table of contents...dhaman, turk eximbank, asei and iciec which increased their business insured by...

30
TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION………………………………………………… 3 2. METHODOLOGY………………………………………………... 3 3. FINDINGS & ANALYSIS……………………………………….. 4 3.1 Ownership………………………………………………………… 4 3.2 Capital…………………………………………………………….. 4 3.3 Client Base ……………………………………………………… 6 3.4 Number of Buyers………………………………………………… 7 3.5 New Business Insured…………………………………………… 8 3.6 Leverage………………………………………………………..…. 17 3.7 Premiums Written………………………………………………… 18 3.8 Claims & Recoveries…………………………………………...…. 21 3.9 Loss Ratios……………………………………………………..…. 25 3.10 Outward reinsurance……………………………………………… 27 4. CONCLUSIONS………………………………………………… 29 ANNEX (AMAN UNION Questionnaire)………………………………….. 31

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jan-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. INTRODUCTION………………………………………………… 3

2. METHODOLOGY………………………………………………... 3

3. FINDINGS & ANALYSIS……………………………………….. 4

3.1 Ownership………………………………………………………… 4

3.2 Capital…………………………………………………………….. 4

3.3 Client Base ……………………………………………………… 6

3.4 Number of Buyers………………………………………………… 7

3.5 New Business Insured…………………………………………… 8

3.6 Leverage………………………………………………………..…. 17

3.7 Premiums Written………………………………………………… 18

3.8 Claims & Recoveries…………………………………………...…. 21

3.9 Loss Ratios……………………………………………………..…. 25

3.10 Outward reinsurance……………………………………………… 27

4. CONCLUSIONS………………………………………………… 29

ANNEX (AMAN UNION Questionnaire)………………………………….. 31

Page 2: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

2

GLOSSARY OF ABBREVIATIONS USED

ASEI : Asuransi Eksport Indonesia

CAGEX : Compagnie Algerienne D’Assurance Et De Garantie Des Exportations, Algeria

COTUNACE : Compagnie Tunisienne Pour L’Assurance Du Commerce Exterieur, Tunisia

DHAMAN : Arab Investment & Export Credit Guarantee Corporation

ECGA : Export Credit Guarantee Agency (S.A.O.C), Oman

ECGE : Export Credit Guarantee of Egypt

ECIE : Export Credit Insurance of Emirates

EGFI : Export Guarantee Fund of Iran

ICIEC : The Islamic Corporation for Insurance of Investment & Export Credit

JLGC : Jordan Loan Guarantee Corporation

LCI : The Lebanese Credit Insurer S.a.L

MEXIM : Malaysia Eximbank

NAIFE : National Agency for Insurance and Finance of Exports

SEP : Saudi Export Program

Shiekan : Shiekan Insurance & Reinsurance Co.

SONAC : Société Nationale d’Assurance du Crédit et du Cautionnement

Turkexim : Turk Eximbank

Page 3: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

3

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 AMAN UNION is an Association of Commercial and Non-Commercial

Risk Insurers and Reinsurers established in October 2009, assembling

Member Countries from the Arab Investment and Export Credit

Guarantee Corporation and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation

(OIC). It aims at promoting and developing the commercial and non-

commercial risks insurance industry and strengthening the mutual

relationships among members through a range of activities listed in

AMAN UNION Charter (available in the Website).

1.2 The purpose of this annual report is to present and analyse data on

business indicators of the members of the AMAN UNION for 2012. It

also attempts to outline the business trends of full members since the

establishment of the UNION and seeks to identify some of the main

developments experienced and key challenges being faced by those

members.

2. METHODOLOGY

2.1 AMAN UNION Secretariat General, managed by ICIEC since

November 2011, circulated a questionnaire (Annex) to the members in

order to collect information for the purposes of this report. All members

have responded. Wherever data was unavailable, estimates or past data

has been used in order to maintain consistency.

Page 4: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

4

2.2 List of ECAs included in the study is given below.

AMAN UNION Full Membres

Country ECA

1 Algeria CAGEX

2 Egypt ECGE

3 Indonesia ASEI

4 Iran EGFI

5 Jordan JLGC

6 Kuwait DHAMAN (Multilateral)

7 Lebanon LCI

8 Malaysia Malaysia Eximbank

9 Oman ECG Oman

10 Saudi Arabia SEP

11 Saudi Arabia ICIEC (Multilateral)

12 Senegal SONAC

13 Sudan NAIFE

14 Sudan Shiekan

15 Tunisia COTUNACE

16 Turkey Turk Eximbank

17 UAE ECIE

3. FINDINGS & ANALYSIS

3.1 Ownership

Out of the 17 members, there are 2 multilaterals (i.e. ICIEC and

DHAMAN), 1 private company (i.e. LCI) , 4 companies with mixed

public/private shareholders (i.e. SONAC, COTUNACE, JLGC and NAIFE)

and the remaining 10 ECAs are Government owned.

3.2 Capital

3.2.1 Collectively, the capital base of the AMAN UNION members in

2012 was USD 7.2 billion up from USD 7.1B in 2011. This was the

result of the capital increase of USD 120m made by EGFI in 2012.

Page 5: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

5

3.2.2 It should be noted that in 2012, the capital base of 3 ECAs (i.e. SEP,

Turkexim and MEXIM) accounts collectively for more than 87% of

the total capital of AU full members.

3.2.3 If we exclude the aforementioned ECAs, the average capital base of

the remaining ECAs comes to USD 72m. This indicates that the

majority of AMAN UNION full members still have a relatively

limited capital base. In light of the increasing demand on credit

insurance, this could impede the growth possibilities of those

ECA’s.

SEP56%Turk Eximbank

17%

MEXIM14%

EGFI4%

DHAMAN3%

ICIEC3%

Others3%

Page 6: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

6

3.3 Client Base

3.3.1 AMAN UNION members had 4,436 policyholders in 2012, up from

3,695 declared in 2011 (20% increase). This gives an average of 261

policyholder per ECA.

3.3.2 We noted that 96% of policyholders are holding Export Credit

Insurance policies.

3.3.3 COTUNACE and Turkexim account for 69% of the total number of

AMAN UNION policyholders with 1,391 and 1,685 respectively.

3.3.4 In 2012, we noted a decrease in 4 ECAs policyholder base

(i.e. JLGC, EGFI, ECGE and SEP) whereas Turk Eximbank

witnessed the highest increase in the number of policyholders by 37%.

Turk Eximbank38%

COTUNACE31%

ECGA5%

MEXIM5%

ICIEC4%

DHAMAN3%

CAGEX3%

ASEI3%

Others8%

Page 7: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

7

3.4 Number of Buyers:

3.4.1 Total number of AMAN UNION buyers increased from 208,780 in

2011 to 233,078 in 2012 (12% increase) . This gives an average of

13,710 buyer per ECA.

3.4.2 It should be noted that Turkexim has the largest number of buyers (i.e.

188,128) which represents 81% of the total number of buyers in 2012.

It also recorded the highest increase in the buyer’s database in 2012

with an additional 21,948 recorded buyers.

3.4.3 If we exclude Turkexim, the average number of buyers is

2,809 buyers per ECA.

3.4.4 It is noted that 96% of the buyers are covered by Export Credit

Insurance.

3.4.5 In 2012, there is an important decrease in Shiekan’s number of

buyers by 66%. It should be noted that Shiekan is basically a general

insurance company.

3.4.6 Even if we consider that many of ECAs may have the same buyers on

their records, and they are being double-counted, this is still a

significant number, and offers a good scope for information sharing

between different agencies. This is a potential area of synergy that can

be better utilized under AMAN UNION Database project.

Page 8: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

8

3.5 New Business Insured

A- Total Business Insured

3.5.1 As shown in the chart below, the Business Insured reached

USD 19.4 billion in 2012, an increase of 11.5% from the previous

year, resultimg in an average yearly growth of 12.1 % during the last

5 years. This is a significant increase, but it must be examined in light

of the impact of the financial crisis and political turbulence in some

member countries on the demand on credit insurance products.

Evolution of Business Insured (in USD Billion)

3.5.2 Comparably, the increase of the Business Insured of the of Berne

Union members for the same period ( 2008-2012) year-on-year over

was approximately 4.7%.

0

5

10

15

20

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

12.3 13.114.8

17.419.4

Page 9: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

9

Evolution of New Business Insured of Berne Union Members (in USD Trillion)

It should, however, be noted that the Berne Union volumes are

extremely large as compared to volumes of our members and

involves products that only few of our members provide

(i.e. Medium Term, Investment Insurance and Bonding), therefore,

the percentage changes are not exactly comparable.

3.5.3 Berne Union Business insured for 2012 totaled USD 1.81 trillion

which represents almost 10% of the world global trade volumes. The

total volumes of AMAN UNION members in the same period was

USD 19.4 billion, or 1.1% of that covered by the Berne Union

members and representing 1.8% of total member countrie’s Non-oil

exports (excluding ICIEC and DHAMAN business figures). If we

include the 2 multilaterals, the share will increase to 2,4%.

3.5.4 The average Business Insured per AMAN UNION member in 2012

was around USD 1.1 billion compared with USD 37 billion average

Business Insured per Berne Union member for the same period.

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

1.51 1.36 1.51.77 1.81

Page 10: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

10

Evolution in the weight of each line of business in the total buisness insured (in %)

Evolution of the business insured by each line of business (in USD Billion)

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Others

F.Invest

MT

Domestic

ST (Exp)

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

ST (Exp) Domestic MT F. Invest Others

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

Page 11: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

11

3.5.5 According to the above chart 1 and 2, Export Credit Insurance

continued its predominance over the other lines of business helped by

an increase in Dollar amounts of its business insured, however its

weight in the total business insured has decreased in the last 5 years

from 86% in 2008 to 75% in 2012. This trend is explained by the

increase in domestic business and foreign investment shares in the

total business insured from 3% to 12% and from 5 to 7% respectively

during the same period.

3.5.6 The biggest player is still Turkexim, accounting for 36% of the total

business volumes for 2012. This solid performance has been

consistent over the previous years. ICIEC and DHAMAN are 2nd and

3rd respectively, with 16% and 9% of the total volumes.

Brekdown of business insured during 2012 (in %)

36

169

6

6

6

4

4

43

6

Turk Eximbank

ICIEC

DHAMAN

EGFI

LCI

ASEI

MEXIM

ECIE

CAGEX

COTUNACE

Others

Page 12: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

12

3.5.7 ECIE Business Insured has grown aggressively by more than 3 times

in 2012 compared with 2011, noting that it started operations only in

2009. Other ECAs have recorded high growth in 2012 including

DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their

Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively.

3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and ASEI account for 79%

of the total Business Insured in 2012.

B- Short Term Business :

3.5.9 The first 6 ECAs in the table below are the main active ECAs in the

short term trade credit insurance business. They represent in average

more than 84% of AMAN UNION short term business insured during

the last few years.

# ECA

2010

2011

2012

1 Turkexim 5,010 5,752 6,923

2 ICIEC 1,467 2,331 2,198

3 SEP 865 717 484

4 DHAMAN 609 1,076 1,339

5 MEXIM 606 1,521 622

6 Cotunace 569 509 546

7 EGFI 371 159 151

8 ASEI 334 446 465

9 ECGA 276 220 211

10 CAGEX 222 222 164

11 ECGE 170 150 130

12 LCI 132 342 393

13 JLGC 81 155 147

14 NAIFE 79 90 134

15 Shiekan 34 12 47

16 ECIE 25 150 766

17 SONAC 18 18 18

Total 10,868 13,736 14,738

Page 13: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

13

3.5.10 Turk Eximbank is the major ECA in the short term business. It

accounts in average around 45% of all AMAN UNION members

short term business insured during the last 5 years.

Brekdown of Short term business insured during 2012 (in %)

3.5.11 ST Business insured of ECIE, DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, Shiekan

and NAIFE increased tremendously in 2012 which improved their

market share.

C- MT Business :

3.5.12 MT business insured reached USD 600m in 2012 compared with

USD 259m in 2011 and USD 1,067m in 2010.

47

15

9

54

20Turk Eximbank

ICIEC

DHAMAN

ECIE

MEXIM

Others

0.5 0.5

1.1

0.3

0.6

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the MT business Insured (USD Billion)

Page 14: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

14

3.5.13 The increase of MT Business insured in 2012 is mainly explained

by the new MT transactions covered by EGFI (USD 259m) and

DHAMAN (USD 189m). The decrease in MT business in 2011

from USD 1,067m in 2010 to USD 259m is explained by the drop

in MT business of EGFI (USD 638m) and DHAMAN (150m).

3.5.14 EGFI, ICIEC, DHAMAN, MEXIM are the main ECAs involved in

the MT business in the last 5 years.

D- Domestic Insurance Business :

32%

43%

8%

17%

Share of each ECA in the MT Business (in 2012)

DHAMAN EGFI ICIEC MEXIM

0.40.7

2.02.3 2.3

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the domestic buisness (in USD Billion)

Page 15: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

15

3.5.15 LCI, CAGEX and ASEI are the main ECAs involved in the

domestic credit insurance in the last 5 years. During 2012, they

represent 87% of total domestic insurance business insured. The

increase in the business insured in 2010 is explained by the

increase in LCI domestic business by USD 0.5m.

D- Investment Insurance Business :

33

27

27

63 4

Domestic business in 2012 (in %)

LCI

ASEI

CAGEX

ICIEC

MEXIM

Others

0.6

0.3

0.7 0.7

1.4

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Foreign Investment (in USD Billion)

Page 16: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

16

3.5.16 Only 4 ECAs in AMAN UNION full members have been actively

involved in the foreign investmnet business since the last 5 years.

3.5.17 During 2012, we witnessed an increase in the foreign investment

business insured for 3 ECAs (i.e. ICIEC, EGFI and MEXIM).

ECA 2011

2012

ICIEC 199 825

EGFI 199 282

MEXIM 14 70

DHAMAN 302 195

3.5.18 ICIEC is the most active ECA in the foreign investment business in

2012 with 60% share followed by EGFI (21%).

ICIEC60%

EGFI21%

MEXIM5%

DHAMAN14%

Share of each ECA in the F. Investment business (in 2012)

Page 17: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

17

3.6 Leverage

3.6.1 Leverage1 can be defined as a measure of the efficiency with which an

ECA uses its capital. Limited capital can prove to be a hindrance

especially when it comes to underwriting large transactions especially

in relatively higher risk countries where reinsurance support may not

be easily available.

Evolution of the leverage of AMAN UNION Members

3.6.2 As per the above chart, the leverage increased by an average 12.2%

during the last 5 years which is the same trend for the business insured

increase given that there has been no major increase in AMAN

UNION capital during the same period.

1 Leverage is defined as the business insured expressed as a multiple of the capital of the ECA.

12.313.1

14.8

17.4

19.4

7.1 7.1 7.1 7.1 7.2

1.7 1.8 2.1 2.5 2.7

0

5

10

15

20

25

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Business Insured (in USDBillion)

Capital (in USD Billion)

Leverage

Page 18: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

18

3.6.3 In 2012 there are 4 ECAs which stand out in comparison to the other

ECAs in ternms of leverage (i.e. LCI, ECIE, COTUNACE and

CAGEX). If we exclude Cotunace from our analysis, the bigger ECAs

like Turkexim and DHAMAN have relatively conservative levels of

leverage. SEP has the lowest leverage, on account of its significant

capital base

3.7 Premiums Written

3.7.1 Premiums Written have shown a substantial increase from

USD 88.5m in 2011 to USD 111.5m in 2012. This increase is mainly

due to the increase in EGFI’s premium earned from MT buisnes

(+USD 15m), ASEI premium from domestic business

(+ USD 4.3m), Turk Eximbank premium from short term activities

(+ USD 2.4m) and ICIEC premium from foreign investment

(+ USD 4.15m). This gives an average of USD 6 cents per

USD 1.00 insured (i.e. average premium rate of 58 bp in 2012).

59.572.9

127.1

88.5

111.5

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of Premium earned (in USD million)

Page 19: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

19

3.7.2 Similar to the business insured, we noted the predominance of short

term premium in the overall premium written. The MT premium is

volatile but the premium coming from domestic business is increasing

over the last few years. The same is experienced by revenues

identified in the above chart under the term “others”.

3.7.3 EGFI is providing other services generating handsome amount of fees

and commissions totaling USD 6.6m in 2012 compared with

USD 7.4m in 2011. This include credit guarantee services related to

local currency and foreign exchange, cover for bank’s bonds and

counter guarantee.

3.7.4 Of the individual ECAs, EGFI is the largest with total premiums of

USD 28.2m in 2012, a 25% share of the total premium written.

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the premium written by line of business

Short Term MT Domestic Invest Others

Page 20: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

20

3.7.5 After upward trend from 2008 to 2010 fueled by the increasing

demand for the credit insurance post the financial crisis, the average

premium rate for AMAN UNION members decreased in 2011

affected mainly by the drop in the MT premium but it increased again

in 2012 owing to an increase in the investment and MT premium

respectively from USD 7m in 2011 to USD 12.6m in 2012 and from

USD 10m to USD 20.1m.

28.17

22.93

15.71

13.85

30.8

Breakdown of premium written in 2012 by ECA (in USD million)

EGFI

Turk Eximbank

ASEI

ICIEC

Others

0.49

0.57

0.86

0.510.58

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Average premium of AMAN UNION members (in % )

Page 21: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

21

3.8 Claims & Recoveries

3.8.1 Claims have increased from USD 35.3m in 2011 to USD 43.2m in

2012 (a 22% increase). Since 2009, claims have been in an upward

trend due to the high claims paid by EGFI (USD 14.5m in 2011and

USD 16.6m in 2012). Turkexim had the 2nd highest incidence of

claims (USD 7.7m), which is understandable given its high volume

of business.

Evolution of the claims paid by ECA (in USD million)

27.522.9 23.4

35.3

43.2

6.1

69.4

25.1

6.8

22.8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Claims

Recoveries

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

EGFI TurkEximbank

COTUNACE CAGEX MEXIM Others

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

(USD million)

Page 22: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

22

3.8.2 The claims paid in ST business has the largest weight given the

predominance of ST business for AU members. No claims were paid

under the Foreign Investment business. However, we observed a

huge increase in MT claims and for the first time in the last 5 years,

a claim was paid under the other business (specifically Buyer Credit

Guarantee) : More details in points 3.8.3 and 3.8.5.

Evolution of the claims paid by line of business (in %)

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

ST 14.7 16.9 17.6 23.8 22.9

Domestic 12.6 5.5 4.5 6.1 5.0

MT 0.2 0.5 1.3 5.4 9.5

Others 0 0 0 0 5.9

05

10152025

Evolution of claims paid (in USD million)

53

74 7567

53

1

26

15

22

46

24 19 17

12

14

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Others

Domestic

MT

ST

Page 23: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

23

3.8.3 The largest claims by line of business in 2012 was paid by :

* Short Term Business : (Turk Eximbank - USD 7.7m),

* Domestic Business : (CAGEX - USD 2.7m),

* MT Business : (EGFI - USD 9.5m),

* “Other Business” : (MEXIM - USD 5.9m) : The claim was related

to a buyer credit gurantee provided by MEXIM to a local bank to

cover lending to a Malaysian investor in Thailand.

3.8.4 By geographical zone, the claims paid in Asia (mainly in UAE,

Thailand, Indonesia and Syria) have experienced a large increase in

2012 followed by claims paid in Europe (mainly Greece, Italy and

Romania).

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Europe 5.8 10.1 13.4 5.8 8.7

Asia 9.0 4.6 3.9 16.9 27.0

Africa 4.8 4.7 2.6 8.3 5.2

S. America 0.8 2.1 2.1 0.4 0.4

Austria & NZ 6.6 1.1 0.9 0.0 0.2

N. America 0.5 0.3 0.5 0.6 1.7

Page 24: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

24

3.8.5 Sector-wise, the chemical and petrochemical business, vehicles,

packaging, construction and furniture have witnessed the highest

claims during the year 2012.

(in USD million)

Countries Claims paid Sector

UAE 14.4 Chemical and petrochemicals

Thailand 5.9 Petrochemical (i.e. Bitumen)

Algeria 2.7 Petrochemical (i.e. Bitumen)

Syria 2.2 Petrochemicals

Cote d’Ivoire 1.7 Vehicules and autotmobiles S.Parts

Canada 1.5 Packaging

Indonesia 1.3 Furniture, rubber, paper, etc..

Lebanon 0.9 Service

3.8.6 Recoveries have increased in 2012 owing to the good amounts

recovered by COTUNACE (USD 4.5m on India) and CAGEX

(USD 13.3m for domestic sales of bitumen to a public buyer).

27.522.9

23.4

35.3

43.2

6.1

69.4

25.1

6.8

22.8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Claims

Recoveries

(USD million)

Page 25: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

25

3.8.7 The decrease in recoveries from 2009 to 2010 resulted from the

handsome amount of recovery made by DHAMAN in 2009

( USD 55.1m) whereas the drop in recoveries from 2010 to 2011 is

mainly explained by COTUUNACE recovery of USD 21.7m in

2010.

3.8.8 COTUNACE and CAGEX recovered 79% of total amount of claims

recovered by AMAN UNION members in 2012 (i.e. USD 4.5m and

USD 13.6m respectively).

3.9 Loss Ratios

3.9.1 Given the high claims paid by EGFI and Turkexim during 2011, the

Loss ratio deteriorated from 18.4% in 2010 to 39.9% in 2011 and it

stagnated in 2012 as premium and claims increased in the same

proportions from 2011 to 2012.

46.2

31.4

18.4

39.9 38.7

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

35.0

40.0

45.0

50.0

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the loss ratio (in %)

Page 26: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

26

3.9.2 Loss Ratio of SEP is the highest, on account of the large claims they

have paid during 2012 followed by MEXIM (i.e. 182% and 104%

respectively). EGFI which paid the highest claims in 2012 has a loss

ratio of 61%.

3.9.3 By line of business, the average loss ratio of MT and ST business in

the last 5 years is 43%. However, unlike ST loss ratio which is

almost stable, the MT loss ratio is very volatile (i.e. 90% in 2008

compared with 7.5% in 2010).

3.9.4 The loss ratio of the domestic business is in the upward trend

increasing from 5.7% in 2008 to 45.7% in 2012 due to higher

growth of claims compared with premium earned.

3.9.5 The loss ratio under “Other business” increased to 82% in 2012 due

to the claims paid by MEXIM, as explained in point 3.8.3.

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0

80.0

90.0

100.0

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the loss ratio (in % )

ST

MT

Domestic

Others

Page 27: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

27

3.10 Outward reinsurance

3.10.1 The ceded volume of business to the reinsurance market increased

by USD 1.5B in 2012 ( or 15.8%) increasing from USD 9.5B in

2011 to USD 11.0 B in 2012. This is mainly due to the increase of

ceded volume of Turkexim by USD 1.0B and MEXIM by

USD 0.8B.

3.10.2 Turk Eximbank, ICIEC, LCI and MEXIM account for 84% of the

ceded business of all AMAN UNION full members in 2012.

7,3186,709

7,720

9,483

10,982

0

2,000

4,000

6,000

8,000

10,000

12,000

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of the ceded volume of business (in USD million)

Page 28: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

28

3.10.3 The premium ceded by AMAN UNION members to reinsurers

increased from USD 25.6m in 2011 to USD 30.8m in 2012 (+20%)

mainly as a result of the increase of the ceded premium of Turk

Eximbank by USD 1.7m, CAGEX and LCI by USD 0.5m.

6,520

959.83

868.79

864.07

1,769

Breakdown of the outward reinsurance business in 2012 (in USD million)

Turk Eximbank

ICIEC

LCI

MEXIM

Others

26 26.3

23.225.6

30.8

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Evolution of Premium ceded (in USD million)

Page 29: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

29

3.10.4 Turk Eximbank, LCI, ICIEC and CAGEX account for 89% of the

premium ceded in 2012.

4. CONCLUSIONS

- 2012 appears to be a good year for AMAN UNION members with an

increase in premium written by 26%, in the business insured by 12%

and in the recoveries by 235%. The average premium rate has also

improved (i.e. 0.58% in 2012 vs. 0.51% in 2011) and the loss ratio has

stagnated (around 93 %).

- Member Countries’ ECAs still face some challenging issues such as

the lack of reliable credit information on buyers (mainly in the GCC

and subasaharan countries), low awareness amongst exporters, limited

reinsurance coverage on higher risk countries, competition from

16.1

3.7

3.7

3.8

3.5

Breakdown of premium ceded by ECA in 2012 (in USD million)

Turk Eximbank

ICIEC

LCI

CAGEX

Others

Page 30: TABLE OF CONTENTS...DHAMAN, Turk Eximbank, ASEI and ICIEC which increased their Business Insured by 20%, 20%, 21% and 17% respectively. 3.5.8 Turkexim, ICIEC ,DHAMAN, EGFI, LCI and

30

multinational insurance providers, lack of adequate IT infrastructure,

low capital base, and training and development needs of staff.

Though many of the problems are systemic in nature, there are some

problems which can be effectively dealt with by the ECAs.

Cooperation among ECAs and close coordination with other

concerned government agencies are some of the ways in which the

above given problems can be tackled. The proposed areas of

collaboration include knowledge sharing, credit information,

insurance and re-insurance.

To solve these problems, AMAN UNION Secretariat General organized

annual technical training programmes with the objective to improve the

technical capabilities which benefited a large number of AMAN UNION

member staff.

The SG has also established the Database Project which shall help the

Subscribers to have reliable credit information at a reasonable cost.