supplementary report for resettlement action plan...permanent land acquisition area has been...
TRANSCRIPT
New Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Supplementary Report for
Resettlement Action Plan
FCTIC, Ministry of Railways of PRC
May 2012
RP735 v3
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
2 / 328
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUMMARY ......................................................................................................................................... 6
1. OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................................ 12
1.1 WHY IS THIS SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT PREPARED ................................................. 12
1.2 ALTERATION TO PROJECT DESIGN ................................................................................. 13
1.3 MAIN CHANGES IN LAND ACQUISITION AND RESIDENT MIGRATION .................. 22
1.3.1 CHANGES IN COVERAGE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND HOUSE DEMOLITION 22
1.3.2 DETAILED ALTERATIONS TO LAND ACQUISITION & HOUSE DEMOLITION .... 26
1.3.3 PROGRESS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND ACQUISITION $ HOUSE
DEMOLITION .................................................................................................................................. 37
1.4 IDENTIFICATION OF COVERAGE OF SUPPLEMENTARY RESETTLEMENT PLAN . 38
1.4.1 PRINCIPLES OF IDENTIFICATION OF MATERIAL EFFECT OF LAND
ACQUISITION AND HOUSE DEMOLITION IN ALTERED PRELIMINARY DESIGN ............ 38
1.4.2 METHOD FOR IDENTIFYING MATERIALLY INVOLVED REGIONS ...................... 39
1.4.3 IDENTIFICATION OF MATERIALLY INVOLVED REGIONS..................................... 40
1.4.4 IMPLEMENTATION OF RESETTLEMENT IN MATERIALLY INVOLVED
DISTRICTS ....................................................................................................................................... 54
2. REVIEW OF IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND ACQUISITION & HOUSE DEMOLITION
58
2.1 IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND ACQUISITION & HOUSE DEMOLITION FOR THIS
PROJECT .......................................................................................................................................... 58
2.1.1 PROGRESS IN COMPENSATION FOR LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT
AND RECOVERY ............................................................................................................................ 58
2.1.2 PROGRESS IN RESETTLEMENT AND RECOVERY FOR RESIDENCE
DEMOLITION AND REMOVAL .................................................................................................... 69
2.1.3 PROGRESS IN COMPENSATION AND RESETTLEMENT FOR NON-RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING DEMOLITION AND REMOVAL ................................................................................ 79
2.1.4 EFFECT ON AND RECOVERY OF INFRASTRUCTURE .............................................. 81
2.1.5 HANDLING OF PUBLIC COMPLAINTS ........................................................................ 83
2.1.6 LAND ACQUISITION AND MIGRATION MANAGEMENT
EVALUATION:MANAGEMENT CAPACITY, SURVEILLANCE AND REPORTING .............. 85
2.1.7 COMPLIANCE WITH RAP AND RESULTS IN LAND ACQUISITION AND
MIGRATION .................................................................................................................................... 87
2.1.8 ISSUES TO BE HANDLED ............................................................................................... 88
2.2 DUE DILIGENCE CONCERNING THE SUPPLEMENT RESETTLEMENT PLAN .......... 90
2.2.1 SCOPE OF DUE DILIGENCE ........................................................................................... 90
2.2.2 METHODS FOR DUE DILIGENCE ................................................................................ 100
2.2.3 IMPLEMENTATION OF MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT .................................................... 100
3. SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY ............................................................................................ 110
3.1 SCOPE OF SUPPLEMENT RESETTLEMENT PLAN ........................................................ 110
3.2 GENERAL SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONDITIONS IN INVOLVED DISTRICTS ................. 110
3.2.1 BAIYUN DISTRICT, GUIYANG CITY .................................................................................... 110
3.2.2 RONGJIANG COUNTY, QIANGDONGNAN PREFECTURE ........................................................ 111
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
3 / 328
3.2.3 YANGSUO COUNTY, GUILIN CITY ...................................................................................... 112
3.2.4 LIWAN DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU CITY ..................................................................... 113
3.2.5 YUEXIU DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU CITY ................................................................... 114
3.3 SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY MODE ................................................................................ 115
3.4 FINDINGS ............................................................................................................................. 116
3.4.1 INVOLVED POPULATION ............................................................................................ 116
3.4.2 ECONOMIC CONDITION OF INVOLVED VILLAGES/COMMUNITIES .................. 121
3.4.3 OVERVIEW OF VULNERABLE GROUPS IN INVOLVED VILLAGES .................... 122
4. INFLUENCE OF LAND ACQUISITION & BUILDING DEMOLITION FOR THIS
PROJECT ........................................................................................................................................ 124
4.1 COVERAGE OF THE PROJECT ......................................................................................... 124
4.2 PHYSICAL INDICATORS OF INFLUENCE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND
MIGRATION .................................................................................................................................. 124
4.2.1 PERMANENT LAND ACQUISITION ....................................................................................... 124
4.2.2 TEMPORARILY USED LAND ................................................................................................ 124
4.2.3 BUILDING DEMOLITION ...................................................................................................... 125
4.2.4 VULNERABLE GROUPS ....................................................................................................... 125
5. MIGRATION POLICY FRAMEWORK ............................................................................... 130
5.1 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT GOAL .................................................................... 130
5.2 APPLICABLE LAWS AND POLICIES ............................................................................... 130
5.2.1 WORLD BANK'S NON-VOLUNTARY MIGRATION POLICY................................... 130
5.2.2 LAW AND POLICY FRAMEWORKS ............................................................................ 132
5.3 RELATED LAWS AND REGULATIONS ........................................................................... 134
6. COMPENSATION CRITERIA AND COMPENSATION BUDGET .................................. 148
6.1 COMPENSATION CRITERIA ............................................................................................. 148
6.1.1 COMPENSATION FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION ...................................................... 148
6.1.2 COMPENSATION FOR HOUSE DEMOLITION ......................................................................... 151
6.2 BUDGET ESTIMATE OF COMPENSATIONS FOR MIGRATION AND
RESETTLEMENT .......................................................................................................................... 154
7. MIGRATION & RESETTLEMENT AND LIVELIHOOD DEVELOPMENT .................... 156
7.1 GENERAL PRINCIPLES ...................................................................................................... 156
7.2 PRODUCTION/LIFE RECOVERY PLAN FOR INVOLVED VILLAGES ........................ 157
7.2.1 BLACK STONE VILLAGE, DULA TOWNSHIP, BAIYUN DISTRICT ....................... 157
7.2.2 DUXI VILLAGE, DULA TOWNSHIP, BAIYUN DISTRICT ........................................ 159
7.2.3 XIAOBAO VILLAGE, GUZHOU TOWN, RONGJIANG COUNTY ............................................... 160
7.2.4 YUEZAI VILLAGE, GUZHOU TOWN, RONGJIANG COUNTY .................................................. 161
7.2.5 KOUZAI VILLAGE, GUZHOU TOWN, RONGJIANG COUNTY ................................................. 162
7.2.6 SIDI VILLAGE, XINGPING TOWN, YANGSUO COUNTY ........................................................ 163
7.2.7 HAINAN VILLAGE, ZHONGNAN SUB-DISTRICT, LIWAN DISTRICT ...................................... 164
7.2.8 ZENGJIAO COMMUNITY, HAILONG SUB-DISTRICT, LIWAN DISTRICT ................................. 165
7.2.9 YAOTAI COMMUNITY, KUANGQUAN SUB-DISTRICT, YUEXIU DISTRICT ............................ 166
7.3 INFLUENCED FACILITIES................................................................................................. 167
8. RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PLAN ................................................................. 168
8.1 RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PROCEDURE .................................................... 168
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
4 / 328
8.1.1 PERMANENT LAND EXPROPRIATION AND COMPENSATION THEREFOR ....... 168
8.1.2 RECOVERY OF PRODUCTION ..................................................................................... 168
8.1.3 HOUSE DEMOLITION AND REBUILDING ................................................................. 168
8.1.4 RECONSTRUCTION OF INFRASTRUCTURE ............................................................. 169
8.2 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT SCHEDULE .......................................................... 169
8.3 APPROPRIATION OF FUNDS ............................................................................................ 171
8.3.1 PRINCIPLE FOR APPROPRIATION .............................................................................. 171
8.3.2 DIVISION IN CHARGE OF FUND MANAGEMENT ................................................... 171
8.3.3 FUND FLOW .................................................................................................................... 172
9. ORGANIZATION AND INSTITUTION .......................................................................................... 173
9.1 ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE .................................................................................... 173
9.2 ORGANIZATIONS' RESPONSIBILITIES ........................................................................... 174
9.3 EXECUTIVE COORDINATION .......................................................................................... 176
9.4 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT AUTHORITIES' COMPETENCE AND TRAINING
176
10. NEGOTIATION, COMPLAINT AND PARTICIPATION .................................................................... 177
10.1 NEGOTIATION..................................................................................................................... 177
10.1.1 STAKEHOLDERS UNDER THIS PROJECT ............................................................................... 177
10.1.2 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION STAGE, MODE AND CONTENT ....................................................... 177
10.1.3 PARTICIPATION IN IMPLEMENTATION STAGE ..................................................................... 179
10.1.4 SURVEY ON PUBLIC OPINIONS ............................................................................................ 179
10.2 DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION........................................................................................... 187
10.3 COMPLAINT CHANNEL ....................................................................................................... 187
10.3.1 COMPLAINT AND APPEAL PROCEDURE ............................................................................... 187
10.3.2 PRINCIPLE OF HANDLING COMPLAINTS .............................................................................. 188
10.3.3 REPLY AND MEASURES ...................................................................................................... 188
10.3.4 RECORD OF COMPLAINT AND SUBSEQUENT FEEDBACK ..................................................... 189
11. SURVEILLANCE AND EVALUATION .......................................................................................... 190
11.1 INTERNAL SURVEILLANCE ................................................................................................. 190
11.1.1 PURPOSE ............................................................................................................................ 190
11.1.2 AGENCY AND PERSONNEL .................................................................................................. 190
11.1.3 SURVEILLANCE CONTENT .................................................................................................. 190
11.1.4 IMPLEMENTATION PROCEDURE .......................................................................................... 191
11.2 INDEPENDENT EXTERNAL SURVEILLANCE AND EVALUATION ............................................ 191
11.2.1 PURPOSE ............................................................................................................................ 191
11.2.2 AGENCY AND PERSONNEL .................................................................................................. 192
11.2.3 MAJOR INDICATORS FOR SURVEILLANCE AND EVALUATION ............................................. 192
11.2.4 METHODS FOR SURVEILLANCE AND EVALUATION ............................................................. 192
11.2.5 WORKING STEP .................................................................................................................. 194
11.2.6 REPORT PREPARING PLAN .................................................................................................. 194
12. INVOLVED PERSONS' RIGHT MATRIX ...................................................................................... 197
13. APPENDICES ............................................................................................................................ 200
13.1 DIAGRAM OF GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY RE-ROUTING .......................................... 200
13.2 STATISTICS ON COVERAGE OF HOUSE DEMOLITION IN ALTERED PRELIMINARY DESIGN ... 201
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
5 / 328
13.3 LAND EXPROPRIATION COMPARISON BETWEEN DPTL AND RAP FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 211
13.4 IDENTIFICATION OF VILLAGES/COMMUNITIES MATERIALLY INFLUENCED UNDER APD FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 219
13.5 STATISTICS ON BUILDING DEMOLITION COMPARISON BETWEEN APD AND RAP FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 256
13.6 PROGRESS IN LAND EXPROPRIATION UNDER APD FOR GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY
PROJECT 263
13.7 PROGRESS IN BUILDING DEMOLITION UNDER APD FOR GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY
PROJECT 278
13.8 PROGRESS IN PROGRESS IN LAND ACQUISITION MATERIALLY INFLUENCED UNDER APD FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 287
13.9 PROGRESS IN PROGRESS IN LAND ACQUISITION MATERIALLY INFLUENCED UNDER APD FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 292
13.10 COMPENSATION CRITERIA FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION AND BUILDING DEMOLITION IN
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 301
13.10.1 CONFIRMATION OF GUIZHOU PROVINCE AND GUANGXI ZHUANG AUTONOMOUS REGION
ON COMPENSATION CRITERIA FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION AND BUILDING DEMOLITION ................. 301
13.10.2 COMPENSATION CRITERIA FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION AND BUILDING DEMOLITION IN
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 305
13.10.3 COMPENSATION CRITERIA FOR BUILDING DEMOLITION IN GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU
RAILWAY PROJECT ........................................................................................................................... 312
13.11 STATISTIC ON PROGRESS IN ENTERPRISE/INSTITUTION BUILDING DEMOLITION FOR
GUIYANG-GUANGZHOU RAILWAY PROJECT ..................................................................................... 316
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
6 / 328
SUMMARY
1 Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project ("this Project") is a trunk railway
engineering funded by the World Bank since April 16, 2009. On June 3, 2010,
under the approval of NDRC, this Project was transformed from a
passenger-freight transport line into a dedicated passenger one. After such
transformation, the main track in this Project is an 861.7-km-long double track
power-driven railway line, with design speed upgraded from 200 km/h to 250
km/h. Therefore, as the preliminary design proposal has be modified to meet the
needs for dedicated passenger line and optimize the design route, the railway
running route is altered. Such route alteration results in change to the coverage of
the resettlement plan due to land acquisition and residence demolition for this
Project. This Supplementary Report is prepared to clearly state and adequately
evaluate the effect of the design proposal alteration on resettlement operation, and
make a summary of some changes related to migration and resettlement operations
and ensure achievement of the resettlement action plan.
2 In December 2009, a Feasibility Study Report on Alterations to
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Line (FSRAGGRL) was proposed by the design
institution in accordance with the technical specification of high-speed railway
and thereby to optimize the original design route. In general, the route design is in
accordance with the original migration plan, except for the technical adjustments
in railway line and station. With respect to railway route, railway easement curve
shall be extended in length, as required in the technical specification of high-speed
railway, so the position of the route in the preliminary design has to be changed
physically to some extent (<100m). With respect to station arrangement design, 11
planned station freight yards, 9 overtaking stations and 2 freight interconnecting
lines are revoked by the design institution. These design changes result in
alteration to the range of land acquisition and building demolition in the
resettlement plan.
3 These alterations include: firstly, in number of involved villages/communities, 219
villages/communities in 86 towns/sub-district offices are change to 294
villages/communities in 91 towns; 11 towns/sub-districts and 93 villages
scheduled in the original plan are revoked while another 16 towns/sub-districts
and 168 villages/communities are added in; falling from 43,480 people in 11,175
households to 39,795 in 10,460, with 3,685 people in 715 households cut down;
thirdly, number of various buildings/structures involved has been reduced,
building demolition area dropping from 1,896,065 m2 in the original plan to
1,292,127m2, with 603,938 m
2 saved; fourthly, due to route optimization,
permanent land acquisition area has been decreased to 30,525.3 mus, with 2,092
mus cut down, including farmland of 1,684.3 mus; as shown in Table 1.
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
7 / 328
Table 1 - Comparison between Coverage of Altered Preliminary Design (APD) and
Original Migration Plan for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Item Unit Original Altered
Number of
Towns/Sub-Districts Involved * 86 90
Number of
Villages/Communities
Involved
* 219 294
Involved Population Households/People 11,175/43,480 10,460/39,795
House Demolition Area M2 1,896,065 603,938
Land Acquisition Area mu 32,617.3 30,525.3
4 As the land acquisition and building demolition for this Project has been
commenced in the districts in the provinces involved since the end of
2008.buildings of 913,295 m2
has been demolished and removed, covering 70.7%
of the total. With respect of permanent land acquisition, 84.6% has been
completed within Guizhou Province, while the uncompleted parts are mainly in
Baiyun District, Guiyang City; 97.2% has been completed within the Guangxi
Zhuang Autonomous Region, except for a small plots of land left aside within
Lingchuan County, Guiling City; 74.5% has been completed within Guangdong
Province, with the majority of the uncompleted left in Foshan (only 57.3%
completed), while 80% of land acquisition has been completed in Zhaoqing and
Guangzhou. In building demolition, 399,800 m 2 has been executed in Guizhou
Province, 81.2% complete, with the uncompleted mainly in Yunyuan District,
Guiyang City, and Lanzhou in Qiangdongnan Prefecture; 303,997.3 m 2 has been
implemented within the Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, 70.5% complete,
except for Yuansuo County, Guilin City; 209,497.6 m 2 has been completed in
Guangdong Province, accounting for 56.9%, except for Guangzhou and Foshan;
as shown in Table 2.
Table 2 - Land Acquisition and House Demolition Progress Statistics
Item Unit Completed
Number
Completion
Progress (%)
Uncompleted
Districts
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
Total mu 26,443 86.6
Guizhou
Province mu 6,202 84.6
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Guangxi mu 12,669 97.2 Lingchuan
County, Guilin
Guangdong
Province mu 7,573 74.5 Foshan City
Building
Demolition
Total M2 913,295 70.7
Guizhou
Province M
2 399,800 81.2
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Guangxi M2 303,997 70.5
Yangsuo County,
Guilin City
Guangdong M2 209,498 56.9 Guangzhou,
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
8 / 328
Province Foshan
5 All physical entities involved by land acquisition and building demolition for this
Project will be compensated and relocated in accordance with the original
migration and resettlement plan. Related compensation standards will be complied
with, which have been verified to accord with the governmental policies and local
actual conditions by the authorities (Office of Land and Resources etc.) in the
involved provinces. Compensation for permanent land acquisition has been paid to
the involved people and social security resettlement will be applied to the farmers
whose land has been requisitioned. Related operations are still in process. Both
individual resettlement and collective resettlement will be carried out for the
migrants. New buildings have been completed for the individually relocated
households, while the collective resettlement communities in the districts along
the railway line are still in construction, most of which have been completed,
while some have not been commenced yet, including: Black Stone Village
resettlement site and two other resettlement sites in Baiyun District, Guiyang City,
Xiaobao Village resettlement site in Rongjiang County and Sidi Village
resettlement site in Yangsuo Village; Two resettlement sites in Jinyang District,
two resettlement site in Nanming Districts and two resettlement sites in Lingchuan
County is being completed and delivered for use. Currently the migrants whose
resettlement sites are still in construction are being settled down temporarily while
the migrants whose resettlement site construction has not been commenced have
not had their original buildings demolished and removed yet.
6 Those added villages/communities involved due to alteration to the preliminary
design need to be distinguished by identifying which are under material effect of
such alteration. These districts under material effect cannot be covered by the
compensation policy and scheme specified in the original resettlement plan, so the
migration and resettlement goal cannot be insured to be achieved in these districts.
The principles to identify whether the district is under material effect of land
acquisition and building demolition in the altered preliminary design include: (1)
alteration to the railway route results in additional large-scale building remove for
land acquisition; (2) route alternation has effect on different minority nationality
regions;(3) route alteration has effect on additional social economy zones; (4)
route alteration has effect on the districts with material changes to compensation
and resettlement policies and measures. These principles will be used to identify
the additional involved villages/communities and identify the ones materially
involved by the land acquisition and building demolition on a comprehensive
basis. 22 villages/communities need to be re-planned for resettlement, including:
(1) all additional involved villages/communities within Guiyang City (14 in total);
(2) Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village and Kouzai Village in Rongjiang County,
Nanzhou in Qiangdongnan Prefecture; (3) Sidi Village, Xingping Town, Yangsuo
County, Guilin City;(4) all additional involved villages/communities within
Guangzhou City (4 in total).
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
9 / 328
7 The original resettlement plan will be still applicable to the 146
villages/communities which are not materially involved, and these resettlement
measures will be implemented to achieve the migration and resettlement goal for
this Project.
8 Resettlement of 13 among the 22 villages under material effect has been
commenced successively in 2010. With the coverage of alteration to the
preliminary design, 1,958 mus' land acquisition and the resident resettlement have
been completed, among which the regions with permanent land acquisition
completed include: Nanming District, Yunyan District and Jinyang District in
Guiyang City, Sidi Village, Yangsuo County, Guilin City and Fanyu District in
Guangzhou City. The regions with permanent land acquisition partly completed
are Hainan Village, Zhongnan Sub-District, Linan District, Guangzhou City (with
157.1 mus land acquisition completed, accounting for 72.5% of the total%;
Various kinds of buildings of 252,022m2 has been demolished and removed, with
5,254 people in 1,336 households involved, among which, the districts with
building demolition and removal completed include: Nanming District, Yunyan
District and Jinyang District in Guiyang City. According to a due diligence,
migration and resettlement in these regions have been carried out in strict
compliance with the principles and requirements as specified in the original
resettlement plan. The local governments at all levels in the regions along the
railway line have appropriated compensation in full to the involved people without
delay, and no case of underpayment by the authorities occurs. Various modes are
available for allocation of the compensation by the village/group - for land
regulation in unit of farmer group, the compensation will be distributed averagely
to the farmers; or the compensations will be directly paid to the involved
households.
9 No resettlement for land acquisition has been carried out in 9 villages within the
coverage of effect. Black Stone Village and Duxi Village in Dula Township,
Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village, Sidi Village and Yuezai Village
in , Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village, Sidi Village and Yuezai
Village in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County, and Yaotai Community, Kuangquan
Sub-District, Yuexiu District, Guangzhou City; The regions where residence
demolition has not been commenced include: Black Stone Village and Duxi
Village in Dula Township, Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village,
Kouzai Village and Yuezai Village in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County, Sidi
Village, Xingping Town in Yangsuo County, and Yaotai Community ,
Kuangquan Sub-District, Yuexiu District, Guangzhou City. In general, 9
villages/communities need re-preparation of specific supplementary resettlement
plan in the involved regions, including: Black Stone Village and Duxi Village in
Dula Township, Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village, Kouzai Village
and Yuezai Village in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County, Sidi Village, Xingping
Town in Yangsuo County, Hainan Village in Zhongnan Sub-District, Zengjiao
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
10 / 328
Community in Hailong Sub-District and Yaotai Community in Kuangquan
Sub-District, Yuexiu District in Guangzhou City.
10 Within the 9 villages/communities covered by the supplementary resettlement
plan, a total population of 2,938 in 803 households has been involved by land
acquisition and residence demolition, among which, 773 people in 211 households
are only under effect of land acquisition; 1,564 people in 444 households are only
under effect of building demolition; 601 people in 148 households are under effect
of both (mainly in Black Stone Village and Duxi Village in Baiyun District,
Guiyang City). These regions contain permanent land acquisition of 1,406.2 mus
and residence demolition area of 241,371.5m 2 (including rural residences of
100,628.3 m 2 , commercial building of 98,845.3m
2 and urban residences of
41,898 m 2 ).
11 As per Chinese laws and governmental policies and the World Bank's policy on
resettlement, all involved people shall be entitled to recovery of their living
standard to the level prior to this Project. All standards of compensation for land
acquisition as specified herein are the lowest standards to be implemented during
resettlement. The standards of compensation for building demolition are
determined based on the replacement cost on the market. The standards of
compensation for land acquisition are based on the Land Law of China revised in
2004 and the compensation for land acquisition shall be 6-10 times of the average
annual output value of the requisitioned land during three years. Determination of
the times of output value for compensation for personnel resettlement shall take
into account the farmland quantity per capita in the involved village prior to land
acquisition, varying within 4-20 times of the average annual output value of the
requisitioned land, with crop compensation counted additionally based on annual
output value. Compensation for land temporarily requisitioned will be paid
directly to the involved people based on the average annual output value and will
be recovered after use. Compensation for building demolition will be directly paid
to the migrated villagers based on the resettlement cost, and the building materials
removed from the demolished buildings will be offered to the farmers for free.
Rural residents whose old buildings are demolished will rebuild their new
buildings on the same village and the building site will be provided by the local
authorities for free. Compensation for involved crops and trees will be paid
directly to the involved people. Compensation for demolition and rebuilding of
residences, factories, school and other institutions and enterprises in the cities will
be paid in accordance with the proper market price.
12 Compensation for land acquisition will be paid to the involved people by the
village committees and based on the final decision made on the villager
conference, or, unified reallocation of land shall be done within village/farmer
group and the compensation be paid per capita, or compensation in cash will be
paid directly to the involved households. All living development measures,
including cash compensation, land reallocation, social security program and
training, shall be applied based on extensive consultation with the involved people
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
11 / 328
to ensure their original living standard to be maintained. The involved people's
new buildings will be rebuilt based on the agreement signed, by means of
individual independent rebuilding or collective resettlement. All rural residences
will be rebuilt quickly in the existing villages/communities. The new building
sites and public services will be provided for the migrants by the local authorities.
Involved enterprises/stores and schools will be rebuilt based on the concluded
agreement and subsequent to market price evaluation. All involved infrastructure
will be recovered as required for the local development.
13 All involved people shall be informed of the effect which may be caused in
various stages of this Project and participate in consultations for such effects. The
stakeholders to participate in the consultations shall include involved households,
village officials, villager representative, local government agencies, and
vulnerable groups including women and national minorities. As this Project
proceeds, related information booklets will be released to the migrants.
Meanwhile, the public and involved people in the project area will be able to
obtain the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for this Project from local authorities.
Involved households in this Project will participate in the development of special
resettlement programs. During implementation of this Project, any complaints
related to land acquisition, building demolition and compensation for resettlement
will be submitted to local regulation authority, government agency, the owner,
external monitoring organization or the court.
14 Specific resettlement of migrants will be implemented by provincial government-/
district-/county-level Office of Railway Construction. The expenditure for
resettlement in the supplementary plan is estimated to be RMB 1.1084 billion
Yuan. The budget of the expenditure for resettlement will be adjusted as required
in implementation of resettlement operation.
15 The Office of Railway Construction under local government shall work in close
collaboration with Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company on implementation and
surveillance of payment of the compensation and building rebuilding. The
Ministry of Railways will prepare and submit a surveillance report to the World
Bank semiannually. Upon completion of all resettlement operations, an evaluation
report on them shall be prepared. In addition, Ministry of Railways will still
commission an independent monitoring institution to perform external
surveillance and evaluation. Such external monitoring institution's duties shall
include: survey on foundation base data, review and verification of payment of
compensations, evaluation of complaint procedure and involved people's
reflection and satisfaction of the interests and compensations, assessment of
involved people's recovery of incomes and summary of lessons taken therein. The
external monitoring institution shall submit survey and evaluation reports to
Ministry of Railways and the World Bank semiannually till end of resettlement,
and subsequently, submit an evaluation report on resettlement of the migrants to
Ministry of Railways and the World Bank within at least two years.
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
12 / 328
1. OVERVIEW
1.1 WHY IS THIS SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT PREPARED
1 In 2009, related Chinese decision-making authorities reviewed the construction
proposal of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project ("this Project"), and proposed
that this Project shall be constructed in compliance with the standard of dedicated
passenger transport line. In 2008, Medium- and Long-Term Railway Network
Plan (MLTRNP) (Revision 2008) was released by Chinese railway planning
authority. As part of the new transport line (Leshan-Guiyang-Guangzhou line)
from Southwest China to South China, this Project plays a significant role in the
Railway Network Plan. Due to adjustment to medium-/long-term planning and
regional economic development, there are huge needs for passenger transport
across the districts covered by the Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway line, so
construction of a dedicated passenger transport line from Southwest China to
Guangzhou and Pearl River Delta is necessary, among which, related lines shall
be able to meet regional freight transport quantity and available for division of
passenger and freight lines, so as to improve transport quality and facilitate
operation management. Therefore, it has been stated in Letter on Adjustment of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Construction Measures (No. 2009-805) issued by
Ministry of Railways that, “I. Some of design parameters shall be adjusted to
facilitate further speeding up. To improve regional fast-speed passenger railway
network, enhance relationship between Southwest China and Pearl River Delta,
Guiyang-Guangzhou line shall be constructed in one time with design speed of
250 km/h to build up a fast-speed railway line. II. freight transport facilities
proposed in the initial design shall be revoked and passenger transport quality and
level shall be enhanced.III. The full-length track structure shall be transformed
from ballast-based track to ballast-free track.” Therefore, in accordance with the
requirements of Ministry of Railways and MLTRNP, in December 2009,
FSRAGGRL was prepared by the design institution for this Project, proposing to
change Guiyang-Guangzhou railway line to a dedicated passenger transport line.
On June 3, 2010, NDRC approved that this Project shall be transformed from a
passenger-freight transport line into a dedicated passenger one. 1
2 Change to dedicated passenger transport line will speed the line up. Considering
that construction of this Project has been commenced, the design institution
intended to use the route designed in the original plan as much as possible, and
made some adjustments to comply with the principle for route selection required
in the design criteria for dedicated passenger transport line. These adjustments
resulted in a little alteration to the router within some sections of the railway line
1Approval of NDRC for Alteration to Guiyang-Guang Railway Construction (NOB-2010-1324).
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
13 / 328
in the original plan, as well as change to coverage of resettlement for land
acquisition and building demolition.
3 The Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan ("this Report") is
prepared to clearly state and adequately evaluate the effect of the design proposal
alteration on resettlement operation, and make a summary of some changes related
to migration and resettlement operations, including changes in coverage of
original migration plan, in regional socio-economic background, in compensation
policy and standards and in migration and resettlement proposal, so as to specify
adaption of the resettlement plan and regulative measures for this Project, and
ensure the involved people's living standard unchanged.
4 This Report is a supplement to the original resettlement plan.
1.2 ALTERATION TO PROJECT DESIGN
5 In accordance with the FSRAGGRL proposed by the design institution, the altered
route in the preliminary design shall be in the similar run to that in the original
resettlement plan. The altered main track is an 861.7-km-long double track
power-driven railway line, with design speed upgraded from 200 km/h to 250
km/h. The altered railway design proposal speeds up the line, and requires higher
reliability and less maintenance than the original, and other related parameters are
changed too, including:
railway gauge increased from 4.6 m to 4.8 m;
the maximum gradient: 20%0 of the main track, 6%0 of the section from
north of Zhaoqing to south of Sanshui;
the minimum curve radius is 4,500 meters. Some adjustments to the
original easement curve, intermediate straight line and circular curve
lengths and vertical curve radius result in changes to routes and
engineering form in some sections.
To improve operation stability, subgrade construction in some sections is
changed into bridge construction,
and side slope of line subgrade is flatted to enhance stability in the side
slope and the line passage section needs to be widened due to principle
of aerodynamics;
related freight transport stations in the original construction proposal are
revoked;
the investment gross increases to 97.554 billion Yuan from 81.26 billion.
(1) Alteration to Railway Route
6 Adjustment to the engineering design for this Project results in changes to the
original route proposal. As line easement curve length is increased to meet the
technical requirement for high-speed railway, position of the dedicated passenger
transport line has been changes spatially. (See Appendix 1 - Route Comparison)
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
14 / 328
7 The comparison between the route in the original preliminary design and the
altered route is shown below: In general, the line route has been changed spatially
to some degree, but not expressly. Within the full length, except that there is an
offset up to 940 m in the section from DK247+400 to DK264+300 (as the
overtaking station Bangtu Station in Guping Township, Congjiang County is
revoked, route optimization made by the design institution resulted in some line
offset, mostly in sections of bridges and tunnels), no line offset above 100 m
occurs in any other sections. The maximum offset in section from Guiyang to
Hezhou is 68.25 m, while the maximum offset in section from Hezhou to
Guangzhou is merely 42 m (See Table 3, Table 4, Table 5 and Table 6 for more
details).
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
15 / 328
Table 3 - Route Offsets in Alterations to Preliminary Design (Guiyang-Hezhou Section - 1)
No. Alteration Start Alteration End Alteration Length (m) Maximum Surface Offset (m) Remarks
1 DK107+044 DK115+808 8,764 -44.00 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
2 DK187+500 DK192+460 5,000 11.4 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
3 DK201+850 DK208+240 6,500 68.25 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient and the high hank is revoked.
4 DK247+400 DK264+300 16,651.55 940 Bangtu Station is revoked for optimization of
re-routing.
5 DK322+310 DK325+185 2,875 -8.23 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
6 DK442+560 DK448+315 5,760 16.93 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
7 DK462+461 DK473+700 11,240 55.82 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
8 DK494+496 DK501+300 6,820 14.94 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
9 DK504+777 DK511+327 6,580 24.19 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
10 DK549+391 DK566+600 17,220 7.73 Length of intermediate straight line is
insufficient for rerouting.
Total 87,410.55
Table 4 - Route Offsets in Alterations to Preliminary Design (Guiyang-Hezhou Section - 2)
No. Alteration Start Alteration End Alteration
Length (m)
Maximum Offset (m) Remarks
1 DK77+400. DK93+000. 15,600 -2.8 Fitted to ensure tunnel through Xishan Mountain and the
tunnel exit in Youzhu Mountain unchanged.
2 DK124+676 DK141+000 16,324 2.7 Fitted to ensure Sandu Tunnel entrance unchanged
3 DK266+090. DK273+400. 7,310 46.7 Fitted to Huanggang Tunnel entrance and Gaotian
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
16 / 328
Tunnel exit
4 DK276+230. DK290+160. 13,929.63 -0.99 Fitted to Luoxiang Tunnel, Pobaishan Tunnel and
Gaoqing Tunnel
36 DK292+830. DK314+950. 22,120 2.41 Fitted to Gaopei Tunnels No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3.
42 DK334+660. DK338+720. 4,059.98 1.19 Fitted to Liangting'ao Tunnel and Banwa Tunnel
47 DK357+790. DK366+868. 9,076.87 -1.08 Fitted to Qiling Tunnel entrance
49 DK378+860. DK384+550. 5,689.56 0.95 Fitted to Tianpingshan Tunnel, Jiangjiashan Tunnel No.
1 and No. 2
58 DK424+000. DK432+400. 8,399.78 -2.03 Fitted to Tianbaling Tunnel
76 DK522+800. DK544+500. 18,600 2.3 Fitted to Liang'an Tunnel exit
83 Total 121,109.82
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
17 / 328
Table 5 - Route Offsets in Alterations to Preliminary Design (Hezhou-Guangzhou Section)
NO.
JOINT
POINT
NO.
ORIGINAL
RADIUS
(M)
ORIGINAL
EC
LENGTH
(M)
ALTERED
RADIUS
(M)
ALTERED
EC
LENGTH
(M)
DISTANCE
TO
ORIGINAL
LINE (M)
ALTERATION
START
ALTERATION
END
ALTERATION
LENGTH (M) REMARKS
1 JD1 4,800 330 4,800 480 0~1.2 DK567+800 DK571+800 4,000 Increase easement curve
length
2 JD2 5,500 280 5,500 380 0~0.9 DK572+200 DK577+900 5,700 Increase easement curve
length
3 JD3 5,000 300 5,000 500 0~1 DK580+700 DK582+600 1,900 Increase easement curve
length
4 JD4 4,500 340 4,500 460 0~1.3 DK584+600 DK587+200 2,600 Increase easement curve
length
5 JD5 7,000 200 8,000 270 0~0.6 DK588+000 DK588+900 900 Increase radius and
easement curve length
6 JD6 9,000 160 8,000 300
0~5.1 DK588+900 DK592+900 4,000
As the length of the
intermediate straight line
to the last curve is
insufficient, the radius
needs to be reduced.
7 JD7 5,500 280 5,500 450
8 JD8 10,000 140 10,000 270 0~0.2 DK594+100 DK594+900 800 Increase easement curve
length
9 JD9 6,000 250 6,000 440 0~0.7 DK599+100 DK600+500 1,400 Increase easement curve
length
10 JD10 7,000 200 7,000 390 0~0.5 DK607+700 DK610+000 2,300 Increase easement curve
length
11 JD11 4,500 340 4,500 540 0~0.7 DK613+000 DK616+600 3,600 Increase easement curve
length
12 JD12 7,000 200 7,000 350 0~0.5 DK622+700 DK623+900 1,200 Increase easement curve
length
13 JD13 6,000 250 6,000 440 0~0.7 DK627+900 DK629+100 1,200 Increase easement curve
length
14 JD14 7,000 200 7,000 390 0~0.5 DK631+800 DK633+300 1,500 Increase easement curve
length
15 JD15 5,000 300 5,000 500 0~1 DK634+200 DK636+200 2,000 Increase radius and
easement curve length
16 JD16 8,000 170 10,000 270 0~0.8 DK637+600 DK638+500 900 Increase radius and
easement curve length
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
18 / 328
17 JD17 5,500 280 5,500 470 0~0.8 DK640+400 DK642+400 2,000 Increase easement curve
length
18 JD18 7,000 200 7,000 390
0~17.7 DK645+100 DK650+200 5,100
Due to the large amount of
excavation and difficult
subgrade bed-parallel
slope cutting nearby
dk646+800, the line
position in this section is
to be altered to optimize
the condition for slope
cutting.
19 JD19 5,500 280 5,500 470
20 JD20 7,000 200 7,000 390
21 JD21 5,500 280 5,500 470 0~0.8 DK652+300
DK654+200 1,900
Increase easement curve
length
22 JD22 7,000 200 6,000 390
0~42 DK657+400 DK662+800 5,400
Due to the large
amount of excavation and
difficult subgrade
bed-parallel slope cutting
nearby dk658+800, the
line position in this section
is to be altered to optimize
the condition for slope
cutting.
23 JD23 7,000 350
24 JD24 6,000 250 5,000 450
25 JD26 6,000 390 7,000 350 0~3.7 DK665+200 DK667 +500 2,300 Increase radius and
easement curve length
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
19 / 328
Table 6 - Route Offsets in Alterations to Preliminary Design (Hezhou-Guangzhou Section - Continued)
NO.
JOINT
POINT
NO.
ORIGINAL
RADIUS
(M)
ORIGINAL
EC
LENGTH
(M)
ALTERED
RADIUS
(M)
ALTERED
EC
LENGTH
(M)
DISTANCE
TO
ORIGINAL
LINE (M)
ALTERATION
START
ALTERATION
END
ALTERATION
LENGTH (M) REMARKS
26 JD27 5,500 280 5,500 420 0~0.5
DK667+500 DK675+100 7,600
Increase
easement curve length
27 JD28 5,500 280 7,000 310 0~3.2
Alter the joint
point a little and
increase the radius and
easement curve length
to ensure sufficient
length of the next
intermediate straight
line
28 JD29 5,500 280 5,500 400 0~2.4 Increase easement
curve length
29 JD30 5,000 300 4,700 430 0~1.7
Reduce the
original radius
properly to ensure the
joint point unchanged
with minimum
alteration and meet the
length of the next
intermediate straight
line
30 JD31 5,500 280 6,100 350 0~0.9 Increase radius and
easement curve length
31 JD32 5,500 280 5,500 470 0~0.8 DK675+900 DK680+100 4,200 Increase easement
curve length
32 JD33 9,000 160 9,000 300 0~0.3 DK682+300 DK684+000 1,700 Increase easement
curve length
33 JD36 6,000 250 6,000 360 0~0.7 DK692+800 DK695+400 2,600 Increase easement
curve length
34 JD37 5,500 280 5,450 390 0~3.2 DK696+600 DK701+400 4,800 Increase easement
curve length to
minimize the loss in
commenced tunnel
Gui-Guang Project Supplementary Report for Resettlement Action Plan
20 / 328
and fit a special radius
to meet the
requirement for
dedicated passenger
line of 300 km/h.
35 JD48 4,500 340 4,500 440 0~0.9 DK730+500 DK733+100 2,600 Increase easement
curve length
36 JD49 4,500 340 5,000 450 0~7.5 DK738+300 DK746+400 8,100 As the depth of
Beiling Mountain
tunnel entrance has
been excavated in
more than 300 m, the
section is to be fitted
to avoid effect on the
section in
construction.
37 JD50 6,000 390 6,000 390
38 JD52 5,000 300 5,000 500 0~1 DK754+000 DK755+900 1,900 Increase easement
curve length
39 JD53 4,500 340 4,500 540 0~1.1 DK762+000 DK763+600 1,600 Increase easement
curve length
40 JD54 4,500 340 4,500 430 Increase easement
curve length; move
the joint point to
facilitate setting of
track regulator on
Qingqiyong main span
41 JD55 4,500 430 4,500 430 0~20.1 DK764+300 DK770+000 5,700 The original radius
and easement curve
length will meet the
requirement for
dedicated passenger
line of 300 km/h.
TOTAL ALTERATION LENGTH 91,500
(2) Alteration to Stations
8 In accordance with the requirements of dedicated passenger transport line design
proposal, Mazipu freight train interconnecting line, North Zhaoqing freight train
interconnecting line and related works; 11 planned station freight yards are
revoked, including these in East Duyun, Sandu, Rongjiang, Congjiang, Ertang,
Yangsuo, Gongcheng, West Zhongshan, Huaiji and Guang Stations; 9 overtaking
stations in Shanjiang Township, Bangtu, Tongle, Shangyue, Lingtian, Liang'an,
Hejie, Ma'ning and Sihui are canceled, so there are totally 21 stations contained in
the full-length line - North Guiyang, Guiyang, North Longli, Changmin, East
Duyun, Sandu, Rongjiang, Congjiang, Sanjiang, Wutong, West Guilin, Yangsuo,
Gongcheng, West Zhongshan, Hezhou, Huaiji, Guangning, East Zhaoqing, South
Sanshui, West Foshan, New Guangzhou, among which there are 1 passenger
station to be newly built, 1 passenger station to be rebuilt, 1 passenger transport in
construction and 18 new intermediate stations to be newly built.North Guiyang
Station is a passenger station to be newly built; Guiyang Station is a passenger
station to be rebuilt; New Guangzhou is a passenger station in construction. See
Table 7 for more details.
Table7 - Alteration to Station Arrangement in this Project
City/Prefectu
re
County/Distri
ct
Reserved
Intermedia
te
Passenger
Station
Revoked
Freight
Stations and
Interconnecti
ng Lines
Revoked
Overtakin
g Stations
New/Rebuilt/In-Progr
ess Passenger Stations
Guiyang City Jinyang
District North Guiyang (new)
Guiyang City Nanmin
District Guiyang (rebuilt)
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Longli
County
North
Longli
Mazipu
interconnecti
ng line
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Guiding
County Changmin
Qiangnan
Prefecture Duyun City
East
Duyun East Duyun
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Sandu
County Sandu Sandu
Qiangdongna
n Prefecture
Rongjiang
County Rongjiang Rongjiang Sanjiang
Qiangdongna
n Prefecture
Congjiang
County Congjiang Congjiang Bangtu
Liuzhou City Sanjiang
County Sanjiang Sanjiang Tongle
Guilin City Lingui
County Wutong Ertang Shangyue
Guilin City Lingchuan
County
West
Guilin Lingtian
Guilin City Yangsuo
County Yangsuo Yangsuo
Guilin City Gongcheng Gongchen Gongcheng Liang'an
County g
Hezhou City Zhongshan
County
West
Zhongshan
West
Zhongshan
Hezhou City Babu District Hezhou Hejie
Zhaoqing
City
Huaiji
County Huaiji Huaiji Ma'ning
Zhaoqing
City
Guangning
County Guangning Guangning
Zhaoqing
City Sihui City Sihui
Zhaoqing
City
Dinghu
District
East
Zhaoqing
North
Zhaoqing
freight train
interconnecti
ng line
Foshan City Sanshui
District
South
Sanshui
Foshan City Nanhai
District
West
Foshan
Guangzhou
City
Fanyu
District
New Guangzhou (in
construction)
Total 18 11 9 3
1.3 MAIN CHANGES IN LAND ACQUISITION AND RESIDENT
MIGRATION
1.3.1 CHANGES IN COVERAGE OF LAND ACQUISITION
AND HOUSE DEMOLITION
9 Adjustment to the route in the preliminary design for this Project results in
corresponding changes in the coverage of land acquisition and building demolition
determined in the original resettlement plan. According to a survey, the areas
within the coverage of the route in this Project are mainly mountainous areas, with
bridges and tunnels accounting for more than 85% of the total distance. A little
alteration to route will re-route out of boundaries of the original
villages/communities and into the new ones. Therefore, among the coverage of the
original resettlement plan, some involved villages are excluded while other
villages/communities located nearby are added in.
10 In general, 78 villages in 4 counties/towns are additionally contained in the
coverage of the altered preliminary design. Within the coverage of the original
plan were 219 villages/communities in 86 counties/ sub-districts, while now 294
villages/communities in 91 townships/towns are contained in the altered
preliminary design. 11 towns/sub-districts and 93 villages scheduled in the
original plan are revoked while another 16 towns/sub-districts and 168
villages/communities are added in (see Table 8 and Appendix 2 for more details).
Within Guizhou Province, 8 counties/sub-districts and 43 villages/communities
are excluded while 5 counties/towns and 45 villages are added in. Within Guangxi
Province, 1 counties/sub-districts and 27 villages/communities are excluded while
5 counties/towns and 64 villages are added in. Within Guangdong Province, 2
counties/sub-districts and 23 villages/communities are excluded while 5
counties/towns and 62 villages are added in.
11 With the route optimization by the design institution, numbers of involved
counties/towns and villages/communities increase, while numbers of involved
households and population reduce, falling from 43,480 people in 11,175
households to 39,795 in 10,460, with 3,685 people in 715 households cut down,
among which, within Guizhou Province, involved residents are 11,891 in 3,054
households, increasing 1,186 residents in 463 households to the original plan;
within Guangxi Province, involved residents are 15,950 in 4,019 households,
increasing 104 residents in 17 households to the original plan; within Guangdong
Province, involved residents are 11,955 in 3,387 households, increasing 4,975
residents in 1,195 households to the original plan.
12 With respect to coverage of building demolition, total quantity of buildings to be
demolished reduces, while the physical quantity of residences increases, since the
reduction mostly covers industrial and commercial enterprises' buildings and
urban residences to be demolished. In the altered preliminary design for this
Project, various types of buildings to be demolished are 1,292,127 m2 , with
603,938 m2 cut down from the original plan (1,896,065 m
2 ), among which,
non-residential buildings of 637,108.9 m2 are cut down while residences of
33,170.9 m 2 are added in.
13 In Guizhou Province, building demolition area is 492,531.9 m2 , with 113,624.1 m
2 cut down from the original plan, among which, residences of 23,467.1 m
2
(mostly in cities) are added in, while non-residential buildings of 137,091.1 m2 are
cut down from the original plan; In Guangxi Province, building demolition area is
431,127.4 m2 , with 39,969.3 m
2 cut down from the original plan, among which,
residences of 131,791.5 m2 are added in, while non-residential buildings of
171,761.1 m2 are cut down. In Guangdong Province, building demolition area is
368,467.6 m2 , with 450,344.4 m
2 reduced in the original plan, among which,
residences of 122,087.7 m2 are cut down while non-residential buildings of
328,256.7 m2 are reduced.
Table 8 - Coverage of House Demolition in Altered Preliminary Design
Count
y/Dist
rict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved People House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Numb
er of
Counti
es/To
wns
Numb
er of
Villag
es
Numb
er of
Counti
es/To
wns
Numb
er of
Villag
es
Numb
er of
Counti
es/To
wns
Number
of
Villages
Numb
er of
House
holds
Number of
People Residences
Non-Resid
ential
Buildings
Total Farmlan
d
Non-Far
mland Total
Guiya
ng
City
RAP 9 19 0 0 0 0 1,096 4,649 138,228.0 207,231.0 345,459.0 1,643.8 1,211.6 2855.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
9 15 3 12 3 8 1,532 5,980 148705.6 187,590.1 336,295.6 1,821.5 389.3 2,210.7
Qiang
nan
Prefec
ture
RAP 15 33 0 0 0 0 897 3,567 67,926.0 101,798.0 169,724.0 1,812.1 1,335.9 3,148.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
15 38 2 10 2 15 894 3,490 92,728.9 35,221.8 127,950.7 1,988.7 1,544.2 3,533.0
Qiang
dongn
an
Prefec
ture
RAP 12 30 0 0 0 0 598 2,486 36,437.0 54,535.0 90,972.0 1,203.6 887.2 2,090.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
9 30 3 21 0 21 628 2,421 22,623.6 5,662.0 28,285.6 847.0 740.4 1,587.4
Total -
Guizh
ou
RAP 36 82 0 0 0 0 2,591 10,705 242,591.0 363,565.0 606,156.0 4,659.6 3,434.8 8,094.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
33 83 8 43 5 44 3,054 11,891 266,058.1 226,473.9 492,531.9 4,657.2 2,673.9 7,331.1
Comp
arison RPD-RAP -3 2 8 43 5 45 463 1,186 23,467.1 -137,091.1 -113,624.1 -2.4 -760.9 -763.3
Liuzh
ou
City
RAP 5 15 622 2,490 30,028.0 45,255.0 75,283.0 871.2 642.1 1,513.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6 13 0 5 1 3 126 378 7,437.6 0.0 7,437.6 504.1 465.9 970.0
Guilin
City
RAP 15 49 0 0 0 0 2,283 8,562 101,760.0 152,734.0 254,494.0 4,570.4 3,369.1 7,939.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
15 61 1 21 1 33 2,159 8,636 111,347.4 106,625.9 217,973.3 4,723.9 2,849.1 7,572.9
Hezho
u City
RAP 7 17 0 0 0 0 1,097 4,794 56,468.0 84,852.0 141,320.0 3,396.3 2,503.6 5,899.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
10 44 0 1 3 28 1,734 6,936 201,262.4 4,454.0 205,716.5 3,036.6 1,448.9 4,485.5
Total -
Guang
xi
RAP 27 81 0 0 0 0 4,002 15,846 188,256.0 282,841.0 471,097.0 8,837.9 6,514.9 15,352.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
31 118 1 27 5 64 4,019 15,950 320,047.5 1,110,790.
9 431,127.4 8,264.5 4,763.8 13,028.4
Comp
arison RPD-RAP 4 37 1 27 5 64 17 104 131,791.5 -171,761.1 -39,969.6 -573.4 -1,751.1 -2,324.4
Zhaoq
ing
City
RAP 17 36 0 0 0 0 1,416 5,974 99,740.0 136,897.0 236,637.0 3,763.2 2,774.0 6,537.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
18 66 1 15 2 45 1,413 5,312 99,028.0 20,121.9 119,149.9 2,617.6 4,722.7 7,340.3
Fosha
n City
RAP 5 18 0 0 0 0 2,397 8,572 102,376.0 154,222.0 256,598.0 879.1 648.0 1,527.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
5 23 0 6 0 11 1,408 5,632 110,840.1 83,343.1 194,183.3 1,310.5 1,199.3 2,509.8
Guang
zhou
City
RAP 1 2 0 0 0 0 769 2,383 130,231.0 195,347.0 325,578.0 636.6 469.2 1,105.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 3 1 2 4 4 566 1,011 391.2 54,743.3 55,134.5 242.2 73.5 315.8
Subtot
al -
Guang
dong
RAP 23 56 0 0 0 0 4,582 16,929 332,347.0 486,465.0 818,812.0 5,278.9 3,891.2 9,170.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
26 95 2 23 6 63 3,387 11,955 210,259.3 158,208.3 368,467.6 4,170.3 5,995.5 10,165.8
Comp
arison RPD-RAP 3 39 2 23 6 63 -1,195 -4,975 -122,087.7 -328,256.7 -450,344.4 -1,108.6 2,104.3 995.7
Total -
Full
Line
RAP 86 219 0 0 0 0 11,175 43,480 763,194.0 1,132,871.
0
1,896,065.
0 18,776.3 13,841.0 32,617.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
91 294 11 93 16 168 10,460 39,795 796,364.9 495,762.1 1,292,127 17,092.0 13,433.3 30,525.3
Comp
arison RPD-RAP 5 75 11 93 16 168 -715 -3,685 33,170.9 -637,108.9 -603,938 -1,684.3 -407.7 -2,092.0
14 Physical quantity involved by project is less than that in the original plan, mostly
in permanent farmland acquisition, which reflects optimization of design and
reduction in effect on residents' life within the coverage of line. Various types of
permanent land acquisition in the altered preliminary design for this Project is
30,525.3 mus, with 2,092 mus cut down from the original plan (32,617.3 mus),
among which, farmland of 1,684.3 mus is cut down while non-farmland of 407.7
is reduced. In Guizhou Province, permanent land acquisition of various types is
7,331.1 mus, with 763.3 mus cut down from the original plan. In Guangxi,
permanent land acquisition is 13,028.4 mus, 2,324.4 mus below the original plan.
In Guangdong Province, permanent land acquisition is 10,165.8 mus, 995.7 mus
above the original plan, but the increase is mostly in non-farmland (2,104 mus),
while farmland of 1,108.6 mus is cut down. See Table 8 for more details.
1.3.2 DETAILED ALTERATIONS TO LAND ACQUISITION
& HOUSE DEMOLITION
(1) Red Line-Enclosed Permanent Land Acquisition Area
15 In general, re-routing in the altered preliminary design has certain effect on land
acquisition and building demolition along the line. Re-routing needs additional
land acquisition, but the design institution has made route optimization and
canceled 9 overtaking stations, 2 freight train interconnecting lines and 11
originally planned station freight yards. These measures have actually cut down
the land acquisition quantity, especially area of requisitioned farmland, and
increased acquisition area of unused land, and so reduced occupation of the
involved people's farmland.
16 By comparing the data concerning land acquisition and building demolition in the
altered preliminary design with those in the original plan, it can be found that: in
the altered preliminary design, permanent land acquisition area is 30,525.3 mu,
2,092 mus less than that in the original plan, among which, farmland area of
1,684.3 mus is cut down (including reduced paddy fields of 36.3 mus, reduced dry
farms of 4,092.9 mus, increased vegetable fields of 1,521.3 mus, increased
orchards of 1,508.3 mus, and increased other farmland of 584.4 mus), ponds
acquisition area of 1,130.6 is reduced, woodland acquisition area of 183 mus is
reduced, construction-purpose land area of 507 mus is reduced, uncultivated land
area of 853.3 is increased, and other unused land acquisition area of 559.5 mus is
increased (See Table 11 for more details).
17 In Guizhou Province, in the altered preliminary design, permanent land
acquisition area is 7,331.1 mus, 763.3 mus less than that in the original plan,
among which, farmland area of 2.4 mus is cut down, pond acquisition area of
317.4 mus is reduced, construction-purpose land acquisition area of 376.5 is
reduced, uncultivated land acquisition area of 353.4 mus is reduced, while
woodland acquisition area of 280.1 mus is increased and unused other land
acquisition area of 6.2 mus is increased (see Table 9).
18 In Guangxi, in the altered preliminary design, permanent land acquisition area is
13 mus, 2,324.4 mus less than that in the original plan, among which, farmland
acquisition area of 573.4, pond acquisition area of 611.8 mus, woodland
acquisition area of 51.2 mus, construction-purpose land acquisition area of 662
mus and unused land acquisition area of 426.1 mus are cut down (see Table 10).
19 In Guangdong Province, in the altered preliminary design, permanent land
acquisition area is 10,165.8 mus, 995.7 mus more than that in the original plan,
among which, construction-purpose land acquisition area of 531.5 mus and
uncultivated land acquisition area of 1,612.4 mus and unused other land
acquisition area of 573.3 mus are increased, while farmland acquisition area of
1,108.6 mus is cut down due to design optimization (see Table 11).
(2) Area of Land Temporarily Requisitioned for this Project
20 In the altered preliminary design, area of land temporarily requisitioned is 27,276
mus, 3,197.6 mus more than that in the original plan, among which, woodland
acquisition area of 5,000.2 mus, uncultivated land acquisition area of 1,339.3 mus,
other unused land acquisition area of 229.4 mus are increased, while farmland
acquisition area of 763.4 mus, pond acquisition area of 976.2 mus and
construction-purpose land acquisition area of 1,631.7 mus are cut down (see
Appendix 3 and Table 9, Table 10 and Table 11 for more details). In Guangxi,
area of land temporarily requisitioned of 3,345.1 mus is cut down, including
increases in farmland acquisition area of 1,157.5 mus, woodland acquisition area
of 3,425.3 mus, other unused land acquisition area of 7.4 mus, and reductions in
pond acquisition area of 430.3 mus and construction-purpose land acquisition area
of 748.4 mus. In Guangdong Province, area of land temporarily requisitioned is
3,784 mus than that in the original plan, including increases in farmland
acquisition area of 161.1 mus, woodland acquisition area of 1,897.5,
construction-purpose land of 145.6 mus, Uncultivated Land of 1,378.5 mus, other
unused land of 240.6 mus, and reduction in pond acquisition area of 39.4 mus.
Table 9 - Comparison of Land Acquisition between Original Plan and Altered Preliminary Design (Guizhou Province)
County
/Distric
t
RAP/Al
tered
Prelimi
nary
Design
Land
Acquisition
Farmland (mu)
Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultiv
ated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegeta
ble
Field
Orchar
d Others
Guiya
ng
City
RAP
Permanent 1,643.8 732.1 642.9 44.6 149.8 74.4 117.6 708.1 235.6 146.1 4.2 2855.4
Temporari
ly Used
Land
450.8 200.8 176.3 12.2 41.1 20.4 32.3 194.2 64.6 40.1 1.2 783.2
Planne
d in
APD
Permanent 1,821.5 290.6 723.5 807.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 335.5 37.1 0.6 0.0 2,210.7
Temporari
ly Used
Land
215.9 0.0 161.7 36.2 18.0 0.0 12.5 3.4 9.8 14.8 0.0 256.4
Qiang
nan
Prefec
ture
RAP
Permanent 1,812.1 807.1 708.7 49.2 165.1 82.0 129.7 780.7 259.8 161.1 4.6 3,148.0
Temporari
ly Used
Land
3,608.5 1,607.1 1,411.2 98.0 328.8 163.4 258.3 1,554.5 517.2 320.7 9.2 6,268.4
Planne
d in
APD
Permanent 1,988.7 1,151.0 784.4 0.0 42.3 11.0 0.0 1,323.0 172.1 49.1 0.0 3,533.0
Temporari
ly Used
Land
3,092.1 884.0 2,208.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1,112.7 0.0 500.3 0.0 4,705.1
Qiang
dongn
an
Prefec
ture
RAP
Permanent 1,203.6 536.0 470.7 32.7 109.7 54.5 86.1 518.5 172.5 107.0 3.1 2,090.8
Temporari
ly Used
Land
3,193.0 1,422.1 1,248.7 86.7 290.9 144.6 228.5 1,375.5 457.7 283.8 8.2 5,546.7
Planne
d in
APD
Permanent 847.0 700.9 73.4 0.0 63.4 9.3 0.0 628.9 82.2 11.2 18.1 1,587.4
Temporari
ly Used 1,862.4 1101.5 590.7 0.0 170.2 0.0 0.0 1,685.4 0.7 156.8 0.0 3,705.3
Land
Total -
GuiZh
ou
RAP
Permanent 4,659.6 2,075.3 1,822.3 126.5 424.5 211.0 333.5 2,007.3 667.9 414.2 11.9 8,094.4
Temporari
ly Used
Land
7,252.2 3,230.0 2,836.3 196.9 660.7 328.3 519.0 3,124.2 1,039.5 644.6 18.6 12,598.1
Planne
d in
APD
Permanent 4,657.2 2,142.4 1,581.3 807.4 105.7 20.3 16.1 2,287.4 291.4 60.8 18.1 7,331.1
Temporari
ly Used
Land
5,170.4 1,985.5 2,960.5 36.2 188.2 0.0 12.5 2,801.5 10.5 671.9 0.0 8,666.8
Comp
arison
RPD-R
AP
Permanent -2.4 67.1 -241.0 680.9 -318.8 -190.7 -317.4 280.1 -376.5 -353.4 6.2 -763.3
Temporari
ly Used
Land
-2,081.8 -1,244.5 124.2 -160.7 -472.5 -328.3 -506.5 -322.7 -1,029.0 27.3 -18.6 -3,931.3
Table 10 - Comparison of Land Acquisition between Original Plan and Altered Preliminary Design (Guangxi)
County
/Distric
t
RAP/Al
tered
Prelimi
nary
Design
Land
Acquisitio
n
Farmland (mu)
Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultiv
ated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetabl
e Field Orchard Others
Liuzho
u City
(Sanjia
ng
County)
RAP
Permanent 871.2 388.0 340.7 23.7 79.4 39.4 62.3 375.3 124.9 77.4 2.2 1,513.3
Temporari
ly Used
Land
1,272.1 566.6 497.5 34.5 115.9 57.6 91.0 548.0 182.3 113.1 3.3 2,209.8
Planned
in APD
Permanent 504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9 453.7 5.6 6.6 970.0
Temporari
ly Used
Land
744.1 478.6 265.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 459.2 0.0 92.9 1,296.2
Guilin
City
RAP
Permanent 4,570.4 2,035.6 1,787.4 124.1 416.4 206.9 327.1 1,968.9 655.1 406.3 11.7 7,939.5
Temporari
ly Used
Land
4,023.9 1,792.1 1,573.7 109.3 366.6 182.2 288.0 1,733.4 576.7 357.7 10.3 6,990.0
Planned
in APD
Permanent 4,723.9 1101.3 933.2 2.1 2,641.4 45.9 20.8 2,401.5 287.0 137.6 2.2 7,572.9
Temporari
ly Used
Land
3,991.1 1,126.2 1,489.6 21.6 1,353.7 0.0 2.0 3,024.5 120.0 379.0 6.6 7,523.2
Hezhou
City
RAP
Permanent 3,396.3 1,512.6 1,328.3 92.2 309.4 153.8 243.1 1,463.1 486.8 301.9 8.7 5899,.9
Temporari
ly Used
Land
762.5 339.6 298.2 20.7 69.5 34.5 54.6 328.4 109.3 67.8 2.0 1,324.6
Planned
in APD
Permanent 3,036.6 1,781.8 1.2 1,198.7 23.1 31.8 0.0 901.0 312.1 235.7 0.0 4,485.5
Temporari
ly Used 2,480.6 1,426.1 1,054.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 2,551.6 0.0 0.1 16.3 5,049.9
Land
Total -
Guangx
i
RAP
Permanent 8,837.9 3,936.2 3,456.4 240.0 805.2 400.1 632.5 3,807.4 1,266.8 785.6 22.6 15,352.8
Temporari
ly Used
Land
6,058.3 2,698.2 2,369.3 164.5 552.0 274.3 433.6 2,609.9 868.4 538.5 15.5 10,524.2
Planned
in APD
Permanent 8,264.5 3,074.0 1,225.3 1,200.8 2,673.9 90.6 20.8 3,756.2 604.8 379.9 2.2 13,028.4
Temporari
ly Used
Land
7,215.8 3,030.9 2,809.6 21.6 1,353.7 0.0 3.3 6,035.2 120.0 472.1 22.9 13,869.3
Compar
ison
RPD-R
AP
Permanent -573.4 -862.2 -2,231.
1 960.8 1,868.7 -309.5 -611.8 -51.2 -662.0 -405.7 -20.4 -2,324.4
Temporari
ly Used
Land
1,157.5 332.7 440.3 -142.9 801.7 -274.3 -430.3 3,425.3 -748.4 -66.4 7.4 3,345.1
Table 11 - Comparison of Land Acquisition between Original Plan and Altered Preliminary Design (Guangdong Province )
County
/Distric
t
RAP/Al
tered
Prelimi
nary
Design
Land
Acquisition
Farmland (mu)
Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultiv
ated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetabl
e Field Orchard Others
Zhaoqi
ng City
RAP
Permanent 3,763.2 1,676.0 1,471.7 102.2 342.9 170.4 269.3 1,621.2 539.4 334.5 9.6 6,537.2
Temporarily
Used Land 510.6 227.4 199.7 13.9 46.5 23.1 36.5 220.0 73.2 45.4 1.3 887.0
Planned
in APD
Permanent 2,617.6 1,906.8 214.7 9.9 331.4 154.8 176.4 1,606.1 523.3 1,861.6 555.3 7,340.3
Temporarily
Used Land 450.1 180.0 209.7 59.5 0.0 0.9 0.0 2,134.6 0.0 1,125.9 180.0 3,890.6
Foshan
City
RAP
Permanent 879.1 391.5 343.8 23.9 80.1 39.8 62.9 378.7 126.0 78.1 2.3 1,527.1
Temporarily
Used Land 39.7 17.7 15.5 1.1 3.6 1.8 2.8 17.1 5.7 3.5 0.1 68.9
Planned
in APD
Permanent 1,310.5 1,110.5 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 250.0 700.0 220.0 29.3 2,509.8
Temporarily
Used Land 231.3 66.3 165.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 174.5 87.5 0.0 493.3
Guangz
hou
City
RAP
Permanent 636.6 283.5 249.0 17.3 58.0 28.8 45.6 274.2 91.2 56.6 1.6 1,105.8
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Planned
in APD
Permanent 242.2 92.2 29.0 13.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 64.8 0.0 2.7 315.8
Temporarily
Used Land 30.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 30.0 0.0 0.0 50.0 214.0 62.0 356.0
Guangd
ong
Provinc
e
RAP
Permanent 5,278.9 2,351.1 2,064.5 143.3 481.0 239.0 377.8 2,274.1 756.6 469.2 13.5 9,170.1
Temporarily
Used Land 550.2 245.1 215.2 14.9 50.1 24.9 39.4 237.1 78.9 48.9 1.4 955.9
Planned
in APD
Permanent 4,170.3 3,109.5 443.7 22.9 439.4 154.8 176.4 1,862.1 1,288.1 2,081.6 587.3 10,165.8
Temporarily
Used Land 711.3 246.3 374.7 59.5 0.0 30.9 0.0 2,134.6 224.5 1,427.4 242.0 4,739.9
Compar
ison
RPD-R
AP
Permanent -1,108.6 758.4 -1,620.
8 -120.4 -41.6 -84.2 -201.4 -412.0 531.5 1,612.4 573.8 995.7
Temporarily
Used Land 161.1 1.1 159.5 44.6 -50.1 6.0 -39.4 1,897.5 145.6 1,378.5 240.6 3,784.0
Total -
Full
Line
RAP
Permanent 18,776.3 8,362.5 7,343.2 509.8 1,710.7 850.1 1,343.8 8,088.8 2,691.3 1,669.0 48.1 32,617.3
Temporarily
Used Land 13,860.9 6,173.3 5,420.8 376.3 1,262.9 627.6 992.0 5,971.2 1,986.7 1,232.1 35.5 24,078.4
Planned
in APD
Permanent 17,092.0 8,325.9 3,250.3 2,031.1 3,219.0 265.7 213.2 7,905.8 2,184.3 2,522.3 607.6 30,525.3
Temporarily
Used Land 13,097.5 5,262.7 6,144.8 117.3 1,541.9 30.9 15.8 10,971.4 355.0 2,571.4 264.9 27,276.0
Comparison Permanent -1,684.3 -36.6 -4,092. 1,521.3 1,508.3 -584.4 -1,130.6 -183.0 -507.0 853.3 559.5 -2,092.0
between RAP and
DPTL 9
Temporarily
Used Land -763.4 -910.6 724.0 -259.0 279.0 -596.7 -976.2 5,000.2 -1,631.7 1,339.3 229.4 3,197.6
(3) Change in House Demolition Area
21 Due to route optimization in the altered preliminary design, compared to the
resettlement action plan (RAP), building demolition area has been reduced as well.
Along the full-length line, the building demolition area is 1,292,127m2,
603,938m2 less than that in the original plan, among which, rural building
demolition area is 796,364.9 m 2 , 33,170.9 m
2 above the original plan; the school
building demolition area is 24,751m2, 5,803m
2 less than that in the original plan;
industrial enterprise building demolition area is 310,289.3 m2, with 174,710.7 m
2
cut down from the original plan (See Table 13 for more details).
22 Total of the building demolition area in Guizhou Province is below that in the
original plan in general, but the reduction is mostly in industrial and commercial
enterprise building and urban residence, while rural building demolition area is
larger than that in the original plan. The total of building demolition area in
Guizhou Province is 492,531 m2 , 113,624.054 m
2 less than that in the original
plan, among which, rural building demolition area is 266,058.1 m 2 , 23,467.1 m
2
above the original plan (the increase mainly in Nanmin District and Baiyun
District, Guiyang City); school building demolition area is 13721.3 m 2 , 4,025.32
m 2 above the original plan (the increase mainly in Sandu County and Duyun City,
Qiangnan Prefecture); industrial and commercial enterprise building demolition
area is 93,928.8 m2 , 59,979.2 m
2 below the original plan; urban residence
demolition area is 118,823.8 m2 , 81137.2 m
2 below the original plan (See Table
12 for more details).
23 Comparison of the building demolition area within the Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region to the original plan is similar to that in Guizhou Province.
The total of building demolition area in the altered preliminary design is
431,127.4 m2 , 39969.6 m
2 less than that in the original plan, among which, 3,090
m2 is cut down in school building demolition, 13,110.1 m
2 cut down in industrial
and commercial enterprise building demolition, and 155,561 m2 cut down in urban
residence demolition, while 131,791.5 m2 is added in rural building demolition
(mainly in Zhongshan County , Babu District and Pinggui District, Hezhou City)
(see Table 12 for more details).
24 In Guangdong Province, the total of building demolition area is 368,467.6 m2 ,
450,344.4 m2 below the original plan, among which, 122,087.7 m
2 is cut down in
rural building demolition, 6,738.3 m2 cut down in school building demolition,
219,897 m2 cut down in urban residence demolition, and 101,621.4 m
2 cut down
in industrial and commercial enterprise building demolition (mainly in Guangzhou
City) (see Table 13 for more details).
Table 12 - Comparison of House Demolition between Original Plan and Altered Preliminary Design (Guizhou and Guangxi)Unit:sq. meter
County/District RAP/Altered Preliminary
Design
Rural Residences Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Bri
ck
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od Primitive
Total - Guiyang RAP 138,228.0 86,394.0 22,115.0 17,969.0 11,749.0 87,727.0 5,526.0 113,978.0 345,459.0
Altered Preliminary Design 150,705.6 132,728.4 8,123.6 456.8 9,396.7 66,766.3 0.0 118,823.8 336,295.6
Total - Qiangnan
Prefecture
RAP 67,926.0 42,451.0 10,865.0 8,831.0 5,772.0 43,094.0 2,715.0 55,989.0 169,724.0
Altered Preliminary Design 92,728.9 30,770.5 23,053.0 28,978.6 3,894.9 21,600.5 13,621.3 0.0 127,950.7
Total - Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
RAP 36,437.0 22,771.0 5,827.0 4,736.0 3,096.0 23,087.0 1,454.0 29,994.0 90,972.0
Altered Preliminary Design 22,623.6 6,563.1 6,470.1 5,886.3 3,703.7 5,562.0 100.0 0.0 28,285.6
Total - GuiZhou RAP 242,591.0 151,616.0 38,807.0 31,536.0 20,617.0 153,908.0 9,696.0 199,961.0 606,156.0
Altered Preliminary Design 266,058.1 170,062.0 37,646.7 35,321.7 16,995.3 93,928.8 13,721.3 118,823.8 492,531.9
Comparison RPD-RAP 23,467.1 18,446.0 -2960.3 3,785.7 -3,621.7 -59,979.2 4,025.3 -81,137.2 -113,624.1
Liuzhou City
RAP 30,028.0 18,766.0 4,805.0 3,903.0 2,552.0 19,158.0 1,207.0 24,890.0 75,283.0
Altered Preliminary Design 7,437.6 653.8 857.4 4,154.4 1,772.0 7,437.6
Altered Preliminary Design 12,508.9 4,777.3 7,712.9 18.7 1,420.5 13,929.5
Total - Guilin RAP 101,760.0 63,600.0 16,283.0 13,231.0 8,650.0 64,658.0 4,074.0 84,002.0 254,494.0
Altered Preliminary Design 111,347.4 35,487.8 42,901.6 13,474.2 19,483.9 106,625.9 0.0 0.0 217,973.3
Total - Hezhou RAP 56,468.0 35,292.0 9,036.0 7,339.0 4,801.0 35,920.0 2,263.0 46,669.0 141,320.0
Altered Preliminary Design 201,262 76,771 55,054 35,808 33,630 0 4,454 0 205,716
Total - Guangxi RAP 188,256.0 117,658.0 30,124.0 24,473.0 16,003.0 119,736.0 7,544.0 155,561.0 471,097.0
Altered Preliminary Design 320,047.5 112,912.8 98,812.6 53,436.1 54,885.9 106,625.9 4,454.0 0.0 431,127.4
Comparison RPD-RAP 131,791.5 -4,745.2 68,688.6 28,963.1 38,882.9 -13,110.1 -3,090.0 -155,561.0 -39,969.6
Table 13 - Comparison of House Demolition between Original Plan and Altered Preliminary Design (Gangdong)
Unit:sq. meter
County/District RAP/Altered Preliminary Design Rural Residences
Enterprise Buildings School Buildings Urban Residences Total Total Concrete-Brick Brick-Wood Earth-Wood Primitive
Total - Zhaoqing RAP 99,740.0 62,339.0 15,960.0 12,965.0 8,475.0 63,372.0 3,992.0 69,533.0 236,637.0
Altered Preliminary Design 99,028.0 53,374.6 20,878.6 11,335.0 13,439.8 15,027.2 5,094.7 0.0 119,149.9
Total - Foshan RAP 102,376.0 63,985.0 16,382.0 13,308.0 8,702.0 65,287.0 4,113.0 84,822.0 256,598.0
Altered Preliminary Design 110,840.1 98,393.8 8,634.7 689.2 3,122.5 81,862.1 1,481.0 0.0 194,183.3
Subtotal -Guangzhou RAP 130,231.0 81,395.0 20,837.0 16,930.0 11,070.0 82,697.0 5,209.0 107,441.0 325,578.0
Altered Preliminary Design 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Subtotal -
Guangdong
RAP 332,347.0 207,719.0 53,179.0 43,203.0 28,247.0 211,356.0 13,314.0 261,795.0 818,812.0
Altered Preliminary Design 210,259.3 152,031.2 29,607.9 12,035.5 16,584.7 109,734.6 6,575.7 41,898.0 368,467.6
Comparison RPD-RAP -122,087.7 -55,687.8 -23,571.1 -31,167.5 -11,662.3 -101,621.4 -6,738.3 -219,897.0 -450,344.4
Total - Full Line RAP 763,194.0 476,993.0 122,110.0 99,212.0 64,867.0 485,000.0 30,554.0 617,317.0 1,896,065.0
Altered Preliminary Design 796,364.9 435,006.0 166,067.2 100,793.3 88,465.9 310,289.3 24,751.0 160,721.8 1,292,127.0
Comparison between RAP and DPTL 33,170.9 -41,987.0 43,957.2 1,581.3 23,598.9 -174,710.7 -5,803.0 -456,595.2 -603,938.0
1.3.3 PROGRESS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND
ACQUISITION $ HOUSE DEMOLITION
25 Resettlement operations for land acquisition and building demolition was
commenced at the end of 2008, the resettlement in the added coverage in the
altered preliminary design has been started in the second half of 2010. So far
permanent land acquisition area of 26,443 .4 mu has been completed, accounting
for 86.6% of the total. Buildings of 913,295 m 2 has been demolished and
removed, accounting 70.7% of the total.
26 However, the progresses in all the involved provinces/regions are not at the same
level. With respect of permanent land acquisition, 84.6% has been completed
within Guizhou Province, while the uncompleted parts are mainly in Baiyun
District, Guiyang City; 97.2% has been completed within the Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region, except for a small plots of land left aside within Lingchuan
County, Guilin City; 74.5% has been completed within Guangdong Province, with
the majority of the uncompleted left in Foshan (only 57.3% completed), while 80%
of land acquisition has been completed in Zhaoqing and Guangzhou;
27 In building demolition, 399,800 m 2 has been executed in Guizhou Province, 81.2%
complete, with the uncompleted mainly in Yunyuan District, Guiyang City, and
Lanzhou in Qiangdongnan Prefecture; 303,997.3 m 2 has been implemented
within the Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, 70.5% complete, except for
Yuansuo County, Guilin City; 209,497.6 m 2 has been completed in Guangdong
Province, accounting for 56.9%, except for Guangzhou and Foshan. (See Table 14
and Section 2.1 for more details)
Table 14 - Land Acquisition and House Demolition Progress Statistics
Item Unit Completed
Number
Completion
Progress (%)
Uncompleted
Districts
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
Total mu 26,443 86.6
Guizhou
Province mu 6,202 84.6
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Guangxi mu 12,669 97.2 Lingchuan
County, Guilin
Guangdong
Province mu 7,573 74.5 Foshan City
Building
Demolition
Total M2 913,295 70.7
Guizhou
Province M
2 399,800 81.2
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Guangxi M2 303,997 70.5
Yangsuo County,
Guilin City
Guangdong M2 209,497 56.9 Guangzhou,
Province Foshan
1.4 IDENTIFICATION OF COVERAGE OF SUPPLEMENTARY
RESETTLEMENT PLAN
1.4.1 PRINCIPLES OF IDENTIFICATION OF MATERIAL
EFFECT OF LAND ACQUISITION AND HOUSE
DEMOLITION IN ALTERED PRELIMINARY DESIGN
28 Alteration to the preliminary design removes some involved villages out of the
coverage of the original plan, and adds some others in. Work needs to be done to
identify which involved villages are added in just because of re-routing of the
railway line, so that the compensation policy as decided in the original plan cannot
cover these regions and cannot ensure to achieve the resettlement goal in these
regions, and thus results in material effect.
29 The principles to identify whether re-routing railway line has caused material
change to resettlement plan and thereby has material effect on implementation of
the resettlement action plan for land acquisition and building demolition in the
original plan include (as shown in Table 15):
(1) alteration to the railway route results in additional large-scale building remove
for land acquisition;
(2) route alternation has effect on different minority nationality regions;
(3) route alteration has effect on additional social economy zones;
(4) route alteration has effect on the districts with material changes to
compensation and resettlement policies and measures.
Table 15 - Principles for Identifying Materially Involved Regions
No. Principle Indicator
1
Re-routing railway line
results in huge effect on
land acquisition and
building demolition
Physical quantity of land acquisition and
building demolition is 10% more than that in
the original plan
Re-routing railway line results in substantial
change to position of the new/planned
station(s)
2
Route alternation has
effect on different
minority nationality
regions
The line is re-routed across new
administrative village(s), where the residents
are of minority nationality different to that in
the originally involved village.
3 Route alteration has Mountainous area or plain area different
effect on additional
social economy zones
from the original involved area
Urban region different from the original
involved region
Urban planning area or suburb different from
the original involved area
4
The new involved region
under effect of route
alteration is subject to
substantial adjustment to
resettlement policy
New compensation and resettlement policies
are applied
Great adjustment to resettlement measures
1.4.2 METHOD FOR IDENTIFYING MATERIALLY
INVOLVED REGIONS
30 Based on the defined principles, multiple indicators shall be used to perform
comprehensive review of the involved counties/towns, sub-districts and
villages/communities added in the altered preliminary design, and thereby identify
those which are not covered by the original plan and involved materially.
31 Any counties/towns, sub-districts and villages/communities which have been
revoked out of the coverage of the original resettlement plan shall be deemed as
effect-free. Any villages/communities falling in the principles of identification
shall be identified as materially involved regions, while the rest shall be deemed
as free of material effect. See Appendix 4 for more details.
32 The involved region shall be deemed to be free of material effect in one of the
following cases: Despite great route alteration, no huge effect on physical quantity
of land acquisition and building demolition has been caused except in small plots,
such as villages/communities involved by tunneling or bridging to a little extent;
Despite a substantial amount of land acquisition and building demolition in the
affect region, the involved region has the same or similar socio-economic
conditions to these in the original plan, such as in the same plain area, in the
neighboring or similar village, of the same nationality, in the same urban planning
area or urban suburb etc., for which the resettlement policy and measures as
specified in the original plan shall be applied.
33 The involved region shall be deemed to be subject to material effect in one of the
following cases: the added area has the socio-economic environment different to
that in the original plan, such as of different geographic condition, administrative
planning area or nationality, or new station to be built around the
village/community, or great change to the compensation and resettlement policies
applied to the new involved region, for which new resettlement policies and
principle shall be determined to ensure achievement of the resettlement goal.
1.4.3 IDENTIFICATION OF MATERIALLY INVOLVED
REGIONS
34 In accordance with the methods as specified in Section 1.4.2, four regions are
identified to be under material effect of land acquisition and building demolition
due to the route alteration.
35 (1)Guiyang City: This region is the central and key point where this Project joins
to Guiyang Railway. When the original resettlement action plan was developed,
the specific route for introducing this Project to the key point had not been
finalized. Route alteration to the preliminary design and the finalized construction
proposal for bullet train have caused great change to the coverage of land
acquisition and building demolition within this region. 12 villages in 3
sub-districts are revoked out of the 19 villages/communities in 9 sub-districts as
planned in the original plan, while other 8 villages/communities in 3 sub-districts
are added in. Among them, as Baiyun District, Guiyang City is where the bullet
train station will be located, due to alteration to construction proposal for bullet
train station, Dula Village in Dula Township is revoked, while two other villages
(in urban planning area), though in the same county, with completely different
socio-economic conditions are added in, which results in material effect. 3
villages/towns/sub-districts (Yunguan Township, Taici Sub-District and Ergezai
Sub-District) in Nanmin District are revoked out of coverage of the original plan,
while two other urban communities where Xingguanlu Sub-District and Zhunyi
Sub-District are located, and Taici Village, Huaguoyuan Community, Dalishi
Community and Xinzai Community etc. are added in. These added regions are
neighboring or the similar economic district to the original affect one in the
original plan. In Yunyuan District, North Sanqiao Road Community (neighboring
to Sanqiao Village and with similar socio-economic conditions) where one urban
sub-district (Sanqiao Sub-District) is located is added to the two involved urban
suburb villages as decided in the original plan. In Jinyang District where the new
North Guiyang Station is to be located, one involved village is revoked out of the
three ones as decided in the original plan, with the original coverage basically
unchanged, and free of material effect. See Table 16 and Table 17 for land
acquisition in Guiyang concerning alterations to route and stations in the
preliminary design. See Table 21 and Table 22 for more details on building
demolition.
Within the 4 involved districts in Guiyang, permanent land acquisition area of
2,210.7 mus has been decided in the altered preliminary design, The land
acquisition is mainly in Baiyun District and Jinyang District .The permanent land
acquisition area in Baiyun District is 957 mus (including 923 mus in Black Stone
Village and 34 mus in Duxi Village). The permanent land acquisition area in
Jinyang District is 996 mus (including 751 mus in Daguang Village and 244
mus in Yangguan Village). The land acquisition area in Nanmin District is only
66.1 mus while that in Yunyan District is 191.5 mus.
House demolition area in Guiyang is 336,295.6m 2 , covering 5,980 people in
1,532 households, including rural residences of 150,705.6 m 2 , industrial and
commercial enterprise buildings of 66,776.3 m 2 and urban residences of
118,823.8 m 2. House demolition is mainly within Nanmin District, in which,
building demolition area is 203,226.7 m 2 (including rural Residences of 23,875.9
m 2 , industrial and commercial enterprise building of 63,293 m
2 and urban
residences of 116,057.8 m 2). The rural residence demolition area in Baiyun
District is 84665 m 2; The building demolition area in Yunyan District is 10,331.3
m 2 (including rural residences of 4,092 m
2 , industrial and commercial enterprise
building of 3,473.3 m 2 and urban residences of 2,766 m
2). Rural residence
demolition area in Jinyang District is 38,072.7 m 2.
36 (2) Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village and Kouzai Village in Rongjiang County,
Qiangdongnan Prefecture. These three villages are the new positions where the
Rongjiang Station is re-routed, since the collective land acquisition and building
demolition for the station result in material effect. 8 involved villages in
mountainous area within the jurisdiction of Guzhou Town are all revoked. The
railway line runs directly across the urban planning area of Rongjiang County and
the new station will be built where Xiaobao Village, Kouzai Village and Yuezai
Village are located, which meets the principle for identifying great physical effect
resulted from different socio-economic districts and construction of station. See
Table 18 for physical quantity of land acquisition; see Table 22 for physical
quantity of building demolition.
In the altered preliminary design, permanent land acquisition area in Xiaobao
Village is 154.2 mus (including farmland of 107.4 mus); permanent land
acquisition area in Kouzai Village is 137.2 mus (including farmland of 136.3 mus);
permanent land acquisition area in Yuezai Village is 95 mus (including farmland
of 90 mus). In addition, residences of 2,403.22m 2 in the 3 villages are demolished
and removed, including 1,936.9 m 2 in Xiaobao Village, 4.4 m
2 in Kouzai Village
and 462 m 2 in Yuezai Village.
(3) Sidi Village, Xingping Town, Yangsuo County, Guilin City , Guangxi
Zhuang Autonomous Region This village is where the Yangsuo Station is
located in the altered preliminary design. The railway line in the original plan runs
across the town mainly through tunnel, while after the line is re-routed, the
original involved districts (Yangdi Township and Langzhou Village, Xiataoyuan
Village and Huilong Village) are all revoked, and the re-routed lines runs across
three villages in Xingping Town - Dayuang Village, Sidi Village and Baishandi
Village. The line passes Dayuang Village and Baishandi Village mainly through
tunnels, while a new station will be built where the Sidi Village is located, which
is a different socio-economic district compared to the original plan, and collective
land acquisition and building demolition result in material effect. See Table 19 for
physical quantity of land acquisition; see Table 22 for physical quantity of
building demolition.
Within Sidi Village, the permanent land acquisition area is 450.7 mus (including
farmland of 425 mus); building demolition area is 99,560 m2 (including rural
residences of 13,560 m and a brickyard building in construction of 86,000 m 2).
(4) Guangzhou City. There are similarities between Guangzhou City and
Guiyang City: The specific approach to introduce this Project into the railway
terminal in Guangzhou has been decided in the altered preliminary design. In the
original plan, only 2 villages (Weiyong Village and Shengshi Village) in 1 town
(Zhongchun Town) are involved. In the altered preliminary design, the Zhongchun
Town is revoked while Third Shibi Village, Shibi Sub-District, Hainan Village,
Zhongnan Sub-District and Zhengjiao Community, Hailong Sub-District in Liwan
District, and Yaotai Community, Kuangquan Sub-District in Yuexiu District are
added in. These additions are, compared to the coverage of the original plan, of
different socio-economic district and under material effect. See Table 20 for
physical quantity of land acquisition; see Table 22 for physical quantity of
building demolition.
In the altered preliminary design, the permanent land acquisition area in
Guangzhou is 315.7 mus, including farmland of 242 mus, woodland of 6 mus,
construction-purpose land of 39 mus, uncultivated land of 25.8 mus and other
unused land of 2.7 mus. The land acquisition area in Fanyu District is 96 mus; the
land acquisition in Liwan District is 216.7 mus; the land acquisition area in
Yuexiu District is 3 mus. In addition, in the altered preliminary design, the
building demolition area in Guangzhou is 55,134.5 m 2 (including rural residences
of 391.2 m 2, industrial and commercial enterprise buildings of 12,845.3 m
2 and
urban residences of 41,898 m 2), among which, no building demolition occurs in
Fanyu District; building demolition area in Liwan District is 12,845.3 m 2 , urban
residence demolition area in Yuexiu District is 41,898 m 2 .
37 Land acquisition and building demolition operations have been commenced in the
aforesaid districts involved in the altered preliminary design, and part of physical
structures acquisition and demolition have been completed (see Section 1.4.4. for
more details).
Table 16 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Guiyang City)
County/Distric
t Township/Town Village
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Farmland
Farm-Purp
ose Pond
Farm-Purpos
e Woodland
Construction-P
urpose Land
Uncultiva
ted Land
Oth
er
Un
use
d
Lan
d
Tot
al Subt
otal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orc
hard
Ot
her
s
Baiyun
District Dula Township
Dula Village RAP 509.
9 227.1
199.
4 13.8 46.5
23.
1 36.5 219.6 73.1 45.3 1.3
88
5.7
Black Stone
Village Planned in APD
723.
0 723.0 0.0
0.0 200.0 0.0
0.0
92
3.0
Duxi 34.0 6.0 28.0
0.0
34.
0
Subtotal -
Baiyuan
District
1 1 RAP 509.
9 227.1
199.
4 13.8 46.5
23.
1 36.5 219.6 73.1 45.3 1.3
88
5.7
1 2 Planned in APD 757.
0 6.0 28.0 723.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
95
7.0
Comparison (APD-RAP) 247.
1 -221.1
-171.
4 709.2
-46.
5
-23
.1 -36.5 -19.6 -73.1 -45.3 -1.3
71.
3
Nanmin
District
Yuanguan
Township
Youzha
Village RAP 31.7 14.1 12.4 0.9 2.9 1.4 2.3 13.7 4.5 2.8 0.1
55.
0
Houchao
Township
Taici Village Planned in APD 2.4
2.4
2.1 12.8
17.
4
Chaoyang
Village
RAP 23.5 10.5 9.2 0.6 2.1 1.1 1.7 10.1 3.4 2.1 0.1 40.
9
Planned in APD 0.2
0.2
7.9
8.1
Houchao
Village
RAP 32.6 14.5 12.8 0.9 3.0 1.5 2.3 14.1 4.7 2.9 0.1 56.
7
Planned in APD 4.3
4.3
14.2
18.
5
Sifanghe RAP 17.6 7.8 6.9 0.5 1.6 0.8 1.3 7.6 2.5 1.6 0.0 30.
5
Huaguoyuan
Sub-District
Office
South of
Jingguang
Road
RAP 15.1 6.7 5.9 0.4 1.4 0.7 1.1 6.5 2.2 1.3 0.0 26.
2
South Section
of Gui'en RAP 22.6 10.1 8.8 0.6 2.1 1.0 1.6 9.7 3.2 2.0 0.1
39.
2
Shachong
Sub-District
Yuxi
Community RAP 15.1 6.7 5.9 0.4 1.4 0.7 1.1 6.5 2.2 1.3 0.0
26.
2
Taoyuan
Village RAP 10.0 4.5 3.9 0.3 0.9 0.5 0.7 4.3 1.4 0.9 0.0
17.
4
Yutian RAP 15.1 6.7 5.9 0.4 1.4 0.7 1.1 6.5 2.2 1.3 0.0 26.
2
Taici Sub-District Art School RAP 22.6 10.1 8.8 0.6 2.1 1.0 1.6 9.7 3.2 2.0 0.1 39.
2
Ergezai
Sub-District
Huiyou RAP 12.6 5.6 4.9 0.3 1.1 0.6 0.9 5.4 1.8 1.1 0.0 21.
8
Nanzhan RAP 17.6 7.8 6.9 0.5 1.6 0.8 1.3 7.6 2.5 1.6 0.0 30.
5
Songhua RAP 15.1 6.7 5.9 0.4 1.4 0.7 1.1 6.5 2.2 1.3 0.0 26.
2
State-Owned Woodland Planned in APD 0.0
22.1
22.
1
Subtotal
-Nanmin
District
6 13 RAP 251.
0 111.8 98.2 6.8 22.9
11.
4 18.0 108.1 36.0 22.3 0.6
43
6.1
4 6 Planned in APD 6.9 0.0 0.0 6.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 24.2 34.9 0.0 0.0 66.
1
Comparison (APD-RAP) -244
.1 -111.8 -98.2 0.1
-22.
9
-11
.4 -18.0 -83.9 -1.1 -22.3 -0.6
-37
0.0
Table 17 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Guiyang City) (Continued -
1)
County/Dist
rict
Township/
Town Village
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Farmland
Farm-Pur
pose Pond
Farm-Purpos
e Woodland
Construction-
Purpose Land
Uncultiva
ted Land
Oth
er
Un
use
d
Lan
d
Tot
al Subt
otal
Pad
dy
Field
Dry
Far
m
Vegetab
le Field
Orc
har
d
Ot
her
s
Yunyan
District
Qianling
Gaicha
RAP 28.9 12.9 11.3 0.8 2.6 1.3 2.1 12.4 4.1 2.6 0.1 50.
2
Planned in APD 9.7
9.7
0.6 10.
3
Sanqiao
RAP 40.3 18.0 15.8 1.1 3.7 1.8 2.9 17.4 5.8 3.6 0.1 70.
0
Planned in APD 67.7
67.7
2.1
69.
9
State-Owned
Woodland Planned in APD
111.3
111
.3
Subtotal -
Yunyan
District
1 2 RAP 69.2 30.8 27.1 1.9 6.3 3.1 5.0 29.8 9.9 6.2 0.2 120
.2
1 2 Planned in APD 77.5 0.0 0.0 77.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 111.3 2.1 0.0 0.6 191
.5
Comparison (APD-RAP) 8.3 -30.8 -27.1 75.6 -6.3 -3.
1 -5.0 81.5 -7.8 -6.2 0.4
71.
3
Jinyang
District
Jingyang
Sub-Distri
ct
Xinzai
Village RAP 73.9 32.9 28.9 2.0 6.7 3.3 5.3 31.8 10.6 6.6 0.2
128
.3
Daguan
Village
RAP 669.2 298.
1
261.
7 18.2 61.0
30.
3 47.9 288.3 95.9 59.5 1.7
1,1
62.
5
Planned in APD 735.7 241.
4
494.
3 16.1
751
.8
Yanggua
n Village
RAP 70.6 31.5 27.6 1.9 6.4 3.2 5.1 30.4 10.1 6.3 0.2 122
.7
Planned in APD 244.3 43.1 201.
2
244
.3
Subtotal -
Jinyang 1 3 RAP 813.7
362.
4
318.
2 22.1 74.1
36.
8 58.2 350.5 116.6 72.3 2.1
1,4
13.
District 5
1 2 Planned in APD 980.0 284.
6
695.
5 0.0 0.0 0.0 16.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
996
.1
Comparison (APD-RAP) 166.3 -77.8 377.
3 -22.1
-74.
1
-36
.8 -42.1 -350.5 -116.6 -72.3 -2.1
-41
7.4
Total -
Guiyang
9 19 RAP 1,643
.8
732.
1
642.
9 44.6
149.
8
74.
4 117.6 708.1 235.6 146.1 4.2
285
5.5
7 12 Planned in APD 1,821
.5
290.
6
723.
5 807.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 335.5 37.1 0.0 0.6
2,2
10.
7
Comparison (APD-RAP) 177.7 -441.
5 80.6 762.8
-149
.8
-74
.4 -101.5 -372.6 -198.5 -146.1 -3.6
-64
4.8
Table 18 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Xiaobao Village,
Yuezai Village and Kouzai Village, Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan Prefecture)
Towns
hip/To
wn
Village
RAP/Alter
ed
Preliminar
y Design
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodla
nd
Constru
ction-Pu
rpose
Land
Uncultiva
ted Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field Dry Farm
Vegetabl
e Field Orchard Others
Guzho
u
Town
No. 2
Village RAP 44.3 19.7 17.3 1.2 4.0 2.0 3.2 19.1 6.3 3.9 0.1 76.9
No. 3
Village RAP 13.6 6.1 5.3 0.4 1.2 0.6 1.0 5.9 2.0 1.2 0.0 23.7
Gaoxing
Village RAP 21.3 9.5 8.3 0.6 1.9 1.0 1.5 9.2 3.1 1.9 0.1 37.0
Ma'an
Village RAP 32.8 14.6 12.8 0.9 3.0 1.5 2.3 14.1 4.7 2.9 0.1 56.9
Lingzhen
Village RAP 13.6 6.1 5.3 0.4 1.2 0.6 1.0 5.9 1.9 1.2 0.0 23.6
Dabai
Village RAP 19.3 8.6 7.6 0.5 1.8 0.9 1.4 8.3 2.8 1.7 0.0 33.6
Gaodong
Village RAP 6.4 2.9 2.5 0.2 0.6 0.3 0.5 2.8 0.9 0.6 0.0 11.1
Sanpan
Village RAP 6.9 3.1 2.7 0.2 0.6 0.3 0.5 3.0 1.0 0.6 0.0 12.1
Yuezai
Village
Planned
in APD 90.0 89.9 0.1
0.7
4.2
95.0
Kouzai
Village
Planned
in APD 136.3 136.3
0.0
1.0 137.2
Xiaobao
Village
Planned
in APD 107.4 106.6 0.8
25.9
12.0 5.3
3.6 154.2
Subtot
al
8 RAP 158.2 70.6 61.8 4.4 14.3 7.2 11.4 68.3 22.7 14.0 0.3 274.9
3 Planned in
APD 333.7 332.8 0.9 0.0 26.6 0.0 0.0 16.3 5.3 0.0 4.5 386.4
Comparison (APD-RAP) 175.5 262.2 -60.9 -4.4 12.3 -7.2 -11.4 -52.0 -17.4 -14.0 4.2 111.5
Table 19 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Sidi Village, Yangsuo
County)
Townshi
p/Town Village
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Farmland
Farm-Purp
ose Pond
Farm-Purpos
e Woodland
Construction-P
urpose Land
Uncultiva
ted Land
Oth
er
Un
use
d
Lan
d
To
tal Subt
otal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orc
hard
Ot
her
s
Xingpin
g Town
Xiangfen
gchang
Village
RAP 34.5 15.4 13.5 0.9 3.1 1.6 2.5 14.9 5.0 3.1 0.1 60
.0
Dayuan
Village Planned in APD
148.
4 16.7 13.6
118.
1 0.7 13.9
3.2 1.1
16
7.
3
Sidi
Village Planned in APD
425.
0 17.2 17.5
390.
3 3.0 20.0
1.7 1.1
45
0.
7
Baishand
i Village Planned in APD 43.1 0.6 1.0
41.5
17.0 43.4
16.2
11
9.
7
Subtotal
1 RAP 34.5 15.4 13.5 0.9 3.1 1.6 2.5 14.9 5.0 3.1 0.1 60
.0
3 Planned in APD 616.
5 34.4 32.2 0.0
549.
9 0.0 20.8 77.2 0.0 21.0 2.2
73
7.
7
Comparison (APD-RAP) 582.
0 19.0 18.7 -0.9
546.
8
-1.
6 18.3 62.3 -5.0 17.9 2.1
67
7.
7
Table 20 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Guangzhou City)
County/D
istrict
Township/T
own Village
RAP/Alter
ed
Preliminar
y Design
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Constru
ction-P
urpose
Land
Uncultiv
ated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Veget
able
Field
Orcha
rd Others
Fanyu
District
Zhongchun
Town
Weiyong RAP 291.2 129.7 113.9 7.9 26.5 13.2 20.8 125.4 41.7 25.9 0.7 505.9
Shengshi RAP 345.4 153.8 135.1 9.4 31.5 15.6 24.7 148.8 49.5 30.7 0.9 600.0
Shibi
Sub-District
Third
Shibi
Village
Planned in
APD 51.0 9.0 29.0 13.0
6.0 39.0
96.0
Liwan
District
Zhongnan
Sub-District Hainan
Planned in
APD 188.2 80.2
108.0
25.8 2.7 216.7
Yuexiu
District
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Communit
y
Planned in
APD 3.0 3.0
3.0
Subtotal -Guangzhou
2 RAP 636.6 283.5 249.0 17.3 58.0 28.8 45.6 274.2 91.2 56.6 1.6 1,105.9
2 Planned in
APD 242.2 92.2 29.0 13.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 39.0 25.8 2.7 315.7
Comparison
(APD-RAP) -394.4 -191.3 -220.0 -4.3 50.0 -28.8 -45.6 -268.2 -52.2 -30.8 1.1 -790.2
Table 21 - Statistics on House Demolition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design
Provi
nce/C
ity
County
/Distric
t
Township/T
own Village
Rem
oved
Hou
seho
lds
Remo
ved
Popul
ation
Rural Residences
Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildin
gs
Urban
Residence
s
Total Total
Concret
e-Brick
Brick-
Wood
Earth
-Woo
d
Primiti
ve
Guiya
ng
City,
Guizh
ou
Provi
nce
Baiyun
District
Dula
Township
Black Stone
Village 125 500 60,460.3 36,991.8 2,446.5 0.0 21,022.0
60,460.3
Duxi Village 77 247 24,204.6 22,167.8 291.8 0.0 1,745.1
24,204.6
Subtota
l 1 2 202 747 86,665.0 59,159.6 4,738.3 0.0 22,767.1
0.0 0.0 84,665.0
Nanmin
District
Houchao
Township
Chaoyang
Village 35 140 4,857.2 4,729.2 108.1
20.0
4,857.2
Houchao
Village 86 344 19,018.7 17,026.4 234.9
1,757.4
19,018.7
Zhunyi
Sub-District
Wuyanqiao
Community 26 78
4,000.0
15,019.8 19,019.8
Huaguoyuan
Sub-District
Office
Huaguoyuan
Community 125 798
20,500.0
32,883.6 53,383.6
Shachong
Sub-District
Yuxi
Community +
Dalishi
Community
320 960
18,793.0
47,403.3 66,196.3
Xingguan Xinzai 336 1,392
20,000.0
20,751.0 40,751.0
Sub-District Community
Subtota
l 5 9 928 3,712 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 0.0 116,057.8 203,226.7
Yunyan
District
Qianling Gaicha
Village 28 90 3,371.5 2,927.9
443.6 0.0
3,371.5
Sanqiao
Village 5 30 720.5 590.7 116.6 13.2 0.0
720.5
Sanqiao
Sub-District
North Sanqiao
Road
Community
78 324
3,473.3
2,766 6,239.3
Subtota
l 2 3 111 444 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
Table 22 - Statistics on House Demolition in Materially Effected Districts in Altered Preliminary Design (Continued - 1)
Provinc
e/City
County/D
istrict
Township/
Town Village
Remov
ed
Househ
olds
Remo
ved
Popul
ation
Rural Residences
Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildin
gs
Urban
Residenc
es
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-
Wood
Earth-Wo
od Primitive
Jinyang
District
Jinyang
District
Jingyang
Sub-Distric
t
Daguan
Village 164 546 33,478.9 25,527.6 3,951.8
3,999.5
33,478.9
Yanggu
an
Village
127 531 4,593.7
973.9
3,619.8
4,593.7
Subtotal 1 2 291 1,077 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Total -
Guiyang 9 16 1,532 5,980 150,705.6 109,961.3 8,123.6 456.8 32,163.8 66,766.3 0.0 118,823.8 336,295.6
Qiangdo
ngnan
Prefectur
e,
Guizhou
Province
Rongjiang
County
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village 16 71 462.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 462.0
462.0
Kouzai
Village 1 5 4.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.4
4.4
Xiaobao
Village 15 68 1,936.9 39.9 455.9 1,008.4 432.7
1,936.9
Subtotal 1 3 32 144 2,403.22 39.9 455.86 1,008.36 899.1 0 0 0 2,403.22
Guilin,
Guangxi
Yangsuo
County
Xingping
Town
Sidi
Village 62 258 13,560.0 6,600.0 3,000.0 2,200.0 1,760.0 86,000.0
99,560.0
Subtotal 1 1
Guangzh
ou City,
Guangdo
ng
Liwan
District
Zhongnan
Sub-District
Hainan
Village 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4
391.2
Hailong
Sub-District
Zengjia
o
Commu
nity
12,845.3
12,845.3
Subtotal 2 2 6 21 391 263 95 11 22 12,845 0 0 13,236
Yuexiu
District
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Commu
nity
302 1,000
41,898.0 41,898.0
Subtotal 1 1 302 1,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41,898 41,898
Total - 3 3 308 1,021 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Guangzho
u
Total 14 23 1,921 7,348 165,060.0 116,864.0 9,674.1 3,676.5 34,845.3 167,611.6 0.0 160,721.8 493,393.4
1.4.4 IMPLEMENTATION OF RESETTLEMENT IN
MATERIALLY INVOLVED DISTRICTS
(1) Land Acquisition and House Demolition Progress
38 As identified in the altered preliminary design, the materially involved districts
include:14 villages/communities, 9 towns/sub-districts, 4 districts in Guiyang City,
Guizhou Province; 3 villages, 1 town in Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan
Prefecture; 1 village, 1 town in Yangsuo County, Guilin City; 4
villages/communities, 4 sub-districts, 3 districts in Guangzhou City. In summary,
22 villages/communities, 15 townships/towns/sub-districts in 9 counties/districts
are under material effect, among which, 16 villages/communities are subject to
land acquisition while 20 ones subject to building demolition.
39 Land acquisition and building demolition have been commenced in the districts
(see Appendix 8 and Appendix 9 for more details). The detailed progress is shown
below:
40 Permanent land acquisition of 1,958 mus has been completed, accounting for 58.2%
of the total (3,364 mus), among which, farmland of 1,669 mus has been
requisitioned, accounting for 58.6 %. The districts where permanent land
acquisition has been fully completed include: Nanming District, Yunyan District
and Jinyang District in Guiyang City, Sidi Village, Yangsuo County, Guilin City
and Fanyu District in Guangzhou City. The districts where land acquisition has
not been commenced include: Black Stone Village and Duxi Village in Dula
Township, Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village, Sidi Village and
Yuezai Village in , Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village, Sidi Village
and Yuezai Village in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County, and Yaotai Community,
Kuangquan Sub-District, Yuexiu District, Guangzhou City. The districts where
land acquisition has been partly completed include: Hainan Village, Zhongnan
Sub-District, Liwan District, and Guangzhou City (72.5% completed).
41 The demolished and removed buildings include residences and non-residential
buildings.in residence demolition, rural residence of 66431.8 m 2 and urban
residences of 118824 m 2 have been demolished and removed, respectively
accounting for 40% and 74%. The completion of building demolition in all
districts is shown below: all urban residence demolition ( 118,824 m 2 ) in
involved districts in Guiyang City has been completed, while rural residence
demolition of 66,041 m2 has been completed, accounting for 44.4%. All involved
rural residences which have not been demolished are in Baiyun District. Rural
residences in 3 villages in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County and Sidi Village in
Xingping Town, Yangsuo County have not been removed yet. Though rural
residence demolition in Liwan District, Guangzhou City has been completed, the
enterprise building demolition in Liwan District and urban residence demolition in
Yuexiu District have not been commenced yet.
42 Non-residential buildings to be demolished include industrial and commercial
enterprise/ institution buildings and school buildings, among which, industrial and
commercial enterprise/ institution building demolition area is 167611 m 2 , mainly
distributed in Guiyang City and Guangzhou City, and 105 enterprises/institutions
are involved and industrial and commercial enterprise/ institution buildings of
66,766.3 m 2 have been demolished, accounting for 40%. All affected
enterprises/institution buildings in Guiyang City have been demolished.
Demolition of one brickyard in construction in Sidi Village, Yangsuo County and
two enterprises in Liwan District, Guangzhou City has not been commenced. No
school is under material effect of the altered preliminary design.
43 Involved infrastructures include: a wide range of infrastructure is involved and the
demolition and recovery mechanisms are of great variety. Currently 90% of the
facilities have been demolished and rebuilt. Roads and water supplies will be
recovered by the construction contractors and the expenses will be contained in
the construction contract price.Pole-mounted wires, electric and communication
cable will be demolished and rebuilt by the specialized agencies.
(2) Implementation of Compensation Standard
44 All compensation policies for permanent land acquisition in the materially
involved districts are in compliance with the resettlement plan for this Project.
45 The compensation prices for demolition of urban residences and
enterprise/institution buildings are decided by certified asset evaluation agencies
based on the market replacement cost. The rebuilding costs for removed/rebuilt
infrastructure are also determined by certified asset evaluation agencies based on
the replacement cost. The rebuilding cost for demolished rural residences are
estimated by the local resettlement authorities based on the local building
replacement cost and determined and released with policy document for
implementation.
(3) Resettlement Situation
46 PROGRESS IN RESETTLEMENT:
All compensation for permanent land acquisition has been paid in full to the
village/farmer group accounts by the resettlement authorities, and the
village/villager team will decide distribution of the compensation on an
independent basis. Two settlement methods will be applied: unified reallocation of
land shall be done within village/farmer group and the compensation will be paid
per capita, or compensation in cash will be paid directly to the affected households.
The manpower of affected households can not only work on the remaining
farmland owned by them, but also participate in the specialized training organized
by the government. The local government will recommend the properly trained
manpower to business in major or coastal cities through cooperation with them. In
case of allocation in cash, the rural families with very a little or without farmland
(farmland area per capita <0.3 mu) will be offered social security resettlement.
Currently, land reallocation operations are being carried out by local
village/farmer group and social security policies have been issued by all levels of
authorities. The Project Owner has provided the provincial department of social
security with funds for social security resettlement of the farmers losing farmland.
The resettlement agencies of local governments are checking and verifying the
number of farmers losing farmland. As land acquisition is still in process, the
verification is being carried out.
47 Progress in residence demolition and resettlement:
Guiyang City:All residence demolition in involved districts in Nanmin District,
Xingyan District and Jinyang District, Guiyang has been completed. Except that a
very small number of involved households choose to monetary resettlement, most
choose to replace the original property right with new building to prevent the risk
of building price rise. All buildings for resettlement will be purchased by the
resettlement authorities or constructed by estate developers commissioned by the
government.Currently, the resettlement communities which have been completed
and used include shenquanliuyun resettlement community, Yunyan District, where
50 households have moved in, lveyuan resettlement community, Nanmin District,
where 600 households have moved in, Jiaoyishan resettlement community,
Nanmin District, where 231 households have moved in. Resettlement
communities which have been completed but not used due to the involved
households' reasons (e.g. Property right dispute etc.) Include: new garden
community, which are to contain 30 involved households in Yunyan District.
Resettlement communities which are still in construction include: Daguan Village
resettlement community in Jinyang District , Qianjiang Road No. 5 and No. 6
resettlement community in Nanmin district. Double compensations for interim
resettlement are paid to the involved people who choose to move into these
resettlement communities for rent of interim buildings. Resettlement communities
which are still planned are black stone resettlement community and Duxi Village
resettlement community in Baiyun District.
Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village and Kouzai Village in Rongjiang County,
Qiangdongnan Prefecture: Due to land acquisition and building demolition for
construction of the county-level station, it is planned to construct a collective
resettlement site for the involved households. This resettlement site is still in
planning now and building demolition in the three villages has not been
commenced yet.
Sidi Village, Xingping Town, Yangsuo County, and Guilin City:Due to land
acquisition and building demolition for construction of the county-level station, it
is planned to construct a collective resettlement site for the involved households.
This resettlement site is still in planning now and building demolition in Sidi
Village has not been commenced yet.
Guangzhou City:6 households' residences have been demolished in Liwan
District, and the households have been relocated to the newly built resettlement
site - New Hainan Village. The urban residents subjected to building demolition in
Yuexiu Districtwill be relocated to the planned collective resettlement zone in the
neighboring cities.
48 Progress in non-residential building demolition and resettlement:
since enterprise building demolition will have effect on corporate
production/operation and staff's life, this project has attracted enterprises' attention
since release of construction information, and involved enterprises have put the
facility demolition on the agenda. Generally speaking, non-state-owned and
small-sized enterprises usually rent buildings or land to develop corporate
production/operation, 85 enterprises/institutions are materially involved by this
project, most of which are located in Guiyang City. For their removal and
reconstruction, the resettlement authorities will carry out their demolition and
rebuilding mainly by resettlement with funds, supported by assistance with the
reconstruction.Private/non-state-owned enterprises usually have solved their
demolition and rebuilding and so tend to desire monetary compensation, while
state-owned enterprises and large-sized institutions have the ability to solve their
demolition and rebuilding.
49 Progress IN Recovery and Rebuilding of Infrastructure:
More than 90% of the infrastructures have been demolished, but most of them,
such as involved roads, water conservancy facilities, bridges and pole-mounted
cables etc., are still to be recovered/rebuilt, and the construction contractor for this
Project has provided interim alternatives for the local communities.
2. REVIEW OF IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND ACQUISITION
& HOUSE DEMOLITION
2.1 IMPLEMENTATION OF LAND ACQUISITION & HOUSE
DEMOLITION FOR THIS PROJECT
2.1.1 PROGRESS IN COMPENSATION FOR LAND
ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT AND
RECOVERY
(1) Progress in Land Acquisition
50 Land acquisition and building demolition for this Project was commenced
respectively in November 2008 in Guizhou Province, in March 2009 in Guangxi
and in January 2009 in Guangdong Province, and carried forward in compliance
with the requirements as specified in the RAP. In June 2010, NDRC agreed that
this Project shall be constructed as a dedicated passenger transport line, and the
design institution made necessary alterations to the design proposal. From the
second half of 2010 to the first half of 2011, as the construction drawing has been
offered by the design institution to the construction contractors, the local
resettlement authorities have confirmed the coverage of the altered preliminary
design and started land acquisition and building demolition in the added involved
districts.
51 By the end of March 2012, land acquisition of 26,443 mus has been completed,
accounting for 86.6% of the planned land acquisition (30,525.3 mus). Farmland
acquisition of 15,591.4 mus has been completed, accounting for 91.2% of the
planned quantity. All of pond acquisition (213.2 mus) has been completed.
Woodland acquisition of 7,617.8 mus has been completed, accounting for 96.4%
of the planned quantity, while construction-purpose land of 1,659.1 mus has been
completed, accounting for 76% of the planned. Uncultivated land acquisition of
1,527.1 mus has been completed, accounting for 60.5% of the planned quantity.
Other unused land acquisition of 194.8 mus has been completed, accounting for
32.1% of the planned quantity.
52 Progress in permanent land acquisition in all provinces/regions is not at the same
level. Permanent land acquisition of 6,202 mus has been completed in Guizhou
Province, accounting for 84.6% of the planned land acquisition (7,331.1 mus),
among which, as the land acquisition for construction of bullet train station in
Baiyun District, Guiyang City has not been commenced, the actual land
acquisition is 1,254 mus, accounting for 56.7% of the planned land acquisition.
Land acquisition of 3,459 mus has been completed in Qiangnan Prefecture,
accounting for 97.9% of the planned quantity. Land acquisition of 1,490 mus has
been completed in Qiangdongnan Prefecture, accounting for 93.8% of the planned
quantity. Land acquisition of 12,669 mus has been completed in Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region, accounting for 97.2% of the planned quantity. In Guangxi,
compensation operations for all land acquisition have been completed in Liuzhou
and Hezhou, while 95.3% of the land acquisition in Guilin has been completed.
Land acquisition of 7,573 mus in Guangdong Province has been completed,
accounting for 74.5% of the planned quantity (10,165.8 mus), among which, land
acquisition of 5,882 mus has been completed in Zhaoqing, accounting for 80.1%;
1,438 mus has been completed in Foshan, accounting for 57.3% of the planned
quantity; 253 mus has been completed in Guangzhou, accounting for 80.1% of the
planned quantity. See Table 23, Table 24 and Appendix 6 for more details.
53 The construction contractors have entered the construction sites along the line.
Land of 27,276 mus for temporary use has been used by the contractors,
accounting 100% of the planned quantity.
(2) Progress in Compensation for Land Acquisition
54 In compliance with the RAP for this Project and related Chinese laws and
regulations, the local governments along the railway line have specially
established organizations in charge of resettlement of migrants for this Project,
and assigned experienced officials to handle the operations. A comparison
between the compensation criterion to be applied in compensation for land
acquisition and the one as required in this Project is provided in Appendix
13.10.2.
Table 23 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition for this Project
County/Di
strict
RAP/Alter
ed
Preliminar
y Design
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Guiyang
City
Planned in
APD 1,821.5 290.6 723.5 807.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 335.5 37.1 0.6 0.0 2,210.7
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
1,064 285 695 84 0 0 16 136 37 1 0 1,254
Progress
(%) 58.4% 97.9% 96.1% 10.5% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 40.4% 100.0% 100.5% 0.0% 56.7%
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Planned in
APD 1,988.7 1,151.0 784.4 0.0 42.3 11.0 0.0 1,323.0 172.1 49.1 0.0 3,533.0
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
1,968 1,147 771 0 41 9 0 1,285 172 33 0 3,459
Progress
(%) 99.0% 99.7% 98.3% 0.0% 97.9% 77.2% 0.0% 97.1% 100.0% 67.9% 0.0% 97.9%
Qiangdon
gnan
Prefecture
Planned in
APD 847.0 700.9 73.4 0.0 63.4 9.3 0.0 628.9 82.2 11.2 18.1 1,587.4
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
778 648 57 0 63.4 9 0 629 82 1 0 1,490
Progress
(%) 91.8% 92.4% 77.5% 0.0%
100.1
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 8.9% 0.0% 93.8%
Total -
GuiZhou
Planned in
APD 4,657.2 2,142.4 1,581.3 807.4 105.7 20.3 16.1 2,287.4 291.4 60.8 18.1 7,331.1
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
3,810 2,080 1,524 84 105 18 16 2,049 291 35 0 6,202
Progress
(%) 81.8% 97.1% 96.4% 10.5% 99.2% 87.7% 100.0% 89.6% 100.0% 57.4% 0.0% 84.6%
Liuzhou Planned in 504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9
453.7 5.6 6.6
970.0
City APD
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9
453.7 5.6 6.6
970.0
Progress
(%) 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
616.5 34.41 32.21 0.00 549.91
20.8 77.2 0.0 23.2 0.0 737.7
Progress
(%) 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 110.3% 0.0% 100.0%
Guilin
City
Planned in
APD 4,723.9 1101.3 933.2 2.1 2,641.4 45.9 20.8 2,401.5 287.0 137.6 2.2 7,572.9
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
4,676 1,101 933 0 2,641 0 21 2,101 276 140 0 7,213
Progress
(%) 99.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 87.5% 96.3% 101.6% 0.0% 95.3%
Progress
(%) 100.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Hezhou
City
Planned in
APD 3,036.6 1,781.8 1.2 1,198.7 23.1 31.8 0.0 901.0 312.1 235.7 0.0 4,485.5
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
3,037 1,782 1 1,199 23 32 0 901 312 236 0 4,485
Progress
(%) 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total -
Guangxi
Planned in
APD 8,264.5 3,074.0 1,225.3 1,200.8 2,673.9 90.6 20.8 3,756.2 604.8 379.9 2.2 13,028.4
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
8,217 3,074 1,225 1,199 2,674 45 21 3,455 594 379.9 0 12,669
Progress 99.4% 100.0 100.0 99.8% 100.0 49.4% 100.0% 92.0% 98.2% 100.0% 0.0% 97.2%
(%) % % %
Table 24 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition for this Project (Continued)
County/Di
strict
RAP/Alter
ed
Preliminar
y Design
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Zhaoqing
City
Planned in
APD 2,617.6 1,906.8 214.7 9.9 331.4 154.8 176.4 1,606.1 523.3 1,861.6 555.3 7,340.3
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
2,526 1,878 217 0 277 155 176 1,570 348 1,074 188 5,882
Progress
(%) 96.5% 98.5%
101.1
% 0.0% 83.6%
100.0
% 100.0% 97.7% 66.5% 57.7% 33.9% 80.1%
Foshan
City
Planned in
APD 1,310.5 1,110.5 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 250.0 700.0 220.0 29.3 2,509.8
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
811 811 100 0 0 0 0 237 376 13 2 1,438
Progress
(%) 61.8% 73.0% 50.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 94.8% 53.7% 5.8% 5.7% 57.3%
Guangzho
u City
Planned in
APD 242.2 92.2 29.0 13.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 64.8 0.0 2.7 315.8
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
180 49 29 13 88 0 0 6 39 26 3 253
Progress 74.1% 53.4% 100.0% 100.0% 81.8% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 60.2% 0.0% 100.0% 80.1%
(%)
Total -
Guangdon
g
Planned in
APD 4,170.3 3,109.5 443.7 22.9 439.4 154.8 176.4 1,862.1 1,288.1 2,081.6 587.3 10,165.8
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
3,516.4 2,737.2 346.1 13.0 365.2 154.8 176.4 1,812.5 762.9 1,112.3 192.6 7,573.0
Progress
(%) 84.3% 88.0% 78.0% 56.8% 83.1% 100.0% 100.0% 97.3% 59.2% 53.4% 32.8% 74.5%
Total -
Full Line
Planned in
APD 17,092.0 8,325.9 3,250.3 2,031.1 3,219.0 265.7 213.2 7,905.8 2,184.3 2,522.3 607.6 30,525.3
Progress
in Land
Acquisitio
n
15,543.4 7,890.
8
3,095.
2 1,296.1
3,144.
0 217.3 213.2 7,316.8 1,648.5 1,527.1 192.6
26,443.
8
Progress
(%) 90.9% 94.8% 95.2% 63.8% 97.7% 81.8% 100.0% 92.6% 75.5% 60.5% 31.7% 86.6%
55 The compensation criterion for land acquisition in this Project has been developed based on
the following related policies:
The Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China issued in
August 1998; The Decision on Modifying the Law of Land Administration of the
People's Republic of China revised by the NPC on August 28, 2004;
Law of the People’s Republic of China on Administration of the Urban Real Estate
issued in April 1994;
The State Council's Decision on Deepening Reform and Managing Strictly Land
(No. CI-2004-28);
Regulations on the Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the
People's Republic of China issued in December 1998;
Regulations of the State Council on the Administration of the Demolition and
Demolition of Urban Buildings issued in June 1991;
Regulations on the Protection of Prime Cropland issued in December 1998;
Instructions on Improving Land Acquisition Compensation System (No.
NI-2004-238);
Notice on Strengthening Land Control and Related Issues (No. CI-2006-31);
Notice of the State Council on Further Strengthening Land Control and Protection of
Farmland issued in 1997;
The Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China and the
Regulations on Implementation of it;
Rural Land Contract Law;
Organic Law on Village Committee;
Regulations of Guizhou Province on Land Control issued in September 2000;
Regulations of Guizhou Province on Administration of Urban House Demolition &
Removal (Code No. 48) issued by the People's Government of Guizhou Province on
July 2000;
Notice on Provision of Employment Training and Social Security for
Land-Requisitioned Farmers, issued by the Government of Guizhou Province on
December 7, 2007;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Plan for Land Expropriation in Construction of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guizhou Section) (No. QOLR-2008-134);
Trial Measures for Implementation of Social Security for Land-Requisitioned Farmers
in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, issued by the Regional Office of Labor and
Social Security, Office of Land and Resources and Office of Finance on January 22,
2008;
Notice on Issuance of Average Three-Year Output Value Standard for Requisitioned
Land and Compensation Standard for House Demolition for Key Infrastructure
Construction Project in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region (No. GIR-2009-52);
Measures for Land Acquisition and House Demolition Compensation for
Infrastructure Construction in Guangdong Province (No. GDGO-2003-46);
Opinions on Resolution of Social Security-Related Issues, issued by the Government
of Guangdong Province on September 9, 2007;
Compensation & Protection Standard of Guangdong Province for Land Acquisition
(No. GDOLR-2006-149) issued on July 2006;
Regulations of Guiyang City on Appraisal of Demolished Houses (Code No. 142)
issued by Guiyang Municipal Government in March 2005;
Notice on Issuance of Resettlement & Compensation Scheme for House Demolition
for New Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Qiangdongnan Prefecture Section) (No.
QPGOI-2009-3) issued by prefecture government office;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Standard of Land Acquisition for Construction of
Guiyang-Guangzhou High-Speed Railway (Sanjiang Section) (No. SGI-2009-1) issued
by the People's Government of Dong Autonomous County, Sanjiang;
Supplementary Notice on Issuance of Compensation Standard of Land Acquisition for
Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou High-Speed Railway (Sanjiang Section) (No.
SGI-2009-5) issued by the People's Government of Dong Autonomous County,
Sanjiang;
Notice on Issuance of Measures for Implementation of land acquisition and building
demolition for construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway (Longsheng Section) (No.
LGI-2009-3) issued by Longsheng Various Nationalities Autonomous County;
Notice on Compensation Standard of Land Acquisition for Construction of
Guangyang-Guangzhou/Hunan-Guangxi High-Speed Railway (Lingui Section) (No.
LGI-2009-12) issued by the People's Government of Lingui County;
Notice on Issuance of Annual Average Output Value Criteria and Compensation
Standard of House Demolition for Requisitioned Land for Key Infrastructure
Construction in Autonomous Region Issued by NDRC of Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region and Distributed by the People's Government of Lingchuan
County (LGO-2009-17);
Notice on Issuance of Rules on Supporting land acquisition and building demolition
for Key Infrastructure Construction Project Issued by NDRC of GZAR and Approved
by Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region (No. GXGI-2008-63);
Notice on Issuance of Rules on Supporting land acquisition and building demolition
for Key Infrastructure Construction Project Issued by NDRC of GZAR, Approved by
Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region and Distributed by the People's Government of
Lingchuan County (LGO-2009-18);
Notice on Implementation of the Rules of GZAR on House Demolition on Collective
Land for Key Infrastructure Construction (No. LCGI-2009-16) issued by the People's
Government of Lingchuan County;
Notice on Matters Concerning Land Acquisition and House Demolition for
Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway (Yangsuo Section) (NO. SGI-2009-11)
issued by the People's Government of Yangsuo County;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Standard for Land Acquisition and House
Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway (Gongcheng Section)
(NO. GGI-2009-5) issued by the People's Government of Autonomous County;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Standard for Land Acquisition and House
Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway (NO. HGI-2009-10)
issued by the People's Government of Hezhou City;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Standard for Land Acquisition and House
Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway and
Nanning-Guangzhou Railway (Zhaoqing Section) (NO. ZOLR-2009-2);
Notice on Issuance of Implementing Regulations on Compensation for Land
Acquisition and House Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway
(Huairou Section) (No. HOLR-2009-7);
Notice on Issuance of Implementing Regulations on Compensation for Land
Acquisition and House Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway
(Guangning Section) (No. NGO-2009-22);
Notice on Issuance of Measures for Implementing Compensation for Land Acquisition
and House Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway and
Nanning-Guangzhou Railway (Dinghu Section) (No. ZDGO-2009-10);
Notice on Issuance of compensation Scheme for Land Acquisition and House
Demolition for Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway and
Nanning-Guangzhou Railway (Zhaoqing Section) (No. ZOLRI-2009-2);
Notice on Issuance of Resettlement Measures of Zhaoqing City for Requisition of
Rural Collective Land for Construction of Key Project (ZOLRI-2009-30);
Meeting Summary on Issues Related to House Demolition in Longli County for
Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou railway (GRCSM-2009-01);
Meeting Summary on Coordinating Issues Related to Demolition and Removal of
Pu'an Middle School in Sandu County and House Demolition in Longli County for
Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou railway (GCSM-2009-08);
56 The compensation standard for permanent land acquisition as required in the resettlement
plan for this Project has been implemented in all involved provinces/regions as below: As
per the compensation and resettlement policy document (No. ZOLRI-2008-134) developed
by Office of Land and Resources of Guizhou Province, compensation for land acquisition
for this Project will be carried out by means of monetary compensation in combination of
other compensation modes. implementation of the compensation standard for permanent
land acquisition is basically in compliance with the requirement in the RAP (Appendix
3.10.2). The monetary compensation is paid directly to the rural collectives and farmers
with land requisitioned by multiplying the approved compensation criterion with the land
area. As for multi-approach compensation, the payment is calculated by multiplying the
corresponding prime cropland area with 30 times of the current annual output value of the
farmland minus the compensation criterion for general farmland, so as to put into practice
the social security measure and mechanism. The multi-approach compensation is mainly
used for the following: 1. land reallocation for the farmers losing all farmland;2. purchasing
pension insurance and medical insurance for the farmers subjected to land acquisition;3.
land management and regulation for the rural collectives and farmers subjected to land
acquisition for improvement to agricultural production conditions;4. supporting investment
in the infrastructure used for collective resettlement of the farmers subjected to land
acquisition;5. setup of rural collective enterprise;6. dealing with the issues left unsettled in
monetary compensation.
57 The actually implemented compensation criteria for land acquisition within Guangxi
Zhuang Autonomous Region basically meet the requirement in the resettlement action plan
for this Project, and mostly even above these as specified in the resettlement action plan,
except in a few types of land in some counties (garden plots in Sanjiang County , dry farm
in Longsheng County, construction-purpose land in Lingui County, paddy field in Yangsuo
County and fishpond in Hezhou City).
58 During implementation of the compensation criteria within Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous
Region, the criteria below those as specified in the resettlement plan are applied just
because the compensation criteria in the plan have been decided based on city, leaving
aside the differences between output values of the land across the counties/districts within
the city. It has been verified by the Office of Land and Resources of Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region that these compensation criteria below the requirements in the
resettlement plan for this Project are in compliance with the land compensation policy
developed by Guangxi government. See Appendix 13.10.2 for more details.
59 In Guangdong Province , proper compensation criteria for permanent land acquisition have
been determined in the involved counties/districts based on the policies of provincial
government in combination of the specific conditions in the involved towns. The actually
implemented compensation criteria have met the requirements in the resettlement action
plan for this Project.
60 The compensation for land temporarily requisitioned for this Project is carried out by
different means in the involved three provinces/regions, and all equivalent to or above the
compensation criteria as specified in the resettlement plan. The details are shown below:
The local compensation criteria for permanent land acquisition has been applied for all land
temporarily requisitioned within Guizhou Province, while in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous
Region, the compensation for land temporarily requisitioned is appropriated by the
provincial resettlement authority to the counties/districts at a rate of 10,000 yuan per mu,
and the local resettlement authorities will pay the compensation to the involved farmers in
accordance with based actual conditions in different counties/districts on either permanently
requisitioned land or output value validity period. In Guangdong Province, compensation
for land acquisition is paid by the construction contractors to the involved people based on
output value validity period.
(4) Progress in Compensation Payment and Resettlement for Land Acquisition and
House Demolition
61 The compensative fund for land acquisition and building demolition in this Project will be
raised and appropriated by the local governments in the three provinces/regions, and in the
basically same procedure. For example, the fund for Guizhou Province will be appropriated
in the following procedure: In addition, the compensations for building demolition and
removal will be appropriated by the Provincial Railway Construction Office to the
resettlement authorities in the prefectures/cities/counties. Based on the principle of "first
prepare compensations in place, last put land into use", the compensations have been
appropriated properly and paid in full to the involved people. Currently, 5,389,009,900
yuan of compensations for land acquisition and building demolition have been appropriated
to the resettlement authorities in the counties/districts, among which 3,716,422,400 yuan
has been paid to the involved people. In Guizhou Province, 1,392,150,600 yuan has been
offered to the involved cities/ prefectures and 1,135,928,300 yuan has been paid to the
involved people. In Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, 1,122,005,200 yuan has been
appropriated, and 1,010,616,800 yuan has been paid to the involved population. In
Guangdong Province, 2,874,854,000 yuan has been appropriated, and 1,569,877,300 yuan
has been paid to the involved population.
62 Apart from payment through bank transfer by the local governments, various modes are
available for allocation of the compensation by the village/group - for land regulation in
unit of farmer group, the compensation will be distributed averagely to the farmers; or the
compensations will be directly paid to the involved households. The linear pattern of land
acquisition for railway line will not cause a large amount of farmland in general.
Meanwhile, land reallocation within the villages or farmer groups in resourceful
mountainous areas will ensure the involved farmers to possess the farming conditions equal
or similar to these of the other local farmers for proceeding with agricultural production. In
addition, the local governments along the railway line will provide free vocational training
for the population with proper manpower, including the people involved by land acquisition,
to adapt them to the non-agricultural industries in the cities.
63 For the villages where land reallocation is unavailable, the compensation for land
acquisition will be paid directly to the households. Any involved farmer who is verified to
meet the standard of land-losing farmer (after land acquisition the remaining farmland area
in the village group > 0.3-0.5 mu per capita) will be subjected to social security
resettlement.
64 pension insurance policies have been established by governments at all levels in the three
provinces/regions along the railway line, however, as the land acquisition hasn't been
completed yet, it is hard to confirm the final number of land-losing population and thereby
the list of insurance applicants, so it has not been in the stage for purchasing social
insurance and distributing social insurance premium. In Guizhou Province, while
appropriating the fund for land acquisition, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company has
paid in full to the provincial social security institution special expenses for social security
resettlement of the land-losing farmers at a rate of 18,000 yuan per mu. Such expenses have
been transferred directly to the social security institution of Guizhou Province for unified
handling of social insurance for the land-losing farmers by the social security institution.
Currently statistical work on social security is being carried out in Duyun City, while the
other cities/towns will purchase social insurance after confirming the number of the final
land-losing population upon completion of current land acquisition for this Project. It is
estimated that all land acquisition operations will be completed at the end of 2012 and then
the number of land-losing households will be finalized and purchase of social insurance
will be performed. Similar to Guizhou, social security resettlement has not been
commenced since land acquisition is still in process in Guangxi. Special funds for social
security have been paid by the resettlement authorities of the counties/cities involved in
Guangdong Province, and related surveys is being performed in some villages where land
acquisition has been completed, while most of cities/towns plan to carry out surveys and
implement arrangements for social insurance upon completion of land acquisition. In
addition, due to good economic condition with the local village committees, substantial
villagers have bought medical and pension insurances.
2.1.2 PROGRESS IN RESETTLEMENT AND RECOVERY FOR
RESIDENCE DEMOLITION AND REMOVAL
(1) General Progress in House Demolition
65 With implementation of land acquisition, building demolition for this Project has been
commenced overall, and most has been completed. In all,913,295.9 m2 of buildings have
been demolished in the three provinces, accounting for 70.7% of the planned quantity. See
Table 26, Table 27 and Appendix 7 for more details.
66 In Guizhou, 399,800.9 m2 of buildings have been demolished, accounting for 81.2% of the
planned quantity, among which, 253630.7 m2 of buildings have been removed in Guiyang,
75.4% completed, with most uncompleted in Baiyun District; 95.2% of the planned
quantity has been completed in Qiangnan Prefecture, with most uncompleted in two
enterprises in Longli County; 86.3% of the planned quantity has been completed in
Qiangdongnan Prefecture, with most uncompleted in Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village and
Kouzai Village, Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County.
67 In Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, 303997.3 m2 of buildings have been demolished,
70.5% completed, with most uncompleted in Sidi Village, Yangsuo County, Guilin City.
68 In Guangdong Province, 209497.6 m2 of buildings have been demolished, 56.9% completed,
with most uncompleted in Foshan and Guangzhou, among which, 89411.7 m2 have been
removed in Foshan City, accounting for 52.9%, while 391.2 m2 completed in Guangzhou
City, with most uncompleted. The uncompleted in Liwan District are enterprise building
demolition, while the uncompleted in Yuexiu District are urban residence demolition.
(2) Progress in Residence Demolition
69 Buildings to be demolished for this Project include rural residences and urban residences.
639,147.4 m2 of rural residences have been demolished for this Project, accounting 80.5%
of the planned quantity, with most uncompleted in Guiyang (only 44% completed, all in
Baiyun District), Qiangdongnan Prefecture (only 82.9% completed, all in Rongjiang
County), Guilin, Guangxi (only 63.1% completed, all in Yangsuo County) and Dinghu
District, Zhaoqing City, Guangdong Province (not commenced yet). 118,823.8 m2 of urban
residences have been demolished for this Project, accounting for 73.9% of the planned
quantity, and most uncompleted lie in Yuexiu District, Guangzhou, while the other districts
(Guiyang City) have completed all urban residence demolition.
(3) Implementation of Compensation Standard for Residence Demolition
70 In general, all compensation criteria are decided by the resettlement authorities based on the
building replacement cost, basically meeting the requirements in the resettlement action
plan for this Project, and in some counties/districts the criteria even exceed the requirement
a lot. However, as one set of compensation criteria has been applied all over the district/city
when the resettlement plan is prepared, and a distinction among the building replacement
cost in all counties/districts has been made by the local governments along the railway line,
therefore, the compensation criteria actually implemented in some of the counties/districts
are below the requirements in the resettlement plan. The involved people in the involved
districts have been clearly informed of the building replace cost as specified in the policy,
and have accepted the compensation criteria decided by the local governments.
(4) Progress in Resettlement for House Demolition and Removal
71 As a whole, the principle of voluntary building demolition has been followed as much as
possible by the resettlement authorities along the railway line, and the compensations have
been paid to the involved residents prior to demolition based on the requirements of the
policy.
72 There are two compensation modes available for residence demolition - monetary
resettlement and rebuilding resettlement. Generally, the compensations for building
demolition will be paid directly to the removing resident's bank account by the resettlement
authorities of counties/districts, while for rebuilding of new building, collective
resettlement and individual separate resettlement are both applied. Usually, rural residents
prefer to individual separate resettlement to live near their contracted land or the
neighborhood, or have to choose collective resettlement when rebuilding for separate
resettlement is unavailable. As the involved districts in this Project are mostly mountainous
areas, especially within Guizhou Province and Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region,
involved by local cultures and customs, the involved residents would choose building
removal date and rebuilding site based on divination and geomantic omen theory, and then
the local government will make necessary coordination to provide the building site as
required by the resident and the land regulation authority will handle the process for free
and make necessary compensation for construction of infrastructure. When plenty of
building demolition is to be carried out in one place and selection of individual resettlement
site is unavailable, a collective resettlement site will be arranged by the local resettlement
authorities, with necessary public services and building site available.
73 Distribution of Collective Resettlement Sites for Migrants: Guizhou Province - New
Garden Community, Shengquanliuyuan Community in Xingyan District; Daguan Village
and Yangguan Village in Jingyang Sub-District, Jinyang District; Lvyuan Community and
Jiaoyishan Community in Nanmin District; and No. 5 and 6 in Qianjiang Road, Houchao
Village provided for rural migrants; Wujia Village in Longli County, Lijia Village in Mazhi
Township, Qiangnan Prefecture; Wenjiang Village in Jiuzhi Town, Guiding County; Putun
Village in Sandu County; Jiahui Village and Zenleng Village resettlement sites in Pingjiang
Village, Rongjiang County, and Yanzai Village and Luoxiang Village resettlement sites in
Congjiang County, Qiandongnan Prefecture;Guangxi - Tongle Township, Sanjiang County;
Bayan Village, Xiling Township, Gongcheng County; Chiling Group, Sanliang Village,
Liang'an Township, Zhongshan County, and Xin'an Village, Zhongshan Town, and
Changlong Village, Huangtian Village and Li'ning Village in Hezhou City. Individual
separate resettlement is applied in Guangdong Province.
74 Currently, construction of most resettlement sites has been completed and the migrants
have moved in. 2 resettlement sites in Baiyun District, Guiyang City and 4 resettlement
sites including Sidi Village site in Yangsuo County, and Xiaobao Village site in Rongjiang
County have not been commenced, while 2 sites in Jinyang District, 2 sites in Nanmin
District and 2 sites in Lingchuan County are being completed and handed over for use.
Currently the migrants whose resettlement sites are still in construction are being settled
down temporarily while the migrants whose resettlement site construction has not been
commenced have not had their original buildings demolished and removed yet. See Table
25 for more details.
Table 25 - Progress in Construction of Resettlement Sites for House Demolition and Removal
Cities/Counties Resettlement Site Progress
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Black Stone Village
Resettlement
Community
Still pending
Duxi Village
Resettlement
Community
Still pending
Yunyan District,
Guiyang City
New Garden
Community Completed and used
Shengquanliuyun
Community Completed and used
Jinyang District,
Guiyang City
Daguan Village
Resettlement
Community
In construction
Yangguan Village
Resettlement
Community
In construction
Nanmin District,
Guiyang City
Lvyuan Resettlement
Community Completed and used
Jiaoyishan Resettlement
Community Completed and used
No. 5 Resettlement
Community in
Qianjiang Road
In construction
No. 6 Resettlement
Community in
Qianjiang Road
In construction
Longli County,
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Wujia Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Lijia Village
Resettlement Site, Mazi
Township
Completed and used
Guiding County,
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Wenjiang Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Sandu County,
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Putun Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Rongjiang
County,
Qiangdongnan
Jiahui Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Xiaobao Village In site selection and
Prefecture Resettlement Site construction
Zenleng Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Congjiang
County,
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Yanzai Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Luoxiang Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Sanjiang County,
Liuzhou City
Tongle Township
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Lingchuan
County, Guilin
Huilong Village
Resettlement Site In construction
Dashudi Village
Resettlement Site In construction
Yangsuo County,
Guilin City
Sidi Village
Resettlement Site In construction
Gongcheng
County, Guilin
City
Bayan Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Zhongshan
County, Hezhou
City
Sanlian Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Xin'an Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Downtown of
Hezhou City
Changlong Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Huangtian Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Li'ning Village
Resettlement Site Completed and used
Table 26 - Progress in House Demolition and Removal
County/Distri
ct
RAP/Altere
d
Preliminary
Design
Rural Residences Enterpris
e
Buildings
School
Building
s
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Bric
k
Brick-Woo
d
Earth-Woo
d Primitive
Guiyang City
Planned in
APD 148705.563 132,728.44 6,123.6 456.8 9,396.713 68,766.3 0 118,823.77
336,295.62
3
Completed 66,040.603 50,801.74 5,385.34 456.8 9,396.713 68,766.3 0 118,823.77 253,630.67
Progress (%) 44.4% 38.3% 87.9% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 75.4%
Qiangnan
Prefecture
Planned in
APD 92,728.92 33,570.49 24,077.39 30,877.13 4,203.92 21,600.5
13,621.3
2 0 127,950.74
Completed 88,528.92 30,720.49 23,552.97 30,051.55 4,203.92 19,600.5 13,621.3
2 0 121,750.74
Progress (%) 95.5% 91.5% 97.8% 97.3% 100.0% 90.7% 100.0% 95.2%
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Planned in
APD 22,623.58 6,563.08 6,470.08 5,886.26 3,703.66 5,562 100 0 28,285.58
Completed 18,757.58 2,697.08 6,470.08 5,886.26 3,703.66 5,562 100 0 24,419.58
Progress (%) 82.9% 41.1% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 86.3%
Total -
GuiZhou
Planned in
APD 264,058.063 172,862.01 36,671.07 37,220.19 17,304.293 95,928.8
13,721.3
2 118,823.77
492,531.94
3
Completed 173,327.103 84,219.31 35,408.39 36,394.61 17,304.293 93,928.8 13,721.3
2 118,823.77 399,800.99
Progress (%) 65.6% 48.7% 96.6% 97.8% 100.0% 97.9% 100.0% 100.0% 81.2%
Liuzhou City
Planned in
APD 7,437.64 653.84 857.44 4,154.38 1,771.98 0 0 0 7,437.64
Completed 7,437.64 653.84 857.44 4,154.38 1,771.98 0 0 0 7,437.64
Progress (%) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0 0 0 100.0%
Guilin City
Planned in
APD 111,347.4 35,487.8 42,901.6 13,474.2 19,483.9 106,625.8 0 0 217,973.2
Completed 70,217.35 17,057.76 34,051.59 5,574.17 13,533.87 20,625.8 0 0 90,843.25
Progress (%) 63.1% 48.1% 79.4% 41.4% 69.5% 19.3% 0.0% 0.0% 41.7%
Hezhou City
Planned in
APD 201,262.4 76,771.2 55,053.6 35,807.6 33,630.1 0 4,454 0 205,716.4
Completed 201,262.4 76,771.2 55,053.6 35,807.6 33,630.1 0 4,454 0 205,716.4
Progress (%) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total -
Guangxi
Planned in
APD 320,047.44 112,912.84 98,812.64 53,436.18 54,885.98 106,625.8 4,454 0 431,127.24
Completed 278,917.39 94,482.8 89,962.63 45,536.15 48,935.95 20,625.8 4,454 0 303,997.29
Progress (%) 87.1% 83.7% 91.0% 85.2% 89.2% 19.3% 100.0% 0.0% 70.5%
Table 27 - Progress in House Demolition and Removal (Continued)
County/Distric
t
RAP/Altered
Preliminary Design
Rural Residences Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-
Brick
Brick-W
ood
Earth-W
ood
Primit
ive
Zhaoqing City
Planned in APD 99,028 53,374.6 20,878.6 11,335 13,439
.8 15,027.2 5,094.7 0 119,149.9
Completed 91,100 50,374.6 15,950.6 11,335 13,439
.8 5,500 5,094.7 0 101,694.7
Progress (%) 92.0% 94.4% 76.4% 100.0% 100.0
% 36.6% 100.0% 0.0% 85.4%
Foshan City
Planned in APD 110,84
0.14 98,393.755 8,634.67 689.225
3,122.
49 81,862.11 1,481 0
194,183.2
5
Completed 95,411.
715 84,000 7,600 689.225
3,122.
49 12,000 0 0
107,411.7
15
Progress (%) 86.1% 85.4% 88.0% 100.0% 100.0
% 14.7% 0.0% 0.0% 55.3%
Guangzhou
City
Planned in APD 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Completed 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 391.2
Progress (%) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.7%
Subtotal -
Guangdong
Planned in APD 210,25
9.3 152,031.1 29,608.0 12,035.6
16,584
.7 109,734.6 6,575.7 41,898.0 368,467.6
Completed 186,90
2.9 134,637.4 23,645.3 12,035.6
16,584
.7 17,500.0 5,094.7 0.0 209,497.6
Progress (%) 88.9% 88.6% 79.9% 100.0% 100.0
% 15.9% 77.5% 0.0% 56.9%
Total - Full Planned in APD 794,36 437,806.0 165,091. 102,691. 88,774 312,289.2 24,751.0 160,721.8 1,292,126
Line 4.8 7 9 .9 .821
Completed 639,14
7.4 313,339.5
149,016.
3 93,966.3
82,824
.9 132,054.6 23,270.0 118,823.8 913,295.9
Progress (%) 80.5% 71.6% 90.3% 91.5% 93.3% 42.3% 94.0% 73.9% 70.7%
2.1.3 PROGRESS IN COMPENSATION AND
RESETTLEMENT FOR NON-RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING DEMOLITION AND REMOVAL
(1) Progress in Non-Residential Building Demolition and Resettlement
75 Non-residential buildings demolished and removed for this Project include
industrial and commercial enterprise buildings, institution buildings and school
buildings.
A. In this Project, 8 schools including 4 primary schools and 4 middle schools
(see Table 28 for more details) in areas of 23,270 m2 have been demolished
and removed as planned.
Table28 - Statistics on School House Demolition & Removal and Relocation
Province/City County/
District)
Name of
Involved School
Number
of
Involved
Populati
on
Demolition
Area (m2)
Progress in
Demolition and
Relocation
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture,
Guizhou
Province
Duyun
City
Xiaowei Village
Cha'nong
Primary School
120 1,143.32 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture,
Guizhou
Province
Sandu
County Jin'an Middle
School
2,060 12,478 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture,
Guizhou
Province
Congjian
g County
Luoxiang Town
Middle School 500 100
Water closet
demolished only;
compensation paid
Hezhou City,
Guangxi
Zhongsh
an
County
Honghua Town
Gulou Complete
Primary School
110 833.03 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Hezhou City,
Guangxi
Pinggui
District
Huangtian No. 3
Middle School 2,000 3,621
Removal and
rebuilding completed
Zhaoqing City,
Guangdong
Province
Guangni
ng
County
Xiangkou
Primary School
in Chengnan
Village, Nanjie
Town
300 2,400 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Zhaoqing City,
Guangdong
Province
Guangni
ng
County
Guangbu Middle
School in
Chengnan
Village, Nanjie
Town
300 1,878.7 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Zhaoqing City,
Guangdong
Province
Guangni
ng
County
Qixing Primary
School in
Lidong Village,
Hengshan Town
150 816 Removal and
rebuilding completed
Total 5,540 23,270.05
B. In total 135 industrial and commercial enterprises/institutions' buildings in
area of 312289.2 m2 are planned to be demolished in the altered preliminary
design, and currently 132054.6 m2 have been demolished and removed, 42.3%
completed. In Guizhou Province, 97.7% of the planned quantity has been
completed, with 2 enterprises in Longli County left behind. In Guangxi, 19.3%
of the planned quantity has completed, with only 1 large-sized brickyard in
construction left behind. In Guangdong Province, only 15.9% has been
completed, with most uncompleted in Foshan City and Guangzhou City.
(2) Compensation for and Rebuilding of Non-Residential Buildings Demolished
76 All compensation criteria for non-residential building demolition and removal
have been determined by certified evaluating institution based on market
replacement cost and the compensations will be paid directly to the
enterprises/institutions' bank accounts.
77 Among the 8 involved schools, Luoxiang Middle School has bad only a toilet (in
area of 100 m2)located out of the main school site demolished, and monetary
compensation for it has been paid, while the other schools will all be rebuilt at the
owner's cost based on appraisal, and the local education administration will be in
charge of rebuilding operations. Construction of all these schools has been
completed and put into operation.
78 Till now for this Project 135 enterprises/institutions' buildings will been demolished, among
which 120 enterprises/institutions' buildings have been demolished along the full-length line,
including 100 enterprises/institutions in Guizhou Province, 10 in Guangxi and 10 in Guangdong
Province. The pending enterprises/institutions are located in Longli County, Qiangnan
Prefecture (2), Yangsuo County, Guangxi (1), Nanhai District in Foshan City, Guangdong
Province (9) and Liwan District in Guangzhou City (2). The compensation criteria for
rebuilding of the demolished enterprise buildings will be determined based on market appraisal
and compensations will be paid to make up for the loss in operation resulted from removal. In
addition to resettlement of some involved enterprises in the local industrial park assisted by the
resettlement authorities, other enterprises will choose the relocation site by themselves based on
their industry nature (with compensations paid), while part of enterprises which are involved
very a little (with minor facilities demolished without effect on business operation)may choose
monetary resettlement to give up the original business operation. As a whole, most of enterprise
building demolition has been completed and monetary compensation is the primary mode for
resettlement. See Appendix 11 for more details.
2.1.4 EFFECT ON AND RECOVERY OF INFRASTRUCTURE
(1) Effect on Infrastructure
79 Construction of this Project has had effect on related infrastructure across the communities
along the railway line, which is in relation to the local residents' production and life. Currently
in total communication facilities in 353 locations an electrical facilities in 408 locations have
been demolished and removed. According to the incomplete statistics on infrastructures as
shown in Table 29, the removed facilities include 1,399 electric poles, 26 transformers, ditch of
40,152 meters, 44 bridges, roads of 265,398 meters, water supply pipelines of 184,275 meters,
farm motor paths of 59,780 meters, communication cable of 46,970 meters, electric cable of
47,640 meters and other facilities of 4,600 meters.
(2) Compensation for and Recovery of Infrastructure
80 Compensation for and recovery of all involved infrastructures have attracted the Project owner
and resettlement authorities' close attention. With the Project Owner's special authorization,
specialized agencies have removed and rebuilt the involved infrastructure, including
communication and electric cables at the Project Owner's cost, and the related expenses have
been verified by certified evaluating institution and incorporated to the construction cost for this
Project. Currently the resettlement authorities have completed removal and reconstruction of
communication facilities in 353 locations and electrical facilities in 485 locations. Permanent
rebuilding of most involved roads, water conservancy facilities, bridges and pole-mounted
cables is in process and proper interim substitutes for these facilities have been provided for the
communities by the engineering organization
Table29 - Statistics on Involved Infrastructure in this Project
Provi
nce City
County/
District)
Ele
ctri
c
Pol
e
Trans
forme
r
Ope
n
Cha
nne
l
(m)
Bri
dg
e
Roa
d
(m)
Wat
er
Pip
elin
e
(m)
Far
m
Mo
tor
Pat
h
(m
)
Commu
nication
Cable
(m)
Ele
ctri
c
Ca
ble
(m)
Ot
her
s
(m
)
Guiz
hou
Guiyan
g City
New
Jinyang
District
2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Yunyan
District 0 0 0 0 0 400 0 1,500
2,0
00 0
Qiangn
an
Prefect
ure
Duyun
City 0 0 0 0
161
,00
0
0 0 0 0 0
Qiangd
ongnan
Prefect
ure
Sandu 9 600
Rongjia
ng
County
0 0 8,0
00 0
3,5
00
3,4
00 0 1,500
3,8
00 0
Congjia
ng
County
0 0 0 0 3,4
79 0 0 0 0 0
Subtot
al 11 0
8,0
00 0
167
,97
9
3,8
00 0 3,600
5,8
00 0
Guan
gxi
Liuzho
u City
Sanjian
g
County
7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,5
50 0
Guilin
City
Longsh
eng
County
0 0 0 0 400 0 0 0 0 0
Lingchu
an
County
67 1 10,
098 0
11,
250
2,0
00
21,
55
0
0 2,5
00
Yangsu
o
County
48 5 1,2
54 20
24,
610
8,0
00
3,1
80 5,300
5,6
50 0
Gongch
eng
County
29 3 2,1
00 11
57,
000
1,8
40
23,
00
0
11,500 8,7
00
1,2
00
Hezho
u City
Zhongs
han
County
0 0 1,5
00 0 0
107
,72
9
50 0 0 0
Babu
District 0 0 0 0 0
6,9
97 0 0 0 0
Pinggui
District 0 0 0 0 0 813 0 0 0 0
Subtot
al 151 9
14,
952 31
93,
260
127
,37
9
47,
78
0
16,800 18,
400
1,2
00
Guan
gdon
Zhaoqi
ng City
Guangn
ing 85 13
7,7
00 1
2,8
50
39,
010
7,8
00 7,000
8,5
00
g County
Sihui
City 40 1
9,5
00 9
1,3
00
8,1
00
4,2
00 9,880
9,0
00
Dinghu
District
1,0
46 3 0 0 0 0 0 9,690
1,1
20 0
Foshan
City
Nanhai
District 66 3
5,9
86
4,8
20
Subtot
al
1,2
37 17
17,
200 13
4,1
50
53,
096
12,
00
0
26,570 23,
440 0
Total - Full
Line
1,3
99 26
40,
152 44
265
,38
9
184
,27
5
59,
78
0
46,970 47,
640
1,2
00
2.1.5 HANDLING OF PUBLIC COMPLAINTS
(1) Public Participation in Complaint
81 As land acquisition and compensation and resettlement proceed, the involved
people have participated in the operations in various ways so that information on
this Project is open to the public and the people's opinions will be handled
properly. People's participation in the affairs and operations includes:
1) Participation in villager conference or owner representative conference: The
resettlement authorities for this Project must go to the village/community to
organize villager/resident/owner representative conference to present the
information on this Project and make communication and coordination with the
involved people on compensation policy and resettlement program. These
conferences will be often held in the communities. On these conferences the
villagers and owner representatives will be informed of the goal, missions of the
construction and information related to land acquisition, building demolition,
compensation and resettlement, and propose their own opinions and ideas.
2) Notices and bulletin boards: The resettlement authorities will release notices
and announcements through media (TV and radio broadcast etc.) to present the
information on this Project and compensation and resettlement policies to the
public.
3) Personal participation in surveys on physical loss and social economy: A
evaluating team consisting of officials of local resettlement authorities,
construction contractor's staff, local village/group officials and the involved
people shall be set up to make survey on the physical materials involved in land
acquisition and building demolition, though which the involved people can
express their opinions on the operations to protect their legal rights.
4) Participation in selection of rebuilding mode and location: Whether for
individual separate resettlement or collective resettlement, the rebuilding location
shall be mainly decided by the involved household.
5) Reading the information booklet: Information booklets on resettlement for this
Project will be distributed to the involved people by the resettlement authorities to
inform them of the related project background, compensation policy and criteria,
and resettlement measures etc.
(2) Complaint Mechanism and Handling
82 During land acquisition, building demolition and migrant resettlement, in case of
any difficulties in production or life, or for any question or complaint about the
compensation or resettlement, the migrants may make submission by the
following means:
1) Submission to the Owner's representative: Project construction headquarters
and operation coordinating offices have been set up in the three provinces/ regions
by the Owner. Land acquisition and building demolition commissioners have been
assigned to the counties/districts by the coordinating offices, who will collect the
involved people's opinions and complaints for the Owner and make necessary
between the resettlement authorities, project constructor and local communities
for solution to the problems;
2) Submission to local village/community official: The complaint are likely to be
submitted by the involved people to the local village/community officials which
they are familiar with, and then transferred through township/town agency to the
Office of Railway Construction in the county/district.
3) Submission to the governmental land regulation authority at all level along the
railway line : These authorities will be responsible for developing and
implementing the compensation and resettlement policies, and their land
regulation agencies set up and official assigned in the township/town will contact
and communicate with the involved people, and give solution and make handling
of the issues.
4) Submission to related governmental complaint receiving divisions: Open hot
lines (generally the office telephone or the director's cell phone) are provided for
reception of the involved persons' complaints at the resettlement authorities in all
towns/districts. In addition, for any unfair treatment, the involved persons may
complain to the reception office of the local complaint division.
5) Legal action: The involved people may claim legal action to the local court to
protect their legal rights.
83 In general, during operation of the complaint mechanism as stated above, the
involved people will submit their opinions and complaints to the constructors,
government agencies at all levels, and especially to the coordinating agencies in
township/town. In addition, for this Project, it is also a useful method to stop the
construction for a solution to the problem.
84 The related officials shall pay much attention to the involved people's any
opinions and complaints expressed in any way. These opinions will be fed back
promptly by the complaint mechanism and necessary evaluation and respond will
be made, or explanation and statement on the policies will be given within the
specified period, or proper solution may be worked out via coordination
mechanism to ensure the involved persons' legal rights and interests.
85 During early stage for construction measurements, the involved people's
complaints are mainly concerning effect on physical materials, applicable policies
and compensation criteria, while in current stage, reclamation of interim land and
reconstruction of infrastructures are highlighted.
2.1.6 LAND ACQUISITION AND MIGRATION
MANAGEMENT EVALUATION:MANAGEMENT
CAPACITY, SURVEILLANCE AND REPORTING
(1) Structural System and Responsibility of Migration and Resettlement
Organization
86 An integral vertical-structured organizational system for migration management
has been set up jointly by the Owner and executive agencies of the local
governments along the railway line, including migration commissioner at the
FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways, migration coordinating office at
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company, provincial railway construction
coordinating offices set up in the three provinces/regions, and
executive/coordinating agencies set up at the involved cities/counties and
extended to government sectors at town/sub-district, and experienced specialized
officials are assigned and an effective set of rules and systems are developed for it.
This organizational system is operating effectively to promote operation of land
acquisition, building demolition, compensation and resettlement along the railway
line. Composition of the Organizational System:
Migration Commissioner Assigned at the FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways
A full-time migration commissioner is assigned at the FCUTIC, Ministry of
Railways, who is responsible for regularly inspecting implementation of migration
and resettlement in related agencies in railway sector, coordinating with the local
government, communicating with the World Bank's migration officials, contacting
external independent monitoring institution and reviewing migration-related
reports. Determination of this role enhances coordination of Ministry of Railways
in migration operations for this Project. Currently Ms. Cai Zhujuan is appointed to
take this role.
External coordinating office set up by Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway
Company
Project construction headquarters and operation coordinating offices have been set
up respectively in the three provinces/ regions by the Owner, which are
responsible for affairs related to land acquisition and building demolition under
the leadership of Mr. Dong Liang. There are 8 staff in the coordinating office, who
are resident at the three headquarters located in Guiyang, Guilin and Foshan,
responsible for coordination in land acquisition, building demolition, migration
and resettlement, and special commissioners are assigned out of them to each
involved county/district for coordination in the operations;
In 2008, provincial land acquisition and building demolition coordinating teams
are set up respectively in all counties/districts. For example, the railway
construction and transport leading team office was set up in Guizhou Province,
under which the Office of Railway Construction (ORC) is responsible for daily
affairs under the leadership of provincial NDRC, Office of Finance and Office of
Land and Resources. ORC is responsible for development of compensation and
resettlement policies and surveillance, as well as general coordination across the
province. Organizations with the same functions are set up in Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region and Guangdong Province as well.
Under the leadership of provincial organizations, leading teams/offices mainly
responsible for coordination in land acquisition, building demolition and
resettlement are set up respectively in all district-level/municipal governments for
coordination in development of related policies and guidance for execution, such
as ORC in Guiyang, the headquarters in Qiangdongnan Prefecture, Railway
Construction Coordinating and Leading Team Office in Guilin, Railway
Construction Assisting Office in Hezhou, Guiyang-Guangzhou/Naning-Guangz
hou/Guangzhou-Zhaoqing-Foshan Inter-City Light Railway (Zhaoqing Section)
Construction Headquarters in Zhaoqing, and Comprehensive Transport
Decision-Making Committee in Foshan etc.
County-Level Coordinating & Facilitating Agency for Land Acquisition and
Building Demolition Proper county-/district-level coordinating agencies are set up
in all counties/districts along the railway line, which make close coordination with
the involved village/town/sub-district governments for coordination and execution
of operations for land acquisition and building demolition.
(2) SURVEILLANCE AND EVALUATION OF MIGRATION AND
RESETTLEMENT
87 The surveillance and evaluation system determined for the resettlement action
plan is effectively operating. The Owner, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company,
is responsible for collecting, sorting and reporting external surveillance
information, and submitting the external surveillance and evaluation report at the
frequency and through the process as specified in the resettlement plan.
88 External Resource Office of Southwest Jiaotong University has started external
surveillance and evaluation of migration and resettlement since 2009. This Office
have properly carried out external surveillances, evaluations and on-site surveys,
and has submitted external surveillance and evaluation reports to the World Bank
respectively in July 2010, February 2011 and July 2011, and has finished the
fourth-stage on-site survey on migration and resettlement in February 2012. These
external reports have given an overall presentation of progress in migration and
resettlement, implementation of compensation policy, appropriating and payment
of funds for land acquisition and building demolition and resettlement results,
notified the Owner of any problems found in on-site surveillance and evaluation,
and provided proper advices to ensure effective execution of the resettlement plan.
2.1.7 COMPLIANCE WITH RAP AND RESULTS IN LAND
ACQUISITION AND MIGRATION
89 The resettlement action plan has been complied with strictly during land
acquisition and building demolition for this Project. The local governments at all
levels in the regions along the railway line have appropriated compensation in full
to the involved people without delay, and no case of underpayment by the
authorities occurs. Various modes are available for allocation of the compensation
by the village/group - for land regulation in unit of farmer group, the
compensation will be distributed averagely to the farmers; the compensations will
be directly paid to the involved households.
90 The involved people's life is being recovered step by step. Due to the linear mode
of land acquisition for this Project, in general the land acquisition will not result in
obvious drop in the life standard of the involved people along the railway line.
Vocational training, employment guidance and service have been provided for the
land-losing farmers in all involved counties/cities in the provinces along the
railway line. Combination of the social security with the employment service for
the involved farmers has facilitated their employment transformation. The public
employment agencies at all levels have provided the involved farmers with
unemployment registration for free and one-stop employment services, to ensure
the land-losing farmers to share the employment support policies implemented by
the government with the registered urban unemployed persons.
91 Support for subsistence allowances has been provided for the vulnerable groups
subjected to land acquisition in the three provinces/ regions. All certified farmers
subjected to hardship due to land acquisition will be covered under the rural
subsistence allowances. All certified farmers who have been registered as urban
residents and are subjected to hardship due to land acquisition will be covered
under the urban subsistence allowances.
92 For a very small number of farmers who have lost their most of family farmland
due to land acquisition for construction of the station and meet the standard of
land-losing farmer, the resettlement authorities in the governments along the
railway line have, in addition to land re-allocation within the village, successively
developed local social security policies to provide supports for the land-losing
farmers.
93 The principle of voluntary demolition has been followed during building
demolition by all resettlement authorities in the districts along the railway line,
and the compensations have been paid to the involved people as required by the
policy prior to demolition and removal.
94 Subsequent to demolition and removal of the involved residents' houses, the
compensations will be paid by the resettlement authorities directly to their bank
accounts. For rebuilding of new building, collective resettlement and individual
separate resettlement are both applied. The local government will make necessary
coordination to provide the building site as required by the resident and the land
regulation authority will handle the process for free and make necessary
compensation for construction of infrastructure. When plenty of building
demolition is to be carried out in one place and selection of individual
resettlement site is unavailable, a collective resettlement site will be arranged by
the local resettlement authorities, with necessary public services and building site
available. Most of people subjected to house demolition currently have been
resettled by means of collective rebuilding (such as in Guiyang) or independent
rebuilding, and moved into new houses with dwelling condition improved greatly,
except in some area (such as in Nanmin District and Jinyang District, Guiyang
City) where construction of collective resettlement site is slow and the involved
people live in interim residences or have not had their residences demolished yet
(e.g. in Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village in Rongjiang County ,
Qiangdongnan Prefecture, Sidi Village in Yangsuo County, Guilin City, Dinghu
District, Zhaoqing City and Yuexiu District, Guangzhou City).
2.1.8 ISSUES TO BE HANDLED
(1) Implementation of Multi-Approach Compensation in Guizhou Province
95 A policy of "multi-approach compensation fund" has been applied in Guizhou
Province, where multi-approach compensation fund scheme is developed by the
resettlement authorities in the counties/districts and approved by the
municipal/prefecture government, and then is submitted to the provincial Office of
Land and Resources to apply for the fund. This fund derives from two sources -
one is the difference2 between the compensation time for prime cropland and
non-basic farmland; the other is the difference between the comprehensive price
compensated for land acquisition implemented in 2010 and the original
compensations for this Project. This fund is mainly used for construction of public
2As per the State Council' Decree No. 25, compensations for prime cropland shall be based on 30 times of the
highest annual output value thereof, while compensations for non-prime cropland shall be based on the local farmland quantity per capita and average annual output value within the recent three years. Compensations for expropriation of non-prime cropland in Guizhou Province are usually based on 15-16 times of the highest annual output value. Since adjacent non-prime cropland and prime cropland actually have the same output value, to avoid unnecessary contradictions among the public and minimize balanced use of national funds, in practice, the compensations for both will be paid based on non-prime cropland, and the amount in compensation criteria for prime cropland which is above the compensation criteria for common farmland will be paid to a multi-approach compensation account specially set for all involved persons.
services, employment training and foundation of public enterprises in the area
subjected to land acquisition and other purposes. Currently, for implementation of
this measure, the involved counties/districts are developing fund use scheme for
approval. The resettlement authorities in all districts think that, as land acquisition
for this Project is still in process now (small plots still to be required for
construction), quantity of prime cropland requisitioned can be determined only
upon end of land acquisition, and then the multi-approach compensations can be
calculated and operations related to application for , appropriating and use of fund
can be commenced. Much attention shall be paid to implementation of
multi-approach compensation and resettlement scheme.
(2) COMPENSATION CRITERIA BELOW RAP FOR SOME LAND
TYPE IN GUANGXI SECTION
96 This is because that the resettlement action plan was developed based on the
annual output value provided by Guilin, which had not taken into account the
difference in land outputs of the counties/districts (for example, there is great
difference between the land output value in Lingui County neighboring Guilin and
that in Longsheng County located in remote mountainous area. It has been
confirmed by the Office of Land and Resources of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous
Region that, the compensation criteria determined by the local counties based on
the local actual conditions comply with related national and local laws and
policies (see Appendix 10 for more details).
(3) Shortage of Compensation Fund in Zhaoqing, Guangdong
97 The compensation fund for land acquisition and building demolition in this
Project within Guangdong Province was raised jointly by Guangdong provincial
government and Zhaoqing municipal government at a ratio of 1:1, while the local
government of Zhaoqing had some difficulties in raising the fund, which caused
appropriation of the compensations to be delayed. Currently the land acquisition
and building demolition leading team of Guangdong Province has decided that
the Railway Investment Company of Guangdong would apply for loan to the bank
by means of "unified loan and return" on behalf of the provincial resettlement
authorities to solve the shortage of fund.
(4) Issues in Implementation of Social Security Mechanism for Land-Losing
Farmers
98 Currently, the governments of all levels along the railway line have developed
social security policies for the land-losing farmers, and the Owner have
appropriated special funds for social security for purpose of this Project to the
Office of Social Security of the three provincial governments. The key reason why
the social security resettlement have not been implemented in all districts along
the railway line lies in: there are still small quantity of land acquisition for this
Project and the local resettlement authorities cannot finalize the number of
land-losing farmers within the district and so fail to implement the social security
policy. Now part of the districts has started to perform special survey in the
involved villages to verify the number of land-losing farmers and push forward
the social security resettlement for the farmers. Much attention shall be paid to the
implementation of the social security resettlement policy for the land-losing
farmers.
2.2 DUE DILIGENCE CONCERNING THE SUPPLEMENT
RESETTLEMENT PLAN
2.2.1 SCOPE OF DUE DILIGENCE
99 The purpose of due diligence is to make an evaluation of the implementation of
land acquisition and building demolition within the coverage of the RAP for this
Project, and verify whether the process of land acquisition and building
demolition is in compliance with national policies and the World Bank's policies
and principles, and whether the livelihood of the involved people has been
recovered and whether there is any issued left pending.
100 The due diligence covers all districts under the coverage of the altered
preliminary design where land acquisition and building demolition have been
completed, including: 3 district (Nanmin District, Yunyan District Xingyan
District and Jinyang District) and 8 towns/sub-districts (Houchao Township,
Zhunyi Sub-District, Huaguoyuan Sub-District, Shachong Sub-District, Qianling
Town, Sanqiao Sub-District and Jingyang Sub-District) and 12 villages (Taici
Village, Chaoyang Village, Houchao Village, Wuyanqiao Community,
Huaguoyuan Community, Dalishi Community, Xinzai Community, Gaicha
Village, Sanqiao Village, North Sanqiao Road Community, Daguan Village and
Yangguan Village) in Guiyang, Guizhou Province);1 town (Xingping Town) and
1 village (Sidi Village (only land acquisition completed)) in Yangsuo County,
Guilin; 2 sub-districts (Shibi Sub-District and Zhongnan Sub-District) and 2
villages (Third Shibi Village and Hainan Village (land acquisition partly
completed)) in 2 districts (Fanyu District and Liwan District). In total 15
villages/communities in 11 towns/ sub-districts in 6 counties/districts are involved,
among which, 10 villages/communities are subject to land acquisition while 12 to
building demolition.
(1) Permanent Land Acquisition
1) Progress in Land Acquisition
101 According to the due diligence, permanent land acquisition of 1,958 mus in total
has been completed within the coverage of the altered preliminary design, among
which, farmland acquisition of 1,669 mus has been completed. The districts where
permanent land acquisition has been fully completed include: Nanming District,
Yunyan District and Jinyang District in Guiyang City, Sidi Village, Yangsuo
County, Guilin City and Fanyu District in Guangzhou City; The regions with
permanent land acquisition partly completed are Hainan Village, Zhongnan
Sub-District, Linan District, Guangzhou City (with 157.1 mus land acquisition
completed, accounting for 72.5% of the total). See Table 30 and Table 31 for
more details.
(2) Progress in Building Demolition
102 According to the due diligence, various kinds of buildings of 252,022 m2 within
coverage of the altered preliminary design has been demolished and removed,
with 5,254 people in 1,336 households involved. See Table 32 and Table 33 for
more details.
Table30 - Due Diligence on Permanent Land Acquisition within Coverage of APD
County/Di
strict
Township/T
own Village
Farmland
Farm-Purpo
se Pond
Farm-Purpose
Woodland
Construction-Pur
pose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Othe
r
Unu
sed
Lan
d
Tota
l Subt
otal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetable
Field
Orch
ard
Oth
ers
Nanmin
District
Houchao
Township
Taici Village 2.4
2.4
2.1 12.8
17.4
Chaoyang Village 0.2
0.2
7.9
8.1
Houchao Village 4.3
4.3
14.2
18.5
State-Owned
Woodland 0.0
22.1
22.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6.9 0.0 0.0 6.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 24.2 34.9 0.0 0.0 66.1
Progress in Land
Acquisition 6.9 0.0 0.0 6.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 24.2 34.9 0.0 0.0 66.1
Progress (%) 100
% 100%
100% 100%
100
%
Yunyan
District
Qianling
Town
Gaicha 9.7
9.7
0.6 10.3
Sanqiao 67.7
67.7
2.1
69.9
State-Owned
Woodland 111.3
111.
3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
77.5 0.0 0.0 77.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 111.3 2.1 0.0 0.6 191.
5
Progress in Land
Acquisition 77.5 0.0 0.0 77.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 111.3 2.1 0.0 0.6
191.
5
Progress (%) 100
% 100%
100% 100%
100
%
100
%
High-Tec
h Zone
Jinyang
District
Daguan Village 735.
7 241.4 494.3
16.1
751.
8
Yangguan Village 244.
3 43.1 201.2
244.
3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
980.
0 284.6 695.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 16.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
996.
1
Progress in Land
Acquisition
980.
0 284.6 695.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 16.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
996.
1
Progress (%) 100
% 100% 100%
100%
100
%
Total - Guiyang
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,06
4.5 284.6 695.5 84.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 135.5 37.1 0.0 0.6
1,25
3.7
Progress in Land
Acquisition
1,06
4.5 284.6 695.5 84.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 135.5 37.1 0.0 0.6
1,25
3.7
Progress (%) 100.
0% 100.0%
100.0
% 100.0%
100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
100.
0%
100.
0%
Table31 - Due Diligence on Permanent Land Acquisition within Coverage of APD (Continued - 1)
County/District Township/Town Village
Farmland
Farm-Purpose Pond Farm-Purpose
Woodland
Construction-Purpose
Land
Uncultivated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal Paddy Field Dry Farm Vegetable Field Orchard Others
Yangsuo County Xingping Town
Sidi Village 425.0 17.2 17.5 390.3 3.0 20.0 1.7 1.1 450.7
Altered
Preliminary
Design
425.0 17.2 17.5 0.0 390.3 0.0 3.0 20.0 0.0 1.7 1.1 450.7
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
425.0 17.2 17.5 0.0 390.3 0.0 3.0 20.0 0.0 1.7 1.1 450.7
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Fanyu District Shibi Sub-District
Third Shibi
Village 51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96
Altered
Preliminary
Design
51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Liwan District Zhongnan Sub-District
Hainan 188.2 80.2 108.0 25.8 2.7 216.7
Altered
Preliminary
Design
188.2 80.2 108.0 25.8 2.7 216.7
Progress in
Land 128.6 40.2 0.0 0.0 88.3 0.0 0.0 25.9 2.7 157.1
Acquisition
Progress (%) 68.3% 50.1% 81.8% 100.2% 101.1% 72.5%
Subtotal -Guangzhou
Altered
Preliminary
Design
239 89 29 13 108 0 0 6 39 26 3 313
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
180 49 29 13 88 0 0 6 39 26 3 253
Progress (%) 75.1% 55.2% 100.0% 100.0% 81.8% 100.0% 100.0% 100.2% 101.1% 80.9%
Total
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,729 391 742 97 498 0 19 161 76 28 4 2,017
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,669 351 742 97 479 0 19 161 76 28 4 1,958
Progress (%) 96.5% 89.8% 100.0% 100.0% 96.1% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.2% 100.7% 97.0%
Table32 - Due Diligence on Building Demolition within Coverage of APD
Pr
o
vi
n
ce
/
C
it
y
Coun
ty/Di
strict
Township/Town Village
Removed
Househol
ds
Remove
d
Populati
on
Rural Residences
Enterprise
Buildings
Schoo
l
Buildi
ngs
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concret
e-Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-W
ood
Primitiv
e
G
ui
y
a
n
g
C
it
y,
G
ui
z
h
o
u
Pr
o
Nan
min
Distr
ict
Houchao
Township
Chaoyang
Village 35 140 4,857.2 4,729.2 108.1 20.0 4,857.2
Houchao
Village 86 344 19,018.7 17,026.4 234.9 1,757.4 19,018.7
Zhunyi
Sub-District
Wuyanqiao
Community 26 78 4,000.0 15,019.8 19,019.8
Huaguoyuan
Sub-District
Office
Huaguoyuan
Community 125 798 20,500.0 32,883.6 53,383.6
Shachong
Sub-District
Yuxi
Community +
Dalishi
Community
320 960 18,793.0 47,403.3 66,196.3
Xingguan
Sub-District
Xinzai
Community 336 1,392 20,000.0 20,751.0 40,751.0
Subtotal 928 3,712 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 0.0 116,057.8 203,226.7
Completed 928 3,712 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 0.0 116,057.8 203,226.7
vi
n
ce
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Yuny
an
Distr
ict
Qianling
Gaicha
Village 28 90 3,371.5 2,927.9 443.6 0.0 3,371.5
Sanqiao
Village 5 30 720.5 590.7 116.6 13.2 0.0 720.5
Sanqiao
Sub-District
North Sanqiao
Road
Community
78 324 3,473.3 2,766.0 6,239.3
Subtotal 111 444 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
Completed 111 444 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Table33 - Due Diligence on Building Demolition within Coverage of APD (Continued - 1)
Pr
o
vi
n
ce
/
C
it
y
Coun
ty/Di
strict
Township/Town Village
Removed
Househol
ds
Remove
d
Populati
on
Rural Residences (sq. m)
Enterprise
Buildings
Schoo
l
Buildi
ngs
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concret
e-Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-W
ood
Primitiv
e
G
ui
y
a
n
g
C
it
y,
G
ui
z
h
o
u
Pr
o
Jinya
ng
Distr
ict
Jingyang
Sub-District
Daguan
Village 164 546 33,478.9 25,527.6 3,951.8 3,999.5 33,478.9
Yangguan
Village 127 531 4,593.7 973.9 3,619.8 4,593.7
Subtotal 291 1,077 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Completed 291 1,077 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Total 1,330 5,233 66,041 50,802 5,385 457 9,397 66,766 0 118,824 251,631
Completed 1,330 5,233 66,041 50,802 5,385 457 9,397 66,766 0 118,824 251,631
Progress (%) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
vi
n
ce
G
u
a
n
g
z
h
o
u
C
it
y,
G
u
a
n
g
d
o
n
g
Liwan
District
Zhongnan
Sub-District
Hainan
Village 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 391.2
Subtotal 6 21 391 263 95 11 22 0 0 0 391
Completed 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 0.0 391.2
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Total 6 21 391 263 95 11 22 0 0 0 391
Completed 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 391.2
Progress (%) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Total - Full Line 1,336 5,254 66,432 51,065 5,480 468 9,419 66,766 0 118,824 252,022
Completed 1,336 5,254 66,431.8 51,064.5 5,480.0 468.1 9,419.1 66,766.3 0.0 118,823.8 252,021.9
Progress (%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
2.2.2 METHODS FOR DUE DILIGENCE
103 In February 2012, the supplementary report preparing agency sent three survey
teams to make due diligence along the railway line by collecting macroscopical
information and performing typical survey. The investigators were informed by
the Owner and construction contractors of the line re-routing in the altered
preliminary design, by the local resettlement authorities of general alterations in
land acquisition and building demolition resulted from route alterations, In
addition, the investigators visited the involved villages in Guiyang, Guangzhou,
Rongjiang and Yangsuo to have discussions with the village officials and involved
persons and obtain the first-hand information and data.
104 The survey was acceptable to the Owner, the resettlement authorities and
construction contractors.
2.2.3 Implementation of Migration and Resettlement
(1) Progress in Implementation of Permanent Land Acquisition
1) Compensation Criteria
105 The compensation criteria applied by the resettlement authorities for the land
acquisition within the coverage of APD (see Section 2.2.1 for more details) are in
compliance with the requirements in the resettlement plan. See Section 2.1.1 and
Appendix 13.10.2 for more details. The compensation criteria applied in Guiyang
and Guangzhou are even far above these specified in the resettlement plan.
2) Progress in Resettlement
106 All compensation for permanent land acquisition has been paid in full to the
village/farmer group accounts by the resettlement authorities, and the
village/villager team will decide distribution of the compensation on an
independent basis. Two settlement methods will be applied: unified reallocation of
land shall be done within village/farmer group and the compensation will be paid
per captivator compensation in cash will be paid directly to the affected
households. The manpower of affected households can not only work on the
remaining farmland owned by them, but also participate in the specialized training
organized by the government. The local government will recommend the properly
trained manpower to business in major or coastal cities through cooperation with
them.in case of allocation in cash, the rural families with very a little or without
farmland will be offered social security resettlement. Currently, land reallocation
operations are being carried out by local village/farmer group and social security
policies have been issued by all levels of authorities. The project owner has
provided the provincial department of social security with funds for social security
resettlement of the farmers losing farmland. The resettlement agencies of local
governments are checking and verifying the number of farmers losing farmland.
As land acquisition is still in process, the verification is being carried out.
(2) Progress in Implementation of Residential Building Demolition
1) Progress in Residential Building Demolition and Removal
107 Rural residence demolition of 66,432m2, urban residence demolition of
118,824m2 and enterprise/institution building demolition of 66,766m
2have been
completed.
2) Compensation Criteria for Building Demolition
108 All compensation criteria for non-residential building demolition and removal
have been determined by certified evaluating institution based on market
replacement cost. The rebuilding cost for demolished rural residences are
estimated by the local resettlement authorities based on the local building
replacement cost and determined and released with policy document for
implementation. Compared to the resettlement plan, the actually implemented
compensation criteria are basically in compliance with the requirements in the
plan.
3) Progress in Residence Demolition and Resettlement
109 Guiyang City:all residence demolition in affected districts in Nanmin
District, Xingyan District and Jinyang District, Guiyang has been completed.
Except that a very small number of affected households choose to monetary
resettlement, most choose the collective resettlement community in place of the
original property right to prevent the risk of building price rise. All buildings for
resettlement will be purchased by the resettlement authorities or constructed by
estate developers commissioned by the government. Currently, the resettlement
communities which have been completed and used include Shenquanliuyun
resettlement community, Yunyan District, where 50 households have moved in,
lveyuan resettlement community, Nanmin District, where 600 households have
moved in, Jiaoyishan resettlement community, Nanmin District, where 231
households have moved in; resettlement communities which have been completed
but not used due to the affected households' reasons (e.g. Property right dispute
etc.) Include: new garden community, which are to contain 30 affected households
in Yunyan District. Resettlement communities which are still in construction
include Daguan Village resettlement community in Jinyang District , Qianjiang
Road No. 5 and No. 6 resettlement community in Nanmin District. Double
compensations for interim resettlement are paid to the involved people who
choose to move into these resettlement communities for rent of interim
buildings.Resettlement communities which are still planned are Black Stone
resettlement community and Duxi Village resettlement community in Baiyun
District.
110 Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village And Kouzai Village in Rongjiang
County, Qiangdongnan Prefecture: Due to land acquisition and building
demolition for construction of the county-level station, construction of a collective
resettlement site for the affected households is still in plan now, and house
demolition in three villages has not been commenced yet.
111 Sidi Village, Xingping Town, Yangsuo County, and GuilinCity: Due to
land acquisition and building demolition for construction of the county-level
station, construction of a collective resettlement site for the affected households is
still being planned now, and house demolition in Sidi Village has not been
commenced yet.
112 Guangzhou City:6 removed rural households subjected to house demolition
have been resettled in the New Hainan Village resettlement site. Construction of
the resettlement community for the residents subjected to house demolition in
Yuexiu District is still being planned. See table 34 for more details.
Table34 - Progress in Construction of Collective Resettlement Sites within Coverage of APD
Cities/Countie
s
Resettlement
Site
Resettlemen
t Capacity
(households)
Progress in
Constructio
n
Planned
Household
s
Resettled
Household
s
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Black Stone
Village
Resettlement
Community
300 Still pending 125 0
Duxi Village
Resettlement
Community
150 Still pending 77 0
Yunyan
District,
Guiyang City
New Garden
Community 200 Completed 30 0
Shengquanliuyu
n Community 500
Completed
and used 50 50
Jinyang
District,
Guiyang City
Daguan Village
Resettlement
Community
600
In
construction
(land leveling
commenced
in October
2011)
280 0
Nanmin
District,
Guiyang City
Lvyuan
Resettlement
Community
1,500 Completed
and used 600 600
Jiaoyishan
Resettlement
Community
700 Completed
and used 231 231
No. 5
Resettlement
Community in
Qianjiang Road
400 In
construction 50 0
No. 6
Resettlement
Community in
Qianjiang Road
400 In
construction 47 0
Rongjiang
County,
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Xiaobao Village
Resettlement
Site
30
In site
selection and
construction
19 0
Yangsuo
County, Guilin
City
Sidi Village
Resettlement
Site
80 In
construction 62 0
Liwan District,
Guangzhou
Hainan Village
Resettlement 300 Completed 6 6
Site
Yuexiu District,
Guangzhou
Yaotai
Community
Resettlement
Site
700 In
construction 302 0
(3) Non-Residential Buildings Demolition and Resettlement
1) Progress in Non-Residential Building Demolition and Removal
113 Non-residential buildings to be demolished include industrial and commercial
enterprise/ institution buildings and school buildings, among which, industrial and
commercial enterprise/ institution building demolition area is 167,611 m2, mainly
distributed in Guiyang City and Guangzhou City, and 85 enterprises/institutions
are involved and industrial and commercial enterprise/ institution buildings of
66,766.3 m2 have been demolished, accounting for 40% (see Table 35 and Table
36 for more details). All affected enterprises/institution buildings in Guiyang
City have been demolished. Demolition of one brickyard in construction in Sidi
Village, Yangsuo County and two enterprises in Liwan District, Guangzhou City
has not been commenced.
114 No school is under material effect of the altered preliminary design.
2) Compensation Criteria
115 All compensation criteria for enterprise/institution building demolition and
removal have been determined by certified estate evaluating institution based on
market replacement cost. Assessment of these compensation costs has taken into
account compensations for enterprises' and staff's loss resulted from close-down
due to demolition and removal.
3) Progress in Resettlement
116 Since enterprise building demolition will have effect on corporate
production/operation and staff's life, this project has attracted enterprises' attention
since release of construction information, and involved enterprises have put the
facility demolition on the agenda. Generally speaking, non-state-owned and
small-sized enterprises usually rent buildings or land to develop corporate
production/operation, so in case that the premises have to be demolished due to
construction of national significant infrastructure, their facility demolition and
reconstruction are more flexible than state-owned enterprises/institutions which
usually independently build their facilities. Most of the 85 enterprises/institutions
involved materially in the APD are located in Guiyang City. For their removal and
reconstruction, the resettlement authorities will carry out their demolition and
rebuilding mainly by resettlement with funds, supported by assistance with the
reconstruction. Private/non-state-owned enterprises usually have solved their
demolition and rebuilding and so tend to desire monetary compensation, while
state-owned enterprises and large-sized institutions have the ability to solve their
demolition and rebuilding. See table 35 and table 36 for more details.
(4) Impact on Infrastructure and Progress in Recovery
1) Impact on Infrastructure
117 A wide range of infrastructures are involved and the demolition and recovery
mechanisms are of great variety. Roads and water supplies usually reconstructed
by the contractors, with the construction cost contained in the construction
contract price. Pole-mounted wires, electric and communication cable will be
demolished and rebuilt by the specialized agencies. More than 90% of the
infrastructures have been demolished, but the permanent reconstruction of most of
them is still in process.
2) Compensation Criteria and Reconstruction
118 All related expenses have been verified by certified evaluating institution and
incorporated to the construction cost for this Project, and will be appropriated by
the Owner. Permanent rebuilding of most involved roads, water conservancy
facilities, bridges and pole-mounted cables is in process and proper interim
substitutes for these facilities have been provided for the communities by the
engineering organization.
(5) Issues Still to be Handled
119 As a whole, the districts within scope of the due diligence where land
acquisition and building demolition have been completed are in the course of
resettlement and reconstruction. The issues still to be handled include:
120 Social security in land acquisition and resettlement. Social security
operations for the land-losing farmers subjected to permanent land acquisition are
still in process and uncompleted. Number of the land-losing farmers within the
coverage of permanent land acquisition needs to be finalized and the social
security policy shall be properly implemented.
121 Resettlement Sites still in Construction. Despite the collective resettlement
sites planned and in construction (see Table 34), the final resettlement of involved
people is still pending.
122 These issues will be traced in the surveillance and evaluation system
developed for this Project for promotion of proper implementation as soon as
possible.
Table35 - Resettlement of Involved Enterprises/Institutions within Coverage of APD
County/D
istrict) Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode Progress
Nanmin
District
Taici Bridge Village Committee Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Education Bureau of Nanmin District, Guiyang City Compensation in cash and
independent resettlement Completed
Women's Federation Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Maqika Group Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Rebuilt
Bureau of National Religious Affairs of Nanmin District,
Guiyang City
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Administration of Environment and Sanitation of Nanmin
District
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Huaguo Police Station, Branch Nanmin, Guiyang
Municipal Public Security Bureau
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Municipal Administration of Nursery Garden Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Neighborhood Committee of Huinong Community,
Huaguoyuan Sub-District Office
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Taici Bridge Village, Houchao Township, Nanmin District,
Guiyang City
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Tongliang Real Estate Development Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Traffic Police Division, Guiyang Municipal Public Security
Bureau
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Wulicong Wholesale Market Compensation in cash and
reconstruction with assistance Completed
Passenger Line Workshop, Track Maintenance Division of
Guiyang
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Linding Automobile Service Center Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Material Recycling Company Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Artist Lamp Plant Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Nanmin Taici Bridge Industry Company Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
North Guard's Room of Railway Station Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Power Supply Section (Transformer Station) Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Labor Service Company (Xinchen Automobile Service),
Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Labor Service Company, Track Maintenance Division of
Guiyang
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Benci Clothing Factory Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Electric Engineering Co. Ltd. of CREG Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
National Security Agency of Guiyang Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Municipal Administration of Water Courses Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Chaoyang Village Committee Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Shida Automobile Service Plant Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Houchao Village Committee Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Railway Building Construction Engineering Company,
CREC
Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Railcom (Guiyang) Company Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Electric Maintenance Division of Chengdu Railway Bureau Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Wuju Social Management Center Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Station of Chengdu Railway Bureau Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Re-Employment Center, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Sanitation Administration, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Office Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Politics Office, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Office Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Daqing Kindergarten Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Neighborhood Committee of Dalishi Community Compensation in cash and
independent reconstruction Completed
Table36 - Resettlement of Involved Enterprises/Institutions within Coverage of APD (Continued - 1)
County/
District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode Progress
Nanmin
District
Neighborhood Committee of Dalishi Community Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Security Guard's Room Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Power Supply Section Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Chaoyang Fittings Plant Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Textile Industry Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Nangang Real Estate Development Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
No. 1 Plastics Manufacturing Plant Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Guizhou Textile Industry Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Toilet No. 77 of Municipal Bureau of Urban
Management
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Toilet No. 4 of Municipal Bureau of Urban
Management
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Toilet No. 76 of Municipal Bureau of Urban
Management
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Minhui Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Toilet of CREG Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
No. 1 Company of CREG Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Ronghua Plastic mold Factory Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Langqinju Estate Management Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Duojing Company of CREC Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Guiyang Jinlixixng Estate Management Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Subtotal - Nanmin District:68 households
Jinyang
District
Guiyang Wudang Wangfa Food Factory
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Gaoxinhengjiang Building Material Co. Ltd.
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Wudang Yuanlong Cement Product
Manufacturing Plant
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Yibai Pharmacy Co. Ltd.
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Liuwenwu Sand Factory of Yangguan Village
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Subtotal - Jinyang District:8 households
Yunyan
District
Food Mall of Gaicha Village Committee Compensation in cash Completed
Liqiang Rubber Product Manufacturing Plant
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Rural Credit Cooperative of Yunyan
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Li Linjun
Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Yu Liming
Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Guo Shijun
Compensation in cash and reconstruction
with assistance Completed
Subtotal - Yunyan District:6 organizations
Total -
Guiyang 82 households
Yangsuo
County
Yuhe Brickyard Still in negotiation Uncompleted
Subtotal (1 household)
Liwan
District
Zengjiao Joint Stock Partnership Economy Cooperative Still in negotiation Uncompleted
Guangzhou Steel Group Company Still in negotiation Uncompleted
Subtotal (2 households)
Total -
Guangzh
ou 2 organizations
Total -
Full Line 85 households
3. SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY
3.1 SCOPE OF SUPPLEMENT RESETTLEMENT PLAN
123 It is found in analysis on the coverage of land acquisition and building demolition
under the altered preliminary design that: Resettlement for land acquisition and
building demolition within the involved districts has been partly completed,
especially in Guiyang. Among the 22 villages/communities involved materially
under APD (see Section 1.4.4 herein for more details), land acquisition and
building demolition have been commenced in 15 ones, and have been completed
in 13 ones, with only 2 left uncompleted (see Section 2.2.1 for more details).
Therefore, the involved districts where land acquisition and building demolition
have not been commenced include: 9 villages/communities in 5
towns/sub-districts in 5 counties/districts, including Baiyun District, Guiyang,
Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan Prefecture, Yangsuo County, Guilin City,
Liwan District and Yuexiu District in Guangzhou City: Black Stone Village and
Duxi Village in Dula Township, Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Xiaobao Village,
Kouzai Village and Yuezai Village in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County, Sidi
Village, Xingping Township in Yangsuo County, Hainan Village in Zhongnan
Sub-District, Zengjiao Community in Hailong Sub-District and Yaotai
Community in Kuangquan Sub-District, Yuexiu District in Guangzhou City.
Targeted survey and analysis on these districts need to be carried out to decide a
targeted resettlement plan, which will be used as supplement and improvement to
this resettlement plan.
3.2 GENERAL SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONDITIONS IN INVOLVED
DISTRICTS
3.2.1 Baiyun District, Guiyang City
124 As one of the 6 districts under the jurisdiction of Guiyang City, Baiyun District is
located at the north of Guiyang, with a total area of 270.37 sq. km, governing two
townships (Dula Township and Niuchang Township), three towns (Yanshahong
Town, Maijia Town and Shawen Town), four sub-districts (Dashandong
Sub-District, Yanshahong Sub-District and Dulaying Sub-District) and 56
administrative villages and 31 communities, and a population of 200,400. This
district is a national trial zone for sustainable development, provincial economic
development zone of Guizhou, and the largest aluminum industry base in China
and important new-type industrial based in the province. Within the district there
are abundant natural resources, and farmland of 1,984.18 hectares,
construction-purpose land of 3,532.78 hectares and unused land of 3,385.64
hectares. The mineral resources mainly include bauxite, iron ore, raw coal,
limestone and marble etc. in large reserve and high quality, easy for mining. The
GDP of Baiyun District always ranks first in the province.
125 Dula Buyi Nationality Township is located about 14 km north of Guiyang
City, southeast of Baiyun economic development zone, between New
Jinyang District and national high-tech development zone, occupying an
total area of 35 sq. km. The township contains 7 administrative villages, 31
farmer groups, an agricultural population of 6,680 in 1,705 households, with
minority nationalities accounting for 53.3% of the total, and is one of the
two minority nationality-involving townships in Baiyun District, Guiyang,
with advantageous geographical position and convenient transportation. The
Sichuan-Guizhou Railway runs across the middle of this township, and
various roads and express way intersect and connect all villages in it,
forming a multi-level road network. It is only 20 minutes' ride from the
township government to Longdongbao International Airport. Sound telecom,
communication and fax networks are available, and every village in the
township has been provided access to power, tap water, telephone and
cableTV. There is farmland of 4,053 mus within this township, including
field of 2,498 mus, land of 1,555 mus and woodland of 19,177 mus. Several
large-/medium-sized enterprises are located in the township, such as
Guiyang Carriage Works of Ministry of Railways, Guiyang North Suburb
Water Works and Guizhou Provincial Beef and Mutton Processing Factory.
In 2002, two another larger business projects were introduced - micro hard
disk project and Xinbang Pharmaceutical. Industrial development within it
has covered six sectors - industry, agriculture, transportation, building trade,
catering industry and service.
3.2.2 Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan Prefecture
126 Rongjiang County is located in the southeast of Rongjiang County, and to the
south of the Qiangdongnan Mao & Dong Autonomous Prefecture, running across
the Pearl River and Yangtze River basins, neighboring Liping County and
Congjiang County in the east, joining Leishan County and Sandu County in the
west, separated from Jianhe County by the border in the north, and connecting
with Libo County in the south. Whole of the county occupies area of 3,315 sq.
command has a population of 340,700, with minority nationalities accounting for
80.37%. This county is divided into 6 towns (Guzhou Town, Zhongcheng Town,
Zaihao Town, Pingyong Town, Leli Town, Langdong Town) and 13 townships
(Zaima Township, Congyi Township, Pingjiang Township, Pingyang Township,
Liangwang Township, Bakai Township, Jihau Township, Renli Shui Township,
Sanjiang Shui Township, Dingwei Shui Township, Xinghua Shui Township,
Shuiwei Shui Township and Tashi Yao & Shui Township), including 5 national
townships.The county seat is located in Guzhou Town. The county has achieved a
total output value of 1.276 billion yuan, including 606,000,000 in the first industry,
238,000,000 in the second industry and 432,000,000 in the third industry. Fast
development has been made in industry, with total industry output value of
259,000,000 yuan achieved in sectors in substantial scale. The state revenues and
expenditures have increased steadily, with a total state revenues of 74.81 million
yuan and an annual total expenditures of 549.14 million yuan. Investment in fixed
assets has increased stably, with a total investment of 525,000,000 yuan.Social
consumable total retail sales are 400,000,000 yuan, and rural net income per
capita is up to 2,350 yuan.
127 Guzhou Town, where the government of Rongjiang County is located, is in the
south of the county, in area of 195 sq. command has a population of 33,700, with
Dong, Miao, Zhuang and Shui nationalities accounting for 51%.Within its
jurisdiction there are 7 village committees and 25 village committees. The
population in it covers Han, Dong, Miao, Shui, Buyi and Zhuang nationalities.
The elevation of its territory is 250 meters.Wurong Road runs across the whole of
the town from north to south, and the Rongjiang Bridge located in the north
connects the downtown to Chezai.There are enterprises in it covering power
generation, machinery, lumber processing, chemicals, food, textile and
papermaking etc.Watermelon and sugarcane are grown broadly in the town.No.
321 national highway joins to Lurong Road and Jinrong Road right here.Duliu
River is navigable for powerboats.
3.2.3 Yangsuo County, Guilin City
128 Yangsuo County is famous for its beautiful scenery, and is located in the
northeast of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, to the south of Guilin City,
with the county seat 65 km far from downtown of Guilin. The territory of this
county is neighboring to Gongcheng County and Pingle County in the east, Lipu
County in the south, Yongfu County and Lingui County in the west, and bordering
Lingchuan County and Yansha District in the north. Its territory occupies area of
1,428.38 sq. km. Yangsuo County has Yangsuo Town under its rule, including 6
towns (Yangsuo, Baisha, Fuli, Xingpin, Putao and Gaotian), 3 townships (Jinbao,
Puyi and Yangdi), 99 administrative villages (residential areas), 6 communities
and 944 natural villages/villager groups. Occupying total area of 1,428 sq. km,this
county has farmland of 2 hectares and population of 30, ruling 6 towns and 3
townships, covering Han, Zhuang, Yao and Hui etc., 11 nationalities in total.
Yangsuo lies in sub-tropic monsoon region, with rich heat sources, plenty of
sunshine and rainfall. It has annual average air temperature of 19 °C, annual
sunlight quantity of 1,465 hours; annual average rainfall capacity of 1,640 mm
and frost-free season of 302 days. With abundant natural resources, sound soil
nature and excellent adaptability, it boasts high and steady crop yields. Rice is the
primary food crop and presents an annual output of 13 tons.Shatian Pomelo,
kumquat, persimmon and Chinese chestnut are the four major local special
products, and especially the Shatian Pomelo is famous for its delicious taste.
Yangsuo County boasts a wide range of natural and human landscapes. The
natural landscapes are mainly mountains, waters, grotto and ancient Banvan,while
the human landscape includes pavilions, terraces and towers and stone inscriptions.
During 2011, the county achieved a total output value of 6.903 billion yuan, state
revenue up to 555,000,000 yuan, investment in fixed assets of 9.743 billion yuan,
urban disposable income per capita of 23,516 yuan, rural net income per capita of
7,427 yuan, social consumable total retail sales of 1.578 billion yuan.
129 As the largest town in Yangsuo County, Xingping Town occupies 305.4 sq. km,
ruling 14 village committees - Qiaotoupu, Xishan, Gupizai, Shujiabao, Baishandi,
Sidi, Dayuan, Jiangchun, Xitang, Shuluo, Xingpinng, Huashan, Yuchun and
Daping - and 2 sub-districts - Xingping and Yuye, and 171 natural villages,
boasting a population of 42,600 in 10,400 households, including nonagricultural
population of 2,500, Han population of 42,156 and other nationality population of
479. Xingping Town is the core of the world-famous Lijiang tourist resort in
Guilin. This town is hilly, with its terrain falling down to the west, The western
area is of karst landform, with peaks standing in clusters on both sides of Lijing,
while the eastern part is of Haopinglong mountain range, steep with elevation in
most part above 400 meters and hundreds of peaks above one thousand meters.
The highest peak is Haopinglong, with elevation of 1,701 meters. Lijing River,
Dayuan River and Hujiayuan run across its territory. There are also dense forests
and intersecting waters in the town, contributing to complex landform.
3.2.4 LIWAN DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU CITY
130 Liwan District lies in the west of Guangzhou, and is a central urban area featuring
south of the Five Ridges and the core of Guangzhou-Foshan megalopolis. It joins
to Yuexiu District at the east, accesses Baiyun District by land and water at the
north and northwest, and border Nanhai District, Foshan at the west, boasting
transportation extending in all directions. It occupies 62.4 sq. km, has a population
of 1.03 million, and rules 22 administrative sub-districts and 193 community
neighborhood committees. Since ancient times there has been flourishing
commerce and trade in Liwan. And now there are 222 specialized markets,
including 31 ones with annual transaction above hundred million yuan, 4 ones
above billion yuan, covering 18 commodity categories. Ten Top specialized
markets in the district involve in communication facilities, ready-to-wear clothing,
shoes, Chinese teas, jewelry and jadeware, medicine, children's garments,
exquisite cultural articles, furniture and building material, flowers and plants, and
pet fishes. Currently it is leading the domestic markets in Chinese tea, shoes,
medicinal materials and flowers and plants. A huge number of famous brands are
gathered in the shoe mall on the west of the station, thus developing the largest,
most diversified and influential shoe service and material market, taking the
leadership in Guangzhou. During 2010, whole of the district achieved a total
output value of 61.255 billion yuan, a total tax revenues of 17.850 billion yuan,
total investment of 18.823 billion yuan in fixed assets, urban disposable income
per capita up to 29,947 yuan. With implementation of the Guideline on Reform
and Development plan(2008-2020)for Pearl River Delta Region, further
advancement of co-urbanization of Guangzhou and Foshan, and proposal of the
aim to building Guangzhou into a national central city, Liwan District has been
committed to comprehensive and challenging great goals concerning
co-urbanization, modern services, urban culture, resource allocation, economic
impact, urban layout and social undertaking etc. Listed as one of the six major
function zones in Guangzhou, White Swan Pond Economic Circle is a key
construction project aiming to build Guangzhou into an international portal city,
while reconstruction of old urban areas, old plant buildings and old countryside is
another significant driving force for Liwan District to speed up transformation of
economic development mode and boost growth. In addition, Liwan District has
played an active role in implementing cultural guidance strategy, promoting
Lingnan culture, building up landmark of traditional Linnan culture and
promoting culture level and city style in Liwan District by building Five Areas
and One Mall (Lizhi Bay culture & leisure area, Chenjiaci Lingnan cultural plaza
area, Shamian European Mainland-Style leisure area, Shisanhang commercial &
cultural area, Shuixiuhuaxiang ecological & cultural area and pedestrian mall.
131 Hailong Community in Zhongnan Sub-District lies in the southwest of
Liwan District, a city-country fringe zone. The sub-district rules 3 economic
cooperatives (Zengjiao, Haibei and Longxi) and 3 community neighborhood
committees, occupying area of 9.49 sq. km, with a permanent resident
population of 12,000.
3.2.5 YUEXIU DISTRICT, GUANGZHOU CITY
132 Yuexiu District is the oldest central urban district in Guangzhou. Since the great
change to administrative areas in Guangzhou City in 2005, Yuexiu District has
become the central urban district with the smallest area but the largest population
density. As the administrative, commercial, financial and cultural center in
Guangzhou, and relying on its unique and advantageous position, Yuexiu District
has developed an industrial layout focusing on the tertiary industry, driving by
characteristic economy and supported by commerce and trade service. A set of
famous commerce and trade areas has been set up, covering Beijing Road, Haiyin
area, Hero Plaza and Yide Road etc., and a leading commerce and trade center and
historical cultural & tourist area have been developed around the 5th Zhongsha
Road, featuring international central commerce around the eastern part, modern
service on Dongfeng Road, flower expo etc. With high-density concentration of
office buildings, traffic of people, materials, fund and information, a characteristic
"headquarters economy" pattern has been developed and serves as a key access
open to the outer world in South China. Yuexiu District has taken the leadership
in total output value, social consumable total retail sales and total merchandise
sales etc., played an outstanding role in commerce and trade in Guangzhou City.
As an epitome of developed commercial culture in Guangzhou, Yuexiu District
has boasted three of four commercial centers in Guangzhou since modern times,
covering Beijing Road, the 4th Zhongsha Road, the Middle Liberation Road
(Sipailou), Changti-Southern People Road. Since 1957, Chinese Export
Commodities Fair hosted by Guangzhou has always been held in Yuexiu District
in Spring and Autumn every year, where a huge amount of business gather here
and the volume of business accounts for one third of the annual total volume of
export trade in China, and is honored as the wind vane and barometer for foreign
trade in China”. Yuexiu District has achieved a total output value of 88.938 billion
yuan, accounting for more than 17% of the total of the city, leading all districts in
Guangzhou. Its increase in the tertiary industry is 85.467 billion yuan, accounting
for nearly one third of the total of the city, leading all districts in Guangzhou. Its
increase in the second industry is 3.470 billion yuan, and the proportion of the
second industry to the tertiary industry is 3.90 : 96.10. During the whole year the
district has achieved social consumable total retail sales of 36.279 billion yuan,
accounting for nearly one fifth of the total of the city; total merchandise sales of
213.967 billion yuan, accounting for nearly one third of the total of the city, both
leading all districts in Guangzhou. 192 enterprise have their sales above hundred
million yuan, contributing to a total of 124.241 billion yuan, mainly covering
gasoline, coal and diesel and other oil products and textile and clothing industries.
133 Kuangquan Sub-District Office was founded in June 1981, ruling 14 community
neighborhood committees and more than 450 basic units, a permanent resident
population of more than 32,000, temporary resident population of more than
24,000, and floating population of more than 100,000. There are 2 middle schools
and 4 primary schools within its jurisdiction. Boasting advantageous geographical
position, developed transportation and booming commerce, Kuangquan
Sub-District is honored as Golden Triangle, in which more than 100 specialized
markets are located.
3.3 SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY MODE
134 In February 2012, the supplementary report preparing agency sent three survey
teams respectively to Guangdong, Guangxi and Guizhou. Based on the survey
schedule as defined in the Operation Program, the route drawing provided by the
design institution (the Second Railway Investigation & Design Institution and the
Fourth Railway Investigation & Design Institution) and interview with the
resettlement authorities in involved districts, the survey team went to the 9
involved villages as stated above, and visited some households (see Section 10.1.4
for more details) by stratified random sampling (with sample rate of 15.2%) to
obtain basic information on the involved villages/communities and involved
people.
3.4 FINDINGS
3.4.1 INVOLVED POPULATION
135 There is a population of 30,078 in 9,160 households within the influenced area. And
agricultural population takes a high proportion of the total, except for the two communities
(Hailong Sub-District in Liwan District and Kuangquan Sub-District in Yuexiu District) in
Guangzhou.
136 The population involved in land acquisition and building demolition for this Project within
the influenced area is 2,938, only accounting for 9% of the total population in the 9 involved
villages/communities, but to different influence extent. The involved population in Black
Stone Village, Dula Village, Baiyun District in Guiyang accounts for 43% of the total, the
one in Duxi Village accounts for 16%, while these in other villages are below 15%.Only 2
enterprises (1 enterprise under the Zengjiao Economic Cooperative) demolished and
removed within Zengjiao Community, Hailong Sub-District, Liwan District in Guangzhou,
accounting for 1%. See Table 37 for more details.
Table37 - Statistics on Population within Influenced Area
Cities/
Counti
es
Townshi
p/Town/S
ub-Distri
ct
Village
Population Involved Population
Total
Househo
lds
Total
Populati
on
Agricu
ltural
Popula
tion
Ratio of
AP (%)
Involved
Populatio
n
Ratio of IP
(%)
Baiyun
District,
Guiyan
g City
Dula
Township
Black
Stone
Village
750 1,352 1,352 100% 580 43%
Duxi
Village 800 1,580 1,580 100% 247 16%
Rongjia
ng
County,
Qiangd
ongnan
Prefect
ure
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village 331 1,586 1,569 99% 182 12%
Kouzai
Village 550 2,280 2,217 97% 182 8%
Xiaobao
Village 285 1,285 1,187 92% 190 15%
Yangsu
o
County,
Guilin
City
Xingping
Town
Sidi
Village 543 2,023 2,023 100% 258 13%
Liwan
District,
Guangz
hou
Zhongnan
Sub-Distri
ct
Hainan
Village 1,150 3,838 3,600 94% 248 6%
Hailong
Sub-Distri
ct
Zengjiao
Communi
ty
1,551 3,334 1,787 54% 50 1%
Yuexiu Kuangqua Yaotai 3,200 12,800 0 0% 1,000 8%
District,
Guangz
hou
n
Sub-Distri
ct
Communi
ty
Total 9,160 30,078 15,315 51% 2938 10%
137 A population of 2,938 in 803 households within the 9 involved villages/communities is
subjected to land acquisition and house demolition, among which, 773 people in 211
households are involved in land acquisition only, 1,564 people in 444 households are
involved in house demolition only, while 601 people in 148 households are subjected to
both (mostly in Black Stone Village, Baiyun District, Guiyang City). See Table 38 for more
details.
Table38 - Statistics on Population Subjected to Land Acquisition/Building Demolition in
Influenced Areas
Cities/Counties
Township/To
wn/Sub-Distr
ict
Village/Comm
unities
Involved Population
Total of
Involved
Population
Population
Involved in
Land
Acquisition
Population
Involved in
House
Demolition
Population
Involved in
Both
Hou
seh
olds
Popul
ation
Ho
use
hol
ds
Popu
latio
n
House
holds
Popu
latio
n
House
holds
Popu
lation
Baiyun District, Guiyang City Dula
Township
Black Stone
Village 145 580 20 80 15 60 110 440
Duxi Village 77 247 0 0 66 202 11 45
Subtotal 222 827 20 80 81 262 121 485
Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village 48 182 45 166 0 0 3 16
Kouzai
Village 48 182 47 177 0 0 1 5
Xiaobao
Village 50 190 35 122 0 0 15 68
Subtotal 146 555 12
7 465 0 0 19 89
Yangsuo County, Guilin City Xingping
Town
Sidi Village 62 258 0 0 62 258
Subtotal 62 258 0 0 62 258 0 0
Liwan District, Guangzhou
Zhongnan
Sub-District
Hainan 70 248 64 227 0 0 6 21
Subtotal 70 248 64 227 0 0 6 21
Hailong
Sub-District
Zengjiao
Community 1 50 0 0 1 50
Subtotal 1 50 0 0 1 50 0 0
Yuexiu District, Guangzhou Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Community 302 1,000 0 0 300 994 2 6
Subtotal 302 1,000 0 0 300 994 2 6
Total 803 2,938 21
1 773 444 1,564 148 601
Table39 - Statistics on Population Industry Distribution and Income in Involved Villages
Villa
ge
Labor Force (Person) Farmland Area (mu) Net Income Per Capita
Total
Labor
Force
Migrant
Worker
s
Industria
l
Workers
Agricultur
al
Workers
Tertiary
Industry-Related
Workers
Farmla
nd
Area
Farmland
Area Per
Capita
Net
Income
Per Capita
0-
80
0
800-
1,50
0
1,500
-3,00
0
3,000
-5,00
0
5,000-
10,00
0
Above
10,000
Black
Stone
Villa
ge
900 115
665 120 7,000 5.18 10,000 12
50 78 610
Duxi
Villa
ge
1,000 200
700 100 7,800 4.94 7,600 15
280 480 125
Yuez
ai
Villa
ge
810 130 70 600 130 1,200 1.01 3,200 50
100 146 20 15
Kouz
ai
Villa
ge
998 270 499 299 200 1,070 0.43 4,600 98 102 100 200 30 20
Xiao
bao
Villa
700 100 140 350 140 1,435 1.21 4,100 78
85 122 30 30
ge
Sidi
Villa
ge
1,638 512
1,126
1,768 0.70 3,500 38 100 375
30
Hain
an
Villa
ge
2,250 100 400 1,650 100 2,650 0.69 19,101
2
1,150
Zengj
iao
Com
munit
y
2,375
375
2,000 400 0.48 18,762
23
1,551
Yaot
ai
Com
munit
y
9,800
1,500
8,300 265 0.07 21,660
12
3,288
3.4.2 ECONOMIC CONDITION OF INVOLVED
VILLAGES/COMMUNITIES
138 With respect to employment condition in the involved villages, the working
population in the villages/communities in suburbs of Guiyang (Black Stone
Village and Duxi Village)and Guangzhou (Hainan Village and Zengjiao
Community and Yaotai Community) are mostly engaged in industries other than
agriculture and have high incomes, while those in under-developed areas such as
Sidi Village, Xiaobao Village,Yuezai Village and Kouzai Village are mostly
engaged in farming, more relying on farmland (see Table 39 for more details),
especially in Sidi Village,Yangsuo County, the farmers obtain their incomes
mainly by growing crops. It is particularly noticeable that there is high farmland
area per capita (more than 5 mus per capita) in two involved villages in Dula
Township, Baiyun District, and Guiyang).
139 See Table 40 for more details. The farmers in two involved villagers in Baiyun
District, Guiyang have increased their incomes by taking the advantage of the
consumer area in the neighboring major cities (rural home inn service) and
traditional crop and plant cultivation (growing chive).The farmers in three
involved villagers in Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County have increased their
incomes by being engaged in building trade, bamboo/timber processing and
shipping in the neighboring counties while growing crops. The farmers in Sidi
Village, Yangsuo County mainly rely on traditional crop and plant cultivation,
especially orange cultivation, and work out during slack farming seasons. The
farmers in the suburb of Guangzhou are mainly engaged in flower cultivation and
sales on their farmland or house rent and trade service by taking advantage of the
neighboring major cities, relying on land very a little.
Table40 - Statistics on Income Sources of Involved Farmers
Cities/C
ounties
Townsh
ip/Tow
n/Sub-
District
Village Income Source
Baiyun
District,
Guiyang
City
Dula
Townshi
p
Black
Stone
Village
1.chive cultivation;2.land transport (20 households);3.rural
home inn service (22 households);4. livestock raising
(hens, pigs);5.migrant employment;
Duxi
Village
1.chive cultivation;2.rural home inn;3.migrant
employment;
Rongjia
ng
County,
Qiangdo
ngnan
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village
1.agricultural cultivation (40% of total income);2.migrant
employment (60% of total income).
Kouzai
Village
1.building trade (building/ bridge construction): 120
people;2.migrant employment in Guangdong or Yunan
etc.:270 people; incomefrom woodland trade (forestry
Prefectu
re
center);4.Orchard:1,000;5.development of small-scale
enterprise2 timber processing enterprises; 5 wood charcoal
processing enterprises, 1 electric pole factory
Xiaobao
Village
1.freighting trade:150 transporting vehicles, including 70
large-sized ones, farmers with driving license accounting
for 70%;2.working in the local timber processing
factory;3.agricultural cultivation (10 households
completely relying on farmland).
Yangsuo
County,
Guilin
City
Xingpin
g Town
Sidi
Village
1.growing taro and fruits (orange growing area above
1,000 mus); 2.migrant employment;
Liwan
District,
Guangzh
ou
Zhongn
an
Sub-Dis
trict
Hainan
Village 1.house rent;2.flower cultivation and sales;
Hailong
Sub-Dis
trict
Zengjiao
Communi
ty
1.house rent;3.flower cultivation and sales;
Yuexiu
District,
Guangzh
ou
Kuangq
uan
Sub-Dis
trict
Yaotai
Communi
ty
1.trade service;2.house rent,
3.4.3 OVERVIEW OF VULNERABLE GROUPS IN
INVOLVED VILLAGES
140 Table 41 presents distribution of vulnerable groups in the involved villages,
which cover the disabled, households enjoying the five guarantees (HEFG),
poverty-stricken families and woman-housekeeping families (WHF) etc., but only
a minority of the families are liable to be involved in land acquisition and house
demolition for this Project.
141 These families exist in both under-developed and well-off villages. They shall be
treated as special cases, and be helped specially to recover their life standard to
the same or above the original one.
Table41 - Distribution of Vulnerable Groups
Cities/Cou
nties
Tow
nship
/Tow
n/Su
b-Di
strict
Village
Population Vulnerable Groups
Total
House
holds
Total
Populat
ion
HEFG
(Person
)
The
Disable
d
(Person
)
WHF
Poverty
-Stricke
n
Family
Baiyun Dula Black 750 1,352 12
30 12
District,
Guiyang
City
Tow
nship
Stone
Village
Duxi
Village 800 1,580 15
15
Rongjiang
County,
Qiangdong
nan
Prefecture
Guzh
ou
Tow
n
Yuezai
Village 331 1,586 3 10 8 50
Kouzai
Village 550 2,280 5 27 17 98
Xiaobao
Village 285 1,285 1 18 10 78
Yangsuo
County,
Guilin
City
ping
Tow
n
Sidi
Village 543 2,023 20 18 34 38
Liwan
District,
Guangzho
u
Zhon
gnan
Sub-
Distr
ict
Hainan
Village 1,150 3,838
25
2
Hail
ong
Sub-
Distr
ict
Zengjiao
Communi
ty
1,551 3,334
51 66 23
Yuexiu
District,
Guangzho
u
Kuan
gqua
n
Sub-
Distr
ict
Yaotai
Communi
ty
3,200 12,800
23
4. INFLUENCE OF LAND ACQUISITION & BUILDING
DEMOLITION FOR THIS PROJECT
4.1 COVERAGE OF THE PROJECT
142 According to the survey on the villages/communities where and building
demolition have not been commenced, among the 9 involved
villages/communities,Sidi Village,Xingping Town, Yangsuo County has
completed all compensation and resettlement operations for land acquisition, and
Hainan Village, Zhongnan Sub-District, Liwan District, Guangzhou has
completed part (about 50%) of the operations, while the others have not
commenced them.
143 This Project has effect on various types of land, buildings and their auxiliary
facilities, related facilities and infrastructure which are involved in land
acquisition within these areas. As the construction contractors have entered the
sites and made arrangement in place, all planned land temporarily requisitioned
has been put into use. The data on influence of the Project and number of involved
population are based on the overall survey in these areas.
4.2 PHYSICAL INDICATORS OF INFLUENCE OF LAND ACQUISITION
AND MIGRATION
4.2.1 Permanent Land Acquisition
144 Land acquisition of 1,406.2 mus under the altered preliminary design has not
been commenced yet, involving a population of 1,374 in 359 households, among
which, 923 mus in Black Stone Village, 34 mus in Duxi Village, 95 mus in Yuezai
Village, 137.2 mus in Kouzai Village, 154.2 mus in Xiaobao Village, 59.7 mus in
Hainan Village, and 3 mus in Yaotai Community.
4.2.2 Temporarily Used Land
145 As the construction contractors has entered the construction sites as early as in
2008, the planned land temporarily requisitioned has been put into use, so there is
no unused temporarily requisitioned land within the coverage of the altered
preliminary design.
4.2.3 Building Demolition
146 Building demolition of 241,371.5 m2 in the influenced areas has not been
commenced, involving a population of 2,165 in 592 households, including rural
residences of 100,628.3 m2 , involving 116 persons in 290 households, industrial
and commercial enterprise buildings of 98,845.3 m2 , and urban residences of
41,898 m2 , involving 1,000 people in 302 households. See Table 43 for more
details.
(1) Residential Building Demolition
147 Rural residences of 100,628.3 m2 have not been demolished, covering Black
Stone Village ( 58,460.3 m2 ) and Duxi Village ( 24,204.6 m
2 ) Dula Township,
Baiyun District, Guiyang, Sidi Village ( 13,560 m2 ), Yangsuo County, and
Xiaobao Village ( 1,936.9 m2 ), Yuezai Village ( 462 m
2 ) and Kouzai Village
( 4.4 m2 ) in Rongjiang County.
148 Urban residences of 41,898 m2 have not been demolished, all in Yaotai
Community, Yuexiu District, and Guangzhou.
(2) Non-Residential Buildings Demolition
149 Non-residential buildings of 98,845.3 m2 have not been demolished, including
one large-scale brickyard of 86,000 m2 in construction in Sidi Village, Yangsuo
County, involving 3 persons; plant buildings of 10,658.6 m2 owned by Zengjiao
Joint Stock Partnership Economy Cooperative in Zengjiao Community, Hailong
Sub-District, Liwan District, involving 50 persons;
4.2.4 Vulnerable Groups
150 There is no vulnerable group in the involved population.
Table42 - Statistics on Physical Impact of Land Acquisition in Influenced Area Unit:mu
County/District Township/T
own Village
Invol
ved
Hous
ehold
s
Invol
ved
Popu
lation
Farmland
Farm-Pur
pose Pond
Farm-Purpos
e Woodland
Construction-
Purpose Land
Uncultiva
ted Land
Oth
er
Un
use
d
Lan
d
Tot
al Sub
total
Paddy
Field
Dry
Far
m
Vegetab
le Field
Orc
har
d
Ot
her
s
Baiyun District,
Guiyang City
Dula
Township
Black
Stone
Village
130 520 723.
0 723.0 0.0 0.0 200.0 0.0 0.0
923
.0
Duxi
Village 11 45 34.0 6.0 28.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
34.
0
Subtotal 141 565 757.
0 6.0 28.0 723.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
957
.0
Rongjiang County,
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village 48 182 90.8 89.9 0.1 0.7 4.2
95.
0
Kouzai
Village 48 182
136.
3 136.3 0.0 1.0
137
.2
Xiaobao
Village 50 190
133.
3 106.6 0.8
25.
9 12.0 5.3 3.6
154
.2
Subtotal 146 555 360.
3 332.8 0.9 0.0
26.
6 0.0 0.0 16.3 5.3 0.0 4.5
386
.4
Yangsuo County,
Guilin City
Xingping
Town
Sidi
Village 0.0 0.0
Subtotal 0 0 0.0 0.0
Liwan District,
Guangzhou
Zhongnan
Sub-District
Hainan 70 248 59.7 40.0 19.
7
59.
7
Subtotal 70 248 59.7 40.0 0.0 0.0 19.
7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
59.
7
Yuexiu District,
Guangzhou
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Communit
y
2 6 3.0 3.0 3.0
Subtotal 2 6 3.0 3.0 3.0
Total 359 1,374 1,18
0.1 381.8 28.9 723.0
46.
4 0.0 0.0 216.3 5.3 0.0 4.5
1,4
06.
2
Table43 - Statistics on Physical Impact of Building Demolition in Influenced Areas
County/District Township/Town Village Removed
Households
Removed
Population
Rural Residences Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Brick Brick-Wood Earth-Wood Primitive
Baiyun
District,
Guiyang City
Dula Township
Black
Stone
Village
125 500 60,460.3 36,991.8 2,446.5 0 21,022 60,460.3
Duxi
Village 77 247 24,204.7 22,167.8 291.8 0 1,745.1 24,204.7
Subtotal 202 747 84,665 59,159.6 2,738.3 0 22,767.1 0 0 0 84,665
Rongjiang
County,
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Guzhou Town
Yuezai
Village 3 16 462 0 0 0 462 462
Kouzai
Village 1 5 4.4 0 0 0 4.4 4.4
Xiaobao
Village 15 68 1,936.9 39.9 455.9 1,008.4 432.7 1,936.9
Subtotal 19 89 2,403.3 39.9 455.9 1,008.4 899.1 0 0 0 2,403.3
Yangsuo
County, Guilin
City
Xingping Town Sidi
Village 62 258 13,560 6,600 3,000 2,200 1,760 86,000 99,560
Subtotal 62 258 13,560 6,600 3,000 2,200 1,760 86,000 0 0 99,560
Liwan District,
Guangzhou
Hailong
Sub-District
Zengjiao
Community 1 50 0 12,845.3 12,845.3
Subtotal 1 50 0 0 0 0 0 12,845.3 0 0 12,845.3
Yuexiu
District,
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Community 302 1,000 0 41,898 41,898
Guangzhou Subtotal 302 1,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41,898 41,898
Total - Full Line 592 2,165 100,628.3 65,799.5 6,194.2 3,208.4 25,426.2 98,845.3 0 41,898 241,371.6
5. MIGRATION POLICY FRAMEWORK
5.1 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT GOAL
151 The migration and resettlement goal for the altered preliminary design is, as
specified in the original plan, to minimize quantity of physical materials subjected
to land acquisition and building demolition by taking all measures in engineering,
technology and economy; and where land acquisition and building demolition is
necessary, to minimize the influence on local residents' life and production by
taking all effective measures;
to make socio-economic survey and prepare proper migration and
resettlement plan during construction preparation stage;
to recover or improve the migrants' original production/life standard based on
the physical demolition indicators and compensation criteria;
to promote development-oriented migration. Rural migration and
resettlement will be based on land and the local developed second and
tertiary industries to expand employment channels;
to develop and improve basic life security system for farmers subjected to
land acquisition;
to encourage migrants to participate in migration and resettlement program;
to resettle the migrants in the same community where they live as much as
possible.
5.2 APPLICABLE LAWS AND POLICIES
5.2.1 WORLD BANK'S NON-VOLUNTARY MIGRATION
POLICY
71. The goal of the World Bank's Non-Voluntary Migration Policy is:
All feasible project design proposal should be sought for to minimize
non-voluntary migration.
where migration is necessary, such migration should be designed and
implemented based on sustainable development. Sufficient funds should be
provided to ensure the migrants to share interests from the project.
Consultation should be done with the migrants to give them access to
participation in the planning and implementation of the migration and
resettlement program.
Every effort should be made to help the migrants improve production and
living standard, and at least recover their life to the same or above the
original level.
72. Measures Necessary for Achievement of Goal:
Proper measure shall be taken in migration and resettlement program or its
policy framework to ensure that the migrants will be informed of their rights
to make choice and other rights concerning migration and resettlement;
be informed of the feasible technical and economic programs, participate in
consultation and have access to choices.
Effective compensation shall be obtained quickly based on all replacement
costs to make up for the direct loss in property resulted from this Project.
For influence on residence removal, proper measures shall be taken in the
migration and resettlement program or the policy framework to ensure the
migrants to obtain necessary assistance (e.g. subsidy for house demolition);
or to obtain residence or house site, or agricultural production location as
required with the conditions at least equivalent to the original ones.
To achieve the goal of this policy, proper measures shall be taken in the
migration and resettlement program or the policy framework to ensure the
migrants to obtain necessary assistance within the interim stage as
estimated/required for recovery of production/living standard;
as well as other assistance, such as in land leveling, credit, training or
employment.
Special attention shall be paid to the vulnerable groups' needs, especially
those living below the poverty line or without land, or liable to be out of
protection from national land compensation laws.
Land-based resettlement strategy shall be considered preferentially for people
living on the land, including resettling the migrants on the public land or
private land purchased for such resettlement. Any alternative land provided
for the migrants shall have the production potential, position advantage or
other comprehensive conditions at least equivalent to these prior to land
acquisition. If the migrants do not put priority to acquisition of land, or the
provided land will have adverse effect on sustainable development of the
park or protected area, or the land cannot be obtained at a reasonable price,
resettlement program based on employment or access to independent
livelihood should be provided in addition to compensation in cash. In case of
shortage of land, necessary explanation shall be given and documented as
required by the World Bank.
Compensation in cash is likely to be paid for loss in property on condition
that:(a) the involved farmer lives mainly on land, but the land requisitioned
is merely a minority of the Property loss, while the rest can be depended on
economically;(b) active land, residence and employment markets are
available for sufficient provision of land and residence; or (c) the involved
farmer does not live on land. Compensation in cash is sufficient to, based on
the full market replacement cost, make up for the loss in land and other
properties.
Related information should be provided promptly for the migrants and their
community or the resettlement community where they are to be resettled.
Necessary consultation should be made with them with respect to migration
and resettlement program, and access should be provided to participation in
planning, implementation and surveillance of the program. Proper and
applicable complaint mechanism shall be available to these groups.
necessary infrastructure and public service should be provided in the new
migrant resettlement site or community for recovery of or improvement to
the original level. Alternative or similar resources should be provided to
make up for the loss in the original ones (e.g. fishing area, pasturing area,
fuel or forage).
The community should be organized in the way applicable to the new
environment as selected by the migrants. The existing social and cultural
systems among the migrants and in the resettlement community should be
maintained as much as possible, and migrants' opinion on resettlement should
be respected and taken into account.
152 All operations in land acquisition and building demolition under the APD for this
Project shall be in compliance with the World Bank's migration and resettlement
policy and necessary measures shall be taken to meet these requirements.
All feasible project design proposal should be sought for to minimize
non-voluntary migration.
where migration is necessary, such migration should be designed and
implemented based on sustainable development. Sufficient funds should be
provided to ensure the migrants to share interests from the project.
Consultation should be done with the migrants to give them access to
participation in the planning and implementation of the migration and
resettlement program.
Every effort should be made to help the migrants improve production and
living standard, and at least recover their life to the same or above the
original level.
5.2.2 LAW AND POLICY FRAMEWORKS
153 The policies applicable to migration and resettlement for increased land
acquisition and house demolition have covered both these involved in the original
plan and the new policies add by the local governments.
154 The specific laws and policies include:
The Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China, issued in
August 1998 and revised on August 28, 2004 based on the Decision on
Revising the Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China;
The State Council's Decision on Deepening Reform and Managing Strictly
Land (No. CI-2004-28);
Instructions on Improving Land Acquisition Compensation & Resettlement
System (No. NI-2004-238);
Regulations on the Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the
People's Republic of China (the State Council's Decree No. 256) issued in
December 1998;
Notice on Strengthening Land Control and Related Issues (No. CI-2006-31);
Regulations on Expropriation of Houses on State-owned Land and
Compensation Therefor (the State Council's Decree No. 590) issued on
January 21, 2011;
Law of the People’s Republic of China on Administration of the Urban Real
Estate issued in April 1994;
Regulations on the Protection of Prime Cropland issued in December 1998;
Notice of the State Council on Further Strengthening Land Control and
Protection of Farmland issued in 1997;The Law of Land Administration of
the People's Republic of China and the Regulations on Implementation of it;
Rural Land Contract Law;
Organic Law on Village Committee;
Regulations of Guizhou Province on Land Control issued in September 2000;
Regulations of Guizhou Province on Administration of Urban House
Demolition & Removal (Code No. 48) issued by the People's Government of
Guizhou Province on July 2000;
Measures for Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the
People's Republic of China in Guizhou Province, Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region and Guangdong Province;
Notice on Issuance of Compensation Plan for Land Expropriation in
Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guizhou Section) (No.
QOLR-2008-134);
Notice on Provision of Employment Training and Social Security for
Land-Requisitioned Farmers, issued by the Government of Guizhou Province
on December 7, 2007;
Regulations of Guiyang City on Appraisal of Demolished Houses (Code No.
142) issued by Guiyang Municipal Government in March 2005;
Standards of Guiyang City for House Cost Price, Civil Engineering
Construction Cost, compensations for Interim Resettlement and Subsidy for
Demolition and Removal (CGOI-2004-109);
Notice of Guiyang Municipal Government on Issuance of Compensation for
Plot Price in Land Acquisition Area and Unified Annual Output Value for
Land Acquisition (CGI-2009-100);
Notice of People's Government of Qiangdongnan Prefecture on Issuance of
Comprehensive Land Price in Land Acquisition Area and Unified Annual
Output Value for Land Acquisition (QGI-2009-64);
The Criteria of Average Annual Output Value of Land requisition and
Compensation for Building Demolition for Construction of Key
Infrastructure Project in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region
(GNL-2005-190);
Trial Measures for Implementation of Social Security for Land-Requisitioned
Farmers in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, issued by the Regional
Office of Labor and Social Security, Office of Land and Resources and
Office of Finance on January 22, 2008;
Measures for Land Acquisition and House Demolition Compensation for
Infrastructure Construction in Guangdong Province (No. GDGO-2003-46)
issued in June 2003;
Opinions on Resolution of Social Security-Related Issues, issued by the
Government of Guangdong Province on September 3, 2007;
Compensation & Protection Standard of Guangdong Province for Land
Acquisition (No. GDOLR-2006-149) issued in July 2006; Measures for
Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic
of China in Guangdong Province;
Notice on Review of Implementation of Social Pension Security for Farmers
Subjected to Land Acquisition in Guangdong Province (GDESP-2008-10);
Regulations on Compensation for Building Demolition on Collective Land in
Guangzhou City (GZNH-2007-955) issued on December 19, 2007;
Measures for House Acquisition and Compensation Therefor on
State-Owned Land in Guangzhou City (GZG-2011-17);
Measures for Implementation of Social Pension Insurance in New-Type
Village in Guzhou Town (GZGO-2010-80):
Social Security Policy of the World Bank (OP/BP 4 - Non-Voluntary
Migration;
design documents, related drawings and survey results for this Project.
5.3 RELATED LAWS AND REGULATIONS
155 Related rules on compensation for land acquisition specified under Article 47 in
the Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China
156 To further enhance land management, the State Council's Decision on Deepening
Reform and Strictly Managing Land (Document No. 28) was issued by the State
Council in 2004 to put forward new requirements for improvement to
compensation for land acquisition. It is stipulated in Article 12 that: Improve the
compensation measures for land acquisition. LocalPeople are Government at and
above the county level shall take feasible measures to ensure the
land-requisitioned farmers' living standard not to fall due to land acquisition.
Compensations for land, subsidy for resettlement and compensations for
attachments and young crops on the land shall be legally paid in full and without
delay. In case that the compensations for land and subsidy for resettlement are not
sufficient to maintain the land-requisitioned farmers' original living standard or to
pay the social security expenses for the farmers who have lost their land due to
land acquisition, the People's Governments of province, autonomous region and
municipality shall approve additional subsidy for their resettlement. In case that
the total of the compensations for land and subsidy for resettlement up to the
upper limit as specified is still not sufficient to maintain the land-requisitioned
farmers' original living standard, the local People's Government shall provide
subsidy by using the revenue from paid use of state-owned land. Comprehensive
land price in land acquisition area and unified annual output value for land
acquisition shall be determined and released by the People's Governments of
province, autonomous region and municipality to ensure unified land price applied
in compensation for land acquisition, and the expenses in land acquisition shall be
incorporated in the budget estimate for construction of national key project. The
measures for compensation criteria and migrants’ resettlement for land acquisition
due to large-/medium-scale irrigation works/hydroelectric works will be stipulated
otherwise.
157 The resettlement of land-requisitioned farmers and procedure for land acquisition
has been stipulated in the State Council's Decision on Deepening Reform and
Strictly Managing Land to properly resettle the farmers. In addition, the land
acquisition program must be discussed with the involved farmer to guarantee the
farmers' interests. It is stipulated in Article 13 that,properly resettle the
land-requisitioned farmers. The People's Governments at or above country level
shall establish specific measures to guarantee the land-requisitioned farmers'
long-term livelihood. For project with constant gains, the involved farmers can
become the shareholders with the approved land-use right for the
construction-purpose land. Within the urban planning area, the local People's
Government shall incorporate the farmers who have lost their land due to land
acquisition into urban employment system and build proper social security system.
Outside the urban planning area and in case of requisition of land owned
collectively by the farmers, the local People's Government shall reserve necessary
land required for the land-requisitioned farmers to farm or provide proper
employment. Any land-losing farmers without basic production/living condition
shall be migrated and resettled in different place. It is also required that the
employment and social security authorities shall work with related agencies to
propose instructions on establishment of vocational training and social security
system for the land-requisitioned farmers. It is stipulated under Article 14 that,
Develop sound land acquisition procedure. During the course of land acquisition,
the farmers' ownership of collective land and right to contracted land management
and the interests involved therewith shall be preserved. The farmers subject to
land acquisition shall be informed of the purpose, position, compensation criteria
and resettlement approach of the land to be requisitioned prior to submission of
the land acquisition procedure for approval. Result of survey on current situation
of the land to be requisitioned shall be verified by the rural collective economic
organization and farmers subject to land acquisition. Where necessary, the land
and resource administration shall organize hearings in compliance with related
rules. The land acquisition document to be submitted for approval shall contain
information which the involved farmers has been informed of and confirmed.
Coordination and arbitrament mechanisms for disputes arising from land
acquisition compensation and resettlement shall be developed and improved
promptly to preserve the land-requisitioned farmers' and land users' legitimate
rights and interests. Except for special cases, any matters as approved concerning
land acquisition shall be released openly.
158 Laws, regulations and policies concerning distribution of land compensations
have been established by Chinese government to ensure the land-requisitioned
farmers' interests to be preserved. It is stipulated under Article 15 in the State
Council's Decision on Deepening Reform and Strictly Managing Land that,
Strengthen surveillance of land acquisition procedure. In case that compensation
and resettlement for land acquisition have not been fulfilled, the requisitioned land
shall not be used forcibly. The People's Governments of province, autonomous
region and municipality shall, based on the principle that compensations for land
acquisition shall be used mainly for the land-requisitioned households, establish
measures for distribution of land compensations inside rural collective economic
organization. The rural collective economic organization subject to land
expropriation shall disclose the amount and distribution of the compensations for
expropriated land and put it under public surveillance. Agriculture and civil
administrations shall strengthen surveillance of distribution and use of the
compensations for land acquisition inside the rural collective economic
organization.
159 The Instructions on Improving Land Acquisition Compensation & Resettlement
System was established by the Ministry of Land and Resources based on the State
Council's Decision on Deepening Reform and Strictly Managing Land, stipulating
land expropriation standard, approaches to resettlement of the land-requisitioned
farmers, land acquisition operation procedure and surveillance of land requisition
etc., further detailing the State Council's related policies.
160 Measures for implementation of provincial land management laws and land
compensation criteria shall follow the principle of national land management law.
Guizhou Province, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region and Guangdong
Province have established their own land management regulations based on The
Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China, detailing the
specific measures for implementation of land expropriation, and compensation
and resettlement therefor.
161 With respect to compensation, it is stipulated in the Regulations on Expropriation
of Houses on State-owned Land and Compensation Therefor that,
Article 17 The compensation to be paid by the city and county people's
governments that have made the decisions on house expropriation to the persons
whose houses are to be expropriated shall include:
(1) The compensation for the value of the houses to be expropriated;
(2) The compensation for relocation and temporary resettlement arising from the
house expropriation; and
(3) The compensation for losses arising from production and business suspension
caused by the house expropriation.
City and county people's governments shall formulate the procedures for subsidies
and incentives, and grant subsidies and incentives to the persons whose houses are
to be expropriated.
Article 18 If the residential houses of any individuals are to be expropriated
and the persons whose houses are to be expropriated meet the conditions for
affordable houses, the city and county people's governments that have made the
decisions on house expropriation shall give priority to providing affordable houses
to such persons. The specific procedures shall be formulated by the authorities of
provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the central
government.
Article 19 The compensation for the value of houses to be expropriated shall
not be less than the market price of the real estate comparable to the houses to be
expropriated on the date of the public notice of the house expropriation decisions.
The value of the houses to be expropriated shall be assessed and determined by
real estate appraisal agencies with appropriate qualifications in accordance with
the procedures for evaluating houses to be expropriated.
Anyone who has objection to the value of the houses to be expropriated that has
been assessed and determined may apply to the real estate appraisal agency for
reassessment. Anyone who disagrees with the results of the review may apply to
the real estate appraisal expert committee for appraisal.
The procedures for the appraisal of the houses to be expropriated shall be
formulated by the competent department of the State Council for housing and
urban and rural construction. In the process of the formulation, opinions shall be
solicited from the general public.
Article 20 Real estate appraisal agencies shall be selected by the persons
whose houses are to be expropriated through consultation. If consultations fail, the
same shall be determined by majority decision, random selection and other
methods. The specific procedures shall be formulated by the authorities of
provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the central
government.
Real estate appraisal agencies shall carry out the assessment of the houses to be
expropriated in an independent, objective and fair manner, free from interference
from any unit or individual.
Article 21 The persons whose houses are to be expropriated may choose
monetary compensation or house property rights exchange.
If the persons whose houses are to be expropriated select house property rights
exchange, city and county people's governments shall provide the houses to be
used for property rights exchange, and, jointly with the persons whose houses are
to be expropriated, calculate and settle the price difference between the values of
the houses to be expropriated and the values of the houses to be used for property
rights exchange.
If personal houses are required to be expropriated due to reconstruction of old city
districts, and the persons whose houses are to be expropriated choose property
rights exchange with houses located at the site of reconstruction, the city and
county people's governments that have made the decisions on house expropriation
shall provide the houses located at or near the sites of reconstruction.
Article 22 If any relocation is caused by house expropriation, the house
expropriation department shall pay relocation costs to the persons whose houses
are to be expropriated. If any persons choose house property rights exchange, the
house expropriation department shall, prior to the delivery of the houses to be
used for property rights exchange, pay temporary resettlement costs or provide
transitional houses to the Persons Whose Houses Are to Be Expropriated.
Article 23 The compensation for any losses arising from production and
business suspension caused by house expropriation shall be determined according
to profits, duration of production and business suspension and other factors prior
to the house expropriation. The specific procedures shall be formulated by the
authorities of provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the
central government.
Article 24 City and county people's governments and their relevant
departments shall strengthen the supervision and management of construction
activities according to law, and shall deal with any construction in violation of
urban and rural planning according to law.
Prior to making decisions on house expropriation, city and county people's
governments shall organize relevant departments to lawfully investigate, identify
and handle any buildings within the scope of expropriation that have not been
registered. With respect to any temporary buildings that are identified as legal
buildings and have not exceeded the approved time limit, compensation shall be
paid, while with respect to any temporary buildings that are identified as illegal
buildings and have exceeded the approved time limit, no compensation shall be
paid.
Article 25 The House Expropriation Departments and the persons
whose houses are to be expropriated shall, pursuant to these Regulations, enter
into compensation agreements with respect the compensation method, the
compensation amount and payment terms, the location and area of the houses to
be used for property rights exchange, relocation costs, temporary resettlement
costs or transitional houses, losses arising from production or business suspension,
period of relocation, methods and periods of transition and other matters.
If, after any compensation agreement is entered into, one party fails to perform its
obligations set forth in the compensation agreement, the other party may file an
action according to law.
Article 26 If any House Expropriation Departments and any persons
whose houses are expropriated fail to enter into compensation agreements within
the time limit for contract execution specified in the expropriation compensation
program, or the owners of the houses to be expropriated are uncertain, the House
Expropriation Departments shall request the city and county people's governments
that have made the decisions on house expropriation to make decisions on
compensation in accordance with the expropriation compensation program and
publish the same to the public in the areas of house expropriation pursuant to these
Regulations.
Compensation decisions shall be fair and shall contain matters in relation to the
compensation agreements as set forth in Clause 1 under Article 25 hereof.
If any person whose house is to be expropriated has objection to the compensation
decision, such person may apply for administrative reconsideration or file an
administrative lawsuit according to law.
Article 27 In carrying out house expropriation, compensation shall
be paid first before relocation.
After the city and county people's governments that have made the decisions on
house expropriation shall pay compensation to the persons whose houses are to be
expropriated, the persons whose houses are to be expropriated shall complete the
relocation the period of relocation as agreed upon in the compensation agreements
or determined in the compensation decisions.
No unit or individual may compel the persons whose houses are expropriated to
relocate through violence, threat or other illegal methods such as water, heat, gas,
power supply and road access suspension in violation of the regulations.
Construction units shall be prohibited from participating in relocation activities.
Article 28 If the persons whose houses are expropriated fail to apply
for administrative reconsideration or institute administrative proceedings within
the statutory time limit, and fail to relocate within the period set forth in the
compensation decision, the city and county people's governments that have made
the decisions on house expropriation shall petition the people's court for
enforcement.
The applications for enforcement shall include materials such as the amount of
compensation and special account number, the locations and areas of the houses
used for property rights exchange and transitional houses as attachments.
162 Measures for Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the People's
Republic of China in Guizhou Province:
Article 28 Compensation and Subsidy Criteria for Land Acquisition:
(1) Land Compensations: Compensation criteria for requisition of paddy
field, vegetable field, fishpond and lotus pond shall be six, five or four times
of annual output value of the involved land respectively based on three grades
- high, medium and low. Compensation criteria for expropriation of dry
farm, orchard or other perennial economic forest shall be five, four or three
times of annual output value of the involved land respectively based on three
grades - high, medium and low. Compensation criteria for requisition of other
types of land shall be two or three times of annual output value of low-grade
dry farm. The annual output value of involved land shall be determined by
land administration of people's government at county level based on the type
of the requisitioned land, general annual outputs of primary and secondary
products of crops, national purchase price and market price, and submitted to
the people's government for approval.
(2) Compensations for Young Crops and Attachments: The land user
shall put the land into use subsequent to harvest of the crops on it.In case the
young crops have to be removed in emergency, compensations shall be paid
based on the actual loss. compensation criteria for trees, buildings and other
attachments shall be determined and submitted by the people's government at
county level to the people's government at the upper level for approval. No
compensation shall be paid for any crops, trees or facilities which are planted
or built subsequent to signature of the land expropriation agreement.
(3) Resettlement Subsidy: Resettlement subsidy for expropriation of
farmland shall be calculated based on the size of the agricultural population to
be resettled. Size of the agricultural population to be resettled shall be
calculated by dividing the quantity of expropriated farmland with quantity of
farmland occupied per capita prior to land acquisition. The resettlement
subsidy for each one of the agricultural population to be resettled shall be
three times of annual output value per mu of the farmland prior to requisition,
but the highest resettlement subsidy per mu shall not exceed ten times of the
annual output value per mute resettlement subsidy for requisition of other
types of land shall be a half of the one for farmland.
Article 29 In case that the land compensations and resettlement subsidies
paid as required under Article 28 herein fail to maintain the involved farmers'
original living standard, additional resettlement subsidies can be paid after a
resettlement scheme for surplus labor power is submitted along with land
acquisition documents by the county people's government to the government
of autonomous prefecture, municipality or district administrative office within
the province and approved by the provincial people's government, but the
total of land shall compensation and resettlement subsidy shall not exceed
twenty times of average annual output value of the requisitioned land within
the last three years.
Article 30 Except the compensations for attachments and young crops
owned by individual on the requisitioned land will be paid directly to the
involved farmers, all compensations and resettlement subsidies for land
expropriated for national construction shall be used for production
development, relocation and employment of surplus labor power and
livelihood of persons which are unavailable to employment, instead of for any
other purpose by any organization or person.
Article 31 Agreement on requisition of land for purpose of national
construction projects, compensation and resettlement therefor shall be
concluded and entered into between the land user and the
land-requisitioned//allocated organization arranged by the county land
administration, defining the both parties' rights and obligations and
procedures for land expropriation/allocation and registration. And the land
user shall pay the land expropriation cost as specified to the involved
organization and individuals. The land user shall pay land management fee to
land administration at or above county level.
Article 32 Surplus labor power resulted from land expropriation for
national construction projects shall be relocated properly by the local
government along with land administration, the land-expropriated/allocated
organization and involved parties based on calculation of labor-land
proportion through the following approaches:
(1) re-allocation of contracted land;
(2) enterprises may be developed under the county/town/village by the
land-expropriated/allocated organization to extend channel for employment;
(3) the land user or other organization may take priority to employment of the
involved surplus labor power. The organization with its land
expropriated/allocated shall transfer the resettlement subsidy paid up to the
organization which employs the labor power.
(4) In case that the involved organization has had all of its farmland
expropriated and the aforesaid approaches are unavailable, its rural residence
registration may be transformed to a non-rural residence registration after a
special report is submitted by the involved county people's government to the
government of autonomous prefecture, municipality or district administrative
office within the province for review and approved by the provincial people's
government.
Article 33 The organization with its land expropriated/allocated shall be
exempt from grain procurement quota and agricultural taxes. Certified
reduction or increase in grain procurement quota shall be regulated and solved
by the people's government at or above country level where the construction
project is located.
Article 34 state-owned land with the use right to be withdrawn as
specified under Article 19 in the Law of Land Administration may be rented
by the rural collective economic organization at its cost for farming, and a
rental agreement shall be concluded and signed between the land
administration and land user. No permanent building shall be built nor
perennial crop shall be planted on the land during the rental term. When it
will have to be used for construction of national project, the rented land must
be returned without any subsequent compensation or resettlement subsidy.
For any young crops on the land, the land user shall pay proper
compensations. For the land farmed by the farmers which has been
expropriated but not used yet, compensations and resettlement subsidies in
reasonable amount shall be paid to the farmers when it will have to be
withdrawn for national construction.
163 Notice of Guizhou Province on Vocational Training and Social Security for
Land-Requisitioned Farmers
164 (II) Comprehending Scope of and Emphasis on Vocational Training and Social
Security for Land-Requisitioned Farmers. Vocational training and social security
shall be provided mainly for the registered farmers who have lost most or all of
their land due to legal land expropriation by the government, and are entitled to
the rural collective contracted land management, and whose land area per capita is
not sufficient to maintain their basic production and life (according to the standard
established by the involved government), especially for the farmers whose land
has been expropriated recently at the age applicable to employment, Including the
agricultural population who has lost most or all of their farmland within urban
(including the designated town) planning area due to land expropriation legally
approved by the State Council or provincial government, and the agricultural
population whose land area per capita is not sufficient to maintain basic
production and life due to approved legal land acquisition outside the urban
(including the designated town) planning area, who cannot be re-arranged by the
rural collective economic organization and cannot be resettled by the local
government. For the new land-requisitioned farmers who meet the conditions as
specified, vocational training and social security shall be provided by the
government upon land expropriation, and the land user shall offer active
assistance. Vocational training and social security provided for the previous
land-requisitioned farmers shall take into account economic and social
development, combination of previous and new policies for proper solution on a
step-by-step basis. Farmers within and outside urban planning area shall be
distinguished for classified guidance. The land-requisitioned farmers within urban
planning area shall be incorporated in urban employment service system and
social security system, while the land-requisitioned farmers outside urban
planning area shall be provided with necessary farmland within their local
administrative district or proper employment. The land-requisitioned farmers who
are located in the area without the proper production and living conditions and
need to be resettled in different place shall be incorporated in social security
system in the resettlement district.
165 (III) Explicitly Dividing Authorities' Duties Involved in Vocational Training and
Social Security for Land-Requisitioned Farmers. As the competent administration
involved in vocational training and social security for land-requisitioned farmers,
employment security authority shall be responsible for preparation and
implementation of measures for vocational training and social security for
land-requisitioned farmers. The financial sector shall be responsible for collection
and surveillance of funds for vocational training and social security. Land and
resource administration shall, during land acquisition, perform surveillance of full
payment of land compensations and resettlement subsidies by the land user, and
work with employment security authority to review vocational training and social
insurance operations. The civil administration division shall be responsible for
incorporating the land-requisitioned farmers who meet the conditions for urban
and rural subsistence allowances, rural five guarantees supporting system and
urban and rural medical assistance in the coverage of social assistance, and
provide the employment security authority with the latest revision of criteria for
urban and rural subsistence allowances. The agriculture sector shall be responsible
for providing changes in contracted land. The supervision authority shall, in
accordance with its duties, lawfully carry out administrative supervision of
vocational training and social security operations for the land-requisitioned
farmers. The audit agency shall legally strengthen audit and surveillance of the
funds used for vocational training and social security for land-requisitioned
farmers. Review and appropriation of vocational training fund, review and
determination of social security benefits and appropriation of funds for the
land-requisitioned farmers shall be conducted by employment service agencies,
involved social insurance organization and new-type rural cooperative medical
service agency at or above country level.
166 (IV) Speed up Preparation of Measures for Implementation of Vocational
Training and Social Security for Land-Requisitioned Farmers. In principle,
vocational training and social security for land-requisitioned farmers shall be
managed uniformly by county or city (prefecture/district) people's government
(administrative office within the province)by adhering to market-oriented
employment mechanisms, unifying urban and rural employment service,
developing opportunities of employment through multiple channels, improving
employment environment, encouraging and guiding enterprises/institutions,
non-state-owned non-enterprise organizations and community organizations to
employ land-requisitioned farmers, providing support for land-requisitioned
farmers' independent employment and business, based on the social security
payment criteria and security level in line with the socio-economic development,
developing social security system for the land-requisitioned farmers to meet their
basic needs at reasonable cost and in balance of income and expenses. The
specific measures for the implementation shall be established by the local
government based on national and provincial guidelines and related policies in
combination of local actual conditions and characteristics of the land-requisitioned
farmers. The districts where trial measures for implementation of vocational
training and social security system for land-requisitioned farmers shall make
necessary improvement to the measures based on national and provincial
guidelines. The districts where vocational training and social security operations
have not been commenced yet shall speed up establishment of specific
implementation plan to preserve the land-requisitioned farmers' legitimate rights
and interests. The implementation plan shall be submitted to city
(prefecture/district) people's government (administrative office within the
province) for approval and to provincial Office of Employment Security, Office of
Finance and Office of Land and Resources for filing. New cases and new issued
occurring in the operations shall be studied on and handled based on the principle
of "first on trial then for promotion" to continuously improve related policies and
measures. All relevant divisions shall make close coordination to actively and
properly carry out vocational training and social security operations for the
land-requisitioned farmers.
167 (X) Determining Vocational Training and Social Security Fund Collection
Proportion. In principle, not more than 60% of pension insurance expense for
land-requisitioned farmers shall be paid by the individual and complemented by
the collective, while not less than 40% of the total shall be borne by the
government%. The expense shall be paid in one or multiple times. The specific
pension insurance and medical insurance expense collection value and sharing
proportion shall be determined by the involved government based on the actual
conditions.
168 (XI) Establishing Payment Criteria for Social Security Interests of
Land-Requisitioned Farmers. Any land-requisitioned farmers aged 60 or above
who have bought pension insurance and paid the expense in full and have had
application for pension interests will be offered guaranteed pension interests from
the next month. In principle, guaranteed pension level of the land-requisitioned
farmers within urban planning area shall not be below local urban residents'
subsistence allowances level, while that of the land-requisitioned farmers outside
urban planning area shall not be less than 60% of local urban residents'
subsistence allowances level%. The pension interests shall be paid in full through
bank, post office or other social distribution channels by the social insurance
agency in the place where the pension insurance has been bought. The guaranteed
pension level of the land-requisitioned farmers may be adjusted based on the local
socio-economic development and subsistence allowance criterion and in
compliance with the specific measures which shall be established by the
employment security authority along with financial sector and land administration,
and submitted to the government at the same level for approval and then
implemented. Medical security payment criterion for the land-requisitioned
farmers shall be as per the local relevant rules and regulations.
169 (XII) Proper Coordination in Social Security System for Land-Requisitioned
Farmers. In case that, after having bought pension insurance, the
land-requisitioned farmers also buy basic pension insurance for urban enterprise
employees, in principle the previous pension insurance account is still valid and
once the conditions for payment of interests are met, the interests on the two
accounts will be calculated and paid respectively. Upon the application by the
insured in person, the pension insurance can be terminated and the principal and
interest on the account will be repaid in full to the insured. Any land-requisitioned
farmers who is poverty-stricken and meet the criteria for subsistence allowance
system shall be covered by the subsistence allowances for urban or rural residents,
or if the conditions for rural five guarantees supporting system, shall be provided
with support and assistance as specified, or if the conditions for urban and rural
medical assistance system, shall be covered by the assistance mechanism.
170 Instructions on Land Expropriation Protection Standard of Guangdong Province
Land Expropriation Protection Standard of Guangdong Province (hereinafter
referred to as "the Standard") is applicable to compensation for requisition of
collective farm-purpose land (farmland, orchard, woodland and cultivation
water) within jurisdiction of Guangdong Province (excluding Shenzhen), and
shall be used along with the District Classification Form for Land
Expropriation Protection Standard of Guangdong Province (hereinafter
referred to as "the Classification Form").The compensation criteria for
expropriation of other types of collective land will be as per the related laws
and regulations currently in force.
The Standard involves only two expense items - compensation and
resettlement subsidy, while the compensations for young crops and
attachments on the land shall be calculated otherwise.
The criterion for development zone site which is not listed in the
Classification Form shall as per that as applied in the local or neighboring
city/town.
Compensations for land acquisition applied in all districts shall not be below
the criteria as specified in the Standard. The people's governments at and
above town (city/district) level shall establish their local compensation
criteria for land expropriation based on the Standard and Classification Form
in combination of the local actual conditions, and submit them to provincial
Office of Land and Resources for filing.
The Standard will be in force from the date of issuance, and for any land
expropriation items which have been submitted to provincial Office of Land
and Resources for handling, the original compensation criteria shall be
applied.
If, due to adjustment to administrative division or other reasons, individual
village has not reach the level of the local town, related reasons for the
proposed compensation criteria shall be contained in the land expropriation
document and submitted to the provincial people's government for approval.
Based on actual conditions, the Standard and Classification Form shall be
revised and updated once every 2-3 years.
Provincial Office of Land and Resources shall be responsible for
interpretation of the Standard and Classification Form.
171 Key Points in Opinions on Solving Social Security-Related Issues of Guangdong
Province
Developing production/life security system for land-requisitioned farmers
1) Object to be Guaranteed. Registered agricultural population entitled to the
rural collective contracted land management, including farmers with land
requisitioned within and outside the urban planning area, namely the farmers
who have lost more than half of their land due to land expropriation within
urban planning area (including the place where the county/town government
is located);persons in households whose land area per capita is less than one
third of that of the agricultural population in the local county (city/district)
after the land expropriation legally approved outside the urban planning area.
The detailed list of land-requisitioned farmers to be covered under social
security shall be discussed on representative conference of collective
economy organization members, submitted by the village committee to
town/county people's government for approval, and then, seven day of release
to the public, submitted to town (city/district) employment security
administration for filing.
2) Security Principle. Expense and security levels meet the level of
socio-economic development; individual payment, collective subsidy and
governmental support are both applied; involved rights are in line with the
obligations; low conditional restriction, wide coverage and multiple levels;
rural and urban social insurance systems are both applied; Completely
accumulative individual account is employed in the basic pension insurance
system for land-requisitioned farmers, and collective account combination
mode applied in some districts shall be transformed into individual account
mode; vocational training security, pension insurance and welfare security
mechanisms are applied In accordance with different age groups.
3) Security Mode. For land-requisitioned farmers aged 16-35, employment
training will be highlighted. For land-requisitioned farmers aged 35-59 who
have not been covered under basic pension insurance for urban employees
shall participate in basic pension insurance locally. Any land-requisitioned
farmers aged 60 or above will be covered under pension subsidy support and
provided with subsistence allowances on a monthly basis till death.
4) Security Fund. The security expenses shall be borne jointly by the
government, collective and individual. Resettlement compensations for land
expropriation, distribution interests for transfer of collective land use right
and bonus from collective economy equity etc. shall be first used to pay the
individual-borne portion of pension insurance expense, supplemented by
other individual's incomes when necessary. The portion to be borne by the
collective shall be determined on the villager representative conference, and
paid with distribution interests for transfer of collective land use right and
proceeds from collective asset operation. The portion to be borne by the
government may be paid with the revenue from transfer of state-owned land
use right. The fund required to appropriate retirement subsistence allowance
shall be from resettlement subsidies legally increased and land compensations
for land-requisitioned farmers, and supported by the revenue of local
government from on-payment use of state-owned land.
5) Training and Employment Security. Training and Employment Security is
provided mainly for land-requisitioned farmers aged 16-35.The
land-requisitioned farmers within urban planning area shall be covered under
public employment service system and urban unemployment registration and
management system, to share the public employment service and related
training support policies with the urban residents. The land-requisitioned
farmers outside the urban planning area who meet the training enrolling
conditions will be covered under Technical Training Program for Rural Youth
and vocational training and employment program. Applicable vocational
training will be provided for them to facilitate their transformation to
non-agricultural industries and employment in cities. And after employment,
they will be covered under social insurance system for urban employees.
Independent employment and business operation by land-requisitioned
farmers shall be promoted. Those who have not got a job and desire to will be
covered under related re-employment support policies, and participate in
basic pension insurance system for land-requisitioned farmers on a voluntary
basis.
6) Reserved Land Security. For land expropriation in future, the land
requisitioner shall reserve or appropriate 10%-15% of the actually
requisitioned land area for development of production by the collective
subjected to land acquisition. Related procedure shall be handled to transform
the reserved land within urban planning area into state-owned
construction-purpose land. The expense spent on transformation of the
reserved land into state-owned construction-purpose land shall be
incorporated in the land requisitioner's budget cost.
6. COMPENSATION CRITERIA AND COMPENSATION
BUDGET
6.1 COMPENSATION CRITERIA
172 Compensation and resettlement criteria for land acquisition and building
demolition for this Project shall be determined based on related policies of the
World Bank and Chinese government and specific conditions in the influenced
areas.
6.1.1 COMPENSATION FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION
173 Compensations will be paid for permanent and temporary requisition of various
types of land (farmland, woodland, orchard, construction-purpose land and unused
land etc.) and all attachments (trees and young crops etc.) on the land as well as
any losses in the requisitioned land and involved infrastructure.
(1) Compensation Criterion for Permanent Land Acquisition
174 It is stipulated in the Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of
China that compensation for permanent land acquisition contains land
compensation and person resettlement subsidy. Compensation for requisition of
farmland is based on 6-10 times of the average annual output values of the
requisitioned land within the recent three years. Time of person resettlement
subsidy is related to land area per capita prior to expropriation, varying between
4-20.For villages where there is large farmland area per capita and less
agricultural population borne per mu, the time of resettlement subsidy is lower.
For villages where there is small farmland area per capita and large agricultural
population borne per mu, the time of resettlement subsidy is higher.
175 The average agricultural annual output value shall be calculated by multiplying
yield of all crops on the land within the recent three years with the corresponding
current market price. Calculation of output value takes into account the value of
secondary products (e.g. straw) from the grain crops.
176 The compensation criteria for various types of permanently requisitioned land are
established based on the calculation of average annual output values issued by the
local governments in the influenced areas and in combination of the measures for
implementation of land law in the involved provinces/regions and surveys on
actual conditions of the involved people's production and life in the influenced
villages. The compensation criteria for Black Stone Village and Duxi Village,
Dula Township, Baiyun District, Guiyang will be based on the local
comprehensive price; the compensation criteria for Xiaobao Village, Yuezai
Village and Kouzai Village, Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County will be based on
the criteria as specified in the urban planning area; the compensation criteria for
Hainan Village , Zhongnan Sub-District, Liwan District and Yaotai Community,
Yuexiu District in Guangzhou will be based on the highest criteria as specified in
the Land Expropriation Protection Standard of Guangdong Province. See Table 44
for more details.
177Compensation for young crops is not contained in the aforesaid compensation
criteria and will be calculated based on average annual output value of the
requisitioned land.
178Compensation for house site of the demolished residence in village will be based
on the compensation criteria for farmland.
179All land compensation criteria are the lowest criterion to be implemented.
Table44 - Compensation Criteria for Permanently Expropriated Land
County/Di
strict
Township/Town/Sub
-District
Village/Comm
unities Land Type
Compens
ation
Criteria
(yuan/mu)
Descriptio
n
Baiyun
District Dula Township
Black Stone
Village/ Duxi
Village
Farmland 67,100 Based on
local
comprehe
nsive price
and
excluding
compensat
ion for
young
crops
(annual
output
value =
1,500
yuan/mu)
Other Land
Type 26,840
Rongjiang
County Guzhou Town
Xiaobao
Village/
Yuezai
Village/
Kouzai Village
Paddy Field 26,800 Based on
compensat
ion cost in
town
planning
area and
excluding
compensat
ion for
young
crops
(annual
output
value =
1,390
yuan/mu)
Dry Farm 14,272
Orchard 8,920
Construction-P
urpose Land 6,244
Woodland 5,850-8,9
20
Unused Land 2,925
Liwan
District
Zhongnan
Sub-District Hainan Village Farmland 66,000
Based on
the highest
criteria in
Land
Expropriat
ion
Protection
Yuexiu
District
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Community Farmland 66,000
Standard
of
Guangdon
g Province
6.1.2 Compensation for House Demolition
180 Based on the currently effective land management laws and policies on house
demolition, the compensations for demolished buildings and their accessories will
be paid directly to the involved estate owner. The compensations will be used for
reconstruction of the demolished houses. In countryside, as per land laws, the
local governments will appropriate house site (leveled and connected to related
public service, if any) to the involved people, and the new house will be built by
the involved people or the village committee. The involved households to be
resettled have the right to use the old building materials for free. In cities,
compensations will be based on house ownership replacement or market price.
House ownership replacement area shall be calculated based on the total building
area of the house to be demolished, while the compensation will be calculated
based on the replacement cost of the house to be demolished, and free of any legal
deal and registration fees.
181 This compensation criteria for the demolished residences in countryside for this
Project are determined based on the aforesaid principles and on-site surveys on
house replacement cost in the influenced areas, including physical costs of
reinforcing steel, cement and other building materials used for house construction
and manpower cost (see Table 45 for more details).
182 The compensation criteria for the demolished residences in cities are based on
estimated market prices.
183 The compensation criteria for demolished non-residential buildings, including
industrial and commercial enterprises/institutions' buildings, will be determined
based on the local estimated market price for current time.
184 The compensations for demolished houses exclude depreciation charge based on
living duration. As urban residences are higher than rural residences in price and
quality, the compensation criteria for urban residences is usually higher than those
for rural residences, and shall be re-determined based on the replacement cost in
combination of the house condition. The compensation criteria for rural
demolished houses are lower than those for urban demolished houses mainly
because that: in cities, the compensations for house demolition include the use
right of the land where the house is located, and based on the market price, while
in countryside, the sites for construction of house are provided by the government
for free, so compensation is paid only based on the direct construction cost. In
addition, the gap between urban land price and rural land price also contributes
much to the difference in compensation criteria.
185 Even though it is stipulated that no house demolition shall be carried out till
construction of new house is completed, many involved households in other
projects would rather choose to construct new houses independently. In
countryside, since the building materials removed from the old house are to be
reused, reconstruction is usually commenced only after the old houses have been
demolished. This means that interim houses are needed for a transitional period of
3-6 months, during which the involved people will be offered compensation for
interim dwelling. Removal subsidy will be paid by the resettlement authorities to
make up for the expenses on manpower and vehicles required during house
removal.
186 House removal subsidies are usually paid to the households to be removed prior
to demolition of the old houses. Compensations will be paid for all accessories
involved in the old house, such as: enclosure walls, toilet, pigpen, yards, well,
electric wire, fruit tree, any other tress or plants owned by the household.
187 The compensations are usually paid based on the standard cost per sq. meter of
the building. For some households to be removed, if the compensations fail to
make up for the reconstruction cost, then additional compensations will have to be
paid to them.
Table45 - Compensation Criteria for Demolished Houses in Influenced Areas
DistrictCriteria Compensation Criteria (yuan per sq.
m) Interi
m
Resettl
ement
Subsid
y
Remova
l
Subsidy
Description Count
y/Dist
rict
Townshi
p/Town/
Sub-Dis
trict
Village/
Commu
nities
Concr
ete-Br
ick
Brick-
Wood
Earth-W
ood
Other
Struct
ures
Baiyu
n
Distri
ct
Dula
Townshi
p
Black
Stone
Village/
Duxi
Village
Based on the market price estimated
upon demolition and resettlement 6/
m2/mo
nth*18
month
s
6/m2/tim
e *2
times
Upon monetary
resettlement
539 539 320 320
Portion beyond the
previous house area
upon replacement of
ownership
Rongj
iang
Count
y
Guzhou
Town
Yuezai
Village/
Kouzai
Village/
Xiaobao
Village
460 400 290
80 5 5-15
monetary
resettlement applied;
the compensation for
the old house site
paid to the household
based on farmland
requisition price
360 300 190
Independent building
on the appropriated
land
Yangs
uo
Count
y
Xingpin
g Town
Sidi
Village 600 450 280 280 5
500/hou
se.mont
h* 6
months
Independent building
on the appropriated
land
Liwan
Distri
ct
Hailong
Sub-Dis
trict
Zengjiao
Commu
nity
Based on the market price estimated upon demolition and
resettlement
Yuexi
u
Kuangq
uan
Yaotai
Commu
Based on the market price estimated upon demolition and
resettlement
Distri
ct
Sub-Dis
trict
nity
6.2 BUDGET ESTIMATE OF COMPENSATIONS FOR MIGRATION
AND RESETTLEMENT
188 Based on the framework as specified in the original resettlement plan, the funds
for migration and resettlement will be raised by the three provincial governments
along the railway line and the following local governments. The fund estimates as
determined based on the aforesaid compensation criteria are shown in Table 46.
189 The total estimate of funds required for migration and resettlement of the
households which have not be removed within the materially influenced areas
under the altered preliminary design is 1,1084 billion yuan, accounting for 1.2 %
of the planned total investment of 97.554 billion yuan, among which the direct
expenses are 943,000,000 yuan, and related taxes are excluded in it.Among the
standards of house unit cost counted in the estimate, except these based on the
compensation criteria as specified, the portion which needs to be based on
estimated market price are based on the market price of commodity house in the
same area at the time of survey, or estimated market price of similar project in
process. For example, the estimated market price of a similar construction project
in process in the same area applied for expense estimate of urban residential house
demolition in Yuexiu District, Guangzhou is 16,000 yuan/m2.
Table46 - Estimate of Expenses for Migration and Resettlement in the Project
County/
County Township/Town
Dula
Township Unit Quantity
Compensation
Criteria
(yuan/mu)
Expense
(*10,000 yuan)
Baiyun
District/
Dula
Township
Farmland
Paddy Field mu 6 67,100 40.26
Dry Farm mu 28 67,100 187.88
Vegetable
Field mu 723 67,100 4851.33
Farm-Purpose Woodland mu 200 26,840 536.8
Building
Demolition
Concrete-Brick sq. m 59,159.6 809 4,786.012
Brick-Wood sq. m 2,738.3 809 221.5,285
Primitive sq. m 22,767.1 320 728.5,472
Subtotal 11,352.36
Guzhou
Town,
Rongjiang
County
Farmland
Paddy Field mu 332.8 26,800 891.904
Dry Farm mu 0.9 14,272 1.28,448
Orchard mu 26.6 8,920 23.7,272
Farm-Purpose Woodland mu 16.3 8,920 14.5,396
Construction-Purpose Land mu 5.3 6,244 3.30,932
Other Unused Land mu 4.5 2,925 1.31,625
Building
Demolition
Concrete-Brick sq. m 39.9 500 1.995
Brick-Wood sq. m 455.5 440 20.042
Earth-Wood sq. m 1,008.4 330 33.2,772
Primitive sq. m 899.1 80 7.1,928
Subtotal 998.5,879
Xingping
Town,
Yangsuo
County
Building
Demolition
Concrete-Brick sq. m 6,600 650 429
Brick-Wood sq. m 3,000 500 150
Earth-Wood sq. m 2,200 350 77
Primitive sq. m 1,760 350 61.6
Enterprises sq. m 86,000 1,000 8,600
Subtotal 9,317.6
Zhongnan
Sub-District,
Liwan
District
Land
Expropriation
Paddy Field 40 66,000 264
Orchard 40.5 66,000 267.3
Hailong
Sub-District,
Liwan
District
Building
Demolition Concrete-Brick sq. m 12,845.3 3,940 5,061.048
Subtotal 5,592.348
Kuangquan
Sub-District,
Yuexiu
District
Land
Expropriation Paddy Field mu 3 66,000 19.8
Building
Demolition Concrete-Brick sq. m 41,898 16,000 67,036.8
Subtotal 67,056.6
Total of Direct Expenses 94,317.49
Land Survey Cost 411
Attachments (5%) 4,715.875
Management Fee (2%) 1,886.35
External Surveillance Fee (300 yuan/km*year) 77.553
Unpredictable Expenses (10%) 9,431.749
Total 110,840
7. MIGRATION & RESETTLEMENT AND LIVELIHOOD
DEVELOPMENT
190 Migration and Resettlement in the areas where land acquisition and House Demolition have not
been commenced within the coverage of the altered preliminary design will still be carried out
by the local governments with support of the Project Owner. Measures for recovery and
development of the involved people's livelihood shall be in compliance with the World Bank's
policies on migration.
191 The areas where migration and resettlement have not been commenced for this Project include
9 villages/communities in Baiyun District, Guiyang City, Rongjiang County, Qiangdongnan
Prefecture, Yangsuo County, Guilin City, and Liwan District and Yuexiu District in Guangzhou,
involving permanent land acquisition area of 1,406.2 mus, with farmland accounting for 84.2%,
and population of 1,374 in 359 households, building demolition area of 241,371.5m 2 , including
rural residences of 100,628.3 m2 , industrial and commercial enterprise buildings of 98,845.3 m
2
and urban residences of 41,898 m2. covering 2,144 residents in 586 Households. 3 enterprises
have to be demolished and reconstructed.
7.1 GENERAL PRINCIPLES
192 General goal of the supplementary resettlement plan for this Project remains to provide proper
measures for livelihood and family development, and ensure the people's living standard to
recover to the level not below that prior to the Project.
193 The general principles of the resettlement plan is to resettle the involved households in the
original community, respect and take into account the local migrants' customs in production and
life and opinions, promote land-based resettlement, ensure the villagers' stable income sources
from agricultural and non-agriculture industries, recover and improve their living standard, and
further maintain sustainable development in the migration districts. Livelihood recovery plan is
based on the following principles:
migration and resettlement planning will be implemented based on physical indicators in
land expropriation and building demolition and compensation criteria therefor.
Migration and resettlement will be integrated with district construction, resource
development, economic growth and environmental protection. Feasible measures for
recovery and development of the migrants' production and life will be established based on
local actual conditions to provide the migrants with access to independent development.
Plan and layout will be developed based on the principle of "facilitate production and life”.
All buildings to been demolished, including Residences, will be reconstructed in the areas
as close to the original site as possible. Almost in any circumstances, all involved
population will be provided with new house site in the current village or sub-district. No
involved people will have their houses demolished till the rebuilding plan is available.
Reconstruction will be conducted in such scale and based on such standard to recover the
original conditions. All funds as required in district development, scale expansion, standard
rise and long-term planning shall be raised solely by the local government and related
authorities. During removal and rebuilding, the farmers will be provided with support from
the village committee, county/town/sub-district government and county resettlement
authorities.
Overall planning and all-round consideration shall be made/taken to ensure a smooth
relationship among the state, collective and individuals.
Combination of compensation, subsidy and productive assistance will be applied and
advantage in local natural resource will be taken sufficiently to achieve the migrants'
production and living standards at or above the original levels on a step-by-step basis.
7.2 PRODUCTION/LIFE RECOVERY PLAN FOR INVOLVED VILLAGES
7.2.1 BLACK STONE VILLAGE, DULA TOWNSHIP, BAIYUN DISTRICT
(1) Overview
194 Black Stone Village has a totally agricultural population of 1,352 covering 750
households,farmland of 7,000 mus, and farmland area per capita of 5.18 mus, achieving an
annual net income per capita of 10,000 yuan, with income sources covering chive cultivation,
land transportation, rural home inn service, livestock herding and migrant employment.
195 Due to land expropriation for construction of motor train station (North Guiyang Station), land
of 923 mus in total in the village will be requisitioned, including farmland of 723 mus and
woodland of 200 mus, involving 580 residents in 145 Households, among which 520 in 130
Households are subject to land acquisition, 500 people in 125 Households are involved in house
demolition, covering area of 640,460.3m2.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
196 Compensations for land acquisition will be appropriated directly to the village. Resettlement
method will be determined on household conference held by the village committee.The
resettlement program include:
1) Land reallocation within village group: If a large amount of land resources are available in
the village, then land reallocation can be conducted within the village subsequent to land
expropriation. After land reallocation, the farmland area per capita is still 4.5 mus within the
village. The villagers still can proceed with their cultivation and aquaculture as before, and the
rural home inn, land transportation and migrant employment are not subject to influence of land
expropriation. Except that the compensations for young crops will be paid directly to the
involved farmers, 20% of the compensations for land acquisition will be reserved by the village
group for public service, while the rest will be distributed per capita to ensure the villagers to
proceed with cultivation and other occupations.
2) The involved villagers who do not like to proceed with farming may choose monetary
resettlement mode, where all compensations for land expropriation will be paid directly to the
related villagers based on the compensation criteria.
3) All registered agricultural population who meets the conditions for land-losing farmers
(farmland area per capita < 0.3 mu) and is entitled to contracted land management will be
resettled based on social security system. The detailed method is:
Object of Security - For laboring population aged 16-60, pension insurance expense will be
paid in full (payment period from the age of 16 to the actual age upon land expropriation; one
year's pension security expense paid for every 2 years, for up to 15 years); for laboring
population aged 60 or above, pension security expense for 15 years will be paid in full;
Payment Standard - As estimated by Social Security Bureau of Baiyun District, the criterion
for pension security expense will be determined based on 60% of monthly average wage of
employees within the province, at a payment proportion of 20%, among which 8% will be
counted in the individual account. Estimate of criterion for the expense is: Monthly average
wage of employees within the province: 24,602 yuan * 60% * 20% = 2952 yuan /yuan·person.
Security Requirements and Interests - For land-losing farmers aged 60 who have paid
pension security expense for 15 years, the pension security will be paid from the next month till
the death. The interests is 15% of monthly average wage of employees within the province in
the last year. For years beyond 15 years, a rise of 1% is offered for each year. For ones with
payment term less than 15 years, the amount on the individual account will be paid in full to
them and the pension security contract will be terminated. The pension security will be adjusted
properly based on economic development level.
197 Vocational training for free: All persons subjected to land acquisition will be provided with
vocational training organized by district/county government and related authorities. The
vocational training will be usually provided seasonally, with training course covering breeding
and planting, computer operation technique, cooking and electronics etc.
198 Employment opportunities will be proposed and provided. The local employment security
authority will register all farmers who have completed the training course, and recommend them
to employment security authorities in coastal developed cities. In addition, posts including
cooks, building workers and cleaners will be accessible during construction of Guiyang Station,
accounting for about 15-20% of the total employment quantity, with daily average pay varying
from 80 yuan (for non-technical posts) to 120 yuan (technical posts); After the station is
completed and put into operation, posts involving estate management, commercial management
and cleaning will be available. All these employment opportunities will be provided
preferentially to the persons subjected to land acquisition.
199
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
200 Two collective resettlement modes are available for the persons in Black Stone Village
subjected to house demolition - monetary resettlement and ownership replacement, between
which the persons involved in house demolition can choose one as required.
Villagers who have, prior to house demolition, bought commodity house in the neighboring
Guiyang City or possessed another permanent residential house may choose monetary
resettlement, and the compensations will be determined by the resettlement authorities based on
the market replacement cost estimated by certified asset evaluating institution, and paid in
sufficient amount to ensure the persons subjected to house demolition to purchase new house
within the local district.
2) Estate Ownership Replacement: The resettlement authority has requisitioned land of 70 mus
within the village, which will be used for construction of collective resettlement Community for
the involved households in Black Stone Village. The aforesaid requisitioned land is uncultivated
land in the village and has been incorporated in the land expropriation area. Community
construction contractors will be determined by the resettlement authority on open bid and the
community capacity will be 300 households. House Allocation Mode in Collective Resettlement
Community: A criterion area of 240 m 2 will be applied for replacement of the ownership for
each household. If the original house area is less than 240 m 2 , the ownership replacement will
be conducted at a ratio of 1:1 and irrespective of the house structure. When the resettlement
house area is larger than the original house area, compensations shall be paid by the involved
person to the house remover based on the comprehensive cost price of the resettlement house. If
the original house area is larger than 240m2, compensations shall be paid by the resettlement
authority to the involved households based on the cost price.
3) Compensations for house removal and interim resettlement will be paid to all people
subjected to house demolition. Compensations for one time's house removal and three months'
interim resettlement will be paid in full to the involved people who have chosen monetary
resettlement mode. Compensations for two times' house removal and interim resettlement will
be paid in full to the involved people who have chosen collective resettlement mode (payment
period of interim resettlement compensation for multi-storey/ small high-storey house is 18
months, that for high-storey house is 24 months. In case that the Resettlement Community has
not been completed and moved in when the payment period is expired, the resettlement
authority shall pay interim compensation to the involved households at a rise of 10% month on
month, but not above five times of the original amount of monthly compensation).
7.2.2 DUXI VILLAGE, DULA TOWNSHIP, BAIYUN DISTRICT
(1) Overview
201 Duxi Village has a totally agricultural population of 1580 covering 800 Households. farmland
of 7,800 mus, and farmland area per capita of 4.94 mus, achieving an annual net income per
capita of 7,600 yuan, with income sources covering chive cultivation, rural home inn service,
and migrant employment.
202 Due to land expropriation for construction of motor train station (North Guiyang Station), land
of 34 mus in the village will be requisitioned, involving 247 residents in 77 Households, among
which 45 in 11 households are subject to land acquisition,20 people in 66 Households are
involved in house demolition, covering area of 24,204.7 m2.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
203 After land acquisition, as determined by the resettlement authority of district government and
Village Committee, monetary resettlement and social security-based resettlement will be
applied, since there is a small quantity of land expropriation in Duxi Village for this Project.
Since flower-type land Allocation mode has been applied in land contracting, no Household in
this village has had its family farmland all requisitioned. Monetary compensation will be
applied for the people subjected to land acquisition, and all compensations for land
expropriation will be paid directly to the involved households based on the compensation
criteria. Social security-based resettlement will be applied for the involved households which
meet the conditions for land-losing farmers (farmland area per capita < 0.3 mu) in the same way
as applied with Black Stone Village (see Section 7.2.1 for more details).
204 Vocational training: As land expropriation has been conducted in this village not only for
Guiyang-Guangzhou railway project but also for other local construction projects, based on
voluntary selection, vocational training course will be provided for the involved people by the
district and town governments, covering cooking, sales and housekeeping.
205 Employment opportunities will be proposed and provided. The local employment security
authority will register all farmers who have completed the training course, and recommend them
to employment security authorities in coastal developed cities. In addition, posts including
cooks, building workers and cleaners will be accessible during construction of Guiyang Station,
accounting for about 15-20% of the total employment quantity, with daily average pay varying
from 80 yuan (for non-technical posts) to 120 yuan (technical posts). After the station is
completed and put into operation, posts involving estate management, commercial management
and cleaning will be available. All these employment opportunities will be provided
preferentially to the persons subjected to land acquisition.
206
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
207 Two resettlement modes will be applied for households subjected to house demolition in Duxi
Village, which will be chosen by the involved households.
1) Monetary Resettlement Mode: Villagers who have possessed another permanent residential
house may choose monetary resettlement, and the compensation criteria will be determined by
the resettlement authority based on the market replacement cost estimated by certified asset
evaluating institution.
2) Collective Resettlement Mode in Resettlement Community based on Estate Ownership
Replacement: The resettlement authority has requisitioned land of 30 mus within the village,
which will be used for construction of collective resettlement Community for the involved
households in this village. The aforesaid requisitioned land is uncultivated land in the village
and has been incorporated in the land expropriation area. Community construction contractors
will be determined by the resettlement authority on open bid and the community capacity will
be 150 households. Collective resettlement house allocation and payment of interim/removal
compensations will be conducted in the same way as in Black Stone Village (see Section 7.2.1
for more details).
7.2.3 Xiaobao Village, Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County
(1) Overview
208 Xiaobao Village, an urban planning area neighboring Rongjiang County, has a rural population
of 1,285 covering 285 households, with agricultural population accounting for 92%. farmland of
1,435 mus, and farmland area per capita of 1.21 mus, achieving an annual net income per capita
of 4,100 yuan, with income sources covering freight transportation and timber processing for
the most, and agricultural crop and plant cultivation for the minority (only 10 households).
209 Due to land expropriation for construction of station (Rongjiang County Station), land of 154.2
mus in the village will be requisitioned, involving 190 residents in 50 households, among which
190 in 50 households are subject to land acquisition, 68 people in 15 households are involved in
house demolition, covering area of 1,936.9m2.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
Land Reallocation-Based and Social Security-Based Resettlement Modes: Based on the county
resettlement authorities' planning and the involved villagers' opinions, it is decided on the
villager conference that land reallocation-based resettlement mode will be applied for the
involved villagers after land expropriation. After land reallocation, due to its sufficient farmland
resource, there is still an land area per capita of 1.1 mus.With development in county
construction in future, value of the land resource in the village is likely to rise up, and in order
to ensure all of the villagers to share the land gains, the village committee has decided to make
land reallocation after each land acquisition. Resettlement Mode for Land Expropriation for this
Project: After the compensations for land expropriation have been appropriated to the village,
except that the compensations for young crops will be paid directly to the involved farmers, the
rest will be re-distributed based on the size of registered population subsequent to farmland
resource reallocation. The resettlement authorities will determine the number of land-losing
farmers in the village based on land area per capita and conducted social security-based
resettlement for the land-losing farmers. After land expropriation in this village for this Project,
121 ones will be identified as land-losing farmers and have access to the social security. Based
on the principle of self-government by the villagers, the villager conference will determine
which people will be identified as the objects for social security. Generally, old people who are
incapable of laboring will be preferentially identified as the objects of social security, and their
due social insurance expenses shall be paid by the resettlement authorities with multi-approach
compensations, and the gap to the full amount, if any, will be paid by the insured. Detailed
measures for implementation of social security system are still being established by the social
security sector of Rongjiang County.
210 Vocational training for free: The resettlement authorities of Rongjiang County, along with
poverty alleviation authorities, the Women's Federation and agricultural sectors to provide free
vocational training for the people subjected to land expropriation in the village. Based on the
principle of voluntary, the training institution will provide vocational training courses covering
automobile repair, building technique and furniture manufacturing etc. on a seasonally basis to
enhance the involved people's employment capacity.
211 Employment opportunities will be proposed and provided. In addition, posts including cooks,
building workers and cleaners will be accessible during construction of the station, accounting
for about 15-20% of the total employment quantity, with daily average pay varying from 60
yuan (for non-technical posts) to 100 yuan (technical posts). After the station is completed and
put into operation, posts involving estate management, commercial management and cleaning
will be available. All these employment opportunities will be provided preferentially to the
persons subjected to land acquisition.
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
212 collective resettlement will be conducted for the people subjected to house demolition for this
Project. Based on related urban planning rules, the resettlement authorities will decide the
collective resettlement site in area of 30 mus for Xiaobao Village, and provide necessary public
service and make land reclamation so that the people subjected to house demolition can build
new houses independently on the resettlement site appropriated for free. The house site
provided for each household is 0.3 mu. Distribution of house sites within the resettlement
community will be decided by means of random draw lots.
7.2.4 Yuezai Village, Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County
(1) Overview
213 Yuezai Village, located neighboring Xiaobao Village, with part of it inside town development
planning area, has a rural population of 1,586 covering 331 households, with agricultural
population accounting for 99%,farmland of 1,200 mus, and farmland area per capita of 1.01
mus, achieving an annual net income per capita of 3,200 yuan. with income sources covering
agricultural planting and breeding (accounting for 40%) and migrant employment (accounting
for 60%).
214 Due to land expropriation for construction of station (Rongjiang County Station), land of 95
mus in the village will be requisitioned, involving 182 residents in 48 households, among which,
16 people in 3 households are involved in house demolition, covering area of 462m2; 182
people in 48 households are involved in land expropriation, covering farmland of 90.8 mus and
woodland of 4.2 mus.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
215 Monetary resettlement mode will be applied primarily, and all compensations for land
expropriation will be paid directly to the involved farmers based on the compensation criteria.
Social security-based resettlement will be applied for the involved households which meet the
conditions for land-losing farmers (farmland area per capita < 0.3 mu. and their due social
insurance expenses shall be paid by the resettlement authorities with multi-approach
compensations, and the gap to the full amount, if any, will be paid by the insured. Detailed
measures for implementation of social security system are still being established by the social
security sector of Rongjiang County.
216 Vocational Training and Employment Opportunity Provided for Free. The people subjected to
land acquisition and house demolition in this village will be provided with vocational training
for free and recommended to employment opportunity just the same as theses in Xiaobao
Village. After the station is completed and put into operation,posts involving estate management,
commercial management and cleaning will be available.
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
217 Collective resettlement will be applied to three households subjected to house demolition in
Yuezai Village, and they will be resettled in the collective resettlement site for Xiaobao Village
by county resettlement authorities in the same way as with those in Xiaobao Village (see
Section 7.2.3 for more details).
7.2.5 Kouzai Village, Guzhou Town, Rongjiang County
(1) Overview
218 Kouzai Village, located neighboring Xiaobao Village, with part of it inside town development
planning area, has a rural population of 2,280 covering 550 households, with agricultural
population accounting for 97%, farmland of 1,070 mus, and farmland area per capita of 0.43
mus, achieving an annual net income per capita of 4,600 yuan. Due to small amount of farmland,
currently most of the households create incomes by developing building trade (construction
team engaged in house building and road/bridge engineering), migrant employment, small-scale
enterprise (timber processing, wood charcoal processing and pole fabrication/processing etc.)
and foresting and orchard trade.
219 Due to land expropriation for construction of station (Rongjiang County Station), land of 137.2
mus in the village will be requisitioned, involving 182 residents in 48 households, among which,
a hut used for crop guarding in area of 4.4 m 2 will be demolished, involving 5 people covering
one household.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
220 Just the same as with Xiaobao Village, combination of land reallocation-based and social
security-based resettlement modes will be applied in Kouzai Village. It is decided on the
villager conference that, after land expropriation, land reallocation-based resettlement mode will
be applied within village/group. According to a survey, there farmland area per capita in this
villagers is 0.42 mu.Though there is small quantity of land resources in this village and the
involved households' incomes are rarely from farmland, with development in county
construction in future, the land resource value will be likely to rise up, so the village committee
has decided to conduct land reallocation after land expropriation to ensure the land resource
available to every household. Resettlement Mode for Land Expropriation for this Project: After
the compensations for land expropriation have been appropriated to the village, except that the
compensations for young crops will be paid directly to the involved farmers, the rest will be
re-distributed based on the size of registered population subsequent to farmland resource
reallocation. The resettlement authorities will determine the number of land-losing farmers in
the village based on land area per capita and conducted social security-based resettlement for
the land-losing farmers. After land expropriation in this village for this Project, 319 ones will be
identified as land-losing farmers and have access to the social security. Based on the principle
of self-government by the villagers, the villager conference will determine which people will be
identified as the objects for social security. Generally, old people who are incapable of laboring
will be preferentially identified as the objects of social security, and their due social insurance
expenses shall be paid by the resettlement authorities with multi-approach compensations, and
the gap to the full amount, if any, will be paid by the insured. Detailed measures for
implementation of social security system are still being established by the social security sector
of Rongjiang County.
221 With respect to vocational training and recommendation of employment opportunity, it is the
same as with Xiaobao Village. See Section 7.2.3 for more details.
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
222 As the house to be demolished in Kouzai Village is a makeshift hut (used for crop guarding),
monetary resettlement will be applied.
7.2.6 Sidi Village, Xingping Town, Yangsuo County
(1) Overview
223 Typically located in agricultural area, Sidi Village is one hour's ride from Yangsuo County, and
has a population of 2,023 covering 543 households, farmland of 1,768 mus, and farmland area
per capita of 0.7 mu, achieving an annual net income per capita of 3,500 yuan, with main
income sources covering planting of taro and fruits and migrant employment in slack seasons.
224 Due to land expropriation for construction of station (Yangsuo County Station), land of 450.17
mus in the village has been permanently requisitioned by the end of 2010 and related
resettlement operations have been completed, and buildings of 99,560 m 2 will be demolished,
including residential houses of 13,560 m2 involving 258 persons in 62 households (including
concrete-brick structure of 6,600m 2 , brick structure of 3,000 m
2 , earth-wood structure of
2,200 m 2 , and primitive structure of 1,760 m
2); In addition, Yuhe Brickyard in construction
in area of 86,000m2 will be demolished, including office buildings, brickkiln, flood-proof trench,
drainage ditch, tank, dormitory area, switch board room, well and roads in the plant area.
(2) Resettlement for Residential House Demolition
225 Resettlement for residential house demolition in Sidi village will be conducted by means of
combination of separate resettlement and collective resettlement, between which the involved
households may choose one.
1) Separate resettlement - after the compensations for house demolition (including
compensations for the original house site), house removal and interim resettlement are paid by
county Office of Railway Construction through bank, the people subjected to house demolition,
with assistance of the town government, may use their own construction-purpose land,
contracted land or land transferred by the neighbor as house site to independently build new
house, with the house site area below 150% of the original house area, and will be provided
with subsidy for infrastructure for the house site by the resettlement authorities, and the
administration sectors will handled related administrative approval procedures for free.
2) Unified collective resettlement - due to construction of the station, this village has been
incorporated in the urban planning area by the county planning sector. In view of livelihood and
business operation of the involved people in future, the county resettlement authority has
established a Residential & Commercial Resettlement Area at the northern side of the Yangsuo
County Station square, which will be used as the collective resettlement community for the
involved people in Sidi Village. The collective resettlement site is 36.7 mus in area, has a
resettlement capacity of 80 households and house site area of 80m 2 per house. The aforesaid
requisitioned land is uncultivated land in the village and has been incorporated in the land
expropriation area. Distribution of new house sites within the resettlement community will be
decided by means of random draw lots. The discrepancy between the original house site area
and the new one will be solved by means of "mutual replacement and compensation". The
infrastructure in the resettlement site will be in the charge of the resettlement authorities, and
design drawing for separate-structured house will be provided for the involved households for
free. Construction cost involving house composition and decoration will be borne by the
involved households and related administrative expenses will be exempted by the resettlement
authority.
(3) Resettlement for Demolition of Yuhe Brickyard
226 Yuhe Brickyard in construction is built by a non-state investor in Sidi Village by means of land
rent and the construction was commenced in 2008 and ceased upon release of notice on the
railway construction, so no worker is involved in its demolition. Monetary resettlement will be
conducted for its demolition. The compensation cost for the brickyard will be determined with
the market replacement cost as estimated by a certified evaluating institution authorized by the
resettlement authority, and the brickyard investor will decide whether to rebuild it. The
resettlement authority will make necessary coordination and support during rebuilding of the
brickyard.
7.2.7 Hainan Village, Zhongnan Sub-District, Liwan District
(1) Overview
227 Hainan Village lies in the suburb of Liwan District, Guangzhou, and has a Population of 3838
covering 1,150 households, and farmland of 2,650 mus and farmland area per capita of 0.69 mu.
A Hainan Joint Stock Economy Cooperative was set up in the village for unified operation of
the village land. The annual net income per capita in this village is 19,101 yuan, with income
sources covering house rent, flower planting and sales, and dividends from the operational gains
of the economy cooperative.
228 As required in the altered preliminary design, farmland of 59.7 mus will be requisitioned in the
village, including paddy field of 40 mus, orchard garden of 19.7 mus, involving 248 people in
70 households.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
229 The resettlement operations for land acquisition will be implemented by the Office of Land
Expropriation and House Demolition of the district government. Combination of monetary
compensation, land reservation and social security will be applied in resettlement for land
expropriation in Hainan Village.
1) Monetary compensation: The resettlement authority will, based on the compensation criteria
for land expropriation, pay in full all compensations to Hainan Economy Cooperative, and then
the village will, based on the principle of villager self-government, decide whether such fund
should be used for development of the economy cooperative or as villagers' dividends.
2) Land reservation based on 10% of requisitioned land area:The resettlement authority of
Liwan District will also, based on the measures of Guangdong Province for land reservation,
determine the land to the reserved based on 10% of the permanently requisitioned land area,
which will be used for commercial development by Hainan Village Economy Cooperative,
including building of storages and stores for rent, with the gains used as dividends or
contributing to livelihood of the villagers subjected to land expropriation.
3) Free vocational training and recommendation of employment: the local employment security
authority will provide the persons subjected to land acquisition with free vocational training
course covering computer operation technique, automobile repair, commercial & trade service,
and recommend them to the communities or enterprises.
4) Social security: The resettlement authority will apply the measures for social security based
on the resettlement policies.
Qualification: Number of the persons whom the social security policy is applicable to will
be determined based on the farmland area per capita and quantity of requisitioned land.
The qualification (rural residences aged 16 or above who have not covered by basic pension
insurance for urban employees, and among them, ones aged 35 or below may participate in
social insurance voluntarily while ones aged 35 or above shall participate in it compulsorily)
for participation in the insurance will be reviewed and verified by the village committee and
then submitted to the sub-district office for approval. If no objection is received within
seven days from release of the qualification, the economy cooperative will have application
procedure handled with the local social insurance agency;
Fund source: The fund will be appropriated by Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Group, the
representative of the Owner, to Hainan Joint Stock Economy Cooperative at a rate of
30,373.2 yuan per mu.
Payment: The insured person will pay the insurance expense of 90 yuan on a monthly basis.
The economy cooperative will offer subsidy to the insured at a rate of 40-60 yuan per
month, while the district government will provide subsidy to the insured at a rate of 30 yuan
per month for a time not more than 15 years (such subsidy is from the gains in transfer of
state-owned land-use right).All subsidies will be appropriated in place upon handling of
insurance procedure and charged to the individual account. The insured may choose to
make payment in full at one time or on a monthly basis.
Distribution of security: The pension consists of basic pension and individual account
pension. The basic pension is funded and set up by financial sector at a rate of 110 yuan per
person·month (for term beyond 15 years, a rise of 0.1% month on month%). Monthly
criterion of individual account pension is the deposit (including interest) in individual
account divided by 139.
The government develops and use local planning reserve fund to make up for the gap left
when the fund on the individual account runs out and by adjustment to pension criterion.
7.2.8 Zengjiao Community, Hailong Sub-District, Liwan District
(1) Overview
230 Zengjiao Community lies in the suburb of Liwan District, Guangzhou, has a population of
3,334 covering 1,551 households, with agricultural population accounting for 54%, and
farmland of 400 mus, and farmland area per capita of 0.48 mu, achieving an annual net income
per capita of 18,762 yuan, with main income sources covering house rent and trade operation,
rarely relying on land.
231 Influence of this Project on this district lies in house demolition, involving 2 enterprises
building of 12,845.3 m2 and 50 persons,
232 including a storage of 2,186 m2 which is used by Guangzhou Steel Group for storage of
materials. and a collective facility owned by Zengjiao Joint Stock Partnership Economy
Cooperative and used for storage rent, in area of 10,659.3 m2 , and operated by 50 management
staff of the cooperative.
(2) Resettlement for Enterprise Building Demolition
233 1) Resettlement for Building Demolition with Guangzhou Steel Group: Monetary resettlement.
The facility of Guangzhou Steel Group in Liwan District is being removed to Fangchun
Community, and the involved storage has not been used, so no worker or management staff will
have their employment influenced. Monetary resettlement will be applied and the compensation
criteria will be determined based on the market replacement cost estimated by a certified
evaluating institution authorized jointly by the both parties. The compensations will be paid by
Guangzhou Key Works Headquarters of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project, Guangzhou
Railway Group.
234 2) Resettlement for House Demolition with Zengjiao Joint Stock Partnership Economy
Cooperative: monetary resettlement and rebuilding on reserved land.
The resettlement authority for Liwan District will pay the compensations for house demolition
in the form of money, and the Zengjiao Joint Stock Partnership Economy Cooperative will
independently select a rebuilding site in the reserved land within its jurisdiction for
reconstruction. The compensation criteria will be determined based on the market replacement
cost estimated by a certified evaluating institution. The estimate will take into account loss
resulted from close-down of operations due to building demolition. The 50 management staff
working on estate management and rent will be relocated by the economy cooperative to
another sector to ensure their employment and income not to be influenced by the demolition.
7.2.9 Yaotai Community, Kuangquan Sub-District, Yuexiu District
(1) Overview
235 Yaotai Community lies in urban area of Yuexiu District, and has a total population (all urban
residences) of 12,800 covering 3,200 households. and farmland of 265 mus and farmland area
per capita of 0.07 mu. All farmland is operated by the joint stock economy cooperative of the
community and mainly used for rent and the earnings therefrom are distributed across the
community.
236 Coverage of land expropriation and house demolition in Yaotai Community include: collective
land of 3 mus, urban residences of 41,898m2,
with 1,000 people in 302 households
involved,including 6 people in 2 households subject to land acquisition.
(2) Resettlement for Land Expropriation
237 As Yaotai Community is subject to a little influence of land acquisition for this Project,
monetary resettlement will be applied. The compensations will be paid by Guangzhou Key
Works Headquarters of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project, Guangzhou Railway Group
directly to the economy cooperative, and the criteria of reserved land to be used for
development of collective economy of the cooperative will be determined based on 10% of the
requisitioned land and the land source will be handled by the resettlement authority. These
reserved land will be planned and used by the economy cooperative for commercial operation
and development, and all earnings will be distributed to the members of community as
dividends.
238 Located in core commercial area of Guangzhou, there are abundant employment opportunities
available in Yaotai Community. The local sub-district office and employment security authority
will jointly provide the community residents with vocational training for free and recommend
them to the enterprise/institution within the community.
(3) Resettlement for House Demolition
239Monetary resettlement and house ownership replacement are both available to the households
subjected to house demolition.
1) Monetary resettlement: The compensation criteria will be determined based on the market
replacement cost estimated by a certified evaluating institution authorized by the resettlement
authority, which will then pay the compensations to the involved people's individual accounts.
The residential house will be obtained solely by the households subject to house demolition.
2) Estate ownership replacement: The resettlement authority will resettle the involved
households to the resettlement sites in the neighboring district ( such as in Haiyuedong
resettlement site and Sunlight Home resettlement community etc.), which have been constructed
by the resettlement authority. The households will, based on the building area of the original
house, choose a resettlement apartment with area most close to the original one and obtain the
permanent ownership by ownership replacement at proportion of 1:1. For any discrepancy
between the original house site area and the new one will be solved by compensation based on
the estimated market price. Currently, the estimated market price of the projects in construction
neighboring the involved district (such as the one in middle north section of Donghaoyong) is
17,000 yuan/m2 for framework-structured house, 16,000 yuan/m
2 for concrete-brick house or
15,000 yuan/m2 for brick-wood house. For any building area to be shared jointly, the
resettlement authority will settle accounts with the involved households at a rate of 3,900
yuan/sq. m.
7.3 INFLUENCED FACILITIES
240 All infrastructures influenced in construction of this Project will be reconstructed by the
construction contractors or specialized agencies authorized by the Owner as required. The
infrastructures influenced in construction of this Project will be reconstructed by taking the
following measures:
To be reconstructed directly by the railway constructor during construction, such as rural
roads and farm ditch etc.;
To be reconstructed by specialized agencies with funds provided by the railway sectors,
such as communication facilities and electrical power facilities etc.;
Compensation for some public services will be paid by the railway sectors to the involved
parties, and the services will be rebuilt by the involved parties, such as potable water tower
and lighting lines etc.
8. RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
8.1 RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PROCEDURE
8.1.1 PERMANENT LAND EXPROPRIATION AND COMPENSATION
THEREFOR
241 Permanent land expropriation and compensation therefor will be fulfilled by cooperation of
related agencies through the following procedure:
a. The design institution for this Project provides land expropriation detail drawings to verify
land acquisition/house demolition range and quantity;
b. County/district resettlement authority submit an application for land expropriation to the local
land administration;
c. The application for land expropriation is reviewed and approved;
d. The resettlement authority discusses with the land administration to determine and implement
policies on compensation for land expropriation and release of related information;
e. County/district land and resources administration visit the site to verify land expropriation
range and quantity along with involved townships/towns, sub-district offices, village groups,
communities and villagers;
f. A Land Acquisition Agreement shall be concluded and signed between county/district land
and resources administration and involved townships/towns, sub-district offices, village groups,
communities;
g. Compensations for land expropriation are appropriated/paid to the involved parties;
h. Related legal procedure is handled.
i. The land is put into use in the railway works for this Project.
242 In addition, the compensations for land expropriation and subsidies for resettlement will be
8.1.2 RECOVERY OF PRODUCTION
243 Agricultural production recovery and relocation will be conducted by the village committee
through the following operation procedure:
a. villager representative conference will be held to work out plans for reclamation or land
reallocation and distribution;
b. release the plans for reclamation or land reallocation and distribution to the public for
discussion;
c. distribute/reallocate the land;
d. farming.
244 Corporate production recovery and relocation will be the involved enterprise.
8.1.3 HOUSE DEMOLITION AND REBUILDING
245 House demolition and rebuilding will be carried out through the following procedure:
a. The design institution for this Project provides land expropriation detail drawings to
verify land acquisition/house demolition range and quantity;
b. The Owner's representative, representative of the local resettlement authorities and
representative of project constructor verify the involved house quantity and quality
along with the involved townships/towns, sub-district offices, village groups,
communities and villagers;
c. the local county/district resettlement authorities, in cooperation with the involved
township/town, sub-district office, village, community, release the list of involved
houses, including house quantity, compensation criteria therefor and demolition date
for discussion.
d. the local county/district resettlement authorities discuss with the involved
township/town,sub-district office,village,community,households, enterprise/institution
and stores etc. on the compensation criteria and sign compensation agreement with
them;
e. the compensations for house demolition are paid to the involved households by
county/district resettlement authorities through bank system;
f. the local county/district resettlement authorities organize construction of collective
resettlement community or the households subjected to house demolition
independently rebuild their houses on the site provided for free;
g. the migrants rebuild new houses and move in;
h. the migrants demolish the old houses.
8.1.4 RECONSTRUCTION OF INFRASTRUCTURE
a. The design institution for this Project provides the detail drawings to verify the
infrastructures within the coverage;
b. Surveys on the influenced infrastructures will be conducted jointly by the county/district
resettlement authorities and specialized facility regulation authorities;
c. county/district resettlement authorities authorize the specialized facility regulation
authorities to propose reconstruction plan based on the migration and resettlement plan;
d. county/district resettlement authorities discuss with the specialized facility regulation
authorities on compensation criteria for the infrastructures and sign Agreement on
Infrastructure Reconstruction and Compensation Therefor;
e. the specialized facility regulation authorities carry out reconstruction of specialized
facilities;
f. the infrastructures are put into operation.
8.2 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT SCHEDULE
246 As the construction of this Project has been in late stage and preparation and planning for house
demolition in the pending districts have been commenced, resettlement for the migrants subject
to land expropriation and house demolition will be commenced in July 20, and the civil
engineering will be started in February 12. It is planned that this Project will be completed in
the second quarter of 7.
247 4-6 months are usually provided for preparation for construction of railway, including land
expropriation and building demolition. The preparations include access to pioneer road,
electrical power and communication lines on the construction site; allocation or construction of
working site and offices; submission and approval of removal of the infrastructure, house
demolition and land acquisition on the involved land.
248 The schedule concerning land expropriation, house demolition and migration and resettlement
shall be established in accordance with the civil engineering schedule to ensure land
expropriation will be completed prior to commencement of civil engineering and sufficient
times (3-5 month) to be provided for house demolition and rebuilding.
249 Schedule concerning main activities related to migration and resettlement is provided in Table
47.
Table47 - Migration and Resettlement Schedule
Activity Responsible Organization Implementatio
n Date
Measurement and determination of
land to be requisitioned
Local land and resources administration, local project
management agencies, the involved township/town, village
and project constructor 2012.7-2012.8
Verification of involved house area
(including attachments)
LOCAL LAND AND RESOURCES ADMINISTRATION, LOCAL
PROJECT MANAGEMENT AGENCIES, THE INVOLVED
TOWNSHIP/TOWN, VILLAGE, HOUSEHOLDS AND PROJECT
CONSTRUCTOR
2012.9
Hold consultations and migration
conferences
Local land and resources administration, local project
management agencies, the involved township/town, village,
households, project constructor and experts from the design
institution
2012.9-2012.10
Establishment of resettlement
implementation plan (including
determination of new house site)
Local land and resources administration, local project
management agencies, the involved township/town, village,
households, project constructor and the design institution
2012.7-2012.10
Preparation and submission of land
use plan to Ministry of Land and
Resources for approval.
Discussion among the design institution and local land
administration, involved village officials, households and
enterprises.
2012.7-2012.11
Disclosure of the migration and
resettlement plan to the involved
people
Local land and resources administration, local project
management agencies, the involved township/town, village,
households and project constructor
2012.10-12
Signature of land acquisition/
house demolition agreement
Office of Railway Construction, land administration,
involved township/town, villages and households 2012.12-2013.1
Payment of compensations constructor, Office of Railway Construction, and the
involved villages and households 2012.12-2013.1
Rebuilding of houses The involved households 2012.12-
Removal The households subjected to house demolition, involved
village, township/town government and the constructor 2012.12-
Construction of civil engineering The railway constructor 2013.02
8.3 APPROPRIATION OF FUNDS
8.3.1 PRINCIPLE FOR APPROPRIATION
250 No demolition shall be done until all necessary resettlement measures have been taken. Before
the constructor use the requisitioned land, all compensations shall have been paid and the
involved people have been resettled properly.
251 All compensations must be paid in full and on schedule to the bank accounts as specified, and
no underpayment is permitted in any cases.
8.3.2 DIVISION IN CHARGE OF FUND MANAGEMENT
252 All funds used for compensation and resettlement shall be raised by the governments of
Guizhou Province, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region and Guangdong Province and in the
charge of related functional division. The compensation and resettlement funds for pending
districts under the altered preliminary design still rely on the existing and functioning migration
and resettlement system, including the resettlement authorities (excluding railway construction
leading group office) and land and resource administration at all levels in the involved districts.
8.3.3 FUND FLOW
253 The fund flows in the three involved provinces/regions are almost the same as below:
representative of the contributor (Provincial Railway Investment Company) >
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company > Provincial Office of Railway Construction > (1)
(compensation fund for land expropriation) > Provincial Administration of Land and Resources >
Municipal/Prefecture Administration of Land and Resources > County/District Administration
of Land and Resources > involved villages/households; (2) (house demolition & removal
fund) > Municipal/ Prefecture Office of Railway Construction > County/District Office of
Railway Construction > involved persons (residents/enterprises/institutions/schools etc.)
9. Organization and Institution
9.1 ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
254 To achieve land expropriation, house demolition, migration and resettlement along the line
under the altered preliminary design, the existing migration and resettlement organization
network is functioning, as shown in Figure 1. The horizontal section of the network contains
Ministry of Railways (including Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company and construction
contractors etc.) and local government agencies, including External Coordination Department of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company, the contractors' land expropriation & house demolition
leading groups, and Office of Railway Construction of governments at all levels and local land
resource administration. The local government is responsible for migration and resettlement
operation.
255 The organizations under operation management division involved in migration and resettlement
include:
External Coordination Department, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company;
contractors' land expropriation & house demolition leading groups;
designers of China Railway No. 2/No. 4 Survey and Design Institute.
256 The departments of local government agency in charge of migration and resettlement include:
NDRC/Office of Railway Construction of Guizhou Province;
NDRC/Office of Railway Construction of Guiyang City;
Guiyang Municipal Bureau of Land and Resources;
Office of Railway Construction of Baiyun District, Guiyang City;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Baiyun District, Guiyang City;
NDRC/ Office of Railway Construction of Qiangdongnan Prefecture;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Qiangdongnan Prefecture;
Office of Railway Construction of Rongjiang County;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Rongjiang County;
NDRC of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region;
Office of Land and Resources of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region;
NDRC of Guilin City;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Guilin City;
Office of Railway Construction of Yangsuo County;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Yangsuo County;
NDRC of Guangdong Province;
NDRC of Guangzhou City;
Bureau of Land and Resources of Guangzhou City;
Township/ Town/ Sub-District Land Expropriation and House Demolition Leading Groups
involving 9 villages/communities.
Figure 1 - Migration & Resettlement Organizations for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
9.2 ORGANIZATIONS' RESPONSIBILITIES
257 Railway construction agencies at township/ town level, led by the deputy township head/town
mayor, consisting of 4-5 officials,responsible for measurement of land, house and attachment
thereof and migration and resettlement operation under the leadership of county/district Office
of Railway Construction.
258 County/district Office of Railway Construction, consisting of 3-4 officials, responsible for
establishment of migration and resettlement plans, payment of compensations and
implementation of migration and resettlement operation under the leadership of Office of
Railway Construction at district level.
259 Bureau of Land and Resources at county/district level, as the executive authority of the
government, responsible for unified land control, review and approval of land expropriation for
construction projects, and improvement to compensation and resettlement plans in cooperation
with Office of Railway Construction at county level.
260 Bureau of Land and Resources at county level is responsible for:
implementation of related laws, regulations and policies concerning land control;
unified management of land and urban and rural land-related affairs and registration, land
survey, statistics, sorting, grading, registration and review of land expropriation and
Involved Village
Committees & Villager
Groups
Coordination
Commissioner of
Ministry of Railways
for M & R
M & R Offices in
Township/Town/Sub-
District
M & R offices in 9
Districts/Cities
M & R offices in
Involved
Counties/Districts
Guiyang-Guangzhou
Railway Construction
Leading Groups in
Guizhou/ Guangxi/
Guangdong
External Surveillance
& Evaluation
Organization
Construction
Coordination Offices
in
Guizhou/Guangxi/Gua
ngdong
M & R Leading
Groups in Involved
Cities/Districts
M & R Leading
Groups in Involved
Counties/Districts
The World
Bank
Guiyang-Guangzhou
Railway Company
appropriation for construction project, review and approval of land expropriation and
issuance of certificate;
review of land expropriation and appropriation, payment of compensations for land
expropriation and land reallocation, interim land expropriation for construction project,
review and approval of land expropriation operation;
management of land market, restraining and rectifying illegal use/misuse of land;
investigating and addressing cases violating land laws;
based on local national economic and social development planning, working related sectors
to developing land use and backup resource development plans, and review and
surveillance of implementation thereof;
surveillance of protection of prime cropland, land development and farmland reclamation.
261 Office of Railway Construction at district level, consisting of 3-4 officials, is responsible for
land expropriation, house demolition and resettlement therefor and fund management within its
jurisdiction, working with railway operation sectors to collect related land acquisition data, and
coordination and management of affairs related to this Project.
262 Provincial Office of Railway Construction (led by the deputy governor or the official appointed
thereby, with its members from NDRC, land and resource administration, human resource, civil
affair, electric power supply sector, security division, industry and agriculture sectors etc.) is
responsible for establishing macro policies, negotiating with Ministry of Railways, coordinating
and working with local divisions, establishment and instructions on macro compensation
policies, appropriation of compensations for land expropriation and house demolition.
263 Construction contractors' land expropriation & house demolition leading groups is responsible
for submitting applications for land acquisition, communicating with local land and resource
administration, reporting work progress, and dealing with emergencies. Railway constructor's
land expropriation group is responsible for establishing land use plan, negotiating with land and
resources administration and Office of Railway Construction at county level.
264 External Coordination Department of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company, consisting of
7-8 officials, is responsible for coordination in land expropriation and house demolition affairs
with Office of Railway Construction of the local governments, providing guidance on the
business of land expropriation and house demolition groups of the constructor, verifying and
summarizing quantity and cost of land expropriation and house demolition on the behalf of the
Owner, communicating and negotiating with provincial NDRC/ Office of Railway Construction,
external surveillance during implementation of the Project.
265 FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways, with one migration commissioner specially assigned for this
Project, is responsible for coordination in establishment of the migration and resettlement plan,
management of socio-economic survey done by the consultants and the designing institute,
coordinating with and submitting surveillance report to the World Bank.
266 Design groups of CREC No. 2/No. 4 Design Institution for this Project is responsible for
investigating and measuring quantity and category of land expropriation, house demolition and
attachments thereof and infrastructure therefor during feasibility study, preliminary design and
construction, preparing cost budgets for land acquisition, house demolition and migration and
resettlement.
9.3 EXECUTIVE COORDINATION
267 As the executive coordination division, FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways is responsible for
operations related to migration and resettlement during preparation, and surveillance and
evaluation during implementation and upon completion of this Project.
268 Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company will perform owner's obligations on the behalf of
Ministry of Railways, and develop close cooperation with Office of Railway Construction of the
three provinces, coordinating their divisions in charge of land expropriation and house
demolition to work closely with Office of Railway Construction at all levels to handle affairs
related to land expropriation, house demolition and migration and resettlement therefor.
269 Office of Railway Construction of the three provinces is responsible for negotiating with
Ministry of Railways on vital issues, establishing macro policies on migration and resettlement.
270 Office of Railway Construction/Office of Resettlement of Guiyang, Qiangdongnan Prefecture,
Guilin and Guangzhou is responsible for implementation of migration and resettlement plan and
coordination and with railway sector in management.
9.4 MIGRATION AND RESETTLEMENT AUTHORITIES' COMPETENCE AND
TRAINING
271 The resettlement authority of local government has had extensive experience in migration and
resettlement concerning municipal construction, expressway and other significant infrastructure
construction projects, and related officials have had abundant knowledge of national and local
laws and policies concerning land expropriation, house demolition, migration and resettlement.
NDRC of Guiyang, NDRC of Guilin and NDRC of Guangzhou have successfully developed
cooperation with the World Bank respectively in migration and resettlement respectively for
projects of Guizhou-Chongqing Railway, Hunan-Guangxi Railway, Wuha-Guangzhou Railway,
Xia-Rong Expressway, Luoyang-Zhanjiang Railway, Guangzhou-Hezhou Expressway, and
have well comprehended the World Bank's non-voluntary migration policy. Obviously, the
officials in the districts/cities along the railway line have had good understanding of Chinese
laws and the World Bank's policies on migration, resettlement and compensation. As is
understood, a common goal lies in both Chinese laws and the World Bank's policies - after
completion of the Project, the involved people will have their living standard at or above the
excising level.
272 During three years' implementation of land expropriation and house demolition, these officials
in migration and resettlement authorities and the experts of the World Bank's delegation,
external surveillance and evaluating institutions have had comprehensive knowledge of the
World Bank's migration policies and related Chinese laws, regulations and policies.
10. Negotiation, Complaint and Participation
10.1 Negotiation
10.1.1 Stakeholders under this Project
273 The directly involved stakeholders include:
people involved in permanent/interim land acquisition;
people involved in house and its attachment demolition and removal;
people involved in plant/premises demolition and removal;
organization involved in demolition of public services;
groups or individuals owning land or underground ancillary facilities;
involved villages and villager groups;
relevant Office of Railway Construction and Bureau of Land and Resources at county level;
Office of Railway Construction and Bureau of Land and Resources in related districts;
related functional divisions of Ministry of Railways, including Construction Department,
Planning Department, Finance Department, FCUTIC, Authentication Center etc.;
External Coordination Department, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company;
the constructor.
274 Indirectly involved stakeholders include:
the Central Government of China;
Ministry of Finance;
National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) at all levels;
Poverty Relief Office at district and county levels;
China Railway No. 2/No. 4 Survey and Design Institute and other design organizations and
engineering consultants involved detail design and construction supervision;
external monitoring organization concerning migration and resettlement for this Project;
domestic and oversea lenders for this Project;
potential passengers on the railway transport line and freight transport clients.
10.1.2 Public Participation Stage, Mode and Content
275 Public participation in this Project lies in:
public participation during preparation for this Project;
public participation during implementation of land expropriation, house demolition and
migration;
public participation during construction of this Project;
public participation in surveillance and evaluation after completion.
276 Public participation will be achieved in the following ways:
negotiation;
migrant conference;
on-site survey on potential loss in materials and property and socio-economic condition;
comments on compensation criteria;
selection of new house sites;
independent construction of new house by the involved people;
investment with collective compensations;
assistance with, recommendation on and training on recovery of incomes.
277 Public participation will be achieved from the following aspects:
At Village Level:i) Village/group leaders and villager representatives will participate in
survey on and verification of quantity of land expropriation, demolition of house and the
attachments. The house owner, villager representatives, village officials, Office of Railway
Construction and railway design institute, constructor will all participate in the survey. ii)
After end of the survey, the involved people will make verification of the estimated loss in
land, building and crops. All involved parties shall sign the compensation agreement. A
copy of the agreement shall be kept respectively in the involved village, local Office of
Railway Construction and the constructor for filing. iii) Location of the new house site will
have direct effect on the villagers' life and business operations in future. The involved
households usually tend to build new house at the side of road or near the station to
promote their business operation. In selection of house site in this Project, the Resettlement
authority will take into full consideration the villagers' will and provide them with much
freedom in selecting their house sites. In this Project, sufficient space will be provide for
the involved villages to make necessary adjustment and improvement to the removal plan to
minimize construction of interim houses. A set of supervision mechanism will be developed
for evaluation of implementation of this procedure.
Public participation is one of the important and essential steps in the survey and design for
this Project. The survey and design organization have collected the related parties' opinions
on and requirements for this Project through negotiations and consultations, and have
solved problems concerning water supply, drainage, waste disposal site, building material
supply etc. by concluding and signing agreements with functional divisions of related
government along the railway line. In addition, survey and design personnel will make
discussion with Office of Railway Construction on interest issues in related areas and
develop proper solutions.
Public participation is also a key element during evaluation. During preparation of
migration and resettlement plan (draft), the design institute and the plan preparing
organization have understood what the involved people are concerned about through
in-depth survey. People at all levels have participated in the Project and had preliminary
knowledge of the Project through the questionnaire issued and visits paid by the survey
teams. In the interviews the farmers provide detailed information on family members, house
area, family incomes and expenditure, housing condition and family durables etc., as well
as the influence of land expropriation and house demolition on them, and also expressed
their opinions on migration and resettlement, and construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou
railway project. This procedure was still implemented during preparation and
implementation of the detailed migration plan.
The course of construction is also a course of public participation. During construction of
this Project, the farmers and urban residents in the districts along the railway line may be
provided with employment opportunities and participate in the construction. Building
materials required in the construction can be supplied locally, which promoted the trade and
business operation in these districts.
Surveillance and evaluation during construction and after completion also need public
participation, and the participants' legal rights and interests would be guaranteed. Surveys
and assessment in surveillance and evaluation need the public's participation and support.
In survey on migrated population, public participation must be part of the migration plan
and after that, public participation would also be part of the surveillance and evaluation
plan.
10.1.3 Participation in Implementation Stage
278 During implementation of land expropriation and house demolition for this Project, many
conferences have been held by the Owner and local governments at all levels, as well as by the
villager representatives, the railway agencies and sectors, including:
villager conference held by the village or villager group;
farmer symposium held by county/town/village governments;
village official representative conference held by county/town/village governments;
conference on resettlement plan held by county project office and township/town Office of
Railway Construction;
routine working conference held by project office at all levels and the constructor's land
expropriation and house demolition groups;
working conference at county level held by project office at district level.
279 On these conferences, the people involved in land expropriation and house demolition have
been informed of related information, and expressed their opinions and advices, including:
1) participation in villager conference or owner representative conference: As required in the
procedure, the resettlement authority must go to the involved villages/communities to hold
villager/community resident conference or household representative conference. These
conferences will be often held in the communities. On these conferences the villagers and owner
representatives will be informed of the goal, missions of the construction and information
related to land acquisition, building demolition, compensation and resettlement, and propose
their own opinions and ideas.
2) reading notices and bulletin boards: The resettlement authorities will release notices and
announcements through media (TV and radio broadcast etc.) to present the information on this
Project and compensation and resettlement policies to the public.
3) personal participation in surveys on physical loss and social economy: A evaluating team
consisting of officials of local resettlement authorities, construction contractor's staff, local
village/group officials and the involved people shall be set up to make survey on the physical
materials involved in land acquisition and building demolition, though which the involved
people can express their opinions on the operations to protect their legal rights.
4) participation in selection of rebuilding mode and location: Whether for individual separate
resettlement or collective resettlement, the rebuilding location shall be mainly decided by the
involved household.
5) Reading the information booklet: Information booklets on resettlement for this Project will be
distributed to the involved people by the resettlement authorities to inform them of the related
project background, compensation policy and criteria, and resettlement measures etc.
10.1.4 Survey on Public Opinions
280 In March 20, with support of the Owner and the resettlement authorities in the involved
districts, the Supplementary Plan preparer acquired 122 sample Households by making random
stratified samplings in the involved villages and make surveys on public opinions to know the
involved households' and the involved villages' ideas on the project construction and migration
and resettlement operation. The results of surveys on the public opinions and ideas are shown in
Table 48.
281 During years' construction, the respondents in the involved districts have known the
information on the construction of this Project and they expressed their approval of it,
282 and they also showed their concern about the influence of land expropriation and house
demolition on their life. With respect to the influence of the Project, all of the respondents
thought that this Project would make improvement to transportation condition and facilitate
traveling, and 82% of the respondents believed that this Project would have effect on the local
investment environment,attract oversea investors and thereby create more commercial
opportunities (see Table 48 for more details),
283 while some people also mentioned of adverse effect.82% of the respondents thought the land
expropriation for this Project would have effect on their life and 80.3-86.1% explicitly stated
that land expropriation and house demolition would likely cause economic loss and reduction in
economic income (see Table 48 for more details). 16.4% thought the local transport would be
influenced during construction of this Project.
284 The respondents proposed various advices for their concerns.16.4% hoped that their land and
house would not be involved in construction of this Project. 94.3% advised that compensation
and resettlement measures should be taken as per related national policies. 13.1% suggested that
the existing compensation criteria should be raised. 96.7% suggested that reasonable
compensation and resettlement should be provided for the people subjected to land
expropriation and house demolition, and house site should be offered to them. As seen from the
above, proper and sufficient compensation for land expropriation and house demolition, security
for the involved people's living standard, resettlement site with access to convenient
transportation and social security measures etc. are the focus of the involved people's concern.
285 Though compensation measures for land expropriation and house demolition for this Project
have not been taken, 98.4% have known about related national compensation policies, and only
1.6% know little about these policies, while 89.3% said they knew how to preserve their lawful
rights and interests.
Table48 - Statistics on Public Opinions on Resettlement Measures for Land Expropriation and House Demolition under APD
N
o. Question Options
Result
1 2 3 4 5
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
1
Do you know
about
construction of
this Project?
(1) Yes.
(2) Not
much. (3)
No.
122 100.0 - - - -
2
Do you
approval of
construction of
this Project?
(1) Yes.
(2) No. (3)
I don't
care.
120 98.4 1 0.8 1 0.8 - - - -
3
Do you think
who will benefit
from this
Project?
(multi-choice)
a) The
State. (1)
Yes. (2)
No.
122 100.0 0 - - - - -
b) The
collective.
(1) Yes.
(2) No.
122 100.0 0 - - - - - -
c)
individual
s. (1) Yes.
(2) No.
118 96.7 4 3.3 - - - - - -
4
What influence
do you think
Guiyang-Guang
zhou railway
will have on
your
production/life?
(1)
Traveling
cost will
be cut
down. 122 100 100 82.0 45 36.9 100 82 122 100
(2) It will
result in
land
expropriati
on and
thereby
have
effect on
my life.
(3)
Nothing.
(4) It will
influence
the local
investment
environme
nt.
(5) It will
achieve
improvem
ent to
transportat
ion and
facilitate
traveling.
5
What's your
suggestion on
construction of
Guiyang-Guang
zhou railway
Project?
(1) A local
station
should be
constructe
d.
100 82.0 20 16.4 - - - - - - (2) It's
better that
my land
and house
would not
be
requisition
ed.
6
What adverse
effect do you
think
Guiyang-Guang
zhou railway
will result in to
you?
(1)
Nothing at
all.
100 82.0 20 16.4 98 80.3 105 86.1 10 8.2
(2)
Constructi
on of the
Project
will
influence
the local
transport.
(3) House
demolition
may cause
economic
loss.
(4) Land
expropriati
on may
cause
reduction
in
economic
income.
(5) Other
adverse
effect.
Table49 - Statistics on Public Opinions on Resettlement Measures for Land Expropriation and House Demolition under APD (Continued)
N
o. Question Options
Result
1 2 3 4 5
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
Number
of
Responde
nts
Proporti
on (%)
7
What's your
opinion and
suggestion on
resettlement
operation for
land
expropriation
and house
demolition for
Guiyang-Guang
zhou railway
Project?
(1)
Compensat
ion and
resettleme
nt
measures
should be
taken as
per related
national
policies.
115 94.3 16 13.1 118 96.7 122 100 - -
(2) The
existing
compensat
ion criteria
is
insufficien
t and
should be
raised.
(3)
Reasonabl
e
compensat
ion and
resettleme
nt
measures
should be
taken and
house site/
resettleme
nt house
should be
provided.
(4)
Compensat
ion for
land
acquisition
and house
demolition
should be
offered.
8
Do you know
anything about
related national
policies on land
expropriation
and house
demolition?
(1) Yes.
120 98.4 2 1.6 - - - -
(2) A little.
(3) No.
9
Do you know
how to
complain when
your lawful
rights and
interests are
violated during
land
expropriation
and house
(1) Yes.
109 89.3 13 10.7 - - - - - - (2) No.
demolition?
10.2 Disclosure of Information
286 Local resettlement authorities have release information to the public via
multiple media to disseminate information concerning this Project and specific
rules on implementation of national policies on land expropriation and house
demolition developed by the governments at all levels.
287 A notice on land expropriation and house demolition shall be released to all the
involved people one month prior to implementation of it, so that the people will be
informed of related matters, range of land acquisition and house demolition,
policies on compensation and resettlement etc.
288 Booklets concerning migration and resettlement will be released by the Office of
Railway Construction of the local government to all involved villages one month
prior to implementation of migration and resettlement. The booklet shall contain
introduction of Guiyang-Guangzhou railway project, range of land acquisition and
house demolition, related procedure and principles, compensation criteria and
complaint mechanism etc.
289 Conferences held at the involved villages/communities is another main approach
for information publish,where the participants will be informed of implementation
of land expropriation,compensation criteria and policy,measures on house
rebuilding and personnel resettlement, and their feedback will be collected as
well.
10.3 Complaint Channel
290 Migration and resettlement is a complicated job. The involved people may want
to express their dissatisfaction and complaints during implementation of
resettlement, so the resettlement authorities will develop a set transparent
procedure to collect and deal with the migrants' dissatisfaction and complaints to
preserve their rights and interests and ensure a smooth process of resettlement.
10.3.1 Complaint and Appeal Procedure
(1) Stage 1
291 The involved people will express their complaints orally or in writing to the
village committee or town Office of Railway Construction, which shall keep a
writing record of the oral complaint and give an explicit reply to it. If a complaint
involves severe issues and has to be reported to the higher authority, a reply must
be given within two weeks.
(2) Stage 2
292 If the complainant is dissatisfied with the reply given in Stage 1, he/she may
submit the complaint to the Office of Railway Construction at higher level within
one month from receipt of the reply, and a proper decision shall be made by the
county/district Office of Railway Construction within three weeks.
(3) Stage 3
293 If the complainant is dissatisfied with the reply given by the county/district
migration office, he/she may submit the complaint to the provincial migration
office within one month from receipt of the reply given in Stage 2,and the
provincial authority shall give a reply within four weeks.
(4) Stage 4
294 If the complainant is dissatisfied with the reply given in Stage 3, he/she may file a
lawsuit to the civil court within 15 days from receipt of the reply given by the
provincial authority.
10.3.2 Principle of Handling Complaints
295 Office of Railway Construction at all levels must make necessary investigation on
the complaints and shall, after collecting the public opinions and negotiating with
them, provide a fair and proper solution as per related national laws and principle
of the migration and resettlement plan, or, for complaint involving matters which
are beyond jurisdiction of the authorities at current level, the authorities must
submit it to the Office of Railway Construction at higher level and make
necessary assistance with investigation.
296 In case no replay is given within the specified time by the decision-making
authorities, the lawsuit may be filed to the authorities at higher level.
297 Women may have special dissatisfaction and complaints during migration and
resettlement, so at least one woman official should be assigned for each migration
and resettlement group to handle women's complaints. local government and
non-government organization (such as civil affair administration and the Women's
Federation) will perform necessary supervision of migration and resettlement to
preserve women's rights.
10.3.3 Reply and Measures
(1) Reply
outline of complaint;
result of investigation;
related national rules and principle and criteria of the migration and
resettlement action plan;
solution and criterion conference;
The complainant has the right to appeal to Office of Railway Construction at
higher level or civil court at the Owner's cost.
(2) Authorities' Response
Response to exceptional complaints shall be delivered to the complainant in
writing,
while response to routine cases shall be disclosed to the public.
All responses in any forms shall be submitted to the local Office of Railway
Construction.
10.3.4 Record of Complaint and Subsequent Feedback
298 During implementation of migration and resettlement, the local Office of Railway
Construction shall maintain a written record of the complaints and solutions
thereto and submit it to provincial Office of Railway Construction, which shall
review the record on a regular basis. A form for the aforesaid record has been
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company as shown below:
Name of Complainant Receptor Office
Date Receiving Site
Complaint Content
Problems to be Handled
Alternative Solution
Effect of Solution
Signed by (complainant): Signed by (recorder):
Notes:
1. The recorder shall record the complaint and the complainant's requirement strictly according to the facts.
2. No blockage or interference shall be made during appeal.
3. The alternative solution to be applied shall be offered to the complainant during planning.
299 the following reception personnel have been assigned to receive the complaints at
the local county/district Office of Railway Construction:
Luo Guangyi,Office of Railway Construction of Guiyangtelephone: 18685161310;
Wang Zhihong, Office of Railway Construction of Baiyun District telephone:
13885182128;
Hu Chengwei,Office of Railway Construction of Rongjiang County telephone:
13885553919;
Yang Rucheng,Office of Land Acquisition and House Demolition of Liwan
District telephone: 13570939033;
Lon Guiguang, Office of Railway Construction of Yangsuo County telephone:
13877378535.
11. Surveillance and Evaluation
300 An overall surveillance will be perform on implementation of land acquisition,
house demolition and resettlement therefor in this Project, while the existing
surveillance and evaluation system is still in service. Such surveillance will be
done both internally and externally.
11.1 Internal Surveillance
11.1.1 Purpose
301 To ensure resettlement authorities at all levels to properly perform their functions
during implementation of the Supplementary Plan and construction of this Project
to be carried out smoothly, and preserve the involved persons' lawful rights and
interests, audit authorities at all levels will independently fulfill audit and
supervision rights on related units within their jurisdictions as per related laws and
regulations. And all responsible authorities shall perform surveillance of their
subordinate divisions to ensure migration and resettlement to be implemented in
compliance with the Supplementary Plan.
11.1.2 Agency and Personnel
302 Internal surveillance will be in the charge of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway
Company, and will be fulfilled by county/city/district Office of Railway
Construction and involved villages. Full-time personnel have been assigned in
resettlement authorities to effectively perform internal surveillance functions, who
have participated in preparation and implementation of the Supplementary Plan
and will carry out internal surveillance in compliance with the Supplementary
Plan.
11.1.3 Surveillance Content
303 Main tasks in internal surveillance include:
(1) appropriation/payment and use of migration compensations;
(2) selection and allocation of new house sites;
(3) rebuilding of independent private-owned houses;
(4) support for vulnerable groups;
(5) employment arrangement for involved labor force;
(6) quantity and quality of reclaimed land;
(7) land reallocation;
(8) distribution of subsidies for resettlement and land reallocation;
(9) resettlement of enterprise and industrial/commercial bodies;
(10) reconstruction of specialized facilities;
(11) schedule concerning the aforesaid activities;
(12) implementation of policies and rules on migration and resettlement plan;
304
(13) migrants' participation and negotiation during implementation;
(14) personnel allocation, training and operation schedule and operation of
resettlement authorities at all levels.
11.1.4 Implementation Procedure
305 Internal surveillance shall be implemented by following the procedure as shown
below:
(1) Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company has developed an internal surveillance
operation mechanism to review the activities in migration and resettlement, build
databases of land expropriation, house demolition and migration and resettlement,
so as to perform an overall surveillance of preparation and implementation of
migration and resettlement.
(2) During implementation, resettlement authorities at all levels shall build
corresponding databases and update them dynamically based on actual
implementation, and submit a record of current activities and implementation
progress to the upstream authorities on a level-by-level basis, so as to ensure a
sequential surveillance of the implementation.
(3) In this surveillance operation, mechanism information forms in specified
formats will be prepared to achieve a sequential information flow from village
authorities to the Office of Migration and Resettlement for this Project.
Town/city/district engineering construction leading group offices (headquarters),
township/town/sub-district resettlement working groups, as integral part of the
internal surveillance system, will conduct regular review and verification.
11.2 Independent External Surveillance and Evaluation
11.2.1 Purpose
306 To conduct regular external surveillance and evaluation of land expropriation,
house demolition and migration and resettlement, and propose evaluation opinions
and advices, provide preventive measures for engineering management sector and
feedback channel for the migrants.
307 The external monitoring organization will act as a commissioner and consultant
concerning migration and resettlement, which will carry out surveillance and
evaluation, and provide consultancy service.
11.2.2 Agency and Personnel
308 An authorized independent external monitoring institution is preforming
surveillance and evaluation to provide technical support for Ministry of Railways
or Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company by carrying out survey on migration
and the involved people's living standard.
11.2.3 Major Indicators for Surveillance and Evaluation
309 The major indicators for external surveillance and evaluation include:
A. Major Indicators for Surveillance
Progress: Including preparation for and implementation of land expropriation,
house demolition and migration, and migration and resettlement etc.
Quality: Including construction quality, migrants' satisfaction etc. during land
acquisition and house demolition.
Investment: Including appropriation/payment and use of funds for land
acquisition and house demolition and migration and resettlement.
B. The major indicators are to be evaluated from the following aspects:
(1) Migrants
Economic Condition: family’s economic development prior to and after
migration, including family's ownership of means of production/livelihood,
property and incomes.
Environmental Condition: dwelling environment prior to and after migration,
including transportation, culture and education, health care, commercial service
and other public services;
Employment Condition: variation in employment prior to and after migration,
including employment rate, assistance with employment for different objects
especially poverty-stricken families;
Community Development: Economic and environmental development,
interpersonal relationship and public opinion in the new resettlement site.
(2) Infrastructure: Variation of infrastructure prior to and after implementation of
resettlement in the involved districts;
(3) Enterprises and Industrial/Commercial Bodies:Variations of operation
environment and condition prior to and after resettlement.
11.2.4 Methods for Surveillance and Evaluation
310 Surveillance and Evaluation are carried out based on the data provided by the
design institution and resettlement authorities. Based on overall investigation,
combination of ample survey and quick assessment will be applied in the
evaluation.
311 The external monitoring and evaluation institution will conduct the following
work:
1) Survey on Migrants' Living Standard
An overall background value survey on basic production/living standard will
be done once or twice every year by collecting sorted samples which are pick
out randomly. Necessary related information will be acquired by regular
investigation, random interview and on-site observation etc., and then
statistical analysis will be done to make assessment. Survey on vulnerable
groups will also be done.
Living standard investigation form will consists of various indicators
measuring production/living standards, and dynamic variation of the
indicators will reflect the changes in production/living standard. Whether
design of the Indicators truly reflect variations of production/living standard
will be verified in the background value survey and necessary correction will
be made as required, so as to ensure acquired information will reflect the
quality and quantity of the migrants' production/living standard on an overall
and true basis.
2) Public Negotiation
The external monitoring institution will attend the public consultative conference
held in village/township/town/sub-district, where the monitoring institution will
evaluate effect of migrants' participation and cooperation in migration and
resettlement plan. These activities will continue during and after implementation
of migration and resettlement.
3) Migrants' Opinions
External monitoring institution will frequently visit county/township/sub-district
and village/group resettlement authorities and interview with migrants to acquire
their opinions, and promptly report the involved people and collectives' opinions
and requirements and propose corrective suggestion to improve implementation
of migration and resettlement.
4) Other Responsibilities
312 The external monitoring institution will conduct the following activities during
implementation:
(1) selection of resettlement site;
(2) rebuilding of houses;
(3) relocation and recovery of production;
(4) support for vulnerable groups;
(5) resettlement of enterprise and industrial/commercial bodies;
(6) reconstruction of specialized facilities;
(7) payment and amount of compensations;
(8) removal of migrants;
(9) employment of labor force;
(10) training;
(11) schedule of the aforesaid items;
(12) organizations for migration and resettlement;
(13) use of compensations for collective land and migrants' gains;
(14) increase in incomes in employment of labor force;
11.2.5 Working Step
313 The external surveillance will be done in accordance with the following steps:
(1) preparing working outline for surveillance and evaluation;
(2) developing Migration Information Surveillance and Evaluation System
(software);
(3) preparing survey outline, forms, record card of typical villages and
households;
(4) designing sample survey plan;
(5) background value survey;
(6) building surveillance and evaluation information system;
(7) surveillance and investigation:
—socio-economic survey in the involved districts;
—surveillance of migration enforcement authorities;
—surveys on typical villages;
—surveys on typical households;
—typical surveys on other objectives.
(8) sorting surveillance information and building database;
(9) making comparison and analysis;
(10) preparing a surveillance evaluation report semiannually or annually.
11.2.6 Report Preparing Plan
(1) Report on Resettlement Action Plan
314 The Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for this Project was prepared in November
2008 and updated with related data and information in discussion with the experts
of the World Bank, and the Supplementary Report is also part of the RAP. The
Supplementary Report will be submitted to the World Bank for evaluation.
(2) Report on Progress in Resettlement
A Reporting Interval
315 From the date of implementing resettlement operations for land acquisition and
house demolition, the resettlement authorities at all levels shall submit a progress
report (internal monitoring report) at least once every three month to the higher
authority, based on which, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Company will
summarize implementation of land expropriation, house demolition within its
jurisdiction to prepare a Report on Progress in Resettlement and submit it to the
World Bank prior to June 3 and December 31 every year.
B Reporting Form
316 As required by the World Bank, the report consists of two parts: text
summarizing land expropriation, building demolition and compensation etc. for
this Project, indicating any issues and problems during implementation and
corresponding solutions and measures therefor,and form, summarizing the
statistics collected semiannually on completion of land expropriation, building
demolition and payment of compensations (see Table 50, Table 51 for more
details).
Table50 - Report Form of Progress in Land Expropriation and Building
Demolition for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Reported by (organization):
Closed on: Reported on:
Item Unit Planned
Quantity
Completion in
Current
Quarter
Accumulative
Completion
Completion
Rate
Appropriation of
Funds
Rebuilding of New
Houses
Move-In
House Demolition
Construction of
Public Services
Reconstruction of
Electrical Lines
Reconstruction of
Communication
Lines
Land Expropriation
Prepared by: Signed by (leader): Official Seal:
Table51 - Utilization of Land Compensations and Resettlement Subsidies
District/Town:
From: Prepared on:
Involved
Units: Description Unit/Quantity
Investment
(RMB) Compensation/Subsidy (RMB)
Prepared by: Signed by (leader): Official Seal:
注:"Description" means water conservancy facilities (channel excavating, pump unit; livestock feeding; land reclamation (mu);
provision of public services; development of infrastructure;
(3) Independent External Surveillance and Evaluation Report
317 The independent external monitoring institution will submit an evaluation report
to the World Bank via FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways prior to July 31 every year.
A. Submission Interval
318 As required by the World Bank, during implementation of migration and
resettlement after commencement of land expropriation and house demolition, the
external surveillance and evaluation shall be conducted twice (respectively in
April and October) a year, and the evaluation report shall be submitted
respectively on July 31 and December 31.After completion of migration and
resettlement, the external surveillance and evaluation shall be conducted once (in
April) a year, and the evaluation report shall be submitted on July 31.
B.Report Content
319 The content of external evaluation report shall contain:
(1) baseline survey;
(2) process of migration and resettlement activities for land expropriation and house
demolition;
(3) relocation and recovery of production;
(4) house demolition, removal and rebuilding;
(5) alternative living standard;
(6) availability and utilization of resettlement funds;
(7) operation and efficiency of organizations implementing migration and resettlement;
(8) assistance to vulnerable groups; and
(9) problems and advices.
12. Involved Persons' Right Matrix
320 Based on the principle of resettlement compensation as defined for this Project,
an involved persons' right matrix is presented in Table 52 and Table 53.
Table 52 - Involved Persons' Right Matrix Influence
Category
Involved
Person
Compensation/Resettlement
Measures Compensation Criteria
Land
Expropriation
Village
Collective
1) compensations for farmland
2) compensations for non-farmland
3) compensations for accessories
owned by village collective
1. Farmland: Subsidies at 67,100 yuan/mu for
Black Stone Village and Duxi Village,
Baiyun District, Guiyang; subsidies at
26,800 yuan/mu for paddy field, 14,272
yuan/mu for dry farm, 8,920 yuan/mu for
orchard in Xiaobao Village, Yuezai Village
and Kouzai Village, Rongjiang;
2. subsidies at 66,000 yuan/mu for all
farmland in Yaotai Community, Yuexiu
District and Hainan Village in Liwan
District, Guangzhou;
3. Non-Farmland: Subsidies at 26,840
yuan/mu for Black Stone Village and Duxi
Village, Baiyun District, Guiyang;
4. Utilization and distribution of the
compensations shall be decided on villager
conference.
Farmer
1) compensations for young crops
2) compensations for accessories
owned by individuals
3) a series of measures for
development of livelihood, including
but not limited to:
a) reallocation of reserved land or
development-purposed land in the
village
b) reallocation of land retained in the
village
c) corporate investment to enhance
productive efficiency of the original
land
d) participation in social security
e) payment of cash to involved
households
f) vocational training
1. compensations for young crops are paid
directly to the involved farmers based on
local average annual output value;
2. compensations for attachments are paid to
the involved households based on market
replacement cost;
3. use of compensations for land
expropriation shall be decided on villager
conference: 1) to be appropriated directly
to involved households' individual
accounts by the resettlement authorities; 2)
upon land reallocation within
village/group, the land compensations shall
be distributed per capita;
4. All land-losing farmers will be provided
with social security.
5. Vocational training will be provided by the
government for the involved villagers for
free.
Table53 - Involved Persons' Right Matrix (Continued)
Influence
Category
Involved
Person
Compensation/Resettlement
Measures Compensation Criteria
House
Removal
Rural
Household
1) Compensations for house
replacement cost
2) Removal expenses
3) Interim resettlement
4) Rebuilding of new houses
1. Resettlement for house-demolished
households in Black Stone Village and Duxi
Village, Baiyun District: (1) monetary
resettlement based on estimated market
price;(2) replacement of estate ownership
at 240 m 2 /h; monetary compensation for
surplus portion at 539 yuan/m 2 for
concrete-brick/earth-wood structure, 320
yuan/m 2 for others.
2. Monetary resettlement and collective
rebuilding will be applied for Yuezai Village,
Kouzai Village and Xiaobao Village,
Rongjiang County. Criteria for monetary
resettlement: compensations at 460 yuan/m2
for Concrete-Brick structure; 400 yuan/m2
for Brick-Wood, 290 yuan/m2 for
Earth-Wood, 80 yuan/m2 for others; in
collective resettlement, compensations at 360
yuan/m2 for concrete-brick, 300 yuan/m2 for
brick-wood, 190 yuan/m2 for earth-wood,
and 80 yuan/m2 for others.
3. Collective independent building on the
appropriated land is applied in Sidi Village,
Yangsuo County, where compensations are
paid at 600 yuan/m2 for concrete-brick, 450
yuan/m2 for brick-wood, 280 yuan/m2 for
earth-wood and others.
4. Compensations for demolished houses in
Zengjiao Community, Liwan District, and
Yaotai Community, Yuexiu District,
Guangzhou are based on estimated market
price.
5. Subsidy Criteria for Interim
resettlement:6/ m2/month *18 month for
Black Stone Village/ Duxi Village, Baiyun
District, Guiyang City; Yuezai Village/
Kouzai Village/ Xiaobao Village, Rongjiang
County and Sidi Village, Yangsuo County;
6. Subsidy Criteria for House
Removal:6/m2/time *2 times for Black Stone
Village/ Duxi Village, Baiyun District,
Guiyang City; 5-15 yuan/m2 for Yuezai Village/ Kouzai
Village/ Xiaobao Village, Rongjiang County;500/h·month
*6 months for Sidi Village, Yangsuo County;
7. Infrastructure in resettlement community
is in the charge of the resettlement authority.
Enterprise
Removal
Owner and
Employees
1) Compensations by the Project
Owner
2) Rebuilding of enterprise
2) Employees
1. Compensation Criteria for Building
Demolition:Based on estimated market
price; compensations for losses in
removal, close-down, shipping and
reconstruction of public services will
be paid;
2. For Guangzhou Steel Group Company,
the demolished buildings will be
replaced with other facilities instead of
rebuilding.
3. The demolished buildings of Zengjiao
Joint Stock Partnership Economy
Cooperative will be rebuilt on the
reserved land within its jurisdiction.
4. No employee will be dismissed and
wages paid in full during demolition.
Removal of
Infrastructure
Involved
Infrastructure
1) Demolished by the Project
Constructor
2) Rebuilt by the owner with the
compensations provided by the
Owner.
1) To be reconstructed directly by the project
constructor during construction, such as rural
roads and farm ditch etc.;
2) To be reconstructed by specialized
agencies with funds provided by the railway
sectors, such as communication facilities and
electrical power facilities etc. Compensation
for some public services will be paid by the
railway sectors to the involved parties, and the
services will be rebuilt by the involved
parties, such as potable water tower and
lighting lines etc.
13. Appendices
13.1 Diagram of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Re-Routing
13.2 Statistics on Coverage of House Demolition in Altered Preliminary Design
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Tow
nshi
p/To
wn
Adminis
trative
Village
Towns
hip/To
wn
Adminis
trative
Village
Towns
hip/To
wn
Admini
strative
Village
Numb
er of
House
holds
Numb
er of
People
Residences
Non-Resi
dential
Buildings
Total Farmlan
d
Non-Fa
rmland Total
Guiya
ng
City
Baiy
un
Distr
ict
RAP 1 1 30,394.0 45,591.0 75,985.0 509.9 375.8 885.7
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 2 0 1 0 2 202 747 82,665.0 2,000.0 84,665.0 757.0 200.0 957.0
Nan
min
Distr
ict
RAP 6 12 31,849.0 47,663.0 79,512.0 152.9 185.0 337.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6 8 3 10 3 5 928 3,712 23,875.9 179,350.8 203,226.7 6.9 59.2 66.1
Yuny
an
Distr
ict
RAP 1 2 20,723.0 267,859.2 288,582.2 69.2 51.1 120.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 3 0 0 0 1 111 444 4,092.0 6,239.3 10,331.3 77.5 114.0 191.5
High
-Tec
h
RAP 1 3 55,262.0 82,892.0 138,154.0 813.6 599.7 1,413.3
Altered
Preliminary 1 2 0 1 0 0 291 1,077 38,072.7 0.0 38,072.7 980.0 16.1 996.1
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Zone Design
Total
-
Guiy
ang
RAP 9 18 0 0 0 0 1,096 4,649 138,228.0 207,231.0 345,459.0 1,643.8 1,211.6 2855.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
9 15 3 12 3 8 1,532 5,980 148705.6 187,590.1 336,295.6 1,821.5 389.3 2,210.7
Qiang
nan
Prefe
cture
Long
li
Coun
ty
RAP 4 6 31,240.0 46,827.0 78,067.0 270.4 199.4 469.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4 6 0 2 0 2 126 466 11,072.0 17,867.0 28,939.0 290.7 642.5 933.2
Guid
ing
Coun
ty
RAP 3 10 14,266.0 21,378.0 35,644.0 516.8 381.0 897.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 10 0 2 0 2 160 592 7,793.7 1,820.0 9,613.7 411.7 279.9 691.5
Duyu
n
City
RAP 3 6 0.0 0.0 720.6 531.2 1,251.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 10 0 0 0 4 351 1,404 67,831.3 1,143.3 68,974.6 1,027.4 464.7 1,492.0
Sand
u
Coun
ty
RAP 5 11 22,420.0 33,593.0 56,013.0 304.3 224.3 528.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
5 12 2 6 2 7 257 1,028 6,031.9 14,391.5 20,423.4 259.0 157.2 416.2
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Total
-
Qian
gnan
Prefe
cture
RAP 15 33 0 0 0 0 897 3,567 67,926.0 101,798.0 169,724.0 1,812.1 1,335.9 3,148.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
15 38 2 10 2 15 894 3,490 92,728.9 35,221.8 127,950.7 1,988.7 1,544.2 3,533.0
Qiang
dong
nan
Prefe
cture
Rong
jiang
Coun
ty
RAP 3 16 17,153.0 25,632.0 42,785.0 657.7 484.9 1,142.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 11 0 9 0 4 323 1,292 13,507.1 3,562.0 17,069.1 482.5 315.1 797.6
Cong
jiang
Coun
ty
RAP 6 7 11,283.0 16,906.0 28,189.0 486.9 358.9 845.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 8 3 7 0 8 185 685 9,116.5 2,100.0 11,216.5 207.6 386.6 594.2
Lipin
g
Coun
ty
RAP 3 7 8,001.0 11,998.0 19,999.0 59.1 43.5 102.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 11 0 5 0 9 120 444 0.0 0.0 156.8 38.8 195.6
Total
-
Qian
RAP 12 30 0 0 0 0 598 2,486 36,437.0 54,535.0 90,972.0 1,203.6 887.2 2,090.8
Altered
Preliminary 9 30 3 21 0 21 628 2,421 22,623.6 5,662.0 28,285.6 847.0 740.4 1,587.4
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
gdon
gnan
Prefe
cture
Design
Total -
GuiZhou
RAP 36 82 0 0 0 0 2,591 10,70
5 242,591.0 363,565.0 606,156.0 4,659.6 3,434.8 8,094.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
33 83 8 43 5 44 3,054 11,89
1 264,058.1 228,473.9 492,531.9 4,657.2 2,673.9 7,331.1
Comparison RPD-RAP -3 2 8 43 5 45 463 1,186 21,467.1 -135,091.
1 -113,624.1 -2.4 -760.9 -763.3
Liuzh
ou
City
Sanji
ang
Coun
ty
RAP 5 15 622 2,490 30,028.0 45,255.0 75,283.0 871.2 642.1 1,513.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6 13 0 5 1 3 126 378 7,437.6 0.0 7,437.6 504.1 465.9 970.0
Guili
n
City
Long
shen
g
Coun
ty
RAP 1 2 5,091.0 7,637.0 12,728.0 120.5 88.8 209.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 3 0 1 0 2 110 440 4,073.7 0.0 4,073.7 118.3 196.8 315.1
Ling RAP 3 12 14,210.0 21,382.0 35,592.0 817.0 602.3 1,419.3
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
ui
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 13 0 5 0 6 349 1,396 8,593.6 0.0 8,593.6 427.6 988.3 1,415.9
Ling
chua
n
Coun
ty
RAP 5 18 58,018.0 87,059.0 145,077.0 2,121.0 1,563.4 3,684.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
5 27 0 9 0 18 655 2,620 47,041.2 19,205.3 66,246.5 1,781.2 1,347.9 3,129.1
Yang
suo
Coun
ty
RAP 2 4 9,128.0 13,746.0 22,874.0 148.2 109.3 257.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 3 1 4 0 3 409 1,636 39,130.0 86,000.0 125,130.0 616.5 121.2 737.7
Gong
chen
g
Coun
ty
RAP 4 13 15,313.0 22,910.0 38,223.0 677.4 499.3 1,176.7
Altered
Preliminary
Design
5 15 0 2 1 4 636 2,544 12,508.9 1,420.5 13,929.5 1,780.3 194.9 1,975.2
Total
-
Guili
n
RAP 15 49 0 0 0 0 2,283 8,562 101,760.0 152,734.0 254,494.0 4,570.4 3,369.1 7,939.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
15 61 1 21 1 33 2,159 8,636 111,347.4 106,625.9 217,973.3 4,723.9 2,849.1 7,572.9
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Hezh
ou
City
Zhon
gsha
n
Coun
ty
RAP 3 7 22,527.0 33,940.0 56,467.0 2,076.7 1,530.9 3,607.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 12 0 0 0 5 907 3,628 50,470.6 833.0 51,303.6 1,373.8 226.5 ,1600.3
Dow
ntow
n of
Hezh
ou
City
RAP 4 10 33,941.0 50,912.0 84,853.0 1,319.5 972.7 2,292.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
7 32 0 1 3 23 827 3,308 150,791.8 3,621.0 154,412.8 1,662.8 1,222.4 2,885.2
Total
-
Hezh
ou
RAP 7 17 0 0 0 0 1,097 4,794 56,468.0 84,852.0 141,320.0 3,396.3 2,503.6 5899,.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
10 44 0 1 3 28 1,734 6,936 201,262.4 4,454.0 205,716.5 3,036.6 1,448.9 4,485.5
Total -
Guangxi
RAP 27 81 0 0 0 0 4,002 15,84
6 188,256.0 282,841.0 471,097.0 8,837.9 6,514.9 15,352.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
31 118 1 27 5 64 4,019 15,95
0 320,047.5 111,079.9 431,127.4 8,264.5 4,763.8 13,028.4
Comparison RPD-RAP 4 37 1 27 5 64 17 104 131,791.5 -171,761. -39,969.6 -573.4 -1,751. -2,324.4
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
1 1
Zhao
qing
City
Huaij
i
Coun
ty
RAP 7 18 20,858.0 18,455.0 39,313.0 1,402.8 1,034.2 2,437.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
7 31 1 7 1 20 558 2,232 61,377.6 0.0 61,377.6 701.1 2,107.9 2,809.0
Guan
gnin
g
Coun
ty
RAP 5 7 36,111.0 54,286.0 90,397.0 906.2 668.0 1,574.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6 14 0 3 1 10 403 1,612 25,650.7 7,698.3 33,349.0 663.2 1,319.6 1,982.8
Sihui
City
RAP 3 8 19,740.0 29,611.0 49,351.0 485.9 470.3 956.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 8 0 3 0 3 310 900 4,071.7 7,923.6 11,995.3 481.5 829.0 1,310.5
Ding
hu
Distr
ict
RAP 2 3 23,031.0 15,545.0 38,576.0 662.0 488.0 1,150.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
2 13 0 2 0 12 142 568 7,928.0 4,500.0 12,428.0 771.8 466.2 1,238.0
Total
-
Zhao
RAP 17 36 0 0 0 0 1,416 5,974 99,740.0 136,897.0 236,637.0 3,763.2 2,774.0 6,537.2
Altered
Preliminary 18 66 1 15 2 45 1,413 5,312 99,028.0 20,121.9 119,149.9 2,617.6 4,722.7 7,340.3
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
qing Design
Fosha
n
City
Sans
hui
Distr
ict
RAP 1 3 12,337.0 18,506.0 30,843.0 251.5 185.5 437.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 3 0 0 0 0 460 1,840 20,550.0 4,480.0 25,030.0 510.5 559.7 1,070.2
Nanh
ai
Distr
ict
RAP 4 15 90,039.0 61,072.0 151,111.0 627.5 462.5 1,090.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4 20 0 6 0 11 948 3,792 90,290.1 78,863.1 169,153.3 800.0 639.7 1,439.7
Total
-
Fosh
an
RAP 5 18 0 0 0 0 2,397 8,572 102,376.0 154,222.0 256,598.0 879.1 648.0 1,527.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
5 23 0 6 0 11 1,408 5,632 110,840.1 83,343.1 194,183.3 1,310.5 1,199.3 2,509.8
Guan
gzhou
City
Fany
u
Distr
ict
RAP 1 2 130,231.0 195,347.0 325,578.0 636.6 469.2 1,105.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 2 0 0 60 180 0.0 0.0 0.0 51.0 45.0 96.0
Liwa
n
Distr
ict
RAP 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
2 2 0 0 2 2 204 1,100 391.2 12,845.3 13,236.5 188.2 28.5 216.8
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Yuex
iu
Distr
ict
RAP 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1 1 0 0 1 1 302 1,000 0.0 41,898.0 41,898.0 3.0 0.0 3.0
Subt
otal
-Gua
ngzh
ou
RAP 1 2 0 0 0 0 769 2,383 130,231.0 195,347.0 325,578.0 636.6 469.2 1,105.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 3 1 2 4 4 566 1,011 391.2 54,743.3 55,134.5 242.2 73.5 315.8
Subtotal -
Guangdong
RAP 23 56 0 0 0 0 4,582 16,92
9 332,347.0 486,465.0 818,812.0 5,278.9 3,891.2 9,170.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
27 93 2 23 6 60 3,387 11,95
5 210,259.3 158,208.3 368,467.6 4,170.3 5,995.5 10,165.8
Comparison RPD-RAP 3 39 2 23 6 60 -1,195 -4,975 -122,087.7 -328,256.
7 -450,344.4 -1,108.6 2,104.3 995.7
Total - Full
Line
RAP 86 219 0 0 0 0 11,17
5
43,48
0 763,194.0
1,132,871
.0 1,896,065.0 18,776.3
13,841.
0 32,617.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
91 294 11 93 16 168 10,46
0
39,79
5 796,364.9 495,762.1 1,292,127.0 17,092.0
13,433.
3 30,525.3
City
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/Altered
Preliminary
Design
Involved
Counties/Towns
/Sub-Districts/V
illages in
Original Plan
Excluded
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Added
Counties/Towns/S
ub-Districts/Villa
ges
Involved in
Building
Demolition
House Demolition (sq. m) Permanent Land Acquisition
(mus)
Comparison between RAP and
DPTL 5 75 11 93 16 168 -715 -3,685 33,170.9
-637,108.
9 -603,938.0 -1,684.3 -407.7 -2,092.0
13.3 Land Expropriation Comparison between DPTL and RAP for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Land Expropriation Comparison between APD AND RAP for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
County/
District RAP/APD
Land
Acquisition
Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegeta
ble
Field
Orchar
d Others
Baiyun
District
RAP
Permanent 509.9 227.1 199.4 13.8 46.5 23.1 36.5 219.6 73.1 45.3 1.3 885.7
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 757.0 6.0 28.0 723.0 0.0 0.0 200.0 0.0 957.0
Temporarily
Used Land 43.0 0.0 25.0 0.0 18.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 43.0
Nanmin
District
RAP
Permanent 152.9 111.8 6.8 22.9 11.4 18.0 108.1 36.0 22.3 0.6 337.9
Temporarily
Used Land 115.8 51.6 45.3 3.1 10.6 5.2 8.3 49.9 16.6 10.3 0.3 201.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 6.9 0.00 0.00 6.94 0.0 0.0 24.2 34.9 0.0 66.1
Temporarily
Used Land 36.2 0.00 0.00 36.23 0.0 0.0 3.4 0.0 0.0 39.6
Returned
Land 89.5 0.0 89.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
89.5
Yunyan
District
RAP
Permanent 69.2 30.8 27.1 1.9 6.3 3.1 5.0 29.8 9.9 6.2 0.2 120.3
Temporarily
Used Land 33.7 15.0 13.2 0.9 3.1 1.5 2.4 14.5 4.8 3.0 0.1 58.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 77.5 0.00 0.00 77.47 0.0 0.0 111.3 2.1 0.6 191.5
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 12.5 0.0 0.0 12.5
Jinyang
District
(Jinyang
District
)
RAP
Permanent 813.6 362.4 318.2 22.1 74.1 36.8 58.2 350.5 116.6 72.3 2.1 1,413.3
Temporarily
Used Land 301.3 134.2 117.8 8.2 27.5 13.6 21.6 129.8 43.2 26.8 0.8 523.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 980.0 284.57 695.46 0.00 0.0 16.1 996.1
Temporarily
Used Land 136.7 0.0 136.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 9.8 14.8 161.3
Total -
Guiyang
RAP
Permanent 1,643.8 732.1 642.9 44.6 149.8 74.4 117.6 708.1 235.6 146.1 4.2 2855.4
Temporarily
Used Land 450.8 200.8 176.3 12.2 41.1 20.4 32.3 194.2 64.6 40.1 1.2 783.2
Altered Permanent 1,821.5 290.6 723.5 807.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 335.5 37.1 0.6 0.0 2,210.7
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Preliminary
Design
Temporarily
Used Land 215.9 0.0 161.7 36.2 18.0 0.0 12.5 3.4 9.8 14.8 0.0 256.4
Longli
County
RAP
Permanent 270.4 120.5 105.8 7.3 24.6 12.2 19.4 116.5 38.8 24.0 0.7 469.8
Temporarily
Used Land 685.5 305.3 268.1 18.6 62.5 31.0 49.1 295.3 98.3 60.9 1.8 1,190.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 290.7 173.9 113.4 0.0 0.9 2.5 508.3 112.8 21.4 933.2
Temporarily
Used Land 358.9 40.4 318.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 134.9 0.0 18.1 511.9
Guiding
County
RAP
Permanent 516.8 230.2 202.1 14.0 47.1 23.4 37.0 222.7 74.1 45.9 1.3 897.8
Temporarily
Used Land 774.2 344.8 302.8 21.0 70.5 35.1 55.4 333.5 111.0 68.8 2.0 1,344.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 411.7 215.44 196.21 0.00 269.2 1.9 8.8 691.5
Temporarily
Used Land 790.6 77.4 713.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 205.4 0.0 28.6 1,024.6
Duyun
City
RAP
Permanent 720.6 320.9 281.8 19.6 65.7 32.6 51.6 310.4 103.3 64.1 1.8 1,251.8
Temporarily
Used Land 1,335.3 594.7 522.2 36.3 121.6 60.5 95.6 575.2 191.4 118.7 3.4 2,319.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,027.4 583.7 414.7 0.0 25.1 3.8 400.5 45.3 18.9 1,492.0
Temporarily
Used Land 1,217.0 305.3 911.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 198.7 0.0 404.3 1,820.1
Sandu
County
RAP
Permanent 304.3 135.5 119.0 8.3 27.7 13.8 21.8 131.1 43.6 27.0 0.8 528.6
Temporarily
Used Land 813.4 362.3 318.1 22.1 74.1 36.8 58.2 350.4 116.6 72.3 2.1 1,413.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 259.0 178.0 60.1 0.0 16.3 4.7 145.1 12.1 0.0
416.2
Temporarily
Used Land 725.6 460.9 264.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 573.6 0.0 49.4
1,348.6
Total -
Qiangna
n
Prefectu
re
RAP
Permanent 1,812.1 807.1 708.7 49.2 165.1 82.0 129.7 780.7 259.8 161.1 4.6 3,148.0
Temporarily
Used Land 3,608.5 1,607.1 1,411.2 98.0 328.8 163.4 258.3 1,554.5 517.2 320.7 9.2 6,268.4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,988.7 1,151.0 784.4 0.0 42.3 11.0 0.0 1,323.0 172.1 49.1 0.0 3,533.0
Temporarily
Used Land 3,092.1 884.0 2,208.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1,112.7 0.0 500.3 0.0 4,705.1
Rongjia
ng
County
RAP
Permanent 657.7 292.9 257.2 17.9 59.9 29.8 47.1 283.3 94.3 58.5 1.7 1,142.6
Temporarily
Used Land 1,376.2 612.9 538.2 37.4 125.4 62.3 98.5 592.9 197.3 122.3 3.5 2,390.7
Altered Permanent 482.5 403.0 38.5 0.0 41.1 0.0 0.0 265.9 20.9 10.2 18.1 797.6
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Preliminary
Design
Temporarily
Used Land 766.9 467.2 299.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 589.9 0.0 91.0 1,447.8
Congjia
ng
County
RAP
Permanent 486.9 216.9 190.4 13.2 44.4 22.0 34.8 209.8 69.8 43.3 1.2 845.8
Temporarily
Used Land 894.6 398.4 349.9 24.3 81.5 40.5 64.0 385.4 128.2 79.5 2.3 1,554.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 207.6 164.8 13.4 0.0 22.3 7.1
324.2 61.3 1.0
594.2
Temporarily
Used Land 751.9 469.4 182.1 0.0 100.4 0.0
740.5 0.7 65.8
1,558.9
Liping
County
RAP
Permanent 59.1 26.3 23.1 1.6 5.4 2.7 4.2 25.4 8.5 5.2 0.2 102.6
Temporarily
Used Land 922.0 410.7 360.6 25.0 84.0 41.7 66.0 397.2 132.2 82.0 2.4 1,601.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 156.8 133.1 21.5 0.0 0.0 2.2 38.8 0.0 0.0 195.6
Temporarily
Used Land 343.6 164.9 108.9 0.0 69.8 0.0 355.0 0.0 0.0 698.6
Total -
Qiangdo
ngnan
Prefectu
re
RAP
Permanent 1,203.6 536.0 470.7 32.7 109.7 54.5 86.1 518.5 172.5 107.0 3.1 2,090.8
Temporarily
Used Land 3,193.0 1,422.1 1,248.7 86.7 290.9 144.6 228.5 1,375.5 457.7 283.8 8.2 5,546.7
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 847.0 700.9 73.4 0.0 63.4 9.3 0.0 628.9 82.2 11.2 18.1 1,587.4
Temporarily
Used Land 1,862.4 1101.5 590.7 0.0 170.2 0.0 0.0 1,685.4 0.7 156.8 0.0 3,705.3
Total -
GuiZho
u
RAP
Permanent 4,659.6 2,075.3 1,822.3 126.5 424.5 211.0 333.5 2,007.3 667.9 414.2 11.9 8,094.4
Temporarily
Used Land 7,252.2 3,230.0 2,836.3 196.9 660.7 328.3 519.0 3,124.2 1,039.5 644.6 18.6
12,598.
1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 4,657.2 2,142.4 1,581.3 807.4 105.7 20.3 16.1 2,287.4 291.4 60.8 18.1 7,331.1
Temporarily
Used Land 5,170.4 1,985.5 2,960.5 36.2 188.2 0.0 12.5 2,801.5 10.5 671.9 0.0 8,666.8
Compari
son RPD-RAP
Permanent -2.4 67.1 -241.0 680.9 -318.8 -190.7 -317.4 280.1 -376.5 -353.4 6.2 -763.3
Temporarily
Used Land -2,081.8 -1,244.5 124.2 -160.7 -472.5 -328.3 -506.5 -322.7 -1,029.0 27.3 -18.6 -3,931.3
Sanjiang
Dong
Autono
mous
County
RAP
Permanent 871.2 388.0 340.7 23.7 79.4 39.4 62.3 375.3 124.9 77.4 2.2 1,513.3
Temporarily
Used Land 1,272.1 566.6 497.5 34.5 115.9 57.6 91.0 548.0 182.3 113.1 3.3 2,209.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9 453.7 5.6 6.6 970.0
Temporarily
Used Land 744.1 478.6 265.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 459.2 0.0 92.9 1,296.2
Longshe RAP Permanent 120.5 53.6 47.1 3.3 11.0 5.5 8.6 51.9 17.3 10.7 0.3 209.3
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
ng
County
Temporarily
Used Land 328.3 146.2 128.4 8.9 29.9 14.9 23.5 141.4 47.0 29.2 0.8 570.2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 118.3 48.37 57.94 0.00 12.0 189.7 0.0 7.1 315.1
Temporarily
Used Land 387.3 221.1 166.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 58.3 120.0 1.8 567.4
Lingui
County
RAP
Permanent 817.0 363.9 319.5 22.2 74.4 37.0 58.5 352.0 117.1 72.6 2.1 1,419.3
Temporarily
Used Land 846.4 377.0 331.0 23.0 77.1 38.3 60.6 364.6 121.3 75.2 2.2 1,470.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 427.6 268.83 28.65 0.7 129.5 947.5 12.7 28.1 1,415.9
Temporarily
Used Land 736.8 468.84 103.33 0.00 164.6 0.0 1,800.0 0.0 139.9 2,676.7
Lingchu
an
County
RAP
Permanent 2,121.0 944.7 829.5 57.6 193.2 96.0 151.8 913.7 304.0 188.5 5.4 3,684.4
Temporarily
Used Land 1,312.2 584.4 513.2 35.6 119.6 59.4 93.9 565.3 188.1 116.6 3.4 2,279.5
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,781.2 687.6 664.0 1.4 382.3 45.9 0.0 1,080.5 203.9 63.5 0.0 3,129.1
Temporarily
Used Land 1,051.1 86.0 948.6 0.0 16.5 0.0 0.0 409.5 0.0 150.9 0.0 1,611.5
Yangsuo
County
RAP
Permanent 148.2 66.0 58.0 4.0 13.5 6.7 10.6 63.9 21.2 13.2 0.4 257.5
Temporarily
Used Land 426.6 190.0 166.8 11.6 38.9 19.3 30.5 183.8 61.1 37.9 1.1 741.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 616.5 34.41 32.21 0.00 549.91 0.00 20.8 77.2 21.0 2.2 737.7
Temporarily
Used Land 850.5 61.4 7.3 0.0 781.9 0.0 2.0 214.4 0.0 28.4 6.6 1,102.0
Gongch
eng
County
RAP
Permanent 677.4 301.7 264.9 18.4 61.7 30.7 48.5 291.8 97.1 60.2 1.7 1,176.7
Temporarily
Used Land 1,034.4 460.7 404.6 28.1 94.2 46.8 74.0 445.6 148.3 91.9 2.6 1,796.8
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,780.3 62.14 150.32 0.00 1,567.
8 0.0 0.0 106.7 70.4 17.9 0.0 1,975.2
Temporarily
Used Land 965.3 288.9 264.2 21.6 390.7 0.0 0.0 542.2 0.0 58.1 0.0 1,565.7
Total -
Guilin
RAP
Permanent 4,570.4 2,035.6 1,787.4 124.1 416.4 206.9 327.1 1,968.9 655.1 406.3 11.7 7,939.5
Temporarily
Used Land 4,023.9 1,792.1 1,573.7 109.3 366.6 182.2 288.0 1,733.4 576.7 357.7 10.3 6,990.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 4,723.9 1101.3 933.2 2.1 2,641.
4 45.9 20.8 2,401.5 287.0 137.6 2.2 7,572.9
Temporarily
Used Land 3,991.1 1,126.2 1,489.6 21.6
1,353.
7 0.0 2.0 3,024.5 120.0 379.0 6.6 7,523.2
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Zhongsh
an
County
RAP
Permanent 2,076.7 924.9 812.2 56.4 189.2 94.0 148.6 894.7 297.7 184.6 5.3 3,607.6
Temporarily
Used Land 514.6 229.2 201.2 14.0 46.9 23.3 221.7 73.8 45.7 1.3 857.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,373.8 903.20 1.18 432.34 5.3 31.8 68.9 157.6 ,1600.3
Temporarily
Used Land 753.5 527.22 226.32 0.00 0.0 0.0 1.3 73.9 0.0 0.1 16.3 845.1
Others 18.9 18.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 3.5 0.0 0.0 22.4
Downto
wn of
Hezhou
City
RAP
Permanent 1,319.5 587.7 516.1 35.8 120.2 59.7 94.4 568.5 189.1 117.3 3.4 2,292.2
Temporarily
Used Land 194.2 86.5 75.9 5.3 17.7 8.8 13.9 83.6 27.8 17.3 0.5 337.3
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,662.8 878.6 0.0 766.4 17.8 0.0 0.0 832.1 154.5 235.7 0.0 2,885.2
Temporarily
Used Land 1,727.1 898.9 828.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2,477.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 4,204.8
Total -
Hezhou
RAP
Permanent 3,396.3 1,512.6 1,328.3 92.2 309.4 153.8 243.1 1,463.1 486.8 301.9 8.7 5899,.9
Temporarily
Used Land 762.5 339.6 298.2 20.7 69.5 34.5 54.6 328.4 109.3 67.8 2.0 1,324.6
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 3,036.6 1,781.8 1.2 1,198.
7 23.1 31.8 0.0 901.0 312.1 235.7 0.0 4,485.5
Temporarily
Used Land 2,480.6 1,426.1 1,054.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.3 2,551.6 0.0 0.1 16.3 5,049.9
Others 18.9 18.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 3.5 0.0 0.0 22.4
Total -
Guangxi
RAP
Permanent 8,837.9 3,936.2 3,456.4 240.0 805.2 400.1 632.5 3,807.4 1,266.8 785.6 22.6 15,352.
8
Temporarily
Used Land 6,058.3 2,698.2 2,369.3 164.5 552.0 274.3 433.6 2,609.9 868.4 538.5 15.5
10,524.
2
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 8,264.5 3,074.0 1,225.3 1,200.
8
2,673.
9 90.6 20.8 3,756.2 604.8 379.9 2.2
13,028.
4
Temporarily
Used Land 7,215.8 3,030.9 2,809.6 21.6
1,353.
7 0.0 3.3 6,035.2 120.0 472.1 22.9
13,869.
3
Compari
son RPD-RAP
Permanent -573.4 -862.2 -2,231.1 960.8 1,868.
7 -309.5 -611.8 -51.2 -662.0 -405.7 -20.4 -2,324.4
Temporarily
Used Land 1,157.5 332.7 440.3 -142.9 801.7 -274.3 -430.3 3,425.3 -748.4 -66.4 7.4 3,345.1
Huaiji
County
RAP
Permanent 1,402.8 624.8 548.6 38.1 127.8 63.5 100.4 604.4 201.1 124.7 3.6 2,437.0
Temporarily
Used Land 206.6 92.0 80.8 5.6 18.8 9.4 14.8 89.0 29.6 18.4 0.5 358.9
Altered Permanent 701.1 290.7 170.1 0.0 85.5 154.8 176.4 566.1 202.5 974.7 188.2 2,809.0
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Preliminary
Design
Temporarily
Used Land 320.4 156.6 162.9 0.0 0.0 0.9 0.0 725.4 0.0 480.6 0.0 1,526.4
Guangni
ng
County
RAP
Permanent 906.2 403.6 354.4 24.6 82.6 41.0 64.9 390.4 129.9 80.5 2.3 1,574.2
Temporarily
Used Land 126.5 56.4 49.5 3.4 11.5 5.7 9.1 54.6 18.2 11.3 0.3 220.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 663.2 547.0 22.6 0.0 93.6 0.0 0.0 660.5 38.2 523.8 97.1 1,982.8
Temporarily
Used Land 36.0 7.2 28.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 588.4 0.0 191.7 180.0 996.1
Sihui
City
RAP
Permanent 485.9 352.8 25.0 72.2 35.9 56.7 341.2 70.4 2.0 956.2
Temporarily
Used Land 138.2 61.5 54.0 3.8 12.6 6.3 9.9 59.5 19.8 12.3 0.4 240.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 481.5 351.5 22.1 0.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 370.5 12.6 265.9 180.0 1,310.5
Temporarily
Used Land 34.2 16.2 18.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 656.1 0.0 145.8 0.0 836.1
Dinghu
District
RAP
Permanent 662.0 294.8 258.9 18.0 60.3 30.0 47.4 285.2 94.9 58.8 1.7 1,150.0
Temporarily
Used Land 39.2 17.4 15.3 1.1 3.6 1.8 2.8 16.9 5.6 3.5 0.1 68.1
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 771.8 717.60 0.00 9.9 44.3 0.0 0.0 9.0 270.0 97.2 90 1,238.0
Temporarily
Used Land 59.5 0.0 0.0 59.48 0.0 0.0 0.0 164.7 0.0 307.8 0.0 532.0
Total -
Zhaoqin
g
RAP
Permanent 3,763.2 1,676.0 1,471.7 102.2 342.9 170.4 269.3 1,621.2 539.4 334.5 9.6 6,537.2
Temporarily
Used Land 510.6 227.4 199.7 13.9 46.5 23.1 36.5 220.0 73.2 45.4 1.3 887.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 2,617.6 1,906.8 214.7 9.9 331.4 154.8 176.4 1,606.1 523.3 1,861.6 555.3 7,340.3
Temporarily
Used Land 450.1 180.0 209.7 59.5 0.0 0.9 0.0 2,134.6 0.0 1,125.9 180.0 3,890.6
Sanshui
District
RAP
Permanent 251.5 112.0 98.4 6.8 22.9 11.4 18.0 108.4 36.1 22.4 0.6 437.0
Temporarily
Used Land 17.4 7.7 6.8 0.5 1.6 0.8 1.2 7.4 2.5 1.5 0.0 30.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 510.5 410.50 100.00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 125.0 350.0 70.0 14.7 1,070.2
Temporarily
Used Land 165.0 0.0 165.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 25.0 85.0 0.0 275.0
Nanhai
District
RAP
Permanent 627.5 279.5 245.4 17.0 57.2 28.4 44.9 270.3 89.9 55.8 1.6 1,090.0
Temporarily
Used Land 22.4 10.0 8.8 0.6 2.0 1.0 1.6 9.7 3.2 2.0 0.1 39.0
Altered Permanent 800.0 700.00 100.00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 125.0 350.0 150.0 14.7 1,439.7
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Preliminary
Design
Temporarily
Used Land 66.3 66.25 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 149.5 2.5 0.0 218.3
Total -
Foshan
RAP
Permanent 879.1 391.5 343.8 23.9 80.1 39.8 62.9 378.7 126.0 78.1 2.3 1,527.1
Temporarily
Used Land 39.7 17.7 15.5 1.1 3.6 1.8 2.8 17.1 5.7 3.5 0.1 68.9
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 1,310.5 1,110.5 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 250.0 700.0 220.0 29.3 2,509.8
Temporarily
Used Land 231.3 66.3 165.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 174.5 87.5 0.0 493.3
Fanyu
District
RAP
Permanent 636.6 283.5 249.0 17.3 58.0 28.8 45.6 274.2 91.2 56.6 1.6 1,105.8
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 51.0 9.0 29.0 13.0 6.0 39.0 0.0 96.0
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 50.0 207.0 257.0
Liwan
District
RAP
Permanent 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 188.2 80.23 0.0 0.0 108.0 0.0 25.8 0.0 2.7 216.8
Temporarily
Used Land 30.0 0.0 30.0 0.0 0.0 7.0 12.0 49.0
Yuexiu
District
RAP
Permanent 0.0
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 3.0 3.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 3.0
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 50.0 50.0
Subtotal
-Guangz
hou
RAP
Permanent 636.6 283.5 249.0 17.3 58.0 28.8 45.6 274.2 91.2 56.6 1.6 1,105.8
Temporarily
Used Land 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 242.2 92.2 29.0 13.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 64.8 0.0 2.7 315.8
Temporarily
Used Land 30.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 30.0 0.0 0.0 50.0 214.0 62.0 356.0
Subtotal
-
Guangd
ong
RAP
Permanent 5,278.9 2,351.1 2,064.5 143.3 481.0 239.0 377.8 2,274.1 756.6 469.2 13.5 9,170.1
Temporarily
Used Land 550.2 245.1 215.2 14.9 50.1 24.9 39.4 237.1 78.9 48.9 1.4 955.9
Altered Permanent 4,170.3 3,109.5 443.7 22.9 439.4 154.8 176.4 1,862.1 1,288.1 2,081.6 587.3 10,165.
County/
District RAP/APD Land
Acquisition Farmland Farm-Pu
rpose
Pond
Farm-Pu
rpose
Woodlan
d
Construc
tion-Purp
ose Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total
Preliminary
Design
8
Temporarily
Used Land 711.3 246.3 374.7 59.5 0.0 30.9 0.0 2,134.6 224.5 1,427.4 242.0 4,739.9
Compari
son RPD-RAP
Permanent -1,108.6 758.4 -1,620.8 -120.4 -41.6 -84.2 -201.4 -412.0 531.5 1,612.4 573.8 995.7
Temporarily
Used Land 161.1 1.1 159.5 44.6 -50.1 6.0 -39.4 1,897.5 145.6 1,378.5 240.6 3,784.0
Total -
Full
Line
RAP
Permanent 18,776.
3 8,362.5 7,343.2 509.8
1,710.
7 850.1 1,343.8 8,088.8 2,691.3 1,669.0 48.1
32,617.
3
Temporarily
Used Land
13,860.
9 6,173.3 5,420.8 376.3
1,262.
9 627.6 992.0 5,971.2 1,986.7 1,232.1 35.5
24,078.
4
Altered
Preliminary
Design
Permanent 17,092.
0 8,325.9 3,250.3
2,031.
1
3,219.
0 265.7 213.2 7,905.8 2,184.3 2,522.3 607.6
30,525.
3
Temporarily
Used Land
13,097.
5 5,262.7 6,144.8 117.3
1,541.
9 30.9 15.8 10,971.4 355.0 2,571.4 264.9
27,276.
0
Comparison between RAP
and DPTL
Permanent -1,684.3 -36.6 -4,092.9 1,521.
3
1,508.
3 -584.4 -1,130.6 -183.0 -507.0 853.3 559.5 -2,092.0
Temporarily
Used Land -763.4 -910.6 724.0 -259.0 279.0 -596.7 -976.2 5,000.2 -1,631.7 1,339.3 229.4 3,197.6
13.4 Identification of Villages/Communities Materially Influenced under APD for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n
Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Townsh
ip/Tow
n
Village/Co
mmunities
Town/
Sub-D
istrict
Village/C
ommunit
ies
Town/
Sub-Di
strict
Added
Villages/C
ommuniti
es
Plai
n
Mo
unta
inou
s
Are
a
Urba
n
Plann
ing
Area
City
Outsk
irts
G
ui
zh
ou
Pr
ov
in
ce
G
ui
ya
ng
Ci
ty
Ba
iy
un
Di
str
ict
Dula
Townshi
p
Dula
Village 0
Dula
Village 0
Black
Stone
Village
√ √
Land of 957
mus
expropriated
and 202
households
removed in
added
involved
districts
Materially
influenced
Duxi
Village √ √
Materially
influenced
N
an
mi
n
Di
str
ict
Yuangu
an
Townshi
p
Youzha
Village
Yuang
uan
Towns
hip
Youzha
Village 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
Houcha
o
Townshi
p
Chaoyang
Village,
Houchao
Village,
Sifanghe
Village
0 Sifanghe
Village 0
Taici
Village √
Adjacent to
Sifanghe
Village, with
land of 17.4
mus
expropriated
and no house
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
demolished
Huaguo
yuan
Sub-Dis
trict
Office
South of
Jingguang
Road ,
South
Section of
Gui'en
0
South of
Jingguan
g Road ,
South
Section
of Gui'en
0
Huaguoyu
an
Communit
y
√
Adjacent to
community of
South Section
of Gui'en, with
45 urban
households
removed, 50
households cut
down from
RAP.
Not
materially
influenced
Shachon
g
Sub-Dis
trict
Yuxi
Village,
Taoyuan
Village and
Yutian
0
Taoyuan
Village,
Yutian
0
Dalishi
Communit
y
√
Not
materially
influenced
Taici
Sub-Dis
trict
Art School
Taici
Sub-D
istrict
Art
School 0 0 Not influenced
Not
materially
influenced
Ergezai
Sub-Dis
trict
Huiyou,
Nanzhan,
Songhua
Ergez
ai
Sub-D
istrict
Huiyou,
Nanzhan,
Songhua
0 0 Not influenced
Not
materially
influenced
Xinggu
anlu
Sub-Di
strict
Xinzai
Communit
y
√
It is planned to
remove 336
households in
the suburb
adjacent to
Taici
Sub-District
Art School
involved in
RAP, with 120
cut down
Not
materially
influenced
Zhunyi
Sub-Di
strict
Wuyanqia
o
Communit
y
√
It is planned to
remove 26
urban
households in
the suburb
adjacent to
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Huiyou
Community,
Ergezai
Sub-District
involved in
RAP, with 50
cut down.
Y
un
ya
n
Di
str
ict
Qianling Gaicha,
Sanqiao 0 0
Sanqiao
Sub-Di
strict
North
Sanqiao
Road
Communit
y
√
It is planned to
remove 78
urban
households in
the suburb
adjacent to
Songhua
Community
involved in
RAP, with 2
added in.
Not
materially
influenced
Ji
ny
an
g
Di
str
ict
Yieya
Townshi
p
(Yinyan
g
Sub-Dis
trict)
Xinzai
Village,
Daguan
Village,
Yangguan
Village
0 Xinzai
Village 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 4 9 19 3 12 3 8
Qi
an
gn
an
Pr
ef
ect
ur
Lo
ng
li
C
ou
nt
y
Gujiao
Town
Guyuan
Village,
Guanyin
Village
0 Guyuan
Village 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
Mazhi
Townshi
p
Xinmin
Village,
Longyun
Village
0 0 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
e
Shuicha
ng
Townshi
p
Shuichang
Village 0
Shuichan
g Village 0
Zhongba
Village √
Adjacent to
Shuichang
Village, with 3
households to
be removed
and mountain
land of 27.89
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Longsha
n Town
Shuiqiao
Village 0 0 0
Dachong
Village √ √
Adjacent to
Shuiqiao
Village,
mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 20.38
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
G
ui
di
ng
C
ou
nt
y
Changm
in Town
Xin'an
Village,
Juibaihu
Village,
Datie
Village,
Gaopo
Village
0 0 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
Yanshan
Town
Xiangshan
Village,
Yongguang
Village,
Leyong
Village
0
Yonggua
ng
Village
0 Yuanshan
Village √ √
Adjacent to
Xiangshan
Village,
mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
unused land of
only 15.29
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan Juizhi
Town
Meng'an
Village,
Wenjiang
Village,
Gucheng
Village
0 Meng'an
Village 0
Tongdang
Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 35 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
D
uy
un
Ci
ty
Daping
Town
Mazai
Village,
Yingpan,
Wuxing
0 0 0 Shanlian √
Adjacent to
Yingpan
Village, with
the line
running across
it and
woodland of
45 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Gantang
Town Bangshui 0 0 0
Lvyinhu
Village √ √
Adjacent to
Bangshui
Village, with
unused land of
22 mus to be
requisitioned)
Not
materially
influenced
Linyin
Village √ √
Adjacent to
Bangshui
Village, with
woodland and
farmland both
in small
amount to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Xiaowei
zai
Sub-Dis
trict
Shajing
Street,
Mawei
0 0 0 Cha'nong √
Adjacent to
Mawei
Village, with
woodland in
small amount
(1.95 mus) to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Sa
nd
u
C
ou
nt
y
Pu'an
Town
Putun
Village,
Pinghe
Village
0 Pinghe
Village 0
Jialan √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 1.39 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Chongyan
g Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 8.94 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Dayu
Townshi
p
Laishu
Village,
Heba
Village,
Yanlao
Village
0 Yanlao
Village 0 0 No variation
Not
materially
influenced
Jiaoli
Townshi
p
Qianjin
Village,
Paiyue
Village,
Wangjie
Village,
Paidai
Village,
Yangdong
Village,
Liangjia
Village
0
Paiyue,
Wangjie,
Yangdon
g Village,
Liangjia
Village
Gaotun
Village √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 8.94 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yangsuo
Village √
With one
household to
be removed
and woodland
of only 4.29
mus involved
Not
materially
influenced
Dujiang
Town
Dujian
g
Town
0 0 0 Not
influenced
Wubu Wubu 0 0 0 Not
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Townshi
p
Towns
hip
influenced
Shanhe
Town
Xiapai
Town √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 17.58
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yangfu
Townsh
ip
Xiaoxi √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 3.49 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yangjia √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 1.66 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 4 15 33 2 10 2 15
Qi
an
gd
on
gn
an
Pr
ef
ect
ur
e
R
on
gji
an
g
C
ou
nt
y
Pingjian
g
Townshi
p
Balu
Village,
Jiahui
Village,
Yalong
Village,
Guili
Village,
Barui
Village
0 Barui
Village 0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Guzhou
Town
No. 2
Village, 0
No. 2
Village, 0 Yuezai √ √
With land of
95 mus to be
Materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
No. 3
Village,
Gaoxing
Village,
Ma'an
Village,
Lingzhen
Village,
Dabai
Village,
Gaodong
Village,
Sanpan
Village
No. 3
Village,
Gaoxing
Village,
Ma'an
Village,
Lingzhen
Village,
Dabai
Village,
Gaodong
Village,
Sanpan
Village
expropriated
and 3
households to
be removed
Xiaobao √ √
With land of
154 mus to be
expropriated
and 15
households to
be removed
Materially
influenced
Kouzai √ √
With land of
137 mus to be
expropriated
and 1
households to
be removed
Materially
influenced
Sanjiang
Townshi
p
Zenleng
Village,
Qiaoyou
Village,
Lengyi
Village
0 0 0 You'ai
Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated,
land of 4.4
mus to be
expropriated
and 1
households to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
C
on
gji
an
g
C
ou
nt
y
Guando
ng
Town
Layang
Village,
Guandong
Village
Guand
ong
Town
Layang
Village,
Guandon
g Village
0 0 Not
influenced
Wangdo
ng
Townshi
p
Wujia
Village 0
Wujia
Village 0 Chaoli √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 5 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan Deqiao √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 17 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Zengying √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 3.4 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Guping
Townshi
p
Gudong
Village 0
Gudong
Village 0
Bangtu √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated,
woodland of
only 22 mus to
be
requisitioned
and 1
household to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
Nongpeng √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 4 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Gaozhe
ng
Townshi
p
Xiaohang
Village
Gaozh
eng
Towns
hip
Xiaohang
Village 0 0
Not
influenced
Qingyun
Townshi
Depan
Village
Qingy
un
Depan
Village 0 0
Not
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
p Towns
hip
Luoxian
g
Townshi
p
Datuan
Village 0
Datuan
Village 0
Luoxiang √
Adjacent to
Datuan
Village, with
woodland of
40 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Dengshuan
g √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 15 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yanzai √
Adjacent to
Datuan
Village, with
woodland of
44 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Li
pi
ng
C
ou
nt
y
Shuangj
iang
Townshi
p
Guimi
Village,
Huanggang
Village
0
Guimi
Village,
Huangga
ng
Village
0
Yiyue √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 7.6 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Sizai √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 4.62 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Zhaoxin
g
Zhaoxing
Village, 0
Yilin
Village 0 Censuo √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Townshi
p
Yilin
Village
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.61 mu
to be
requisitioned
influenced
Dengjiang √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.91 mu
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Guima √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 3.63 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Jitang √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 4.94 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Shangzai √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.51 mu
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Long'e
Townshi
p
Pingjin
Village,
Guibai
Village,
0
Guibai
Village,
Gaoqing
Village
0 Meigeng √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Gaoqing
Village
only 1.43 mus
to be
requisitioned
Shang'e √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 7.06 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 3 12 30 3 21 0 21
Total 11 36 82 8 43 5 44
G
ua
ng
xi
Li
uz
ho
u
Ci
ty
Sa
nji
an
g
D
on
g
A
ut
on
o
m
ou
s
C
ou
nt
y
Tongle
Guidong,
Cenjia,
Tongle,
Gaopei,
Jingdai
0
Cenjia
Village,
Jingdai
Village
0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Cheng
Village
Cheng
Village 0
Cheng
Village 0 Sili √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 17.42
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Liangko
u
Heli,
Nanzai,
Gunliang
0 Nanzai
Village 0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Gaoji
Gaoji,
Jiangkou,
Gongjiang,
Tongye
0 Tongye 0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Guyi Silian,
Maping 0 0 0 0
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 4.5 mus
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
to be
requisitioned.
Doujian
g Town
Baiyan √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 13.5 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Fuping √ √
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 1 5 15 0 5 1 3
G
uil
in
Ci
ty
Lo
ng
sh
en
g
C
ou
nt
y
Sanmenj
ie
Townshi
p
Tandi
Village,
Shuangjian
g Village
0 Tandi
Village 0
Tonglie
Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 34.4 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Daluo
Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 7 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Li
ng
ui
C
ou
nt
y
Huangs
ha
Townshi
p
Weiling
Village 0
Weiling
Village 0 Huangsha √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.38 mu
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Wutong
Town
Wutong,
Datang, 0 0 0 Bu'e √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Xishan,
Tongshan,
Shanyou
excavated and
woodland of
only 15.33
mus to be
requisitioned
influenced
Renhe √
Adjacent to
Datang
Village, with
woodland of
only 6 to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Sijiang √
Adjacent to
Tongshan
Village, with
woodland of
only 0.09 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Xinan √ √
Adjacent to
Tongshan
Village, with
woodland of
only 6.10 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Xunjiang √ √
Adjacent to
Tongshan
Village, with
woodland of
only 16.16
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Lingui
Town
Qilin,
Tianhua,
Shatang,
Tashan,
Fenghuang,
0
Shatang,
Tashan,
Fenghuan
g,
Lingshan
0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Lingshan
Li
ng
ch
ua
n
C
ou
nt
y
Dingjian
g
Dingjiang,
Fayuan,
Baolu
0 Baolu
Village 0
Daoguang √
Adjacent to
Dingjiang
Village, with
land of only
15 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Lijia √
Adjacent to
Baolu Village,
with land of
only 9 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Lingchu
an
Babachang,
Damian,
Shuangzho
u, Wangjia
0 Babachan
g 0
Shuangtan √
Adjacent to
Damian
Village, with
woodland of
only 2.3 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Hejiapu √
Adjacent to
Wangjia
Village, with
farmland of
only 6 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Lingtian Lishui,
Lingtian 0
Lishui
Village,
Lingtian
Village
0 Hushan √
Adjacent to
Lishui Village,
with woodland
of only 33 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Jiangnan √ Adjacent to Not
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Lishui Village,
with woodland
of only 17 mus
to be
requisitioned.
materially
influenced
Liu
Village √
Adjacent to
Lingtian
Village, with
woodland of
only 18 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Dating √
Adjacent to
Lingtian
Village, with
orchard of 2
mus to be
requisitioned
and 1
household to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Dawei
Nanji,
Xiong
Village,
Xiazhang,
Yuanjia
0
Xiong
Village,
Xiazhang
, Yuanjia
0
Huilong √
Adjacent to
Nanji Village,
with land of
only 14 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Xima √
Adjacent to
Xiong Village,
with
uncultivated
land of only
23 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Jiansha √
Adjacent to
Xiong Village,
with land of
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
11 mus to be
requisitioned
and 3
households to
be removed
Fulian √
Adjacent to
Yuanjia
Village, with
woodland of
44 mus to be
requisitioned
and 4
households to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
Shanglongt
ang √
Adjacent to
Xiazhang
Village, with
woodland of
only 32 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Chaotia
n
Liu Village,
Zhatou,
Shenjing,
Wangtang,
Nanwei
0
Liu
Village,
Nanwei
Village
0
Dantang √
Adjacent to
Liu Village,
with woodland
of only 3.5
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Chaotian √
Adjacent to
Zhatou
Village, with
woodland of
21 mus to be
requisitioned
and 6
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Fuzu √ √ Mainly with Not
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 8 mus to
be
requisitioned
materially
influenced
Taiping √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.9 mu to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Dashankou √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 10 mus to
be
requisitioned,
and 1 hut to be
removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Y
an
gs
uo
C
ou
nt
y
Yangdi
Townshi
p
Langzhou
Village,
Xiataoyuan
Village,
Huilong
Village
Yangd
i
Towns
hip
Langzhou
Village,
Xiataoyu
an
Village,
Huilong
Village
0 0 Not
influenced
Xingpin
g Town
Xiangfengc
hang
Village
0
Xiangfen
gchang
Village
0 Dayuan √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated,
land of 13.88
mus to be
expropriated
and 2
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan Sidi
Village √
With a station
to be built, and
therefor land
of 450 mus to
be
expropriated
and 61
households to
be removed
Materially
influenced
Baishandi √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 34.8 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
G
on
gc
he
ng
Y
ao
A
ut
on
o
m
ou
s
C
ou
nt
y
Ping'an
Townshi
p
Qiaotou
Village,
Beixi
Village
0 0 Lukou √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 21.9 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Lianhua
Town
Dongke
Village,
Yangmei
Village,
Longwei
Village,
Huangniga
ng Village
0
Longwei,
Huangnig
ang
0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Gongch
eng
Town
Menlou
Village,
Mengjia
Village,
Zhoutang
Village,
Jiangbei
0 0 0 Mantang √
Adjacent to
Menlou
Village, with
woodland of
only 21 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Village
Xiling
Townshi
p
Bayan
Village,
Xiasong
Village,
Xinhe
Village
0 0 0 Wagou
Village √
Adjacent to
Bayan Village,
with dry farm
of 11.9 mus to
be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
0 0
Sanjian
g
Townsh
ip
Xijiaoling √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 14.18
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 5 15 49 1 21 1 33
He
zh
ou
Ci
ty
Zh
on
gs
ha
n
C
ou
nt
y
Liang'an
Yao
Townshi
p
Shanlian
Village 0 0 0
Liang'an √
Adjacent to
Shanlian
Village, with
woodland of
26 mus to be
requisitioned
and 10
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Shaping √
Adjacent to
Shanlian
Village, with
land of 11 mus
to be
requisitioned
and 2
households to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan Xingzai √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 18.6 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Honghu
a Town
Tongpan
Village,
Gulou
Village,
Taojia
Village
0 0 0 0 No
variation
Zhongsh
an Town
Liuyan
Village,
Shengping
Village,
Huping
Village
0 0 0
Wudang √
Adjacent to
Yangyan
Village, with
woodland of
10.5 mus to be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Chaotan √
Adjacent to
Shengping
Village, with
land of 16.38
mus to be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Ba
bu
Di
str
ict
Liantan
g Town
Xinyan
Village,
Luoqiao
Village,
Meiyi
Village,
Guishui
Village
0 0 0 Liantang
Village √
Adjacent to
Fuping
Village, with
unused
wasteland of
16.65 mus to
be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Hejie
Town
Longyang
Village,
Baisha
Village
0 0 0
Daya
√
Adjacent to
Longyang
Village, with
woodland of
76.2 mus to be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Donglian √
Adjacent to
Baisha
Village, with
woodland of
43.86 mus to
be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Liandong √
Adjacent to
Longyang
Village, with
woodland of
20.8 mus to be
requisitioned
and 1 hut to be
removed
Not
materially
influenced
Nongchan
g √
Adjacent to
Baisha
Village, with
woodland of
41.3 mus to be
requisitioned
only
Not
materially
influenced
Shoufeng √
Adjacent to
Baisha
Village, with
woodland of
15.12 mus to
be
requisitioned
only.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan shuangrui √
Adjacent to
Longyang
Village, with
woodland of
24.37 mus to
be
requisitioned
only.
Not
materially
influenced
Xinping √
Adjacent to
Longyang
Village, with
woodland of
17.2 mus to be
requisitioned
only.
Not
materially
influenced
Butou
Town
Datang
Village,
Xiangshi
Village,
Rongmu
Village
0 0 0 0 No
variation
Pi
ng
gu
i
Di
str
ict
Huangti
an
Townshi
p
Youmayan
Village 0
Youmaya
n Village 0
Anshan √
With land of
2.59 mus to be
expropriated
and 3
households to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
Changlong √
Adjacent to
Youmayan
Village, with
woodland of 7
mus to be
requisitioned
and 5
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Huangtian √
Adjacent to
Youmayan
Village, with
woodland of 7
mus to be
requisitioned
and 2
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Li'ning √
Adjacent to
Youmayan
Village, with
woodland of
3.15 mus to be
requisitioned
only.
Not
materially
influenced
Gonghe √
With
woodland of
only 1.94 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yingshi √
With
woodland of
only 7.77 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
0 0 0 0
Xiwan
Sub-Di
strict
Shangsong √
With farmland
of only 8.31
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Feima √
With land of
39.8 mus to be
expropriated
and 6
households to
be removed
Not
materially
influenced
Xiwan √ With land of Not
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
34.93 mus to
be
expropriated
materially
influenced
Yangto
u Town
Leishi √
With
woodland of
only 8.66 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Dongshi √
With
woodland of
only 2.2 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Songmu √
With
woodland of
only 1.18 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Jinzhu √
With only
paddy field of
0.22 mu to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Wangg
ao
Town
Qingchi √
With
woodland of
only 16.66
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Baifu √
With only
uncultivated
land of 79.98
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 3 7 17 0 1 3 28
Total 9 27 81 1 27 5 64
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
G
ua
ng
do
ng
Pr
ov
in
ce
Zh
ao
qi
ng
Ci
ty
H
ua
iji
C
ou
nt
y
Ma'ning
Town
Ma'ning,
Tanbo,
Zhuguang
0 0 0
Zai Village √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 16.9 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Jinqun √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 25.7 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Susha √
Adjacent to
Ma'ning
Village, with
land of only
17.57 mus to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yaotang √
Adjacent to
Ma'ning
Village, with
woodland of
only 63 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Tangguang √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 0.195 mu
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Lanzhon
g
Shangzhu,
Xiazhu, Shangzhu 0 0
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Townshi
p
Shaping influenced
Guangpi
ng
Town
Wei'an,
Muyuan
Guang
ping
Town
Wei'an,
Muyuan 0 0
Not
influenced
Lengken
g Town
Hongsheng,
Jinwu,
Gangshan,
Zhongchen
g
0
Gangshan
,
Zhongche
ng
0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Liangch
un
Town
Lanma,
Sha'ning 0 0 0
Shi'ai √
Adjacent to
Sha'ning
Village,
mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated, and
woodland of
only 12.08
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yonghong √
Adjacent to
Lanma
Village, with
woodland of
only 32.9 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Shatian √
Adjacent to
Sha'ning
Village,
mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated, and
woodland of
only 8 and to
be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Huaiche
ng
Town
Gaofeng,
Huaigao 0
Huaigao
Village 0
Meitian √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 13.6 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yigang √
Adjacent to
Huaigao
Village, with
woodland of
only 44.46
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Huanggan
g √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 5.7 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Changlong √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 16.9 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Meishi √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 9.2 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Mulan √ Adjacent to
Gaofeng
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Village, with
land of 23.86
mus to be
requisitioned
influenced
Panbu √
Adjacent to
Gaofeng
Village, with
wasteland of
13.7 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Xingfu √
Adjacent to
Gaofeng
Village, with
land of 22.45
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Aozai
Town
Aozai,
Xianxi 0
Xianxi
Village 0
Luoda √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 5.8 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Fengheng √
Adjacent to
Xianxi
Village, with
land of 6 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Shangdong √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 19.7 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Zhagua
ng
Town
Jiaoji √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 6.32 mus
to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
G
ua
ng
ni
ng
C
ou
nt
y
Gushui
Town Dapan 0 0 0
Nuiqi √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 1.99 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Mengkeng √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 28.5 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Guidong √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 3.14 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Xiabang √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 10.44
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Nanjie
Town Chengnan 0 0 0 Xiaojing √
Adjacent to
Chengnan
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Village, with
woodland of
32 mus to be
requisitioned.
influenced
Shouyue √
Adjacent to
Chengnan
Village, with
woodland of
33.7 mus to be
requisitioned
and 3
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Shijian
Town
Hengjing,
Shijian,
Renshangli
Shijian,
Renshang
li
0 0
Not
materially
influenced
Paisha
Town Fuluo 0 0 0 0
No
variation
Binheng
Town Daidong 0 Daidong 0
Luowen √
Adjacent to
Daidong
Village, with
woodland of
only 36.1 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Jiangxi √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 15.82 mu
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Siwan √
Adjacent to
Daidong
Village, with
woodland of
only 4.25 mus
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
to be
requisitioned.
Hengsh
an
Town
Lidong √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 20.31 mu
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Si
hu
i
Ci
ty
Huangti
an Town
Wandong,
Xi'an,
Yanlang,
Lilang
0
Wangdon
g Village,
Xi'an
Village
0 Daixia √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 4.86 mu
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Shigou
Town
Shigou,
Cheng
Village
0 0 0 0 No
variation
Zhensha
n
Sub-Dis
trict
Kengkou,
Longtou 0
Kengkou
Village 0
Longtou √
Adjacent to
Kengkou
Village, with
land of only
20.76 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Jinxing √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
only 3.38 mus
to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Di
ng
hu
Di
Lianhua
Town Buji 0 0 0 Fulang √ √
Mainly with
tunnels to be
excavated and
woodland of
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
str
ict
only 13 mus to
be
requisitioned.
Yong'an
Town
Changbei,
Changnan 0
Changbei
,
Changna
n
0
Shuangbu √
Adjacent to
Changnan
Village, with
land of only
10 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Wunan √
Adjacent to
Changnan
Village, with
land of only 6
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Beishui √
Adjacent to
Changnan
Village, with
land of only
12.3 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Xin
Village √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only 3
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Dashe √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only
20 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Qizhou √
Only
infrastructure
involved
(removal and
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
reconstruction
of electrical
cable lines)
Sigu √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only 7
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Jiangxi √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only 2
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Fuchao √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only
30 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Dalang √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only
11 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Guixi √
Adjacent to
Changbei
village, with
land of only
24 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 4 17 36 1 15 2 45
Fo
sh
Sa
ns
Xinan
Sub-Dis
Qingqi,
Jianggen, 0 0 0 0
No
variation
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
an
Ci
ty
hu
i
Di
str
ict
trict Zhoubian
N
an
ha
i
Di
str
ict
Danzha
o Town
Xinnong,
Xilian, He
Village
0 0 0 0 No
variation
Shishan
Town
Baisha,
Xiaotang,
Xinjing
0 Baisha 0 Zhaoda √
Adjacent to
Baisha
Village, with
land of 12 mus
to be
requisitioned
and 2
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Dali
Town
Hengguang
, Caobian,
Shuitou,
Xiebian,
Tanbian,
Hexi,
Dongxiu
0
Henggua
ng,
Caobian,
Xiebian
0
Zhongbian √
Adjacent to
Tanbian
Village, with
land of 27 mus
to be
requisitioned
and 5
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Dazhen √
Adjacent to
Hengguang
Village, with
land of 15 mus
to be
requisitioned
and 3
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Taiping √ Adjacent to
Hexi Village,
Not
materially
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
with land of
14 mus to be
requisitioned
and 5
households to
be removed.
influenced
Qicha √
Adjacent to
Dongxiu
village, with
land of only
21 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Lian'an √
Adjacent to
Xiebian
village, with
land of only 3
mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Yanbu √
Adjacent to
Shuitou
Village, with
land of only
5.5 mus to be
requisitioned
Not
materially
influenced
Hedong √
Adjacent to
Hexi Village,
with land of 8
mus to be
requisitioned
and 1
households to
be removed.
Not
materially
influenced
Huangqi √
Adjacent to
Caobian
village, with
land of only 3
mus to be
Not
materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
requisitioned.
Guichen
g
Sub-Dis
trict
Zhongqu,
Linyue 0
Zhongqu,
Linyue 0
Yongyuan √
Adjacent to
Zhongqu
Community,
with land of 5
mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
Xintiandi √
Adjacent to
Linyue
Community,
with land of
22 mus to be
requisitioned.
Not
materially
influenced
To
tal 2 5 18 0 6 0 11
G
ua
ng
zh
ou
Ci
ty
Fa
ny
u
Di
str
ict
Zhongc
hun
Town
Weiyong,
Shengshi
Zhong
chun
Town
Weiyong,
Shengshi 0 0
Not
influenced
Shibi
Sub-Di
strict
Shibi No.
2 √
With land of
96 mus to be
requisitioned
in added
involved areas.
Materially
influenced
Li
w
an
Di
str
ict
Zhongn
an
Sub-Di
strict
Hainan √
Land of
216.73 mus to
be
expropriated
and 6
households to
be removed in
added
involved areas.
Materially
influenced
Hailong
Sub-Di
strict
Zengjiao √
With 2
enterprises to
be removed in
added areas.
Materially
influenced
Pr
ov
in
ce
Ci
ty
C
ou
nt
y/
Di
st
ri
ct
Involved Villages Added Identifiers in Coverage of Influence
Influence
Identification
Verificatio
n Original Migration
Plan
Canceled Town/
Village under
APD
Added Town/
Village under APD
Mai
n
Pass
ing
Tun
nel
Same Socio-Eco District as in
Original Coverage
Differ
ent
Socio-
Eco
Distri
ct
Statio
n,
Subgr
ade
and
other
Conce
ntrati
ve
Land
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Appli
cable
Comp
ensati
on
Polici
es
N
at
io
n
al
M
in
o
ri
ty
D
is
tr
ic
t
Signif
icant
Chan
ge to
Resett
lemen
t Plan
Y
ue
xi
u
Di
str
ict
Kuangq
uan
Sub-Di
strict
Yaotai
Village √
Land of 3 mus
expropriated
and 308
households
removed in
added
involved
districts
Materially
influenced
To
tal 3 1 2 1 2 4 4
Total 9 23 56 2 23 6 60
Total -
Full
Line
29 86 219 11 93 16 168
13.5 Statistics on Building Demolition Comparison between APD and RAP for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Guiyang City Baiyun District RAP 30,394.0 18,996.0 4,863.0 3,951.0 2,583.0 19,300.0 1,216.0 25,075.0 75,985.0
Altered Preliminary 84,665.0 81,926.7 2,738.3
84,665.0
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Design
Nanmin District
RAP 31,849.0 #DIV/0 5,096.0 4,140.0 2,707.0 20,177.0 1,271.0 26,215.0 79,512.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 116,057.8
203,226.
7
Yunyan District
RAP 20,723.0 12,952.0 3,316.0 2,694.0 1,761.0 13,159.0 829.0 253,871.2 288,582.
2
Altered Preliminary
Design 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
High-Tech Zone
RAP 55,262.0 34,539.0 8,841.0 7,184.0 4,698.0 35,091.0 2,210.0 45,591.0 138,154.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Total - Guiyang
RAP 138,228.
0 86,394.0 22,115.0 17,969.0
11,749.
0 87,727.0 5,526.0 113,978.0
345,459.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design
150,705.
6 132,728.4 8,123.6 456.8 9,396.7 66,766.3 0.0 118,823.8
336,295.
6
Qiangnan Prefecture
Longli County
RAP 31,240.0 19,523.0 4,997.0 4,061.0 2,655.0 19,823.0 1,249.0 25,755.0 78,067.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 11,072.0 3,985.9 3,764.5 3,321.6 17,867.0 28,939.0
Guiding County
RAP 14,266.0 8,916.0 2,281.0 1,854.0 1,212.0 9,050.0 570.0 11,758.0 35,644.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 7,793.7 2,401.5 3,573.6 1,245.3 573.3 1,820.0 9,613.7
Duyun City RAP 0.0
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Altered Preliminary
Design 67,831.3 24,383.1 15,714.9 27,733.3 1,143.3 68,974.6
Sandu County
RAP 22,420.0 14,012.0 3,587.0 2,916.0 1,905.0 14,221.0 896.0 18,476.0 56,013.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 6,031.9 1,913.5 12,478.0 20,423.4
Total - Qiangnan
Prefecture
RAP 67,926.0 42,451.0 10,865.0 8,831.0 5,772.0 43,094.0 2,715.0 55,989.0 169,724.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 92,728.9 30,770.5 23,053.0 28,978.6 3,894.9 21,600.5 13,621.3 0.0
127,950.
7
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Rongjiang County
RAP 17,153.0 10,719.0 2,743.0 2,230.0 1,457.0 10,851.0 684.0 14,097.0 42,785.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 13,507.1 4,928.1 637.9 5,068.7 2,872.5 -3,562.0 17,069.1
Congjiang County
RAP 11,283.0 7,052.0 1,804.0 1,465.0 959.0 7,157.0 451.0 9,298.0 28,189.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 9,116.5 1,635.0 5,832.2 817.6 831.2 2,000.0 100.0 11,216.5
Liping County
RAP 8,001.0 5,000.0 1,280.0 1,041.0 680.0 5,079.0 320.0 6,599.0 19,999.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 0.0
Total - Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
RAP 36,437.0 22,771.0 5,827.0 4,736.0 3,096.0 23,087.0 1,454.0 29,994.0 90,972.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 22,623.6 6,563.1 6,470.1 5,886.3 3,703.7 5,562.0 100.0 0.0 28,285.6
Total - GuiZhou RAP 242,591.
0 151,616.0 38,807.0 31,536.0
20,617.
0 153,908.0 9,696.0 199,961.0
606,156.
0
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Altered Preliminary
Design
266,058.
1 170,062.0 37,646.7 35,321.7
16,995.
3 93,928.8 13,721.3 118,823.8
492,531.
9
Comparison RPD-RAP 23,467.1 18,446.0 -2960.3 3,785.7 -3,621.
7 -59,979.2 4,025.3 -81,137.2
-113,624.
1
Liuzhou City Sanjiang Dong
Autonomous County
RAP 30,028.0 18,766.0 4,805.0 3,903.0 2,552.0 19,158.0 1,207.0 24,890.0 75,283.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 7,437.6 653.8 857.4 4,154.4 1,772.0 7,437.6
Guilin City
Longsheng County
RAP 5,091.0 3,182.0 815.0 662.0 433.0 3,233.0 204.0 4,200.0 12,728.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 4,073.7 95.2 3,978.5 4,073.7
Lingui County
RAP 14,210.0 8,882.0 2,273.0 1,848.0 1,207.0 9,052.0 570.0 11,760.0 35,592.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 8,593.6 1,194.7 4,120.3 380.9 2,897.7 8,593.6
Lingchuan County
RAP 58,018.0 36,260.0 9,282.0 7,543.0 4,932.0 36,855.0 2,322.0 47,882.0 145,077.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 47,041.2 13,085.8 22,123.2 1,214.8
10,617.
5 19,205.3 66,246.5
Yangsuo County
RAP 9,128.0 5,705.0 1,461.0 1,187.0 776.0 5,819.0 367.0 7,560.0 22,874.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 39,130.0 16,430.0 8,850.0 7,900.0 5,950.0 86,000.0 0.0
125,130.
0
Gongcheng County
RAP 15,313.0 9,571.0 2,452.0 1,991.0 1,302.0 9,699.0 611.0 12,600.0 38,223.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 12,508.9 4,777.3 7,712.9 18.7 1,420.5 13,929.5
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Total - Guilin
RAP 101,760.
0 63,600.0 16,283.0 13,231.0 8,650.0 64,658.0 4,074.0 84,002.0
254,494.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design
111,347.
4 35,487.8 42,901.6 13,474.2
19,483.
9 106,625.9 0.0 0.0
217,973.
3
Hezhou City
Zhongshan County
RAP 22,527.0 14,079.0 3,605.0 2,927.0 1,916.0 14,368.0 905.0 18,667.0 56,467.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 50,470.6 15,561.7 28,465.6 929.8 5,513.6 833.0 51,303.6
Downtown of Hezhou
City
RAP 33,941.0 21,213.0 5,431.0 4,412.0 2,885.0 21,552.0 1,358.0 28,002.0 84,853.0
Altered Preliminary
Design
150,791.
8 61,209.5 26,588.0 34,877.8
28,116.
5 0.0 3,621.0 0.0
154,412.
8
Total - Hezhou
RAP 56,468.0 35,292.0 9,036.0 7,339.0 4,801.0 35,920.0 2,263.0 46,669.0 141,320.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 201,262 76,771 55,054 35,808 33,630 0 4,454 0 205,716
Total - Guangxi
RAP 188,256.
0 117,658.0 30,124.0 24,473.0
16,003.
0 119,736.0 7,544.0 155,561.0
471,097.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design
320,047.
5 112,912.8 98,812.6 53,436.1
54,885.
9 106,625.9 4,454.0 0.0
431,127.
4
Comparison RPD-RAP 131,791.
5 -4,745.2 68,688.6 28,963.1
38,882.
9 -13,110.1 -3,090.0 -155,561.0 -39,969.6
Zhaoqing City Huaiji County
RAP 20,858.0 13,036.0 3,339.0 2,711.0 1,770.0 13,232.0 833.0 4,390.0 39,313.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 61,377.6 31,754.4 7,075.4 11,335.0
11,212.
8 61,377.6
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Guangning County
RAP 36,111.0 22,571.0 5,778.0 4,694.0 3,069.0 22,981.0 1,448.0 29,857.0 90,397.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 25,650.7 16,018.0 7,450.7 2,182.0 2,603.6 5,094.7 33,349.0
Sihui City
RAP 19,740.0 12,338.0 3,158.0 2,566.0 1,678.0 12,535.0 790.0 16,286.0 49,351.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 4,071.7 2,602.2 1,424.5 45.0 7,923.6 11,995.3
Dinghu District
RAP 23,031.0 14,394.0 3,685.0 2,994.0 1,958.0 14,624.0 921.0 38,576.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 7,928.0 3,000.0 4,928.0 4,500.0 12,428.0
Total - Zhaoqing
RAP 99,740.0 62,339.0 15,960.0 12,965.0 8,475.0 63,372.0 3,992.0 69,533.0 236,637.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 99,028.0 53,374.6 20,878.6 11,335.0
13,439.
8 15,027.2 5,094.7 0.0
119,149.
9
Foshan City
Sanshui District
RAP 12,337.0 7,711.0 1,975.0 1,604.0 1,048.0 7,834.0 494.0 10,178.0 30,843.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 20,550.0 20,550.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2,999.0 1,481.0 0.0 25,030.0
Nanhai District
RAP 90,039.0 56,274.0 14,407.0 11,704.0 7,654.0 57,453.0 3,619.0 151,111.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 90,290.1 77,843.8 8,634.7 689.2 3,122.5 78,863.1 0.0 0.0
169,153.
3
Total - Foshan RAP
102,376.
0 63,985.0 16,382.0 13,308.0 8,702.0 65,287.0 4,113.0 84,822.0
256,598.
0
Altered Preliminary 110,840. 98,393.8 8,634.7 689.2 3,122.5 81,862.1 1,481.0 0.0 194,183.
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Design 1 3
Guangzhou City
Fanyu District
RAP 130,231.
0 81,395.0 20,837.0 16,930.0
11,070.
0 82,697.0 5,209.0 107,441.0
325,578.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 0.0 0.0
Liwan District
RAP 0.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 0.0 13,236.5
Yuexiu District
RAP 0.0
Altered Preliminary
Design 0.0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 41,898.0 41,898.0
Subtotal -Guangzhou
RAP 130,231.
0 81,395.0 20,837.0 16,930.0
11,070.
0 82,697.0 5,209.0 107,441.0
325,578.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Subtotal - Guangdong
RAP 332,347.
0 207,719.0 53,179.0 43,203.0
28,247.
0 211,356.0 13,314.0 261,795.0
818,812.
0
Altered Preliminary
Design
210,259.
3 152,031.2 29,607.9 12,035.5
16,584.
7 109,734.6 6,575.7 41,898.0
368,467.
6
Comparison RPD-RAP -122,08
7.7 -55,687.8 -23,571.1 -31,167.5
-11,662
.3 -101,621.4 -6,738.3 -219,897.0
-450,344.
4
Total - Full Line RAP 763,194.
0 476,993.0 122,110.0 99,212.0
64,867.
0 485,000.0 30,554.0 617,317.0
1,896,06
5.0
City County/District RAP/APD
Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise
Buildings
School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Br
ick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-Wo
od
Primiti
ve
Altered Preliminary
Design
796,364.
9 435,006.0 166,067.2
100,793.
3
88,465.
9 310,289.3 24,751.0 160,721.8
1,292,12
7.0
COMPARISON BETWEEN RAP AND DPTL 33,170.9 -41,987.0 43,957.2 1,581.3 23,598.
9 -174,710.7 -5,803.0 -456,595.2
-603,938.
0
13.6 Progress in Land expropriation under APD For Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Baiyu
n
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
757.0 6.0 28.0 723.0 0.0 0.0
200.0
0.0
957.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Nan
min
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6.9 0.00 0.00 6.94 0.0 0.0
24.2 34.9 0.0
66.1
Progress in 6.94 0 0 6.94 0
0.0 24.2 34.9 0.0 0.0 66.1
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Yuny
an
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
77.5 0.00 0.00 77.47 0.0 0.0
111.3 2.1 0.6
191.5
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
77.5 0.00 0.00 77.47 0.0
0.0 111.3 2.1 0.6 0.0 191.5
Progress% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.5% 0.0% 100.0%
Jinya
ng
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
980.0 284.57 695.46 0.00 0.0
16.1
996.1
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
980.0 284.57 695.46 0.00 0.0
16.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 996.1
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Subto
tal -
Guiy
ang
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,821.5 290.6 723.5 807.4 0.0 0.0 16.1 335.5 37.1 0.6 0.0 2,210.7
Progress in 1,064 285 695 84 0 0 16 136 37 1 0 1,254
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 58.4% 97.9% 96.1% 10.5% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 40.4% 100.0% 100.5% 0.0% 56.7%
Longl
i
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
290.7 173.9 113.4 0.0 0.9 2.5
508.3 112.8 21.4
933.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
270.4 170.0 100.4 0.0 0.0
0.0 470.0 112.8 0.0 0.0 853.2
Progress% 93.0% 97.8% 88.5%
0.0% 0.0%
92.5% 100.0% 0.0%
91.4%
Guidi
ng
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
411.7 215.44 196.21 0.00
269.2 1.9 8.8
691.5
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
411.7 215.44 196.21 0.00 0.0
0.0 269.2 1.9 14.4 0.0 697.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 164.2% 0.0% 100.8%
Duyu
n
City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,027.4 583.7 414.7 0.0 25.1 3.8
400.5 45.3 18.9
1,492.0
Progress in 1,027.4 583.7 414.7 0.0 25.1 3.8
400.5 45.3 18.9
1,492.0
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Sand
u
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
259.0 178.0 60.1 0.0 16.3 4.7
145.1 12.1 0.0
416.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
259.0 178.0 60.1 0.0 16.3 4.7
145.1 12.1 0.0
416.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
%
100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0% 100.0%
100.0%
Subto
tal -
Qian
gnan
Prefe
cture
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,988.7 1,151.0 784.4 0.0 42.3 11.0 0.0 1,323.0 172.1 49.1 0.0 3,533.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,968 1,147 771 0 41 9 0 1,285 172 33 0 3,459
Progress% 99.0% 99.7% 98.3% 0.0% 97.9% 77.2% 0.0% 97.1% 100.0% 67.9% 0.0% 97.9%
Rong
jiang
Coun
Altered
Preliminary
Design
482.5 403.0 38.5 0.0 41.1 0.0 0.0 265.9 20.9 10.2 18.1 797.6
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
ty Progress in
Land
Acquisition
413.1 350.0 22.0 0.0 41.1
0.0 265.9 20.9 0.0 0.0 699.9
Progress% 85.6% 86.9% 57.2%
100.1
% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 87.8%
Cong
jiang
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
207.6 164.8 13.4 0.0 22.3 7.1
324.2 61.3 1.0
594.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
207.6 164.8 13.4 0.0 22.3 7.1
324.2 61.3 1.0
594.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Lipin
g
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
156.8 133.1 21.5 0.0 0.0 2.2
38.8 0.0 0.0
195.6
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
156.8 133.1 21.5 0.0 0.0 2.2
38.8 0.0 0.0
195.6
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Sub-t Altered 847.0 700.9 73.4 0.0 63.4 9.3 0.0 628.9 82.2 11.2 18.1 1,587.4
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
otal -
Qian
gdon
gnan
Prefe
cture
Preliminary
Design
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
778 648 57 0 63.4 9 0 629 82 1 0 1,490
Progress% 91.8% 92.4% 77.5% 0.0% 100.1
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 8.9% 0.0% 93.8%
Total
-
GuiZ
hou
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,657.2 2,142.4 1,581.3 807.4 105.7 20.3 16.1 2,287.4 291.4 60.8 18.1 7,331.1
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
3,810 2,080 1,524 84 105 18 16 2,049 291 35 0 6,202
Progress% 81.8% 97.1% 96.4% 10.5% 99.2% 87.7% 100.0% 89.6% 100.0% 57.4% 0.0% 84.6%
Liuzh
ou
City
(Sanji
ang
Coun
ty)
Altered
Preliminary
Design
504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9
453.7 5.6 6.6
970.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
504.1 190.9 290.9 0.0 9.4 12.9
453.7 5.6 6.6
970.0
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Long
sheng
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
118.3 48.37 57.94 0.00 12.0
189.7 0.0 7.1
315.1
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
118.3 48.37 57.94 0.00 12.0
0.0 189.7 0.0 7.1 0.0 315.1
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Lingu
i
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
427.6 268.83 28.65 0.7 129.5
947.5 12.7 28.1
1,415.9
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
427.0 268.83 28.65 0.0 129.5
847.0 2.0 28.1 0.0 1,304.0
Progress% 99.8% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 89.4% 16.0% 99.9% 0.0% 92.1%
Lingc
huan
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,781.2 687.6 664.0 1.4 382.3 45.9 0.0 1,080.5 203.9 63.5 0.0 3,129.1
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,733.9 687.6 664.0 0.0 382.3
880.0 203.9 63.5 0.0 2,881.3
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Progress% 97.3% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 81.4% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 92.1%
Yang
suo
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
616.5 34.41 32.21 0.00 549.91 0.00 20.8 77.2
21.0 2.2 737.7
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
616.5 34.41 32.21 0.00 549.91
20.8 77.2 0.0 23.2 0.0 737.7
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 110.3% 0.0% 100.0%
Gong
cheng
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,780.3 62.14 150.32 0.00 1,567.8 0.0 0.0 106.7 70.4 17.9 0.0 1,975.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,780.3 62.14 150.32 0.00 1,567.8 0.0 0.0 106.7 70.4 17.9 0.0 1,975.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Subto
tal -
Guili
n
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,723.9 1101.3 933.2 2.1 2,641.4 45.9 20.8 2,401.5 287.0 137.6 2.2 7,572.9
Progress in 4,676 1,101 933 0 2,641 0 21 2,101 276 140 0 7,213
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 99.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 87.5% 96.3% 101.6% 0.0% 95.3%
Zhon
gshan
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,373.8 903.20 1.18 432.34 5.3 31.8
68.9 157.6
,1600.3
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,373.8 903.20 1.18 432.34 5.3 31.8
68.9 157.6
,1600.3
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0% 100.0%
100.0%
Dow
ntow
n of
Hezh
ou
City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,662.8 878.6 0.0 766.4 17.8 0.0 0.0 832.1 154.5 235.7 0.0 2,885.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,662.8 878.6 0.0 766.4 17.8 0.0 0.0 832.1 154.5 235.7 0.0 2,885.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
% 0.0% 100.0%
100.0
% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Subto
tal -
Altered
Preliminary 3,036.6 1,781.8 1.2 1,198.7 23.1 31.8 0.0 901.0 312.1 235.7 0.0 4,485.5
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Hezh
ou
Design
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
3,037 1,782 1 1,199 23 32 0 901 312 236 0 4,485
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0%
100.0
%
100.0
% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total
-
Guan
gxi
Altered
Preliminary
Design
8,264.5 3,074.0 1,225.3 1,200.8 2,673.9 90.6 20.8 3,756.2 604.8 379.9 2.2 13,028.4
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
8,217 3,074 1,225 1,199 2,674 45 21 3,455 594 379.9 0 12,669
Progress% 99.4% 100.0
%
100.0
% 99.8%
100.0
% 49.4% 100.0% 92.0% 98.2% 100.0% 0.0% 97.2%
Huaij
i
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
701.1 290.7 170.1 0.0 85.5 154.8 176.4 566.1 202.5 974.7 188.2 2,809.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
692.1 281.7 170.1 0.0 85.5 154.8 176.4 540.0 202.5 974.7 188.2 2,773.9
Progress% 98.7% 96.9% 100.0
% #DIV/0!
100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0% 95.4% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 98.8%
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Guan
gning
Coun
ty
Altered
Preliminary
Design
663.2 547.0 22.6 0.0 93.6 0.0 0.0 660.5 38.2 523.8 97.1 1,982.8
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
663.2 547.0 22.6 0.0 93.6
0.0 650.0 38.2 0.0 0.0 1,351.4
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
%
100.0
% 98.4% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 68.2%
Sihui
City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
481.5 351.5 22.1 0.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 370.5 12.6 265.9 180.0 1,310.5
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
424.5 351.5 24.5 0.0 48.6
0.0 370.5 3.0 99.1 0.0 897.1
Progress% 88.2% 100.0
%
110.9
% 45.0%
100.0% 23.7% 37.3% 0.0% 68.5%
Ding
hu
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
771.8 717.60 0.00 9.9 44.3 0.0 0.0 9.0 270.0 97.2 90 1,238.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
746.6 697.34 0.00 0.0 49.2
0.0 9.0 104.2 0.0 0 859.8
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Progress% 96.7% 97.2%
0.0% 111.1
% 100.0% 38.6% 0.0% 0.0% 69.4%
Subto
tal -
Zhao
qing
Altered
Preliminary
Design
2,617.6 1,906.8 214.7 9.9 331.4 154.8 176.4 1,606.1 523.3 1,861.6 555.3 7,340.3
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
2,526 1,878 217 0 277 155 176 1,570 348 1,074 188 5,882
Progress% 96.5% 98.5% 101.1
% 0.0% 83.6%
100.0
% 100.0% 97.7% 66.5% 57.7% 33.9% 80.1%
Sansh
ui
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
510.5 410.50 100.00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 125.0 350.0 70.0 14.7 1,070.2
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
510.5 410.50 100.00 0.0 0.0
0.0 111.9 26.1 0.0 0.0 648.5
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 89.5% 7.4% 0.0% ith 60.6%
Nanh
ai
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
800.0 700.00 100.00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 125.0 350.0 150.0 14.7 1,439.7
Progress in 300.0 400.00 0.00 0.00 0.0
0.0 125.0 350.0 12.7 1.7 789.4
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 37.5% 57.1% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 8.4% 11.5% 54.8%
Subto
tal -
Fosha
n
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,310.5 1,110.5 200.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 250.0 700.0 220.0 29.3 2,509.8
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
811 811 100 0 0 0 0 237 376 13 2 1,438
Progress% 61.8% 73.0% 50.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 94.8% 53.7% 5.8% 5.7% 57.3%
Fany
u
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
51.0 9.0 29.0 13.0
6.0 39.0 0.0
96.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
51.0 9.0 29.0 13.0
6.0 39.0 0.0
96.0
Progress% 100.0% 100.0
%
100.0
% 100.0%
100.0% 100.0%
100.0%
Liwa
n
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
188.2 80.23 0.0 0.0 108.0 0.0 25.8 2.7 216.8
Progress in 128.5 40.23 0.0 0.0 88.3 0.0 0.0 25.8 2.7 157.1
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 68.3% 50.1% 81.8% 0.0% 100.0% 72.5%
Yuex
iu
Distri
ct
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3.0 3.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 3.0
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Subto
tal
-Gua
ngzh
ou
Altered
Preliminary
Design
242.2 92.2 29.0 13.0 108.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 64.8 0.0 2.7 315.8
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
180 49 29 13 88 0 0 6 39 26 3 253
Progress% 74.1% 53.4% 100.0% 100.0% 81.8% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 60.2% 0.0% 100.0% 80.1%
Total
-
Guan
gdon
g
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,170.3 3,109.5 443.7 22.9 439.4 154.8 176.4 1,862.1 1,288.1 2,081.6 587.3 10,165.8
Progress in
Land 3,516.4 2,737.2 346.1 13.0 365.2 154.8 176.4 1,812.5 762.9 1,112.3 192.6 7,573.0
Coun
ty/Di
strict
RAP/APD
Farmland Farm-Pur
pose
Pond
Farm-Pur
pose
Woodlan
d
Construct
ion-Purpo
se Land
Uncultivate
d Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegetab
le Field
Orchar
d Others
Acquisition
Progress% 84.3% 88.0% 78.0% 56.8% 83.1% 100.0% 100.0% 97.3% 59.2% 53.4% 32.8% 74.5%
Total
- Full
Line
Altered
Preliminary
Design
17,092.0 8,325.9 3,250.3 2,031.1 3,219.0 265.7 213.2 7,905.8 2,184.3 2,522.3 607.6 30,525.3
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
15,543.4 7,890.
8
3,095.
2 1,296.1
3,144.
0 217.3 213.2 7,316.8 1,648.5 1,527.1 192.6
26,443.
8
Progress% 90.9% 94.8% 95.2% 63.8% 97.7% 81.8% 100.0% 92.6% 75.5% 60.5% 31.7% 86.6%
13.7 Progress in Building Demolition under APD for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m)
Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences Total
Total Concrete-Brick Brick-Wood Earth-Wood Primitive
Baiyun District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
82,664.96 81,926.7 738.26 0 0 2,000 0 0 84,664.96
Completed 0 0 0 0 0 2,000 0 0 2,000
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 2.4%
Nanmin District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
23,875.95 21,755.58 343 0 1,777.36 63,293 0 116,057.8 203,226.743
Completed 23,875.95 21,755.58 343 0 1,777.36 63,293 0 116,057.8 203,226.75
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Yunyan District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,091.99 3,518.55 116.64 456.8 0 3,473.3 0 2,765.97 10,331.26
Completed 4,091.99 3,518.55 116.64 456.8 0 3,473.3 0 2,765.97 10,331.26
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% #DIV/0! 100.0% 100.0%
High-Tech Zone
Altered
Preliminary
Design
38,072.663 25,527.61 4,925.7 0 7,619.353 0 0 0 38,072.66
Completed 38,072.663 25,527.61 4,925.7 0 7,619.353 0 0 0 38,072.66
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Total - Guiyang Altered
Preliminary 148705.563 132,728.44 6,123.6 456.8 9,396.713 68,766.3 0 118,823.77 336,295.623
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed 66,040.603 50,801.74 5,385.34 456.8 9,396.713 68,766.3 0 118,823.77 253,630.67
Progress% 44.4% 38.3% 87.9% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 75.4%
Longli County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
11,072 3,985.92 3,764.48 3,321.6 17,867 28,939
Completed 10,072 2,985.92 3,764.48 3,321.6 15,867 25,939
Progress% 91.0% 74.9% 100.0% 100.0% 88.8% 89.6%
Guiding County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
7,793.72 2,401.5 3,573.6 1,245.3 573.32 1,820 9,613.72
Completed 7,793.72 2,401.5 3,573.6 1,245.3 573.32 1,820 9,613.72
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Duyun City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
67,831.26 24,383.07 15,714.89 27,733.31 1,143.32 68,974.58
Completed 67,831.26 24,383.07 15,714.89 27,733.31 1,143.32 68,974.58
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Sandu County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6,031.94 2,800 1,024.42 1,898.52 309 1,913.5 12,478 20,423.44
Completed 2,831.94 950 500 1,072.94 309 1,913.5 12,478 17,223.44
Progress% 46.9% 33.9% 48.8% 56.5% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 84.3%
Total - Qiangnan
Prefecture
Altered
Preliminary 92,728.92 33,570.49 24,077.39 30,877.13 4,203.92 21,600.5 13,621.32 0 127,950.74
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed 88,528.92 30,720.49 23,552.97 30,051.55 4,203.92 19,600.5 13,621.32 0 121,750.74
Progress% 95.5% 91.5% 97.8% 97.3% 100.0% 90.7% 100.0% 95.2%
Rongjiang
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
13,507.09 4,928.08 637.87 5,068.68 2,872.46 3,562 17,069.09
Completed 9,641.09 1,062.08 637.87 5,068.68 2,872.46 3,562 13,203.09
Progress% 71.4% 21.6% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 77.4%
Congjiang
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
9,116.49 1,635 5,832.21 817.58 831.2 2,000 100 11,216.49
Completed 9,116.49 1,635 5,832.21 817.58 831.2 2,000 100 11,216.49
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Liping County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
0
Completed
Progress%
Total -
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
Altered
Preliminary
Design
22,623.58 6,563.08 6,470.08 5,886.26 3,703.66 5,562 100 0 28,285.58
Completed 18,757.58 2,697.08 6,470.08 5,886.26 3,703.66 5,562 100 0 24,419.58
Progress% 82.9% 41.1% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 86.3%
Total - GuiZhou Altered
Preliminary 264,058.063 172,862.01 36,671.07 37,220.19 17,304.293 95,928.8 13,721.32 118,823.77 492,531.943
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed 173,327.103 84,219.31 35,408.39 36,394.61 17,304.293 93,928.8 13,721.32 118,823.77 399,800.99
Progress% 65.6% 48.7% 96.6% 97.8% 100.0% 97.9% 100.0% 100.0% 81.2%
Sanjiang Dong
Autonomous
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
7,437.64 653.84 857.44 4,154.38 1,771.98 7,437.64
Completed 7,437.64 653.84 857.44 4,154.38 1,771.98 7,437.64
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Longsheng
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,073.7 95.2 3,978.5 4,073.7
Completed 4,073.7 95.2 3,978.5 4,073.7
Progress% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Lingui County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
8,593.6 1,194.7 4,120.3 380.9 2,897.7 8,593.6
Completed 8,593.6 1,194.7 4,120.3 380.9 2,897.7 8,593.6
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Lingchuan
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
47,041.2 13,085.8 22,123.2 1,214.8 10,617.5 19,205.3 66,246.5
Completed 45,041.15 11,085.76 22,123.17 1,214.77 10,617.45 19,205.3 64,246.45
Progress% 95.7% 84.7% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 97.0%
Yangsuo County Altered
Preliminary 39,130 16,430 8,850 7,900 5,950 86,000 125,130
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Gongcheng
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
12,508.9 4,777.3 7,712.9 18.7 1,420.5 13,929.5
Completed 12,508.9 4,777.3 7,712.92 18.72 1,420.5 13,929.5
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.1% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total - Guilin
Altered
Preliminary
Design
111,347.4 35,487.8 42,901.6 13,474.2 19,483.9 106,625.8 0 0 217,973.2
Completed 70,217.35 17,057.76 34,051.59 5,574.17 13,533.87 20,625.8 0 0 90,843.25
Progress% 63.1% 48.1% 79.4% 41.4% 69.5% 19.3% 0.0% 0.0% 41.7%
Zhongshan
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
50,470.6 15,561.7 28,465.6 929.8 5,513.6 833 51,303.6
Completed 50,470.6 15,561.7 28,465.6 929.8 5,513.6 833 51,303.6
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Downtown of
Hezhou City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
150,791.8 61,209.5 26,588 34,877.8 28,116.5 0 3,621 0 154,412.8
Completed 150,791.8 61,209.5 26,588 34,877.8 28,116.5 0 3,621 0 154,412.8
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total - Hezhou Altered
Preliminary 201,262.4 76,771.2 55,053.6 35,807.6 33,630.1 0 4,454 0 205,716.4
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed 201,262.4 76,771.2 55,053.6 35,807.6 33,630.1 0 4,454 0 205,716.4
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Total - Guangxi
Altered
Preliminary
Design
320,047.44 112,912.84 98,812.64 53,436.18 54,885.98 106,625.8 4,454 0 431,127.24
Completed 278,917.39 94,482.8 89,962.63 45,536.15 48,935.95 20,625.8 4,454 0 303,997.29
Progress% 87.1% 83.7% 91.0% 85.2% 89.2% 19.3% 100.0% 0.0% 70.5%
Huaiji County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
61,377.6 31,754.4 7,075.4 11,335 11,212.8 61,377.6
Completed 61,377.6 31,754.4 7,075.4 11,335 11,212.8 61,377.6
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%
Guangning
County
Altered
Preliminary
Design
25,650.7 16,018 7,450.7 2,182 2,603.6 5,094.7 33,349
Completed 25,650.7 16,018 7,450.7 2,182 0 5,094.7 30,745.4
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0% 92.2%
Sihui City
Altered
Preliminary
Design
4,071.7 2,602.2 1,424.5 45 7,923.6 11,995.3
Completed 4,071.7 2,602.2 1,424.5 45 5,500 9,571.7
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 100.0% 69.4% 0.0% 0.0% 79.8%
Dinghu District Altered
Preliminary 7,928 3,000 4,928 4,500 12,428
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Total - Zhaoqing
Altered
Preliminary
Design
99,028 53,374.6 20,878.6 11,335 13,439.8 15,027.2 5,094.7 0 119,149.9
Completed 91,100 50,374.6 15,950.6 11,335 13,439.8 5,500 5,094.7 0 101,694.7
Progress% 92.0% 94.4% 76.4% 100.0% 100.0% 36.6% 100.0% 0.0% 85.4%
Sanshui District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
20,550 20,550 0 0 0 2,999 1,481 0 25,030
Completed 18,000 18,000 18,000
Progress% 87.6% 87.6% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 71.9%
Nanhai District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
90,290.14 77,843.755 8,634.67 689.225 3,122.49 78,863.11 0 0 169,153.25
Completed 77,411.715 66,000 7,600 689.225 3,122.49 12,000 89,411.715
Progress% 85.7% 84.8% 88.0% 100.0% 100.0% 15.2% 0.0% 0.0% 52.9%
Total - Foshan
Altered
Preliminary
Design
110,840.14 98,393.755 8,634.67 689.225 3,122.49 81,862.11 1,481 0 194,183.25
Completed 95,411.715 84,000 7,600 689.225 3,122.49 12,000 0 0 107,411.715
Progress% 86.1% 85.4% 88.0% 100.0% 100.0% 14.7% 0.0% 0.0% 55.3%
Fanyu District Altered
Preliminary 0 0
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed
Progress% 0
Liwan District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 0.0 13,236.5
Completed 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 391.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 3.0%
Yuexiu District
Altered
Preliminary
Design
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41,898 41,898
Completed
Progress% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Subtotal
-Guangzhou
Altered
Preliminary
Design
391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Completed 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 391.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.7%
Subtotal -
Guangdong
Altered
Preliminary
Design
210,259.3 152,031.1 29,608.0 12,035.6 16,584.7 109,734.6 6,575.7 41,898.0 368,467.6
Completed 186,902.9 134,637.4 23,645.3 12,035.6 16,584.7 17,500.0 5,094.7 0.0 209,497.6
Progress% 88.9% 88.6% 79.9% 100.0% 100.0% 15.9% 77.5% 0.0% 56.9%
Total - Full Line Altered
Preliminary 794,364.8 437,806.0 165,091.7 102,691.9 88,774.9 312,289.2 24,751.0 160,721.8 1,292,126.821
County/District RAP/APD Rural Residences (sq. m) Enterprise Buildings School
Buildings
Urban
Residences
Total
Design
Completed 639,147.4 313,339.5 149,016.3 93,966.3 82,824.9 132,054.6 23,270.0 118,823.8 913,295.9
Progress% 80.5% 71.6% 90.3% 91.5% 93.3% 42.3% 94.0% 73.9% 70.7%
13.8 Progress in Progress in Land Acquisition Materially Influenced under APD for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
County/
District
Town
ship/
Town
Village
Farmland Farm-
Purpos
e Pond
Farm-P
urpose
Woodla
nd
Constru
ction-Pu
rpose
Land
Uncultiv
ated
Land
Other
Unused
Land
Total Subtotal
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm
Vegeta
ble
Field
Orchard Other
s
Baiyun
District
Dula
Town
ship
Black Stone
Village 723 723 0 0 200 0 0 923
Duxi Village 34 6 28 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34
Altered
Preliminary
Design
757 6 28 723 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 957
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Nanmin
District
Houc
hao
Town
ship
Taici Village 2.38 2.38 2.14 12.84 17.36
Chaoyang
Village 0.22 0.22 7.91 8.13
Houchao
Village 4.34 4.34 14.19 18.53
State-Owned
Woodland 0.00 22.09 22.09
Altered
Preliminary
Design
6.94 0.00 0.00 6.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 24.23 34.94 0.00 0.00 66.11
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
6.94 0.00 0.00 6.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 24.23 34.94 0.00 0.00 66.11
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Yunyan
District
Qianli
ng
Town
Gaicha 9.73 9.73 0.59 10.32
Sanqiao 67.74 67.74 2.13 69.88
State-Owned
Woodland 111.29 111.29
Altered
Preliminary
Design
77.47 0.00 0.00 77.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 111.29 2.13 0.00 0.59 191.49
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
77.47 0.00 0.00 77.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 111.29 2.13 0.00 0.59 191.49
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
High-Tec
h Zone
Jinya
ng
Distri
ct
Daguan
Village 735.69 241.43 494.26 16.09 751.78
Yangguan
Village 244.35 43.14 201.20 244.35
Altered
Preliminary
Design
980.04 284.57 695.46 0.00 0.00 0.00 16.09 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 996.13
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
980.04 284.57 695.46 0.00 0.00 0.00 16.09 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 996.13
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Total - Guiyang
Altered
Preliminary
Design
1,821.45 290.57 723.46 807.42 0.00 0.00 16.09 335.53 37.07 0.00 0.59 2,210.73
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1,064.45 284.57 695.46 84.42 0.00 0.00 16.09 135.53 37.07 0.00 0.59 1,253.73
Progress% 58.4% 97.9% 96.1% 10.5% 100.0% 40.4% 100.0% 100.0% 56.7%
Rongjian
g County
Guzh
ou
Town
Yuezai
Village 90.02 89.91 0.11 0.71 4.24 94.98
Kouzai
Village 136.28 136.28 0.00 0.96 137.24
Xiaobao
Village 133.30 106.56 0.82 25.91 12.01 5.34 3.56 154.20
Altered
Preliminary
Design
359.60 332.76 0.93 0.00 26.63 0.00 0.00 16.25 5.34 0.00 4.52 386.42
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Yangsuo Xingp Sidi Village 424.97 17.18 17.51 390.28 3.00 19.97 1.70 1.08 450.71
County ing
Town
Altered
Preliminary
Design
424.97 17.18 17.51 0.00 390.28 0.00 3.00 19.97 0.00 1.70 1.08 450.71
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
424.97 17.18 17.51 0.00 390.28 0.00 3.00 19.97 0.00 1.70 1.08 450.71
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Fanyu
District
Shibi
Sub-
Distri
ct
Shibi No. 2
Village 51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96.00
Altered
Preliminary
Design
51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96.00
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
51.00 9.00 29.00 13.00 6.00 39.00 96.00
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Liwan
District
Zhon
gnan
Sub-
Distri
ct
Hainan 188.23 80.23 108 25.8 2.7 216.73
Altered
Preliminary
Design
188.23 80.23 108 25.8 2.7 216.73
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
128.57 40.23 0 0 88.34 0 0 25.8 2.7 157.07
Progress% 68.3% 50.1% 81.8% 100.0% 100.0% 72.5%
Yuexiu Kuan Yaotai 3 3 3
District gquan
Sub-
Distri
ct
Community
Altered
Preliminary
Design
3 3 3
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0% 0% 0%
Subtotal
-Guangzhou
Altered
Preliminary
Design
242 92 29 13 108 0 0 6 39 26 3 316
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
180 49 29 13 88 0 0 6 39 26 3 253
Progress% 74.1% 53.4% 100.0% 100.0% 81.8% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 80.2%
Total
Altered
Preliminary
Design
2848.25 732.74 770.90 820.42 524.90 0.00 19.09 377.74 81.42 27.50 8.88 3363.59
Progress in
Land
Acquisition
1668.99 350.98 741.97 97.42 478.62 0.00 19.09 161.49 76.07 27.50 4.37 1,957.51
Progress% 58.6% 47.9% 96.2% 11.9% 91.2% 100.0% 42.8% 93.4% 100.0% 49.2% 58.2%
13.9 Progress in Progress in Land Acquisition Materially Influenced under APD for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
G
u
i
y
a
n
g
C
it
y,
G
Ba
iyu
n
Di
stri
ct
Dula Township
Black
Stone
Village
125 500 58,460.3 36,991.8 446.5 0.0 21,022.0 2,000.0 60,460.3
Duxi
Village 77 247 24,204.6 22,167.8 291.8 0.0 1,745.1 24,204.6
Subtotal 202 747 82,665.0 59,159.6 738.3 0.0 22,767.1 2,000.0 0.0 0.0 84,665.0
Completed 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Na
nm
in
Houchao
Township
Chaoyang
Village 35 140 4,857.2 4,729.2 108.1 20.0 4,857.2
Houchao 86 344 19,018.7 17,026.4 234.9 1,757.4 19,018.7
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
u
iz
h
o
u
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e
Di
stri
ct
Village
Zhunyi
Sub-District
Wuyanqia
o
Communit
y
26 78 4,000.0 15,019.8 19,019.8
Huaguoyuan
Sub-District
Office
Huaguoyu
an
Communit
y
125 798 20,500.0 32,883.6 53,383.6
Shachong
Sub-District
Yuxi +
Dalishi
Communit
y
320 960 18,793.0 47,403.3 66,196.3
Xingguan Xinzai 336 1,392 20,000.0 20,751.0 40,751.0
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
Sub-District Communit
y
Subtotal 928 3,712 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 0.0 116,057.8 203,226.7
Completed 928 3,712 23,875.9 21,755.6 343.0 0.0 1,777.4 63,293.0 0.0 116,057.8 203,226.7
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Yu
ny
an
Di
stri
ct
Qianling
Gaicha
Village 28 90 3,371.5 2,927.9 443.6 0.0 3,371.5
Sanqiao
Village 5 30 720.5 590.7 116.6 13.2 0.0 720.5
Sanqiao
Sub-District
North
Sanqiao
Road
Communit
y
78 324 3,473.3 2,766.0 6,239.3
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
Subtotal 111 444 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
Completed 111 444 4,092.0 3,518.6 116.6 456.8 0.0 3,473.3 0.0 2,766.0 10,331.3
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Jin
ya
ng
Di
stri
ct
Jingyang
Sub-District
Daguan
Village 164 546 33,478.9 25,527.6 3,951.8 3,999.5 33,478.9
Yangguan
Village 127 531 4,593.7 973.9 3,619.8 4,593.7
Subtotal 291 1,077 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Completed 291 1,077 38,072.7 25,527.6 4,925.7 0.0 7,619.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 38,072.7
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Total 1,532 5,980 148705.6 109,961.3 6,123.6 456.8 32,163.8 68,766.3 0.0 118,823.8 336,295.7
Completed 1,330 5,233 66,041 50,802 5,385 457 9,397 66,766 0 118,824 251,631
Progress% 86.8% 87.5% 44.4% 46.2% 87.9% 100.0% 29.2% 97.1% 100.0% 74.8%
Q Rongji Guzhou Yuezai 3 16 462.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 462.0 462.0
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
ia
n
g
d
o
n
g
n
a
n
P
r
e
f
ang
County
Town Village
Kouzai
Village 1 5 4.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.4 4.4
Xiaobao
Village 15 68 1,936.9 39.9 455.9 1,008.4 432.7 1,936.9
Subtotal 19 89 2,403.22 39.9 455.86 1,008.3
6 899.1 0 0 0 2,403.22
Completed 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
e
ct
u
r
e,
G
u
iz
h
o
u
P
r
o
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
v
i
n
c
e
G
u
il
i
n,
G
u
a
n
Yangs
uo
County
Xingping
Town
Sidi
Village 62 258 13,560.0 6,600.0 3,000.0 2,200.0 1,760.0 86,000.0 99,560.0
Subtotal 62 258 13,560.0 6,600.0 3,000.0 2,200.0 1,760.0 86,000.0 0.0 0.0 99,560.0
Completed 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Progress% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
g
x
i
G
u
a
n
g
z
h
o
u
C
it
Liwan
District
Zhongnan
Sub-District
Hainan
Village 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 391.2
Hailong
Sub-District
Zengjiao
Communit
y
12,845.3 12,845.3
Subtotal 6 21 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 0.0 13,236.5
Completed 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 391.2
Progress% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 0% 3%
Yuexiu
District
Kuangquan
Sub-District
Yaotai
Village 302 1,000 41,898.0 41,898.0
Subtotal 302 1,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41,898 41,898
P
r
o
v
i
n
c
e/
C
it
y
Co
unt
y/
Di
stri
ct
Township/Town Village
Remove
d
Househ
olds)
Removed
Population
)
General House (sq. m)
Total Total
Concrete-
Brick
Brick-Wo
od
Earth-
Wood Primitive
Enterprise
Buildings
Scho
ol
Build
ings
Urban
Residences
y,
G
u
a
n
g
d
o
n
g
Completed 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Progress% 0% 0%
Total 308 1,021 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 12,845.3 0.0 41,898.0 55,134.5
Completed 391.2 262.8 94.7 11.3 22.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 391.2
Progress% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.7%
Total - Full Line 1,921 7,348 165,060.0 116,864.0 9,674.1 3,676.5 34,845.3 167,611.6 0.0 160,721.8 493,393.4
Completed 66,431.8 51,064.5 5,480.0 468.1 9,419.1 66,766.3 0.0 118,823.8 252,021.9
Progress% 40% 44% 57% 13% 27% 40% 74% 51%
13.10 Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building
Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
13.10.1Confirmation of Guizhou Province and Guangxi Zhuang
Autonomous Region on Compensation Criteria for Land
Expropriation and Building Demolition
Office of Land and Resources of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region
Statement on
Compensation Criteria for
Land Expropriation and
Building Demolition in Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
(Guangxi Section)
FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways:
We have paid close attention to your question that the compensation criteria for land
expropriation and building demolition within Qiangdongnan Prefecture and Qiangnan Prefecture
for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guangxi Section) is undervalued, and have made
further investigation and verification, and we now give our reply as shown below:
I. When land expropriation and building demolition for this Project (Guangxi Section) were
commenced in 2008, involving three cities – Liuzhou, Guiling and Hezhou, and the towns/districts
within the jurisdiction of the three cities – Sanjiang, Longsheng, Lingui, Lingchuan, Yansuo,
Gongcheng, Zhongshan and Guiping etc. Compensation for land expropriation and building
demolition in these districts was carried out in compliance with the provisions in Measures for
Implementation of the Law of Land Administration of the People's Republic of China in Guizhou
Province, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region.
II. Consistent criteria of annual output value were issued and implemented in compensation
for land expropriation in our province from January 1, 2010, which consist of land compensation
and resettlement subsidy, excluding compensation for young crops, and as a whole a little higher
than the criteria as speicified in Measures for Implementation of the Law of Land Administration
of the People's Republic of China in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, but not much.
III. Land use in construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway was formally approved in
2010, but compensation operations for land expropriation had been completed prior to issuance
and implementation of the consistent criteria of annual output value, and the compensation criteria
for land acquisition and house demolition had been released and put into force, to maintain the
consistency of policy during implementation, the original criteria were still applied.
IV. As far as feedbacks from the involved districts are concerned, the compensation criteria
for this Project are acceptable to the public, and the compensations have been paid properly. Land
expropriation and house demolition conducted by the local government were actively supported
by the involved people.
In conclusion, we think that the compensation criteria for in construction of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway comply with related national and regional policies.
Issued by:
Office of Land and Resources of
Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region
(Official Seal)
On April 23, 2012
Guizhou Provincial Office of Land and Resources
Statement on
Compensation Criteria for
Land Expropriation and
Building Demolition in Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
(Guizhou Section)
FCUTIC, Ministry of Railways:
Based on the study on your question that the compensation criteria for land expropriation and
building demolition within Qiangdongnan Prefecture and Qiangnan Prefecture for Guiyang-Guangzhou
Railway Project (Guizhou Section) is undervalued, we now give our reply as shown below:
I. When land expropriation and building demolition for this Project were commenced in 2008, we,
in thorough negotiation with provincial Office of Railway Construction, Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway
Corporation, the people's governments of Guiyang, Qiangnan Prefecture and Qiangdongnan Prefecture
and the local governments/management committees in the eleven counties/districts/cities/development
districts, established Compensation Plan for Land Expropriation in Construction of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guizhou Section), which was then submitted to and approved by
provincial people's government, and subsequently issued Notice on Issuance of Compensation Plan for
Land Expropriation in Construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guizhou Section) (No.
QOLR-2008-134) (hereafter referred to as "the Document No. 134).
II. Consistent criteria of annual output value and comprehensive land price were applied in
Compensation for land expropriation in our province from January 1, 2010, while land use in
construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway was formally approved in June 2010, and the new criteria
was higher than the provisions in the Document No. 134. It is stipulated in Document No. 134 that, “If,
upon issuance of the consistent criteria of annual output value and comprehensive land price, land use
in construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway had not been formally approved, and land
expropriation had not ended, then additional budget estimate shall be made by the Owner for the gap
between the old and new compensation criteria, and in principle, the balance will not be paid in
currency directly to the rural households, but shall be incorporated in the multi-approach compensation
sum used for resettlement of the households subjected to land expropriation.” As various types of
compensation criteria had been released and put into force, to maintain the consistency of policy during
intersection of new and old policies, compensation for this Project went on following the criteria as
specified in the Document No. 134 along with the multi-approach compensation, and combination of
the two compensation criteria would basically comply with the consistent criteria of annual output
value and comprehensive land price.
III.Compensation operations for land expropriation in construction of Guiyang-Guangzhou
Railway is coming to an end, as far as feedbacks from the involved districts are concerned, the
compensation criteria for this Project are acceptable to the public, and the compensations have been
paid properly.
In conclusion, we think that the compensation criteria for land expropriation in construction of
Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway meet the actual needs while maintaining the continuity of policies, and
are adequate and feasible.
Issued by:
Provincial Office of Land and Resources of Guizhou
(Official Seal)
On May 31, 2012
13.10.2Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
54Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project)
Land Type Vegetable Field Paddy Field Dry Farm Orchard Fish
Pond
Lotus
Pond Woodland
Grassl
and
Other
Farmlan
d
Constru
ction-Pu
rpose
Land
Unused
Land
Tempora
rily Used
Land
Cit
y
Count
y/Dist
rict
Unit yuan/mu yuan/mu yuan/mu yuan/m
u
yuan/m
u
yuan/m
u yuan/mu
yuan/
mu
yuan/m
u
yuan/m
u
yuan/m
u yuan/mu
Gu
iya
ng
Cit
y
Yunya
n
Distric
t
RAP 70,200 29,497 20,579 9,498 52,000 78,000 4,749 None None 8,706.5 2,374.5
Based on
the
monetary
compens
ation
criteria
for main
track
Actua
l
Monetary
compensation 117,000 46,982 31,224
14,961.
5 117,000 117,000 14,961.5
14,961.
5
14,961.
5 5,204
Multi-Approa
ch
Compensatio
n
18,000 7,228 7,806
New
Jinyan
g
Distric
t
RAP 70,200 29,497 20,579 9,498 52,000 78,000 4,749 None
8,706.5 2,374.5
Actua
l
Monetary
compensation 110,700 44,452.2 30,183.2 9,972.9 82,600 110,700 9,972.9
5,223.9 9,181.4 2,849.4
Multi-Approa
ch
Compensatio
n
24,300 9,757.8 8,846.8
Qiangnan
Prefecture
RAP None 18,900 17,500 11,700 25,200 None 6,825 None
6,825 2,925
Actua
l
Monetary
compensation 37,800 22,400 14,272 8,920
5,850-8,920 5,850
6,244 2,925
Multi-Approa
ch
Compensatio
n
37,800 (Longli)
29,700
(Guiding)
34,200 (Duyun)
3,780 (Sandu)
9,100.04 (Longli)
2,905.01
(Guiding)
7,780 (Duyun
City)
9,100.04 (Sandu)
14,878.05 (Longli)
6,591.78 (Guiding)
2,971.72 (Duyun)
14,977.95 (Sandu)
Qiangdongn
an
Prefecture
RAP None 22,000 22,000 13,200
13,200
12,100 4,400
Actua
l
Monetary
compensation 37,800 22,400 14,272 8,920 0 0 5,850-8,920 5,850 0 6,244 2,925
Multi-Approa
ch 4,200 (Liping)
12,358.9 (Liping)
19,600
(Rongjiang)
14,020
(Congjiang)
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guangxi)
Land Type
Region
Vegetab
le Field Paddy Field Dry Farm Orchard Fish Pond Woodland
Grassla
nd
Other
Farmlan
d
Construction-Pur
pose Land
Unus
ed
Land
Temporarily Used Land
City County
Unit yuan/mu
Liuzh
ou
City
Sanjiang
County
RAP 42,000 19,200 10,500 15,903 29,250 6,300
6,300 1,400
Actu
al
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
\ 20,120/24,6
60 15,725 15,725
20,120/24,6
60 11,100
1,850 Paddy Field/Fish
Pond:1006;
Dry
Farm/Orchard/Woodlan
d925;
Uncultivated Mountain
(Field):555.
Pioneer
Road
14,084/17,2
62 12,025 12,025
14,084/17,2
62 8,325
1,850
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
503 463
1,000-4,000
Guilin
City
RAP 56,000 31,616 18,000 10,800 26,000 10,800
10,800 2,400
Longshe
ng
County
Actu
al
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
29,592 13,836 13,836-20,8
16 29,592
8,071-13,83
6 2,306
Paddy Field/Fish
Pond:1,233
Dry Farm (including
orchard and
woodland):1153;
Uncultivated
Mountain:690
Pioneer
Road 17,262 8,071 11,530 17,262
4,612
(fuel-wood
forest) -
5,765
(economic
forest)
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
1,233 1,153
600-4,000
Lingui
County
Actu
al
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
22,380-37,3
00
14,904-27,3
24
12,000-41,2
32
21,320-58,2
53
11,178-13,6
62 9,936 2,484
Paddy Field:5968;
Dry Farm:4968;
Orchard 4,000-13,744;
Woodland:4968;
Fish Pond:6560-17924;
Other Farmland:3312;
Unused Land:2980.
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
600 600
750-6000;
2,000-3,000
(young
plant)
820-2,800 1,200-3,000
850-2,0
00
Lingchu
an
County
Actu
al
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
26,970 19,502 52,740 36,101 16,716
Compensations for
young crops paid based
on service life
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
1,798 1,393 4,395 2,777 1,393
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guangxi) (Continued - 1)
Land Type
Region
Vegetabl
e Field
Paddy
Field
Dry
Farm Orchard Fish Pond Woodland
Grasslan
d
Other
Farmlan
d
Construction-Purp
ose Land
Unuse
d
Land
Temporarily Used
Land
Guilin
City
RAP 56,000 31,616 18,000 10,800 26,000 10,800
10,800 2,400 Paddy Field:5960;
Dry Farm:4968;
Orchard:10216-137
44;
Woodland:4968;
Fish
Pond:6560-17924;
Other
Farmland:4968;
Unused Land:2,980
Yangsuo
County
Actua
l
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
25,364 18,630 28,094-37,7
96
22,960-62,7
34
8,694-37,79
6 2,484
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
746 1,242 1,000-4,500
600-3,000 9,936
Gongchen
g County
Actua
l
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
34,316
(prime
cropland
);
32,824
27,324
(prime
cropland
); 24840;
44,668
(farming
seeds);
41,232
(Orchard)
18,040-49,2
91 3,726-9,936
2,484
Paddy Field:5968;
Dry Farm:4968;
Orchard:4968-5968;
Fish
Pond:6560-17924;
Woodland:1242-49
68; Unused
Land:1242.
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops
746 621 750-3,436 820-2,800 350-3,000
Hezho
u City
RAP 32,382 21,380 18,140 20,997 43,589 8,163
8,163 1,814
Zhongsha
n County
Actua
l
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
26,856 18,630 18,630-26,8
56 26,856
11,178-16,1
46 2,484
Paddy Field:1492;
Dry Farm,
woodland, unused
Land:1242.
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops (paid
based on
crops)
1,200
1,050 (rice)
1,200 (lotus root,
calla, taro)
1,670 (sugarcane)
800 (other dry-land
crops)
700-6,600
Pinggui
District,
Babu
District
Actua
l
Permanent
Land
Acquisition
26,971 18,109 18,109-26,9
71 26,971
11,144-16,7
16 2,786
Compensati
on for
Young
Crops (paid
based on
crops)
1,200
1,050 (rice)
1,200 (lotus root,
calla, taro)
1,670 (sugarcane)
800 (other dry-land
crops)
700-6,600
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Land Expropriation and Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project (Guangdong)
Region Land Type
Farmland Orchard Woodland Aquaculture
Waters
Construction-Purpose
Land
Unused
Land
City County Township/Town 10,000 yuan/mu
Zhaoqing
Huaiji
County
Huaizheng Town
RAP 2.6 2 0.8 2.7
/
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 7th Category
2.86
(Paddy
Field)
2.2 0.88 3.3 (Fish
Pond) 0.8
Aozai Town,
Zhaguang Town,
Liangchun Town,
Lengkeng Town,
Ma'ning Town,
Lanzhong Town
RAP 1.8 1.4 0.6 1.9
Actual
Permanent Requisition - the 9th Category 2.431 1.7 0.88 3.1
0.6
Compensation for Young Crops 0.06-0.12 0.3-1.8 0.2-0.3 0.2-0.3
Guangning
County
Nanjie Town RAP 2.2 1.7 0.7 2.3
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 8th Category 2.5 2.3 0.9-1.7 2.8 1.45
Shijian Town RAP 1.8 1.4 0.6 1.9
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 9th Category 2.2 2.2 0.8-1.6 2.45 1.4
Hengshan Town,
Binheng Town,
Gushui Town
RAP 1.6 1.2 0.5 1.6
Actual
Permanent Requisition - the 10th
Category 1.9 2.1 0.7-1.5 2.1 1.35
Compensation for Young Crops 0.06-0.12 5-315/* 0.1-0.25 0.2-2.5
Dinghu
District
Yong'an Town,
Lianhua Town,
Fenghuang Town
RAP 2.9 2.2 0.9 3
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 6th Category 3.5 2.2 0.88 3.6
Guicheng, Guangli
Sub-District Actual Permanent Requisition 3.12 2.4 0.96 3.24
Sihui City Huangtian Town, RAP 2.2 1.7 0.7 2.3
Shigou Town Actual Permanent Requisition - the 8th Category 2.21 1.7 0.68 2.29
Zhenshan
Sub-District
RAP 2.9 2.2 0.9 3
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 6th Category 3.5 2.2 1.2 3.5
Foshan City Sanshui
District Xinan Sub-District
RAP 3.1 2.4 1 3.2
Actual Permanent Requisition - the 5th
Category 11 23
Nanhai
District 11.5 (comprehensive contracted price) 24.8
Guangzhou City
23 (Fanyu District), 19.8 (Yuexiu District), 29.4
(Liwan District) 28
13.10.3 Compensation Criteria for Building Demolition in Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Demolished Buildings (Guizhou)
City County Unit
Building Structure
Framework Concrete-Brick Brick-Wood Timber-Tile Earth-Wood Others
Interim
Resettlement
Subsidy
Removal Subsidy Incentive Fees
Guiyang City
yuan/m2 RAP 850
810-890
(currency);
450 (removal and
rebuilding)
700-760
(currency),
360
(removal
and
rebuilding)
605-660
(currency),
220-249 (removal
and rebuilding)
605
-660(currency),
220-250
(removal and
rebuilding)
500 (currency),
180-220
(removal and
rebuilding)
8 (residence),
10-15
(non-residence)
8 (residence),
10-15
(non-residence
Yunyan
District
Nanmin
District
yuan/m2 Actual
950 (currency)
450 (removal and
rebuilding)
815
(currency)
360
(removal
and
rebuilding)
680 (currency)
250 (removal and
rebuilding)
600 (currency),
220 (removal and
rebuilding)
10 (residence)
20
(non-residence)
10 (residence)
20 (non-residence)
2,000
(residence),
4,000-6,000
(non-residence)
New
Jinyang
District
yuan/m2 Actual
890 (currency),
441 (removal and
rebuilding)
760
(currency),
350
(removal
and
rebuilding)
660 (currency),
240 (removal and
rebuilding)
500 (currency),
215 (removal and
rebuilding)
6 (residence)
10-12
(non-residence)
6 (residence)
8-12
(non-residence)
2,000
(residence),
4,000-6,000
(non-residence)
Qiangnan
Prefecture
yuan/m2 RAP 530 440 400 320 320 320 3
Longli
County
Guiding
County
Duyun
City
Sandu
County
yuan/m2 Actual
720
(currency)
620
(removal
and
rebuilding)
500 (currency),
400 (removal and
rebuilding)
440
(currency)
340
(removal
and
rebuilding)
370 (currency)
270 (removal and
rebuilding)
330 (currency)
230 (removal and
rebuilding)
5
5 (residence)
15 (premises)
10 (production
facilities, storage,
offices)
3 (various types
of building),
2,000 yuan/h
(subsidy for
individual
separate
resettlement)
Longli
County
yuan/m2 For building demolition conducted within specified time, additional compensation at 100 yuan/sq.m and subsidy for public services at 20,000 yuan/h will be paid.
Qiangdongnan
Prefecture
yuan/m2 RAP 600 663 288 180 180 80 3
5 (residence),
10-15
(non-residence)
Rongjiang
County
Congjiang
County
yuan/m2 Actual
720
(currency)
620
(removal
and
rebuilding)
500 (currency)
400 (removal and
rebuilding)
440
(currency),
300-340
(removal
and
rebuilding)
370 (currency)
270 (removal and
rebuilding)
330 (currency)
230 (removal and
rebuilding)
0 5
5 (residence)
15 (premises)
10 (production
facilities, storage,
offices)
3 (various types
of building),
2,000 yuan/h
(subsidy for
individual
separate
resettlement)
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Demolished Buildings (Guangxi)
City County Unit
Building Structure
Framework Concrete-Brick Brick-Wood Timber-Tile Earth-Wood Others Interim Resettlement
Subsidy
Removal
Subsidy
Liuzhou
yuan/m2 RAP 400 400 280 200 200 80 3 5
Sanjiang
County yuan/m2 Actual
600 380 380 300 100
200 yuan/h.month* 6
months /
Guilin
RAP 556 463 367 312 312
3 5
Longsheng
County yuan/m2 Actual
480 350 300 250 120
Lingui
County yuan/m2 Actual
600 (mixed
bricks)
450-500
(black/red
brick);
300-350
(loam brick)
450-500 300 (loam wall);
150 (mud-grass) 80
Lingchuan
County yuan/m2 Actual
600 500 500 500 350
3 yuan/ sq. m.month*
6 months >=120 yuan/h
Yangsuo
County yuan/m2 Actual
500 400 300 200 80
50 yuan/h.month* 6
months 200 yuan/h
Gongcheng
County yuan/m2 Actual
600 350 350 300 120
RAP 600 400 280 150 150 70 3 5
Hezhou
Zhongshan
County yuan/m2 Actual
600 400 300 300 180
4 yuan/ sq. m.month*
6 months
Pinggui
District
Babu
District
yuan/m2 Actual
600 400 300 300 180 4 yuan/ sq. m.month*
6 months
Statistics on Compensation Criteria for Demolished Buildings (Guangdong)
City County Unit
Building Structure
Framewo
rk
Concrete-Bri
ck
Brick-Wo
od
Timber-Ti
le
Earth-Wo
od Others
Interim
Resettlement
Subsidy
Removal
Subsidy
Zhaoqin
g
RAP 700 550 300 200 200 150 200 yuan/h.month 300 yuan/h
Huaiji
County
yuan/
m2
Actu
al 800 720 380
300 150
300
yuan/h.month* 12
months
2,000 yuan/h
Guangni
ng
County
yuan/
m2
Actu
al 1,500 1380 900
400
300
yuan/h.month* 18
months
2,000 yuan/h
Dinghu
District
yuan/
m2
Actu
al 1100 650
450 150
500-1,000
yuan/h
Sihui
City
yuan/
m2
Actu
al 1100 1,000 800
400
Foshan
RAP 500 400 350 150 150 100 50-150 yuan/h
Sanshui
District
yuan/
m2
Actu
al 1,600 1,300 700
500
10 yuan/ sq.
m.month* 24
months
8 yuan/ sq.
m.time* 2 times
Nanhai
District
yuan/
m2
Actu
al Based on estimated market price
8 yuan/ sq.
m.month * 18
10 yuan/ sq.
m.month* 24
months
Guangzhou City
1,800 1,000 700
13.11 Statistic on Progress in Enterprise/Institution Building Demolition for Guiyang-Guangzhou Railway Project
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Nanmin District
Taici Bridge Village Committee Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Education Bureau of Nanmin District, Guiyang City Compensation in cash and independent
resettlement Completed
Women's Federation Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Maqika Group Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction
Rehabilitat
ed
Bureau of National Religious Affairs of Nanmin District, Guiyang City Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Administration of Environment and Sanitation of Nanmin District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Huaguo Police Station, Branch Nanmin, Guiyang Municipal Public Security Bureau Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Municipal Administration of Nursery Garden Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Neighborhood Committee of Huinong Community, Huaguoyuan Sub-District Office Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Taici Bridge Village, Houchao Township, Nanmin District, Guiyang City Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Tongliang Real Estate Development Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Traffic Police Division, Guiyang Municipal Public Security Bureau Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Guiyang Wulicong Wholesale Market Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Passenger Line Workshop, Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Linding Automobile Service Center Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Material Recycling Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Artist Lamp Plant Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Nanmin Taici Bridge Industry Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
North Guard's Room of Railway Station Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Power Supply Section (Transformer Station) Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Labor Service Company (Xinchen Automobile Service), Track Maintenance Division
of Guiyang
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Labor Service Company, Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Benci Clothing Factory Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Electric Engineering Co. Ltd. of CREG Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
National Security Agency of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Municipal Administration of Water Courses Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Chaoyang Village Committee Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Shida Automobile Service Plant Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Houchao Village Committee Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Railway Building Construction Engineering Company, CREC Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Railcom (Guiyang) Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Electric Maintenance Division of Chengdu Railway Bureau Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Wuju Social Management Center Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Station of Chengdu Railway Bureau Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Re-Employment Center, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Sanitation Administration, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Politics Office, Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Office Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Daqing Kindergarten Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Neighborhood Committee of Dalishi Community Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Neighborhood Committee of Dalishi Community Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Security Guard's Room Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Power Supply Section Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Track Maintenance Division of Guiyang Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Chaoyang Fittings Plant Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Textile Industry Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guizhou Nangang Real Estate Development Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
No. 1 Plastics Manufacturing Plant Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Guizhou Textile Industry Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Public Toilet No. 77 of Municipal Bureau of Urban Management Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Toilet No. 4 of Municipal Bureau of Urban Management Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Public Toilet No. 76 of Municipal Bureau of Urban Management Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Minhui Company Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Toilet of CREG Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
No. 1 Company of CREG Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Ronghua Plastic mold Factory Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Langqinju Estate Management Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Shachong Sub-District Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Duojing Company of CREC Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Guiyang Jinlixixng Estate Management Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Subtotal - Nanmin District:68 Households
Jinyang District Guiyang Wudang Wangfa Food Factory
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Guiyang Gaoxinhengjiang Building Material Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and independent Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
reconstruction
Guiyang Wudang Yuanlong Cement Product Manufacturing Plant
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Yibai Pharmacy Co. Ltd.
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Liuwenwu Sand Factory of Yangguan Village
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Subtotal - Jinyang District:8 Households
Yunyan District
Food Mall of Gaicha Village Committee Compensation in cash Completed
Liqiang Rubber Product Manufacturing Plant
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Rural Credit Cooperative of Yunyan
Compensation in cash and independent
reconstruction Completed
Li Linjun
Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Yu Liming
Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Guo Shijun
Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Subtotal - Yunyan District:6 organizations
Total - Guiyang 82 Households
Longli County
Guizhong Province Longli Longteng Iron Alloy Co. Ltd. Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Guiding Road Management
Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Longli County Changlong Aquaculture Service Center Compensation in cash and reconstruction with Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
assistance
Longli Ironworks
Compensation in cash and reconstruction with
assistance Completed
Longli Partnership Chemical Clothing Factory Still in negotiation
Uncomplet
ed
Longli Guilonglin Company Still in negotiation
Uncomplet
ed
Subtotal - Longli County:6 organizations
Duyun City Xiaoweizai Cha'nong School Rebuilding Moved in
Sandu County Pu'an Supply and Marketing Cooperative
Monetary compensation No
rebuilding
Sandu County Jin'an Middle School Rebuilding Moved in
Sandu County Total:2 organizations
Total - Qiangnan
Prefecture 11 organizations
Rongjiang County
Sanjiang Township Wuhong Power Station Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Sanjiang Township People's Government's Office Building Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Sanjiang Township Liantong Base Station Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Sanjiang Township Station high tank for water supply Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Processing workshop of Kaihong Wood Industry Co. Ltd. Monetary compensation and rebuilding Completed
Rongjiang County Huaguoyuan Specialized Cooperative Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Total:7 organizations
Congjiang County Luoxiang Town Hospital Rebuilding
Interim
constructio
n
completed
and
permanent
facilities
still in
constructio
n as per
local
planning.
Congjiang County Luoxiang Town Middle School Rebuilding Moved in
Congjiang County Total:2 organizations
Total - Qiangdongnan
Prefecture 9 organizations
Total - GuiZhou 102 Households
Lingchuan County
Lingchuan Town Guihu Bamboo & Wood Crafts Processing Factory
Lingchuan Town Zhengjin Timber Processing Factory Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Lingchuan Town Hejiapu Cement Pipeline Manufacturing Plant Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Dingjiang Town Xinxing Shale Brickyard Monetary compensation and intended closedown Paid off
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Dingjiang Town Shunda Gas Co. Ltd. Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Dingjiang Town Liziyuan Quarry Monetary compensation and intended closedown Paid off
Lingchuan County Balijie Industrial Park Zone General development Company Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Dingjiang Town Xiaowu Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Dingjiang Town Xingwang Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Lingchuan County Hongfu Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Dingjiang Town Li'echu Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Dingjiang Town Xiaolong Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
industry
planning
zone
Dingjiang Town Longquan Timber Processing Plant Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Dingjiang Town Xinda Plywood Factory Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Guilin Guibei Bamboo & Wood Trade Market Co. Ltd. Monetary compensation and rebuilding in
assistance
Moved to
local
industry
planning
zone
Subtotal (15 organizations)
Yangsuo County Yuhe Brickyard Still in negotiation
Uncomplet
ed
Subtotal (1 household)
Gongcheng County
Explosive Storage of County Material Company Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
County Water Supply Company Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Subtotal (2 organizations)
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Total - Guilin Subtotal (18 organizations)
Zhongshan County Honghua Town Gulou Complete Primary School Rebuilding Moved in
Pinggui District Huangtian No. 3 Middle School Rebuilding Moved in
Total - Hezhou Subtotal:2 organizations
Total - Guangxi Subtotal (20 organizations)
Guangning County Nanjie Town Chengnan Village Public Health Centre Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Guangning County Xiangkou Primary School in Chengnan Village, Nanjie Town Rebuilding Moved in
Guangning County Guangbu Middle School in Chengnan Village, Nanjie Town Rebuilding Moved in
Guangning County Guangning County Automobile Inspection Factory, Transportation Bureau, Xiaojing
Village, Nanjie Town
Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Guangning County Qixing Primary School in Lidong Village, Hengshan Town Rebuilding Moved in
Guangning County Subtotal (5 household)
Sihui City Chengzhong Sub-District Deng Village Paper Mill Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Dinghu District Yong'an Town Fulang Village Gas Station of Sinopec Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Subtotal - Zhaoqing Subtotal (7 organizations)
Sanshui District
Shatang Nail Clippers Plant in Jianggeng Village, Xinan Sub-District Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Nantong Chemical Plant in Zhoubian Village, Xinan Sub-District Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Zhongzheng Industrial Metal Product Plant in Zhoubian Village, Xinan Sub-District Monetary compensation and independent
rebuilding Completed
Subtotal (3 organizations)
Nanhai District Jinzhou Paint Industrial Co. Ltd. in Xilian Village, Danzhao Town Still in negotiation Uncomplet
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
ed
Xilian Xinyanli Powder Factory in Xilian Village, Danzhao Town Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Weijia Metal Product Factory in Xilian Village, Danzhao Town Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Yongyuan Metal Stationery Factory in Xilian Village, Danzhao Town Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
He Village and Yuelong Village Group in Danzhao Town Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
New Countryside Telecommunication Engineering Co. Ltd. of Guangdong Province
in Danzhao Town Still in negotiation
Uncomplet
ed
Foshan Cotton Mill of Guangdong Province in Lutang Village, Luochun Sub-District Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Naixiang refrigeration Co. Ltd. of Nanhai District, Foshan City in Lutang Village,
Luochun Sub-District (Luo Honghui) Still in negotiation
Uncomplet
ed
Foshan textile machinery Co. Ltd. in Lutang Village, Luochun Sub-District Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Subtotal (9 household)
Total - Foshan Subtotal (12 organizations)
Liwan District
Zengjiao Joint Stock Partnership Economy Cooperative Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Guangzhou Steel Group Company Still in negotiation Uncomplet
ed
Subtotal (2 households)
Total - Guangzhou 2 organizations
Total - Guangdong 21 organizations
County/District Name of Involved Organization Resettlement Mode and
Progress
Total - Full Line 143 organizations