tatak integridad, serbisirong dekalidad, kaagapay se … of...aparri school of arts and trades...

Thank you and best regards. SOf SERVICE 7R zceivod 1)

4, .,C--:sra,S10

kt".1

TECHNICAL EDUCATION AND SKILLS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

ISO 9001 : 2008 CERTIFIEDTatak Integridad, Serbisirong Dekalidad, Kaagapay se Pag - unlad

22 March 2013

HON. ROSALINDA DIMAPILIS-BALDOZSecretaryDepartment of Labor and EmploymentIntramuros, Manila

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENTOffice of the Secretary

DATE:

TIME

RECEIVED BY: ,,-1Tx/ovi.)Attention: MS. AMUERFINA R. REYES

Director IVHuman Resource Development Service (HRDS)

Dear Secretary Baldoz:

This is to officially submit to your office the attached first quarter monitoringreports on the pending cases and complaints involving TESDA personnel.

Please acknowledge receipt hereof.

Very truly yours,

POLAR G. D E

Director IVOffice of the Chief of Servicesfor Administration

East Service Road, South Luzon Expressway, Taouig City, Metro Manila, Philippines • Tel No 887-7777 Telefax No: 893-2454 • VVebsite: httpillyvvAvitesda.gov.ph

Republic of the PhilippinesTECHNICAL EDUCATION AND SKILLS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

TESDA Complex, East Service Road, Taguig City -.

LIST OF DECIDED CASES(based on the Submitted Pending Cases)

1st Quarter, 2013

FORM 03

No. OFFICE DOCKET No. Complainant RESPONDENT/Position NATURE OF CHARGE

FOILEDATE

DD-MM-W(B A) ,DATE OF DECISION

DD-MM-YY

AGING

By Year andby Months

.

TYPE OF CASE

PREVIOUS STATUS

(In case of Appeal orMR)

CURRENT STATUS PENALTY/REMARKS DATE OFIMPLEMENTATION

1TESDACamarinesNorte

CSCResolution No.

10-00079CSC Hedy R.

Marin/Director III

Falsification of OfficialDocuments(For making it appear thatshe has not reached theretirement age)

21December

200907 September 2010 9 months Administrative

-

On 14 October 2010,Ms. Mann filed anUrgent Motion forEarly Resolution ofMotion forReconsideration.

The Commission denied theMotion for Reconsideration filedby Marin on her request forcorrection of date of birth fromFebruary 14, 1943 to February14, 1946.

The permanentappointments of Ms.Marie as ChiefAdministrative Officer .and Director 111 at TESDAeffective 11 August2009 and 19 March2010, respectively, weredisapproved.

She mandatorily retired inthe government serviceeffective 14 February 2008.

2

ApaniSchool ofArts andTrades,Region It

CSC-R02RES. NO. 10-01R-015 (CSCRO2 CN. 07-

010 & 07-011)

RenelitoPescador

Vicente R. Paguilaand Genoveva D.Maximo

Grave Misconduct,Falsification of OfficialDocuments, and ConductPrejudicial to the BestInterest of the Service

11 February2006 06 September 2011 5 years and

7 months

•

Administrative

Ms. Maximo filed aPetition for Review ofthe decision dated 24November 2010 ofthe CSC RegionalOffice No. II

•

The appeal of Ms. Maximo wasgranted by the CSC.

The CSC decision dated24 November 2010finding her guilty ofSimple Misconduct andimposing upon her thepenalty of one (1) monthand one (1) daysuspension from thegovernment service andthe Resolution dated 25

•January 2011 denyingher motion forreconsideration wasreversed and set asideby the CSC.

Aparri School of Arts andTrades (ASAT) paid theback wages of Ms. Maximoon 3D September 2011 forthe period 01 February 2011to 07 March 2011.

GeneralServices

CentralOffice

Mr. Buhay D.Padua/Administrative Aide IV Mr.Resty B. Hemandez/Administrative AideIV

ple Misconduct 22 March2011 25 July 2011 4 months Administrative N/A

.TESDA issued a stem warningto the foregoing personnel. Sternly Warned 25 July 2011

4 TESDARegion II N/A Anonymous

TESDA RegionalOffice inTuguegarao City

Administrative Complaint09

September2011

N/A Admtnistrative N/A

TESDA issued a Letter to CSCdated 28 November 2011informing the latter about theupdates on the case andlikewise requesting for thecontact numbers of thecomplainants in order forTESDA to immediately respondto their needs.

N/A N/A

Page 1


FOILEDATE

DD-MM-YY

DATE OF DECISION

DD-MM-YY

AGING-A)(B

ymeoanr andMonths

Bby Year TYPE OF CASE

PREVIOUS STATUS


CURRENT STATUS PENALTY/REMARKSDATE OF

IMPLEMENTATION

5TESDARegion IV-BMIMAROPA

N/A Jay Rejano Director Baron JoseL. Lagren Grave Misconduct 24 October

2011 25 February 2011 4 months Administrative N/A

TESDA issued an order dismissing

the complaint for lack of prima faciecase to support the allegations onthe complaint.

N/A 25 February 2011

6CaviteTESDA

N/AGutierrezLucy Ms. Grace Cecilia V.

Malig / Senior TESDSpecialist

Inefficiency and Impropriety15 2011

March14-Feb-12 11 months Administrative WA

TESDA issued a stern warning to

Ms. Malig for not strictly observing

government office hours and

reasonable office rules andregulations.

Sternly Warned N/A

7

TESDATrainingCenterTaguigCampus(TTCTCE)

N/A TESDARodono P. Cruz,Administrative AideIII

Habitual Tardiness 25 July2011

18 January 2012 6 months Administrative N/ATESDA issued a stern warningto the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned N/A

8 PTC Bilar N/A Rizal E. CuaManchu D.Administrative

Mende,tive Aide

IIIFalsification of OfficialDocuments

26 January2012

02 April 20122 mos. & 7days

Administrative N/ATESDA issued a stern warning to the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned N/A

9

GeneralServicesDivision(GSD)

N/A

5 TVVCTrainees:Liza Ba-ay,Florinda S.Diaz, NoemaF. Flejoles,TherizOmadle &

Almi Ann A.Patina

Romando T.Buday/Administrative Aide IV

Grave Misconduct23 April

201205 June 2012

1 month &

13 daysAdministrative N/A

TESDA issued a stem warningto the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned N/A

10TESDA LaUnion

CSCResolution No.

120170

mobile no.09084098208

Carmelita A.Dulay/Senior TESDSpecialist

Grave Misconduct04 August2009

25 May 2010 (TESDA)21 March 2012 (CSC)

2 yrs, 6mos. & 16days

Administrative

CSC modified theDecision made byTESDA by finding Ms.Dulay guilty ofConduct Prejudicial tothe Best Interest ofthe Service andimposing the penaltyof one (1) yearsuspension from theservice.

TESDA issued an appointmentreinstating Ms. Dulay to theService effective 12 April 2012.

one (1) year suspension

Ms. Dulay was reinstated tothe service effective on theday she reported for work.The appointment of Ms.Dulay is still pending withthe Civil ServiceCommission for attestation.

rPage 2

No. OFFICE DOCKET No. Complainant RESPONDENT/Position ATURE OF CHARGE

ATEFILEDD

DD-MM-YY

DATE OF DECISION

DD-MM-YY

AGING(B-A)

By Year and

by MonthsTYPE OF CASE

PREVIOUS STATUS



IMPLEMENTATION

1UnionRTC La

N/A

ChitoGuamos ofLAUS Groupof Companies

Arturo G. Ganalon/Supervising TESDSpec ia lis t

Grave Misconduct February10, 2012 June 4, 2012

3 mos. & 25days Administrative N/A

TESDA issued a stem warningto the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned

12TESDARica) N/A Ramon J.

RoblesVelma S. Salazar,Provincial Director Grave Misconduct March 21 ,

2012July 19 ,2012,

3 monthsnd 28

ado y sAdministrative N/A

The complaint was dismissedfor lack of prima fade case tosupport the allegations on thecomplaint.

NIA N/A

13

BuyabodSchool ofArts andTrades(BSAT)

N/A AnonymousJoaquinRegio/Administrative Aide II

Grave Misconduct March 23,2012

July 17, 20123 months

and 24days

Administrative N/ATESDA issued a stern warningto the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned N/A

1 4

BuyabodSchool ofArts andTrades(BSAT)

N/A TESDA

Cristina G.Parreno/AdministrativeOfficer IV

Grave Misconduct March 23,2012

July 17, 20123 monthsand 24days

Administrative N/A TESDA issued a stern warningto the foregoing personnel.

Sternly Warned N/A

,'

ProvincialOfficeDavao delNorte,TESDARegion XI

N/A Ms. Shirley G.Roa

Provincial DirectorUrbario B. Budtanand MsN. Gamale, TESD

. Mafel Joan

Specialist II

alleged corrupt activities May 222012

September 3, 2012 3 monthsand 13 days

Administrative N/A

The complaint against Dir.Budtan was dismissed for lackof prima fade case to supportthe allegations on the complaint.

N/A N/A

16Quezon CityDistrictOffice ofTESDA NCR

N/A TESDA

Mr. Teodoro A.Marinas,Administrative AideIV

Grave Misconduct June 25,2012

01 October 2012 2 monthsand 6 days

Administrative N/ATESDA issued a stern warningto the foregoing personnel.

N/A N/A

17

MisamisOriental

Office,Provincial

TESDARegion X

N/A

TSG RubenM. Guilot PA(RET), CoopManager ofGunneryCreditCooperative

AustoliolgoUSupervisingTESD Specialist andRa uel B. Toro no,q y

AdministrativeAssistant III

Grave Misconduct June 24,2012

01 October 20122 months

and 5 da ysAdministrative N/A

TESDA issued a stern warningto the foregoing personnel.

N/A N/A

Page 3


DFILED

DD-MM-YY

DATE OF DECISION

DD-MM-YY

(13ATE

AAGIN G

-)By ygar and

by MonthsTYPE OF CASE

PREVIOUS STATUS


CURRENT STATUS PENALMREMARKSDATE OF

IMPLEMENTATION

18 TESDARegion 1 N/A

ConcernedPersonnel ofthe RegionalOperationsDivision ofRegion 1

iils. Perlita E.Bambao/SeniorTESD Specialist

Grave Misconduct 10 August2009

17 May 2010 9 monthsand 7 days

Administrative N/A

Ms. Bambao filed a Motion forReconsideration with Prayer forReinvestigation of the decisiondated 17 May 2010 of the thenDirector General Pastor Z.Guiao. On 16 June 2010, thenDG Guiao modified theforegoing decision by excludingthe administrative penalties.

The Civil ServiceCommission (CSC)issued a Resolution No.12-0789 on 19 November2012 on the appeal ofMs. Bambao, affirmingthe decision dated 17May 2010 issued byTESDA. The CSCissued a Resolution No13-00419 dated 26February 2013 denyingthe motion forreconsideration withclarification of Ms.Bambao and affirmed theCSC Decision No. 12-0789 dated 19November 2012.

Ms. Bambao was dismissedfrom the service effective 09June 2010.

19

RegionalOffice,TESDARegion II

N/A Civil ServiceCommission

Valerio D.Rola/Regional

Directoralleged irregularities

27December

2012N/A

1 month and19 days

Administrative N/A

TESDA directed RegionalDirector to comment on the

foregoing complaint. RD Rolasubmitted his answer on theforegoing complaint. TESDA

informed the CSC on the actiontaken by the TESDA on the

foregoing complaint. In view ofthe foregoing letter of TESDA,the CSC considered the matter

duly acted upon.

N/A N/A

20 TESDARegion VII

CA G.R. SPNO 119892/

UDK No.14708

TESDA vs.Erlando L.

Majan

.

Erlando L.Majan/TESDSpecialist II

Being NotoriouslyUndesirable

11 August2008

5-Sep-124 yearsand 28days

Administrative

The petition forreview which wasfiled by Mr. Majanwas dismissed bythe Court ofAppeals for lack ofmerit.

The petition for review whichwas filed by Mr. Majan wasdismissed by the Supreme

Court on 05 September 2012for lack of merit.

N/A N/A

Page 4

No OFFICE DOCKET No. ComplainantRESPONDENT/Posit

ion

NATURE OF CHARGE

FOILED

DD-MM-YY

DATE OF DECISION

DD-MM-YY

(BATE

AAGIN)G

-

By Year andby Months

TYPE OF CASE

PREVIOUS STATUS



IMPLEMENTATION

21 N/A

SimpliciaDuran

<[email protected]

ma

AustolioIgot/SupervisingTESD Specialist

Grave Misconduct12 May2012

TESDA referred thecomplaint to TESDARegion X. TESDAissued a Letteraddressed to the Officeof the Ombudsmaninforming the actiontaken by the TESDA onthe foregoing complaint.

3 monthsand 9 days

Administrative N/A

The TESDA Region X findsthe issue against Mr. Igot as

moot and academic andrecommended that theforegoing complaint be

dismissed_

N/A N/A

Page 5


TESDA Complex. East Service Road. Taguig City

LIST OF PENDING COMPLAINTSis Quarter, 2013

FORM 02

No.REFER

ENCENO

OFFICECOMPLAINANT

RESPONDENT/

POSITIONNATURE OF

COMPLAINT/SDATE FILEDDD-MM-YY STATUS OF COMPLAINTS

CASES LODGED AT THENo. of Personnel with cases

AS RESPONDENT)TYPE OF CASE REMARKS

TESDA CSCOmbudamen

3rd levelRank and

FileTotal Admin Criminal Civil

QuezonNational

AgriculturalSchool(ONAS)

TESDA

Nestor C. Ulan,Assistant Professor 1and Zoraida V.Amper, VocationalSchoolSuperintendent

Gross Neglect ofDuty

31 January 2012

The ACC recommended toformally charge Mr. Ulan andMs. Amper for Gross Neglect ofDuty.

1 0 0 0 2 2 2 0 0The Formal Charge is for signatureof the Director General.

2

TorrijosPoblacion

School of Artsand Trades

(TPSAT)

Anonymous

Mr. Silvestre J.Nagutom, VocationalSchool Administrator,Ms. Heidi V. Pereda,Public Health Nurse Iand Ms. Clarice F.Reyes of TorrijosPoblacion School ofArts and Trades

Falsification ofOfficial Documents(Daily TimeRecord)

03 February 2012

Mr. Nagutom, Ms. Reyes andMs. Pereda filed theirrespective resignation on 08June 2012, and 14 June 2012.

0 0 0 3 3 3 0 0

The resignation of Mr. Nagutom tookeffect on 27 July 2012 while theresignation of Ms. Reyes and Ms.Pereda took effect on 04 Jul 2012.y

3

BalangigaNational

AgriculturalSchool (BNAS)

Anonymous

Melvin Joel B.SacmarNocationalSchool AdministratorII

Grave Misconduct 20 February 2012Mr. Sacmar filed his

nresignation

_o 23 April 2012. 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0The resignation of Mr. Sacmar tookeffect on 30 April 2012.

MisamisOriental

ProvincialOffice

Simplicia Duran<narudcia@ya

hoo.com >

Maynard C.JumawaniTESDSpecialist II

Grave Misconduct 12 May 2012

TESDA referred the complaintto TESDA Region X. TESDAissued a Letter addressed tothe Office of the Ombudsmaninforming the action taken bythe TESDA on the foregoingcomplaint.

1considering that there are complaints

0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0

TESDA Region X recommended thatthe issue be thoroughly investigated

raised regarding non-issuance of NCcollecting assessment fees withoutissuance of OR and unauthorizedcollection of fees.

4 Passi TradeSchool

Ladeva P.Marquez,AssistantProfessor 1

Anabelle P. Lizada,Administrative Assistant

1

Gross Neglect of

Duty05 September 2012

TESDA directed Ms. Lizada toexplain in writing within seventy-two (72) hours why she shouldnot be charged with GrossNeglect of Duty. Ms ' Lizadasubmitted her answer on theforegoing memorandum. TheACC recommended to formallycharge Ms.Lizada with GrossNeglect of Duty.

1 0 0 0 1 1 00 The Formal Charge is for signature

of the Director General.

5 TESDAPangasiean

Joseph ReyesDagupan City

Manuel B.Wong/ProvincialDirector

Misconduct 03 January 2013

TESDA directed PD Wong toComment on the complaint. PDWong submitted his commenton the foregoing memorandum.

1 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 0

The ACC recommended to dismissthe complaint considering that thereis no substantial evidence that wouldsupport the claims against ProvincialDirector Wong.

No.REFERENCE

NO.OFFICE

COMPLAINANTRESPONDENT/

POSITIONNATURE OF

COMPLAINT/SDATE FILEDDD-MM-W

STATUS OF COMPLAINTS

CASES LODGED AT THE(AS RESPONDENT)

No. of Personnel with casesTYPE OF CASE REMARKS

TESDA CSCOmbudsman

3rd levelRank and

FileTotal Admin Criminal Civil

6 TESDA IV-A TESDA NCRManuel G.Ocular/TESD SpecialistII

Disregard of SimpleOffice Regulations

08 January 2013

TESDA directed Mr. Ocular toexplain in writing within severity-two (72) hours why he shouldnot be charged with Violation ofExisting Civil Service Law. Mr.Ocular submitted his answer onthe foregoing memorandum.The ACC recommended toreiterate the memorandumissued to the Regional Directorsof TESDA-NCR and TESDARegion IV-A to submit a writtenreport relative to the non-submission of the DTRs of Mr.Ocular.

1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 For investigation

7Passi TradeSchool

Ms. Ladeva C.Marquez andMs. Ma. Teresa S.Paniza

Mr. Manuel A.Jaramilla/Office-in-Charge

alleged irregularities 03 July 2012

TESDA created a Fact FindingCommittee to conduct aniinvestigation on the complaintfiled against Mr. Jaramilla.

1 0 1 0 1 1 0 0For submission of the report andrecommendation of the Fact FindingCommittee

TOTAL 8 0 1 1 10 11 11 0 0

2


TESDA Complex, East Service Road, Taguig City

LIST OF PENDING CASES1st Quarter, 2013 FORM 01

OFFICE COMPLAINANT DOCKET No. RESPONDENT/ Position NATURE OFCOMPLAINTS


STATUS OF CASES LODGED AT THE No. of Personnel with cases (AS

c * I LTYPE OF CASE

DATE FILEDDO - MM - YY

TESDA sLeerg iacle Oremtd s CSC Court ofAppeals

Sand ganbcyan

Office ofthe

President3rd be el

Ran and

F le

,tOtAl AdMin Criminal Civil

Luciano MilianMemorialSchool of Artsand Trades(LMMSAT),Region 1

TESDA vs.Manuel A.

Jaramitla, Jr.

CA-G.R. No.119933

Manuel A. Jaramilla,former VSA of

LMMSAT

Grave Misconductand Dishonesty

Pending resolution with the Court of Appeals. 23 January 2008 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0

TESDARegion II

Joyce ElizabethR. Meneses vs.Mr. Valetio D.

Rola

N/A Valeeo D.Rola/Regional Director

Sexual Harassmentand Acts of

Lasciviousness

The complaint filed by Elizabeth R. Menesesagainst Valeno D. Rola was dismissed for lack ofjurisdiction as per CSC Resolution No. 10-0864 .The complaint was forwarded to the Office of thePresident considering that Mr. Rola is apiesidential appointee.

27 February2009

0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0

-r

No. OFFICE COMPLAINANT DOCKET Na. RESPONDENT/ Position NATURE OFCOMPLAINTS


STATUS OF CASES LODGED AT THE No. of Personnel with cases ASRFSPONDENTI

TWE OF CASE

DATE FILEDOD-MM-YY

TESDALegal

ServiceOmbucts

manCSC

Court ofAppeals

Sandiganbayan

Office ofthe

President3rd level

Rank andFile

Total Admin Criminal Civil

6Passi Trade

School

Ma. Teresa S.Paniza,

Instructor 1,Ladeva C.Marquez,

Instructor III,Rhyziel P.

Mendoza, CHSGraduate vs.Mr. Eddie A.

Vilvar

CPL-V-10-0537(Ombudsman)

Eddie A. Vilvar, FormerVSA, Passi Trade

School

Sexual Harassmentand Rape

The case is with the Office of the Ombudsman. 04 October 2010 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 o 1 1 1 0

7TESDA NorthCotabato

TESDA vs.Florante L.

HerreraNIA

Florante L. Herrera/Provincial Director

Grave Misconduct(For violating

UTPRAS rules andregulations)

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that PD Herrera be held liable forGrave Misconduct and be meted out the penaltyof dismissal from the service. The case is forresolution by the Director General.

18 January 2010 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0

8

TESDAWomenCenter/CentralOffice

TESDA vs.Leonora S.

SottoN/A

Leonora S. Sotto/

Cook ilHabitual Tardiness

The ACC recommended for the issuance of anorder suspending Ms. Sotto for fifteen (15) days.The case is for resolution by the DirectorGeneral.

19 January 2010 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

1 1 1

0 0

TESDA was again directed Ms. Sotto to explainin writing within seventy-two (72) hours why sheshould not be charged with FrequentUnauthorized Tardiness. Ms. Sotto submitted heranswer on the foregoing memorandum.

09 August 2012 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

9

TorrijosPoblacionSchool of Artsand Trades/RegionalOffice IV-BMIMAROPA

TESDA vs.Clarice F. Reyes

N/AClarice F.

Reyes/AdministrativeOfficer IV

Simple Misconduct

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Ms. Reyes be held liable forthe charge of Simple Misconduct and besuspended for one (1) month and one (1) day.The case is for resolution by the DirectorGeneral.

18 February2011

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0

10

CamarinesSur Institute ofFisheries andMarineSciences(CASIFMAS)

TESDA vs.Sonia E. de

RamosN/A

Ms. Sonia E. deRamosNocational

School Superintendent


The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Ms. De Ramos be heldliable for Gross Neglect of Duty and be metedwith the penalty of six (6) months and one (1)day to one (1) year suspension for the servicewithout pay. The case is for resolution by theDirector General.

25 February2011

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0

JS

Na. OFFICE COMPLAINANT DOCKET No. RESPONDENT/ Position NATURE OFCOMPLAINTS

STATUS OF COMPLAINTSDATE FILEDDD-MM-YY

STATUS OF CASES LODGED AT THE No or Personnel with cases AS

R SPONOFNTITYPE OF CASE

TESDA.Legal

ServiceOmbods

manCSC

Court ofAppeals

Sendigano

aYan

Office of

thePresident

3 rd levelrHank

andFile

al <kernel Criminal Civil

., .,


TESDA vs.Victorino B.

Almario,N/A

Mr. Victorino B.Almario/Instructor 1

Grave Misconductand Gross Neglect

of Duty

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Mr. Aimed° be held liablefor Gross Neglect of Duty and SimpleMisconduct and be meted out with the penalty ofone (1) year suspension from the service withoutpay. The case is for resolution by the DirectorGeneral.

25 February2011

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

12


TESDA vs.Eliseo R.

Cadag, Jr.N/A R. Cadag,

Jr./Security Guard II

Grave Misconductand Gross Neglect

of Duty

Eliseo R

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Mr. Almario be held liablefor Gross Neglect of Duty and be meted out withthe penalty of one (1) year suspension from theservice without pay. The case is for resolutionby the Director General.

25 February2011

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0

13

CamarinesSur Institute ofFmi ashrienreies and

Sciences(CASIFMAS)

TESDA vs.Prospero B.

BiguejaN/A

Prospero B.Bigueja/Security Guard

II


The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Mr. Bigueja be held liable forSimple Neglect of Duty with penalty of six (6)months suspension from the service without pay.The case is for resolution by the DirectorGeneral.

25 February2011

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

14

Passi TradeSchool

/TESDARegion VI

TESDA vs.Herrninio H.

Pedroso, AraceliC. Panolino and

Thelma P.Andraje

N/A

Herminio H. Pedrosa,Officer-in-Charge,

Araceli C. Panolino,Accountant I, and

Thelma P. Andraje,Cashier I

Grave Misconduct

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Mr. Pedroso, Ms. Panolinoand Ms. Andraje be held liable for GraveMisconduct and be meted out with the penalty ofsix (6) months suspension from the servicewithout pay. The case is for resolution by theDirector General.

27 May 2011 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 3 1 0 0

7'

No. OFFICE COMPLAINANT DOCKET No. RESPONDENT/ Position NATURE OF STATUSCOMPLAINTS

OF COMPLAINTS

STATUS OF CASES LODGED AT THENo. of Personnel with c-ses AS

RtSPONSFNTI.TYPE OF CASE

DATE FILEDDD-MM-W

TESDA ServiceLegal Ombuds

manCSC

CourtAppeals

of Sandiganbayan

Office ofthe

President3rd level

Rank and

FileTotal Adnun Criminal Civil

15

TESDACentral Office

Office of theOmbudsman

FieldInvestigation

Office

OMB-C-A-11-0332-F

(AdministrativeCase)

Former DirectorGeneral Augusto L.

Syjuco, Former ChiefAccountant Guillerma

L. Aguilar, FormerDirector Antonio B. Del

Rosario, FormerAttorney VI Marjorie S.

Docdocil, FormerDirector General

Rogelio C. Peyuan ,Maximiano F.

Montemayor, Jr.,Administrative Officer

1, Juanito L Belda,Chief, AdministrativeOfficer, Francisco D.

Fang, Sr.Administrative

Assistant 1, Buen S.Mondejar former

Director IV (RegionalDirector), Ma AdodndaDe Jesus-Forro, BoardSecretary VI, Ernesto

A. Beltran, Director IV,Teodoro S. Sanico,

Director IV andAnnabelle T. Quimbo,Chief AdministrativeOfficer, Vicente G.

Rotas, President andChairman of the Board

and Lyndon C. Ang,President/Manager.

•

Serious Dishonesty, pursuantGrave

Administrative

Misconduct andSyjuco,

Conduct Prejudi-oral to the BestInterest of the

Service

and in view of her death.

dismissedOmbudsmanforfeituredisqualification

and

responders

insufficiency

Beltran, Beide, Montemayor and Fang werefrom the service by the Office of the

with cancellation of eligibility,of retirement benefits, and perpetual

from holding public officeto Section 52 of the Revised Rules on

Cases in the Civil Service. SincePeyuan, Del Rosario, Sanico, Mondejar,

Doodad were no longer connected in TESDAdismissal from the service cannot be

effected anymore, the alternative penalty of fineequivalent to one (1) year salary for each

shall be imposed with the sameaccessory penalties thereof. In the case ofAguilar and Quimbo, the case is dismissed for

of evidence while the chargesagainst Forro were dismissed lack of evidence

The Office of the Ombudsman issued aconsolidated resolution dated 24 January 2013recommending for the filing before theSandiganbayan of a criminal case for violation ofSection 3(e) of RA 3019, as amended, andSection 3(g) of RA 3019, as amended, againstSyjuco, Peyuan, Del Rosario, Beltran, Sanico,Mondejar, Docdocil, Beide, Montemayor andFang.

04 February2011 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 2 4 E 1 1 0

OMB-C-C-11-0321-F (Criminal

Case)

Violation of Sec.3(e), R.A. 3019 and

Malversation ofPublic Funds; Viol.of Sec. 3(g), R.A.3019 and Secs..

65.1(5) 65.2(1), RuleXXI of the IRR of

R.A. 9164 (asagainst respondentsexcept Lyndon Ang);

and Viol. of Sec.3(g) of R.A. 3019

and Secs.. 65.1(5),65.2(1), Rule XXI ofthe IRR of R.A. 9184(as against Lyndon

Ang)

NOTE: 1) Atty. Marjorie S. Docdocil , Mr. Antonio B. Del Rosario , Ms. Guillerma L. Aguilar and Mr. Bunn S. Mondejar had retired from the service on 31 December 2009, 10 December 2008, 15 February 2008 and 04 July 2011 , respectively. 2) Mr. Augusto Boson Syjuco and Mr. Rogelio C. Peyuan

longer connected with TESDA. 3)Ms. Adorinda DJ Forro died on 11 February 2010.

are no

16 TESDA AklanTESDA vs.Edwin S.

VillanuevaN/A

Edwin S.Villanueva/Provincial

DirectorGrave Misconduct

The designated Hearing Officer from theDepartment of Labor and Employmentrecommended that Mr. Villanueva be held liablefor Grave Misconduct and be meted out with thepenalty of dismissal. The case is for resolutionby the Director General.

30 January 2012 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

No. OFFICE COMPLAINANT DOCKET No. RESPONDENT/ Position NATURE OF STATUSCOMPLAINTS

OF COMPLAINTS

STATUS OF CASES LODGED AT THENo. of Personnel with cases (AS

RFSRONDFITFITYPE OF CASE

DATE FILEDDO-MM-YY

TESDA st:rvg ill e °mtrudsroan CSC

Court of SandiganbCZpoms ayan

° fire of

siiedentPre t 3' d level

Rank andFile

Total Admin Criminal Civil

17TESDAWomen

Center (TVVC)

TESDA. vs.Mensel S. Drilo

N/AMensel S. Drilo,Administrative

Assistant IIIGrave Misconduct

TESDA formally charged Ms. Drilo for GraveMisconduct on 13 August 2012. Ms. Drilosubmitted her answer on the foregoingmemorandum. The case is for resolution by theDirector General.

30 April 2012 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

18 TESDACentral Office

FieldInvestigation

Office, Office ofthe

Ombudsman,Agham Road,Quezon City

OMB-C-A-12-0415 (Admin.

Case)

Annabelle T. Quimbo,Chief Administrative

Officer, Budget DivisionGrave Misconduct

For investigation by the Office of theOmbudsman

13 November2012

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

1

19TESDA

Central Office

FieldInvestigation



OMB-C-C-12-0415 (Crim.

Case)

Annabelle T. Quimbo,Chief Administrative

Officer, Budget Division

Violation of Article220 of the RPC;

Section 3(e) and (g)of R.A. 3019, in

relation to Section65 of R.A. 9184


13 November2012

0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

20TESDA

Central Office

FieldInvestigation



OMB-C-C-12-0415 (Grim.

Case)

Cariza A.Dacuma/Chief

Accountant

Violation of Article220 of the RPC;

Section 3(e) and (g)of R.A. 3019, in

relation to Section65 of R.A. 9184


13 November2012

0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

21Manila District

Office

TESDA vs.Rowena D.

PadillaN/A

Rowena D. Padilla,Administrative Officer

IVGrave Misconduct

TESDA formally charged Ms. Padilla for GraveMisconduct on 31 January 2013. Ms. Padillasubmitted her answer on the foregoingmemorandum. For investigation by thedesignated Hearing Officer from the Departmentof Labor and Employment (DOLE).

15 June 2012 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0

22Nueva Ecija

ProvincialOffice

TESDA vs. JulieAnn D.

Banganan,N/A

Julie Ann D.Banganan, Provincial

DirectorGrave Misconduct

TESDA formally charged Ms. Banganan forGrave Misconduct on 31 January 2013. Ms.Banganan has not submitted her answer on theforegoing memorandum. For investigation by thedesignated Hearing Officer from the Departmentof Labor and Employment (DOLE).

23 October 2012 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 0

TOTAL 12 0 6 0 4 1 1 8 21 29 21 4 0