strategies for defending liability claims in the construction context · 2016-03-10 · blaney...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada www.blaney.com
Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction ContextAndrew J. [email protected]
![Page 2: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Construction claimsare complicatedmulti party, multi issue
relationships primarily contractualusually involves some allegation of professional negligenceoverlap of tort and contract
![Page 3: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
![Page 4: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Every major construction claiminvolves a professional eg. architect and/ or engineer (and specialty sub-consultants)building inspector and plans examinercontractor, specialty contractor, manufacturer
![Page 5: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
![Page 6: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Who is a professional?no all inclusive definitionspecialized skill derived from training and experiencecommitted to higher standards of service and principles for the benefit of the community as a wholeself regulating admission and standards
![Page 7: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Regulation of Professionsgenerally provinciallyLaw Society ActProfessional Engineers ActArchitects Act
![Page 8: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Civil Liability“With the added prestige and value of his or her services has come, as leaders of the profession have recognized, a concomitant and commensurately increased responsibility to the public.”
![Page 9: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Some professionals may be able to take advantage of
statutory protections eg. municipal building inspectorscontractual protections eg. financial advisor account agreements, geotechnical engineers limitation of use or reliance language eg. lawyers retaining the right to act against former clients in unrelated transactions
![Page 10: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Professional liability claims may arise for breach of contract and in negligence
concurrent liabilitycontract sets the standard of carecan limit liabilitycan’t reduce the professional’s performance below that of reasonable care
![Page 11: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Standards of practice evolve over timestandards of legal, engineering and medical practice of the 1950’s aren’t the standards of todaymust keep on top of new developments and new technology
![Page 12: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Construction ContextI am not dealing with coveragedo note that many claims are being defended which years ago may not have triggered coverage
![Page 13: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Examplescontractor sues ownerclaims a lienowner counterclaims, sues contractor and bonding company separately under the performance bonddefence triggered
![Page 14: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Exampleseveryone third parties subcontractorsdirect damages claimed, consequential damages claimed, pure economic loss claimeda headache!
![Page 15: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Examples (cont’d)take two aspirin and call your defence counselto properly defend must value claim for unpaid contract balancework with bonding company (they hold indemnity from principals of contractor)was there truly fault on the part of contractor or simply failure to perform
![Page 16: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Examples (cont’d)is there a contractual indemnity (to the owner)is there a contractual indemnity (from the subcontractor)sometimes can get subcontractor to assume the defence
![Page 17: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Examples (cont’d)always check the contract language
sets the standard of performance and hence breach (tort or otherwise)
![Page 18: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Under the Ontario Rules, three main pre-trial attacks on a proceeding
motion to strike (Rule 21)dismissal for delay (Rule 24)summary judgment (Rule 20)
![Page 19: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
motion to dismiss for delay brought by defendantmotion to strike or for summary judgment can be brought by any partymost of my comments from a defendant’s perspective
![Page 20: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
motion to strike (Rule 21)
![Page 21: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
is it plain and obvious the plaintiff’s case cannot succeed?is the plaintiff without legal capacity to sue?
![Page 22: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
must bring the motion promptlythe whole idea is to bring the proceeding to an early halt not inexpensive
![Page 23: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
a legal issue with a novel aspect is not suitable for determination under Rule 21 where “factual considerations arise”damages evidence still had to be led at a trial, no real cost savings, and factual inferences were being made from the pleadingsPDC 3 Partnership v. Bregman + Hamman [2001] O.J. No. 422 (CA)
you can’t use Rule 21 to decide an admissibility question or whether to move for summary judgment BDO Dunwoody v. Buckingham Securities (2008) O.R. (3d) 207 (SCJ)
![Page 24: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
three tips on a motion to striketactically, does it seriously undermine the plaintiff’s case?are you making the plaintiff’s pleading better?don’t focus unduly on dismissing the whole action, attack parts where possible
![Page 25: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
motion to dismiss for delay (Rule 24)
![Page 26: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
can be brought when statement of claim not served in the prescribed timewhere more than six months after pleadings closedplaintiff has had action struck off trial list and has not moved for leave to put it back on within 30 says
![Page 27: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
is the default intentional and contumeliousis there inordinate delayput in the evidence of the affected parties
Armstrong v. McCall 2006 CarswellOnt 3134
![Page 28: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
has a witness died?how long has it been since the events in question?has the plaintiff demonstrated necessary witnesses have a sufficient recollection of events
Baranick .v Counsel Trust 2007 CarswellOnt 3287, affirmed 2008 ONCA 142 (CA)
![Page 29: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
moving party must not be in defaultdo you need to show actual prejudice or presumption of prejudice?
![Page 30: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
three tips for motions to dismiss for delayalways prepare and serve your sworn affidavit of documents are you really asking for case management or a timetable?what is the real prejudice?
![Page 31: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
motion for summary judgment (Rule 20)
![Page 32: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
can move after delivery of pleadingsplaintiff can move with leave where special urgency shown
![Page 33: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
must show there is no genuine issue for trialno genuine factual issuean issue of credibility on a material fact can create a triable issue
![Page 34: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
can be brought at any timebefore or after discoveries
get admissions at discoveryavoid the discovery cost, and move before discoverybut there will be cross examinations
![Page 35: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
whole process very expensiveif unsuccessful, risk substantial indemnity costsdon’t do it if you are essentially not saving much time or money, have the trial
![Page 36: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Where a court is satisfied there is no genuine issue for trial with respect to a claim or defence, must grant summary judgment
Irving Ungerman v. Galanis (1991) 4 O.R. (3d) 545 (CA)
![Page 37: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
to oppose, must show “real chance of success”at trial
Guarantee Company v. Gordon Capital [1999] S.C.J. No.60
![Page 38: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
to oppose judgmentmust offer affidavit evidence in responsecannot be mere denialsconsider use of Rule 39.03
![Page 39: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
seek in the alternative, partial summary judgmentan order defining what material facts are not in dispute
![Page 40: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
summary judgment remains the exception not the rule, but…“A summary judgment motion cannot be defeated by vague references to what may be adduced in the future, if the matter was allowed to proceed.”
Canada (Attorney General) v. Lameman 2008 SCC 14
![Page 41: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
three tips for summary judgmentis the motion the application of settled law to essentially undisputed facts?almost always cross examine best if you can prove the facts out of the mouth of the opponent’s deponent, or documentary evidence
![Page 42: Strategies for Defending Liability Claims in the Construction Context · 2016-03-10 · Blaney McMurtry LLP - 2 Queen Street East, Suite 1500 - Toronto, Canada Strategies for Defending](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e70075e5b0c09398e048bd6/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Conclusion
Construction professionals who hold themselves out as having special skills and expertise face exposure concurrently in contract and tortclaims against professionals can be attacked a number of ways before trial if you are defending a professional liability claim there must be evidence of the appropriate standard of practicemay well need independent expert evidence