tata cellular v union of india 1996.doc

8/13/2019 Tata Cellular v Union of India 1996.doc

1/58

MANU/SC/0002/1996

Equivalent Citation: AIR1996SC11, JT1994(4)SC532, (1994)6SCC651,

[1994]Supp2SCR122

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appel N!"# 494$%50 !& 1994#

'eie *+ 26#0$#1994

Appell+-"Tata CellularVs.

Re"p!+e+- Union o In!ia

Hon"#le $u!%es:M# N# .e+-li, CJI#, M# M# u+i+ S# M!+, JJ#

Counsels:! Appell+-/e-i-i!+e/li+-i&& S!li J# S!ee, M## 7i+8, A"! Se+, i" N#Slve+ ul: .+v-i, Av"

! Re"p!+e+-"/'e&e++- '## up-, S!lii-! e+el, A#7# 'iv+, ;#"+, ;#;# .e+u8!pl+ # R:" C!e !& Ci:i+l !eue, 19$3 % Se-i!+ 4?2> R#S#C# % *e

59 Rule 3(2)

Cases Reerre!:M+ @l v# ' e: C+, MANU/SC/0001/195$> A"! ;u: v v# S--e !&=+,MANU/SC/0026/19?5> S-eli+8 C!:pu-e" @i:i-e v# M#N# uli-i!+"@i:i-e, AIR 1993 SCB 6?3> U+i!+ !& I+i v# i+u"-+ 'evel!p:e+-C!p!-i!+, MANU/SC/0219/1994N uli-i!+ @i:i-e v# M#T#N#@# (1992) 4 '@24>u"i+ Duip:e+- E Ce:il" @-# v# S--e !& Be"-7e+8l, MANU/SC/0061/19$4> M!:: F u""i+ v# M!:: I&-i

u""i+, MANU/R/001$/1931> #7# M+ v# Jl8!+ Mu+iiplC!u+il,MANU/SC/02?4/1991> ! S-eel C!p!-i!+ v# +e" +8i+eei+8

B!", MANU/SC/0363/1991> R+i- Tu v# U+i!+ !&

I+i, MANU/SC/0691/19?$> C+ @l Su v# U+i!+ !&I+i, MANU/SC/02?5/1990>MANU/SC/02?5/1990> Civil Sevie U+i!+ v# Mi+i"-e &!
http://fncitation%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996');http://fnopenjudges%28%27433%27%29/http://fnopenjudges%28%27468%27%29/http://fnopenjudges%28%27557%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%273736%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2710077%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%273282%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275442%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275442%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2710078%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%27728%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272718%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272162%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272162%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2734%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275122%27%29/http://fnopencatch%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996')http://fnmentionedin%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0001/1957','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0219/1994','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0061/1974','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/PR/0017/1931','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0284/1991','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0363/1991','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0691/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://suggestcitationaddbtn%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996',%221%22)http://fnsavedoc%28%29/http://fnnewemail%28%29/http://showprint%28%29/http://fnopenjudges%28%27433%27%29/http://fnopenjudges%28%27468%27%29/http://fnopenjudges%28%27557%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%273736%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2710077%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%273282%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275442%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275442%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2710078%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%27728%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272718%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272162%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%272162%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%2734%27%29/http://fnopencounsel%28%275122%27%29/http://fnopencatch%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996')http://fnmentionedin%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0001/1957','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0219/1994','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0061/1974','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/PR/0017/1931','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0284/1991','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0363/1991','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0691/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://fncitation%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996');


2/58

-e Civil Sevie, (19?5) 1 A C 3$4> N!- Ble" !lie v# v+", (19?2)3 All R141> u+-!+ v# Mi+i"-e !& e+"i!+" + N-i!+l I+"u+e, (1963) 1 B@R 1?6 "iCu= v# 'ie-! e+el, '!!"+, MANU/SC/0154/19??> R: E S=:C!# v# S--e !& =+,MANU/SC/001$/19?5> i T#M# ""+ R 'vi" C!+--!" @-# v# e:U#'#C#, (1956) 2 All R 145> #C#I# v# ;:e+u C--le ee

I+u"-ie",MANU/SC/025$/1993> M!!= v# Ci-= !& U+ive"i-= 2$? SB 2 912 (C-Civ App TeG 1955)> R+i- Tu v# U+i!+ !& I+i, MANU/SC/0691/19?$> 'i"-i- !&

C!lu:i v# !ll, (1961) 343 US 451> U+i!+ Cie C!p!-i!+ v# U+i!+ !&I+i, MANU/SC/005?/1992> C+ @l Su v# U+i!+ !&

I+i, MANU/SC/02?5/1990> ! S-eel C!p!-i!+ v# +e" +8i+eei+8B!", MANU/SC/0363/1991> Cle C!:p+= v# Ci-= !& R!e"-e (1?99) 1$? US3$3

Aut(orities Reerre!:Miel Suppe"-!+e + J:e" !uie i+ HJuiil Revie 7l"@< 'i-i!+= SiG- i-i!+> 'e S:i-" C!+"-i-u-i!+l + A:i+i"--ive @< Ne e!&&e= A li i+ N-ul Ju"-ie i+iple" + -il Appli-i!+ 19$9i-i!+

Prior Histor+:!: -e Ju8:e+- + *e -e 26#2#93 !& -e 'eli i8 C!u- i+ C#B# N!"#4030%32/92, 4302/91 + 163 !& 1993#

Citin% Reeren'e:

'i"u""e

15

'i""e+-e

1?

Me+-i!+e

44

Case Note:

Constitution &u!i'ial revie, Arti'le - o Constitution o In!ia /rin'i/les o&u!i'ial revie, a//lies to e0er'ise o 'ontra'tual /o,er #+ 1overn2ent#o!ies in or!er to /revent ar#itrariness or avouritis2 t(ere are in(erentli2itation in e0er'ise o /o,er &u!i'ial revie, 1overn2ent is %uar!ian o

inan'es o State 1overn2ent is e0/e'te! to /rote't inan'ial interest oState ri%(t to reuse lo,est or an+ ot(er ten!er is al,a+s availa#le to

1overn2ent ,(ile a''e/tin% or reusin% ten!er /rin'i/les lai! !o,n inArti'le - to #e 3e/t in vie, 4 ,(en 1overn2ent tries to %et #est /erson or
http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0154/1988','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0017/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0516/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0257/1993','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0691/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0058/1992','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0363/1991','1');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','2');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','6');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0154/1988','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0017/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0516/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0257/1993','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0691/1987','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0058/1992','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0285/1990','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0363/1991','1');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','2');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','6');http://fnopencr%28%27manu/SC/0002/1996','1');


3/58

#est quotation t(ere 'an #e no question o inrin%e2ent o Arti'le - ri%(t to'(oose 'annot #e 'onsi!ere! as ar#itrar+ /o,er.

$UD1MENT

S. Mo(an5 $.

1# @eve 8+-e#

2# All -e"e ppel" + e el-

Tele!::u+i-i!+#

4# A Tele!: C!::i""i!+


4/58

"u:i--e -! -e Tele!: C!::i""i!+, -e :--e :e up &! i"u""i!+ :!+8 -e:e:e" !& -e C!::i""i!+# *+ 2$#5#92 -e Tele!: C!::i""i!+ ep-e -ee!::e+-i!+" !& -e Te+il vlu-i!+ C!::i--ee# Te Ci:+e!::e+e -- -e "!-%li"- !& ie", -e e!::e+-i!+" !& -e Te+evlu-i!+ C!::i--ee + -e p!p!"l &! &i++il i" e ple e&!e -e"ele-i!+ C!::i--ee - -e elie"-#

$# I- eDuie" -! e +!-e, - -i" "-8e, -- Sele-i!+ C!::i--ee l"! e"ie "ApeG/i8%p!

C!::i--ee# *+ 2#9#92 -e "e!+ Te+e vlu-i!+ C!::i--ee "u:i--e i-"

e!::e+-i!+"# !


5/58

p!e"" e !:ple-e = '!- i+-e+ll=>

2# *+l= !+e p-= := e 8+-e lie+e &! !+e i-=> +

3# Te -ul "ele-i!+ !& -e lie+"ee "!ul e :e pi:il= !+ -e!+"ie-i!+ !& e+-l" + -e :" !-i+e i+ e"pe- !& &!ei8+

eG+8e i+&l!< + !u-&l!< i-ei!+ + eGpeie+e !& -e lie+"ee#

11# *+ 9#10#92, i+ !+e


6/58

15# S! :+ipul-e -ee= i-ei!+


7/58

(iii) 'e- eDui-= -i! "!ul +!- e :!e -+ 21#

22# I- i" !+e !u- = e!" -- !u- !& -e "eve+ i-ei i+ evlu-i+8 -e &i++ili, "iG p:e-e" l!+e 23# Be+ -i" i" -e p!"i-i!+, "-+8el=, -e ppell+- i" i+&!:e " &!ll!


8/58

Cellul Tee&!e, 7##@#

&- -- Ni

30# I+ -e "e !& :!"- !& -e ie" -e &!ei8+ eG+8e i" +!- :e- = -e &!ei8+

!ll!-!# I+ -e "e !& I+i Tele!:p -e e- eDui-= -i! i" 11# Tei -!-lp!e- !"- i" "--e -! e R"# 101 !e"# Ti" :e+" R"# 50#50 !e" epe"e+-eDui-= + -e !-e R"#50#50 !e" epe"e+- eG-e+l !::eil !!

"-i-l= pplie 7-i Cellul, M!i Tele!:, M!ile !::u+i-i!+", u-i"!+ MG,S=ell C!::u+i-i!+

i +!- &ul&il -i" C!+i-i!+#

31# I-


9/58

&!ei8+ !ll!-!", +:el=, MC< Cellul


10/58

!ll!-! &! e ie# I+ -e "e !& 7-i Cellul i- 40# A" 8i+"- 7@ -e -- i" " u+e

1# 7@ i +!- ppl= -! SIA/I7 u- -! Re"eve 7+ !& I+i (R7I)#

2# Te &!ei8+ !ll!-!


11/58

!& 1993 i" -- i- ll!


12/58

-e i8 C!u- ++!- "i- i+ u8:e+-# T! "--e i- i" lie vei&i-i!+ !& plei+8 i" -!!vel!! -- -e plei+8" e 8!ve+e = -e CC

&!ei8+ eG+8e# B- i" eDuie u+e -e -e+e !+i-i!+ i" -e p!e-i!+ !&&!ei8+ eG+8e i+&l!< + !u-&l!< el-i+8 -! -e ellul p!+e !+--# Ti"


13/58

:e+" i+&l!< i+ &!ei8+ eG+8e " e"ul- !& -e !pe-i!+ !& ellul p!+e"="-e:# e+e, -e e+i+8 &!: -!ui"-" + u"i+e"" -velle" i" ve= elev+-!+"ie-i!+# @ie -i" e"p!+e+-, u-i"!+ MG "ele-e &! -e 7!:= Ci-= l"!p!e-e &! -e &!ei8+ eG+8e !pe+i+8 = -e u"e !& ellul p!+e = -!ui"-"+ u"i+e"" -velle"# Te 8u:e+- -- -e &!ei8+ -!ui"-" + u"i+e""-velle" e +!- liel= -! u"e ellul -elep!+e i" +!- !e- "i+e -e ll" :e

-!u8 -e ellul -elep!+e" e +!- !+l= epe u- l"! ville " 24 !u"!:p+i!+# T-, !& !u"e, i" 8e-e &ili-=# I+ -e +!-e :e = -e Mi+i"-e i-

" ee+ :e+-i!+e -- -e e"p!+e+- " u+e-e+ -! e !u+ = !+i-i!+"!+-i+e i+ -e -e+e !u:e+-" -! -e e&&e- -- -e e+-ie &!ei8+ eG+8e

eDuie:e+- "ll e :e- = -e &!ei8+ !ll!-!# I+ &-, -e &!ei8+ !ll!-!" l"! !+&i:e -i"#

53# A" e8" -e lle8-i!+ !& C7I i+Duie, i- i" "u:i--e -- -e le+e Ju8e" !&-e i8 C!u- peu"e -e +!-e !& -e Ci:+ Tele!: C!::i""i!+# I- http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0061/1974','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','17483','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0061/1974','1');


14/58

5$# Te p:e-e" &! i+-e&ee+e i+ "u :--e

(i) Ml &ie

(ii) 7i"

(iii) Ai-i+e"" -! -e eG-e+- !& peve"i-=#

5?# I& +!+e !& -e"e i" pe"e+-, -e !u- "!ul +!- i+-e&ee# I- :u"- e le&- -! -eu-!i-ie"# Te !+-= 8u:e+-" v+e !+ el& !& -e ppell+-" 8i+"- -i"e"p!+e+- e +!- -e+le#

59# M# #S# Ni:+, le+e C!u+"el ppei+8 &! 7@ i+ -e &!e:!"- 8ue" ="ele-i!+


15/58

-! = -i" C!u- i+ R+i- Tu v# U+i!+ !& I+i MANU/SC/0691/19?$19??Ci@J15? # Te le+e C!u+"el &-e e&ei+8 -! -e elev+- "e l< "u:i-"-- "e" !& i" + !"-e+"ile i" -! e e8e i+ -e li8- !& -ei !

64# Te le+e S!lii-! e+el p!ue -e !pie" !& -e elev+- !u:e+-" i+

-e &ile + -!! u" -!u8 -e ":e# I- i" "u:i--e, &-e !u-li+i+8 -e p!e"" !&evlu-i!+ i+ -e "e!+ "-8e "iG p:e-e"

el-i!+ i+ "pei&ie &!: -! -e i !u:e+-"# Te el-i!+ 8ive+ =u-i"!+ MG


16/58

!& "eui+8 i8 :"#

66# M/"# I+i Tele!:p "eue -e "e!+ ple &! Clu--# I+ " :u " -e= -e ":e &!ei8+ p-+e " U" M-i+ -ee
http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0026/1985','1');


17/58

Cellul

$5# I+-e+-i!+l !:i+8 i" elev+- !+"ie-i!+# !: -e -e+e !u:e+- i-

$?# Te p!i+- 8i+"- u-i"!+ MG i", -e e&e- i+ i-" -e+e, :e -! e p!i+-e!u-, eDuii+8 i- -! !:pl=


18/58

?0# M# A"! Se+, i+ i" epl=

?1# M# i" Slve, i+ epl=,

el-i!+ -! !::!+ &!ei8+ !ll!-!# Ti" "!?3# vi+8 e8 -! -e !ve 8u:e+-"


19/58

9# I- :u"- e !& &ull :!u+-#

?5# I- ++!- e e+ie -- -e pi+iple" !& uiil evie<

-e S--e# Te i8- -! e&u"e -e l!

p!

90# Juiil evie< i" !+e+e http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','16910','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','16910','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','16910','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','16910','1');


20/58

Juiil Revie< i" !+e+e, +!-

Ti" e:e=, v"-l= i+e"e i+ -e eG-e+-, + e+ee, !ve l!+8 pei!i+ ee+- =e", !& i+&i+i-el= :!e !+ve+ie+- e"" -+ -- p!vie = -e

!l pe!8-ive -! "ee -- -e elev+- u-!i-ie" e -ei p!


21/58

p-iul ei"i!+ -e+ i+ -e &ul&ill:e+- !& -- p!li= i" &i# I- i" !+l= !+e+e +!- i-=, piii!u", !i""e> :u le"",

u-!i-= i+evi-l= le -! i&&ee+e" !& uiil !pi+i!+ " -! -eiu:"-+e" i+

p-il + u+eDul i+ -ei !pe-i!+ " e-


22/58

eGeu-ive i"e-i!+ 8e+ell= i+ A""!i-e !vi+il i-ue !u"e" @-# v#Be+e"u= C!p!-i!+# Ti" "e

p8e 229,

(1) I- i" !pe+ -! -e !u- -! evie< -e ei"i!+%:e" evlu-i!+ !& -e


23/58

&-"# Te !u-


24/58

Due"-i!+#H

Te "e!+ !+"ie-i!+ lei+8 -! +!< evie< -- !& le+ pe""ue#

I+ p-il -e:" i- := e -e :!e i:p!-+- !+"ie-i!+# M!e -+ +=

-e!= !& li:i-e evie< i- i" -e pe""ue !& -e uiil le+ !:i+e

li:e+- !&-e+ e+-u"-" -e ei"i!+ !& :--e -! "pei&ie pe"!+ ! !=,

:i+8 != i" i+&lue+e = !+"ie-i!+" ! &il" -!-e i+-! !u+- :--e" !u-"ie i-" p! e&i+i+8


25/58

-e:"elve" -! eii+8 e"!+le+e""> -e= ! +!- li&= -e :e+i+8 !&e"!+le+e"" u- e-i+ &ull i"e-i!+ i+ e "e -! "-e- i- i+ ei-e ie-i!+#

103# I+ U+ive"l C:e C!p!-i!+ v# N@R7 340 US 4$4 - 4??, Ju"-ie+&u-e "--e

A &!:ul &! uiil evie< !& :i+i"--ive -i!+ := &&! 8!u+" &! e-i-ueu- ++!- ""ue e-i+-= !& ppli-i!+# S!:e "!pe &! uiil i"e-i!+ i+ ppl=i+8

-e &!:ul + e v!ie !+l= = &l"i&=i+8 -e -ul p!e"" !& u8i+8 ! = u"i+8-e &!:ul " + i+"-u:e+- !& &u-ile "ui"-=# I- ++!- e -!! !&-e+ epe-e --

u8e" e +!- u-!:-# Te ul-i:-e eli+e &! -e &i !pe-i!+ !& += "-+ i" uii= !& i8 !:pe-e+e + -e + -e !+"-+- pl= !& + i+&!:ep!&e""i!+l i-iDue up!+ i-"

104# A+ i++!v-ive pp! i" :e = Clive @e


26/58

-e &i+l &iel#

###!! puli :i+i"--i!+ eDuie" p!pe !+"ie-i!+ !& -e pulii+-ee"-# I+ -i" !+-eG-, -e See-= !& S--e i" -e 8ui+ !& -e pulii+-ee"-#

###!! puli :i+i"--i!+ eDuie" p!pe !+"ie-i!+ !& -e le8i-i:-ei+-ee"-" !& i+iviul i-iFe+", !


27/58

u-!i-=

+-!p!:!pi !+ep-i!+ !& u"-ie, i", + :u"- e, -e !u- i-"el###

See 'vi" C!+--!" @-# v# e: U#'#C# [1956] 2 All R 145#

e- +!-e e !& e"!+le+e"" !& -e e"-i-i!+" !+ -e&u+:e+-l i8-" !&


28/58

Re&ei+8 -! -e !-i+e !& u+e"!+le+e"", ! Be "=" i+ A:i+i"--i!+ @

tata cellular v union of india 1996.doc

Documents