state of clinical development costs - kate tranotti & ross petit
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
1Confidential – Not for Distribution
State of Clinical Development Costs
TTC, Philadelphia 2011
Kate Tranotti ICON VP Clinical Operations
Ross Pettit AMAG VP Clinical Operations
2Confidential – Not for DistributionFT-15 5/08
Corporate Headquarters
AMAG Pharmaceuticals & ICON Clinical Research
3Confidential – Not for Distribution
Effective CRO Budgeting and cost control
Scope of work
Contract typeMutually beneficial termsUsing incentives, penalties, partnerships
Governance, Communication, meetings, issue escalation and resolution process
Monitoring toolsActual vs. Budget varianceEarned Value Management
Budget Development and Trial PlanningBenchmark dataUnit costs and Unit cost development
Regional, Globalization costs
Reporting and reconciliation of Trial expense data
Management of Direct costs vs. Pass-through
4Confidential – Not for Distribution
Financial Terms
FFP = firm fixed priceFFP = firm fixed price CS = Cost SharingCS = Cost Sharing
FFP/EPA = Firm Fixed price / economic adjustFFP/EPA = Firm Fixed price / economic adjust CR = Cost ReimbursementCR = Cost Reimbursement
FPIF = Fixed Price Incentive FirmFPIF = Fixed Price Incentive Firm CPIF = Cost Plus Incentive FeeCPIF = Cost Plus Incentive Fee
FPR = Fixed Price RedeterminedFPR = Fixed Price Redetermined CPAF = Cost Plus Award FeeCPAF = Cost Plus Award Fee
T&M = Time & MaterialsT&M = Time & Materials CPFF = Cost + fixed feeCPFF = Cost + fixed fee
FFPFFP FFP/EPAFFP/EPA FPIFFPIF T&MT&M CSCS CPIFCPIF CPAFCPAF CPFFCPFFFPRFPR CRCR
LOWLOWLOWLOW
LOWLOWLOWLOWHIGHHIGHHIGHHIGH
HIGHHIGHHIGHHIGHBuyerBuyerBuyerBuyer
SellerSellerSellerSeller
BuyerBuyerBuyerBuyer
SellerSellerSellerSeller
LESSLESSLESSLESS
MOREMOREMOREMORE LESSLESSLESSLESS
MOREMOREMOREMORE
RISKRISKRISKRISK
CONTROLSCONTROLSCONTROLSCONTROLS
5Confidential – Not for Distribution
Financial Terms
Unit price – fixed cost controlTeams (sponsors) must be aware of the make up of a unit – removes unforeseen costs
Flexibility in the use of units by the CRO eg. Using one monitoring visit; extra days on site
Use of penalties and incentives – more commonAgreement when this is applicable
Clear communication and escalation for out of scope approvals
Ensure dispute resolution mechanism in place for all contractual disputesLate payments
6Confidential – Not for Distribution
DEFINING UNITS AND SCOPE
Fully transparent means better control……
7Confidential – Not for Distribution
Estimation and Accuracy
Ball Park 25%
Comparative 15%
Feasibility 10%
Definitive 5%
Annual Annual BudgetBudgetAnnual Annual BudgetBudget
SOWSOWSOWSOW
BenchmarkBenchmarkBenchmarkBenchmark
RFPRFPRFPRFP
8Confidential – Not for Distribution
Scope of Work
Devil is in the details
Functional partitioning
Impact analysis [cross functional]
Milestone driven [A to Z]
Communication Plan
Risk Plan
Governance and Oversight (metrics)Performance indicators
Earned value analysis
9Confidential – Not for Distribution
Keys to Scope Development
Detailed task structure
Shared risks and responsibility
Defined tolerance
Implementing lessons learned
Metric assessment
Goals and expectations
10Confidential – Not for Distribution
DEFINING TOLERANCE
Tolerance around extended use of resource
Too slow
Too expensive
Tolerance must be set up front
Communication of expectations is paramount
Tolerance levels are a shared risk**in a CRO partnershipDecrease in resources may result in release of staff which may not be available when ready. Sponsors need to be prepared for this
CROs need to remain flexible in maintaining resources to maintain consistency and quality
11Confidential – Not for Distribution
Incentives
Incentive Type Positive (reward)
No Reward or Penalty
Negatives (Penalties)
Objective Incentives
|under budget On Budget Over budget |
| early delivery On time delivery Late delivery |
| exceed requirements
Achieve contract requirements
Do not achieve requirements|
Subjective Incentives
Award feeOther special incentives
TOLERANCE
12Confidential – Not for Distribution
Effective CRO Budgeting and cost control
Scope of work
Contract typeMutually beneficial termsUsing incentives, penalties, partnerships
Governance, Communication, meetings, issue escalation and resolution process
Monitoring toolsActual vs. Budget varianceEarned Value Management
Budget Development and Trial PlanningBenchmark dataUnit costs and Unit cost development
Regional, Globalization costs
Reporting and reconciliation of Trial expense data
Management of Direct costs vs. Pass-through