swimming pools 2013 appendix 2 servicing the building
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
1/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
April Revision 004 1 Sport England 2013
DesignGuidance Note
Creating a sporting habit for life
SwimmingPoolsUpdated Guidance for 2013
Appendix 2Servicing the building
(To be read in conjunction with the main document)
May Revision 004 Sport England 2013
Energy implications
Energy usage in swimming
pool buildings
Water efficiency
Pool water quality Disinfection
Chemical dosing
Water softness
Filtration systems
Turnover rates
Water temperature
Air temperature and humidity
Electrical services Size of plant rooms
Plant room spaces
Air distribution systems
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
2/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 1 Sport England 2013
Servicing the building
A safe, comfortable and attractive internalenvironment is essential in order to attract andsustain high levels of use. Good conditions arealso required for the lifeguards, teachers andspectators as well as achieving a reasonable lifeexpectancy from the building1.
The engineering challenge in achieving thefunctional requirements in a sustainable manner issubstantial2. For example:
Large volumes of swimming pool water needto be kept warm and continually treated todeal with the pollution from bathers
Air temperature, moisture content and airquality in the pool hall need to be carefullycontrolled
Potentially corrosive atmosphere needs to becontained and controlled in the appropriateareas
Internal acoustic conditions and noisebreakout to surrounding areas need to bemoderated.
It has been estimated3that the building servicesinstallation can account for between 30 and 50%of the capital costs of a modern pool.
The operational sustainability is therefore criticaland the full pattern of use, operation andmaintenance regimes of the swimming pool shouldbe allowed for within the services design. Theoperators requirements should be obtained at anearly stage in the design process.
Energy implications
Swimming pools use high levels of energy. It isimperative that the building footprint is minimisedat the design stage and internal volumes carefullymodulated to give an appropriate feeling of spaceand airiness. The building fabric should also bewell-insulated and effectively sealed from theoutside environment and any adjoining buildingelements.
Energy usage in swimming pool buildings
At the initial planning stages careful consideration
should be given to the energy and servicingstrategy for the building 4. It is important to agreean energy strategy early in the process as it couldimpact on the orientation, form and externalappearance of the building. A range of energysaving measures can be implemented that willreduce consumption. In deciding which is the most
The plant requirementscan be considered in thefollowing groups:
Incoming services: Water,electricity, gas and meters
Pool water treatmentsystem: Water filter(s)circulation pumps andpipework, chemical dosingequipments and backwashdisposal
Foul water disposal/drainage
Heating system: To heat
the pool water, areas of thebuilding and domesticwater supply includingstorage vessels andpressurisation systems
Energy/resource recoveryequipment: Heatexchangers, CHP plant,water re-use
Air-handling plant: Heatingand conditioning the pool
hall air and associatedspaces
Electrical distributionequipment
Water storage
Movable floor and/orbulkhead systems.
1The HSE publication HSG179Managing Health and Safety inSwimming Pools is a key reference.
2CIBSE Guide GPublic Health Engineering: Swimming pools.
3See Sports Council Guidance Note Swimming Pool - BuildingServices Nov 1994 and Sport Englands Affordable Community
Swimming Pools 2012.4The UK national planning system has recently been amendedto make sustainability its underlying principle (PPS1).
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
3/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 2 Sport England 2013
Table 1 Low/zero carbon techniques to consider
Be LEAN
Optimum orientation of the building and usageof glazing and/or solar shading to achieve:
Maximum benefit from natural light
Prevent glare
Optimum levels of solar gain withoutoverheating
Ancillary accommodation to the pool hall:
Natural ventilation
Night cooling
CO2or humidity detection to modulate fresh air
Pool cover / reduced ventilation
Enhanced thermal envelope and air permeability,
especially in the pool hall which is heated theyear round to 30C
Lighting:
High efficiency
Automatic controls
Direct lighting which is more efficient thanindirect lighting
Zoning of plant to specific areas to suit type andfrequency of use
Variable-speed drives on pumps and fans
Heat recuperation from extract air
Heat recovery from pool water / showers
Low water usage appliances
Power factor correction
Building and energy management systems
Pool water treatment plant:
Variable speed control of pumps to allow theturnover rate to be based on water quality
Altering UV output based on water quality
Use of appliances which have the highestavailable rating under the EU Energy EfficiencyLabelling Scheme
Be CLEAN
Combined heat and power (CHP): The yearround heat demand of pools makes them anideal application for CHP to be sized on theheat profile of the building to minimize heatbeing dumped
Use of energy sources beyond the siteboundaries such as district heating and/orcooling schemes for the wider use in the generalarea (which could include the use of CHP andabsorption cooling technologies).
Be GREEN
The use of on-site low/zero carbon technologies:
Photovoltaic panel
Wind turbines
Solar heating
Biomass heating
Air/ground source heat pumps
appropriate, whole-life costs, rather than initialcapital costs, should be considered and theminimum standards in the Building Regulationsshould be exceeded.
Energy usage in swimming pool buildings isgenerally high per square metre when comparedto other building types. The proportion of energynot controlled under the Building Regulation(unregulated energy) is also very high. For example,the electricity used for the pool water treatmentcould amount to 50% of the total electricityconsumption but is not controlled. It is important
that the energy strategy deals with all of the energyusage. Compliance with Part L alone could delivera building with unacceptable levels of energyconsumption.
The table below summarises low/zero carbontechniques to be considered when establishing theenergy strategy for a pool.
General power
5.5%
Space heating
53%
Water heating
25%
Fans and pumps
10%
Lighting 6.5%
Typical energy profile for a swimming pool building
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
4/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 3 Sport England 2013
Rainwater harvesting
Automated monitoring equipment for watermake-up
Grey water harvesting collecting water fromthe pool filtration system and showers to beused for WC flushing
Pool cover
Pool water quality
The quality of the pool water is of criticalimportance and will depend upon the design,
bather load and the ongoing operation. It is atechnically complex subject on which specificspecialist advice must be sought for eachparticular project. The Pool Water Treatment Group(PWTAG) publicationsSwimming Pool Water 2009and Code of Practice 2013are regarded as thestandard texts on the subject.
The selection of the most appropriate type of watertreatment system for a swimming pool will dependupon a number of factors:
Type and size of pool
Bather load
Characteristics of the source water supply
Pool operation and maintenance.
Comply with relevant localenergy policies:
e.g. the Energy Hierarchy within
the London Plan
Use less energy - be lean
Supply energy efficiently - be clean
Use renewable energy - be green
http://www.london.gov.uk/
Water efficiency
Swimming pools use large amounts of waterthrough the backwashing of filters, constant freshwater make-up (30 litres per swimmer), showersand cleaning. The reduction in water usage has anindirect benefit on energy consumption since lesswater is used, less water has to be heated andtransported using pump energy. The followingshould be considered:
Low water consumption taps and flushes fortoilets and urinals
Automatic shower controls
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
5/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 4 Sport England 2013
Table 2 Common disinfection measures
Pool type / bather load Conventional
disinfection
UV* O3*
Conventional / low6
Conventional / medium6 6
Leisure / high6 6
*Residual disinfection is required in addition to preventcross infection in the pool.
Disinfection
A conventional chlorine system has generallybeen considered to give an appropriate balance ofcapital costs, water and air quality, bather comfort,ease of control, maintenance and economy ofoperation. Sodium hypochlorite or calciumhypochlorite are commonly used to maintain afree chlorine level in the pool water to deal withthe pollution from bathers or other sources.Automatic control and dosing systems areregarded as essential to maintain safety, and giveobvious staffing and operational benefits.
However, water purification based on Ultra-Violet(UV) and to a lesser extent Ozone (O3) equipment
is commonly added into modern public poolinstallations. They both involve additionalequipment within the plant room areas, to treat thecirculating water and make subsequent disinfectioneasier. The benefits of such systems are:
Reduction in chlorine levels in the pool
Improved water quality particularly wherehigh bather load is expected
Improved air quality in the pool hall throughreduction in airborne chloramines associatedwith red eyes, sore throats aggravation ofasthma and bronchitis, particularly beneficial
to asthma sufferers, pool staff and long-termpool users.
However, such systems can add significantly tothe capital and running costs and can also requireincreased expertise from the operator.
There are particular safety and technical issueswith all water treatment systems, but as a generalguide, the use of purification systems are as setout in Table 2.
Chemical dosing
Chlorine is used in the pool water to kill bacteriaand prevent cross infections between bathers. Themost common chlorine donors are:
Sodium Hypochlorite (NaOCI)
Calcium Hypochlorite (Ca (OCI)2).
These individually produce free chlorine, achlorine compound for disinfection, and combinedchlorine, when free chlorine is combined withpollutants - the cause of the typical chlorine smellin swimming pools.
It is necessary to control the acidity (pH) balance
of the treated water. For example, dilutedhydrochloric acid (HCI) is added when sodiumhypochlorite is used.
Using other chemical treatments should bediscussed in detail with the water treatmentengineer. In particular, the use of SodiumBiSulphate (NaHSO4) should be avoided due to therisk of sulphate attack on cementitious grouts,renders and concrete. See the PWTAG publicationsfor more detail.
Pool water chemicals should always be dosed andmonitored by automatic equipment. Additionalmanual testing of water samples from the pool
should be undertaken regularly (at least twice aday) as an additional check on the system.
Water softness
The use of calcium hypochlorite is often preferredin areas of soft water since it is a calcium hardnessdonor to the pool. This will minimise the effects ofsoft water on cementitious materials used in thepool construction.
See the PWTAG publications for more more detailsand the appropriate design standards.
Ozone contact vessel and de-ozonising
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
6/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 5 Sport England 2013
Filtration systems
An effective filtration system is required to maintainthe clarity of the swimming pool water. For publicpools, sand filters are most commonly used. Inorder to maintain their effectiveness, these willneed to be backwashed regularly. This is achievedby reversing the flow through the sand beds andthen discharging the backwash water to a fouldrain.
The discharge to the drains is classified as tradeeffluent and the consent may place restrictions onthe timing, volume and/or flow rate discharge perday. Backwash tanks to hold the backwash watermay be required to allow a controlled discharge tothe foul drainage system.
The overall hydraulics of the system, the rating ofpumps and the position of inlet and outlet grills inthe pool tank need to be carefully designed toensure contaminants are effectively removed fromthe water. Deck level systems are most effective inremoving contaminants from the water surface.
To assist the filtration process, chemicals knownas flocculants are automatically added to the waterprior to it passing through the filters. Polyaluminium chloride is most commonly used and itforms a floc that helps trap fine particles,
microbes and pollutants in the water.
UV filtration system
Turnover rates
The time for the total volume of pool water tocirculate through the treatment plant and return tothe pool is known as the turnover rate. The perioddepends on the shape, size and use of the pooland should be considered early in the designprocess as part of the water treatment systemperformance requirements.
See the PWTAG 2009 publication and Code ofPractice 2013for more details and the appropriatedesign standards.
Typical filter installation
Pool TypeDepth(Metres)
Pool TurnoverRate (Hours)
Diving Varies 4.0 - 8.0
Swimming Varies 2.5 - 4.0
Learner/Teaching 0.5 - 1.5 0.5 - 1.5
Leisure 1.5 2.0 - 2.5
Table 3 Recommended turnover rates
The risk of contamination ofthe pool water can be
minimised through:
Careful design and locationof showers and toilets
Good housekeeping
Bather education.
(See Changing layouts in main
document Section 5.0 Developed
Design Considerations - Changingfacilities)
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
7/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 6 Sport England 2013
Pool 28-30C
Poolcalorifier
UV or ozonewater purification
Filters
Exhaust
Toilets
Changing rooms
Office
Pool hall
Fresh airsupply
Temperatureand humiditysensor
Temperatureand humiditysensor
Temperaturesensor
Disinfection
Office/changingair handling unit
Heatexchanger
Extract fan
Temperatureand humiditysensor
Temperatureand humiditysensor
Pool cover
Grey waterharvesting
Samplecell
Luminaires withdaylight control
Luminaires withdaylight control
Glazing
Radiators, pipe-coils and underfloor heating
Hydraulic circuit design to considercontrol valve arrangement toradiators, pipe coils or underfloorheating as may be appropriate
Weathercompensationvalve
Low and zerocarbon technology
LZC
Fresh airsupply
Exhaust
Heatexchanger
Extract fan
Low lossheader
Boilers
1c above watertemperature
Pool airhandling unit
Glazing
Ventilation system
Key
Filtration system
Heating system
Monitoring sensor
Differential pressureand control valves
Motorised volumecontrol damper
Heater battery
Pump Separate foul
drainage to
poolside
Schematic services diagram for a typical small pool
Sodium hypochlorite bulk and day tanks
Water temperature
Over the years there has been a steady trend toincrease water temperatures to increasecustomer satisfaction. This is demonstrated inthe latest update of the PWTAG publication(2009)6that quotes maximum temperatures forswimming pools that are 1-2 degrees higherthan the previous edition of 1999 (see Table 4below). However the energy usage implicationsshould be carefully considered and it should be
Pool types / uses
Previous / currentrecommended maximumpool water temperatures
PWTAG1999
PWTAG2009
Competitive swimming anddiving, fitness training
27C 28C
Recreational, adult teaching,conventional main pool
28C 29C
Leisure pools 29C 30C
Childrens swimming As above 31C
Babies, young children, disabled 30C 32C
Hydrotherapy 35C
Spa pools 40C
noted that the PWTAG 2009 document alsoadvises that operators may run their poolsatisfactorily at temperatures 1-2 degrees lowerthan the recommended maximum.
Higher water temperatures may be attractive torecreational swimmers, disability groups andchildren, but are likely to be less suitable for fitnessswimming or competition. Higher watertemperatures may also have an adverse impact onthe water treatment and environmental controlsystems. See notes on the PWTAG web site on theproblems associated with operators running poolsat higher temperatures.
Table 4 Updated PWTAG pool water temperaturerecommendations
6Swimming pool water treatment and quality standardsPoolWater Treatment Advisory Group (PWTAG 2009).
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
8/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 7 Sport England 2013
720C is recommended for ancillary areas. SeeHSE documentHSG179 Managing Health and Safety in Swimming Pools.
8IEE guide and HSE Electricity at work regulation1989.
Air temperatures and humidity
Pool hall
Temperature and humidity control is required in thepool hall to maintain comfortable conditions forbathers. Air temperatures are usually kept at onedegree above the pool water temperature tominimise evaporation, relative humidity and airvelocity values as follows:
Air temperature: approx 30C(assuming 29Cwater temperature)
Relative humidity: 60% 10%
Air velocity: Approx. 0.1 m/s in theoccupied areas of thepool hall
Min fresh air supply: 4-10 air changes / hour
There should be even distribution and extractionof warm air from the pool hall so there are nodraughts on the pool surrounds or in the shallowend where people may be standing up.
The above conditions assume that the mean radianttemperature is approximately equal to or slightlyhigher than the air temperature. The atmospheric
conditions within an enclosed space are neverhomogeneous and vary with time and location.They are particularly influenced by bather activity.
Care should be taken that moisture and smellsfrom the pool hall cannot pass to adjoining areas.Effective moisture vapour barriers are required andgaps should be sealed to avoid potential damageto the building elements, particularly whereservices and ducts pass through walls. A negativepressure difference between the pool hall andadjoining areas, such as changing areas, can beused to help contain the pool environment.
See PWTAG 2009 for the importance of the
ventilation system in removing airborne disinfectantby-products and contaminants from the pool halland ensuring an adequate distribution of fresh air.
Spectator area
Spectators in adjacent seating and viewing areaswill require a lower temperature created by anincreased fresh air supply as follows:
Air temperature: approx 25C7
Relative humidity: 60% 10%
Air velocity: approx 0.3 m/s
Min fresh air supply: 10 air changes/hour
However, where such additional air supply systemsare considered, care should be taken to avoidcooler air dropping into bather areas and causingdiscomfort.
Changing and clothes storage areas
The airflow should be evenly distributed anddesigned to remove smells, particularly in changingareas and toilet areas. There should be no draughtscaused by airflow. In order to provide comfortableconditions as people change and move back intothe public areas, the following conditions shouldbe provided:
Air temperature: approx 24-25 C
Min fresh air supply: 10 air changes / hour
This should be arranged as a separate systemfrom that for the main pool hall. Some additionalfresh air supply within the system could bebeneficial in vanity areas where people would bein their normal clothing.
Baby changing accommodation should haveseparate rates of ventilation.
Electrical services
Special care should be taken with electrical
services in view of the damp warm and corrosiveatmosphere 8. Mains voltage must not beaccessible within the pool hall.
Light fittings
For general lighting design issues, see MainDocument Section 5.0 Developed DesignConsiderations - Pool Hall - Artificial Lighting.
There are particular issues with underwaterlighting:
Size/type needs to suit the pool beingilluminated
Reliability
Expected lamp life / replacement cost
Ease of re-lamping
Water safety no fittings should exceed 20Voperating current / need for transformerslocated relatively close to each fitting.
Where movable floors are used, the underwater lightfittings will need to be flush with the pool wall.
Some underwater light fittings may also sufferfrom high temperatures at the glass lens, and inorder to avoid the risk of bather injury, the
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
9/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 8 Sport England 2013
9PWTAG / Sports Council Guidance Note: Swimming poolsBuilding Services.
operational temperature of the surface of the glassshould never become so hot as to be uncomfortableor dangerous.
Sizes of plant rooms
Plant rooms should be located in close proximity tothe areas they serve in order to reduce service runs,system losses, and minimise fan power. Theyshould also be sized to give good access to theequipment that they house and allow for operation,maintenance, replacement and deliveries.
Typically, the pool water treatment plant roomshould be between 15-30%9of the water area thatit serves.
An economical solution is to locate the air-handlingplant at high-level, providing there is adequateaccess. A rule of thumb to calculate the overallarea required is to allow approximately 15% of thepool building area.
Plant room spaces
The location, size and distribution of the plantwithin the building needs to be considered early inthe design process along with the operation andmaintenance factors.
The plant room spaces should:
Allow the plant and equipment to be installed,commissioned, operated and maintainedsafely and efficiently
Allow for service access and removal/replacement of all individual elementsincluding bulky items such as filters, whichmay require extra wide access doors orremovable panels
Minimise service runs, with water treatmentplant located close to the deep end of the pooltank
Locate pool water circulation pumps at thesame level as the bottom of the deepest waterso that they are continually flooded
Allow for the delivery and storage of chemicalsin a separate, ventilated area, ideally at groundfloor level. Include appropriate safetyarrangements such as bund walls for chemicalstorage tanks and dosing equipment andemergency drencher and eye wash facilities.The acid and chlorine stores will requireseparate ventilation system
Ensure adequate ventilation rates to all plantroom areas. If ozone treatment is used, providean automatic ozone detection alarm systemand consider the need for similar systems forchlorine and carbon dioxide
Ensure adequate floor drainage in the plantroom and provide a hosepipe point
Provide an accessible balance tank toaccommodate water displaced by bathers (fordeck level pools only). Access via a lateralaccess way from the plant room is preferredto manholes in the pool surround floor
Provide holding tanks if required for the maindrainage system to deal with the quantity offilter backwashing water (can be separate fromplant room)
Allow space for new technology such ashousings for underwater camera control panels
Provide adequate space for a workbench,desk and chair, tools, maintenance manualsand so on
Ensure flues, air intakes, ventilation and extractlouvers/cowls are positioned away from publicand residential areas
Ensure safe access to all plant/equipment
requiring regular inspection
Allow for control equipment and underwaterpool windows associated with computerassisted underwater pool supervision
Be connected to all emergency alarms.
Access to plant rooms
Access to the plant room should be available bothinternally, via a controlled access point, andexternally, via a delivery entrance. All doorsleading to the plant room must have secure lockingmechanisms fitted to prevent access by untrained
staff and members of the public.
If an external service yard is provided, the externalaccess should incorporate the provision of a steelshutter door system. The door should be fittedwith a high-security locking system and beconnected to the centres security alarm. The idealopening size is 3.0 m wide by 3.0 m high tofacilitate filter replacement. There should also bean additional side door for external access to theplant room, to reduce wear and tear on the steelshutter and the probability of it being left openduring a period of frequent use.
Doors in the plant room should be of a heavy-dutynature and have a minimum opening width of 1.0 m(1.5 m preferred).
-
7/25/2019 Swimming Pools 2013 Appendix 2 Servicing the Building
10/10
Swimming Pools DesignGuidance Note
May Revision 004 9 Sport England 2013
Air distribution systems in the pool hall
There is a marked move away from supplying airthrough overhead ducted systems to the use ofducts incorporated at low-level into the pool tankdesign. These systems either sit adjacent to thepool water overflow system or are set at low-levelaround the perimeter of the pool hall. If locatedunder glazed curtain walling, they have theadditional benefit of reducing the condensationthat can form on the windows.
Low-level systems need to be designed to preventingress of water due to flooding from the poolsurround or ground water. This can impact uponthe pool hall environment and result in damage to
the air handling plant. Integrating drainage systemsmay not resolve the problem as traps will inevitablydry out allowing the passage of foul air into thebuilding.
Overhead ducting is still specified in some pooldesigns and as with direct lighting units, it canprove difficult to avoid positioning directly overwater and maintenance becomes very problematic.
The ductwork fixings must be carefully selected asthere have been several cases of ducting sectionsfalling from height due to corrosion and subsequentfailure of the fixings studs etc. Regular inspectionof all ventilation ductwork and fixings must takeplace. This requires suitable access.