre KoAeKcbI MI'IHI{M€TJIbHOE KOJII{qECTBO HOPM, PE|YNI{PYIOqI4X TIPI{MEHEHI{E AAHHO|O LTHCTT{TyTa B paMKaX fpaxAaHcKofo cyAorrpou3BoAcTBa, ocTaBI{B TeM caMbIM Mecro nu6o Arrfl cyAeficr<oro ycMorpeHnr, nu6o Anfl npLIMeHeHI{t cy.urefi AH€LJIO|I'IU 3AKOHA ]/ITI]/. AHAJIO|I{I{ ilPABA. IIPUUqUUbI MEA}IATIAEHOfi IPOIIEAYPbI, oilr{cblBaeMbre B 3aroge (O Me4uaIJvrkr>>, TaKxte Aaror HaM ocHoBaHI,Ie yrBepxAarb, qro pefyJrr4poBaHr4e AaHHoro rlpaBoBoro I,IHcrLITyra qpe3Bblqafiso rroBepxHocTHo. Haru.{ue llpoerra Kouqeuquu KoAexca rpa)I(AaHcKoro cyAonpou3BoAcrBa B Hacrorrrlee BpeMr He BHocvr cra6umHocrr{ B paccMarpHeaeN,Irrfi AucceprauToM Borrpoc o MeAr4arlrrr4, HecMorpf, Ha H€uIHqI4e rlpeAno)KeHl{t o BBeAeHuu ruasa 15 <flpnrr,rr.rpr{TeJrbHbre npoqeAyprr. MzpoBoe corJIaIxeHI{e), a noroMy BbIBoAhI t4 ronoxeHux, c sopvrynlrpoBaHnrr e K. A. Illyrvronofi B Al4cc ep r ar\krvr, I{Meror o co6 oe 3HAIICHI4E. flocraereHHble Ar.rccepraHToM 3a4aqa flBJltrorc.a cBoeBpeMeHHbIMI4 vr vrx MoxrHo crrr4Tarb perxeHHbrMvr, aqenb pa6otn - paspa6orKa HayrIHo o6ocuoeaHHofi cr{creMbr rrpr{HrlufloB MeAra a rJkrvr, a raKxe p eKoMeHA a\uit rro c oBeplueHcrBoBaHuro 4eficrnyorlero 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa o Meg'uan.1larz., ToJIKoBaHI{Io u [puMeHeHnro HOpM, 3aKpenJrsroulr4x rrpr{Hllrrnbr MeAI{aIII{I{ Ha OCHOBe I|IX KOMnJIeKCHO|O TeopeTl,rKo-npaBoBofo aHarru3a, rro3BoJlf,Iolrlefo onTI{MI{3I4poBaTb IIpI4MeHeHI4e

Upload: others

Post on 01-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: test.ssla.rutest.ssla.ru/dissertation/dissert/23-11-2015-1do.pdf · 2015. 11. 23. · Created Date: 11/23/2015 10:57:03 AM

OT3bIB HayrlHoro pyKoBoAI'ITeJrfl

o Arrccepra rlr u IIIyivr o nofi Kpucru nsI A.nexca HApoBH bI

Ha TeMy: <<ilpunqurrbr MeArraqu[>,

rrpeAcraBJreHHofi Ha corrcKaH[e yueuoft cTerreHrr

Ka HArrA aTa rop r.rA n rrecKrrx HayK rro c [equaJr bHocTrr

12.00.15 - rparr(Aancnufi rpoqecc; apdurpaxHufi rpoqecc

,{uccepraqzx K.A. Illyl,ronofi nocB.f,rrleHa anryamnofi reMe. OurrrcoBpeMeHHoro pa3Bvrrurfl. MeAr4arluu qpe3Bblqafino saxeH TeM, qro o[peAeneHrleMecTo 3aKoHoAaTeJrbcTBa o MeAr.raqvrvr B cucTeMe coBpeMeHHoIo poccuficxororrpaBa AoJrxrHo KoHrlenryzrJrbHo c$oplarEpoBarb cucreMy poccnficxofi ue4uaquu,He 3aropMo3rrB peQoputtpoBaHze rpaxAaHcKoro cyAorlpou3BoAcrBa B groM

HarrpaBneHvrr\ c nan6oree BbrcoKLrM rcoe$$raql4eHToM noJle3Horo AeficrnnxMexaHr{3Ma yperyirkrpoBaHus, cnopoB c rloMolqbro MeAl{aropoB. llpuuuuax roBHr{MaHr.Ie, qTO MeAr4ArJVrs. B ee coBpeMeHHoM TIOHHMaH?IH AJIf, POCCUU

cpaBHlrreJrbHo HoBoe npaBoBoe rBJreHI,Ie (xorx, KaK LI3BecrHo, caMo uo ce6eypefyJrr4poBaHI{e roHSrlltrron c rroMorrlblo He3aBlrcr4Mofo rrocpeAHr{Ka

rrorBr4Jrocb paHee rccyAapcrBeHHoro cy4a), cJreAyer fILITbIBam Ia oco6eHHocrl4

pocczficroro MeHT€rJrr{Tera. Kar clpaBeAJrr4Bo orMeqaerc.f, B AI{ccepraIII4r{,rrpr4HlrB 03 (O MeAr,rarlr4r4>, 3aKoHoAarenb BHec B rrpoqeccyulrrbHbre KoAeKcbI

MI'IHI{M€TJIbHOE KOJII{qECTBO HOPM, PE|YNI{PYIOqI4X TIPI{MEHEHI{E AAHHO|O

LTHCTT{TyTa B paMKaX fpaxAaHcKofo cyAorrpou3BoAcTBa, ocTaBI{B TeM caMbIM

Mecro nu6o Arrfl cyAeficr<oro ycMorpeHnr, nu6o Anfl npLIMeHeHI{t cy.urefi

AH€LJIO|I'IU 3AKOHA ]/ITI]/. AHAJIO|I{I{ ilPABA. IIPUUqUUbI MEA}IATIAEHOfi IPOIIEAYPbI,

oilr{cblBaeMbre B 3aroge (O Me4uaIJvrkr>>, TaKxte Aaror HaM ocHoBaHI,Ie

yrBepxAarb, qro pefyJrr4poBaHr4e AaHHoro rlpaBoBoro I,IHcrLITyra qpe3Bblqafiso

rroBepxHocTHo.

Haru.{ue llpoerra Kouqeuquu KoAexca rpa)I(AaHcKoro cyAonpou3BoAcrBa

B Hacrorrrlee BpeMr He BHocvr cra6umHocrr{ B paccMarpHeaeN,Irrfi AucceprauToMBorrpoc o MeAr4arlrrr4, HecMorpf, Ha H€uIHqI4e rlpeAno)KeHl{t o BBeAeHuu ruasa 15

<flpnrr,rr.rpr{TeJrbHbre npoqeAyprr. MzpoBoe corJIaIxeHI{e), a noroMy BbIBoAhI t4

ronoxeHux, c sopvrynlrpoBaHnrr e K. A. Illyrvronofi B Al4cc ep r ar\krvr, I{Meror o co6 oe

3HAIICHI4E.

flocraereHHble Ar.rccepraHToM 3a4aqa flBJltrorc.a cBoeBpeMeHHbIMI4 vr vrx

MoxrHo crrr4Tarb perxeHHbrMvr, aqenb pa6otn - paspa6orKa HayrIHo o6ocuoeaHHoficr{creMbr rrpr{HrlufloB MeAra a rJkrvr, a raKxe p eKoMeHA a\uit rro c oBeplueHcrBoBaHuro

4eficrnyorlero 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa o Meg'uan.1larz., ToJIKoBaHI{Io u [puMeHeHnro

HOpM, 3aKpenJrsroulr4x rrpr{Hllrrnbr MeAI{aIII{I{ Ha OCHOBe I|IX KOMnJIeKCHO|O

TeopeTl,rKo-npaBoBofo aHarru3a, rro3BoJlf,Iolrlefo onTI{MI{3I4poBaTb IIpI4MeHeHI4e

Page 2: test.ssla.rutest.ssla.ru/dissertation/dissert/23-11-2015-1do.pdf · 2015. 11. 23. · Created Date: 11/23/2015 10:57:03 AM

npr{Mrapr{TeJrbHofi rporreAypbr c yqacrLleM rocpeAH?IKa e Pocc[ficrofi @egepaqun

- Aocrr4rHyrofi.K.A. Illyuoaofi 6rrna npoBeAeHa 6oruruas LrccJleAoBareJlbcKafl pa6ora uo

r43yqeHlrro rpyAoB poccuficrux yqeHbIX-rpaBoBeAoB, HopM lpaxAaHcKoroflpoqeccyaJrbHoro, ceMeftHoro, fpaxAaHcKoro I{ tIHbIX orpaclefi [paBa, a raK xea1anu3a cy4e6uofi npaKTr4KLr. Teoperl4rlecKa{ vr gMnl4pllrlecKaf, 6asn

I4 CCneAOB aHVrfl, .4OCTaTOqHbI.

,{uccepraqur rrafikrcana aBToPoM caMocrotreJrbHo, o6naAaer

BHyTpeHHI4M eAI{HCTBOM, COAepXHT HOBbIe HayqHble pe3yJrbTaTbr vr

noJroxeHns, BbrqBr.rraeMbre 4r.a uy6nuqHofi 3aIrII,ITbI. B 4IaCCepTATIUU BrIepBbIe B

HayKe fpaxAaHcKoro npoqeccyaJrbHofo npaBa cI4cTeMa IpI4HIII{IOB MeAI{aIIULI

paccMarptrBaercs, KaK rpurepufi sQQexrunnofi peanu3ar\krur npuv,r4pLrrelrnofi

rporleAypbr c yqacTlreM nocpeAHuKa B paMKax rpaxAaHcKofo cyAorlpol43BoAcrBa.

Csopnrynr{poBaHHbre vr o6ocnosaHHue B uccJleAoBanukr BbIBoAbI [oMoryrpaculrpr{Tb TeopeTl4rrecKI{e npeAcTaBJreHI{t o Bo3Mo)KHOCT.f,X UeAUarUnnOfi

rrpaKTrlKr4 c yrreroM ucrunuofi peaJrr43allnu ee pyKoBoAs[II{x Harl€u B Aocrl{xeHnvrqenn lpaxAaHcKoro cyAorrpor43BoAcrBa. 3ru BbIBoAbI 6yayr noJIe3HbI He roilbKo

.unr flpoqeccyalsHofi Teoprrr{, Ho r,r cyge6nofi [paKTI{KI4, rIpaKTIdKu Mel.vrar\ur4,

MoryT 6rrrr [crroJrb3oBaHbr n yve6uoM rlpoqecce u flBJl.f,Iorct cyqecrBeHHblM

BKJTaAOM B HayKy.

Co4epNaHrae Atraceprar\vrkt coorBercrByer crIeIII4aJIbHocrpI 12.00.15,

Ar{ccepraqna lllyvronofi KpncruHut A.nerccaHApoBHbl Ha reMy: <<Ilpunqnnut

MeArraquu)> .rrBJrrerc.f, HayqHo-KB€rJrl{Suraquounofi pa6orofi, coorBercrByloqefi

llonoxeur4ro o [oprAKe rrpucyxAeHr{f, yrIeHbIX crelleHefi, B Koropofi co4epxl{TctperxeHr{e 3a4aql4, I,IMeloqefr 3HalIeHI{e l.nfl pa3BI4TLIfl' rpaxAaHcKoro

npoqeccy€urbHofo npaBa, a ocHoBHbre BbIBoAbI HaIUJIPI AOCTaTOTIHOe OTpaX{eHI4e B

ny6nuraqrErx vr AoKJraAax Ha rcon$epenlll{f,x. ,{uccepraqur orBerlaer

rrpeAbrBnf,eMbrM K Ar{cceprarlraoHHbrrra pa6oravr rpe6onalnvrflv', a ee aBTop - K.A.

Lllyuoea, 6es scsxoro coMHenvrfl,3acrryxl{Baer rrpl4cy]KAenvrfl efi yreuofi crenenu

KaHAHAara ropuApIrIecKI,IX HayK.

,{orrop rcpI{AHq e crculr HaYK,

npoSeccop ZcaenKosa

Y,reHbr{ ce{perapbOe4eparbHoe rocyAapcraenxoe 6o4xerroe

OA