state of the art of masonry and adobe buildings in peru universidad nacional de ingenieria lima-peru...

22
STATE OF THE ART OF MASONRY AND ADOBE BUILDINGS IN PERU UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE INGENIERIA LIMA-PERU Facultad de Ingeniería Civil CENTRO PERUANO JAPONES DE INVESTIGACIONES SISMICAS Y MITIGACION DE DESASTRES - CISMID Patricia GIBU & Carlos ZAVALA

Upload: kassidy-muchmore

Post on 14-Dec-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

STATE OF THE ART OF MASONRY AND ADOBE BUILDINGS IN PERU

UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE INGENIERIA LIMA-PERUFacultad de Ingeniería Civil

CENTRO PERUANO JAPONES DE INVESTIGACIONESSISMICAS Y MITIGACION DE DESASTRES - CISMID

Patricia GIBU & Carlos ZAVALA

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

1. Use of adobe and masonry

2. Standards vs. Design & construction

3. Experimental, analytical and diffussion work at CISMID

Adobe Masonry Other related

4. Structural Laboratory at CISMID

Topics

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

1. USE OF ADOBE & MASONRYMASONRY Extensively use for houses & small

buildings (up 5 stories) in urban areas Confining elements (RC beam,

colums)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

ADOBE Commonly used for houses (up 5 stories) in countryside: small

towns & rural areas Built by the users themselves

1. use of adobe & masonry

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

2. STANDARDS VS. DESIGN& CONSTRUCTION

MASONRY (NTE-E070-1982)

Elastic Design under service conditions

Provide allowable stresses values New proposal: ultimate capacity

approach – planning, wall density, design details for RC elements

Both materials included in National Standard for Construction (RNC) as a specific codes for each material

Table 1: Peruvian confined masonry stresses Stress Type Formula (Kg/cm2)

Compression due to axial load in Walls

Fa=0.20 f’m f’m: compression strength of

masonry

Compression due to bending Fb=0.40 f’m Tension due to Bending

- Normal to horizontal joints

Ft=1.00 Shear Vm=1.2+0.18fd < 2.7

fd: dead load normal stress

Crushing on Masonry - In whole area

- In 1/ 3 of area

Fca=0.25 f’m Fca=0.37 f’m

Elastic Modulus Shear Modulus

Em= 500 f’m Ev=0.4 Em

D&C:Local goverment offices: project examination vs. actual construction up to workers or foreman as contractor. Among elder&young engineers: missunderstanding of system (RC)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

2. Standards vs. Design & Construction

ADOBE (NTE-E080-1999)

Simple reinforcing elements are required: cane rods, wood, wire mesh or RC elements

Allowable stresses based on unit compression strength

D&C: design or check are rarely made. Owners construct by themselves difficult to promote use of reinforcing element if means higher cost

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

3. EXPERIMENTAL, ANALYTICAL & DIFUSSION WORK AT CISMID

a) Adobe walls retroffiting (Zavala&Igarashi)

at the corners of walls of existing houses using polietilene textile (bags)

carrizo mat (estera)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

b) Brochure on Tapial construction (Planning Dpt: Alarcon&Rios)

Diffusion promoted jointly with private mining company

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

c) Optimization of masonry structures – Phase 1 : Materials(Chariarse&Pique&Scaletti 1990) JOINTLY RESEARCH SUPPORTED BY JICA

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

d) Confined Masonry walls – Lateral cyclic loading(Gibu&Serida&Pique 1993) Undergraduate Civ. Eng.Thesis supported by Buckley&Konno Engs.

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

M u r o C o n f i n a d o S t a n d a r d 1

Fu

erz

a (

t)

- 3 0 - 2 0

2 0

D e s p l a z a m i e n t o ( m m )

- 2 5

- 2 0

- 1 5

0

- 1 0

- 1 0- 5

0

1 5

5

1 0 2 0 3 0 3 5

C U R V A H I S T E R E T I C A

3 0

2 5

- 3 5

Different kinds of reinforcement and parameters studied (axial load, connection wall-confining column)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

e) An Analytical Study of Behavior of Confined Masonry under Lateral cyclic loading (Rojas, V. 1994)

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

Adopting a micro-model proposed by Noguchi (1984), numerical analysis was performed using previous experimental data of tested walls. Comparison of failure pattern

-5.00

0.00

5.00

10.00

15.00

20.00

0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00displacement (mm)

MCST1

MCST2

MC4C1

MC4C2

MLCC1

M-H

MicroModel

Cyclic Test Peak Envelopes vs Micro Model

For

ce (

Tf.

)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

f) Full Scale on Line Test on Two Story Masonry Building Using Handmade Bricks (Zavala, Honma, Gibu &Gallardo, 2002) Under support of Japanese side: BRI, Yokohama Ntl. Univ., Center for Better Living & IDI)

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

Project CISMID/FIC/UNI-IDIConfined Masonry Wall Test- January 27th 2003

WALL C2-HM

-30

-25

-20

-15

-10

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

-0.015 -0.012 -0.009 -0.006 -0.003 0 0.003 0.006 0.009 0.012 0.015

Drift

Lo

ad (t

)

CH-100 Monitor

Project CISMID/FIC/UNI-IDIConfined Masonry Wall Test- January 24th 2003

WALL C2-FM

-30-25

-20-15

-10-50

510

1520

2530

-0.015 -0.012 -0.009 -0.006 -0.003 0 0.003 0.006 0.009 0.012 0.015

Drift

Load

(t)

CH-100 Monitor

Monitoring Construction

Material & walls testing

Full scale model testing

Masonry Construction Guide

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

f) ...Full Scale on Line Test on Two Story Masonry Building

3. Experimental.... Work at CISMID

Test specimen setting & Guide for construction

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

以上 - MUCHAS GRACIAS

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

4. STRUCTURAL LABORATORY AT CISMIDSteel structures behavior

a) Structural components (braces, beams, columns, joints)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

b) Full scale structures

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

Traditional structures (adobe & masonry)

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

Others works & servicesa) Thin wall systems

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

b) Special structures

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

c) Urban Vulnerabilty modelsIndice de Vulnerabilidad de Shiga

Parametros NTE-030 RNC - Distrito de la MolinaEdificios Esenciales Zonas con FAD=1 PGA=0.60g

0

5

10

15

20

25

0 40 80 120 160 200

Densidad de Muros (cm2/m2)

Qu

/Am

u y

V

n/A

mu

(kg

/cm

2)

Vn/Amu

Qu/(Amu+Acol)

Acol/Apiso=10

Acol/Apiso=50

Acol/Apiso=100

Acol/Apiso=200

Respuesta Maxima como funcion del Periodo y FAD Viviendas Distrito de la Molina Sismo NT-030 FAD=1 y PGA=0.60g FAD=2~4 y PGA=0.70g FAD=4~5 y PGA=0.52g FAD>5 y PGA=0.36g

0.0000

0.5000

1.0000

1.5000

2.0000

2.5000

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25

Periodo (seg)

Rp

ta.M

ax

ima

(c

m)

FAD=1

FAD2~4

FAD=4~5

FAD>5

Elastico

Maximo

Vulnerabilidad Baja

Vulnerabilidad Media

Vulnerabilidad Alta

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

Energy disipation devices

PERÚ-JAPAN CENTER FOR EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND DISASTER MITIGATION

Services