technology to fast-track learning in regional anesthesia
TRANSCRIPT
@EMARIANOMD
@@EMARIANOMD
Technology to Fast-Track Learning in
Regional AnesthesiaEdward R. Mariano, M.D., M.A.S.
Professor of Anesthesiology, Perioperative & Pain MedicineStanford University School of Medicine
Chief, Anesthesiology and Perioperative CareVeterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System
@EMARIANOMD
Financial Disclosures
• Halyard Health, B Braun – Unrestricted educational program funding paid to my institution
The contents of the following presentation are solely the responsibility of the speaker without input from any of the above companies.
@EMARIANOMD
Overview
• The “learning curve” • Technology for teaching and learning• Technology for assessment
@EMARIANOMD
Overview
• The “learning curve” • Technology for teaching and learning• Technology for assessment
@EMARIANOMD
How Hard Can It Be?
NYSORA.COM -
@EMARIANOMD
The “10,000 Hours Rule”
@EMARIANOMD
Deliberate Practice
Ericsson. Acad Emerg Med 2008;15:988
@EMARIANOMD
Regional Anesthesia “Learning Curve”
Reg Anesth. 1996;21:182
@EMARIANOMD
Learning Curve for UGRA
RAPM 2004;29:544
@EMARIANOMD
Novice Behavior
• 520 ultrasound-guided nerve block captured on video and reviewed– 7 errors: needle not visualized, inadequate
equipment preparation, poor ergonomics, target malpositioning on screen, unintentional probe movement, awkward hand position on needle, and excessive visual focus on hands
• By the 60th block, still 2.8 errors per block
Sites, et al. RAPM 2007;32:107
@EMARIANOMD
Barrington, et al. RAPM 2012;37:334
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. RAPM 2016;41:151
Avg 7 (2–22 min)for the control group vs. 48 (29–65 min) for the DP group (p<0.001).
No other differences!
@EMARIANOMD
Predictors of Learning UGRA
Shafqat, et al. Anesth 2015;123:1188
@EMARIANOMD
Predictors of Learning UGRA
Shafqat, et al. Anesth 2015;123:1188
Maybe we are not all the same!
@EMARIANOMD
Overview
• The “learning curve” • Technology for teaching and learning• Technology for assessment
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
@EMARIANOMD
What Is “Simulation”?
79 articles involving simulation were reviewed:1. Simulation-based educational interventions
(14)2. Novel simulator design (18)3. Use of a simulated environment as an
experimental setting (11)4. Other/outside scope of review (36)
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
Studies of Simulation Interventions
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
Studies of Simulator Design
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
Inorganic Simulator
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
Organic Simulator
@EMARIANOMD
“Hybrid” Simulator
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
@EMARIANOMD
Ramlogan R, et al. RAPM 2017;42: 217http://www.pie.med.utoronto.ca/VSpine/index.htm
NEW!
@EMARIANOMD
Udani & Mariano, et al. Local Reg Anesth 2015;8:33
Studies Using a Simulation Setting
@EMARIANOMD
Anesthesiology-DirectedAdvancedProcedural Training
@EMARIANOMD
Lectures,
Scanning
Iterative Practice,Simulatio
n
8 Hour Program
Mariano, et al. JUM 2015;34:1883
@EMARIANOMD
Mariano, et al. JUM 2015;34:1883
@EMARIANOMD
Echogenic Technology
Mariano, et al. JUM 2014;33:905
@EMARIANOMD
Needle Guidance Systems
McVicar, et al. RAPM 2015;40:150
@EMARIANOMD
Overview
• The “learning curve” • Technology for teaching and learning• Technology for assessment
@EMARIANOMD
AssessmentCategory Description Points Procedural Time (min) Starting when US probe touches skin and ending when
placement needle is removed 2 (≤5 min) 1 (6-10 min) 0 (>10 min)
Needle Passes (#) Withdrawal of the placement needle >1 cm with readvancement 2 (1) 1 (2) 0 (>2)
Procedural Performance
Needle visualization during advancement 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Equipment preparation (e.g., probe selection, machine settings) 2 (Excellent) 1 (Good) 0 (Poor)
Target positioning (eg, able to see target and feasible needle trajectory)
2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Probe stability (eg, no unintentional movement) 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Needle manipulation (eg, comfortable grip on needle and catheter)
2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Visual focus (eg, appropriately focused on machine and not hands during procedure)
2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Confirmation of proper injectate spread 2 (Excellent) 1 (Good) 0 (Poor)
Confirmation of proper catheter tip position 2 (Excellent) 1 (Good) 0 (Poor)
Ergonomic Factors Positioning of ultrasound machine 2 (Excellent) 1 (Good) 0 (Poor)
No thoracolumbar flexion (≥45 ) 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
No head/neck rotation (≥45 ) 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
No lateral shoulder tilt (≥30 ) 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
No crossing sterile field to non-dominant side 2 (All the time) 1 (Part of the time) 0 (None of the time)
Mariano, et al. JUM 2015;34:1883
@EMARIANOMD
DOPS
Wragg, et al. Clin Med 2003;3:131Watson, et al. Anaesth 2014;69:604Chuan, et al. Anaesth Int Care 2016;44:2
@EMARIANOMD
DOPS
Wragg, et al. Clin Med 2003;3:131Watson, et al. Anaesth 2014;69:604Chuan, et al. Anaesth Int Care 2016;44:2
@EMARIANOMD
Global Rating Scale
Cheung, et al. RAPM 2012;37: 329Wong, et al. RAPM 2014;39:399
@EMARIANOMD
Video Recording and Review
@EMARIANOMD
Hand Motion Analysis
Chin, et al. RAPM 2011;36:213
@EMARIANOMD
Eye Tracking
Harrison & Mariano, et al. J Anesth 2015;30:530
The Expert94 sec
1.85 fixations/sec
The Novice257 sec
0.86 fixations/sec
@EMARIANOMD
J Anesth 2015;30:530
How Does Expertise Look?
Can We Quantify It?
@EMARIANOMD
Borg & Mariano, et al. Submitted
@EMARIANOMD
Summary
We discussed:• The “learning curve” • Technology for teaching and learning• Technology for assessment
@EMARIANOMD
“Regional anesthesia is a vital skill for any anesthesiologist and ultrasound-guided techniques have enhanced our ability to achieve effective and consistent blocks. It is important that we ensure our graduating residents have the requisite skills to perform basic regional techniques in a safe and effective manner in order to disseminate the benefits of regional anesthesia to the broader surgical population.”
McCartney & Mariano. RAPM 2016;41:663.
www.asra.com
April 19–21, 2018New York Marriott
MarquisNew York City, USA
www.asra.com/World-Congress