technical bulletin how to select a conformal coating material...single part acrylic, urethane and...
TRANSCRIPT
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
TechnicalBulletinHowtoSelectaConformalCoatingMaterial
Choosingaconformalcoatingmaterialisacomplicatedandinvolvedprocessusuallybalancinganumberoftrade-offsandcompromises.Thisisbecausethereisnosuchthingasauniversallyapplicableconformalcoating.Theaimofthisarticleistogiveyouanideaofthequestionstoaskyourselfandyoursupplierstoshortlistsuitablematerialsfortheendapplication.
FactorstoConsider
Whenselectingaconformalcoatingyouaregoingtoneedtoconsiderseveralfactorswhichifyouareluckywillalladduptoatleastonematerialchoice.Ifnot,thencompromisesarerequired.
Factorstobeconsideredare:
• TemperatureOperatingRange• International,CustomerorNationalStandards• EnvironmentalConsiderations• ChemicalResistance• RequirementtoReworktheConformalCoating• ApplicationProcessConsiderations• Curingtheconformalcoating• National,State,RegionalLegislationandInsurance• SupplierPerformance• Price
Eachofthesefactorsisexaminedbrieflytoallowaninsightintothecomplexityofselectingaconformalcoatingmaterial.
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
TemperatureOperatingRange
Conformal-coatedassemblieswilloftenbeexposedtoawiderangeofoperatingtemperaturesduringtheirservicelife.Itisimportanttounderstandthemaximumandminimumtemperaturesthattheunitwillbeexposedto.Thisneedstoaholisticandrealisticappraisal.
Forexample,ifyourboardsareoperatinginanunheatedpartofanaircraft,theycouldeasilysee-65ºCwhenairborne.Whenontherunway,theycouldeasilysee+100ºC.Thenyouneedtoconsidertheheatingeffectsofthecircuit,certainlocalhotspotsontheassemblycouldreachlocalmaximumsof125ºCsay.Thenyouroperatingrangebecomes-65to+125ºC.
Ifyouroperatingrangegoesbelow-65ºCorabove150ºCthenyourchoiceismadesimple,becausesiliconeconformalcoatingsaretheonlymaterialsthatwillsurviveextendeduseatthisrange.Ifyouroperatingrangeiswithinthiswindow,thenkeepreading.
International,CustomerorNationalStandards
Thenextquestiontoaskiswhetheryourcustomerorendapplicationrequirestheconformalcoatingtobequalifiedorapprovedtointernational,nationalorcustomerspecificstandards.
ExamplesofthesewouldbeUL746E(WhichincludesUL94)NorthAmericanSafetyStandard,MIL-I-46058C,orBMWGS95011-5.TheQualifiedProductLists(QPL)willsignificantlyreducethenumberofcoatingsavailabletoyou.TheSpecificationssuchastheIPC-CC-830Standarddoesnothaveaqualifiedproductlist.However,anyproductthatappearsontheMIL-I-46058CQPL,isautomaticallysaidtomeettherequirementsofIPC-CC-830.Therearealotofmaterialsthatstatethatthey‘meettherequirementsofIPC-CC-830’.AnymaterialmakingthisclaimthatdoesnotappearontheMILQPLmusthaveapubliclyavailabletestreporttobackuptheseassertions.Youwillneedtoseethisreportinordertokeepamaterialinyourshortlist.
EnvironmentalConsiderations
Aconformal-coatedprintedcircuitboardcanbeexposedtomanydifferenttypesofdeleteriousenvironments.Foranyunitthatwillbeplacedinapartiallysealedprotectivehousing,theconformalcoatingwouldbeconsideredsecondaryprotectiononlyandthereforelikelytobesubjectedonlytocondensationandhumidityasthetemperaturewithinthehousingchanges.Acrylicmaterialsarewidelyusedinsuchapplications,althoughsiliconematerialsgenerallyofferthebestprotectionincondensingenvironments.Thefollowingdescribesthemostcommonlyencounteredenvironmentalconditionsthatmayneedtobemet:
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
HighHumidity
Whenhighhumidityistheissue,SiliconeMaterialscanbeanorderofmagnitudemoreporoustowatervapourthanothercoatingchemistries.AcrylicsandUrethanechemistriesallhavegoodresistancetohighhumidityenvironments.Two-component(two-part)materialsandmaterialsthatchemicallycross-linktoasignificantdegreewouldallbeexpectedtoprovideabetterbarriertohumidity.
Salt-SprayEnvironments
Thisisaverycommonrequirementinmanycustomerspecifications,butnotwithinanyofthecommongeneralspecifications.ThekeytosuccesswithSaltSprayenvironmentsareevenanduniform,void-freecoverageoftheassembly.Chemically,salt-waterisbenigntomostcoatings.However,thetestsandtheenvironmentswilltestworkmanshipandfinddefectsintheappliedcoating.Siliconematerialsandurethanechemistriesareoftenusedintheseapplications,althoughacrylicscanpassmosttestregimes.
Corrosivegases
Theseenvironmentsareperhapsthetoughestofall,sincethecorrosivegaseswillexposeanydefectsorvoidsintheappliedcoating.Inaddition,thereisarealdifferentiationbetweencoatingchemistriesinprotectivecapability.Acrylicsandsingle-componentalkyd,orurethanechemistriesareallextremelysusceptibletocorrosivegases.Two-partpolyurethaneandepoxychemistrymostlyshowgoodresistance,butsomesinglecomponentUVcurablematerialsandsinglecomponentsiliconechemistriesprovideverygoodresistancetoo.UVcurablematerialsaresignificantlycross-linkedandsothisisnotsurprising.Siliconematerialsseemtoworkbyreactingtoformchemicalbondswiththemetalsurfaceswhichlargelyinertthemetalsubstratefromcorrosion.
ImmersionEnvironments
Whentheassemblyislikelytobeimmersedinwater,thereisonlyonerealchoice,andthatistouseParylene,avapourdepositedconformalcoatingthatprovidesexceptionalcoverageandinsulation.Liquidappliedsiliconecoatingscanprovidedecentprotectionifappliedatagenerousthickness.
Corroded PCB not protected by conformal coating
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
However,thekeyisqualityworkmanshipandprocessqualitycontrolsinceimmersionwillfindanyweakareasofcoverage.
Forimmersion-inorsplashbysolvents,theresultsareverydependentupontheparticularcoatingchemistryandsolventofinterest.Ingeneral,two-partmaterialswouldbethebestchoice,althoughsomeUVcurablematerialsprovideoutstandingchemicalresistance.
RequirementtoReworktheConformalCoating
Itispossibletoreworkmosttypesofconformalcoatingifnecessary,althoughsomeconformalcoatingscanbeverydifficulttorework.Ifyourassemblyhasalongservicelife,willbeplacedinahousingandbesubjectedtomultipleupgradesandrepairsoveritslife(commoninmilitaryandaerospaceapplications)thenacrylicsarewithoutadoubttheeasiesttypeofcoatingchemistrytoremoveandrework,duetotheirverylimitedchemicalresistance.Singlepartacrylic,urethaneandalkydmaterialscanbe
removedbychemicalmethodsinmachineslikeaconformalcoatingwetstrippingsystem.
Anytwo-partchemistry,Silicones,Parylene’sandUVcurablematerialsarebestremovedlocallybymediablastingwithanESDsafemediablaster.Providedthecoatingislesshardthanthesoldermask,thenagooddegreeofselectivitycanbeachievedwiththismethod,whichwillbecoveredinaforthcoming‘HowTo’guide.
ApplicationProcessConsiderations
Withenoughengineeringexpertiseandbudget,anymaterialcanbemadetoworkinanytypeofapplicationmethod,withtheexceptionofParylene,whichcanonlybeappliedbyvapourdepositioninadedicatedapplicationsystem.
However,therearecertaincombinationsthatleadtoextremeprocessdifficultyand/orcostimplicationsandareworthconsidering:
Solvent-Basedmaterials
Allsinglecomponentsolvent-basedmaterials,withtheexceptionofsomemoisturecureurethanechemistriescanbesuccessfullyappliedbyanyofthecommontechniques.Two-partsolventbased
Stripping Conformal Coating from a PCB
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
materialsworkbestwithsprayorbrushapplicationsandcanbeappliedthroughroboticapplicationswiththerightsystemspecification.Unlessyouarewillingtothrowawayadiptankofmaterialwhenthepot-lifeisexceededthendippingisfarfromideal.
UVcurablematerials
UVcureconformalcoatingsareideallydesignedforhighvolume,highthroughputenvironmentsandarebestappliedbyselectivecoatingequipmentwithanimmediatein-line,conveyorisedcureoperation.However,duetotheiroutstandingprotectiveproperties,theyfindapplicationinlowvolumeapplicationstoo.Inthiscase,manualspraycoatingisacceptable,aslongasthecoatingthicknessandcureprocessarecarefullycontrolledtoensurethethicknessiswithinspecificationandtoavoidover-cure.Also,whencuringUVmaterialsandmaskingisinvolved,considerationmustbegiventothis.
Water-basedmaterials
Workbestinamanualapplicationprocess,beitdip,sprayorbrush.Water-basedmaterialsaredifficulttoapplywithrepeatabilityandreproducibilitywithselectivesprayequipment,andcanbeimpossibletocureinanin-lineprocessduetotheexcessivethicknessofmaterialappliedinthesemethods.
Siliconebasedmaterials
RTVsiliconesarenotreallysuitablefordipcoatingapplicationswithoutinertgassystemsinplace,butheat-curesiliconematerialsareideal.Withthisexception,siliconechemistrycanbesuccessfullyappliedbyanymethodology.
SelectiveRoboticCoating
Nearlyalloftheroboticmanufacturersmakeequipmentcanapplyconformalcoatingssuccessfullyifcorrectspecified.Thekeyistounderstandthevalvetechnologiesandhowthatrelatestothematerial,thequalityofthesprayprocessandthespeedofprocessing.Forinstance,whenconsideringswitchingfromasolventbasedcoatingusinganon-atomisedvalvetoanenvironmentallyfriendlycoatingsuchasaUVcureorsiliconecureproductthenitshouldberealisedthatachangeofvalvetechnologyisprobablyneededandtherewillbespeedlimitations,andthereforethroughputpenalties.
Dipping
Generally,allconformalcoatingscanbedippedinadipcoatingsystem.However,awiseruleofthumbistoavoiddip-coatingmethodsforanymaterialcontainingamoisture-curemechanismunlessyouwish
Robotic System applying conformal coating
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
toaddinexpensiveprocesscontrolssuchasinertgassystems.Also,althoughperfectlypossibletodipUVcurecoatingsitiscriticalthatthesystemisdesignedtodothiswithparticularsafeguardsinplace.
HandSpraying
Allconformalcoatingscanbehandsprayedwithinasprayboothandtheprocessofconsiderationisthesameasfortherobots.Theeasiestarethesinglepartcoatings.TwopartcoatingswillhaveashelflifetoconsiderandproductssuchasUVcureandmoisturecurewillneedtobehandledcarefully.
Ifyouareconstrainedbyexistingcapitalequipmentthenyourchoicesmaybemorelimited,butifnewequipmentcanbepurchased,thentherearefarmorechoices.
Curingtheconformalcoating
Whentalkingaboutcuretimes,thereareseveraldefinitionstobeawareof:
1. DryingTimetohandle.Thisisthetimeatroomtemperatureatwhichthecoatingisdrytothetouchandcanbehandledormovedontoanotheroperation.
2. Timetofullcure.Thisisthetimeuntilanyphysicaldryingprocesshasbeencompletedandanycross-linkingreactionhastakenplace.Elevatedtemperaturesorothermethodsofcatalysiscanusuallyreducethetimetofullcure.
3. Timetooptimumproperties.Intuitionwouldtellyouwouldthinkthiswouldbethesameastimetofullcure.However,evenwhenthecoatingisfullycured,otherpropertiessuchasadhesioncandevelopovertime
Fromaproductionflowpointofview,itisdesirabletominimizethetimetohandleandtimetofullcureasmuchaspossible,takingintoaccountthefactorspreviouslydiscussed.Fromaleanproductionpointofview,minimisingthetimetooptimumpropertiesenablesyoutoshipproductyouknowisatitsoptimum,orenablesthesepropertiestodevelopduringtransporttimetotheendcustomer,withouthavingtostoreasignificantnumberofdaysofinventory.
National,State,RegionalLegislationandInsurance
Mostcountries,statesandevenregionshavetheirownlegislationrelatingtotheemissionofVolatileOrganicCompounds(VOCs),withdifferingdefinitionsandinterpretations.Wheninstallinganewprocessyouneedtobemindfulofthese,andifpossible,useacompliantmaterial.Forexistingprocesses,thereareoptionsincludingcarbonfiltration,solventcollection,oroxidising(afterburner)unitsthatcanbeinstalledatsignificantexpense,althoughthiscanbemoreeffectivethanre-qualifying
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
newmaterialswithmultipleendcustomers.Sometimes,processand/orperformanceconsiderationswillrequirethistypeofsolution,evenfornewqualifications.
Shippingflammable,hazardousmaterialsisexpensiveandrequiresaspecialisedfreightfirminmostcountries.Usingasafermaterialcansimplifylogisticsandreducecost.Usingflammable,hazardousmaterialsisinherentlymoredangerouswithagreaterriskofseriousinjury,long-termexposureeffectsorcatastrophicincidents,andthisisreflectedininsurancepremiums,whichisanotheropportunitytosavecost.Sometimes,incidentswithinplants,suchasfireswillnecessitateachangeinmaterial,regardlessofprocess,lackofbusinesscaseoranyotherdriver,otherthancompliance.
SupplierPerformance
Choosingaconformalcoatingmaterialisalongandexhaustiveprocess,withmanyconsiderationsandconflictingchoicesandtradeoffstobemade.Mostsupplierswouldwalkyouthroughasimilarframeworktothistodecideonthemostsuitableconformalcoatingforconsiderationonyourshortlist.
Thisconsultationprovidesavaluableinsightintoyourpotentialmaterialsupplier.Iftheyareunwillingorunabletohelpyouthroughtheselectionprocess,thentheyareunlikelytobemuchhelptoyouwithanyongoingissuesthatneedtoberesolved.Ifyougetgreatsupportandback-uppriortoqualification,thenthisisanindicatorthatyoursupplierknowsyourbusinesswellenoughtobecomeavalue-addedsupplierduringproduction.
Thesamplingprocesswillhelpyouunderstandthegeographicreachofyourpotentialsupplier,andlocalavailabilityetc.Ifyoursamplehastoshiphalfwayacrosstheworld,thenyoursupplychainislikelytobeunsuitableordifficultinproduction.
Finally,akeyfactorisqualitycontrolofthemanufacturingprocess.Considerthecostsforwithdrawingaproductthathasbeencoatedinaconformalcoatingthathasbeenproducedincorrectly.Traceabilityandqualitycontroloftheprocessiscriticaltoavoidadisasteratalaterpoint.
Price
Manymaterialsareselectedonprice.Althoughthisisavalidpoint,considerationofalltheotherfactorsisarguablyasimportantifnotmore.Ultimately,thecostofthecoatingisfractionsofthetrueofmanufactureandthewrongmaterialspecifiedatthedesignstagecancostmanytimesthesavingoriginallyconsidered.
-
SCHTechnologiesisaTradingNameofSCHServicesLimited
NewburghBuilding,McLintockWay,Barnsley,SouthYorkshire.S706BFTel:+44(0)1226297711Fax:+44(0)1226297733
www.conformalcoating.co.uk
Conclusions
SelectingaConformalCoatingisacrucialstageofthedesignprocess.However,itshouldbeconsideredinthecontextofallthefactorsoutlinedabove.Ifnot,thenitshouldnotbeasurprisetofindproblemslaterdowntheprocessstreamthatcouldhavebeenavoidedfromthestart.
Ifindoubt,checkwiththesupplierandindependentexperts.Donotneglectthisstageoryourprocessandfinalproductcouldbecompromised.
SIGNUPNOW
Ifyouhaven’talreadyclickSignUptoTechnicalBulletinMailingListNOWsoyoucanreceivenotificationwheneachnewBulletinisavailabletodownloadfromourwebsite.
PleaseNote
YourinformationisveryimportanttousandwillneverbeusedbyusforanythingotherthansendingyoualinktothenextTechnicalBulletin.Wedonotpassyourinformationontoanyother3rdpartiesandtreatthedatawithalevelofconfidentiality.
Ifyouareindoubtjustunsubscribefromourlist.