steve b. howell (noao) don hoard (spitzer science center bob stencel (u. of denver)

23
Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Upload: joshua-compton

Post on 27-Mar-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Steve B. Howell (NOAO)Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center

Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Page 2: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Image credit: Babak Tafreshi (TWAN) [Astronomy Picture of the Day, 5 Dec 2009]

What is Epsilon Aurigae?

-Bright naked eye object. Presence of eclipses first reported in 1821.

-Eclipses last almost 2 years, and happen every 27.1 years (mid-eclipse ~5 Aug 2010)

-What is the “invisible” object that causes the eclipses?

-Why do the eclipses last so long and change over time?

-What is the nature of the primary (i.e., eclipsed) star, the secondary star, and the disk?

Capella Eta (η)Zeta (ζ)

Epsilon (ε)

Beta (β)

Theta (θ)

Page 3: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

What we knew at the start of the current eclipse

The Eclipsed Star:

• F spectral type, temperature 7800 K

• Very large (radius ~150 Rsun)

• Is it a massive supergiant (20 Msun)?

Supernova in the future?

• Or a low mass star (up to a few Msun)? post-Asymptotic Giant Branch object?

= Dying star, planetary nebula in the next few thousand years

Page 4: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

What we knew at the start of the current eclipse

Page 5: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

The Object at the Center of the Disk:

• Maybe it is Nothing? Only if the disk is very massive (but then the disk would be too hot)

•Maybe a Black hole? Nope (no X-ray emission)

• A massive star? Two somewhat less massive stars?

Only required if the F star is massive Too bright (in the UV)?

• A single, normal, B-type star?

Only if the disk and F star are not massive

What we knew at the start of the current eclipse

Page 6: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

+

+

Things are not always as they appear…

Page 7: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

SED to the Rescue

Page 8: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

IUE-SWP(1985)

FUSE (2001)

UBVRI(2008)

JHK (1997-2000)

Spitzer IRS (2005)

Spitzer MIPS-24, -70and MIPS-SED

(2005)HST-GHRS(1996)

Spitzer IRAC(2009)

IUE-LWP(1986)

Optical spectra(1982; 1990-92)

Page 9: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Investigate the Dust Disk

Page 10: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Epsilon Aurigae was estimated to…

…exceed IRAC saturation limit for shortest full array exposure (2-sec) by factor of ~50

…exceed IRAC saturation limit for shortest sub-array exposure (0.02-sec) by factor of ~3

IMPOSSIBLE to observe with IRAC!!!

Well, so they thought!!

IRACMIPS

IRS

Page 11: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

What an image of a star REALLY looks like…

Page 12: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Take advantage of reduced sensitivity at pixel corners.

Spread brightest part of remaining stellar imageover four pixels.

IRAC Observing Strategy

Page 13: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

First Spitzer IRAC Observation of Epsilon Aurigae

•26 April 2009

•used Channel 1 (3.6 microns) and Channel 2 (4.5 microns)

•256 x 64 exposures, each 0.02 seconds long = 5.1 seconds total per channel

Page 14: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Spectral Energy Distribution of Epsilon AurigaeUltraviolet Infrared

F0 type post-AGB star

normal B5 type star

Cool dust disk

B Star - Hubble Space Telescope 1 Sept, Dec, & Mar 2011

Page 15: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Spectral Energy Distribution of Epsilon Aurigae

Page 16: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

B Kloppenborg et al. Nature 464, 870-872 (2010) doi:10.1038/nature08968

Synthesized images from the 2009 observations.

Page 17: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

R = 135 Rsun = 0.63 AU

R = 3.8 AU

h = 0.95 AU

R = 3.9 Rsun

B5 starT = 15,000 KM = 5.9 Msun

F0 post-AGBT = 7750 KM = 1-3 Msun

Dust DiskT = 550 KM ~ Mearth?

1 Astronomical Unit (AU) = Sun-Earth separation

Stellar Separation = 18 AU (~ Sun-Uranus distance)

Page 18: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Lissauer et al. 1996, ApJ, 465, 371

The changing view of the disk

pre-eclipse view

Page 19: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

JHKs(2MASS; 1999)

MSX (unfilled diamonds;1996-97)

ground LM (white squares; 1997-2000)

The changing view of the disk - Eclipse

T = 550 K disk

Page 20: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

Lissauer et al. 1996, ApJ, 465, 371

The changing view of the disk mid-cycle view

pre-eclipse view

Page 21: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

T = 1100 K disk

The changing view of the disk – Anti-Eclipse

“Front” Side

Page 22: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)

END

Page 23: Steve B. Howell (NOAO) Don Hoard (Spitzer Science Center Bob Stencel (U. of Denver)