t pruitt digital thesis

7/27/2019 t Pruitt Digital Thesis

1/303

"#$%&'($) *+, $%- .'&,#/$(&+ &0

1+&23-,4- (+ "'/%*-&3&4)

"#$% &' ($)*++

"$*,*+- &.//#0#

"1*2 3*22#$+%+*., *2 4)56*++#7 8.$ +1# 3#0$## .8

3.9+.$ .8 (1*/.2.:1-

3#:%$+6#,+ .8 ;$91%#./.0-

?@@


2/303

ii

"56$'*/$;)+1.$*+- %,7 +1# ($.7)9+*., .8 A,.B/#70# *, ;$91%#./.0-

5- "#$% &' ($)*++

"1*2 +1#2*2 #C%6*,#2 +1# $./# .8 %)+1.$*+- *, +1# :$.7)9+*., .8 %$91%#./.0*9%/D,.B/#70#' E+ #C%6*,#2 1.B 8/)*7 *7#%2 %,7 .52#$=%+*.,2 8.$6#7 *, +1# 8*#/7 5#9.6#

%)+1.$*+%+*=#F 8%9+)%/F 2./*7 %$91%#./.0*9%/ :$.7)9+2F /*D# 29*#,+*8*9 +#C+2F $#9.,2+$)9+*.,2 .$

6)2#)6 7*2:/%-2' E+ %2D2F B1%+ 6%D#2 % :#$2.,F % +1*,0 .$ %, %99.),+ .8 1*2+.$- 2.6#+1*,0

+1%+ *2 %)+1.$*+%+*=#G H1%+ 6%D#2 2.6#.,# %, %)+1.$*+- ., +1# :%2+G H1%+ *2 %$91%#./.0*9%/

%)+1.$*+-G "1*2 +1#2*2 7#9.,2+$)9+2 %,7 #C:.2#2 %)+1.$*+- *, %$91%#./.0*9%/ :$%9+*9#' E+

+%$0#+2 1.B :$%9+*+*.,#$2 .8 %$91%#./.0- %9+*=#/- #,%9+F 9.,2+$)9+ %,7 *6:/#6#,+ %)+1.$*+-

*, +1# :$.9#22 .8 :$.7)9*,0 D,.B/#70#' I.$6%/ $#:$#2#,+%+*.,2 .8 +1# :%2+ $#/- 1#%=*/- .,

%, ),7#$/-*,0 ,.+*., .8 +1# J%)+1.$*+%+*=# %99.),+K' "1# #,+*$# :$.9#22 .8 $#9.,2+$)9+*,0 +1#

:%2+ *, %$91%#./.0- *2 7#:#,7#,+ ., *,7*=*7)%/2 %,7 *,2+*+)+*.,2 #C*2+*,0 %2 %)+1.$*+*#2F B1.

%9+*=#/- .$ :%22*=#/- *6:/- +1%+ %$+#8%9+2F 2*+#2 %,7 8*,%/ *,+#$:$#+%+*.,2 %$# J%)+1#,+*9K .$

1%=# J8*7#/*+-K +. +1# :%2+' "1*2 2+)7- #C%6*,#2 1.B %)+1.$*+- %,7 %9+2 .8 /#0*+*6%+*., %$#

#6:/.-#7 %,7 7*2+$*5)+#7 +1$.)01 +1# 6#7*)6 .8 29*#,9#F %,7 1.B +1#- ,##7 +. 5# %9+*=#/-

:#$8.$6#7 *, .$7#$ +. %9L)*$# %,7 6%*,+%*, 2+%+)2' "1*2 +1#2*2 ,.+ .,/- %$0)#2 +1%+

%)+1.$*+- *2 #65#77#7 *, #=#$- 2+%0# .8 +1# %$91%#./.0*9%/ :$.9#22F 5)+ *6:.$+%,+/-F *+

*7#,+*8*#2 1.B +1*2 %)+1.$*+- 6%,*8#2+2 +1$.)01 +1# 6#7*)6 .8 29*#,+*8*9 %9+2'

"1*2 +1#2*2 *2 2+$)9+)$#7 %$.),7 +B. 9.6:%$%+*=# 9%2# 2+)7*#2M .,# 9%2# .8

:$.8#22*.,%/ %$91%#./.0- %,7 .,# 9%2# .8 %/+#$,%+*=# %$91%#./.0-' N.+1 %$# %$91%#./.0*9%/

2*+#2 +1%+ :$.7)9# +1#*$ .B, J%)+1.$*+%+*=#K %99.),+2 .8 +1# :%2+ +1$.)01 :$%9+*9#2F

:)5/*9%+*.,2 %,7 :$#2#,+%+*.,2' "1# 8*$2+ 9%2# *2 +1# :$.8#22*.,%/ %$91%#./.0*9%/ :$.O#9+ .8

P%+%/1Q-RD *, +1# S#:)5/*9 .8 ")$D#-F ),7#$ +1# 7*$#9+*., .8 E%, T.77#$ %+ 4+%,8.$7


3/303

iii

7-/3*'*$(&+

"1*2 7*22#$+%+*., *2 +1# $#2)/+ .8 6- .B, B.$D %,7 *,9/)7#2 ,.+1*,0 B1*91 *2 +1#

.)+9.6# .8 B.$D 7.,# *, 9.//%5.$%+*., #C9#:+ B1#$# 2:#9*8*9%//- *,7*9%+#7 *, +1# +#C+'

"1*2 +1#2*2 7.#2 ,.+ #C9##7 +1# /*6*+2 2#+ 5- +1# I%9)/+- .8 ;$91%#./.0- %,7;,+1$.:./.0-F *,9/)7*,0 % >YF??? B.$7 #C+#,2*., %::$.=#7 5- +1# ;$91%#./.0- %,7

;,+1$.:./.0- 3#0$## &.66*++## %,7 +1# N.%$7 .8 Z$%7)%+# 4+)7*#2 %+ +1#


4/303

iv

"/8+&23-,4-9-+$6

E %6 #C+$#6#/- 0$%+#8)/ +. S.5*, N.%2+ 8.$ %7=*2*,0 %,7 2)::.$+*,0 +1*2 $#2#%$91

8$.6 9.,9#:+*., +. 9.6:/#+*.,' "1%,D -.) 8.$ 0*=*,0 6# 2. 6%,- *,+#//#9+)%/ %,7

:$%9+*9%/ .::.$+),*+*#2 +. 0$.B' E %/2. +1%,D [%$*# \.)*2# 4+*0 4]$#,2#,

%,7 ^#*/ N$.7*#

8.$ +1#*$ 2)::.$+ %,7 #C:#$+ 9.66#,+%$-F #2:#9*%//- 7)$*,0 6- #%$/- $#2#%$91' E %/2.

+1%,D &%+1#$*,# T*//2 %,7 ^*91./%2 (.2+0%+# 8.$ 5#*,0 %++#,+*=# B1#, ),8.$#2##,

9*$9)62+%,9#2 %$.2# #%$/- *, 6- 7.9+.$%/ 9%$##$ %,7 8.$ 1#/:*,0 6# +. 8*,7 % 2+%5/# :/%9#

*, +1# 7#:%$+6#,+' E %6 8.$#=#$ 0$%+#8)/ +. S.7#$*9D [9E,+.21 %+ _%/#


5/303

v

9.6:%,- 7)$*,0 +1# E&N( 9.,8#$#,9#a -.) 0$#%+/- .:#,#7 6- ),7#$2+%,7*,0 .8 +1#

B.$/7F %,7 E +1%,D -.) +$#6#,7.)2/- 8.$ +1%+' E B.)/7 %/2. /*D# +. +1%,D [)5#$% ()/.

%,7 .+1#$ 6#65#$2 .8 +1# V*2.D. [)2#)6 2+%88F %2 B#// %2 g*/D% A)O),7c*9UV#Oc%0*9 %,7

6#65#$2 .8 2+%88 8$.6 +1# ^%+*.,%/ [)2#)6 *, 4%$%O#=.F 8.$ 21.B*,0 6# %$.),7 +1#

6)2#)62 %,7 $#2:.,7*,0 +. 6- #6%*/2 %,7 L)#2+*.,2' "1%,D -.) +. ;,+1.,- T%$7*,0 %+

+1# ??h 9.,8#$#,9#F %,7 2*6*/%$ +1%,D2 0.#2 +. +1# T*2+.$*#2 i [-2+#$*#2

&.,8#$#,9# *, b7*,5)$01 8.$ % 6#6.$%5/# #C:#$*#,9#' E %/2. B*21 +. +1%,D +1# 4WSW4\%,0)%0# 491../ *, 4%$%O#=. 8.$ +1# N.2,*%, /%,0)%0# 9/%22#2a E /#%$,#7 % 0$#%+ 7#%/F %,7

+1%,D -.) 8.$ +1# .::.$+),*+-' E 0*=# +1%,D2 +. N#% T#$6%,, 8.$ -.)$ 8$*#,721*: 7)$*,0

6- 2+%- *, 4%$%O#=.F %,7 +. 4%,#/% %+ [3 ;:%$+6#,+2 8.$ -.)$ 1.2:*+%/*+-F #,+1)2*%26

%,7 1#/: B*+1 +$%,2/%+*.,'

E 0*=# 2:#9*%/ +1%,D2 %,7 %, #,.$6.)2 1)0 +. 3.,,% _%+#2F B1. B%2 %/B%-2 +1#$#

8.$ 6# *, +1# ):2 %,7 7.B,2 .8 $#2#%$91' _.) %$# %, *,2:*$%+*.,F %,7 E %6 2. +1%,D8)/ 8.$

-.)$ 8$*#,721*:' E %/2. 0*=# +$#6#,7.)2 +1%,D2 +. 2. 6%,- :##$2 *, +1# 3#:%$+6#,+ .8

;$91%#./.0-F :%$+*9)/%$/- A%+1#$*,# \#9D*#F S.5*, E,0/*2F ^%.6* I%$$*,0+.,F b66%

\*01+8..+F N$*++ N%//*#F 3%9*% V*#O. S.2#F N#,O%6*, [.$$*2F (%)/ bB.,)2F ^*21% 3.21*F

\*,72#- I$*#76%,F ;/#C ($-.$F T)0. W/*=#*$%F [.,*L)# N.77*,0+.,F [%$D 4%:B#//F

3.6*,*9 H%/D#$F 4D-/%$ ^#*/F E2%5#//# V#//% Z$#0.$-F ;/* A/#=,j2F 3%=*7 A/*,0/#F d%6#2

T.//.B%-F d#,,*8#$ Z.77%$7 %,7 41%7*% "%1% 8.$ +1#*$ 9.6:%,-F %7=*9#F 1#/: %,7

2)::.$+ 7)$*,0 +1*2 :$.O#9+' E %/2. +1%,D +1# ;$91%#./.0*9%/ S#=*#B 8$.6 &%65$*70#F +1#

;$91%#./.0- Z$%7)%+# 4.9*#+-F %,7 I*$2+ %,7 "1*$7 "$*,*+- N.%+ &/)5 8.$ %// .8 +1#

B#/9.6*,0 7*2+$%9+*.,2 %,7 +1# /#%$,*,0 .::.$+),*+*#2'

E 9.)/7 ,.+ 1%=# 8*,*21#7 +1*2 O.)$,#- B*+1.)+ ;6,% T%fc*%57*XF d.1%,,% ")7#%)F

S.5#$+ [*//%$F ;,O%/* 4%$*,F ^*71* A)6$%F b7 (%)/F 4#5%2+*%, (%,9$%+cF 3.6*,*D V)F &1$*2

b%0/#F W/*=#$ A$.#6#$F &1#/2#% &/-,#2F \%)$% +#, N/.#6#,7%/F \%)$% [%$*# A#$21%B %,7

;,+1.,- [9&/.2D-' _.) %$# +1# 5#2+ 8$*#,72 % :#$2., 9.)/7 %2D 8.$'

;5.=# %//F E +1%,D 6- :%$#,+2F 3#5.$%1 %,7 ".6 ($)*++F %,7 6- 5$.+1#$ ^%+1%,F 8.$

2)::.$+*,0 6# /*+#$%//- +. +1# #,72 .8 +1# #%$+1' "1#$# %$# ,. B.$72 +. 7#29$*5# 1.B

0$%+#8)/ E %6 8.$ -.)$ ),8%*/*,0 /.=# %,7 2)::.$+'

I*,%//-F E +1%,D 3%=*7 ($*9#F B*+1 %// 6- /.=#F 8.$ %52./)+#/- #=#$-+1*,0' "1%,D -.)

8.$ 5#*,0 B*+1 6#F #=#$- 2+#: .8 +1# B%-F ., +1*2 0$#%+ %7=#,+)$#'


6/303

vi

IWS [_ I;[E\_


7/303

vii

:*53- &0 ;&+$-+$6

&1%:+#$ W,#'@'@ E,+$.7)9*,0 "1#.$- %,7 &.,9#:+2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @@

>'@'> E,+$.7)9*,0 ;)+1.$*+- %,7 +1# 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*., .8 A,.B/#70#'''''''''''''''''''''''''' @>

>'> 3#8*,*,0 ;)+1.$*+- %,7 +1# 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*., .8 A,.B/#70#'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @l

>'>'@ 3#8*,*,0 ;)+1.$*+-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''' @l

>'>'@'@ "1# 3*88#$#,9# N#+B##, (.B#$ %,7 ;)+1.$*+-'''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @l

>'>'@'> "$%7*+*.,%/ ;::$.%91#2 +. 3#8*,*,0 ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @o>'>'> &%+#0.$*#2 %,7 3#9.,2+$)9+*,0 ;)+1.$*+- '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' @n

>'>'>'@ &%+#0.$*#2 .8 ;)+1.$*+- '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @n>'>'>'> bC#9)+*=# ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @n

>'>'>'k b:*2+#6*9 ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' >@

>'>'>'l E,+#//#9+)%/ ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''' >@

>'>'>'Y ;)9+.$2 %,7 ;)9+.$*+%2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >>>'>'k ;)+1.$*+- %2 %, ;99.6:/*216#,+ .$ b88#9+F $%+1#$ +1%, % `)%/*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >l

>'>'l ;)+1.$*+- .8 "1*,02F E,2+$)6#,+2F %,7 E7#%2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''' >o

>'>'Y ;)+1.$*+-F 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*=*26 %,7 49*#,+*8*9 A,.B/#70#''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' >h

>'>'Y'@ ;$91%#./.0- 8$.6 % 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*=*2+ (#$2:#9+*=#''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' k?>'>'o 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*=*26M (.B#$ S#/%+*.,2F 4.9*%/ W$0%,*2%+*., %,7 A,.B/#70# '' kl

>'>'m 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*=*26M "$%,2:%$#,9- *, &.,8/*9+ %,7 &.,+#2+%+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''' km

>'k ;)+1.$*+- *, ;$91%#./.0*9%/ "1#.$- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' km

>'k'@ E,+$.7)9*,0 ;)+1.$*+- *, +1# 3*29*:/*,# .8 ;$91%#./.0-''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' km

>'k'> ;)+1.$*+- *, ($.9#22)%/ %,7 (.2+:$.9#22)%/ "1#.$-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' kh

>'k'k ;)+1.$*+- *, ;$91%#./.0*9%/ 4)57*29*:/*,#2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' l@

>'l &1%:+#$ &.,9/)2*.,M N)+ H1%+ *2 ;)+1.$*+- *, ;$91%#./.0*9%/ ($%9+*9#G ''''''''''''''''''''''' lk


8/303

viii

&1%:+#$ "1$##>-$%&,&3&4) *+, ;*6- @$#,(-6

k'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' lYk'@'@ E,+$.7)9*,0 [#+1.7./.0- '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' lY

k'@'> E,+$.7)9*,0 % &%2#UN%2#7 [#+1.7./.0*9%/ ;::$.%91''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' lo

k'@'k &1%:+#$ "1#6#2 %,7 4+$)9+)$#'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' lh

k'> [#+1.7./.0*9%/ &.,2*7#$%+*.,2'''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ln

k'>'@ [#+1.7./.0*9%/ 4.)$9#2'''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ln

k'>'@'@ 49*#,9# %,7 "#91,./.0- 4+)7*#2 p4"4qF [%+#$*%/ E,29$*:+*.,2 %,7"$%,2/%+*.,2F %,7 +1# ;9+.$U^#+B.$D "1#.$-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' Y?

k'>'@'> ;$91%#./.0*9%/ b+1,.0$%:1- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' Yk

k'>'> ,+$%/ [#+1.7./.0*9%/ "1#.$-M &.,+#2+%+*., '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''' Yo

k'k [#+1.7./.0- *, I*#/7B.$D %,7 3%+% &.//#9+*.,'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' Yh

k'k'@ &%2# 4+)7- (%$%6#+#$2M ;*62 %,7 3#/*6*+%+*.,2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''' Yh

k'k'> &%2# 4+)7*#2M 3%+% &.//#9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' o@

k'k'>'@ "1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72 *, V*2.D.F N.2,*%UT#$c#0.=*,% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' o@k'k'>'> P%+%/1Q-RD *, +1# S#:)5/*9 .8 ")$D#- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' ok

k'k'k S#2#%$91 4+$%+#0-''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ol

k'k'k'@ 3.9)6#,+ &.//#9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' oYk'k'k'> (%$+*9*:%,+ W52#$=%+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' oY

k'k'k'k E,8.$6%/ E,+#$=*#B2'''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' om

k'k'l b+1*9%/ S#2#%$91 Z)*7#/*,#2 %,7 E22)#2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''' m?

k'k'l'@ E,8.$6#7 &.,2#,+''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' m?

k'k'l'> &.,8*7#,+*%/*+-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' m@k'k'l'k &.,2#L)#,9#2'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' m@

k'k'l'l S./# .8 +1# S#2#%$91#$'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' m>k'k'Y \*6*+%+*.,2 %,7 3*88*9)/+*#2 b,9.),+#$#7 *, +1# I*#/7''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' mk

&1%:+#$ I.)$

"#$%&'($) *6 "//#9#3*$-,A :'*+63*$-, *+, @$*5(3(6-,=

B*$*3%C)D8 *6 * ;*6- @$#,)

l'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' mm

l'@'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,M ;)+1.$*+- %2 ;99)6)/%+#7F "$%,2/%+#7 %,7 4+%5*/*2#7'''''''''''''''''''''' mml'@'> &%2# 4+)7- (%$%6#+#$2M S#/#=%,+ ($.O#9+ N%9D0$.),7'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''' mh

l'> ;)+1.$*+- 8$.6 4.9*%/ 4+$)9+)$# %,7 E,+#$%9+*.,'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''' h>

l'>'@ "1# 4.9*%/ &.,2+$)9+*., .8 I%9+2 %,7 +1# I%9+)%/ &.,2+$)9+*., .8 4.9*%/ ;0#,+2

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' h>l'>'> 4.9*%/ ;$#,%2 .8 ;)+1.$*+- %,7 ($%9+*9# %+ P%+%/1Q-RD''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' hY

l'>'>'@ 4+$)9+)$# %,7 4:%9#''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''' hY

l'>'>'> "1# P%+%/1Q-RD bC9%=%+*., 4*+# %2 % 4.9*%/ ;$#,% .8

A,.B/#70# ($.7)9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''' hm

l'>'>'k "1# P%+%/1Q-RD 3*0 T.)2# %2 % 4.9*%/ ;$#,%'''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' n>l'>'>'l ()5/*9 4:%9#2M W,2*+# bC:#$+ H*+,#22*,0 %,7 ()5/*9 b,0%0#6#,+ %+

+1# 3*0 T.)2# %,7 bC9%=%+*., 4*+#2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''' nm

l'>'>'Y W882*+# 4.9*%/ ;$#,%2M \%5.$%+.$*#2F [)2#)62F ($#22 %,7 V*$+)%/ 4:%9#2'''' nn

l'k ;)+1.$*+- 8$.6 ;99#22F 4:%+*%/ &.,2+$%*,+ %,7 &.,2#,+''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?@

l'k'@ "1# ;)+1.$*+- .8 4:%+*%/ &.,2+$%*,+ %,7 &.,2#,+'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?@

l'k'@'@ (1-2*9%/ ;99#22 %,7 &.,+$./''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?@l'k'@'> bC#9)+*=# %,7 \#0%/ &.,2#,+ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?ll'k'@'k b:*2+#6*9 %,7 E,+#//#9+)%/ ;99#22 %,7 &.,2#,+ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?o


9/303

ix

l'k'> ()5/*9 ;99#22 %,7 &.,2#,+''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@?n

l'k'>'@ ()5/*9r($*=%+# 3.6%*,2 %,7 +1# %$$.B*,0 .8 ;99#22''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@@Yl'k'k "#6:.$%/*+-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@@o

l'k'l A,.B*,0 _.)$ (/%9#M "1# (.B#$ .8 4:%9#F 4+$)9+)$# %,7 3*=*2*., %+

P%+%/1Q-RD'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@>>

l'l E,29$*:+*.,F "$%,2/%+*., %,7 N/%9D5.C*,0M ;)+1.$*+- *, +1# 4./*7*8*9%+*., .8S#:$#2#,+%+*.,2 *,+. ;99.),+2 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@>m

l'l'@ ;)+1.$*+- +1$.)01 +1# 4+%5*/*2%+*., .8 ($%9+*9#2 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''@>ml'l'> ;)+1.$*+- *, E,29$*:+*., %,7 "$%,2/%+*.,M 4./*7*8*9%+*., +1$.)01

S#:$#2#,+%+*.,F &*$9)/%+*., %,7 [.5*/*2%+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@>h

l'l'k "1# "$%,2/%+*.,F ($.7)9+*., %,7 &)$$#,9- .8 S#:$#2#,+%+*=# "1*,02M

"1# bC%6:/# .8 +1# (/%2+#$#7 4D)// N)$*%/'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@kll'l'l ;, E$$#9.,9*/%5/# &.,+$%7*9+*.,G 3*$#9+*., =#$2)2 [)/+*=.9%/*+- %+ P%+%/1Q-RD

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@lm

l'Y &1%:+#$ &.,9/)2*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@Yk

l'Y'@ &.,9/)2*.,2 ., ;)+1.$*+-M "1# E6:.$+%,9# .8 ^.,UT)6%, ;9+.$2 %,7

4+%5*/*+- *, +1# ($.7)9+*., .8 ;)+1.$*+%+*=# A,.B/#70#''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@Ykl'Y'> I*,%/ &.,9/)2*.,2 %,7 S#8/#9+*.,2 ., +1*2 4+)7-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''@Yo

&1%:+#$ I*=#

"#$%&'($) (+ .&3($(/6 *+, .-'0&'9*+/-= :%- E&6+(*+ .)'*9(,6 *6 * ;*6-

@$#,)

Y'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@oYY'@'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,M ;)+1.$*+- 8$.6 &.,+#C+F E,2+*+)+*.,2 %,7 4.9*.U(./*+*92 ''''''''''''''''@oY

Y'@'> &%2# 4+)7- (%$%6#+#$2M S#/#=%,+ ($.O#9+ N%9D0$.),7'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@oo

Y'> ;)+1.$*+- N#1*,7 &%+#0.$*#2 %,7 ;/+#$*+- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@mlY'>'@ "1# ;)+1.$*+- 5#1*,7 &/%22*8*9%+*., %,7 N.),7%$*#2M ;$91%#./.0- %2

% A,.B/#70#U($.7)9*,0 &)/+)$# ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@ml

Y'>'> &1%//#,0*,0 &%+#0.$*#2M ($.8#22*.,%/ ;)+1.$*+- %,7 ;/+#$,%+*=#;$91%#./.0*9%/ &/%*62'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@mY

Y'>'k &%+#0.$*2*,0 ;/+#$*+-M (2#)7.%$91%#./.0- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''@mm

Y'k 4.9*.U(./*+*92 %,7 +1# S#9#:+*., .8 ;$91%#./.0*9%/ ;)+1.$*+-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@mnY'k'@ E,+$.7)9*,0 4.9*.U(./*+*92 %,7 +1# &%2# .8 +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72'''''''''''''''''''''''''@mn

Y'k'> "1# (.B#$ .8 (./*+*92F (/%9#2 %,7 [%+#$*%/*+*#2'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''@h?Y'k'k &.,2+$)9+*,0 ;)+1.$*+- +1$.)01 ^%+*.,%/*26 %,7 E7#,+*+-''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@h@

Y'k'l ;)+1.$*+- +1$.)01 +1# (./*+*92 .8 [.,#-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''@hl

Y'k'Y "1# (./*+*92 .8 bC:#$+2 %,7 bC:#$+*2# ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@hh

Y'k'Y'@ "1# ;)+1.$*+- .8 &$#7#,+*%/#7 bC:#$+2M "1# b0-:+*%,2 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@hh

Y'k'Y'> "1# ;)+1.$*+- .8 &$#7#,+*%/#7 bC:#$+2M "#%6 [#65#$2 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@nkY'k'o &.,+#2+%+*., %,7 ;9%7#6*9 ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@nm

Y'k'm 4.9*.U(./*+*92 %2 E,+#0$%/ +. 49*#,+*8*9 ;)+1.$*+-'''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@nh

Y'l (#$8.$6*,0 49*#,9#M Z%*,*,0 ;)+1.$*+- "1$.)01 ;::$.:$*%+# (#$8.$6%,9#'''''''''''''>??

Y'l'@ [%D*,0 S#%/*+*#2M ;)+1.$*+- &$#%+#7 *, +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*7 ($.O#9+''''''''''''''''''>??

Y'l'> ;9+)%/*+*#2 %,7 V*$+)%/*+*#2 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?@

Y'l'k [#+1.7 +. +1# [%7,#22M E,=#,+*,0 ;)+1.$*+- +1$.)01 (#$8.$6%,9# %,7 [#7*%''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?Y

Y'l'k'@ 4#/8US#:$#2#,+%+*.,M E9.,2 %,7 (#$2.,%/*+*#2'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?o

Y'l'k'> ^%$$%+*., .8 V*//%*, ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?mY'l'k'k 3$%B*,0 ., E,2+*+)+*.,2F \.0.2 %,7 N$%,7*,0 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?n

Y'l'k'l 49*#,+*8*9 S#:$#2#,+%+*., '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@l


10/303

x

Y'Y ;)+1.$*+- 8$.6 49*#,9# %2 % [%2+#$ 3*29.)$2# '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''>@o

Y'Y'@ 3$%B*,0 ., 49*#,9#''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@oY'Y'> "1# bC%6:/# .8 S%7*.9%$5., 3%+*,0 .8 +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@h

Y'Y'k "1# @2+E,+#$,%+*.,%/ 49*#,+*8*9 &.,8#$#,9# .8 +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72 ''''''''''''''''''>@n

Y'Y'l 3$%B*,0 ., +1# ;)+1.$*+- .8 S%7*.9%$5., [#+1.7./.0-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>o

Y'o &1%:+#$ &.,9/)2*.,M ;)+1.$*+- *, +1# (./*+*92 %,7 (#$8.$6*,0 .8 (-$%6*72 ''''''''''''''>>n

&1%:+#$ 4*C

;&+/3#6(&+= "#$%&'($) (+ $%- .'&,#/$(&+ &0 "'/%*-&3&4(/*3 1+&23-,4-

o'@ E,+$.7)9+*., %,7 4)66%$-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>kl

o'> &.6:%$*2., %,7 4*0,*8*9%,9# .8 +1# &%2# 4+)7*#2 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''>kYo'>'@ E,+$.7)9+*.,M 4)66%$*2*,0 &%2# 4+)7*#2'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''>kY

o'>'> 3*88#$*,0 S#2#%$91 S#2)/+2 %,7 +1# 4)99#22#2 %,7 I%*/)$#2 .8

+1# "B. &%2# 4+)7*#2 ko

o'>'k &%2# 4+)7*#2 &.6:%$*2., %,7 4*0,*8*9%,9#M &.,+$*5)+*., +. km

o'k 3#9.,2+$)9+*,0 ;)+1.$*+- *, +1# ($.7)9+*., .8 ;$91%#./.0*9%/ A,.B/#70#'''''''''''''''>l>

o'k'@ ;)+1.$*+- *, 3*=*7*,0 ($%9+*9#2F &%+#0.$*#2 %,7 ;/+#$*+-''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>l>o'k'> ;)+1.$*+- *, "$%,2/%+*.,F 4+%5*/*2%+*., %,7 +1# ;0#,9- .8 ^.,1)6%, ;9+.$2''>lY

o'k'k ;)+1.$*+- *, b:*2+#6*9 3#:#,7#,9#'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''>lm

o'k'k'@ 3#8*,*,0 b:*2+#6*9 3#:#,7#,9#'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>lm

o'k'k'> b:*2+#6*9 3#:#,7#,9# *, ;$91%#./.0*9%/ &.,2)6:+*.,FV%/*7%+*., %,7 I*7#/*+- ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>Y@

o'l 3#%/*,0 B*+1 ;)+1.$*+-M 4)00#2+*.,2 8.$ I)$+1#$ S#2#%$91 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>YY

;::#,7*C ;'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>Yh

;::#,7*C N'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>Yn

;::#,7*C & '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>o?

;::#,7*C 3'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>o@

;::#,7*C b'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>ol

;::#,7*C I '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>oo

;::#,7*C Z'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>on

;::#,7*C T'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>mk

E(53(&4'*?%) FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGHI


11/303

J(6$ &0 K(4#'-6

I*0)$# @M ;$91%#./.0*9%/ %9+*=*+- %+ P%+%/1Q-RD ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''' k>I*0)$# >M E%, T.77#$ 0*=*,0 % 2*+# +.)$ +. % 0$.): .8 +.)$*2+2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' n@

I*0)$# kM [%: .8 +1# P%+%/1Q-RD 7*0 1.)2#''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''' nm

I*0)$# lM "1# P%+%/1Q-RD V*2*+.$ ,+$#'''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''' nnI*0)$# YM "1# N#$D#/#- sS#6*C*,0 P%+%/1Q-RDs =*$+)%/ :$.O#9+ ., !"#$%& ()*" ''''''''''''''''''@??I*0)$# oM E%, T.77#$ 0*=*,0 % 2*+# +.)$ +. +#%91#$2''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''@@@

I*0)$# mM "1# P%+%/1Q-RD (%*,+#7 4D)//F $#7*29.=#$#7 *, >??n '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@@Y

I*0)$# hM P%+%/1Q-RD I%),%/ :$.9#7)$%/ 8/.B 91%$+''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@@Y

I*0)$# nM 4-65./2 .8 P%+%/1Q-RD 2.9*%/ 9%+#0.$*#2''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@>Y

I*0)$# @?M A,.B/#70# %2 s%9+*=#/- :#$8.$6#7s'''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''@>hI*0)$# @@M d.1, 4B.00#$K2 *//)2+$%+*.,2 .8 +1# P%+%/1Q-RD :/%2+#$#7 2D)// 5)$*%/'''''''''''@kh

I*0)$# @>M 3*%0$%6 .8 +1# :/%2+#$#7 2D)// 5)$*%/ *,+#$:$#+%+*.,'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@lo

I*0)$# @kM [%: .8 V*2.D.F N.2,*%UT#$c#0.=*,% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''@oh

I*0)$# @lM E9.,*9 *6%0# .8 V*2.D. %,7 V*2.t*9% T*// p(-$%6*7 .8 +1# 4),q '''''''''''''''''''''''''@on

I*0)$# @YM 4#6*$ W26%,%0*X 9.)$+2 +1# :$#22 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''@m@I*0)$# @oM bC9%=%+*., 2*+# %+ (/O#u#=*9% T*// p(-$%6*7 .8 +1# [..,q''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''@mk

I*0)$# @mM \.0. .8 +1# (-$%6*7 I.),7%+*., %,7 +1# N.2,*%, 8/%0 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@h>I*0)$# @hM ".)$*26 %,7 ,#B 5)2*,#22#2 *, V*2.D.' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''@hY

I*0)$# @nM [%D#21*8+ 2.)=#,*$ 21.:2 *, V*2.D. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''@ho

I*0)$# >?M V./),+##$2 %,7 (./*+*9*%,2 %+ +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72 2*+# '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@hm

I*0)$# >@M 3$' b/ ;,5%BB- %$0)#2 1*2 :.*,+ %+ +1# E&N( &.,8#$#,9# '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''@n>

I*0)$# >>M &.,9/)2*.,2 8$.6 +1# E&N( &.,8#$#,9#'''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''@nlI*0)$# >kM "1# (-$%6*7 ($.O#9+ *2 % :#$8.$6%,9# ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''>?l

I*0)$# >lM 4#6*$ W26%,%0*X *, 1*2 *9.,*9 8#7.$% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''>@?

I*0)$# >YM 4%6:/# 2/*7# 8$.6 % 29*#,+*8*9 /#9+)$# 5- % s:-$%6*7 #C:#$+s ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@k

I*0)$# >oM ;)+1.$*+%+*=#F :$.8#22*.,%/U/..D*,0 :-$%6*7 2*0,%0# '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@l

I*0)$# >mM 4%6:/# :%0# 8$.6 W26%,%0*XK2 !#)"%+)*)# ,-)&"%#"$#:.$+ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@mI*0)$# >hM ($.8#22*.,%/U/..D*,0 E&N( 9.,8#$#,9# 6%+#$*%/2''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>?

I*0)$# >nM ;++#6:+*,0 +. 9.,=*,9# % 29#:+*9%/ 291./%$ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''>>>

I*0)$# k?M E6%0# 8$.6 +1# E&N( &.,8#$#,9# '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>Y

I*0)$# k@M I.),7%+*., =./),+##$ %,7 1*2 s:-$%6*7 %$+#8%9+s $.9D'''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''>>YI*0)$# k>M "B. J%)+1.$*2#7K %$91%#./.0*9%/ J%)+1.$*+*#2K ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''>kn

J(6$ &0 "/'&+)96

N&bM N#8.$# &.66., b$%

N(M N#8.$# ($#2#,+E&N(M @2+E,+#$,%+*.,%/ 49*#,+*8*9 &.,8#$#,9# .8 +1# N.2,*%, (-$%6*72

44AM 4.9*./.0- .8 49*#,+*8*9 A,.B/#70#

4"4M 49*#,9# %,7 "#91,./.0- 4+)7*#2


12/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

1

!"#$%&' )*&+

,-./0123.40-+ #/356708094368 #2.50/4.: 6-1

.57 ;6-987 0< $/63.437/!" $%&'%(%)* +,$ -../ 0,12.3 "1%0 4+. $4,14 -* 4+. 3'$&%5.1* 4+,4 ,&4'%/ 6,$ %5.14,2./ -* %4+.1,)./&'.$7 '4 +,$ -../ $8911.3 .5./ 0%1. "%1&."9((* -* 4+. .4+'&,(7 8%('4'&,(7 ,/3 .08'1'&,( 3'$&%5.1*

4+,4 4+.1. .:'$4 +'.1,1&+'.$7 ,$*00.41'.$7 ,/3 '/.;9,('4'.$< 4+,4 4+. $%&',( 6%1(3 '$ =9$4 ,$

3'"".1./4',4.3 , (,/3$&,8. ,$ , 19)).3 ,/3 0%9/4,'/%9$ 4.11,'/< 4+,4 /% ,0%9/4 %" ./4+9$',$07 "1..

6'((7 %1 '/)./9'4* &,/ 0,2. 4+%$. ,$*00.41'.$ )% ,6,*< 4+,4 4+.* ,(( $..0 4% 6.')+ ,$ +.,5'(* ,$ 4+.

8*1,0'3$>4+,4 ,/* 4+'/2.1 6+% 3./'.$ 4+%$. '/.;9,('4'.$ ,/3 3'"".1./&.$ '$ .'4+.1 )9(('-(. %1

$%0.6+,4 1.,&4'%/,1*< ,/37 "'/,((*7 4+,4 ')/%1'/) $%&',( ,$*00.41* '$ ,$ 1'3'&9(%9$ ,$ &(,'0'/) 4+,4

?.64%/',/ )1,5'4,4'%/ 3%.$ /%4 .:'$4@0 1234567 899:; = ,-./0123.40-+ #2.50/4.: 6-1 #/35670809:

=>=>= #2.50/4.: 6-1 .57 $/0123.40- 0< ?-0@87197 4- #/35670809:

%>?@ 4>A@?@ 3@B@; C>34 ?@ 4>A 75DA 5E 364>57?4F ?G 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

BG5CDAIKAL %5 AMHD57A 4>?@ J57A N6A@4?5GO 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?GPA@4?K34A@ 4>A J5QHDAM

GAK54?34?5G@O 473G@E57Q34?5G@ 3GI >A4A75KAGA56@ 3J4@ 4>34 K5 ?G45 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E

364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4O @6J> 3@ 3J3IAQ?J 4AM4@O 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 7AJ5G@476J4?5G@

3GI Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@R %>?@ 4>A@?@ AM3Q?GA@ >5C ED6?I ?IA3@ 3GI 5S@A7P34?5G@ E57QAI ?G

4>A E?ADI SAJ5QA 364>57?434?PAO E3J463DO @5D?I 3JJ56G4@ 3S564 C>34 >3HHAGAI ?G 4>A H3@4R *4

3@B@O C>34 Q3BA@ 3 HA7@5GO 3 4>?GK 57 3G 3JJ56G4 5E >?@457F @5QA4>?GK 4>34 ?@

T364>57?434?PAUL V>34 Q3BA@ @5QA5GA 3G 364>57?4F 5G 4>A H3@4L V>34 Q3BA@ 3 H75EA@@?5G3D

?G4A7H7A434?5G TQ57A 7?K>4U 57 TQ57A AMHA74U 4>3G 3G 3Q34A67 5GAL *G J3@A@ C>A7A 3Q34A67

57 3D4A7G34?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 >3PA Q57A 364>57?4F 4>3G H75EA@@?5G3D 5H?G?5GO 4>AG

C>FL V>F I5 @5QA 5H?G?5G@ >5DI Q57A CA?K>4 4>3G 54>A7@O C?4>?G 3GI C?4>564 4>A

H75EA@@?5G3D I?@J?HD?GAL W674>A7Q57AO C>34 A4>?J@ 3GI 3JJ56G43S?D?4F D?A SA>?GI

37J>3A5D5K?J3D 364>57?4FL %>?@ 4>A@?@ @AAB@ 45 3II7A@@ 4>A@A N6A@4?5G@ SF J3GI?IDF

IAJ5G@476J4?GK 3GI AMH5@?GK 364>57?4F ?G 4>A I?@J?HD?G37F H73J4?JA@ 5E 37J>3A5D5KFR %>A

3?Q ?@ 45 AM3Q?GA >5C 364>57?4F ?@ S54> H3@@?PADF 3GI 3J4?PADF AQSAIIAIO 6@AIO 473G@D34AIO

IA@?7AI 57 7A@?@4AIX@476J4673DDFO J5GJAH463DDF 3GI @H34?3DDFX?G 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E

37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R


13/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

2

=>=>A B7A H3@4 37A J5G@476J4AI 3GI G37734AI SF H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5K?@4@

6@?GK Q34A7?3D J6D467AO C>?J> ?@ 3JN6?7AI 4>756K> H73J4?JA@ D?BA AMJ3P34?5G 3GI 4>AG

?G4A7H7A4AI 45 5EEA7 4>A SA@4 Y6IKAQAG4@ 3S564 TC>34 3J463DDF >3HHAGAI ?G 4>A H3@4 3GI

C>FUR %>?@ ?G4A7H7A4AI H3@4 ?@ H7A@AG4AI 45 54>A7 3J3IAQ?J@ 3GI 45 4>A H6SD?J ?G 4>A E57Q

5E H6SD?J34?5G@O Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@O 7AJ5G@476J4?5G@O 3GI ?G E576Q@ @6J> 3@ J5GEA7AGJA@ 3GI

@AQ?G37@R Z6J> E57Q3D 7AH7A@AG434?5G@ 5E 4>A H3@4 7ADF >A3P?DF 5G 3G 6GIA7DF?GK G54?5G 5E

4>A T364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4UR %>A AG4?7A H75JA@@ 5E 7AJ5G@476J4?GK 4>A H3@4 ?G 37J>3A5D5KF ?@

IAHAGIAG4 5G ?GI?P?I63D@ 3GI ?G@4?464?5G@ 3J4?GK 3@ 364>57?4?A@O 3J4?PADF 57 H3@@?PADF

?QHDF?GK 4>34 374AE3J4@O @?4A@ 3GI E?G3D ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 37A T364>AG4?JU 57 >3PA TE?IAD?4FU 45

4>A H3@4R

,PA7 4>A H3@4 4>?74F FA37@O Q3GF 3J3IAQ?J@ >3PA 37K6AI 4>34 4>A H73J4?JA 5E@J?AGJA ?@ ?GAP?43SDF 3EEAJ4AI SF ?4@ @5J?3D J5G4AM4O 3GI 4>34 @J?AG4?E?J H73J4?JA H75K7A@@A@

3JJ57I?GK 45 3J3IAQ?J E3@>?5G@ 5E 4>A 4?QA 1[6>G )\]9^ WAFA73SAGI )\]:=R %>AF >3PA

37K6AI 4>34 @J?AG4?@4@ C57B C?4>?G H373I?KQ@ 5E H73J4?JA 3GI BG5CDAIKAO 3GI 4>AF

/344AQH4 45 AM4AGI 3GI AMHD5?4 _4>A@A H373I?KQ@` ?G 3 P37?A4F 5E C3F@0 1[6>G )\]9; \)=R *G

4>A E?ADI 5E ZJ?AGJA 3GI %AJ>G5D5KF Z46I?A@ 1Z%Z=O 3J3IAQ?J@ >3PA 37K6AI 4>34 BG5CDAIKA

?@ 3JN6?7AIO IAPAD5HAIO I?@47?S64AI 3GI J5G4A@4AI ?G 3 @5J?3D AGP?75GQAG4 1234567 3GI

V55DK37 )\aA IAPAD5HQAG4 5E 3 TE3J4UX@5QA4>?GK 7AK37IAI

45 SA 3 4764> 3S564 4>A G34673D 57 @5J?3D C57DIX?@ 3 @5J?3DO H>F@?J3D 3GI Q34A7?3D 564J5QA

5E HA5HDA C>5 ?G4A73J4 C?4>?G @5J?3D GA4C57B@R cAJ36@A 5E 4>A @5J?3D G3467A 5E E3J463D

BG5CDAIKAO 7AH7A@AG4AI T4764>@U 3S564 4>A C57DI 37A 3DC3F@ 7AD34?PA 45O 3GI 7ADF 6H5GO

@476J467A@ 5E 364>57?4FXH5CA7 3@FQQA47?A@ SA4CAAG ?GI?P?I63D@O ?G@4?464?5G@O Q34A7?3D@

3GI 7AH7A@AG434?5G@R

%>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?@ @?4634AI C?4>?G 4>?@ KAGA73D @473?G 5E 7AEDAM?PA @46IF 5E

@J?AG4?E?J H73J4?JAO 3GI ?4 E5J6@A@ 5G 4>A 5S@A7P34?5G 3GI ?IAG4?E?J34?5G 5E 364>57?434?PA

@476J467A@ ?G>A7AG4 ?G IAJ?@?5GdQ3B?GKO ?G4A7H7A434?5G 3GI H75I6J4?5G 5E BG5CDAIKA ?G

37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JAR %>?@ 4>A@?@ AQH>3@?@A@ 4>A H75I6J4?5G 3GI H7A@AG434?5G 5E TE?G3D

H75I6J4 3JJ56G4@U 5E C>34 >3HHAGAI ?G 4>A H3@4O C>?J> 37A 37K63SDF 4>A D3@4 3GI Q5@4

?QH5743G4 @4AH@ ?G 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@R %>?@ @46IF ?@ 5HA734?5G3DDF S3@AI 5G 4>A

?IA3 4>34 J5G4A@434?5G 3GI 4AG@?5G ?G 3 H75JA@@ 3DD5C E57 ?4@ ?G4A7G3D J5QHDAM?4?A@ 45

SAJ5QA Q57A 473G@H37AG4O 3 4>A57F J3DDAI TSD3JBS5M?GKU ?G ZJ?AGJA Z46I?A@R c76G5 234567

1234567 )\\\; e9b= J5?GAI 4>A 4A7Q TSD3JBS5M?GKU 45 IAE?GA 3 H75JA@@ 57 Q5IAD 4>34 76G@ @5

@Q554>DF 3GI AEE?J?AG4DF 4>34 G5 5GA @45H@ 45 N6A@4?5G ?4@ ?G4A7G3D J5QHDAM?4?A@O 5GDF ?4@

?GH64@ 3GI 564H64@R 234567 37K6A@ 4>34 H75JA@@A@ ?G @J?AGJA 5E4AG 5HA734A @5 7?K5756@DF3GI AEE?J?AG4DF 4>34 @J?AG4?@4@ 737ADF N6A@4?5G 4>A ?G4A7G3D @5J?3D J5QHDAM?4?A@ 5E 4>A?7 5CG


14/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

3

7564?GA 3J4?5G@^ 4>AF 5GDF N6A@4?5G 4>A?7 I343 3GI 7A@6D4@R #JJ57I?GK 45 4>?@ 4>A57FO C>AG

J5G4AG4?5G 57 J5GED?J4 37?@A@O 57 C>AG @5QA4>?GK K5A@ 3C7FO 4>A TSD3JBS5MAIU @F@4AQ@ 5E

H73J4?JA SAJ5QA Q57A 473G@H37AG4R *G J5G4A@4AI H73J4?JAO HA5HDA J3G Q57A 4>5756K>DF

AM3Q?GA 4>A ?G4A7G3D J5QHDAM?4?A@ 5E 4>A?7 5CG C57B?GK @F@4AQO S7A3B?GK I5CG 4>A C3DD@

5E 3 TSD3JBS5MAIU @F@4AQR %>?@ ?@ 3 J5GJAH4 * I?@J6@@ ?G IAH4> ?G !>3H4A7@ %C5 3GI %>7AA

1ZAJ4?5G@ 8R8R] 3GI eReR8=R

A@A@B@A C."'/'/) , DE'/,( F1%39&4G H&&%9/4 %" 4+. F,$4

W57 4>A H67H5@A@ 5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GO 3 TE?G3D H75I6J4U 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4 ?@ IAE?GAI

3@ 3G AMHD3G34?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D Q34A7?3D 4>34 3HHA37@ ?G J5GIAG@AI E57Q QA3G4 E57

H6SD?J J5G@6QH4?5GR %>A TH6SD?JU ?G 4>?@ IAE?G?4?5G ?@ @?QHDF 4>5@A C>5 7AJA?PA 57 J5G@6QA

3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R %>?@ J34AK57F ?GJD6IA@ S54> 4>A KAGA73D H6SD?J 5E D3F HA7@5G@ ,$ 6.((

,$@HAJ?3D?@4@ 57 AMHA74@ ?G 37J>3A5D5KFR &M3QHDA@ 5E 3 TE?G3D H75I6J4U 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4

?GJD6IA 37J>3A5D5K?J3D AMHD3G34?5G@ 4>34 3HHA37 ?G GAC@H3HA7 7AH574@O 4ADAP?@?5G QAI?3O

CAS@?4A@O 3@ CADD 3@ 3J3IAQ?J 7AH574@O Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@ 3GI H6SD?J J5GEA7AGJA

H7A@AG434?5G@R %>A 7A3@5G 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?GJD6IA@ 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 3DD

J5G@6Q3SDA P37?A4?A@XE75Q H75EA@@?5G3D J5GEA7AGJA H7A@AG434?5G@ 45 H5H6D37 @J?AGJA

4ADAP?@?5G @>5C@X?@ SAJ36@A 4>A@A 3JJ56G4@ 37A 3DD E6GI3QAG43DDF S3@AI 5G 4>A @3QA

H7?GJ?HDA; 4>AF 37A 3J4@ 5E @6QQ37?@?GKO 3S@473J4?GK 3GI @43S?D?@?GK 4>A ED6?IO Q3GKDAI 3GI6G@43SDA @5J?3D H75JA@@A@ 5E BG5CDAIKA H75I6J4?5G 4>34 D?A SA>?GI 4>A?7 J5G@476J4?5GR %>A

4A7Q T3JJ56G4U ?@ 6@AI SAJ36@A 4>A@A H6SD?J AMHD3G34?5G@ 37A T3JJ56G4?GK E57U Q34A7?3D

J6D467A SF IA@J7?S?GK 57 AMHD3?G?GK 4>A 3J4?P?4?A@ 5E H3@4 HA5HDA@R %>A 7A3@5G 4>?@

I?@@A7434?5G J3DD@ 4>A@A TE?G3D H75I6J4@U ?@ G54 SAJ36@A 4>A@A 3JJ56G4@ 37A QA3G4 SF 4>A?7

364>57@ 45 SA @AAG 3@ TE?G3DU ?G 4>A @AG@A 5E A4A7G3D 57 6GJ>3GK?GKR '34>A7O TE?G3D H75I6J4U

3JJ56G4@ 37A ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 4>34 3HHA37 3@ @43S?D?@AI AMHD3G34?5G@ ?G 3 TE?G3DU E57Q QA3G4

E57 H6SD?J J5G@6QH4?5GR %>AF 37A 5E4AG QA3G4 45 SA J5G4A@4AI 3GI J>3GKAI ?E 3HH75H7?34A

1A@HAJ?3DDF 4>A H75I6J4@ 5E $&'./4'"'&BG5CDAIKA H75I6J4?5G=^ >5CAPA7O 4>AF 37A H7A@AG4AI

?G 3 TE?G3DU E57Q34 C>?J> ?@ QA3G4 45 SA 3@ E3?4>E6DDF 7AH7A@AG434?PA 45 57?K?G3D Q34A7?3D 57

J5GJAH463D 6GIA7@43GI?GK 3@ H5@@?SDAR

W?G3D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 37A TE75G4 @43KAU H75I6J4@O C>?J> J5G@5D?I34A 3GI TSD3JB

S5MU 3DD 5E 4>A QA@@F H75JA@@A@ 4>34 CAG4 ?G45 4>A Q3B?GK 5E 4>A 3JJ56G4@ ?G 4>A TS3JB

@43KAU @5J?3D 37AG3@ 5E BG5CDAIKA H75I6J4?5GR # H6SD?@>AI 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H3HA7 Q?K>4O E57

?G@43GJAO >A3ID?GA 4>A 3JJ56G4; /fAI?AP3D @BADA45G @>5C@ @?KG@ 5E 374>7?4?@0R cA>?GI 4>?@

@434AQAG4 D?A@ 3DD 5E 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3J4?P?4F 4>34 CAG4 ?G45 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E 4>?@

3JJ56G4; 4>A J5QHDAM >?@457F SA>?GI C>F 4>?@ H374?J6D37 @BADA45G C3@ J>5@AG 45 SA @46I?AI


15/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

4

3GI 3JJ56G4AI E57 SF 3G 37J>3A5D5K?@4O C>F 3GI >5C 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?@4 SAJ3QA 3G

37J>3A5D5K?@4 ?G 4>A E?7@4 HD3JAO C>F 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?@4 ?@ J5G@?IA7AI 3G 3KAG4 C574>F 45

@HA3B 3S564 @BADA43D H34>5D5K?A@O C>A7A 4>?@ @BADA45G J3QA E75QO >5C ?4 C3@ AM>6QAI 57

AMJ3P34AIO >5C 3GI C>F 4>34 @BADA45G C56DI SA I?3KG5@AI C?4> 374>7?4?@O 4>A J5QHDAM

>?@457F 5E S?5D5K?J3D 3G4>75H5D5K?J3D @46I?A@ 4>34 CAG4 ?G45 4>A IAPAD5HQAG4 5E 3 H34>5D5KF

5E 374>7?4?@ ?G 4>A E?7@4 HD3JAO 4>A 6@A 3GI 3KAGJF 5E J5QHDAM 4AJ>G?J3D 3HH37346@A@ 4>34

467GAI 4>A @BADA45G ?G45 3G 7AH7A@AG434?5G 5E T374>7?4?@UO >5C 3GI C>F 4>A I343 3GI 7A@6D4@

CA7A E?G3DDF H7A@AG4AI ?G 3 4AM463D E57QX3DD 5E 4>A@A H75JA@@A@ SAJ5QA QA7A ,$$9084'%/$

4>34 D?A SA>?GI 4>A TE?G3D H75I6J4U 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4R

f5@4 ?QH5743G4DFO /%4 ,(( ,&&%9/4$ ,1. .;9,(@ Z5QA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 37A @AAG 3@

Q57A 364>57?434?PA 4>3G 54>A7@O 3@ Q57A 57 DA@@ P3D?IO 3GI 3 K7A34 Q3GF E3J457@ HD3F ?G45

4>?@ HA7JA?PAI @4346@ 5E 3G 3JJ56G4R %>A 3@@6QH4?5G@ SA>?GI 3 @?GKDA @434AQAG4 J5QA@H3JB3KAI C?4> 6+% ?@ @3F?GK 4>A @434AQAG4O +%64>A @434AQAG4 ?@ @3?I 57 H7A@AG4AIO 6+*

4>A @434AQAG4 ?@ SA?GK H7A@AG4AI 3GI 6@AIO 3GI 6+.1.4>A @434AQAG4 ?@ H7A@AG4AIR *E 4>?@

@434AQAG4 ?@ H7A@AG4AI SF 3 H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5K?@4 ?G 3 $5CA7$5?G4 H7A@AG434?5G 34 3

Q3Y57 @J?AG4?E?J J5GEA7AGJA 5G @BADA43D H34>5D5K?A@O E57 AM3QHDAO ?4 D?BADF J377?A@ 3 E37

>?K>A7 @4346@ 3GI S67IAG 5E P3D?I?4F 4>3G ?E ?4 ?@ 4FHAI ?G 3 GAC@ED3@> >A3ID?GA SF 3G

3D4A7G34?PA Y567G3D?@4 E57 +AM6@ f3K3g?GAR cA>?GI 4>?@ @434AQAG4 3GI ?4@ H7A@AG434?5G D?A 3

G6QSA7 5E 3@@6QH4?5G@ 3S564 4>A TS3JB @43KAU 3J4?P?4?A@ 4>34 CAG4 ?G45 ?4@ H75I6J4?5GR

#G 3JJ56G4 J3G SA J3DDAI T364>57?434?PAU C>AG HA5HDA 3JJAH4 ?4@ ?GE57Q34?5G 3GIAMHD3G34?5G 3@ E?G3D 57 P3D?IO 3GI 6+./ 8.%8(. $4%8 $..2'/) ,(4.1/,4'5. 2/%6(.3).

1[76KD3G@B? )\a\^ '3P?PO c37d%3D A4 3DR 899e=R V>AG BG5CDAIKA 57 ?GE57Q34?5G SAJ5QA@

?IAG4?E?AI 3@ T364>57?434?PAUO HA5HDA Q3F 43BA AMAJ64?PA 3J4?5G S3@AI 5G 4>34 ?GE57Q34?5GO

C>?J> J3G 6D4?Q34ADF 3EEAJ4 7A@6D4@O @?4634?5G@ 3GI 564J5QA@ E75Q 4>A 3J4?5G@ 4>34 HA5HDA

43BA S3@AI 5G ?GE57Q34?5G 4>AF HA7JA?PA 3@ P3D?IR %>A J5GJAH4 5E 364>57?4FXS54> ?G 4A7Q@

5E 4>A ?QQAI?34A TE75G4 @43KAU 364>57?434?PA H7A@AGJA 5E 4>A 3JJ56G4O 3@ CADD 3@ 4>A 3443J>AI

57 3@@6QAI TS3JB @43KAU N63D?4?A@XHD3F@ 3 Q3Y57 75DA ?G >5C 3G 3JJ56G4 ?@ HA7JA?PAIO

J5G@6QAIO 7A3J4AI 45 3GI 7AK37IAI SF 4>A D3F 3GI AMHA74 H6SD?JR V>34 Q3BA@ 3G 3JJ56G4

5E 4>A H3@4 Q57A 57 DA@@ T364>57?434?PAU ?@ 4>A AM4AG4 45 C>?J> HA5HDA 3JJAH4 ?4 3@ P3D?IR

=>=>F ;6G0/ %57H7D+ I863JK0L4-9M %/6-D86.40- 6-1 &N4D.7H43 B7N7-17-37

%>7AA JAG473D 4>AQA@ E57Q 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GU@ AMHD5734?5G 5E 4>A 75DA 5E 364>57?4F ?G

4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D BG5CDAIKA; SD3JBS5M?GKO 473G@D34?5G 3GI AH?@4AQ?J

IAHAGIAGJAR W?7@4O 4>A7A ?@ 4>A J5GJAH4 5E SD3JBS5M?GK ?G ?G@4?464?5G3D J5G4AM4@O C?4> ?IA34>34 J5G4A@434?5G J3G S7AAI 473G@H37AGJFR *G@4?464?5G@XJ6@45Q@O D3C@O >?A737J>?A@O


16/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

5

@476J467A@ 5E 364>57?4FXJ3G H54AG4?3DDF SD3JB S5M 3 @F@4AQO 3@ CADD 3@ J7A34A 3GI @6@43?G

AH?@4AQ?J 3GI AMAJ64?PA 364>57?4F 5E HA5HDA 3GI 4>?GK@ 57 3S@473J4?5G@R %>?@ 4>A@?@

AMHD57A@ >5CO ?G 4>A 4A7Q@ 5E 234567U@ J5GJAH4 5E TSD3JBS5M?GKU 1)\\\; e9b=O 37J>3A5D5K?@4@

N6A@4?5G ?GH64@ 3GI 564H64@R #7J>3A5D5K?@4@ 5E4AG N6A@4?5G C>34 5SYAJ4@ 3GI I343 4>AF

E?GI 3GI Q3G3KA 1?GH64@= 3GI C>A4>A7 57 G54 4>A?7 ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 5E 4>5@A 5SYAJ4@ 37A

J5QHA4AG4 57 ?GJ5QHA4AG4 1564H64@=^ >5CAPA7O 4>AF 5E4AG I5 G54 N6A@4?5G 4>A 3J463D

@F@4AQ 3GI @476J467A 5E 4>A?7 5CG A@43SD?@>AI @F@4AQO 3@B?GK >5C 3GI C>F 4>A?7 @F@4AQ 5E

H73J4?JA 5HA734A@ D?BA ?4 I5A@ ?G 4>A E?7@4 HD3JAR #G 6GIA7DF?GK J5GJAH4 ?G 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?@

4>A ?IA3 4>34 C>AG 3 @6JJA@@E6D @5J?3D @F@4AQ 5E H73J4?JA ?@ ?G HD3JAO ?4 J3G SA >37I 45 S7A3B

564 5E 4>34 @F@4AQ 45 @AA C>34 ?@ 3J463DDF >3HHAG?GK SAD5C 4>A @67E3JAR V>AG J5G4A@434?5G

37?@A@O 4>A @F@4AQ J3G S7A3B I5CG 3GI SAJ5QA Q57A 473G@H37AG4O SAJ36@A J5G4A@434?5G

S7?GK@ E5J6@ 45 4>A 6GIA7DF?GK 5HA734?5G 5E 3 SD3JBS5MAI @F@4AQR %>?@ J5GJAH4 5EJ5G4A@434?5G 3GI SD3JBS5M?GK ?@ 3 JAG473D J5GJAH4 5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G @46IFU@

QA4>5I5D5K?J3D 3HH753J>O 3GI ?@ I?@J6@@AI E674>A7 ?G !>3H4A7 %>7AAR

# @AJ5GI Q3Y57 4>AQA ?@ 4>34 5E 473G@D34?5GR #JJ57I?GK 45 234567U@ T473G@D34?5G

Q5IADU)1)\aA >3GI@ 5E 3 Q6D4?46IA 5E I?EEA7AG4 3J457@R .GIA7DF?GK 4>?@ 4>AQA ?@ 4>A J5GJAH4 4>34 3

CAS 5E 3J457@X>6Q3G 3@ CADD 3@ Q34A7?3DO S54> 43GK?SDA 3GI ?G43GK?SDAX37A ?G4A77AD34AI

6GIA7 3 @F@4AQ 5E H73J4?JAR %>?@ 4>A@?@ AMHD57A@ >5C 364>57?4F ?@ 5GDF S6?D4 3GI @6@43?GAI

4>756K> 4>A 3JJ6Q6D34?5G 5E GAK54?34?5G@ SF Q3GF I?EEA7AG4 3J457@ ?G 3 GA4C57B^ A3J>3J457 @6HH574@ 3GI @6@43?G@ 3 K?PAG 5SYAJ4O G37734?PAO 37J>3A5D5K?J3D ?G4A7H7A434?5G 3GI @5

E574>O ?G 57IA7 45 E674>A7 3GI 3J>?APA >?@ 5CG K53D@ 3GI 3?Q@R *G H73J4?JAO 3G 374AE3J4 57

3JJ56G4 3JJ6Q6D34A@ H5CA7 5PA7 HA5HDA 3GI H73J4?JA 3@ ?4@ ?G4A7H7A434?5G ?@ 473G@D34AI

4>756K> A3J> 3J457U@ K53D@ 3GI 3?Q@R %>?@ J5GJAH4 ?@ I?@J6@@AI E674>A7 ?G !>3H4A7 %C5O 3GI

?4 ?@ AM4AGIAI ?G !>3H4A7@ W567 3GI W?PAR

W?G3DDFO 4>?@ 4>A@?@ E6GI3QAG43DDF 7A@4@ 5G 4>A J5GJAH4 5E AH?@4AQ?J IAHAGIAGJAR

T&H?@4AQ?J IAHAGIAGJAU ?@ 4>A /3HHA3D 45 ?G4ADDAJ463D 364>57?4F 3GI 4>A C3F ?G C>?J> @6J>

3G 3HHA3D J5G@4?464A@ Y6@4?E?J34?5G E57 SAD?AP?GK 3GI BG5C?GK0 1"37IC?K )\a:; eeA7 C57I@O 3 HA7@5G Q3F SAD?APA Q3GF 4>?GK@ E57 C>?J> >A I5A@ G54 H5@@A@@ I?7AJ4

AP?IAGJA E57O S64 >A 7AD?A@ 5G 4>A 364>57?4F 5E AMHA74@ C>5 >A 4>?GB@ I5 H5@@A@@ 4>A

GAJA@@37F AP?IAGJAR &H?@4AQ?J IAHAGIAGJA ?@ A@@AG4?3D 45 >5C CA ?G4A73J4 C?4> BG5CDAIKA

SAF5GI 567 AMHA7?AG4?3D J3H3S?D?4?A@R %>?@ J5GJAH4 ?@ I?@J6@@AI ?G IA43?D ?G !>3H4A7 Z?MR W57

G5CO ?4 ?@ 6@AE6D 45 H5?G4 564 4>34 AH?@4AQ?J IAHAGIAGJA HD3F@ 3 BAF 75DA ?G >5C 3JJ56G4@

37A J5G@476J4AI 3GI 473G@D34AIO K3?G?GK 364>57?4F 3GI @4346@ SF H5D?4?J@ 3GI HA7E57Q3GJAR

)ZAA ZAJ4?5G 8R8ReR


17/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

6

%>A@A Q3Y57 ?@@6A@XSD3JBS5M?GKO 473G@D34?5G 3GI AH?@4AQ?J IAHAGIAGJAXE57Q

JAG473D 4>AQA@ ?G 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GU@ AMHD5734?5G 5E 4>A 75DA 5E 364>57?4F ?G 4>A H75I6J4?5G

5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D BG5CDAIKAR %>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ @476J467AI 3756GI 7AD34AI 4>AQ34?J 37K6QAG4@R

1)= &MAJ64?PA 3GI AH?@4AQ?J 364>57?4F ?G 3G 3J3IAQ?J I?@J?HD?GA D?BA 37J>3A5D5KF Q3G?EA@4

I?7AJ4DF ?G 4>A H75JA@@ 5E @43S?D?@34?5GO C>?J> 5JJ67@ 4>756K> H75JA@@A@ D?BA ?G@J7?H4?5G 3GI

473G@D34?5GR8 %>34 ?@O I67?GK 4>A H75JA@@ 5E TH75I6J?GK BG5CDAIKAU ?G 37J>3A5D5KFO ED6?I

?IA3@ 37A 3J4?PADF 467GAI ?G45 @43SDAO E57Q3D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4O @6J> 3@ 4AM463D

7AH7A@AG434?5G@ 57 Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@R *G 4>A H75JA@@ 5E BG5CDAIKA E57Q34?5GO 4>A7A ?@ 3

E6GI3QAG43D 4?HH?GK H5?G4 SA4CAAG E3J463D BG5CDAIKA 3@ ?4 ?@ J5G@476J4AI ?G 3 ED6?I

IAPAD5HQAG4 H>3@AO 3GI 4>A BG5CDAIKA 3@ ?4 3HHA37@ @5D?I?E?AI ?G 3 H7A@AG43SDAO

H6SD?@>3SDA IAPAD5HQAG4 H>3@AR *4 ?@ ?G 4>?@ 4?HH?GK H5?G4 4>34 QA7A ?IA3@ SAJ5QA @5D?I

E3J4@O @47AGK4>AGAI 3GI Q3IA 364>57?434?PA SF 4>A 75S6@4GA@@ 5E 3 GAC Q34A7?3D 3GI QAI?3H7A@AGJAR %>?@ 37K6QAG4 E57Q@ 4>A H7?Q37F I?@J6@@?5G 5E !56N.7/ O02/R 18= %>A H5CA7 5E

AM4A7G3D @5J?5dH5D?4?J@ J3G 3EEAJ4 >5C 7A3I?DF 4>A KAGA73D H6SD?J 57 @J?AG4?E?J J5QQ6G?4F

3JJAH4@ 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R f3GF /H75SDAQ@ 5E DAK?4?Q3JF 3GI 5E AM4AG@?5G 37?@A SAJ36@A

T4>A @HAAI 5E H5D?4?J@ ?@ E3@4A7 4>3G 4>A @HAAI 5E @J?AGJAU0 1!5DD?G@ 3GI &P3G@ 899]; )8:=R

'AK37IDA@@ 5E 4>A 5G45D5K?J3D P3D6A 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D G37734?PA@ 57 ?G4A7H7A434?5G@O @5QA

3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 Q3F SA Q57A 7A3I?DF 3JJAH4AIO >?K>DF 7AK37IAI 3GI @AAG 3@

T364>57?434?PAU SF 4>A KAGA73D H6SD?J SAJ36@A 5E 4>A @5J?3D GAAI@ 4>AF E6DE?DR 1e= %>A H5CA7

5E 6@?GK 4>A T3HH75H7?34A HA7E57Q3GJAU 5E @J?AG4?E?J SA>3P?567 J3G 3D@5 I?7AJ4DF 3EEAJ4 4>A364>57?4F 5E 3G 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4R %>A@A D344A7 4C5 37K6QAG4@ E57Q 4>A H7?Q37F

I?@J6@@?5G 5E !56N.7/ O4P7R 1b= #64>57?4F ?@ H75I6JAI 3@ Q6J> 3@ ?4 ?@ J5G@6QAIR V>?DA

364>57?4F ?@O ?G AEEAJ4O S6?D4 3GI 3JJ6Q6D34AI SF P37?56@ 3J457@O ?4 ?@ 3D@5 J5G@6QAI ?G 4>A

H75JA@@ 5E 473G@D34?5GR *G 37J>3A5D5KFO 4>?GK@ 3GI G37734?PA@ 37A 5E4AG H3JB3KAI E57

J5G@6QH4?5GO 3GI 4>A H75JA@@A@ 5E ?G@J7?H4?5GO 473G@D34?5G 3GI HA7E57Q3GJA 37A

?G4A74C?GAI C?4> >5C @4346@ 3GI 364>57?4F 37A 7AJA?PAI 3GI J5G@6QAI SF 4>A H6SD?JR

!56N.7/ Q4L J5GJD6IA@ C?4> 3 I?@J6@@?5G 3S564 4>A ?QHD?J34?5G@ 5E 4>A H75I6J4?5G 3GI

J5G@6QH4?5G 5E 364>57?4F ?G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JAR

%>?@ I?@@A7434?5G 564D?GA@ 4>A@A 37K6QAG4@ 6@?GK 4C5 ?DD6@4734?PA J3@A @46I?A@O S54>

5E C>?J> 37A ?GP5DPAI ?G DAPAD@ 5E ?G4A7H7A4?PA J5G4A@434?5GR %5 Q3M?Q?gA IA@J7?H4?PA P3D6AO

4>?@ 7A@A37J> AQHD5F@ 5GA J3@A 5E H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5KF 3GI 5GA J3@A 5E 3D4A7G34?PA

37J>3A5D5KFR c54> J3@A @46I?A@ 37A 37J>3A5D5K?J3D @?4A@ 4>34 H75I6JA 4>A?7 5CG

T364>57?434?PAU 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 4>756K> 4>A?7 H73J4?JA@O H6SD?J34?5G@ 3GI H6SD?J

8%>A J5GJAH4@ 5E AMAJ64?PA 3G AH?@4AQ?J 364>57?4F 37A ?G475I6JAI ?G ZAJ4?5G 8R8R8R %>A J5GJAH4@ 5E?G@J7?H4?5G 3GI 473G@D34?5G 37A ?G475I6JAI ?G ZAJ4?5G 8R8R:R)O 3GI E674>A7 AMH3GIAI ?G ZAJ4?5G@

eR8R)R) 3GI bRbR)R


18/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

7

H7A@AG434?5G@R %>A E?7@4 J3@A @46IF ?@ 4>A H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75YAJ4 5E h343D>iFjB

?G 4>A 'AH6SD?J 5E %67BAFO 6GIA7 4>A I?7AJ4?5G 5E *3G "5IIA7 5E Z43GE57I .G?PA7@?4FR

!56N.7/ O02/AM3Q?GA@ @?4AU@ ?G4AG4?5G3D 7AEDAM?PA H73J4?JA 3GI ?4@ H75EA@@?5G3D @4346@ 3@ 3

>?K>DF 364>57?434?PA 3GI H7A@4?K?56@ 37J>3A5D5K?J3D @?4AR %>A @?4A 5E h343D>iFjB H75I6JA@

S54> 364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 3GI 364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E H7A@AG4

37J>3A5D5K?J3D QA4>5I5D5KFO C>?J> >3PA SAAG 5HAGDF J5G4A@4AIO SF S54> 3J3IAQ?J 3GI

3D4A7G34?PA K756H@R %>?@ J3@A @46IF ?@ AQHD5FAI 45 5EEA7 ?G@?K>4@ 3S564 >5C 4>A H75JA@@A@

5E ?G@J7?H4?5GO 473G@D34?5G 3GI SD3JBS5M?GK J3G 3EEAJ4 3GI A@43SD?@> 364>57?4F ?G

H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JAR *4 3D@5 3II7A@@A@ >5C H>F@?J3D 3GI ?G4ADDAJ463D @H3JAO

3@ CADD 3@ ?@@6A@ 5E 3JJA@@ ?G D5J3D?@AI BG5CDAIKAdH75I6J?GK @5J?3D 37AG3@O J3G 3EEAJ4

37J>3A5D5K?J3D 364>57?4FR %>A @AJ5GI J3@A @46IF ?G 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?@ 4>A J5G475PA7@?3D

3D4A7G34?PA 37J>3A5D5KF 5E k?@5B5O c5@G?3 J5QQ5GDF 7AEA77AI 45 3@ 4>A c5@G?3G $F73Q?I@R%>?@ H75YAJ4O 6GIA7 4>A I?7AJ4?5G 5E 4>A T3Q34A67 37J>3A5D5K?@4U ZAQ?7 ,@Q3G3K?lO >3@ SAAG

PA7F @6JJA@@E6D 34 J7A34?GK 3G 3JJ56G4 5E H7A>?@457F E57 4>A KAGA73D H6SD?JO C>?J> >3@ SAAG

7AJA?PAI SF 4>A KAGA73D c5@G?3G H6SD?J 3@ 364>57?434?PAO IA@H?4A 5SYAJ4?5G@ 45 4>A H75YAJ4

SF 4>A H75EA@@?5G3D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D J5QQ6G?4FR !56N.7/ O4P7 6@A@ 4>?@ J3@A @46IF 45

AMHD57A >5C 364>57?4F J3G SA S6?D4 6H5GO Q?Q?JBAI 3GI HA7E57QAI 4>756K> I73C?GK 5G

3J3IAQ?J 37AG3@ 5E @J?AG4?E?J H73J4?JA 3GI 4>756K> A3KA7 H6SD?J H374?J?H34?5GR ZHAJ?E?J3DDFO

4>?@ @46IF >?K>D?K>4@ 4>A ?QH5743GJA 5E AM4A7G3D @5J?5dH5D?4?J@O 3@ CADD 3@ I73C?GK 6H5G

364>57?434?PA ?G@4?464?5G@ 3GI HA7E57Q3GJA@O ?G 4>A J5G@476J4?5G 3GI Q3?G4AG3GJA 5E37J>3A5D5K?J3D 364>57?4FR

=>A # !/4D4D 0< #2.50/4.: 4- #/35670809:R

=>A>= %57 ,HN0/.6-37 0< #11/7DD4-9 #2.50/4.: 4- #/356708094368 $/63.437

#D5GK C?4> 3 IA43?DAI AMHD5734?5G 5E >5C 364>57?4F 5HA734A@ ?G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

H73J4?JA 3GI H7A@AG434?5GO 4>?@ 4>A@?@ 3D@5 J5G47?S64A@ 3G AM4AG@?PA IAJ5G@476J4?5G 5E 4>A

4A7Q T364>57?4FU ?G !56N.7/ %@0R #64>57?4F ?@ 3 J5GJAH463D 3S@473J4?5G 4>34 I?7AJ4DF

7AEDAJ4@ 3@FQQA47?J3D @5J?3D H5CA7 7AD34?5G@>?H@O 3GI ?4 3D@5 Q3G?EA@4@ ?G Q34A7?3D C3F@;

3GF 4C5 4>?GK@ 57 HA5HDAO C>AG H64 ?G 43GIAQO I?7AJ4DF 7AD34A 45 5GA 3G54>A7 ?G 4A7Q@ 5E

3@FQQA47?J3D H5CA7O ?GED6AGJA 3GI @4346@R # Q3Y57 J5G47?S64?5G 5E 4>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ 45 564D?GA

@5QA 5E 4>A 7554@ 3GI IAS34A 3S564 4>A G3467A 5E 364>57?4F 4>34 >3PA AQA7KAI ?G

I?@J?HD?GA@ 564@?IA 5E 37J>3A5D5KFO ?QHDAQAG4?GK 3 C?IA7 J5DDAJ4?PA 6GIA7@43GI?GK 5E 4>A4A7Q E57 6@A ?G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D I?@J567@AR %>?@ ?@ G54 45 @3F 4>34 364>57?4F >3@ SAAG


19/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

8

I?@7AK37IAI 57 GAKDAJ4AI ?G 4>A E?ADI 5E 37J>3A5D5KFO 57 4>34 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G ?@ 73?@?GK

?@@6A@ 3S564 364>57?4F 3GI 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA E57 4>A E?7@4 4?QAR *G E3J4O 4>?@ ?@ N6?4A

4>A 5HH5@?4A; H75SDAQ@ 5E 364>57?4F 3@ 4>AF 7AD34A 45 54>A7 Q3Y57 ?@@6A@ C?4>?G 4>A E?ADI

>3PA SAAG 73?@AI SF 37J>3A5D5K?@4@ E57 IAJ3IA@ 3@ ?QH5743G4 3GI C574> 567 J5GJA7GX

A@HAJ?3DDF ?G I?@J6@@?5G@ 5PA7 ?@@6A@ D?BA 4>A ?QH3J4 5E HA7@5G3D S?3@A@ 5G 4>A Q34A7?3D

7AJ57IO 4>A GAAI E57 Q6D4?P5J3D?4F 3GI J5DD3S5734?5G C?4> 4>A H6SD?JO ?@@6A@ 5E H>F@?J3D

3JJA@@ 57 5CGA7@>?H 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D Q34A7?3DO 3DD Q344A7@ 4>34 I?7AJ4DF 7A@4 6H5G 4>A

J5GJAH4 5E 364>57?4FR "5CAPA7O 4>?@ 4>A@?@ 37K6A@ 4>34 C>?DA 4>A E?ADI @AAQ@ 45 7A3I?DF

AGK3KA C?4> ?@@6A@ 5E 364>57?4F 3GI H5CA7 7?K>4@O 737ADF >3@ 4>A 7554 J5GJAH463D

6GIA7@43GI?GK 5E C>34 364>57?4F ?@ 3GI >5C ?4 Q3G?EA@4@ ?G 4>A E?7@4 HD3JA APA7 SAAG

AMHD?J?4DF I?@J6@@AIR

W674>A7Q57AO ?G 4>A E?ADI 5E 37J>3A5D5KF CA >3PA 5E4AG SAAG N6?JB 45 3II7A@@364>57?4F SF I?@Q?@@?GK ?4R ,E4AG 364>57?4F ?@ 7AEA77AI 45 3@ @5QA4>?GK GAK34?PAO @5QA4>?GK

45 SA 3P5?IAIO @5QA4>?GK 4>34 >?GIA7@ J5DD3S5734?5G 3GI H6SD?J 3JJA@@R "5CAPA7O 364>57?4F

?@ 3G ?G4AK73D 3GI GAJA@@37F H374 5E 3GF 3J3IAQ?J AGIA3P567O AQSAIIAI ?G 4>A @5J?3D

@476J467A@ 5E 3J3IAQ?3 3GI ?G 4>A @J?AG4?E?J 473I?4?5G@ 4>34 CA >3PA S756K>4 I5CG E75Q 4>A

&GD?K>4AGQAG4R *G 37J>3A5D5KFO H73J4?JA@ @6J> 3@ 3JN6?7?GK J7AIAG4?3D@O HA7E57Q?GK 57

3JJAH4?GK AMHA74 4A@4?Q5GFO AGK3K?GK ?G H73J4?JA@ 5E C?4GA@@?GK 3GI HAA7 7AP?ACO 3@ CADD 3@

3DDF?GK 3GI IAEAGI?GK 567 5CG ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 4>756K> 4>A HA7E57Q3GJA 5E 3HH75H7?34A

SA>3P?567@ 57 SF I73C?GK 5G 4>A 3HH75H7?34A J34AK57?A@ 5E H73J4?JAO 37A 3DD @F@4AQ34?J@5J?3D C3F@ 45 3JJ6Q6D34AO GAK54?34A 3GI PA7?EF 364>57?4FR %>?@ 4>A@?@ C?DD 3II7A@@ 4>A@A

?@@6A@ ?G IAH4>R V>?DA @6J> 364>57?434?PA H73J4?JA ?@ ?GG34A ?G 567 H75EA@@?5G3D I?@J?HD?G37F

QA4>5I5D5KFO ?4 ?@ 3D@5 5E4AG I?@J6@@AI 3@ ?E ?4 CA7A 3 E6GI3QAG43D Tc3I %>?GKU ?G 4>A C3BA

5E H5@4Q5IA7G I?@J567@AR *G 37J>3A5D5KFO 4>A57?A@ 3GI GAC 6GIA7@43GI?GK@ 5E Q6D4?P5J3D

?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 3GI H5@4dJ5D5G?3D 73Q?E?J34?5G@ 5E 5CGA7@>?H >3PA 37K63SDF DAE4 6@ ?G 3G

6GJ5QE5743SDA 7AD34?5G@>?H C?4> 567 5CG H5CA7 3GI 364>57?4FR

%>?@ 4>A@?@ 37K6A@ 4>34 ?4 ?@ ?QH5743G4 45 3JBG5CDAIKA 4>A 7554 J36@A@ 3GI

GAJA@@37F 7AD?3GJA 6H5G 364>57?4F ?G 4>A C3F CA H75I6JA BG5CDAIKAR *G 4>A I?@J?HD?GA 5E

37J>3A5D5KFO ?4 ?@ G54 5GDF ?QH5743G4 45 3II7A@@ 364>57?4F 3@ 3 @?IAdAEEAJ4 57 7AD34?5G3D

?@@6A ?G H75SDAQ@ 5E 3JJA@@ 7?K>4@ 3GI J5G475D 5E 4>A H3@4O S64 ?4 ?@ 3D@5 J7?4?J3D 45

3JBG5CDAIKA AM3J4DF 6+,4 ,94+%1'4* '$ 3@ 3 7554 @F@4AQ 5E H73J4?JAR VA GAAI 45 3II7A@@

C>A7A 567 364>57?4F J5QA@ E75QO >5C ?4 Q3G?EA@4@ ?G 567 5CG H73J4?JAO >5C I?@J?HD?G37F

364>57?4F ?@ H75I6JAI 3GI J5G@6QAI SF QAQSA7@ 5E 4>A H6SD?J 3GI G54 Y6@4 ?GI?P?I63D@

C?4>?G 4>A H75EA@@?5GX3GI HA7>3H@ Q5@4 ?QH5743G4DFXCA GAAI 45 3II7A@@ 4>A ?QH3J4 5E

567 5CG 364>57?4FO 3JBG5CDAIKAI 57 G54O 5G 567 5CG ?G4A7H7A434?5G@R *G 57IA7 45 3II7A@@

4>A@A J5GJA7G@O 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G AM3Q?GA@ 364>57?4F ?G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA SF


20/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

9

A4>G5K73H>?J3DDF 5S@A7P?GK >5C TE3J463D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4U 37A H75I6JAI 4>756K> 4>A

37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@R *@@6A@ 5E 364>57?4F 3GI @J?AG4?E?J H73J4?JAO 3GI 4>A N6A@4?5G@ 4>34

7AD34A 45 >5C CA 6GIA7@43GI 3GI 3JJ56G4 E57 567 H3@4 3GI H7A@AG4 C57DIO 37A 3 Q344A7 5E

@5J?3D ?G4A7A@4R %>A7AE57AO 4>A@A 37A @5J?3D J5GJA7G@ 3GI Q344A7@ 5E @5J?3D A4>?J@O ?@@6A@

C>?J> ?QH3J4 S54> 567 @5J?3D 3GI G34673D 6GIA7@43GI?GK 5E 4>A C57DIO 3GI ?QH5743G4 45

3II7A@@ ?G IA43?DR

=>F %57H6.43 Q./23.2/7 0< .54D %57D4D

%>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ I?P?IAI ?G45 4>7AA 4>AQ34?J @AJ4?5G@R %>A E?7@4 @AJ4?5G 1!56N.7/D

)-7M %@0 6-1 %5/77= ?G475I6JA@ 4>A 7ADAP3G4 4>A57A4?J3D J5GJAH4@O S3JBK756GI 3GI

4>A57F SA>?GI 4>?@ @46IFR # IA43?DAI IAJ5G@476J4?5G 3GI I?@J6@@?5G 5E 364>57?4F 3GI

7AEDAM?PA 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA ?@ ?G4AK73D 45 4>?@ H75YAJ4R !56N.7/ %@0 H7A@AG4@ 3G

57?K?G3D IAJ5G@476J4?5G 5E 4>A J5GJAH4 5E T364>57?4FU 3GI ?IAG4?E?A@ ?4@ 7ADAP3GJA ?G S753IA7

3J3IAQ?J D?4A73467AR %>?@ J>3H4A7 ?G475I6JA@ T364>57?4FU 3@ S54> 3G 3S@473J4 J5GJAH4 3GI 3@

3 @F@4AQ 5E H73J4?JAR %>A 4A7Q ?@ J5GJAH463DDF 4?AI 45 H5CA7 7AD34?5G@>?H@O ?QHD?J34?GK C>5

>3@ 4>A DAK?4?Q34A 7?K>4 45 AMA7J?@A H5CA7 3GI ?GED6AGJA 54>A7@R %>?@ B?GI 5E I?@J567@A

H75P?IA@ 3 6@AE6D S3@AD?GA E57 3 7AEDAM?PA @46IF 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA 3GI 4>AH75I6J4?5G 5E 364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 ?G 3 J5G4A@4AI AGP?75GQAG4X3G 3HH753J>

4>34 ?@ 6@AI D34A7 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GR !56N.7/ %5/775EEA7@ 4>A QA4>5I5D5K?J3D S3JBK756GI

5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GU@ J3@A @46I?A@ 3GI A4>G5K73H>?J 3HH753J>R %>?@ J>3H4A7 ?G475I6JA@ 4>A

4C5 J3@A @46IF @?4A@Xh343D>iFjB 3GI 4>A c5@G?3G $F73Q?I@X3GI ?DD6@4734A@ 4>A 4>AQA@O

J5GJAH4@ 3GI ?@@6A@ SA>?GI 4>A E?ADIC57B 3GI J3@A @46IFdS3@AI 3HH753J> 5E 4>?@ @46IFR

%>A @AJ5GI 4>AQ34?J @AJ4?5G 5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5G 1!56N.7/D O02/ 3GIO4P7= 73?@A

4>A Q3?G 37K6QAG4@ 3S564 4>A G3467A 5E 364>57?4F ?G 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R %>A@A J>3H4A7@ 6@A 4C5 J3@A @46I?A@ 45 I?@J6@@ 4>A ?QHD?J34?5G@ 5E

>5C 364>57?4F ?@ Q3G?EA@4AIO J5G@476J4AI 3GI J5G@476AI S54> ?G@?IA 3GI 564@?IA 4>A

I?@J?HD?GAR W?7@4O !56N.7/ O02/ ?G475I6JA@ >5C 364>57?4F ?QH3J4@ 4>A C3F 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

BG5CDAIKA ?@ H75I6JAI 3GI J5G@6QAIR %>?@ J>3H4A7 7A?G475I6JA@ 4>A Q3Y57 ?@@6A@ 5E

?G@J7?H4?5GO 473G@D34?5G 3GI SD3JBS5M?GK ?G 4>A H75I6J4?5G 5E BG5CDAIKA 3GI AMHD57A@ >5C

364>57?4F ?@ 3JJ6Q6D34AIO GA4C57BAI 3GI 473G@D34AI ?G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JAO 564D?G?GK

4>A C3F 3J463D H73J4?JA@ 37A Q3GKDAI 3GI J5QHD?J34AI 3EE3?7@R %>?@ J>3H4A7 6@A@ 4>AQA@

3GI ?@@6A@ 4>34 375@A I67?GK QF E?ADIC57B 34 h343D>iFjBO 3GI ?4 6@A@ 4>?@ 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

@?4A 3@ 3 QA3G@ 45 ?DD6@4734A 4>A 37K6QAG4 4>34 364>57?4F ?@ E57QAI ?G 4>A H75JA@@ 5E


21/303

!"#$%&' ) *+%',-.!%*,+

10

@43S?D?@?GK ED6?I ?IA3@ ?G45 E57Q3DO Q34A7?3D 7AH7A@AG434?5G@ 3GI 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R

!56N.7/ O4P7O 3II7A@@A@ 4>A C3F AM4A7G3D @5J?3D E3J457@X?GED6AGJA@ 3GI H7A@@67A@ E75Q

@5J?5dH5D?4?J@ 3GI 4>A H6SD?J 564@?IA 5E 4>A J57A @J?AG4?E?J J5QQ6G?4FXJ3G I?7AJ4DF

473G@D34AO 3JJ6Q6D34A 3GI J5G47?S64A 45 4>A 364>57?4F 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D ?G4A7H7A434?5G@R

%>?@ J>3H4A7 3D@5 3II7A@@A@ 4>A ?QH5743GJA 5E HA7E57Q34?PA SA>3P?567@ ?G 4>A J7A34?5G

3GI @6@43?G?GK 5E @4346@ 3GI 364>57?4F ?G 37J>3A5D5KFR

*G 4>A 4>?7I 3GI E?G3D @AJ4?5G 5E 4>?@ 4>A@?@O !56N.7/ Q4LO * J5GJD6IA 4>34 364>57?4F ?@

S6?D4 3GI 473G@D34AI 3GI 3JJ6Q6D34AI SF P37?56@ 3J457@O S64 ?4 3D@5 J5G@6QAI ?G 4>A

H75JA@@ 5E 473G@D34?5GR *G 37J>3A5D5KFO 4>?GK@ 3GI G37734?PA@ 37A H3JB3KAI E57

J5G@6QH4?5GO 3GI 4>A C3F J5G@6QH4?5G I?7AJ4DF J5G47?S64A@ 45 3GI ?QHD?J34A@ 364>57?4F ?G

37J>3A5D5KF ?@ 3G ?QH5743G4 ?@@6A 4>34 GAAI@ 45 SA 3II7A@@AIR %>?@ J>3H4A7 73?@A@ 4>A

?QH5743GJA 5E JD5@ADF D?GBAI J5GJAH4@ @6J> 3@ TE?IAD?4FU 3GI T3JJ56G43S?D?4FUR %>A 4A7QTE?IAD?4FU J5QA@ E75Q 4>A 234?G C57DI"'3.('4,$O QA3G?GK TE3?4>E6DGA@@UO 3GI ?4 7AEA7AGJA@ >5C

3JJ6734A 3 J5HF 57 @?Q6D34?5G ?@ 45 3G 57?K?G3D 1,&- )\a\=R %>A G54?5G 5E T3JJ56G43S?D?4FOU 3

J5GJAH4 ?G A4>?J@ 4>34 1?G 4>?@ @?4634?5G= IAQ3GI@ 7A@H5G@?S?D?4F E57 3GF 6GA4>?J3D Q?@6@A

5E 364>57?4FO 5HAG@ 3G ?QH5743G4 I?@J6@@?5G 3S564 4>A A4>?J@ 5E 7A@6D4@ 3GI J5G@AN6AGJA@

5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D ?G4A7H7A434?5G@O 7AJ5G@476J4?5G@ 3GI 364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R

%>?@ 4>A@?@ AM3Q?GA@ >5C Q5IA@ 3GI @476J467A@ 5E 364>57?4F 37A ?GAM47?J3SDA E75Q

4>A J5DDAJ4?5GO J5G@476J4?5G 3GI I?@47?S64?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D BG5CDAIKA 3GI Q34A7?3DR *4

@AAB@ 45 @>5C >5C H73J4?4?5GA7@ 5E 37J>3A5D5KF 3J4?PADF AG3J4O J5G@476J4O 3GI ?QHDAQAG4364>57?4F ?G 4>A H75JA@@ 5E H75I6J?GK BG5CDAIKAR *4 3?Q@ 45 AM3Q?GA >5C 364>57?4F 3GI

3J4@ 5E DAK?4?Q34?5G 37A 3J4?PADF AQHD5FAI 3GI I?@47?S64AI 4>756K> 4>A QAI?6Q 5E @J?AGJAO

3GI ?4 ?GPA@4?K34A@ >5C 4>A@A 3J4@ 37A AQSAIIAI 3GI ?GAM47?J3SDA E75Q H73J4?J3D

37J>3A5D5K?J3D QA4>5I@ 3GI 4>A57A4?J3D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D ?G4A7H7A434?5G@R %>?@ 4>A@?@ G54

5GDF Q3BA@ 4>A 37K6QAG4 4>34 P37?56@ Q5IA@ 5E @476J4673D 3GI AH?@4AQ?J 364>57?4F 37A

AQSAIIAI ?G APA7F @43KA 5E 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@O S64 ?QH5743G4DFO ?4 ?IAG4?E?A@ >5C

4>?@ 364>57?4F Q3G?EA@4@ 4>756K> 4>A QAI?6Q 5E @J?AG4?E?J 3J4@R


22/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

11

!"#$%&' %S)+

!0-37N.D 6-1 %570/:+ #2.50/4.: 6-1 .57 Q03468

!0-D./23.40- 0< #/356708094368 ?-0@87197IJ&'./&. '$ 6'3.(* ,&&.84.3 4% -. 4+1.. 3'"".1./4 4+'/)$K , 0.4+%3 %" 9/3.1$4,/3'/) ,/3 %" .$4,-('$+'/) ",&4$

,-%94 4+. 9/'5.1$.< 4+. ",&4$ 4+.0$.(5.$7 4+. 81%39&4$ %" 4+,4 0.4+%3< ,/3 , 5%'&. %" ,94+%1'4* ,/3

&%/$.;9./4(* , (%&9$ %" &9(491,( 8%6.1@L 1f37B@ 899\; :=

A>= ,-./0123.40-

A>=>= ,-./01234-9 %570/: 6-1 !0-37N.D

*4 >3@ SAJ5QA 3 476?@Q 4>34 4>A H3@4 ?@ J5G4A@4AI @H3JAO 4>34 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@ 37A

G54 @434AQAG4@ 5E E3J4O S64 734>A7 AI6J34AI ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 3S564 C>34 TQ?K>4 >3PA >3HHAGAIU ?G

>?@457F 125CAG4>3D )\a:^ VASS 8998=R V>?DA 4>A57A4?J3D I?@J6@@?5G@ 3S564 4>A @5J?3DDF

J5G@476J4AI H3@4 >3PA 7344DAI 4>A >3DD@ 5E 3J3IAQ?3 E57 5PA7 4>?74F FA37@O 4>A H75EA@@?5G 5E

37J>3A5D5KF >3@ 37K63SDF 7AQ3?GAI 4>A @475GKA@4O Q5@4 ?G43J4 3GI 364>57?434?PA P5?JA ?G >5C4>A Q34A7?3D H3@4 ?@ 3JJ56G4AI E57 ?G H6SD?J @A44?GK@O ?G E576Q@ @6J> 3@ Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@ 3GI

QAI?3 H75I6J4?5G@O 3GI ?G 5EE?J?3D H6SD?J34?5G@ @6J> 3@ S55B@ 3GI 374?JDA@ 5G 4>A H3@4R H94+%1'4*O

4>A 3S@473J4 ?GED6AGJA 3GI H>F@?J3D E57JAO HD3F@ 3 Q3Y57 75DA ?G >5C 3GI C>F 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4

J5QA 45 SA 3JJAH4AI 3@ J577AJ4X3@ 364>57?434?PAXSF S54> 4>A H75EA@@?5G3D 3J3IAQA 3GI 4>A

?G4A7A@4AI H6SD?JR %>A @6SYAJ4 5E 4>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ 4>A T364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4U; >5C ?4 ?@

H75I6JAIO C>F @5QA 3JJ56G4@ 37A 47A34AI 3@ Q57A 364>57?434?PA 4>3G 54>A7@O C>F @5QA HA5HDA

3GI Q34A7?3D@ 37A 7AK37IAI Q57A 364>57?434?PA 4>3G 54>A7@O >5C 364>57?4F ?@ AQSAIIAI ?G 4>A

37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@ 3GI 6D4?Q34ADF Q3G?EA@4@ ?G 4>A 3JJAH43GJA 57 7AYAJ4?5G 5E TE?G3D H75I6J4U364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R

$7AP?56@DFO 4>A *G475I6J4?5G 5E 4>?@ 4>A@?@ 564D?GAI 4>A H75SDAQ@ 3GI @476J467A 5E 4>?@

I?@@A7434?5GR %>?@ J>3H4A7 3II7A@@A@ 4>A J5GJAH4@ 3GI 4>A57F SA>?GI 4>?@ @46IFR %>A E?7@4 @AJ4?5G

?IAG4?E?A@ 4>A E56GI34?5G 5E 4>?@ 4>A@?@; 4>A 37K6QAG4 4>34 BG5CDAIKA ?@ @5J?3DDF J5G@476J4AIR %>A

@AJ5GI @AJ4?5G 3II7A@@A@ 4C5 7AD34AI S64 I?@4?GJ4?PA J5GJAH4@XTH5CA7U 3GI T364>57?4FUX3GI

H3F@ H374?J6D37 344AG4?5G 45 4>A 4A7Q T364>57?4FUO C>?J> >3@ D5GK SAAG H75SDAQ34?J ?G @5J?3D

@46I?A@R %>?@ @AJ4?5G 5EEA7@ 3 E73QAC57B E57 4>?GB?GK 3S564 T364>57?4FU ?G 4>A J5G4AM4 5E 4>A

4A7QU@ 57?K?G@O 3GI ?4 ?IAG4?E?A@ 4>A Q3?G 4>7A3I@ 5E I?@J6@@?5G 4>34 473I?4?5G3DDF 3HHA37 ?G S54>


23/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

12

@5J?3D @46I?A@ 3GI ?G 4>A E?ADI 5E 37J>3A5D5KFR *G 4>A 4>?7I @AJ4?5GO 4>?@ J>3H4A7 5EEA7@ 3 GAC C3F

5E 4>?GB?GK 3S564 4>A 4A7Q T364>57?4FU E75Q 4>A HA7@HAJ4?PA 5E @46I?A@ ?G 4>A @5J?5D5KF 5E

@J?AG4?E?J BG5CDAIKAO 37K6?GK 4>34 364>57?4F ?@ 3 J7A34AI 3GI A37GAI 564J5QA 5E J5QHDAM @5J?3D

?G4A73J4?5G@R '34>A7 4>3G SA?GK 3 @?GKDA N63D?4F 57 J>373J4A7?@4?J 4>34 ?@ TH5@@A@@AIU 57 TG54

H5@@A@@AIU SF 3G ?GI?P?I63DX4>A 473I?4?5G3D 3HH753J> 45 IAE?G?GK 3GI 4>?GB?GK 3S564

364>57?4FX4>?@ 4>A@?@ ?G@4A3I 5HAG@ 4>A 37K6QAG4 4>34 364>57?4F ?@ 3G AEEAJ4 57 3JJ6Q6D34?5G 5E

@4346@ K3?GAI I67?GK 3 J5QHDAM H75JA@@ 5E @5J?3D ?G4A73J4?5G@R %>?@ 37K6QAG4 C?DD SA E5DD5CAI

4>756K> 4>A 7AQ3?GIA7 5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GO 3GI ?4 ?@ JAG473D 45 4>A @46IF 3GI I?@J6@@?5G 5E 4>A

4C5 J3@A @46I?A@ ?G 4>?@ C57BR %>A AGI 5E 4>?@ J>3H4A7 @HAJ?E?J3DDF E5J6@A@ 5G 364>57?4F 3@ ?4 >3@

SAAG I?@J6@@AI ?G KAGA73D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 4>A57FO 3GI J5GJD6IA@ C?4> 3 J3DD E57 E674>A7

IAJ5G@476J4?5G 5E 4>A 3J463D H75JA@@A@ 3GI QAJ>3G?@Q@ 4>34 J5G@4?464A 364>57?4F ?G

37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA@R

A>=>A ,-./01234-9 #2.50/4.: 6-1 .57 Q03468 !0-D./23.40- 0< ?-0@87197

%>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ S3@AI 5G 4>A H7AQ?@A 4>34 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@ 37A @5J?3DDF J5G@476J4AI

1VFD?A )\a\=R V>?DA 4>?@ Q?K>4 @AAQ 45 SA 3G 5SP?56@ @434AQAG4X@?GJA 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@

37A JDA37DF H75I6JAI SF HA5HDA ?G 4>A H7A@AG4 C>5 @46IF Q34A7?3D J6D467A 4>34 C3@ 3D@5

H75I6JAI SF HA5HDA ?G 4>A H3@4X4>A7A ?@O >5CAPA7O 3 KAGA73D I?J46Q 4>34 @5QA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A

H3@4 37A Q57A 7?K>4 57 Q57A J577AJ4 4>3G 54>A7@R -A@H?4A C3PA@ 5E H5@4Q5IA7G?@Q 4>56K>4Oe

C?4> 37K6QAG4@ 456J>?GK 5G 7AD34?P?@Q 3GI J5G@476J4?P?@Q 4>34 >A3P?DF ?QH3J4AI 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

4>A57F 1@AA 23QHA4A7 #7J>3A5D5K?J3D V57B@>5H )\\]=O 4>A7A ?@ @4?DD 3 @475GK 3@@6QH4?5G ?G 4>A

E?ADI 5E 37J>3A5D5KF 4>34 3 E57Q 5E T4764>U 3S564 C>34 >3HHAGAI ?G 4>A H3@4 ?@ T564 4>A7AU C3?4?GK

45 SA 5SYAJ4?PADF I?@J5PA7AIR %>?@ 3@@6QH4?5G ?@ P?@?SDA ?G >5C 4>A I?@J?HD?GA ?@ @476J467AI 3GI

57IA7AIO 3GI ?G >5C 37J>3A5D5K?@4@ 3HH753J> 3GI ?G4A7H7A4 4>A H3@4R ,GA 5E 4>A Q5@4

E6GI3QAG43D 4AGA4@ 5E G34673D @J?AGJA ?@ 4>A ?IA3 4>34 G3467A ?@ J5G@43G4O 3GI 4>34 @J?AG4?@4@ J3G

J7A34A TE3J4@U 4>756K> 4>A 3J4@ 5E I?@J5PA7FO 5S@A7P34?5G 3GI 3G3DF@?@ 5E 5SYAJ4?PA I343R -343O ?G

4>?@ @AG@AO ?@ HA7JA?PAI 45 SA DAK?4?Q34A Q34A7?3D E75Q 4>A G34673D C57DIO ?GIAHAGIAG4 5E 3GF

@5J?3D >?A737J>F 57 3GF @5J?5d57K3G?g34?5G3D E57Q 5E 364>57?4F 1f37B@ 899\=R #7J>3A5D5K?@4@O

E75Q 4>A ?GJAH4?5G 5E 37J>3A5D5KF 3@ 3 H75EA@@?5G3D I?@J?HD?GAO >3PA C57BAI 6GIA7 4>?@ H7AQ?@AO

E?GI?GK >6Q3GdQ3IA 5SYAJ4@ 3@ 3G 3@475G5QA7 C56DI E?GI GAC @437@ ?G 4>A G?K>4 @BF7 3GI

?G4A7H7A4?GK J6D467A 3GI >6Q3G SA>3P?567@ S3@AI 5G 4>A ?IA3 5E I?@J5PA7FO 5S@A7P34?5G 3GI

3G3DF@?@R %>A Q5@4 G543SDA J>3GKA 5E 4>56K>4 3EEAJ4?GK 4>?@ H75JA@@ ?G 37J>3A5D5KFX5JJ677?GK

C?4> 4>A H5@4H75JA@@63D 4>A57?A@ 5E TQ6D4?P5J3D?4FU 3GI T7AEDAM?P?4FU 1n5>G@5G )\\\^ "5IIA7

3See Section 2.3.2.


24/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

13

8999^ "5D475E 3GI [37D@@5G 8999^ "5IIA7 899)^ "5IIA7 899e^ "5IIA7 899a=X>3@ 7A@6D4AI ?G 3

Q6J> Q57A J5QHD?J34AI C3F 4>34 37J>3A5D5K?@4@ D55B 34 3GI 6GIA7@43GI 37J>3A5D5K?J3D

?G4A7H7A434?5G@O APAG ?E 4>A S3@?J 5SYAJ4?P?4Fd57?AG4AI QA4>5I@ ?G 37J>3A5D5KF >3PA J>3GKAI

PA7F D?44DAR

-A@H?4A 4>A E3J4 4>34 4>A PA7F G54?5G 5E 5SYAJ4?P?4F >3@ SAAG IAJ5G@476J4AI 3GI

E73KQAG4AI ?G 7AJAG4 FA37@ SF H5@4H75JA@@63D 4>A57FO 7A@6D4?GK ?G 3 GAC 6GIA7@43GI?GK 5E 4>A

H3@4 3@ 3 J5QHDAMO >A7QAGA64?J3D 3GI ?G4A7H7A4?PA @H3JAO Q5@4 3J463D 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H73J4?JA

45I3F @4?DD C57B@ 6GIA7 4>A 5PA737J>?GK QA4>5I@ 5E I?@J5PA7F 3GI 5S@A7P34?5GO 3G3DF@?@ 3GI

TH75I6J?GK 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4UR %>A 3J4 5E AMJ3P34?GK 3GI H6SD?@>?GK TE56GI I343U @4?DD 7AQ3?G@

?G43J4 3@ 4>A S3@?J C3F 4>A I?@J?HD?GA 5HA734A@R *G 4>A E?ADIO CA @4?DD 43DB 5E TE?GI?GK@U 3GI TI343UO

T5S@A7P34?5G@U 3GI T3G3DF@A@UR %>A ?G4A7H7A4AI H3@4O C>?J> AQA7KA@ E75Q 4>?@ H75JA@@O ?@ 4>AG

H7A@AG4AI 45 54>A7 3J3IAQ?J@ 3GI 45 4>A H6SD?J ?G 4>A E57Q 5E H6SD?J34?5G@O Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@O7AJ5G@476J4?5G@O 3GI ?G E576Q@ @6J> 3@ J5GEA7AGJA@ 3GI @AQ?G37@R Z6J> E57Q3D 7AH7A@AG434?5G@

5E 4>A H3@4 7ADF >A3P?DF 5G 3G 6GIA7DF?GK G54?5G 5E 4>A T364>57?434?PA 3JJ56G4UR %>A AG4?7A H75JA@@

5E 7AJ5G@476J4?GK 4>A H3@4 ?G 37J>3A5D5KF ?@ IAHAGIAG4 5G ?GI?P?I63D@ 3GI ?G@4?464?5G@ AM?@4?GK

3@ 364>57?4?A@O C>5 A?4>A7 3J4?PADF 57 H3@@?PADF ?QHDF 4>34 374AE3J4@O @?4A@ 3GI E?G3D

?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 37A T364>AG4?JU 57 >3PA TE?IAD?4FU 45 4>A H3@4R

%>A 3@@6QH4?5G 4>34 @5QA DAPAD 5E 5SYAJ4?P?4F 57 J577AJ4GA@@ J3G SA 7A3J>AI 4>756K> 4>A

H75JA@@ 5E @J?AG4?E?J 37J>3A5D5KF ?@ HA7>3H@ Q5@4 P?@?SDA ?G 4>A 364>57?434?PA @4346@ 5E ?GI?P?I63D

37J>3A5D5K?@4@O 5E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D ?G@4?464?5G@ D?BA 4>A 6G?PA7@?4F 3GI 4>A Q6@A6QO 3GI Q5@4?QH5743G4DFO ?G 4>A 364>57?4F 5E ?GI?P?I63D ?G4A7H7A434?5G@Rb #64>57?4FO C>?DA 5E4AG 4?AI ?G45 3

JD3?Q 5E J577AJ4GA@@ 57 364>AG4?J?4FO 3D@5 3HHA37@ 45 SA AN63DDF 4?AI ?G45 4>A DAPAD 5E H6SD?J

3JJAH43GJA 5E 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4R %>A @6JJA@@ 5E 3G 3JJ56G4 5E 4>A H3@4 J3G 5E4AG SA 4?AI 45 4>A

@5J?5dH5D?4?J3D GAAI@ 57 IA@?7A@ 5E 3 @5J?3D J5QQ6G?4FO 57 ?G 4>A H7A@4?KA 57 H5CA7 5E 3

J>37?@Q34?J ?GI?P?I63DR %>A J3@A 5E H@A6I537J>3A5D5KF ?G k?@5B5O c5@G?3 ?@ 3 H7?Q37F AM3QHDA 5E

>5C 4>A 364>57?434?PA @4346@ 5E 3G 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4 ?@ 4?AI ?G45 HA7E57Q34?PA SA>3P?567@O

@5J?5dH5D?4?J3D GAAI@ 3GI J>37?@Q34?J HA7@5G3D?4?A@R:

%>?@ J7A34A@ 3G ?G4A7A@4?GK H373I5M; ?E 37J>3A5D5K?J3D 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 37A

6GIA7@455I 45 SA @5J?3DDF J5G@476J4AIO 4>AG C>F 37A @5QA 3JJ56G4@ J5G@?IA7AI Q57A 7?K>4 4>3G

54>A7@L *E BG5CDAIKA ?@ 3 @5J?3DDF J7A34AI AG4A7H7?@A 1J5G@476J4AI SF HA5HDA C>5 J7A34A 3GI 6@A

BG5CDAIKA E57 4>A?7 5CG H67H5@A@ 3GI E57 J5G4AM463D 7A3@5G@=O 4>AG C>F ?@ 4>A7A 3 KAGA73D

@AG@A 4>34 @5QA 3JJ56G4@X?G 4>A E57Q 5E Q6@A6Q I?@HD3F@O H6SD?J34?5G@ 57 QAI?3X7AH7A@AG4 3

Q57A 364>57?434?PA E57Q 5E T4764>U 57 3G T364>AG4?JU H3@4L * 37K6A 4>34 4>A Q3?G ?GK7AI?AG4

4

W75Q 4>A HA7@HAJ4?PA 5E @5J?3D J5G@476J4?P?@QO ?GI?P?I63D @434AQAG4@ 5E ?G4A7H7A434?5G 3GI 5SYAJ4@ 5EJ7A34?5G D?BA ?Q3KA@O 5GJA KAGA734AI SF 37J>3A5D5K?@4@O J3G 4>AQ@ADPA@ SA ?QS6AI C?4> 364>57?4FR5See Chapter Five.


25/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

14

@6@43?G?GK @5QA 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4 3@ J577AJ4X4>34 H75HAD 54>A7 3JJ56G4@ 45 4>A H5H6D37 E57AO

4>34 J5GIAQG APAG 54>A7@ 45 3 @AG4AGJA 5E @6IIAG IA34> 57 3 N6?A4 7A4?7AQAG4 I6A 45

6GH5H6D37?4FX?@ ,94+%1'4*R V>34 ?@ 364>57?4FL "5C 3GI C>F ?@ ?4 AQSAIIAI ?G 4>A

37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@L V>34 Q3BA@ @5QA HA5HDA 364>57?4?A@ 5G 4>A H3@4 3GI 54>A7@ G54O 3GI

C>34 Q3BA@ @5QA 3JJ56G4@ 3GI ?G4A7H7A434?5G@ Q57A 364>57?434?PA 4>3G 54>A7@L %>A@A

N6A@4?5G@ 3D@5 73?@A ?QH5743G4 A4>?J3D J5GJA7G@; >5C ?@ 364>57?4F J5GGAJ4AI 45 JD3?Q@ 5E

364>AG4?J?4F 3GI J577AJ4GA@@O 45 4>A J5GJAH4@ 5E 476@4 3GI C?4GA@@?GKO 45 3 Q573D?4F 5E C>34 ?@

7?K>4 3GI C75GK 3S564 @HA3B?GK E57 HA5HDA C>5 37A D5GK IA3IL %>A H3@4 ?@ ?G Q3GF C3F@ 3

Q3DDA3SDA 3GI 6GBG5C3SDA 4>?GKX@5O C>5 >3@ 4>A 364>57?4F 45 @HA3B 3S564 4>A H3@4O 3GI C>5

I5A@ G54L ,G 4>A 54>A7 @?IA 5E 4>A J5?GO >5C 3GI C>F I5 @5QA HA5HDA >3PA 4>A 364>57?4F 45

@?DAGJA 3D4A7G34?PAO DA@@ 364>57?434?PA P?AC@L "5C 3GI C>F @>56DI @5QA HA5HDA SA K73G4AI

3JJA@@ 45 3 G5Gd7AGAC3SDA 7A@567JAX37J>3A5D5K?J3D Q34A7?3DX45 ?G4A7H7A4 ?4 3@ 4>AF HDA3@AOC>?DA 54>A7@ @>56DI G54L .D4?Q34ADFO 4>?@ 4>A@?@ ?@ ?G4A7A@4AI ?G N6A@4?5G?GK; C>34 ?@

37J>3A5D5K?J3D 364>57?4FL "5C I5A@ 364>57?4F Q3G?EA@4 ?G 4>A 37J>3A5D5K?J3D H75JA@@ 3GI 3EEAJ4

4>A 3JJAH43GJA 5E 3JJ56G4@ 5E 4>A H3@4L #GI C>34 I5A@ 364>57?4F QA3G 45 4>A I?@J?HD?GAL

A>A B7


26/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

15

!7?4?J3DDF >A7AO c37GA@ @?GKDA@ 564 @5QA 5E 4>A Q57A ?QH5743G4 H5?G4@ 3S564 4>A 7AD34?5G@>?H 5E

364>57?4F 45 4>34 5E TH5CA7UR c37GA@ 7AD3F@ 4C5 I?EEA7AG4 P?AC@; 5G 4>A 5GA >3GIO 364>57?4F ?@

Q5@4 473I?4?5G3DDF 7AH7A@AG4AI 3@ 3 TDAK?4?Q34AU E57Q 5E H5CA7 4>34 Q6@4 7ADF 5G J5G@AG4 57

?G@4?464?5G3D?@34?5G ?G 57IA7 45 AM?@4^ 364>57?4F ?@ 3 J3H3J?4F 4>34 ?@ 5GDF 5HA734AI 57 AG3J4AI C?4>

4>A AMA74?5G 5E H5CA7R #D4A7G34?PADFO c37GA@ 37K6A@ 4>34 364>57?4F J3GX3GI @>56DIXSA @AAG 3@

3 H3@@?PA H5CA7 ?G ?4@ 5CG 7?K>4O @5QA4>?GK 4>34 ?@ DA@@ E57JAE6D 57 AMHAI?AG4 4>3G @473?K>4d6H

H5CA7O @5QA4>?GK 4>34 K?PA@ 3 HA7@5G H3@@?PA 7?K>4@ 45 3J4 C?4>564 I?@J7A4?5GO C>?J> Q3F 57

Q3F G54 473G@D34A ?G45 H5CA7R

%5 JD37?EF 4>A D344A7 H5?G4O c37GA@ K?PA@ 4C5 AM3QHDA@R %>A E?7@4 ?@ 5E 3 Q5G37J> C>5

H5@@A@@A@ 4>A 364>57?4F 45 @?KG #J4@ 5E $37D?3QAG4 ?G45 D3CR %>?@ 364>57?4FO c37GA@ 37K6A@O I5A@

G54 3DC3F@ 7AH7A@AG4 H5CA7; 4>A o6AAG 5E &GKD3GI >3@ G5 H73J4?J3D H5CA7 45 3D4A7 57 C?4>>5DI

3@@AG4 45 Q5@4 D3C@ AG3J4AI ?G 4>A J56G47F 45I3FR %>6@O c37GA@ 37K6A@O 364>57?4F ?@I?@4?GK6?@>3SDA E75Q 3J4?PA H5CA7 3GI ?@ Q57A 5E 3 H3@@?PA H5CA7 57 7?K>4 1c37GA@ )\aA7 AM3QHDAO c37GA@ K?PA@ 4>A J3@A 5E 3G T364>57?4F 5GU #7?@454DAR %>?@ 364>57?4FO c37GA@

@3F@O ?@ AQH5CA7AI SF 3G ?GI?P?I63DU@ AM4AG@?PA BG5CDAIKA 5E #7?@454DAO C>5 IA7?PA@ >A7

@43GI?GK /C>5DDF 3GI AG4?7ADF E75Q >?@ @5J?A4F0O 7AGIA7?GK /3GF 3J463D J5GGAJ4?5G SA4CAAG 4>A

364>57?4F 3GI #7?@454DAO 57 #7?@454DAU@ 4AM4@pJ5G4?GKAG4O A@@AG4?3DDF 3JJ?IAG43D0 1c37GA@ )\a57?4FO 3@ ?4 ?G 73C H5CA7; /#G 364>57?4F 5G #7?@454DA ?@ 4>A H3@@?PA 3KAG4 5E #7?@454DAO 734>A7

3@ 4>A H5@@A@@57 5E 364>57?4F ?@ 4>A H3@@?PA 3KAG4 5E 3 H5CA7R +54A 4>34 CA >3PA 364>57?4?A@ 5G#7?@454DA ?G 3 C3F 4>34 CA J56DI G54 J5G4AQHD34A >3P?GK H5CA7@ 5PA7 #7?@454DA0 1c37GA@ )\a57?4F; 364>57?4F ?@ 3

Q57A @6S4DA Q344A7 5E 7?K>4O ?GED6AG4?3D J5G475D 3GI DAK?4?Q3JF^ H5CA7 ?@ 3 Q6J> Q57A J5GJ7A4A

Q344A7 5E 73C E57JAO AMAJ64?PA J5G475D 3GI 3J4?5G S3@AI 5G I?@J7A4?5G 57 Y6IKAQAG4R

V>34 c37GA@ @5QAC>34 GAKDAJ4@ ?G >?@ IAE?G?4?5GO >5CAPA7O ?@ 4>A E3J4 4>34 364>57?4F ?@

G54 3 IAJ5G4AM463D?@AI 57 H5@@A@@AI T4>?GKUO 3 H5?G4 C>?J> ?@ I?@J6@@AI ?G Q57A IA43?D ?G 4>A GAM4

@AJ4?5GR V>?DA 364>57?4F J3G SA I?@4?GK6?@>AI E75Q 73C AMAJ64?PA H5CA7O ?4 GAPA74>ADA@@ 7AD?A@

>A3P?DF 5G J5G4AM463D Q34A7?3D@ 3GI 3J457@ ?G 57IA7 45 AM?@4X364>57?4F ?@ @5QA4>?GK G54

3JJ?IAG43DO ?GJ?IAG43DO G57 @5QA4>?GK 4>34 AM?@4@ C?4>564 ?4@ ?G4A7IAHAGIAGJA 5G J5G4AM4@ 5E

DAK?4?Q34?5GR *4 ?@ H75SDAQ34?JO E57 ?G@43GJAO E57 c37GA@ 45 JD3?Q 4>34 T3G 364>57?4FU 5G #7?@454DA

>3@ 5GDF H3@@?PA H5CA7X364>57?434?PA HA5HDA Q3F >5DI H5@?4?5G@ ?G 3G ?G@4?464?5G D?BA 3

6G?PA7@?4FO E57 AM3QHDAO C>?J> K?PA@ 4>AQ JA743?G 7?K>4@O H7?P?DAKA@O 3JJA@@A@ 3GI 3J4?PA H5CA7@

4>34 @5QA5GA C>5 ?@ G54 3G 364>57?4F I5A@ G54 >3PAR %>?@ H5CA7O * C56DI 37K6AO ?@ H374 5E C>34

CA QA3G C>AG CA 6@A 4>A 4A7Q T364>57?4FUR V>34 c37GA@ J3DD@ T3JJ?IAG43DU 57 TJ5G4?GKAG4U E3J457@

37A 3J463DDF E6DDF AQSAIIAI ?G 4>?@ HA7@5GU@ TH5@@A@@?5GU 5E 364>57?4F 57 4>A HA7@5GU@ ?IAG4?4F 3@

3G 364>57?4F^ 4>A AMAJ64?PA 364>57?4F 5E 4>A 6G?PA7@?4F H75EA@@57 ?@ ?G4A74C?GAI ?G >?@ AH?@4AQ?J


27/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

16

364>57?4F 3@ 3G AMHA74 5G #7?@454DARA7AE57AO IA@H?4A 4>A E3J4 4>34 c37GA@ 5EEA7@ 6@AE6D

AM3QHDA@ 3GI I?@4?GJ4?5G@ SA4CAAG H5CA7 3GI 364>57?4FO >?@ G3775C IAE?G?4?5G 5E 364>57?4F 3@ 3

H3@@?PA H5CA7 @>56DI SA @6HHDAQAG4AI SF 3 P?AC 5E 364>57?4F 3@ 3G 3JJ5QHD?@>QAG4 57 AEEAJ4O

@47A@@?GK ?4@ ?G@AH373SDA D?GB C?4> Q5IA@ 5E DAK?4?Q34?5GO 3GI C?4> J5G@43G4 @5J?3D ?G4A73J4?5G@

3GI GAK54?34?5G@R

*4 ?@ ?QH5743G4 45 5EEA7 4>A I?@J6@@?5G 3S5PA 5G 4>A I?@4?GJ4?5G SA4CAAG TH5CA7U 3GI

T364>57?4FU SAJ36@A 4>AF 37A S54> 3S@473J4O >?K>DF ED6?I 3GI IAS343SDA J5GJAH4@O FA4 AGIDA@@DF

I?@J6@@AI ?G S54> 4>A 3J3IAQA 3GI 4>A C?IA7 H6SD?JR WAC 45H?J@ >3PA SAAG AGK3KAI 3@ Q6J> ?G

3J3IAQ?3O 34 DA3@4 ?GI?7AJ4DFO 3@ 4>34 5E 364>57?4F 3GI 3@FQQA47?J @5J?3D H5CA7 7AD34?5G@>?H@R

#64>57?4F 456J>A@ 3GI ?QH3J4@ 3 P3@4 73GKA 5E >6Q3G AMHA7?AGJAO S54> ?G 4>A H7A@AG4 3GI 4>A

H3@4R #@ 3 @5J?3D J5GJAH4O ?4 ?@ E37d7A3J>?GK 3GI 3S@473J4R VA @HA3B 5E 364>57?4FO ?G 364>57?4FO 5G

364>57?4FR %>?GK@ Q3F SA 364>57?434?PAO HA5HDA Q3F SA 364>57?434?PAO 4AM4@ Q3F SA 364>57?434?PAO3J4?5G@ 3GI @HAAJ> Q3F SA 364>57?434?PAO 3S@473J4?5G@ D?BA TBG5CDAIKAU Q3F SA 364>57?434?PAX

57 G54R #64>57?4F J3G >3PA Q34A7?3D 3GI H>F@?J3D J5G@AN6AGJA@R # IA@?7A E57 364>57?4F J3G DA3I

HA5HDA 45 AM47AQA@ 5E SA>3P?567 3GI 7?@BO 3GI 4>A D5@@ 5E ?4 J3G J36@A IA@H3?7O 3GKA7 57 K7?AER

*GI?P?I63D@ 57 J5DDAJ4?PA@ 37A 5E4AG I73CG 45 J>37?@Q34?J DA3IA7@ 3GI @5J?3D Q5PAQAG4@ ?G 4>A

>5HA 45 3443?G @5QA QA3@67A 5E 364>57?4F 57 SAGAE?4 E75Q 364>57?4FR Z46IAG4@ 3GI 3HH7AG4?JA@

DA37G E75Q 4>A 364>57?4F 5E 4>5@A C>5 4A3J> 4>AQO 3GI 364>57?4?A@ DA3I ?G4ADDAJ463D AGIA3P567@R

$A5HDA ?G @A37J> 5E 57 T?G H5@@A@@?5G 5EU 364>57?4F J3G 467G ?G45 H5CA7E6D J5G@6QA7@ 3GI

H75I6JA7@ 5E T364>57?434?PAU K55I@R *QH5743G4DFO 364>57?4F J3G 3D@5 SA Q?Q?JBAI 3GI HA7E57QAIO3GI HA5HDA 5E4AG Q3BA IAD?SA734A J>5?JA@ ?G >5C 45 HA7E57QO @AAB 564O 57 6GIA7Q?GA

364>57?434?PA HA5HDAO 4>?GK@ 57 BG5CDAIKAR]

B@B@A@B M1,3'4'%/,( H881%,&+.$ 4% C."'/'/) H94+%1'4*

%>A 4A7Q T364>57?4FUO Q6J> D?BA 4>A 7AD34AI 4A7Q TH5CA7UO >3@ SAAG /6@AIO 7Ad6@AIO 3GI

AGIDA@@DF 3S6@AI0 123C )\\); ) H5H6D37 3GI I?@J?HD?G37F I?@J567@A 5G @5J?3D H5CA7

7AD34?5G@; /_E`AC C57I@ >3PA K7A34A7 J677AGJF ?G 57K3G?g34?5G3D 4>A57F 3GI 57K3G?g34?5G3D D?EA

4>3G I5A@ 4>A 4A7Q 364>57?4FR Z4?DD 4>A J5GJAH4 5E 364>57?4F ?@ 3@ 5HAG 45 J5GED?J4?GK

?G4A7H7A434?5G@ 3@ 3GF0 1-3D45GO c37GA@ A4 3DR )\A 4A7Q ?@ I?EE?J6D4O @?GJA ?4

J3G 7AEA7 45 S54> 43GK?SDA 3J4@ 3GI 3J457@X@6J> 3@ HA7@5G@ C>5 Q3F SA T364>57?4?A@U 4>34

AMAJ64A 4>A?7 364>57?4F 4>756K> AMAJ64?PA E57JAX3@ CADD 3@ 3S@473J4 N63D?4?A@ 3GI 43J?4

3@@6QH4?5G@X@6J> 3@ 4>A T364>57?4FU 43J?4DF H5@@A@@AI SF 3 HA7@5G C>5@A 5H?G?5G >5DI@

?GED6AGJA 5PA7 54>A7@R #64>57?4F 473G@JAGI@ G57Q3D QA45GFQF 1?RARO F56 J3G SA T3G 364>57?4FU

6See Section 2.2.2 for further discussion on the terms executive authority and epistemic authority.]%>A@A J5GJAH4@ 37A 6GH3JBAI ?G IA43?D ?G !>3H4A7 W?PA 3GI !>3H4A7 Z?MR


28/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

17

3GI F56 J3G T>3PA 364>57?4FUO 3GI ?G S54> J3@A@ T364>57?4FU ?@ G54 Y6@4 3 H374 @43GI?GK ?G E57 3

C>5DA=^ ?G@4A3IO 364>57?4F 7AEA7AGJA@ 43J?4 @5J?3D 7AD34?5G@ 3@ CADD 3@ 43GK?SDA 564J5QA@ 3GI

AMAJ64?PA QA3@67A@ 6H5G C>?J> HA5HDA 3GI 4>?GK@ 7A3J4 3GI ?G4A73J4R %>A J5GJAH4 ?@ 476DF

7AD34?PAO S3@AI 5G @5J?3D 7AD34?5G@ 3GI 3@FQQA47?J H5CA7O 5E4AG IAAHDF AG43GKDAI C?4> 54>A7

J5GJAH4@X@6J> 3@ H5CA7O ?GED6AGJAO J5A7J?5GO HA7@63@?5GO 364>AG4?J?4FO 3JJ673JF 3GI

DAK?4?Q34?5GX@5 Q6J> 4>34 A3J> 4A7Q EAAI@ ?G45 A3J>O 3GI 3GF 7A3D?@4?J IAE?G?4?5G Q6@4 7ADF

>A3P?DF 5G Q6D4?HDA 54>A7 J5GJAH4@ ?G 57IA7 45 AM?@4 ?G QA3G?GK 5G ?4@ 5CGR $A7>3H@ ?4 ?@ SAJ36@A

364>57?4F ?@ @AAQ?GKDF 5SP?56@O FA4 @4?DD 3QS?K656@O 4>34 4>A 4A7Q >3@ SAAG 6@AI @5 H75D?E?J3DDF ?G

3J3IAQ?J 7A@A37J> C?4>564 3GF @?KG?E?J3G4 IAJ5G@476J4?5G 5E C>34 4>A 4A7Q 3J463DDF QA3G@

3J75@@ I?@J?HD?GA@O 57 34 4>A PA7F DA3@4O 564@?IA 5E 4>A G3775C @J5HA 5E 3 @?GKDA D?4A737F

I?@J6@@?5GR &PAG C?4>?G I?@J?HD?G37F S56GI37?A@ 4>A 4A7Q 5E4AG 7AQ3?G@ 3S@473J4R *4 ?@ HA7>3H@

G54 @67H7?@?GK 4>34 /_A`PA7F EAC FA37@ 3 C7?4A7 C?DD 76AE6DDF 3K7AA C?4> A37D?A7 C7?4A7@ 4>34364>57?4F 7AQ3?G@ 3 I?EE?J6D4 J5GJAH4 5G C>?J> 45 A@43SD?@> 3GF 3K7AAQAG4 ?G 4A7Q@0 1-3D45GO

c37GA@ A4 3DR )\57?4F >3@ 5E4AG SAAG

I?@J6@@AI ?G 4A7Q@ 5E >6Q3G H54AG4?3D E57 @5J?3D H5CA7 3GI J5G475DO 3II7A@@?GK C>F 3 HA7@5GO

H374F 57 @5J?3D K756H ?@ I5Q?G3G4 5PA7 57 7A@?@43G4 45C37I@ 3G54>A7 1-3D45GO c37GA@ A4 3DR )\57?4F >3@ SAAG H7?Q37?DF ?G4A7A@4AI ?G

J36@Ad3GIdAEEAJ4 H>F@?J3D 564J5QA@ 5E 364>57?4F 3GI @5J?3D 7AD34?5G@>?H@X@AAB?GK 3G@CA7@ 45

N6A@4?5G@ @6J> 3@; C>F C3@ "?4DA7 3SDA 45 J5QQ3GI @5 Q6J> T364>57?4FU 5PA7 >?@ @6SYAJ4@1f?DK73Q )\]b; bea^ $344AG )\]]=O 57 C>F I5 @5QA S6@?GA@@A@ 3GI 57K3G?@34?5G@ @AAQ 45 4>7?PA

C>AG >A3IAI SF 3 J>37?@Q34?J 364>57?434?PA E?K67AL 1ZQ?4> 899\=R %>?@ 4FHA 5E 364>57?4F ?@

I?7AJ4 3GI @HAJ?E?JO D?GBAI PA7F Q6J> 45 3J4?5G 3GI HA5HDA C?4> H5CA7 ?G @5J?3D >?A737J>?A@X

TAMAJ64?PAU ?G G3467ARa

f5@4 473I?4?5G3D @5J?5D5K?J3D D?4A73467A 5G 364>57?4F ?@ ?G4A7A@4AI ?G H5CA7 7AD34?5G@ ?G

4>A T@5J?3D 57IA7UO >5C H5CA7 3GI 364>57?4F 37A @6@43?GAI 57 7A@?@4AI 5PA7 4?QA SF P37?56@ @5J?3D

J5QQ6G?4?A@ 57 ?IA5D5K?A@R %>AF 3@B N6A@4?5G@ @6J> 3@O >5C I5 J5QQ6G?4?A@ Q3?G43?G 57

J5DD3H@A 57IA7@ 5E 364>57?4FO H5CA7 3GI 7A@?@43GJAL [37D f37M 3GI f3M VASA7U@ C57BO E57

AM3QHDAO S54> 7AD34A 364>57?4F @HAJ?E?J3DDF 45 AJ5G5Q?J@O H5CA7 3GI 7AP5D4^ 4>AF 7AK37I

AMAJ64?PA J5G475D 3GI I5Q?G34?5G 5E JA743?G QAQSA7@ 57 K756H@O ?G P37?56@ @J3DA@ 5E @5J?3D

J5QQ6G?4?A@ 1f37M )aaa^ VASA7 )\7AA @5J?5D5K?J3D J34AK57?A@ 5E

364>57?4F ?G @5J?A4FO @HAJ?E?J3DDF 7AD34?GK 4>A J5GJAH4 5E T364>57?4FU C?4> 4>34 5E TDAK?4?Q34?5GUO 3

4A7Q C>?J> ?QHD?A@ 4>A H5CA7 45 ?GED6AGJA 54>A7@ 4>756K> 4>A E57JA PA@4AI ?G 5GAU@ ?G@4?464?5G3D

H5@?4?5G 57 ADAP34AI @4346@ 1,&- )\a\=R *G >?@ C57BO VASA7 IAE?GA@ 364>57?4F 3@ 3 4FHA 5E

8See Section 2.2.2.2 for further discussion on executive authority.


29/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

18

TDAK?4?Q34A H5CA7U 3@ 5HH5@AI 45 ?DDAK?4?Q34A E57JAO\3GI >?@ 4FH5D5KF 5E 364>57?4?A@ 37A K756HAI

?G45 4>7AA J34AK57?A@R *G 4>A E?7@4O !>37?@Q34?J #64>57?4FO 364>57?434?PA H5CA7 5HA734A@ 4>756K>

HA7@5G3D DA3IA7@>?H 3GI 473G@E57Q34?5G3D H75Q?@A^ ?G 4>A @AJ5GIO %73I?4?5G3D #64>57?4FO

364>57?434?PA H5CA7 ?@ PA@4AI ?G 3 @AG@A 5E E?IAD?4F 45 3G A@43SD?@>AI 473I?4?5GO @4346@ 57 5JJ6H?AI

H5@?4?5G^ 3GI ?G 4>A 4>?7IO 2AK3Dd'34?5G3D #64>57?4FO 364>57?434?PA H5CA7 5HA734A@ ?G 5SAI?AGJA

45 S67A36J73JFO 76DA@ 3GI D3C 1VASA7 )\]a=R %>A@A J34AK57?A@O C>?DA @5QAC>34 37S?4737FO E57Q

3 6@AE6D E73QAC57B 45 SAK?G 4>?GB?GK 3S564 >5C 364>57?4F 5HA734A@ ?G @5J?3D K756H@^ 4>AF 5EEA7 3

DAG@ E75Q C>?J> 3 7A@A37J>A7 J3G SAK?G 45 6GIA7@43GI 4>A @5J?3D 5HA734?5G 3GI ?QH3J4 5E

364>57?4F E75Q 4>A Q5@4 ?GI?P?I63D 3GI HA7@5G3D DAPADX!>37?@Q34?JX45 4>A Q5@4 J5QQ6G3DO

@476J467AI 3GI J5QHDAMX2AK3Dd'34?5G3DR f3GF D34A7 @46I?A@ 5G 364>57?4F ?G Q3G3KAQAG4O

H5D?4?J@ 3GI @5J?5D5KF 5E4AG SAK?G 4>A?7 4>A@A@ C?4> 3 G5I ?G 4>A I?7AJ4?5G 5E VASA7U@ A37DF C57BR

-AE?G?4?5G@ 3GI I?@J6@@?5G 5E 364>57?4F >3PA 3D@5 3HHA37AI ?G 4>A E?ADI@ 5E AI6J34?5GOH>?D5@5H>F 3GI H@FJ>5D5KFO ?G 3II?4?5G 45 4>?@ A37D?A7 ?G4A7A@4 SF H5D?4?J3D @J?AG4?@4@ 3GI

@5J?5D5K?@4@ D?BA VASA7^ >5CAPA7O 3 I?EEA7AG4 D3GK63KA @A4 ?@ 5E4AG 6@AIR T#64>57?4FU >3@ SAAG

E7AN6AG4DF I?P?IAI SF 4A7Q?G5D5K?A@ D?BA TAMAJ64?PAU 3GI TAH?@4AQ?JU 1[76KD3G@B? )\a\^ 2?GJ5DG

)\\b^ $?A7@5G )\\b=O C>?J> >?K>D?K>4 4>A I?EEA7AGJA SA4CAAG 3J4?5GdS3@AI 364>57?4F 3GI

BG5CDAIKAdS3@AI 364>57?4FR *G D?4A737F J7?4?J?@QO H@FJ>5D5KF 3GI I?@J567@A 3G3DF@?@ 7A@A37J>O

364>57?4F ?@ 5E4AG 7AEA7AGJAI ?G 4A7Q@ 5E SA?GK TPA74?J3DU 3GI T>57?g5G43DUO C>A7A TPA74?J3DU

364>57?4F ?IAG4?E?A@ H5CA7 7AD34?5G@ 4>34 37A Q57A @476J4673D 3GI ?G@4?464?5G3DDF S3@AIO 3GI

T>57?g5G43DU 7AEA7AGJA@ 3 Q57A IFG3Q?J HD3GA 5E @5J?3D 7AD34?5G@O C>A7A 364>57?434?PA H5CA7 ?@AQA7KAG4 3GI 3J4?PADF A@43SD?@>AI SA4CAAG ?GI?P?I63D@ 123GI@SA7KA7 )\34O 3DC3F@O 4>A@A J34AK57?A@ 37A 37S?4737F 3GI H54AG4?3DDF 76G 4>A 7?@B 5E

5PA7@?QHD?E?J34?5G 57 Q?@7AH7A@AG434?5GR # @46IF 5E 4>A PA7F I?EEA7AG4 I?P?@?5G@ 5E D3GK63KA 3GI

J34AK57?J3D 6@A 5E 4>A J5GJAH4 T364>57?4FU C?4>?G 3GI 3J75@@ I?@J?HD?GA@ ?@ Q6J> GAAIAI ?G E6467A

7A@A37J> 3GI 7AH7A@AG4@ 3 C574>C>?DA E6467A @46IF^ >5CAPA7O 3 J5QH7A>AG@?PA @46IF 5G 4>?@

45H?J ?@ SAF5GI 4>A @J5HA 5E 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GR *G@4A3IO * @?QHDF G54A 4>A@A Q3GF 5PA7D3HH?GK 3GI

5E4AG J5G473I?J457F 4A7Q?G5D5K?A@O 3GI * C?DD 5EEA7 5GDF 3 @HAJ?E?J J>5?JA 5E 4A7Q?G5D5K?A@ ?G 4>A

GAM4 @AJ4?5GXE56GIAI 5G @5QA 5E 4>A Q57A H7AP3DAG4 3GI J677AG4DF H5H6D37 4A7Q?G5D5K?A@

E75Q H5D?4?J3D @J?AGJA 3GI H@FJ>5D5KFXE57 4>A A3@A 5E E6467A I?@J6@@?5G ?G 4>?@ I?@@A7434?5GR

9See Section 2.2.2.2 for further discussion on legitimate authorityand de facto authority.


30/303

!"#$%&' 8 !,+!&$%Z #+- %"&,'m

19

A>A>A !6.79

t pruitt digital thesis

Documents