technicalevaluationstat1032631

18
This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s) STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00 Top Sheet: Department: STORES Section: P 2 Tender Document Cost (INR): 0.00 EMD (INR): 0.00 Tender Type: Special Limited Trade Group: NIL Bidding System: Single Bid System Rate Page Type: Supply Actual Opening Date/Time : 30/09/10 15:24 Prebid Query Date/Time : Not Applicable No of Vendors purchased / downloaded Tender Documents : 13 No of Vendors submitted Bids : 11 Tender Description: Bolster spring inner [BOXN] RDSO Drg No WD-83069-S-1 Item-2 alt-15 to MATL Spec IS 3195 Gr,60 ST 7 and IRS R2 Instructions/Remarks: 1.Inspection,By RDSO. 2.Railway reserves the right to place entire-Bulk Qty order on RDSO approved sources. 3.The part II approved firms shall be considered normally for 15 Percent qty Development order but may be considered for more qty Development order subject to 25 Percent of NPQ or max.qty supplied against a single order during last 3years whichever is minimum. Hence firms to support their claim with attested copy of PO plusI-C plusReceipt Note for max.qty supplied against a single order during lasts 3Years. 4.Firms to submit latest RO-PO copies received from any Railways-PUs. 5. Railway Should recover from the contractor as agreed Liquidated Damages and not by way of penalty, a sum equivalent to 2 Percent [ Two percent] of price of any stores [ including elements of Taxes, Duties, freight etc.]. Which the contractor has failed to deliver within the period fixed for delivery in the contract or as extended for each month or part of a month during which the delivery of such stores may be in arrears where delivery thereof is accepted after expiry of the aforesaid period, subject to a maximum of Ten percent of value of the delayed supplies MUTHUKRISHNAIYER SREEDHAR / amm mmis BALASUBRAMANIAN CG / senior section officer Purchase Member (Name/Designation): Finance Member (Name/Designation): Page 1 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

Upload: mahendra-singh

Post on 06-Apr-2015

38 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Top Sheet:

Department: STORES Section: P 2

Tender Document Cost (INR): 0.00 EMD (INR): 0.00

Tender Type: Special Limited Trade Group: NIL

Bidding System: Single Bid System Rate Page Type: Supply

Actual Opening Date/Time : 30/09/10 15:24 Prebid Query Date/Time : Not Applicable

No of Vendors purchased /downloaded TenderDocuments :

13 No of Vendors submitted Bids : 11

Tender Description: Bolster spring inner [BOXN] RDSO Drg No WD-83069-S-1 Item-2 alt-15 to MATL Spec IS 3195 Gr,60 ST 7 and IRS R2

Instructions/Remarks: 1.Inspection,By RDSO. 2.Railway reserves the right to place entire-Bulk Qty order on RDSO approved sources. 3.The part IIapproved firms shall be considered normally for 15 Percent qty Development order but may be considered for more qtyDevelopment order subject to 25 Percent of NPQ or max.qty supplied against a single order during last 3years whichever isminimum. Hence firms to support their claim with attested copy of PO plusI-C plusReceipt Note for max.qty supplied against asingle order during lasts 3Years. 4.Firms to submit latest RO-PO copies received from any Railways-PUs. 5. Railway Shouldrecover from the contractor as agreed Liquidated Damages and not by way of penalty, a sum equivalent to 2 Percent [ Twopercent] of price of any stores [ including elements of Taxes, Duties, freight etc.]. Which the contractor has failed to deliverwithin the period fixed for delivery in the contract or as extended for each month or part of a month during which the deliveryof such stores may be in arrears where delivery thereof is accepted after expiry of the aforesaid period, subject to a maximumof Ten percent of value of the delayed supplies

MUTHUKRISHNAIYER SREEDHAR / amm mmis BALASUBRAMANIAN CG / senior section officerPurchase Member (Name/Designation): Finance Member (Name/Designation):

Page 1 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Page 2 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Note: Purchase officers are requested to refer to respective offers also for complete details and vendor's input against deleted Eligibility Criteria/ Checklist & Special Conditions/ Technical Specifications, if the

same have not been updated by the vendor after issue of corrigendum.

Part A: Eligibility Criteria

1) Please furnish BANK DETAILS i.e. your bank account No,IFSC No,MICR No,Bank city,Bank address,type of Account to facilitate payment through EFT along withE.offer.

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA Yes Submitted

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA Yes yes

MINI IRON AND ALLOYS PRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA Yes NIL

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-KOLKATA Yes YES ALREADY SENT TO YOU

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATE LIMITED-DEHRADUN Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR Yes NIL

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA Yes NIL

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR Yes yes

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON Yes NIL

QUALITY SPRING AND ENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH Yes NIL

2) supply should be as per tendered description

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYS PRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA Yes MATERIAL AS PER RDSO DRAWING

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR Yes yes

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA Yes Yes

QUALITY SPRING AND ENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR Yes NIL

Page 3 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-KOLKATA Yes YES

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA No Delivery to commence after 60 days from the date of receipt of Confirmed Purchase Order and to be su

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA Yes yes

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATE LIMITED-DEHRADUN Yes NIL

Part B: Terms And Conditions

Offer Valid upto Mode ofDispatch

FOR Inspection Delivery Period Delivery Schedule Payment Terms

As per Tender --> As qouted byfirms | V

NIL NIL NIL RDSO NIL within 60 days 100 percent paymentagainst acceptance ofmaterial.

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATE LIMITED-

DEHRADUN

29/11/2010 Road Destination RDSO TO BE SUPPILED WITH IN60 TO 90 DAYS

TO BE SUPPILED WITH IN60 TO 90 DAYS

98 2

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

30/10/2010 Road Destination BY RDSO KOLKATA WITHIN 4 TO 5 MONTHSFROM THE DATE OFRECEIPT OF FIRM ORDER

WITHIN 4 TO 5 MONTHSFROM THE DATE OFRECEIPT OF FIRM ORDER

95 PERCENT AGAINSTRECEIPTED CHALLANAND INSPECTIONCERTIFICATE ANDBALANCE 5 PERCENTAGAINST RECEIPT NOTE

QUALITY SPRING AND

ENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-

HOWRAH

30/10/2010 Road Destination RDSO Kolkata at ourpremises.

NIL Full quantity will bedelivered within 5 to 6months from the date ofreceipt of your firm order.

98 percent payment againstreceipted challan alongwithIC and balance 2 percentpayment against receiptedchallan alongwith IC.

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-

ROURKELA

30/10/2010 Road Destination RDSO 8 months 8 Months 98 percent against signedchallan and inspectioncertificate and balance 2percent against RR note.

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-

GURGAON

29/12/2010 Rail/Road Destination RDSO within 60 days after issue ofP.O.

within 60 days 100 percent paymentagainst acceptance ofmaterial.

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-

KANPUR

29/11/2010 Road Destination RDSO 3-4 MONTHS 3-4 MONTHS 95 PLUS 5 PERCENT

Page 4 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-

KOLKATA

29/12/2010 Road Destination By RDSO Kolkata at ourfactory premises beforedespatch of material

Delivery to commence after60 days from the date ofreceipt of ConfirmedPurchase Order and to besupplied in a period of 120days thereafter

Delivery to commence after60 days from the date ofreceipt of ConfirmedPurchase Order and to besupplied in a period of 120days thereafter

98 percent payment has tobe made against ReceiptedChallan of the Consigneeaccompanied by InspectionCertificate issued by RDSOKolkata and balance 2percent against ReceiptNote of the Consignee

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

29/11/2010 Road Destination RDSO Kolkata Supply will be completedwithin 6 months from thedate of receipt of yourformal purchase ordercompleted in all respect

Supply will be completedwithin 6 months from thedate of receipt of yourformal purchase ordercompleted in all respect

95 percent payment againstsigned challen andinspection certificate andbalance 5 percent againstR. Note

MINI IRON AND ALLOYS PRIVATE

LIMITED-KOLKATA

29/12/2010 Rail/Road Destination RDSO 90 TO 120 DAYS COMMENCING AFTER 90DAYS FROM THE RECEITOF PO AND WITHINANOTHER 30 DAYSTHERE AFTER

98 PLUS 2

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

29/11/2010 Road Destination RDSO MUMBAI Complete within 6 to 8months from receipt of clearformal order including MAif required at our end.Permit 10 days transitperiod for delivery by RoadTransport. Supply will bemade in phased manner.

Complete within 6 to 8months from receipt of clearformal order including MAif required at our end.Permit 10 days transitperiod for delivery by RoadTransport. Supply will bemade in phased manner.

98 percent advancepayment to be releasedagainst Receipted Challan /IC and balance againstReceipt Note.

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR 29/11/2010 Rail/Road Destination RDSO Lucknow at ourworks before dispatch

90 to 120 days from thedate of receipt of firm andclear order and afterinspection by RDSOLucknow as per RDSOsinspection scheduledsubject to railways standardforce majeaur clause

90 to 120 days from thedate of receipt of firm andclear order and afterinspection by RDSOLucknow as per RDSOsinspection scheduledsubject to railways standardforce majeaur clause

98 percent payment againstreceipted challan andinspection certificate andbalance 2 percent on receiptnote from consignee and tobe paid by FACAO SOUTHWESTERN RAILWAYHUBLI

Part C: Performance Statement

Note :- Please refer to Vendors bid for details.

Page 5 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Part D: Technical Specifications

No Technical Specification(s) to display

Part E: Technical Deviation Statement (In case of bids submitted before deployment of new design, deviation statement details entered by vendors are shown here.)

Bidder Name Clause No Document Name Description as per Clause Deviation Details

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

NA NO DEVIATION NA NA

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-

ROURKELA

0 nil nil Nil

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR 0 NIL NIL NIL

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATE LIMITED-

DEHRADUN

0 NIL 0 NIL

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-

GURGAON

NIL N/A NIL NIL

Part F: Commercial Deviation Statement

Bidder Name Clause No Document Name Description as per Clause Deviation Details

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

NA NO DEVIATION NA NA

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-

GURGAON

NIL N/A N/A NIL

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-

ROURKELA

0 nil nil nil

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

0 Octroi and Entry Tax New Impost

MODVAT and VAT Credit Option

As per tendered schedule If Octroi and Entry tax are levied at the time of

dispatch the same will be reimbursed against

Page 6 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Clause Road permit or Way Bill documentary evidence Any statutory increase in

taxes duties levies and or new imposition as result

of revision of orders of the Govt. after the date of

our quotation and within the currency of contract

shall be on buyers account While quoting our rate

we have taken into consideration the MODVAT

benefit availed on inputs and any increase or

decrease in MODVAT benefit subsequent to the

date of our quotation the same will be to ours

account While quoting our rate we have taken into

consideration the VAT benefit availed on inputs and

any increase or decrease in VAT credit subsequent

to the date of our quotation the same will be to ours

account Any increase and decrease in ordered qty

after the placement of the order the same will be

done with our mutual consent only Road permit will

be required for transportation of materials at

destination

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATE LIMITED-

DEHRADUN

0 NIL 0 NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR 0 NIL NIL NIL

Part G: Special Conditions & Checklist for Bidders

1) This is a safety item and all firms to deposit Security Deposit performance guarantee for tendered item irrespective of their registration with Railway or NSIC or on theapproved list of RDSO, RAILWAY or CORE or PU and in case of delay or non-supply, their security deposit should be forfeited apart from taking note of their poorperformance in future tenders. The amount of SD wll be 10 of the total value of the contract subjected to upper ceiling of Rs.10Lakhs for contract valuing upto Rs.10Crore Rs.20 Lakhs for the contract valuing above Rs.10 Crore.

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

Yes NIL

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

No Exempted

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD- Yes Noted

Page 7 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

KOLKATA

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

No Exempted as registered with RDSO and a NSIC

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

Yes YES NSIC REGISTERED FIRM

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

2) Have you quoted delivery period correctly and precisely

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Yes

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

Page 8 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

Yes YES

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

No 8 months

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

Yes NIL

3) Have you kept your offer valid for 90 days[validity of 120 days is required for items of Machinery and Plants]

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

No 60 DAYS

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

Yes 60 DAYS

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO 30 DAYS

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

No 60 days from the date opening of this tender and thereafter subject to our reconfirmation

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

No 30 days

Page 9 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

No 60 days

4) Have you furnished the details of equipment-quality control[Para 2.2b of Instructions to tenderers and Annexure 3]

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Yes

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

No NA

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

No N/A

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

No NA

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

Yes yes

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

No RDSO APPROVED FIRM

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

No RDSO APPROVED VENDOR AS PART 1

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

5) Have you furnished the performance statement.[Para 2.2a of Instructions to tenderers and Annexure 2]

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

No NEW RDSO APPROVED FIRM

Page 10 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

No To be produced if required by railways

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

No NA

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Furnished

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

Yes yes

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

No NO

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

No .

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

6) Have you quoted price on the basis of free delivery to destination, indicating the break up [Para 6.1 of Instructions to tenderers]

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Yes

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

Page 11 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

No EXEMPTED

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

No no

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

Yes NIL

7) Have you furnished your income tax clearance certificate

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

No NA

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

No no

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

No RDSO APPROVED VENDOR AS PART 1

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

No ALREADY SUBMITTED IN RDSO

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

No NA

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO

RAHUL PRECISION WORKS No .

Page 12 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

No N.A.

8) Railway reserves the right to place entire-Bulk Qty order on RDSO approved sources.

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

Yes yes

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Noted

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

Yes YES

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

Yes NIL

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

Yes NIL

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

9) Have you submitted the Banker s report.[Para 2.1b of Instructions to tenderers]

Page 13 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

Bidder Name Complied (Y/N) Remarks

INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVTLTD-KOLKATA

No NO

FRONTIER SPRINGS LIMITED-KANPUR

Yes YES

ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR

Yes NIL

MINI IRON AND ALLOYSPRIVATE LIMITED-KOLKATA

Yes NIL

QUALITY SPRING ANDENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH

Yes NIL

KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-KOLKATA

Yes Submitted

HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-KOLKATA

No NA

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRA LIMITED-ROURKELA

Yes yes

RAHUL PRECISION WORKSPVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

No .

TOP FORTY SUSPENSION-GURGAON

Yes NIL

G.B. SPRINGS PRIVATELIMITED-DEHRADUN

No RDSO APPROVED VENDOR AS PART 1

Part H: List of Document(s) Attached

Sr. No Bidder Name File Name Description/Subject of File

1 ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR NSICNew.pdf NSIC Certificate

2 ABOK SPRING PVT. LTD.-JAIPUR RDSOCertificatePartI.pdf RDSO Certificate

3 HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED- Bank.pdf Bank Account Details for NEFT Payment

Page 14 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

KOLKATA

4 HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-

KOLKATA

ISO.pdf ISO Certificate No 43117 2008 AQ IND RvA valid upto 15th Nov 2010

5 HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-

KOLKATA

NewSpring.pdf RDSO Part I approval vide certificate no MW IL Regn Howrah Forgings C dt 7th April

2010 valid upto 31st MARCH 2013

6 HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITED-

KOLKATA

NSIC.pdf NSIC Certificate No NSIC KOL GP RS REGN WB H 95 85 dated 2nd December 2009

valid upto 25th November 2011

7 INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

ITCISO1.pdf ISO REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE ENCLOSED

8 INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

itcnsic1.pdf NSIC REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE ENCLOSED

9 INDIA TOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

SPRING.pdf RDSO REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE ENCLOSED

10 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

ISO.pdf ISO

11 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

NSICPAGE2.pdf NSICPAGE2

12 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

NSIPAGE1.pdf NSIPAGE1

13 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformancDocument5.pdf PerformancDocument5

14 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument1.pdf PerformanceDocument1

15 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument1byA.pdf PerformanceDocument1byA

16 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument2.pdf PerformanceDocument2

17 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument3.pdf PerformanceDocument3

18 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument4.pdf PerformanceDocument4

Page 15 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

19 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument5byA.pdf PerformanceDocument5byA

20 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

PerformanceDocument6.pdf PerformanceDocument6

21 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

Performancedocument7.pdf Performancedocument7

22 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

Performancedocument8.pdf Performancedocument8

23 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

performancedocument9.pdf performancedocument9

24 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

RDSOPART1_1.pdf RDSOPART1

25 KALIMATA VYAPAAR PVT LTD-

KOLKATA

RDSORENEWAL.pdf RDSORENEWAL

26 MINI IRON AND ALLOYS PRIVATE

LIMITED-KOLKATA

BANKCERTIFICATE.pdf BANK LETTER

27 QUALITY SPRING AND

ENGINEERING CO. PVT. LTD.-

HOWRAH

scan0003.pdf Scan copies of RDSO NSIC and ISO Regn Certificates.

28 RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

ISO.pdf ISO CERTIFICATE

29 RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

NSICRPWL.pdf NSIC CERTIFICATE

30 RAHUL PRECISION WORKS

PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR

RPWLRDSOCERTIFICATE.pdf RDSO CERTIFICATE

Digital Signature Certificate Details of Vendor User who have signed and submitted Financial Rate Page

Firm's Name User Name / User Id Subject Issuer Details Expiry Date

QUALITY SPRING GAUTAM / [email protected] OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=btwoa r@rediffmail com CN=mtnlTrustLine Class 3 Authorised Individual Fri Feb 25 16:44:21

Page 16 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

AND ENGINEERINGCO. PVT. LTD.-HOWRAH-HowrahAmta Road,Balitikuri,,Howrah

OID 2 5 4 5=00183255 CN=GAUTAM PATRAOU=Quality Spring AND Engineering Co Pvt LtdO="mtnlTrustLine Authorised Individual Subscriber"C=IN

Subscriber Sub CAG1,OU=mtnlTrustLine,O=Mahanagar TelephoneNigam Limited,C=IN

GMT+05:30 2011

RAHUL PRECISIONWORKS PVT.LTD-PITHAMPUR-PlotNo.13 & 14 ,SectorIII,,Pithampur

RAHUL JAIN / [email protected] CN=Rahul Jain OID 1 2 840 113549 1 91=rahuljain@rahulprecision com OU=Class 3Certificate OU=Manufacturing OU=CompanyOU=TCS-CA - Registration Authority O=RahulPrecision Works Private Limited L=H-101A MetroTower Scheme No 54 A B Road Indore ST=MadhyaPradesh C=IN

ST=AP,1.2.840.113549.1.9.1=#161661646d696e407463732d63612e7463732e636f2e696e,L=Hyderabad,CN=Tata Consultancy Services CertifyingAuthority,OU=TCS CA,O=India PKI,C=IN

Sun Jun 17 16:36:02GMT+05:30 2012

HOWRAH FORGINGSLIMITED-KOLKATA-18,R.N.MukherjeeRoad,,Kolkata

SHIVAJI GHOSH /[email protected]

OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=howrahforgings@yahoocom OID 2 5 4 5=00181446 CN=SHIVAJI GHOSHOU=HOWRAH FORGINGS LIMITEDO="mtnlTrustLine Authorised Individual Subscriber"C=IN

CN=mtnlTrustLine Class 3 Authorised IndividualSubscriber Sub CAG1,OU=mtnlTrustLine,O=Mahanagar TelephoneNigam Limited,C=IN

Thu Feb 10 14:14:52GMT+05:30 2011

G.B. SPRINGSPRIVATE LIMITED-DEHRADUN-16,BALLUPURROAD,P.O. BOX213,DEHRADUN

VINEET KUMAR GUPTA /[email protected]

OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=gbslddn@sancharnet inCN=V K GUPTA OU=G B Springs Pvt Ltd OU=IndiaRCAI Class 3 O=SafeScrypt Limited L=DehradunST=Uttaranchal C=IN

CN=Safescrypt India-RCAI Class 3 ConsumerCA,OU=Terms of use athttps://www.safescrypt.com/rpa (c)03,O=SafescryptLimited,C=IN

Fri Aug 17 05:29:59GMT+05:30 2012

FRONTIER SPRINGSLIMITED-KANPUR-E-14,INDUSTRIAL AREASITE-I,,KANPUR

KAPIL BHATIA / [email protected] CN="KAPIL BHATIA 760949 FRONTIER SPRINGSLTD" OU=Class IIIb O=(n)Code Solutions CertifyingAuthority C=IN

CN=(n)Code Solutions,OU=(n)Code SolutionsCertifying Authority,O=India PKI,C=IN

Thu Sep 29 00:00:00GMT+05:30 2011

SHAKTI RAIL-INFRALIMITED-ROURKELA-5/1 INDUSTRIALAREA,,ROURKELA

MAHAVIR PODDAR /[email protected]

OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=mgmt@shaktirailinfra comCN=Mahavir Poddar OU=Shakti Rail-Infra LimitedOU=India RCAI Class 3 O=SafeScrypt Limited

CN=Safescrypt India-RCAI Class 3 ConsumerCA,OU=Terms of use athttps://www.safescrypt.com/rpa (c)03,O=SafescryptLimited,C=IN

Thu Jan 13 05:29:59GMT+05:30 2011

KALIMATA VYAPAARPVT LTD-KOLKATA-14/2, old china bazarstreet,3rd floor, roomno-213,kolkata

ANANT JHAWAR / [email protected] OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=kiipl@cal2 vsnl net in OID2 5 4 5=00206735 CN=ANANT JHAWAROU=KALIMATA VYAPAAR PRIVATE LIMITEDO="mtnlTrustLine Authorised Individual Subscriber"C=IN

CN=mtnlTrustLine Class 3 Authorised IndividualSubscriber Sub CAG1,OU=mtnlTrustLine,O=Mahanagar TelephoneNigam Limited,C=IN

Sun Sep 04 17:21:46GMT+05:30 2011

MINI IRON ANDALLOYS PRIVATELIMITED-KOLKATA-

SOHAN LAL JAISWAL / [email protected] OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=miniiron@dataone inC=IN ST=WEST BENGAL L=KOLKATA O=MINIIRON AND ALLOYS PVT LTD OU=Class 3

ST=AP,1.2.840.113549.1.9.1=#161661646d696e407463732d63612e7463732e636f2e696e,L=Hyderabad,CN=Tata Consultancy Services Certifying

Sun Feb 13 12:37:42GMT+05:30 2011

Page 17 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36

This tabulation is based on digitally signed e-bid(s)

STORES/SOUTH WESTERN RLY Techno-Commercial Tabulation for Tender No: 38101305 Due Date/Time: 30/09/10 14:00

37A BENTINCKSTREET,202BENTINCKCHAMBERS,KOLKATA

Certificate OU=Manufacturer and sale of Hot CoiledHelical Coil Spring OU=Company OU=TCS-CA -Registration Authority CN=SOHAN LAL JAISWAL

Authority,OU=TCS CA,O=India PKI,C=IN

ABOK SPRING PVT.LTD.-JAIPUR-101-103IndustrialArea,Jhotwara,Jaipur

KISHORE MEHTA / [email protected] OID 1 2 840 113549 1 9 1=abok_aspl@hotmail comOID 2 5 4 5=00163160 CN=KISHORE MEHTAOU=ABOK SPRING PVT LTD O="mtnlTrustLineAuthorised Individual Subscriber" C=IN

CN=mtnlTrustLine Class 3 Authorised IndividualSubscriber Sub CAG1,OU=mtnlTrustLine,O=Mahanagar TelephoneNigam Limited,C=IN

Sun Nov 14 14:09:02GMT+05:30 2010

TOP FORTYSUSPENSION-GURGAON-SHASTRINAGAR INDUSTRIALAREA,VILLAGEDAULTABADROAD,GURGAON

RAMAN UPPAL / [email protected] CN=RAMAN UPPAL OID 1 2 840 113549 1 91=ramanuppal@topfortyauto com OU=Class 3Certificate OU=MANUFACTURING OU=CompanyOU=TCS-CA - Registration Authority O=TOP FORTYSUSPENSION L=GURGAON ST=HARYANA C=IN

ST=AP,1.2.840.113549.1.9.1=#161661646d696e407463732d63612e7463732e636f2e696e,L=Hyderabad,CN=Tata Consultancy Services CertifyingAuthority,OU=TCS CA,O=India PKI,C=IN

Thu Jun 21 19:27:42GMT+05:30 2012

INDIA TOOLSCRAFTS PVT LTD-KOLKATA-19,R.N.MUKHERJEEROAD,EASTERNBUILDING,2NDFLOOR,KOLKATA

PRANAY JHUNJHUNWALA /[email protected]

CN="PRANAY JHUNJHUNWALA 667762 INDIATOOLS CRAFTS PVT LTD " OU=Class IIIbO=(n)Code Solutions Certifying Authority C=IN

CN=(n)Code Solutions,OU=(n)Code SolutionsCertifying Authority,O=India PKI,C=IN

Wed Nov 17 00:00:00GMT+05:30 2010

MUTHUKRISHNAIYER SREEDHAR / amm mmis BALASUBRAMANIAN CG / senior section officerPurchase Member (Name/Designation): Finance Member (Name/Designation):

- - - - - - - - - - End of the Report - - - - - - - - - -

Page 18 of 18 Run DateTime: 01/10/2010 11:36